CHAPTER V CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
B. Suggestions
Based on the results of this research, the researcher gives some suggestions: 1. For the third semester students of English and Literature Department, it is
important to study grammar in creating writings which are easily understood and well organized so the great ideas, reasonable arguments and new knowledges in the writings can be extended to the readers.
2. For the learners, it is essential to learn grammar as the fundamental of English understanding to be a good speaker and writer.
65
3. For the society, vocabulary and grammar are basic to master all the skills in English, listening, speaking, reading and writing. The more the people know the vocabulary and grammar the more the people can master the English.
1
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brinton, Laurel J. 2000. The Structure of Modern English: a Linguistic
Introduction. Amsterdam: John Benjamin Publishing Company.
Brown, H. Douglas. 2000. Principles of Language Learning and Teaching. New York: Addition Wesley.
Brown, H. Douglas. 2004. Language Assesment: Principles and Classroom
Practices. New York: Pearson Education, Inc.
Brown, H. Douglas. 2006. Principles of Language Learning and Teaching. Fifth Edition. USA. Pearson Education.
Burchfield, R. W. 2000. The New Flower’s Modern English Usage, Revised
Edition. USA: Oxford University Press.
Choiriyah, Binti. Syntactical Errors in Thesis Proposal on Syntax Study Written
by the Students of English Letter and Language Depertment of the State Islamic University of Malang, A thesis. UIN:Malang, 2007.
Dulay. 1982. Language Two. Oxford. New York: University Press.
Ellis, Rod. 1997. Second Language Acqusition. Hong Kong. Oxford University Press.
Fraenkel, Jack R. and Norman E. Wallen. 2003. How to Design and Evaluate
Research in Education. Fifth Edition. New York; McGrow-Hill.
Hung, Tony T. N. 2005. Understanding English Grammar; a Course Book for
Chinese Learners of English. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.
Hancock, Beverley. 2007. An Introduction to Qualitative Research. Nothingham. Harmer, Jeremy. 1998. How to Teach English. Malaysia: Copyright
Hornby, A.S. 2003.Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary (5thed). Oxford University Press. New York.
Jackson, Howard. 1982. Analyzing English: an Introduction to Descriptive
Linguistics. Second Edition. England: Pargamond Press.
Kane, Thomas S. 2000. The Oxford Essential Guide to Writing. New York: Barkley Books.
2
Krisnawati, Ekaning. 2013. Errors or Mistakes? Incorrectness in Students’
Answers in A Subject-Matter Examination. Vol. 4. Bandung
Leacock, Claudia et.al.. 2010. Automated Grammatical Error Detection for
Language Learners. Toronto: The Morgan & Claypool Publishers.
Nasrul. 2015. Grammatical Error Analysis of Members’ Writings in Al-Markaz
for Khudi Enlightening Studies (MAKES). A Thesis. UIN Alauddin:
Makassar.
Patel, M. F. and Jain, M. P. 2008. English Language Teaching: Methods, Tools &
Techniques: Jaipur; Sunrise.
Puspasari, Atika & Iwan Romadon. 2011. Grammatical Errors Made by The
Facebook Users. Jurnal Ilmiah. BINA BAHASA Vol.4 No.1.
Putri, Andi Batari Andisa. 2012. Grammatical Errors in Students’ Essays; a
case study at English Department of Hasanuddin University. A thesis.
Universitas Hasanuddin: Makassar.
Richards, J. C. 1974. Error Analysis: Perspectives on Second Language
Acquisition. London: Longman.
Shihab, M. Quraish. 2002. Tafsir Al-Misbah: pesan, kesan dan keserasian Al-
Qur’an/M.Quraish Shihab.—Jakarta: Lentera Hati.
Sugiyono. 2009. Statistika Untuk Penelitian. Bandung: Alfabeta, Cetakan keempat belas.
Trawinski, Mariuz. 2005. An Outline of Second Language Acqusition Theories. Krakow: Widawnictwo Naukowe Akademi Padagogicznej.
Woods, Gareldine. 2010. English Grammar for Dummies; Second Edition. Indiana: Wiley Publishing.
STUDENTS’ ERRORS DATA D a t u m Error O m i s s i o n A d d i t i o n M i s f o r m a t i o n M i s o r d e r i n g Correction Student 1 1 There are many amazing spots,
one of it is Big Ben. √
There are many amazing spots, one of them is Big Ben.
2 I also love a weather in London “not too hot”.
√ I also love the weather in London “not too hot”. 3 I have seen on Youtube a
beuty of London city. √
I have seen on Youtube a beauty of London city. Student 2
1 Because on Sunday is the most free time to do all the
activities.
√ Because Sunday is the most free time to do all the activities. 2 The most important thing ^
we can take a rest.
√ The most important thing is we can take a rest.
3 For e√ample like going to holiday, mutual cooperation, go to the market and so on. √
√ For e√ample like going holiday, mutual cooperation, going to the market and so on. 4 Sundays are also used as the
prefect time to clean up the environment.
√ √ Sunday is also used as the perfect time to clean up the environment.
Student 3 1 I learn to not make
cry. √
√ I learn not to make crying. 2 But we growing up day by day
and make Sunday different than another Sunday ^ we ever passed.
√
√ But we grow up day by day and make Sunday different than another Sunday that we ever passed.
3 That’s why am I feel so free. √ That’s why I feel so free. Student 4
1 I cannot count it and telling to you one by one.
√ I cannot count it and tell to you one by one.
2 I just and we only can say “Oh! I see”.
√ We only can say “Oh! I see” 3 Because we ^ already known
about the place.
√ Because we have already known about the place. 4 I think I can spend the rest of
my life only for visit this place. √
I think I can spend the rest of my life only for visiting this place.
5 That I had been dreamed about.
√ That I had dreamed about. Student 5
1 So, to fulfill that dreams I gotta learn seriously.
√ So, to fulfill those dreams I gotta learn seriously.
2 I believe that the process never
betray the result. √
I believe that the process never betrays the result.
3 So, I think I can manage the spot ^ I will go. √
So, I think I can manage spot that I will go.
visit the most. to visit the most. Student 6
1 England also has a target entire limitation on their graduated program.
√
England also has a target entire limitation on their graduation program.
2 We need to keep study even on the summer.
√ We need to keep studying even on the summer. 3 While if you more like to
discuss the new era of English,you are in modern English.
√ While if you like more to discuss the new era of English, you are in modern English. 4 It is literature books or
analysis books
√ √
They are literature books or book analysis.
5 We need a super efforts to get all the things undercontrol and finish the study on time.
√ We need a super effort to get all the things undercontrol and finish the study on time. 6 Because everything need hard
work to gain high expectation.
√ Because everything needs hard work to gain high expectation. Student 7
1 We was in the Bahari beach around 2 hours, because our parents forbid us to went home.
√
√
We were on the Bahari beach around 2 hours, because our parents forbade us to go home. 2 That day was the best to went
out.
√ That day was the best to go out.
3 When we was in the beach, we talked about our experience when we was new student in
√
√
When we were on the beach, we talked about our experience when we were new student in
the university. the university. 4 Of course we lauged together,
meet with my friends mad me forgot anything.
√ √
Of course we laughed together, meeting with my friends made me forgot anything.
5 That days were my great holiday.
√ Those days were my great holiday.
Student 8 1 There I can gether with my
family, jog, swim in river, fishing in my grand father’s fishpond, plant cocoa tree, ^ pick out chili.
√ √
There I can gether with my family, jog, swim in river, fish in my grand father’s fishpond, plant cocoa tree, and pick out chili.
2 So you can find rivers which flow down over my the mountains.
√
So you can find rivers which flow down over the mountains. 3 Now, my village becomes one
of the most ^ tourism places in Polewali Mandar regency which everyday get visitors not only from Sulawesi but also from Kalimantan and other island.
√ √
√
Now, my village becomes one of the most favorite tourism place in Polewali Mandar regency which everyday gets visitors not only from Sulawesi but also from Kalimantan and other islands.
4 But sometimes when my grandparent need their grandchildren’s help, they will call my parents up.
√
But sometimes when my grandparents need their grandchildren’s help, they will call my parents up.
grandparent’s demand, so it will be taking cocoa.
my grandparent’s demand, so it will be taking cocoa.
Student 9 1 I chose Japan because Japan
has many dream places.
√ I choose Japan because Japan has many dream places. 2 I am interested whit that. √ I am interested with that.
3 Why ^ I like Tokyo? √ Why do I like Tokyo?
4 Why do I like it. √ Why I like it.
5 Something in myself give me suggestion I have to go there include Arabia, Egypt, Turkey, etc.
√
√
Something in myself gives me suggestion I have to go there included Arabia, Egypt, Turkey, etc.
6 My dream ^ go there bacause back to my major.
√ My dream to go there bacause back to my major.
7 Everyone who is in this major certainly has a dream to continued their study to abroad.
√
Everyone who is in this major certainly has a dream to continue their study to abroad.
8 America & Australia are both of places to continued our study.
√
America & Australia are both of places to continue our study.
9 Eventhough it doesn’t
guarantee, we must go there if
we want to success. √
Eventhough it doesn’t
guarantee, we must go there if we want to succeed.
Student 10 1 There are many activity that I
do.
√ There are many activities that I do.
cleaning my home and then make a breakfast.
√ clean my home and then make a breakfast.
3 Let me tell you about the most important ^ that I have do in my village.
√ √
Let me tell you about the most important thing that I have done in my village.
4 But there is one of the most important in our life that my village don’t have. What it is? Enthusiasm of reading.
√ √
But there is one of the most important in our life that my village doesn’t have. What is it? Enthusiasm of reading. 5 So my cousin make a home
read.
√ √ So my cousin makes a read home.
6 But our home read ^ still small and legal.
√ √ But our read home is still small and legal.
7 We have many activity in there.
√ √ We have many activities there. 8 There are; make a poetry, short
story, telling story ^ discussion.
√
√ There are; making a poetry, short story, telling story and discussion.
9 I think this ^ the best holiday. √ I think this is the best holiday. Student 11
1 I always watching TV or film that have setting place in London and I am so interesting to go there. √ √ √ √
I always watch TV or film that has place setting in London and I am so interested to go there.
2 I want to see all of ^ thing that be icon of London.
√
√
I want to see all of the things that become icon of London. 3 Reach your dream as higher a
sky.
√ Reach your dream as high as the sky.
4 I don’t confuse if I want to speak with Britanian.
√ I am not confused if I want to speak with Britanian.
5 The other reason that make me want to visit London is the education.
√ The other reasons that make me want to visit London is the education.
6 I mean ^ include one of the big clubs football in the world.
√
√
I mean it’s included one of the big football clubs in the world. Student 12
1 If I was lazy ^ went to wherever, I just stay at home and cleaned my room, decorated my room, and cooked some foods.
√ √
√ When I was lazy to go to wherever, I just stayed at home and cleaned my room,
2 For me, Sunday is a day that pass quickly, enjoyable, a day for lazy, and always be waited especially by adolescent for meet up, go to shop and reunion with old friends.
√
√
For me, Sunday is a day that passes quickly, enjoyable, a day for lazy, and always be waited especially by adolescent for meeting up, going to shop and reunion with old friends. 3 For some person Sunday ^
same with other days.
√ For some persons Sunday is same with other days. 4 They can ^ vacation with their
family or their someone special.
√ They can have vacation with their family or their someone special.
5 Actually I ^ often like that, although on Sunday I still did my assignment.
√ Actually I was often like that, although on Sunday I still did my assignment.
bath. bath. 7 I went to my friend’s home for
did assignment together or I went to bookstore ^ brought book.
√
√ √ √
I went to my friend’s home to finish assignment together or I went to bookstore to buy book. Student 13
1 I want to looking for ^ history about my name.
√ √ I want to look for the history about my name.
2 She name is Rabiatul Adawiah. Yeah ^ like my name. √
√ Her name is Rabiatul Adawiah. Yeah it’s like my name.
3 She have a beautiful eyes but she is a bad girl.
√ √ She has beautiful eyes but she is a bad girl.
4 She get a guidance and then she loves Allah so much.
√ She gets a guidance and then she loves Allah so much. 5 She just give her heart for
Allah SWT.
√ She just gives her heart for Allah SWT.
6 Her name ^ like my name. √ Her name is like my name. 7 That story make me wonder. √ That story makes me wonder. 8 She loves Allah so much and
have a beautiful eyes. √ √
She loves Allah so much and has beautiful eyes.
9 My uncle tell me that
“Rabiatul Adawiah is a strong woman and never forget her god, yo must be like her!”
√ √
My uncle tells me that
“Rabiatul Adawiah is a strong woman and never forgets her god, yo must be like her!” 10 I want ^ loves Allah so much. √ √ I want to love Allah so much. 11 I want to be a reall Rabiatul
Adawiah.
√ I want to be a real Rabiatul Adawiah.
Student 14 1 We leaved our house to the
Sultan Hasanuddin International airport.
√ We left our house to the Sultan Hasanuddin International airport.
2 My father directly check in for our flight.
√ My father directly checked in for our flight.
3 Not so long after check in we were seat in the waiting room.
√
√
Not so long after checking in we sat in the waiting room. 4 We are take off from
makassar to Jakarta.
√ We took off from makassar to Jakarta.
5 When the plane was take off, I was scared and closed my eyes.
√ When the plane took off, I was scared and closed my eyes. 6 My uncle and his family was
waiting for our coming.
√ My uncle and his family were waiting for our coming. 7 We were welcome with his
warm family.
√ We were welcomed with his warm family.
8 Because from the airport to his
house taken so much time. √
Because from the airport to his house took so much time. 9 We had been presented by
many variants of food so we eaten together.
√ √
We had been presented many variants of food so we ate together.
10 The first day ^ we were in Jakarta we just stayed at home.
√ The first day when we were in Jakarta we just stayed at home. 11 The next day, we went to
visited Ragunan, Bogor. √
The next day, we went to visit Ragunan, Bogor.
12 There was so many kind of animals.
√ √ There were so many kinds of animals.
crocodile, bear, elephant, panda, kinds of bird, kinds of monkey, gorilla and etc that I can not mention it one by one.
crocodile, bear, elephant, panda, kinds of bird, kinds of monkey, gorilla and etc that I can not mention one by one. 14 We were surround the zoo by
foot.
√ We surrounded the zoo by foot.
15 We took a rest and ate some
snack. √
We took a rest and ate some snacks.
16 In the two next day, we went to visited Taman Mini Indonesia.
√ √
√ In the next two days, we went to visit Taman Mini Indonesia. 17 I’m so sorry if I have much
mistaken from it.
√ √
I’m so sorry if I have many mistakes from it.
Student 15 1 If I am asked ^ go, I will
definitely choose Malaysia.
√ If I am asked to go, I will definitely choose Malaysia. 2 People from all the country √ People from all the countries 3 You feel as if you are in your
home, country, and wonderful
few. √
You feel as if you are in your home, country, and wonderful view.
Student 16 1 I like to camp on the mountain
bacause I can ^ happy with my friends.
√
I like to camp on the mountain bacause I can be happy with my friends.
2 If I was on the top of the mountain, i ^ feel so happy bacause I can conquer the height of the mountain.
√
√ If I were on the top of the mountain, I would feel so happy bacause I can conquer the height of the mountain.
3 Looking at the sunrise and sunset adds to the satisfaction of the weary of climbing the mountain.
√
Looking at the sunrise and sunset adds the satisfaction of the weary of climbing the mountain.
4 Watching the sunrise in the accompaniment of a guitar and singing with friends adds to this section.
√
Watching the sunrise in the accompaniment of a guitar and singing with friends add to this section.
Student 17 1 It is included as one of five
Islam pillar. √
It is included as one of five Islam pillars.
2 I also want to visit is Tokyo. √ I also want to visit Tokyo. 3 The reason that I want to go
there because for 3 years later, Tokyo will perform Olympic.
√ The reason why I want to go there because for 3 years later, Tokyo will perform Olympic. 4 It’s a multi-event sports that ^
organized for every 4 years.
√ √ It’s a multi-event sport that is organized for every 4 years. 5 There will be many athlete to
compete and lots of sports to be matched.
√ There will be many athletes to compete and lots of sports to be matched.
Student 18 1 Sunday is the day that I ^
activity outside the campus.
√ Sunday is the day that I do activity outside the campus. 2 I also ^ a lot of time for fun. √ I also spend a lot of time for
fun. 3 On Sundays I also do activity
with my friends.
√ On Sunday I also do activity with my friends.
activities. activities. 5 I followed the activity with
friends and senior brother. √
I followed the activity with friends and senior.
6 That’s why I prefer the day of the Sunday.
√ That’s why I prefer Sunday. Student 19
1 There are so many my favourite singer, actor, and actress there.
√
There are so many my
favourite singers, actors, and actress there.
2 You knowlah Hawaii is the best island in the world.
√ You know Hawaii is the best island in the world.
3 I want to take a many pictures √ I want to take many pictures 4 I want to go to one of the best
beaches there, ^ is Lanika beach.
√
I want to go to one of the best beaches there, it is Lanika beach.
5 So many tourists to visit there. √ So many tourists visit there. 6 “Heavenly sea” have a