Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Physics
of
the
Dark
Universe
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / d a r k
EURECA
Conceptual
Design
Report
The
EURECA
Collaboration
G.
Angloher
n,
E.
Armengaud
b,
C.
Augier
g,
A.
Benoit
f,
T.
Bergmann
k,
J.
Bl
¨umer
i ,j,
A.
Broniatowski
e,
V.
Brudanin
h,
P.
Camus
f,
A.
Cazes
g,
M.
Chapellier
e,
N.
Coron
c,
G.A.
Cox
i,
C.
Cuesta
s,
F.A.
Danevich
l,
M.
De
J
´esus
g,
L.
Dumoulin
e,
K.
Eitel
j,
A.
Erb
o,
A.
Ertl
o,
F.
von
Feilitzsch
o,
D.
Filosofov
h,
N.
Fourches
b,
E.
Garc
´ıa
s,
J.
Gascon
g,
G.
Gerbier
b,
C.
Ginestra
s,
J.
Gironnet
g,
A.
Giuliani
e,
M.
Gros
b,
A.
G
¨utlein
o,
D.
Hauff
n,
S.
Henry
p,
G.
Heuermann
i,
J.
Jochum
r,
S.
Jokisch
j,
A.
Juillard
g,
C.
Kister
n,
M.
Kleifges
k,
H.
Kluck
i,
E.V.
Korolkova
q,
V.Y.
Kozlov
j,
H.
Kraus
p,
V.A.
Kudryavtsev
q,
J.-C.
Lanfranchi
o,
P.
Loaiza
m,
J.
Loebell
r,
I.
Machulin
u,
S.
Marnieros
e,
M.
Mart
´ınez
s,
A.
Menshikov
k,
A.
M
¨unster
o,
X.-F.
Navick
b,
C.
Nones
b,
Y.
Ortigoza
s,
P.
Pari
a,
F.
Petricca
n,
W.
Potzel
o,
P.P.
Povinec
t,
F.
Pr
¨obst
n,
J.
Puimed
´on
s,
F.
Reindl
n,
M.
Robinson
q,
T.
Rol
´on
s,
S.
Roth
o,
K.
Rottler
r,
S.
Rozov
h,
C.
Sailer
r,
A.
Salinas
s,
V.
Sanglard
g,
M.L.
Sarsa
s,
K.
Sch
¨affner
n,
B.
Schmidt
i,
S.
Scholl
o,
S.
Sch
¨onert
o,
W.
Seidel
n,
B.
Siebenborn
i,
M.
v.
Sivers
o,
C.
Strandhagen
r,
R.
Strauß
o,
A.
Tanzke
n,
V.I.
Tretyak
l,
M.
Turad
r,
A.
Ulrich
o,
I.
Usherov
r,
P.
Veber
d,
M.
Velazquez
d,
J.A.
Villar
s,
O.
Viraphong
d,
R.J.
Walker
b ,i,
S.
Wawoczny
o,
M.
Weber
k,
M.
Willers
o,
M.
W
¨ustrich
o,
E.
Yakushev
h,
X.
Zhang
p,
A.
Z
¨oller
o aCEA,Centred’Etudes´ Nucl´eairesdeSaclay,IRAMIS,91191Gif-sur-YvetteCedex,FrancebCEA,Centred’´EtudesNucl´eairesdeSaclay,IRFU,91191Gif-sur-YvetteCedex,France
cCNRS,Institutd’AstrophysiqueSpatiale,Universit´eParis11,Orsay91405,France
dCNRS,Universit´edeBordeaux,ICMCB,87avenueduDr.A.Schweitzer,Pessaccedex,33608,France
eCentredeSpectroscopieNucl´eaireetdeSpectroscopiedeMasse,UMR8609IN2P3-CNRS,Univ.ParisSud,OrsayCampus,91405,France
fInstitutN´eel,CNRS,38042Grenoblecedex9,France
gIPNL,Universit´edeLyon,Universit´eLyon1,CNRS/IN2P3,4rueE.Fermi,Villeurbanne69622,France hLaboratoryofNuclearProblems,JINR,Dubna141980,RussianFederation
iKarlsruheInstituteofTechnology,Institutf¨urExperimentelleKernphysik,Karlsruhe76128,Germany
jKarlsruheInstituteofTechnology,Institutf¨urKernphysik,Karlsruhe76021,Germany
kKarlsruheInstituteofTechnology,Institutfur¨ ProzessdatenverarbeitungundElektronik,Karlsruhe76021,Germany
lInstituteforNuclearResearch,MSP03680Kyiv,Ukraine
mLaboratoireSouterraindeModane,CEA-CNRS,Modane73500,France
nMax-Planck-Institutfur¨ Physik,80805Munchen,¨ Germany
oPhysik-DepartmentE15,TechnischeUniversit¨atMunchen,¨ Garching85747,Germany
pUniversityofOxford,DepartmentofPhysics,KebleRoad,OxfordOX13RH,UK qUniversityofSheffield,DepartmentofPhysicsandAstronomy,SheffieldS37RH,UK
rEberhard-Karls-Universit¨atT¨ubingen,Tubingen¨ 72076,Germany
sLaboratoriodeF´ısicaNuclearyAstropart´ıculas,PedroCerbuna12,UniversidaddeZaragoza,Zaragoza50009,Spain
tComeniusUniversity,DepartmentofNuclearPhysicsandBiophysics,Bratislava84248,Slovakia
uNRC“KurchatovInstitute”,Kurchatovsq.1,Moscow,Russia
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Keywords:
Darkmatter WIMPs Directdetection Cryogenicbolometers EURECAexperiment
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
The EURECA (European Underground Rare Event Calorimeter Array) project is aimed at searching for dark matter particles using cryogenic bolometers. The proponents of the present project have decided to pool their strengths and expertise to build a facility to house up to 1000 kg of detectors, EURECA, consisting in the first instance of germanium and CaWO 4crystals. The shielding will be provided through a large water
tank in which the cryostat with detectors will be immersed. The EURECA infrastructure will be an essential tool for the community interested in using cryogenic detectors for dark matter searches. Beyond European detectors, it will be designed to host other types of similar cryogenic detectors, requiring millikelvin operating temperatures. In particular, this includes the germanium detectors currently in use by the SuperCDMS team, following the current collaborative work performed by the EURECA and SuperCDMS collaborations. EURECA
2212-6864/$-seefrontmatterc 2014TheAuthors.PublishedbyElsevierB.V.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBYlicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 3.0/).
will have two stages. The first phase aims at a sensitivity of 3 ·10 −10pb and will involve building the
infrastructure, cryostat and shielding, and operating 150 kg of detectors. The second phase will be completed with 850 kg of additional detectors, the relative weight between the different detectors being decided by the collaboration according to the physics reach. A sensitivity of 2 ·10 −11pb is aimed for at the second stage.
EURECA will ideally benefit from the planned extension of the deepest underground laboratory in Europe – LSM. With a site-independent design, it can also be hosted in other locations at similar or deeper sites such as SNOLAB.
c
2014 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).
1. Executivesummary
The EURECA (European Underground Rare Event Calorimeter
Array)projectispartofthequestforunderstandingthecomposition ofouruniverseandinparticularthelargefraction,26.8%[1 ],ofits un-knownmass-energydensitycalleddarkmatter.Thisquestion,raised 80yearsago,hasstillnoanswerandthereisafierceracetowardsthe directdetectionofdarkmatterparticles.Manyastrophysical obser-vationsconvergeontheassumptionthatitwouldconsistofparticles stillunknown,asyetundetectedandfugitive,presentsincetheearly momentsoftheuniverse.
Manyexperimentsaroundtheworld,alllocatedinunderground environments,aimto trackdown thepresence oftheseparticles. Amongthese,EDELWEISS,locatedattheLSMlaboratory,andCRESST, installedattheGranSassolaboratory,arecryogenicexperiments in-volvingsolidstatedetectorscooledtoverylowtemperatures.
TheexperimentsattheLHChavenotshownanyhintssofar,asof March2013,ofSUSY,thefavouredtheoryprovidinganatural candi-datefordarkmatter.However,thequestionoftheexistenceofdark matterintheuniverseandthequestionofwhichtheorydescribes bestbeyondstandardmodelphysicsaredifferent.Assuch,direct de-tectiondarkmatterexperimentsremainmuchinasituationwhere theattainmentofcontinualimprovementonupperlimitsfor WIMP-nucleoncrosssectionsthroughenhancingthedetectors’sensitivities remainsaveryimportantobjective.
Inthepresentsituation,wherewedonotyethaveexperimental proofofSUSY,norconvincingevidenceoftheexistenceofWIMPs bydirectdetectionexperiments,thenextgenerationofdirect detec-tionexperiments,providinganincreaseofsensitivitybytwoorders ofmagnitude,willbeneededtotackletheissueofthedarkmatter nature.TherecentavatarsoflowmassWIMPhints,notconsidered yetasevidence[2 ],confirmthatseveralexperimentswith comple-mentarydetectionprincipleswillbeneededtoestablishaconclusive demonstrationofsignalidentification.Thespecificstrengthsof cryo-genicdetectors,namelytheirverygoodenergyresolution,excellent discriminationagainstbackgroundandtheredundancyofferedby theuseofmultipletargetnucleiinthesamecryogenicinfrastructure, equipEURECAwithasignificantadvantagefortheidentificationofa darkmattersignal.
Theproponentsofthepresentproject,mostlyoriginatingfromthe EDELWEISS,CRESSTandROSEBUDcollaborations,thereforehave de-cidedtopooltheirstrengthsandexpertisetobuildafacilitytohouse upto1000kgofdetectors,EURECA,consistinginthefirstinstanceof germaniumandCaWO4detectors.Thedetectorswillbemountedin
subunitsoftowers,housedina6-m3cryostat,withshieldingprovided
byalargewatertank.InnovativecryogenicswillrelyonEuropean expertiseinthefield,andtogetherwithadaptablecablingand elec-tronicsoptions,theEURECAinfrastructurewillbeanessentialtoolfor thecommunityinterestedintheuseofcryogenicdetectorsfordark mattersearches.BeyondEuropeandetectors,itwillbedesignedto hostothertypesofsimilarcryogenicdetectors,requiringmillikelvin
operatingtemperatures.Inparticular,thisincludesthegermanium detectorscurrentlyinusebytheSuperCDMSteam,followingthe cur-rentcollaborativeworkperformedbytheEURECAandSuperCDMS collaborations.
EURECAwillhavetwostages.Thefirstphaseaimsatasensitivityof 3·10−10pbandwillinvolvebuildingtheinfrastructure,cryostatand
shielding,andoperating150kgofdetectors.Thesecondphasewill becompletedwith850kgofadditionaldetectors,therelativeweight betweenthedifferentdetectorsbeingdecidedwithinthe collabora-tionaccordingtothephysicsreach.Afinalsensitivityof2·10−11pb
isaimedfor.
EURECAwillideallybenefitfromnewspaceprovidedbyanew plannedextensionoftheLSM,acavityprojectcalledDOMUS. Fur-thermore,thesiteofFr´ejusisbestsuitedtothisresearchbeingthe deepestinEurope.Withasite-independentdesign,itcanbehosted inotherlocationsatsimilardepthsorevendeepersiteslikeSNOLAB. Suchauniquefacility,plannedtooperatelong-term,willbe de-signedtoensureanexceptionallyradio-pureenvironmentinorderto provideoptimalsensitivityfordarkmattersearchescurrentlyunder design.
2. Science
Thissectiondescribesthecurrentcontextofdarkmattersearches andtheplacethatEURECA,theEuropeanUndergroundRareEvent CalorimeterArray,willoccupywithinthescientificlandscape. Table 1 summarisestheobjectivesofEURECA,splitintotwophases,starting withatargetmassof150kginPhase1andreachingthedesignvalue of1000kginPhase2:
Table 1
ObjectivesofEURECA
EURECA Goals
Phase1
Crosssection(SI) 3·10−10pb
Masstobeoperated 150kg
Residualbackground(allsources) 10−2evts/kg/yinROI
Dutycycle 70%
Timeofoperation 1year
Phase2
Crosssection(SI) 2·10−11pb
Masstobeoperated 1000kg
Residualbackground(allsources) <10−3evts/kg/yinROI
Dutycycle 70%
Timeofoperation 3years
Figure 1. ThesensitivitiesobtainedbytheexperimentsEDELWEISS-II(green)[6], CDMS(grey)[10],EDELWEISS-CDMScombined(cyan)[11],ZEPLIN-III(magenta)[12] andXENON100(blue)[13];thepotentialsensitivityofEDELWEISS-III(dashedgreen) witha12000kg·dbackground-freeexposure;andthepositionthattheproposed ex-perimentsofSuperCDMS(dashedgrey)[14],XENON1T(dashedblue)[15]andEURECA (Phase1:upperdashedred,Phase2:lowerdashedred)willplayintheirimprovement. ThesensitivityforEURECAPhase2isaspresentedinTable1,withoneevent/t/y as-suminga50:50masssplitofGe:CaWO4,5-(15-)keVthresholdfor200kg(300kg)of Geanda10-keVthresholdforCaWO4aspresentedinthisCDR.SensitivityforPhase1
is15%scaledbymassfromPhase2,for70%dutycycleofoneyear.(Forinterpretationof thereferencestocolourinthisfigurelegend,thereaderisreferredtothewebversion ofthisarticle.)
2.1. Scientificenvironment
TheEURECAprojectispartofthequestforunderstandingthe com-positionofouruniverseandinparticularthelargefraction,26.8%,of itsunknownmass-energydensitycalleddarkmatter[1 ].This ques-tion,raised80yearsago,stillhasnoanswerandthereisafiercerace towardsthedirectdetectionofdarkmatterparticles.
Manyastrophysicalobservationsconvergeontheassumptionthat it wouldconsist ofparticlesstillunknown, asyet undetectedand fugitive,presentsincethebirth ofthe universe.Whiletheoretical models have providedmany candidates,which span50orders of magnitudeofmassandcrosssection,themostmotivatedcandidates aretheweaklyinteractingmassiveparticle(WIMP),theaxionand possiblyasterileneutrino.Inanycase,darkmatterrequiresphysics beyondthestandardmodelofparticlephysics.
ThefavouredcandidatefordarkmatterisaWIMPrelatedtonew physicsattheTeVscale.AmongthevariousWIMPcandidatesatthis scale,themostappealingisthelightestsuper-symmetric(SUSY) par-ticle(LSP),theneutralino,whichisembeddedinaconsistentmodel, e.g.theminimalsupersymmetricstandardmodel(MSSM).TheMSSM postulatesthattheeffectivescaleofSUSYbreakingisaroundaTeV andthatthereisanadditionalsymmetrycalledR-paritywhichwould keepthelightestSUSYparticlestable.Otherextensionsofthe stan-dardmodelprovidesuitableWIMPdarkmattercandidates,e.g.the lightKaluza-Kleinparticle(LKP)inextra-dimensionaltheories[3 ]and thelightestT-oddparticle(LTP)inLittleHiggsmodels[4 ].
TheparameterspaceofWIMPsislargelycoveredbytheproposed cryogenicdirectdarkmattersearch,whichcouldprobedarkmatter particles withamass intherangefromGeVto TeVwitha spin-independentWIMP-nucleoncrosssectiondowntoafew10−11 pb.
Currentdata,obtainedattheLHC,donotshowanyhintofSUSY particlesinproton-protoncollisionsforatotalintegratedluminosity of10.5fb−1 [5 ]up toan energyof√s =8TeV.Noindicationof
particlespredictedbyextra-dimensional modelsorbyLittleHiggs modelshaveshownupeither.However,theremainingparameter spaceisplannedtobeinvestigatedaftertherestartoftheLHCin 2015,withfinalintegratedluminositygoalsof250fb−1by2020and
3000fb−1by2030.
Nonetheless,thediscoveryofacandidateparticlefordarkmatter attheLHCalonedoesnotprovethatitistheCDMparticlerequired bycosmology.Forthatpurpose,thedetectionofcosmologicalWIMPs isnecessary.Conversely,thedetectionofcosmologicalWIMPswould shownewphysicsbutnotprovethattheyareSUSYparticles.Forthat purpose,identificationandinvestigationatacceleratorsisnecessary. ThesynergybetweentheLHCandthenextgenerationofdarkmatter searchesisobviousandconstitutesanexcitingperspective.
Inthepresentsituation,wherewedonothaveexperimentalproof ofphysicsbeyondtheStandardModelattheLHC,norconvincing evidenceoftheexistenceofdarkmatterparticlesbydirectdetection experiments,theEURECAproject,byoperatingcryogenicdetectors ofuptoonetontargetmassandaddressinganincreaseofsensitivity bytwo(three)ordersofmagnitudeathigh(low)mass,asshownin Fig. 1 ,isanessentialtooltotacklethemysteryofdarkmatter.
2.2. Scientificcase
Manyexperimentsaroundtheworld,alllocatedunderground,aim attrackingdownthepresenceofdarkmatter.EDELWEISS[6 ,7 ], lo-catedattheLaboratoireSouterraindeModane(LSM)undertheFr´ejus mountain,andCRESST[8 ,9 ],installedattheGranSassolaboratory,are ‘cryogenic’experimentsinvolvingsolidstatedetectorscooledtovery lowtemperatures.Theystillhavenotshownevidenceofthese parti-clesandwillbelimitedinthecomingyearsintheirsensitivitybythe sizeofthecryostatshousingthedetectors.
Cryogenicdetectors,asdemonstratedbythelatestpublished re-sults,exhibitexcellentcapabilityfortheirexploitationinfacilitiesfor thedirectdetectionofdarkmatterparticles.Thequalityofthenext generationofcryogenicgermaniumdetectors,withsignificantly im-proveddiscriminationpoweragainstbackgroundevents,issuchthat onecananticipatetorunmassesoftheorderof100-1000kgwithout significantbackground.
TheteamsoftheEDELWEISSandCRESSTcollaborations,together withotherEuropeanteams,inparticularfromtheROSEBUD collab-oration,leadinginnovativeR&Donnewscintillatingdetectors,have decidedtopooltheir strengthsandexpertisetobuildafacilityto houseupto1000kgofdetectors:EURECA.
Suchanextremelysensitivesearchshouldbecarriedoutinthe bestpossibleenvironment,thatisinthedeepestsiteinEurope,to reduceasmuchaspossiblethecosmicmuon-inducedbackgrounds. ThisledtheEURECAcollaborationtofavourtheFr´ejussiteastheideal locationoftheexperiment.
Withthecurrentbaselinedesign,consistingofashieldofalarge watertankinwhichwillbeimmersedthecryostathousingthe de-tectors,EURECAistoolargetofitwithintheexistingcavityofthe Fr´ejuslaboratory.Itwillideallybenefitfromtheextensionofthe laboratory,theDeepObservatoryforMultidisciplinaryUnderground Science(DOMUS),plannedtobeduginconjunctionwiththealready startedsafetytunnel(diggingfromFrancereachedthepositionofthe currentLSMlaboratoryinMarch2013)oftheFr´ejusroadtunnel.In caseofcancellationofthisextensionproject,analternativedesign ofamixedwater
/
denseshieldmayallowEURECAtofitwithinthe availablespaceofthelab.EURECAwillconsistofasinglecryostat,installedinadedicated watertankandwillhave twostages.Thefirst phasewill involve acryostatandshieldingwith150kgofdetectorswhilethesecond phasewillbecompletedwith850kgofadditionaldetectors.The two-phasedapproachprovidesuswiththeopportunitytohaveastaged productionofthelargenumberofindividualdetectors.
targetnucleiinordertobeabletoprovethattheobservedratesand energyspectraofapossiblecandidateshowtheexpectedcorrelation ofaWIMPsignal.Itwillbedesignedtooperatevarioustypesof cryo-genicdetectors:germaniumbolometerscurrentlydevelopedwithin EDELWEISS,measuringheatandionisationsignals;andCaWO4
scin-tillatingbolometersallowingmeasurementoflightandheatsignals, developedbyCRESST.R&Disongoingtocharacteriseother scintillat-ingtargets,specificallythoseincludingnucleiwithenhanced sensitiv-itytospin-dependentinteractions,andlow-massWIMPs.Depending ontheachievedperformance,oneofthesematerialscouldbe incor-poratedasanadditionaltargetinEURECA,mostlikelyinthesecond phase.
ForgermaniumdetectorsdevelopedwithinEDELWEISS,the in-creaseofsensitivitywillbeobtainedinthreeways:decreaseofthe localradioactivebackgroundbyselectionofmaterialsandimproved surfacetreatment,increasedrejectioncapabilityagainstgammarays andbetas,andimprovement ofenergyresolutionsallowinglower thresholds.Thesethreeavenuesofdevelopmentarebeingpursued withinEDELWEISS-III,andtheobtainedresultsallowtoextrapolate totherequiredsensitivityforEURECA.
Scintillation-phonondetectorsprovideanexcellentsuppressionof gammabackground.Sofarthispotentialcouldnotyetbefullyshown duetoeffectsrelated toan alphabackground, thisiswhyefforts toincreasethesensitivityarethereforedominatedbyavoidingand taggingthealpharelatedbackgrounds.
Differenttypesofrecoilingnucleicantosomeextentbe distin-guishedwithinonedetectormodule.WiththepresentlyusedCaWO4
detectorsoftheCRESSTexperiment,oxygenrecoilscanclearlybe dis-tinguishedfromtungstenrecoilsbytheirdifferentlightyield(ratio betweenlightandphononsignal).Thus,suchdetectorsarecapableof partiallydiscriminatinganeutronbackgroundfromasignalcaused byaWIMPheavierthan∼20 GeV.
Thedetectorsmentionedaboveusedifferentreadoutschemes, whichwillneedflexibilityinthedesignofwiringandelectronics housingoftheEURECAcryostat.Suchflexibilitywillalsobeakey featureallowingtohouseothertypesofdetectors.
Othertypesofdetectors arebeingdevelopedwithin aparallel projectleadbytheAmericanteamofSuperCDMS,thesuccessorof theCDMScollaboration.Thisprogram,whosegoalistooperate150 kgofgermaniumdetectors,isverysimilartoEURECAPhase1.Indeed, theverysimilarqualityofdataobtainedsofarbytheEDELWEISSand CDMScollaborationsledthetwoteamstocombinebothdatasets toproduceanimprovedlimitrelativetoeachindividualresult[11 ]. Thesuccessofthiscollaborativeworkledthetwocollaborationsto startmoreconcreteworkonthedesignoftheirnextgenerationof theprojectsdescribedabove,inordertopossiblyexchangedetectors andfurthercombinefuturedatasets.
Other100-kgtotonne-scaleprojectsarebeingpursuedwithliquid noblegases.Self-shieldingeffectsandcapabilityofthelocalisationof interactionsaredistinctivefeaturesofliquidnoblegastwo-phase technology.ThemostadvancedareXENON1T(two-phaseliquidXe, 1000-kgfiducialmass),LUX(two-phase liquidXe,100-kgfiducial mass),andXMASS(single-phaseliquidXe,100-kgfiducialmass).
Withtheirlowthresholdandgoodenergyresolution,the cryo-genicdetectorsexhibitverygoodpotentialforreliablydetecting low-massWIMPs.Theverydifferentdetectiontechniquesmakethetwo approachescomplementary,astronganddecisiveadvantageincase apossiblecandidateisseenbyoneofthedetectorsandneedstobe cross-checkedandconfirmedbytheother.
Insummary,suchauniquesetupinEurope,plannedtooperate long-term,willbedesignedtoprovideanexceptionallygood radio-pureenvironment.Itwillbedesignedtohouse,inthefirstinstance, detectorsdedicatedtothesearchfordarkmatter.Inparticular, elec-tronicsandcablingwillbe designed tooperate differenttypesof cryogenicdetectors,whethersemiconductorssuchasgermanium,or scintillatingtypeasCaWO4,oranyothercryogenicdetectors.
3. Infrastructure
AlthoughEURECAcanbeplacedinanysuitablysizedunderground location,discussionherefollowsthepreferredlocationoftheLSM extension(DOMUS).Aviewoftheoveralllayoutoftheproposednew spaceisshowninFig. 2 .Herewedescribetheinterfacesbetweenthe hostlaboratoryandtheEURECAfacility.Table 2 summarisessomeof thekeyfeaturesoftheEURECAinfrastructure.
Figure 2. Positionofthenewfacility,towardsthetopoftheimage,withrespectto theexistingroad(lowermost)andlaboratoryspace(shaded).
Table 2
KeyfeaturesoftheEURECAinfrastructure
Infrastructure Baselineoption
Space
EURECAvolume 10×24-mfootprint×12-mheight Cryostat 2-mdiameter×2-mheight Watershieldtank 8-mdiameter×12-mheight Waterbuffer 6.5-mdiameter×12-mheight Infrastructurebuilding 6×8-mfootprint×12-mheight,3or4
storeys
Cleanroomsuite 48-m2footprint×3-mheight
Cryogenics 6×5-mfootprint×3-mheight Power,volume,flowsanddatarate
Powerpeak 270kW
Powerrunning 230kW Low-Rnairflux 150m3/h
Watervolume 400m3
Coolingneed equivalentto8m3/hofwater
Shieldingwaterrecirculation 2m3/h
Figure 3. Layoutofthemainwatertank(left)containingthecryostat,adjacent infras-tructureandcleanroomtower,andwaterstoragetank(right)withinthe50-m-long halloftheDOMUSlab.Proximitycryogenicsareshownwithinthecoldboxconnected tothecryostat.Clearanceofatleast1mhasbeenincludedbetweenthecavernwalls andtheexperimentalinfrastructure.Theyellowlineindicatesthefloorspaceavailable withinthecurrentLSM,althoughwiththereducedheightofonly10m.(For interpre-tationofthereferencestocolourinthisfigurelegend,thereaderisreferredtotheweb versionofthisarticle.)
3.1. Generalexperimentinfrastructure
Aschematicforthehousingoftheexperimentisshownin Fig. 3 .Thedetectorswillbeplacedinacryostatwithinawatertankto shieldagainstneutronsandgamma-rays.Abuildingislocatednext tothetankthroughwhichaccesstothecryostatwillbeprovided. Anadditionaltankwillbeplacedinthevicinityoftheexperiment forstorageofwaterwhenaccesstothecryostatisrequired.Some elementsofthecryogenicssystemwillbelocatedinimmediate prox-imitytothecryostat,housingthedetectors.Theotherelementsof thecryogenicsystems,especiallylargeplant(compressors,cryogenic machines)pronetocontributenoiseandvibration,willbeplacedat somedistancefromthecryostat.Furtherdetailsareprovidedbelow.
3.1.1. Housingoftheexperiment
Thedetectorcryostatwillbesurroundedbyatleast3mof ultra-purewater,ineachdirection,withinastainlesssteelwatertank.Next tothiswillbetheinfrastructuretowerwhichwillincludespacefor storageofmaterials,slowcontrolandDAQsystems,water purifica-tionplant,andacleanroom.Thecleanroomisplacedatthetopofthe towerandservesasaccesstothewatertankwithcleanroomintegrity extendingintothewatertank.Thetankissealedatthepointof en-trybymeansofanairlocktopreservethelow-Rnatmosphere.All connectors(electrical,cryogenic,vacuum)throughthewatercontain bends,orincludesufficientsolidshielding,topreventadirectpath forneutrons.Anadditionalwatertankislocatedbythesideofthe towerforuseasawaterstoragelocationwhenaccesstothecryostat isneeded.Theextratankwillbematchedinheighttothewatertank tominimisetheamountoffloorspaceused,butwillbeofasmaller volumesincenointernalaccessisrequired.
Foracryostatwithaheightanddiametereachof2m,thewater tankwouldneedtohaveadiameterof8mandaheightof12m.This includesaclearanceofabout4mabovethewaterlevelforaccess andcranes.Analternativesizeforthewatershieldispresentedin Appendix A .Thethicknessofthetankwallswillbeupto20mm, withtheprecisethicknesstobedeterminedthroughstandarddesign procedures(forexampleFEAanalysis)intheTDR.Theinternalsofthe watertankwillrequiresurfacepassivationafterthoroughcleaning, withelectro-polishingbeingalikelymethodforthelatter.
Withawatertankof8-mdiameter,theadjacenttowercouldhave similardimensions.Afootprintof8×6mprovidesadequate clean-roomspace(see Section 3.3 ).Averticalspaceof12mcould accom-modatefourfloors.Abuildingthistallwithinacurvedcavernshown inFig. 4 ,wouldallowspaceforthecleanroomoverpressurefanstobe placedontopofthebuilding.Sufficientspacewouldthenalsoexistto allowaflowofairtocooltheoverpressurefans.Thelowermostfloor
Figure 4. PositionofthewatertankwithinthecrosssectionofthenewDOMUS laboratory,approximatelytoscale.Thewidestpartofthehallis18.2m.Thecylindrical envelopeforthewatertankistoscalewithinthecrosssection,andhasaheightof12 mandadiameterof8m.
couldhousemostofthewaterpurificationplant.Anexceptiontothis wouldbetheRn-strippingcolumn(ifused),whichwouldlikelybetoo talltobehousedwithinasinglelevel.Themiddlefloororfloorscould bededicatedtoslowcontrolandDAQ,whilst theuppermostfloor orfloorscouldcontainthecleanrooms.Alllevelscouldalsoprovide someformofstorage.
Anon-detailedanalysisusingthelaboratorycross-sectionshown inFig. 4 andassumingaregularcylindricalshapeforthewatertank suggestssitingthetankwitha1-mclearancefromthecranebeam wouldallowahorizontaldistanceof2.0mtothewallononeside,and 5.0montheotherside.Notethatthe1-mclearanceshowninFig. 4 is mostlimitedintheverticaldirection,leavingahorizontalclearance of1.1mbetweenthetopofthetankandthecranebeam.Structural integrityusingFEAwillbeinvestigated,withcloseattentiontothe topofthewaterstoragetankwherethewaterlevelmayapproach closertothetopofthetank.Iffloorspaceisconsideredmore pre-cious,adifferentshapeforthetopofthewatershieldtankshouldbe considered,allowingtheexperimentalhousingtobesituatednearer tothesideofthecavern.Sloping,orstepping,thetopsectionofthe watertanksabovethewaterlevelwouldallowthetanktobeplaced nearerthecavernwall,butdependsinpartontherequirementson thereachofthecraneinternaltothattank.Thisdependsonwhether thecraneneedsthecapabilityofhorizontalmovementacrossthefull radiusofthetank,andwhetherthisisneededaroundthefullarcof 2
π
.3.1.2. Cryogenicsystems
Acryogenicunit,positionedimmediatelyadjacenttothewater tankforcloseproximitytothecryostat,housesthe1-Kpotandstill, theheatexchangersandthe3Hecondenser.Thevalvesforthefast
precoolingofthedetectorarraywillalsobesituatedinsidethis cryo-genicunit.Theunitwillhavedimensionsofabout1.5× 2.5m,and willbemountedonthesamebaseplateasthedetectorarray, con-nectedbyarigidcryo-line.
Theremainderofthecryogenicsystemconsistingofpumps, com-pressorandgasstoragewillbeplacedinaseparatecavernupto100 mfromthedetectorstoreducemicrophonics.Possiblelocationsare thesidesofaccesstunnelsoraseparatecavitycutintotherock.5 m3isrequiredforgasstorage,withthecompressorapproximately
2.5×2×2m,andafurther1.5×1×2mrequiredforoilfiltration. Afootprintofatleast6× 5mwouldberequiredfortheseitems,if allofthemareonthesamelevel.
Thelinestothe3Heand4Hepumps,aswellastheliquid
he-lium(LHe)transferline,willpassbetweenthemaincavernandthe acousticallydecoupledcryogenicfacility.Thecryogenicunitwillbe decoupledfromvibrationbyflexiblesectionsanddampingstructures thatareoptimisedforthespectrumofthevibrationofthepumpsand theheliumliquefier.Theseflexiblesectionswillalsoallowthe nec-essarymovementoftheplatformsbyseveralcmwhenemptyingor fillingthewatershieldingtanks.
Fulldetailsofthecryogenicsystemareprovidedinthededicated Section 4 .
3.1.3. Undergroundstorageofdetectorsandothermaterials
Cosmicrays(neutronsandprotons)interactingwithdifferent ma-terialsat thesurfaceproduceradioactive isotopes.Some ofthese isotopeshavearelativelylonghalflifeand,aftermaterialsand com-ponentsaremovedundergroundandinstalledinthedetectors,may contributeto thebackground eventratecompromisingthe detec-torsensitivity.TheprimeconcernfortheEURECAexperimentisthe Gecrystalsandcopper.Boththesematerialswillbepresentinlarge quantities.Irradiationofcopper bycosmicrayswillproduce 60Co
amongstotherradionuclideswithshorterhalflives,whereas expos-ingGetocosmicrayswillgiveseveralisotopes,themostproblematic being68Geand65Zn.
Theestimatesofneutronflux intensityatdifferentdepthsand copperactivationshowthatcoppercanbesafelystoredatashallow depthofabout10m.w.e.Thiswillgiveasaturationactivityofless than0.3
μ
Bq/
kgwhichiswellbelowthetoleratedupperlimitof about10μ
Bq/
kg.Coppercanbestoredinanundergroundstorage placeinoneoftheinstitutionsandquicklymovedtotheprocessing siteandthenundergroundreducingthetimeofirradiationbycosmic rays.InducedactivityinGecrystalsismoreproblematicandagreater depthforstorageisrequired.Theexposuretocosmicraysatthe sur-faceshouldbeminimisedandthecrystalswillbestoredunderground beforeandafterdetectorpreparation.Thedecaysof68Geand65Zn
givepeaksatabout10keV.Incaseofahigheventrateatthese en-ergies,wewillremovetheregionaroundtheseactivationlinesfrom thedarkmatterdataanalysis.
MoredetailsaregiveninAppendix B .
3.1.4. Heavyliftingequipment
Cranagewillbeneededbothinsidethewatertanksforremovalof thecryostatthermalshielding,andaccesstothebolometertowers; andexternallyforuseasthetanksarebuiltupandcomponentsof theinfrastructureareadded.Thecraneinsidethetoweristherefore likelytoberatedtoasafeworkingloadofnogreaterthan1t.This maybeincreasediftheinternalshieldingcannotbesplitintosmaller components(seebelowregardinginternalgammashielding).For ex-ample,a15-cm-thickCushieldofdiameter1.6mwouldweighnearly 3t.FurtherdetailsofthecleanroomcraneareinSection 3.3 .Thecrane
outsidethewatertank,inthemainexperimentalhall,willneedtobe ofahigherrating,upto8t.
Placementofaliftpassingalongtheoutsideofthebuildingto allowtheeasytransportofgoodsuptotheupperfloorswouldbe beneficial.Aworkingloadof1tmaybesufficientforthis.
Accesswillbeneededforheavyequipmenttobeplacedin loca-tionssuchasthecleanroom(laminarflowcabinets,otherfurniture), orsidecaverns(cryogenicplant).Somemovementofequipmentwill be withportable floorcranesandpallet-trucks,whichare readily availablewithworkingloadsofuptoatleast3t.
3.2. Interfaceswiththehostlaboratory
3.2.1. Electricity
Powerconsumptionandheatloadsfromanumberofitems de-tailedinthissectionaretobeconsidered.Thepowerconsumptionof thecurrentLSMisapproximately200kW,withelectricitysupplied at400kVA.Anestimationforthepowerdrawnbymanyitemsis includedin Appendix C .Thissuggeststhepowerrequirementsfor EURECAwillbearound450kVA(270kW).Itemsincludedinthatlist aresummarisedhere.
Thetotalpowerdrawnfromthecryogenicplantisestimatedtobe 130kW.Itemsconsideredforthisarethecompressor,vacuumpumps, refrigerator,electronicsandthepossibilityofwatercooling,ifneeded, atatotalrateof8m3
/
h.Otheritemslikelytodrawlargeamountsofpowerarethewatershieldpurificationplant(20kW),low-Rnair supply(30kW),DAQandslowcontrol(12kW),andcleanroomplant (9 kW).Furtherdetailsabouteach ofthesearecontainedintheir dedicatedSectionsbelow.
3.2.2. Computinginfrastructure
ComputingwillbeneededforcontrolofDAQ(detectorandveto), slowcontrol(detectorandwaterpurification)andcryogenicsaswell asforgeneraluseforcommunications,monitoring,logbookentries, etc.EDELWEISS-IIIwillprovideatestbedfortheEURECADAQ,which willinturndictatepartofthecomputinginfrastructurerequirements. TheDAQwilloperateatroomtemperatureandrequireaircooling. MoredetailsaregiveninSection 7.1 .
Allocationmustbemadeforlocaldatastorageandslowcontrol machinestoincludedatalogging.Bothcryogenicandwater purifica-tiondata,alongwithinformationaboutambientconditions (temper-ature,pressure,Rnlevels,etc.)willbestored.
3.2.3. Coolingwateranddrainage
Theamountofcoolingwaterrequireddependsontheamountof heatproduced,andcannotbeaccuratelyknownuntiladesignofthe cryogenicsystemhasbeenfinalised.Initialestimateshavequoted thatpartsofthecryogenicplantneedeitherwatercoolingatarateof 8m3ofwaterperhour,or14000m3ofairperhour.Thefire-fighting
circuitshavepreviouslyprovidedwaterforcoolingsystemswhich wasdisposedofafteruse.
3.2.4. Laboratorycooling
Theheatproducedbythecryogenicplant,vacuumpumps, com-puting,DAQ,waterandairpurification
plantswillneedtobeextractedfromthelaboratory.Thefirstorder estimateofpowerconsumptionisshowninSubsection 3.2.1 .Apower consumptioncorrespondingto30%ofthetotalelectricalpowerhas beenassumedforprovisionofcooling.Itwillbepossibletoprovidea moreprecisefigureoncedetaileddesignsofthecryogenics,DAQand waterpurificationplanthavebeenfinalised.Thesewillbeincluded withinthefutureTDR.
3.2.5. Low-radonairsupply
Figure 5. SchematicofthelowRnairfacility.
withinaregimewherebyonlythevolumeabovethewateris sup-pliedwithlow-Rnair,witharesidualRnconcentrationinairofa “few” mBq
/
m3[18 ].Inthisinstance,asystemofthesamescaleasthatoperatingintheLSMforNEMOandEDELWEISScouldprovide thenecessaryflowoflowRnair.
Thecurrentsystemconsistsofacompressor,airbufferanddryer atonelocation,withafootprintofapproximately6×1m;and sev-eralfilters,anaircoolerandaseriesofcarbonadsorptioncolumnsat anotherlocation,withafootprintofapproximately5×2m.Theair cooler,andthetonneofcarbon,arecooledto−50◦C.Powerdrawn bythisisestimatedtobearound30kWwhenrunningforboth EDEL-WEISSandNEMO.Thesystemprovides150m3
/
hofairwithafactor1000reductionforRn,tolessthan15mBq
/
m3.AschematicofthecurrentRnreductionfacilityisshowninFig. 5 .
Further details about Rn progeny deposition are provided in Section 3.3 .
ThecurrentRnmonitoringsysteminuseattheLSMcouldbeused formonitoringthelocalenvironmentofEURECA.Ifagreater sensi-tivityisrequired(dependentonsimulationstoshowhowlowaRn concentrationinairweneed),itwouldbepossibletoincreasethesize oftheelectrostaticcollectionvesselandoperatethePINdetectorata highervoltage,aswasdonewiththeSuperKamiokandeRndetector. Further,anumberofsimilarsystemsatdifferentlocationsaroundthe caverncouldbeinoperationsimultaneously.
3.2.6. Low-radonwatersupply
Simulationshaveshownthatitisnecessarytoincludea3-m thick-nessofwatertoefficientlysuppressthegammabackground.Thisis inexcessofthe70cmofwaternecessarytoreducetheneutron back-groundtobelowthesensitivityofthedetector.RequirementsforRn inwateraretobelessthan100mBq
/
m3.GERDAusedasimilarvol-umeofwaterandobtainedU,Th,K,Pbcontaminationsbelowppt levels,withaveryefficientremovalofparticleswithsizes
>
1μ
m [19 ].EURECAwilloperatewithasimilarlylowlevelofcontaminants inthewater.Workingwiththebaselineofawatertankofdiameter8mand aheightof12mcontaining8mdepthofwater,EURECArequires around 400m3ofultra-purewaterforonecryostat.Anadditional
tankcapableofstoringtheentirecapacityofwaterfromtheshielding tankwillalsoberequired.
Wewillrequireatwo-stagepurificationprocess.Aschematicof thewaterpurificationplantisshowninFig. 6 .Feedwaterisinitially passedthroughasystemconsistingoffiltrationandreverseosmosis severaltimesbeforeenteringasecondstage.Upto70%ofthe wa-termaybelostduringtheinitialstage.Thesecondstageconsistsof ultrafiltration,electrodeionisationandmembranedegasification,and formspartofthecontinuouspurificationloopwhichwillbe neces-sarytomaintainthecleanlinessofthewater.UVtreatmentand
/
or coolingmayalsobenecessaryduringthesecondstage,tolimit bac-terialgrowthwhichwouldreduceopticaldepth.Forthefirststage purification,afootprintofaround4× 2misenvisaged,dependingFigure 6. Schematicofthewaterpurificationplant.Theabbreviationsare:UF, ultra-filtration;RO,reverseosmosis;EDI,electrodeionisation;andUV,ultraviolet.
onfinaldesign.Thesecondstagemay(againsubjecttofinaldesign) fitintoafootprintofaround6 × 4m.However,ifabuffertankis usedwithinthe(secondstage)purificationloop,anadditionalspace oftheorder10m3maybeneeded.
OfparticularconcernarethelevelsofRninwater.Thisisnotonly forRndaughtersactingasasourceofbackgroundwithinthewater butalsoforthepossibilityofoutgassingofthewaterincreasingtheRn concentrationwithintheairofthecleanroom,whichwillbeattimes opentothewatertank.Borexinousea6-mtall,approximately40-cm diameterRn-strippingcolumn.Waterflowsinonedirection (down-wards),withacounterflowofN2,toachieveaRnlevelof3mBq
/
m3(reductiontothislevelachievedaftermanycyclesthroughthe purifi-cationloop)[20 ].Thefootprintfortheirsystemisabout1×1m.An alternative,asusedbySuperKamiokande,wouldbetouseavacuum degasifierwiththepre-treatmentofRn-reducedairtoincreasethe degasificationefficiency.
FormonitoringtheRnconcentrationinwater,asimilarsystemto thatcurrentlyemployedattheLSMformonitoringRninaircanbe used,whichisbasedonthedesignemployedbySuperKamiokande [21 ].Withthisdetector,waterispassedthroughamembrane degasi-fierallowinggastoflowintoachamberofRn-reducedairwhichis fedintothemonitoraswiththe‘standard’Rn-in-airdetector.Quoted sensitivityisaround1mBq
/
m3ofRninwaterforaone-daymea-surement.Itwouldbebeneficialtohaveatleasttwosuchdetectors; onemonitoringtheRnconcentrationwithinthewatertank,andthe otherattheoutletoftheRndegasificationunit.
Itmaybenecessarytoinstallanadditionalresin-basedRnfilter withinthefirst-stagepurificationprocess.Suchastepwoulddepend onthequalityofthefeedwater,likelydependentonitsorigin.
Aninputflowrateofupto10m3
/
hisforeseenwithrecirculationdependentoncontaminationarisingfromthesystem.
Forthecryostatoutershell,anumberofpossibilitiesexist.Ideally Cuwouldbeused.However,Cu isknownto corrodeindeionised water[22 ],necessitatingapolymer(orother)coating.Hence,PMMA (acrylic,Perspex),asdiscussedinSection 4 ischosenasoutershellfor thecryostat.
Itmaybepossibletousestainlesssteelforthepipework. How-ever,theuseofpolymersispreferredtopreventmetallic contamina-tionwithinthewater.Metallicparticulatescanaidthetransportof bacteria.PVDFandPEarebothfavouredinultrapurewatersystems. Materialscontainingfluorineusedherewouldbesufficientlyfarfrom thedetectorsforittobeofnoconcernwith(
α
,n)reactions.3.3. Cleanrooms
Weplanforatleasttwocleanroomareas,onewithinthewater tankandtheotheratthetopoftheinfrastructuretower.Thelatter willbeusedfordetectorpreparationanditwillbethroughthisthat accesstothewatertankwillbeprovided.Anoptionexistsforhaving eitherthewatertankandthecleanroomastwoseparatecleanrooms, eachwithitsownlow-Rnairsupplyandvent;orhavingtheairsupply tothewatertank,inturnoverpressurisingthecleanroom.Thetwo mustbemechanicallydecoupledtopreventunnecessaryvibration ofthedetector,butalsosealagainsttheoutsidetomaintain cleanli-nesswithin.Additionalcleanroomspacemaybeavailableforgeneral facilityuseelsewherewithintheundergroundlaboratory.
Inadditiontothecleanarea,extraspacemustbeavailablefor changingrooms,andthestorageofbothcleanroomandeveryday clothing.Aclean-offareaandamaterialshatchwillrequirespaceas theywillneedadoubleairlocksystem.
Externaltothecleanroom,spacemustbemadeavailableforthe interfacesbetweeninsideandoutsidethecleanrooms.Provisionmust bemadeforgascylinderplacement,liquidnitrogen(LN2)dewar
stor-age(ifboil-offofLN2istobeusedasapurgegas),andthesupplyand
disposalofwater.
3.3.1. Cleanroomaroundcryostat
Sincethereexistsarequirementforthecryostattobeshielded byultra-purewater,thenthewatertankmustbeconsideredtobea cleanroom.Accesstothecryostatwillbeviathewatertank,initially throughtheadjacentman-tower,theupperfloorofwhichwill func-tionasacleanroom.AlikelycategorywouldbeISO6to7(class1000 to10000,respectively).
Low-Rnaircouldbeintroducedatthetopofthewatertank,further filteredtotherequirementsofthecleanroom.Anoverpressurewill bemaintainedwithinthetank,although theoptionofusing boil-offfromLN2willbeconsideredduringdetectoroperations.Careful
considerationmustbegiventodeadzonesofairwithinthetank.It maybenecessarytopipethecleanairdowntothebottomofthe tankwhilethecryostatisopen.Thewaterwillalreadyhavealow concentrationofRn.
Theentrancefromthecleanroomwillleadontoaplatforminthe tankabovethe levelofthewater. Thisisenvisagedto beasolid structureofstainlesssteel.Twotrapdoorswillbelocatedinthefloor, oneattheedgeprovidingaccesstothebottomofthewatertank;the otherinthecentreallowingaccesstothecryostat.
Acranewillbeincludedwithinthewatertank,likelywithaload limitof1tonne.Thecranewillbeusedformovingshields,andforthe detectortowers.Theminimummovementnecessaryforthecrane willneedtobedefined(fordetectortowerplacement)aswillthe reachofthecrane.Ifaccessisrequiredtothewholevolume, modifi-cationswillbeneededtotheplatformatthetopofthetanktoenable ittobetemporarilymoved.
Spacemustbeavailableforthesixdetectorthermalshields.One optionwouldbetoincludeafloorstageataroundthelevelofthe openingofthecryostat.Adequatedrainagewouldhavetobe consid-ered,e.g.useofagrilledfloor,aswouldaccessofthecrane.
3.3.2. Cleanroomfordetectormountingandpreparation
Thecleanroomlocatedatthetopfloorofthetowerwillbefor detectormountingandpreparation.ThiswillbeaISO7cleanroom containinglaminarflowcabinetsofISO5.
Sincewewillhavemultipletargetmaterials, andthereforethe possibilityofmultiplegroupsworkingwithinonearea,thereshould beatleasttwoofthesededicatedareas.Returnairfromthecleanroom willbepassedtotheinputoftheairhandlingunit,tominimisethe inputoflow-Rnair.
Storageandmountingspacewithinthiscleanroomwillbeneeded forindividualdetectors,thosemountedontobaseplates,andthose
mountedintowers.Consideringthatindividualtowersofdetectors maybeupto1-mlongandupto30-cmdiameter,adequatestorage spaceneedstobeplanned.
Apparatusforcleaningwillbeneeded.Thisincludesanultrasonic bath,aclean(deionisedandfiltered)watersupplyforrinsing,awater disposalroute,fumehoodsandstoragecabinetsforworkwith haz-ardouschemicalsandsolventssuchasdichloromethane,andagas supply.Mainswatercanbeinputtothecleanroom,withsmallscale filteringoccurringtherein.Gascylindersand
/
orLN2dewarscouldbeplacedexternaltothebuildingandgaspipedintothecleanroom. Abuildingofdimensions6 × 8mhasbeenpresentedwithin Section 3.1 .Ifthisprovidesinsufficientfloorspaceforthecleanroom, alternativesofalargerfootprintorpartiallysubmergingthebuilding willbeconsidered.CleanroomoverpressureandHEPA-filteredfans willbeplacedontopofthebuilding.
3.3.3. Radonprevention
222Rn decay leads to deposition of the relatively long-lived
progeny210PbontosurfacesexposedtoRn.210Pbdecaysmainlyby
emission oftwo
β
s andanα
beforereachingthestable206Pb.Inordertoreducethebackgroundtobelowoneevent
/
tonne/
yearin theWIMP-searchregionofinterest(ROI),specialcaremustbetaken toreducesuchdepositionontosurfaceswhichareindirectviewof thedetectorcrystals.Alow-Rnenvironmentmustbesupplied for mountingthedetectorsintotheEURECAcryostat.The222RnlevelinsidethecurrentLSMlaboratoryis10–15Bq
/
m3duetotheventilationsystemsupplyingairfromoutsideofthe
mountainat7000m3
/
h(twolaboratoryvolumesperhour).Low-Rnairisalsosuppliedtoareasofthecurrentlaboratorytoamaximum rateof150m3
/
hwithameasuredconcentrationattheexitofthelow-Rnfacilityoflessthan15mBq
/
m3.Furtherdetailsofthesystemarepresentedin Section 3.1 .AnaverageRnlevelintheproximityof theEDELWEISS-IIcryostatattheLSMoflessthan100mBq
/
m3hasbeenachieved,withairsuppliedfromthissystematarateof0.5m3
/
h.
WeplantouseasimilarRnreductionsystemtothatalreadyin placeasaninputtothecleanroomoverpressurefans.Sincethe re-quiredairflowthroughthecleanroomisinexcessofthelow-Rnair flowbyafactorofaround10,wewillrecyclethelow-Rnairsuch thatthefanfilterunitsdrawairinfromtheroomitself,astandard cleanroompractice.
CalculationshavebeenperformedtoestimatetheamountofRn progenydepositedonasurfaceforgivenexposuretimesand concen-trationsofRn.FurtherdetailsaregiveninAppendix D .Foraninitially cleansurfaceexposedto100mBq
/
m3ofRnfor90days,wewouldexpecttoobtain2.5
α
sand5β
sintheROIpertonneperyearwith arejectionpowerforbothof1.7×104[23 ,24 ].Thisactivityisafac-torof∼10toohigh.PossiblemethodsofreducingtheamountofRn withinthecleanroomtoanacceptablelevelwouldbebyincreasing theflowrateofairthroughtheRntrap,andinstallinguptotwo ad-ditionalcharcoalfilters.Thefinalspecificationsforthisimprovement willbedetailedatalaterstage.The90daysprovidesanexampletime forassemblyofthedetectors.
Withinthewatertank,sourcesofRnmayarisefromthePMTsand stainlesssteelofthetank.Amembranedegassingunit(see[21 ]for anexample)willbeincludedwithinthewaterpurificationcircuitto lowerthelevelofRntobelowtherequired100mBq
/
m3.3.4. ElectromagneticShielding
numbereddocuments.Generalregulationsandgoodpracticeprovide sufficientguidanceforthedesignandimplementationofgeneral ex-perimentinfrastructure.
Specialconsiderationisnecessaryforthespacehousingthe de-tectorsandfront-endelectronicsatthecentreofthecryostat.Here, requirementstypicallygobeyondthegeneralgoodpracticedescribed aboveandaredescribedinmoredetailintherelevantsectionon electronics. Broadly,the detectoraccommodation willneedto be designed andimplementedasa Faradaycage.Inaddition,further shieldingagainstmagneticinterferencemaybecomenecessaryifthis noise contributionis identifiedasbeingtoohigh. Typical sources ofmagneticcontributionsarevacuumandrecirculationpumpsand othermotorsandcompressors.Theseshouldbelocatedatsufficient distancefromthedetectorcompartment.
3.5. Muonvetosystem
Thewatertankhousingthecryostatwillbetheshieldingforany neutronandgammaactivityfromtheconcreteofthelaboratory(see Section 3.6 )andwillactasanactiveshieldforcosmicmuons.Forthat purpose,thewatertankwillbeequippedwithPMTs.Thedetailed parametersofthePMTsetup(e.g.PMTsize,number,position,trigger threshold)willbedefinedinanoptimisingprocessbasedonMC sim-ulations.Theoptimisationprocesswillincludetheexactgeometryof thesupportstructureofthecryostat,theinfrastructureandcabling pipesfromthetankwalltothecryostatandwillexaminedifferent solutionsforthetanksurfacesuchashighlyreflectivefoils.Alikely configurationwillconsist oftheorderof1008-inchencapsulated PMTsfixedonamountingstructureatthetankwall,bottomandtop. AllPMTswillhavetobeleakcheckedtoensurecompatibilitywith longtermuse.Fromfirstsimulations(Section 8.4 ),thesignal thresh-oldcorrespondingtoanenergydepositof0.2GeVhastobeachieved tosuppressanymuon-inducedneutronbackgroundinthebolometer array.
The simulationsshowthat lessthan fivesinglenuclearrecoils inducedbycosmicmuonsareexpectedfora3tonne·yearsexposure. AllthebackgroundeventslinkedtosinglenuclearrecoilsinEURECA crystalsshowenergydeposits
>
0.2GeVinthewatertank.Forsuch energydeposits,anefficiencyfarinexcessof90%istypicalforsuch waterCherenkovvetoes,thusanymuon-inducedsinglenuclearrecoil isexpectedtobevetoed.AsstatedinSection 8.4 ,anupperlimiton theunvetoedsinglenuclearrecoilsis0.3events/
yearassumingan 0.2GeVenergythresholdforthevetosystem.EachPMTwillbesuppliedwithanindividualhighvoltagebased onaHVsystem(MPOD2HLXHV-EXmainframehousing10boards with16or32HVchannelseach)toindividuallyadjustthePMT re-sponse.Calibrationandstability
/
puritycontrolwillbeensuredby laserpulses,movablebulbsandradioactivesources.Severaloptions forthedeadtime-freesignal readoutanddataacquisitionare cur-rentlyunderinvestigation.Themuonvetodatastream(asdigitisedtraces)willbeintegrated intothemaindataacquisitionsystem(seeSection 6 ).
3.6. MonteCarlosimulationsfortheshieldingdesign
Alphaandbetaparticleshaveshortrangeswithinmaterials.The 5-mm-thickcopperscreenswillbesufficient toshieldfromthese sourcesofradiation.
Neutronsandgammas fromrockcanbeefficientlyshieldedby variousmaterials.Asuppressionofgamma-rayandneutronfluxes by aboutsixorders ofmagnitudeis required to reduce the non-discriminatedbackgroundbelowthelevelofdetectorsensitivity.In oursimulationswehaveconsideredbackgroundradiationfromrock andconcreteofthelabwalls. Fig. 7 showstheattenuationofthe gamma-rayfluxfromconcrete beyondthewatershield,asinthe baseline designofEURECA.Ourresultsshowthat3mofwateris
Figure 7. Gamma-rayspectrafromtheThdecaychaincontainedintheconcreteof thelaboratorywallsattenuatedbydifferentthicknessesofwatershielding(givenin metres).
requiredtoattenuatethegamma-rayfluxfromthelabwallssothe remaininggamma-rayinducedbackground(beforediscrimination)in theregionofinterestwillbeabout2000peryearinatonneoftarget. Thisleadstoasizeofthewatertankofabout8mindiameterand8 minheightforatonne-scaleexperiment.With3mofwatershield theneutronfluxfromrockandconcreteofthelabwallswillbe sup-pressedtoalevelwellbelowthedetectorsensitivity.Moredetailsof simulationsaregiveninAppendix F .
4. Cryogenicsandcryostat
4.1. Cryogenics
ThecryogenicsolutionforcoolingEURECAispresentedinthis section.Table 3 summarisestheaimsofthecoolingsystem.
Table 3
BaselinedesignfortheEURECAcryostatandcryogenics.
Cryogenicsandcryostat
Basetemperature 7mK Coolingpoweratbasetemperature 20μW
Cooldowntime 20daystobasetemperature Cryostatsize 2mdiameter,2mheight Coldvolume 1.5mdiameter,1.5mheight
ThebasetemperaturetobeprovidedbytheEURECAcryogenic systemwillbe7mKtocooladetectormassof1t.Detectorsequipped withNTD-Gesensorscanoperatewithexcellentsensitivityat20mK; but10mKoperatingtemperature(withmargin)isrequiredforthe operationofCaWO4detectors,equippedwithtransitionedgesensors
(TESs).ThecriticaltemperatureoftungstenTESsisaround 15mK withaspreadofafewmK.Forreliablestabilisationoftheoperating temperatureforTESs,abasetemperatureof10mKisrequiredatthe detectorholders,andthus7mKisspecifiedasthebasetemperature forthecryogenicsystem.
Thislowtemperaturewillbecreatedby adilutionrefrigerator (DR).Circulatedlow-temperaturegaswithintheDRcircuitwill fur-thercooltwointermediatelow-temperaturestages:aheatintercept at50mKandathermalshieldat500mK.Additionalthermal shield-ingwillbemaintainedat1.8Kand60KbyaHerefrigerator,which willalsoprovidepre-coolingtoallcryogeniccomponentsduringthe firststageofcool-down.Adiagramofthecryogeniccircuitisshown inFig. 8 .
Figure 8. DiagramofthecryogenicsystemforEURECA.Numbereditemsreferto:1, pressurisedgaseousheliumcoolingloop;2,pre-coolingheliumloop;3,liquidhelium supply;4,superfluidheliumsupply;5,pumpingline(16mbar,returnfromClaudet bath);6,dilution3Hepumpingline(return);7,dilution3Hesupply.
polarisationof3He[25 ]andwiththecurrentdesignoftheCUORE
cryostat[26 ].AfeasibilitystudyonthedesignoftheEURECAdilution refrigeratorhasbeencarriedoutwithintherecentdesignstudyfor EURECA[27 ].
Basedoncompletedstudies [17 ,27 ,28 ] ourdesignincludesthe followingfeatures:
• Athermalshieldbelowroomtemperatureat60K;thethermal loadisdrivenbytheradiativeloadfromroomtemperature;the coolingpowerisprovidedbyapressurisedheliumloop.
• A1.8Klevel,cooledbyapressurisedsuperfluidheliumlinkin ordertominimisethemircro-vibrations(avoidingboilinghelium); theheatloadisdrivenby theconductionfromthesupporting strutsandcabling,andtheheatingintroducedbytheelectronics front-end.
• Thedilutionrefrigeratorisoptimisedtominimisetheconductive loadonthecoldeststage:
- Aclosed500mKshieldinterceptsthebulkoftheconductive loadfromstructuralelementsandthedetectorwiring. - Anintermediate50mKstagelimitstheconductiveloadson
thelaststage.
- Anenclosureofthedetectorcompartmentat10mK.
• Low-temperaturedilutionrefrigeratorcomponentsarelocatedin acommoncoldboxwiththeHerefrigerator(i.e.thestillandthe
3Hepre-cooling).
Forcomparison,theCUOREexperiment[29 ,30 ]hasasimilar re-quirementforthecoolingof1tofdetectorswithacoolingpower of5
μ
Wat12mK.CUOREusesseveral40-Kand4-Kcryo-coolersto establishanumberofintermediatestages.FortheEURECAdesign,we decidedagainsttheuseofcryo-coolerstominimisepotentialissues withvibrations.Inaddition,theEURECAsolutionofusinga combi-nationofaHerefrigeratorandadilutionrefrigeratorisfavouredfor reasonsoffastcool-downandhighefficiency.4.1.1. Requirements
Themaindriversforthecryogenicdesignare:
• Abasetemperatureof7mKforadetectortemperatureof10mKis chosenfordetectorsensitivity.Thelargecoolingpower(20
μ
W) isdrivenbytheestimatedthermalrelaxationprocessinthepure copperusedforpartofthelow-backgroundshielding.• Acoldspacevolumeofupto1.5-mdiameterand1.5-mheight toaccommodate1tofdetectors,andinternalshieldingagainst radioactivity.
• An allocation of cooling power at a temperature
<
4 K for theSQUID-basedcoldelectronics,orotherfront-endelectronics (1.5Watthe1.8-Kstage).• Materialselectionforthecryogenicpartsinsideexternal shield-ing.
• Minimisationofthevibrationsexportedfromthecryogenic equip-ment,i.e.thecompressorsandpumps,thefluids’circulationand phasechanges.
• Lifetimeoftheequipmentlongerthan20years,withtypical mea-surementperiods
>
1year.• Acool-downtime
<
5daystoreach1Kandafurther<
15daysto reachoperationalconditions.4.1.2. Overallcryogenicsystem
Thecryogenicsystemiscomposedoffivemainelements,which arethecryostat,containingthedetectors,acryo-line,throughwhich thecoolingtothecryostatisprovided,acoldbox,housingcryogenics, aDRandaHerefrigerator.
Thecryostatwillcontainthedetectorsmountedbelowthemixing chamber,withfront-endelectronicsmountedabove.Thecryo-line connectsthecryostat,placedwithinthewatertank,tothecoldbox. Ourdesignisbasedonatotalallowablelengthofthecryo-lineof20m, althoughtheaimistokeeptheoveralllengthbelow10mtoreduce heatandpressurelosses,andtherequiredamountof3He.Further
detailsaregivenbelow.
4.1.3. Heliumrefrigerator
The He refrigeratorwillprovide cooling ofthe thermalstages at60Kand1.8K,andwillalsobeusedfortheinitialpre-cooling ofthecolderstages.Coolingofthe60Kshieldwillbeachievedwith Hegasat40K,pressurisedto7-15bar.Asanexample,aflowof20g
/
s (5mol/
s)withatemperatureelevationof20Kgivesacoolingpower of2200W.For the 1.8-K stage, a direct Joule-Thomson expansion of He to16mbarwillcreatea1.8-Kbath.Thiswillbecombinedwitha Claudetbath(seeAppendix E.1 )toprovidepressurisedsuperfluidHe (HeII)tothecryostatat1.25bar.TheuseoftheClaudetbathstops microphonicnoiseproducedbyHeboilingwithinthepipe.Acooling powerof10WextractedfromtheHeIIheatpipecreatesan evapora-tionrateof0.05g
/
s/
W(0.013mol/
s/
W).Thisflowislowcompared tothe40-Kcoolingloop,allowingtohaveadirectextractionofthe 1.8-Kvapourswithoutcirculationintheregenerativeheat exchang-ers.AsmallcommercialHerefrigerator,withmodifications,isan op-timalsolutionfortheEURECAcoolingsystem.Thesmallestliquefiers availablefromthemainmanufacturersprovide100Wat4K[31 ], whichisneededforcoolingdowntoatemperatureof4Kwithin about4days.Further,ithassufficientcoolingcapacityduring nor-malrunning.At1.8Kthecoolingpoweristypicallyaquarterofthat at4K.Twoweeksofcoolingareexpectedforreachingoperational conditions.IncorporatingsuchaHerefrigeratorintothecooling sys-temallowssimplificationofthethermalarchitectureofthesystem throughaccessofcoolingstageswithintherefrigeratorandlinking themdirectlytocorrespondingshieldsandstageswithintheEURECA cryostat.
TheHerefrigeratorconsistsofa5m3gastankfortheclosedcycle 4Hestorage,acompressorandpumps.Theseitemswillbeplaced
atasignificantdistancefromthedetectorstolimitnoisegenerated bythehighlevelofvibration,particularlyfromthecompressor.The onlylimitisthepumpingspeedforthelow-pressureflows(1.8-KHe bathanddilutionstill).Additionalitemsincludeheatexchangers,two gas-bearingturboexpanders,aJoule-Thomsonvalveandthecontrol system,allcontainedwithinthecoldbox.
AsuitableunitisamodifiedHELIALMLseriesfridge, manufac-turedbyAir Liquide[31 ].Thisdraws75kWatfullpower,during cool-down,reducingto50kWunderpartloadoncethesystemis attheoperationaltemperature.Anadditionalpumpwillberequired forthe1.8KHe IIwithin theClaudet bath.The compressoris of dimensions2225 × 1960 × 1885mm3,andrequiresadedicated
about7m3isneededwithinthecoldboxfortheitemsrelatedtothe
Herefrigerator.
WiththemodifiedHerefrigerator,thefastcoolingphasecanbe managedentirely by thissystemusingthe samecompressor and pumps.ThecoldboxoftheHerefrigeratorcanalsoaccommodate severalelementsoftheDR:the3Hepre-coolingandthestill.
Com-paredtosmallercryocoolers,thethermodynamiccycleofaliquefier (theClaudecycle)is∼10timesmoreefficient.TheClaudetbath, com-binedwithafastcool-downto1.8K,isthemainjustificationtousea smallHerefrigerator,derivedfromaliquefierdesign.
AnexampleofaHerefrigeratorcoupledwithacryostatwitha superfluidthermallinkistheNeuroSpincryogenicsystem[32 ].More detailsofthissystemareprovidedinAppendix E.1 .
4.1.4. Dilutionrefrigerator
TheDRcoolsthreeprogressivelycolderstagesat500 mK,50mK and7mK.It iscomposed ofa gashandlingunit (placedwiththe compressoroftheHerefrigerator),aheatexchangerandstillwithin thecoldbox,andthemixingchamberlocatedwithinthecryostat.
Due tothe20
μ
W coolingpower requirementcombinedwith thelowtemperatureof7mK,theperformanceofthedilution re-frigeratordependscriticallyonthepropertiesofthesintered mate-rialusedforthediscretecounter-flowheatexchangers.Theclassical choiceistousesinteredAgheatexchangers.However,commercialAg powdersareknowntoexhibitradioactivityincompatiblewith low-backgroundrequirements.PowerconsumptionbytheDRislikelyto beupto20kWduringcool-down,estimatedtobe15daysfor1t ofdetectormaterial,startingfromatemperatureof1.8K.Thiswill reduceto10kWduringlow-temperatureoperation.AdesignbasedonsinteredCuhasbeentestedforEURECA[17 ], showing10cm3ofsinteredCuisnecessarytoachievethe
require-ments.Examplesareshownin Appendix E.2 .Basedontheseresults weconcludethattheEURECAthermalrequirementsarewellwithin thestate-of-the-art.Theprocurementofcommercialpowderand de-tailsofthesinteringprocesswillbedefinedandcharacterizedduring thetechnicaldesignforEURECA.
Severalcommercialpowdershavebeenidentifiedandthe follow-ingpropertieswillbestudiedbeforethefinaldecisiononpurchasing thepowderismade:
• Porositycharacterisation,optimisationofthesinteringprocess. • MeasurementoftheKapitzaresistance.
• Measurementoftheradioactivitylevel.
4.2. Powerbudgetanddetectortowerthermalrequirements
Theestimatedthermalloadonbothstagesisgivenin Table 22 . Atthisstageofthedesign,comfortablemarginsforcoolingpower (
>
100%)havebeenincluded.Table 4 summarisesthecoolingpowers andtheirrequiredgasflowsforthedifferenttemperaturestages.The3Heisotope molarflowisdrivenbythecoolingpower
re-quirementonthelowesttemperaturestage(10mK).Theestimation givenhereincludesa100%margin.Thecontributionstoeachstage areshowninmoredetailinTables22 and23inAppendix E.3 .
EURECAdetectorswillbemountedinarraysoftowerswhichwill beheatsunktoeachofthetemperaturestages.Thedesignfiguresfor thedifferentstagesofthetowersareat75 K,3 K,700 mK,60mK and10mK.The powerbudgetateachstagebothonthe cooling-systemsideandthedetectorsideisshownin Table 5 withfurther detailsofthecontributiontothe10mKstagelistedinAppendix E.3 . Contributionstotheheatloadarefromdissipationofthereadout electronics,dissipationandheatreleaseinthedetectors,and con-ductionthroughthewiring,neglectingtheradiativeloadfromthe detectortowers.Section 5.3 providesdetailsconcerningthe mount-ingofdetectorswithintowers.
Figure 9. EURECAcryostatsketchshowingthethermalshields,Cu,PEandPMMA shieldingagainstradioactivityandotherelements.Oneexampleofatop-loading de-tectortowerisshown.ThecryogeniclineconnectstheHerefrigeratorwiththedilution refrigeratorthroughseveralcoolingloops.
4.3. Cryostatdesign
Adetaileddesignforthecryostatwillbecarriedoutforthe Tech-nicalDesignReport.Herewepresentaconceptofthecryostat em-phasisingonlyitsmainfeatures.
4.3.1. Mainfeatures
Thecryostatwillbeinstalledwithinahigh-puritywatertank.The variouscryogenicstagesarethermallylinkedtotheHerefrigerator anddilutionrefrigeratorthroughacryo-line.
Inadditiontotheoutervacuumcontainer(OVC)atambient tem-perature,thermalshieldsareplacedattemperaturesof60 K,1.8 K, 500 mK,50mKand10mK. Fig. 9 showsaschematicofthe cryo-statcrosssection.TheHerefrigeratorprovidescoolingforthe60K and1.8Kstagesinadditiontotherequiredcoolingpowerforthe readoutelectronics,operatingatatemperatureofaround100K.The detectorvolumeisprotectedbycopper,polyethylene(PE)andacrylic (PMMA)shielding.Thecold-plate,operatingatthebasetemperature of10mKisonepartofthecoppershielding.Thebulkofthecopper shielding,aswellasthePEandPMMAwillbethermallyconnected tothe50mKtemperaturelevel.Thecoolingpowerforthedetector towersisprovidedbyconductionthroughthecold-plateontowhich thecoolingelementswillbemounted.Around10cm3ofsintered
materialwillbeusedtocouplethecold-platetothelowtemperature Hemixture.
The60Kshieldlimitstheheattransfertothe1.8Kstageand pro-videsalargecoolingpowerforthereadoutelectronics.Itisactively cooledbyhighpressuregaseousHesuppliedat40K,atupto15bar. Themainthermalloadistheradiationfromthe300Kexternalwall. Thetemperaturegradientalongtheshieldisanissuetobeconsidered tocontrolthethermalloadatthe1.8Kstage.Twooptionsare consid-ered:eitherasinglewallcooledbyaheatexchangermountedalong thecylindricalpartoftheshield,oradouble-walledstagecooledby thecold-plate.
Table 6 presentsanoverviewofalltemperaturestagesofthe cryo-stat.FiguresfortheheatbalancearepresentedinTable 7 .Calculations forTable 7 assumeanemissivityofthecoppershieldsof10%,which isaconservativevalueforuncoatedpurecopper.Theexternalwall (PMMA)hasanemissivityof100%.
4.3.2. Cryostatmechanicalinfrastructure