DESIGN A NEW BIONIC ARM TO ASSISTS PARALYZE ARM
BURHANUDDIN BIN ABDUL MAJID
A report submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Bachelor in Mechatronics Engineering
Faculty of Electrical Engineering
UNIVERSITI TEKNIKAL MALAYSIA MELAKA
“I hereby declared that I have read through this report entitled “Design a new bionic arm to assists paralyze arm” and found that it has comply he partial fulfilment for awarding the degree of Bachelor of Mechatronic Engineering”
Signature : ...
Supervisor’s Name : ...
I declare that this report entitle “Design a new bionic arm to assists paralyze arm” is the result of my own research except as cited in the references. The report has not been accepted for any degree and is not concurrently submitted in candidature of any other degree.
Signature : ...
Name : ...
ABSTRACT
Based on the statistic, stroke is one of the largest killers in Malaysia only after heart
disease and cancer where an estimated 40,000 people in Malaysia suffer from this type of
disease. Another statistic shows 12 to 53 new spinal injuries per million inhabitants in the
developed countries per year. These injuries lead to disability of human body parts including
paralyzed arm. In order to assist paralyzed arm sufferers, studies have been conducted to
improvise the development of bionic arms. Based on the problem statement, previous studies
on bionic arm had some limitation to users. Moreover, previous study has also shown that the
design of bionic arms is lacking in engineering characteristic. The objectives of this project are
to derive the mathematical model of bionic arm using kinematic analysis and formulate joint
torque and to design and validate the bionic arm in term of structural strength and torque. This
proposed motion study is to provide opportunity and benefit for the patient who are suffering
from paralyzed arm. Next, the methodology of the project started with kinematic analysis and
mathematical model of bionic arm and validation by Robotics Toolbox MATLAB Software.
Then, the formulate joint torque of bionic arm by static forces in manipulator is analysed. After
that, the bionic arm was designed and analyzed by SolidWorks simulation. Finally, Maximum
torque was simulated by SolidWorks Motion. As the result, the joint angle configuration on
kinematics calculation and MATLAB Simulation both have obtained[1,0,0],[−1,0,0], [0,−1,0]
and [0.5,0.5,0]. Then, SolidWorks Simulation obtained factor of safety, where the value is 34
and 14 for whole part testing and 772, 155, 4, 1273, 15 and 8 for by part testing. After that, the
calculated result of formulate torque is 19.14Nm, 19.14Nm, 11.05Nm, 4.458Nm and 4.458Nm.
Meanwhile, the results of SolidWorks Motion are 66.75Nm, 66.31Nm, 37.71Nm, 0.04Nm and
5.22 for dynamic motion method and 66.94Nm, 66.27Nm, 37.78Nm, 0.04Nm, and 5.21Nm for
static motion method. For the conclusion, the derived kinematic model for bionic arm has been
validated by MATLAB Simulation. Then, all analyzed structure strength parts are safe. Finally,
ABSTRAK
Berdasarkan statistik, strok merupakan pembunuh nombor satu di Malaysia selepas sakit
jantung dan barah dimana dianggarkan 40,000 rakyat Malaysia menghidap penyakit ini. Statistic
lain menunjukkan 12 dari 53 kecederaan tulang belakang setiap sejuta penghuni di negara
membangun setiap tahun. Kecederaan ini telah menyumbang kepada kecacatan bahagian tubuh
badan termasuklah ketidakupayaan tangan. Untuk membantu pengidap ketidakupayaan tangan,
kajian telah dilakukan untuk memperbaiki pembangunan tangan bionik. Berdasarkan penyataan
masalah, kajian lepas terhadap tangan bionic mempunyai keterbatasan terhadap pengguna.
Tambahan pula, kajian lepas juga telah menunjukkan reka bentuk tangan bionic kekurangan
ciri-ciri kejuruteraan. Objektif projek ini adalah untuk menerbitkan model matematik tangan
bionik menggunakan analisis kinematik dan memformulasi sendi daya kilas dan untuk mereka
bentuk dan mengesahkan model tangan bionik dari sudut struktur kekuatan dan daya kilas.
Sasaran kajian ini adalah menyediakan peluang dan kebaikan untuk pesakit yang mengidap
ketidakupayaan tangan. Seterusnya, metodologi projek telah bermula dengan analisis kinematik
dan model matematik tangan bionik dan telah disahkan oleh perisian Robotics Toolbox
MATLAB. Kemudian, memformulasikan daya kilas tangan bionik dengan daya statik dalam
manipulator. Selepas itu, tangan bionik telah direka bentuk dan dianalisis dengan simulasi
SolidWorks. Akhirnya daya kilas maksimum telah disimulasikan dengan SolidWorks Motion.
Dan keputusannya, kedua-dua konfigurasi sudut sendi pada pengiraan kinematik dan simulasi
MATLAB telah mendapat [1,0,0],[−1,0,0], [0,−1,0] and [0.5,0.5,0]. Kemudian, keputusan
simulasi SolidWork telah mendapat darjah keselamatan diamana nilainya 34 dan 14 untuk ujian
keseluruhan bahagian dan 772, 155, 4, 1273, 15 dan 8 untuk ujian separuh bahagian. Selepas
itu, keputusan yang telah dikira untuk memformulasi daya kilas adalah 19.14Nm, 19.14Nm,
11.05Nm, 4.458Nm and 4.458Nm. Manakala keputusan SolidWorks Motion 66.75Nm,
66.31Nm, 37.71Nm, 0.04Nm dan 5.22 untuk kaedah pegerakan dinamik dan 66.94Nm,
66.27Nm, 37.78Nm, 0.04Nm, dan 5.21Nm untuk pegerakan statik. Kesimpulannya, model
Kemudian, semua struktur kekuatan yang telah dianalisis adalah selamat. Akhirnya, jenis motor
ACKNOWLEDGE
While preparing this report, I was in gained many sources of important information
especially lecturers, academicians, researchers and beloved friends. Their sharing of knowledge,
information and explanations have contributed a lot towards my understanding and thought
through this project. I would like to express my thousands of gratitude and appreciation to my
supervisor, Mr. Mohd Bazli Bin Bahar (final year project 2) and Mr. Nur Latif Azyze Bin Mohd
Shaari Azyze (final year project 1) who is the biggest contribution in guiding me during the
preparation of this report. I am also very thankful to my parents Ustaz Abdul Majid and Ustazah
Noraziah, for back support for my journey in UTeM. Not forget to my brother, sister, classmates
and also housemate who also involved in providing support, advice and motivation to me.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE
ABSTRACT i
TABLE OF CONTENTS v
LIST OF TABLES x
LIST OF FIGURES xi
LIST APPENDICES xv
1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Project Background 1
1.2 Motivation 2
1.3 Problem Statement 3
1.4 Objectives 4
1.5 Scope 4
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE
2 LITERATURE REVIEW 5
2.1 Introduction 5
2.2 Limb 6
2.3 Kinematic 7
2.4 Actuators 11
2.5 Sensor 13
2.6 Power Transmission 15
2.7 Material 18
2.8 Ergonomics 20
2.9 Microcontroller 21
2.10 Conclusion 22
3 METHODOLOGY 23
3.1 Introduction 23
3.2 method of research 25
3.3 K-chart 25
3.4 project assumption 26
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE
3.6 Kinematic analysis and mathematical model of bionic arm 29
3.6.1 Forward kinematics 30
3.6.2 Inverse kinematics 31
3.6.3 Kinematics validation by using Robotics Toolbox
MATLAB Software
33
3.6.3.1 Determining the position and orientation of the
end-effector of bionic arm manipulator
33
3.6.3.2 Study the workspace of the kinematic of bionic
arm.
34
3.7 Formulate joint torque of bionic arm. 34
3.7.1 Static forces in manipulator 35
3.8 The Bionic Arm design by using SolidWorks 36
3.9 Finite element analysis of the bionic arm by SolidWorks
simulation
37
3.9.1 Whole part testing 37
3.9.2 By part testing 39
3.9 Maximum torque analysis by SolidWorks Motion 47
3.9.1 Introduction 47
3.9.2 List motor to be examine 49
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE
3.9.4 Static motion 50
4 RESULT 51
4.1 Introduction 51
4.2 Kinematic analysis and mathematical model of bionic arm 51
4.2.1 Forward Kinematics 52
4.2.2 Inverse kinematics 55
4.2.3 Kinematics validation by Robotics Toolbox
MATLAB Software
58
4.3 Torque joint 62
4.4 The bionic arm design by SolidWorks Software 68
4.5 Finite element analysis of the bionic arm by SolidWorks
simulation
69
4.5.1 Whole part testing 69
4.5.2. By part testing 75
4.6 Maximum torque analysis by SolidWorks Motion 93
4.6.1 Dynamic motion testing 93
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE
5 DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS 103
5.1 Introduction 103
5.2 Kinematic Analysis And Mathematical Model Of Bionic
Arm
103
5.3 Design And Finite Element Analysis Of Bionic Arm Model 104
5.4 Formulate Torque And Torque Analysis Of Bionic Arm 107
6 CONCLUSION 109
REFERENCES 112
APPANDICES A 117
APPANDICES B 119
APPANDICES C 129
APPANDICES D 131
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE TITLE PAGE
2.1 Comparison between actuator used by previous studies. 12
2.2 Comparison between sensors used by previous studies. 14
2.3 Comparison between power transmissions used by previous
studies.
18
2.4 Comparison between materials used by previous studies. 19
3.1 percentages of segment length and body mass 27
4.1 D-H table of bionic arm 53
4.2 percentages of segment length and body mass 63
5.1 Joint angle configuration of bionic arm manipulator 104
5.2 properties of material 105
5.3 Stress and FOS of bionic arm from whole part method 105
5.4 Stress and FOS of bionic arm from by part method 106
5.5 Maximum torque of bionic arm 107
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE TITLE PAGE
2.1 Degree of freedom (DOF) of arm 7
2.2 D-H parameters and link frame assignments for the entire
manipulator.
8
2.3 Kinematic and manipulator of L-Exos. 9
2.4 Kinematic model of MAHI exoskeleton. 10
2.5 Mechanical structure of ARMin 16
2.6 Upper arm rotary module 16
2.7 Operation of cable transmission with motor 17
2.8 Structure of WOTAS support. 20
3.1 Flow chart of the project 24
3.2 K-Chart of bionic arm 26
3.3 Degree of freedom (DOF) of arm 30
3.4 Free body diagram of arm. 35
3.5 Complete two dimensional drawing of bionic arm 36
FIGURE TITLE PAGE
3.7 Horizontal position of The Bionic Arm 38
3.8 Vertical position of separate part of the bionic arm 39
3.9 Vertical position of the part 1 40
3.10 Vertical position of the part 2 41
3.11 Vertical position of the part 3 42
3.12 Horizontal position of separate part of the bionic arm 43
3.13 Horizontal position of the part 1 44
3.14 Horizontal position of the part 2 45
3.15 Horizontal position of the part 3 46
3.16 Bionic arm for SolidWorks Motion analysis 48
4.1 Manipulator of bionic arm 52
4.2 the plane of the Manipulator of bionic arm 57
4.3 plot joint angle configuration for [0° 0° 0° 0° 0°] 58
4.4 plot joint angle configuration for [0° 0° 180° 0° 0°] 59
4.5 plot joint angle configuration for [0° 0° 90° 0° 0°] 60
4.6 plot joint angle configuration for [90° 90° -90° -90° -90°] 61
4.7 workspace of manipulator of bionic arm 61
FIGURE TITLE PAGE
4.9 Complete design of bionic arm 68
4.10 Displacement result of vertical bionic arm 69
4.11 Strain result of vertical bionic arm 70
4.12 Stress result of vertical bionic arm 71
4.13 Strain result of horizontal bionic arm 72
4.14 Strain result of horizontal bionic arm 73
4.15 Stress result of horizontal bionic arm 74
4.16 Strain result of Part 1 75
4.17 Displacement result of part 1 76
4.18 Stress result of part 1 77
4.19 Strain result of Part 2 78
4.20 Displacement result of part 2 79
4.21 Stress result of part 2 80
4.22 Displacement result of Part 3 81
4.23 Stress result of part 3 82
4.24 Strain result of part 3 83
4.25 Strain result of Part 1 84
4.26 Displacement result of Part 1 85
FIGURE TITLE PAGE
4.28 Stress result of Part 2 87
4.29 Displacement result of part 2 88
4.30 Strain result of part 2 89
4.31 Strain result of Part 3 90
4.32 Displacement result of part 3 91
4.33 Stress result of part 3 92
4.34 Motor 1 torque result for dynamic motion 93
4.35 Motor 2 torque result for dynamic motion 94
4.36 Motor 3 torque result for dynamic motion 95
4.37 Motor 4 torque result for dynamic motion 96
4.38 Motor 5 torque result for dynamic motion 97
4.39 Motor 1 torque result for static motion 98
4.40 Motor 2 torque result for static motion 99
4.41 Motor 3 torque result for static motion 100
4.42 Motor 4 torque result for static motion 101
LIST OF APPENDICES
APPENDIX TITLE PAGE
A Bionic arm kinematic MATLAB coding 117
B Bionic Arm Drawing and Dimension 119
C Harmonic Drive RSF-20A Datasheet 129
D Maxon EC 45 Flat Datasheet 131
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Project Background
Recently, a lot of researchers are developing artificial arm which can closely resemble
the function of a human arm. Bionic arm is applicable to various field such as the military and
medical. In the medical field, this technology is mostly applied to help patients who are suffering
from paralyzed arm resulted from stroke, upper limb injury and old age factor. These inabilities
may cause inconveniences for them to perform daily routines. There are various types of bionic
arm. Many research were conducted to improve on the development of bionic arm. A bionic
arm is a complex piece of engineering. It requires deep understanding of the knowledge and
process to successfully build a bionic arm. In order to help patients with paralyzed arm, the study
of bionic arm is introduced. The motion study of a new bionic arm design to assist patients with
paralyzed arm was proposed to overcome and improve the situation for real life application.
Hopefully, this will help to improve the life of the sufferer, provide more comfort and ease their
daily activities. The bionic arm also is designed to be ergonomic so that the users of the bionic
1.2 Motivation
Bionic engineering is a method to study the living system with the intention to apply the
principles to the design of an engineering system. The bionic arm is used in the medical field as
a rehabilitation robot. The users are able to improve the movements and functions of their arm
using this bionic arm.
Based on the National Stroke Association of Malaysia (Nasam) statistic, stroke is one of
the largest killers in Malaysia only after heart diseases and cancer. At another edge, stroke is
one of the contributors to severe disability, and year by year an expected 40,000 people in
Malaysia suffer from this disease. In the year 2005 alone, 17909 stroke sufferers were admitted
into public hospitals all over the country. By the year of 2020, this statistic is expected to rise to
25,000 per year. On top of that, a study conducted by Dr. Tan Chong Tin, the senior consultant
at the neurology clinic of University Malaya Medical Center suggested that 70% of stroke
patients who recuperated from stroke stopped taking parts in social activities, 30% are in need
of assistance and 15% passed away within a month. [1]
According to The Neurosurgical Association of Malaysia (NAM), there are 12 to 53 new
spinal discomfort per million inhabitants in the developed countries per year. At a certain time
in the United States only, 721 to 906 people are suffering from spinal cord injury per million
populations. The new spinal cord injury is predicted to increase in Malaysia. For instance, in the
Neurosurgical service in Sarawak General Hospital, a case of spine injury is reported every
month for patients with head injury. These patients usually are young and a ratio of two thirds
of these happen to a person less than 30 years of age. However, it varies from country to country.
About 20 to 57 percent of people diagnosed with spinal cord injury have injuries elsewhere. [2]
1.3 Problem Statement
Some patients who are suffering from stroke, injury on the upper limb, and some older
patients are unable to move their arm and hand normally. This problem causes limitations for
patients to perform their daily activities as they cannot move their upper limb properly.
Therefore, the need for a new motion study to design bionic arm as assistive technology to
overcome the problem is vital. This study may be beneficial for patients who lost abilities to
move their arm by providing more comfort, convenience, and self-reliability in their daily life.
Previously, the design and functions of a bionic arm were limited. For instance, many of
the bionic arms only function as an assisting tool for rehabilitation therapy. The patients mainly
used the bionic arm during therapy sessions, but they did not always wear it all day long to
perform daily routines at home. Thus, it is vital that the design for this new bionic arm serves
not only for therapy purposes, but is also used to assist patients in moving their hand just like a
healthy person all day long.
Other than the aforementioned disadvantages, the design of previous bionic arms were
lacking in engineering characteristics such as the absence of ergonomics implementation on
bionic arm. Consequently, it caused injury, discomfort, and was unsafe to the user of bionic arm.
Other than that, previous bionic arms were also not portable as it was attached to the wheelchair
or it was too big and heavy to carry, thus limiting the mobility of the user. In order to overcome
1.4 Objective
The objective this project are:
1. To derive the mathematical model of bionic arm using kinematic analysis and
formulate joint torque.
2. To design and validate the bionic arm in term of structural strength and torque.
1.5 Scope
This project will focus on supporting system of an 80kg able-bodied user suffering with
the disability to move the arm. The bionic arm is design to be an exoskeleton robot where it will
be actuated by an electrical actuator available on the market. In this project, the kinematics of
the bionic arm manipulator will be derived. Besides, the exoskeleton arm will be designed in
three dimensions by using SolidWorks Software. Apart from that, the upper limb exoskeleton
will be analyzing the performance of the bionic arm in term the structural strength and torque
requirement.
1.6 Project Significance
This proposed motion study of a new bionic arm design to assist paralyzed arm will
provide opportunities and benefits for patients who are suffering from paralyzed arm especially
those resulted from stroke and spinal cord injury. This study may improve on previous bionic
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
This chapter is dedicated for preliminary reviews for the research method of bionic arms
making approach. The literature review will clarify sustainability associated with this research
study. This chapter will review exoskeleton as mechanism in bionic arm robot. Then, the
anatomy of the upper limb is discussed thoroughly. Next, the explanations of actuators, sensors,
power transmission, material, ergonomics mechanism, and microcontroller are clearly discussed
throughout this chapter.
2.1 Introduction
According to the American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Bionic is
defined as the Application of biological principles to the study and design of engineering
systems, especially electronic systems. [3] Referring to the Oxford Advance Learner’s
Dictionary, exoskeleton is defined as a hard outer covering that protects the bodies of certain
animals. [4] Exoskeleton robots are an actuated skeleton-like, external supportive structure
robots applied to human. There are many functions of exoskeleton such as, extending or
powering human performance as applied in military equipment or rehabilitation process of
contact with an illusionary physical environment or object. These haptic devices are usually
referred to as kinesthetic interfaces. Other possible applications are in gaming and advanced
fitness equipment. [5] Exoskeleton robots are also applied in training human motor skills. For
example, it is used in the rehabilitation of arm functionality or gait after a stroke. [5]
2.2 Limb
Limb is a jointed or prehensile, appendage of human body. The limb is divided into the
upper and the lower limb. In human anatomy, the upper and lower limbs are commonly referred
as the arms and the legs. According to Basic Human Anatomy website, a lower limb has four
major parts: a girdle formed by the hip bones, the thigh, the leg, and the foot. Its main function
is to support the weight of the body, adapting to gravity, and locomotion. As for the lower limb,
it is customary to include regions that are transitional between the limb and the trunk, especially
the gluteal and inguinal regions. [6] The human upper limb can be separated into shoulder joint,
upper arm, elbow joint, forearm, wrist joint and hand. The upper arm is linked to the torso by
the shoulder joint. Then, the forearm is connected to the upper arm through the elbow joint, and
forearm and the hand link the wrist joint. The human upper limb can be simplified as a spatial
linkage mechanism composed of several rigid links connected through revolute pairs according
to the human anatomy and mechanisms. The skeletons are links, and the revolute pairs represent
the joints. The upper limb consists of seven main independent degree of freedom, and they are
the shoulder flexion and extension movement, the shoulder abduction and adduction movement,
the shoulder medial and lateral rotation movement, the elbow flexion and extension movement,
the forearm pronation and supination movement, the wrist flexion and extension movement, the
wrist abduction and adduction. [7] And the kinematical model of the human upper limb is shown