• No results found

Early gene expression of adenovirus type 2: R-loop mapping of mRNA and time course of viral DNA, mRNA, and protein synthesis.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2019

Share "Early gene expression of adenovirus type 2: R-loop mapping of mRNA and time course of viral DNA, mRNA, and protein synthesis."

Copied!
12
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

JOURNAL OF VIROLOGY, Mar. 1977, p. 1019-1030 Copyright© 1977 AmericanSociety for Microbiology

Vol.21,No.3

Printed in U.S.A.

Early Gene Expression of Adenovirus

Type

2:

R-Loop

Mapping of mRNA and Time Course of Viral DNA, mRNA,

and

Protein

Synthesis

PAUL D. NEUWALD,' JURG MEYER,2 JACOB V. MAIZEL, JR., AND HEINER WESTPAHL* Laboratory of Molecular Genetics, National Institute of Child Health andHumanDevelopment, Bethesda,

Maryland20014

Received for publication20July 1976

Adenovirus type 2 DNA was hybridized to early mRNA isolated from the cytoplasm ofinfected cellsprior totheinitiationof viral DNA synthesis.

Result-ing Rloops were visualized in the electronmicroscope, andtheir positions were

oriented with the help of DNA fragments generated by digestion with the

restriction endonuclease Bam HI. Early RNA was found to map (in order of

relative R-loop frequency) with midpoints near positions 0.95, 0.80, 0.03, 0.65,

and 0.09 on the conventional adenovirus map. The time of appearance of

individual viral mRNA's was comparedto the time course of viral protein and

DNAsynthesis. Wepresent a refined map ofadenovirusgenefunctions which is basedonresultsdocumented inthisand the accompanying study by Meyer et al.

(1977), aswell as ondata publishedby otherlaboratories.

Theintricatecontrol systemof initial

adeno-virus type 2 (Ad2) gene expression assigns a

number ofearly viral functions to individual classes of mRNA, transcribed from distinct

re-gionsof the genome (5, 7) which comprise

non-contiguous parts of either viral DNA strand

(32, 38). At least six polypeptides of different

electrophoretic mobilities, specified by these

RNAs, have been observed in extracts of

in-fected cells (4, 16, 19, 36, 37, 44) or incell-free

translations(2, 10, 26, 36, 37). Lewis etal. (26)

allocated these early viral gene functions to specific regions of the Ad2 genomeidentifiedby

restrictionendonuclease cleavage.

Uponentering apermissive cell,the

adenovi-rusneedstobring the host'sregulatorysystem underits owncontrol sothat viraland cellular functions can cooperate in virus gene

expres-sion. The early Ad2 polypeptides observed by

the various laboratories are integrated inthis

processinsome asyetunknownmanner. They

are commonly listed according to molecular weight. The 72,000 molecular weight polypep-tide, seen first by Anderson etal. (1) in

Ad2-infected cells, is the polypeptide subunit (26)

ofa single-stranded DNA-binding protein (42) which is implicated in DNA replication (21,

43). At least five additionalearly virus-specific

'Presentaddress:Biological Markers Program, Freder-ick CancerResearch Center, P.O. BoxB, Frederick, MD 21701.

2Present address: Biozentrum der Universitat Basel, AbteilungMikrobiologie, CH-4056Basel,Switzerland.

polypeptides

(seeTable 2)have been described inthe literature, withmolecular weightsat or

near 50,000, 19,000, 17,000, 14,000, and 11,000.

Each of thesepolypeptides qualifiesas anearly viral geneproduct encodedin one of the early

regions of the Ad2 genome (26). The 19,000

molecular weightcomponent is a

glycopolypep-tide (19). Some of the early polypeptides are

enrichedinnuclear, othersincytoplasmic

frac-tionsoftheinfectedcell (see Table 3).

A subset ofearly viral RNA found in Ad2-transformed cells (15) maycodefor early viral functions involved in the process of virus-in-duced cell transformation. This RNA

repre-sents several early species, ofwhichthose

de-rived from theleft end of the viralgenome (12) aresufficientto elicit cell transformation (14). RNA transcribed from the left end of the ge-nomeduring lytic infection givesrise invitro to twopolypeptides with molecular weights near

50,000 and 14,000 (26). Virus-specific

polypep-tides ofcorresponding molecular

weights

have notyetbeendetected within transformed cells, whereas, in several established lines of

Ad2-transformedcells, the 72,000 molecular weight

polypeptide has been unequivocally identified

(22). The functions ofearly virus polypeptides

during lytic infection or in the process of cell transformationremain to beelucidated.

Inthis report, we deal with some

quantita-tiveaspects ofearly Ad2 gene expression.

Us-ing the R-looptechnique ofWhiteandHogness

(personal communication) we visualized

indi-1019

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

(2)

1020 NEUWALD ET AL.

vidualclassesofearly mRNA

hybridized

with Ad2DNA,

established

their map

positions,

and

compared their relative

frequencies

atvarious

times after infection. At the same

time,

we

examinedthe timecourseof invivosynthesisof earlyandlate Ad2

polypeptides.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Cells and virus stocks. The propagation and infec-tion ofKBcells with purified virus is describedin

theaccompanyingarticle (28).

Purification and electron microscopy of early

Ad2 mRNA.Poly(A)-containingRNA wasextracted atvarious times after infection from the cytoplasm of cells incubated inthe presence ofcycloheximide

(10 ,ug/ml) aspreviouslyreported (9, 11, 28).

Thehybridization ofearly Ad2 mRNA with Ad2

DNA and thevisualizationof Rloops in theelectron

microscopearedescribedinthe accompanying

arti-cle (28). In all of the hybridizationsofthis report,

theDNAconcentration was10 ,ug/ml and the RNA

concentration was 100 ,tg/ml. The use of higher

RNAconcentrationswasimpracticalsinceextensive

RNAbackgroundinterfered with the visualization

of Rloops.

In vivo labeling of proteins and preparation of cell extracts. ThepolypeptidesofAd2-infected cells were labeled with [35S]methionine as follows. At

varioustimes afterinfection, aliquotsof6x 106cells

wereremoved from both infected and mockcultures. The cells were sedimented by centrifugation,

washed once with 10 ml ofmethionine-freemedium,

and resuspended in 10 ml of methionine-free medium to which was added 0.3 mCi of L

[35S]methionine (233 Ci/mmol, New England

Nu-clear). The cells werelabeled for1 hat37°C,

sedi-mented bycentrifugation,washed once with 10 ml of

phosphate-bufferedsaline(PBS), andsuspendedin1 ml of 0. 15MKCl,5mMMgCl2,3mMCaCl2,0.1mM EDTA, 0.01 MTris-hydrochloride(pH 7.5). Thecells werelysed andfractionatedasdescribedpreviously

(9), andthe nuclei wereresuspendedin 1mlofPBS.

Thesupernatantcytoplasm was clarified by a second

centrifugation at 12,000 x g for 5 min. Both the

nuclear andcytoplasmic fractionswerediluted with 1 volume of2 x electrophoresis sample buffer (1x samplebuffer= 1% [wt/vol]sodiumdodecylsulfate

[SDS], 1% [vol/vol]

f8-mercaptoethanol,

10% [vol/

vol]glycerol,0.01% [wt/vol]bromophenolblue, 0.05

MTris-hydrochloride[pH6.8]),boiled for2min, and

appliedto 13% SDS-polyacrylamidegels for electro-phoresis (9, 11). Quantitationofindividualproteins was obtained bycutting the bands outofthe dried gel andcountingthe gelslicesin 10mlofFilter-Solv

liquid scintillation fluid (Beckman). Radioactivity

inthecorrespondingregion of themock-infectedcell

sample wassubtracted from the counts in each pro-teinband cut out of theinfected cell sample. The use

J. VIROL.

of

long

(26cm) slab

gels

allowedsuperior separation

oftheindividualproteinbands and thusfacilitated

quantitation

by

thismethod.

TimecourseofDNAsynthesis.Theappearanceof

Ad2-specific

DNA was determined

by

DNA:DNA

hybridization

on nitrocellulose membranes. KB

cellswereinfectedasdescribed (28),and10-ml ali-quots

containing

3 x 106cells wereremoved every hour from 0to9hafter

infection,

and

again

at25h after

infection,

andlabeled with 50 ,uCi of

[methyl-3H]thymidine

(12

Ci/mmol,

Schwarz-Mann) for 30 min at

370C.

Thelabeled cellswere sedimented

by

centrifugation,

suspended in 1 ml of 0.3 N NaOH,

and

placed

in

boiling

waterfor 10 min. The

lysate

wascooledto

00C

andneutralized with1ml of0.3 N

HCl,

0.01M

Tris-hydrochloride

(pH

7.5). DNA was

extractedtwice withan

equal

volume of

phenol (pH

7.5),

precipitated

with 2.5 volumes of ethanol at

-20'C,

suspended

in200 1.d of1.5 mM

NaCl,

0.15 mMsodium citrate

(pH

6.8), heated for 15min at

1000C,

rapidly

cooledto

0C,

and

hybridized

with3 ,I.g of

purified

Ad2 DNA bound to nitrocellulose

filters (17).

Radioactivity

in

hybrids,

measured at

given

time

points,

wasnormalizedtothe total DNA in each

sample

to correctfor minorvariations in the

amountofDNA addedtoeachfilter.

RESULTS

Visualization

and

mapping

ofR

loops

gen-erated

by early

mRNAinAd2DNAmolecules.

In thefirst sectionofthis

report

we

described

the

visualization

of

early

Ad2 mRNA inviral DNA:RNA

hybrids. Figure

1

depicts

full-sized

Ad2 DNA molecules

carrying

several

loops

whichwere

generated

by

Ad2 mRNA

annealing

to

antiparallel

regions

ofthe

double-stranded

DNA and

thereby displacing

the

homologous

DNA sequences. One branch of each R

loop

thusformed contained

double-stranded

nucleic acid

(thick

contour);

the otherbranch contained

single-stranded

nucleic acid

(thin contour).

RNA which didnot

participate

inthe

hydridi-zation reaction

displayed

a

highly

condensed

secondary

structureseen

especially

inthe

back-ground

oftheupperelectron

micrograph.

TheRNA used in this series of

experiments

was

synthesized

in human cells

lyrically

in-fectedwitha

high

dose of Ad2. We found

that,

underourconditionsof

infection,

the

individual

stages

ofthe

lytic cycle

wereboth

synchronized

and

condensed,

as evidenced

by

the fact that

DNA

synthesis

(see

Fig.

8, top

panel,

andTable

4) occurred earlier and at a more

rapid

rate

thanwas

reported previously

(40).

Thisallowed

for a more accurate assessment of the time

FIG. 1. WholeAd2 DNAcontainingRloops formed byhybridizationto RNAisolatedfromAd2-infected cells 8 h after infection. DNA (0.1 pg) andRNA (1.0 Pg) were incubated in 10

pi

ofR-loop buffer at 52°C for 4 days, and examined in the electron microscope. The bars indicate 1

jim.

Abbreviations:

ds, double-strandedsideofloop; ss,single-strandedsideof loop.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

(3)

* 'h1 ', @ '

S J * * 7.. J t *

.7 .4 *

t'It * - I*I*,,g

I

A.4-H i'- *.-. l j ;. . *

- ._'t'1 -,P ~ $5

f

J

.A

- D1

*f-i.'

*'

'r

;%~

\)-

Is

** . , *s!

. .*4 .

,

..4

.

!

l

4

'~~~~~~~

''S

'X~

I

,f

II|,

*' ' *'

'X l1.,

e

/

''"

3

*'L

r

.'

.

4

?

>

;

'1

I~~~12

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

(4)

1022 NEUWALD ET AL.

course of Ad2 genetic expression. Since early

and late mRNA synthesis followed each other

within a narrow time span in cells infected in

this manner, wehadtotake properprecautions

to obtain early RNA preparations that were

free ofcontaminating late RNA. We chose cy-cloheximide as an inhibitor of late viral RNA synthesis(18)becausenoquantitativeor

quali-tativeinfluenceof thisdrugonearly viralRNA

synthesis wasnoticed inprevious experiments (6, 16, 26).

RNA was extracted from the cytoplasm at

different times after infection, and purifiedon oligo(dT)-cellulose (3)to selectfor poly(A)-con-taining Ad2 mRNA (33). R loops were gener-ated under conditions defined previously (28,

46) and examined in the electron microscope.

Figure2summarizes observations ofAd2 DNA

molecules carrying early Ad2 mRNA extracted

at2, 4, 6,or8hafter infection. The histograms

show the average size, position, andfrequency

of Rloops. Moleculeswithmultiple loops facili-tated theorientationof thevarious Rloops with

respect to each other. Molecules containing a

single loop were aligned such that the R loop wascoincidentwith one of the positions onthe multilooped molecules. For example, the

left-most R loop (midpoint near position 0.03) was

closertotheend ofthe DNAmoleculethanwas

the right-most loop (midpoint near position

0.95). The orientation with respect to the

con-ventionalAd2 DNA map wasbased upon

exper-iments which will be described below, and

which confirmed the results obtainedinFig. 2.

Equal amounts ofcytoplasmic RNA were used

for each of the four hybridizations. Thus, the histograms show the relative amounts of each species of early Ad2 mRNA contained in the

cell at the indicated times after infection. As

expected, the R loops occurredin theearly

re-gions (32, 38)of the Ad2 DNA, and mapped, in

orderof relativefrequency, nearpositions 0.95,

0.80, 0.03, 0.65, and 0.09. These positions refer

to the midpoints ofeach histogram peak dis-playedinFig. 2. At veryearly times (2 h after infection), R loops were infrequently observed

between positions0.5 and0.6 (e.g., Fig. 2, top

panel). Since these loopsarelocatedinaregion

codingforhexon mRNA (28), the significance of

thisfinding is unknown.

Withinthe areas of the major loops, i.e., at

positions 0.95, 0.80, and 0.03, the quantity of

earlyRNAappearedtoincreasesteadily during

the first 6hofinfection, whereas surprisingly

fewloops formedatposition 0.65, which

corre-spondstothe RNAcodingfor the 72,000

molec-ularweightpolypeptide (26),anearly Ad2

poly-peptide givingriseto averyprominentbandon

1001

80 2 Hr P.I.

60-40L

80r 4HrP. I.

60~

-uj 40 D

uJ

-i

201-0

U- 0

0

o 6 rP.1

LU

LUI

60-0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

FRACTIONAL LENGTH

FIG. 2. Timecourseof Ad2 mRNA production in

infected cells as determined by R-loop analysis.

Poly(A)-containing RNA wasisolated from infected

cellsatvarious timesafter infection. Each RNA

prep-arationwashybridizedtowhole Ad2 DNA for 16 hat 520C.Hybrid molecules were examined in the

elec-tron microscope, andthepositions of R loops were

determined. Thecombined datafor 50 molecules at eachtimepointarepresentedin theform ofa

histo-gram.Theabscissa shows the fractional length of the

adenovirusgenome,andthe ordinate gives the

per-centageofDNA molecules containing anR loopat thatposition.

SDS-polyacrylamide gels (i.e., Fig. 7). This

finding prompted us to repeat part of the

ex-periment, allowing more time for RNA:DNA

hybridizationtooccur.Andindeed, Fig. 3 shows

that,under theseconditions, the 8-hRNA,but

notthe 2-hRNA,formedaprominent peakof R

loopsatposition0.65. We cannotdecide, onthe

1.0 J. VIROL.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:4.501.283.439.58.452.2]
(5)

MAPPING OF EARLY Ad2 mRNA 1023

basis of this experiment, whether the RNA specific for position 0.65 was in short supply

even 8hafterinfection or whether the higher

G+C content of DNA in thatregion of the

ge-nome (8, 29)causedadelay (28, 41) intherate

of DNA:RNA hybridization. The experiment

did show, however, that significantly more of

thisRNA was present at 8 h thanat 2 hafter

infection.

Orientation of R-loop positionsto the con-ventional Ad2 map. Cuts introduced by the

restriction endonucleaseBamHIinto Ad2 DNA

were utilized as markers for the orientation of

R loops. The enzyme cleaves at positions 0.3,

0.43, and 0.6 of theconventionalAd2 DNA map

(Mulder and Greene, personal communication), therebygeneratingfourfragments in theorder

B,

D, C, A. The lengthdistribution of all

frag-ments contained in the complete Ad2 DNA

di-gest is shown in Fig. 4. The two larger

frag-ments, A and B, corresponding to the ends of

the molecule, showed distinct length distribu-tionsand thuscould easilybeidentifiedin elec-tron micrographs of a mixture of fragments. This task was more difficult with the small internal fragments, C and D, which displayed overlappinglength distributions.We were nev-ertheless ableto arrive at a correctly oriented mapofRloops generated by early mRNA,since wecould correlateRloopsindistinctfragments towhole Ad2DNAmoleculescarryingmultiple loops. The electron micrograph of Fig. 5depicts aBamHI A-fragment containing twoR loops.

In Fig. 6, line drawings offragmented DNA

carryingRloops have beenarrangedinsucha waythat they reflect the distribution of loopsin

intact DNA. This methodof R-loop orientation

was used to determine the accuracy of

subjec-tive orientation based upon the position of a

100

2Hr RNA

80 16HrHYB

8Hr RNA 16 Hr HYB

60 I

-i

40--i20

0

0

2802HrRNA 8HrRNA

Z 4DayHYB ayHYB

60.

40iIll

-

11~i1

h.

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.00 0.2 FRACTIONAL LENGTH

0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

FIG. 3. R loops generated by Ad2 early mRNA after differentperiods of hybridization. Poly(A)-con-taining RNA wasprepared from infectedcells at2 and8 hafter infection,andhybridizedtoAd2 DNA at52Cfor16hor4days (96 h).

70

C50-°z,

~40

0

~30

z~~~~~~~

10-1 2 3 4 5 6

LENGTHINMICROMETERS

FIG. 4. Length distribution of fragments gener-ated by digestion of whole Ad2 DNA with BamII restriction endonuclease. BamHI (0.4 unit, Be-thesda Research Laboratories, Inc.) was added to 3

Mg

of Ad2 DNA in10

pJ

of 6 mMMgCl2, 6 mM

,3-mercaptoethanol, 6mMTris-hydrochloride (pH 7.5), and incubated for 2 h at 370C (20). The digested DNA wasdiluted into R-loop buffer and examined in the electron microscope. Electron micrographs of 437 BamHIfragments were measured and the distribu-tion waspresented as a histogram. Since the proba-bilityof larger fragments extending off the electron micrograph, and thus not beingscored, was greater than that of smaller fragments, the number counted wasinversely proportional to the size offragments.

single loopinrelationto oneof the positionson a multilooped molecule (Table 1). Maps ofR loops were established either with the help of

specific

fragments of DNA carrying R

loops

(Fig. 6) or with the help of intact molecules

containing multiple Rloops (Fig. 2). Ineither

case,theratioofRloops occurringtothe left of

position0.07andtotheright of position0.9was

close to 1:2 in hybridizations using RNA ex-tracted 2 h after infection, and 1:1 in those

using RNA extracted8hafter infection.

Timecourseof Ad2polypeptidesynthesisin

vivo. Inaneffort tocorrelate thetime courseof early Ad2 RNA synthesis to that of the

corre-sponding

viralgene

products,

cellswerelabeled with [35S]methionine atvarious timesafter in-fection, and thepolypeptides containedin

frac-tionated cell extracts wereexamined.

Autoradi-ograms of35S-labeled polypeptides resolved by

SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis are

shown in Fig. 7. Five of theearly

Ad2-specific

polypeptides-of 72,000, 19,000, 17,000, 14,000

and 11,000 molecular

weight-could clearly

be

discerned from the

background

of host cell

poly-peptides present at the initial stages of

infec-0 u-p ...

VOL. 21, 1977

D

c

I

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:5.501.276.441.51.259.2] [image:5.501.55.245.477.611.2]
(6)

1024 NEUWALD ET AL.

At X

e,'-,,- , Cb : e a

-.. k. H- - "'.

FIG. 5. BamHIA-fragment containingtwoRloops formed by hybridizationwithRNA isolatedfromcells2 hafter infection with Ad2. The DNAwasdigested withBamHIenzyme asdescribed in thelegendtoFig. 4, andhybridizedtotheRNAfor16hat520C. The barindicates1 ,um.

B D C A

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0

;

I-0

z

0

co

FIG. 6. PositionsofRloopsonBamHIfragments

ofAd2 DNA as described inFig.5. Allfragments

containing one or more loops were photographed,

andthepositionsoftheRloopsweredetermined. The

fractional length ofthe conventional Ad2 map

cov-ered by each fragment is given at the top ofeach column. Upperset:Rloops formed by hybridization to RNA isolated 2 h after infection. Lower set: R loopsformed by hybridization toRNA isolated8 h afterinfection.

tion. Some of these virus-specific polypeptides

were abundant in the nucleus, others in the

cytoplasm.Asurveyofearlyvirus-specific

poly-peptides described in the literature (Table 2)

shows that, in addition to the early products

seen in Fig. 7, one additional polypeptide,

around40,000to50,000 molecular weight, was

commonly observed by other laboratories. The

highbackground of host cell polypeptide bands

intheareaof the gelcorrespondingtoaproduct

ofthis sizemayberesponsible forourfailureto

TABLE 1. Analysis of endloops

Timeafter . Bamfragmentsa Whole DNAb

Timeaftern

Positionof

infection N. Fe o

(h) loop No Fre- No

Fre-quency quency

2 0-0.07 24 0.36 22 0.37

0.9-1.0 42 0.64 38 0.63

8 0-0.07 38 0.49 23 0.48

0.9-1.0 40 0.51 25 0.52

aAsdescribedinFig.6.

bWhole Ad2 DNA hybridized to cytoplasmic mRNA at520C for 16 h and oriented according to the relative positions ofmultiple loops occurring within individual molecules (Fig. 2).

detect the 40,000 to 50,000 molecular weight

polypeptide. Polypeptides of comparable

elec-trophoretic mobilitieswereobserved ininfected

cells pretreated with 25pug of cycloheximideper

ml (16). Thedistribution of early virus-specific

polypeptides among subcellularfractions (Fig.

7)compared well with similar data in the

litera-ture (Table 3). Minor variations were most

likely dueto differences in the methods of cell

fractionation used by the individual groups of

investigators.

To quantitate our observations, we

deter-mined theradioactivity containedinindividual

polypeptide bands, subtracted the correspond-ing mock values, and related these data to the time course of Ad2 DNA synthesis in the in-fected cells. Time points between 7 and 25 h

after infection were taken from a gel (not

shown) similar to that ofFig. 7. Only

virus-specific polypeptides that could be cleanly cut

fromthe gels were utilized in thisanalysis. The

results (Fig. 8 and Table 4), indicated that

19,000 and 11,000 molecular weight

polypep-tides wereamong the earliest of the

virus-spe-J.- VIROL.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:6.501.77.444.72.223.2] [image:6.501.59.254.269.448.2] [image:6.501.262.458.273.385.2]
(7)

MAPPING OF EARLY Ad2 mRNA

1025

NUCLEUS

CYTOPLASM

INF

1 3 5 7 24 1

MOCK

3 5 7 24

INF MOCK

1 3 5 7 24 1 3 5 7 24 HRS

_

w-iiAr

a

_.

11.5K loo

FIG. 7. SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of nuclear and cytoplasmic polypeptides synthesized at various times after infection.Ad2-infectedormock-infected KB cellswerepulse-labeledwith[35S]methionine

for1h priortoharvesting. Cellswerefractionated into nuclear and cytoplasmicfractions and analyzedon13%

polyacrylamide slab gels. Sampling times (hours after infection) are shown at the top of each column.-Apparent molecular weights (calibrated by co-electrophoresis of the24-hINFsample with known marker proteins) aregiven in thecenter, with virion polypeptides (24) showninparentheses. Abbreivations:INF, samples preparedfrom Ad2-infectedcells; MOCK, samples prepared from mock-infectedcells.

TABLE 2. Comparison of early virus-specific polypeptides observed by various groupsofinvestigators Results of Walter and Chin and Saborio etal. (37) SaborioandOberg (36) Atkins etal.

this study Maizel (44) Maizel (4) (2) (invitro)

(in vivo) (in vivo) (in vivo) Invivo In vitro Invivo Invitro

72a 70 70 70 70 74 74 72b

67 67

60 60

45 45 44-55b

42 42-50 42

40

35 35

26.5

19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19b

18.5 18.5

17 17 17 17 17.5 17.5

14.5-16 15.5 15.5b

15 15b

14 14 14.5 14.5

12.5 12.5

11 10 11 10 10 10.5 10.5 11

aMolecularweight x103.

bShowntobevirus-coded byLewis etal. (26). VOL. 21, 1977

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:7.501.47.444.63.359.2] [image:7.501.47.444.457.640.2]
(8)

TABLE 3. Intracellular location ofearly viral-specific polypeptides

Location Polypeptide (mol

wt x 103)a Results of this Walter and Mai- Chin and Ma- Saborio et al. Saborio and

Oh-study zel(44) izel (4) (37) erg(36)

72 N(C)b C N,C C C

40-50 C C C

19 C(N) C C C(N) C(N)

17 C C C

14 C C C

11 N N N N N

aApparent molecularweightsvaryslightlyamongobservationsbydifferent laboratories.

bAbbreviations: N,polypeptidefound innucleus; C,polypeptidefoundincytoplasm.Lettersin

parenthe-sesindicate location ofaminorfraction ofpolypeptide.

= 0.4

0a

z L0

CNcl0.2 E

< a

30j

0

0.

C,) (n

qn

2.5

0

200

0

20-0 5 10 15 20 25

HOURS AFTER INFECTION

FIG. 8. Time ofappearance ofAd2-specific

pro-teins and of viral DNA in infected cells. DNA synthe-sis was measured by DNA:DNA hybridization on

nitrocellulose filters as described in Materials and

Methods. Levels of both early and late polypeptides synthesized ateach timepoint were determined by

scintillation counting of 35S radioactivity contained in individual polypeptide bands of the SDS-poly-acrylamide gels. Radioactivitypresent in the same

regions of the corresponding mock samplewas

sub-tracted from each value and the net amount was

plotted. Totalradioactivity recovered from the

appro-priate regionsofeach gelwasasshown in Table 4.

cific polypeptides, followed by the 72,000

mo-lecular weight polypeptide, which appeared

concomitant with the start of Ad2 DNA

repli-cation. Polypeptides II (hexon) and pVII, both

late Ad2 gene products located in the virion particle, appeared within a few hours after the

onset of Ad2 DNA synthesis, and continued

tobe produced while the rate of early

polypep-tide synthesis decreased. Thehighbackground

ofhost cell polypeptides present in the 17,000

and14,000 molecular weight regions of thegels

prevented quantitation of these early,

virus-specific polypeptides. Distinct bands were not observed at these locations in the

autoradi-ograms until5 to 7 h after infection. However,

thesepolypeptides may exist prior to that time

atlevels undetectablebyourassay method.

DISCUSSION

Agenetic map ofadenovirustype 2 may be

constructed from the data contained in this

study, inthe accompanyingreport (28), andin

thepublished accounts of otherlaboratories. In

Fig. 9, we present two histograms which are representative for the spectrum ofRloops

ob-servedinhybridizations of Ad2 DNA with early

orlate Ad2 mRNA. Below thesehistograms we

have drawn a map of the genetic elements of

Ad2 which, in our opinion, represents the best

fit ofall available data. Transcriptional units

are drawn as arrows. Their extent and

posi-tionsaredefined by the sizes and positions of R

loops, bythemap positions of strand switches of transcriptional units (28, 32, 38), by the map positions of certain size classes of early RNA (5, 7), and by the map positions of the special

markers VA and ND, i.e., thevirus-associated

RNAs (27, 30, 31, 34, 35, 39, 45), andthe Ad2

DNA sequences deleted in nondefective (ND)

Ad2-SV40 hybrid viruses (see reference 28 for details). Bars within the arrows indicate the

minimumsequences needed to code for the

var-1026

NEUWALD ET AL. J. VIROL.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:8.501.57.457.84.186.2] [image:8.501.81.225.230.528.2]
(9)
[image:9.501.52.449.93.221.2]

MAPPING OF EARLY Ad2 mRNA 1027

TABLE 4. Totalradioactivity recovered from the appropriate regions of each gel mentioned in the legend to Fig. 8

35Sradioactivity (counts/min) Protein band Cellsa

lb 3 5 7 9 12 16 25

72,000 INF 277 393 586 1,716 2,722 5,573 4,908 595

(nuc) MOCK 402 414 353 336 850 733 908 492

19,000 INF 585 1,265 1,837 1,989 1,978 2,119 1,239 199

(cyto) MOCK 621 724 728 583 967 1,064 1,049 629

11,000 INF 196 393 706 691 276 271 185 118

(nuc) MOCK 222 200 250 212 178 143 176 206

II INF 5,300 4,985 5,093 9,361 9,986 10,646 36,022 37,832

(cyto) MOCK 5,679 5,911 5,749 4,994 4,492 4,031 4,092 3,731

pVII INF 385 333 368 971 1,030 851 3,299 3,961

(nuc) MOCK 336 317 282 264 216 169 206 240

aAbbreviations: INF, samples prepared from Ad2-infected cells;MOCK, samplesprepared from mock-infected cells.

bHoursafterinfection.

ious early and late polypeptides listed on the

map. Thesepolypeptides havepreviously been

allocatedtorestriction fragments of Ad2 DNA (2, 25,26), andthus we wereabletoalign them with the individualRloops.

LateAd2gene expression isdiscussedinthe

accompanying report (28). Here we will touch

on somefeaturesofearlyAd2 geneexpression.

The early region to the left of position 0.1 is of chiefinterest because of its primary

involve-ment in celltransformation (14). The

polypep-tidemostlikelyspecified bythemRNAforming the left-mostRloopisofuncertainsize.

Accord-ing tocell-freetranslation, itssize is near50,000

molecularweight (26). However,thecoding ca-pacityof the correspondingmRNA, judged, by the R-loop size,iscertainlygreater. It is

tempt-ing tospeculate thata58,000 molecularweight

polypeptide which is specific for

Ad2-trans-formedhamster cells(Chin, Lewis, and Maizel,

personalcommunication) isidenticaltothe pol-ypeptide seen by Lewis et al. (26), and thus specified bythe left-mostearlyAd2 mRNA.

According to Atkins et al. (2), the 14,000 molecularweightpolypeptidemapstothe

right

of the 50,000 molecular

weight

polypeptide.

ThiscorrespondstotheR-loop peak observedat

position 0.09 intheupper

histogram

of

Fig.

9.

Although

R

loops

werenotobservedinthis

re-gion of the DNA when hybridized with RNA isolated 2 hafter infection (Fig. 2 and 6), the limitations of the

R-loop

technique

in

regard

to

quantitation of individual mRNAspeciesdonot

allow us to ruleoutthepresence of this message

atveryearlytimes after infection.

The Rloopcorrespondingtothe well

charac-terized72,000 molecularweightpolypeptide

ap-pearedintheregion between position 0.61and

0.68, an area matching itsminimal codon size

andflankedbystrand switchpoints(28,32,38).

In keeping with the proposed function of this

early Ad2 geneproduct during Ad2 DNA

repli-cation (43), itmay be interesting to note, from

the results ofour study, that both the 72,000

molecular weight product and its mRNA

ap-peared concomitant with Ad2 DNA synthesis,

i.e., later thanthe earliest Ad2 polypeptides. A

similar result was obtained by Gilead et al.

(13).

Thethird early region of Ad2 mapped within

positions 0.77 to 0.84 and included the ND

dele-tion.Judging from the size of the corresponding

Rloop, a polypeptide of up to 80,000 molecular

weight could be encoded here. Yet, the only product known to map in this area of the

ge-nome is the 15,500 molecular weight

polypep-tideof Lewis et al. (26), which probably

corre-spondsto our17,000molecularweight polypep-tide.InourAd2 map, we have tentatively posi-tioned this product to the left of the ND deletion becauseitseemedunlikely to us that the 15,500

to 17,000 molecular weight product is encoded

byanareaof thegenome which is not required forlytic infectionofhuman cells in culture (23).

As yet, the presence of the 15,500 to 17,000

molecular weight polypeptide in Ad2+ND4 in-fected cells hasnotbeenreported.

A rather large and quite abundant R loop generated by early Ad2 mRNA waslocated to the right of position 0.9. The corresponding

19,000 and 11,000 molecular weight

polypep-tides (26) require only afraction of the coding capacity of an RNA of this size. We have no evidencethat morethan one RNA is

responsi-ble for theirsynthesis. Both polypeptides may,

infact, be breakdown products of some larger,

yetunstable, Ad2 geneproduct. The19,000 and

11,000 molecular weightpolypeptides appear to

be the earliest viral gene products synthesized

after infection.

VOL. 21, 1977

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

(10)

1028 NEUWALD ET AL.

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7

FRACTIONAL LENGTH

0.8 0.9 1.0

50K,14K L VA(UIL)p3M pMI 1K 17K E

- _ )->

0.1 02

(1 j2)a, L

0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8

72K

5' 13

(-c1-1

(09K,1K)

FIG. 9. Comparison oftheR-loop patterns

gener-atedby early and late Ad2 RNA andproposed

ge-neticmapof adenovirustype2.Theupperhistogram

isrepresentative of early R loops and is derived from Fig. 3 (lower right panel). The lower histogram is representative ofmost late R loops and is derived from Fig. 6, panel three, of Meyeret al. (28). The

mapshown below thehistograms is baseduponthe

accumulateddata of several laboratories,andis dis-cussed in detail in thetext. Thepolarity of both the heavy (h) and light (1) strands of theDNA molecule is indicated (38).NDreferstotheregion ofdeletion of Ad2 DNA sequences in nondefective Ad2-SV40 hybrids. Thearrowsgive the direction of

transcrip-tion and size of mRNA species produced both early and lateininfection. Boxes insertedinthesearrows

indicate the minimal length of mRNA required to code for each polypeptide. The locations of boxes within arrows isarbitrary. Early (open boxes) and

late (closed boxes) polypeptides mostlikely encoded by these messages are indicated. Thegeneorder is unknownfor those polypeptides within parentheses. Abbreviations: L, unknown late products; E,

un-knownearly products. VAshows themapposition of

virus-associated, low-molecular-weight RNA.

Because of the differential kinetics of loop

formation in various regions of the Ad2

ge-nome, it is difficult to correlate the relative

frequencies ofR loops with the proportions of

mRNA's present ininfected cells(28).However,

in this report we have compared the

frequen-ciesofRloopsgenerated bymRNA'sisolatedat

various times after infection. In this case, we feel itisvalidto correlateR-loop

frequency

at

any one position to the relative amount of

mRNA present at different times ofinfection,

since dissociation of the DNA duplex in this

regionwouldremain constantforeach

hybridi-zation. Thus, although one cannot

accurately

comparethe frequencies of mRNA'sproducing

Rloops at,for example,positions 0.65and0.95,

one cansaythat theRNAwhichgeneratesthe

R loop at position 0.65 is considerably more

abundant at 8hthan at2 hafter infection.

The R-loop technique certainly has not yet

been fully exploited by the experiments dis-cussed here. Further studies are expected to detect additional, less abundant classes of Ad2

mRNA. Itshouldalso be interesting to mapthe

Ad2 mRNA's present in various

Ad2-trans-formed cells, as well as the viral transcripts

isolated from nuclei of both virus-infected and

transformed cells. Since, at the same time,

work on the Ad2 polypeptides is expected to

reveal further details of thevarious viralgene functions, all thepiecesof the puzzlemay even-tually be elucidatedso as to construct a gratify-ing picture of the molecular genetics of Ad2 gene expression.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The expert technical assistance of Sing Ping Lai and Margery Sullivan and the editorial assistance of Cecilia Levi aregratefullyacknowledged. We wishtothank

Wil-liam Chin and Andrew Lewis, Jr., Raymond White and David Hogness, andCarel Mulder and Ronni Greene for transmittingtheir results priortopublication. Wearealso grateful to Jose Saborio and Bo Oberg, and to Marjorie Thomas, Raymond White, and Ronald Davis for making their manuscripts available beforepublication.JurgMeyer was supported by a fellowship from the Swiss National Science Foundation andbyaPublic HealthService Interna-tional ResearchFellowship (no. F05TW2256-01).

LITERATURE CITED

1. Anderson, C. W., P. R. Baum,and R. F.Gesteland. 1973.Processing ofadenovirus 2-induced proteins.J.

Virol. 12:241-252.

2. Atkins, J. F., J. B. Lewis, C. W. Anderson, P. R.

Baum,and R. F.Gesteland.1975.Mapping of

adeno-virus 2genesby translationof RNAselectedby hy-bridization, p.293-298. In A. L.HaenniandG.Beard (ed.),InstitutNational delaSanteetde la Recherche

Mddicale Symposium no. 47. Editions INSERM, Paris.

3. Aviv, H.,and P. Leder. 1972.Purification ofbiologically activeglobin messengerRNAbychromatographyon

(n IL

C-0 0 z

0U

U

J. VIROL.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

[image:10.501.62.254.55.410.2]
(11)

MAPPING OF EARLY Ad2 mRNA 1029

oligothymidylic acid-cellulose. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 69:1408-1412.

4. Chin,W.W., and J. V. Maizel, Jr. 1976. The polypep-tides of adenovirus. VII. Further studies of early polypeptides in vivo and localization of E2 and E2A to the cellplasma membrane. Virology 71:518-530.

5. Craig, E. A., M. McGrogan, C. Mulder, and H. J. Raskas. 1975.Identification of early adenovirus type 2RNAspecies transcribed from the left-hand end of the genome. J. Virol. 16:905-912.

6. Craig, E. A., and H. J. Raskas. 1974. Effect of cyclohex-imide on RNA metabolism early in productive infec-tion withadenovirus 2. J. Virol. 14:26-32.

7. Craig, E. A., S. Zimmer, and H. J. Raskas. 1975. Anal-ysisof earlyadenovirus 2 RNA using Eco R * RI viral DNAfragments. J. Virol. 15:1202-1213.

8. Doerfler, W., and A. K.Kleinschmidt.1970. Denatura-tion pattern of the DNA ofadenovirus type 2 as determined by electron microscopy. J. Mol. Biol. 50:579-593.

9. Eron, L., R.Callahan, and H. Westphal. 1974. Cell-free synthesis ofadenovirus coat proteins. J. Biol. Chem. 249:6331-6338.

10. Eron, L., and H. Westphal. 1975. Cell-free translation products of early RNA from adenovirus type 2-in-fected KB cells, p. 299-304. In A. L. Haenni and G. Beard (ed.), Institut National de la Sante et de la Recherche M6dicale Symposium no. 47. Editions INSERM,Paris.

11. Eron, L., H. Westphal,and R. Callahan. 1974. In vitro synthesis of adenovirus core proteins. J. Virol. 14:375-383.

12. Flint, S. J., P. H. Gallimore, and P. A. Sharp. 1975. Comparison of viral RNA sequencesinadenovirus

2-transformed andlyricallyinfected cells. J. Mol. Biol. 96:47-68.

13. Gilead, Z., K. Sugawara, G. Shanmugam, and M.

Green.1976.Synthesis of theadenovirus-codedDNA bindingproteinininfected cells. J. Virol. 18:454-460.

14. Graham, F. L., A. J. vander Eb, and H.L.Heijneker. 1974.Sizeand location of the transforming regionin

human adenovirus type 5 DNA. Nature (London) 251:687-691.

15. Green, M., J. T. Parsons, M. Pifia, K. Fujinaga, H. Caffier,and I. Landgraf-Leurs. 1970.Transcription ofadenovirus genesin productively infected andin

transformed cells. Cold Spring HarborSymp. Quant. Biol.35:803-818.

16. Harter, M.L., G. Shanmugam, W. S. M.Wold, and M. Green.1976. Detectionof adenovirus type 2-induced earlypolypeptidesusingcycloheximidepretreatment toenhanced viral protein synthesis.J.Virol. 19:232-242.

17. Horwitz, M. S.1971.Intermediates in thesynthesisof type 2 adenovirus deoxyribonucleic acid. J. Virol. 8:675-683.

18. Horwitz, M. S., C. Brayton, and S. G. Baum. 1973. Synthesisof type2adenovirus DNAinthe presence ofcycloheximide.J.Virol. 11:544-551.

19. Ishibashi, M., and J. V. Maizel, Jr. 1974. The poly-peptidesofadenovirus. VI.Earlyand late glycopoly-peptides. Virology 58:345-361.

20. Ketner,G., andT.J.Kelly,Jr. 1976.Integratedsimian virus 40sequencesintransformed cellDNA:analysis using restriction endonucleases. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73:1102-1106.

21. Levine, A.J., P.C. vanderVliet, B. Rosenwirth,J. Rabek, G.Frenkel, andM.Ensinger.1974. Adenovi-rus-infected, cell-specific, DNA-binding proteins. Cold Spring HarborSymp. Quant. Biol. 39:559-566.

22. Levinson,A.,A.J.Levine,S.Anderson,M.Osborn,B.

Rosenwirth, and K. Weber. 1976. The relationship between group Cadenovirus tumor antigen and the adenovirus single-strand DNA-binding protein. Cell 7:575-584.

23. Lewis, A. M., Jr., M. J. Levin, W. H. Wiese, C. S. Crumpacker, and P. H. Henry. 1969. A nondefective (competent) adenovirus-SV40 hybrid isolated from the ad2-SV40 hybrid population. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 63:1128-1135.

24. Lewis, J. B.,C. W. Anderson, J. F. Atkins, and R. F. Gesteland. 1974. The origin and destiny of adenovirus proteins. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 39:581-590.

25. Lewis, J. B., J. F. Atkins, C. W. Anderson, P. R. Baum,and R. F. Gesteland. 1975. Mapping of late adenovirus genes by cell-free translation of RNA se-lected by hybridization to specific DNAfragments. Proc. Natl.Acad.Sci. U.S.A. 72:1344-1348. 26. Lewis, J. B., J. F. Atkins, P. R.Baum, R. Solem, R. F.

Gesteland, and C. W. Anderson. 1976. Locationand identification of the genes for adenovirus type 2 early polypeptides. Cell 7:141-151.

27. Mathews, M. B. 1975. Genes for VA-RNAinadenovirus 2. Cell 6:223-229.

28. Meyer, J., P.D. Neuwald, S. P. Lai, J.V.Maizel,Jr., and H. Westphal. 1977. Electron microscopy of late adenovirus type 2 mRNA hybridized to double-stranded viral DNA. J. Virol. 21:1010-1018.

29. Mulder, C., J. R. Arrand, H. Delius, W. Keller, U. Pettersson, R. J. Roberts, and P. A. Sharp. 1974. Cleavage maps of DNA from adenovirus types2and5

by restriction endonucleases Eco RI and Hpa I. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 39:397-400.

30. Ohe, K. 1972. Virus-coded origin of a low molecular weight RNA from KB cellsinfected with adenovirus 2.Virology 47:726-733.

31. Pettersson, U., and L. Philipson. 1975. Location of sequences ontheadenovirus genomecoding for the 5.5S RNA. Cell 6:1-4.

32. Pettersson, U., C. Tibbetts, and L. Philipson. 1976.

Hybridization maps of early and late messenger RNA sequences onthe adenovirus type2genome.J. Mol. Biol. 101:479-501.

33. Philipson, L., R. Wall, G. Glickman, and J.E.Darnell.

1971.Addition ofpolyadenylatesequences to virus-specific RNA during adenovirus replication. Proc. Natl.Acad.Sci. U.S.A. 68:2806-2809.

34. Raska, K., L. M. Sehulster, and F. Varricchio. 1976.

Three new virus-specific low molecularweight RNAs

inadenovirus type2infectedKBcells. Biochem. Bio-phys. Res. Commun. 69:79-84.

35. Reich, P. R.,B.G. Forget, S. W. Weissman, and J.A.

Rose.1966.RNA of low molecularweightinKBcells infected with adenovirus type2.J. Mol. Biol. 17:428-439.

36. Saborio,J., and B. Oberg. 1976.In vivoand invitro synthesis of adenovirus type2earlyproteins. J. Vi-rol. 17:865-875.

37. Saborio,J., B.Oberg,and L.Philipson.1975.In vitro synthesisofadenovirustype2early proteins,p.

325-330. In A. L. Haenni and G. Beard (ed.), Institut National de la Sante et de la Recherche M6dicale Symposiumno. 47.EditionsINSERM,Paris. 38. Sharp, P. A., P. H. Gallimore, and S.J. Flint. 1974.

Mapping of adenovirus2RNA sequencesinlyrically infected cells andtransformed cell lines. Cold Spring HarborSymp. Quant. Biol.39:457-474.

39. Soderlund,H., U.Pettersson, B.Vennstrom,L.Philip. son, and M. B. Mathews. 1976. A new species of

virus-coded low molecular weight RNA from cells infected with adenovirus type2.Cell7:585-593. VOL. 21, 1977

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

(12)

1030 NEUWALD ET AL.

40. Thomas, D. C., and M. Green. 1969.Biochemical

stud-iesonadenovirus multiplication. XV. Transcription

of theadenovirus type 2genome duringproductive

infection. Virology 39:205-210.

41. Thomas, M., R. L. White, and R. W. Davis. 1976.

Hybridization of RNAtodouble stranded DNA: for-mation of R-loops. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73:2294-2298.

42. van derVliet, P. C., and A. J. Levine. 1973. DNA-bindingproteinsspecificforcells infectedby

adenovi-rus.Nature (London) New Biol.246:170-174. 43. vander Vliet, P.C., A. J. Levine, M. J.Ensinger,and

H. S. Ginsberg. 1975. Thermolabile DNA binding

proteins from cells infected witha

temperature-sensi-tive mutant of adenovirus defective in viral DNA

synthesis. J. Virol. 15:348-354.

44. Walter, G.,and J. V.Maizel, Jr.1974.Thepolypeptides of adenovirus.IV. Detection ofearly and late virus-induced polypeptides and their distributionin subcel-lular fractions. Virology57:402-408.

45. Weinmann, R.,T.G.Brendler,H.J.Raskas,and R.G. Roeder. 1976. Low molecular weight viral RNAs transcribed by RNA polymeraseIIIduring

adenovi-rus2infection. Cell7:557-566.

46. Westphal, H., J. Meyer, and J. V. Maizel, Jr. 1976.

Mapping ofadenovirus messengerRNA by electron

microscopy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73:2069-2071.

J. VIROL.

on November 10, 2019 by guest

http://jvi.asm.org/

Figure

FIG. 2.gram.Poly(A)-containingcellsadenovirus520C.arationeachcentagetrondetermined.infectedthat Time course of Ad2 mRNA production incellsas determined by R-loop analysis
FIG. 4.DNABamHIrestrictionatedandthanthesdationmercaptoethanol,themicrograph,wasbilityMg Length distribution of fragments gener- by digestion of whole Ad2 DNA with BamIIendonuclease
FIG. 5.andh after BamHI A-fragment containing two R loops formed by hybridization with RNA isolated from cells 2 infection with Ad2
TABLE 2. Comparison of early virus-specific polypeptides observed by various groups of investigators
+4

References

Related documents

(B) Action value as computed by the goal-directed system (LP in blue: lever pressing; CP in cyan: chain pulling; DN in green: doing nothing) and Pavlovian value (PV in red)

This paper empirically assesses the relative contribution of common (push) and country-speci…c (pull) factors to the variation of bond and equity ‡ows from the US to 55

The predicted flow, temperature and vapor concentration field for the experimental case of [60] 368. are shown in Fig. The gravitational forces are quite strong and the droplet

This paper reviews these existing regulations and green rating tools and explores the full potential for natural ventilation in Kuala Lumpur, in order to

To measure the deficit bias, I analyse the dynamic behavior of an optimal growth model with overlapping dynasties and factor taxation, calibrated for the US economy, and consider

Estimation of T antigen molecular weight from SV40-infected CV1-P cells using random-coil chromatography. The relationships of

some alkaline nuclease after infection at 390C ts13-infected cells after a shift to a permissive.. (Moss and Hay,

 Recognition of differences between the extent and nature of agency conflicts in various institutional environments