• No results found

A framework for role-based group delegation in distributed environments

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2019

Share "A framework for role-based group delegation in distributed environments"

Copied!
8
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

4-653+(#-%7'-6)

8:9<;>=;0?A@ B1CD9<EGFG?A@IH*C JKF?LKMMNCPO QRSCTU?WVXOY0OZE1[O\ J]C_^S`A;a\SMb=c;aR[FG?

d4efhgikjml#e2nSjNop,qrgsjutZvwxAoUl#fhyzju{|n~}h~€'n~{|ei‚vu{ƒj…„†op,‡ˆoUyzjutheimn/‰4yheenZvkŠ‹gnhŒ

GoˆosŽAoˆoUlhg6‰*0d’‘S“U”•#–yZv…jmimgŠ—{‹g

˜<l™g{|ŠPš›…œhžzŸ< ¡h¢¤£z¥~¦žˆŸ< §S¨ˆ¨Z¢© ¨z©Uª~©¥«©U¬< ™¬SœhU­Z«¦ž¯®°£±«²A³k©U¨U£N³…£

´†µ,¶·2¸º¹h»·

¼oŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ¾Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnKl6ozŒze2Š¿ÁÀÂNÃ*ÄÆÅǏhgvue2ŒKon¾jmt~e

iuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤ŒXgÈ2È(e2vmv#È(onSjmiuoUŠ4¿ÁÀ'ÂÉÊ4ÅtZgvf~iuosUen]jmoKe

g/ËheÌz{—~Š|e%gnhŒÍyhvue(pÎy~ŠgUÈÈ(e¤vuv#È(oUnSjuimoŠl#ozŒze2ŠNpÎoi6{|nzpÎoiu½

l6gju{|on6vktZgim{—n~}*{|n#gnjz{‹v…jmiu{|~yzjme2Œ6È(oUŠ—Š‹goi‚gsjm{—Ue<e2nSˆ{|iuoUnz½

l#e2nSj2Ï,ÐÑnjmoˆŒhgº„Òvt~{|}t~Š|„Œz„ˆnhgl#{‹ÈŒz{|vkjuim{|~yzjue¤Œ6vk„zvkjuel™v2

gÇyhvke2iopÓjmen6n~ee¤Œ~vjuoŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjueg*iuoUŠ—ejmoÇgŠ—Šhl#e2lei‚v,op

gÇ}imoy~f6gsj1jmt~evmgl6eNju{|l6eÏ,ÐDj<f~ime2vuenSjmvjmt~e'ȂthgŠ—Š|enh}eNop

t~osŽXjuo*~y~{|Š‹Œg4iuoUŠ—e½_Zgvue2Œ}UiuoUy~fŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnpÎi‚gl6eŽoimÔ

Ž{ƒjmt~{—n/À'ÂÉÊÕ{|n%Œz{|vkjuim{|~yzjue¤Œ§enˆˆ{—imon~l6e2nUj¤Ï

Nt~{‹vfhgfeig{|l6v0juo4~y~{|Š|Œg}UiuoUy~fŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnÇpÎimgl#e½

ŽAoUiuÔ/Ž{—juth{—nXÀÂNÉÊÏ0Nt~e6pÎi‚gl6e2ŽAoUiuÔ%{|nhÈ(Š|yhŒze¤vg§iuoUŠ—e½

hgvue2ŒX}UiuoUy~f֌ze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnÖ}i‚gnSjm{—n~}rl#ozŒze2ŠP}UiuoUy~f֌ze2Š—e½

}Ugsjm{—oUn/imeozÈ2gsju{|onl6ozŒzeŠ_¯}i‚gnSjm{—n~}†gyzjuthoim{—פgsju{|on/gnhŒ

iue2ozÈgju{|onÍgyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|onaÏÙØKe%gnhgŠ|„ˆ×eځsgiu{|oyhv#imeUo½

Ègsjm{—oUnhv™gnZŒÍjmt~e%{|l#fZgÈÛj†op4imeUoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUnhv#on:iuoUŠ—et~{|eiu½

gi‚È‚t~{—e¤vÏ#Nt~e6{—l6f~Š|el6e2nUj‚gsjm{—oUnKŽ{—jut]Ü4ÄrÝُZgvue2ŒrjuoˆoŠ‹v

Œzel6onZv…jmimgjue2vGjmt~eNpÎimgl6eŽoimÔÇgnhŒgyzjuthoim{—פgsju{|onl6e(jut~½

oˆŒhvÏ,Þ{—nhgŠ—Š|„SÈ(oUl#fZgim{|vuonhvGŽ{—jut6ojmt~eiimeŠ‹gsjme2ŒŽoimÔgime

{—nhŒ~{|È2gsjue¤Œ¯Ï

ß àá ·¸sâaãäG»·2åÁâ á

Nt~eæ4gsju{|onZgŠ0ÐÑnZv…jm{ƒjmyzjueopA‡Sj‚gnhŒ~gimŒhv'gnZŒ%0e¤È‚t~n~oŠ|o}U„

ŒzeUeŠ|ofe2Œ6jmt~e4imoŠ|e(½DhgUvke¤Œ#gUÈÈe2vmv<È(oUnSjuimoŠG¿PÀÂNÉÊ'Å1f~iuo½

juoj…„ˆfe™¿ÁÞ~e2{—nZv…jme{|nçÏ~1ϯè¤ééU”UÅ1gnhŒ†f~yh~Š—{‹vut~e2ŒgpÎoiml6gŠ

l#ozŒze2Š0¿ÁÞheimimg{—oUŠ—o*dÏUÞAÏUgnhŒ#êÇy~t~n6dÏU¼Ï~è2éUéUëUÅÛÏ0ÀÂNÉÊ

thgvee2nՎ{‹ŒzeŠ|„Æyhvue2ŒÕ{|nIŒ~gjmghgvue¾vu„zv…jmel7l™gnhg}Ue(½

l#e2nSjÚgnhŒìŒz{‹v…jmiu{|~yzjme2Œ:enˆˆ{|iuoUn~l6enSjmv™vu{—nZÈ(e%{—j†enhg~Š—e¤v

l6gnhg}U{—nh}ÙgnZŒ>enzpÎoUimÈ{—nh}Ùvue2È(yhiu{—j…„Ù{|n튋gim}e½DvmÈgŠ—e/gnhŒ

enSjue2iuf~im{‹vke½_Ž{‹Œze3vu„zv…jmel™v2ÏÙÀÂNÉÊî{—nˆoUŠ—Ue2v{—nZŒz{—ˆ{‹ŒzyhgŠ

yhvke2imv4e{|n~}§gUvuvuozÈ({‹gsjme2ŒŽ{—jutrimoŠ|e2v*gv'ŽAe2Š—ŠgUv'imoŠ|e2v'Ze½

{—n~}KgvmvkozÈ({‹gsjme2Œ¾Ž{—jutÖfeiml6{|vmvk{|onZv†¿Á˜AgȂtXfeiml#{‹vmvk{|on]{‹v

g3fZg{|i4opAo~ï…e2ÈÛj‚vÇgnhŒKofei‚gsjm{—oUnhvmÅ(ϖ'vvuyhȂtaag§imoŠ|e{‹v

yhvke¤ŒÖjmoXgvmvkozÈ({‹gsjme3yZvke2imv6gnZŒÖfeiml#{‹vmvk{|onhv2ÏٖcyZvke2i#{|n

jut~{‹vNl6oˆŒ~eб{|vNgtSyhl6gnڏe{|n~}hÏ1–ÕimoŠ|e'{‹vg'ï…oÚpÎy~nhÈ(ju{|on

oiÇï…oÙju{—juŠ|e%Ž{—jut~{|nÍjmt~e%oim}Ugn~{|×2gsjm{—oUnÍgvmvuoˆÈ{|gjue¤ŒÖŽ{—jut

gyzjmt~oim{ƒj…„3gnhŒ3iue¤vkfonZvk{|~{|Š—{—j…„Ï

ð,eiml6{|vmvu{—oUn{|vgn#gf~f~imossgŠSopZg*fhgikjm{|Èy~Š|giGoUfZe2imgju{|on

juoe'feiupÎoiml6e2Œ6on™oUn~eoUi1l6oimeozï…e¤ÈÛj‚vÏ,–'vAvkt~osŽn™{|n

ÞG{|}yhiueñèjmt~eimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvut~{—fZv'e(j…Žee2nryhvuei‚v4gnhŒ%imoŠ|e2v2

gnhŒ#e(j…Žeen#imoŠ|e2v,gnhŒfeiml#{‹vmvk{|onhvgiuel™gnˆ„S½Pjmo½Dl™gnˆ„

¿Î{_ÏeUÏ1gfZe2iul6{‹vuvu{|on†Ègn™Ze*gvmvkozÈ{|gjue2Œ6Ž{—jutÚon~eoUi<l6oime

iuoUŠ—e¤v±gnhŒrg™iuoUŠ—eÈgnrZe#gvmvkozÈ({‹gsjme2ŒŽ{—jut/oUn~eoUi'l6oime

fZe2iul6{‹vuvu{—oUnhv‚ÅÛÏòNthe¾vue2Èy~iu{—j…„>foŠ|{|Ȅ>opjmt~e]oim}Ugn~{—פgs½

ju{|on͌zejue2iul6{|n~e2viuoUŠ—e†l6e2lei‚vkt~{|fÖgnZŒ¾jut~e§gŠ|Š—ozÈgju{|on

op,e2gȂt§imoŠ|eÒvÈ2gfhg~{|Š—{—ju{|e2v2Ï

Nt~eÖÀÂNÉÊól6ozŒzeŠvky~fhfZoUikj‚v§jut~eÖvufZe¤È({—ôZÈgju{|onIop

vke2ei‚gНgUvkfe2È(jmv2Ï

õ±öÛ÷(ø¤ùPúüûÛýþ6ÿ þ_ùüú'õ±ö÷ þkùö ÿ úÑþÓø

ÿ ýºú

÷

÷ …ù!‚÷º÷ "‚ù$#%mþ

!&

$(þÓø')(0úþPý þ_ù ú'õ±ö÷ þ…ù*

ÿ

ú$

ÿ

õ±ö+,…ù$ ÿ

õ*ºõ 0/132

ö4‚ùÁþ

5¤ú 66

þPù7üú 68

‚ùPø

õ¯ö'+9…ù$

ÿ

ú;:<‚ù

ÿ

ý=#?>ù7

ÿ

þPú

ÿ

Nú +|öÛù5

þPúüö ÿýºöüöÛû‚ø *@

öBA0C

@

#ºúúüùED

þPúF¤úÁõ!

þ_ùPö=#HGú

I ö44ºú DJ#

:*…÷ºù_öK#

ÿ

þPúüöL+—öÛù5

ÿ

#"ú

ÿ

ºö‚þMN+—öÛù÷ºù_öOºþ'÷ ù

÷ö

÷ …ùúþÁþ$#*÷¤ù_ö<F2ú#$#4þPýºú

þ1Pþú

ú ÿ #"#

g~ϙ€'vuei0QºimoŠ|e#gUvuvuozÈ({‹gsjm{—oUnhvSR/jmt~e™È(oUnhv…jmimg{—nSj‚vvkfe2È{ƒ½

p΄ˆ{|n~}6yhvke2igyzjmt~oim{|×2gsjm{—oUnhvAjuo™feiupÎoiml imoŠ|e2v'T

aÏb¼oŠ|ert~{|ei‚gi‚È‚t~{|e2vR:jut~e¾È(oUnhv…jmimg{—nSj‚vÚvufZe¤È({—p΄S{|n~}

Žt~{‹È‚tXimoŠ|e™l6gº„¾{|n~t~eim{—j#gŠ|Š<opNjut~e3fZe2iul6{‹vuvu{—oUnhvopgnz½

ojut~e2iiuoUŠ—eUT

ÈÏ0d4yzj…„Çvke2fhgi‚gsjm{—oUn*Èonhvkjui‚g{|nSjmvJRjmt~e2vue1gimeiuoUŠ—eQºimoŠ|e

gUvuvuozÈ({‹gsju{|onZv<{|nhŒz{‹Ègju{|n~}†È(oUnzËh{‹ÈÛjop,{—nSjmeime2vkj2š

ÈèÏ4‡Sj‚gsjm{|ÈvuefZgi‚gsjue¤Œ%Œzyzj…„]¿VWV~ÃÅSRg†Èonhvkjui‚g{|nSj

vufZe¤È({—p΄ˆ{—n~}/juthgj#g%yhvuei#Ègn~n~ojZe§gyzjmt~oim{—×2e2ŒKpÎoij…ŽAo

Œz{,X±eimenSjiuoUŠ—e¤vKT

ȤëzÏÖd4„ˆnhgl6{‹È§vuefZgi‚gsjue¤ŒÖŒzyzj…„Æ¿PÃYV~ÃÅ;RÖgKÈonz½

vkjui‚g{|nSj#vufZe¤È({—p΄S{|n~}Kjuthgj6gryhvuei6ÈgnُZegy~jut~oUiu{|×e¤Œ]pÎoi

j…Žo/Œz{,Xe2iue2nUjimoŠ|e2v~yzjÈ2gn~n~ojgÈ(jvk{|lyhŠƒj‚gn~e2oyhvuŠ—„K{—n

ojmt*T

Œ¯Ï>xgimŒ~{—nhgŠ—{—j…„ZRXjut~el™gsÌz{|ly~l nˆy~lZe2i6op4yZvke2imv

gŠ—Š|osŽAe¤Œ¯{PÏeÏ/thosŽbl™gnS„]yhvuei‚vÈ2gnXe3gyzjut~oUiu{|×e¤Œ¾pÎoi

gnS„XfZgiuju{‹È(y~Š‹gi#iuoUŠ—e]¿ÎimoŠ|eÈgi‚Œz{|nhgŠ|{—j…„zÅ(<eUÏ}Zϗ1oUn~Š|„Öon~e

l™gnZg}e2i2Ï

Nt~eNnSyhleiopiuoUŠ—e¤v,gnhŒyhvuei‚vG{|n6g4Š‹gim}eenSjmeimf~iu{‹vue

vu„zv…jmel Ègn’eÍtˆy~nZŒziue¤Œ~v/oUi%juthoyhvmgnhŒhvÏ q/gnhg}U{—nh}

jmt~e2vueimoŠ|e2v<gnhŒ™yhvuei‚v2UgnZŒ6jut~e2{—i{|nUjmeimiue2Š|gju{|onhvut~{|fhv{‹vAg

ˆ{—jmgŠGȂthgŠ|Š—e2n~}eÇjmthgsj*{|vopÓjue2n/t~{|}t~Š|„Œze2ÈenSjui‚gŠ|{—×2e2ŒgnZŒ

Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2Œjuo4g4vkl™gŠ—ŠUjue¤gl’op~fhiuoï…e2ÈÛj}imoy~fZvÏ0€4vke2ik½DimoŠ|e

gUvuvu{—}Un~l6enSj0{‹vGgfhgiuju{‹È(y~Š‹gimŠ|„*Èiu{—ju{‹ÈgŠUgŒ~l#{|n~{‹v…jmimgju{|e<gUÈÛ½

jm{—ˆ{—j…„Ke2È2gyhvue†gvmvk{|}nh{—n~}%feoUf~Š|e™juo%j‚gvuÔzv{|vgn~oiml™gŠ

l™gnZg}e2iu{‹gŠapÎy~nhÈÛjm{—oUnKgnhŒ/gvmvu{—}Un~{—nh}™yhvke2imv'juo3iuoUŠ—e¤v{‹v4g

nhgjuy~i‚gŠˆfhgikjopgvmvu{—}Un~{—nh}4yhvuei‚vGjuo*jmgUvkÔzv2ÏGÞhy~ikjmt~eiml6oime

jmt~e§gUÈÛjm{—ˆ{—ju{|e2v#{—nìŒz{‹v…jmiu{|~yzjme2ŒÙenˆˆ{—imonhl#e2nSj#gimeŒze2Èenz½

jmimgŠ—{|×e¤Œ>gnhŒÆŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ:juoÍyZvke2imvÚimgjut~e2i†jutZgnívu„zv…jmel

gUŒzl6{—n~{‹vkjui‚gsjuoUimv2Ï

d'e2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn]{|vgn]{—l6foiujmgnSjgUvkfe2È(jopÀÂNÉÊ gnZŒ

opÓjuen§ime}UgimŒ~e2ŒÚgUvon~eÇopjuthe*fhiu{|nhÈ({|fhgНl#oju{|sgsju{|on§e(½

t~{|nhŒ¾ÀÂNÉÊÏ0–Š—juthoy~}Utrjmt~e™{—l6foiujmgnhÈ(e6opNŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn

{|n3ÀÂNÉÊíthgvee2nÚime2È(oU}n~oU×e¤Œ6pÎoiNgŠ|onh}ju{|l6ez{—jthgv

n~oj'ime2È(e2{—Ue2Œ3lyhȂt/gjkjmenSju{|onaÏ\[tZgn~}™ej4gŠ¿[thgn~}†1Ï|

–'t~n=]#Ï|gnhŒxAtˆy;^*Ïs땕hè[±thgn~}41Ï|–t~n=]#Ï|gnZŒxAtSy

^*Ϥ땕SëÅZiue¤È(e2nUjmŠ—„4f~imofoUvue2ŒÇgimy~Š—e½_Zgvue2Œ4pÎimgl6eŽoimÔpÎoi

imoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ#Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn6{—nhȊ—yZŒz{—nh}jut~e*ÀÃ*Ä`_baUacal6ozŒzeŠ_Ï

ؾeyhvueAjmt~eÈ(oUnhÈ(e2fzjop±iuoUŠ—e½_Zgvue2ŒŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on#ZoUiuimosŽe2Œ

pÎimol jut~e2{—iAŽAoUiuÔ±Ï,Nt~e4ÈenSjui‚gŠZÈ(onSjmiu{|~yzjm{—oUnhv1op¯jut~{‹vAgik½

jm{|Ȋ—e§gime™juo¾Œze2vmÈ(im{—e†t~osŽ Že3È2gnX~yh{—Š‹ŒÍgpÎi‚gl6e2ŽAoUiuÔ

opimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ}imoyhf6Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on6Ž{—jut~{|n†ÀÂNÉÊì{|n†gŒz{‹v…½

jmiu{|~yzjme2ŒÖe2nˆS{|imon~l6enSj6gnhŒ]jmoK{|l6f~Š|el6enSj#jut~e%Œze2Š—e2}Ugs½

jm{—oUnpÎi‚gl6eŽoimԎ{—jut#Ü4Ä/ݏhgUvke¤ŒjmoˆoŠ‹vgnhŒŠ|gn~}yZg}e¤vÏ

Nt~eiue2l6g{—nZŒzei6op4jut~{‹v6fhgfZe2i™{|v6oUiu}Sgn~{|×e¤ŒÖgv#pÎoUŠƒ½

Š|osŽvš*‡ˆe2È(ju{|onXë†f~ime2vuenSj‚vjmt~e6iue2Š|gjue2ŒrŽAoUiuÔ%gUvuvuozÈ({‹gsjue¤Œ

Ž{—jutjut~eŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onl#ozŒze2Š|vgnhŒÀ'ÂÉÊϖ4v,jutheime2vuy~Š—jmv

op*jmt~{‹vÚvue2ÈÛjm{—oUnaŽe%ôhnhŒìjmthgsj§Zojut>}UiuoUy~fz½Dhgvue2ŒìŒze2Šƒ½

e2}Ugsjm{—oUnَ{—juth{—n>ÀÂNÉÊgnhŒ:{ƒj‚v™{—l6f~Š|el6e2nUj‚gsjm{—oUn:Ž{—jut

Ü*Ä/ÝrtZgvn~ojee2n3gnZgŠ|„ˆvue2Œ3gnhŒÚf~ime2vuenSjue¤Œ†{|n†juthe*Š|{—jk½

e2imgjuy~imeÏ%‡ˆe2È(ju{|on֓%fhiuoUfZoSvke¤vg/ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnKpÎi‚gl6e2ŽAoUiuÔ

Žt~{‹È‚t6{—nZÈ(Š|yhŒze2vjut~e'vkjuimyhÈ(juy~ime2v,opimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2ŒŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn

gnhŒ:iuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤ŒÍ}UiuoUy~fìŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onìl6ozŒzeŠ‹v2ÏI‡ˆe¤ÈÛju{|on>‘

f~imosˆ{|Œ~e2v*ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on¾gyzjmt~oim{|×2gsjm{—oUnhv2Ïd]*i‚gnSju{|n~}gyzjmt~o½

im{—פgsjm{—oUn§Ž{—jutKf~ime(½DiueeUyh{|vu{ƒjmeÈ(oUnhŒz{—ju{|onhv*gnhŒimeUozÈgsjm{—oUn

gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|on>gime/Œz{‹vuÈyhvmvke¤Œì{—n>jmt~{‹vÚvue2ÈÛjm{—oUnaÏ d4e(ôhn~{—½

jm{—oUnhv1op6fhgUi jlkmMk'nogUp$klqfhgUi rkslt uokSwv<x y,zYv<{|b}Uzgiue{|nz½

(2)

Role_Name

User_Name

Indicates

m

n

Senior−

Junior

m

n

OPERATION

PERMISSIONS

m

n

m

n

many−to−many relationships

Permission−role assignment (PA)

User−role assignment (UA)

OBJECT

USERS

ROLES

Þ{|}y~ime6èš1¼5^N–'xìimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvut~{—f0Ï

jut~e™imoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ/}imoy~f¾ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onKyhvu{—n~}Ü*Ä/ÝÙjue2Ȃthn~oŠ—½

o}„]gnZŒÍ‡ˆe2È(ju{|onKÈ(oUl#fZgime2vÇjmt~e3ŽoimÔr{|nXjmt~{|v#fhgfZe2i

gnhŒ§imeŠ‹gsjue¤ŒÚfhiue2S{|oyZvNŽAoUiuÔ±Ï1Þ{—nZgŠ|Š—„Uzjut~eÈonhȊ—yZvk{|on§op

jut~efhgfZe2i{|v{—n/‡ˆe¤ÈÛju{|on~Ï

¹z· ã âZ¸

d'e2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnr{‹vÇgn¾{—l6foiujmgnSj*pÎe2gjuy~ime{|n¾l6gnˆ„ÈoŠ|Š|gZo½

imgju{|onÙgf~f~Š|{|È2gsjm{—oUnhvÏìÞ~oUi6e(Ì~gl6f~Š|eA{—l™g}U{—nhe3jmthgsj6jmt~e

ÐÑl#l6{|}i‚gsjm{—oUnÙd4efhgikjml#e2nSj#{‹v6ŒzeUeŠ|of~{|n~}rfZgiujun~e2imvut~{|fhv

Zej…ŽAe2enÚ{|l6l6{—}Uimgju{|onÚg}enZÈ({|e2v<gnhŒ†feoUf~Š|e'{|nڊ|oˆÈ2gбgiu½

e2gvjuo]gŒhŒziue¤vuvfZoSvuvu{|~Š—e§f~imo~Š|el™v2ÏKÐÑl6l6{|}i‚gsju{|onÍo6½

È(ei‚v<giueg~Š|ejuofhiue2enSj<{|Š|Š—e2}UgŠZv…j‚gº„ˆv<gnhŒ™Èiu{|l6e{ƒp¯jmt~e„

e†È({|enSjuŠ|„3ÈoŠ|Š|gZoUimgjue4Ž{ƒjmt3jmt~efeofhŠ—eUÏ1Nt~eÇf~iuoU~Š|el#½

oim{—e2nUjme2ŒX{|l6l6{—}Uimgju{|n~}rvu„ˆvkjue2l ¿"V0Å{‹vf~imofoUvue2Œ¾jmo

{—l6f~imose4jut~evueimˆ{|Èe*gUvg#fhgikjNopGjut~eÇÐÑl6l6{—}Uimgju{|on§d'e½

fhgiujul6enSj¤Òvonh}o{|n~}*È(ol6ly~n~{—j…„*eKXoUikj‚v{—nhȊ—yZŒz{—nh}4{‹Œzen~½

ju{—p΄S{|n~}†fojmenSju{‹gŠ0f~iuoU~Š|el™vgnZŒ3ime2vuoŠ|ˆ{—nh}jmt~el e(pÎoime

jut~e2„Ze¤È(oUl#evu{—}Un~{—ôZÈgnUj¤ÏGØ>{—jut#e†È{—e2nUj1Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onaopÓ½

ôZÈ(e2imv0iue¤vkfonhŒ eSy~{‹È‚ÔˆŠ—„4juo4y~im}enSj0l6e¤vuvmg}Ue2vagnhŒÇ{—nZÈ(ime2gvue

jut~eÇjm{—l6evufZe2nUj'ÈonzpÎimonSjm{—n~}6f~imohŠ—e2l6v2Ï

ÐÑn"V±±o†È(e2imv'l6{—}UtUjǏe{|nˆoŠ|e¤Œ%{|nrl™gnˆ„%È(oUnz½

È(y~imiue2nSj™gUÈÛjm{—ˆ{—ju{|e2v†vuyhȂtìgv™È(oUnhŒzyhÈ(ju{|n~}X{|n~{ƒjm{|gŠ{|nSUe2vkju{—½

}Ugsjm{—oUnhv2gnhgŠ|„zvk{|n~}†gnZŒ/È(oUnzpÎiuoUnSju{|n~}ÚÈ(im{|l#e¤vf~imefhgiu{|n~}

{—l6l6{—}Uimgju{|onÙiue2fZoUikj‚v<gnhŒ:gvmvke¤vuvu{—nh}rf~imoï…e¤ÈÛjmv2ÏÖÐÑn:oiu½

ŒzeiNjmo#gUȂt~{—e2e4jut~{‹v2zyhvke2imvl™gº„™thgºUe'onhe*oUiAl6oUiue*iuoUŠ—e¤v

vkyhȂtìgv6Š|e2gUŒÍo†È(ei¤<fZgiuju{‹È({|fhgnSj6o†È(e2i2Aoi6iue2fZoUikjmei¤Ï

ÐÑnìjut~{‹v†eÌzgl6f~Š—eU0oUnS„UgXŒz{—ime2È(juoUi2Nn~e2e2Œ~v6jmoÍÈ(oˆoUimŒz{—½

nhgsjme6gnhgŠ|„zvk{|n~}gnhŒKÈ(oUnzpÎiuoUnSju{|n~}§Èiu{|l6e2vÇgnZŒKgUvuvue2vmvk{|n~}

f~iuoï…e2È(jmv2Ï%xAoUŠ—Š‹goi‚gsjm{—oUnK{‹vn~e¤È(e¤vuvmgim„%pÎoi{—n~pÎoiml6gju{|on

vkthgiu{|n~}KŽ{ƒjmtÙl6elZe2imvpÎimolójuthe2vue3j…Žorfhiuoï…e2ÈÛj‚vÏ֍Go

È(oŠ|Š‹goi‚gsjueÈ(Š|oUvueŠ|„gnhŒ/l™gÔej…ŽoÚfhiuoï…e2ÈÛj‚v'l6oUiue#vkyhÈ(½

È(e2vmvkpÎy~ŠP0oUnˆ„¾ŽoyhŠ|ŒÍŠ—{|ÔeÚjuo]ŒzeŠ|e}SgsjueÈ(e2ikj‚g{|nÖime2vufZoUnz½

vk{|~{|Š—{—ju{|e2v3juo>xAt~im{|vkju{|n~e]gnhŒ>theiv…j‚gX,ύNtherf~imeime'eSy~{—½

vk{—jue%È(oUnhŒz{—ju{|onhv6giueÚjuoXvke¤È(y~ime†jmt~e2vuef~imoˆÈe2vmvke¤vgnhŒXjmo

l#oUn~{—juoijmt~eÇf~iuoU}ime2vmv1opajut~eŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onaÏ,Þ~y~iujutheiml#oUiueU

xAt~iu{‹vkju{|n~el™gº„3nhee2Œ§jmoڌze2Š—e2}UgsjmeÇjut~e#ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ§iuoUŠ—eÇjmo

t~ei<vkjmg XÚgv,n~e¤È(e¤vuvmgim„oi,jmonj~eŠ|e}UgjuegÇimoŠ|e<jmogŠ|Šzl#e2l#½

Ze2imvop±gÇ}UiuoUy~f6gsjjuthe'vugl6eAjm{—l6eUÏØ>{—juthoyzjAŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

vkԈ{|Š—Š_1vke¤È(y~im{—j…„Ko™Èei‚vthgºUe™juoKŒzoreÌzÈe2vmvk{|eڎAoUiuÔKZe½

ÈgyZvke6opjuthe{|i{—nˆUoŠ|el6e2nUjÇ{|nXee2iu„/vu{|n~}Š|e™È(oŠ|Š‹goi‚gs½

ju{|e3gUÈÛjm{—ˆ{—j…„Ï]Nt~e3l™gï…oiime'eSy~{|imel6enSjmvopimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on§{|n3jmt~{‹ve(Ì~gl6f~Š|egimeš

èÏ5]*iuoUy~fz½Dhgvue2ŒÚŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onÚl#e¤gnhvAjmthgsjgŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|n~}

yhvueil™gº„Únhee2Œ3jmo†ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjueg6imoŠ|e*juoÚgŠ—Š0l#e2lei‚v

opg#}imoy~fgsjNjuthevugl#e*jm{—l6eÏ

ëzÏq%y~Š—ju{‹v…jmef ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnÆozÈÈ(yhimv3Žt~en g͌~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

Ègn/ZepÎy~iujut~e2i*Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2ŒaÏ*‡ˆ{|n~}Š|e(½Ñvkjuef/Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

l6e2gnZvjutZgsjjutheŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ§iuoUŠ—eÈ2gn~nhojepÎy~iujut~e2i

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ¯Ï

“hÏN¼eozÈ2gsju{|on%vmȂt~el6e¤vgimegn%{|l6fZoUikj‚gnSjpÎe¤gsjuyhiueop

ÈoŠ|Š|gZoUimgju{|on/vu„zv…jmel™vÏ#Nt~e„j‚gÔUe#gºŽNgº„§jut~e™Œze2Šƒ½

e2}Ugjue2Œ:feiml6{|vmvk{|onZvÏ Nt~eime/gime/Œz{,Xe2iue2nSjÚiue2oUÔU½

{|n~}¾vuȂt~e2l6e2v'TAgl6oUn~}%juthel gime3vkjuimonh}rgnhŒÖŽAe¤gÔ

imeUozÈgsjm{—oUnhv2*È2gvmÈgŒ~{—n~}ÆgnhŒIn~onZÈgvmÈgUŒz{|n~}ìiue2o½

È2gsjm{—oUnhvgUv†ŽeŠ|Š4gvÚ}i‚gnSjk½ÑŒze2fZe2nhŒzenSjÚgnhŒì}i‚gnSjk½

{|nhŒze2fZe2nhŒze2nUj#iue2ozÈgju{|onhvÚ¿ÎØ]gn~}rçϗAxgohÏ,gnZŒ

[±thgn~}Ï땕U“UÅ(Ï

‘ZÏxAoUnhvkjui‚g{|nUj‚v3giue]gnÕ{—l6foiujmgnUjpÁgUÈÛjuoUi{—n ÀÂNÉÊ

pÎoUi<Š‹gº„ˆ{—n~}oUyzj<t~{|}theiu½_Š|eUeŠ~oUiu}Sgn~{|×2gju{|onhgŠzfZoUŠ—{‹È({|e2v

¿Áؾgn~}çϗ~xgoZÏUgnhŒ [thgn~}ψë•U•~è¤Å(ύNthe„6Œze(½

ôZn~eŽt~ejut~e2i'oi'n~ojjmt~eŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onoiimeUozÈgsjm{—oUn

fhiuozÈ(e¤vuv{‹vsgŠ|{|ŒaÏ

”~ÏNðgikjm{|gЧŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onòl#e¤gnhv:oUn~Š—„òvky~Zvkejmv:opKjut~e

feiml6{|vmvu{—oUnhv'giueŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ%Žt~{|Š—ejuoj‚gŠ,ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn

l6e¤gnhvAgŠ|ŠZfeiml6{|vmvk{|onZv<gime'Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2ŒaÏðgikjm{|gŠZŒze2Šƒ½

e2}Ugju{|on6{|vgnÚ{—l6foiujmgnSj1pÎe¤gsjmy~iue4Ze¤Ègyhvke4{ƒjNgŠ|Š—osŽv

yZvke2imv<on~Š|„#juo6ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjue4iueeSy~{—ime2Œ6feiml6{|vmvu{—oUnhvÏ,Nt~e

ŽeŠ|Š—½_Ԉn~osŽn%Š|e2gUv…j*f~iu{|ˆ{—Š|e}Uevue2Èy~iu{—j…„f~im{—nhÈ{—fhŠ—e6Ègn

e{|l#fhŠ—e2l#e2nSjue2Œ3jmt~iuoUy~}t§fhgikjm{|gбŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onaÏ

–Š—jut~oUy~}trjut~e™È(oUnhÈ(e2fzjÇopAŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on/{‹vÇn~ojÇn~e2Ž {—n

gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|onhv¿Á–'y~img§ÇÏ,è2éUéé~J^NgimÔºgژϯgnhŒ¾‡zgnZŒztˆy

¼Ïë•U••Ug~Ø]gn~}:çÏ|Y[thgn~}Ï|*xgohÏNgnZŒ! 1gi‚gŒˆ½

thgimgïkgn" ÏÕ땕U“~¯Ø]gn~}/çϗ1‡ˆy~n֐<ϗ [tZgn~}#ϗgnZŒ

xgoZÏ땕S”Å(siuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤ŒŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnime2Èe{|e2ŒgsjujuenSjm{—oUn

oUn~Š—„Úiue¤È(enSjmŠ—„/¿^giuÔsg6˜Ï~gnhŒ‡zgnhŒ~tSy¼ÏZ땕U•g~b^NgimÔsg

˜'ÏgnhŒ†‡~gnhŒztˆy†¼Ïˆë•U••0U[thgnh}1Ï|S–'t~nB]#Ï|SgnhŒ†xAtSy

^*Ïhë•U•~èUW[±thgn~}™<ϗh–'t~n ]#ϗZgnhŒ/xAtˆy ^4Ïh땕SëÅÛϖ'y~img

¿P–y~i‚gÇÏhè¤ééUéUÅ{|nUjmiuozŒzyZÈ(e2Œ6ÔUe„S½Doim{—e2nUjme2Œ#Œz{‹vuÈiueju{|onhgiu„

gUÈÈ(e¤vuv,ÈonSjuimoŠˆvk„zvkjue2l6vjmthgsj<giuehgUvke¤Œon6Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnop

gUÈÈ(e¤vuv±im{|}tSjmv±Ž{—jutf~yh~Š—{‹ÈÛ½DÔe2„4Èeiuju{—ôZÈgjue2v2Ï0Nt~eAvk„zvkjuel™v

e2l#fhthgvu{—×2e2ŒKŒze2ÈenSjui‚gŠ|{—פgsjm{—oUnropNgyzjmt~oim{—j…„rgnhŒKofei‚gs½

jm{—oUnhv,~yzj1jmt~e{|i<gf~f~imoUgȂt{|v<g*pÎoimlWop¯Œz{‹vuÈiueju{|onhgiu„gUÈÛ½

Èe2vmv<È(oUnSjuimoŠ_Ïç'enhÈeˆjuthe„™Ègn†n~e{—jutheiNe(Ìzf~ime2vmv1l™gnZŒ~gs½

jmoim„fZoUŠ—{‹È({|e2v1Š—{|ÔeNjmt~e\^eŠ|Šƒ½Ñ0gUðgŒzyhŠ|g4l6oˆŒ~eŠG¿^eŠ|ŠhdϘÏ|

GgðgŒ~y~Š|g1Ïhϯè¤é$#UÅÛSn~oUiA{‹v{ƒjfoUvmvk{|~Š|e'jmo#Ueim{ƒp΄#jmthgsj

vuol6eoUn~e/Œzoˆe2v3n~oj3thgºUe/gÍÈ(e2ikjm{ƒôÈgsjmeÏ Þhy~ikjmt~eiml6oime

vuol6e{—l6foiujmgnUj†foŠ|{‹È({|e2v™vuyhȂt>gv™vuefhgimgju{|onÍopnj~yzj…„

foŠ|{|È{—e¤vÈgnhn~ojZe]ëfhiue¤vuvue2ŒíŽ{ƒjmtÕoUn~Š—„ÆÈeiuju{—ôZÈgjue¤vÏ

Nt~e2„Ön~e2e2ŒìvkoUl6egUŒ~Œz{—ju{|onhgŠl6e2Ȃthgn~{|vul jmoXl6g{—nSj‚g{|n

jmt~e6f~iue2ˆ{—oUyhvkŠ|„%}i‚gnSjme2Œ%im{—}UtSjmvÇgnhŒrjuthe#th{|vkjuoUiu{|e2v*lyZv…j

ey~f±Œ~gsjme2Œ{|n%iue¤gбju{|l6eŽt~e2n%n~eŽ È(e2ikjm{ƒôZÈ2gsjme2vgiueÇ{‹v…½

vuy~e2ŒaÏd4eŠ|e}Sgsju{|on#{‹vgŠ‹vkoÇgf~fhŠ—{|e2Œ#{|n6Œ~e2È(e2nSjui‚gŠ|{—×2e2ŒjmiuyZv…j

l™gnZg}e2l6enSj3¿M^Š‹g×2eÚqXÏÞ~e2{—}Uenˆhgyhl%ZϗÐÑoSgn~nh{|Œz{‹v&hÏ

gnhŒêÇe2iuoUl„Sju{‹v0–Ïzè2ééUé~ºa{zæÏgnhŒ=]*imoUvuop^*ÏsæÏ땕U•UÅÛÏ

^Š‹g×e¾e(j/gІ¿M^Š|g×eXqXÏÞhe{|}enˆhgy~l'Zϗ*ÐÑoUgn~n~{‹Œz{‹v(hÏ

gnhŒ3êÇe2iuoUl„Sju{‹v–Ï0è2ééUéUÅ<{|Œ~enSju{—ôhe2Œ§jmt~eÇjuimyhvkjl™gnhg}e(½

l6enSjf~imo~Š|el gvgnjz{‹v…jm{—nhÈ(j<gnhŒ{|l#foiujmgnSjÈol6fon~e2nUj

opvke¤È(y~im{ƒj…„:{|nÆn~e(j…ŽoimÔÙvueimˆ{|Èe2v3gnhŒÆ0{4ej§gŠ#¿Pa{ÇæÏ

gnhŒ ]*iuoSvkopY^*Ï<æÏNë•U••UÅl™gŒ~e/g]Š—oU}{‹ÈÛ½Dhgvue2ŒÙԈn~osŽŠƒ½

(3)

vk„zvkjuel™v2ÏÕd4eŠ|e}Sgsju{|onìŽNgv6yhvue2Œ:jmoÖgŒ~Œ~iue¤vuv#jmt~e%juimyhvkj

l6gnhg}Uel6enSjf~imo~Š|el{|nhȊ—yhŒ~{—n~}pÎoUiuly~Š‹gsju{|n~}vke¤È(y~im{—j…„

fZoUŠ—{‹È({|e2vgnhŒvke¤È(y~im{ƒj…„Èiue¤ŒzenSju{‹gŠ‹v2¤Œzejue2iul6{|n~{—nh}'Žt~ejut~e2i

fhgiuju{‹È(y~Š‹givkejmvAopGÈiue¤ŒzenSjm{|gŠ|vAvugju{‹v…p΄#juthe4imeŠ|esgnSj<foŠ|{—½

È({|e2v2,gnhŒÖŒzepÎeimiu{|n~}%jmiuyZv…jjmo/jmt~{—i‚ŒXfhgikjm{—e¤vÏ'jmt~eiiue½

vke¤gi‚È‚t~ei‚v'tZgºe#{—nˆe¤v…jm{—}Sgsjme2Œ/l™gUȂt~{—nhejmol6gUȂt~{|n~e#gnhŒ

tSyhl6gn†jmol™gȂth{—n~e*ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnhv4¿Áؾgn~}çϗZxgoZÏSgnhŒ

[thgnh}!Ïë•U•~è4–hgUŒz{#qÖϗ^y~iuimosŽv/qXÏ|Ggl6fhvuon

^4Ï|,gnhŒ¾ð1Š|ojmÔS{|n ]#Ï1è2éUé“SÅÛϙÞ~oUie(Ì~gl6f~Š|eGؾgn~}e(jgŠ

¿ÎØ]gn~}Íçϗ'xgo hÏ<gnhŒ [thgn~}"ÏN땕hè¤Åf~imofoUvue2Œìg

vke¤È(y~ime0vmÈgŠ|g~Š|e#gn~onˆ„ˆl6{ƒj…„/fZgº„Sl6e2nUjÇf~imojmoˆÈoŠ,pÎoUi*ÐÑn~½

jueimn~ej*f~yhimȂthgUvke¤vjmt~imoy~}Utrgnrg}e2nUj*Žt~{‹È‚trf~imosˆ{|Œze¤Œ/g

t~{—}Ut~eign~onˆ„ˆl6oyhvNÈeiuju{—ôZÈgjuegnhŒ§{|l6f~iuosUe2Œ†jut~evue2Èyz½

iu{—j…„]op4Èonhvuy~l6ei‚vÏ]Nt~e§g}e2nSj#È(e2ikjm{ƒôZe2ŒXime(½DenhÈiu„ˆfzjme2Œ

Œ~gsj‚g/gspÓjmeiUeim{ƒp΄ˆ{|n~}jut~eځºgŠ—{‹Œz{—j…„ropjmt~eÚÈonSjue2nUjpÎiuoUl

È(onZvky~l6e2imv2Ï>Nt~e/g}UenSj™{|v†g¾tˆy~l™gnÙjuoXl™gUȂt~{—nheŒ~eŠ—½

e}Ugju{|on’Žt~{‹È‚t Ègn’f~imosS{‹ŒzeXn~e2Ž È(e2ikjm{ƒôZÈ2gsjme2v2Ïñç'osŽN½

ee2i2zl™gnS„3{—l6foiujmgnUjimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ3È(oUnhÈ(e2fzjmv2zpÎoieÌ~gl#½

f~Š—eU~imoŠ|e*th{—e2imgimȂt~{|e2v2zÈ(oUnhv…jmimg{—nSj‚vˆimeozÈ2gsju{|on3ŽAe2iueÇn~oj

l#e2nSju{|on~e¤Œ¯Ï

[thgn~}#e(jgŠ1¿7[thgnh}#<ϗ~–'t~nH]#Ï|hgnhŒ§xAtˆyH^4Ïh땕hè

[thgnh}ǐ<ϗS–t~n.]#Ï|UgnhŒ†xAtSy ^*ÏU땕UëUÅafhiuoUfZoSvke¤ŒgÇimy~Š—e½

hgvue2ŒKpÎi‚gl6eŽoimÔ%pÎoiiuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤ŒrŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on]{—nZÈ(Š|yhŒz{|n~}

jut~eÀÃ*Ä`_baUaca6l6oˆŒ~eŠ_Ï,Nthe*ÀÃ*Ä`_oacaca™l6ozŒzeб{‹vhgvue2Œ

onXjmt~e§À'ÂÃ*Ä a]l6oˆŒ~eŠŽt~{|ȂtÍ{|v#grvu{—l6f~Š|e3Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

l#ozŒze2Švky~fhfZoUikjm{—n~}§onhŠ—„§ËZgj*imoŠ|e2v*gnhŒKvk{|n~}UŠ—e#v…jmefKŒ~eŠ—½

e}Ugju{|onaÏÞ~y~iujutheiml#oUiueUhgv'g†ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn3l6ozŒzeŠ_h{—j*Œ~oSe¤v

n~oj'vuy~f~foiuj}imoy~fz½DhgUvke¤ŒÚŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnaÏ

Nt~{‹vafhgfZe2i¯pÎozÈ(yhvue2v0e(Ì~È(Š|yhvu{—UeŠ|„ongimoŠ|e(½DhgUvke¤Œ'Œze2Š—e½

}Ugsjm{—oUnl#ozŒze2ŠaŽt~{‹È‚t/vkyhf~fZoUikj‚v}imoyhfz½_Zgvue2ŒÚŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

gnhŒ:{—jmv†{|l6f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|onìŽ{—jut>Ü4ÄrÝIjue2Ȃthn~oŠ|o}U„ÏÆØ¾e

e(̈jue2nhŒÍoUy~i#f~iue2ˆ{—oUyhvŽoimÔXgnhŒÍf~imofoUvueÚgKŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

pÎimgl#e2ŽAoUiuÔí{—nhȊ—yZŒz{—nh}íŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnI}UimgnSju{|n~}>gnhŒ imeUo½

Ègsjm{—oUn>l6oˆŒ~eŠ‹vN}imoyhfz½_Zgvue2Œ:ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on0ÏՍGoXf~iuosˆ{‹Œze

vky †È{—e2nUj§pÎy~nhÈ(ju{|onhv§Ž{—jut>jmt~eKpÎimgl#e2ŽAoUiuÔ±Njmt~{|v§fhgfZe2i

gnhgŠ—„zvue2vNt~osŽIȂthgn~}Ue2vAjuo™oUiu{|}{|nhgŠimoŠ|egvmvk{|}nhl#e2nSj{|l#½

fhgÈ(jNyhfZoUn§Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÚime2vuy~Š—jmv2ύNt~{|vԈ{|nhŒÚopGimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ

}imoy~fXŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnXgnhŒ¾{—jmv{|l6f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|onXŽ{—jutXÜ*Ä/Ý

thgºeÇn~ojNee2n%v…jmyhŒz{|e2Œ§ZepÎoimeÏ

â µ,¹~¶ ãh¸sâä>ã Z¹~·2åÁâ á ¸º¹ âh¸

ÐÑnÚjmt~{|v'vke¤ÈÛju{|on3ŽAeÇf~imofoUvue4g#imoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ†}imoy~fڌ~eŠ|e}Ug½

ju{|onÙpÎimgl#e2ŽAoUiuÔXÈ2gŠ|Š—e¤ŒÍÀÂÃîŽt~{‹È‚tìvky~fhfZoUikj‚vimoŠ|e

t~{—e2imgimȂtˆ„ÆgnhŒí}UiuoUy~fՌ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onՏS„í{—nSjuimozŒzyhÈ{—n~}:jmt~e

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on§imeŠ‹gsju{|on0Ï

â

µ¹h¶

ã:ã

¹z·2åPâ

á

Öâaã

– vue2vmvk{|onî{|v:gn {|l6fZoUikj‚gnSj>È(onZÈ(ef~jَ{—jut~{|nòÀÂNÉÊ

Žt~{|Ȃtìl6e2gnhv†g¾l™gf~fh{—n~}Xe(j…Žee2n>gKyZvke2i†gnhŒ:foUvmvk{—½

~Š—„Íl6gnˆ„¾imoŠ|e2v2ÏXÞ~oUi#eÌ~gl6f~Š|e<gKyhvuei#l6gº„Xe¤v…j‚g~Š|{‹vkt

g#vue2vmvu{—oUn3ˆ„ÚgUÈÛju{|sgsjm{—n~}™vuol6evkyhhvkejop,gvmvk{|}n~e¤Œ†imoŠ|e2v2Ï

– vke¤vuvu{|on{|v4gŠ|Žgº„zvgUvuvuozÈ({‹gsjue¤ŒÚŽ{—jutKg™vk{|n~}Š|eyhvuei'gnhŒ

e2gȂt§yhvueiNl™gº„†e2vkjmg~Š|{|vut3×2eimooUiNl#oUiueÇvue2vmvk{|onhv2ύNt~eime

l6gº„’e:t~{—e2imgimȂth{—e¤vrŽ{—jut~{|nWimoŠ|e2v2Ï ‡ˆe2n~{—oUiKimoŠ|e2v¾gime

vkt~osŽn¾gsjÇjuthejmof¾op1jmt~e6t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚t~{—e¤vÏ#‡ˆen~{|oiÇimoŠ|e2v4{—n~½

t~eim{ƒjNfeiml#{‹vmvk{|onhv<pÎimol ï…y~n~{|oiimoŠ|e2v2ϐ0e(j™Œze2n~ojme

Ú{‹v1vke2n~{|oijmoŽ{—jut™oUSˆ{|oyhv,ëjuenZvk{|on6jmo±Ï¼oŠ|e

t~{—e2imgimȂth{—e¤vNf~iuosˆ{‹Œzeg6fZosŽeiupÎy~ŠagnhŒÈ(onˆUen~{|enSjl6e2gnhv

juo¾enzpÎoUimÈe†juthe§fhiu{|nhÈ({|f~Š|e3opŠ—e¤gvkj#fhiu{|ˆ{—Š|e}Ue3vu{—nhÈe3oUn~Š|„

iueeUyh{—ime2Œ¾feiml#{‹vmvk{|onhvjuo/feiupÎoiml g§j‚gvuÔ¾giue™gvmvu{—}Un~e2Œ

juo6jutheiuoUŠ—eUÏ

–Š—juthoy~}UtÖjuthe3È(oUnhÈ(e2fzj6op'g/yZvke2iÈgn֏e3eÌSjmenhŒ~e2Œ

juo¾{—nhȊ—yZŒze3{|nSjue2Š—Š|{—}UenSj™gyzjmon~oUl#oUyhv#g}e2nSjmv2l6gUȂt~{|n~e2v2

ee2n]n~e(j…ŽoimÔzv¯Že6Š—{|l6{ƒjg§yhvueiÇjmo/g§tSyhl6gn]Ze2{—n~}%{|n

oy~il6ozŒzeŠapÎoivu{—l6f~Š|{|È{ƒj…„UÏ

Þ{—}Uy~ime ë:vkthosŽvÚjmt~eXimoŠ|eKt~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„>v…jmiuyhÈ(juy~ime]op

ÀÂNÉÊW{|n "V±Ï¯Nt~e#pÎoŠ|Š|osŽ{—n~}g~Š|e3è#e(Ìzf~ime2vmvue2v*gn

e(Ì~gl6f~Š|eÇop,yhvke2ik½DimoŠ|e*gUvuvu{—}Un~l6enSjN{—n("V¯Ï

Nt~e2iuegime*j…ŽAo™vue(j‚vNop,yhvke2imvgUvuvuozÈ({‹gsjme2Œ†Ž{—jutimoŠ|eÇi2š

4im{—}U{—nhgбyhvke2imvNgiue'jut~oSvkeÇyhvuei‚vŽt~o#giueÇgvmvu{—}Un~e2Œ6jmo

jut~eimoŠ|eÇi'T

d4Ѕ¼ 0oUnˆ„

çè xAt~im{|vkju{|n~e

çÇë q/{—ÔUe

xAoZè ¼{|ȂtZgi‚Œ

¼eè Uothn

xN‡ –t~n

Gg~Š|e™èš€'vueiu½D¼oŠ|e*imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvut~{—f0Ï

d'e2Š—e2}Ugsjme2ŒÚyhvke2imvgimejmt~oUvue*yhvke2imvŽt~o6gime4Œ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ

jmojmt~eimoŠ|e*i¤Ï

Nt~evmgl6eyhvuei'È2gn%egn%oUiu{|}{|nhgŠ0yhvke2iopoUn~eiuoUŠ—e

gnhŒÚg#ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ†yZvke2iAopgnhojutheiiuoUŠ—eUÏ,–'Š|vuo#{ƒj{‹vAfoUvmvu{ƒ½

~Š|eÇpÎoi4g6yhvke2iNjuo†eojut/gnoim{—}U{—nhgНyhvuei'gnhŒg™ŒzeŠ|e(½

}Sgsjue¤Œ#yhvke2i1op±jmt~e'vmgl6eimoŠ|eÏ,Þ~oi<e(Ì~gl6f~Š|eU{ƒpxAt~im{‹v…jm{—n~e

Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2vt~ei#iuoUŠ—e rjuor¼{‹È‚thgimŒ¯jmt~en:¼{|ȂtZgi‚Œ]{|v

ojmt#gnoUiu{|}{|nhgŠˆyhvuei¿Áe(Ìzf~Š|{|È{ƒjmŠ—„~Å,gnhŒgnjze2Š—e2}Ugjue2Œyhvuei

¿Á{—l6f~Š|{|È{ƒjmŠ—„~ÅGop~imoŠ|e*Ê"!# 'e2È2gyhvue1jmt~eNiuoUŠ—e$ *{|v,vuen~{|oi

jmojut~e4iuoUŠ—e#Ê"!% Ï,Nt~e4oim{—}U{—nhgŠ~yhvueigvmvk{|}n~l6e2nUj*¿'&GÉÇÅ

{‹v'g™l™gnS„S½_juo½_l™gnˆ„†yZvke2i4gvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjiue2Š|gju{|one(j…Žeen

oUiu{|}{|nhgŠyZvke2imvgnhŒ]imoŠ|e2v2ϧNthe3Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2Œ¾yhvuei#gvmvk{|}nz½

l6enSj4¿(&GÉ4ÃÅ<{|vAgŠ‹vkogÇl™gnˆ„S½_juo½Dl™gnˆ„yhvueiAgvmvk{|}n~l6e2nUj

imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnڏe(j…Žeen%Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2Œ3yhvuei‚vNgnhŒ§imoŠ|e2v2Ï

ØKe6thgºUejmt~e#pÎoŠ|Š—osŽ{|n~}%È(oUl6fZoUn~enSjmv4pÎoUiiuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ

Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÚl6ozŒze2ŠPš

) q+*dq-,’gnhŒ/.Ígime4vue(j‚vAop0yhvuei‚vSimoŠ|e2v2Ufeiml6{|vmvk{|onZv

gnhŒ3vue2vmvu{—oUnhvˆime2vufZe¤ÈÛjm{—UeŠ|„Ï

èUÏ0)132546)879*{‹v*gÚl™gnˆ„S½Pjmo½Dl6gnˆ„§oUiu{|}{|nhgŠ0yhvuei

jmo6iuoUŠ—egvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ

ë~Ï0)1;:<4)7=*Æ{|v1gÇl™gnS„S½_juo½_l™gnˆ„Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2Œyhvuei

jmo6iuoUŠ—egvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ

“hÏ0)1?>?)12@)13:A

‘ZÏN€4vke2imv2šB*6C ëEDG{|v*g6pÎy~nZÈÛju{|onrl6gf~f~{|n~}ÚopiuoUŠ—e¤vjuo

vue(j‚vNop,yhvuei‚vÏ

)=F'krGFS¿)rÅ=><HJILK—¿MIq"rÅONP)1Q†Žt~e2iue)1{|vyZvke2ik½

imoŠ|eÇgvmvk{|}n~l6e2nUj¤Ï

”~Ï0)=F'krGFS¿)rÅR>S)FkrTF 26¿MrsÅU@)Fk'rGF :/¿MrsÅ

Žtheime

)=F'krGF 26¿)rÅV>WHXIYKZor\[ rq¤¿MIq"rT[ÓÅVN)132]Q

)=F'krGF :/¿)rÅ$>^HXIYKZbr [ rq¤¿MIq"r [ÅBN)1;:_Q

)=F'krGFS¿)rÅ4{—nZÈ(Š|yhŒze2vÇgŠ—Š,yhvuei‚v'Žtho3gimel6e2lei‚v'op

imoŠ|e rˆÏNt~eyhvuei‚vl™gº„3Zeoim{—}U{—nhgŠagnhŒ%Œ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ

yZvke2imv2Ï Nt~eXoim{|}{|nhgŠÇyhvuei‚v)FkrGF 26¿MrsÅrgime]n~oj

oUn~Š|„Çjut~el6elei,opZimoŠ|e r~y~jgŠ|vuo4jut~el6elei,op

g§vuen~{|oi*iuoUŠ—e#opErˆÏNt~e6l6elZe2imv*{|n`)FkrGF :/¿)rÅ

giueÇvu{—l6{|Š|giNjuo6jutZgsj{—n9)FkrGF 26¿)rÅÛÏ

Ø>{ƒjmtÚjmt~e2vueÈ(ol6fon~e2nSjmv2SŽeÇgnhgŠ—„zvue'}imoyhf3Œze2Š—e2}Ugs½

jm{—oUn3{|n§jut~eimel™g{|n~{|n~}6fhgiujopGjut~{‹vvue2ÈÛjm{—oUnaÏ

â

µ,¹~¶

ãZ¸ºâäUba

¹z·2åPâ

á

Nt~evmÈ(oUfZe'op±oy~i1l6ozŒze2Šh{‹vjuogŒ~Œzime2vmv,yhvueiu½Pjmo½Dyhvuei1Œze2Šƒ½

e2}Ugsjm{—oUn™vky~fhfZoUikjm{—n~}iuoUŠ—eth{—e2imgimȂt~{|e2v<gnhŒ™}UiuoUy~f†Œze2Š—e2}Ugs½

jm{—oUnhvÏØ¾e*Èonhvu{|Œ~ei<oUn~Š|„jmt~e4ime}Uy~Š‹gi1imoŠ|e'Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn™{—n

jmt~{|v<fhgfei¤e2e2n6jut~oUy~}t™{—j<{‹v1foUvmvk{|~Š|e'gnhŒ™Œ~e2vu{—i‚g~Š|eNjuo

Œze2Š—e2}UgjueÇgn%gŒzl6{|n~{‹v…jmimgju{|e*iuoUŠ—eUÏ

–òŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÖimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUní¿ÁÃc<ÝGÀ'Åe(Ìz{|vkjmv{|nÖjuthe§imoŠ|e(½

hgUvke¤ŒòŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onòl#ozŒze2Š/Žt~{‹È‚tc{—nhȊ—yZŒze2v:jmt~iue2e’eŠ|e(½

l6enSj‚vš¯oUiu{|}{|nhgŠsyZvke2iGgvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjmvB&É*2Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2Œ*yhvuei

gUvuvu{—}Un~l6enSj`&GÉ4ÃgnhŒìÈ(oUnhvkjui‚g{|nUj‚vÏÆNthe/l6oju{|sgsjm{—oUn

et~{|nhŒíjut~{‹v§iue2Š|gju{|onÆ{‹v3juoìgŒ~Œ~iue¤vuvÚjut~e]imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvkth{—fhv

gl#oUn~}Œz{,Xe2iue2nSjÈ(oUl6fZoUn~enSjmv<{—nˆUoŠ|e2Œ#{|nÚgŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onaÏ

ÐÑn gÍyZvke2ik½_juo½_yhvueiŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnajmt~eimeXgimerôZe]È(ol6fo½

(4)

Analysis Assessment

Project (AP) Project (AsP)

Report 1

Head Officer (HO1)

Collaborator 1

(Co1)

(Re1)

Report 2

(Re2)

Collaborator 2

(Co2)

Head Officer (HO2)

Director (DIR)

Community

Service (CS)

Project 1 Project 2

Þ{—}Uy~iueë~š1¼oŠ|eÇt~{—e2imgimȂtˆ„6{|n"V±Ï

Þ~oi<e(Ì~gl6f~Š|e ! ˆÃ …À ÑÊ ˆÃ …À E !

l#e¤gnhvNGonˆ„†gÈ(ju{|n~}#{—n§iuoUŠ—eÇÅÀՌze2Š—e2}Ugjue2vimoŠ|e4ÅÀÆjmo

xAt~iu{‹vkju{|n~e%onìÞ~im{|Œhgº„Ï:ØKe/gUvuvuy~l6e3e¤gȂtìŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnÍ{‹v

gvmvkozÈ({‹gsjme2ŒÍŽ{ƒjmt:×2eimo]oi6l6oimeÈonhvkjui‚g{|nSjmv2Ï:NtheŒ~eŠ—½

e}Ugju{|on%imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnrvkyhf~fZoUikj‚vfhgikjm{|gŠŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on%{|nrg†imoŠ|e

t~{—e2imgimȂth{—e¤vš¯gyhvueiGŽt~o{‹v0gyzjut~oUiu{|×e¤Œ4juo4Œ~eŠ|e}Ugjue1gimoŠ|e

r3ÈgnKgŠ|vuo§Œ~eŠ|e}Ugjue6g§iuoUŠ—e=r [ juthgjÇ{‹vï…y~n~{|oiÇjmoBrˆÏ™Þ~oUi

e(Ì~gl6f~Š|e"# ! Aà …À $‹É% NÀ&T ' B !™l6e2gnhv

0oUnS„¾gÈ(ju{|n~}{—nXimoŠ|e™Ã …À Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2vgï…y~nh{—oUiiuoUŠ—e†À(T

juo֖thn>on>Þ~im{|Œhgº„Ï햌ze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on:iue2Š|gju{|on:{|v™oUn~e(½_juo½

l6gnˆ„™iue2Š|gju{|onhvut~{|fÚon3yhvueigvmvk{|}nhl#e2nSjmv2ÏGÐDjÈ(oUnhvu{|vkjmvAop

oim{—}U{—nhgŠAyZvke2i#Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|oní¿NÀ …ÃÅ#gnZŒÍŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2ŒÍyhvke2i

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on¾¿ÁÃc<ÝGÃÅÛÏZÞG{|}yhiue “{—Š|Š|yhv…jmimgjue¤vÈol6fon~e2nUj‚v

gnhŒ3juthe{|iiue2Š|gju{|onhvN{|n%gimoŠ|e(½DhgUvke¤Œ†ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn3l6ozŒzeŠ_Ï

Þ~imolòjuthegoseŒz{‹vuÈyhvmvk{|onhv2ˆjuthepÎoŠ|Š—osŽ{|n~}†Èol6fZo½

n~enSjmv'gime'pÎoUiul™gŠ|{|×e2Œaš

èÏ:*)$+$*64?)1W79)1^7 fhtiF{|voUn~e(½_juo½_l™gnS„†Œ~eŠ—½

e}Sgsju{|on>imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ – Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on>imeŠ‹gsju{|onÆÈ2gn>e

iue2f~ime2vuenSjue¤ŒÍˆ„Õ¿u¿MIq"rÅq¤¿MI

[

q"r

[

ÅqfhtiFºÅN6:*)"+R*#

Žt~{‹È‚t:l6e¤gnhv#jmt~e/ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—n~}¾yhvuei I>Ž{—jutìimoŠ|eBr

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ/imoŠ|edr

[

juo§yhvke2iI

[

Žt~e2n/jmt~e™È(onZv…jmimg{—nSj

fhtiF{‹vvmgsju{‹vkôhe2Œ¯Ï

ëzÏ02*-,: 4P)1327)13:S7YfhtiFN{‹vgnoim{—}U{—nhgŠˆyhvke2i

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn3imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ

“~Ï:*)$+$: 4 )1;: 7 )13: 7 fhtiF3{|vg/Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2Œ

yhvueiŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn3imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ

‘hÏ:*)$+$*S>b2*-,E: @ :*)$+R:

Nt~eŠ|gUv…j*e'eSyhgsjm{—oUn/vkthosŽvjutZgsj*Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on%imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhv

È(onZvk{‹v…jop0oUiu{|}{|nhgŠZgnZŒ†ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ™yhvueiNŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn™iue2Š|g½

ju{|onhv2Ï

æosŽ ŽeÚgnhgŠ|„zvke†}UiuoUy~f֌ze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnaÏ%ÐÑnXjmt~{|v#fhgfZe2i

ŽAeoUn~Š|„Œ~{|vmÈ(yhvmvyZvke2ik½D}imoy~fŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnhvŽt~{‹È‚trÈonhvu{|vkj

op,oim{—}U{—nhgбyhvke2ik½D}imoyhfÚgnhŒ§Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2Œ3yhvueiu½_}UiuoUy~fڌze2Š—e½

}Ugsjm{—oUnhv2ÏǍNthen~e2Ž’iue2Š|gju{|on/op<}imoyhfrŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn/{|v*Œze½

ôhn~e2ŒÕgv§ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn>}imoy~f>imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUn ¿ÁÃc<ÝRÀ4ņŽt~{‹È‚t

{—nhȊ—yZŒze2v2š3oUiu{|}{|nhgŠ<yhvuei™gvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjmv&GÉ*Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjme2Œ

yhvke2i'gvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjmv &É'ÃŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ3}UiuoUy~fgvmvk{|}n~l6e2nUj‚v

É'ÃgnhŒ/.x |021v<{43|510ÛÏíÐÑnÆg]yZvke2ik½D}imoy~f:ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUna

jut~e2iueNgime<ôZeNÈ(ol6fon~e2nSjmv2š0g4Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|n~}'yZvke2iN¿Áoi,g4Œ~eŠ—½

e}Ugjue¤Œ/yhvueiÛÅÛagŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—nh}ÚimoŠ|eag§ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjue¤Œ/}UiuoUy~faag

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjue¤Œ6iuoUŠ—eUUgnhŒ†gvmvuoˆÈ{|gjue¤Œ#Èonhvkjui‚g{|nSjmv2ÏGÞhoi<eÌ~gl#½

f~Š—eU6 ! ±Ã …À 78'!'9':0 ; ÅÀ< Y >=aca2?A@*BC!=aca2?A@

Ä!DD§l6e2gnZvڍGonˆ„:gUÈÛjm{—n~}X{|nÆimoŠ|e/à …À ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjue¤v

iuoUŠ—e§Ã …Àîjuo]gŠ|ŠNfZe2of~Š|e3{|nˆoUŠ—Ue2Œ]{|nÙð1imoï…e¤ÈÛj§è§Œzyhiu{|n~}

蚕•fhl;Rz“~š••f~l’on™q%oUnhŒ~gº„Ï,–>}UiuoUy~f#Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on#iue2Š|g½

ÐDj<Èonhvu{|vkjmv,opZoUiu{|}{|nhgŠzyZvke2i}imoy~f#ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on¿NÀ 'ÃÅ

gnhŒ%ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œyhvuei4}imoy~f/Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÖ¿ÁÃc<Ý$ÃÅ(ϱÞ{|}½

y~ime ‘K{|Š|Š—yhvkjui‚gsjme2v6È(oUl6fZoUn~enSjmv6gnhŒXjmt~e{|i6iue2Š|gju{|onhv{—n

imoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2ŒŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on/l6ozŒzeŠ_Ïçe2nhÈ(e#ŽethgºUejuthepÎoUŠƒ½

Š|osŽ{—nh}e2Š—e2l#e2nSjmvgnhŒ†pÎyhnhÈÛjm{—oUnhv{|n§}UiuoUy~f3Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onaš

èUÏ<E {‹vÚg]vkejÚopÇyhvuei‚vÏFE1{|vÚgXvkejÚopÇ}imoy~f~½_imoŠ|e

gUvuvu{|}n~l6enSj‚vÏ

ë~ÏB:G)$+6E* 4 )1<7HE1 7 fhtiF¾{‹vÚoUn~e(½_juo½_l™gnˆ„

Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on™imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaϖՌze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on™imeŠ‹gsju{|on3ÈgnڏZe

imefhiue¤vke2nUjme2ŒÕˆ„ ¿k¿I6q<rÅq2¿Eq"rÅqfhtiFºÅSN :*)$+R*#

Žth{|Ȃt:l6e2gnZv#jut~e/Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|n~}KyZvke2i I>Ž{ƒjmt:imoŠ|eHr

Œ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤Œ4imoŠ|e3rjuo}UiuoUy~f(E:{—pˆjut~eÈ(onZv…jmimg{—nSjfhtiF

{‹vvmgsju{‹vkôhe2Œ¯Ï

“hÏ2*-, E:<4P)12 7IE1;:<7BfhtiFÇ{‹vg#iue2Š|gju{|on†op

gn3oUiu{|}{|nhgŠyZvke2ignhŒ§g6}imoy~f3Ž{ƒjmt%È(onZv…jmimg{—nSjmv2Ï

‘ZÏB:G)$+6E:<4)1;:87JE13:67 fhtiF'{|vgimeŠ‹gsju{|on6op

g6Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue2Œ3yhvueignhŒ3g#}UiuoUy~f3Ž{—jut%Èonhvkjui‚g{|nSjmv2Ï

”~ÏB:G)$+6E* > 2*-,E: @ :*)"+6E:A

^gUvke¤Œ:on>jmt~e/ime2vuy~Šƒj‚v†opjut~e¾v…jmiuyhÈ(juy~ime/Ž{—jutÆimoŠ|e(½

hgUvke¤Œ/}UiuoUy~fKŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|ona¯Že#Œ~{|vmÈ(yhvmvÇ}imoyhfrŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn

gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|onhv{|nÚjmt~en~eÌSj'vue2È(ju{|onaÏ

K

a

¹z·¤åÁâ

á

´3ä0·LGâZ¸såM¹~·2åÁâ

á

ؾe Œze2e2Š—oUf ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|n~}îgnhŒimeUoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUn l6ozŒze2Š|vÕ{—n

jmt~{|vvke¤ÈÛjm{—oUnaÏ%Nt~e†n~oju{|onXopgONwv<zKv<zQP'R!3S023T11zO.x |U43T1V3Mx|Z

fhgli jUkmkKnoglp$kgnZŒfhgli rkslt uWk'gimeNÔe2„fhgikj‚v,{—n™}UiuoUy~f

Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÚfhiuozÈ(e¤vuv2Ï

KUÁß ´ÚäG·Lâh¸såMU¹z·2åPâ á Íâaã ¶

Nt~eìŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|on }oUgŠ{|l6fZoSvke¤v]iue¤v…jmiu{‹ÈÛ½

jm{—oUnhvoUn¾Žth{|ȂtÖimoŠ|e†Ègn]Ze§ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjue¤Œ¾juo/ŽtholÏØKe

fhgikjm{|gŠ—Š|„ÍgUŒzofzj™jmt~e/n~oju{|onìopÇf~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jue/ÈonhŒ~{ƒjm{—oUn

pÎimol ¿Áؾgn~}™çÏ|xgo ZÏ~gnhŒ [thgn~}&ÏZ땕“SÅ,jmo™{—nSjuimo½

ŒzyZÈ(e1Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUngyzjmt~oim{—פgsjm{—oUn4{|nÇjut~eAŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on4pÎi‚gl6e(½

ŽoimÔ±Ï

–WNJv<zKv<zQPR!3S0Q3T11zX.x |U;3T13Mx |W{‹vÍgn eÌzf~iue¤vuvu{|onyhvu{—n~}

^oˆoŠ|e2gnXofei‚gsjuoUimvJY gnhŒHZ’oUnXjue2iul™v#op'jut~e3pÎoiml r

gnhŒ\[rŽt~eime%r{|vgimoŠ|e*gnhŒOYÖl6e2gnZv^]ugnZŒ_~ZXl6e¤gnhv

]uoiQ_~ÏG– fhiue2iueeUyh{|vu{ƒjme*ÈonhŒ~{ƒjm{—oUn3{‹vNesgŠ|yhgjue2ŒÚpÎoig#yhvuei

IS„*{|nUjmeimf~ime(ju{|n~}5rjmo'e1juimy~eA{ƒp0¿Zbr [ rsÅ0q2¿I6q<r [ÅVN)1

gnhŒ`[rjuo6eÇjuimy~e{—pN¿TaJr [ rÅq2¿I6q<r [Å-bN)1~Žt~e2iue )1

(5)

UAO

UAD

Constraints

ORID

DELD

Þ{—}Uy~iue“hš1¼oŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ3ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn3l6ozŒzeŠ_Ï

UAO

UAD

Constraints

DELD

GAD

ORIGD

DELGD

ORID

Þ{|}y~imeǑhš1¼oUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ†}UiuoUy~f§Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on3l#ozŒze2ŠPÏ

ؾe4vmgº„#g}UiuoUy~f†vmgsju{‹vkôhe2v1gf~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jueÈonhŒz{—ju{|onÚ{ƒp

gŠ|Š1yhvuei‚vÇ{—n]jmt~e™}imoy~f]vmgsju{‹vkp΄/juthe†f~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jue™È(oUnhŒz{—½

ju{|onaÏ

Þ~oUig#}{|en§vkejopGimoŠ|e2vB*’Š|e(j%f*WŒzen~ojuegŠ|НfoUvmvk{—½

~Š—e#f~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jue#È(oUnhŒz{—ju{|onhv'juthgjÇÈ2gnKZepÎoiml6e2Œ/yZvk{|n~}

jut~e3iuoUŠ—e¤v{|n*#GpÎoUieÌzgl6f~Š—eU f* > rYZr Z rUÏ/ÐÑn[

vkoUl#e#ÈgUvke¤v±Žel™gº„n~ee¤Œ%juoŒzeôhn~e#Žt~e(jmt~ei*oi*n~ojg

yhvke2iÈ2gn†Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue'giuoUŠ—ejmog}UiuoUy~f†gnZŒ#pÎoit~osŽìl6gnˆ„

ju{|l#e¤v±oUiy~f%jmo™jut~el™gsÌz{—ly~lcŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on/Œ~efzjmtaÏ'æoj

ee2iu„yZvke2i,È2gn#ŒzeŠ|e}SgsjueNg4iuoUŠ—eAjuoÇg'yZvke2i2Ï,Nt~eApÎoŠ|Š—osŽ{|n~}

iue2Š|gju{|on§f~iuosˆ{‹Œze2vŽthgjiuoUŠ—e¤vg#yhvke2iÈgnŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjueǎ{—jut

f~iue2iueeSy~{|vu{—jueÈ(oUnhŒz{—ju{|onhv2Ï

a ,á åη2åPâ á ß fhgli jUkmkKnoglp$kÚ{‹v6grimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnÍop3* 7

f* 7 ŽtheimeO*dqf*dq gime6vkejmv*opiuoUŠ—e¤v±f~imeime'eSy~{—½

vk{—jue§È(onZŒz{ƒjm{—oUnhv2gnhŒXl™gsÌz{|ly~lñŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn]Œ~efzjmtaiue½

vkfe2È(ju{|eŠ|„Ï c

Nt~e*l6e2gnh{—n~}#op<¿Mrqrq<i0ÅBN fhgUi jlkmMk'nogUp$k4{‹v<jmthgsjg

yhvke2iŽt~o#{|vg#l6elZe2iopGimoŠ|eYr3¿ÎoUigimoŠ|eÇvke2n~{—oUijuorÅ

Ègn6Œze2Š—e2}UgsjmeNiuoUŠ—e r¿Áoi1g*imoŠ|eGï…yhn~{—oUi,juo rÅGjuognˆ„}imoy~f

Žt~oUvueÈ(y~imiue2nSje2nUjm{ƒjmŠ—e2l6enSjmv{|n6iuoUŠ—e¤v,vugju{‹v…p΄jmt~ef~imeime'eU½

y~{|vu{—jueÇÈ(onZŒz{ƒjm{—oUnBf* Ž{—jut~oUyzjeÌ~È(ee¤Œz{|n~}jmt~e'l™gsÌz{|ly~l

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onXŒze2fzjut iύGo/{‹ŒzenSjm{ƒp΄]g%imoŠ|e™imgn~}e™Ž{—jut~{|n

jut~e™imoŠ|eth{—e2imgimȂtˆ„jmt~e6pÎoŠ|Š—osŽ{|n~}È(Š|oUvue2ŒKgnhŒKofen¾{—n~½

jueimsgНn~ojmgju{|on{|vNyZvke¤Œ¯Ï

q+ >WHr N* K rY r] Q

¿Mq+ >WHr N_* K r<YBrO Q

6q ~Å">WHr N_* K r<YBrO Q

€'vueiu½_}UiuoUy~f Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn {‹v gy~jut~oUiu{|×e¤Œ ˆ„

fhgli jUkmkKnoglp$kSÏ g~Š|ebëòvut~osŽv>jmt~e fhgli jlkmMk'nbglp$k

imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhv Ž{ƒjmt juthe f~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jue ÈonhŒz{—ju{|onZv {|nñjut~e

"V e(Ì~gl#fhŠ—eUÏ Nt~el6e¤gn~{|n~}óop fhgli jlkmMk'nbglp$k

¿:*,*dq

f.3q 92#è7qèºÅ™{‹v†jmthgsjgÖl6elZe2i3opimoŠ|erà …À

È2gnìŒzeŠ|e}SgsjueimoŠ|e%à …ÀgnhŒìgŠ|ŠiuoUŠ—e¤v6{—n!"V ¿Ávu{|nhÈ(e

gЗНimoŠ|e2vNgimeï…y~n~{|oiNjmo6ÅÀ'Åjmo™g}UiuoUy~fڎthoUvueÇÈy~imiue2nUj

l6elZe2imvut~{|fÖvugju{‹v…ôZe2vjmt~eÚfhiue2iueeUyh{|vu{ƒjmeÚÈ(oUnhŒz{—ju{|onPÊ V

& 3Ž{ƒjmt’on~e½Dvkjue2f Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onaÏóNt~eÖvue2È(oUnhŒÕjuy~fhŠ—e

gyzjut~oUiu{|×e¤v6jutZgsj3gXyZvke2iÚopimoŠ|e ÙÈgnÆgUvuvu{|}nìiuoUŠ—e

& zgnhŒ¾Ê"!% ; zÀ(T 4 hÉÕgnhŒKÊ V/juo6g}imoy~f3{—n§Žt~{‹È‚t

yhvuei‚vgiuel6e2lei‚vop1e2{ƒjmt~ei*imoŠ|eÉ oi6Ê"!% hoi*À&T

¿Pvk{|nhÈ(eXÉ #Ê"!% >gnhŒÕÀ(T Ægiue]{|nÕjmt~eXi‚gn~}UeKopƒÉ

& 2#¤Ï

¼oŠ|e2æ4gl6e™¿Á¼'Å ð1imeime'eÏxAonhŒz{—ju{|onK¿_x¼'Å æ

d'Ѕ¼

xN‡±~çè è

çè

–4ð,hçèºÅ ë

–4ð xN‡ è

xN‡ ë

Gg~Š—eë~š<xgnŒzeŠ|e}SgsjueÇimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvN{—nðV4Ðk‡¯Ï

Nt~eimegimeÇiue2Š|gjue2Œvuy~zjmŠ—eju{|e2vjmthgsj*gim{|vueÇ{—n/ÀÂÃ

ÈonhÈeimn~{—nh}juthe{—nSjue2imgUÈÛjm{—oUne(j…Žeen#ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—n~}gnhŒime(½

UoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUnÕop6yZvke2ik½D}imoy~fIŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnIl6e2lei‚vkt~{|f gnZŒ

jmt~eiuoUŠ—e*t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„Ï

a

,á åÁ·2åÁâ

á

(6)

Nt~eÇl6e2gn~{—nh}#opfhgli rk'sbt uokˆ¿M6q6ÅA{|vjmthgsjgl#e2l#½

Ze2i'opimoŠ|eÍ¿ÎoUi'g™l6elZe2i'op,g™imoŠ|eÇjutZgsj'{‹v'vuen~{|oiNjmo

ÅÈgn†iue2oUÔeŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn™iue2Š|gju{|onhvut~{|f†op0g}imoy~f†pÎiuoUl

gnˆ„ÚimoŠ|eNÚhŽt~e2iue Œ~e(ôhn~e¤vNjuthe.v<{|b}Uzx?v<zx.{

13Mx |hÏ<g~Š|e“#}{|e¤vjut~exgnz½_imeUoÔUe'imeŠ‹gsju{|on§{|nÞ{|}y~ime

ëzÏǍNt~eôhi‚vkj'juyhf~Š—e6vut~osŽvjmthgsjÇg†l6elZe2i4op1iuoUŠ—eO

Ègnriue2oÔUegڌze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on%imeŠ‹gsju{|onZvkt~{|f/op<g™}imoy~f/pÎiuoUl

gnˆ„†imoŠ|e*{|nÁÊ"!# 4 0Ê VuÏ

¼oŠ|e2æ'gl6e ¼oUŠ—e¼gn~}e

çè

xAohèZxN‡

¼eè

¼eèU~–'ð

ghŠ—e“hš,˜1Ì~gl6f~Š|e*opÈ2gniue2oUÔe'imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnaÏ

Nt~e2iue'giueNj…ŽoԈ{|nhŒ~v1op¯iue2ozÈgju{|onhv¿Áؾgn~}çÏ|~xgo

hÏgnhŒ [thgn~}Ï,ë•U•“UÅ(Ï3Nt~e6ôZimvkjonhe™{|vŽe2gÔrimeUo½

Ègsjm{—oUn3Žth{—Š|eÇjut~evue2ÈonhŒ3onhe*{‹vvkjuimon~}6imeozÈ2gsju{|on0ÏGؾe

e(̈jue2nhŒjmt~eŒze(ôZn~{ƒjm{—oUn6ophëfhŠ—{‹È({—j1gnhŒ{—l6f~Š|{‹È({—j1l#e2lei‚v

opgimoŠ|e*pÎiuoUlîg#yhvueiNjuo†g#}UiuoUy~faÏ

a ,á åη2åPâ á –I}imoy~fGEW{|vNgnÚe(Ìzf~Š|{‹È({—jNl6e2leiNop

g'imoŠ|eR6{—p¿MIq ±ÅVN)1spÎoUi,gŠ—Š IN E’gnhŒjmthgsj E>{‹v,gn

{—l6f~Š|{|È{ƒjl6elZe2iNop0imoŠ|e3§{—p0pÎoivuol6e;

[

q¤¿MIq

[

ÅBN

)1zpÎoUigŠ|Š IN E6Ï c

ؾe2gÔ imeUoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUn’on~Š|„ iue2oÔUe2v%eÌzf~Š—{‹È({—j]l#e2leiu½

vkt~{|fKpÎiuoUl gÚyZvke2ignhŒKŒzoˆe2vÇn~ojÇimeUoÔUe{—l6f~Š|{‹È({—jl#e2l#½

Ze2imvut~{|faÏ 4nìjut~eKojmt~ei†tZgnhŒ¯4v…jmiuoUn~}Xiue2ozÈgju{|on:iue½

eUyh{—ime2v4iue2ozÈgju{|onopAZojut/ëfhŠ—{‹È({—jÇgnhŒ%{|l6f~Š—{‹È({—jÇl#e2l#½

Ze2imvut~{|faÏr‡Sjuimonh}/iue2ozÈgju{|on¾op%E [F†l6e2lei‚vkt~{|fX{|n

iueeUyh{—ime2v†juthgjOEñeKimel6ose¤Œ:n~oj§on~Š|„ÍpÎimol ëfhŠ—{‹È({—j

l#e2lei‚vkth{—f {|n G~yzjrgŠ‹vuoÍpÎimol7eÌzf~Š—{‹È({—jÍ¿Î{|l6f~Š|{|È{ƒjÛÅ

l#e2lei‚vkth{—fÖ{|nÖgŠ|Š<imoŠ|e2vvke2n~{—oUijuo90ÏK‡SjmiuoUn~}%imeozÈ2gs½

ju{|on]jutheime(pÎoime™thgUvg%ÈgUvuÈ2gŒz{|n~}e0X±e2È(jy~fˆŽgimŒhvÇ{—n]jmt~e

iuoUŠ—e3t~{—e2imgimȂtˆ„UÏ]Þhoi#e(Ì~gl6f~Š|eAvky~fhfZoSvke3jut~e2iuegime†j…Žo

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onZv ¿k¿\ti wq+:*,E*Åq2¿1i q+13,Åqhr1jlg~ŒgnhŒ

¿k¿*ti q+*hkSè¤Å0q2¿1Wi q-1;,Å0qhr1jUgE~Å,gnhŒ6Gonˆ„ŽNgnSjmvjmo

iue2l#osUejmt~e6l#e2lei‚vkth{—f¾opB1;, pÎimol –'t~n]on¾Þ~im{|Œ~gº„UÏ

Ø>{ƒjmtَe2gÔ¾imeUozÈgsjm{—oUna,jutheÚôhi‚vkj6Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÖimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnz½

vkt~{|f:{|v6imel6ose¤Œ¯1~y~j™jut~e%vue2È(oUnhŒ:ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onÙthgv#n~oj

„e(j4iue2l#osUe2Œ¯Ï<ÐDj'l6e2gnZvNjuthgj'–t~nr{|vvkju{|Š|ŠGg6l6elZe2iop

1;,6ÏØ>{—jut/vkjuimon~}#iue2ozÈgju{|onÚj…ŽAo™Œze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnÚimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnz½

vkt~{|fhvNgime'imel6osUe2Œ™gnZŒ™t~enZÈ(eǖt~n3{|vn~ojgl#e2leiop

1;,6Ï

å` ˆá ·¤¹z·2åPâ á

Nt~{|v vke¤ÈÛjm{—oUn f~ime2vuenSj‚v jut~e {|l6f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|on opÙjmt~e

}imoy~f Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on Ž{—jut Ü*Ä/Ýîjue2Ȃthn~oŠ|o}U„Ï Nt~eÍpÎoiu½

l6gj opîg7}imoyhf ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on pÎimol ‡ˆe¤ÈÛjm{—oUn“ {‹v

¿k¿MIq"rÅ0q2¿Eq<rÅqfhtiFºÅ(ÏñGoìl™g{|nUj‚g{|nIjut~eXimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvkth{—f

Zej…ŽAe2ení}UiuoUy~fhv2ŽAe¾e(̈jmenhŒÆjut~e]Œze(ôZn~{ƒjm{—oUníopvke2n~{—oUi

gnhŒ†ï…y~n~{|oi*iuoUŠ—ejuo3jut~e6Œze(ôZn~{ƒjm{—oUnrop<vke2n~{—oUi*gnhŒ6ï…y~nh{—oUi

}imoy~faÏ

a

,á åη2åPâ

á K

–I}imoy~fGE6è*{‹vvke2n~{—oUi<jmo#g}imoyhfGEë

{ƒp4gnˆ„Kl6elZe2iop&E6èÚtZgvjmt~e§fZosŽeiopjutheÚl6elZe2i

{—n EërgnhŒÖl™gº„XthgºUe3gUŒ~Œz{—ju{|onhgŠfosŽei#~yzj™n~oj6ˆ{|Èe

ei‚vmg~Ï c

aej E6è^WEëìvu{|}n~{—p΄Æjmthgsj E6è]{‹v/vke2n~{|oijuo Eë~Ï

çenZÈ(eg*l6elei<opE6è{‹vÈ(oUnhvu{|Œze2iue¤Œvuenh{—oUiGjmog*l#e2l#½

Ze2i'op EëzÏÐDp8E6è{|v4vke2n~{|oiNjuoIEë#ŽAegŠ|vuo™vugº„†juthgj&Eë

{|v±ï…yhn~{—oUi1jmo$E6èÏ,Þ~oiAÈ(onˆUen~{|enhÈeNŽAeyhvueNjutheNôhŠ—e¤v }cv<x4R

ND3Mz! #"=yzgnhŒ v<x y,z$D3Mz! %"dySjuo6v…jmoimejmt~e4}UiuoUy~f†t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„

gnhŒÆjut~e]imoŠ|ert~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„Ùopjut~eXȂt~{|Š‹Œziue2nígnZŒÆfhgiue2nUj‚v

}imoy~fhvgnhŒ3iuoUŠ—e¤vÏ

^Ngvue2ŒXoUn֍Gg~Š|erè1g/fhgiujopjut~e3}imoy~fXt~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„

opÞ{|}y~imeë{‹vl#ozŒze2Š—Š|e2Œ3{|nH}cv<x4RN&D3Mz! #"=yˆyhvu{—nh}…Ã*À0cR

gsjkjm{—hyzjue¤v'¿Áq/{|ȂthgeŠhçÏUë•U•~èºÅGgUvvkthosŽn#{|n™Gg~Š|e‘hÏ,Nt~e

t~{—e2imgimȂtˆ„]{‹vnhoj™g/jmiue2e3~y~j™gK}i‚gfhta,pÎoi™È(Š‹gim{—j…„]gnhŒ

È(onZÈ({‹vke2n~e2vmv±g~Š|e‘Úvut~osŽvjut~e#t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tS„§gv4g†n~e¤v…jme2Œ

iue2Š|gju{|onaÏ<Ntheôhi‚v…j'ÈoŠ|y~l6n§}U{—Ue2vjmt~e}imoy~fnhgl6ezjmt~e

vke¤È(onZŒ%È(oŠ|y~l6n%}{|e¤vNjuthe{|l#l6e¤Œz{|gjuefZgimenSj}imoy~fZvop

oUi4Ȃt~{|Š|ŒKgv'jut~e6ÈgUvkel6gº„eπ'vu{|n~}H}cv<x;RND3Mz! #"=yƒaŽAe

È2gn6ôhnhŒ3gŠ|Švuenh{—oUimvAgnhŒÇï…yhn~{—oUimv1pÎoiNg}imoyhf™S„6ime2vufZe¤ÈÛ½

jm{—UeŠ|„rȂthgvu{|n~}Újmt~e™fhgiue2nUj‚vÇgnhŒ¾È‚t~{|Š|Œzimen¾yhvu{—nh}vu{|l#fhŠ—e

'(S{41)deSy~eim„Úëfhiue¤vuvu{—oUnhv2Ï1–n%e(Ì~gl#fhŠ—eÇop,jmt~eiuoUŠ—eth{ƒ½

e2imgimȂtˆ„op¯Þ{—}Uy~ime'ëÇ{|v1iue2f~iue¤vke2nSjue2Œ#{|nHv<xy,z$D3Mz! #"=yUyhvu{—n~}

…Ã*À0cRÕgsjuju{|~yzjue¤vgvvut~osŽn§{—n%g~Š|e”zÏ

¼oŠ|eæ'gl#e ‡ˆenh{—oUiiuoUŠ—e Uy~n~{|oiimoŠ|e

d4Ѕ¼ çèUhçÇë

çè d4Ѕ¼ xAoZèz¼eUè

çÇë d4Ѕ¼ xAoˆëzz¼eºë

xAohè çè –'ð

¼eè çè –'ð

–'ð xAoZè~¼eUè xN‡

xN‡ –4ð,~–'vmð

Gg~Š—e”~š ]*iuoUy~f3th{—e2imgimȂtˆ„™op,Þ{—}Uy~iueë~Ï

d'eôhn~{—ju{|on6“'thgUvGŒ~e2vmÈ(im{—e2Œg'}UiuoUy~fjuoǏegnLz* 'NJy3.3T1

oUi 3+"%Nwy3.'3T1Çl6elZe2i†opg]imoŠ|eÏI–}imoy~fìl™gº„͏ergn

z* 'NJy3.3T1gnhŒO3+"%Nwy3.3T1l6e2lei<opagÇiuoUŠ—evu{—ly~Š—jmgnheoyZvkŠ|„Ï

Go4vu{—ly~Š‹gsjueNgimoŠ|e<th{—e2imgimȂtˆ„*ŽAeyhvue<{|nzpÎoiml™gsju{|on#goyzj

ëfhŠ—{‹È({—j,gnhŒ{|l6f~Š|{|È{ƒjl6elZe2imvut~{|f{|n v<x y,z,.-ÏçosŽee2i2

v<x y,z*,-r{‹v0n~ojvuy †È({|enSjjuo4Œ~{|vkju{|n~}yh{|vutjutheÈ2gvue1Žt~eimeAg

}UiuoUy~f{|vGojut#gneÌzf~Š—{‹È({—jgnhŒ{|l6f~Š|{|È{ƒj,l6elei,ophvkoUl#e

imoŠ|eNpÎiuoUl jmt~e4È2gvueŽt~eimejuthe}imoy~f6{‹v1oUn~Š—„6gn™{|l6f~Š|{|È{ƒj

l6elZe2iopjuthe3imoŠ|eÏ]Þ~oUijmt~{|v#f~yhiufoUvueڎe3{|nSjuimozŒzyhÈ(e

gn~ojmt~eiôZŠ—e=z* 'NJy3.3T1! %"dyjmthgsjAÔee2fhv1{|nzpÎoUiul™gsjm{—oUn†goyzj

ëfhŠ—{‹È({—jl#e2lei‚vkth{—fonhŠ—„UÏ

Nt~eimer{‹v3gÍf~imoˆÈe2Œzyhiue%pÎoUi§Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|n~}ÙgÍyhvuei3juoÙg

}UiuoUy~f {—n’oUy~i/{|l#fhŠ—e2l#e2nSjmgsjm{—oUnaÏ Nt~eÖfhiuozÈ(e¤Œzy~imeÖÈgŠ—Š

{‹v/,=zKy,z7}l{411z107v<x y,z32 } vx4RN#4sÏíNthe%fhgi‚gl6e(jmei‚v#iuoUŠ—e%gnZŒ

}UiuoUy~fvufZe¤È({—p΄Žt~{‹È‚timoŠ|eA{‹vjuo*ZeŒze2Š—e2}Ugjue2ŒjuoÇg*}imoy~faÏ

Nt~eŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on#pÎy~nhÈ(ju{|on™thgUv,juthepÎoŠ|Š—osŽ{|n~}l™g{|n†vkjuefZvš

èºÅ‡zeŠ|e2ÈÛj<gÇimoŠ|ejuoeŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjme2Œ§¿Îoi<iue2oÔUe2ŒhÅ0Të҈e2Š—e¤ÈÛj

g#}imoyhf†juo™Œze2Š—e2}Ugjue™¿ÎoUiimeUoÔUe¤ÅTz“SÅNxAthe2ȂԆŽt~ejut~e2iiuo

n~ojjmt~e§}imoy~fÍvmgsjm{|vkôhe¤vjmt~e3fhiue2iueeUyh{|vu{ƒjme3ÈonhŒz{—ju{|onÙ{—n

jmt~e™iue2Š|gju{|on65 {| UczKy,z{K}>17zKT1‘ˆÅ‡ˆe(jmy~fÖÈ(oUnhv…jmimg{—nSj‚vKTgnZŒ

”Uŀf±Œ~gjue#jut~e™Ãc<Ý$ÀWŒ~gjmgZgvueÏÞ~oUi*Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on/ime(½

UoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUnaU{|nhvkjue¤gŒ†op0jmt~ev…jmefhvN“#gnhŒ3‘hzȂt~e¤È‚Ô™Žt~e(jmt~ei

oUin~ojjmt~eimeUoÔe¤ŒÚimoŠ|e{‹v{—njmt~eimoŠ|eimgn~}eopGjmt~eime(½

Š‹gsjm{—oUnBfhgli rksbt uokSύNt~e*Ãc<Ý$ÀíŒ~gjmghgvuel™g{|nSjmg{|nhv

}UiuoUy~ft~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„4{|nzpÎoiml™gsjm{—oUnÚ¿}cv<x4RN&D3Mz! #"=yÅ(UimoŠ|e<th{—e2ik½

gimȂtˆ„†{|nzpÎoiml™gsjm{—oUn]¿"v<xy9z*!3Mz7! #"dyÅÛ±e(Ìzf~Š|{‹È({—j4l6elZe2imvut~{|f

¿z 'NJy3.'3T1! #"=yÅ(UgnhŒjmt~e5fhgli jUkmMk'noglp$kgnhŒfhgUi rksbt uok

imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUn†jmg~Š|e2v2Ï

ÐÑnÚoi‚Œze2i<jmol™gÔUe'oUy~iA{|l6f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|on§l6oime4È(oUnˆe(½

n~{|enSjŽe3Œ~ee2Š—oUfZe¤ŒXg%}i‚gfht~{|È2gŠ1yZvke2i{|nUjmeiupÁgÈe†Žt~{‹È‚t

{|nSjuei‚gÈ(jmv4Ž{ƒjmt/jmt~{|vÇfhiuozÈ(e¤Œzy~imejmo§Œzo3iuoUŠ—e½_Zgvue2Œ%}UiuoUy~f

Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onaÏ,Nt~e*}i‚gf~t~{‹ÈgŠZyZvke2iA{|nSjueiupÁgÈe4{‹v{—Š|Š|yhv…jmimgjue¤Œ

{|n§Þ{|}y~ime”zύNt~{‹vN{—nSjue2ikpÁgUÈ(e*ŽgUvAŒ~ee2Š—oUfZe¤ŒÚyZvk{|n~}8':9<;

gnhŒ{‹v0yhvue2Œjuo*{—n~{—ju{‹gsjme<}UiuoUy~fŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUn{—nZv…jme2gŒop~j…„ˆfz½

{|n~}jut~egose4f~imoˆÈe2Œzyhiue*ÈgŠ|Š_Ï1Nt~{|v{|l6f~Š—e2l6enSjmgju{|on§{|v

Èonˆe2n~{—e2nSj0pÎoiyZvke2imv,vu{—nhÈe<jmt~e„on~Š|„n~e2e2ŒjuoŒze(ôZn~ejut~e

}UiuoUy~fÚt~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tˆ„†gnhŒÚjutheiue2Š|gju{|onÈgn~½DgUvuvu{—}UnaÏ

= >

â `,¹z¸såÁ¶¤â

á

Nt~eȊ—oSvke¤ŒÚŽoimԙjmo6jut~{‹vfhgfZe2i{|vonl6o~{|Š—{—j…„ÚopyZvke2ik½

imoŠ|ergvmvu{—}Un~l6enSjK¿ÎØ]gnh}ÙçÏ|*‡zy~ní1Ï|h[±thgn~} Ï|4gnZŒ

xgo ZÏë•U•U”UÅGgnhŒiuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤ŒŒze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on¿M^NgimÔsg*˜'ÏgnZŒ

‡zgnhŒztˆy¼ÏZë•U••UgUÅÛÏ

4y~if~imeˆ{—oUyhv*ŽAoUiuÔÙ¿ÎØ]gn~}%çÏ|‡ˆy~nX1Ï|3[tZgn~} Ï|

gnhŒ¾xgoZϯ땕S”ÅŒ~{|vmÈ(yhvmvue2Œ%jmt~e6l6o~{|Š—{—j…„%opAyhvke2ik½DimoŠ|e

imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvkth{—f{|nÀ'ÂÉÊÍl™gnhg}e2l#e2nSjgnZŒf~imosˆ{|Œze¤Œn~e2Ž

gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|on/gŠ—Š|ozÈgsjm{—oUnKgŠ—}Uoim{ƒjmt~l™vpÎoUi*ÀÂNÉÊbgŠ|onh}

Ž{—jut6l6o~{|Š|{ƒj…„jmthgsj<giueNhgUvke¤ŒoUn6iue2Š|gju{|onhgŠˆgŠ—}Ue~i‚g4ofz½

e2imgju{|onhv2Ï/Nt~e„]gime™jmt~e3gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|onX}UimgnUjm{—nh}/gŠ|}o½

im{ƒjmt~lzŽAe¤gԙimeUoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUn3gŠ|}oUiu{—juthl gnhŒ§v…jmiuoUn~}#iue2ozÈg½

jm{—oUnKgŠ|}oUiu{—juthl§ÏNt~efZgfeiŒzoˆe2v*n~ojÇyZvke#iuoUŠ—e6Œze2Š—e2}Ugs½

(7)

0oUnS„ ð1imoï…e¤ÈÛj¤èzð1imoï…e¤ÈÛj‚ë

ð1imoï…e¤ÈÛj¤è Gonˆ„ –'t~n

ð1imoï…e¤ÈÛjÛë Gonˆ„ –'t~n

–'t~n ð1imoï…e2È(j2èUˆð<iuoï…e2È(j‚ë

Gg~Š|e*‘Zš ]*iuoUy~fgnhŒ3{ƒj‚vimoŠ|e2vt~{|ei‚gi‚È‚tS„™opÞ{|}y~imeëzÏ

Þ{—}Uy~ime”~š ]*iuoUy~fŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on3{—nSjmeiupÁgÈ(eUÏ

iuoUŠ—e¤vǏ~yzjvut~eQst~e†Ègn~n~ojgÈÈefzjojut~e2iiuoUŠ—e¤vÇ{ƒpvut~eQst~e

thgv*gn%{|l6l#oU~{|Š—e#iuoUŠ—eUÏ'Nt~el#oU~{|Š—{—j…„%È(oyhŠ|Œeˆ{|eŽe2Œ

gv0gvufe2È({‹gŠSÈgUvkeopˆimoŠ|e(½DhgUvke¤Œ4Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onÇ{—njut~e2{—iGŽAoUiuÔ±Ï

^Ay~jÇvuol6e{|l6fZoUikj‚gnSjŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onpÎe¤gsjmy~iue¤v4vuyhȂtrgUv4Œ~eŠ—½

e}Ugju{|on]È(oUnzËh{‹ÈÛjmvgnhŒ]ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnKimeUoˆÈ2gsjm{—oUnrthgºUen~oj

Ze2en%È(oUnhvk{‹Œze2iue¤Œ¯Ï ^A„3È(onSjmimgUv…j¤Ujmt~eŽoimÔ#{|n§jut~{‹vfhgfZe2i

f~iuosˆ{‹Œze2v*g†im{‹È‚t/sgim{—ej…„§op1ofzjm{—oUnhv'juthgjÇÈ2gnrŒze¤gŠ,Ž{—jut

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|ongy~jut~oUiu{|×2gju{|on3gnhŒ§iue2ozÈgju{|onaÏ

^NgimÔsg gnhŒ‡zgnhŒztˆy ¿M^NgimÔsg ˜ÏÚgnhŒ‡zgnhŒ~tSy ¼Ï

땕U•gSÅf~imofoUvue2ŒÙg]vk{|l6f~Š—el6ozŒzeŠpÎoi™imoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2ŒÖŒ~eŠ—½

e}Ugju{|on¾ÈgŠ|Š|e2Œ¾ÀÂNÃ4Ä a/Ž{—juth{—nXÀÂNÉÊ aUajut~e™vu{—l6f~Š|e2vkj

pÎoiml op,ÀÂNÉÊé¿_‡zgnhŒ~tSy¼Ï¯è¤éé$#ÅÛύNt~e2„ÚŒzeUeŠ|ofe2Œ

gÇpÎimgl6eŽoimÔpÎoiA{|Œ~enSju{—p΄ˆ{—n~}{—nSjmeime2vkju{|n~}ÈgUvke¤vjutZgsjÈ2gn

ZeÙyhvke¤Œ pÎoir~y~{|Š|Œz{|n~}ÕiuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on l6ozŒzeŠ‹v2Ï

Nt~{|vG{‹v0gÈ2È(oUl#fhŠ—{‹vkthe2Œ*ˆ„4{‹ŒzenSjm{ƒp΄ˆ{|n~}jmt~e<ȂthgimgUÈÛjue2iu{‹vkju{‹Èv

iue2Š|gjue2Œ:jmo͌ze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnaNyhvu{—n~}Öjut~e¤vkerȂtZgi‚gÈÛjmeim{|vkju{‹Èv#jmo

}enhei‚gsjueÇfoUvmvk{|~Š|eŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onÈgUvke¤vύNt~e2{—iŽoimԙ{‹vŒz{—pÓ½

pÎeimenSj0pÎimolIoy~i‚va{|njmt~iue2e<gvufe2ÈÛj‚vÏÞ{—i‚v…j¤º{ƒjGpÎoˆÈyhvue2vaoUng

vk{|l6f~Š—eAŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|onÇl6ozŒzeŠˆvuy~f~foiuju{|n~}on~Š|„4ËZgsj0imoŠ|e2v¯gnhŒ

vk{|n~}Š|ev…jmefŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUnaÏ1‡ˆol6e*{—l6foiujmgnSjNpÎe2gjuy~ime2vvuyhȂt

gvÇimoŠ|e#th{—e2imgimȂt~{|e2v2aÈ(oUnhvkjui‚g{|nUj‚vgnhŒKimeozÈ2gsju{|onZv4Žeime

n~oj6vky~fhfZoUikjme2Œ¯Ï ^„¾ÈonSjui‚gvkj2oyhiŽoimÔrthgUvgnhgŠ—„zvue2Œ

ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on%gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|on§gnhŒ§imeozÈ2gsju{|on§l6ozŒzeŠ‹vŽ{—jut

È(onZv…jmimg{—nSjmv#{|nˆoŠ|ˆ{—nh}rimoŠ|e§th{—e2imgimȂt~{|e2v2Ïهˆe¤È(oUnhŒ¯1jmt~e„

n~e{—jut~e2i}Ugºerjut~e]Œzeôhn~{—ju{|onIopimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2Œ>Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

iue2Š|gju{|onaŽt~{‹È‚tX{|vgrÈ(im{ƒjm{|È2gŠ1n~oju{|on¾juo/jut~eڌ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on

l#ozŒze2ŠÇn~oiŒz{‹vuÈyhvuvue2Œ:jmt~e¾iue2Š|gju{|onhvut~{|fhvÚgl#oUn~}ÍoUiu{|}{—½

nhgНyhvueignhŒÚŒze2Š—e2}Ugjue2ŒÚyhvuei¤Ï3^„ÚÈonSjui‚gvkj2Ujuthenj~eŠ|e}Ug½

ju{|on6pÎi‚gl6eŽoimÔ{|n6jut~{‹v1fZgfei<{‹v1Zgvue2Œ6on6oUiu{|}{|nhgŠhyhvke2i

gnhŒŒ~eŠ|e}Ugjue¤ŒÇyhvke2ivu{|nhÈ(e<jut~eŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|n~}imeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvut~{—f{|n

jut~{‹v<fZgfeithgv1ôhe'Èol6fon~e2nUj‚v'¿u¿MIq"rÅq¤¿MI [q<r [Å0qfhtiFºÅÛÏ

Nt~{—i‚Œ¯jmt~e„XtZgºeÚnhoj™Œz{|vmÈ(yZvuvue2ŒÍ}imoy~fz½DhgUvke¤Œ¾Œ~eŠ|e}Ug½

ju{|onaz~y~jNŽe*thgºe*gnhgŠ—„zvue2Œ†e2Š—e2l6enSjmvNgnZŒ™pÎy~nhÈ(ju{|onhvN{|n

}imoy~fXŒze2Š—e2}Ugsjm{—oUnXgvŽeŠ|ŠAgUv{ƒj‚v{|l6f~Š—e2l6enSjmgju{|onXŽ{—jut

Ü4Ä/Ý<Ï

> â á » ä¶2åPâ á ¶

Nt~{‹v>fhgfZe2iÆthgUvƌz{‹vuÈyhvuvue2ŒcgimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2ŒòŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUn

l6ozŒzeŠgnhŒÖ{—jmv6{|l6f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|on:Ž{ƒjmtÙÜ*Ä/Ý1ÏØ¾e%thgºUe

gnhgŠ|„zvke¤ŒKnhojoUn~Š|„¾g/Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|n~}%pÎi‚gl6eŽoimÔ/{|nhÈ(Š|yhŒz{|n~}

Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|n~}’gyzjmt~oim{—פgsjm{—oUn gnZŒ imeUozÈgsjm{—oUn Ž{—jut Èonz½

vkjui‚g{|nSjmv2U~y~jgŠ|vuo}UiuoUy~fz½Dhgvue2Œ™Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onaÏ,Gof~imosˆ{|Œ~e

g%fhimgUÈÛju{‹ÈgŠvuoŠ|yzjm{—oUn]pÎoi#iuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ¾}imoy~f֌ze2Š—e2}Ugju{|ona

Že%thgºe/gnhgŠ|„zvke¤Œ:iuoUŠ—e%t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚t~{|e2v™gnhŒ:jut~eKiue2Š|gju{|onz½

vut~{|f:opÇvuenh{—oUi6gnhŒKï…y~n~{|oi†imoŠ|e2v2ÏÆNt~ejmt~eoUiu„Ö{|n:jut~{‹v

fhgfZe2i4ŽNgv4Œzel6oUnhv…jmimgjue¤Œ%ˆ„§{—jmv*{|l6f~Š—e2l6enSjmgju{|onrŽ{—jut

Ü*Ä/Ý1ύNt~e/ŽoimÔÍ{|n>jut~{‹v†fZgfeiÚtZgvÚvu{|}n~{—ôZÈgnSjuŠ|„Íe(̈½

jmenhŒze¤Œ™f~imeˆ{|oyhv<ŽAoUiuÔ#{—n3vke2ei‚gŠZgvufZe¤ÈÛjmv2UpÎoie(Ì~gl6f~Š|e

jmt~e6}imoy~fz½DhgUvke¤Œ%ŒzeŠ|e}Sgsju{|on0¯}imoy~frŒ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on¾gyzjmt~o½

im{—פgsjm{—oUnXŽ{ƒjmtÍf~imeime'eSy~{‹vk{—jue3È(onZŒz{ƒjm{—oUnhv#gnhŒXimeUozÈgsjm{—oUn

gyzjut~oUiu{|×2gju{|onaÏ

Nt~e'pÎy~juy~imeǎAoUiuÔ6Ž{|ЗНe'jmt~eŒzeUeŠ|of~l6e2nUjNopgvu„zv…½

jmelîl™gnhg}Uel6enSjŽ{ƒjmt%Ü4Ä/Ý֎t~{|Ȃt{|nˆoŠ|e¤vAjut~eimoŠ|e(½

hgUvke¤ŒÚ}UiuoUy~f3Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|onvkyhhvk„zvkjue2l§Ï

´3» á â ã ˆá ·

Nt~e3gyzjmt~oi‚vŽoy~Š‹Œ]Š—{|Ôe†juo/jmthgnhÔKimeˆ{|eŽei‚vÇpÎoijmt~e{|i

}UoSozŒ§vkyh}}e¤v…jm{—oUnhvgnhŒÈ(oUl6l#e2nSjmv2Ï

E

¸

ˆá

»

–'hgŒz{qXϗ=^AyhiuimosŽv%qXÏ|0gl#fZvkoUn ^*Ï|gnZŒIð<Š—ojuԈ{|n

]#Ï<¿kè2éUé“UÅ(– È2gŠ‹È(y~Š|yhv*pÎoUigÈÈe2vmvÇÈ(onSjmiuoUŠ{|nXŒz{‹v…½

jmiu{|~yzjme2Œ¾vk„zvkjuel™v2җ 5ov{|0 (Ev<x} v{ "8 ;{ |l}

0Q1 ß ¿Î‘SÅ( #s• R #s“‘ZÏ

–'y~img͍ÇÏÇ¿kè2éUééUÅ(d4{‹v…jmiu{|~yzjme2ŒígUÈÈe2vmv…½Diu{|}tSj‚v™l™gnhg}e(½

l6enSj†Ž{—jutƌze2Š—e2}Ugju{|onìÈ(eiuju{—ôZÈ2gsjue¤vÒ| zQ.Rov23T1

|

11z0v|wz'1 NJv<x}cv<{ " " 3|b}Çf~faÏëzèè%R3ë“S”zÏ

^NgimÔsg'˜'ÏgnhŒ6‡zgnZŒztˆy#¼Ï~¿_ë•U••gSÅÛsÞ~i‚gl6e2ŽAoUiuÔ*pÎoiimoŠ|e(½

(8)

È(y~im{—j…„Æ–f~f~Š|{‹Ègsjm{—oUnhv/xAonzpÎe2iue2nhÈ(eUҗÇæe2Ž 4imŠ—e¤gnhv2

f~faÏaè Rè# #ˆÏ

^giuÔsgI˜ÏgnhŒb‡~gnhŒztˆy¼Ï†¿P땕U•ZÅ(6Þhimgl6eŽoimÔÕpÎoUi

iuoUŠ—e½_Zgvue2Œ†Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on§l#ozŒze2Š|v2 3| üð1imoˆÈee¤Œz{—nh}Uvop

jut~eë“i‚ŒÚæ'gju{|onhgбÐÑnzpÎoiml™gsju{|on%‡ˆ„zvkjuel™v‡ˆe¤È(y~im{—j…„

xAonzpÎe2iue2nhÈ(eUҗW^NgŠƒjm{—l6oimeˆf~f0Ïaè2•hèRèUè‘ZÏ

^Ae2Š—ŠNdϘ'ϗ0gKðgŒzyhŠ|g%<ÏZÏA¿kè2é$#UÅ( ‡ˆe2Èy~ime3È(oUl6f~yzjue2i

vk„zvkjue2l§š,€nh{ƒôhe¤Œ™e(ÌzfoUvu{ƒjm{—oUnÚgnZŒ6ly~Š—ju{‹ÈvA{—nSjmeimf~iue½

jmgju{|onaÒ|~0e¤È‚t~n~{‹ÈgНiue2fZoUikj˜A‡~d½Ñ¼N½ #”º½Ñ“• ~Ï

^AŠ‹g×2eqXÏhÞhe{|}enˆhgy~l ZϗhÐÑoUgnhn~{|Œ~{|v ZÏhgnZŒ§êÇe2iuoUl„Sju{‹v

–ϱ¿…è¤éééSÅÛ Nthe'imoŠ|eopajmiuyZv…jl6gnhg}Uel6enSj<{|n3Œ~{|vk½

juim{—hyzjue¤Œ§vu„zv…jmelîvue2Èy~im{ƒj…„±Ò| zQ.'Rov23T1 |517zKv|Jz1Nwv<x

} v{ " " 3|b}Çf~faÏaèU” R3ëzè2•hÏ

Þ~e{|nhvkjue2{—n%çÏZ1Ïa¿…è¤ééS”ÅÛzÞ{|nhgŠaimefoiuj2šæ'{|vkjvkl™gŠ|Н~yhvu{—½

n~e2vmvN{|n~n~ossgsjm{—Ueiue¤vke¤gi‚È‚tK¿Ávu~{|i‚Å}UimgnSj2šimoŠ|ehgvue2Œ

gÈ2È(e2vmvÍÈonSjuimoŠ_šf~thgUvke èÏjue¤È‚t~n~{‹ÈgЧimefoiuj2\3|

ü‡~˜<–’xAoUiuf0ϗÒ|Ï

Þ~eimi‚g{|oŠ|odÏ,ÞAÏgnhŒXêÇyht~nXdÏ,¼ÏA¿kè2éUéUëÅ(G¼oUŠ—eڏhgvue2Œ

gÈ2È(e2vmvbÈ(onSjmiuoUŠP 3| ‹è¤”sjut æ'gsjm{—oUnhgŠÕxAoUl6f~yzjue2i

‡ˆe2Èy~im{ƒj…„XxAonzpÎe2iue2nhÈ(eUҗ0pÎeimimg{—oUŠ—oSéUësimoŠ|eZgvue2Œ¯ÏtSjul6ŠP

f~faÏZ”U”s‘ Rz”U“~Ï

a{æÏ*gnhŒ ]*imoUvuop ^4Ï*æÏ#¿Pë•U••SÅÛ– f~i‚gÈ(ju{‹ÈgŠ—Š|„í{|l#½

f~Š|el6enSjmgju{|onÍgnhŒXjmimgUÈÛj‚g~Š|e§Œ~eŠ|e}Ugju{|on֊|o}U{|È3|

Ѕ˜A˜<˜ ‡ˆ„ˆl6fZoSvk{|y~l oUnc‡ze2È(yhiu{—j…„îgnZŒòð<iu{|sgÈ(„±Ò|

f~faÏZë$#'Rˆ‘SëzÏ

q%{|ȂtZgeŠçÏÇ¿_ë•U•~è¤Å(' ; (Ev<x}cv<{ " "zKv0%z0zKv<zK|.z

Ø>{—Š|e„UÏ

‡zgnhŒ~tSyX¼Ï1¿kè2éUé$#Å(0¼gju{|onhgŠ,pÎoiÇjuthe†ÀÂNÉÊéÚpÁgl6{|Š—„

opNgÈÈe2vmvÇÈ(onSjmiuoUŠl#ozŒze2Š|v283| üð1imozÈ(ee¤Œz{|n~}Uv*opÇè2vkj

–'xqóØKoUiuÔzvut~ofon%¼oUŠ—e½_Zgvue2Œ§–'ÈÈe2vmv4xAonSjmiuoUŠPÒ|

–'xq ð<iue¤vuv2ˆf~faÏ ‘R #ëzÏ

‡zgnhŒ~tSyò¼Ï§¿kè2éUéUÅ(Ú¼oUŠ—eIgÈÛjm{—sgju{|on t~{|ei‚gi‚È‚t~{|e2v2 3|

Nth{—i‚Œ –'xq ؾoimԈvut~oUfboUn ¼oŠ|e'^NgUvke¤Œ –'ÈÈe2vmv

xAonSjuimoŠ_Ò|ˆ–'xqñð<iue¤vuv2ˆf~faÏh“U“RS‘S•~Ï

ؾgn~}%çÏ|xgohÏagnhŒ [thgnh} #Ï1¿Pë•U•~èºÅÛa–È(oUnhvkyhl#e2i

gn~oUnˆ„Sl6{—j…„ÆvuÈ2gŠ‹g~Š|e]fhgº„ˆl6enSj/vuȂt~e2l6eXŽ{ƒjmtIimoŠ|e

hgvue2ŒgUÈÈ(e¤vuvÈonSjuimoŠ_3| ësnhŒÐÑnSjmeimnhgsjm{—oUnhgŠGxAoUnz½

pÎeimenhÈe†on]ؾeÖÐÑn~pÎoiml6gju{|on͇ˆ„zvkjue2l6v˜1n~}U{—nheeiu½

{—nh}¿ÁØ>Ðk‡z˜<•hè¤Å(җ~êDŽUojuoZ UgfhgnazfhfaÏZ”“RSëzÏ

ؾgn~}KçϗxgoZÏgnhŒ [±thgn~}Ï¿P땕“SÅÛÞ~oUiul™gŠgyz½

jut~oUiu{|×2gju{|ongŠ|Š|oˆÈ2gsjm{—oUngf~f~imoUgUȂt~e2v¯pÎoi0feiml6{|vmvu{—oUnz½

iuoUŠ—e/gUvuvu{|}n~l6enSj‚v6yhvk{|n~}ÖimeŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhgŠgŠ—}Ue~i‚g¾ofeiu½

gsjm{—oUnhv"3| üð1imozÈ(ee¤Œz{|n~}UvÚopjmt~eìè‘jmtí–yZv…jmimgŠ—{‹gn

d4gjmghgvue*xAon~pÎeimenhÈe'–'dxNë•U•“~Ò|ˆ–'Œze2Š|g{|ŒzeUS–'yhvk½

jui‚gŠ|{|ghÏ

ؾgn~}/çÏ|<xgoZϗ [thgnh}ÏA¿_ë•U•U”Å( ü–Ëhë{|~Š|e™fhgº„S½

l6enSjvuȂthel6e™gnhŒK{ƒj‚vimoŠ|e#Zgvue2Œ¾gÈÈe2vmvÇÈ(onSjmiuoUŠPÒ|

ov<{ |0K{>.1V3Mx|0Sx|=|JxEy9zU'}Uz\{|U ,d{411{ |&

};3|wzz0v23|b}

ß

0¿Á“SÅÛz‘ˆë”Rˆ‘U“ ~Ï

ؾgn~} çϗ ‡ˆy~n 1Ï| xgo Zϗ gnhŒ [thgn~} #Ï

¿P땕‘ˆÅÛ–'n~onˆ„ˆl6oyhvgUÈÈ(e¤vuv,vmȂt~el6epÎoie2Š—e¤ÈÛjmiuoUn~{|È(½

vke2iuˆ{‹È(e¤v  3|üð1imozÈ(e2e2Œz{|n~}Uv op jmt~e NŽenSj…„S½

‡ˆeUenSjut –'yhvkjui‚gŠ‹gvu{|gnòxAol6f~yzjmei>‡zÈ({|enhÈe xAoUnz½

pÎeimenhÈeí¿Á–'xN‡ZxN땕‘SÅ(җd4y~n~e¤Œz{|na™æeŽ [±e2gŠ‹gnZŒ¯

f~faÏZëéRˆ“•S”zÏ

ؾgn~}’çÏ|ڇˆy~n1Ï|.[±thgn~} Ï|†gnZŒbxgo ZÏ6¿_ë•U•U”Å(

–yzjmt~oim{|×2gsjm{—oUn –Š|}oim{—jut~l™v]pÎoUiXjut~eIq%oh{—Š|{ƒj…„ op

€'vueiu½D¼oŠ|e/¼eŠ‹gsjm{—oUnhvkth{—fa 3| ð<iuozÈee2Œ~{—n~}Sv6opjmt~e

ëjut†–yZv…jmimgŠ|gUvk{‹gnÚxAol6f~y~jueiN‡zÈ({|enZÈ(eÇxAoUnzpÎeimenZÈ(e

¿Á–'xN‡hxN땕S”ÅÛÒ|3æ'eŽNÈgUv…jmŠ—eU§–'yhv…jmimgŠ—{‹g~§f~faϧè #'R

è#~Ï

¿_땕‘SÅ( ü–W}UŠ—oUhgŠ0ju{‹È‚Ôe(ju½_Zgvue2Œ%gÈ2È(e¤vuvvmȂt~e2l#epÎoi

l6oh{—Š|e3yZvke2imv2җ Nz.3M{y 0Q0QRz x |KzQ.1 v23MzK|11zU

53y3MzK|1 z0v3z0v |517zKv|Jz1 |&3v<x| "zK|10$2 |70x v3"{

1V3Mx| 0217z" 0*v<x|513MzKvQ0

=

¿…èºÅÛ~“S”RS‘$~Ï

Ø]gn~}ìçÏ|;[thgn~}#ϗxgoZÏgnhŒ 1gi‚gŒ~thgi‚gsïkgn! Ï

¿_땕U“UÅ( ü–'Ȃt~{|eˆ{|n~}vue2È(yhiue'gnhŒ#Ëhë{|~Š|e'l#½Ñvke2iuˆ{‹È(e2v

jmt~iuoUy~}tÇjm{|ȂÔUe(j‚vÒ| Wv<{ |0K{>.13Mx |0Sx| 0211z " 0$2

`{|&2S{ |U 5 zKv|Jz1V3.20$2 (S{v21 .2 NzQ.'3M{ y3S0Q02Rzx|

zKv33.z'0AfhfaÏ é#'R #s•hÏ

<go¾Ø’Ï|q%oˆozŒz„Ùê6Ï1gnhŒ ^gUÈ(oUnZÏ'¿P땕hè¤ÅÛ–cl6oˆŒ~eŠ

op±oSgvu{|v,imoŠ|e(½DhgUvke¤ŒgUÈÈ(e¤vuv<È(onSjmiuoUŠhgnhŒ6{—jmvAvkyhf~fZoUikj

pÎoUi,gUÈÛjm{—Uevue2Èy~iu{—j…„3| üð1imozÈ(e2e2Œz{|n~}UvGop±–'xq ‡z„Sl#½

foUvu{—yhlWon6–'È2È(e¤vuvAxAoUnSjuimoŠzq%ozŒzeŠ‹v1gnhŒ60e¤È‚t~n~oŠ|o½

}U{—e¤vÒ|zf~faÏaè #ˆè0RèhèÏ

[tZgn~}ڐ<ϗ¯–'t~n ]#Ï|agnhŒ¾xAtSy ^*Ï¿_땕hè¤Å(– iuyhŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ

pÎi‚gl6eŽoimԒpÎoUiÍimoŠ|e(½Dhgvue2ŒbŒzeŠ|e}Sgsjm{—oUna 3| üð1imo½

Èee2Œ~{—n~}Svop™–'xq ‡ˆ„ˆl#foUvu{|y~l oUn –4ÈÈe2vmvrxAonz½

jmiuoUŠq%ozŒze2Š|vNgnhŒ†Ge2Ȃt~n~oUŠ—oU}{|e2v4¿P‡z–'xq/–Ië•U•~è¤Å(җ

xAthgnSju{|Š—Š|„ ,–~fhfaÏa褔“R±è Uë~Ï

[tZgn~}§1Ï|±–'t~n ]#ϗagnhŒ¾xAtˆyZ^*Ï¿P땕SëÅÛ±– iuoUŠ—e½_hgUvke¤Œ

Œze2Š—e2}Ugju{|on#pÎimgl6eŽoimÔpÎoiAt~e2gŠƒjmthÈgiue{|nzpÎoiml™gsjm{—oUn

vu„zv…jmel™v3| ð<iuozÈee2Œ~{—n~}Svop¯–'xqc‡z„Sl6foUvu{—yhl oUn

–4ÈÈ(e¤vuvxAonSjmiuoUŠGq%ozŒze2Š|vÇgnZŒrGe2Ȃt~n~oUŠ—oU}{|e2v¿_‡z–'x<½

References

Related documents

6 In column (1), our key explanatory variable is an indicator variable, restatement , that is equal to one for SEOs by firms that have previously restated earnings, regardless

While the auto company’s own employees leveraged the new platform for their service tasks, TeleTech’s Customer Management Solutions division used the customer database to

Step 4 For each VM, edit the domain XML descriptor file (and any network XML files, if present) to configure a vNIC interface that is directly attached to the VIC and uses the

patent market — reflecting a rise in the transfer rate from 1.4% in 2012 to 2.4% in 2015, and far outstripping the rate of biotechnology patent transfers, which totaled 0.8% to

The spatial analysis of soil depth, slope, zinc and salinity levels based on the information available on the database are undertaken in order to produce the geographical

In documenting the recent Japanese experience, this study also serves as a unique evaluation of the intriguing proposition Taylor (2000) put forth on the relationship between

Therefore, it is generally advised that women only take hormone replacement therapy if they are having difficulty in dealing with the symptoms of menopause. It is recommended that

Finally, Airbnb was most commonly used as a mid-range hotel substitute, but Airbnb’s varied performance expectations versus mid-range hotels (including outperforming mid-range