• No results found

Entrepreneurial marketing : a historical perspective on development and practice

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2019

Share "Entrepreneurial marketing : a historical perspective on development and practice"

Copied!
11
15
1
Show more ( Page)

Full text

(1)

I n t r odu ct ion a n d H ist or ica l Pe r spe ct ive

The m arket ing/ ent repreneurship int erface has developed a

subst ant ial body of lit erat ure over t he last decade. Market ing has m uch t o offer t he st udy of ent repreneurship ( Murray, 1981; Hills, 1987) and likew ise ent repreneurship can look t o m arket ing as t he key funct ion w it hin t he firm , w hich can encom pass innovat ion and creat ivit y. Om ura et al. ( 1993) perceive t he int erface bet w een t he t w o disciplines as having dist inct areas of bot h difference and overlap. The differences are bet ween t radit ional m arket ing w hich operat es in a consist ent environm ent , w here m arket condit ions are cont inuous and t he firm is sat isfying clearly perceived cust om er needs and pure ent repreneurship w hich operat es in an uncert ain environm ent , w here m arket condit ions are discont inuous and t he needs of t he m arket are as yet unclear. The overlap exist s in t w o areas; one where m arket condit ions are cont inuous and

ent repreneurship aids t he process of ident ifying as yet unperceived needs and secondly in a discont inuous m arket w here

ent repreneurship guides m arket ing st rat egy t o develop exist ing needs in a new environm ent . I n essence t hese researchers perceive t he I nt erface as focusing on ident ifying opport unit ies in a changing environm ent .

I n our opinion, m arket ing and ent repreneurship have t hree key areas of int erface: t hey are bot h change focused, opport unist ic in nat ure and innovat ive in t heir approach t o m anagem ent . Carson et al. ( 1995) perceive t he cent ral focus of t he int erface as being

change. Kurat ko ( 1995) in describing t oday's ent repreneur as: an innovat or or developer w ho recognises and seizes opport unit ies, convert s t hose opport unit ies int o w orkable/ m arket able ideas, adds value t hrough t im e, effort , m oney or skills, assum es t he risks of t he com pet it ive m arket place t o im plem ent t hese ideas and realises t he rew ards from t hese effort s. highlight s t he im port ance of change as one of t he key drivers in ent repreneurial act ivit y. Many of t he act ions undert aken by t he ent repreneur are key concept s in m arket ing t heory, w hich suggest t hat successful m arket ing is undert aken by firm s w ho ident ify new opport unit ies, apply innovat ive t echniques t o bring t he product / service t o t he

(2)

I f w e accept t hree key areas of t he m arket ing/ ent repreneurship int erface as being change focused, opport unist ic in nat ure and innovat ive in m anagem ent approach, t his has im plicat ions for educat ion. Specifically, t his suggest s t hat curricula are adequat ely developed t o encourage st udent s t o learn how t o deal w it h change, ident ify viable opport unit ies and develop t heir innovat ive skills. The business educat ion lit erat ure suggest s how ever t hat educat ional inst it ut ions are st ill som e way from appreciat ing t he ent repreneurial role of m arket ing and incorporat ing t his w it hin t he curriculum

( O'Brien and Hart , 1999) .

The hist orical developm ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing has evolved over t wo decades. Early work in t he area focused on t he issues associat ed w it h t he overlap bet w een convent ional m arket ing t heories and t hose advocat ed by ent repreneurship. Much of t his research w as conduct ed in t he USA and focused, as out lined

previously, on t w o dist inct disciplines m erging in areas of com m on int erest . ( Hills, 1987; Om ura et al., 1993) . As t his area of research has expanded researchers have ext ended t heir w ork int o not only t he t heoret ical developm ent but t he pract ical applicat ions and im plicat ions for ent repreneurial m arket ing in t he w orkplace and in t he educat ional environm ent ( Carson and Crom ie, 1989; O'Brien and Clark, 1997; Shaw , 1998) . The early 1990s saw t he

est ablishm ent of bot h US and European groups of academ ics

w orking in t he areas of t he int erface bet w een ent repreneurship and m arket ing. This int erface bet w een t he t w o disciplines has now developed int o a key focus of research w it hin m ainst ream

m arket ing research. These developm ent s have seen t he range and nat ure of research st udies expand, w it h areas such as creat ivit y, net w orking, st rat egy and educat ional issues now included. Research st udies in t he early t w ent y- first cent ury are focusing on t he key issues associat ed w it h applying ent repreneurial m arket ing t ec niques in indust ry, w hilst also invest igat ing educat ional pract ices w hich w ill enable st udent s t o be skilled in an ent repreneurial m arket ing firm ( Collinson and Quinn, 1999; Robson, 1996) .

An ent repreneurial focus t o m arket ing

Ent repreneurial cult ure

(3)

grow t h it can be difficult t o sust ain an ent repreneurial focus in a m ult ilayered m anagem ent st ruct ure.

Given t he difficult y in ident ifying t ruly ent repreneurial large

organisat ions, t he m aj orit y of t he research is in t he dom ain of t he sm all firm sect or, but increasingly larger organisat ions are

developing t his approach. Sm all firm s are how ever int risically different in m ake- up from t he larger count erpart s. These basic differences affect t he planning process, t he m an gem ent st ruct ure and t he w ay in w hich m arket ing is im plem ent ed ( Carson et al., 1995; Carson and Crom ie, 1989; Liu, 1995; St okes, 1995) . I n addit ion t o t he organisat ional st ruct ure, t he ent repreneurial

personalit y hl s a direct effect on t he w ay in w hich m a agem ent is undert aken ( Chell, 1986) . Ent repreneurs, by t heir nat ure, w ill focus on var ous opport unit ies at once and are not easily convinced by t he sequent ial, st ruct ured approach t o m anagem ent , w hich is t he focus of m ost m anagem ent / m arket ing t ext s ( O'Brien and Hart , 1999) .

Following on from t he early focus on t he ent repreneur, researchers at t he int erface have at t em pt ed t o ascert ain changes in

ent repreneurial act ivit y over a firm 's life cycle, by m easuring t he ent repreneurial effort in m anagem ent act ivit ies coupled w it h t he ent repreneurial scenario faced by t he firm . This enables t he

ent repreneurial personalit y t o be seen in t he cont ext of t he firm and relevant indust ry. The t erm " ent repreneurial effort " has em erged. The t erm " ent repreneurial effort " encom passes a num ber of

charact erist ics, nam ely energy, zeal, com m it m ent , det erm inat ion, persist ence, opport unit y and focus, w hich are exhibit ed by t he ent repreneur or m anagem ent t eam . The ent repreneurial scenario is charact erised by t he perceived level of risk facing t he firm , t he available resources and t he individual's need for skills, know ledge, experience and personal independence. I n com bining t hese t wo set s of crit eria t he ret urn on ent repreneurial effort can be ascert ained. This reflect s t he degree t o w hich t he vent ure develops and grow s over t im e as a consequence of t he ent repreneur's effort s and changing circum st ances ( Carson et al., 1995) .

One of t he key problem s facing sm all firm s is t hat as t hey grow it can be increasingly difficult t o m aint ain t he sam e level of

ent repreneurial effort as w as expended in t he init ial st ages of t he firm 's life. I n addit ion t o t his barrier, it is a nat ural t endency t o veer t ow ards act ivit ies t hat reduce levels of risk and consolidat e t he firm 's posit ion.

(4)

resources and skills requirem ent s is a key area of current research in ent repreneurial m arket ing act ivit y ( Collinson and Quinn, 1999) .

How ever, as m ent ioned previously ent repreneurial m arket ing is not solely t he dom ain of t he sm all firm . Many large organisat ions can be ent repreneurial in t heir approach t o m arket ing act ivit ies. Take for exam ple Richard Branson, w hose organisat ion, Virgin, spans m any indust ries and is const ant ly ent repreneurial in it s out look t o

ident ifying new m arket opport unit ies and developing t hese. I t m ust be st at ed, however, t hat in m any cases it needs a very

ent repreneurial leader w it hin t he organisat ion t o m aint ain t his m anagerial focus and cult ure.

Ent repreneurial m anagem ent

As it is only recent ly t hat t he m arket ing/ ent repreneurship int erface has been recognised, t here is a scarcit y of lit erat ure w it hin

m ainst ream m arket ing t ext s w hich considers how ent repreneurial m arket ing can be m anaged. This is despit e t he realit y t hat for m any sm all and ent repreneurial organisat ions, ent repreneurial m arket ing is som et hing t hat has long been pract ised and for m any is

som et hing w hich is " second nat ure" . This is not t o suggest t hat t he m anagem ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing has not been considered. From t he grow ing body of lit erat ure on t he m arket ing/

ent repreneurship int erface, a num ber of t hem es relat ing t o t he m anagem ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing can be ident ified. The first of t hese is t hat t he process of m anaging ent repreneurial

m arket ing differs from t he process of m anaging regular approaches t o m arket ing. One key reason for t his is t hat w here ent repreneurial m arket ing is pract ised, it com m only t akes place w it hin a fluct uat ing and changing environm ent w hich rest rict s opport unit ies for

engaging in t he m arket ing planning process, t ypically adopt ed w hen planning regular m arket ing act ivit ies ( Carson et al, 1995) . Wit hin such environm ent s, if t im e is t aken t o engage in a rigorous planning process, by t he end of t hat process it is likely t hat m arket

condit ions w ill have changed sufficient ly t o render any decision result ing from t his process as no longer relevant . I nst ead, t he m anagem ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing involves a short er decision- m aking process, w hich is oft en preceded by lit t le form al planning.

(5)

responsible for t he m arket ing funct ion. This is because for

ent repreneurial organisat ions, a closeness w it h t he m arket place, oft en m ade possible by t heir sm aller size, leads t o a keen sense of cust om er needs, want s and dem ands w it hout t he need for

invest m ent in expensive and t im e consum ing m arket research or designat ed m arket ing depart m ent s ( St okes, 1995) .

Relat ed t o t his a t hird t hem e can be ident ified. Wit hin

ent repreneurial organisat ions, an inform al rat her t han form al approach is oft en adopt ed t o t he m anagem ent of m arket ing. This can be explained by com m it m ent at an organisat ional level t o underst anding, ant icipat ing and responding t o t he needs of a const ant ly changing m arket place. Wit hin such an organisat ional cont ext t he need t o m anage t he process of m arket ing becom es less necessary as m arket ing becom es an act ivit y ow ned and m anaged by t he whole organisat ion ( St okes, 1995) .

Ent repreneurial com pet encies

The differences bet w een ent repreneurial and regular m arket ing suggest a num ber of im plicat ions for t he m anagerial com pet encies required. The m anagem ent of regular m arket ing can be

charact erised by a careful planning process w hich is inform ed by m arket research t o guide t he select ion of t arget m arket s and t he com posit ion of a m arket ing m ix w it h w hich t o posit ion product s com pet it ively w it hin t he m arket place. Consequent ly, t he

com pet encies w hich it requires include planning, rigour and fam iliarit y w it h st at ist ics and figures. I n cont rast , as has been described above, t he m anagem ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing is charact erised by int uit ion, inform alit y and speed of decision m aking, all of w hich require different com pet encies. This area of

ent repreneurial com pet encies has received increasing at t ent ion from researchers w orking at t he int erface, since t he lat e 1980s and has developed concept s in m arket ing educat ion w hich are m ore suit ed t o t he ent repreneurial m arket ing scenario ( Carson and Coviello, 1997; Cunningham , 1997) .

Managem ent com pet ency has been defined by Boyat zis ( 1992) as:

... an underlying charact erist ic of a person, w hich result s in effect ive and/ or superior perform ance in a j ob.

(6)

m anagem ent and being opport unist ic in t heir behaviour in t he m arket place. Drucker ( 1973) suggest s t hat ent repreneurial

innovat ion w ill be as im port ant t o m anagem ent in t he fut ure as t he m anagerial funct ion it self is t oday. He suggest s com pet encies also include lat eral t hinking and forw ard t hinking, w hich m eans building up som et hing new as opposed t o analysing som et hing old. The lit erat ure covering ent repreneurial charact erist ics is w ide and varied and som e w ould suggest t hat t he set t ing and cult ure in w hich an ent repreneur applies t hese com pet encies is j ust as im port ant as t heir personal charact erist ics.

Carson et al. ( 1995) ident ify four key com pet encies associat ed w it h ent repreneurial m arket ing m anagem ent :

1 experience of bot h t he indust ry and t he j ob;

2 know ledge of t he product aid m arket ;

3 com m unicat ion skills in being able t o direct t he organisat ion; anc

4 sound j udgem ent in being ble t o ident ify good m arket opport unit ies or key appoint m ent s in personnel,

support ed by high levels of percept ion and int uit ion.

As can be appreciat ed from t he above, t he t ypes of com pet encies required are int angible and not easily acquired over a short period of t im e. The challenge facing firm s at t em pt ing t o adopt an

ent repreneurial approach t o t heir m arket place is how t o harness and develop t hese com pet encies and ensure t hat t hey are m anaged a support ive environm ent . Tradit ionally, t raining for m anagem ent has focused on t he t angible, m ore readily m easurable com pet encies of know ledge and skills such as j udgem ent and int uit ion are

perceived as secondary. Wit h t he ent repreneurial m arket er, a w ider range of skills and com pet encies requires t o be developed. This also has im plicat ions, not only in m anagerial t raining in indust ry, but also w it hin higher educat ion, here again t he focus has been

t radit ionally on acquiring t he know ledge base but w hat have been loosely t erm ed as t ransferable skills, have been given less

im port ance in he curriculum developm ent . This scenario is gradually changing but aw areness of t he im port ance of t his wide range of com pet encies is st ill low .

(7)

caught up in t he day t o day m anagem ent of t he firm , w hich is now a m ore com plex organisat ion. Given t he key com pet encies

discussed earlier. firm s m ust ensure t he t hat t he cult ure w it hin t he organisat ion rem ains ent repreneurial in it s focus, t hrough enabling such skills as j udgem ent and int uit ion t o play t heir part in

m anagem ent . Being creat ive or innovat ive should not be som et hing only expect ed of t hose involved in new product developm ent , but should be com pet encies deem ed essent ial t hroughout t he firm . Research in ent repreneurial m arket ing has m ore recent ly focused on ascert aining t he im pact of t raining schem es t o aid sm all firm s t o m anage t heir grow t h in an ent repreneurial set t ing ( Collinson and Quinn, 1999) .

There have been a num ber of governm ent sponsored init iat ives in t he UK direct ed t ow ards t he sm all firm sect or, w hich have

concent rat ed on developing bot h ow ner m anager learning and ext ending t he skills base w it hin t he firm . Wit hin t hese schem es, a num ber have concent rat ed on developing sm all firm links w it h t he universit y sect or and encouraging SMEs t o em ploy a larger num ber of bot h st udent s and graduat es. These include t he Teaching

Com pany Schem e, Graduat e int o Business and Profit Through

Know ledge, t o nam e but a few . Em pirical resear ch invest igat ing t he benefit s of such schem es on com pet ency developm ent have

highlight ed t hat graduat es can play an im port ant role in t he sm all firm . Typically, t hey provide a useful source of ideas, an obj ect ive view point t o t he st rat egy being adopt ed and can oft en suggest alt ernat ive approaches t o problem solving ( O'Brien and Clark, 1997) . I n addit ion t o t hese benefit s, research has also show n t hat t hose w it hin t he firm ext end t heir com pet ency base, t hrough int roduct ion t o ot her m anagem ent skills and closer links w it h academ ic est ablishm ent s ( Collinson and Quinn, 1999; Robson, 1996) .

Ent repreneurial m arket ing is charact erised by a responsiveness t o t he m arket place and a seem ingly int uit ive abilit y t o ant icipat e

changes in cust om er dem ands. Because of t his, t he abilit y t o collect t hat m arket inform at ion w hich is pert inent t o t he cont inued

achievem ent of organisat ional goals on a regular, alm ost daily basis is im perat ive and is an im port ant com pet ency for t he

ent repreneurial m arket ing m anager. Research show s t hat w it h few er financial resources and rest rict ions on t he t im e available t o engage in m arket research, ent repreneurial organisat ions m ake excellent use of t he net w orks of relat ionships in w hich t hey are em bedded. Specifically, relat ionships w it h buyers, suppliers and ot hers along t he supply chain and in t he im m ediat e m icro

(8)

const ant ly changing environm ent is relevant t o t heir success and m ust be regularly collect ed and underst ood.

Wit hin t his cont ext , net w orking com pet encies are essent ial t o t he abilit y t o develop and m anage a diverse net w ork of relat ionships. The w hole area of net w orks and m anaging t hese net w orks is now cent ral t o t he lit erat ure in ent repreneurial m arket ing, in bot h it s t heoret ical developm ent and pract ice.

Net w orking: an ent repreneurial m arket ing t ool

The net w orks w it hin w hich ent repreneurs and t heir organisat ions are em bedded have been found t o provide accurat e inform at ion and advice, w hich can be used t o t ake m arket decisions and evaluat e t he validit y of t hese decisions. For exam ple, ent repreneurial organisat ions have been found t o access inform at ion about

cust om ers from t heir net w orks and use t his inform at ion t o im prove t heir pricing st ruct ures and t ailor t heir com m unicat ions ( O'Donnell and Cum m ins 1999; Shaw , 1998) . One reason explaining why t hese net w orks cont ribut e t o t he m arket ing effect iveness of

ent repreneurial organisat ions is t hat w hen lacking m arket

inform at ion and know ledge, such organisat ions oft en m ake use of t heir personal cont act net works t o provide t hem w it h t he m arket inform at ion and advice t hey need if t hey are t o develop t heir business furt her and progress t hroughout t he ent repreneurship process ( Carson et al., 1995) . A second reason relat es t o t he

rest rict ed t im e and resources w hich ent repreneurs and sm aller sized ent repreneurial organisat ions have available t o t hem . As

ent repreneurs rarely have t he t im e, resources or t he inclinat ion t o purchase m arket research report s or seek t he advice of business advisers, t hey oft en glean m arket inform at ion from t heir personal cont act net w orks, t ypically w hen undert aking ot her act ivit ies, such as liaising w it h suppliers. Sim ply put , for m any ent repreneurs t he conversat ions t hey have wit h people t hey int eract w it h on a regular basis w hile running t heir business, const it ut e t he m arket scanning w hich t hey undert ake and use t o keep t hem inform ed and up t o dat e about condit ions and changes in t heir m arket . Relat ed t o t his, an im port ant finding of such research is t hat t he inform at ion and advice provided t o ent repreneurs from t heir net works is

t rust w ort hy, reliable and can be act ed upon ( Hill and McGow an, 1997) . An im port ant reason for t his is t hat individuals providing t his inform at ion and advice have been found t o share m ore t han an inst rum ent al relat ionship w it h t he ent repreneur and/ or t heir

(9)

and advice, but also w it h inform at ion and advice w hich t hey are able t o t rust and t herefore do not have t o spend t im e validat ing.

While it has been est ablished t hat m any ent repreneurial

organisat ions do not conform t o t he m arket ing st rat egies pract ised by t heir oft en larger, m ore inflexible com pet it ors, research has found net w orks t o cont ribut e t o t he product , pricing and

prom ot ional decisions of ent repreneurs. By accessing m arket

inform at ion from t heir personal cont act net w orks, ent repreneurs are able t o keep inform ed about and ident ify m arket opport unit ies and respond t o t hese in innovat ive w ays, oft en involving t he

developm ent and int roduct ion of new product s. Relat ed t o t his, once dem and for a product or service is est ablished by an ent repreneur, research has revealed t hat by fost ering inform al relat ionships w it h cust om ers, product s can be cont inually review ed and m odified t o ensure t hat t hey consist ent ly m eet t he needs, w ant s and dem ands of t heir cust om ers. Given t he im port ance of net w orks and

successful net w orking t o ent repreneurial m arket ing, t his area is likely t o be t he focus of m any fut ure research st udies.

Conclusions

This art icle has aim ed t o provide t he reader w it h an insight int o t he hist orical root s and developm ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing and w here current t heory lies. I n essence, t his area of research has em erged from t w o key m anagem ent disciplines, nam ely

ent repreneurship and m arket ing. Early research focused on developing t his overlap and invest igat ing how bot h areas could benefit from each ot her. Developm ent of ent repreneurial m arket ing has expanded t o include areas such as creat ivit y, net w orking,

st rat egy, im pact on educat ion and grow t h issues. Current research uses prim arily qualit at ive approaches t o underst and how

ent repreneurial m arket ing t echniques are being adapt ed in t he w orkplace.

I f ent repreneurial m arket ing is t o be successfully adopt ed by a firm , it requires t hat t he organisat ional cult ure is such t hat it support s a different st yle of m anagem ent from t he very st ruct ured and rural approaches oft en advocat ed in t he m anagem ent lit erat ure. I t also requires addit ional com pet encies t o t hose perceived as key in

successful m anagem ent . As Drucker, as far back as 1973, indicat ed a different perspect ive requires t o be adopt ed w it h regards t o skills such as j udgem ent , creat ivit y and innovat iveness. This present s a challenge t o bot h educat ion and indust ry t raining inst it ut ions. The key skill of net w orking is crucial t o any firm adopt ing an

(10)

ent repreneurs ut ilise t heir net w orking skills t o grow successful com panies. The fut ure of ent repreneurial m arket ing research is current ly developing m any of t he areas discussed in t his paper and also focusing on t he area of e- m arket ing and how t his is best

m anaged in t he ent repreneurial firm .

Re fe r e n ce s

Boyat zis, R.E. ( 1992) , The Com pet ent Manager, John Wiley, New York, NY

Carson, D. and Coviello, N. ( 1997) " The

m arket ing/ ent repreneurship int erface: a dist inct paradigm for researc and educat ion" , in Hills, G.E., Giglierano, J.J. and Hult m an, C.M. ( Eds) , Researc at t he Market ing/ Ent repreneurship int erface, The Universit y of I llinois at Chic o, I L, pp. 59- 67.

Carson, D. and Crom ie, S. ( 1989) , ` Market ing planning in sm all ent erprises a m odel and som e em pirical evidence" , Jo rnal of Market ing Managem ent , Vol. No. 1.

Carson, D., Crom ie, S., McGow an P. and Hill, J. ( 1995) , Market ing and Ent repreneurship in SMEs, An I nnovat ive Approach, Prent ice-Hall, Englew ood Cliffs, NJ.

Chell, E. ( 1986) , " The ent repreneurial personalit y: a few ghost s laid t o rest " , I nt ernat ional Sm all Business Journal, Vol. 3 No. 3.

Collinson, E.M. and Quinn, L. ( 1 99) , " Profit by placem ent schem e and it s im pact on grow t h in SMEs" , Proceedings of t he ,rd Ent erprise and Learning Conference, Universit y of Paisley, Glasgow , Novem ber, pp. 253- 64.

Cunningham , A. ( 1997) , " Educat i n for t he int erface - t he

challenge" , in Hills, G.E., Giglierano, J.J. and Hult m an C.M. ( Eds) , Research at t he Market ing/ En t repreneurship I nt erface, The

Universit y of I llinois at Chicago, I L, pp. 83- 97.

Drucker, P. ( 1973) , Managem ent Tasks, Responsibilit ies and Pract ices, Harper & Row, New York. NY.

Hill, J. and McGow an, P. ( 1997) , " Market ing developm ent t hrough net w orking: a com pet ency based approach for sm all firm

ent repreneurs" , in Hills, G.E., Giglierano, J.J. and Hult m an, C.M. ( Eds) , Research at t he Market ing/ Ent repreneurship I nt erface, The Universit y of I llinois at Chicago, I L, pp. 543- 61.

(11)

Ent repreneurship I nt erface, in Hills, G.E. ( Ed.) , The Universit y of I llinois at Chicago, I L, pp. 3- 15.

Kurat ko, D. ( 1995) , " Ent repreneurship" , I nt ernat ional Encyclopedia of Business and Managem ent , 1995, I nt ernat ional Thom son Press, London.

Liu, H. ( 1995) , " Market orient at ion and firm size: an em pirical exam inat ion in UK firm s" , European Journal of Market ing, Vol. 29 No. 1.

Murray, J. ( 1981) , " Market ing is hom e for t he ent repreneurial process" , I ndust rial Market ing Managem ent , Vol. 10, pp. 93- 9.

O'Brien, E.M. and Clark, D. ( 1997) , " Graduat es t heir ent repreneurial role in t he sm all firm " , Market ing Educat ion Review , Special Edit ion, dedicat ed t o t he Market ing/ Ent repreneurship I nt erface, Vol. 7 No. 3, Fall, pp. 29- 37.

O'Brien, E.M. and Hart , S.J. ( 1999) , " Act ion learning: t he link

bet w een academ ia and indust ry?" , Educat ional Research,Vol. 41 No. 1, Spring, pp. 75- 87.

O'Donnell, A. and Cum m ins, D. ( 1999) " The use of qualit at ive m et hods in researching net w orking in SMEs" , Qualit at ive Market Research: An I nt ernat ional Journal, Vol. 2 No. 2, pp. 82- 91. Om ura, G.S., Calant one, RA and Schm idt , J.B. ( 1993) ,

" Ent repreneurism as a m arket sat isfying m echanism in a free m arket syst em " , Hills and Mohan- Neill, ( Eds) , Research at t he Market ing/ Ent repreneurship I nt erface, The Universit y of I llinois at Chicago, I L, pp. 161- 71.

Robson, E.H. ( 1996) , " Linking sm all firm s w it h higher educat ion" , I ndust ry & Higher Educat ion, Vol. 10 No. 2, April, pp. 103- 8. Shaw , E. ( 1998) ," Social net w orks: t heir im pact on t he innovat ive behaviour of sm all service firm s" , I nt ernat ional Journal of

I nnovat ion Managem ent , Special I ssue, pp. 201- 22.

References

Related documents

We have audited the parent company financial statements of Serco Group plc for the year ended 31 December 2007 which comprise the balance sheet and the related notes 1 to 15.

Founding family fi rm and type of local investors: the Landi Renzo Spa case-study. Panel A depicts the ownership structure of Landi Renzo Spa. Panel B i) categorises the

Combined analysis of variance depicted significant ( P ≤ 0.01) differences among genotypes (G) and planting times (D) for number of bolls, boll weight and seed cotton yield ( Table

We examine using of the spectral method formalism to the probabilistic analysis problem for the stochastic sys- tems with jumps generated by Erlang flow of events.. Finding of

Summary: The arteriovenous (AV) loop model is an in vivo tissue engineering strategy for generating axially vascularized tissues using the own body as a bioreactor.. A

➤ Professional project management drives project progress and corrects deviations ➤ With LOGIKA your project members stick to contents and deadlines. ➤ Ongoing problems

bilingual phrases 2000 frases bilingues NIVEL 5 para el quinto curso de las escuelas de idiomas LEVEL 5 for the fifth course of the schools of languages...

From 1 January 198 3.Intil the conclusion or the exchange of letters referred to in Article 18 of the Cooperation Agreement between the Community and Tunisia, until

Furthermore, the process of globalisation was put in place by the conscious and calculated lobbying and long term policy planning carried out in organisations

The S and N atomic concentrations obtained from wide scan spectra and siloxane contribution from the Si2p curve fitting have been plotted against the concentration of the

- Search using index words and with wildcards - Hierarchical search with Explorer display AND/OR searches within one field or between fields - Select lists for each

Dominion Energy Virginia has applied for t he license renewal for t heir t wo nuclear react or plant s at Nort h Anna.. If t he license is renewed anot her t ime (t his 2020

ECONOMIC DIMENSION – Customer Relationship Management – Innovation Management ENVIRONMENTAL DIMENSION – Climate Strategy – Environmental Policy / Management System –

What sets the literature written for Harmonie ensembles apart from other pieces of that time is the abundance of transcriptions of substantial works, many of them operas, that

Overall, the committee concludes that the course tests, the bachelor’s theses and the performance of graduates in the master’s programme demonstrate the achieved level

In this case study, the patient was a 73-years-old man who exhibited a solitary hepatic mass on ultrasonography in a routine body examination when he presented to the 1st

The derived reduced order model is able to define an approximate dynamics for the MBC containing any number of levels without modifying the order of the

Then, results of fusion of individual methods obtained for key frames extracted at 1fps for SIFT and 1 key frame per shot for Opponent SIFT (f 5 to f 8).. At last, we display results

Graph representing the different lymphocyte levels in the peripheral blood of the normal control group, the model group, the combination dose groups (B+R40, B+R60, B+R80), and

This evaluation scenario is intended to evaluate how well our system can adapt to an entirely new domain with only raw text from the new domain (for example, parsing biomedical

We find that the altruistic coalition formation solution yields significant gains in terms of reduced average false alarm probability and increased average throughput per CR as

This paper presents the phonological layer of a Kwak’wala finite-state morphological transducer, using the phonological hypotheses of Lincoln and Rath (1986) and the

JSF 2, PrimeFaces, Java 7, Ajax, jQuery, Hadoop, RESTful Web Services, Android, Spring, Hibernate, Servlets, JSP, GWT, and other Java