Rochester Institute of Technology
RIT Scholar Works
Theses
Thesis/Dissertation Collections
1984
Three installations: a thesis chronicle
Jonathan F. Kline
Follow this and additional works at:
http://scholarworks.rit.edu/theses
This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Thesis/Dissertation Collections at RIT Scholar Works. It has been accepted for inclusion
in Theses by an authorized administrator of RIT Scholar Works. For more information, please contact
.
Recommended Citation
THREE INST
ALLATIONS:
A
THESIS
CHRONICLE
by
Jonathan
F
.
K
l i ne
Submitted in Parti
al
Fulfillment of the
R
equi r emen t s for the
D
egr e e
MASTER OF FINE ARTS
MFA PHOTOGRAPHY PROGRAM
SCHOOL OF PHOTOGRAPHIC ARTS AND SCIENCES
ROCHESTER INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
MASTER OF FINE ARTS
MFA PHOTOGRAPHY PROGRAM
SCHOOL OF PHOTOGRAPHIC ARTS AND SCIENCES
ROCHESTER INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
ROCHESTER,
-
NE
W
YORK
August, 1984
N
a t ha n Lyons,
B
ha i r ma n
Professor, Director
V
i s ua l
S
t udi e s
W
or k sh op
Bea
N
e t t l e s
Associate Professor
P
ermission
Page
I prefer to be contacted each ti
me
a request for
reproduction of my thesis is made
.
I can be reached
a
t
the follo
wing
address:
Jon Kline
2194 Le
wis R
oa d
S
out h
t
l
a l e s ,
N
evi
Y
or k
1413
9
S
e pt ember 19
84
S
e pt ember 1
984
Jon Kline
Table
ofContents
Introduction
1
I.
Early Work,
1974-1978
2
II.
Rochester,
1981-1983
21
III.
Jordanian
Entries
35
IV.
Thesis
Development,
1983-1984
39
V.
Acknowledgements
81
VI.
Conclusion
82
VII.
Bibliography
83
Introduction
This
is
a specialbook.
It
servesto
document
the
course ofmy
workand,
morespecifically,
the
devel
opment
ofmy
the
si soexhibition.
As
adocument
it
is
filled
with copies of relevantjournal
entries,
drawings,
and
photographs
wovenin
withthe
text.
Fulfilling
the
written requirementfor
the
degree
in
this
way has
allowed meto
step back
andobjectively
look
at whereI've
comefrom
and what'sbeen
done.
Sifting
through
the
many
boxes,
journals,
and portfoliosin
orderto
putthis
together has
been very
valuable.
The
thesis
is
seen
as
a series of projectsdone
at a certain pointin
time,
derived
from
the
succession ofideas
going back
eightor nine
years.
This
book
wasdone
primarily for my
ownbenefit
asI
first
movedto
California in
the
summer of1974.
I
had
just
completed
the
two-year foundation
programin
the
art
school
at
RIT
which
included
somebasic photography
classes.
At
the
time,
I
was
then
eagerto
get on withthe
making
ofart
in
a more vibrantsetting.
Initially,
I
spenttwo
years atthe
San Francisco
Art
Institute
completing
the
requirements
for
aBFA
degree
by taking
lots
ofdrawing, filmmaking,
andprintmaking.
The
mainemphasis
ofmy
study,
however,
revolved aroundphotography.
This
seemedto
surprise mebecause
I
neveractually
felt
myselfto
be
aphotographer
norto
be
steepedin
the
history
andhardware
ofphotography.
None
the
less,
the
camerawas
becoming
anintriguing
tool
with whichI
kept
finding
more and moreinteresting
applications.
Unlike
painting
orsculpture,
photography
is
capable
ofdealing
moredirectly
withissues
oftime
andplace.
I
was
fascinated
by
photography's
ability
to
record and reproduce specific
segments
ofreality
andthereby
cameto
regard
the
medium as aframing
andmeasuring
device.
People
such
as
Jan
Dibbets,
Douglas
Heubler,
andMel
Bochner
wereproducing
work whichI
found
to
be
interesting
atthe
time.
Using
a standard35mm
camera,
I
was engagedby
the
way
movement and actionin
spacebecame
flattened,
fragmented
within a
rectangle,
recordedlinearly,
and readleft
to
right.
-i
Important
books
atthe
time
were
Lucy Lippard,
Six Years
(New
York:
Praeger,
1973)
andUrsula
Meyer,
CffU^rf
fyfauy-->
CcuAc&
'g/'ji***
&
o
-J*
K^C'<>J<-i.cift;i4
a sSuyj/fi
^loul
//'V
<yp*-<JL
lA-tts) aC<tS''U'u<
' jt-UU^XJUt -ttit<-^
ot&UJ iu<.Zu'-j
6h.
; IIAjt f/fsCWUi^&C?
-~S\A->c _L_7-ora
THREE
CONSTRUCTIONS
Process-/nscr/bing A ShapeinSpaceWith A Camera Using The View/noerS Ffw*
As A Building Block
-
'A
A
Vv
twitWZ
jC
-5i
Horizontal Rectangle
^ga.
^7
":'.*7
i.-A-'
Vertical Rectangle /nteorated Square
OMT/*"*0*
fi**>G**lt
Drawing
publishedin
Lew
Thomas,
Photography
andFLATTENED
CURVE
Inscribing
a
curved
line in
space with a
camera;
the
photographs
to
be
mounted
horizontally.
\
6
/
6
/
IIII
key
n
directioncamera pointscamlhaplane
I PHOluCiHAPM
SUMMtrl137!
Flattened
Cubes,
Installation;
San
Francisco
Art
Institute,
1976.
To
me,
the
viewfinder was perceived as abuilding
block
and
I
developed
a series of photographic exercises whichdis
cussed
the
contrastsbetween
specificactions
andthe
way
they
became
reconstructed viaphotography.
Overleaf:
Detail,
Flattened
Cubes,
Installation;
80
Langton
9
The
incentive
for
agreat
deal
ofthis
work camefrom
spending
alot
oftime in
certainareas
ofNorthern
California.
The
feel
ofthe
land helped
shapethe
type
of questions
posed.
I
was
drawn
to
the
ridge ofhills running along
the
westernborder
ofthe
San
Joaquin
Valley,
about40
miles east of
San
Francisco.
Soft,
undulating hills
ofvast
treeless
ranchland andlunar
stillness seemed somagnetic and alien
in
the
clearNorthern
California
light.
Cloudless
blue
sky
vaulted overthe
gentlecrests
and valleysof
the
foothills
below.
Hiking
into
this barren
yet voltaic
environmentinvoked
similarfeelings
to working
withclean white sheets of
drawing
paper;
sky,
earth,
andhori
10
General
view ofhills
nearDublin,
12
The
site,
the
photographicinterpretation
ofthe
site,
andthe
reconstruction ofthat
interpretation
vialarge
scale photographicinstallations
fascinated
me.
Walked
lines,
squares,
arcs,
and circles weresome of
the
fundamental
geometries performedin
the
mostminimal of
locales
as structure predominatedimage
andaction.
13
TWO
180
ARCS
IT
I
I
f~l
FastareslrxSngn btneOposition end^scribinga
180"
arc(romonehorizonaaossthes*ylo theceppsitehorizoni asinglesweec corrcosed oi sn exposures Thetertglholihecamerasvwwfmder is parallel wilh ihehorizon lineTwocopaesottnrsarc arethen made; eres positioned s-debestfe(la),iheotter ispositioned endioend(lb)
Secondarcinscribinganother
160"
arc similarro melsleceptihrs ime thewidtholthecameo'smewlrte'is parallel withthe horizon b-eAgaintwocooes are made andpositionedsadebyside(2a)andendtoend12b]
A
,7bnrrvesligalion olthecamera's rectangular viewlmoer and its mi erpreIationpihorizontallyandverticallywithnthecontext oli
ownlengthandwidth
Two
180
Arcs,
drawing,
1976.
With
time
however,
the
engineering
of a pieceboth
in
terms
ofits
logic
as
well asits
design
became
even moreimportant
than actually going
out andperforming
it.
The
work evolved
into
a series ofdiagrammetric
studies of speci14
ssdLia
Landscape
Rotation.
(Seascape
Version),
Installation;
San
Francisco
Art
Institute,
1977.
See
also
Photography
and
Language,
pp.
66-67.
The
horizon line
became
increasingly
moreimportant
as
an
element
within
the
photographs
because it
acted
as
adivider between
earth andsky,
the
only
edge withinthe
image.
I
investigated
the
horizon's
relationship to
the
viewfinder
's frame.
16
As
time
wenton,
I
investigated
the
contrastbetween
the
rectangular or squareformat
ofthe
cameraand
the
enclosed shape ofthe
areaphotographed.
i&mmmmmwumi
rM^mwwsmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmwKimi
ibeis
-t?si f^~^mm
*Arm
mm
msmwmmmmm*nmmi'fOTrti gg-3
wz*m
mmm\mWLwmwwwmm
HtSS3T0^m^J
WS?3
g"l73pw"': *!"""; s"^T^ ^f? r^KPCT
S71S
rT71r. ~1
jst5r:r*~*im?M *~*-5 pasar?t
^rs^ t&mimt"|
ssjt*"wsg>rg
5 nr3rr1
ESTl E^ S"^ 'S5S?E*S
e&^svzzns.wee tr^r*!7
R
7*273ET.*r!5
BC!?1C**"^-TTT^cat
jw$TCjraa"^^Df"*":^-^ r*ra
mm
m m v*
saa
nss
p^a sasa ^5^^sriarto*f!7
asa
mm
i
mr$m mmwmt
*?i**eM obim* Raw
wji
jswsb
KSS
f^S ^aPSgi
WC3 BBBH
W
SDl
asma cs
s?gs
rkmssf
I
MM
F3**imX2ml%m mm r-ra
s^eaS
-rpa|?w^jfwar**?*
H3GH
6K3I1 ^rsirwiKiessafs"aassai73
5te *AAA$t\ mmm^mm mzsM
mm mm
parsr*^
t?,-j efy??r^
o*3 "&.ff^iWAm
ixsai n*mn^wmwttBn
T^m-'"STHT'""^"-'^ Wr'l*"7"0? &3zwnatVt*G% T^r^
*mw%
$**%;B9C3MteS-^S54.'
^^I-__77-23l
ES1.
f>,7l.ii*> >^rr-i^ **jr
-i^aiwi ; mnii*^^-U*
I
began
by
;focusing
obliquely
ontoflat
surfaces,
tracing
the
projection ofthe
viewfinder'
s
frame
ontothe
surface,
thereby
comparing
the
square photographto
a17
I
continuedthis
approachby focusing
ontotwo
surfaces
coming
together,
such as acorner,
andpairing
the
photograph withthe
actualtaped
outline ofthe
imaged
area.
I
studied)the
way
convex and concave surfacesin
tersected
withinthe
viewfinder' stwo
dimensional
frame.
PLANE
PHOTOGRAPHS
An investigationof thecamera's viewfinder, in thiscasea square, projectedobliquely onto alternatesurfaces composedof one, two, or three planes.
Dealing with theinherent discrepancy between theviewfinder's perimeter andthe resultingshapeof that perimeter as it isprojected ontothe varying surfaces. The transformation ofa square intoa 4.5, 6, or 7-sided figure via
photography.
One Plane Projection; Two Plane Projection; Three Plane Projection;
0
?
The camera'ssquare viewfinder
proiectedobliquely onloaflat, smgle-planed surlace.
/
Q
?
a.
Thecamera's squareviewlmderptoiecled obliquelyontotwo perpendicular surfaces, convexand concave
The camera's squareviewlindei
proieciefl onto ihieesuflaces intersecimg al90*.convex and concave
Plane
Photographs,
drawing,
1980.
A
corner withthree
surfacescoming
together
provedeven more complex as
the
frame
capturing
these
intersecting
planes
became
abstractedfrom
the
scene.20
The
work
continued
to
be
as
minimal
asthe
land
scape work
that had
come
before.
Walls
andcorners,
in
both
convex andconcave
orientation
to
the
camera,
weresimply generic,
unconnected
with
issues
oflight
andcolor,
In
May
1978,
I
left
San
Francisco
for
the Middle
East.
I
spentthe
following
two
yearsthere
working for
the
Israeli
Department
ofAntiquities
as anarchaeological
photographer.
During
this
period,
I
kept
only
journals
of22
SH CD H H H fn o Cij CDH
CO H 0) _p CU CD!>>
CO?
rH S5
-h CDO ^ T
PS rH cti
* 7 Tl XJ o -p Tl CD cti H
SH
^
7 o -p o o ctiX
ft
%
Hu
!>>
CDS-lo P> 0
r
H ,7
o
o HO
> T"3 Ph
Cti 0
CO E CD CD
H 7! 7
o
P V
N
H
CO
7 CD Pi
crj f-H -P P crj 0 M tuC 0
1
* C CDH Ti P
fi CQ !^ ra CD crj CD 7]
H
B
OH CD o
CD
>
-P7
7
O o H -p o cti f-i M -p0
S3 -P -I cti*
O
e
H CO 3 cS3
CQ
cd
^
o f-i -P o
U
CO !h TlciJ 0 H
e
fA^r
CO P>
O CDE
K Cti HU
o Tl5
t^ o CD -p>
H 0 -P CQ O o 0X
Ph o CQ H H CD Pi P -7 o S3 0 Cti o CO SH CJ Ph H -P o Ph CQ O H 7 SHSH
cti 0 H CO3
cti o hH o S3 (D o ,3 E -P T 0 o O CQ 0 0E
H H
c--Ph -P
r-H CT\ O Tl T S3 O
H E
H 0 o
Ph -P
p
0
T o 0H H ^ CQ R o
Cti o
X 0 X
S3 CD
CD O -P
U O
o
i>,
S3H Ph
P
0
SH
w
O CD0 O Xi
O H o O -P o -p P -7 Cti 0 -d
3
0 ES3
^
o H UlP
-P cti T
S3
o S3 P
o 0 CD
43
^
J; cri M -p cti -P 0 0 7E
H cti iH S3 T cti^MMbllJ Hi
'
r\m
;^
:'^24r
I
;T:7:v
iiA"7,I:ls-!^H^"':^^',J
*4
.**.
n*j
.'I-:>7
7
'A
\
y,
\4^
A
A7f
i^jSi^
|_
72
4
-7
-H
-i i
"S
25
|
111
|
i
r
i
[II
ra Cti -p fi H o H rO 0 CtiS
-P CQ 71 Cti W) CQ2
!>>
Ho
P
ctip
0P
rQ bO
p
cti
B
P
E
O HbO
X
P
CO -P -H
V 0 <:
SH
X
o O Ph HrH Is cti H
H H O
Cti to bO
Tl
-P 0 o
0 H 0 0
R
TJp
,p fi O -P PX
CO
\ 0
H t3 O cti 0 p
fi P TJ CO S3 O
H Cti
p
!> H PH P
r-*
0 1 H
o 7! 0
T -P P -Ph
X
Tl +J O
o Cti S3 cti o o
S3 CO
p
o p S3
t>>
pH -H o H Ph
P CM
>,
0 Cti cti in (7 fi3
x
O Ul c^o S3 0 0 0 * rti S3 0 rP cti fi 0 > -P -P mP,P
ro HP
O Ph P. P OH Cti
B
-HCQ
p
7 H ObQ P CQ 0
0 O H P
X
-P 5 bO o-P O P o
X
co HbO Ph CO
^
Tl
P
cti P oH Is H o O
>
E
H
Ph
ctip
Cti 00
P
TJ bO 0 -P
>^> 0 fi cti 0
P
H 0 \- o
,7 Tli 0 0 N cti H
>
p,rH E-i H
o
P
3s -P i-H O 0 Cti COX
S3 -H28
Horizon
Run;
3
24x32
in.
B&W
prints,29
bo
S3
H fi 0
3 CO X
5
rfi>>
.-3 -P ctiCO Cti
E
*s
>>
7fi
ro X cti
7
X s
-P CD 0 CO H
H
b'J r. P
fi E-i Cti
H H
E
7! p-:
E
P fi
O TJ Ul
s fi
cti s Td 0 0 P 7
fi o 0
fi -fi E fi. H ra O 0 -P 71 m
Ph fi P
O 0 -7 71 o
"r--_-H
-p ^
H I: 0 O
IS
X
5 b:;N -p fi
fi P P H
CD fi
E
cti fiP o 0 X O
Cti P P H
p-l bfl T -P
fi 0 co
H H Ul O 0
cti
E
CD 0 fiPi o -P H
a-fi o Cti P
E
fi -PCQ 7 Cti m
fi
Cti cti H o a P -P H bO fi CDCQ p 0 P
-P Cti T fi
o 7! O 71 -P CD > P 0
-P P O fi
fi
>>
fi 3 Po X O P
o P O Ul
X to -P
Is 0
X
71
HN Cti cti0 -PH H O 15 So ro -P
T P>
-0 CO
N
H Ul CD fiCO t> X CD p
0 CD 0 0
vs
P
CD 0p
g; -P fi0 bO 0 0
fi fi O P 0
p H s H
o H p T >~,
o 0
B
0
>-J
>>
0Ph
p71
*s-P 0 0
-H
>
NX
0 H30
It
was
a complex piecethat
compared
the
camera's
image
to
the
shape ofthe
imaged
area.
White
walls andcorners
were
exposed on8x10
film
andthen
contacted ontoa single sheet of mural
paper.
I
drew
the
shape ofthe
imaged
area over eachphotograph.
One
ofthe
mostinsightful
responses
to
this
particular mural wasthe
questionfrom Nathan:
"Are
yourintentions
to
explicate principlealone,
orto
provide an
interesting
example ofthe
principlein
action?"Many
suggestions were offeredby
Keith
Smith
to
help
move onto
the
next step:-continue
working
on paper with anglesand
diagrams,
and also workthree
dimen-sionally
by
building
small mock-ups ofthe
drawings.
-explore ways of
coming
offthe
paper.
31
Despite
allthe
winds
of change aroundme,
I
spentthe
following
monthoTWorking
on aseries
offive
B&W
printsthat
were
hauntingly
reminiscent
ofwork
I
had
done
long
before
in
California.
They
wereinfluenced
by
origami andbased
on a series ofdrawings
done
in
1977.
HX
32
<P H 0 H -dTl
fi
H Cti t3 o 0a
fi
H 0 H1
t=i o H 0 O XTl
0 cti HbO
CQfi
h
cd cti^
-P ra 0 O
fi
0 0 HP
rfi H0 p
fi
rfiP
o -P 0 N
>
H 0 oP
>
O Cti 0
X
s 0 -Pp
ro Hcd
P
o H oTl
H H H
P
raa
cti cti ctiT|
T|
H T>0 0 H
a
M
P
cti -Pa
bO 0
fi
X
0 H -pX
-P -pCti
bO
0fi
Tl
H o
d S3
fi
P O cti P HbO ro -P
0
P
X
fi
O H 0U&
o nd CQ
fi
0+3
rfi
H ro -P 0
P
P
Cti 0 0 -pfi
0 H rfi -P ra cti ra 3= ctid
0 -pH
X
raft
p
P
0 H o HP
-P 0 0H rfi -P
P
o -Pfi
a
-pH
H
*
p
H PbO
cti cti rafi
H o H H rfia
^
a
bOCQ H
P
-p Cti ra o S3a
o
P
rficti
Td o P 9% 0 -p 0 i>
X
PiH ?
Cti Cti o 0 0 rfi
S>
a
ft
CQ S3 raH p d
o o 0
rfi ^-i -p CQ
o o
H t 0 Ph
rfi CQ H ra
Cti rO fi 13 Cti cti
-P
P
o -P 0 -P 0 H
p
r-3P
0 wo CQ
>>
P
0p
ft P Ul
rfi
p 0 -P -P
ft
a
H
fl
Cti oP
0P
0 o bO bOH 0 o
Tl
fi
-P -PTl EH o 0 H rfi H Ti
ft
P
P
bO 0 00
0 Tl rfi r-i 0 o+^
0
rfi
o O P ra
fi
-P CQ cti -P 0-P 0
!>>
CO Ht>0
o cti o 0fi
s
bO Tdp
ctifi
bflp
0 id cti 0 Hfi
fi
ft rfi cti 0 0 CQEH
0
P
fi
*. o
P
Ctiro p cti
p
0
P
pP
t>,
0
p *t *ra cti
X
>>
o 0P
Hft
p
Cti bO33
I
decided
to
write
up
athesis
proposal
that
wouldallow me
to
bring
to
fruition
my
obsession
with
structure,
and,
atthe
same
time,
challenge
meto
explore
some ofthe
recentsuggestions
offered
atVSW.
Statement of Purpose
I am interested in
doing
a series of pieces which deal with the connections that exist between the way thecamera interprets a space and observing the photographic
reconstruction of that space in another environment.
Some
ofthe
optionsI
outlinedfor
investigation:
Procedure
Some of the concerns that I will be
investigating
involve:
-extending basic theories and principles of monocular optics which have already been extensively dealt with in past
work into pieces which illustrate those same theories/prin
ciples in action.
-examining the folded edge vs. the photographed edge. -continuing to explore ways of activating the whole
space in the gallery;
having
the work become a function ofthe viewer's movement through that space via projected imagery.
-investigating possibilities of
dealing
with scale issuesoutside the gallery environment, i.e., projected
imagery
out34
The
proposal
was
submitted
andapproved
withthe
board
consisting
ofNathan
Lyons,
Bea
Nettles,
andEllen
Brooks.
Ellen
had
been
afaculty
member atthe
San
Fran
cisco
Art
Institute
and wascurrently
living
andworking
in
New
York.
I
looked
forward
to
visiting her
andthe
city
for
input
onthe
thesis.
It
was
atthis
time
that
I
was offered a chanceto
return
to
the
Middle East
with oldfriends
from
the Univer
sity
ofArizona,
Tucson,
and work asthe
staff photographeron an excavation
in
the
Jordan
Valley.
I
decided
to
leave
Rochester
and usethis
time
in
the Middle
East
to
rekindlesome of
the
passionI
deeply
felt
for
its
environment andhistory.
My
work neededthat
sort ofintensive
energy
more
than
any
further
classtime.
On
March
31,
I
flew
to
Amman, Jordan,
for
a36
Au'di, Hussein,
andMuschrif.
37
Petra,
A/23/Q1-.
The
light
is
bare-bulbed
overhead
with
turquiose
sheets
and
aprivate
room
onthe
top
floor
of
the
Petra
Resthouse.
I've
got
the
floor
to
myself
and
amountain
outthe
back deck
which,
after
afour
minute
climb,
affords
awonderful
view ofthese
entrancing,
alien
landscapes.
The
rock
structures
are
simply
amazing.
Tumbled,
rough
yet wornbits
ofdoughy
sandstone,
soft
andgranular,
easily
dug
into.
Curving
volumes
with
their sloping
edges.
Erosion
and
water
andwind.
And
on and oninto
the
far dis
tances
which
are
disturbingly
perspectiveless
in
the
brillant
dazzle
ofmid-day,
caught
in
ashimmering
blue
haze,
softly
immobile
and
flat.
As
the
sunsets,
the
gentle
heat
haze
renders
the
distant horizons
in
muted
purples
offuchsia
andmauve.
Twilight,
andI
walk
excitedly
to
the
top.
The
airis
filled
with
something
familiar;
not
the
Negev
try
asI
might,
but
to
the
California
coastline,
something
soft andsaline,
scented
yetillusive.
I
pickthe
last
ofthe
winter's
rainflowers,
bits
ofstill-blossoming
flora,
a cache of colormidst
sand,
stoneand
boulder.
Burying
my
nosedeep
into
afreshly
cut
stalk,
biting
its
stem,
I
waitfor
something
powerfully
familiar
to
present
itself.
It's
as
if
it's
there,
only
waiting
for
the
sunto
dry
it
out
andlet
its
inner
juices
crystalize,
crisp
anddry
in tie
desert
sun.
Too
early.
Deir
Allah,
5/12/83:
Very
magicalafternoon
today.
No
nap
and
arequest
to
drive
into
town for
supplies
and other urgenterrands
from
friends.
Black
clouds
to
the
south andquite a
wind.
By
the
time
I
gotthe
Chevy
truck into
town,
the
sky
overheadwas
grey-orange andthreatening.
Lightning
coming
down
the
valley.
Distant
thunder
coming
closer.
Shop
keepers
pulledtheir
wares
indoors
andthe
airbecame
heavy
and
still.
Arabs;
mother with smallboy
in
knickers
andknee
socks,
school girlsin
turquoise
jumpers
withblack
trousers
beneath;
Beduoin
kids
in
rags;
youthsin
tight
jeans
andMarlboros;
the
religiousin
dusty
gelabas;
allin
a greatvariety
ofhead
gear.
Dirt
andlife,
action andentropy.
Remember
Cairo.
And
then
the
town
grewdark
andthe
lights
came
on;
neontriangles
andkerosine
lamps
flooded
someinter
iors,
while
in
the
mudbrickhomes
ofthe
poor a singlebare
bulb
cast adulling
dimness
throughout.
And
then it
rained andrained,
washing
the
dust
away
38
5/15/83:
And
the
ridehome
was
the
best.
Coming
down
offthe
high
plateau
onthe
west
side ofthe
Beka
Valley,
slowly
following
ancient
roads
west anddown
to
';
the
Jordan
River.
Down
anddown, descending
slowly
through
terraced hills
pocketed
with
cream yellow rocksin
the
redbrown
soil,
grape
vines,
olivegroves,
and
scruboak.
Corn
flowers,
meadowgrasses,
andpoppies.
Small Moslem &
Christ
ian
villagestucked into
the
niches
ofthe
hillsides,
offering
grand vistasdown
into
the
Valley
and acrossto
Israel.
Crusader
fortresses high
atop
strategic mountainpasses,
Bellevoir
andAjlun
Castle^
Saracens
andthe
Holy V/ars,
Sulieman
andRichard.
Taken
andre-taken;
lines
of warfarepast and
present.
Deir
Allah,
5/21/83:
Twilight.
Listening
to
the
evening
callto
prayerfrom
the
roof of ourhouse.
Over
looking
life
going
onin
the
yards and gardensbelow
me.
The
muezzinchanting his
call,
slow,
deep
anddreamlike.
Chickens
nesting
nearby,
akite
flying
from atop the
tel.
Fading
orange yellowsky
aglow,
softgrey
purplehills
to
the1
north and
west.
Chickens
aimlessly running
aboutin
the
dusk
light.
A
motorcycle gains speedin
the
distance.
Silverware
tinkling
in
the
dining
roombelow.
Scents
of40
I
knew
when
I
returned
to
the
States
that
I
wanted
to
work
on a seriesof
three
to
four
projects
that
would
be
specifically
designed
for
the Photo
Gallery's
spaceat
RIT.
I
wanted
to
work
with
the way
light
illuminated
each piece asif
to
install
some ofthe
magical
presence
ofthe
Jordan
Valley's
light in
the
work.
I
read
enthusiastically
Lawrence
Weschler's
biography
ofRobert
Irwin,
Seeing
is
Forgetting
the
Name
ofthe
Thing
One
Sees.
In
early
July
I
went
to
New
York
andjust
talked
with
Ellen
Brooks
aboutlight,
revitalized
energy,
and newinsight.
She
suggestedinvestigating
the
recent
work ofJim
Turrell,
Elyn
Zimmerman
andMaria
Nordman.
She
showed meJaap
Reitman's
bookstore
onSpring
Street
where
I
immediately
gotlost
in his
collection of art
books,
museumcatalogues,
and other relevantpublications.
A
wonderful
spotwhich
I
would continueto
visiton
future
trips.
Researching
in
the
art
library
ofRush Rhees
over atthe
University
ofRochester
as wellas
the Memorial Art
Gallery's
library
to
find
out what'sbeen
asked,
what's
been
workedout.
Over
the
ensuing months,
Rush Rhees
andthe
Memorial
Art
Gallery
(MAG)
libraries
would provideprivacy
andthe
complete collections
of publicationsnecessary
for
the
development
ofthis
thesis.
Full
days
wereto
be
richly
spenthunting
down
obscurearticles,
searching
outimportant
interviews,
andenjoying
all41
Knowing
I
had
the
full
gallery's
spaceto
exhibit
the
thesis
which
was
slated
for
March
9-16,
1984,
I
continued putting
together
thoughts
and
ideas,
prioritizing
whatI
felt
needed
to be
communicated.
Projecting
Reflecting
Function
ofwind
Function
of people's movementHuge
Scale
Rich
Color
Plastic/fabric/gauze
Photography
as
a richrecording
device
Thoughts
of universal principles ofheat/light/motion
Organic
richtextures
andthe
implication
of speedLarge
muralsGeometric
sequencing
Horizon
lines
Enveloping
Engaging
Meditative
Inducing/encouraging
imagination
42
bfl
S3
0 H
CQ H O
0 O H
0 rfi
P
rQ CQ P H H0 O CQ
rfi Td H -P 0
>
Tdi>
fi
ra
P
fi
Hra 0 H
o m 35 0
P
rQ,fi
o o 0 p
cti
X
I
1
!
0 P rfi
0 P
a
f>3
4cti p* rD o 0
1
fi -PP
CD H
H
Tl
i> Obfl o H
i
66
fi
fi
0 H cti H Cti OBC cti m P 0
$
o .0
P
I
1-3P
H 0cti
P
t op
p
cti Ul 0 0 o Td a-*1
rfi -P t H 03
f>s
HI
CQ Tl r*1 TTl
CQ o!>>
o bflOk KA
P
P
fi
CO -P bO 0 H
-CTi S3
a
CQI
T-P H CQ
!
-P rfictifi
P
fi
CQ Ctift a.ra -p
fi
a
i
0
-P 0 O%
bb
ra rfi Ov>
0
tj Ti -Pfi
c<
cti fi 0so o cti o
Jit
P
P 0 c 0P
fi rfio. H
X
0 H EH
-O o !>
H cti o ft
p
S3 X fi 0
O bO
fi
pP
0C
rfi H cti ,fi rfi H o Ctis
O P H
p
bflH cti cti Td <
fi
P
0S
Ph
p
Pfi
-P o 0 0 O
Cti nd -p !> ra
P
cti O Ho CQ n -P
o 0 0 x> P
a
!> p T0
0 0 H 0 o cti np
P
-pt3 cti CQ
p
T
*-P 0 o
bO P 0 !>
fi
S3 bO rs O 0H 0 S3 CQ
ft
0
H bfl 9\ Ctift & 0
fi
r*. 0H CD rO H H H
H
P
-P 0O T ra
P
P
0
O HP
fi
H ft CQ OO 0 H ra Td f-i
a
Tl k
fi
r0
fi
00
P43
Throughout
the
development
ofthe
thesis,
my
workrooms
four
windows played a significant role.Through
the
day
they
delivered
avariety
ofdifferent
types
oflight
44
X
V
Ul -H
v~
^
5
8
><
XV-
VI
*
3
45
Autumn
By
early October
I
had
laid
out onpaper
afloor
plan of
the
gallery
andstarted
to
draw
up
plans
for
three
installations.
I
knew
I
wanted
to
somehow usethe
two
30 foot
long
windows
that
ranalong
the
north
and eastwalls
of
the
gallery.
Each
ofthe
pieces
developed simultaneously;
while
one
was
onthe
drawing table,
the
othertwo
were closeby.
With
each
pieceit
was
my intention
to
encourage
reflection
and
imagination
onthe
part ofthe
viewer.
With
the interaction
oflight
and spaceI
hoped
to
convey
a senseof
immediacy
andpresence.
Wonder
invocation
sensationreflection
absorption
^diffusion
event context structure
minimal
sensual
animateclear
honest
aliveEdge
Dissemination/Atmospheric
Analogy
My
first
thoughts
withthis
piece centered aroundthe
notion
ofsequentially
magnifying
an edgeto
such adegree
that
it
eventually
becomes
fused
withthe
spacesurrounding
it;
anexample
ofthe
breakdown
of matterinto
constantly moving fields
of
atomic
energy
where no clearboundaries
exist.
The
mergenceof
positive
and negativespace.
I
visualizedthe
edge scattering
and
dispersing
withincreased magnification,
andit
took
on
the
appearance
of ahorizon
line
seenthrough
avariety
ofdistances
and
atmosphericconditions.
I
referedto
Webster's:
analogy:
.. .partial resemblenceexplaining
something
by
comparing
it
to
something
else...
similarity in
some respectsbetween
things
otherwiseunlike.
dissipate
disseminate
disperse
dispel
46
I
conceived of a series ofhuge
muralssequentially
revealing
this
phenomenaas
recorded
onthe
Scanning
Electron
Microscope
with arazor's
edge
usedto
simulatethe
horizon
line.
Yet
why
notjust
go out and shoot a series ofhorizon
lines
whichactually
appear
the
way
I
preconceivedthem,
from
hard
edgeclarity
to misty,
cloud-hiddenblur?
Because
the
act of
simulating
this
with magnification on a microscope provided evidence of matter'simmateriality
in
muchthe
sameway I
felt
light
and atmosphere affectedthe
appearance ofthe
horizon
line.
One
was
real yetinvisible
to
the
eye,
whilethe
other wasequally
as
real,
yetpoetically
visible and present.
Their
visual and conceptual similaritiesfascinated
me.
I
wantedthe
muralsto
be
illuminated
by
diffuse
light
coming
through
the
north windowin
the
gallery.
I
wantedthe
way
they
wereto
be
installed
andlighted
to have
adirect
re48
The
second pieceI
was
developing
atthis
time
dealt
with
the
continuing
interest
I
had
in horizon lines
andfold
ed
edges.
I
visualizedintersecting,
suspended colorimages
that
would somehow revealthe
order andgeometry
of successively
bisected
rectangles.
Working
on avariety
of ways of presenting
this
withdiffused
gallery
light,
I
consideredboth
free-form,
arbitrary
planes of color as well as a much moresystemized method of
arrangement.
I'll
referto
this
asthe
Folded
Horizons
piece.
- V"
i
1
S 'i
rVL >*v^/^:
&
r*r ^?^J .^tWVLWiis-j <r
i-SL
W
4 -r-i7=8
I
JC
-ts
ft
__l -4Ttfl-k
t
;. ~iA
."T.0-4!h a. V.:0* AVS>
,
1
H!^
ESm^< fx I J^BK i
!
<eSoi
1
i
> l-P^t.l
*-KJ
ppaKJ
1
iisl&
^f^jjHpflM
An
7-i
l$i
xV|ifr>
i
I
7*
i&iV
1 A
f
<*
\ r1
L
"tL-.17
v&il
/
rj
kJ
1
:
i
i / '.-S
Hv.7
ac r " K^H
-fifed^
P
1
[
i
' '
^ijBjHEbiijMH
^^>7
T^r: .i_l
7
51
fi H
CM
X
CO
0
-P
H
rfi
ft
Cti
p
bfl
fi
fi
cti
fi
o
t>J
ctip
o
bfl fi H
52
Initially,
the
third
piecewas
conceived
as
aspace
to
be
illuminated
by
continually
changing
slidesof
dawn/dusk
light
that
had
been
shot whilein
Jordan.
I
began
drawing
up
different
projection
systemsfor
the
gallery
space.
My
main concernwas
whether
the
piece wouldbe
something
walkedthrough like
acorridor,
orsomething
arrived at andremained
in
for
awhile.
In
time,
moredrawings
wouldbe
generatedfor
this
project,
referred
to
as
the
Skylight
piece,
than
the
first
two
,projects.
In
allthe
pieces,
I
began
looking
atJapanese
architecture and
its
usage ofdiffused
light
indoors.
I
then
became
interested
in
the
way
contemporary Western
architects are
using
naturallight
in
their
designed
in
teriors.
'
A,
A
fifat^_
- ' l*r'"/
^it^iw .1:."//->.*/f* .-'yi-jWr4J*J-*if r ... '.
'
53
Mid-October
I
arranged
meetings
with
Bea
Nettles,
Tim
Callahan,
Dick
Floberg,
andNTID
theater
people
to
discuss
the
actualmaterials
necessary
for
the
successful
presentation
ofthese
projects.
Bea
suggestedgetting
in
touch
withContact Supplies
here
in Rochester
and see abouttheir Xerox 20-60
Copier2which
handles
originals
up
to
23
inches
wideby
any length.
It
is
also capable ofphotocopying
the
original
ontovellum,
mylar,
andbond
paper.
She
also suggestedinvestigating
Kodak's
Translite
Film
#5561,
aB&W
emulsion coated on atransparant
and
very
drawable
base.
Sold
in
large
sheets andlong
rolls,
this
couldbe
anideal
materialfor
the
large
Folded
Horizons
piece.
It
would meanimaging
it
in
B&W
andhand-coloring
it
afterwards.
Tim
suggestedthat
Kodak's
Duratrans
Display
Film
#4022,
a rear-pro
jection
color material on atranslucent
base,
couldbe
usedfor
the
Folded
Horizons
piece.
Examples
ofthis
productin
action canlhe7seenin
airports aroundthe
country
as well asin
Grand
Central
Station,
wherethe
huge
mural of eight seatedbabies
greets
commuters24
hours
aday.
Tim
also suggestedthat Rosco
Laboratories
made avariety
ofdiffusion
materialsthat
couldbe
perfect,
yetcostly,
for
covering both
ofthe
gallery
windows.
Dick
Floberg
andBob
Pratt,
anNTID
theater
designer,
both
suggestedinvestigating
the
local
company
Brighton
Lites
to
see what specificRosco
productsthey
carried.I
was alsoinformed
that
;
yracuseScenery,
ahuge
theater
supply
company
in
Syracuse,
sold muslinin
ninefoot
widebolts,
and alsocarried
the
BD
Company's
line
ofless
expensivediffusion
material.
For
further
information
aboutthis
productand
allthe
54
Late
October
New
York:
Whitney
-"Minimalism
to
Neo-Expressionism""Sculptor
as Draughtsman"Avery
Fischer Hall
-open
rehearsal:
Zubin
Mehta
andthe
NY
Philharmonic
working
with
Carlo Menotti
on a recentcomposition of
his
to
be
performedthat
evening.
Carnegie
Hall
-Segi
Ozawa
and
the
Boston
Symphony
Orchestra
with
mezzo soprano
Fredericka
Von
S
trade
performing
'Six
Songs'by
Berlioz.
Brooklyn
Academy
ofMusic
-opening night;
Lucinda
Childs Dance
Group
performance with music
by
Laurie Anderson
and stage
designs
by
Robert
Rauschen-berg.
I
met withEllen
Brooks
and showedher
the
drawings?:
done
to
date:
Folded
Horizons
- make surethe
materialsadd
to
the
lushness
and reflectivity
ofthe
earth/
sky
phenomenon.Magnification
- make surethe
windowis
really
being
incorporated
into
the
piece.
Skylight
- a room or corridor?Is
there
any
way
to
integrate
architecturally
the
presence of multi-layered
translucent
surfaces
in
the
piece withoutdistract
ing
the
viewer andlessening
the
sensa-of
light
envelopment?5These
sets wereincredibly interesting;
twelve
movieprojectors
projecteddown
ontothe
stage wherethree
translu
cent
tent-like
structures containedthe
dancers.
Film/music/
55
KZiXlam
^
BbBniMBBBM^^
^p^_ . - .-,.."iiimiwyi
""
"v
"~ . . .;. h
-t-j
; i^LL , c_7rt
'
n 1 */.'
- .... 4
*J/i-4
7-^
1
$fs&*?4
S^T^f^s^i^Lt
i~ 7 -__*_
//
-+
-h
-ft*
~At&iAt.i
1
r
^
-t'-
-1
h
-!
tusq^AtCcyt
'i4fA--j
Ut
**A&ft/AciA
ft,
'.
_. i
7
;_.j
_."i
*
-1
_^
i
u
-+J!
j
f--T
-! i" a^ 'VV
1t^_i
,/jTv
j
\|77
^^
^7
l/C ,
;
i__
^/l
"V
1Vi/
|
y. _...
j
^^Y
"--f
/ve_
"??w^.
1
i -+-/-\i -jXiV/
L.^r7.j._i
-44-J^
x\M4A^)iiMt\^^Au/
A&Tu/
A*#t*-f
dMxu/x. iL
1
V-
-^k^i^-AAt-
-i -1-4.^/W^f/),/^l^ac
i^i. *i**Cc4**<<-L -J..-4._
l'^f
4*y
JUt
,Ai^ u/?<ai**f-//
du^Au*
'AjS/t#A/kr</&/<*&l_
Oin/rtL***/}
:^/
"^ \ _i_
J ....>>JC--fi
-i-~f 4-
-;.-.7
h 1
^
i**^?vtf7 13^;_^f
^/#f. <7c4--h-4
1
I1
!
jfci4f>**S
1 1
7
+- J ..1--1 ...L..1
. l.._iI-'H
1
"1
j
1 1 '"f
C<2
; -J -4--J-1 U_jiL.
. 4.!
j
~" 7"
'"~7
ri
1
i
l 1L
_.! t-.-t-
- .|
-7-.-^._l__
1i^-T^---^
f-7
M
Sja^
1
T
,!^~7
T
i
j^r^
^
fi
ii^7:
,0t
ft
A
WTJ
4-|_HIL-.-r
lr/1-ll
tCt
fhf^y
-'--y-yv
.t_
_!_nrr
pz/M
r
L
/
>
:
/ - - 1-j
/
/ i/
"tL/A i r
I
7
strffyflfala- fl/i^tt e//AJ/f mAW
~ i_.|./N4-_
'|.p
, ' ; ,\
' _ji^ft$^lti^L*aJ[tti'fr
<t+ 1/7iL
\ ? Ty^~~ "
'
i~^v '
'
i
'"
;,(nj
V
"is
^S^^T
''^H
--I
jU--' V' "0 " 7 ~"T"'1
77 7
J7"7_V
17 i
I
\
1:
; ! 1
1
i
!
;
-^
/
\
i ;,
"T" ~
;
t'
r I ^
i _
!
!
'
: :
7
; i i : : ;i
j
!
:.
,
|
;t.
1 ! ! ; 7; l
i
Wjl7
1 1 ,'
;
,
74
7T~
/ / fi\
x^^
/r'\|~T~"i
~,
-- - .-j.
"i_
-V-V
~ f~
I
[
^'!xx->
|
-.._L_^z^2tr
t-
jx
_J
" ~"A~" 1 " "
1
4i)
"^A
uq7"hX-
-, 1 _L7-v
J
/li
\,
,"^
_A
1
J
J
ALL
t
^e\.iitw ;
- "
1~ /r"
^t^nI
^ i-.. --'
j
1->-/
--L^ .]-
pjiSpi .1
i
i
11
!
1
wsyHd
) 1
1
1 L V--J 1 1. -J Lm
JPI||:^.^.,J^.iii^P^.^W!Pl^i^W*!l
^8|lf|i|$jp*i^^
'' r'
>' *H^|f^s^*,.B..!!?^sSP
Refreshed,
I
cameback
to Rochester
andworked
out moredrawings
ofthe
Skylight
piece,
trying
to
incorporate
a sense58
I
also
thought
aboutworking
moredirectly
withthe
windowwhich
illuminated
the Magnification
piece.
I
thought
oflouvred
systems
that
would referto
what wasoccuring in
the
imagery;
the
horizon
wasbeing
altered,
why
not alterin
a similarway
the
light
that
cameinto
60
I
began
researching
attitudes
ofcontemporary
painterstoward
light
and
its
presence
In
their
work.
Edward
Hopper:
time
ofday
assubject.
Willem LeKooning:
sheer
luminosity
ofwhite.
Mark
Rothko:
atmospheric
light
ofland
andsea.
Larry
Poons:
glowing,
recurrent
light.
Jules
Olitski:
diffused,
volumetric
spaces.
10/23/83:
I
went
to
seethe
Motherwell
show atthe
Albright.
Such
huge
canvases
hung
in
near claustralfashion.
Most
attractedto his
Open
Series
which
speak aboutlight,
space,
and
enclosure
with
minimal color and abstractedforms.
There
is
noreference
to
the
symbolic use of color asin
his
older series
dealing
with
his
perceptions
ofthe
Spanish War
in
the
Thirties.
Also
saw asculptural
pieceby
Charles Wilmarth
whileat
the
Albright.
It
was a sheet offolded
black
steel andthick
frosted
glassin
front
ofit.
Heavy
materialtranslated
via glass and
light
into
something entirely
different.
10/31/83:
I've
visitedthe
fabric
showtwice
atthe
Memorial Art
Gallery.
So
many
greatpieces
whichdeal
withthe
suspension anddrapping
of materialsin
innovative
ways.
Only
onepiece
was
illuminated
withdiffuse
light
from
behind.
Caught
the
lecture
by
Paterson
Sims,
one ofthe Whit
ney
curators
who putthe
show"Minimalism
to
Neo-Expressionism"together.
Discussion
of
the
Post-Modernist
obsession withdeath/
self/holocaust
that
comes closeto
predominating
much of contemporary
painting.
However,
a sense of pluralismin
the
artsexists
as
neverbefore.
It's
an environment which can supportthe
recent
strong
contributions ofMinimalists
such asBrice
Marden
andEllsworth
Kelly,
aswell
asthe
army
of youngerNeo-Expressionists
led
by
Julian
Schnabel.
Early
November
I
took
alot
ofmy
currentdrawings
overto Jim
Thomas,
my
sculptureinstructor
from my
freshman
year atRIT.
His
in
put
was
really
good atthis
stage.Cautioning
me aboutthe
dis
crepancy
between
drawings
and actualconstruction,
he
advisedme
to
be
awareas
soonas
possible ofthe
limits
ofthe
mater61
color and
the
way
they
were
illuminated.
He
questionedthe
direction
ofthe
Skylight
piece:
"Why
waste
time
recreating
the
effect of aplanetarium?
It
would
be
impossible
to
pulloff
skillfully
giventhe
time
frame
ofthe
thesis
exhibition.
Why
notdesign
something
for
that
spacewhich
acts as away
of
introducing
the
viewer
to
the
gallery
andthe
othertwo
pieces?"
11/6/83:
Tibetan
chantsheard
in
the
high-ceiled
gallery
ofthe
MAG,
entrancing
spatial
sounds.
Steve Reich
atKilbourn
Hall,
talking
rapid-fireabout
his
musicaldevelopment;
quick-witted,
open,
demon
strating
withclapping hands
anddouble
beat
the
metamorphosis
of asingle
beat into
arythmic
symphony.
Spent
afew
weekends
searching
the
shores ofLake
Ontario
for
siteto
shootthe
Folded
Horizons
series.
Con
sidering
avariety
ofbeaches
that
providedifferent
perspectives
ofthe
water andhorizon.
Working
with sea andsky
rather
than land
andsky
seemedto
make much more senseto
me;
water reflectslight
andis
adirect
function
ofthe
sky.
Earth,
for
the
mostpart,
introduces
too many
ofits
own variables
which
are muchless
dependent
onthe
sky
than
wateris.
I
finally
chosethe
heights
ofChimney
Bluffs
to
shootfrom.
One
hundred
or sofeet
abovethe
beach
I
couldlook
out62
While
atthe Rush
Rhees
Library,
I
discovered
anew
Itook
out onthe
California
artist
Richard Liebenkorn
that
contained
this
passage:
"He
has
learned
that
large
flat
spaces,
if
the
color
is
notopaque,
can alsosuggest
aninfinite
space,
like
that
ofthe
sea andsky.
"^
Driving
outto
Chimney
Bluffs
atdifferent
times
of
the
day,
I
watched
the
changes
in
the
light
ofthe
sky
and on
the
lake
as
it
altered
dramatically
day
to
day
in
erratic
November
weather.
Cloudy/clear/
snowy/
quiet/white-capped.
Dawn/morning/midday/late
afternoon/dusk.
Always
changing,
always
absorbing.
I
took
all
the
drawings
done
up
untilthis
pointdown
to
VSW
and showedthem
to
Nathan.
By
mid-January
he
wanted
to
see a model ofthe
gallery
space with allthe
pieces
built
to
scale.
We
discussed
the
needto
have
eachproject
workin
relationto
the
others,
andto
considerthe
directional
flow
ofthe
viewersthrough
the
gallery'sspace.
It
was
suggestedthat
one piecebe
usedas
an entry/introduction
to
the
rest ofthe
showthus
forcing
peopleto
seeit
twice,
onceto
getin
and once againto
exit.
Re-seeing
it,
they
mightbe
awakenedto
feelings
activatedby having
viewedthe
othertwo
pieces.
Maurice
Tuchman's
book,
Art
andTechnology,
was
lent
to
me.
I
had
been
searching
aroundfor
acopy
because
it
included
the
early
collaboration attempts ofRobert
Irwin
andJim
Turrell
with some ofthe
R&D
people atGarrett
Aerospace
Industries
during
the
late
'60s
in
California.
%ark
Stevens,
Richard
Diebenkorn,
Etchings
and
63
December
This
was
the
month
spent
predominantly
getting
the
murals
made
for
the
Magnification
piece.
The
actual
images
of anordinary
razor's
edge
were
first imaged
onto
4x5
Tri-X film
onthe
Scanning
Electron
Microscope
overin
the
College
ofScience.
Dr.
Frederick
was more
than willing to
help
out
and
provided
the
machine
for my
use.
We
shotthe
sameportion
ofthe
razor's
edge