The 2015 Televised Election Debates; Democracy on Demand?

(1)

This is a repository copy of

The 2015 Televised Election Debates; Democracy on

Demand?

.

White Rose Research Online URL for this paper:

http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/92862/

Version: Published Version

Monograph:

Coleman, S orcid.org/0000-0001-9571-4759, Blumler, J, Moss, G

orcid.org/0000-0003-3486-7748 et al. (1 more author) (2015) The 2015 Televised Election

Debates; Democracy on Demand? Report. Leeds University Press , Leeds.

eprints@whiterose.ac.uk

https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/

Reuse

Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless

indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by

national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of

the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record

for the item.

Takedown

If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by

(2)

T T E D Democracy on Demand?

The 2015

Televised Election Debates

Democracy on Demand?

Authors

(3)

I I

A N

S C J G B G M M H

C N A

P

(4)

T T E D Democracy on Demand?

Acknowledgements

W ITV

T T M C R

W J C M S G W

W E P

S R C EPSRC D P W U L D A D L D B P O U

F

S M C U L

(6)

E

T TV

M

I T

P

T

S W

W

TV O

T

• T

debaters.

• T

W

Q T P D W

• T A

• O ITV

(7)

• M

• A

M

• A

• O

• H

ITV

• O

TV

W

• W

• I

E

• T

• M

• B T

(8)

E

P

W

• O B

• T

• O

A

B

A

T TV

W

I

T UK

T C L L D

I

TV

(9)

(10)

C D D D

C

D

T W

TV H

I

W TV

I

M TV

P

I TV

T

T P M

TV

T L P

P M T L D

D P M T UK

I P L D

T P M T G

L D E E I

UKIP G T A

W

C

BBC G L G

I

B

TV

O TV

I TV I B E

M S N V UK

N S STV N P TV

(11)

C O D

C P M D C B

A

W

TV

C M M A

T

W L

T P D C L

I

R

D A S

H N N G

C M

TV

C TV

elites.

I

TV

W

W TV

A

E

C

R B TV

(12)

C D D D

T

O T

A

T

U

supporter.A

J

TV

I

A

O

N

P

T T

TV B

T

T R L

T P

W

I

T

H

Y

A

E

J

T

(13)

P

B

W

P

T

W

H

T

F A

P I I

R

O T G

Y A

T A I I

S

W

S

R

P

A

I

S I T

(14)

C D D D

T

O

H

P

A

I

E T

A

T

W

F

P

V

S

T

A

W

(15)

A

T

A S C M D

C E M

T

A A ITV T

A D C N C

BBC A

A BBC Q T A D C E

M N C T

T

M I

ITV A

P D

A Q T

W C R

ITV

A BBC C D A BBC Q T A

W

ITV

A

W B I

T

F

I

Q

(16)

C D D D

• P

• E

• P

R T

T

R

W

B I

BBC P E A I

W

4

F I N A

TV A

TV

T

D F

D M

C F P S

C M P S

U F V

U M V

F F V

F M V

M A D T U

F A D T U

F P M P

T

O ITV

W ITV

US

W

S C BBC BBC D P

F

B H

(17)

(18)

C W D W L

Chapter 2 - What Did We Learn?

O

C T

W

P M

B C C

P M

R

N F UKIP N S SNP N B

G L W P C W

W

I T

I S

F S

D

T O

I

D

S S

N

P N

T

I

B

(19)

[image:19.420.33.389.67.142.2]

TABLE 2.1

D T

V F N

N

Y

Y N

N

I ITV

O

A

T A

I

TV

S

E

A

T

TABLE 2.2

A

P D P D

F

E

P

O

A

[image:19.420.42.386.419.495.2]

(20)

[image:20.420.31.386.88.222.2]

C W D W L

TABLE 2.3

P

P P P A_P R P

V

F

N

TABLE 2.4

P

I

P P P A_P R P

V

.

F

N

I

T

A

W W

O

T T

[image:20.420.35.385.285.420.2]

(21)

[image:21.420.36.386.50.228.2]

TABLE 2.5

I ITV

S

C

J

H

U

R F

H

P

B

T

M

I

A I

A

B

ITV W T

(22)

[image:22.420.33.386.52.205.2]

C W D W L

TABLE 2.6

N

Y

T

I

M

D

T

I

E

I

C

T T

I

D ITV

B T

D

N

A

M

T

U

(23)

Younger (and Older) Voters and the Debates

A

C B

W

H

A

O

B

A

A G

R

voters!

W H

S

A

O

M

(24)

C W D W L

T

I

R

P A A A Q T A P

A

F

D

P

E

U

O

T

[image:24.420.40.388.401.504.2]

TABLE 2.7

P

Q

T

D

G

T

U

O

T

I

(25)

C S

F

S

T

B M Q G

Talk with others

E T

T

I

C O

N

L

[image:25.420.33.386.341.383.2]

TABLE 2.8

D

T Y I

N I

M

A

TABLE 2.9

D

T Y I

(26)

C W D W L

W A

T

[image:26.420.34.390.166.249.2]

supposed.

TABLE 2.10

W

T F

F W

Neighbours

C

D U V

A

P D F

T

M

O

E

T

D T I N

(27)

T T

T

TV D

TV

A

TV A

T

T E

T

I

L

H

B

D

W W

H

W

I

W

TV

M

I D

W

(28)

C W D W L

H

W

B

I

O

T

S

B

M

T

C

A

T

E

F

ITV

S

(29)

[image:29.420.34.387.33.321.2]

FIGURE E

F

N

A

E

T

A

T

Q.1 Do you think you will watch the debate on Thursday evening?

No, definitely not No, probably not

Yes, probably Yes, definitely

Mean MeanEntitlement

2.50

2.75

3.00

3.25

3.50

(30)

[image:30.420.33.388.34.318.2]

C W D W L

FIGURE R E

A A

• P

• E

• G

F

T

F

Mean Entitlement

4.00 3.50

3.00 2.50

2.00 1.50

1.00

No. of reasons to watch

10

8

6

4

2

0

Cases weighted by Weighting Factor

R2_{Linear = 0.012}

(31)

[image:31.420.32.388.32.321.2]

FIGURE R E

O A

• A

• E

• P

F

the more likely they were to express an interest in following the rest of the campaign. T

F

4.00 3.50

3.00 2.50

2.00 1.50

1.00

No. of reasons to not watch

10

8

6

4

2

0

0 20 40 60 80 Scale

(32)

[image:32.420.33.387.33.322.2]

C W D W L

FIGURE E

I A

S

B T

I

I I

T

F

Q.8 As a result of watching the debate, have you become...?

Less interested in the campaign Neither more or less interested in

the campaign More interested in the election

campaign

2.20

2.40

2.60

2.80

3.00

3.20

3.40

(33)

[image:33.420.32.385.31.318.2]

FIGURE E K

A A

T T

T

W the more

T F

Q.7 I now know more about some of the policies that are being put forward

Disagree Agree

2.40

2.60

2.80

3.00

(34)

[image:34.420.35.386.34.295.2]

C W D W L

FIGURE C E

Mean Entitlements

4.00 3.50

3.00 2.50

2.00 1.50

1.00

Mean Charitable

4.00

3.50

3.00

2.50

2.00

1.50

1.00

0 10 20 30 40 Scale

(35)

[image:35.420.35.388.32.298.2]

FIGURE P E

O A

A B I

A A

A D E

B R

Mean Entitlements

4.00 3.50

3.00 2.50

2.00 1.50

1.00

Mean Perjorative

4.00

3.50

3.00

2.50

2.00

1.50

1.00

0 10 20 30 40 Scale

(36)

C W D W L

T

P

R

E

R

T

I

A

T

H B

A

B I B

B

W

B

H

TABLE 2.11

S T T S

A A D D

P

(37)

T F B

S

T

O

Y

B

T

C

B

P

[image:37.420.36.392.250.556.2]

A T

TABLE 2.12

P

S T

T S

D

Not in real world

S T

T

S

D

W

S

T T

S

D

S

T

S

(38)

C W D W L

W

O

B

O

W

A

C L D L UKIP

O

P

T

UKIP L L D C

O

I

F

A

T Y

I

A Y TV

F

I B

TV

I

A

(39)

F T

[image:39.420.32.386.75.194.2]

TABLE 2.13

P

P P

N A P A W

S

A

B

A

I

T

F

S R

A

W

A I

(40)

(41)

(42)

C S M D

Chapter 3 - Social Media and the Debates

Nick Anstead1

P UK

A

F T I D

T

TV C TV

H T TV

A A O L C E S B

T

P W

T

R O

UK O

O A

T

C Q F I M

I M

C

TV A

F

T

TV

3.1 Who was using social media during the TV debates?

U

O

H

(43)

T

C

C C

F P

(44)

C S M D

F P D

C Q

T UK T

W

N UK G

SNP C N

S

UK A S E E

C

L N E E

L

T

C J M T

L P L T

M

BBC N O N

(45)

F P

L C C Q E

H K I M

O F

L C

T

L

I

C P

E

R D U S

T

L L C

C B I

T

(46)

C S M D

S

T ITV A

T

I

T W

T

A O L H

C

F

A O L

T

O

BBC O A

T BBC

B F N T UK

T BBC N O

O

T C

T L P H Y E T

M TV

T

A O L T

D D U S

T TV

A T

C T

C N D T

P T

B

M W

T

I

F

S

T T

(47)

I

A

T

I

S

ITV N W T

O T

G

A

C I SNP W N F S

G T

T

ITV W T W A

T D

G

S TV

F BBC th A W

G T BBC

D C N C

C

I

C P

T

I

TV

T

(48)

C S M D

F TV

E

A

M

TV

B

T I

M A

A O L

O T

TV

T

A P D M C L S E P S

(49)

(50)

C D D S U

C

D

S

U

W W

TV H

I

I TV

I

T TV

W

H

S I

D C

O F N T

S TV US

UK M W

W

D H T T predicted that the

ITV A M DA

E S

B A

TV

W

TV

F

B O

(51)

A

B

F

A

F

G

O O

B

V

A

I

A A N A

T

ITV

I A

I

T

(52)

C D D S U T J A V

H W

T

M W

D B

D T

I O I R T

T A

ITV C

I I H I I A

A O J T G

G W D

TV F

UK EU

E

(53)

T

A

T

W

T

H

T

I L D TV

H

D BBC Q

T C

O

H L

I

TV

I

S

A F

TV

W

TV I

C

H W

UK R

S

W

(54)

C D D S U

F

S

T

B M Q G

W

T

W

Q

F

E

T

A

T

S C G M U L P

W O U A D L B P

D R C

A D R

D ITV D R

T

TV

S TV

A ITV

E M D C

A I

G E

I W

(55)

W

I

T UK T C L L D

I

TV O

W

A

B

UK E U T

TV L

O T

TV

Y T CNN US

T D

A W

W T

W

T

D R

C U

B

E U T

W

(56)

C D D S U

F

TV W

D E

I

E

D

S I

W I O

W

T T

B

T

I A

T

O

UK

E U UK

H

B

(57)

Bibliography

A L A N O L B T C T

UK G E I C S

D

A N O L B T BBC Q T T

I J P P

A N O L B S UK G E

J C M C

BBC N O A E T M R S

BBC N O M E W R

S

BBC O A H R O

B D S P C D I K K K H J E T O H

P C O OUP

B J G M Q D T P I U I L F F

B J A T T R

C J R E I R S

C A B F

P A

C N A W T R

C S L L R T P M D

O U O

C S M G R W I

J P P O

C S B S S D L A M G P N W P A

EDV P B

D R

EDV B .

C S B S S D L A M G P N W P E

EDV P B A R

EDV

C O M .

D I A G E T S T

D T R

G E T S

D J L T G F A R

E G L T N M S

F A A C R S

G N A S I

(58)

B

G E W T R O

W T

G M C S B J G O I E K P S E

T E T I I W L A SAGE

H J T T C A V B B P

H O K R N N G E L H C L

H M T M D D P N J P U P

I M A H B R S

H B

I M A R S

A

ITV N A T W E D R N

L R T T P T P L L N Y B B

M C E W T R S

E W

T

M C G S S R K J A C M T R R .

L D I M

M S M W T

that. T G R

N M C C H H U P

O A L O

P J BBC Q T T G F M

R

P H O THE FIRST GENERAL ELECTION DOMINATED BY SOCIAL MEDIA R

S

S A T I J L P B

S A B J L T R C V W D C P I A

L P

S A L ICM G M R O

T C I E UK R S E UK

T A H L D T R

W K D L M B T P O Q

(59)

Appendix

T T

I

Variable

P

E S

P

M E

Age

E

M P

G S

M C

V

R S

R

Variable

P

E S

P

M E

G

Age

S

M P

M C

(60)

A

R

Variable

P

E S

Age

M P

M E

P G S

M C

R S

B

Variable

P

E S

P

Age

E S G

R S

L

Variable

M E

P G S

Age

P R N

(61)

C

Variable

P

E S

M E

Age

S E P G

R S

P

Variable

P

E S

Age

P E G

(62)

(63)

(64)

(65)

University of Leeds Leeds, United Kingdom

T TV B

UK

I

A

TV

L B T

T

I

S D B

N C

The 2015 Televised Election Debates; Democracy on Demand?

This is a repository copy of