5HVHDUFK RQ SUREOHP VROYLQJ VNLOOV RI
RULHQWHHULQJDWKOHWHVLQWHUPVRIVRPHYDULDEOHV
Baak Arif Kaan
!"#$%%%&&
'()( (' !"*# %%+&
$EVWUDFW
-. #/ 01 %%2 13&""% #" " 4 . & 4 ! 5 5 6 4 -7"" 8 9 $:; " & - < < 8 7"" 9 $$1;. 5 " & ). 5 4 -4 9:#.##=%.0#; "- "" " - " 9">%.%#;.5-" "" " "- ". 6-" "" " ," "" " " "-.
,QWURGXFWLRQ
&4"- ?4@"-A, B"B4?4 @ACD.E9%%/; "- B " A CD. - -4"4 F4 -C D.
G " "-C $D.-4 4-7""8"
"H-I..
DOI: 10.1051/
0 0 (2016) 6310 0
2016
, shsconf/201
31
SHS Web of Conferences ERPA
9 $:/; - 4 " C 1D " F F C$D. - " 2 " 4C:D.
E x 9 $: ; "- - " " "- - - .CD.
z - " 4 - " . & " 4 - "" " " C/D. 5 - " - " " " 4 " "".G " 4 - - "- " "C*D.
7KH$LPRIWKH5HVHDUFK
& , "- -.
7KH3UREOHPRIWKH5HVHDUFK
5 4 4 - "- .
0HWKRG
#/01%%2 1 3 & "" % # " " 4 .
& 4-!55 64-7""89 $:;"&-< < 8 7"" 9 $$1; C $D. - ! 5 1# , -{ 9" - { " "" ;. ? -4 95 4 - ; * 95 - ; 4 4 . & 4 " 41, "$$.&-4 10 1 0 # / #*1%104.&4 -41 $" .& " F - F - "- . E -{ 9 "" { "" "" " "" ; 4 - " "- "" .E-{9" "" ;4 - "-"" . 5 4.::- 4 |.: .
)LQGLQJV
&4"--{ 4 4 " "" 4 }~|$./*/.0/ "" 4 }~|| .$ 0.0 "" 4 }~| %.$#0.:/ "" 4 }~|/.1 ./: { "" 4 }~| *.01#.0 """ 4}~|$. /1.*#.& "- 4 :#.## %.0#.
E &- -4 "" -{49/.%0.*#;4 "9:.11.%1;9">%.%#;.
7DEOH
--3UREOHP6ROYLQJ 1 *HQGHU ;ࡄ6' 3
5" #/
01
x G
$./#/.1
$./$:. 1 %.$:
& #/
01
x G
.*:0.0
./00.: %. *
E #/
01
x G
%.$#. .%*1.11
%.:*
#/
01
x G
/.%0.*#
:.11.%1 %.%%
!{ #/
01
x G
*. ##.00
/.00#. %. *
#/
01
x G
$.%11.:
$.*/.$# %.1
& #/
01
x G
:0.*%.##
:$.% $.$0 %. 9">%.%#;
E &- 4 , " " "" -{ 9">%.%#;. 5 4 ""-"" 9{ "; " "" { . & " -" -"4-"4 -".
7DEOH
--3UREOHP6ROYLQJ 1 0DULWDOVWDWXV ;ࡄ6' S
5" /
/1
x !
/.00/./0
1%. /.1: %.%:
& /
/1
x !
$.$1./1
.10.1* %.%%
E /
/1
x !
:.: 0.#
.:0.:# %.%
/
/1
x !
*. 0.#:
/.0$.// %.%
!{ /
/1
x !
1.0.0
*.$1#.1$ %.%%
/
/1
x !
/.0:./1
$.011./ %.%%
& /
/1
x !
/.0 :./:
:/.* $.$: %.%% 2016
9">%.%#;
E 4 -4 4 " "" -{"-9">%.%#;. 54- "" """ -{9&-1;.
7DEOH
--"3UREOHP6ROYLQJ 1 $JH ;ࡄ6' S
5" 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% 1 .$//.0 1%.$/.0 1%.$1:.: #.10./: *.00#.1* #.##*.1 %.%%1 & 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% .$0.#0 ./$0.0$ .**0.% $./*1.1 :.11.# $.01.0: %.%% E 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% . $0./ .#.: %.%*1.#$ /.:0.* /..// /.$#1.:: %.%% 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% /.:#1.%0 /.# ./# /.*1.* *.#1 .$0 *.##.1# *.# .:: %.# !{ 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% /.$0.:0 *.*/#.# *.1#.#$ 0./*0.$: 0#./0 0./##.0$ %. 1 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% $.:#0.$# $.#$1. 1 :./11.10 /./*.* /.::.1 :. 1.*$ %. * & 0 :* 1% 1 $ % #{ / :{% {1 0{* /{$ "1% $./ /. $ :$.%:%.1 :0.$%.: / .$ 0.$0 /%.00 /.1: / $. :
%.%%
9">%.%#;
- " " ""--- "9&-0.;
7DEOH
--," "3UREOHP6ROYLQJ 1 6SRUWDJHVLQRULHQWHHULQJ ;ࡄ6' S
5" 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ 1%.:0/.*$ /.#//.1* /.:##.: %.% & 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ .:10.#* %.:1.* $.#1.: %.%% E 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ .//0./1 $.00.%# $.1:#.0* %.%% 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ /.*.$ /.%.0/ *.0 .11 %.%* !{ 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ /.##.# 0.$01.$0 0./*#./: %.% 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ $.#11.: $.%#1.*/ /.$ .#: %.%* & 1 1# 10 {1 0{* "/ :$.:/%.%# /:.: //: /#.:# $.: %.%% (*p<0.05) E&-#"-4 { , E&-#"-4; E&-#"-4; { " "" -{9">%.%#;. 5 4 "" -{ { { " "" -{ . & "- - " " 4"44 "4{.
7DEOH
---3UREOHP6ROYLQJ 1 6WDWXVRIEHLQJQDWLRQDOSOD\HU ;ࡄ6' S
5" 0% *% " " :.*./* 1%. #/.* %. 1 & 0% *% " " %.%/1./* .1/0.00 %.%% E 0% *% " " $.0.* .1$0.$ %.% 0% *% " " *.0. /.#1.:/ %.%
!{ 0%
5HVXOWVDQG'LVFXVVLRQ
G - 4 4 "-4}~|:#.##. 5 - 4 "- - , ."4 4 - 4 . G 4 - " "" "- - 4 . & -{4"-44".5 8-9%%$; - 4 9}~|:1.: ; C :D. 8 () 9%%*; "- - " 4 9}~|:0.#1; 9}~|:.$#;C*D" .54-.9%%:; , 9}~|$%.*:; C#D. 5 - 8 9% ; , E 9% 1; -, E.9% %; , 4 , " "--C * 1D.
5 4 "" -{.54- 8< 9%%*;"--" "4"4 -89% ;8-9%%$;47""89 $:; " "- - " " C 0 * : D.-8 9% ;) 9% ; ? 9% %; ) 8 - 9%%*; 4 8 9%%0; 4 "- C /1 %0#D. & -4 4 - " .
5 4 - " "- -" " "-"" . 8 9%%0; ," " " "- -C#D. "-C:D.
E " ," "" . ) 9% ; " " C1D. 7 "" -{4.74 E- 9% ; 4 " - " C0D .9% %;4 8<9%%*;4--"C/ 0D8 -9%%$; C :D4 4 "-.
4-4"---""," -?(9%%:;C D.
5 4"" "--" "".58-9%%$;4-.9%%$;C : #D 4-4-"-.
& ," - "- - " ". E ," " " -" -" -" -". 5 -" -," " { "" 4 "- ". 6 " 4 "- 4 " "" """ .
5HIHUHQFHV
. E . 6- "- ) - &) ! ! ((&(.9% 1;.
. E . . "- . -. 9%%/;
1. E x ? 7. 8 & . , "- " 4 -. z E ! !" ! x 7H*1#*1:9% %;.
0.E-E..E"- "-) - -)- &)?) ((E&(.9% ;.
#.7.!.&.8').!"" "-) - . !"9 ;H*{//.9%%:;.
*. ) . ?. 6. ' z. ?( +. E. 8 E E. ((E2'E.9% ;.
/. ", HC#%%% D.E8 -3.3.9%%*;.
:x.)(6.8"<.-"-) () -. !" !" *9;0${#:9%%:;.
$. x. 8 E '. "2H ?{{. E 'E.9 $$*;.
%. ? !. . " - "- ) - . -19; 1#{ 0/9% %;.
.?(.6()- " "- ) - . '( 3 &) ! (( E &(. 9%%:;.
. 7"" . . 8 . 7. & " 5" -!5. .$9 ;**{/#.9 $:;. 2016
1. 7"" . . 8 " . . E {" "" " "-.& #91;1/ {00/9 $:/;.
0. ?. 8 < . E " -- " "-)- -.!"!" 09 ;#{ %.9%%*;.
#. - .z. . 8 E. -(( "- ) - 9E?);.!" 191;/{/$.9%%$;.
*. - . z. 8 E. ? ) ( "-)- .!" !"$9;/ {:%.9% ;.
/.-.z.8 7.' "-) - - 9 ;. E 6( 9 ;/{1:.9% ;.
" ( "- ) - - .?)6($9;00 {0#:9%%$;. $. x . . & "- . 9 ;. 4 'H G. 7.
6".9 $$;.
%. x &. 2 ? -. . E 7. EH 7 " 2(('H ./19 $: ;.
.)E.x.8&..!"-H#" 4{ -4'.!"-"H0.9%%/;.
.z, z,.9%%1;
1. ) !. () )) 6 - " ( "- ) - () . '( 3 &) 6 !(()&(..9% ;.
0. ) ?. 8 - x. "-)- $.!"91 #;x$#/{$#$.9%%*;.
#. . 8 6. - "- ) - . !" !"9;##{*%.9%%0;.
*. . 8 () . 6- ( "- ) - . $. !" 91# ; x*11{*1/.9%%*;.
/.E.-.z.8)E.5"- 1{ # -- " -. z E E !"F! x E 7 ! %9 !"".;0%*{0 0.9% %;.
:.!.?H.?)-. E.9%%#;.