• No results found

Brookes equation: The basis for a qualitative characterization of information behaviours

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2019

Share "Brookes equation: The basis for a qualitative characterization of information behaviours"

Copied!
11
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

City, University of London Institutional Repository

Citation

:

Bawden, D. (2011). Brookes equation: The basis for a qualitative

characterization of information behaviours. Journal of Information Science, 37(1), pp. 101-108. doi: 10.1177/0165551510395351

This is the unspecified version of the paper.

This version of the publication may differ from the final published

version.

Permanent repository link: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/3130/

Link to published version

:

http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0165551510395351

Copyright and reuse:

City Research Online aims to make research

outputs of City, University of London available to a wider audience.

Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the author(s) and/or copyright

holders. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and

linked to.

(2)

Brookes equation: the basis for a

qualitative characterisation of

information behaviours

!"#$%&!'#(&)*!!

Department of Information Science, City University London, UK

!

+,-./#0.!

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

-4::#/%-%*7!%*81/:#.%1*!,)6#$%14/5!#*&!188)/!.6)!"#$$%&%'%()!#*!&+%,-!.+/+'#"+.!%,(#!0#1+!$#"2%$(%34(+.!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+!

(1+4(0+,($7!

!!

8+)9#1.$:!;1##<+$!+564(%#,=!3#-,%(%/+!"414.%-0=!"#9+1!'49$=!0+,(4'!04"$=!%,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#61!

B>

!?*./1&40.%1*!

>,!?@ABC!;+1(140!;1##<+$!*%,4'%$+.!4!'%,+!#*!1+$+4132!92%32!2+!24.!*#''#9+.!*#1!$+/+14'!)+41$C!&)!"6&'%$2%,-C! %,! 4! "4"+1! %,!Journal of Information ScienceC! 924(! 2+! .+$31%&+.! 4$! D(2+! *6,.40+,(4'! +564(%#,! #*! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+D!E?F7!G2%$!+564(%#,C!92%32!2+!24.!"6(!*#1941.!%,!/41%#6$!*#10$C!94$!2+1+!"1+$+,(+.!4$:!

!

8!HIJ!K!!>!L!8!HI!K!!IJ!!! !

M! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+C! 8! HIJ! %$! 324,-+.! %,(#! 4,! 4'(+1+.! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+! 8! HI! K!!IJ! &)! 4,! %,"6(! #*! %,*#104(%#,C!!>7!!I! %$! 4,! %,.%34(#1! #*! (2+! +**+3(! #*! (2+! 0#.%*%34(%#,7! G2+! $40+! %,*#104(%#,! 04)! 24/+! .%**+1+,(! +**+3($!#,!.%**+1+,(!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$7!>(!%$!4!.+$31%"(%#,!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!3#006,%34(%#,!"1#3+$$!4$!%(!4**+3($! #,+! %,.%/%.64'D$! <,#9'+.-+C! 4,.! 2+,3+! %$! 1+-41.+.! 4$! 4! *#6,.4(%#,! #*! (2+! 3#-,%(%/+! "414.%-0! %,! %,*#104(%#,!

!

(3)

$3%+,3+!EPC!\C!]C!WF7!^#'+!6$+.!%(!4$!4!_&4$+'%,+_!*#1!4!3#,$%.+14(%#,!#*!4!$6&[+3(%/%$(!3#,$(163(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,! EVFC!92%'+!>,-9+1$+,!H?@@PJ!.+1%/+.!+`(+,.+.!/+1$%#,$!#*!(2+!+564(%#,!ETF7!

;1##<+$!2%0$+'*C!4,.!,60+1#6$!46(2#1$!$6&$+56+,(')C!24/+!"#%,(+.!#6(!(24(!(2%$!%$!,#(!4,!+564(%#,!%,!(2+!6$64'! 04(2+04(%34'! $+,$+=! G#..! EAF! 4,.! ^#1,+'%6$! E@FC! %,! 1+/%+9%,-! (2+! /4'6+! 4,.! 4""'%34&%'%()! #*! (2+! +564(%#,C! -%/+! 433#6,($!#*!(2+$+!/%+9"#%,($7!G2+!+564(%#,!4$!"1+$+,(+.!-%/+$!6$!,#!94)!#*!564,(%*)%,-!(2+!40#6,(!#*!%,*#104(%#,! #*!<,#9'+.-+!%,!8!HIJC!,#1!4,)!94)!#*!.+1%/%,-!(2+!.%**+1+,3+!Q!564'%(4(%/+!#1!564,(%(4(%/+!a!&+(9++,!%(!4,.!8!HI!K! !IJC! 4'(2#6-2! ^#'+! 24$! $2#9,! #,+! 94)! %,! 92%32! (2%$! 0%-2(! &+! .#,+! E?BF7! ! ;1##<+$! 43<,#9'+.-+.! (24(! %(! 94$! "$+6.#a04(2+04(%34'!4,.!#/+1a$%0"'+C!4,.!(24(!%($!(+10$!4,.!$)0&#'$!9+1+!6,.+*%,+.7!b+%''!E??C!"7!\VF!$6--+$(+.! (24(![6$(!(2+!6,.+*%,+.!_K_!$%-,!_3#,(4%,+.!4,!+,(%1+!.%$3%"'%,+_!!

!

R+$"%(+!(2%$!'43<!#*!+564(%#,a,+$$!4&#6(!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,C!%(!24$!&++,!#*(+,!56#(+.!4$!4!564'%(4(%/+!$60041)! #*! 4! 3+,(14'! %$$6+! 9%(2%,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+$=! (2+! G2#0$#,! >I>! .4(4&4$+$! %,! 0%.aPB?B! $2#9+.! (2+! "4"+1! 24/%,-!&++,!3%(+.!#/+1!?BB!(%0+$7!M$!^#1,+'%6$!$4)$!_>(!04)!24/+!&++,!6,#"+14(%#,4'!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$)$(+0$C!&6(! %(! 24$! 1+04%,+.! #"+14(%#,4'! 4$! 4! -+,+14'! 3#,$%.+14(%#,C! +/+,! %*! ,#(! %,! +`"+1%0+,(4'! .+$%-,C! 9%(2%,! %,*#104(%#,! 1+(1%+/4'!(2+#1)!4,.!9%(2%,!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+D$!(2+#1%c%,-!#*!%,*#104(%#,_!E@C!"!]BTF7!!>(!24$!4'$#!&++,!4""'%+.!(#! 4! /+1)! '%0%(+.! .+-1++! %,! "143(%3+:! 564'%(4(%/+')C! 4$! 4! *140+9#1<! *#1! (2+! $(6.)! #*! -+,+14'! "6&'%3! %,*#104(%#,! 6(%'%c4(%#,!*#1!2+4'(2!%,*#104(%#,!EAC!?PFC!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+')!%,!4!$(6.)!#*!41324+#'#-%34'!1+$+4132!E?BF7!d#9+/+1C! _*#1! (2+! 0#$(! "41(e! (2+! +564(%#,! 1+04%,$! 4$! 4! 14(2+1! 1+"1#432*6'! 1+0%,.+1! #*! 2#9! *41! 9+! 41+! *1#0! *6'*%''%,-! ;1##<+$D!1+$+4132!"1#-1400+_!E?\C!"!]?@F7!

>(!$++0$!(2+1+*#1+!(24(!%(!04)!&+!9#1(2!+`40%,%,-!(2+!+564(%#,!*61(2+1C!(#!$++!%*C!&)!04<%,-!$#0+C!2#"+*6'')! 1+4$#,4&'+C!4$$60"(%#,$C!%(!04)!&+!"#$$%&'+!(#!-#!&+)#,.!(2+!/+1)!'%0%(+.C!4'0#$(!"%3(#1%4'C!6$+!#*!(2+!+564(%#,! 92%32! 24$! &++,! (2+! ,#107! I"+3%*%34'')C! (2+! "61"#$+! 9%''! &+! (#! $++! %*! (2+! +564(%#,C! (26$! 0#.%*%+.C! 9%''! )%+'.! 4! $+,$%&'+!4,.!1+4'%$(%3!564'%(4(%/+!"%3(61+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!(14,$*+17!>*!$#C!(2%$!9#6'.!$6--+$(!(24(!*61(2+1!$(6.%+$!0%-2(! #**+1!(2+!"1#$"+3(!#*!564,(%(4(%/+!$(6.)7!

f%1$(C! %,! "41(! P! #*! (2+! "4"+1C!9+! $24''! +`40%,+! (2+!!>! (+10! %,! (2+! +564(%#,C! (2+! %,*#104(%#,C! #1!<,#9'+.-+C! %,"6(7! G2+,C! %,! "41(! \C! 9+! $24''! +`40%,+!!IC! (2+! 324,-+!%,! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7!g+! 9%''! 3#,$%.+1! 92+(2+1! (2+! +564(%#,! 34,! 2+'"! (#! -%/+! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 6,.+1$(4,.%,-! #*!what kind #*! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! %$! #33611%,-! %,! 4,)! "41(%36'41! 34$+C! 4,.!what kind #*! 324,-+! %,! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+! %,! #33611%,-7! >,! "41(! ]C! 9+! $24''! 3#0&%,+! (2+$+C!(#!-%/+!4!564'%(4(%/+!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!(2+!324,-+!.+$31%&+.!&)!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!

C>

!

?D!#!-:#;;!,%.!18!2*1(;)&7)!

!

;1##<+$!!.+$31%&+.!(2%$!(+10!%,!(2+!+564(%#,!4$!1+"1+$+,(+.!4,!%,"6(!#*!_4!$04''!&%(!#*!<,#9'+.-+_!E?C!"!?\?F=! 2#9+/+1C! 2+!"1+*+11+.! (#! (+10! %(! %,*#104(%#,C! (#! 04<+! (2+! "#%,(! (24(! (2%$! 24.! 4,! #&[+3(%/+! 564'%()C! 4'&+%(! (24(! %(! 0%-2(!346$+!.%**+1+,(!+**+3($!#,!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!#*!.%**+1+,(!%,.%/%.64'$7!

;1##<+$! "1+$604&'+! 6$+.! (2+! 9#1.! D&%(D! %,! %($! %,*#104'! 0+4,%,-=! &6(! 9+! 3#6'.C! #*! 3#61$+C! 564,(%*)! 4,)! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! %,! (+10$! #*! &%($C! %,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! (2+#1+(%3! $+,$+7! G2%$! 9#6'.! ,#(C! 2#9+/+1C! 2+'"! %,! 6,.+1$(4,.%,-!924(!<%,.#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!%(!%$7!!

G#!&+-%,!(#!.#!$#C!9+!9%''!(1+4(!!>!,#(!4$!4!,60&+1C!&6(!4$!4!*6,3(%#,7!g+!.#!,#(!<,#9C!a prioriC!924(!(2%$! *6,3(%#,!%$=!,#(!+/+,!%($!-+,+14'!,4(61+7!;6(!9+!04)!(4<+!4,!+.634(+.!-6+$$!(24(!(2+!0#$(!'%<+')!*#10!#*!$632!4! *6,3(%#,!9#6'.!&+!(24(!#*!4!power law7!G2%$!$++0$!'%<+')C!$%0"')!&+346$+!"#9+1!'49$!41+!/+1)!3#00#,')!*#6,.!%,! 04,)!4$"+3($!#*!(2+!&%#'#-%34'!4,.!$#3%4'!.#04%,$=!%(!%$!.%**%36'(!(#!$++!4,)!14(%#,4'+!*#1!32##$%,-!4,)!#(2+1!*#10! #*! *6,3(%#,7! g%(2%,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+$C! (2+)! 41+! +,3#6,(+1+.! 4$! 14,<a*1+56+,3)! *6,3(%#,$C! $632! 4$! h%"*D$! i49!4,.!Z41+(#D$!i49C!4,.!4$!$%c+a*1+56+,3)!*6,3(%#,$C!$632!4$!i#(<4D$!i49!E?]F7!!!!

G2+$+!(4<+!(2+!-+,+14'!*#10!! ! ! )!L!4!`$!

!

(4)

David Bawden

92+1+!4!%$!4!3#,$(4,(!4,.!$!%$!(2+!+`"#,+,(!#*!(2+!*6,3(%#,7! G2%$!1+$6'($!%,!4!$+1%+$!92+1+!(2+!/4'6+!*#1!(2+!<(2!+'+0+,(!%$!

!

! ! ?U<$!

! ! aaaaaaa!

! ! "!?U,<! !

(2+!.+,#0%,4(#1!&+%,-!$600+.!#/+1!4''!(2+!(+10$!#*!(2+!$+1%+$7!

I%,3+! 9+! 41+! %,(+1+$(+.! #,')! %,! 564'%(4(%/+! "4((+1,$C! 14(2+1! (24,! ,60+1%3! 564,(%(%+$C! 9+! 04)! %-,#1+! (2+! .+,#0%,4(#1C!$%,3+!%(!%$!(2+!$40+!*#1!4''!+'+0+,($!#*!(2+!$+1%+$7!!

>,!(2%$!34$+C!(2+!$+1%+$!"1#.63+.!&)!$632!4!*6,3(%#,!9#6'.!1+"1+$+,(!(2+!3#,(1%&6(%#,!#*!+432!#*!$633+$$%/+! %,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!%*!(2+1+!9+1+!0#1+!(24,!#,+C!(#!(2+!324,-%,-!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!M$!9+!41+!*%((%,-!(2%$! 9%(2%,!(2+!3#,(+`(!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!D3#,(1%&6(%#,D!.#+$!,#(!0+4,!%,*#104(%#,!3#,(+,(!0+4$61+.!%,!&%($!Q!(24(! 3#6'.!&+!4$$+$$+.!$+"414(+')!Q!&6(!14(2+1!(2+!+`(+,(!(#!92%32!+432!%,"6(!&1%,-$!4&#6(!(2+!324,-+7!G2%$!4''#9$!*#1! "#$$%&%'%()!(24(!(2+1+!04)!&+!$+/+14'!.%$31+(+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!&1%,-%,-!4&#6(!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!324,-+7! >,.++.C!;1##<+$!$"+3%*%34'')!4''#9+.!*#1!(2%$!E?WC!AF!%,!4,!+41')!/41%4,(!#*!2%$!+564(%#,C!$2#9%,-!$633+$$%/+!%,"6($:!

!

>?!K!HIJB!!!!HIJ?!

>P!K!HIJ?!!!!HIJP!

4,.!$#!#,7! !

>*!9+! <,+9! (2+! /4'6+!#*! (2+!+`"#,+,(! $Q!92%32!9+!.#!,#(!Q! 9+! 3#6'.!.%1+3(')! 34'36'4(+! (2%$! 3#,(1%&6(%#,7! Y4(2+1C! 9+! 9%''! 3#,$%.+1! 924(! "4((+1,$! +0+1-+! *1#0! /41)%,-! (2+! #*! /4'6+$! #*! $C! 6$%,-! (2+! $%0"'+$(! *#10! #*! (2+! $+1%+$C!9%(2!/4'6+$!?!U!<$C!4,.!,#(%,-!(24(!*#1!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,($!!

4a0!L!?!U!40!

4,.!(24(!!

! ! 4B!L!?!

G2+!/4'6+!#*!(2+!+`"#,+,(!04)!14,-+C!%,!"1%,3%"'+C!*1#0!"'6$!%,*%,%()!(#!0%,6$!%,*%,%()7!>,!#1.+1!(#!$++!(2+! #/+14''!"4((+1,C!%,!(2+!$%0"'+$(!94)C!9+!(4<+!%($!/4'6+!(#!&+:!!

" '41-+!4,.!"#$%(%/+C!$4)!?BB!

" $04''!4,.!"#$%(%/+C!$4)!P!

" c+1#!

" $04''!4,.!,+-4(%/+C!$4)!aP!

" '41-+!4,.!,+-4(%/+C!$4)!?BB!

g1%(%,-!#6(!(2+!*%1$(!*%/+!(+10$!#*!(2+!$+1%+$!%,!+432!34$+C!%,!*43(%#,4'!+`"#,+,(%4'!*#10C!9+!34,!$++!(2+!"4((+1,! 9%(2#6(!,++.%,-!(#!34'36'4(+!4!,60+1%34'!/4'6+7!

!

2

!

!

!

!

!

!

?BB!

?!

?UP

?BB!

?U\

?BB!

?U]

?BB!

?UW

?BB!

P!

?!

?UP

P!

?U\

P!

?U]

P!

?UW

P!

B!

?!

?!

?!

?!

?!

aP!

?!

P

P!

\

P!

]

P!

W

P!

a?BB!

?!

P

?BB!

\

?BB!

]

?BB!

W

?BB!

!

(5)

Z#$%(%/+C!,+-4(%/+!4,.!c+1#!+`"#,+,($!1+$6'(!%,!$+1%+$!*#1!92%32!(2+!/4'6+$!1+$"+3(%/+')!.+31+4$+C!%,31+4$+!4,.! 1+04%,!3#,$(4,(C!4$!(2+!+'+0+,(!,60&+1!%,31+4$+$7!!

M(!2%-2!4&$#'6(+!/4'6+$!#*!<C!(2+!D/4'6+D!#*!(2+!$+1%+$!%$!3#,3+,(14(+.!%,!(2+!*%1$(!4,.!'4$(!+'+0+,($!1+$"+3(%/+')C! 92%'+!4(!'#9!4&$#'6(+!/4'6+$!(2+1+!%$!4!$0##(2+1!(14,$%(%#,7!f#1!+`40"'+C!9%(2!4!/4'6+!#*!<LPC!(2+!$+1%+$!(4<+$!(2+! /4'6+$!!

?C!?!U!]C!?!U!@C!?!U!?V!e77!

3#11+$"#,.%,-!(#!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!9%(2!/4'6+$! ?C!B7PWC!B7??C!B7BV!e7!

G2%$!/+1)!$%0"')!4""'%34(%#,!#*!4!"#9+1!'49!*6,3(%#,!9%(2%,!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,!$6--+$($!*%/+!04%,!34(+-#1%+$! #*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!92%32!41+!-%/+,!(2+!'4&+'$!%?a%W:!

%B!Q!'41-+!"#$%(%/+!+`"#,+,(!

$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!4(!$(41(!#*!$+1%+$!

%C!Q!$04''!"#$%(%/+!+`"#,+,(!

$+56+,(%4'!.+31+4$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!

%E!Q!c+1#!+`"#,+,(!

$+56+,(%4'!+564'!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!

%F!Q!$04''!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,(!

$+56+,(%4'!%,31+4$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!

%G!Q!'41-+!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,(!

$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!4(!+,.!#*!$+1%+$!

>(!$2#6'.!&+!+0"24$%$+.!2+1+!(24(!(2+!D$%c+D!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!%$!,#(!0+4$61+.!#&[+3(%/+')!%,!&%($=!(24(! 3#6'.! &+! .#,+C! &6(! %$! 4! $+"414(+! %$$6+7! g+! 41+! 0+4$61%,-! $%c+! 2+1+C! %,! (2+! ;1##<+$D! +564(%#,! 3#,(+`(C! &)! (2+! 3#-,%(%/+!%0"43(!#,!(2+!1+3%"%+,(7!

G2+$+! *%/+! 34(+-#1%+$! 41+! ,#(C! #*! 3#61$+C! 4&$#'6(+7! d#9+/+1C! %(! %$! 3'+41! (24(! #,')! 4! $04''! %,31+4$+! %,! (2+! 4&$#'6(+!/4'6+!#*!(2+!+`"#,+,(!1+$6'($!%,!4!564'%(4(%/+!%B!#1!%G!34(+-#1%$4(%#,7!G2+1+!%$!'%(('+!$3#"+!*#1!4..%,-!+`(14! D(14,$%(%#,4'D!34(+-#1%+$C!92%32!$6--+$($!(24(!(2+$+!*%/+!34(+-#1%+$!41+!4!,4(614'!3#,$+56+,3+!#*!4""')%,-!4!"#9+1! '49!*6,3(%#,!9%(2%,!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!

G2+!$+1%+$!24/+!&++,!"1+$+,(+.!%,!(2+!6$64'!#1.+1+.!*#10C!&6(!Q!(2%,<%,-!-+,+14'')!Q!(2+1+!%$!,#!1+4$#,!92)! (2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!#*!$+1%+$!$2#6'.!&+!"+13+%/+.!%,!(2%$!94)!&)!(2+!1+3%"%+,(7!M,)!*#10!#*!#1.+1!%$C!%,!"1%,3%"'+C! "#$$%&'+=!9+!9%''!3#,$%.+1!#,')!(2+!#,+!92%32!%$!0#$(!.%$(%,3(!*1#0!(2+!#1.+1+.!$+1%+$C!(24(!%,!92%32!(2+!+,(1%+$!41+! 14,.#0%$+.7!!

Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%E!04<+$!,#!.%**+1+,3+!(#!(2+!"4((+1,C!$%,3+!(2+!+,(1%+$!41+!+564'!%,!04-,%(6.+7! Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%C!#1!%F!-%/+$!4!,+9!"4((+1,=!4!$+1%+$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!9%(2!$%-,%*%34,(!/4'6+! 411%/%,-!%,!14,.#0!#1.+17!

Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%B!#1!%G!4'$#!-%/+$!4!,+9!"4((+1,:!4!$%,-'+!$%-,%*%34,(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!411%/%,-! 14,.#0')!40#,-!%,"6($!#*!,#!/4'6+7!!

g+!.+,#(+!(2+$+!4$!(9#!,+9!34(+-#1%+$:!

%H!Q!$04''!+`"#,+,(C!$+1%+$!14,.#0%$+.! 14,.#0')!4114,-+.!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!

%I!Q!'41-+!+`"#,+,(C!$+1%+$!14,.#0%$+.! $%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!14,.#0')!"#$%(%#,+.!

!

(6)

David Bawden

g+!,#9!(#!3#,$%.+1!&#(2!(2+!/4'%.%()!4,.!(2+!,+3+$$%()!#*!(2+$+!1+$6'($7!R#!(2+$+!$+/+,!34(+-#1%+$!04(32!#61! <,#9'+.-+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!433+$$C!4,.!41+!(2+$+!0#.+$!#*!433+$$!92%32!(2+)!.#!,#(!34"(61+j!M,.!%$!%(!,+3+$$41)!(#! 6$+!(2%$!*#104'%$0!(#!.+1%/+!(2%$!34(+-#1%$4(%#,j!

^#,$%.+1%,-!(2+!34(+-#1%+$!%,!(61,C!(2+!"4((+1,$!#*!!%C!4,.!%F!41+!&#(2!324143(+1%$(%3!#*!search7!G2+!.%$(%,3(%#,! '%+$! %,! (2+! 3#-,%(%/+! 4$"+3($7!%CC! 9%(2! %($! .+31+4$%,-! %,"6($! #*! %,*#104(%#,C! 04)! &+! 1+-41.+.! 4$! 4!01*8%/:#.1/@! -)#/06=! (2+!*%1$(! %,"6(!-%/+$!0#$(! #*! (2+! %,*#104(%#,C! 9%(2! $6&$+56+,(! %,"6($! 4..%,-! 3#11+$"#,.%,-')! '+$$7!%F!%$! &+$(! .+$31%&+.! 4$! 4!! 01*-1;%&#.%*7! -)#/06C! "+124"$! %,! 4! 41+4! #*! <,#9'+.-+! ,+9! (#! (2+! $+4132+1=! 4$! 0#1+! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6($! 41+! 4..+.C! (2+)! &+3#0+! #*! %,31+4$%,-! /4'6+C! 4$! (2+)! 34,! &+! %,(+-14(+.! 9%(2! (2+! .+/+'#"%,-! <,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!

%B!34,!4'$#!&+!$++,!4$!4!*#10!#*!$+4132C!4!"41(%36'41')!+**+3(%/+!#,+C!92%32!"1#/%.+$!(2+!*6''!%,*#104(%#,!%,!(2+! *%1$(!%,"6(=!%(!%$!()"%34'!#*!4!/)8)/)*0)C!#1!2*1(*9%.):C!$+4132C!$4(%$*%+.!&)!4!$%,-'+!%,"6(7!!

G2+!14,.#0')!411%/%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!#*!%H!$++0!324143(+1%$(%3!#*!,/1(-%*7C!#*!(2+!"61"#$%/+!#1!.%1+3(+.! /41%+()7!

%IC! 9%(2! %($! $%,-'+! %$#'4(+.! 14,.#0')! 411%/%,-! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! .+,#(+$! (2+! <%,.! #*! %,*#104(%#,! 433+$$! .+$31%&+.!4$!#00%&)*.#;C!-)/)*&%<%.14- #1!)*014*.)/%*77!!

?GC!%,!92%32!(2+!$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!411%/+$!4(!(2+!+,.!#*!4!$+1%+$!#*!,+-'%-%&'+!%,"6($C!%$!&+$(!(2#6-2(!#*!4$! (2+!)4/)2#!$%(64(%#,C!(2+!+41'%+1!%,"6($!24/%,-!"1+"41+.!(2+!3#-,%(%/+!$(163(61+!*#1!(2+!%,,#/4(%/+!'+4"7!

f%,4'')C! (2+! "4((+1,! #*!%E!1+*'+3($! 4!:1*%.1/%*7!$%(64(%#,C! 9%(2! 4! $+1%+$! #*! %,"6($! #*! +56%/4'+,(! /4'6+=! 0#$(! '%<+')!$#0+!1#6(%,+!#1!3#0"414(%/+!433+$$7!

>(! $++0$C! (2+1+*#1+C! (24(! 4''! #*! (2+$+! "4((+1,$! 34,! &+! +564(+.! (#! 3'+41')! 6,.+1$(##.! "4((+1,$! #*! %,*#104(%#,! 433+$$7! G2+)! +,3#0"4$$! $+4132%,-C! %,! %($! "1+3%$+! 4,.! 0#1+! -+,+14'! *#10$C! &1#9$%,-! 4,.! 433%.+,(4'! .%$3#/+1)C! 31+4(%/+!%,,#/4(%#,C!4,.!1#6(%,+!%,*#104(%#,!0#,%(#1%,-=!4!3#0"1+2+,$%/+!3#/+14-+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!433+$$!*1#0!4! 3#-,%(%/+!"+1$"+3(%/+7!

g2%'+C! 4$! ,#(+.! &)! (2+! 1+*+1+,3+$! 4&#/+C! $+/+14'! #*! (2+$+! "4((+1,$! 24/+! &++,! .+$31%&+.! %,! (2+! '%(+14(61+! #*! %,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#61!4,.!6$+C!(2%$!3#0"1+2+,$%/+!$+(!#*!"4((+1,$!24$!,+/+1!&++,!$+(!#6(7!G2%$![6$(%*%+$!(2+!/4'6+! #*!(2%$!+`(+,$%#,!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!

>(!9%''!&+!,#(+.!(24(!(2%$!(1+4(0+,(!.#+$!,#(!%,3'6.+!(2+!$%(64(%#,!92+1+!,#!%,*#104(%#,!4(!4''!%$!4356%1+.!%,!4,)! 94)7!G2%$!%$!1+4$#,4&'+!4,.!4""1#"1%4(+C!$%,3+!(2+!+564(%#,!1+'4(+$!#,')!(#!(2#$+!$%(64(%#,$!92+1+!(2+1+!%-!$#0+! %,*#104(%#,C!24/%,-!$#0+!+**+3(7!!

E>

!

JD!#!017*%.%$)!:#<!

G2+!!I! (+10! %,! ;1##<+$! +564(%#,! 1+"1+$+,($! 4,! %,(+1,4'C! 3#-,%(%/+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! ! M$! 9%(2! #61! (1+4(0+,(!#*!(2+!!>!(+10C!9+!9%''!04<+!$#0+!0%,%04'!4$$60"(%#,$C!4,.!$++!92+1+!(2+)!'+4.7!

;1##<+$!94$!6,$"+3%*%3!4&#6(!2#9!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!9+1+!(#!&+!1+"1+$+,(+.C!#(2+1!(24,!.+$31%&%,-!(2+0! -+,+14'')!4$!3#-,%(%/+!04"$7!M!/+1)!3#00#,!94)!#*!.+4'%,-!9%(2!(2%$!%$$6+!%,!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+$!24$!&++,! (#!4.#"(!(2+!%.+4!#*!4!0+,(4'!04"!#1!0+,(4'!0#.+'C!(#!.+$31%&+!4,!%,(+1,4'!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+=!4!*+9!+`40"'+$! ()"%*)!(2%$!4""1#432!E?VC!?TC!?AC!?@C!PBF7!G2%$!%$!0#$(!3#00#,')!4,!4114,-+0+,(C!0#1+!#1!'+$$!3#0"'+`!433#1.%,-! (#!,++.C!#*!3#,3+"($![#%,+.!&)!1+'4(%#,$2%"!'%,<$7!G2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!3#,3+"($!4,.!#*!(2+!'%,<$!04)!&+!.+$31%&+.!%,! /41)%,-! .+-1++$! #*! .+(4%'C! 4,.! (2+! $(1+,-(2! #*C! #1! 3#,*%.+,3+! %,C! &#(2! 3#,3+"($! 4,.! '%,<$! 04)! #1! 04)! ,#(! &+! 4$$+$$+.7!

>*! 9+! (4<+! (2+! $%0"'+$(! "#$$%&'+! *#10! #*! (2%$! 1+"1+$+,(4(%#,! Q! 4,.! 9+! 24/+! ,#!a priori 1+4$#,! *#1! .#%,-! #(2+19%$+!a!9+!34,!$++!(24(!(2+1+!41+!(21++!-+,+14'!94)$!%,!92%32!%(!04)!&+!324,-+.C!92%32!9+!'4&+'C!%,!4!$%0%'41! 94)!(#!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!!4$!-BC!-C!4,.!-E7!

-B!! (2+!"4((+1,!#*!3#,3+"($!4,.!'%,<$!%$!6,324,-+.C!(2#6-2!(2+!$(1+,-(2!#*!4,)!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!04)!&+! %,31+4$+.!#1!.+31+4$+.!

!

(7)

-C!! 4(!'+4$(!#,+!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!%$!4..+.C!&6(!,#,+!%$!1+0#/+.=!-B!04)!4'$#!#3361!

-E!! 4(!'+4$(!#,+!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!%$!1+0#/+.=!-B!4,.U#1!-C!04)!4'$#!#3361!!

-BC!92%32!9+!9%''!34''!4!01*8%&)*0)!324,-+C!%0"'%+$!(24(!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!24$!%,31+4$+.!#1!.+31+4$+.!(2+! $(1+,-(2!#*!$#0+!"41(!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!>,!%,3'6.%,-!(2%$!"#$$%&%'%()!9+!*#''#9!;1##<+$!E?F!92#!41-6+.! (24(!(2+!!324,-+!%$!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!04)!,#(!&+!4..%(%/+C!&6(!0%-2(!%,/#'/+!4!324,-+!#*!$(163(61+7!^#'+!EVFC!%,! 4.#"(%,-!;1##<+$!+564(%#,!4$!"41(!#*!4!#"+14(%#,4'%c4(%#,!#*!(2+!3#,3+"(!#*!%,*#104(%#,C!%,$%$(+.!(24(!(2+!324,-+! 06$(!&+!4!324,-+!#*!$(163(61+C!4,.!(24(!(2+!324,-+!92%32!9+!34''!-B!%$!&+((+1!1+-41.+.!4$!D3#,*#10%,-D!%,"6(!#1! .4(47!>,!(2+!%,(+1+$($!#*!-+,+14'%()C!9+!9%''!$(%3<!9%(2!;1##<+$D!%.+47!

-CC! 92%32!9+! 9%''! 34''! 4,!)=<#*-%1*!324,-+C! .+,#(+$! 4,! %,31+4$+! %,! (2+!+`(+,(! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+C! 9%(2!,+9!3#,3+"($!#1!'%,<$!&+%,-!4..+.!4$!4!1+$6'(!#*!%,"6(!%,*#104(%#,!

-EC! 92%32! 9+! 9%''! 34''! 4!&%-/4<.%$)!324,-+C! .+,#(+$! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 324,-+! %,! (2+! "4((+1,! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7!

>(!9#6'.!&+!"#$$%&'+!(#!-%/+!4!0#1+!.+(4%'+.!#1!$#"2%$(%34(+.!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!324,-+$!#*!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+C! &6(!4,)!$632!9#6'.!&+!.+"+,.+,(!#,!(2+!,4(61+!#*!$#0+!"41(%36'41!0+,(4'!04"=!%,!4,)!+/+,(!(2+)!41+!,#(!,+3+$$41)! *#1! (2+! 41-60+,(! 2+1+7! I%0%'41')C! %(! 9#6'.! &+! "#$$%&'+! (#! +`(+,.! (2%$! (1+4(0+,(! &)! -%/%,-! $#0+! 564,(%(4(%/+! 0+4$61+!#*!(2+!+`(+,(!#*!(2+!+`"4,$%#,!#1!(2+!$(163(614'!324,-+=!4-4%,!(2%$!%$!,#(!,+3+$$41)!*#1!#61!"61"#$+$7!G2%$! $%0"'+C!4,.!4''a%,3'6$%/+C!(21++a94)!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!9%''!$6**%3+7!

;1##<+$C! 4$! 2+! 04.+! 3'+41C! .+1%/+.! 2%$! +564(%#,! /+1)! 0632! %,! (2+! 3#,(+`(! #*! 4! &+'%+*! %,! 841'! Z#""+1D$! "2%'#$#"2)!E?C!AF7!>(!%$!(2+1+*#1+!%,(+1+$(%,-!(#!,#(+!(24(!-BC!-C!4,.!-E!34,!&+!%,(+1"1+(+.!%,!Z#""+1%4,!(+10$!a!$++C! *#1!+`40"'+C!SDd+41!EP?C!324"(+1!\F!! 4,.!^#1/%!EPPC!324"(+1!WF!a!4$!4!*4%'+.!*4'$%*%34(%#,C!(2+!31+4(%#,!#*!4!(1%4'! $#'6(%#,C!4,.!4!$633+$$*6'!*4'$%*%34(%#,!1+$"+3(%/+')7!

F>

+!0#.)71/%-#.%1*!18!2*1(;)&7)!06#*7)-!

g+!,#9!24/+!4!$+/+,a*#'.!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!4,.!4!(21++a*#'.!324143(+1%$4(%#,!#*!324,-+$! %,! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! Z6((%,-! (2+$+! (#-+(2+1C! 4$! (2+! +564(%#,! %,/%(+$! 6$! (#C! -%/+$! (2+! "#$$%&%'%()! #*! 4,! #/+14''! 564'%(4(%/+! "4((+1,C! 9%(2! (9+,()a#,+! 34(+-#1%+$7! I#0+! 41+! &+((+1a+$(4&'%$2+.! (24,! #(2+1$C! %,! (+10$! #*! &+%,-! .+$31%&+.! %,! (2+! '%(+14(61+C! &6(! 4''! 41+! 3#2+1+,(! 4,.! 3#0"1+2+,$%&'+7! G2%$! '%$(! #*! 34(+-#1%+$! $2#6'.! &+! 4! 6$+*6'! $(%06'6$!(#!4$$+$$%,-!92+(2+1!(2+)!24/+!)+(!&++,!#&$+1/+.=!92+1+!(2+)!24/+!,#(C!(2%$!04)!&+!4!$(%06'6$!+%(2+1!(#! %,/+$(%-4(%,-!(2+0C!#1!"+124"$!(#!3#,$%.+1%,-!92+(2+1!,+9!*#10$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$)$(+0!4,.!$+1/%3+!41+!,+3+$$41)! (#!$6""#1(!(2+07!

!G2+!P?!34(+-#1%+$!41+!'%$(+.!4,.!.+$31%&+.!%,!M""+,.%`!?7!M!*+9!+`40"'+$!9%''!$6**%3+!(#!-%/+!(2+!D*'4/#61D7! ^4(+-#1)!\!H%\a$?J!.+,#(+$!(2+!$+56+,(%4'!4..%,-!#*!4!$+1%+$!#*!+56%/4'+,(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!9%(2!(2+!1+$6'(! (24(!(2+!+`%$(%,-!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!%$!$(1+,-(2+,+.7!G2%$!34,!&+!6,.+1$(##.!4$!4!$2#1(a(+10!+/+,(C!*#1!+`40"'+!4! $+4132! *#1! +$$+,(%4'')! (2+! $40+! %,*#104(%#,! %,! .%**+1+,(! $#613+$C! #1! '#,-+1a(+10! 4$! 4! 1#6(%,+! 0#,%(#1%,-! #*! %,*#104(%#,!#/+1!(%0+C!%,!+%(2+1!34$+!3#,*%10%,-!4,!+`%$(%,-!3#-,%(%/+!/%+9"#%,(7!!

^4(+-#1)! A! H%?a$PJ!.+,#(+$! 4,! %00+.%4(+! $%,-'+! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(C! 92%32! 346$+$! 4,! +`"4,$%#,! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!G2%$!34,!&+!6,.+1$(##.!4$!4!(41-+(+.!$+4132C!#1!1+*+1+,3+!U<,#9,a%(+0!+,56%1)C!"+124"$!*#1!4! $"+3%*%3!"%+3+!#*!*43(64'!%,*#104(%#,C!92%32!%$!4..+.!%,(#!4,!+$(4&'%$2+.!$(163(61+7!

^4(+-#1)!??!H%]a$PK!.+,#(+$!4!$+56+,(%4'!4..%,-!#*!$+4132!1+$6'($C!+432!#*!-1+4(+1!$%-,%*%34,3+C!9%(2!(2+!1+$6'(! #*!4,!+`"4,.+.!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!G2%$!9#6'.!3#/+1!(2+!4356%$%(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!*1#0!$314(32!%,!4!,+9!41+4C! 92+1+!+432!4..+.!+'+0+,(!24.!-1+4(+1!$%-,%*%34,3+!4$!%(!94$!*%((+.!9%(2%,!(2+!-1#9%,-!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!!

^4(+-#1)!?@!H%Wa$\J!.+,#(+$!(2+!Dk61+<4D!0#0+,(C!92+,!4!$+56+,3+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!4""+41!(#!24/+!,#! +**+3(C! 6,(%'! (2+! *%,4'! #,+! 346$+$! 4! .%$16"(%/+! 324,-+! %,! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! Z+124"$! 9+! $2#6'.! 34''! %(! +,'%-2(+,0+,(7!

!

(8)

David Bawden

G2+!+`40"'+!#*!34(+-#1)!\!4&#/+!$2#9$!(24(!(2+$+!34(+-#1%+$!#*!<,#9'+.-+!324,-+$!04)!+432!1+"1+$+,(!(2+! 1+$6'(!#*!.%**+1+,(!43(%/%(%+$C!(4$<$!4,.!(%0+!$34'+$7!f61(2+10#1+C!%(!04)!,#(!&+!+4$)!(#!.+(+10%,+C!$#'+')!*1#0!4! $(6.)!#*!%,*#104(%#,a1+'4(+.!&+24/%#61C!924(!34(+-#1)!%$!1+'+/4,(7!

f#1! +`40"'+C! b%32#'4$C! d6,(%,-(#,C! g%''%40$! 4,.! R#&1#9#'$<%! EP\F! %.+,(%*%+.! 4! &+24/%#61! .+,#(+.! 4$! D32+3<%,-D=!1+"+4(+.')!+`40%,%,-!924(!94$!4""41+,(')!(2+!$40+!%,*#104(%#,!#,!.%**+1+,(!9+&!$%(+$7!>(!%$!(+0"(%,-C! 4,.! "1#&4&')! 3#11+3(! %,! 04,)! 34$+$C! (#! +564(+! (2%$! (#! ^4(+-#1)! P! H%Pa$?J! :! 4! $+1%+$! #*! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6($! #*! .+31+4$%,-!$%-,%*%34,3+!Q$%,3+!4''!(24(!%$!&+%,-!*#6,.!%$!1+"+(%(%#,!#*!(2+!*%1$(!%,*#104(%#,!'+4.%,-!(#!3#,*%104(%#,! #*!4,!+$(4&'%$2+.!$(163(61+7!d#9+/+1C!%(!04)!&+!(24(!(2+!/+1)!*43(!#*!(2+!9%.+!1+"+(%(%#,!#*!(2%$!"%+3+!#*!%,*#104(%#,! %$!#*!%,(+1+$(!*#1!$#0+!1+4$#,=!%,!(24(!34$+C!(2+!324,-+!0%-2(!&+!+`"4,$%#,C!4,.!(2+!$+56+,(%4'')!4..+.!%,*#104(%#,! %(+0$!0%-2(!&+!#*!+564'!#1!%,31+4$%,-!$%-,%*%34,3+C!$#!(24(!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!324,-+!0%-2(!&+!34(+-#1)!?B!#1!??7!G2%$! %$! 4,! %,.%34(%#,! #*! (2+! "#9+1! #*! (2%$! 34(+-#1%$4(%#,! 4$! 4! (##'! *#1! +`40%,%,-! [6$(! 2#9! 9+''! 9+! 6,.+1$(4,.! %,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#617!

>(!%$!4'$#!(16+!(#!$4)!(24(!%(!04)!"#$$%&'+!(#!%.+,(%*)!9%(2!3#,*%.+,3+!(2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!&6(! 1+04%,!%,!%-,#14,3+!#*!(2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!324,-+7!M,!+`40"'+!#*!(2%$!%$!(2+!%.+,(%*%34(%#,!&)! k1.4'+c! EP]F! #*! (2+! "2+,#0+,#,! #*! D+,3#6,(+1%,-DC! (2+! $+1+,.%"%(#6$! 4356%$%(%#,! #*! %,*#104(%#,7! G2%$! $++0$! (#! +564(+!(#!%,*#104(%#,!324,-+!%TC!&6(!%($!3#,$+56+,3+$!%,!(+10$!#*!$(163(61+!324,-+!06$(!1+04%,!6,<,#9,!9%(2#6(! <,#9'+.-+!#*!(2+!"41(%36'41!3%1360$(4,3+$=!(2+!1+$6'(!3#6'.!&+!4,)!#*!$?C!$P!#1!$\7!

G>

L1*0;4-%1*-!

;)!04<%,-!(2+!4$$60"(%#,$!(24(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!34,!&+!1+"1+$+,(+.!&)!(2+!$%0"'+$(!*#10!#*!"#9+1!'49C!4,.! <,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!&)!(2+!$%0"'+$(!*#10!#*!0+,(4'!04"C!4,.!4""')%,-!(2+$+!9%(2%,!(2+!*140+9#1<!#*!;1##<+$! +564(%#,C! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 324143(+1%$4(%#,! #*! (2+! "1#3+$$+$! 1+"1+$+,(+.! &)! (2+! +564(%#,! 34,! &+! .+1%/+.7! G2%$! 24$! 4! "4((+1,!#*!$+/+,!*#10$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!4,.!(21++!*#10$!#*!324,-+!%,!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+C!-%/%,-!(9+,()a#,+! 34(+-#1%+$! #/+14''7! >(! 9#6'.! &+! "#$$%&'+! (#! 32##$+! 0#1+! 3#0"'+`! 4'(+1,4(%/+$! (#! 1+"1+$+,(! &#(2! *6,3(%#,! 4,.! $(163(61+C! &6(! (2+1+! %$! ,#! 14(%#,4'+! *#1! .#%,-! $#C! 4,.! %(! 9#6'.! 1+$6'(! %,! 4! 34(+-#1%$4(%#,! 92%32! 94$! 0#1+! 3#0"'%34(+.!4,.!06'(%*43+(+.C!(#!(2+!"#%,(!#*!&+%,-!6,2+'"*6'7!

G2+$+!04)!&+!6$+.!.%1+3(')C!4$!4,!+`"'4,4(#1)!(##'!4,.!(4`#,#0)!*#1!$(6.)%,-!4,.!$60041%$%,-!%,*#104(%#,! &+24/%#61!4,.!6$+C!4,.!Q!%,!"41(%36'41!Q!*#1!$2#9%,-!92+,!6,.+1$(4,.%,-!%$!'+$$!(24,!*6''7!f61(2+10#1+C!$%,3+!(2+)! 1+$6'(!*1#0!4!/+1)!$%0"'%$(%3!$+0%a564,(%$4(%#,!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,C!(2+)!#**+1!(2+!"#$$%&%'%()!#*!&+%,-!.+/+'#"+.! %,(#!0#1+!$#"2%$(%34(+.!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+!(1+4(0+,($7!

H>

M)8)/)*0)-!

E?F! ;7^7!;1##<+$C!G2+!*#6,.4(%#,$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Z41(!?7!Z2%'#$#"2%34'!4$"+3($C!Journal of Information

Science!PH\U]J!H?@ABJ!?PWa?\]!

EPF! b7N7!;+'<%,C!G2+!3#-,%(%/+!/%+9"#%,(!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!?VH?J!H?@@BJ! ??a?W!

E\F! Z7!>,-9+1$+,C!^#-,%(%/+!"+1$"+3(%/+$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!1+(1%+/4'!%,(+143(%#,:!+'+0+,($!#*!4!3#-,%(%/+!>Y!(2+#1)C!

Journal of Documentation!WPH?J!H?@@VJ!\aWB!

E]F! b7!f#1.C!l#.+'%,-!3#-,%(%/+!"1#3+$$+$!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-:!*1#0!Z#""+1!(#!Z4$<C!Journal of the

American Society for Information Science and TechnologyC!WWH@J!HPBB]J!TV@aTAP!

EWF! Z7!>,-9+1$+,!4,.!87!Nm1/+'%,C!The Turn: Integration of information seeking and retrieval in context! EI"1%,-+1C!R#1.1+32(C!PBBWJ!

!

(9)

EVF! ^7!^#'+C!S"+14(%#,4'%c%,-!(2+!,#(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!4$!4!$6&[+3(%/+!3#,$(163(C!Journal of the American

Society for Information ScienceC!]WHTJ!H?@@]J!]VWa]TV!

ETF! Z7!>,-9+1$+,C!Information retrieval interactionC!HG4)'#1!n14240C!i#,.#,C!?@@PJ!

EAF! Y7N7!G#..C!;43<!(#!#61!&+-%,,%,-$:!%,*#104(%#,!6(%'%c4(%#,C!;+1(140!;1##<+$!4,.!(2+!*6,.40+,(4'!+564(%#,! #*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Information Processing and ManagementC!\WHVJ!H?@@]J!AW?aATB!

E@F! >7!^#1,+'%6$C!G2+#1%c%,-!%,*#104(%#,!*#1!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Annual Review of Information Science and

TechnologyC!\V!HPBBPJ!\@\a]PW!

E?BF! ^7!^#'+C!^4'36'4(%,-!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!3#,(+,(!#*!4,!%,*#104(%#,!"1#3+$$!*#1!4!.#04%,!+`"+1(!6$%,-!I24,,#,D$! 04(2+04(%34'!(2+#1)!#*!3#006,%34(%#,:!4!"1+'%0%,41)!4,4')$%$C!Information Processing and ManagementC! \\HVJ!H?@@TJ!T?WaTPV!

E??F! I7!b+%''C!;1##<+$C!Z#""+1!4,.!#&[+3(%/+!<,#9'+.-+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!]H?J!H?@APJ!\\a\@! E?PF! Y7N7!G#..7!o(%'%c4(%#,!#*!2+1#%,!%,*#104(%#,!&)!4.#'+$3+,(!-%1'$!%,!M6$(14'%4:!4!3#-,%(%/+!4,4')$%$C!Journal of

the American Society of Information ScienceC!WBH?J!H?@@@J!?BaP\!

E?\F! R7!;49.+,C!I0##(2+1!"+&&'+$!4,.!(2+!$2#6'.+1$!#*!-%4,($:!(2+!.+/+'#"%,-!*#6,.4(%#,$!#*!%,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!\]H]J!HPBBAJ!]?Wa]PV!

E?]F! i7!k--2+C!Power Laws in the information production process: Lotkaian informatics!Hk'$+/%+1C!M0$(+1.40C! PBBWJ!

E?WF! ;7!;1##<+$C!Y#&+1(!f4%1(2#1,+!4,.!(2+!$3#"+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Journal of DocumentationC!\BHPJ! H?@T]J!?\@a?WP!

E?VF! i7!g+$(&1##<C!l+,(4'!0#.+'$:!4!(2+#1+(%34'!#/+1/%+9!4,.!"1+'%0%,41)!$(6.)C!Journal of Information

ScienceC!\PHVJ!HPBBVJ!WV\aWT@!

E?TF! I7!l4<1%C!M7!;'4,.*#1.C!N7!n#9C!N7!Y%00+1C!^7!g419%3<!4,.!n7!;6324,4,C!M!'%&141)!#1![6$(!4,#(2+1! %,*#104(%#,!1+$#613+j!M!34$+!$(6.)!#*!6$+1$D!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!(14.%(%#,4'!4,.!.%-%(4'!'%&141%+$C!Journal of

the American Society for Information Science and TechnologyC!WAH\J!HPBBTJ!]\\a]]W!

E?AF! ^7!^#'+C!p7!i%,C!N7!i+%.+C!M7!i41-+!4,.!N7!;+2+$2(%C!M!3'4$$%*%34(%#,!#*!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!6,.+1-14.64(+$! $++<%,-!%,*#104(%#,!*#1!4!!3#61$+!+$$4)!%,!2%$(#1)!4,.!"$)32#'#-):!"1+'%0%,41)!%,/+$(%-4(%#,!%,(#!4'%-,%,-! (2+%1!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!9%(2!#,'%,+!(2+$461%C!Journal of the American Society for Information Science and

TechnologyC!WAH?\J!HPBBTJ!PB@PaP?B]!

E?@F! g7!d+C!I7!k1.+'+cC!f7!g4,-!4,.!^7!I2)6C!G2+!+**+3($!#*!3#,3+"(64'!.+$31%"(%#,!4,.!$+4132!"143(%3+!#,!6$+1$D! 0+,(4'!0#.+'$!4,.!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-!%,!4!34$+a&4$+.!1+4$#,%,-!$)$(+0C!Information Processing and

ManagementC!]]H?J!HPBBAJ!P@]a\B@!

EPBF! N7!Z%$4,$<%!4,.!l7!q60+1C!l+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!(2+!&%&'%#-14"2%3!6,%/+1$+7!Z41(!?:!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*! .+$31%"(%#,$C!Journal of DocumentationC!VVHWJ!HPB?BJ!V]\aVVT

EP?F! M7!SDd+41C!Karl Popper!HY#6('+.-+C!i#,.#,C!?@ABJ!

EPPF! Y7!^#1/%C!An introduction to the thought of Karl PopperC!(14,$'4(+.!&)!Z7!^40%''+1C!HY#6('+.-+C!i#,.#,C! ?@@TJ!

EP\F! R7!b%32#'4$C!Z7!d6,(%,-(#,C!Z7!g%''%40$!4,.!G7!R#&1#9#'$<%C!Y+a4""14%$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-!&+24/%#61! %,!4!.%-%(4'!+,/%1#,0+,(!Q!&#6,3+1$C!32+3<+1$C!1+(61,++$!4,.!(2+!'%<+C!Journal of DocumentationC!VBH?J! HPBB]J!P]a]\!

EP]F! I7!k1.+'+cC!>,/+$(%-4(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!+,3#6,(+1%,-!%,!(2+!3#,(1#''+.!1+$+4132!+,/%1#,0+,(C!Information

Processing and ManagementC!]BHVJ!HPBB]J!?B?\a?BPW!

!

!

(10)

David Bawden

!""#$%&'

!

(

!

)*+#,-.&/*+&-$

!

-0

!

1$-23#%,#

!

45*$,#/

!

!

(! &(!6!/(!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!+,!!,+),/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&! 7! &7!6!/(!

! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&!

8! &8!6!/(!

! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&! !9! &9!6!/(!

! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&! :! &:!6!/(!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!&#3!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&!

;! &;!6!/(!

! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&! <! &<!6!/(!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!2(#'"3&#2&!21+#$&!

=! &(!6!/7!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!,+),!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! !>! &7!6!/7!

! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (?! &8!6!/7!

! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&!

((! &9!6!/7!

! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (7! &:!6!/7!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!&#3!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (8! &;!6!/7!

! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&!

(9! &<!6!/7!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (:! &(!6!/8!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!,+),!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&!

(;! &7!6!/8!

! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! !

(<! &8!6!/8!

!

(11)

!

N#61,4'!#*!>,*#104(%#,!I3%+,3+C!OO!HOJ!PB??C!""7!?Q?B!RS>:!?B7??TTUB?VWWW?WBV,,,,,,! ?B!

! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! (=! &9!6!/8!

! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! (>! &:!6!/8!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!&#3!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! !7?! &;!6!/8!

! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! 7(! &<!6!/8!

! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&!

! !!

! !

References

Related documents

The effect of heart failure nurse consultations on heart failure patients' illness beliefs, mood and quality of life over a six-month period.. This version of the publication

Initial discussion with heads of service for IMS in some local authorities suggested that it might be useful to focus on developing an understanding of inclusive practice

Polymerase activity of superlnatant fraction (0), pellet (@), and reconstituted supernatant fractionl plus pellet (A) of vesicular stomatitis virionls fraction- ated

We outline a cognitive com- putational model for neural-symbolic integration, position the model in the broader context of multi-agent systems, machine learning and automated

2(a) shows the wear rate of titanium pins against hardened gauge plate disks at constant sliding speeds and variable normal loads and Fig.. 2(b) shows the wear rate of titanium

Statistical evaluation of the influence of several sample pretreatment methods on the mercury content detectable by chemical analysis of contaminated soil samples

physicians believing generic medicines are less safe than brand name medicines (8), augmented by currently concerns with the low quality threshold for registration of medicines

We conclude that there are no physically relevant positive monad bundles on the 101 simple Calabi-Yau hypersurfaces in smooth toric varieties over and above what has been found