City, University of London Institutional Repository
Citation
:
Bawden, D. (2011). Brookes equation: The basis for a qualitativecharacterization of information behaviours. Journal of Information Science, 37(1), pp. 101-108. doi: 10.1177/0165551510395351
This is the unspecified version of the paper.
This version of the publication may differ from the final published
version.
Permanent repository link: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/3130/
Link to published version
:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0165551510395351Copyright and reuse:
City Research Online aims to make research
outputs of City, University of London available to a wider audience.
Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the author(s) and/or copyright
holders. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and
linked to.
Brookes equation: the basis for a
qualitative characterisation of
information behaviours
!"#$%&!'#(&)*!!
Department of Information Science, City University London, UK
!
+,-./#0.!
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
-4::#/%-%*7!%*81/:#.%1*!,)6#$%14/5!#*&!188)/!.6)!"#$$%&%'%()!#*!&+%,-!.+/+'#"+.!%,(#!0#1+!$#"2%$(%34(+.!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+!
(1+4(0+,($7!
!!
8+)9#1.$:!;1##<+$!+564(%#,=!3#-,%(%/+!"414.%-0=!"#9+1!'49$=!0+,(4'!04"$=!%,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#61!
B>
!?*./1&40.%1*!
>,!?@ABC!;+1(140!;1##<+$!*%,4'%$+.!4!'%,+!#*!1+$+4132!92%32!2+!24.!*#''#9+.!*#1!$+/+14'!)+41$C!&)!"6&'%$2%,-C! %,! 4! "4"+1! %,!Journal of Information ScienceC! 924(! 2+! .+$31%&+.! 4$! D(2+! *6,.40+,(4'! +564(%#,! #*! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+D!E?F7!G2%$!+564(%#,C!92%32!2+!24.!"6(!*#1941.!%,!/41%#6$!*#10$C!94$!2+1+!"1+$+,(+.!4$:!
!
8!HIJ!K!!>!L!8!HI!K!!IJ!!! !
M! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+C! 8! HIJ! %$! 324,-+.! %,(#! 4,! 4'(+1+.! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+! 8! HI! K!!IJ! &)! 4,! %,"6(! #*! %,*#104(%#,C!!>7!!I! %$! 4,! %,.%34(#1! #*! (2+! +**+3(! #*! (2+! 0#.%*%34(%#,7! G2+! $40+! %,*#104(%#,! 04)! 24/+! .%**+1+,(! +**+3($!#,!.%**+1+,(!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$7!>(!%$!4!.+$31%"(%#,!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!3#006,%34(%#,!"1#3+$$!4$!%(!4**+3($! #,+! %,.%/%.64'D$! <,#9'+.-+C! 4,.! 2+,3+! %$! 1+-41.+.! 4$! 4! *#6,.4(%#,! #*! (2+! 3#-,%(%/+! "414.%-0! %,! %,*#104(%#,!
!
$3%+,3+!EPC!\C!]C!WF7!^#'+!6$+.!%(!4$!4!_&4$+'%,+_!*#1!4!3#,$%.+14(%#,!#*!4!$6&[+3(%/%$(!3#,$(163(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,! EVFC!92%'+!>,-9+1$+,!H?@@PJ!.+1%/+.!+`(+,.+.!/+1$%#,$!#*!(2+!+564(%#,!ETF7!
;1##<+$!2%0$+'*C!4,.!,60+1#6$!46(2#1$!$6&$+56+,(')C!24/+!"#%,(+.!#6(!(24(!(2%$!%$!,#(!4,!+564(%#,!%,!(2+!6$64'! 04(2+04(%34'! $+,$+=! G#..! EAF! 4,.! ^#1,+'%6$! E@FC! %,! 1+/%+9%,-! (2+! /4'6+! 4,.! 4""'%34&%'%()! #*! (2+! +564(%#,C! -%/+! 433#6,($!#*!(2+$+!/%+9"#%,($7!G2+!+564(%#,!4$!"1+$+,(+.!-%/+$!6$!,#!94)!#*!564,(%*)%,-!(2+!40#6,(!#*!%,*#104(%#,! #*!<,#9'+.-+!%,!8!HIJC!,#1!4,)!94)!#*!.+1%/%,-!(2+!.%**+1+,3+!Q!564'%(4(%/+!#1!564,(%(4(%/+!a!&+(9++,!%(!4,.!8!HI!K! !IJC! 4'(2#6-2! ^#'+! 24$! $2#9,! #,+! 94)! %,! 92%32! (2%$! 0%-2(! &+! .#,+! E?BF7! ! ;1##<+$! 43<,#9'+.-+.! (24(! %(! 94$! "$+6.#a04(2+04(%34'!4,.!#/+1a$%0"'+C!4,.!(24(!%($!(+10$!4,.!$)0&#'$!9+1+!6,.+*%,+.7!b+%''!E??C!"7!\VF!$6--+$(+.! (24(![6$(!(2+!6,.+*%,+.!_K_!$%-,!_3#,(4%,+.!4,!+,(%1+!.%$3%"'%,+_!!
!
R+$"%(+!(2%$!'43<!#*!+564(%#,a,+$$!4(!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,C!%(!24$!&++,!#*(+,!56#(+.!4$!4!564'%(4(%/+!$60041)! #*! 4! 3+,(14'! %$$6+! 9%(2%,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+$=! (2+! G2#0$#,! >I>! .4(4&4$+$! %,! 0%.aPB?B! $2#9+.! (2+! "4"+1! 24/%,-!&++,!3%(+.!#/+1!?BB!(%0+$7!M$!^#1,+'%6$!$4)$!_>(!04)!24/+!&++,!6,#"+14(%#,4'!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$)$(+0$C!&6(! %(! 24$! 1+04%,+.! #"+14(%#,4'! 4$! 4! -+,+14'! 3#,$%.+14(%#,C! +/+,! %*! ,#(! %,! +`"+1%0+,(4'! .+$%-,C! 9%(2%,! %,*#104(%#,! 1+(1%+/4'!(2+#1)!4,.!9%(2%,!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+D$!(2+#1%c%,-!#*!%,*#104(%#,_!E@C!"!]BTF7!!>(!24$!4'$#!&++,!4""'%+.!(#! 4! /+1)! '%0%(+.! .+-1++! %,! "143(%3+:! 564'%(4(%/+')C! 4$! 4! *140+9#1<! *#1! (2+! $(6.)! #*! -+,+14'! "6&'%3! %,*#104(%#,! 6(%'%c4(%#,!*#1!2+4'(2!%,*#104(%#,!EAC!?PFC!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+')!%,!4!$(6.)!#*!41324+#'#-%34'!1+$+4132!E?BF7!d#9+/+1C! _*#1! (2+! 0#$(! "41(e! (2+! +564(%#,! 1+04%,$! 4$! 4! 14(2+1! 1+"1#432*6'! 1+0%,.+1! #*! 2#9! *41! 9+! 41+! *1#0! *6'*%''%,-! ;1##<+$D!1+$+4132!"1#-1400+_!E?\C!"!]?@F7!
>(!$++0$!(2+1+*#1+!(24(!%(!04)!&+!9#1(2!+`40%,%,-!(2+!+564(%#,!*61(2+1C!(#!$++!%*C!&)!04<%,-!$#0+C!2#"+*6'')! 1+4$#,4&'+C!4$$60"(%#,$C!%(!04)!&+!"#$$%&'+!(#!-#!&+)#,.!(2+!/+1)!'%0%(+.C!4'0#$(!"%3(#1%4'C!6$+!#*!(2+!+564(%#,! 92%32! 24$! &++,! (2+! ,#107! I"+3%*%34'')C! (2+! "61"#$+! 9%''! &+! (#! $++! %*! (2+! +564(%#,C! (26$! 0#.%*%+.C! 9%''! )%+'.! 4! $+,$%&'+!4,.!1+4'%$(%3!564'%(4(%/+!"%3(61+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!(14,$*+17!>*!$#C!(2%$!9#6'.!$6--+$(!(24(!*61(2+1!$(6.%+$!0%-2(! #**+1!(2+!"1#$"+3(!#*!564,(%(4(%/+!$(6.)7!
f%1$(C! %,! "41(! P! #*! (2+! "4"+1C!9+! $24''! +`40%,+! (2+!!>! (+10! %,! (2+! +564(%#,C! (2+! %,*#104(%#,C! #1!<,#9'+.-+C! %,"6(7! G2+,C! %,! "41(! \C! 9+! $24''! +`40%,+!!IC! (2+! 324,-+!%,! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7!g+! 9%''! 3#,$%.+1! 92+(2+1! (2+! +564(%#,! 34,! 2+'"! (#! -%/+! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 6,.+1$(4,.%,-! #*!what kind #*! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! %$! #33611%,-! %,! 4,)! "41(%36'41! 34$+C! 4,.!what kind #*! 324,-+! %,! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+! %,! #33611%,-7! >,! "41(! ]C! 9+! $24''! 3#0&%,+! (2+$+C!(#!-%/+!4!564'%(4(%/+!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!(2+!324,-+!.+$31%&+.!&)!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!
C>
!
?D!#!-:#;;!,%.!18!2*1(;)&7)!
!
;1##<+$!!.+$31%&+.!(2%$!(+10!%,!(2+!+564(%#,!4$!1+"1+$+,(+.!4,!%,"6(!#*!_4!$04''!&%(!#*!<,#9'+.-+_!E?C!"!?\?F=! 2#9+/+1C! 2+!"1+*+11+.! (#! (+10! %(! %,*#104(%#,C! (#! 04<+! (2+! "#%,(! (24(! (2%$! 24.! 4,! #&[+3(%/+! 564'%()C! 4'&+%(! (24(! %(! 0%-2(!346$+!.%**+1+,(!+**+3($!#,!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!#*!.%**+1+,(!%,.%/%.64'$7!
;1##<+$! "1+$604&'+! 6$+.! (2+! 9#1.! D&%(D! %,! %($! %,*#104'! 0+4,%,-=! &6(! 9+! 3#6'.C! #*! 3#61$+C! 564,(%*)! 4,)! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! %,! (+10$! #*! &%($C! %,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! (2+#1+(%3! $+,$+7! G2%$! 9#6'.! ,#(C! 2#9+/+1C! 2+'"! %,! 6,.+1$(4,.%,-!924(!<%,.#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!%(!%$7!!
G#!&+-%,!(#!.#!$#C!9+!9%''!(1+4(!!>!,#(!4$!4!,60&+1C!&6(!4$!4!*6,3(%#,7!g+!.#!,#(!<,#9C!a prioriC!924(!(2%$! *6,3(%#,!%$=!,#(!+/+,!%($!-+,+14'!,4(61+7!;6(!9+!04)!(4<+!4,!+.634(+.!-6+$$!(24(!(2+!0#$(!'%<+')!*#10!#*!$632!4! *6,3(%#,!9#6'.!&+!(24(!#*!4!power law7!G2%$!$++0$!'%<+')C!$%0"')!&+346$+!"#9+1!'49$!41+!/+1)!3#00#,')!*#6,.!%,! 04,)!4$"+3($!#*!(2+!&%#'#-%34'!4,.!$#3%4'!.#04%,$=!%(!%$!.%**%36'(!(#!$++!4,)!14(%#,4'+!*#1!32##$%,-!4,)!#(2+1!*#10! #*! *6,3(%#,7! g%(2%,! (2+! %,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+$C! (2+)! 41+! +,3#6,(+1+.! 4$! 14,<a*1+56+,3)! *6,3(%#,$C! $632! 4$! h%"*D$! i49!4,.!Z41+(#D$!i49C!4,.!4$!$%c+a*1+56+,3)!*6,3(%#,$C!$632!4$!i#(<4D$!i49!E?]F7!!!!
G2+$+!(4<+!(2+!-+,+14'!*#10!! ! ! )!L!4!`$!
!
David Bawden
92+1+!4!%$!4!3#,$(4,(!4,.!$!%$!(2+!+`"#,+,(!#*!(2+!*6,3(%#,7! G2%$!1+$6'($!%,!4!$+1%+$!92+1+!(2+!/4'6+!*#1!(2+!<(2!+'+0+,(!%$!
!
! ! ?U<$!
! ! aaaaaaa!
! ! "!?U,<! !
(2+!.+,#0%,4(#1!&+%,-!$600+.!#/+1!4''!(2+!(+10$!#*!(2+!$+1%+$7!
I%,3+! 9+! 41+! %,(+1+$(+.! #,')! %,! 564'%(4(%/+! "4((+1,$C! 14(2+1! (24,! ,60+1%3! 564,(%(%+$C! 9+! 04)! %-,#1+! (2+! .+,#0%,4(#1C!$%,3+!%(!%$!(2+!$40+!*#1!4''!+'+0+,($!#*!(2+!$+1%+$7!!
>,!(2%$!34$+C!(2+!$+1%+$!"1#.63+.!&)!$632!4!*6,3(%#,!9#6'.!1+"1+$+,(!(2+!3#,(1%&6(%#,!#*!+432!#*!$633+$$%/+! %,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!%*!(2+1+!9+1+!0#1+!(24,!#,+C!(#!(2+!324,-%,-!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!M$!9+!41+!*%((%,-!(2%$! 9%(2%,!(2+!3#,(+`(!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!D3#,(1%&6(%#,D!.#+$!,#(!0+4,!%,*#104(%#,!3#,(+,(!0+4$61+.!%,!&%($!Q!(24(! 3#6'.!&+!4$$+$$+.!$+"414(+')!Q!&6(!14(2+1!(2+!+`(+,(!(#!92%32!+432!%,"6(!&1%,-$!4(!(2+!324,-+7!G2%$!4''#9$!*#1! "#$$%&%'%()!(24(!(2+1+!04)!&+!$+/+14'!.%$31+(+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!&1%,-%,-!4(!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!324,-+7! >,.++.C!;1##<+$!$"+3%*%34'')!4''#9+.!*#1!(2%$!E?WC!AF!%,!4,!+41')!/41%4,(!#*!2%$!+564(%#,C!$2#9%,-!$633+$$%/+!%,"6($:!
!
>?!K!HIJB!!!!HIJ?!
>P!K!HIJ?!!!!HIJP!
4,.!$#!#,7! !
>*!9+! <,+9! (2+! /4'6+!#*! (2+!+`"#,+,(! $Q!92%32!9+!.#!,#(!Q! 9+! 3#6'.!.%1+3(')! 34'36'4(+! (2%$! 3#,(1%&6(%#,7! Y4(2+1C! 9+! 9%''! 3#,$%.+1! 924(! "4((+1,$! +0+1-+! *1#0! /41)%,-! (2+! #*! /4'6+$! #*! $C! 6$%,-! (2+! $%0"'+$(! *#10! #*! (2+! $+1%+$C!9%(2!/4'6+$!?!U!<$C!4,.!,#(%,-!(24(!*#1!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,($!!
4a0!L!?!U!40!
4,.!(24(!!
! ! 4B!L!?!
G2+!/4'6+!#*!(2+!+`"#,+,(!04)!14,-+C!%,!"1%,3%"'+C!*1#0!"'6$!%,*%,%()!(#!0%,6$!%,*%,%()7!>,!#1.+1!(#!$++!(2+! #/+14''!"4((+1,C!%,!(2+!$%0"'+$(!94)C!9+!(4<+!%($!/4'6+!(#!&+:!!
" '41-+!4,.!"#$%(%/+C!$4)!?BB!
" $04''!4,.!"#$%(%/+C!$4)!P!
" c+1#!
" $04''!4,.!,+-4(%/+C!$4)!aP!
" '41-+!4,.!,+-4(%/+C!$4)!?BB!
g1%(%,-!#6(!(2+!*%1$(!*%/+!(+10$!#*!(2+!$+1%+$!%,!+432!34$+C!%,!*43(%#,4'!+`"#,+,(%4'!*#10C!9+!34,!$++!(2+!"4((+1,! 9%(2#6(!,++.%,-!(#!34'36'4(+!4!,60+1%34'!/4'6+7!
!
2
!
!
!
!
!
!
?BB!
?!
?UP
?BB!?U\
?BB!?U]
?BB!?UW
?BB!P!
?!
?UP
P!?U\
P!?U]
P!?UW
P!B!
?!
?!
?!
?!
?!
aP!
?!
P
P!\
P!]
P!W
P!a?BB!
?!
P
?BB!\
?BB!]
?BB!W
?BB!!
Z#$%(%/+C!,+-4(%/+!4,.!c+1#!+`"#,+,($!1+$6'(!%,!$+1%+$!*#1!92%32!(2+!/4'6+$!1+$"+3(%/+')!.+31+4$+C!%,31+4$+!4,.! 1+04%,!3#,$(4,(C!4$!(2+!+'+0+,(!,60&+1!%,31+4$+$7!!
M(!2%-2!4&$#'6(+!/4'6+$!#*!<C!(2+!D/4'6+D!#*!(2+!$+1%+$!%$!3#,3+,(14(+.!%,!(2+!*%1$(!4,.!'4$(!+'+0+,($!1+$"+3(%/+')C! 92%'+!4(!'#9!4&$#'6(+!/4'6+$!(2+1+!%$!4!$0##(2+1!(14,$%(%#,7!f#1!+`40"'+C!9%(2!4!/4'6+!#*!<LPC!(2+!$+1%+$!(4<+$!(2+! /4'6+$!!
?C!?!U!]C!?!U!@C!?!U!?V!e77!
3#11+$"#,.%,-!(#!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!9%(2!/4'6+$! ?C!B7PWC!B7??C!B7BV!e7!
G2%$!/+1)!$%0"')!4""'%34(%#,!#*!4!"#9+1!'49!*6,3(%#,!9%(2%,!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,!$6--+$($!*%/+!04%,!34(+-#1%+$! #*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!92%32!41+!-%/+,!(2+!'4&+'$!%?a%W:!
%B!Q!'41-+!"#$%(%/+!+`"#,+,(!
$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!4(!$(41(!#*!$+1%+$!
%C!Q!$04''!"#$%(%/+!+`"#,+,(!
$+56+,(%4'!.+31+4$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!
%E!Q!c+1#!+`"#,+,(!
$+56+,(%4'!+564'!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!
%F!Q!$04''!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,(!
$+56+,(%4'!%,31+4$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!
%G!Q!'41-+!,+-4(%/+!+`"#,+,(!
$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!4(!+,.!#*!$+1%+$!
>(!$2#6'.!&+!+0"24$%$+.!2+1+!(24(!(2+!D$%c+D!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!%$!,#(!0+4$61+.!#&[+3(%/+')!%,!&%($=!(24(! 3#6'.! &+! .#,+C! &6(! %$! 4! $+"414(+! %$$6+7! g+! 41+! 0+4$61%,-! $%c+! 2+1+C! %,! (2+! ;1##<+$D! +564(%#,! 3#,(+`(C! &)! (2+! 3#-,%(%/+!%0"43(!#,!(2+!1+3%"%+,(7!
G2+$+! *%/+! 34(+-#1%+$! 41+! ,#(C! #*! 3#61$+C! 4&$#'6(+7! d#9+/+1C! %(! %$! 3'+41! (24(! #,')! 4! $04''! %,31+4$+! %,! (2+! 4&$#'6(+!/4'6+!#*!(2+!+`"#,+,(!1+$6'($!%,!4!564'%(4(%/+!%B!#1!%G!34(+-#1%$4(%#,7!G2+1+!%$!'%(('+!$3#"+!*#1!4..%,-!+`(14! D(14,$%(%#,4'D!34(+-#1%+$C!92%32!$6--+$($!(24(!(2+$+!*%/+!34(+-#1%+$!41+!4!,4(614'!3#,$+56+,3+!#*!4""')%,-!4!"#9+1! '49!*6,3(%#,!9%(2%,!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!
G2+!$+1%+$!24/+!&++,!"1+$+,(+.!%,!(2+!6$64'!#1.+1+.!*#10C!&6(!Q!(2%,<%,-!-+,+14'')!Q!(2+1+!%$!,#!1+4$#,!92)! (2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!#*!$+1%+$!$2#6'.!&+!"+13+%/+.!%,!(2%$!94)!&)!(2+!1+3%"%+,(7!M,)!*#10!#*!#1.+1!%$C!%,!"1%,3%"'+C! "#$$%&'+=!9+!9%''!3#,$%.+1!#,')!(2+!#,+!92%32!%$!0#$(!.%$(%,3(!*1#0!(2+!#1.+1+.!$+1%+$C!(24(!%,!92%32!(2+!+,(1%+$!41+! 14,.#0%$+.7!!
Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%E!04<+$!,#!.%**+1+,3+!(#!(2+!"4((+1,C!$%,3+!(2+!+,(1%+$!41+!+564'!%,!04-,%(6.+7! Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%C!#1!%F!-%/+$!4!,+9!"4((+1,=!4!$+1%+$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!9%(2!$%-,%*%34,(!/4'6+! 411%/%,-!%,!14,.#0!#1.+17!
Y4,.#0%$%,-!(2+!+,(1%+$!#*!%B!#1!%G!4'$#!-%/+$!4!,+9!"4((+1,:!4!$%,-'+!$%-,%*%34,(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!411%/%,-! 14,.#0')!40#,-!%,"6($!#*!,#!/4'6+7!!
g+!.+,#(+!(2+$+!4$!(9#!,+9!34(+-#1%+$:!
%H!Q!$04''!+`"#,+,(C!$+1%+$!14,.#0%$+.! 14,.#0')!4114,-+.!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!
%I!Q!'41-+!+`"#,+,(C!$+1%+$!14,.#0%$+.! $%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(C!14,.#0')!"#$%(%#,+.!
!
David Bawden
g+!,#9!(#!3#,$%.+1!&#(2!(2+!/4'%.%()!4,.!(2+!,+3+$$%()!#*!(2+$+!1+$6'($7!R#!(2+$+!$+/+,!34(+-#1%+$!04(32!#61! <,#9'+.-+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!433+$$C!4,.!41+!(2+$+!0#.+$!#*!433+$$!92%32!(2+)!.#!,#(!34"(61+j!M,.!%$!%(!,+3+$$41)!(#! 6$+!(2%$!*#104'%$0!(#!.+1%/+!(2%$!34(+-#1%$4(%#,j!
^#,$%.+1%,-!(2+!34(+-#1%+$!%,!(61,C!(2+!"4((+1,$!#*!!%C!4,.!%F!41+!&#(2!324143(+1%$(%3!#*!search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
%B!34,!4'$#!&+!$++,!4$!4!*#10!#*!$+4132C!4!"41(%36'41')!+**+3(%/+!#,+C!92%32!"1#/%.+$!(2+!*6''!%,*#104(%#,!%,!(2+! *%1$(!%,"6(=!%(!%$!()"%34'!#*!4!/)8)/)*0)C!#1!2*1(*9%.):C!$+4132C!$4(%$*%+.!&)!4!$%,-'+!%,"6(7!!
G2+!14,.#0')!411%/%,-!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!#*!%H!$++0!324143(+1%$(%3!#*!,/1(-%*7C!#*!(2+!"61"#$%/+!#1!.%1+3(+.! /41%+()7!
%IC! 9%(2! %($! $%,-'+! %$#'4(+.! 14,.#0')! 411%/%,-! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(! .+,#(+$! (2+! <%,.! #*! %,*#104(%#,! 433+$$! .+$31%&+.!4$!#00%&)*.#;C!-)/)*&%<%.14- #1!)*014*.)/%*77!!
?GC!%,!92%32!(2+!$%,-'+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!411%/+$!4(!(2+!+,.!#*!4!$+1%+$!#*!,+-'%-%&'+!%,"6($C!%$!&+$(!(2#6-2(!#*!4$! (2+!)4/)2#!$%(64(%#,C!(2+!+41'%+1!%,"6($!24/%,-!"1+"41+.!(2+!3#-,%(%/+!$(163(61+!*#1!(2+!%,,#/4(%/+!'+4"7!
f%,4'')C! (2+! "4((+1,! #*!%E!1+*'+3($! 4!:1*%.1/%*7!$%(64(%#,C! 9%(2! 4! $+1%+$! #*! %,"6($! #*! +56%/4'+,(! /4'6+=! 0#$(! '%<+')!$#0+!1#6(%,+!#1!3#0"414(%/+!433+$$7!
>(! $++0$C! (2+1+*#1+C! (24(! 4''! #*! (2+$+! "4((+1,$! 34,! &+! +564(+.! (#! 3'+41')! 6,.+1$(##.! "4((+1,$! #*! %,*#104(%#,! 433+$$7! G2+)! +,3#0"4$$! $+4132%,-C! %,! %($! "1+3%$+! 4,.! 0#1+! -+,+14'! *#10$C! &1#9$%,-! 4,.! 433%.+,(4'! .%$3#/+1)C! 31+4(%/+!%,,#/4(%#,C!4,.!1#6(%,+!%,*#104(%#,!0#,%(#1%,-=!4!3#0"1+2+,$%/+!3#/+14-+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!433+$$!*1#0!4! 3#-,%(%/+!"+1$"+3(%/+7!
g2%'+C! 4$! ,#(+.! &)! (2+! 1+*+1+,3+$! 4&#/+C! $+/+14'! #*! (2+$+! "4((+1,$! 24/+! &++,! .+$31%&+.! %,! (2+! '%(+14(61+! #*! %,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#61!4,.!6$+C!(2%$!3#0"1+2+,$%/+!$+(!#*!"4((+1,$!24$!,+/+1!&++,!$+(!#6(7!G2%$![6$(%*%+$!(2+!/4'6+! #*!(2%$!+`(+,$%#,!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,7!
>(!9%''!&+!,#(+.!(24(!(2%$!(1+4(0+,(!.#+$!,#(!%,3'6.+!(2+!$%(64(%#,!92+1+!,#!%,*#104(%#,!4(!4''!%$!4356%1+.!%,!4,)! 94)7!G2%$!%$!1+4$#,4&'+!4,.!4""1#"1%4(+C!$%,3+!(2+!+564(%#,!1+'4(+$!#,')!(#!(2#$+!$%(64(%#,$!92+1+!(2+1+!%-!$#0+! %,*#104(%#,C!24/%,-!$#0+!+**+3(7!!
E>
!
JD!#!017*%.%$)!:#<!
G2+!!I! (+10! %,! ;1##<+$! +564(%#,! 1+"1+$+,($! 4,! %,(+1,4'C! 3#-,%(%/+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! ! M$! 9%(2! #61! (1+4(0+,(!#*!(2+!!>!(+10C!9+!9%''!04<+!$#0+!0%,%04'!4$$60"(%#,$C!4,.!$++!92+1+!(2+)!'+4.7!
;1##<+$!94$!6,$"+3%*%3!4(!2#9!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!9+1+!(#!&+!1+"1+$+,(+.C!#(2+1!(24,!.+$31%&%,-!(2+0! -+,+14'')!4$!3#-,%(%/+!04"$7!M!/+1)!3#00#,!94)!#*!.+4'%,-!9%(2!(2%$!%$$6+!%,!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+$!24$!&++,! (#!4.#"(!(2+!%.+4!#*!4!0+,(4'!04"!#1!0+,(4'!0#.+'C!(#!.+$31%&+!4,!%,(+1,4'!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+=!4!*+9!+`40"'+$! ()"%*)!(2%$!4""1#432!E?VC!?TC!?AC!?@C!PBF7!G2%$!%$!0#$(!3#00#,')!4,!4114,-+0+,(C!0#1+!#1!'+$$!3#0"'+`!433#1.%,-! (#!,++.C!#*!3#,3+"($![#%,+.!&)!1+'4(%#,$2%"!'%,<$7!G2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!3#,3+"($!4,.!#*!(2+!'%,<$!04)!&+!.+$31%&+.!%,! /41)%,-! .+-1++$! #*! .+(4%'C! 4,.! (2+! $(1+,-(2! #*C! #1! 3#,*%.+,3+! %,C! &#(2! 3#,3+"($! 4,.! '%,<$! 04)! #1! 04)! ,#(! &+! 4$$+$$+.7!
>*! 9+! (4<+! (2+! $%0"'+$(! "#$$%&'+! *#10! #*! (2%$! 1+"1+$+,(4(%#,! Q! 4,.! 9+! 24/+! ,#!a priori 1+4$#,! *#1! .#%,-! #(2+19%$+!a!9+!34,!$++!(24(!(2+1+!41+!(21++!-+,+14'!94)$!%,!92%32!%(!04)!&+!324,-+.C!92%32!9+!'4&+'C!%,!4!$%0%'41! 94)!(#!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!!4$!-BC!-C!4,.!-E7!
-B!! (2+!"4((+1,!#*!3#,3+"($!4,.!'%,<$!%$!6,324,-+.C!(2#6-2!(2+!$(1+,-(2!#*!4,)!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!04)!&+! %,31+4$+.!#1!.+31+4$+.!
!
-C!! 4(!'+4$(!#,+!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!%$!4..+.C!&6(!,#,+!%$!1+0#/+.=!-B!04)!4'$#!#3361!
-E!! 4(!'+4$(!#,+!3#,3+"(!#1!'%,<!%$!1+0#/+.=!-B!4,.U#1!-C!04)!4'$#!#3361!!
-BC!92%32!9+!9%''!34''!4!01*8%&)*0)!324,-+C!%0"'%+$!(24(!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!24$!%,31+4$+.!#1!.+31+4$+.!(2+! $(1+,-(2!#*!$#0+!"41(!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!>,!%,3'6.%,-!(2%$!"#$$%&%'%()!9+!*#''#9!;1##<+$!E?F!92#!41-6+.! (24(!(2+!!324,-+!%$!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!04)!,#(!&+!4..%(%/+C!&6(!0%-2(!%,/#'/+!4!324,-+!#*!$(163(61+7!^#'+!EVFC!%,! 4.#"(%,-!;1##<+$!+564(%#,!4$!"41(!#*!4!#"+14(%#,4'%c4(%#,!#*!(2+!3#,3+"(!#*!%,*#104(%#,C!%,$%$(+.!(24(!(2+!324,-+! 06$(!&+!4!324,-+!#*!$(163(61+C!4,.!(24(!(2+!324,-+!92%32!9+!34''!-B!%$!&+((+1!1+-41.+.!4$!D3#,*#10%,-D!%,"6(!#1! .4(47!>,!(2+!%,(+1+$($!#*!-+,+14'%()C!9+!9%''!$(%3<!9%(2!;1##<+$D!%.+47!
-CC! 92%32!9+! 9%''! 34''! 4,!)=<#*-%1*!324,-+C! .+,#(+$! 4,! %,31+4$+! %,! (2+!+`(+,(! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+C! 9%(2!,+9!3#,3+"($!#1!'%,<$!&+%,-!4..+.!4$!4!1+$6'(!#*!%,"6(!%,*#104(%#,!
-EC! 92%32! 9+! 9%''! 34''! 4!&%-/4<.%$)!324,-+C! .+,#(+$! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 324,-+! %,! (2+! "4((+1,! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7!
>(!9#6'.!&+!"#$$%&'+!(#!-%/+!4!0#1+!.+(4%'+.!#1!$#"2%$(%34(+.!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!324,-+$!#*!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+C! &6(!4,)!$632!9#6'.!&+!.+"+,.+,(!#,!(2+!,4(61+!#*!$#0+!"41(%36'41!0+,(4'!04"=!%,!4,)!+/+,(!(2+)!41+!,#(!,+3+$$41)! *#1! (2+! 41-60+,(! 2+1+7! I%0%'41')C! %(! 9#6'.! &+! "#$$%&'+! (#! +`(+,.! (2%$! (1+4(0+,(! &)! -%/%,-! $#0+! 564,(%(4(%/+! 0+4$61+!#*!(2+!+`(+,(!#*!(2+!+`"4,$%#,!#1!(2+!$(163(614'!324,-+=!4-4%,!(2%$!%$!,#(!,+3+$$41)!*#1!#61!"61"#$+$7!G2%$! $%0"'+C!4,.!4''a%,3'6$%/+C!(21++a94)!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!9%''!$6**%3+7!
;1##<+$C! 4$! 2+! 04.+! 3'+41C! .+1%/+.! 2%$! +564(%#,! /+1)! 0632! %,! (2+! 3#,(+`(! #*! 4! &+'%+*! %,! 841'! Z#""+1D$! "2%'#$#"2)!E?C!AF7!>(!%$!(2+1+*#1+!%,(+1+$(%,-!(#!,#(+!(24(!-BC!-C!4,.!-E!34,!&+!%,(+1"1+(+.!%,!Z#""+1%4,!(+10$!a!$++C! *#1!+`40"'+C!SDd+41!EP?C!324"(+1!\F!! 4,.!^#1/%!EPPC!324"(+1!WF!a!4$!4!*4%'+.!*4'$%*%34(%#,C!(2+!31+4(%#,!#*!4!(1%4'! $#'6(%#,C!4,.!4!$633+$$*6'!*4'$%*%34(%#,!1+$"+3(%/+')7!
F>
+!0#.)71/%-#.%1*!18!2*1(;)&7)!06#*7)-!
g+!,#9!24/+!4!$+/+,a*#'.!34(+-#1%$4(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!4,.!4!(21++a*#'.!324143(+1%$4(%#,!#*!324,-+$! %,! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! Z6((%,-! (2+$+! (#-+(2+1C! 4$! (2+! +564(%#,! %,/%(+$! 6$! (#C! -%/+$! (2+! "#$$%&%'%()! #*! 4,! #/+14''! 564'%(4(%/+! "4((+1,C! 9%(2! (9+,()a#,+! 34(+-#1%+$7! I#0+! 41+! &+((+1a+$(4&'%$2+.! (24,! #(2+1$C! %,! (+10$! #*! &+%,-! .+$31%&+.! %,! (2+! '%(+14(61+C! &6(! 4''! 41+! 3#2+1+,(! 4,.! 3#0"1+2+,$%&'+7! G2%$! '%$(! #*! 34(+-#1%+$! $2#6'.! &+! 4! 6$+*6'! $(%06'6$!(#!4$$+$$%,-!92+(2+1!(2+)!24/+!)+(!&++,!#&$+1/+.=!92+1+!(2+)!24/+!,#(C!(2%$!04)!&+!4!$(%06'6$!+%(2+1!(#! %,/+$(%-4(%,-!(2+0C!#1!"+124"$!(#!3#,$%.+1%,-!92+(2+1!,+9!*#10$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$)$(+0!4,.!$+1/%3+!41+!,+3+$$41)! (#!$6""#1(!(2+07!
!G2+!P?!34(+-#1%+$!41+!'%$(+.!4,.!.+$31%&+.!%,!M""+,.%`!?7!M!*+9!+`40"'+$!9%''!$6**%3+!(#!-%/+!(2+!D*'4/#61D7! ^4(+-#1)!\!H%\a$?J!.+,#(+$!(2+!$+56+,(%4'!4..%,-!#*!4!$+1%+$!#*!+56%/4'+,(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!9%(2!(2+!1+$6'(! (24(!(2+!+`%$(%,-!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!%$!$(1+,-(2+,+.7!G2%$!34,!&+!6,.+1$(##.!4$!4!$2#1(a(+10!+/+,(C!*#1!+`40"'+!4! $+4132! *#1! +$$+,(%4'')! (2+! $40+! %,*#104(%#,! %,! .%**+1+,(! $#613+$C! #1! '#,-+1a(+10! 4$! 4! 1#6(%,+! 0#,%(#1%,-! #*! %,*#104(%#,!#/+1!(%0+C!%,!+%(2+1!34$+!3#,*%10%,-!4,!+`%$(%,-!3#-,%(%/+!/%+9"#%,(7!!
^4(+-#1)! A! H%?a$PJ!.+,#(+$! 4,! %00+.%4(+! $%,-'+! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6(C! 92%32! 346$+$! 4,! +`"4,$%#,! #*! (2+! <,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!G2%$!34,!&+!6,.+1$(##.!4$!4!(41-+(+.!$+4132C!#1!1+*+1+,3+!U<,#9,a%(+0!+,56%1)C!"+124"$!*#1!4! $"+3%*%3!"%+3+!#*!*43(64'!%,*#104(%#,C!92%32!%$!4..+.!%,(#!4,!+$(4&'%$2+.!$(163(61+7!
^4(+-#1)!??!H%]a$PK!.+,#(+$!4!$+56+,(%4'!4..%,-!#*!$+4132!1+$6'($C!+432!#*!-1+4(+1!$%-,%*%34,3+C!9%(2!(2+!1+$6'(! #*!4,!+`"4,.+.!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!G2%$!9#6'.!3#/+1!(2+!4356%$%(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!*1#0!$314(32!%,!4!,+9!41+4C! 92+1+!+432!4..+.!+'+0+,(!24.!-1+4(+1!$%-,%*%34,3+!4$!%(!94$!*%((+.!9%(2%,!(2+!-1#9%,-!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+7!!
^4(+-#1)!?@!H%Wa$\J!.+,#(+$!(2+!Dk61+<4D!0#0+,(C!92+,!4!$+56+,3+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!4""+41!(#!24/+!,#! +**+3(C! 6,(%'! (2+! *%,4'! #,+! 346$+$! 4! .%$16"(%/+! 324,-+! %,! (2+! <,#9'+.-+! $(163(61+7! Z+124"$! 9+! $2#6'.! 34''! %(! +,'%-2(+,0+,(7!
!
David Bawden
G2+!+`40"'+!#*!34(+-#1)!\!4&#/+!$2#9$!(24(!(2+$+!34(+-#1%+$!#*!<,#9'+.-+!324,-+$!04)!+432!1+"1+$+,(!(2+! 1+$6'(!#*!.%**+1+,(!43(%/%(%+$C!(4$<$!4,.!(%0+!$34'+$7!f61(2+10#1+C!%(!04)!,#(!&+!+4$)!(#!.+(+10%,+C!$#'+')!*1#0!4! $(6.)!#*!%,*#104(%#,a1+'4(+.!&+24/%#61C!924(!34(+-#1)!%$!1+'+/4,(7!
f#1! +`40"'+C! b%32#'4$C! d6,(%,-(#,C! g%''%40$! 4,.! R#&1#9#'$<%! EP\F! %.+,(%*%+.! 4! &+24/%#61! .+,#(+.! 4$! D32+3<%,-D=!1+"+4(+.')!+`40%,%,-!924(!94$!4""41+,(')!(2+!$40+!%,*#104(%#,!#,!.%**+1+,(!9+&!$%(+$7!>(!%$!(+0"(%,-C! 4,.! "1#&4&')! 3#11+3(! %,! 04,)! 34$+$C! (#! +564(+! (2%$! (#! ^4(+-#1)! P! H%Pa$?J! :! 4! $+1%+$! #*! %,*#104(%#,! %,"6($! #*! .+31+4$%,-!$%-,%*%34,3+!Q$%,3+!4''!(24(!%$!&+%,-!*#6,.!%$!1+"+(%(%#,!#*!(2+!*%1$(!%,*#104(%#,!'+4.%,-!(#!3#,*%104(%#,! #*!4,!+$(4&'%$2+.!$(163(61+7!d#9+/+1C!%(!04)!&+!(24(!(2+!/+1)!*43(!#*!(2+!9%.+!1+"+(%(%#,!#*!(2%$!"%+3+!#*!%,*#104(%#,! %$!#*!%,(+1+$(!*#1!$#0+!1+4$#,=!%,!(24(!34$+C!(2+!324,-+!0%-2(!&+!+`"4,$%#,C!4,.!(2+!$+56+,(%4'')!4..+.!%,*#104(%#,! %(+0$!0%-2(!&+!#*!+564'!#1!%,31+4$%,-!$%-,%*%34,3+C!$#!(24(!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!324,-+!0%-2(!&+!34(+-#1)!?B!#1!??7!G2%$! %$! 4,! %,.%34(%#,! #*! (2+! "#9+1! #*! (2%$! 34(+-#1%$4(%#,! 4$! 4! (##'! *#1! +`40%,%,-! [6$(! 2#9! 9+''! 9+! 6,.+1$(4,.! %,*#104(%#,!&+24/%#617!
>(!%$!4'$#!(16+!(#!$4)!(24(!%(!04)!"#$$%&'+!(#!%.+,(%*)!9%(2!3#,*%.+,3+!(2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($C!&6(! 1+04%,!%,!%-,#14,3+!#*!(2+!,4(61+!#*!(2+!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+!324,-+7!M,!+`40"'+!#*!(2%$!%$!(2+!%.+,(%*%34(%#,!&)! k1.4'+c! EP]F! #*! (2+! "2+,#0+,#,! #*! D+,3#6,(+1%,-DC! (2+! $+1+,.%"%(#6$! 4356%$%(%#,! #*! %,*#104(%#,7! G2%$! $++0$! (#! +564(+!(#!%,*#104(%#,!324,-+!%TC!&6(!%($!3#,$+56+,3+$!%,!(+10$!#*!$(163(61+!324,-+!06$(!1+04%,!6,<,#9,!9%(2#6(! <,#9'+.-+!#*!(2+!"41(%36'41!3%1360$(4,3+$=!(2+!1+$6'(!3#6'.!&+!4,)!#*!$?C!$P!#1!$\7!
G>
L1*0;4-%1*-!
;)!04<%,-!(2+!4$$60"(%#,$!(24(!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6($!34,!&+!1+"1+$+,(+.!&)!(2+!$%0"'+$(!*#10!#*!"#9+1!'49C!4,.! <,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+$!&)!(2+!$%0"'+$(!*#10!#*!0+,(4'!04"C!4,.!4""')%,-!(2+$+!9%(2%,!(2+!*140+9#1<!#*!;1##<+$! +564(%#,C! 4! 564'%(4(%/+! 324143(+1%$4(%#,! #*! (2+! "1#3+$$+$! 1+"1+$+,(+.! &)! (2+! +564(%#,! 34,! &+! .+1%/+.7! G2%$! 24$! 4! "4((+1,!#*!$+/+,!*#10$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!%,"6(!4,.!(21++!*#10$!#*!324,-+!%,!<,#9'+.-+!$(163(61+C!-%/%,-!(9+,()a#,+! 34(+-#1%+$! #/+14''7! >(! 9#6'.! &+! "#$$%&'+! (#! 32##$+! 0#1+! 3#0"'+`! 4'(+1,4(%/+$! (#! 1+"1+$+,(! &#(2! *6,3(%#,! 4,.! $(163(61+C! &6(! (2+1+! %$! ,#! 14(%#,4'+! *#1! .#%,-! $#C! 4,.! %(! 9#6'.! 1+$6'(! %,! 4! 34(+-#1%$4(%#,! 92%32! 94$! 0#1+! 3#0"'%34(+.!4,.!06'(%*43+(+.C!(#!(2+!"#%,(!#*!&+%,-!6,2+'"*6'7!
G2+$+!04)!&+!6$+.!.%1+3(')C!4$!4,!+`"'4,4(#1)!(##'!4,.!(4`#,#0)!*#1!$(6.)%,-!4,.!$60041%$%,-!%,*#104(%#,! &+24/%#61!4,.!6$+C!4,.!Q!%,!"41(%36'41!Q!*#1!$2#9%,-!92+,!6,.+1$(4,.%,-!%$!'+$$!(24,!*6''7!f61(2+10#1+C!$%,3+!(2+)! 1+$6'(!*1#0!4!/+1)!$%0"'%$(%3!$+0%a564,(%$4(%#,!#*!;1##<+$D!+564(%#,C!(2+)!#**+1!(2+!"#$$%&%'%()!#*!&+%,-!.+/+'#"+.! %,(#!0#1+!$#"2%$(%34(+.!4,.!564,(%(4(%/+!(1+4(0+,($7!
H>
M)8)/)*0)-!
E?F! ;7^7!;1##<+$C!G2+!*#6,.4(%#,$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Z41(!?7!Z2%'#$#"2%34'!4$"+3($C!Journal of Information
Science!PH\U]J!H?@ABJ!?PWa?\]!
EPF! b7N7!;+'<%,C!G2+!3#-,%(%/+!/%+9"#%,(!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!?VH?J!H?@@BJ! ??a?W!
E\F! Z7!>,-9+1$+,C!^#-,%(%/+!"+1$"+3(%/+$!#*!%,*#104(%#,!1+(1%+/4'!%,(+143(%#,:!+'+0+,($!#*!4!3#-,%(%/+!>Y!(2+#1)C!
Journal of Documentation!WPH?J!H?@@VJ!\aWB!
E]F! b7!f#1.C!l#.+'%,-!3#-,%(%/+!"1#3+$$+$!%,!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-:!*1#0!Z#""+1!(#!Z4$<C!Journal of the
American Society for Information Science and TechnologyC!WWH@J!HPBB]J!TV@aTAP!
EWF! Z7!>,-9+1$+,!4,.!87!Nm1/+'%,C!The Turn: Integration of information seeking and retrieval in context! EI"1%,-+1C!R#1.1+32(C!PBBWJ!
!
EVF! ^7!^#'+C!S"+14(%#,4'%c%,-!(2+!,#(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!4$!4!$6&[+3(%/+!3#,$(163(C!Journal of the American
Society for Information ScienceC!]WHTJ!H?@@]J!]VWa]TV!
ETF! Z7!>,-9+1$+,C!Information retrieval interactionC!HG4)'#1!n14240C!i#,.#,C!?@@PJ!
EAF! Y7N7!G#..C!;43<!(#!#61!&+-%,,%,-$:!%,*#104(%#,!6(%'%c4(%#,C!;+1(140!;1##<+$!4,.!(2+!*6,.40+,(4'!+564(%#,! #*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Information Processing and ManagementC!\WHVJ!H?@@]J!AW?aATB!
E@F! >7!^#1,+'%6$C!G2+#1%c%,-!%,*#104(%#,!*#1!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Annual Review of Information Science and
TechnologyC!\V!HPBBPJ!\@\a]PW!
E?BF! ^7!^#'+C!^4'36'4(%,-!(2+!%,*#104(%#,!3#,(+,(!#*!4,!%,*#104(%#,!"1#3+$$!*#1!4!.#04%,!+`"+1(!6$%,-!I24,,#,D$! 04(2+04(%34'!(2+#1)!#*!3#006,%34(%#,:!4!"1+'%0%,41)!4,4')$%$C!Information Processing and ManagementC! \\HVJ!H?@@TJ!T?WaTPV!
E??F! I7!b+%''C!;1##<+$C!Z#""+1!4,.!#&[+3(%/+!<,#9'+.-+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!]H?J!H?@APJ!\\a\@! E?PF! Y7N7!G#..7!o(%'%c4(%#,!#*!2+1#%,!%,*#104(%#,!&)!4.#'+$3+,(!-%1'$!%,!M6$(14'%4:!4!3#-,%(%/+!4,4')$%$C!Journal of
the American Society of Information ScienceC!WBH?J!H?@@@J!?BaP\!
E?\F! R7!;49.+,C!I0##(2+1!"+&&'+$!4,.!(2+!$2#6'.+1$!#*!-%4,($:!(2+!.+/+'#"%,-!*#6,.4(%#,$!#*!%,*#104(%#,! $3%+,3+C!Journal of Information ScienceC!\]H]J!HPBBAJ!]?Wa]PV!
E?]F! i7!k--2+C!Power Laws in the information production process: Lotkaian informatics!Hk'$+/%+1C!M0$(+1.40C! PBBWJ!
E?WF! ;7!;1##<+$C!Y#&+1(!f4%1(2#1,+!4,.!(2+!$3#"+!#*!%,*#104(%#,!$3%+,3+C!Journal of DocumentationC!\BHPJ! H?@T]J!?\@a?WP!
E?VF! i7!g+$(&1##<C!l+,(4'!0#.+'$:!4!(2+#1+(%34'!#/+1/%+9!4,.!"1+'%0%,41)!$(6.)C!Journal of Information
ScienceC!\PHVJ!HPBBVJ!WV\aWT@!
E?TF! I7!l4<1%C!M7!;'4,.*#1.C!N7!n#9C!N7!Y%00+1C!^7!g419%3<!4,.!n7!;6324,4,C!M!'%&141)!#1![6$(!4,#(2+1! %,*#104(%#,!1+$#613+j!M!34$+!$(6.)!#*!6$+1$D!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!(14.%(%#,4'!4,.!.%-%(4'!'%&141%+$C!Journal of
the American Society for Information Science and TechnologyC!WAH\J!HPBBTJ!]\\a]]W!
E?AF! ^7!^#'+C!p7!i%,C!N7!i+%.+C!M7!i41-+!4,.!N7!;+2+$2(%C!M!3'4$$%*%34(%#,!#*!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!6,.+1-14.64(+$! $++<%,-!%,*#104(%#,!*#1!4!!3#61$+!+$$4)!%,!2%$(#1)!4,.!"$)32#'#-):!"1+'%0%,41)!%,/+$(%-4(%#,!%,(#!4'%-,%,-! (2+%1!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!9%(2!#,'%,+!(2+$461%C!Journal of the American Society for Information Science and
TechnologyC!WAH?\J!HPBBTJ!PB@PaP?B]!
E?@F! g7!d+C!I7!k1.+'+cC!f7!g4,-!4,.!^7!I2)6C!G2+!+**+3($!#*!3#,3+"(64'!.+$31%"(%#,!4,.!$+4132!"143(%3+!#,!6$+1$D! 0+,(4'!0#.+'$!4,.!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-!%,!4!34$+a&4$+.!1+4$#,%,-!$)$(+0C!Information Processing and
ManagementC!]]H?J!HPBBAJ!P@]a\B@!
EPBF! N7!Z%$4,$<%!4,.!l7!q60+1C!l+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*!(2+!&%&'%#-14"2%3!6,%/+1$+7!Z41(!?:!0+,(4'!0#.+'$!#*! .+$31%"(%#,$C!Journal of DocumentationC!VVHWJ!HPB?BJ!V]\aVVT
EP?F! M7!SDd+41C!Karl Popper!HY#6('+.-+C!i#,.#,C!?@ABJ!
EPPF! Y7!^#1/%C!An introduction to the thought of Karl PopperC!(14,$'4(+.!&)!Z7!^40%''+1C!HY#6('+.-+C!i#,.#,C! ?@@TJ!
EP\F! R7!b%32#'4$C!Z7!d6,(%,-(#,C!Z7!g%''%40$!4,.!G7!R#&1#9#'$<%C!Y+a4""14%$%,-!%,*#104(%#,!$++<%,-!&+24/%#61! %,!4!.%-%(4'!+,/%1#,0+,(!Q!,3+1$C!32+3<+1$C!1+(61,++$!4,.!(2+!'%<+C!Journal of DocumentationC!VBH?J! HPBB]J!P]a]\!
EP]F! I7!k1.+'+cC!>,/+$(%-4(%#,!#*!%,*#104(%#,!+,3#6,(+1%,-!%,!(2+!3#,(1#''+.!1+$+4132!+,/%1#,0+,(C!Information
Processing and ManagementC!]BHVJ!HPBB]J!?B?\a?BPW!
!
!
David Bawden
!""#$%&'
!
(
!
)*+#,-.&/*+&-$
!
-0
!
1$-23#%,#
!
45*$,#/
!
!
(! &(!6!/(!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!+,!!,+),/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&! 7! &7!6!/(!
! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&!
8! &8!6!/(!
! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&! !9! &9!6!/(!
! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&! :! &:!6!/(!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&!
;! &;!6!/(!
! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&! <! &<!6!/(!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!2(#'"3&!21+#$&!
=! &(!6!/7!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!,+),!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! !>! &7!6!/7!
! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (?! &8!6!/7!
! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&!
((! &9!6!/7!
! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (7! &:!6!/7!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (8! &;!6!/7!
! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&!
(9! &<!6!/7!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!&6-+#!"(#!21+#$&! (:! &(!6!/8!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!,+),!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&!
(;! &7!6!/8!
! !&4.&#,"+%!3&2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! !
(<! &8!6!/8!
!
!
N#61,4'!#*!>,*#104(%#,!I3%+,3+C!OO!HOJ!PB??C!""7!?Q?B!RS>:!?B7??TTUB?VWWW?WBV,,,,,,! ?B!
! !&4.&#,"+%!&4.+%!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! (=! &9!6!/8!
! !&4.&#,"+%!"#2)&+!"#$!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! (>! &:!6!/8!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!+,!!('!!&)"&!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! !7?! &;!6!/8!
! )+#3(*%5!+))+#$&3!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,!/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&! 7(! &<!6!/8!
! !"#$%&!"#'()*+,"(#!"#-.,/!)+#3(*%5!-(!","(#&3/!0",1!3"!).-,"7&!21+#$&!
! !!
! !