Stock returns and economically neutral behavioral variables: evidence from the Nepalese stock market

(1)

Stock returns and economically neutral

behavioral variables: evidence from the

Nepalese stock market

Joshi, Nayan and Bhattarai, Ram Chandra

(2)

!"#

$%

&'

()#

*(+#

,! ( -.

!*/

/

0#

1%&

'

*/

#

2%3*4.

&'

*/

#

5*'

.

*6/

%)7

#

,4.

+%(!%#

8 '

-#

3%#

1%9*/

%)%#

!"#

:*'

"%

#

;'<#$*-#=3*(+'*#23**'*.>?1*0*(#@'.)3(*#A )3.B

C913771D17E7179292117777123494717FF371

E74F29E19773112732237819728997G07

HI0173J87E1K17L7179247131M32997317197992987

1217117971271E77123497189732237819

7289979797717E7179N328327917791897O

291N72FF73172979OGC7FD317177P17372F

E74MF297FF373179471F29Q17791897RQ72FF7317

2979R8121F2917Q3283279RGC77FD97213217112

1272F9781238717F297727779DD12349471G

S<#S1T$U;V=TSU1

# T3%'%#.)#*#W' X.(W#'%)%*'!3#.(#3%#8.%/+# 8#6%3*4. &'*/#8.(*(!%#3*#%Y*-.(%)#3%# %88%!# 8#- +)#*(+#8%%/.(W)# (#) !"#-*'"%#'%&'()<#T3%)%#)&+.%)#*'W&%#3*# %! ( -.!*//0#(%&'*/#6%3*4. &'*/#4*'.*6/%)#Z- +#9' Y0#4*'.*6/%)[#.(8/&%(!%#3%#- +# 8# .(4%) ')\#X3.!3#.(#&'(#.(8/&%(!%#3%#) !"#'%&'()#ZA*! 6)%(#?#:*']&%'.(W\#^__[<# T3%)%#4*'.*6/%)#*'%#!*%W '.`%+#*)#*#! (.(& &)# '# 8#*#).(W/%#%4%(#Z,+-*()\#a*'!.*#?# 1 '/.\#^__b[<##,Y*-9/%)# 8#3%#! (.(& &)#4*'.*6/%#*'%#X%*3%'#Z!/ &+#! 4%'# '#)&()3.(%# *(+#%-9%'*&'%[\#)%*) (*/#*88%!.4%#+.) '+%'#Z6. '303-)[#*(+#/&(*'#!0!/%#X3./%#3*# 8#*# ).(W/%#%4%(#*'%#+*0/.W3#)*4.(W)#.-%#!3*(W%)#Z6. '303-)[\#( ()%!&/*'#3 /.+*0)#*(+# .(%'(*. (*/#) !!%'#'%)&/)<##

# T3%#)%-.(*/#X '"#.(#3.)#*)9%!#.)#3*# 8#*&(+%')#Zcdd[<#e%#8.(+)#3*#8 '#3%#V\# !/ &+#! 4%'#.)#).W(.8.!*(/0#*(+#(%W*.4%/0#! ''%/*%+#X.3#) !"#'%&'()<#f !&).(W# (#3%# 3'%%#.(+.!%)g3%#;ASh#.(+%Y\#4*/&%iX%.W3%+#.(+%Y#*(+#1j,kh:,l#%]&*/#X%.W3%+# .(+%Yg3%#+ !&-%()#3*#/%))#!/ &+#! 4%'#Z)&()3.(%[#.)#*)) !.*%+#X.3#3.W3%'#'%&'()# *(+#3%#'%&'(#+.88%'%(!%)#6%X%%(#3%#!*%W '.%)#X.3#3%#- )#!/ &+#! 4%'#*(+#3*#X.3#

>_#m%!_&'_%'_\_#;%9*'_-%(_{# 8}_{#,! ( -.}_!)\_#T'_._63&4*(#V(._4%'_)._0\_#n*_*(#:&/_._9/_%#=*-9&)\_#m*/_._9&'_\_#,i_-*._/₇_#

'*-6o(!<(%<(9

(3)

!"#!$%&"&

!!'&

"() !*+!(),,-*!"

+)."/ !

012)01130₄_!_!_!₊

!

5!

19(),,&),,6*

! "7!&

&!

5/

&

!"7&8!&8!9(),,,*

"!!

:8!&8!9(),,-*

"!"/ &"

!!5"

!+:;(+:;*)₅_!_;

%(),,0*<&==(),,0*

" 7&7+!!(),,0*

4+&%(4+"!" *

! '-₄_&

7+(%3<*

<!8 (;:!*:0!&>

3(),,.*!! /

5!"4&

!"!! !&

!5 "!

/ 3 "!"5

!/

&?(

! *!(+:;*5

!!@"!"

&!

5 A+55!

/"+555!

! +58!

5

0₅₅_!

!! ' & /& !

)₅_!_#_$_+:;_!

!;8!BCDEF&),,-

(4)

223567268926556

!"

#$"" $%"

# "&$#%'(&3

)*+,-*./+01/2,345/6*,7.08/

8"#9 :$ $$

:"# #$$#

#%;:<=>?@8:A???@B"C:3:A??1: 3 DA0&3'"%<==E&"$"!"30

# <=AD<=>=%(F2"%(F2&&<=GA

<=>=%HI!'!9%HI'6&J#'!69%K6L&&:

M"%?NA?<??&# "

"3O$"$%?NA?&

$"$%<??&"! 3"#

""$$#HI'6JK6L31_'"

" $#!P#Q"F"$:

!:##""$"$B":

"!%A #&3C#5"%<==D&

'"%<==E&"R#"#!"

$""'"#$"$ 23

O'"#$%A??E&#!"$$

$"##!

"AG!9 #<=>A<==D3

# #$"$$

!"36"

:$"$$

#""32"$""S8%A??0:

A??1&9#>!9"# "

3G_$_$_"_$_M

# "!#!""!

!:# "!"

%!N!& $%!N&

"B"# !!

0_'"_"_" _$

%"":"#$: & "% $&"# "#3"HI!S$"9$"# P Q%## &9

#! $ 3

1_T"_"_#_%_<=>EN_<=>=&₃

G_H_I_!:_:_:_!_"_:_'_!_#:_'$$:_!$₃_$

(5)

23426784942442342₃₄₇₂₃₆₈₂₃₇₂₂₆₄₂₆₇₆₄₄₇₂₄

66472482324467264234462342446726423433462346426784 4673474823777784223722364723324746

2344623723424623723423424467264337723

8724764642466426446234472722772 4674724664724 242442446726478264263462346 32372234664262276724672424278472782 647264472462662344673784642664724 22342

!3422346447637468424844472346442234647647

246484434 2446274"76878#76$%&&'()73

2642634367838244778*7672$%&&'(

632642684678+36778)32,$%&&'(6-).-/ 2642684606446142,77823$%&&%(82372472346 44284243767642746672346237887426346 234642)7846$344'(78*6344678)37$%&&'(645662

4723462342344 748727742342678724266234

468777634432446344133646442720&4642227

88764687884246472467842467628)2348

627846442346422644924887748 2872678722467226274223447234678344642887 267846723464472346442:7882234764822227 478872464422647;62234764277482464 32724878442424376774237887)48234

76446737846484887426237223438744

4482347472346456623464642347642746727

2347278872472262223464234472346442;6232343234,4

237222746377244982$8<7647877

4764(784 742348764724244234746746478374782347

456624723463484237264788488778344234

466426234487=

>?@ABCDBEFGHIJGKD@LMGNODPAIF

:74 72344272472346964724886 76746442 64476337764823722346474242446323$7323427

7224672467234278Q62442(78264263

_;6₂₃₄₃₇₆₄₄₇₆₃₇₄₆_446778!4_$_%&&0_%&&R(_77478076₉₄₆_$_%&&0

(764237223446447637466472422344 46422446726478374376846 4 264476784 26448244672643342682649424 464442 2642346282446726476446284672424467264:7234628$344%&&' 3&(6146767244262348237223464647234244486426$6426 7486472747864267887(78234746748724467264262346647 472346$348467867(234644 264723222

=₃₆₆₃₆₈₇₄₂₇_$_%&&3₉₂₄₈₁₄₂_,7_S₂₃_%&&%_3'(₃₃₂₃₇₂₂₃₄₆₄

(6)

234352676593523353734535239475537323435267

97323594733397335732593232947335495363

42324732772 43974235273973

9273297347323344395454354952362239323449765943 297359293259234499734292432!59449"#$$$

7323593 595959%9324754565234943

4354956759397373272457&3435267474752534

59932399623543753"36543739623543435495

32396349577246629"3 32395234352679467

6394563529'33393234495932324'%5'93752953

25934394"9697435959659523727739'43339 593234495933393234495924'53249"(5425)*+,-#$$.

7734/37543549552599397565939325343549552599

3232940₁₄₉₅₅₅₂₉₉₃₉₃₂₉₅₉₅₄_{6'3 675934}₇₃₄₅₃

32523479343432341$352459472343432342$3524 6535524534529732323399739273297347323

4353559973473297347323373473396349659

33697343549566346'23294346'52'343 323963737734 232942973472"52'549325973342329429739"27 544325974339532692923%'9952'3435495459 73239293955624734549475336423299639 7352'34577325332734273352223436373732 52'34653973927329594732973473234"5777347329 52'34"732373435494523233243"235649747543695973 97533645432696973552532$

73467659'475(5425)*+,-#$$.43475323639339

626/3(359!3467'3#$$77352375467655982365 32523759'43529323449352924'5324975493339 345473577736244%43695235933393234495924'532494 7543393454737354657573243497532344935'454 7396622973529733236332%93252:56439

0_;5439₇₃₉₆₃₉₆₃₃₆₅₃_39639"₇_4435495₂₃₅₃₄₇₃₃₉₇_5"₇₆₇

33949435495953"9759<=><?@>)"7673394969344A5223"(5425 B(2532"#$$0

2$_C467₆₅₃₂₅₂₃₍₅₄₂_5)*_+,-_D_"_#$$.₄₃₄₇₃₃₂₃₄₄₃₃₃₆₄_59739632_4'

(7)

234627897309772729727923

4234347427727723

3223222323374

!"#""$!6%#&'!'(')*

#894223+1,72342329$2

-%.23$%/-%34.#34.22904234222342

2732771239272344+!723+33_#42₂₂₇

2347-975274$2#42277973334.27

292493038923

6 7

3 83

9 : :

: @<;<=>? ;<=>?

A BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BCDEF

07A:33999344722332734.;<=>?:

2734.2234;<=>?:832734.2G3

#02742239472347297234272347

)733$2!273&4723467#02723

94#7923 373232"77294,H03I0,2J$2342

747734289422#7932329

327422222234297.

.233

K94K77#2-K7-LK

#-LK27227713423732947M231

39472427223434223947242

3#-LK2729347942974297772342 32320+2$2-234274#$-#03.7232+0+ 210+22343N72322970292272-LK7 2427+0+2+0+$-#347$%/-%72439732443

0942324-LK330&77234-9022#

42794297242-LK2472232

23797332_N7₄₂₃₂_O₃₂₇₂₉₄₃₂₉₇₂₃

33_-₀₀₀₂₃₂₃₂₄₂₂₇₇₃₃₇₉₃_34.

3_#₃₃₀_-29347₃₄₄₂_-29347₂₇₉₂₂₀₂₇₉₀₇₇₉₂

724323727237492347324432727233$227 97224740344922343932037 337243L22349GPG4427ML22349027247.'3 2)O23234Q9

32₍₉₇₂₃₂₃₄_-9_O₂₀₇₃₉₀₃₂₇₂₂₄₀₇₄₉₇

(8)

2346478977242344732347949287248473796

47847423474874748473232346478!7786

2383"4448#97724774874234$$4872982372

782978232346478898$$%6478749762347964776% 7&242'#92472347782978769234234

23234929449729479482378776774729447234 924#2(393924)34847248947%7&242'#

*4487284*+,-#

*+,-7897499484449.2947842(94473767294294

/0071*7720001**347979924487284484

72237229498482477979924487284247724234796

24487284994(923772493440#72347487479799 2448728424234447794*+,-78974623923474(76723728 234789747424926*+,-2'

477)4294"9848)"#

*34)"78974 6785#974234483842(44427

894923477(9248$0_*34_)"₇₈₉₇₄ 5

678#99467287427 3449#

)"2: 8287976923477(92482348(94

4 $3 ;2 < = > ?

(3484@5923429484228947277829787297237#94

483893294627787897298348972894286

A B

_C

D E F G H _I J K L M N OPQ ? R ? S 2

2 27

9T4 3 27 78 U3 U 30 ;

(3484

Q

8484422347292482323472982344V72872379 3UW031823#7

I

592344972974946

A

B

C D E F G H _? J K L M N O P R S

I &97 /430 9T0 3 9 0$43 4 2 2

(3484&972977897423728748$29T09TT9476478#8484429234

482347692346478!9724V7$8!7786$38!778637

$0_*34₇₇₍₉₂₄₈₄₈₉₉₄₉₄₇₄₂₄₄₈_3$₂_,78₃₃₄₈₂₃₄₁₈₂₃₄₈_;49₃₄₈₄_*34₇

(9)

234678292222

!"##$%&!"

" $ #! ''# !4

()**+,-.(/+/01/021.

"##$3" 4%&! &!

543"6#14157 %14818

4!''! $!498415: !''! $'4

04;0843"<&'%34 '3"4

!!""'"'"! $6!%' !$ "! '"54

=65>"##$

?+,0+@AB1. CD._F@1GDE_.. HB+I. (/JG.KBLG. H0I. H+M. (NBOIB11. P),/D101.

9"QRS T087 141T 1485 98415 04;7 9147T 5U488 !3$% U;;U U480 T4TV 1411 8411 1410 954T8 #"Q_S _U;;7 _5;4₅₅ ₀₄_1: _:4₇₁ _TV4_:0 ₉₁₄_:T ₉₅₄_5:

CD/B1>&! !$"##$#! WTU65;;0U56T1104 %&! & " !$'"686 <4'' < & #6=XY44# <$%&! !$!" %'#1 8 !$#" '!"4!"#T!" "#&&% #! !"#U :# %4!"#0 74 ##"# #<#"#%!"%&!4!!"#V 8 &34 3"4

!$!" %6#U480 %T4TV4!'

!4!" %48 1%!$434!Z '

<$##!Q#!S &"4!3"!'4

!!"!" %'"'"! $6!%' !$!" %! '"T4

!$#"#%" 5;[4! %!

0[4!4#"4:471[ '#"4TV4:0[4

#"!'%346 '###

%<#!$! $<#!$ $4!!"#"

'"'"! $6!%' !$#"

! '"U4'":4%!" !$#"4

(10)

2345648983668333318384536343688346 488362344 34648!3883624 63"10

# $# %# &# #'# #(# #)# '## '*# '+# $,# $$# $%#

-#.(

-#

-,.(

,

,.(

#

#.(

/0

12

34

56

07

58

498

4:

;<=41>40?644=6<5

@9A7564BC4;<9D=4/01234560758

# $# %# &# #'# #(# #)# '## '*# '+# $,# $$# $%# -'

-# , # ' $ * ( % + )

E

F

G

4<

8H

4E

F

G

I

;<=41>40?64=6<5

@9A7564JC4;<9D=4GD17H4G1K65

LMNO LMN

10_P₃₃₃₈₃₈₃₆₆₈₃₆₄₆₆₃₈₈₄₅₃₂₄₃₃₃₃₁₃₃₄₆₆₃₆₆₈₃₈

(11)

2 32 42 52 262 272 282 622 692 62 32 332 342 7

7 2 27 6 67 3

!"#$

%&'() %&'(

*+, -./ 37 337 347 65 75 85 225 295 25 65 635 0

07 20 207 60

1

2

3 14

(12)

23453667899676

86636635378967333933898793537855736

96853596359388794534536678967758653 !!1"9 #89$37 !!%"&53596('"5353453663898969

)

!"&44353596353

93366589347653*75385+,-,793./0_"₉₃₈₃₃₈₉₈₇₉₃₅

573686835&33553&31"2833538988958853 3893393.486633/5

# / / !

5 #6

5:)89;8) 87 _"

/ / !

5 ,3-6

5:)89;8) 87 _1"

/ / !

5 1

5:)89;8) 87 _%"

353573653637937963789<<<3.3(';/76344333939

573

3538563536658599794353453667893*7896 &19%853 3975363357835366797388358377397686773'4 6767=/0>"96749779/!353933867497793&6443679453596 795363579438677588835368839386773 8377398335533'37698674977938939789338 67497793$753458383773981&7769347396767 796749779338?63@5385379368983686

3838858.57363.79853937435398577897968

53596A35353667973393793338987935

3785573679353453667897977&379367497795378967 86773"85388358998853355391

/0₃₄₃₉₄₇₆₃₃₅₇₉₃₆₇₉₄_B?₉₄₄_C8.

D

₃₆₃_E_3363&_!!0"_F85₇_6&₃₇₅₆₅₉

353453667897844353596<B?944C8.

D

3653?363836768985367 885537898583946389335396749779333&37939835495333 583538846

/5_C363_G867₉_#_!!0"₉_G867_!!0"₅₃₈₅_.₈₆₆₆₃₇₉₄₃₃₉₃₈₉₄₈₄

(13)

23456899

3!

6"

#

%

$

'

& ()* 26+,* 3! 3-.8

2 ) $.$.$&$/0& &0.$.812/$1* &.$.3/***$&01 4 4 $.$1$3

2 $.$.$&&303 $.&0.8118$0* 4 $.$.$$3313 4 $.$1$2

3! $.&.$8&1&2 $.&0.8121$1* 4 4 4$.4$.$8$111 $.$1$2

5678992:: ::; 3!<.2=;<:. 274>?4.2 @82&//0!2&8$$0.

* :&$4=4. ** :04=4 *** :&4=4

A=::

=:=B.

2 ) & & $

()* 26+,* 3!

E%D'_FD% D% D% DC GHIJ (87KLM.;8$$2<)>;8$$1<;<

;%$<=;B:N6, 6"<

;

3!<.3B=:+::

"4::.

,3:22:B0:

.2,3:22:

28=

.O::;74P&.1$<

:&$::::

7:::: 3!

:.+:-8

:22;,3<=""

:.Q

:;<="

(14)

12345789

2!"

#

$ &% '() 15*+) 2! 2,-9.

/012345

5

#-#-#%6767 9-#-#6))).78% #-%-#%067#) #-#-##9066 :#-:#-#%909; #-#7#7

/01234<

=: #-#7#;

%-.8 8-#-.8)))%%7. :#-:#-###.#. #-#-##%8%9 #-#-##677# #-#%%# : #-##7.

#-%# %0-#-778.#.))) #-.-#.6;#;)) #-%-#%70.; :#-:#-#.;#97 #-%0%. /01234> ? ? ? ? ? ? (

3@A #-%-#;#6%7 #-#-#89%;8 #-%-#87876) #-#-#%%%8. :#-:%-#;#7%6 #-##.9

BCD2E81FF 2!"-1 G"F-1D: HI:-5 J.7%660!7%.##0GFJ.7%660 J7#.###J%.###!7%.##0-

) F%#:G:- )) F0:G: ))) F%:G:-

1FGF:+3F

17-=G:G

F:AK-21

73"FFF 2!G

:-!F:FFF

FGF 2!F-

LG:FFF

#-#.6;"GFD:F.-#;GFFF

2!F-1G

G:F:

:F:-@

2!FFF

MGFF-1AA

%0FF:-

*FFG

AGAGFFA

-=GL5+ 5(3AAA-1

(15)

234568964389595686895945246434889 8584888558858988595884!"#

$953389528968553584982946

435964%3398898859596488&4343384989

534234568965968963896'433584985342 3846 5368399642958(94898859)6389832 38462 48863894962 3846389438%8953935368943446 34538528*353596+,-

./012+$/0+

$986963534992949485935

258435538525964%339649689+5963(!##)'8383596 +5(344)5459658(34463440)59675355(344)258989

054%53%$953853449344634538525

4989484535353852(4643596353)596836498

5284353852(+,-)344364538898859

358498(488)294%33959649485935258435

5385233962464388968988949894534362

+5963(!##)596'8383596+5(344)44236898859958 358498294%3395964643

5834353596+,-538526494423898859

358498353548949894896896493568954596

58(34463440)59675359:;<(344)43436898859958

358498294%339596353596488596898859

358498294%339596+,-5385238$938943

8968953434989432 3846(84988353846) 59643494896385896

89689896855054%53%894889895%43

83449(4643)43446345385259643 53943898494844634538528946453889

!"₃₅₈₅₈₈₅₈₄₉₈₅₈₉₄₃₅₉₂₉₈₃₄₂₄₈₉₅₅₃₄₈₃

44689436345486446=25633438983>69596356('8383?

+5344)'435@5429596&53A389(3446)489598953

4335685495968853646889854983894

5895495539894%339343333534629635%9 4498334396&434355925843848945 68384943338953538245894446 4353493568925843(25964668849)5969488943 4533864596483446595%2368849

!"₈₈₄₉₄₃₄_BC₈₈₉_&53_%_'4₈_D_/₃₈₉₆₈₃₄₉₄₃₅₉₆₃₄₉₄₃₄

(16)

2343235637

68987982 !"89!8#$%&'()* +,-./01(2--38#84#5"667779!

6898038"87$95798 !"8

9!8#$%&'()*+,-./01(2-38#84#5"667779!

65987485!8$8!825!89 8:3$838"

792%;'<(+/=-'>-?*+/+@*/=-A@'+'B*@C0D

E53FE8 E89G86$#3HH792%&'()*

+,-./01(2I3$9H5:8J7599#38#84#5"667779! 3!8EK888L59#M7"97!8792%

4959!:NO1-;'<(+/=-'>-?*+/+@1238#84#5"667778P9H9:

48!8349D13HH68"8#82379H 59$83!"8#9% NO1-;'<(+/=-'>-?*+/+@10QRSTSU91

48!8349DD93HH68"8#8FF%NO1;'<(+/=-'>-?*+/+@1VQ0R9010U 9V91

4G87485!8$8!959U7#82:#8792 5

F!"89H5W:5W9#$E8$95I73X$8%-&'()*+,-./01(38#84# 5"667779!

K8FY8!88GY8!J#8!Z889

5[9H2%-&'()*+,-./01(38#84#5"667779!

K9\!8585]52897555853HH^%

&'()*+,-./01(38#84#5"667779!

W5#HE8 75!78$SK99E8$7579285

85%NO1-;'<(+/=-'>-?*+/+@1-0TQSR9DU9S

894J88X:F585^%&'()*+,-./01(38#84# 5"667779!

955Y84JY60 55"8#7983HH$868#8 9!8#%A@'+'B*@-_1`*1ab-c@@/C*'+/=-./01(deUT0

955YVE8$U9HU5U3HHF8F$7"H[59!9^%NO1 A@'+'B*@-;'<(+/=-'>-f10/=-DQ9Rb9U9

Y8!8GY8!8EG3G9:7#"858 5

E8$#:5U783:9!8#$%gB1(*@/+-A@'+'B*@-_1`*1ah-ijklR90U999

Y8!8GY8!8EG3SJ#7E798

6$#%gB1(*@/+-A@'+'B*@-_1`*1aimkdnSUSS

Y##6JG49Lo488769Y959#8#0

8!W8886#8W8 569:3HH9H859998

69:9%.Cp@O'=',*@/=-q@*1+@1-9VQDR1U1S9

Y##$[845033U7!8792%

&'()*+,-./01(38#84#5"667779!

G9:588[75#\S8579285F!"89HG98#\ 8:J5839%-&'()*+,-./01(38#84#5"667779!

8:9L3379H3"!9#9:8#797898#HH3

E9%g@r/-.Cp@O*/r(*@/-q@/+s*+/`*@/9991VU9T