• No results found

DPWH - Cost Estimation

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "DPWH - Cost Estimation"

Copied!
63
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)
(2)

Cost Estimation Process

The Cost Estimation

Process as it evolves to

specific stages of project

development.

Planning Design Procurement

Identify and Prepare Feasibility Studies and Preliminary Design Perform Detailed Design Prepare Bidding Documents Receive and Evaluate Bids

BBPEE BBDEE Estimate for the ABC

Planning Service,

(3)

Cost Estimation Process

Review/Study Design Drawings

Data Collection Field Surveys

Labor Equipment Materials Materials Sources Labor

Evaluation/processing of Data Calculation (Bill Pay Item Quantity of Quantities) Cost Estimate

Unit Price Analysis Construction Pay Items Unit Rates Maintenance Unit Rates Maintenance Activities Project Cost Maintenance Cost

(4)

Project Estimate Components BBPEE BBDEE ABC A. Direct Cost √ √ √ Materials √ √ √ Labor √ √ √ Equipment √ √ √ Dayworks √ Per DO 46 s2007

Provisional Sum √ Per DO 46 s2007

B. Indirect Cost Per DO 57 s2002 Per DO 57 s2002 Per DO 57 s2002

OCM √ √ √

Profit √ √ √

Mobilization/Demobilization √ √ √

C. VAT 12% (A+B) 12% (A+B) 12% (A+B)

D. Total Civil Works Cost A+B+C A+B+C A+B+C

E. Contingency 10% of D 10% of D 5% of D

F. Engineering Costs Per NEDA Per NEDA Detailed Engineering 4-6% (D+E)

Construction Supervision* 8-10% (D+E) 8-10% (D+E)* Administrative Cost 3.5% (D+E) 3.5% (D+E) G. Feasibility Cost (Optional for Pre-FS) 1-3% (D+E)

H. IROW Acquisition Cost √ √

I. Total Estimated Project Cost D+E+F+G+H D+E+F+G+H D+E

Project Estimation Phase

(5)

•  Work type – proposed improvement works of the project

•  Location of the project – includes terrain types and

embankment and aggregate material sources

•  Design plans and specification – working drawings and

DPWH Standard Specifications Vol. II, Ed. 2004

•  Equipment rental rates – ACEL Guidebook, ed. 22, yr.

2003

•  Labor rates and fringe benefits – DOLE, Regional Wage

Board, SSS, Philhealth, Pag-Ibig, & bonus

•  Construction Materials List and Material Sources Map

•  DPWH Department Orders – DOs relevant to cost

estimation

•  NEDA Circular – Circular/memo relevant to cost

estimation

(6)

Unit Price Analysis

Two Main Parts:

•  Direct Cost

•  Labor

•  Materials

•  Equipment

•  Indirect Cost

(% of Direct Cost as defined in DO 57)

•  OCM (overhead, contingency & miscellaneous)

•  profit

(7)

Unit Price Analysis

Elements of the Direct Cost

•  Labor

•  basic wage

•  fringe benefits

•  bonuses

•  social security & other social charges

•  Equipment

•  bare hourly & rental operating cost

•  fuels & lubricants

•  repairs & maintenance

•  labor

•  Materials

•  labor

•  equipment

processing & transport

(8)

Unit Price Analysis

Labor Categories

Labor Category

Labor Index

1.  Foreman, construction

2.  Leadman

3.  Operator, Heavy

4.  Operator, Light

5.  Labor, Highly Skilled

6.  Driver

7.  Labor, Skilled

8.  Labor, Unskilled

1.80

1.65

1.50

1.40

1.40

1.30

1.30

1.00

(9)

Basic Labor Rates Calculation

•  Monthly Wages based on 314 days per year, 8 hours per day (Basic Daily

Wage x (314/12))

•  Leave, vacation and sick = Basic Monthly Pay / 12

•  Bonus, 13th Month Pay = Basic Monthly Pay / 12

•  SSS, Medicare, Employer's Compensation = Amount Representing

Employer's Contribution, Graduated Scale

•  Pag-ibig, Employer's Compensation = Amount Representing Employer's

Contribution, (2% of Basic Monthly Wage or P100 max.)

•  Rate per Hour = Total rate per month x (12/314/8)

(10)

Unit Price Analysis

Take the value of non-agricultural sector

(11)

Unit Price Analysis

Take the values under the column of total monthly contributions in reference with range of compensation

(12)

Unit Price Analysis

Take the values under the column of total monthly contributions

(13)
(14)

Equipment Category Sample Equipments • Earthmoving equipment • Compaction equipment • Lifting equipment • Excavating equipment • Foundation equipment • Asphalting equipment • Concreting equipment • Hauling equipment • Air equipment • Pumping equipment

• Power generating equipment • Shop equipment

• Special support equipment • Miscellaneous equipment • Plants

• Offshore equipment

• Cable stringing equipment • Others

–  wheel loader, grader, tractor dozer – vibratory steel drum, plate compactor – cranes, forklifts

– backhoe, trenchers

– pile vibratory driver, pile hammer, drill rig – asphalt paver/finisher, asphalt distributor – paver/finisher, mixer, transit mixer

– dump truck, cargo truck, trailer

– compressor, pneumatic breakers handheld – submersible pump, diaphragm pump

– generator set

– welding machine, shop machine – truck water wagon/pump

– joint sealer, rebar cutter/bender

– asphalt concrete plant, concrete batching plant – dredger, crane barge, tugboat

– cable tensioner/puller, splicing machine – chip spreader, power broom

(15)

Equipment Unit Rate Analysis

Basic Calculation

•  Bare Month Rental – Bare monthly rate ÷ 200h/mo.

•  Repair & Miscellaneous

• 

Repair - 6.3% of Bare Rental

• 

Spare Parts – 5.1% of Bare Rental

• 

Miscellaneous – 0.6% of Bare Rental

•  Fuel

• 

Fuel – Price/lit. x HP x 0.1514

• 

Oil & Lubricant – Price/lit. x HP x 0.003

•  Labor

• 

Operator or driver – Labor rate/hr

(16)

Unit Price Analysis

Sample calculation of

adjusted equipment

rates in spreadsheet

(17)

Materials Category Sample Materials •  Commercial Materials

•  Contractor’s processed materials

–  Portland Cement

–  Reinforcing Steel Bars (RSB or Rebars) –  Lumber

–  Plywood –  Tie Wire

–  Structural Steel

–  Common Wire Nails (CWN) assorted sizes –  Emulsified Asphalt (SS-1)

–  Cut-Back Asphalt (MC-70/MC-250) –  Asphalt Cement Penetration 85/100 –  Joint Sealer

–  Reflective Paints

–  Metal Beam Guard Rails, –  Guard End Pieces

–  Reflective Pavement Stud (raised or low profile) –  Fuel (Diesel/gasoline/premium gasoline

–  Lubricants

–  Reinforced Concrete Pipe Culvert (RCPC) –  Base/Subbased Courses

(18)

Unit Price Analysis

Sample of contractor’s process

materials

(19)

Unit Price Analysis

Hauling Unit Rate Analysis

•  Basic Consideration

–  Terrain type

–  Road condition

–  Dump truck capacity

–  Selection of loader capacity, output, bucket fill factor and operating

factor (to estimate loader production rate)

–  Material type

•  Cycle time

•  Loader

– Load bucket and shift gears

– Turn and dump the load

– Travel distance and time from dumping to loading position and return to

the loading position

Total Cycle T

(20)

Hauling Unit Rate Analysis (cont.)

•  Cycle time

•  Dump Truck

– Average hauling distance

– Terrain type

– Loading time

– Loaded travel time

– Initial traveled distance during acceleration

– Succeeding traveled distance at an average speed

– Final speed at a distance until it stops

– Unload and maneuver

– Return empty

– Same as loaded but at a greater speed

– Allowance for delay

•  Number of dump truck trips, n

Unit Price Analysis

Total Cycle

T

ime,

(21)

Unit Price Analysis

Hauling Unit Rate Analysis (cont.)

•  Number of dump trucks

•  Average hauling output

•  Total hauling cost per hour

– Equipment

1 – Wheel loader, ___ m

3

/hr --- _____ P/hr

N – Dump trucks, ___ m

3

--- _____ P/hr

– Labor

1 – Leadman, rate --- _____ P/hr

2 – Laborers, rate --- _____ P/hr

Total Cost per hour _____ P/hr

(22)

Sample of hauling cost analysis using spreadsheet

(23)

Production Rate Derivation of a Pay Item

(24)

Unit Price Analysis

Elements of the Indirect Cost

•  Profit – contractor’s profit

•  Overhead Expenses

• 

Office Expenses (office equipment and supplies)

• 

Engineering and Administrative Cost

• 

Transportation allowances

• 

Contractor’s All Risk Insurance

• 

Premiums on Bid Security and Performance Security

• 

Premium/charges/fees on credit lines

•  Contingencies

•  Miscellaneous Expenses

• 

Laboratory Tests

• 

Other expenses

(25)

Estimated

Direct Cost

(EDC)

Indirect Cost % for OCM

and Profit (Maximum

Ranges)

% Cost for

Mob/Demob

(Maximum)

Total

Maximum

Indirect

Cost % for

OCM, Profit

and Mob/

Demob

OCM (% of

EDC)

Profit (% of

EDC)

Up to P1Million

13

15

1

29

Above P1M to

P5M

12

14

1

27

Above P5M to

P10M

12

13

1

26

Above P10M to

P20M

11

12

1

24

Above 20M to

P50M

11

11

1

23

Above P50M

10

10

1

21

Unit Price Analysis

(26)

Unit Price Analysis

Cost Currency Components:

•  Foreign Cost Component

• 

imported equipment & spare parts

• 

foreign currency component of locally goods

• 

& services

• 

wages of expatriate personnel

• 

foreign overheads & profits

•  Local Cost Component

• 

local materials

• 

equipment & supplies

• 

wages, local supervision

• 

transport & freight

• 

overhead & profits

•  Tax Component

(27)

Cost Component of Selected Construction Items

Unit Price Analysis

Description

Components

Foreign Local Tax (%) (%) (%) Heavy Equipment Light Equipment Reinforcing Steel Structural Steel Lumber Asphalt Cement Diesel fuel Engine oil Tires

Imported Miscellaneous Materials

Locally Produced Miscellaneous Materials Skilled Foreign Labor

Unskilled Labor Royalty 68 65 54 85 33 76 40 60 60 47 64 17 65 0 0 10 15 35 4 57 2 45 13 13 43 7 69 25 90 90 22 20 11 11 10 22 15 27 27 10 29 14 10 10 10

(28)

Quantity Calculations for Pay Items Bill of Quantities

Pointers in the conduct of quantity calculations:

•  Based on the design plans and specifications

•  Units of measurement are all in metric based on

DPWH Standard Specifications.

•  Solid mensuration is extensively used and other

mathematical formulae.

•  Used of computer softwares in calculations.

•  Used of calculators (simple or scientific)

•  Conversion factors

•  Rates of application of materials such as, liquified

asphalt materials, paints, etc.

(29)

Unit Price Analysis

Sample Formula of Plane Shapes & Figures

Area of a Triangle

A = ½ x base x height = ½ (bh)

Perimeter of a Triangle

P = side1 + side2 + side3

Area of a Parallelogram A = ½ x base x height = ½ (bh) Perimeter of a Parallelogram P = 2a + 2b Area of a Rectangle A = width x length = (wl) Perimeter of a Rectangle P = 2(lwidth) + 2(length) = 2(w) + 2(l) Area of a Circle A = πr2 Circumference of a Circle C = 2πr = πD π = 3.14 159

(30)

Sample Formula of Solid Geometric Figures

Unit Price Analysis

Volume of Rectangular Solid

V = abc Surface Area SA = 2(ab + ac + bc) Volume of Cube V = a3 Surface Area SA = 6a2 Volume of Sphere V = 4/3 πr3 Surface Area SA = 4πr2

Volume of Circular Cone

V = 1/3 πr2h

Surface Area

SA = πr2 + πrl

Volume of Circular Cylinder

V = πr2h or πD2 ÷ 4

Surface Area

(31)

Unit Price Analysis

(32)

●  Estimating the work output of a piece of equipment is determined in 2 ways:

•  Using work output formula based on the cycle of operation and other factors which controlled production.

•  Using tables based on past experiences of average work output under varying conditions for different operations.

●  To calculate earthmoving equipment consider the volume changes in earth caused by handling. These volume changes have the following terms, to wit:

•  Swell – increase in volume of earth that results when it is dug from its natural position. •  Shrinkage – decrease in volume of earth when compacted.

•  Loose yards – volume of earth after it has been removed from its natural location and swell has taken place.

•  In-place yards – volume of earth in its natural location before handling.

•  Compacted yards – volume of earth that has been properly compacted in embankment on fill.

●  Basis of calculations for excavation and fill

•  Loose yards – are used to express the carrying capacity of earth moving equipment.

•  In-place yards – are converted to compacted yards to determine the volume of materials in a fill that will be realized from a given amount of materials in its natural location.

•  In-place yards – are converted to loose yards to determine the amount of earth moving equipment required to handle the materials.

•  The output of equipment in loose yards must be converted to compacted yards to determine the final volume of fill

Methods of Estimating Work Output

(33)

1.0 m3 in natural condition (in-place yards) 1.25 m3 after digging (loose yards) 0.9 m3 after compaction (compacted yards)

Volume Changes in Common Earth Caused by Handling

Bowl Capacity of Dozer

Illustrations of Soil Handling

(34)

Formula for Earthmoving Equipment Work Output

where:

Q = bowl capacity in loose cubic meters

f = soil conversion factor

60 = minutes per hour

E = efficiency factor

Cm = total cycle time in minutes

The working capacity of construction equipment is expressed by

the work practically done by the operation of equipment per unit

time ( 1 hour or day)

(35)

Conversion Factors, f

Soil Type Present Condition

Converted to

In-place Loose Compacted Sand Common Earth Clay In-place Loose Compacted In-place Loose Compacted In-place Loose Compacted 1.00 0.90 1.05 1.00 0.80 1.11 1.00 0.70 1.11 1.11 1.00 1.17 1.25 1.00 1.39 1.43 1.00 1.59 0.95 0.86 1.00 0.90 0.72 1.00 0.93 0.63 1.00 Tractor Model Bulldozer Angle Dozer

D4 D6 D7 D8 1.25 m3 1.44 m3 2.20 m3 2.40 m3 1.82 m3 2.01 m3 2.58 m3 2.97 m3

Bowl Capacity of Dozers (loose yards)

Unit Price Analysis

(36)

Sample Calculation for Work Output

Given: Average haul distance one way – 30 m

Soil type - common earth Efficiency factor (E) - 80%

Speed - 2.5 kph

Required: Determine in place cubic meters moved per hour if D7 tractor dozer is to be used. Solution:

Step 1. From conversion factor table, the soil conversion factor (f), soil type common earth loose to in-place, f = 0.80

From dozer bowl capacity table, D7 tractor dozer, Q = 2.2 m3

Step 2. Determine fixed time

@ 2 gear shift @ 10 sec. per shift = 20 sec = 0.33 min Step 3. Determine variable time

Travel forward 30 m @ 2.5 kph

Travel backward 30 m @ 5.0 kph

Step 4. Add fixed and variable time

Total cycle time, Cm = 0.33 + 0.72 + 0.36 = 1.41 min. Step 5. Substitute in work output formula

(37)

Unit Price Analysis

Sample Typical Cross-Section of Drainage Structures

Sample Quantity Calculation for Volume of Excavation:

Sample: Given a RCPC 1220mmØ and a length of 5.0 meters, compute volume of excavation. Solution: Size of excavation as given from the above drawings for 1220mmØ:

width = 1.60m, height = 2.0 m, length = 5.0 m

Volume = w x h x l = 1.6 x 2 x 5 = 16 m3 compacted volume (stated in the plans)

Applying the soil conversion factor, common earth from compacted to loose, use factor, f = 1.39 the excavated loose volume = 16 x 1.39 = 22.24 m3

(38)

Volume of Backfill and Bedding Materials:

Sample: Using the same sample, calculate backfill and bedding materials Solution: Size of excavation as given from the above drawings for 1220mmØ: width = 1.60m, height = 2.0 m, length = 5.0 m

Volume of trench = w x h x l = 1.6 x 2 x 5 = 16 m3

Volume of bedding materials at compacted state, using thickness of 15cm = 1.6 x 0.15 x 5 = 1.2 m3

Using soil conversion factor, compacted to loose, f = 1.17

Volume of bedding materials required to purchase = 1.2 x 1.17 = 1.404m3

Volume of backfill = Voltrench – (VolRCPC + Volbedding) = 16 – (7.371+1.2) = 7.429 m3

Applying conversion factor, compacted to loose, f = 1.39 Volume of backfill required = 7.429 x 1.39 = 10.326 m3

Sample Quantity Calculation

(39)

Composition and Strength of Concrete for Use in Structures

This composition of concrete is used for concrete batching plant.

(40)

Mixture

Class of

Concrete

Proportion Cement

in Bags

Sand

cu. m.

Gravel

cu. m.

AA

A

B

C

1:1½:3

1:2:4

1:2½:5

1:3:6

12.0

9.0

7.5

6.0

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

1.0

1.0

1.0

1.0

Concrete Proportion

This concrete proportion is used for manual mix.

(41)

Mixture

Class of

Concrete

Proportion

Cement

in Bags

40 kgs.

Sand

cu. m.

A

B

C

D

1:2

1:3

1:4

1:5

18.0

12.0

9.0

7.5

1.0

1.0

1.0

1.0

Cement and Sand Proportion for Mortar and Plastering

Unit Price Analysis

Sample Calculation:

Given: Volume = 10 m3 of mortar, use class A

Solution: Refer to the above table

Cement = 10 x 18 = 180 bags Sand = 10 x 1.0 = 10 m3

(42)

Sample Calculation for Asphalt Concrete Pavement:

Given: Carriageway width = 6.7m, Length = 1 km., thickness = 50cm, use 301(1) - MC-70 Cut-Back Asphalt

Solution:

Determine Item 301(1) - Bituminous Prime Coat

Determine Item 310 – Bituminous Concrete Surface Course, Hot-Laid (AC – Asphalt Concrete)

The derived quantities are then summarized in the bill of quantities and subsequently, manually entered in the estimated construction cost spreadsheet which are multiplied by the unit prices to come up with total cost of that item and summed up all the pay items to calculate the total direct cost. After which, indirect cost is applied to determined the total estimated project cost.

(43)

Unit Price Analysis

Item Number

Description

Unit

Quantity

100(1)

102(1)

102(2)

103(3)

103(6)

104(1)

105(1)

105(3)

200

201

301(1)

310

500(1)

Clearing and Grubbing

Unsuitable Excavation

Surplus Common Excavation

Foundation Fill

Pipe Culverts and Drainage Excavation

Embankment

Subgrade Preparation (Common Material)

Subgrade Preparation (Unsuitable Material)

Aggregate Subbase Course

Aggregate Base Course

Bituminous Prime (MC-70 Cut-Back Asphalt)

Bituminous Concrete Surface Course, Hot-Laid

RCPC 610mmØ

ha.

m

3

m

3

m

3

m

3

m

3

m

2

m

2

m

3

m

3

ton

m

2

l.m.

20

1,000

11,000

2,000

1,858

7,500

3,000

5,000

10,455

12,156

30,780

5,689

3,105

(44)

Sample of unit

price analysis in

spreadsheet

(45)

Unit Price Analysis

(46)

Unit Price Analysis

(47)

Unit Price Analysis

(48)

Unit Price Analysis

(49)

Unit Price Analysis

(50)

Maintenance Cost

Highway Maintenance

- is defined as the act of preserving and keeping each

highway type of highway as nearly as possible in its

original conditions as constructed or as subsequently

improved. It does not include rehabilitation, betterment

and improvement

Two calculation methods for maintenance cost

- EMK (Equivalent Maintenance Kilometrage)

- Traffic Dependent Method

(51)

Two Categories:

•  Routine Maintenance

• 

vegetation control

• 

cleaning and repairing culverts

• 

cleaning ditches

• 

cleaning and repairing traffic signs

• 

climatic loss of gravel on shoulder

•  Periodic Maintenance

• 

road surface repairs

• 

resurfacing

• 

shoulder repair & resurfacing

General Cost

(52)

Maintenance Cost

EMK Factors

Source: BOM/ DPWH 0 AADT AADT Basic Formula: Road:

MCR = EMKbudget x Ft x Fw x Length where:

MCR = maintenance cost for road EMKbudget = annual allocation Ft = factor for surface type

Fw = factor for carriageway width

Length = in kilometer Bridge:

MCB = EMKbudget xFb x Length where:

MCB = maintenance cost for bridge

EMKbudget = annual allocation Fb = factor for bridge type Length = in meter

(53)

Traffic Dependent Method

Traffic volume in terms of vehicle units:

•  Light vehicles → 0.4 vehicle units

•  Buses → 2.5 vehicle units

•  Trucks → 3.0 vehicle units

(54)

Maintenance Cost

Basic assumptions in calculating routine maintenance unit rates : •  Vegetation Control

•  0.5 ha/km/year •  400 m2/crew day •  2 - knapsack movers •  2 - unskilled laborers

•  Cleaning and Repair of Culverts

•  1 – 4 number units/day/km •  1 – dump truck

•  3 – unskilled laborers •  Materials

•  Replace, Clean and Repair Traffic Signs

•  2 – 5 units repaired, repainted or replace daily •  1 – pick-up vehicle

•  Materials

•  Clearing Side Ditches

•  40 – 1000 l.m./day (half by grader and half by hand or manual) •  1 – grader

•  3 – unskilled laborers

(55)

Maintenance Cost

Periodic Maintenance

•  Road Surface Repair

• 

Regravelling gravel road and gravel shoulder

• 

Grading & reshaping gravel road

• 

Joint & crack sealing for PCCP

• 

Pothole repair (spot regravel) for gravel road

• 

Patch potholes for ACP

• 

Crack sealing for ACP

• 

Edge break for ACP

•  Resurfacing

• 

Asphalt Concrete Overlay

•  Shoulder Repair & Resurfacing

• 

Regravelling

• 

Grading and reshaping

(56)

Maintenance Cost

Sample of routine maintenance unit price analysis

(57)

Maintenance Cost

(58)

Maintenance Cost

General Formula for Maintenance Cost Calculations

•  Routine Maintenance (peso/km)

–  Maintenance Task = Qtytable x Lshoulder x W x 365 days x unit rateactivity –  General Cost

•  Periodic Maintenance (peso-vehicle unit/km)

–  Maintenance Task = (Qtytable x L x W x 365 days x unit rateactivity) ÷ Frequencyvehicle where:

L = length in meters W = width in meters

Qtytable = Periodic Maintenance Task Table unit rateactivity = maintenance unit price analysis

Frequency = benchmark of traffic volume in terms of v.u. as shown in Periodic Maintenance Task Table

(59)

Maintenance Cost

Routine Maintenance Unit Cost

Road Segment Economic Financial

a.  Vegetation control

b.  Cleaning and repair culverts

c.  Replace, clean and repair traffic signs d.  Clearing side ditches

P 5,312.58/km 4,880.19/km 5,384.64/km 10,813.92/km P 6,498.57/km 7,055.90/km 6,667.53/km 13,250.68/km Total per annum P 26,391.34/km P 33,472.67/km

Routine Maintenance Unit Cost

Bridge Segment Economic Financial

a.  Concrete bridge b.  Steel bridge

P 568.79/l.m. 3,714.14/l.m.

P 721.41/l.m. 4,710.72/l.m.

(60)

Maintenance Cost

Maintenance Tasks Unit Cost

Economic Financial 1.  Gravel ( Surface )

2.  Regrade and Reshape a.  Carriageway b.  Shoulder

3.  AC Resurfacing ( 3 cm.) 4.  AC Overlay ( 5 cm. )

5.  Replacement of Failed Bay a.  t = 230 mm

b.  t = 200 mm

6.  Repair of Cracks/Joints 7.  Patching and Pothole Repair

a.  Pothole Repair ( Gravel ) b.  Pothole Repair (AC)

c.  Sealing and Patching (AC) 8.  Road Stripping (painted lines)

P 481.87/m3 5.14/m2 15.41/m2 94.36/m2 135.51/m2 2,527.25/m2 2,197.69/m2 18,066.78/m2 498.56/m3 494.06/m2 510.81/m2 48.53/m P 579.45/m3 6.29/m2 18.87/m2 113.28/m2 162.25/m2 3,089.00/m2 2,686.20/m2 22,123.42/m2 598.08/m3 597.05/m2 617.50/m2 57.48/m

(61)

Summary of Maintenance Costs

Road Type Maintenance Category

Routine Periodic

Economic Financial Economic Financial Gravel Roads (5.0m roadway)

AC with gravel shoulders a.  0.5+6.1+0.5 b.  1.0+6.1+1.0 c.  1.5+6.1+1.5 d.  3.0+6.7+3.0 PCC with gravel shoulders

a.  0.5+6.1+0.5 t = 230 mm t = 200 mm b. 1.0+6.1+1.0 t = 230 mm t = 200 mm c. 1.5+6.1+1.5 t = 230 mm t = 200 mm d. 3.0+6.7+3.0 t = 230 mm t = 200 mm 49,521.08 31,210.03 36,028.73 40,847.42 55,303.51 31,210.03 31,210.03 36,028.73 36,028.73 40,847.42 40,847.42 55,303.51 55,303.51 61,286.05 39,267.13 45,061.58 50,856.03 68,239.39 39,267.13 39,267.13 45,061.58 45,061.58 50,856.03 50,856.03 68,239.39 68,239.39 737.36a 80.05a 100.55a 121.06a 186.01a 62.77a 62.12a 83.27a 82.62a 103.77a 103.12a 166.34a 165.69a 896.59a 96.33a 121.40a 146.47a 225.81a 75.81a 75.01a 100.88a 100.08a 125.95a 125.15a 202.43a 201.63a

Maintenance Cost

Sample of Summary Maintenance Cost

(62)

Sample of Summary of

Work Unit Cost used

(63)

References

Related documents