VOLUME 71
#{149}
JUNE 1983#{149} NUMBER 6Pediatrics
Croup:
An I 1-Year
Study
in a Pediatric
Practice
Floyd
W. Denny,
MD, Thomas
F. Murphy,
MD, Wallace
A. Clyde,
Jr,
MD, Albert
M. Collier,
MD, and Frederick
W. Henderson,
MD
In collaboration with R. S. Senior, MD, C. I. Sheafter, MD, W. G. Conley III, MD, and R. M. Christian, MD
From the Department of Pediatrics, University of North Carolina School of Medicine, Chapel Hill
ABSTRACT. The etiology and epidemiology ofcroup were
studied in a pediatric group practice over an 11-year period, 1964 to 1975. Croup was diagnosed in 951
in-stances in 6,165 cases of lower respiratory tract infection (LRI) studied. As census figures of the practice clientele were available, attack rates were calculated. The mci-dence of total LRI was highest in the first year of life. In contrast, the attack rate for croup was highest in the second year of life; the rate declined gradually after that age. Croup was not diagnosed in the first month of life. Boys were 1.43 times more likely to develop croup than were girls. Three hundred sixty agents were isolated from the 951 croup cases. The parainfluenza viruses accounted for 74.2% of all isolates; 65% of the parainfluenza isolates were classified as parainfluenza virus type 1. Respiratory syncytial virus, influenza viruses A and B, and Myco-plasma pneumoniae were the only other agents isolated in appreciable numbers. The propensity of various agents to produce croup symptoms in children with LRI due to specific microorganisms was 58% for parainfluenzae type 1, 60% for parainfluenzae type 2, and 29% for parainflu-enzae type 3; similar figures for the other agents varied from 5% to 16%. The role of the various agents in the etiology of croup varied with patient age and depended on the propensity of the agent to produce the croup syndrome and the frequency of isolation of the agent at that age. The parainfluenza viruses were the most impor-tant croup agents at all ages; respiratory syncytial virus caused croup in children less than 5 years of age whereas
Received for publication June 14, 1982; accepted Nov 2, 1982. Reprint requests to (F.W.D.) 535 Burnett-Womack Clinical Sciences Building, 229-H, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27514.
PEDIATRICS (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright © 1983 by the
American Academy of Pediatrics.
the influenza viruses and M pneumoniae were significant causes of croup only in children more than 5 to 6 years old. Croup occurred predominately in late fall and early winter, times when the parainfluenza viruses, especially type 1, occurred most frequently. The epidemiology of croup differs from that of bronchiolitis, pneumonia, and tracheobronchitis; knowledge of this should be helpful to the clinician caring for children with LRI. Pediatrics
1983:71:871-876;
croup, lower respiratory tract infection,parainfluenza virus.
Croup is one of the common manifestations of infection of the lower respiratory tract in children. It is a syndrome characterized by varying degrees of inspiratory stridor, cough, and hoarseness
re-suiting from obstruction in the region of the larnyx. The cause is generally considered to be a respiratory
virus, and parainfluenza virus type 1 is the agent
most frequently implicated. Most reported studies on the characteristics of croup have been from hospitalized patients and have consisted of
epide-miologic
and
clinical
descriptions
of
infections
3O
24 w
>-z
iLl
8
-I I 0
0 0 2
H
I
I
AGE
Fig 1. Age- and sex-specific attack rates of total lower
respiratory tract illness (LRI) and croup in pediatric group practice, Chapel Hill, NC, 1964 to 1975.
TABLE 1. Incidence of Croup by Patient Age and Sex,
Chapel Hill, NC, 1964 to 1975
adding
a
new dimension to our knowledge of theepidemiology of croup.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was performed between July 1964 and
June 1975 in the only private practice of pediatrics
in Chapel Hill, NC. All children seen in the practice
from
birth
to 15 years of age with lower respiratoryinfections (LRI) were admitted to the study; the
specific criteria for characterization of these
ill-nesses have been described.1 Those cases
diagnosed
as croup, which consisted of hoarseness and a
bark-ing cough, with or without inspiratory stridor, are
included in the present report. Chest
roentgeno-grams and blood counts were done as clinically
indicated and are not included as a part of this
report. Blood was not drawn for serologic studies.
After parental consent was obtained, clinical and
epidemiologic data were obtained and the
orophar-ynx was cultured for viruses and mycoplasmas.
Detailed descriptions of the data collected, the
methods used to determine the practice census, and the techniques employed to isolate and identify
viruses and mycoplasmas have been published
pre-viously.2
RESULTS
From 1964 to 1975 the pediatric practice
in-creased from two pediatricians caring for 3,500 children to four pediatricians caring for 6,500
chil-dren. During the 11 years of the study, 6,165 cases of lower respiratory tract infection were investi-gated, of which 951 were diagnosed as croup. These cases form the basis for this report. The 951 epi-sodes were seen in 903 children or 1.05 episodes per child. Fever was present in 82.55% of cases. Twelve or 1.26% of the patients required hospitalization; the ages of the hospitalized children ranged from 7 to 50 months with an average age of 21 months.
Croup was the sole diagnosis in 93.7% of the cases. Eighteen children (1.9%) had associated tracheo-bronchitis; 29 (3.0%) also had wheezing and 13 (1.4%) had pneumonia.
Attack
Rates by Age and SexThe age- and sex-specific attack rates of total
lower respiratory tract illness and croup in the
practice are shown in Fig 1. The incidence of total
LRI was highest during the first year of life; the
rate in the second 6 months was slightly higher
than that in the first 6 months. In contrast, the
attack rate for croup was highest in the second year
of life, 4.7/100 children per year, having risen from
2.4/100 children per year during the first 6 months.
Croup was not diagnosed in children in the first
month of life; there were six cases (1.50/100
chil-r-1-r-1
TOTAL LRicou
JI a t i --- . ..
0- 6- -2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6 6-9 9-12 12-15
6
2MONThSI YEARS I
Age (yr) Incidence/100 Chil-then/yr (M/F)
Incidence by Sex (M#{247}F)
0-#{189}
#{189}-i
1-2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6 >6
2.76/2.01
4.95/2.86
5.60/3.66 3.55/2.63 2.55/1.60 1.69/1.16 1.15/0.92 0.47/0.44
1.37
1.73
1.53 1.35 1.59 1.46 1.25 1.07
All ages 1.82/1.27 1.43
dren per year) in the second month and 11 cases
(2.76/100 children per year) in the third month.
After the second year, the rate decreased gradually
so that after 6 years of age it was only 0.46/100
children per year. These incidence figures for LRI
and croup reflect the changing proportion of LRI due to croup at various ages. In children less than
6 months of age, 15% of LRI was diagnosed as
croup; from age 1 to 2 years the figure was 24%; between ages 2 to 6 years the percentage fell
grad-ually, and after 6 years of age only 9% of LRIs were
classified as croup.
As is shown in Fig 1 croup was predominately a
disease of male children. The age-specific relative
risk of boys as compared with girls is
shown
inTable 1. Overall, boys were 1.43 times more likely
to develop croup than girls. Between the ages of 6
and 12 months, boys were at greatest risk, 1.73
times greater than girls.
The etiologic agents recovered from children with
croup during the study are shown in Table 2.
A
total of 360 agents were recovered from 358
pa-tients; two children with parainfluenzae type 1
in-fections were also infected with Mycoplasrna
pneu-moniae. The overall isolation rate was 37.6%; this
TABLE 3. Distribution of Principal Agents Recovered from Children with Croup Patient Age (yr) Total Cases of Croup Cases of Croup with Isolates
Parainfluenza Virus* Respiratory
Syncytial Vis*
Influenza Viruses A and B*
Mycoplasma
pneumoniae*
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3
0-1 1-2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6 >6 169 25i 162 114 71 48 i36 53 91 72 51 29 24 40
24 (45) 4 (8) 6 (11)
34 (37) 7 (8) 24 (26)
44 (61) 2 (3) 14 (19)
29 (57) 4 (8) 6 (12)
15 (52) 6 (21) 3 (10)
10 (42) 4 (17) 7 (29)
17 (43) 4 (10) 3 (8)
9 (17) 6 (7) 11 (15) 6 (12) 4 (14) 0 0 4 (8) 5 (5) 0 3 (6) 1 (3) 3 (13) 9 (23) 1 (2) 5 (5) 1 (1) 1 (2) 0 0 5 (13)
All ages 951 360 173 (48) 31 (9) 63 (18) 36 (10) 25 (7) 13 (4)
* Values are number of isolates; percent of cases of croup with isolates is shown in parentheses.
TABLE 4. Occurrence
NC, 1964 to 1975*
of Croup in Children with Lower Respiratory Illnesses Due to Certain Agents, Chapel Hill,
. .
Parainfluenza Virus Respiratory. .
Syncytial Virus
Influenza Viruses
A and B
Mycoplasma
.
pneumoniae
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3
Patient Age (yr) No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % No. %
0-1 i-2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6 >6 42 55 65 44 30 16 49 57 62 68 66 50 63 35 6 66 9 78 6 33 8 50 7 86 5 80 11 36 47 47 36 22 21 19 26 13 51 39 27 15 37 12 91 10 79 8 71 15 42 14 30 13 15 0 27 0 13 31 11 45 10 0 18 17 11 9 18 22 78 12 5 20 12 42 12 8 17 6 15 0 19 0 162 3
All ages 301 58 52 60 218 29 355 10 159 16 242 5
* Values are number of total lower respiratory tract illnesses due to agent and percent of illnesses associated with
croup.
29%, in children less than 1 year and more than 6 years of age, respectively. Between these age
ex-tremes the isolation rate varied from 36% to 51% and was highest in the age group 5 to 6 years. The marked association of the parainfluenza viruses, especially type 1, with croup is reflected in these figures. This group of myxoviruses accounted for
74.2% of all isolates from our croup cases. The
smaller roles of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), influenza viruses types A and B, and Mpneumoniae
are shown clearly. The small number of other agents isolated (19) emphasizes that croup is caused predominately by a relatively small group of respi-ratory agents.
TABLE 2. Etiologic Agents with Croup, Chapel Hill, NC,
Recovered from 1964 to 1975
Children
No. % Total
Parainfluenza virus type 1 Parainfluenza virus type 3 Respiratory syncytial virus Parainfluenza virus type 2
Influenza virus type A
Mycoplasma pneumoniae Influenza virus type B Miscellaneous viruses 173 63 36 31 13 13 12 19 48.1 17.5 10.0 8.6 3.6 3.6 3.3 5.3
Total 360 100
The
role of the
various agents in the etiology of croup varied with patient age. The distribution of the principal agents recovered from children ofdifferent ages is shown in Table 3. The
parainflu-enza viruses were the predominant agents at all
ages, and there was little difference between age groups. In contrast, RSV caused croup in children less than 5 years of age but not in older children
whereas influenza viruses A and B and M
pneu-moniae were significant causes of croup only in
children more than 5 or 6 years old.
The propensity of the various agents to cause croup in children of different ages is shown in Table
4. In all children with LRI due to parainfluenzae
type 1, 58% had croup and this varied little by age.
Parainfluenzae type 2 was equally likely to cause croup in infected children of all ages. Only 29% of children with parainfluenzae type 3 infections had croup, again with little age variation. Infections
with RSV, influenza viruses A and B and M
pneu-moniae were much less likely to cause croup; even
though RSV and M pneumoniae were common
causes of LRI, they were relatively unimportant causes of croup.
Epidemic and Seasonal Occurrence
U)
Ld
I-.
-J
0U)
Li.
0LU
z
6-A Paroinfluenza virus type I
0-0
Porainfluenza vwuS type 2 o-o Parainfluenza virus type 3.- -. Respirotory syncyticl virus
U)
LU
U)
20
Li.
0
100
LU
80
z
60
40
20
July Sept. Nov. Jan. March May
MONTH
Fig 2. Prevalence of cases of croup by month of
occur-rence in pediatric group practice.
I I I I I I I I I I I I
month of the year during the 1 1-year study is shown
in Fig 2. There
was a dramatic
increase
of croup
cases beginning in September, a peak was reached
in November, and the number of cases decreased
sharply
in December. Beginning in Januarythe
number of cases began to decrease more slowly and
this trend continued until late spring.
The
monthly prevalence of the four mostfre-quently isolated agents from croup patients offers
an explanation, at least in part, for this marked
seasonal occurrence (Fig 3). Croup due to the three parainfluenza viruses occurred more frequently during the fall. RSV had a midwinter peak and was found in increased numbers during the spring as well, probably accounting for many of the croup
cases at that time. Although M pneumonio,e
and
influenza types A and
B did
not appear to befrequent causes of croup, the regular occurrence of
M pneumoniae during the fall and the frequent occurrence of influenza outbreaks during the winter probably influenced the seasonal distribution of croup cases as well.
The epidemic occurrence of croup cases is dem-onstrated in Fig 4, which shows the incidence of
cases in children 0 to 5 years of age over a period
of
1 1 years. This age group was chosen forillustra-tion because 81% of croup cases occurred in
chil-dren less than 5 years of age. The arrows in Fig 4
mark
the
months in which there were ten or moreisolates of the parainfluenza viruses and show that
these agents were responsible for the largest
out-breaks. The peak in October 1971 is an exception
200
80
60
140
MONTH
Fig 3. Monthly prevalence of selected respiratory
vi-ruses isolated from children with croup in pediatric group
practice.
to this. During this month there were two isolations
of parainfluenza
type
1,one of parainfluenza
type
2, one of M pneumoniae,
and
one adenovirus.It
seems probable that this represents a peak primar-ily due to parainfluenza viruses and that the
effi-ciency
of isolating
these
agents
duringthis
time
was less then optimal. This phenomenon occurred
several times during the study. In addition, there
were
other
smaller peaks in croup incidence forwhich
no correlative
isolates
were
identified.
The
peak in
December
1965 was associated with severalisolations of parainfluenza type 3 and M
pneumo-niae.
The
peak
inFebruary
1969
was
associated
with a sharp outbreak of influenza and RSV infec-tions. The peak in December 1972was
associated
with the frequent isolation of M pneumoniae.
The
January 1975 peak occurred during an outbreak of
influenza virus
and
RSV
infections.
The
peaks
in
May 1967 and October 1974 were associated with
so few isolations that no associations can be made.
Thus, of 15 sharp outbreaks of croup during the study, nine could be attributed to the parainfluenza
viruses and four to the influenza viruses, RSV or
Mpneumoniae.
There
were only two outbreaks
that
could not be associated with these agents. In April
1969 there were 14 isolates of parainfluenzae type
3 with no increase in occurrence of croup. This is
of interest and possibly reflects the weaker
associ-ation of parainfluenza type 3 with croup
than
is
seen with types 1 and 2.
DISCUSSION
Most published studies on croup are from
hospi-talized patients and report the association of this
syndrome with respiratory viruses, especially
par-ainfluenza type i.”
Although
these
studies
have
provided
valuable
information
concerning
the
1965 ‘ 1966 ‘ 1967 ‘ 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 973 1974 ‘ 975
YEARS IN MONTHS
I I-.
z 0
Ui
a: 0
-I
I C) 0 0
0
U)
Ui
U)
0
Fig 4. Epidemic occurrence of croup in children aged 0 to 5 years in pediatric group practice. Arrows indicate months in which parainfluenza viruses were prevalent. Asterisks mark peaks when other agents were prevalent or when no agent was isolated in sufficient number to implicate it as cause of epidemic; see text.
a general population. The data reported by Foy et
al’2 are an exception to this and record the
mci-dence of croup in preschool-aged children belonging
to a prepaid medical care group in Seattle. In this study the attack rates were 5.2/1,000 children per year in the 0- to 5-month age group, 11.0 in the 6-to 1 1-month age group, 14.9 in the 1-year-old group, 7.5 in the 2- to 3-year-old group, and 3.1 in the 4-to 5-year old group. Comparable figures in the present study were 24.3, 39.7, 47.0, 31.2, and 14.5 or approximately 3 to 5 times higher than in the Seattle study. The reasons for this discrepancy are not clear, but procedural differences probably played a large role. It is of interest to note, however, that the relative incidence of croup in various age groups in both studies was similar, with the peak incidence in the 1- to 2-year-old group.
The parainfluenza viruses have been shown to be
the major cause of croup when etiologic studies
have been performed, especially parainfluenza type
1.1320
Type
2 produces croup symptoms in a high percentage of children with LRI due to this agent, but the relative infrequency of occurrence of type 2 makes it a less important cause of croup. Type 3, although less likely to cause croup in the infected child than are the two other parainfluenza viruses, is a more important cause of croup than type 2 because of the greater frequency of its occurrence. Parainfluenza virus type 4 was not isolated in our study.In addition to the parainfluenza viruses, RSV and M pneurnoniae are the other common causes
of LRI in children.2’ The present studies support reported observations that these agents are less likely to cause croup than are the parainfluenza
viruses. Inasmuch as RSV is the most common
cause of LRI in small children and M pneumoniae
is the most common cause in children more than 5
years old, the clinician should be aware that these agents can and do cause croup.
The influenza viruses were relatively infrequent
causes of croup in our study. A number of articles in the literature report the severity of croup due to the influenza viruses,2227 but in our patients these agents were not recognized to cause croup more severe than that caused by the other agents. There
are anecdotal reports of all other respiratory viruses
as causes of croup, including the mumps virus,28
but these are infrequent. It should be noted that
the adenoviruses, important causes of upper and
lower respiratory tract infections in children, are
infrequent causes of croup.
It has been speculated that children who have
croup are at increased risk in later years for
devel-oping lung changes that result in decreased
pul-monary function.30’3’ The present study provides
base line incidence data that should be valuable in designing studies to evaluate this possibility.
IMPLICATIONS
AND RELEVANCE
Croup, along with tracheobronchitis,32
bronchiol-itis,2 and pneumonia,33 are syndromes caused by infections of the lower respiratory tract in children.
In general, the same group of microorganisms,
pri-manly respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza viruses types 1 and 3, and Mycoplasma pneumoniae,
with parainfluenza virus infections, especially type 1; it
occurs
mostly in boys, has a peak occurrencein the second year of life, and occurs predominately
in the late fall and early winter. The characteristic
clinical and epidemiologic pictures of the syn-dromes caused by infections of the lower respiratory tract in children, especially croup, sbould be helpful to the clinician caring for children with these
com-mon and important infections.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by the Vaccine Development
Branch, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Dis-eases, NIH (contract PH 43-67-48); the US Army Medical
Research and Development Command (contract DADA 17-71-C-1095); and the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, NIH (SCOR grant No. HL 19171-03).
We thank F. A. Loda, W. P. Glezen, A. S. Dajani, R.
I. Slotkin, R. P. Lipman, G. W. Fernald, N. F. Rodman,
and K. H. Fendt for their contribution to this work.
REFERENCES
1. Loda FA, Clyde WA Jr, Glezen WP et al: Studies on the
role of viruses, bacteria and M pneumoniae as causes of lower respiratory tract infections in children. J Pediatr
1968;72:161-176
2. Henderson FW, Clyde WA Jr, Collier AM, et al: The etio-logic and epidemiologic spectrum of bronchiolitis in pediat-nc practice. J Pediatr 1979;95:183-190
3. Feigin RD, Cherry JD (eds): Textbook of Pediatric Infectious
Diseases, Philadelphia, WB Saunders Co, 1981, vol 1, pp
146-155
4. Eller JJ: Attack rates for hospitalized croup in children in a military population: Importance of A2 influenza infection.
Pediatr Res 1972;6:386
5. Halzel A: Virus isolations from throats of children admitted to hospital with respiratory and other diseases, Manchester
1962-64. Br Med J 1965;1:614-619
6. Mufson MA: Viruses, Mycoplasma pneumoniae and bacteria associated with lower respiratory tract disease among in-fants. Am J Epidemiol 1970;91:192-202
7. Parrott RH: Clinical syndromes among children. Am Rev Respir Dis 1963;88:73-76
8. Parrott RH: Viral respiratory tract illnesses in children. Bull
NYAcad Med 1963;39:629-648
9. Chanock R: WHO respiratory disease survey in children: A serological study. Bull WHO 1967;37:363-369
10. Horn MEC: Respiratory viral infection in childhood: A survey in general practice, Roehampton 1967-1972. J Hyg
1975;74:157-168
11. Buchan KA, Marten KW, Kennedy DH: Etiology and epi-demiology of viral croup in Glasgow, 1966-1972. J Hyg
1974;73:143-150
12. Foy HM, Cooney MK, Maletzky AJ, et al: Incidence and
etiology of pneumonia, croup and bronchiolitis in pre-school children belonging to a prepaid medical care group over a four year period. Am J Epidemiol 1973;97:80-102
13. Bisno AL: An outbreak of acute respiratory disease in Trin-idad associated with para-influenza viruses. Am J Epidemiol 1970;9i:68-77
14. Hall CB, Geiman JM, Breese BB, et al: Parainfluenza viral infections in children: Correlation of shedding with clinical manifestations. J Pediatr i977;91:194-198
15. Downham MAPS, McQuillin J, Gardner PS: Diagnosis and
clinical significance ofparainfluenza virus infections in
chil-dren. Arch Dis Child i974;49:8-15
16. Gardner PS: Observations on clinical and immunofluores-cent diagnosis of parainfluenza virus infections. Br Med J 1971;2:7-12
17. Parrott RH: Acute respiratory diseases of viral etiology: III.
Myxoviruses: Parainfluenza. Am J Public Health
1962;52:907-917
18. McLean DM: Parainfluenza viruses in association with acute laryngotracheobronchitis, Toronto, 1960-61. Can Med
Assoc J 1961;85:290-294
19. McClean DM, Bach RD, Larke RPB, et al: Myxoviruses associated with acute larnygotracheobronchitis in Toronto,
1962-63. Can Med Assoc J 1963;89:1257-1259
20. Herrmann EC Jr: Experiences in laboratory diagnosis of parainfluenza viruses in routine medical practice. Mayo Clin
Proc 1970;45:i77-i88
21. Glezen WP, Loda FA, Clyde WA Jr, et al: Epidemiologic patterns of acute lower respiratory disease of children in a
pediatric group practice. J Pediatr i971;78:397-406
22. Kim HW, Brandt CD, Chanock RM, et al: Influenza A and B virus infection in infants and young children during the
years 1957-1976, abstract ad. Pediatr Res 1978;12:423 23. Howard JB: Influenza A2 virus as a cause of croup requiring
tracheotomy. J Pediatr 1972;81:i148-1150
24. Hall CB, Douglas RG Jr: Respiratory syncytial Virus and
influenza: Practical community surveillance. Am J Dis Child
1976;130:615-620
25. Parrott RH: Serious respiratory tract illness as a result of Asian influenza and influenza B infections in children. J
Pediatr 1962;61:205-2i3
26. Brocklebank JT: Influenza A infection in children. Lancet
1972;2:497-500
27. Forbes JA: Severe effects of influenza virus infection. Med
JAust 1958;2:75-79
28. Foy HM, et a!: Isolation of mumps virus from children with
acute lower respiratory tract disease. Am J Epidemiol 1971;94:467-472
29. Brandt CD: Infections in 18,000 infants and children in a controlled study of respiratory tract disease: I. Adenovirus
pathogenicity in relation to serologic type and illness syn-drome. Am J Epidemiol 1969;90:484-500
30. Burrows B, Knudson RI, Lebowitz MD: The relationship of
childhood respiratory illness to adult obstructive airway disease. Am Rev Respir Dis 1977;i15:751-760
31. Loughlin GM, Taussig LM: Pulmonary function in children with a history of laryngotracheobronchitis. J Pediatr 1979;94:365-369
32. Chapman RS, Henderson FW, Clyde WA Jr, et a!: The epidemiology of tracheobronchitis in pediatric practice. Am J Epidemiol 1981;i14:786-797
33. Murphy TF, Henderson FW, Clyde WA Jr, et al: Pneu-monia: An eleven year study in a pediatric practice. Am J