Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
½{Z{Z]¹y¹uyuuyZ)ºÀ¯¾³Zz³ºsb*Yz]±MzÀgZc¹yZ°À]µv½{Z¶À^b)zo¾]Z¿{yY
)LOWHUHG%DFN3URMHFWLRQ ¹
,WHUDWLYHPHWKRG
½º){©ºyvÀzd)u
æ
µuY{¾kZo²p¯zd)u
ç
½{º³{²À¯Y
æ
uY&³²¯º¯½v¸¯
æ zd)u
Z³Z¿yM±Yz¯Z)
æ
¾*sZ)Z]uZyvÀo¹zd)u
æ
Î
Zy Z¯Y ±ZdyZ°À] ½Y ¶d· ¾*| t]
v¸¯ ¾*| º¬ µZ.³Yu
Ï v¸¯ ¾*| º¬ µZ.³Yu ¾*| µv*³Yu ¾*| (¿|À t]
bZ¿yu r¿yZc
çê æå íè mÈY r¿yZc
çæ ææ íè z¿x r¿yZc
ë æç íè
µvÀ*#
¶¯v¤¯
ºdÀ¯\¬£b*YZl³Y²ÀoyuyZ°À]b)zo ²*Yyu[wZ)WZ¤³uZl¿YfZ]v³Y
uuz-yZ°À]
µv³¾yz]Z·b* cyM²¿Y½¹yz]z¿ºc½{Z{Z]¬dt¯½Z·¹yzÀgZc
bY yuv³Yºc¾¯µvuZl¿YWZ¤³Z]±M±Z¯{av¯Z¿¹b)zoªp¯¹avZ^cyY²ÀÀc
b)zonÀpc½Z·yY|Yz³¾oYzyu²À´$°·¹[wZ)WZ¤³²¿Y¾yz]
vZ]µv´´)(°)
vZ]¾¯½{Z{Z]¬dt¯½Z¸¹yyuWZ¤³²¿Y¾yz]½Yz]¶À«¹Y¶«Z¯(¿zZo¶«Z¯
Z·¹y¹uYº¯
¡¹z½yZ°À]{Y®)©Z°doYZ]®³Zs(¿{Y¾À^\¬£±%ºÀzb*Y
z¿ºc±Z¯{yu¾d)zo¶³º.$À·½Y¶d·¾*|td¯¶ºc¾yz]yu¶)½z³¹z) Yuz] yu¹bYv³½y ÐÏ
½Z°³ ÐÍ yu½Y¶À³Zg ÎÕÍ
¾yz]uyº¯uº]µv½yYuz]z¿ºc¶kyu
bz-yYz£
½Z·Z°³yu¶À«¹Y²*Y¾WZl]Zk Ô
ÎÓ ¹ ÏÑ
¾WYvd]Y¾oYº³±Yº´¶]
¹¹
½yYuz]z¿ºc¾WZ¸d³Y
±Z¯{av¯¶]²À´$°·¹ª*À¶¹¹u(¿½Z·avZ]¹ ÐÍ
Zc ÖÍ
ºc¶À³Zg yY|Yz³
Vision
bz-ayº
½Z·yºp¯yu²*Y¾WZl]Zk²À´$°· X
¹ Y yu¹
v¿uz-Zl³Y¾ ´¯¹b^h¯aZ¸k
Zl³Yz¿xZ³b-z]¹z¿xb-z]ayº¹u¶]Z·¾WZl]Zk
Zº°l¯¹ bz-ÎÑÑ
¹y¹uZ]¶)vuZl¿Yv¿vk²*Y Iterative
º³ Ordered Subset
Expectation Maximization (OSEM) ¹
Filtered Back projection (FBP)
v³v½{Z{Z]
ÏÕÕ
z¿ºc
v´dz-yYz£¾°)¶°À³zÀ cuyº¯¹
Z·¶dZ¿
yu¾À^zÀ½Z·²*Yb^³ª*À¶¹¹u(¿±Y|À¯¶]½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu
½{Z{Z]¹y FBP
\Àczc¶] Õ
Ï ÏÒ ¹ Ó ÐÖ ¹yyu¶*À«Zoyuuº] OSEM
\Àczc¶] Õ
ÎÕ Õ ÑÐ ¹ Õ ÓÕ
v³uº]¾À^zÀZ·²*Y (P<0.001)
zÀ c¢Yºc (Kappa)
¹u²À]yu
©uZ¯½{Z{Z]¹y ÑÕ
Í uº] (P<0.001)
²*Yz·¾°lc¾]xk{ZÀd¯Yºd¯ [summed score
(SS)] ½{Z{Z]¹yyuvZ]¾¯±%ºÀz¤³b¹¹av{Y½Y¶³Z³¶) FBP
ÏÒ Ò ¹
½{Z{Z]yu OSEM
©uZ¯ ÍÕ Õ uº] P<0.05 ºd¯ SS ¹yyu OSEM
½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu¹
a¹Z d¯½Z·av¯¶]z¿xb-z]
Z¿Z°³¶¹¹u(¿ ÐÍ
ÓÍ ¹ ÖÍ ¶À³Zg \Àczc¶] ÒÏ
Ï
¹ Ó ¹ Î Õ uº] P<0.05 ºd¯½{Z{Z]¹y²¿Yyu²À´$°· SS
¿uZ¤¯¶]½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu z
\Àczc¶]ª*À¶¹¹u(¿ ÕÒ
Ð ¹ ÔÔ Õ ¹ ÒÕ ÎÎ uº] P<0.001 zÀ½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu
v³yY|-¾À^z¿ºc{Y½uyº¯"À·½{Z{Z]¹y¹uz·yu¹z¿xb-z]
½zÀ-¶lÀd³
½{Z{Z]¹yyu¶)uYu±Z³zZo¶«Z¯ OSEM
¹y¶]b^³ FBP
zo{Y¾Z³½Z·b* cyM±Y|À¯ ½Z·b* cyMb¹¹av|À³¹vZ]¾¯zdÀ]yZ°À]b)
bYzdÀ]¹y²¿Yyu|À³¾d)zo
zdÀ]¾WZl]Zkav¯¿Y|YZ]Z·b* cyMav²À´$°·
uº¾¯
½vÀ¬)½Z·µ%Y¹
b)zo \¬£±%ºÀzb*Y
½{Z{Z]¹y yZ°À] OSEM
¹y
½{Z{Z] FBP
©ºX¯ µv´¿º³
{ ©ºy vÀ zd)u ½º)
Zy Z¯Y ±ZdyZ°À] v¸¯
½Y ¶d· ¾*| t]
zakavi@mums.ac.ir E-mail:
±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d· ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
¶¯v¤¯
²Àoyu¾yz]uyº¯±Zº-yYZº¿¹yZ°Àº]bº)zo Zl³Yyuµº¤«Z]aÈ*¯{Y¾*¿½yYuz]z¿ºcZºl³Y
cyMfZ]bY²º*°¯¹bºY½yYuzº]z¿ººc
b*
uº¶¬Zoz¿¹Zºcyu½uvdº¯½Zº·
æ ¹ ç b)zo
b* cyM{Y¾*¿{y¹Zl³Y{Y~ºÇZº]¶º]\º¬£ ²¿Y{Y½zÀ-º¬k½Yzº]¶º)bºYµvº¶dsZ´º½Zº· ¶¤À£uµu\¬£¾Yz-º¯ºc¶)bYµv¶Àºc©Z*ºY uºººZººl³Y{y¹Zºº°cY{Y~ºº
ç ½Z·yY|ººYzºº³
]yuyZ°À]b)zonÀpc½Yz]uºkº¯
uyYº¯{Y½yZÀ
¾sz]yu½yYuz]z¿ºcyYz*c¹v´dÀ³t]b¿Zºy
vZ]¾¯uºkº¯[Ztd³Y²¿zd¸]uyYº¯{Y
è yYz*cZ¯Y
uyº¯yu}yu¹{uvl¯yZd³Yb¬]½yYuzº]z¿ººc
vZ^³©Z*ºY{Y¾º«ZsbºY²º*°¯ºÀº«Zc
¾z{Y
ª°pcª]Z£zÀyZ°À]½Yz]Z·Z-½yYuz]z¿ºcyYzº*c uZ¿¹ bY²*°¯zÀ®)Yzczt](¿y
æ
½{Zººº{Z]¹y{YµuZ dºººY Iterative
(OSEM)
¹bY¶dz-yYz£¶kºcuyº¯zÀºsY¶º·uyuz¿¹Zºc ¹y¶ºº]b^ºº³ Filtered Back projection
(FBP)
bººYµuYu¶ººWYyYYy½zdºº¸]j¿Zdºº³
é ì ±Y|Àºº¯Zºº¯Y
¹y²¿YyuyZ°À]bº)zo{YªºZo½Zº·bº* cyM º{Z]
bºÀ³tº¯½{Z
½Z·b* cyM{Y¾º·Z-M
Z·b* cyM²¿Yav¹yZ°À]b)zo{Y¾Z³ª°dºp¯
bY½y¹z(|½Yz]Z¸d)zo¬dºt¯Yºº³Yyu
b¹¹avº¶º)v´º)¾º¯¾ºzºZo¶º«Z¯
¹µvuZl¿Y¾d)zo½Z¸dº* cyM ¬dt¯½Z¸¹yzÀgZc
v´)¾]Z¿{yY¡º½Z·b* cyMyuYy½{Z{Z]
¹y
yZ)
yu¶)¾^¬£½yZ°À]v£Z®³Zs(¿¾ºÀ^²*ºY ½Y¶d·¾*|td¯¶ºc¾°#¾ºyz] ²À´$°·¹bYv³½yYuz]z¿ºc±Z¯{yu¾d)zo"À· uº]±ZdZ¿®-YzZ¿uºc¾³ºdÀc½Z°³v£Zº
bz-yYzº£¾ºyz]uyºº¯
(¿ºc½yYuz]z¿ºc
Zººzº(ºc½Yzº°)Zº¯Z-µZ.dºu ©v¯
DSX yu
vZl³Yb¶º]µvÀº]YºsbÀº¹
½yYuz]z¿ºc
yYv¤¯¢¿y|ºc{Y~ºbZº(º¿ çå
{Y½yº)¾¬À¯
yu¹¾^À¯Zdººº¿|Àºº´*c½¹yYuººº¿uYy èç
½Zºº°³ èå
{Yµz¿Yu®À³(¿yu¶º)vºZºl³Y½Y¶Àº³Zg éê
¶kyu
Zc¹¹zbºYy¾º¯Yv£ª¿Zº¯ éê
¾ ¬sª¿Z¯¶kyu
)¾¯YvÀº¶º¯YuYº# uz
µuZ dYuyº¯~¿zcZ¯ ëé
yu ëé
²ÀWZ½%z³YZ]yºcZ°À«º)µuZ dYuyº¯yºcZ°Àº«º)¹
uºº]ÇZº](Àº* c¶ºkyu¹
½z¿ºcª*Àzº· é
ë
uº]zd°À¬À¯
yY|Yz³{YµuZ dYZ]yZ°À]¾À^²*Y
VISION
½Z·yºp¯yu
X ¹ Y ¹b^h¯aZ¸kyu¹
ª*À¶¹¹u(¿±Y|À¯¶º]¾º ´¯ vZl]Zk
Z°c
½Z·Z°³yuZ·¾WZl]Zk ì
æë ¹ çé ¾oYº³±Yº´¶]
½yYuz]z¿ºc½Z¸d³Y¹º¹Yvdº]Y
(¿uYvc¶]¹
®·zb½Z°³¶º¹¹u
±Z¯{av¯ èåëå
¹ îå
¶Àº³Zg ¶]¾WZl]Zk{Y~¶)\Àczc²¿Y¶]vºZºl³Y ¾¯µuYub-z]¶À«¹Y±Z*¯¶º]tº¯±Zº¯{avº¯
v³vº ½Z·¾WZl]Zk±Yº´bºpcZº·¾ºWZl]Zk²º¿Y
v³vµvÀ¯Z³zº¿xbº-z]
¶]¾WZ·¾WZl]Zk²À´$°·
½Z·Z°³yuz¿xZ³b-z]ayºº ì
æë ¹ çé ©Z°Y
bº-¾º°³zº]¶Àº«¹Y±Zº*¯
ª*º æ ©Zh¯±Yº´¶]
½Zº°³yubº)zo ì
yuyZ°À]¹v¾¯Zl³Y bÀ¹
½yYuz]z¿ººc½Z¸dº³YZºcvº¿vk
½Z°³ èç ¾¯¾£Z]
v³Z¯ Z·¾WZl]Zk²¿YªZo æéé
¶)uº]v¿vkz¿ºc
¶ºº]z¿¹Zººc½{Zºº{Z]¹y¹u{YµuZ dººYZºº]¾ºº.°· ayºº FBP ¹ OSEM zd¬À{YµuZ dYZº]¹ Metz
Z]
order í ºº£~³Z)zºº¹ í
é yYzºº£½{Zºº{Z]uyººº¯
¹yuyº¯yu OSEM
uYvc í Iteration ¹
ç
subset vººµuZ dººY
Zººº°l¯ çíí
¬dººt¯z¿ºººc
½Y¶d·¾*|td¯(¿ºc¶)v¯Mbºv]
bz-yYz£zÀ c¹¾ºyz]uyºº¯
ayº¶]z¿¹Zc
yu¾°)¶°Àº³zÀº c æì
¹±Z°. ê
uyº¯¾]xk¶^cy
±Yº´bpc¾º¬)µzº°³(º¿¹v´ºdz-yYzº£¾ºyz] Summed Score) SS
z.³ZÀ]¶)vµuYu²*Yz·¶º]
uºº]bº* cyMbº¹¹avº
ª*º ç ¶]z¿¹Zc
¶yu¹v´dz-yYz£¾]Z¿{yYuyº¯|À³¾°º#ayºº
±¹v]¾W|k[xºk·Zº)
tº¯º¤³
v³v½v´º]®Àº¤c¾ºÀ^zÀº¹
Z·yºp¯yuµvµuYub)zo½Z·²*Y¶ºº°l¯
X
¹ Y aZº¸k ^h¯ ¾ ´¯¹b
av ¶Z¿¹¹u(¿
ªº*À bº)zoºº³¹
b-z]Zº¿zº¿xbº-z]
zº¿xZ³ v³v¶¿Z¤¯®·Zº]
b* cyM±Y|À¯²À´$°·
z¿¹Zc½{Z{Z]º³¹uyuZ·
OSEM Z¿ FBP Z]|À³
v³v¶¿Z¤¯z.¿u®·
¾ À)½Z·zÀd¯½yZ¯M¶¿Z¤¯
bc{YµuZ dºYZº]¾°ºY McNemar
¿Z¤¯¹ zÀd¯¶
{YµuZ dYZ]z¿ºc½{Zº{Z]¹y¹uyu¾º°)½Zº· t-test {Y|À³µ¹z-¶¶¿Z¤¯½Yz]¹vZl³Y¾ºk¹{
zo zÀgPc \¬£ b¨Y z] yZ°À] µv ½{Z¶À^ b§ ±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d· ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
ª*
æ
«Y
b)zo±¹v]¶À«¹Y²*Y(ÀcZ°½Z°³
[
yºp¯yuz¿xb-z]b)zo
+Y (¿yu
½yYuz]z¿ºc¾WYvd]Yº
-z]zÀb)zo(ÀcZ°½Z°³
yºp¯yuz¿xb
+Y Y¹Yyu¹
½yYuz]z¿ºc
ª*
ç
\¬£¾³Zz³ºs²*Y¾°)¶°À³zÀ c½Yz]µuZ dYuyº¯½v´]±Z°.½Z°³
¹y²¿Yyu
¶]uyZ)ºÀ¯Z°c
æì {Yav}ZYz]±Z°.z·yu[xk·Z)±Y|À¯¹uº¾¯®À¤c±Z°.
z
¾À^b«Zo
Zc
ê
[xkv
µz°³ uº¾¯½v´]
Z¸³Z°.aYz°³º°l¯
Summed Score (SS)
¾¯µvÀ¯Z³
uº
¶z*¿~³Zº¿yY¹|Àº«Z³M
ANOVA
¹vµuZ dY
bc{Y~³Z¿yY¹|À«Z³M±º¯{M±uº]yYu¾´¯uyYº¯yu Bonferroni bc±Yº´¶]
Post-Hoc
vµuZ dY
yu
{Yzd°)½yYu¾´¯nZ¸³º¯{MZº°c åê
å ¶] ±Yº´
v¶dz-z³yu©º^£ª]Z£n
Z·
¶dZ¿
µvZl³YaYzÀÀc¶ºº°l¯{Y æéé
bv]²*Y
¹y¹uZ]¾º.°·¶º)vº¯M FBP
¹ OSEM ½{Z{Z]
µvº Zº°l¯ çíí
z¿ºc
v³vzÀ c¹
zÀ cyu
¹y¶]½{Z{Z]yuZ·²*Y¾ À) FBP
¤ í ç
º]µvZl]Zkª*À(¿¶)¾¿Z·²*Y v³u
z´z
bº)zoºº³Zº¿bº¸k{Y
¹v³uº]¾À^zÀ ë
æé
v´dYu¾´À]Z´À]b* cyM è
íè
v³uº]¾À^uyYº¯²¿Y
¹y¶º]½{Zº{Z]yu OSEM
\Àczc¶]uYvY²¿Y í
æí è í ¹ î ìç
yYvºº¤¯¶ºº]½Zºº·¾ººWZl]Zkyu ç
zÀºº cªºº*À
¶]¾À^¹¾´À]Z´À]¾À^zÀ yu\Àczc
çê í çå
¹ ç êé ¹yyuuyYº¯ FBP
yu¹ í éè çê ¹
è èæ ½{Zº{Z]yu OSEM
½{Z{Z]yu
FBP
yYv¤¯¶]½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu¹ è
zÀzÀ cª*À
\Àczc¶]¾À^¹¾´À]Z´À]¾ºÀ^
ë èî æ çì ¹
ÐÑ ±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d· ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
è èè ½{Z{Z]yu¶)vyY|-uyYº¯ OSEM ¶] czc \À í ëí êê æç ¹ í æí uº] yu¾À^zÀ¹¾À^½Z·²*Yb^º³¶º¿Z¤¯ Zl]Zk½Z·²*Yyu¶)uYu±Zº³½{Zº{Z]¹y¹u ½{Z{Z]¹yyu¾À^zÀ½Zº·¶dºZ¿±Y|Àº¯µvº OSEM ½{Zºº{Z]¹y{YzdººÀ] FBP vººZºº]¾ºº¯ (P<0.001) ½{Zºº{Z]¹y¹uyu½zÀºº c¢ººYºc (Kappa) ººº¯ ©uZ éíí å uºººº] (p<0.001) ¹avººº bººº* cyM¾ººº°)¶°Àººº³bººº¹ (SS) ¹y¹uyu µvZl]Zk½Z·²*Yyu¶º)vº¶º¿Z¤¯½{Zº{Z] ºººd¯ yZÀºº¯Yzººp³Y SS ½{Zºº{Z]¹yyu OSEM åç í t åë í ½{Z{Z]¹yyu¹ FBP è ë t çê ê uºº] (p<0.05)
b-z]zÀ½Z·¾ºWZl]Zkyu y¹uz·yu¹z¿x z¿ºc{Y½uyº¯"À·½{Z{Z]¹ vº³yY|º-¾ºÀ^ b¹¹av±Y|À¯ººd¯ Z¿Z·bº* cyY SS yZÀ¯Yzp³Y ¶]½Z·¾WZl]Zkyu \Àczc¶]ª*À¶¹¹u(º¿zº¿uZ¤¯ æ è t íê è ì í t ìì í ¹ î í t êí ææ uººº] (P<0.001) ¶ºº¿Z¤¯ uºk¹|À³¾ºk¹{ayºº]¶º³Z-¶º½Z¸·¹zº-²º¿Y ÈdºsY vÀWZcYyZ¸·¹z-Z°c²À]½yZ¯M¶oȯª]Z£ uz)¾¯ .(P<0.05) zÀgZc¾]Z¿{yYyu¹z¿xbº-z]½Zº·bº)zoyu {Y²*Y¶lÀd³yub)zoavº¯ èë µvZl]Zk²*Y Z°³(¿µ{Yvº³Y¶º] av¯ èå ¶À³Zg ¹yyu FBP Z°c ½{Z{Z]¹yyu¹v³uº]¾ºÀ^Zº·²*ºY OSEM ¹¾À^zÀ²*Y(º¿ ì v³uº]¾´À]Z´À]uyº¯ {Y èë Z°³¹u±Y|À¯¶]µvZºl]Zk²*ºY ëå ¶À³Zg î z¿ºc ¹yyu FBP v³uº]¾À^¶À¤]¹vyY|-¾´À]Z´À] ¹y¶º]½{Zº{Z]yu¶*Àº«Zoyu OSEM æè z¿ºc ¹¾ºÀ^zÀº ë v³uº]¾´À]Z´À]z¿ºc {Y²À´$°· èë ±Y|À¯¶]µvºµuYubº)zo²*ºY è Z°³ îå ¶À³Zg yu ¹y FBP î ¹¾´À]Z´À]z¿ººc æè ¾À^zÀz¿ºc ½{Zº{Z]¹yyu¶*Àº«Zoyuvº³uº] OSEM z¿¹Zc ¾º´À]Z´À] é ¾À^zÀz¿¹Zc¹uyº¯ çæ yY|-uyº¯ v³vº ¹uz·yu¹z¿xZ³b-z]½Zº·¾ºWZl]Zkyu yY|-¾À^z¿ºc{Y½uyº¯"Àº·½{Zº{Z]¹y vº³ ¹avºººd¯ Z¿Zº·bº* cyYbº¹ SS yZÀº¯Yzºp³Y ¶]z¿xbº-z]½Zº·¾ºWZl]Zkyu a¹Z d¯½Zº·avº¯ Z¿Z°³¶Zc(¿ èå Zc îå ¶À³Zg \ººÀczc¶ºº] çæ æ t êç ç í é t ë ¹ æ ê t æ í uººº] P<0.05 ¹av±Y|À¯ºd¯¾WZl]Zk±Zº¯{¾º]Z¿{yYyu Z¿Z·b* cyYbº¹ SS yZÀ¯Yzp³Y ]Zkyu ¾WZl ½Z°³{Yzº¿xbº-z]½Zº· ì z¿ºc¶À«¹YªoYz¯Z¿ ©uZº¯½yYuzº] î ê t ì ë uºº] ¾WZl]Zkyuuv²º¿Y ½Z°³{Y½Z· æë ½yYuz]z¿ºc¹ ©uZ¯ æ é t ç ê ½Zºº°³{Y½Zºº·¾ººWZl]Zkyu¹ çé z¿ºººczººsY¹Y ½yYuz] ©uZ¯ ë è t ì é uº] P=0.178 ºººd¯zºº¿xZ³bºº-z]½Zºº·¾ººWZl]Zkyu SS yZÀº¯Yzºp³Y ½Z°³{Y½Z·¾ºWZl]Zkyu ì ©uZ¯ ç ê t ê í ½Zºº°³{Y½Zºº·¾ººWZl]Zkyu¹ æë ¹ çé ¶ºº] ©uZ¯\Àczc í ææ t é æî ¹ æ ææ t ì æí uº] P=0.01
½Z·yºp¯yu²*ºY¾ºWZl]ZkzÀºgZc¾º]Z¿{yYyu {Y¬dºt¯ ìç yºp¯yuµvºZºl]Zk²*ºY X yu¹ ¹y¶]½{Z{Z] FBP æê Àz¿ºc ¾À^z í çå æë ¾´À]Z´À]z¿ºc ç çç ¹ éæ ¾À^z¿ºc î êë
yºp¯yu½Z·¾WZl]ZkyuuYvY²¿Y
Y \ºººÀczºººc¶ººº] ë çè é æî ¹ î êë vººº³uº] P=0.879 ¹y¶º]½{Zº{Z]yu OSEM {Y|À³ ìç yºp¯yu¶dZ¿zÀÀcz¿ºc X ê èì ¾À^zÀ î æè À]Z´À] ¹¾ºº´ ë éí vºº³uº]¾ººÀ^ yuuYvººY²ºº¿Y yºp¯yu¶dZ¿zÀÀcz¿¹Zc Y \Àczc¶] êå ì æë ¹ è èè P=0.172 b)zob¸kzÀgZc¾yz]yu {Y èë Zl]Zk²*Y bº¸kyuµvº -X ½{Z{Z]yu¹ FBP î æè zÀ b¸kyuµvZl]Zk½Z·²*Yyu¹¾À^ +X í çì Àº vº³uº]¾ºÀ^z P=0.33 {Z]yuuYvºY²º¿Y ½{Z OSEM ¶] \Àczc æ èë ¹ î èí v³uº] P=0.7 |À³Z·²*Y¾°)¶°À³¾yz]yu SS ¾WZl]Zkyu ½Z· bºººº¸k +X) íè é bºººº¸kyu¹ -X éç é uººººº] P=0.73
fp]
bY²*°¯\¬£²*ºY²ºÀoyuyZ°Àº]bº)zo º¶¬Zoz¿¹Zcyu[wZ)WZ¤³fZ] ¹av¹u ¹yZ°À]b)zoº³}ZYz]Z·b* cyY²º¿Ybº¹ µuZ dYuyº¯½Yz°)Z¯Z-º³ z¹uZ¿z(c ²*°¯ vºZ]a¹Z dº¯bºY è yuyZ°À]b)zoayººyu {Z]{Yª^£z¿¹Zc¾WZl]ZkZ]±Yººc¾º¯²*ºY²ºÀo ²¿Yµuz)b)zo½Z·Z°³yu¾duayºº]¹½{Zº ¶)uYu·Zº)YyZº·bº)zo yu½Z·b)zouyº¯yu yºp¯ X ¹ Y yZÀ]yZ)²¿YZ¯YbYµv´´)(°)yZÀ]\¬£ b¨Y z] yZ°À] µv ½{Z¶À^ b§zo zÀgPc ±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d· ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
vZ]¾¯yºcYz¹Y¶]¶d]Y¹¹zÀ-bº£¹
½Z·yY|Yz³
¶)uyYuuºk¹|À³b)zoyZ)uººsnÀpºc¬dºt¯
v´ºZ]¾º¯µv´º´)(º°)
î í ½Z·yY|Yz³\¬YZ¯Y
v´dºÀ³ºt]b¿ZºyȯZº)uººkº¯
æå {Y¾·Z-M
vº yZ°À]b)zozgYyuµvuZºl¿Y½Zº·bº* cyMa
bºY½y¹zº(º|½Yzº]
aZÈY²¿Y²À´$°·
z³¾oYzyu¶Àº«¹YaZºÈY±Yº´º¶º]vº³Yºc¾º¯ uzÀ-yYz£µuZ dYuyº¯b)zonÀpc½Z·yY|Y
¹y¶]½{Z{Z]yu¶)uYu±Zº³zºZo¶º«Z¯ OSEM
b^³¾d)zo½Z·b* cyMb¹¹avº
]¶º] ¹y¶º]½{Zº{Z FBP
zdÀ]¾¸kºcª]Z£yºº]
bY yu¾À^zÀ½Z·zÀ c¾^³¾³Y¹Yz²À´$°·
¹y OSEM ¹y{YzdÀ]¾¸kºcª]Z£yºº] FBP
vºZ]¾º¯
½ÇZ]bÀZo¶³Z³v³Yºc¾¯¡º¶dºZ¿
½{Zºº{Z]¹y OSEM
Zºº·bºº* cyM±uzºº)YvÀººyu
vZ] ¹y½zcz]½uvd¯aZ«Z¯ OSEM
Yy b^³
¹y¶] FBP
bYµuYu±Z³z¿¹Zc½{Z{Z]yu
ì
é uyYub¤]Z¯aZ«Z¯²¿Yj¿Zd³Z]|À³zZo¶dZ¿
Z·b* cyYb¹¹av¶)uYu±Z³Z¯¾yz] ¾°)¶°À³zÀ cyu¶#¹²*Y¾°#zÀ cyu¶#
±M ¶¶]ª*À(¿{Y¾ºWZl]Zkavº¿Y|ºYZº]
v]Zº¿¾º¯¿Y|ºYªº*À
ºcZ¯ºcZ¯¶«Z¯yu
è ¹
¶]b)zo{Y¾¸kºcª]Zº£bº* cyM|Àº³³YyZº*°· av¿Y|ºYZº]¹vº³uZºl¿Yªº*À(º¿µ{Yvº³Y bZ¿¿Y|YZ·b* cyM±Y|À¯¾WZl]Zk
½Z·¾WZl]Zkyub)zoav¯zÀgZcZº¯¶º«Z¯yu ayºyu¶*¿yº]uº]¶kºcª]Z£yZÀ]z¿xb-z]
avº°]¾ºWZl]Zk èå
¶Àº³Zg Z°³(º¿ ¶¬Zoz¿¹Zc
¾WZl]Zk½Z·avyu¾do¶)v³uº]¾À^Z¯º° è
uºº]¡uZºzº¯Y²º¿Y|Àº³¾¬º*À
av¯¿Y|ºYZº]
bZ¿¾¯¿Y|Y®º·Zº·bº* cyMavº¾ºWZl]Zk
av¯¾^³bÀ°·Yµv´·v³Zº³vº³Yºc¾º¯¡ºº¶dºZ¿ vZ]±Mav¶]b^³¾WZl]Zk
¶«Z¯ Botvinick ¹
yZ*°· ¹y¶]½{Z{Z]yu¶)uYu±Z³|À³³Y FBP
Zc¾ºWZl]Zk çå
(¿yu¤¶)¾cyºyu|À³ª*À
v´)¾°³uZl¿Y¾d* cyMuºZl³YZº°³
ææ ²À°·yu
b)zoav¶º«Z¯
µvZl]Zk½Z·ª*ÀuYvc
Zººl]Zk½Zºº·Z°³uYvººcZºº]bºº* cyMuZººl¿Y½Yzºº]{Ç µv ¾WZl]Zk±Z¯{av¯
*¯b^³ bYu}º
z]b* cyMavz¿xb-z]½Z·¾ºWZl]Zkyu
¾ºWZl]Zk±Zº¯{}ZºY
z¿ºc½Z¸d³YZ¿º¹Yvdº]Y ½yYuzºº]
½Zºº·¾ººWZl]Zkyu¾ºº«¹bººYv³a¹Zºº c
z¿ºººc½Yvdºº]Yyu½Zºº·bºº)zozºº¿xZ³bºº-z] ½yYuzº] ½Zº°³ ì ¶]b^³Yy½zd°)½Zº·bº* cyM
½yYuz]z¿ºc½Z¸d³YZ¿¹yu½Zº·bº)zo
½Z°³
æë ¹ çé v³uzººº)¾ººº¯uZºººl¿Y
¶ººº«Z¯ Botvinic
¹
±Z¯{Z]b* cyMªºp¯¶º)uYu±Zº³|Àº³³YyZº*°·
½yYuzº]z¿ººc²ºÀoyubº)zo
Z¸d³YZ¿¹Yvd]Y
uyYuZ^ºcyY
ææ
t¯¶«Z¯±Zº°·yu²ºÀ´$°·
½Z·Z°³uYvc¹¾WZl]Zkªºp¯¶*Àcyººyu¶º)vº º* cyMavºvºZ]bº]ZgµvºZºl]Zk
¿Y|YZº]Z¸d
v]Z¿¾¯·Z)~¹¿Y|YYvd]Y¾ºWZl]Zkavº
av¶*Àcyººyu¶º)v´ºdz-¶lÀºd³²ºÀ¤¤p¯²º¿Y Z¸d* cyMavºvºZ]zdºÀ]²º]zº£{Y¾ºWZl]Zk v]Z¿¾¯·Z)
Z·b* cyM±Y|À¯¶)uYu±Z³²À´$°·Zº¯¶º«Z¯ yººp¯yu¾ºWZl]Zkyu X
yººp¯Zº]¾ºc¹Z c Y
uyYv³
Àº¯²ºÀ´$°· b¸kyu½Z·¾WZl]ZkyuZ·b* cyM±Y|
Z]bY²*°¯Z·yºp¯{YYv)zº·yubº^h¯¹¾º ´¯
vZ]¶dYv³¾c¹Z c®·
¬dt¯½Z·yºp¯yub)zo
b* cyMuZl¿Yªp¯v³Yºc¾¯a¹Z d¯aZ¸kyuZ¿¹
Z·
¾yz]ª]Z£¶¬X¯²¿YzZo¶«Z¯yuZ¯Yv·uzÀÀcYy ¯{²¿Yyu½z.¿u¶«Z¯¹uº^³ uºZl³Yv¿Z]¶´À
½zÀ-
¶lÀd³
Î
¹yyub)zo{Y¾Z³½Z·b* cyM±Y|Àº¯
½{Zºº{Zºº] OSEM
½{Zºº{Z]¹y{YzdººÀ]
FBP vZ]¾¯
Ï yu¾ººd)zo½Zºº·bºº* cyMbºº¹¹avºº
½{Zººººº{Z]¹y OSEM
¹y{YzdºººººÀ]
½{Z{Z] FBP vZ]¾¯
Ð Zºº°³(ºº¿yuyZ°Àºº]zºº¿xbºº-z]¾ººWZl]Zk
av°] èå ¶À³Zg ¹yyu ½{Z{Z] FBP
"À·
v´º*À°³uZºl¿Y¾ºd* cyM
av¶]¶kºc±¹v]
¾WZl]Zkyºp¯Z¿¾WZl]Zkbº¸k¾ºWZl]Zk
¹yyu¹ OSEM
bY²º*°¯ayv´º]|Àº³
uºb* cyMfZ]
Ñ
yuµvuZl¿Y½Z·b* cyMbº¹¹avº
¾WZl]Zkav¯¿Y|YZ]z¿xb-z]aZ)zo uº¾¯zdÀ]
Ò
Y½Z·bº* cyMbº¹¹avº
Z]µvuZl¿
¾WZl]Zkav¿Y|ºY
ª*À¶Zc(¿{Y
ÐÓ ±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d· ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
Downloaded from
http://journals.tums.ac.ir/
on Sunday, August 12, 2012
uº¾¯zdÀ]
Ó ¹avººzºº¿xZ³bºº-z]½Zºº·bºº)zoyu ¹¶³ZÀ¯yu¶)¾WZ·b)zoyub* cyMb¹ {YzdÀ]v·u¾º¯qy½yYuzº]z¿ººc½Z¸dº³Y bY½yYuz]z¿ºc½Yvd]Yyub)zo
¾³Yuyv£
¹
z*c
·¹&b³¹Z¯b¿Z°oZ]·¹&²º¿Y µZ.³Yu¾
¾³Yuyv£¶¬Àº´¿v]¶)v¿uz-Zl³Yv¸¯¾*|º¬ uuz-¾¯
]Z´¯
1. Britten A J, Jamali F, Gane J N, JosephAnton EA. Motion detection and correction
using multi-rotation 180 single-photon
emission tomography for thallium myocardial
imaging. Eur J Nucl Med 1998; 25: 1524
1530.
2. Wackers Frans JTH. Myocardial perfusion
imaging. In: Sandler MP, Coleman RE,
Patton JA. Diagnostic nuclear medicine. 4th ed. Philadelphia, USA, Lippincott Williams
& Wilkins, 2003; 273-341.
3. Matsumoto N, Berman DS, Kavanagh PB.
Quantitative assessment of Motion artifacts
and validation of a new Motion-Correction
program for Myocardial perfusion SPECT. J
Nucl Med 2001; 42: 687-694.
4. Hatton RL, Hutton BF, Angelides S, Choong
KK, Larcos G. Improved tolerance to missing
data in myocardial perfusion SPET using
OSEM reconstruction. Eur J Nucl Med Mol
Imaging. 2004; 31(6): 857-61.
5. Wells RG, King MA, Simkin PH, Judy PF,
Brill AB, Gifford HC. Comparing filtered
backprojection and ordered-subsets
expectation maximization for small-lesion
detection and localization in 67Ga SPECT. J
Nucl Med. 2000; 41(8): 1391-9.
6. Seret A. Number of iterations when
comparing MLEM/OSEM with FBP. J Nucl
Med. 2004; 45(12): 2125-6.
7. Bai J, Yokoyama K, Kinuya S, Nakajima K,
Yamada M, Ichiyanagi K. Preliminary
evaluation of image reconstruction by
ordered-subset expectation maximization in
thallium-201 lung scintigraphy. Ann Nucl
Med. 2003; 17(7): 619-24.
8. Lee KJ, Barber DC. Use of forward
projection to correct patient motion during
SPECT imaging. Phys Med Biol. 1998; 43:
171-187.
9. O'Connor M K, Evaluation of
motion-correction techniques in cardiac SPECT. J
Nucl Med 2000; 41(7):1298.
10. Leslie WD, Dupont JO, McDonald D,
Peterdy AE. Comparision of motion
correction algorithms for cardiac SPECT. J
Nucl Med 1997; 38(5): 785-789.
11.
MW. A quantitative assessment of patient
motion and its effect on myocardial perfusion
SPECT images. J Nucl Med 1993;
34:303-310.
\¬£ b¨Y z] yZ°À] µv ½{Z¶À^ b§zo zÀgPc · ¾¨| ¶¬l¯
±Yz¿Y ½Y¶d
