Cities and Quality of Life-Should We
Monitor Pakistani Cities?
Hasan, Lubna
Pakistan Institute of Development Economics
2007
Online at
https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/6522/
+ ,
- . ! "# $ % & ' (
) *
!+,* "# - . / 0
1 + !01+" 2 3 !01+ 4" $ 5
! 6 4"#
# 0 7
!8 $" 9 # (
:
# 1 8 $
!, 7 2;<<"#
1 8 $
# ( !.
/"
# ( 0 + ) . 8 $/
= # (
> !2;;;" . 7
2 ( ? % + @ 7# (
/
!, "# ( )
# A B
C 8 $ )
) )
. 7 /!> 2;;;"#
( # @ ! D"
23
1
. #/ 1 ' / 0 !, * 2;<2"
E4D
8 $ C =
C : E!@ D"#
( # 1 )
# ( =
5 # A #
# A .
/
# .
/
!+ % @ * 2F 3"# ( )
! "#
C #
( # 5
4G !' - 4"# 5
F $ E G 5 D G
H?5 ! + % 1 2"#
* A % 6 ! E"#
E * !2;3E" $ !2;3 " 8 $ + * * * #
D = #
( : ) # 1
! "# (
!> 2;;;"# ( . /
. /C 8 $ #
. I
7 7
/ !@ 2;;4F 2E"# 1
) . /
! " #
>
# 1
#
C . / $ ! 2"C
!A "# H J * : ! 2"
B
# 8 $
# +
# * ! " 8 $ D G
+* #
. /C C !>
2;;;"#
!
# +
D )
F # #
! "B
B ! )
7 = "B B
# B 8 $
! # #
) "# ( 8 $ ) )
K
7 # ( 2
8 $ #
!
" # " $
%&' %&( %) %)) %)) %)% %%*
! "
# " $
%
#
&
! ' ()***+,
' = 8 $ )
# (
) !@?1" + %
# 0)
% 8 $ )#
-! D" ) 7 7
C > !2;;3" 8 $ , #
8 $ :
. / C C
!> 2;;;"# 1
# A $ !2;; " .
/ # ( ! # #
) " ! "#
* 8 $ ) )
# 0 # # ' / 0 7
# @ 7
# ( # > !2;;3"
8 $ ) # (
!* = 2;;2"#
+ , - , . $ . / !
$ ,
)
- .
/
0 %
1
2 $ $
3 . ( 4 4 +
5 !
* $ 6
)7
))
)- ( 4 4 4 4 +
! ' 8 ()**1+,
( = # ( ) B # (
F
• +%K@ ,1( ( @ H + 1 5 !H+15"
• ? , ! ?," ? , ! ?," ?
• % 8 $ > *
• 8 $ > *
• + 6 , 1 )
$% &'( ' )$
( H+15 + % @ * 5 # (
H + 1 ? !H+1?2" 2;; 4 E3
2;;E # )
# ( 1 L4 ! 2"
2;;<# (
H + 1 ? !H+1? " E 22E
# ? !( E"
+*
1 A !1 A" 2 !!3#
4 0 2;<< @ 1 5 2;;E
' 01# , 2 ,$ 3 ,
4 4 9 9 4
: & 4 4 4
; 9 4 " 4 4
& & 4
& & 4 4
# ( 4 4 4
+4
$
<=# 4 4 4 4
4 $
!
"
1 7 F
•
• :
•
• :
•
•
•
•
• K #
( ?1 # (
# 0 ) :
2# ( D
?1# ( #
4 3 5, 01# , 2 ,$
, 6
& & " 17 > " 17
( " ? -1+ " 17 27 > (/- ? + " 17
/),*-" -1 > " -1
# ( ? 0,2)+ " )77 1,**
=: (: " > " > " > " > "+
1
! ' ;@9 8: <;:=-,
'*( *( * +
( ?, 2;;;
?, 5 >
K # (
= ) .
/ ! ?, 2F )"# ? 2D 2 #
( 2E F
• : B
• B
• B
• B
• B
• B
• B
• B
• B
• B
( F , !1 " , !J : > "
% !5 " !* $ " ? !, " @ !- % " @ @ J ! " J !% " $ !5 " !1 "
• B
• B
• #
( ) F ! " ?1 ! " )
! " )#
( ?1 K @?1# 1 )
# ( :
2 # (
# ( )
# A )
#
( 4 # (
#
7 3 5, 5 5
, 6
: -1 " > -1 " > -1 " > -1 "
& & " 17 > " 17
( " ? -1+ " 17 27 > (/- ? + " 17
/),*-" -1 > " -1 > " -1 > /17 "
-1
# ( ? 077+ " /7 -,3) > ( ? ),*5+ " /7 0,52 > 07
" ( ? -,35+ 2,3
(: " > " > " > " >
"+ 1
( ? -,75+ " /7 -,3) > ( ? ),*5+ " /7 0,52 > 07 "
( 9-,35+ 2,3
( : > 7,3) 2,/0+ > 2,3 > ( ? /,0-+ 1,31 > ( ? 0,//+ 1,-3 ? 7,73 /,/
% , - . !
( % 8 $ > * 2;;;# 1
8 $ % K # ( D
2 ! "
•
•
• 9
•
• 9
• 9
•
•
• #
3 < !4 9
2 4 9 "#
. !
( 8 $ > * 2;;; A
# 1 8 $ ) 3
) F
•
• 7
•
•
•
• #
( ) !A
8 $ > * "
# (
34 #
' $ +
3 ( 2 2;;;# 1 )
( + 6 1 ) =
# 1 8 $ = !
" = ! "#
( )
# (
# ( )
F
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #
( % 6 1 ) # 1
F
•
•
•
• #
.
#
, 5 )
# J $
+%M@ ,1( ( H+15 ?1 2
$ 2#2C K # (
?1 D#E <#2# A 2
City Developemnt Index 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Sto ckho lm Mad rid Pra gue Doh a Buen
os A
ires
San
to A
ndre
/ Sao
Pau lo Bula way o Por
t of S
pain Har are Jaka rta Ceb u Dam ascu s Laho re Col ombo Cas abla nca Asu ncio n Bag
hdad Gaz
a Chi ttago ng Kin shas a C D I V a lu e CDI
$ ?, ?, 5 >
. K / <
) ! D" ) !3E#2"#
< ( ?, ?1 +%K@ ,1( ( ?1# 6 $
+ Connectivity 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Hon g Ko
ng Seo
ul Melbo
une Ban galo re Han oi Kath man du Ceb u Dha ka Man dalu yong Med an Col
ombo Lahore Suva Bishk
ek
Phno m P
enh Ula
anba atar Naga
Hoh hot A E Congestion 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Dha ka Seo ul Ban galo re Laho re Man dalu yong Hon
g K ong
Hoh hot
Col
ombo Medan Han oi
Phn om P
enh Kat hman du Ula anba
atar Cebu Bis
K K ) !( <" J 2D
K K ) 4 #2 4 # 1
* !? #4 ,
4 #D" ) < ! K K ) O 3;#;"#
( - 1 31 ! , 6
1 31 ! , 6
- +**( - +**7 - +**( - +**7
25 )71 A : 3*,* 37,5
)/) )-3 = $ 8 2-,1 2-,1
)/* )0) 8 : 12,0 1),3
)07 )/2 B # $ 12,) 12,)
! ' A 4 9 9 ! 4 & $ -772,
( 01+ 8 $ ) 4 J ) )
G ! G 2 G ) 4 G
#"#
!!
8 $ 5 # (
5 C+%K@ ,1( ( H+15 ?, ?,C F ! "
) ! " )
! " # ( H+15
+%K@ ,1( ( ?, + 1
: #
( 8 $
5 # ( # #
= = # ' = !
#" F ! "
B ! " = # #
# ( . 7
= K
/ !? * 2;;3F 2;D"# (
= # ?
!2;;4" K ) 8 $
# ( =
* =
= # @
#
* = 7
!? * 2;;3"#
6 # @
P 1 ! 2;3
2;< " 7 # (
#
# > !2;;3"
! > 2;;;"#
( 8 $ 5 =
= #
' = . / ! " =
. / 7
!-D"# ( # (
> !2;;;" ? * !2;;3"
-! D"# .6
/ !? * 2;;3F 3"# = # (
! "
# ( # @
8 $ 5 #
?,# 2# 4 5 1 6 1 7 8 # 0 # # *# 6 -#
# - # F ?,#
, ,# ?# $ -# > # #- . 9 4 9
. # 6 5 % # 2 # % * 0 > +
* * # F # # 9 9 9 K2 #
, 7 H# # # # , Q# 5# @ # 2;<<# % 0 8 $
+ #0 9 / D2F 2 ;M2< #
># # ># 0 Q# 5 Q# - - Q# * # 5 ># = #
8 $ ? + # F
F99 7 # # # 9 )R 9 )#
6 @ , # 4# 9 1 5 # F
# # 9 9= 9 9@ #=
? 0# 0# * # 2;;3# 8 $ F 0 * * =
1 # / D F 2<;M 2 #
0 1 + !01+" ! 4" 5 > # F F99 # #
A (# ,# % # (# 6 # E# 5 - . 9 9
; . + 1 # F
F99 # # # 9 9 92 <9 929 2 < #
A # D# < ;15 - . /
/ )**= - . 1 5 # F
F99 # # 9 97 9 #
A ># # ( 0 H ( # 0 0 0
> ; !D"F 3DEM344#
H > * $ # 4# - . ( ? % : .
1 C/ % # F # # # :9 D98 R R$ R
DR R #
@ 5# 2;;4# ( H + ( # 1 Q# , # , 0# , #
1 1 # F $ #
@ *# # *# $ # 1# ># ># ># # D# >
5 @ F 5 ' # 0 @ '
;D !D"#
$ # 1# 2;; # 8 $ ? + > ' F > #
' 7 3 !D"F 3D;M332#
> # + # > $ C* *
F # # # # 9 95?A 9> 9 ,
$ * * * #
@ > ! " 6 K 8 $ * #
F # # 9
> ># Q# 2;;;# 8 $ # 4 E !4M "F ; ;M
* H# &# $# $ S# 6 # 4# 8 $ + A 5
? ? # / 4 D# F # # # # 9
* Q# # # * F 8 $ 5 H 0
@ #/ 9 << ! "#
+,*# # 48 A' 9 6 0 1 ' ' > #
' (# A *# @ H# J K* F
F99 # # 929 9 R 9 R R 9 #
+ % @ * !+% @*"# 2# < + % 1 #
+% @*#
- ># D# B 5 + , # ? 5 % # D9 3# +
