Cheap is not always best:
How to get performance and value for your
presented by
Shannon Vaillancourt
Less-than-truckload (LTL)
Tender shipments that optimally
match your carriers’ network
Full Truckload
Take advantage of carriers with
backhaul opportunities
Inbound Routing
Empower suppliers to make the
optimal transportation decisions
Mode Determination
Utilize real-time rating to automate
Common Rate Base
50,000 lanes X %
Y %
Z %
Lane Awards & Final Pricing
Carriers submit pricing off one common rate base with state to state or regional discounts Carriers submit pricing based on highest cost in lane and city groupings
Shippers compare discounts by hand to award a state or region to a carrier
50,000 (lanes) + 3 (carriers) = 50,000 total lanes
common rate base = less flexibility for carriers
Carriers are provided with one year of historical data with exact lane and product details Carriers submit pricing on their own rate base with zip-to-zip discounts & floor charges Shippers utilize predictive analytics to model data and determine proposal outcomes
Carrier’s Rate Base
500,000 lanes
Carrier’s Rate Base
500,000 lanes
Carrier’s Rate Base
500,000 lanes ABC %
XYZ %
JKL %
500,000 (lanes) x 3 (carriers) = 1,500,000 total lanes
Lane Awards & Final Pricing
greater flexibility,
more lanes, less risk = more aggressive pricing for shippers
Predictive Analytics Engine
OUTCOME
1 OUTCOME 2
OUTCOME
Carriers enjoy a uniform profit level, shipper enjoys sustainable rates Provides carrier with tangible results, i.e. “Do X get Y”
More of a collaborative approach
Analysis “tells” carriers the exact discount level required to receive the
amount of freight they want
Objective approach provides carrier with assurance that the amount of freight will be obtained
New process puts you in lockstep with the carrier • Carrier’s rates are lowest in the lanes they operate efficiently • One carrier’s low cost lane may be another carrier’s high cost lane
Shipment from Cranbury, NJ to anywhere in Indiana • Common rate base has
7
distinct lanes• Carrier X has
24
distinct lanes ($0-$10 price range) • Carrier Y has75
distinct lanes ($14-$32 price range) • Carrier Z has21
distinct lanes ($0-$54 price range) Zero-Sum Game• Carrier X
• Aggressively prices based on $0 lanes—carrier loses • Conservatively prices based on $10 lanes—shipper loses • Carrier Y
• Aggressively prices based on $14 lanes—carrier loses • Conservatively prices based on $32 lanes—shipper loses • Carrier Z
Shipper & Carrier wins—Win-Win
Have carriers price based on their rate base
Tender freight to the carrier that is lowest in the given lane
Freight is inexpensive in the lanes that the carrier wants, i.e. operates well
in
Reverse Auction Platform
Ensures lowest cost solution
Ability to audit all ‘spot quotes’
Minimizes work at Branch level
One time input No calling carriers
Easy to find lowest bidder
Auction Timed to maximize results Results can be leveraged in the future Initial bids level set on market
intelligence
5-star rating system Carrier Development
Simple to expand carrier base Access to additional Truckload
Capacity
Attract high quality, high capacity
carriers
Take advantage of dynamic backhaul opportunities
Benefits to Shipper & Supplier
Optimize mode selection between parcel, LTL & Full Truckload shipments
Optimize inbound and 3rd party shipment
carrier selection
Supplier prints parcel labels, Bills of Lading and custom packing slips
Visibility to open and fulfilled purchase orders through dashboard KPI
Integration with ERP or WMS
Access key Purchase Order details such as parts, quantities, and reference numbers Automated shipping feedback eliminates
manual communication processes
View entire shipping history and re-print shipping labels & documents
» Provide automated tools for all suppliers to fulfill purchase orders and optimize
Mode Determination through Real-Time Rating
Optimize mode selection between hundredweight and LTL shipments Allow TMS to plan shipments based on given day or wave of orders
Replace the inbound routing guide with an inbound portal that determines mode Use deliver-by-date logic to enforce cost and service business requirements
» Utilize a real-time rating engine to determine mode rather than static elements
Weight Pieces Mode
> 150 lbs. > 15 pieces LTL
≤ 150 lbs. ≤ 15 pieces Parcel
Savings Key Performance Indicator (KPI)
•
Calculate “before” cost to measure savings
Lost Savings Key Performance Indicator (KPI) • Calculate optimal carrier to measure lost
savings
• View your trend over time
• Identify what is preventing you from achieving
your goal