CHEVRON RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY COMPANY
RICHMOND, CA
December 1998
Manual sponsor: For information or help regarding this manual, contact R.A. (Rich) Doyle, (510) 242-3247
Coatings Manual
First Edition October 1988
First Revision December 1990
Second Revision February 1992
Third Revision August 1992
Fourth Revision January 1995
Second Edition September 1996
First Revision December 1998
The information in this Manual has been jointly developed by Chevron Corporation and its Operating Companies. The Manual has been written to assist Chevron personnel in their work; as such, it may be interpreted and used as seen fit by operating management.
Copyright 1988, 1990, 1992, 1995, 1996, 1998 CHEVRON CORPORATION. All rights reserved. This document contains proprietary information for use by Chevron Corporation, its subsidiaries, and affili-ates. All other uses require written permission.
Restricted Material
Technical Memorandum
This material is transmitted subject to the Export Control Laws of the United States Department of Commerce for technical data. Furthermore, you hereby assure us that the material transmitted herewith shall not be exported or re-exported by you in violation of these export controls.
Coatings Manual
The following list shows publication or revision dates for the contents of this manual. To verify that your manual contains current material, check the sections in question with the list below. If your copy is not current, contact the Technical Standards Team, Chevron Research and Technology Company, Richmond, CA (510) 242-7241. Section Date 50 September 1996 100 November 1998 200 September 1996 300 September 1996 400 September 1996 500 September 1996 600 September 1996 700 September 1996 800 September 1996 900 September 1996
Quick Reference November 1998
Appendix A None Given
Appendix B January 1995 Index September 1996 2000 September 1996 COM-MS-4042 January 1996 COM-MS-4732 January 1996 COM-MS-4738 January 1996 COM-MS-4739 January 1996 COM-MS-4743 January 1996 COM-MS-4771 January 1996 COM-MS-5005 January 1996 COM-MS-5006 January 1996
List of Drawings See the list in the Standard Drawings and Forms section of this manual. Current revi-sion dates are shown for Forms. Current revision numbers are shown for Standard Drawings.
Coatings Manual
If you have moved or you want to change the distribution of this manual, use the form below. Once you have completed the information, fold, staple, and send by company mail. You can also FAX your change to (510) 242-2157.
❑ Change addressee as shown below. ❑ Replace manual owner with name below. ❑ Remove the name shown below.
Send this completed form to: Document Control, Room 50-4328
Chevron Research and Technology Company 100 Chevron Way (P.O. Box 1627)
Richmond, CA 94802
CRTC Consultants Card
The Chevron Research and Technology Company (CRTC) is a full-service, in-house engineering organi-zation.
CRTC periodically publishes a Consultants Card listing primary contacts in the CRTC specialty divi-sions. To order a Consultants Card, contact Ken Wasilchin of the CRTC Technical Standards Team at (510) 242-7241, or email him at “KWAS.”
Previous
Owner: Title:
Last First M.I.
Current
Owner: Title:
Last First M.I.
Company: Dept/Div:
Street: P.O. Box:
City: State: Zip:
Coatings Manual
We are very interested in comments and suggestions for improving this manual and keeping it up to date. Please use this form to suggest changes; notify us of errors or inaccuracies; provide information that reflects changing technology; or submit material (drawings, specifications, procedures, etc.) that should be considered for inclusion.
Feel free to include photocopies of page(s) you have comments about. All suggestions will be reviewed as part of the update cycle for the next revision of this manual.
Send your comments to: Document Control, Room 50-4328
Chevron Research and Technology Company 100 Chevron Way (P.O.Box 1627)
Richmond, CA 94802
Page or Section Number Comments
Name Address
This document contains extensive hyperlinks to figures and cross-referenced sections. The pointer will change to a pointing finger when positioned over text which contains a link.
Manual Sponsor: R.A. (Rich) Doyle / Phone: (510) 242-3247 / E-mail:
[email protected]
List of Current Pages
50 Using this Manual 50-1
100 General Information 100-1
200 Environment, Health & Safety 200-1
300 Coatings Selection 300-1
400 Surface Preparation 400-1
500 Application 500-1
600 Coating Concrete 600-1
700 Downhole Tubular Coatings & Linings 700-1
800 Offshore Coatings 800-1
900 Pipeline Coatings 900-1
Quick Reference Guide QR-1
Appendices
Appendix A Conversion Charts Appendix B Color Chips
Abstract
In this manual, you will find procedures for coating steel and other metal
substrates. Additionally, there are individual sections for those surfaces and logis-tics requiring special consideration: concrete, downhole tubulars, offshore, and pipe-line coatings.
This section offers broad, general information: the reasons for coatings, the compo-nents of a coating and coatings systems, a successful coatings program, and the structure of this manual.
Contents Page
51 Scope and Application 52 Organization
60 Reasons for Coating 50-3
61 External Coatings
62 Under Thermal Insulation and Fireproofing 63 Internal Coatings
70 Components of Coatings and Coating Systems 50-5
71 Components of Coatings 72 Coating Systems
80 The Successful Coating Program 50-7
51
Scope and Application
The Coatings Manual is intended:
• For Company personnel who are responsible for selecting, applying, or inspecting coatings
• For both entry-level personnel and non-specialists regardless of experience • As a source of practical, useful information based on the Company's
experiences
Your input and experience are important for improving subsequent revisions and keeping this manual up-to-date; therefore, we have included a form in the front of the manual to facilitate your suggesting changes.
Note Do not use this manual as a substitute for sound engineering judgment.
52
Organization
The colored tabs in the manual will help you find information quickly. In summary:
White tabs are for table of contents, introduction, appendices, index, and general
purpose topics.
Blue tabs denote Engineering Guidelines.
Gray tabs are used for Specifications and related forms.
Red tab marks a place for you to keep coatings documents that are developed at
your facility.
Engineering Guidelines
The Engineering Guidelines cover: • An overview of coatings
• General information about selecting coatings; preparing surfaces; and applying, inspecting, and maintaining coatings
• Specific information about surfaces and logistics that require special consideration—concrete, downhole tubulars, offshore, and pipelines
Specifications
The specifications include:
• A Quick Reference Guide (for selecting coating systems; coatings system data sheets; list of acceptable brands; and Coating Compatibility Chart)
• The Company's specifications in commented form • Standard Forms
Other Company Manuals
Within this manual, there are references to documents in other Company manuals (example: COM-MS-4738 in this manual). These documents carry the prefix of the particular manual.
These prefixes are as follows:
60
Reasons for Coating
The Company coats structures and equipment for several reasons. Many of these reasons are discussed below.
61
External Coatings
External coatings are generally for aesthetics, corrosion prevention, evaporation reduction, and safety.
Prefixes Company Manuals
CIV Civil and Structural
CMP Compressor
COM Coatings
CPM Corrosion Prevention
DRI Driver
ELC Electrical
EXH Heat Exchanger and Cooling Tower
FFM Fluid Flow
FPM Fire Protection
HTR Fired Heater and Waste Heat Recovery ICM Instrumentation and Control
IRM Insulation and Refractory
MAC Machinery Support Systems
NCM Noise Control PIM Piping PMP Pump PPL Pipeline PVM Pressure Vessel TAM Tank UTL Utilities WEM Welding
Aesthetics
Coatings improve the appearance of objects, which contributes to good employee morale, advertising, neighborhood relations, and civic pride.
Corrosion Protection
Atmospheric corrosion is a significant problem in humid, warm, coastal locations; in chemical and fertilizer plants; and on offshore structures.
Regardless of the geographical location, coating is essential for protection against corrosion in most plant areas.
Evaporation Reduction
Painted in light colors, the roofs of storage tanks reflect rather than absorb the sun's energy thus reducing evaporative loss of the stored material.
Safety
Special coatings mark fire equipment, traffic lanes, and piping that carries hazardous materials.
62
Under Thermal Insulation and Fireproofing
A properly designed coating system, applied to the substrate under thermal insula-tion and fireproofing systems, gives the best long-term protecinsula-tion against chloride stress-corrosion cracking (CSCC) of stainless steel and reduces corrosion of carbon steel.
CSCC and increased corrosion occur:
• When moisture permeates the insulation or fireproofing system and condenses against the substrate, creating a condition similar to immersion service
• Because steel operating temperatures affect the corrosivity of water
• As long as the temperature of the water remains below its boiling point: the hotter the steel, the hotter the water, the higher the rate of corrosivity • When moisture leaches soluble salts that contain chloride or sulfide ions Again, the hotter the solution, the greater the effect.
Because they develop under insulation and fireproofing, these conditions are very hard to detect. Maintenance and inspection are very difficult and usually require removing the insulation or fireproofing. Often the first indication of a problem is an equipment failure.
For guidance on choosing coatings, refer to “Coatings Under Insulation and Fire-proofing” in the System Number Selection Guide (part of the Quick Reference Guide).
63
Internal Coatings
Internal coatings can maintain product purity, reduce stockside and underside corro-sion, and affect potable water.
Product Purity
Even at low corrosion rates, some corrosion occurs. An internal coating may be necessary to prevent the products of corrosion—such as iron oxide (rust) or scales— from contaminating the stock and causing problems.
Stockside Corrosion
Internal coatings extend the life of the tank or vessel and reduce the chance of leaks, especially in storage tank bottoms. The water layer which settles out in the bottom of the tank causes most of the tank bottom internal corrosion.[1]
Underside Corrosion
For tanks, the corrosion rate of the underside depends mainly on soil composition and moisture content. Based on experience, you can predict when underside corro-sion may be a problem.[1]
Potable Water
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration regulates coatings for lining potable water tanks.
70
Components of Coatings and Coating Systems
71
Components of Coatings
A coating consists of a pigment, a vehicle (binder plus solvent), and additives. Pigments give color and protective properties to the paint.
The vehicle provides curing to form a continuous film and adhesion to the
substrate. The vehicle is made of the binder (which forms the film) and the solvent (which dissolves the binder and adjusts viscosity to improve application). The solvent also partly controls drying rate.
Additives are drying and wetting agents, ultraviolet screening agents, etc.
Methods of Film Formation
Understanding how binders work is critical when choosing a coating system. For most coatings, film forms in one of several ways.
Thermoplastic. The solid resin, melted for application, resolidifies when it cools. Example: Tar in roof coatings.
Solvent Evaporation. The coating dries as the solvent evaporates (or dries at lower
temperatures than those which involve a chemical reaction). If re-exposed to the same solvent, the coating can redissolve.
Example: Vinyls, chlorinated rubbers and lacquers.
Oxidation. Coatings composed of drying oils cure by reacting with air. Oxygen
cross links the resin molecules into a solid gel.
Example: Alkyds.
Cross Link. Dual-component products cross link at room temperature, either with
or without a catalyst.
Example: Epoxies (two polymers react, no catalyst), polyesters (catalyzed) and urethanes (catalyzed).
Heat Cure. Heat causes direct cross-linking between filmformer molecules, or
acti-vates a catalyst to cause cross-linking. Normally, these coatings are shop-applied only, because of the special heating requirements.
Example: Baked phenolic linings.
Emulsion. When the water evaporates from an emulsion of resin particles and
water, the resin particles coalesce to form a film.
Example: Latex acrylics.
72
Coating Systems
A coating system refers to the layers that make a complete coating: primer, tiecoat or intermediate coat, and topcoat.
Primer Coats
Primer coats adhere well to the substrate and inhibit corrosion and undercutting at defects, such as pin holes or holidays (breaks) in the film.
Note that holidays are pinholes or thin spots which either develop during applica-tion or nicks and scrapes which occur later. Corrosion will start at these spots. Primer coats also bond well to the intercoat, tolerate variations in application condi-tions and handling, and resist weathering (helpful because delays may occur between priming and topcoating).
Tiecoats
Tiecoats (or intermediate coats) build film thickness, bond the primer to the topcoat, and protect substrate and primer from aggressive chemicals in the environment.
Topcoats
Topcoats protect the substrate and undercoats from the environment, provide chem-ical resistance, enhance the surface appearance, and provide non-skid and other properties.
Some coatings are incompatible. Before choosing coatings to apply over previously coated surfaces, see the Coating Compatibility Chart in the Quick Reference Guide.
80
The Successful Coating Program
The successful coating program has four elements: • Selection
• Surface preparation • Application
• Quality control (inspection and on-going maintenance) Each of these elements is described in more detail in this manual.
90
References
1. Chevron Corporation. Corrosion Prevention Manual, “Corrosion of Storage Tank Bottoms,” Chevron Research and Technology Company. Richmond, CA: January, 1994.
Abstract
Among the general information in this section is a description of the coatings and coating systems, which includes the advantages, disadvantages, and uses. Coatings are also described in the individual sections for special surfaces such as: concrete, downhole tubulars, and pipelines.
Note This manual does not contain information about coatings for architectural surfaces.
Quality control is essential for any project. Among the key elements of quality control for coatings are inspections, monitoring progress, and protecting the
Company’s equipment. For assistance with specific questions about coatings, see the listing of the Company’s specialists and coating manufacturers in the Quick Refer-ence Guide.
Contents Page
110 Coating Descriptions (A-E) 100-3
111 Acrylics 112 Alkyds 113 Epoxies 114 Elastomers 120 Coatings Descriptions (P–Z) 100-13 121 Phenolics 122 Polyesters 123 Polyurethanes 124 Silicones 125 Vinyls 126 Zinc-rich Coatings 130 Petroleum-based Tapes 100-21 140 Water-based Coatings 100-21
151 Non-reinforced Thin-film Coatings 152 Glass-flake-reinforced Coatings 153 Laminate-reinforced Coatings 160 Quality Control 100-27 161 General Information 162 Inspection Programs 163 Inspectors 164 Monitoring Progress
165 General Inspection Procedures 166 Specific Inspection Procedures 167 Instruments, Tools, and Equipment 168 Protecting the Company’s Equipment
110 Coating Descriptions (A-E)
The following coatings are described in this section: • Acrylics
• Alkyds • Epoxies • Elastomers
For details about each type of coating, read the following descriptions. See also Figure 100-1, Summary of Properties in Coatings.
111 Acrylics
Acrylic ester resins are polymers and co-polymers of the esters of acrylic and meth-acrylic acids. As thermoplastics, they soften at high temperatures.
Advantages:
• Good moisture and mild chemical resistance
• Either fast-drying solvent evaporation or coalescence
Disadvantages:
• Poor resistance to aromatic solvents
Uses:
• Solvent acrylic: truck and machinery finishes • Latex emulsions: stucco, wood, and masonry • By Company: as architectural coatings
112 Alkyds
Alkyd resins are basically modified polyesters. An alkyd is the reaction product of a polyhydric alcohol and a polybasic acid. A common alkyd resin uses glycerol as the alcohol and phthalic acid as the polybasic acid.
Oxidation in the air cures alkyd coating resins. Adding drying oils to pure alkyd modifies the alkyd into alkyd coating resins.
These resins are classified by oil length (long, medium, and short). The alkyd resin without oil modification is hard and brittle. As the oil length increases (more oil added), the film becomes softer and more flexible.
Advantages:
• Perform well in moderate environments • Easy-to-handle, single-component coatings • Inexpensive
Fig. 100-1 Summary of Properties in Coatings (1 of 2)
Coatings Type of Cure
Effect of Sunlight Wet Atmo-sphere 1. Atmosphere 2. Splash/Spillage
Acid Alkali Oxidizing Solvent Acrylic Solvent Evaporation Chalk Resistant Good 1. Good 2. Poor- Fair 1. Good 2. Poor-Fair 1. Good 2. Poor-Fair 1. Fair 2. N/R Alkyd Oxidation Slow
Chalk Poor-Good Yellows 1. Fair- Poor 2. N/R 1. Poor 2. N/R 1. Fair 2. N/R 1. Fair 2. N/R Amine-cured & Amine Adduct Epoxy
Cross Linked Chalks Yellow Excellent 1. Good 2. Fair 1. Excellent 2. Excellent 1. Limited 2. N/R 1. Excellent 2. Excellent Polyamide Epoxy
Cross Linked Chalks Yellow Excellent 1. N/R 2. Poor-Fair 1. N/R 2. Excellent 1. N/R 2. N/R 1. N/R 2. Very Good Coal-tar Epoxy Polyamide
Cross Linked Chalks, Cracks N/R 1. Excellent 2. Good 1. Excellent 2. Good 1. Excellent 2. N/R 1. Poor 2. N/R Chlorinated Rubber
Solvent Evap. Slow Chalk Excellent 1. N/R 2. Very Good 1. N/R 2. Very Good 1. N/R 2. Good 1. N/R 2. N/R Epoxy Phenolic Cross Linked N/R N/R 1. N/R(1)
2. Good(1) 1. N/R(1) 2. Very Good(1) 1. N/R(1) 2. N/R(1) 1. N/R(1) 2. Very Good(1) Baked Phenolic Heat Cured N/R N/R 1. Good(1)
2. Lid Mineral Acids(1) 1. Good(1) 2. N/R(1) N/R(1) 1. Poor(1) 2. Out-standing(1) Moisture-cured Urethane (II)
Cross Linked Aromatic Yellows; Aliphatic Excellent
Very Good 1. Good 2. Fair 1. Good 2. Fair 1. Poor 2. N/R 1. Excellent 2. Good
Silicone Heat Cured Cross Linked
Excellent Very Good 1. Good 2. Poor 1. Good 2. Poor 1. Very Good 2. Poor 1. Fair 2. Fair
Silicone Alkyd Oxidation Excellent Very Good 1. Good 2. Poor 1. Good 2. Fair 1. Good 2. Poor 1. Good 2. Good-Poor Vinyl Solvent Evap. Slow
Chalk Excellent 1. Excellent 2. Very Good 1. Excellent 2. Good 1. Excellent 2. Good 1. Poor 2. N/R Organic Zinc-rich
Cross Linked Chalk Excellent(2) 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Excellent 2. Very Good Post-cured Inorganic Zinc
Cross Linked None Excellent(2) 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Excellent 2. Excellent Solvent-based Self-cured Inorganic Zinc
Cross Linked None Excellent(2) 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Topcoat 2. N/R 1. Excellent 2. Excellent
• Good service on large, flat surfaces
Example: Good service is exemplified by this coating’s almost 20 years on Hawaiian refinery tanks.
Disadvantages:
• Long drying time
• Not chemically resistant; unsuitable for highly corrosive areas such as chem-ical and fertilizer plants or offshore structures
• Unsatisfactory for water immersion
Coatings Immersion
Tank Linings
Physical Properties
Abrasion Heat Hardness Gloss Range of Color Acrylic N/R N/R Good Limited Good High to Semi Full
Alkyd N/R N/R Fair Fair Fair Chalks to Flat Full Amine-cured &
Amine Adduct Epoxy
Very Good N/R Good Good Very hard Chalks to Flat Full
Polyamide Epoxy
Very Good Solvents Water
Good Good Hard Chalks to Flat Full
Coal-tar Epoxy Polyamide
Excellent Water Limited Excellent Very Hard Flat Black, Red
Chlorinated Rubber
Very Good Water Fair-Poor Poor Good Semi to Flat Wide
Epoxy Phenolic Very Good Wide-range Solvent
Good Outstanding Very Hard High Dark
Baked Phenolic 1. Excellent(1) 2. Very Good
Wide Resis-tance
Good Excellent Excellent Excellent Clear Dark
Moisture-cured Urethane (II)
N/R N/R Excellent Good Excellent High Full
Silicone N/R N/R Good Excellent Good High Full Silicone Alkyd N/R N/R Good Very Good Good High Full Vinyl Very good Water Fair-Poor Poor Good Semi to Flat Wide Organic
Zinc-rich
Good(3) N/R Good Good Very Good Semi to Flat Some
Post-cured Inorganic Zinc
Good(3) Fuels Solvent
Excellent Excellent Excellent Flat Earth Tones
Solvent-based Self-cured Inorganic Zinc
Good(3) Fuels Solvent
Excellent Excellent Very Good Flat Earth Tones
(1) As tank lining (2) When top-coated (3) With epoxy topcoat
• Not suited to highly alkaline surfaces such as fresh concrete, galvanized steel, and inorganic zinc
• Chalk in sunlight
• Usually fail within a few years on piping and structural components • Not VOC-compliant
Uses:
• In external primers and finish coatings
Long-oil Alkyds (60 to 70 Percent Oil)
Advantages:• Good flexibility and wetting properties
Disadvantages:
• Very slow drying
Uses:
• Over poorly prepared steel where the oil penetrates rust and develops adhesion
Medium-oil Alkyds (45 to 60 percent oil)
Advantages:• Hard, tough films
• Dry faster, generally, than long-oil alkyds
Uses:
• Finish coats
Note The Company’s most popular choice of alkyd
Short-oil Alkyds (35 to 45 percent oil)
Uses:• Fast air drying and baking enamels for hardness and mar resistance
Note The Company uses very little of these.
113 Epoxies
The most common epoxy resins are formed by the reaction of epichlorhydrin and bisphenol-A. This reaction can be controlled to produce resins ranging from liquids of low-molecular weight to solids of high-molecular weight.
Complete curing gives epoxies their chemical and water resistance. Curing time increases at temperatures below about 70°F, essentially stopping below about 50°F unless it is a specially formulated low-temperature epoxy.
Epoxies have very good resistance to bases and many solvents. Epoxies have poor acid resistance unless modified with a phenolic.
Advantages:
• Resist water and chemicals, especially caustics, superbly • Resist weather well
• Adhere well, particularly to concrete • Apply easily
Disadvantages:
• Do not retain color and gloss as well as alkyds • Tend to chalk rapidly
• Do not have good acid resistance
• Need surfaces between layers of epoxy roughened by solvent or blasting when applying multiple coats as many epoxies cure with a hard, slick surface
• Need successive coats of epoxy applied as soon as possible to obtain satisfac-tory adhesion between coats. Manufacturers normally recommend a maximum time between coats.
• Need long cure time. For epoxy linings at 70°F, curing may take one week. In the field, coatings applicators often accelerate the curing of an internal coating with a low-temperature bake (100 to 150°F).
☞
Caution Do not put internal coatings into service until they are fully cured. Uses:• Epoxy resins are the most popular resin for thin-film coatings on concrete. There are six groups of epoxy coatings in this section: amine cured, amine adduct, polyamide, coal tar, epoxy mastics, and epoxy novolac.
Amine-cured Epoxies
These coatings are epoxy resins cross-linked with one of several amine compounds.
☞
Caution Because the amines can present a health hazard, apply them according to manufacturers’ safety recommendations.Amine Adduct Epoxies
Amine adducts are stable intermediate products resulting from the reaction of a portion of the epoxy resin with an amine curing agent. The amine adduct, instead of the amine, is added to the epoxy coating to cure it.
Advantages:
• Same properties as liquid amines, but much less hazardous • Very good resistance to oils, solvents, and chemicals
Disadvantages:
• Ultraviolet degradation causes rapid chalking
Uses:
• Lining gasoline storage tanks, chemical tanks
• Corrosion-resistant primer under polyurethane foam insulation
Polyamide Epoxies
Polyamide resins are produced from polyamines and fatty acids. Epoxy coatings for atmospheric exposures are usually polyamides. Mastic coatings which adhere to wet surfaces and which will cure under water are formulated with polyamide epoxies.
Advantages:
• Good surface-wetting properties
• Longer pot life, more flexibility and better water resistance than amine or amine-adduct cured epoxies
• Good resistance to alkalies, petroleum products, and salt water
Disadvantages:
• Not quite as chemically resistant as amine adduct epoxies.
Uses:
• Topcoats and tiecoats in severe exposures
Coal-tar Epoxies
As the name suggests these coatings are blends of epoxy resins and coal tar.
Note Coal tar is a suspected carcinogen but is tied up sufficiently in the polymer so that manufacturers consider the cured film safe.
Coal-tar epoxies can be either polyamide- or amine-adduct cured. Usually applied in two heavy coats of eight mils each, these coatings are normally self-priming.
Advantages:
• Outstanding for water-immersion service
Disadvantages:
Uses:
• Underwater, in water tank linings (except potable water tanks), and on buried structural steel
Note Although coatings manufacturers continue to use them for municipal water-tank linings, the Company prefers FDA-approved polyamide or amine-adduct epoxies for potable-water tank linings.
Epoxy Mastics
Advantages:• Perform better than alkyds
• Adhere to a variety of surface preparations, including tightly adhered rust • Adhere to any old coating firmly attached to the substrate
• VOC compliant
Disadvantages:
• More expensive than alkyds
Uses:
• For less-than-perfectly prepared surfaces
Epoxy Novolac
Epoxy novolac resins are second-generation epoxies with greater cross-linking density.
Advantages:
• Greater resistance to chemical attack and high temperatures than standard epoxies
Disadvantages:
• More expensive and less flexible than standard epoxies
Uses:
• Common coating for concrete
114 Elastomers
An elastomer is a polymeric substance with more than 100 percent elongation in a tensile test. Included in this category are natural- and synthetic-rubber products (which also have the physical characteristics of natural rubber). The chemical, oil, and water resistance of elastomers vary widely.
Coatings applicators can apply modified elastomers as coatings. The Company uses many elastomeric coatings, such as chlorinated rubber and hypalon, alone over steel and other surfaces or, as required, with special primers such as inorganic zinc.
There are two classes of elastomers: cross-linking and air-drying.
Catalyzed Cross-linking Elastomers
Neoprene, butyl, thiokol, silicone, and hypalon are the most common, catalytic-setting, elastomer coatings.
Neoprene. A synthetic rubber, produced by polymerizing chloroprene, neoprene is
either pigmented or clear and is manufactured as thin flexible films or mastics.
Advantages:
• Good heat and flame resistance • Good acid, alkali, and water resistance
Disadvantages:
• Softened by aromatic solvents
Uses:
• Block insulation coatings
Butyl. A copolymer of isobutylene and isoprene, butyl is polymerized with an
aluminum chloride catalyst.
Advantages:
• Exceptionally low water permeability
• Better sunlight and weather resistance than most rubbers
Disadvantages:
• Unknown
Uses:
• Coating urethane foam and block insulation • Piping tape wrap primers and tape mastics
Thiokol. Thiokol is a polysulfide rubber. Advantages:
• Excellent gasoline and water resistance
Disadvantages:
• Unknown
Uses:
• Caulking compounds
• Flexible seal over leaking rivet seams in oil tanks • Pond and tank linings (in sheet form)
Silicone Rubber. Silicone rubber is a room-temperature vulcanizing (RTV)
sili-cone.
Advantages:
• Good for hot service
Disadvantages:
• Poor solvent resistance
Uses:
• Gaskets in hot services • Caulking
• Potting materials
Hypalon. Hypalon is a chlorinated polyethylene resin. Advantages:
• Excellent sunlight resistance • Good chemical resistance
Disadvantages:
• Unknown
Uses:
• Flexible coating vehicles or mastics and sheet lining
• Mild acid spill protection for concrete (the Company's most popular use) • Topcoat over polyurethane foam or block insulation
• Pond and tank linings
Air-drying Elastomers
Chlorinated rubber, an air-dried formulation of hypalon, and butadiene-styrene are the most popular elastomers for air-drying coatings.
Chlorinated Rubber. Chlorine and natural rubber latex produce chlorinated rubber
resins. When suitably plasticized and pigmented, these resins exhibit outstanding resistance to a broad range of corrosive chemicals and environments.
Advantages:
• Shows outstanding resistance to severe chemical environments such as acids, alkalies, salt fog, water, oxidizing agents, bleaches, and cleaning compounds • Dries rapidly, allowing application of several coats in one day
• Produces excellent bond between old and new coats as the solvents in the new coat penetrate the old coat
• Does not resist sunlight damage as well as alkyds and acrylics • Causes alkyd or oil coatings to blister if applied over them • Dissolves in oils and solvents
☞
Caution Oil spills could potentially soften these coatings. Uses:• Offshore platforms • Humid coastal refineries
Hypalon. The air-drying hypalon is a chlorosulfonated polyethelene. Advantages:
• Good weatherability
Disadvantages:
• Unknown
Uses:
• Topcoat elastomers to improve weather resistance
Butadiene-Styrene. The most widely used type of synthetic rubber,
butadiene-styrene is a copolymer of three parts butadiene and one part butadiene-styrene.
Advantages:
• Good resistance to alkali, water, and mild acids • Excellent external durability if pigmented properly
Disadvantages:
• Embrittles with age if formulated improperly
Uses:
• Vehicles in coatings and mastics for stucco and masonry
Polyurethane Elastomers. Polyurethane elastomers are thermal plastic polymers. Advantages:
• Aliphatic—Excellent color and gloss retention
Disadvantages:
• Aromatic—Yellows badly in sunlight
Uses:
• Vehicles for thin or semi-mastic coatings for sealing polyurethane foam insulation
120 Coatings Descriptions (P–Z)
The following coatings are described in this section: • Phenolics • Polyesters • Polyurethanes • Silicones • Vinyl • Zinc rich
121 Phenolics
Phenolic resins, formed by the reaction of phenol with formaldehyde, produce a range of coatings from hard plastics (Bakelite) to oil-soluble resins and from heat-reactive varnishes to air drying oils. The Company uses two phenolic resins in coat-ings: a baked pure phenolic and an air-drying epoxy phenolic.
Baked Phenolics
Baked phenolics are almost exclusively shop-applied due to a complicated baking procedure. They contain resins which are polymerized by being heated above 300°F. The reaction time and temperature depend on the modifying oils and resins.
Note The Company uses baked phenolics only in the most severe immersion services where no other material will work, such as container inner-coatings and tank car linings.
Advantages:
• Excellent chemical and water resistance
• Withstand immersion in almost all petroleum products • Good abrasion resistance
Disadvantages:
• Poor wetability (the ability of a coating to flow over a surface) • Require maximum surface preparation
• Poor adhesion • Embrittles
Note To overcome poor adhesion and brittleness, some formulas are modified with epoxy resins, giving them better caustic resistance than pure phenolics but not equal resistance to strong solvents.
Epoxy Phenolics
Catalytic setting (non-baking) phenolics are usually composed of phenolic resins and epoxies.
Advantages:
• Better chemical and solvent resistance than pure epoxies
Disadvantages:
• Lower resistance to chemicals and solvents than pure baked phenolics
Uses:
• Lining tanks, vessels, containers, etc.
122 Polyesters
While there are two major classes of polyester resins, the Company uses only isophthalic. Isophthalic polyesters, the resin preferred for corrosion protection, is also the main resin in laminate-reinforced systems.
While the chemical and temperature resistance of polyester is usually poorer than any of the other resins, they are also the least expensive.
123 Polyurethanes
Polyurethane resins are formed by the reaction of isocyanates with polyols and are used for a variety of purposes from foam insulation to air-drying coatings and varnishes. The isocyanate may be either aromatic or aliphatic.
There are literally thousands of polyurethane formulations—from hard roller skate wheels to elastomeric materials that stretch like rubber bands—which have many different properties. Some of these properties are:
• Abrasion resistance • Chemical resistance • Elasticity
• Impact resistance • Tensile strength
☞
Caution Remember that increases in one property result in decreases in another. Because of this, many elastomeric polyurethanes are not as chemically resistant as the more rigid polyurethanes.The most common polyols are acrylics and polyesters, although there are epoxies, vinyls, and alkyds.
Advantages:
• Highly resistant to abrasion and impact
• Catalyzed urethanes are highly chemical resistant • Better performance than alkyds
• Aliphatic—For atmospheric coatings, usually as easy to overcoat as epoxies • Aromatic—More chemically resistant than aliphatic urethanes
Disadvantages:
• More expensive than alkyds
• Aromatic—Not designed for external exposure as they chalk and yellow; diffi-cult to overcoat because adhesion is poor
Uses:
• Aliphatic—Non-fading, non-chalking external finishes
• Aromatic—Tank linings, chemically resistant coatings, flexible elastomeric coatings for polyurethane foam insulation coverings
Classifications. Urethane coatings cure by a variety of mechanisms as classified by
ASTM D16-75 types. Types II, IV, and V are considered high performance and are described below. Most of the Company's experience has been with Type V, the two-package polyol-cured urethane.
Type II, One-package Moisture-cured. The Company has limited experience with
these urethanes which cure by reacting with moisture in the air. The moisture reacts with a prepolymer containing isocyanate so that the isocyanate is released for cross-linking. The reaction also releases CO2which must migrate to the surface before the film sets up.
☞
Caution In high humidity areas, such as offshore, the reaction can occur so rapidly that the CO2 cannot escape; and the film is filled with gas bubbles and pinholes.Type IV, Two-package Catalyzed. These urethanes cure by reacting with a
low-molecular-weight-reactive catalyst. They cure in a similar way not only to moisture-cure (although the catalyst is in a separate package), but also to epoxy coatings.
Type V, Two-package Polyol-cured. These urethanes are the Company's most
common choice for high-performance coating systems such as for offshore plat-forms and chemical plants. To cure, polyol-cured coatings react with pre-reacted (adduct) hydroxyl-bearing polyols. They require no additional curing agent; however, coatings applicators may add an agent to promote low-temperature curing.
124 Silicones
Silicones are a group of various organo-silicon-oxide polymers available as fluids, elastomers, and resins. Because of their chemical composition, silicones have excel-lent resistance to heat, weathering, and moisture.
Note Repairing silicone coatings is very difficult because almost nothing will adhere to them. For small repairs, sand the failure and apply fresh silicone coating with a brush. For large repairs, remove the coating by abrasive blasting and recoat.
Heat-reactive
Silicone resins are cross-linked polymers which require a high-temperature cure to produce heat-stable films. Catalyzed formulations which cure at room temperature are now available. Non-catalyzed formulations remain tacky until heated above about 300 to 400°F. For this reason, most field applications use the catalyzed, room-temperature cure.
The film thickness of baked silicone coatings is low compared to that of other coat-ings. A self-primed two-coat application usually produces only 1½ to 2 mils dry film thickness (DFT).
Advantages:
• Excellent sunlight resistance
• Good durability at high temperatures
Disadvantages:
• Apply only on abrasion-blasted surfaces
Uses:
Furnaces and stacks up to 600°F (up to 750°F for aluminum and black colors)
Note The color and gloss retention of baked silicones depends on the pigments.
Modified or Air-drying
Modified or air-drying silicones are produced by reaction with organic resins such as alkyds or acrylics.
Advantages:
• Excellent gloss and color retention • Good weather and sunlight resistance • Many resist temperatures up to 300°F
Disadvantages:
• Tend to cure quite slowly even at ambient temperature, taking weeks to harden and resist damage in cool weather.
Note Topcoat inorganic zinc with an epoxy or silicone acrylic.
125 Vinyls
Vinyl resins are formed from the reaction of acetylene with acetic or hydrochloric acids. Varying this process produces resins consisting of 100 percent vinyl chloride, or 100 percent vinyl acetate. The resins in protective coatings are usually co-polymers containing 80 to 90 percent vinyl chloride and 5 to 15 percent vinyl acetate.
Vinyl resins are hard and brittle and must be combined with plasticizers and dissolved in solvents to form vehicles for coatings. Vinyl solutions contain only 15 to 40 percent solids depending on the co-polymers.
The various vinyl-resin solutions are compatible and may be blended to emphasize desired properties. Some blends adhere very well to concrete and metal and are used in formulating primers. Other blends are pigmented and plasticized to produce high-build films. Used for finish coats, some blends have low solids and adhere poorly to steel but have very good chemical and weather resistance.
The Company uses vinyls for many services, often where water exposure is expected such as on floating tank roofs, docks, and on offshore platforms near the water.
Advantages:
• Excellent chemical, water, and aliphatic oil resistance • Excellent shelf life
• Ready bond to weathered vinyl films
• Removable with a solvent wash when desired
• Easy to patch old coatings without blistering or wrinkling • Easy to apply by spray
Disadvantages:
• May lose their plasticizer over time and embrittle, a problem with vinyl as a weathercoat over polyurethane-foam insulation
• Do not have good gloss retention or stain resistance
• Dissolved by ketones, esters, chlorinated solvents, and some aromatics • Need good ventilation to avoid prolonged (solvent evaporation) drying • Tend to lift and blister because of the strong solvents
• Difficult to brush or roll because of their rapid drying
• Tend to bubble and pinhole when applied over porous inorganic zinc
Uses:
• With alkyds or epoxy esters to improve film build, gloss, and adhesion which are excellent as vehicles:
– In rust-inhibiting primers for ferrous metals
– In seal or tiecoats over inorganic zinc primers to improve adhesion of vinyl, alkyd, chlorinated rubber
– In epoxy ester topcoats
• In formulae ranging from thin-bodied, air-drying coatings to semi-mastic putties and air-drying, baking plastisols
• To formulate a wide variety of latex materials in glues, paper sizes, and emul-sion coatings
• In vinyl-emulsion-latex coatings for both internal and external services. The retention of deep colors by vinyl latexes is superior to that of most other coatings.
Vinyl Ester
Vinyl ester resin is a reaction product between polyesters and epoxies and shares many of the attributes of polyesters.
Advantages:
• Resistance to acid, solvent attack, and high temperatures
Disadvantages:
• More expensive than an isophthalic polyester or normal epoxy
Uses:
• Coating concrete
126 Zinc-rich Coatings
Zinc-rich coatings, which have zinc dust as the pigment and inorganic or organic vehicles, are divided into two classes: inorganic and organic zinc.
Zinc-rich coatings offer good corrosion resistance for steel due to the sacrificial nature of the zinc pigment. The zinc acts as an anode to protect the steel galvani-cally and prevent corrosion. This coating is applied alone or as a primer under a variety of topcoats. Under suitable topcoats, all of these primers greatly enhance the life of the coating system in many exposures, especially in marine services.
When testing to determine the benefit of zinc in a coating, the Company found the quality of performance to be rated (best to worst) as follows:
1. Inorganic zincs
2. Zinc-rich organic coatings 3. Organic coatings
Inorganic-zinc Coatings
Inorganic-zinc coatings consist of two components:
• A pigment composed solely or principally of zinc powder
• Any of a variety of patented and proprietary inorganic or semi-inorganic vehi-cles to form the matrix of the coating
Post-cured inorganic zincs have a third component: a curing agent such as phos-phoric acid.
When properly mixed, applied to blasted steel surfaces, and allowed to cure, the resultant coatings have outstanding resistance to weathering, humidity, elevated temperatures, organic solvents, animal and vegetable oils, both fresh and salt water, and most petroleum products. In addition, these coatings (especially post-cured) have excellent abrasion resistance. The corrosion resistance of the cured film is similar to that of galvanized iron; the weather resistance is superior to galvanized iron.
Two types of inorganic zinc coatings are self-cured and post-cured.
Self-Cured Inorganic Zinc Coatings
Self-cured inorganic zinc coatings are either solvent- or water-based vehicles. While both produce an inorganic film, their methods differ. Current technology is almost all solvent-alkyl-silicate-resin based.
Solvent-based Coatings. The Company uses self-cured, solvent-based, inorganic
zincs in many places such as piping, tanks, and offshore. Although manufacturers have used several inorganic silicate vehicles such as ethyl silicate and bi-metallic alkoxide complexes to make these coatings, almost all self-cured inorganic zincs are now alkyl silicates such as ethyl silicate.
Ethyl-silicate-based coatings convert to an inorganic, insoluble state in reaction to moisture. Some formulae require long periods (three to four weeks) of high
humidity to reach ultimate hardness. Many manufacturers now claim their ethyl sili-cates can be topcoated almost immediately since enough moisture permeates through the topcoats to cure the primer.
Solvent-based coatings are popular because their vehicles show superior wetting ability, they dry fast and resist water immediately, and their film thickness is less critical than for post-cured inorganic zinc coatings.
Some self-cured inorganic zincs are modified to include some organic resin for more rapid film formation and increased flexibility. Properly formulated, they can perform as well as normal alkyl silicates.
☞
Caution The Company does not recommend single-component inorganic zincs. Laboratory tests and experience show that these zincs do not perform as well as the two-component zincs. One reason is that the zinc settles in the can and is not easily put back in suspension. The applied coating is, therefore, deficient in zinc.Coatings applicators mix the multi-component zincs at the time of application and agitate them continuously to avoid the settling problem.
Water-based Coatings. Tests show that, for weather resistance, water-based
coat-ings are inferior to solvent-based and post-cured inorganic zincs.
Note Future changes to clean air regulations may force us to use water-based or new, presently untested, formulations of inorganic zincs.
Composed of zinc dust pigment and vehicles containing sodium silicate, or phos-phates, the vehicles are water solutions similar to those of the post-cured coatings. After application, the film is water sensitive for some time, the length of which depends on the formula. The vehicle’s reaction with moisture in the air converts the
water-soluble film to an insoluble film. Conversion time depends on the vehicle and the relative humidity and temperature.
Some of these coatings undergo a color change as they cure, indicating when they are completely cured.
☞
Caution Do not topcoat or place these coatings in water-immersion service until they are thoroughly cured.Post-Cured Inorganic Zinc Coatings
Post-cured inorganic-zinc coatings are composed principally of zinc powder and sodium silicate. When mixed, the zinc-dust pigment and sodium silicate produce a water-soluble coating. coatings applicators must keep the applied film dry until it has cured by a chemical curing agent, such as phosphoric acid, which converts the film to a water insoluble coating.
Advantages:
• Long life under extreme service conditions such as exposure to marine environments
Disadvantages:
• Sensitivity to moisture until cured • White-metal surface preparation
• Necessity of removing the powder-like post-cure reaction chemicals (by washing very thoroughly) before topcoats will adhere
Uses:
• Extreme conditions such as offshore structures in marine environments.
Note While post-cured inorganic zinc coatings have a long, successful field history, the Company limits post-cured zincs to extreme services where their long life is needed such as near the water on offshore platforms. Today, however, because self-cured inorganic zincs can last almost as long and are much easier to apply properly, you may choose them instead.
Zinc-rich Organic Coatings
Epoxies, urethanes, chlorinated rubbers, phenolics, styrenes, silicones, and vinyls are vehicles for zinc-rich organic coatings. Epoxies are most common. The zinc content of these coatings should generally be about 80 percent by weight of total solids.
The mechanism for curing zinc-rich organic coatings depends on the binder. (See Section 70 of this manual for methods of film formation.) The coatings can be either single- or multi-component. Performance tends to be a function of the durability of the binder, and epoxies are generally considered superior.
Advantages:
• Excellent water and weather resistance
• Better wetting ability, because of their organic vehicles, than inorganic zinc • Usable over a broader range of surface preparation conditions than inorganic zinc
Disadvantages:
• Not as oil resistant as the inorganic coatings
Uses:
• Touch up for inorganic-zinc-primed systems • Subsea equipment primers
• As primers under other coatings
Note Often one coat of IOZ alone gives excellent performance. For higher perfor-mance or aesthetics, topcoat with epoxy or epoxy plus urethane.
Example: One coat of IOZ has lasted 15 plus years on a Richmond Long Wharf line. Pascagoula successfully used a two-coat system of Carboline Coating Company’s IOZ with Carboline high-build urethane.
130 Petroleum-based Tapes
Petroleum-based tapes, such as denso, work well in severe service as a wrapping for pipe and structural components.
Advantages:
• Adheres to moist surfaces with minimum surface preparation • Adheres to irregular shapes, valves, and pipe fittings
Disadvantages:
• Could shield cathodic protection if tape fails
Uses:
• Reinforce heavily corroded lines
140 Water-based Coatings
Chevron Corporation OpCos are required to use coating systems that meet both federal and local regulations controlling the emissions of VOCs. Because
water-based coatings use water instead of solvents as the pigment carrier, they typi-cally do not contain any “Volatile Organic Compounds” (VOC) that could be released into the air. Many OpCos may, in the future, be required to use water-based coating systems in order to meet these regulations.
After 6 months of testing the major manufacturers’ water-based coatings, Chevron has concluded that several are acceptable for inclusion in the Coatings Manual. However, since these coatings do not perform as well as solvent based coatings, we
cannot recommend them for severe exposure environments (ie: offshore or indus-trial environments). Refer to the “System Number Selection Guide” in the
Coat-ings Manual Quick Reference Guide for a listing of the acceptable brands of
water-based coatings for both new construction and maintenance systems.
150 Coating Systems for Immersion Service
Coating systems usually include a first coat (primer), second coat (tiecoat), and a final coat (topcoat).
There are three types of coating systems for immersion service and each is described below along with its advantages, disadvantages, and cost. The coatings described are: • Non-reinforced, thin-film coatings
• Glass-flake-reinforced coatings • Laminate-reinforced coatings
151 Non-reinforced Thin-film Coatings
Typically only 10 to 20 mils thick (thin films), these non-reinforced coatings: • Contain no glass flakes or fibers or laminates for reinforcement
• Usually have inert fillers such as silica or carbon to reduce shrinkage during cure and to improve abrasion resistance
• Resemble some of the high-build layers of external coating systems
• Usually are spray applied in two or more coats: a primer/sealer and one or two high-build topcoats
• Have recommended dry film thickness (DFT) of 15 to 20 mils—thicker systems for more severe services
Most thin-film coatings for tanks are based on epoxy resins, although vinyls, inor-ganic zinc, and other types of coatings have been used.
Advantages:
• Low cost
• Use least amount of material • Require no expensive hand work • Easiest to apply
• Product purity
Disadvantages:
• Lack of thickness leads to no resistance to abrasion, severe chemical attack, physical abuse
• Always have some damaged areas, called holidays
Uses:
• Temporary service
• Protection from mild corrosion, splash, or spillage environments
Note Apply and inspect this coating system properly to ensure that there are rela-tively few holidays. The small amount of corrosion which occurs will not be a problem in mild-corrosion environments if the product is pure.
If the corrosion environment is severe, however, the holidays will initiate pits that quickly become unacceptable leaks. For severe corrosion service, pre-coated tanks may have similar problems if they are scratched or damaged while being erected. For severe corrosion applications, select a thin film coating if the tank’s interior is also cathodically protected to prevent corrosion at damaged areas of the coating. [1]
Life Expectancy
The expected life of a thin-film internal coating is approximately ten years. After ten years, the coating commonly blisters, and corrosion at holidays is usually occur-ring over enough of the surface that blasting and replacing the entire coating are required.
Note Early failure due to blistering often indicates either a problem with the surface preparation or an incorrect coating selection.
Periodic inspection and repair (touch-up) of the internal coating may extend its life. As the Company inspects tanks on a ten-year cycle, periodic inspection and touch-up is usually not possible.
Limitations and Cost
Because they can be sprayed, thin-film coating systems are generally the easiest and fastest to apply, and also the least expensive.
Example: For a tank over 50,000 bbls, it might take a total of four weeks at a minimum to carry out the entire project:
• Approximately two weeks to clean, blast, and prime • Approximately one week to apply the coating • An additional week for final curing
Ease of application and cost also vary among different categories of thin film coat-ings. Factors which make a coating easier or more difficult to apply include: • Its ability to flow smoothly and form an even film
• How well it “hangs” on vertical surfaces without running or sagging • Its tendency to form pinholes
• Its tolerance to inadequate surface preparation • The amount of drying time required between coats
These factors also vary from product to product within a category, so it is difficult to make general statements. Coal-tar epoxies are, however, usually very easy to apply and relatively inexpensive, but the black color makes them difficult to inspect. Straight epoxies (polyamides or amine adduct) are also fairly easy to apply and only slightly more expensive than the coal tars. Epoxy-phenolics are often significantly more expensive and more difficult to apply.
152 Glass-flake-reinforced Coatings
Glass flakes in coatings, available in spray and trowel formulae: • Make the coating less permeable and more abrasion resistant • Reinforce the resin, allowing thicker film buildup
Note Epoxy and polyester resins are used for glass-flake-reinforced coatings.
The main difference between these two formulae is that the trowel coatings have larger reinforcing glass flakes than the spray. The layers are therefore as follows: • Trowel: Two 20 to 40 mil (DFT) coats for a total of 60 to 80 mils (DFT) • Spray: Two 15 to 20 mil (DFT) coats for a total of 30 to 40 mils (DFT)
Coatings applicators must roll each layer of both spray and trowel formulae to orient the glass flakes parallel to the surface. Rolling reduces the permeability of the coat-ings.
Cathodic protection should not be required with glass-flake-reinforced coatings (especially trowel-applied types) because they are so thick and are not easily damaged.
Advantages:
• Both (trowel and spray) are more protective than thin-film coatings because they are thicker and have fewer holidays.
• Both are highly advantageous in services where erosion or abrasion would damage thin-film coatings.
• Spray can be applied at twice the thickness of thin-film systems, and over more uneven surfaces—because of the coating's thickness—than thin film.
• Trowel is more resistant to chemical attack, abrasion, and physical abuse than either spray formula or thin-film coatings.
Disadvantages:
• Spray is marginally more expensive than thin-film coatings and rolling is required to improve resistance to chemical attack.
• Trowel is much more expensive than thin-film coatings; it is considerably more difficult and time-consuming to apply than either the spray formula or thin films, and hand smoothing and rolling is required.
Note The cost of glass-flake-reinforced coating may be justified if corrosion rates are expected to be relatively high but not severe, or permeation through the coating is a potential problem.
Uses:
Recommended for both mild and severe corrosion applications. Generally, select: • Spray for mild corrosion and for uneven surfaces
• Trowel for severe corrosion (as an alternative to a thin-film coating with cathodic protection)
Note This coating system is the most widely used one for concrete because of its excellent properties for most environments and lower cost than laminate systems.
Life Expectancy
Expect glass-flake-reinforced coatings to last at least ten years before inspection. Depending on the condition of the coating and the service, making necessary repairs may allow the coating to last another ten years. Frequently, however, it will be necessary to replace the coating after only ten years, especially for sprays. Trowel applications have a better chance of lasting through a second decade.
Limitations and Cost
The spray-applied glass-flake-reinforced coatings are usually only slightly more difficult to apply than non-reinforced coatings. Rolling the glass flake properly takes additional time during application. Spray-applied glass-flake coatings are more costly than non-reinforced coatings.
Trowel-applied glass-flake coatings are considerably more difficult and time consuming to apply than sprays. The coating is hand smoothed and rolled to orient the glass flakes. Coating application may take two to three weeks for an average size tank (increasing the total time to five to six weeks), and the total installed cost will be higher than sprayed glass-flake coatings.
Epoxy-glass-flake coatings are generally easier to apply than polyesters or vinyl esters, both of which require a final wax coat to obtain full surface curing. If the coating is premixed with wax, common for sprays, the coatings applicator must apply the second coat within the manufacturer-specified time (known as the maximum allowable time) because the second coat will not adhere well if the wax layer has fully cured the first coat.
153 Laminate-reinforced Coatings
The coatings applicator applies laminate reinforced coatings by hand, alternating layers of resin and fiberglass mat to a total thickness of typically 80 to 125 mils. Generally, they apply three layers of resin and two layers of mat.
For some services, specifications call for an additional layer of a special surfacing veil of chemical grade glass or polyester and another coat of resin.
Note The veil prevents any glass fibers from protruding through the resin surface, which could allow wicking or chemical attack of the glass itself.
After the completed laminate is inspected, the coatings applicator applies a final coat of resin. For epoxy resins, this gel coat simply provides additional protection from chemical attack.
For polyester resins, the coatings applicator adds a wax to the final resin coat to obtain full curing. Without the wax coat the surface of a polyester coating always remains slightly tacky and lacks its optimum chemical resistance, and the body of the laminate cures very slowly.
Advantages:
• A laminate-reinforced coating provides the best protection against severe corrosion. • Laminates should not require cathodic protection as they should not contain any
holidays.
• A laminate is the only type of internal coating which has significant structural strength by itself.
• Because it does not need to be as thick, epoxy-resin laminates are less expen-sive than polyester or vinyl ester laminates.
Disadvantages:
• Compared to thin-film and glass-flake-reinforced coatings, laminates are the most expensive coating.
• Laminate-reinforced coatings are the most difficult and time consuming to apply.
Uses:
• Laminates are generally used for stockside corrosion only when there is severe corrosion or when underside corrosion is expected or has occurred.
Life Expectancy
Laminate reinforced coatings will last for 20 years, but inspect and repair them after 10 years. Eventually, the laminate will start to crack and lose its adhesion to the steel, especially if the tank bottom flexes or settles significantly.
If underside corrosion occurs, remove the coupons to check the condition of the steel bottom. Replace the laminate and the bottom if the bottom is essentially corroded through.
☞
Caution Never apply a second laminate over a failed laminate.Limitation and Cost
Laminate-reinforced coatings are the most difficult and time consuming to apply. The hand layering of fiberglass mat is a slow process, normally requiring at least three weeks for an average-size tank, increasing the total time to a minimum of six
weeks. Laminates are also expensive. The total cost per square foot is equal to or higher than that of trowel-applied glass-flake coatings.
Because it does not need to be as thick, epoxy-resin laminates are less expensive than polyester or vinyl ester laminates. Polyesters and vinyl esters require a final wax coat to obtain full surface curing; however, as they remain fluid longer before starting to cure, they are easier to use.
Note The time between mixing and cure is called the gel time.
The coatings applicator can adjust the gel time by mixing different amounts of cata-lyst and promoter into the resin. After the resin sets, it will reach 90 percent of full cure in a short time. As epoxy resins do not have a gel time, they cure at a relatively constant rate, starting immediately after mixing, and therefore do not remain as fluid for as long as laminates.
160 Quality Control
161 General Information
Do the job right the first time.
Essentially a system of checks and balances, quality control helps ensure that a project’s participants fulfill the specification’s requirements. For coatings projects, the process should yield a high-quality result that:
• Contributes to the maximum service life of the structure and equipment • Reduces future expenditures for field maintenance
Offshore
Achieving high-quality coatings is more difficult offshore than onshore due to some of the following conditions:
• Adverse weather
• Simultaneous operations with other platform activities • Congested platform areas
• Limited availability of transportation
• Existing substrate surfaces that can be deeply pitted and contaminated with soluble surface salts
• Inaccessible items
Careful design and planning help to minimize the effects of these conditions. A major component of quality for offshore coatings includes cure and recoat times before returning a facility to service. Critical areas are the +/- 10-foot splash zone, work decks and helidecks, and sweating equipment and piping. See detailed infor-mation about quality control for offshore coatings in Section 800 of this manual.
Keys to Successful Projects
Comprehensive quality control activities are, however, key to any successful project.
The quality control for a specific project depends not only on type of project but also on available resources: financial and personnel. Most projects have the best financial result over the structure’s life by involving qualified individuals in the project at the most appropriate time for as long as necessary to ensure that the speci-fications are prepared properly and met.
Regardless of the size, among the keys to success of any coating project are the specifications, specialists and inspectors, and the Company’s Project Development and Execution Process (CPDEP).
Specifications
☞
Caution Avoid the pitfall of writing specifications so vague and general that they confuse everyone and allow the contractor to provide substandard work.A well-written specification includes: • Requirements for the pre-job conference • Coating schedule for all items
• Work schedule
• Materials, including coatings and abrasive • Minimum standards for equipment
Example: Equipment such as moisture traps on coating and blast pots, coating gun types and hose sizes, and quality of compressed air.
Coating Specialists and Inspectors
Industrial coating applications are highly specialized work processes that require support from individuals with particular knowledge and experience: the coating specialist and inspector.
Coating Specialist. A coating specialist provides the project's engineering team with:
• Advice about selecting, inspecting, and applying coatings • Information about premature failures
• Technical and tactical recommendations for day-to-day activities and interac-tion with the contractor
Coating Inspector. The goal of the project's coating inspector, usually a contractor,
parallels the program's objectives to ensure that all surfaces are prepared and all coatings applied within specification. The inspector:
• Enforces the specification during each phase of the work activities • Maintains detailed records of the coating activities