UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
DAJIA DAVENPORT, on behalf of herself and all
others similarly situated.
Plaintiff,
V.ELITE MODEL MANAGEMENT
CORPORATION,
Defendant.
1: 13-cv-0 I 061-AJN
CLAS
ACTION SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND RELEASE
This Class Action Settlement Agreement and Release ("Agreement") is entered into by and
among Dajia Davenport ("Plaintiff''), Polina Mosendz, Stacey Robinson, Annie Byun, and
Elizabeth Defeo (each, an "Opt-In Plaintiff''), on behalf of themselves and as representatives of the
Settlement Class Members (as hereinafter defined), and Elite Model Management Corporation
("Elite" or "Defendant"). The Plaintiff and the Opt-In Plaintiffs are collectively referred to herein
as the "Class Representatives." The Class Representatives and Elite are collectively referred to
herein as the "Parties."
This Agreement is made for the sole purpose of attempting to consummate the settlement
of the action entitled Davenport v. Elite Model Management Corporation, 13-cv-1061 (S.D.N.
Y.)(the "Action") on a class-wide basis (the "Settlement"). As detailed below, in the event that the
Court does not execute and file an Order Granting Final Approval of the Settlement (as hereinafter
defined), or in the event that the associated Judgment does not become final for any reason, this
Agreement shall be deemed null and void ab initio and shall be of no force or effect whatsoever.
A.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND RECITALS
l.
On
February
15,2073, Plaintiff
filed
a
Classand Collective Action
Complaint
(the"Complaint")
in
theAction
initiating
a purported class and collective actionlawsuit
against Elitein the United States
District
Court for the SouthernDistrict
of NewYork
(the"Court").
2.
The Complaint alleged causesof
action under the Fair Labor StandardsAct ("FLSA"),29
U.S.C.
$$ 201-219,for a
failure
to
pay minimum
wages andovertime
andfailure
to
keep andmaintain appropriate records and, under
Article 6
andArticle
19of
the
New York
Labor Law
("NYLL"),
and theNew
York
Codes, Rules and Regulations,for
failure to
payminimum
wages,overtime, and "spread
of
hours" pay, failure to keep and maintain appropriate records, and failure to provide wage statements and certain other wage-related notices.3.
On
April
26,
2013,Plaintiff
filed
a First
Amended ClassAction Complaint. Plaintiff
sFirst Amended Class
Action
Complaintwithdrew
her recordkeeping and notice-related causesof
action, and added factual allegations regarding
Plaintiff
s alleged internshiphours.
On June 14,2013,
Plaintiff filed
a Second Amended ClassAction
Complaint,which
is the current complaint in theAction.
In
the
Second Amended ClassAction
Complaint,Plaintiff
allegesFLSA
claimsfor
failure to
payminimum
wages and overtimeon
behalfof
herself andall
personswho
served asunpaid interns
for
Elite
in
theUnited
States at anytime
since February15,2010,
andNew York
state law claims
for
failure to payminimum
wages, overtime, and "spreadof
hours" pay on behalfof
herself andall
personswho
served as unpaid internsfor Elite in New York
at anytime
since Februarv 15.2007.4.
Subsequent to the commencement of theAction,
the Opt-In Plaintiffsjoined
theAction
by2013;
Stacey
Robinson-April
28,
2013;
Annie
Byun-May 30,
2013;
and
ElizabethDefeo-September
17, 2013.5.
On
June24.
2013.
Plaintiff
filed
a
motion
for
conditional
certification
of
an
FLSA
collective
action. By
order
dated
July
19,
2013,
Plaintiffs
motion
for
conditional
FLSA
certification
was administratively deniedwith
leaveto re-file
on
or
before September17,2013.
By
order dated October 15,2013, the Court administratively deniedPlaintiff
sre-filed
motionfor
conditional FLSA certification, inlight
of the Parties' resolution of this Action.6.
On
September26,
2013,the
Parties participatedin
a
mediation beforeAlfred G.
Feliu,Esq., of the
firm
of
Vandenberg&
Feliu,LLP,
an experienced andwell
regarded neutral mediator.That
effort
was productive, and based on the Parties' extensive discussions at the mediation andcontinuing thereafter,
the
Parties reached the conditional agreement reflectedin
this
Agreement.At
all
times,the
Parties'
negotiationswere vigorous,
adversarial,non-collusive, and
at
arms' length.7.
In
connectionwith
thelitigation
of
thisAction,
Class Representatives havefiled
a motion for collective action conditional certification under the FLSA, and reviewed and analyzed the factsand circumstances relating to the claims asserted
in
theAction
as knownby
Class Representativesto date,
including
analyzing thousandsof
documents producedby Elite in
connectionwith
andfor
the purposesof
the mediation, communicatingwith
theOpt-In Plaintiffs,
engagingin
numerous discussions, communications, and negotiationswith Elite's
counsel, preparingfor
(including
the submissionof
an extensive mediationbriefl
and participatingat the
mediation, and researchingpertinent case
law.
Basedon this
investigation, Class Counsel andthe
Class Representativesmaintain that the claims and contentions
in
theAction
have merit.but
have decidedto
enter intothis
Agreement aftertaking
into
account, among other things,(i)
the facts developed during thecourse of mediation-related discovery and negotiations;
(ii)
the risksof
continuedlitigation
and the absenceof
any
SecondCircuit ruling
on the
issues;(iii)
the
costsof
litigation both
in
absolute terms andin
proportionto
the maximum potential recovery;(iv)
the conclusion reachedby
ClassCounsel
and
the
Class Representativesthat the
settlement reachedherein
is
fair,
reasonable,adequate
and
in
the
best
interests
of
the
Class
Members.
Class
Counsel
and
the
Class Representatives also recognize and acknowledge the significant expense and lengthof
continued proceedings necessary to prosecute theAction
againstElite
throughtrial
and through appeals, and aremindful
of
the
inherent problemsof proof
and possible defensesto
the Alleged Claims
(ashereinafter
defined).
Both Class Counsel and the Class Representatives believe that the settlement setforth in
this Agreement confers substantial benefits upon the Settlement Class and eachof
the Settlement Class Members.8.
Nothing
in
this
Agreement,nor
the
fact
of
the
Agreementitself,
shall be
construed ordeemed to be an admission
of liability,
culpability,
negligenceor
wrongdoingof
anykind
on thepart
of
Elite
with
respectto
theAlleged
Claims (as hereinafterdefined). Elite
deniesall of
theclaims and contentions alleged by the Class Representatives
in
theAction.
Nonetheless,Elite
hasconcluded
that further litigation would be
protractedand
expensive,and would also
divertmanagement and employee
time.
Elite
has taken into account the uncertainty and risks inherent inlitigation, particularly
in
multi-party
cases.Elite
has therefore concluded thatit
is
desirable that the Action befully
andfinally
settled in the manner and upon the terms and conditions setforth
inthis Agreement.
9.
The Parties aresufficiently familiar
with
the factsof
theAction
and the applicablelaw
soParties exchanged
discovery including
Elite's
production
of
thousandsof
pagesof
documentsincluding hardcopy documents and e-mails pertaining to
Elite's
internships.10.
The Parties are representedby
competent counsel and have had the opportunity to consultwith
counsel prior to the submission of this Agreement to the Court.I
1.
Pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 408, this Agreement, and any related documents hledor
createdin
connectionwith
it,
shall be inadmissiblein
evidencein
any proceeding, except asnecessary to approve, interpret or enforce this Agreement.
NOW THEREFORE,
IT
IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED by
and amongthe
Class Representatives,for
themselvesand
for
the
membersof
the
Settlement Class (as hereinafter defined), andElite
that, subjectto
the conditions precedent setforth in
Paragtaph 52below, the
Action
andthe
ReleasedClaims
(as hereinaftgrdefined) shall be
finally
andfully
compromised, released, resolved, relinquished, discharged and settled, and
the
Action
shall
be dismissedwith
prejudice, andwithout
any adverselse, upon and subject to the terms and conditions
B.
DEFINITIONS
As used in this Agreement, the
following
te12.
"Alleged
Claims" means the claims thatClass
Action Complaint,
the
Second
Amend subsequent or amended complaints that might beclaims that
Elite
failedto
payminimum
wages,to
keep appropriateor
maintain appropriate rec provide accurate wage statements or other notice14.
"Claims Administrator"
means Tilghman&
Co., P.C., the non-party claims administrationfirm
selected and retained by Class Counsel.15.
"Claim Form"
means the"Claim
Form, IRS Form, and Release" attachedto
the Noticeof
ClassAction
Settlement.16.
"Class" and "Class Members" mean the members of theNYLL
Class and theFLSA
Class,collectively.
17.
"Class Counsel" means The Law Officeof
StevenL.
Wittels, P.C.18.
"Class Period" means(a)
for
membersof
theNYLL
Class, the periodfrom
February 15, 2007to
the Dateof
Preliminary Approval;
and(b) for
membersof
the
FLSA
Class, the periodfrom February 15,2010 to the Date of Preliminary Approval.
19.
"Class Representatives" means Dajia Davenport, Polina Mosendz, Stacey Robinson, Annie Byun, and Elizabeth Defeo.20.
"Compensable Workweeks" means thetotal
numberof
calendar weeks a Settlement Class Member served as an internfor Elite
during the Class Period, as stated by a Participating Claimanton a Qualifying Claim Form.
21.
"Court"
means the United StatesDistrict
Court for the SouthernDistrict
of New York.22.
"Date
of
Final Approval"
meansthe
date
the Court
entersan Order
Granting
Final Approval of the Settlement.23.
.,Dateof
Preliminary
Approval"
meansthe
date
the Court
entersan
Order
Granting Preliminary Approval of the Settlement.24.
..Day,'or "Days"
(whether capitalizedor
not) means calendar day, unless expressly stated otherwise.a.
If
no
objectionsto
the
Settlement are submitted,the
daythe
Judgment approving the Settlement is entered;b.
If
any objections are submitted, and no appeal is taken, the date onwhich
the time tofile
any appeal from the Judgment has expired; orc.
If
any objections are submitted, and an appealis
timely filed with
respectto
theJudgment, the date such an appeal is dismissed or the Judgment is affirmed, and the
Judgment is not subject to further
judicial
review or reconsideration by any court.26.
,,Final
Approval Hearing" shall
have
the
meaning
set
forth
in
Paragraph54
of
the Agreement.27.
,,FLSA
Class" meansall
individuals,
other thanthe
membersof
the
NYLL
Class, who served as unpaid internsfor Elite or
any subsidiaryof Elite in
theUnited
States between February15,2010 and the Date
of
Preliminary Approval of the Settlement.2g.
.,Judgment" means the judgment or order to be rendered and entered by the Court pursuant to this Agreement.29.
"Last Known
Address" means the most recently recordedmailing
address(if
known) and(if
known)
for
a
Class Member as suchinformation
is
maintainedin
the regular course of business inElite's
records.30.
..Litigation
Expenses" means those expenses and costsof
litigation
actually
incurred by Class Counsel and approved for reimbursement by the Court, excluding costs or fees of the ClaimsAdministrator.
31.
,,Maximum SettlementAmount"
means the maximum amount thatElite
shall pay under theterms
of this
Agreement,which is
Four
HundredFifty
ThousandDollars
($450,000.00), and isAdministration Costs, and Service Awards
to
the
Class Representatives.This
amount does notinclude
Elite's
shareof
payroll
taxes, such asFICA
andFUTA,
exceptto
the
extent that those taxes may be paid by Elite using any Unclaimed Amount'32.
..Net
SettlementAmount"
meansthe
Maximum
SettlementAmount
lessthe
maximum amountsClass Counsel
may
request
for
Attorneys'
Fees
and Litigation
Expenses, Claims Administration Costs, and any Service Awards to the Class Representatives.33.
..Notice
of
ClassAction
Settlement"or
'Notice"
shall
have
the
meaning set
forth
in
Paragraph 63 of this Agreement.
34.
,.Noticeperiod"
shall have the meaning set forth in Paragraph 66 of this Agreement'35.
.NYLL
Class"
meansall
individuals who
servedas
unpaid interns
for
Elite
or
any subsidiary of Elite inNew
york
from February 15,20Q7 through the Date of Preliminary Approvalof the Settlement.
36.
.,Order GrantingFinal
Approval
of
the
Settlement"shall
havethe
meaning setforth
in
Paragraph 52 of this Agreement.
37
.
..Order Granting Preliminary Approvalof
the Settlement" shall have the meaning setforth
in Paragraph 52 of this Agreement.
3g.
.,participating Claimant" means each Class Member who submits aQualifying
Claim Formin response to the Notice
of
ClassAction
Settlement'39.
..preliminaryApproval
Motion"
shall have the meaning setforth in
Paragraph 54of
thisAgreement.
40.
,.Qualifying
claim
Form"
meansa claim
Form that
is
properly
completed, properlyexecuted, and
timely
returned to theclaims
Administrator.42.
..Releasedparties"
meansElite
Model
Managementcorp.,
Elite
Model
ManagementCorporation,
a
California
Corporation,Elite Model
ManagementMiami
Corporation,a
FloridaCorporation,
and
their
respective present
or
former officers, directors,
direct
or
indirect stockholders,partners, members,
or
other
owners,
or
the
affiliates,
subsidiaries, divisions,predeCeSSors, SuCC9SSOTS, agents, employeeS, insurers, co-insurerS, attorneys, aOcountants' auditOrs'
advisors, representatives, consultants, pension and welfare plans, plan fiduciaries, administrators, trustees andior assigns
of
any of the foregoing'43.
.,Settlement" means the terms and conditions set forth in this Agreement.44.
.,settlement Class" and "settlement Class Member" meanall
membersof
theNYLL
Classwho have not opted
out
of
the Settlement afterNotice,
andall
membersof
theFLSA
Class who have submittedeualifying
Claim
Forms, andwho
are thereforein
the
classthat
is
certified for
purposesof
Settlementonly, following
the entryof
an appropriate Order by the Court'4s.
..Settlementpayment"
meansthe
total,
gross amount dueto
an
individual
ParticipatingClaimant, which shall be calculated as described
in
Paragraphs 70 and 73 of this Agreement'46.
.,ServiceAward"
shall have the meaning set forth in Paragraph 59 of this Agreement'47.
,.Total
SettlementAmount"
meansthe total
amountpaid
by
Elite
in
considerationfor
settlement of theAction,
including Settlement Payments,Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses'Claims Administration Costs,
and
ServiceAwards
to
the
ClassRepresentatives'
The
TotalSettlement Amount shall not include any Unclaimed Amount.
4g.
,.UnclaimedAmount"
shall have the meaning setforth in
Paragraph 73of
this Agreement'Elite
shall, atall
times, retain custody,control,
and exclusivefinal
possessionof
the unclaimedAmount.
50.
"UpdatedAddress"
meansa mailing
addressthat was
updatedvia
an
updated mailingaddress provided by the United States Postal Service or a Class Member.
C.
CONDITIONS
PRECEDENT
TO THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF
THIS AGREEMENT
51.
The Parties enter into this Agreement and the Settlement on a conditional basis.52.
This
Agreementwill
becomefinal
andeffective
only
uponthe
occurrenceof
all of
thefollowing
events:a.
b.
c.
d.
The Court enters an Order Granting Preliminary Approval of the Settlement;
The Court enters an Order Granting Final Approval of the Settlement;
Judgment is entered by the Court dismissing the
Action with
prejudice; andThe Effective Date
occurs,
and any
challenge
to
the
Settlement,whether
by objection or appeal, is resolved in favorof
enforcement of the Settlement.Unless the
Court
orders otherwiseor
agreedto in writing by
the Parties,this
Agreementshall be deemed
null
and voidab
initio
upon thefailure
of
anyof
the foregoing eventsto
occur.Upon the
failure
of
anyof
thesefour
eventsto
occur, theAction
will
resume unless the Partiesjointly
agree to seek Court approvalof
a renegotiated settlement.D.
CONDITIONAL
CLASS
ACTION AND COLLECTIVE ACTION CERTIFICATION
53.
The
Parties stipulate
to
class
certification
of
the
NYLL
Class
and collective
actioncertification
of
theFLSA
Class solelyfor
the purposesof
this settlement.
If
the Court does not grant preliminary orfinal
approvalof
this Settlement or,if
appealed, the Judgment is not affirmed,the
Parties agreethat
classcertification
andcollective
actioncertification
will
automatically be deemedrevoked.
The Partieswill
take any other steps necessary todecertiff
the Settlement Class.In
the
casethat
classcertification
andcollective
activecertification
are deemed revoked, thosecertifications shall have no precedential value and shall not be introduced into evidence or used
for
any other purpose.
E.
MOTIONS
FOR
COURT APPROVAL
54.
Motion for
PreliminaryApproval.
Onor
before December19,2013 (or
such later date asmay be set
by
theCourt),
Plaintiff
shallfile
amotion
for
an OrderConditionally Certifying
the Classfor
Settlement Purposes andPreliminarily
Approving the Settlement("Preliminary
ApprovalMotion"),
togetherwith:
(a) a copyof
this Agreement; (b) separately, a proposed Order Granting Preliminary Approvalof
the Settlement,in which
the Court shall seta
datefor
a hearingfor
hnal approvalof
the
settlement("Final
Approval Hearing");
and(c)
any other
documents consistentwith
the
Settlement and reasonably necessaryto
obtainthe Court's
approvalof
the
Settlement.Class Counsel
will
provide
Elite with
reasonabletime
to
review and
approvethe
Preliminary ApprovalMotion
andall
supporting papers.55.
Motion
for
Final
Approval.
The Parties shall request that theFinal Approval
Hearing be setfor
hearingwithin
45 days after the last dayof
theNotice
Period,or
as soon thereafter as theCourt's calendar shall
allow,
but in no event shallit
be set sooner than 100 daysfollowing
the date the PreliminaryApproval Motion
isfiled with
theCourt. At
least seven (7) daysprior
to the FinalApproval Hearing, Class Representatives shall
file
amotion
for final
approvalof
the
Settlementthat
asksthe Court
to
enter an orderwhich:
(l)
grantsfinal
approvalto
the
Settlement as fair,adequate and reasonable; (2) incorporates the terms
of
the Release, as describedin
Paragraphs 86and 87
of
this
Agreement; (3) permanently enjoinsall
Settlement Class Membersfrom
pursuing and/or seeking to reopen any Released Claim; and (4) dismisses theAction with
prejudice("Final
ApprovalMotion").
The FinalApproval Motion
shall include the proposed Order Granting Final Approval of the Settlement.At
the same time that Class Representativesfile
their Final ApprovalMotion,
they shall alsofile
their Motion(s)
for
Attorney's
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, ClaimsAdministration Costs, and Class Representative Service
Awards.
Class Counselwill
provide Elitewith at
least fourteen
(14)
days
to
review
and
approvethe Final Approval Motion
and all
supporting papers.
F.
ATTORAIEY'S
FEESAND
LITIGATION
EXPENSES56.
Class Counselwill
submit an applicationfor
an awardof
no more than One Hundred FortyThree Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($143,500.00) for
Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses.The
amountsset
forth
in
this
Paragraphwill
constitutecomplete
considerationfor all
work
performed and expenses incurredto
date andfor all
workedto
be performed and expensesto
be incurred through the completionof
theAction
andits
Settlement.Elite
will
not
oppose a motionfor
approvalof
Class Representatives'Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses consistentwith
this Paragraph. The application
for Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, as set forth herein, is a matter separate and apartfrom
the Settlement among the Parties, andno
decisionby
the Courtconcerning the granting,
in
whole orin
part,of
suchAttorneys'
Feesor Litigation
Expenses as setforth herein shall affect the
validity
of
this Agreementor
finality
of the Settlementin
any manner.In
the event the Court awards Class Representatives'Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expensesof
less than $143,500.00, the difference shall become an UnclaimedAmount
(to be retainedby
Elite in accordancewith
Paragraph 73), subject to the Court's approval.57.
TheAttorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses shall be paid according to Paragraphs 82 and 83 of this Agreement.G.
CLAIMS
ADMINISTRATION
COSTS58.
"Claims Administration Costs" shall include
all
costsand
expensesdue
to
the
ClaimsAdministrator
in
connectionwith
its administration of the Settlement including, but notlimited
to,providing the Notice
to
Class Members,
processingOpt-Out Forms and Claim
Forms,
and administering anddistributing
Settlement Payments to the ParticipatingClaimants.
Class Counselwill
submit an applicationfor
an award of no more than Fifteen Thousand Dollars ($15,000.00) to be paid from theMaximum
Settlement Amountfor
ClaimsAdministration Costs.
The applicationfor
Claims Administration
Costs,as
setforth
herein,
is
a
matter
separateand
apartfrom
the Settlement among the Parties, and no decision by the Court concerning the granting, in whole orin
part,
of
suchClaims Administration
Costsas
setforth
herein shall affect
the validity
of
this Agreementor finality
of
the
Settlementin
anymanner.
In
the
eventthe Court
awards ClaimsAdministration
Costsof
lessthan Fifteen
ThousandDollars
($15,000.00),the
difference
shall become an Unclaimed Amount, subject to the Court's approval.H.
CLASSREPRESENTATIVE
SERVICE
AWARDS
59.
Class Counselwill
submit
an applicationfor
no
more thana
total
of
Twenty
ThousandDollars ($20,000.00) as "Service
Awards" to
the Class Representativesfor
their time, effort
andparticipation
in
the
Action as
Class
Representatives,to
be
distributed among
the
ClassRepresentatives
as
follows:
Dajia
Davenport-$5,000; Polina Mosendz-$3,500;
StaceyRobinson-$3,500; Annie
Byun-$4,750;
Elizabeth
Defeo-$3,250.
Elite
will
not
oppose amotion
for
approvalof
such ServiceAwards,
and agreesthat the
requestis fair
and reasonable under the circumstancesof
thiscase.
The applicationfor
Service Awards, as setforth
herein, is amatter separate and apart
from
the
Settlement amongthe
Parties, andno
decisionby
the
Courtconcerning the granting,
in
whole orin
part,of
such Service Awards as set forth herein shall affectthe
validity of
this Agreementor
finality
of
the Settlementin
anymanner. In
the event the Courtawards Service Awards
of
less thanTwenty
ThousandDollars
($20,000.00), the difference shall become an Unclaimed Amount, subject to the Court's approval.60.
The Service Awards shall be paid according to Paragraphs 82 and 83 of this Agreement.I.
COOPERATION
61.
The parties shall cooperatefully with
one anotherin
seeking approvalof
the Courtof
thisAgreement and
to
usetheir
respective besteffons
to
consummatethe
Settlement and cause the Judgment to be entered and to becomefinal.
The Parties therefore agree to cooperatein
goodfaith
to
promptly
prepare,execute
andfinalize
all
Settlement-related documents, seekall
necessaryCourt approvals, and do
all
other things necessary to consummate the Settlement-All
Settlement-related documents, including, but notlimited
to, this Agreement, the Preliminary ApprovalMotion
(and any supporting papers), and the Final Approval
Motion
(and any supporting papers) must be acceptable in bothform
and content to each of theParties.
In the event that the Parties are unableto reach agreement on the
form
or contentof
any documents neededto
implement the Settlement,or on
any
supplementalprovisions
that
may
become necessaryto
effectuatethe
termsof
theSettlement, the parties agree
to
seek the assistanceof
theCourt.
The Partiesfuither
agree that allsuch
documents, supplementalprovisions, and
requestsfor
assistanceof
the Court shall
beconsistent
with
this Agreement.62.
No
party
to
this
Agreementshall
seekto
evadeher
or its
goodfaith
obligationsto
seekapproval and implementation of this Settlement by virtue
of
anyruling,
order, governmental reportor
other development, whetherin
the Actions,
in
any otherlitigation or
otherwise that hereafter might occur and might be deemedto
alter the relative strengthsof
the Partieswith
respectto
anyclaims or defenses or
their
relative bargaining powerwith
respectto negotiating.
The Parties and their respective counselof
record deemthis
Settlement to befair
and reasonable and have arrivedat
this
settlementin
arms-length negotiationstaking
into
accountall
relevant factors, present orpotential.
J.
NOTICE
PROCEDURE
63.
Noticeto
ClassMembers.
Within
fifteen (15) business days after the Dateof
Preliminary Approval,Elite
will
provide
to
the ClaimsAdministrator
the name and LastKnown
Addressof
each Class Member(the
"ClassList").
With
the productionto
the
ClaimsAdministrator
of
the ClassList, Elite
shall have satisfied its obligationto
furnish Class Members' contact information.Elite
will
actin
goodfaith to
respondto
inquiriesfrom
the ClaimsAdministrator
regarding, or toclarify
information
containedon, the
ClassList.
However,the Claims Administrator shall
besolely responsible
for
conducting theNotice. Not
later thanforty five (45)
daysfollowing
theDate
of
Preliminary Approval, the Claims Administrator shall
send,via
U.S.
both
addresses are available)to
eachLast
Known
Addressof
the
Class Members, aNotice
of
ClassAction
Settlement (hereinafter, the"Notice"),
and aClaim
Form (eachof
whichshall have a unique identification number for purposes of verification), each in a form approved by
the
Court.
TheNotice
shallinform
each Class Memberof
the material termsof
the
Settlement,including the
Maximum
Settlement Amount and the procedurefor
obtaining a Settlement Paymentand
the
procedurefor
opting out
of
the
Settlement,and
shall
include
an
explanationof
howSettlement Payments
will
be
calculated. In
advanceof
the Claims Administrator emailing
anyNotice, counsel for the Parties shall negotiate
in
good faith(l)
the content of the email which shall attach theNotice,
and (2) alist of
frequently asked questions and answers("FAQs")
to be used bythe Claims Administrator
in
responding to inquiries from Class Membersfollowing
the issuanceof
anyNotice.
If
the ClaimsAdministrator
determines thatit
cannot respondto
a Class Member'sinquiry
because theinquiry falls
outsideof
the scopeof
the FAQs, then the Claims Administrator shall contact counselfor
the Parties simultaneouslyby
email and requestguidance.
Counselfor
in
good
faith
any
issuesraised
by
the
Class
Member's
inquiry.
Thereafter,
the
ClaimsAdministrator
shall
communicatethe
agreed-upon responseto
the
ClassMember.
If
neitherPlaintiffs'
nor
Defendant's
counseltimely
respondsto
an
issueraised
by a
Class Member'sinquiry,
thenthe Claims Administrator
shall useits
professionaljudgment
in
respondingto
theClass
Member's
inquiry and shall promptly
advise
counselfor
the
Partiesvia
of
the response.64.
For any Class Member to whom Notice is sentonly by
mail, Notice shall be
deemedmailed on the
datethe Claims Administrator
places theNotice
with
the U.S. Postal Servicefor mailing.
For any Class Memberto
whomNotice is
sentonly by e-mail, the Notice shall be deemed mailed on the date the Claims Administrator sends the
e-mail.
For Class Membersto
whom the ClaimsAdministrator
sendsNotice bv
bothe-mail, Notice shall be deemed mailed on the earliest of the date the Claims Administrator places the
notice
with
the U.S. Postal Servicefor mailing or
sends theNotice via
e-mail. In
the event that, subsequent to thefirst mailing
and at least seven(7)
daysprior to
the endof
the Notice Period, amailed
Notice
is
retumed
by
the U.S.
Postal Service
to
the Claims
Administrator
with
aforwarding
addressfor
the recipient, the Claims Administrator shall re-mail the notice
to
that address no later than the last dayof
the Notice Period, and the forwarding addresswill
be deemed the Updated Addressfor
that ClassMember.
In the event that subsequent to thefirst mailing
andat
least seven(7)
daysprior to
the endof
theNotice
Period theNotice
is
returnedby the
U.S. Postal Serviceto
the ClaimsAdministrator without a forwarding
address (i.e.,the
addressis
nolonger
valid
andthe
envelopeis
marked"Return
to
Sender"),the
Claims Administrator
shall complete one standard skip tracein
an effort to ascertain the current address of the particular ClassMember
in
question and,if
such address is ascertained, the Claims Administratorwill
re-send theNotice no later than the last day of the Notice Period;
if
no updated Address is ascertained for thatclass
Member, theclaims
Administrator
will
re-send theNotice to
the LastKnown
Address no later than the last dayof
theNotice
Period. In
the eventthat
an e-mailedNotice is
returned as undeliverableto
the claims
Administrator
becauseof
an invalid e-mail
addressfor a
class Memberto
whom
only
e-mailedNotice
was sent,the
ClaimsAdministrator
shall complete one standard skip tracein
aneffort to
ascertain the current addressof
the particular Class Memberin
question and,if
such addressis
ascertained, the ClaimsAdministrator
will
re-send theNotice
no later than the last day of the Notice Period'65.
For those Class Members who are re-sent the Notice under Paragraph 64, the Notice Period shall be extended another ten (10) days beyond theinitial
Notice Period, except thatfor
any classMember
who
was sentNotice
only by mail
and re-sentNotice
under Paragraph64,
the NoticePeriod shall be extended another twenty (20) days beyond the
initial
Notice Period'66.
Opt-Out and Claims Procedurea.
NYLL
ClassMembers.
Subjectto
Court
approval,NYLL
Class Members shallhave sixty (60) days from the date that the Claims Administrator mails the Notice to them (referred
to hereafter as the ..Notice
period") to
properly complete theclaim
Formor
anopt-out
Form (awritten
statementwith
the
Class Member's name, address, and phone number stating"I'
[insertname],
wish
to
opt-out
of
the
Elite
classaction
settlement, andnot
receiveany
benefitsor
be boundby
thejudgment
in
the
case.")and
to
return
it
by mail, e-mail,
or
fax
to
the
claims
Administrator
prior
to
midnight,
eastern standardtime, on
the
final
day
of
the
Notice
Period'Members of the
NYLL
Class who do not properly and/ortimely
submit an Opt-Out Form become Settlement class Members and shall be subject to the Judgment.b.
FLSA
ClassMembers.
Subject to Court approval,FLSA
Class Members shall haveuntil
no later than the last dayof
the Notice Period to properly complete theClaim
Form (whichshall constitute evidence
of
suchFLSA
Class Members' consent tojoin
theAction),
and to returnit
by mail, e-mail,or
faxto
the Claims Administratorprior
tomidnight,
eastern standard time, on the final day of the NoticePeriod.
Members of theFLSA
Class who do notproperly
and,lortimely submit a Claim Form shall not be subject to the Judgment.c.
The dateof
mailing
of
an Opt-Out Formor Claim
Formis
deemedto
be the datethe form
is
(1) depositedin
the U.S.
Mail,
postageprepaid, as
evidencedby
the
post-mark, (2) received electronicallyby fax by
the ClaimsAdministrator,
as evidencedby
the transmissiondata appearing
on the Claims Administrator's
fax-receivedcopy
of
the Opt-Out
Formor
Claim Form;or (3)
received electronicallyby
e-mailby
the ClaimsAdministrator,
as evidencedby
the"received date" appearing on the Claims
Administrator's
copyof
the email transmitting theOpt-Out
Form
or Claim
Form.
Any
Opt-Out Form
or
Claim Form mailed after midnight,
eastern standard time, on thefinal
dayof
the Notice Period is untimely and shall not be considered by the Claims Administrator.d.
Class Members who submit both a Claim Form and an Opt-Out Form shall be senta cure letter by the Claims Administrator seeking
clarification
of the response they want to submit.Absent any cure, such Class Members
will
be deemedto
have excludedhim
or
herselffrom
the Settlement.the omitted information.
e.
The Settlement Administratorwill
e-mail simultaneously Class Counsel andElite's
counsel copies
of
all
Claim
Forms and Opt-Out Forms receivedfrom
Class Memberswithin
three(3) business days of their
receipt.
The Claims Administrator shall retain the originals ofall
ClaimsForms and
opt-out
Forms receivedby mail,
and envelopes accompanyingmailed Claim
Forms and Opt-Out Forms,in
itsfiles until
such time as the Claims Administrator is relievedof
its duties and responsibilities underthis Agreement.
Forall claim
Forms andopt-out
Forms received bymail,
the
ClaimsAdministrator shall
stamp the postmarked dateon the original
of
each Claim
Form and Opt-Out Form.
f'
Within ten (10)
days
after
the
expiration
of
the
Notice period,
the
ClaimsAdministrator shall provide
simultaneously
Class
Counsel
and
Elite's
counsel
with
final
information regarding(i)
any Class Members who have opted outof
the Class; and(ii)
the Class Members who have submittedeualifying
Claim Forms.g.
The Parties and counselfor
the Parties agreeto work
in
goodfaith
with
each other andthe
ClaimsAdministrator
in
orderto
resolve any disputeswhich
arise regarding whether aClaim Form or Opt-Out Form was properly completed and executed, and
timely
submitted.h.
If
ten percent(10%)
or
moreof
the
membersof
theNYLL
Classopt-out
of
the Settlement, thenElite
shall
havethe
right, in its
sole discretion,to void this
Agreement and torevoke class
certification
andcollective
actioncertification.
Elite
hastwenty (20)
business daysfollowing
itsnotification by
the Claims Administrator regarding thefinal
numberof
NYLL
Class Members who have optedout
of
the
Settlementto
notify
Class Counselof its
intentto void
this Agreement and to revoke class certification.i.
Class Representatives and Class Counsel represent and warrant that they have not,nor
will
they: (a) attemptto void
this Agreementin
anyway; (b)
opt-outof
the Settlement Class;(c) solicit, encourage or assist in any fashion Class Members to opt-out; or (d) solicit, encourage or assist
in
any fashion
any effort
by
any
person(natural
or
legal)
to
object
to
the
Settlement.Nothing
in
this provision shall prevent Class Counselfrom
advising aclient of his
or herright
to opt out or object.j.
Elite
represents and warrantsthat
it
hasnot, nor
will it:
(a)
attemptto void
this Agreementin
any
way,
except asprovided
in
Paragraph66(h)
of
this
Agreement;(b)
solicit,encourage
or
assistin
any fashion Class Membersto
opt-out;or
(c)solicit,
encourageor
assist inany fashion any effort by any person (natural or legal) to object to the Settlement.
67.
Objections. Any
ClassMember
who
wishesto
objectto
the
Settlementmust
file
anddeliver
a written
objection
with the
Court,
and serve copiesof
the written
objection
to
ClassCounsel and counsel
for
Elite, no later than the last day of the NoticePeriod.
The date of deliveryof
the written objection
is
deemedto
be the
datethe objection
is
depositedin
the U.S. Mail,
postage pre-paid, as evidenced by the
postmark.
The objection must set forth,in
clear and concise terms, the legal and factual arguments supporting theobjection.
Unless otherwise orderedby
theCourt, Class Members
shall not
beentitled
to
speak atthe Final Approval
Hearing unless they have submitted atimely written
objection pursuantto this
Paragraph. Class Members who haveproperly and
timely
submitted objections may appear at the Final Approval Hearing, although they are not requiredto
do so, eitherin
person or through a lawyer retained attheir
own expense.If
aClass Member intends to object to the Settlement through retained counsel, then that counsel must
file
a
noticeof
appearanceno
later
thanthe last day
of
the
Notice
Period
anda
statementof
whether counsel intends
to
appear at theFinal Approval
Hearing.
The Partiesmay
file with
theCourt
written
responsesto
any
filed
objectionsno
later than three
(3)
daysbefore
the
FinalApproval
Hearing. Any
NYLL
Class Member who has opted out of the Settlement may not object to the Settlement or speak at the Final Approval Hearing'68'
Declarationof compliance. No
later than (20)days
prior
to
the FinalApproval
Hearing,the Claims
Administrator
shallprovide
Class Counsel andElite,s counsel
with
a Declaration
of
Compliance to be
filed with
the Court by Class Counsel.K.
69'
Total
SettlementAmount.
Elite
agreesto
pay
eachparticipating
claimant his
or
her Settlement Paymentas
considerationfor
settlementof
the
Action.
The
Maximum
SettlementAmount
shall
not
exceed
the
aggregate
sum
of
Four
Hundred
Fifty
Thousand
Dollars ($450,000'00)' Notwithstanding any other provision in this Agreement, asidefrom Elite,s share
of
payroll
taxes,in
no eventwill
Elite
be obligatedto
pay more than Four HundredFifty
ThousandDollars
($450,000.00)in
total
settlementof
the Action, including
all
Settlement payments,
Litigation
Expenses,Claims Administration Costs,
Service
Award,
or
any
other
amounts whatsoever.
70.
Each Participating Claimant
shall
receive
aSettlement Payment,
which is a
shareof
the
Net
SettlementAmount
basedon
the
numberof
Compensable Workweeks
for which
the Participating Claimant internedfor
Elite.
The SettlementPayment
for
each
individual
Participating
Claimant shall
be
calculated
by
multiplying
the ParticipatingClaimant's
Compensable Workweeks,up
to
amaximum
of
ten (10)
weeks,by
theamount
of
One Hundred
SeventyFive Dollars
and
Sixteen Cents($175.16).
The
maximumSettlement Payment to any Participating Claimant shall be $1,751.61. Each participating Claimant
shall
receive
a
minimum
Settlement Payment calculated basedupon
four
(4)
Compensable Workweeks, for aminimum
Settlement Payment to each Participating Claimantof
$700.64.71.
Within fifteen (15)
days
after
the Date
of
Preliminary
Approval,
Elite
will
provide verification toPlaintiff
as to the numberof
Class Members reflectedin
its recordsin
the formof
adeclaration to be furnished
by
Elite.
If
thefinal
numberof
Class Members as reflectedin
Elite,s records exceeds155,
the maximum and minimum
SettlementPayment
to
any
participatingClaimant, as described
in
ParagraphT0, shall be reduced on a pro ratabasis.
At
Plaintiffs'
option,if
thefinal
numberof
Class Members as reflectedin
Elite's
records exceeds 171, the Parties shallhave additional discussions regarding the terms
of
thedistribution of
theNet
Settlement Amountdescribed in Paragraph 70.
72.
Elite agrees to pay Service Awardsof
a totalof
Twenty Thousand Dollars ($20,000.00), tobe
divided
amongthe
Class Representatives,upon
Class Counsel's application andthe
Court'sapproval, pursuant to Paragraphs 59 and 60 of this Agreement. The Class Representatives shall be issued an IRS Form 1099 for any Service Award.
73.
Unclaimed Portionof
theNet
Settlement Amount.Elite
shallnot
be requiredto
pay anyamount
of
theNet
SettlementAmount that
remains after paymentof
the
Settlement Payments. The "UnclaimedAmount"
shall be the sumof
the amountof
theNet
SettlementAmount
less thetotal
of
Settlement Payments allocated to Participating Claimants, plus any difference between the amounts requestedby
Class Counselfor
Attorneys'
Fees and Expenses,Claims
AdministrationCosts, and Service Awards and the amounts awarded
by
the Courtfor
such fees, expenses, costs and awards.Elite
shall, atall
times, retain custody, control, and exclusivefinal
possessionof
the Unclaimed Amount.a.
In the event that thetotal
amountof
Settlement Payments allocatedto
ParticipatingClaimants
is
less thanNinety
ThousandDollars
($90,000.00), thetotal
amountof
the Settlement Paymentsto
the Participating Claimants shall be adjusted accordinglyto
equalNinety
ThousandDollars
($90,000.00).
In
that case,the
Settlement Paymentfor
each Participating Claimant shallbe increased
to
include apro
rata
shareof
the
adjustment amount,not
to
exceed an additional$1,000
per
ParticipatingClaimant.
If
any
amountof
the
$90,000 remains unclaimed
after
the additionalpro
rato
distribution to Participating claimants,that amount shall be donated under the
cy pres doctrine to the National Employment Lawyers Association,
which
is a charity selected byPlaintiff
and Class Counsel.b'
The
claims
Administrator shall
notify class
counsel
andElite,s
counselof
theunclaimed Amount pursuant to paragraph g0 of this Agreement.
74'
Elite understands and agrees thatit
shall be responsiblefor
paying the employer,s shareof
any applicable payroll taxes, including those collected under the authority of
the Federal Insurance
contributions
Act (FICA),
separate and apartfrom,
and
in
additionto,
theMaximum
SettlementAmount'
Elite shall use funds from the Unclaimed Amount,if
any, to pay theFICA
taxes.75'
The
Total
SettlementAmount
will
constitute adequate considerationfor this
Settlementand
will
be madein
full
andfinal
settlement of:a.
The Released Claims;b.
Class Counsel's claim forAttomeys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses;c.
Service Awards;d.
Claims Administration Costs; ande'
Any
other obligation of the Parties and/or Class Counsel under this Agreement.76'
Receiptof
a Settlement Payment does not entitle Class Representatives or any participatingClaimant
to
any
additional
compensationor
benefits,
or
create
eligibility
for
any
such compensation
or
benefits, underany
of
Elite's
compensationor
benefit
plansor
agreementsin
placeduring the
Class Period,nor
will it
entitle the
Class Representativesor
any
participating Claimantto, without limitation,
any retirementbenefits,4l0(k)
contributions,severance benefits,
deferred compensation
benefits, vacation
pay,
or
holiday
pay.
Elite
Settlement Payments "compensation" for purposes of determining
eligibility
for,
or benefit accrualwithin, an
employeepension
benefit plan, an
employeewelfare
benefit plan,
or
other
plansponsored by Elite or its predecessors, subsidiaries, or successors.
77
'
The
Settlement Paymentsshall be paid
according
to
Paragraphs82
and
83
of
this Agreement.L.
TAX CONSIDERATIONS
78.
For purposesof
calculating applicable taxes, the Parties agree that onethird
(33 ll3%)
of
each Settlement Payment constitutes wages (and each Participating
Claimant
will
be
issued anIRS Form
W-2 for
such paymentto
her orhim),
and onethird (33
Il3%)
liquidated damages and onethird
interest(33
ll3%)
(for
which
each Participating Claimantwill
be issued an IRS Form1099).
Elite
shallnot
be responsiblefor
payroll tax
paymentson
anyportion
of
the
SettlementConsideration
that
is
attributable
to
Attorneys' Fees
and
Litigation
Expenses,
ClaimsAdministration
Costs, liquidated damages, interest,or
any Class Representative Service Award. The Parties further understand that the Class Representatives and any Participating Claimant who receives any Settlement Payment pursuantto
this
Agreement shall be solely responsiblefor
any and all tax obligations associatedwith
such receipt, except as set forth in this Paragraph.M. PAYMENT
OF
CLAIMS
79-
As a condition of receiving any Settlement Payment under this Agreement, (a) membersof
theNYLL
Class must not"opt out" of
the Class, must submit aQualifying
Claim Form, and must release the Released Claims; and (b) members of theFLSA
Class must submit aQualifying
Claim Form, and must releasethe
Released Claims. Each ParticipatingClaimant
shall be entitledto
apayment equal
to
the
sumof
the
Settlement Payment, less the ParticipatingClaimant's
shareof
taxes and
withholding.
The Settlement Payment shall be determined by the Claims Administratorin the manner described
in
Paragraph 70 (and Paragraph 73,if
necessary) of this Agreement.80.
Within
ten (10)
daysof
noticeby
the
ClaimsAdministrator
of
the
Class Members who have made claims andwho
have optedout
of
the Classin
accordancewith
paragraph66(f),
the Claims Administratorwill
notify
Elite's
counselofi
(a) theNet
SettlementAmount;
(b) the TotalSettlement
Amount; (c)
the UnclaimedAmount,
if
any; and(d)
the
Settlement payments due to each Class Member.81.
Not
later thanthirty
(30) daysfollowing
the Effective Date,Elite
shall provide the ClaimsAdministrator
with
theTotal
SettlementAmount.
However,in
the event that the Order on Class Counsel's applicationfor
Class Representatives'Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, ClaimsAdministration
Costs, and ServiceAwards
is not final within thirty (30)
daysof
the
EffectiveDate, any amounts payable under such Order as part
of
theTotal
SettlementAmount
will
be paidby Elite within thirty (30)
daysafter
suchOrder
is
deemedfinal
andno
longer
subjectto
any further j udicial reconsideration, review or appeal.82.
The Claims Administrator shall be
responsiblefor mailing
paymentsto
the
Settlement Class Members, aswell
as issuing payment of any Service Awards,Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, and Claims Administration Costs.
83'
Not
later thanforty
(40) daysfollowing
the Effective Date, the Claims Administrator shall (a) mail to each Settlement Class Member a checkin
the amount calculated pursuant to Paragraph 70 (and Paragraph13,if
necessary) of this Agreement; and (b) issue to Class Counsel paymentfor
Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, ClaimsAdministration
Costs, and ServiceAwards.
The Claims Administrator shall be responsiblefor
making any applicable employeepayroll
deductionsfrom
the
SettlementPayments.
Paymentsof
Attorneys'
Fees andLitigation
Expenses, ClaimsAdministration Costs, and Service Awards shall be
in
a manner to be specifiedby
Class Counsel,without withholding, and reported to the IRS and each respective payee on an IRS
Form 1099. In
order
to
receive
paymentsunder
this
Paragraph,Class Counsel, Class
Representatives, andParticipating Claimants
shall provide
to the
Claims Administrator
their
taxpayer identificationnumber and/or social security number, as applicable.
84.
Any
checks issued to Participating Claimants shall remain negotiablefor
a period of ninety(90)
daysfrom
the
dateof mailing.
Any
check issuedto
a
ParticipatingClaimant that
is
notnegotiated
within
the 90-day periodwill
bevoid,
anda
stop paymentwill
be placedon
it.
TheClaims Administrator shall return
all
funds relating to non-negotiated Settlement Payment checksto Elite
within thirty
(30) days of the expiration of the 90-dayperiod.
Participating Claimants whofail
to negotiate their check(s)in
atimely
fashion shall,like
all
Settlement Class Members, remain subject to the terms of the Judgment.85.
Elite agrees notto
seek reimbursementfrom Plaintiffs
or the Claims Administratorfor
any costs or expenses incurredby Elite in providing
information to the Claims Administratoror
Class Counsel that is necessaryto identify
or pay Participating Claimants,including
any cost associatedwith
advising the ClaimsAdministrator
of
information necessaryfor
the Claims Administrator tomake the required
tax
deductions before payments are madeto
Participating Claimants, and tonotify
the appropriate taxing authorities.N.
RELEASE OF
CLAIMS
86.
Settlement Class Release. The Class Representatives andthe
Settlement Class Members, on behalf of themselves, and each of their heirs, representatives, successors, assigns, and attorneys,hereby compromise, release, resolve, relinquish, discharge and settle each and
all
of
the ReleasedParties