High-density matter: current status and future challenges

(1)

F

D

_{!! "#$$%&'(()}

! " # $ % & ' ! % ()*+, " -)*+"

% ! % % "

)+. ('/, !(0, ( , (0, ( *1, " -2+ 32+ 45 6 '!3 45 $+! . % % 32+5!3 )+. %

_{7" 8}

! C

(2)

)*+ %

% % )*+ 5 9 6% 5(65, 5 : 65 + )+. 5 ; )* + ()*+, 5 <5 5 =

6% 5(65,5 >0

WKHRU\ RI LGHDO JDVHV WKH UHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH SUHVVXUH 3 HQHUJ\ GHQVLW\ İ DQG WHPSHUDWXUH 7 RI

&

(/,

U H

7 (, 65

(,H

(3)

SQȁȈȄǻDQGPHVRQVʌ.+ ,. (, ?/9@*% * $A - +. . 5 )+. B % 0 % & '9

! 0 "

C D 65 265 " 65 (, #

(4)

0 % 9;E !

ȕ%

- 5 0 5 . "

1 9=: (3*', ?F@ (56/, 50 3*' (569 569, 3*' (569 569, ; :3*'

.ĲY, :< 569 :E 5692

3*' !

* (5$*,(% + ,

6EG /= *1 UE H E/= :

%

(5)

($$, % > 2'(>2', .> 2'(.>2',! ': ( ,% $$ % >2' ( , (>',(, >' .>2' ( ,

3 ': +6'

$:_-

(, 65?J@ 65

6 65% % ( , & 65% . 5 ?/E@+. ?//@$A - ?//@)+.?/9@ *?/:@ ';

6% %?/E/:@

% 65 65 & 5 :2 5 ?/;@ ' <

K =IL J<L

65 :ELM<EL 65

(6', ) *

+

(6)

! "

. % % & 7

6 3

/; '

% 65

#!

(7)

+ '=

4 1 (1, % % " 7

(9,

5 % % H 6% 9 ( ,

' B

H65% 1% 5

0 / 65

6 1 % 65 3/<

(8)

"

K (-*K>, K K ?9/9<9J@ % -*K>(

?9;9=9I:E:/@, %

6

B *#* 3 B53AEF:F:E:J /9;J EEE/ - ?/=@ B53>/J/:N/= /;;/; EEEE9 2 ?/F@ B53A/JE:NE:9F /==F EE9/ '?/I@ B53A/=/;99:E /JF EE; .?/J@ B53AE:;INE;:9 9E: EE: ! ?9E@

5 K -*K> % -*K> '

3?@ _*#* +

L 5 3 ///9 /; 6K/F;<M9;I

;/=EIM<99 ;/I9EM:E KF(;F, Ȧ&HQ */: 5 9E/E?9;@

O/; P9: ;/F9;M:EF 5 9E//?9<@ /E;/9J /; =IJ< ;/=EIM<99

.6M9=E 6K/F;<M9;I ;/I9EM:E KF(;F, Ȧ&HQ */: $4+=:JF 5 9E/:?/;@ F=/E; *

JE */:Ȧ&HQ $4+=:JF $4+=:E; *9I

49E/:?9F@

//;/9I

/EJ/9F /99E/; JE */:Ȧ&HQ $4+=:JF $4+=:E; *9I

- 5 9E/:?9=@

///</9== /E;</9;< /; >65 6 65 JE Ȧ&HQ */: $4+=:JF $4+=:E; *9I

- 5 9E/;?9I@

O/: /99; ;/=EIM<9 B 9E/;?9J@ /E/:

Ȧ&HQ$4+=:JF 2 9E/;?:E@

J/; /; O/I (/;,

K<(;F,

KF(;F, 2 9E/;?:/@

P

(9)

! ?9/@ 3 K?9J@

(9,

65

$

! "! " ! # $ #% ! &'() !! *+! ! ,! $%-.#! *+ ! ! ! /$%0 ! 1 2$%0! ! !13 !! ' ! ! !! ! 4*

+ $% ! !

" ₅_!

6 !*+ !! *+ ! ! ! !! ! * + $% ! ! ,! 7! *

+ " $%$% # ! ! "! !, !"

!8* γͳǤͷ9*2:ٖǡγͺ9&(*

&*2 :ٖ ! , ! ! ! * +$%! ! "*; ' "

" * + "

! ! !!! *" # * + $% < 4 ! # " !! ! !! ! ! " * =! ! *5 *

( 9EE=

9E/9 :V

* 5 * !! 0

! " # # # $ "%&' ( )

(10)

"

(+ .Q/=<EEFE:,?:J@*

& '= 6?;E@

9E/9 0+ ( !+5 ?:9@, ?:9@ ?;E@ 0 ?:I@

ı

3:9(/ '9, (9, 4 (*$5H/=;I*Ĵ 3$5 H /E: ?:9::@R *$5 H /=9 *Ĵ 3$5 H /E/JR ?;E,@ $2 ILWDQGLWVı

?:9::@ EH9EE;I9

( ,

ILW DQG LWV ı HUURU WR WKH >@

EH 9EE=F< ?:=@ ( , ?:I@ /

(*$5 H /=;F*Ĵ 3$5 H /E::, ($2 , ( $2 9EE= 9E/9,' 9EE=?:9::@ $OOHUURUVLQWKLVSORWDUHıHUURUV,

ͳɐ ȋȌ ǡ ȋȌ

7 "*>, ! *+.*(*

+ ! %

+!( +! ,% " & B?:I@(,(,

% &

%!

2 (2+,

G:<*1#!<1#! $5+- !S*

4532+ -2+( , '!3 $+!(,! 5 "%

(11)

! G:< *1#! 9 41#! *1 # ?;/@ 65 ?;9;=@% 65 65

: ! ! " #

$ ! " !! )*&'_%

( $&'?=@_{%! 7}

!! *+ :=*+ ! "

! !! 7 &)2_"!

!! ! !*+ ! 8! ! ! ! !!* # ! ! ! 8 $A?5% ! 88 ! ! 8 !* + ! !" *

! ! 5 " ($$,

$$T'

:₂:₂F_-F_{> 5 ?;=@}

<

?;/;:;;@ /JF_!N/JF_{! G<E/EE*1#!}

G <E *1

2+ >0 % ( ?;9;<@, * . (*., 4 ?;F;J@> " *.

& % 2+ " 2+ 65 C D65 :

'

3 9 :

7KH VWXG\ RI ȁ K\

?<E<<@6\VWHPDWLFVWXGLHVRIWKHHQHUJ\OHYHOVRIOLJKWȁK\SHUQXFOHLKDYHHQDEOHGWKH

LO FRQFHUQLQJ WKH HIIHFWLYH ȁM$ 5

A-

$VIRUȈDQGȄK\SHUQXFOHLWKHVLWXDWLRQLVTXLWHGLIIHUHQW7KHVSHFLDOFDVHRI;₂ QRH[SHULPHQWDOHYLGHQFHIRUDQ\ȈK\SHUQXFO?<=<I@

(12)

RIREVHUYDWLRQVRIGRXEO\VWUDQJHQXFOHL/RQJDZDLWHGVWXGLHVRIȄK\SHUQXFOHLZLWKQHZIDFLOLWLHVD AB!3+ '!3

+ (, 2+ P/41#! (, (B$5, I 9E 5 >- $ $T$ ( , T

%()*+

)+. ?9@2 0 > ?<J@ % % ! )+. 65 0

**, )-. ' /).0**

% % 65 & %

+ )6. % + % 5 $$ %

2+ B$5

P<E*1 P<E*1

6 G/941#: _G/41#:

> P/<UE 9:UE

/E9:9; _//E

5

5>- 5 &>-

+ 7 $$T T

.

5

(13)

$$ $$ ?=E@> $$ .> 2' (.>2', >2' ?=/=9@ ?=:=;@ ?=<@ 4 V (5+4',?==@% * + %?=FF9@

?JF:F;@ $$

2

$$ % /JIEV4 ?F<@ 4 ?F=@

! A + .RUHD>0

6(?FF@,& ?<@

% * % ?F<@

- 7 5 )+. W % ?FJ@ 3 7 )+. ( B ! * 4 ,

(14)

! )*+ $$ *

%LVRVFDODUPHVRQıPHDQILHOGJH

! H[FKDQJH PRGHOV WKH ı LV D FUXGH EXW FRQYHQLHQW ZD\ WR

%

ȦDQGȡPHVRQV2%

! ?F<@

*% % %

3E

>"% % % % % ! % %

! %

(:, 0 0

)*+ 3> _!

%

(;,

% * 0 % -

QRQOLQHDUı ?F<@ 3*'%

0 > 0

XFWLRQ RI WKH ı1

V )*+

0 * 0

$$%

)*+

2 ?F<FF@ "

0 )*+

(15)

(<,

"

(

EI /E ,

V

WKWKHʌʌUHVRQDQFHZKLFKKDVDZLGHGHFD\ZLGWKREVHUYHGLQVFDWWHULQJH[SHULPHQWV

V =EEFEE*1

(?<<J;@ ,

! + % )*+

,&).*

)*+ 65 ?<@( ?FF IEI9@, & )*+FEE (FEE

V %FEE*1,!B3?=:@ 5*T

?I:@ 5 !B3

!/INGNKT (9E, 5*T

'I65 ( ,)*+FEE !B3 5*T65( , ( ,! " 5$* B$* & )*+ %

6% B$* 5$*)*+FEE( , !B3 5*T65 65

)*+

(16)

UHVRQDQFHVZKLFKILQGV.EP:/<*1?I<@)*+

(65,

E% 'J )*+FEE

)*+FEE ($)*+FEE, (')*+FEE,

H G =EE *1:₆₅

!B3 5*T ( , & >A (>A, ?I;@ ')*+FEE >A )*+

- 73UHVVXUH DV D IXQFWLRQ RI WRWDO HQHUJ\ GHQVLW\ IRU VDPSOH (R6 IRU ȕ% N NNȝ1)*+FEE, (')*+FEE, 3 73>A!B35*_{7KHFXUYH3 İVKRZVWKHVWLIIHVWSRVVLEOH(R6}_'

5HODWLYH SRSXODWLRQ RI EDU\RQV DQG OHSWRQV LQ ȕ% )*+FEE '

(17)

2 65

5*_{565 !B3}

)*+3*'! '/E)*+ ILUVW K\SHURQV WR DSSHDU DUH WKH FDVFDGHV Ȅ WRJHWKHU ZLWK WKH ȁ K\SHURQ 7KH Ȉ

/9í:

% )*+ 3*'(

?<@,)*+6 6

'// ?I=IF@ 2 9UE 7KH SUHVHQFH RI WKH Ȉ K\SHURQV GHSHQGV FUXFLDOO\ RQ WKH VLJQ RI WKH QXFOHRQ SRWHQWLDO WKHUH DUH QR Ȉ K\SHURQV SUHVHQW IRU D UHSXOVLYH SRWHQWLDO /HIW SORW DWWUDFWLYH Ȉ

UHSXOVLYHȈSRWHQWLDOVHH>@,

;

3*'

; 6 %

AB!3+

3*'%

/ 6 ;

$$ ! '//?I=IF@ 6 ( ,

6 6 (,

Ȉ GEF<:_{( '//,B(,}

;

'// ; GE;:

)*+

(18)

'/9 $( , '( ,)*+FEE C 00D('/:?IJ@,

( , ( ,')*+FEE (, $)*+FEE (,?<@ /JI*#* EI9:

/9:I0 ?/J9E@

5 7 ?JE@ ! '. * +(!'.*+,

$/ ?J/@ ?J9@)*+

00

(19)

,).*

)*+ 4 ?J:@

/= ;E₊;E₊

3*'& 5-4 ?F=@)*+ 2 0 2'2 5> 5 )*+ 550 .?=@ 5

?J;@)*+ 5*T 0 2M'M> % 2

0 ȡE H E/= :_6#!_í_{/<I< *1}

AH:E*1

(20)

?J<@)*+ 2 2'N>+5 )*+6%< 7

/FP6#!P/<*1E/<PȡEPE/F:_{9IPAP:;*1-P9<*1 9<EP}_._P:<E*1

(- , )*+

% 7/E=P4VP/999F;P4ZPIF9 F9P4ZPIF9

/;₊9FE_.

! % ! ' /; E9L B %

% 5

1 " -

! ! 65

& 65 4

(?;/@, 65

3 (, % ! " .

(21)

?JF@ '!3 $+!

'

)*+ ! > % 5

6 $

7

/ '&BB$B /J:(9EE<,

9 &&BB$B 9JJ(9E/9,

: A35 B43 BB$B :;/(9EEF,

; B3 BB$B /J:(/JJ=,

< A35 B!*4 22* !&$B:;/(9EEF,

= *.- A55* !. A35 B.5 B3+

E:<9E/(9E/9,

F *.- 55! >1+ !. .B* 0+B

5A35 B3+E<<9E:(9E/;,

I Y2--2A50&Y-&+ 23*B3+E;F:E;

(9EE=,

7.UXJHU.+HEHOHU!5 B3+E9<IE9(9E/:,

/E 2+ *>4'>2A50B3.E;<EE=(9E/9,

// .->+B 1 B3.E9:EE:(9E/9,

/9$.XUNHOD35RPDWVFKNH$9XRULQHQ3K\V5HY'/E<E9/(9E/E,

/: 5& 54B*2A5 >!A--/;(9E//,

/; !&5 A*-6'> !A--<(9E/:,

/< ' *26BA!;=(9E/;,

/= !4- 5 9E(9EE;,

/F 3!2 A2!A- -</(/JF<,

/I B++'*$3!59F=:(9E//,

/J B.B *563&2$/EI/(9E/E,

9E A! 5 ;;I(9E/:,

9/ +2 A B7+ 5 E/9EE/(9E/:,

99 '.*DOORZD\030XQRA*2 .B.+!A5:=E(9E/E,

9: 'Z0 .BB3./E:EE:(9EEJ,

9; !&5 A*-6'> !A::(9E/E,

9< 15 AB *3 .:HUQHU!A/99(9E//,

9= A*- !&5 K7/:E<:9;9(9E/:,

9F 54*5$!&363!AF(9E/:,

9I A*- !&5 !A/9:(9E/;,

9J -3RXWDQHQ-1DWWLOD--(.DMDYD20/DWYDOD'*DOORZD\(.XXONHUV96XOHLPDQRY

*$3!5:FFF(9E/;,

:E +2 *$3!5;;;;;:(9E/;,

:/ +2 A64 .!-B.6 K7E:E/9:<(9E/;,

:9 &+42 +2 $F/(9EEJ,

:: +2 &+42!A--/=F(9E/E,

:; .B*BA*-!&5 B3-EI//E/(9E//,

:< .>24 .$1 '&B3!E99IE9(3,(9E/9,

(22)

3$55 '&! $#!$::<$=#FFE:MFEI(9E/;,R :F .4W&+42B55 +2 !WB

*$3!5/JFF(9E//,

(* F*5 ?*?*5 =*> G*H #I&('$)&%

:J >B9E/; ;:JJB

;E .*6+2 435&+42B55

.4W.AB -.!A99(9E/:,

;/ *> A35 B3+E/<IE:(9E/9,

;9 B. 0$BI9(/JJJ,

;: B. 0$B:F<(9EEE,

;; B. 03-&4- 5 /<J9(9EE9,

;< >! --:HQ&KHQ&KH0LQJ.RB3//:(9EEI,

;= +'BB$B/(9EEJ,

;F *> WY B. 0B3-/99FE/(9EEJ,

;I &4- *> WY BB$B;9F(9EEJ,

;J ' ! B3!E/;=EI(9EEJ,

<E 32.0!4! B/=F(/JFI,

</ >BBB$B /I:(/JIF,

<9 <<DPDPRWR70RWRED++LPHQR.,NHGDDQG61DJDWD+ , +-//F:=/ (/JJ;,

<: !4BB5/(9EE;,

<; 2 2BB$B<=;(9EE=,

<< 3$0*XLFKRQ$:7KRPDVDQG.7VXVKLPD1XFO3K\V==(9EEI,

<= 5>B3-<9:I(/JJJ,

<F 2$B3- EF9:E/(9EE9,R

2$B3-E;JJE9(9EE9,6

<I 3.6DKDHWDO3K\V5HY&E;;=/:(9EE;,

3D * A&B3- /FE9E/(9EE<,

=E 9*-6WRNV5$0.ORPS&3)7HUKHJJHQDQG--5B3+9J<E(/JJ;,R

3>& 14A5 35:I(/JJ<,R-6 *2"A 3

*2* !B$B!I<(/JJF,R3*B3+

E9;EE/(9EE/,

=/ >2 3*B39EF(/JIF,R6$6 . +'!'

$B!99F(9EE;,R'A 2- B3+:EJJ(/JJI,

=9 A+ B. !-" YB!;EJ(/JIF,R&Y!"

-A'*6BA!;=J(9EE9,R> -B3+/IJ9

(/JJ/,R>.. 3>& /E<F(/JI<,R*>4'> 2A

50E<<IE/(9EEE,R1 !B!3-6 *2"A

E:<IE/(9EEE,

=: !!13B .43 B3+/IE;(/JJI,

=; !*" 13B B3+E:<IE9(9EEF,=E!' 5

' B->9=:(/JJ:,R+> '!54+ !' B

3+E<;:E;(9EE=,

=< W.&2..1 $635 *&%B3-

/<9<E/(9EE:,

== 7)ULFNDQG+0XࡇWKHU3K\V5HY&E:;:/E(9EE:,

=F >5B 13B A+ 5+B 3>& B3+/F9E

(/JJF,

=I .(6FKPLGWDQG6)DQWRQL3K\V/HWW>JJ(/JJJ,

=J A+ A*A13B .43 B3+E9<IE9(9EE:,

FE 6*DQGROIL)3HGHULYD6)DQWRQLDQG.(6FKPLGW3K\V5HY/HWWE99<EF(9EEF,

F/ 54 !W 5' '3HGHULYDDQG.(6FKPLGW3K\V5HY/HWW

/:9<E/(9EEI,

(23)

F: .+HEHOHUDQG$6FKZHQN3K\V5HY&E/;:/;(9E/E,

F; .+HEHOHU-0/DWWLPHU&-3HWKLFNDQG$6FKZHQN3K\V5HY/HWW/=//E9(9E/E, F< B!*4 B->9EE9:<(/JII,

F= B!*4 !&B3-/:9<E9(9EE;,

FF .-& XU\-'&DUUROO$:7KRPDV.7VXVKLPD-56WRQH3K\V5HY&E=<IE/ (9E/;,

FI '>'4+$.LWVRQ>4-.>- !5 !4&

A*Y $B>(B5,99(9EE<,#E<E/EE;

FJ '>B3.//;</9(9EEF,

IE 70L\DWVX7.DWD\DPD.6DLWR3K\V/HWWV%9;9(9E/9, I/ **.&KHRXQ.6DLWRB3+E/<IE9(9E/:, I9 **.&KHRXQ.6DLWR-36&RQI3URFE/:EIE(9E/;,

I: A>B) *>+4 2>2 $B!FJ(/JI9,

I; 2!>*>A $B!/(/JF;,

I< A35 $A5 5!*0B3+E;;:/=(9E/;,

I= A5 >$B!9FJ(9E/E,

IF A5 $* B3+;/=(/JJ=,

IJ 2A50 3" B3+E:<IE/(9E//,

JE 1[.-+B\ !B>6B-//EE9(9E//,

J/ .- 'B54 A B7+ 5E/9E/9(9E/;,

J9 !1! 5+005. B3.IJ/E:<EJ(9E/;,

J: B!*4 .6DLWR(5RGLRQRY$:7KRPDV1XFO3K\V$

J; B!*4 22* $5 !&$B!/(9EE=,

J< A35 B!*4 B43 !&( ,

J= 7## ## #

High-density matter: current status and future challenges

F

! "

% &

, )-. *' /).*0

1 " -

**, )-. ' /).0**