Optimizing Converged Cisco Networks (ONT)
Module 3: Introduction to IP QoS
Introducing QoS
Objectives
Explain why converged networks require QoS.
Identify the major quality issues with converged networks.
Calculate available bandwidth given multiple flows.
Describe mechanisms designed to use bandwidth more efficiently.
Describe types of delay.
Identify ways to reduce the impact of delay on quality.
Describe packet loss and ways to prevent or reduce packet loss in the network.
Traditional Nonconverged Network
Traditional data traffic characteristics:
Bursty data flow FIFO access
Not overly time-sensitive; delays OK Brief outages are survivable
Converged Network Realities
Converged network realities:
Constant small-packet voice flow competes with bursty data flow.
Critical traffic must have priority.
Voice and video are time-sensitive.
Brief outages are not acceptable.
Converged networks must provide secure, predictable, measurable, and, sometimes, guaranteed services.
Converged Network Quality Issues
Lack of bandwidth: Multiple flows compete for a limited amount of bandwidth.
End-to-end delay (fixed and variable): Packets have to traverse many network devices and links; this travel adds up to the overall delay. (Fixed: serialization + propagation. Variable: Processing + queuing)
Variation of delay (jitter): Sometimes there is a lot of other traffic, which results in varied and increased delay.
Packet loss: Packets may have to be dropped when a link is congested.
Measuring Available Bandwidth
The maximum available bandwidth is the bandwidth of the slowest link.
Multiple flows are competing for the same bandwidth, resulting in much less bandwidth being available to one single application.
A lack in bandwidth can have performance impacts on network applications.
Increasing Available Bandwidth
Upgrade the link (the best but also the most expensive solution).
Improve QoS with advanced queuing mechanisms to forward the important packets first.
Compress the payload of Layer 2 frames (end to end, takes time, may increase delay).
Compress IP packet headers (TCP or RTP, hop by hop).
Using Available Bandwidth Efficiently
Using advanced queuing and header compression mechanisms, the available bandwidth can be used more efficiently:
Voice: LLQ and RTP header compression
Interactive traffic: CBWFQ and TCP (Van Jacobson) header compression
Voice
(Highest)
Data
(High)
Data
(Medium)
Data
(Low)
1 1
2 2
3 3 3
4 4 4 4
4 3 2 1 1
Voice
• LLQ
• RTP header compression
Data
• CBWFQ
• TCP header compression
Types of Delay
Processing delay: The time it takes for a router to take the packet from an input interface, examine the packet, and put the packet into the output queue of the output interface.
Queuing delay: The time a packet resides in the output queue of a router.
Serialization delay: The time it takes to place the “bits on the wire.”
Propagation delay: The time it takes for the packet to cross the link from one end to the other.
The Impact of Delay and Jitter on Quality
End-to-end delay: The sum of all propagation, processing, serialization, and queuing delays in the path
Jitter: The variation in the delay.
In best-effort networks, propagation and serialization delays are fixed, while processing and queuing delays are unpredictable.
For private networks, 200 ms of delay is a reasonable goal and 250 ms a limit.
Ways to Reduce Delay
Upgrade the link (the best solution but also the most expensive).
Forward the important packets first.
Enable reprioritization of important packets.
Compress the payload of Layer 2 frames (takes time).
Compress IP packet headers.
Reducing Delay in a Network
Customer routers perform:
TCP/RTP header compression LLQ
Prioritization
ISP routers perform:
Reprioritization according to the QoS policy
The Impacts of Packet Loss
Telephone call: “I cannot understand you. Your voice is breaking up.”
Teleconferencing: “The picture is very jerky. Voice is not synchronized.”
Publishing company: “This file is corrupted.”
Call center: “Please hold while my screen refreshes.”
Types of Packet Drops
Tail drops occur when the output queue is full. Tail drops are common and happen when a link is congested.
Other types of drops, usually resulting from router congestion, include input drop, ignore, overrun, and frame errors. These errors can often be solved with hardware upgrades.
Ways to Prevent Packet Loss
Upgrade the link (the best solution but also the most expensive).
Guarantee enough bandwidth for sensitive packets.
Prevent congestion by randomly dropping less important packets before congestion occurs.
Traffic Policing and Traffic Shaping
Time
Traffic Traffic Rate
Time
Traffic
Traffic Rate
Time
Traffic Traffic Rate
Time
Traffic Traffic Rate
Policing
Shaping
• Only policing can be applied to inbound traffic on an interface.
• Shaping requires sufficient memory and a scheduling function for later transmission of any delayed packets i.e. CBWFQ and LLQ.
Reducing Packet Loss in a Network
Problem: Interface congestion causes TCP and voice packet drops, resulting in slowing FTP traffic and jerky speech quality.
Conclusion: Congestion avoidance and queuing can help.
Solution: Use WRED (Weighted Random Early Detection and LLQ (Low Latency Queuing).
Summary
Converged networks carry different types of traffic over a shared infrastructure. This creates the need to
differentiate traffic and give priority to time-sensitive traffic.
Various mechanisms exist that help to maximize the use of the available bandwidth, including queuing techniques and compression mechanisms.
All networks experience delay. Delay can effect time sensitive traffic such as voice and video.
Without proper provisioning and management,
networks can experience packet loss. Packet loss is especially important with voice and video, as no
resending of lost packets can occur.
Resources
Quality of Service Networking
http://www.cisco.com/univercd/cc/td/doc/cisintwk/ito_doc/qos.ht m
QoS Congestion Avoidance
http://www.cisco.com/en/US/tech/tk543/tk760/tsd_technology_s upport_protocol_home.html
QoS Congestion Management (queuing)
http://www.cisco.com/en/US/tech/tk543/tk544/tsd_technology_s upport_protocol_home.html
Implementing Cisco
IOS QoS
Objectives
Describe the need for QoS as it relates to various types of network traffic.
Identify QoS mechanisms.
Describe the steps used to implement QoS.
What Is Quality of Service?
Two Perspectives
The user perspective
Users perceive that their applications are performing properly
Voice, video, and data
The network manager perspective
Need to manage bandwidth allocations to deliver the desired application
performance
Control delay, jitter, and packet loss
Different Types of Traffic Have Different Needs
Application Examples
Sensitivity to QoS Metrics
Delay Jitter Packet Loss Interactive
Voice and Video
Y Y Y
Streaming
Video N Y Y
Transactional/
Interactive Y N N
Bulk Data Email File Transfer
N N N
Need to manage bandwidth allocations
Real-time applications
especially sensitive to QoS
Interactive voice Videoconferencing
Causes of degraded performance
Congestion losses
Variable queuing delays
The QoS challenge
Manage bandwidth allocations to deliver the desired
application performance
Control delay, jitter, and packet loss
Cisco IOS QoS Tools
Congestion management:
Priority Queuing (PQ) Custom Queuing (CQ)
Weighted Fair Queuing (WFQ) Class Based WFQ (CBWFQ)
Queue management
Weighted Random Early Detection (WRED)
Link efficiency
Link fragmentation and interleave RTP and Compressed RTP (cRTP)
Traffic shaping and traffic policing
QoS Toolbox
Priority Queuing
PQ puts data into four levels of queues: high, medium, normal, and low.
Custom Queuing
CQ handles traffic by assigning a specified amount of queue space to each class of packet and then servicing up to 17 queues in a round-robin fashion.
Weighted Fair Queuing
• WFQ makes the transfer rates and interarrival periods of active high-volume conversations much more predictable.
Weighted Random Early Detection
•WRED provides a method that stochastically (random) discards packets if congestion begins to increase. WRED combines the capabilities of the RED algorithm with IP precedence and is RSVP aware.
Implementing QoS
Step 1: Identify types of traffic and their requirements.
Step 2: Divide traffic into classes.
Step 3: Define QoS policies for each class.
Step 1: Identify Types of Traffic and Their Requirements
Network audit: Identify traffic on the network (CPU use).
Tools: NetFlow Accounting, Network-based Application
Recognition (NBAR), and QoS Device Manager (QDM).
Business audit: Determine how important each type of traffic is for business.
Service levels required: Determine required response time.
Understanding the characteristics of
applications
Step 2: Define Traffic Classes
Scavenger Class
Less than Best Effort
Priorities and QoS policy
5, use LLQ
4, use CBWFQ
3, use CBWFQ
2, use CBWFQ
1, use WRED
Step 3: Define QoS Policy
A QoS policy is a network- wide definition of the specific levels of QoS that are
assigned to different classes of network traffic.
Activities:
Setting a minimum bandwidth guarantee
Setting a maximum bandwidth limit
Assigning priorities to each class
Using QoS technologies, such as advanced queuing, to manage congestion
Quality of Service Operations How Do QoS Tools Work?
Classification and Marking
Queuing and (Selective) Dropping
Post-Queuing Operations
Self Check
1. What types of applications are particularly sensitive to QoS issues?
2. What is WFQ? How is it different than FIFO?
3. What are the 3 basic steps involved in implementing QoS?
4. What is Scavenger Class?
Summary
QoS is important to both the end user and the network administrator. End users experience lack of QoS as poor voice quality, dropped calls or outages.
Network traffic differs in its ability to handle delay, jitter and packet loss. Traffic sensitive to these issues
requires priority treatment. QoS measures can provide priority to sensitive traffic, while still providing services to more resilient traffic.
Implementing QoS involves 3 basic steps: identify the types of traffic on your network, divide the traffic into classes, and define a QoS policy for each traffic class.
Q and A
Resources
QoS Best Practices At-A-Glance
http://www.cisco.com/application/pdf/en/us/guest/tech/tk759/c14 82/cdccont_0900aecd80295aa1.pdf
QoS Tools At-A-Glance
http://www.cisco.com/application/pdf/en/us/guest/tech/tk759/c14 82/cdccont_0900aecd80295abf.pdf