Public and private choice in UK health insurance

P

UBLIC AND

P

RIVATE

C

HOICE IN

UK

H

EALTH

I

NSURANCE

John Hall

Ian Preston

THE INSTITUTE FOR FISCAL STUDIES

M*U @?_ h@|i LUi ? Nk Oi@*|

W?th@?Ui

aL? O@**

W?t|||i uLh 6tU@* 5|_it

W@? hit|L?

N?iht|) L**i}i wL?_L? @?_ W?t|||i uLh 6tU@* 5|_it

Li4Mih fcbbH

_{Zh duh judwhixo iru wkh frpphqwv ri Wlprwk| Ehvoh|/ Ulfkdug Eoxqghoo/ Frvwdv Phjklu dqg}

, iU|i 544@h)

@?) T@h|t Lu |i TM*U tiU|Lh ULi t| | Th@|i ThLtL? Lu t4*@h tihUit @?_ ? tU UhU4t|@?Uit i 4@) i TiU| |L €?_ ?|ih@U|L? Mi|ii? TM*U @?_ Th@|i ULUit "@*|) Lu TM*U*) ThL_i_ tihUit ** Mi @ Ui?|h@* ?i?Ui L? _iUtL?t i|ih |L 4@!i ti Lu Th@|i tMt|||it @?_ ti Lu Th@|i tMt|||it ** uii_ M@U! ?|L @|||_it |L@h_t |i *ii* Lu TM*U tTi?_?} W? |t T@Tih i Thiti?| i_i?Ui t?} |i h|t 5LU@* |||_it 5hi) |L tL |@| ?__@* |@!i T Lu Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui ?M|t tTTLh| uLh tTi?_?} L? |i TM*U i@*| tiU|Lh 5U igiU|t @i Mii? tL? |L Mi @TThiU@M*i @?_ @**L@?Ui uLh |i L?| _i|ih4?@|L? Lu ?th@?Ui _iUtL?t @?_ @|||_it 4@}?€it |i t3i Lu |i it|4@|i_ igiU|t

 W?|hL_U|L?

W? |i u@Ui Lu UL?|?@* T@h_ Thitthi L? TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} U@ti_ M)c @4L?} L|ih |?}tc_i4L}h@TU U@?}ic|i h@h|) Lu *@MLh t@?} |iU?U@* ThL}hitt @?_ |i ?|hL_U|L? Lu ?Uhi@t?}*) ULt|*) ?i 4i_U@* |iU?L*L})c}L ih?4i?|t @i Mii? !ii? |L i?ULh@}i }hL| ? Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui |L hi*ii Thitthi L? TM*U M_}i|t Bi? € i_ TM*U tTi?_?}c|i _t|hM |L?@* 4T*U@|L?t Lu |t 4@) Mi i TiU|i_ |L Mi ThL}hitti @t ?__@*t L LT| L| @?_ |ihiM) uhii T hitLhUit uLh L|iht @hi Th4@h*) i**Lg )i| UL?|?i |L UL?|hM|i |L |i €?@?U?} Lu |i TM*U i@*| tihUi |hL} |ih |@ it Etii *@U!LhM) @?_ #L?@*_tL? bHHcit*i) @?_ L@|i bb U@ti L? }hL?_t Lu @**LU@|i iUi?U) uLh @**L?} LT|?} L| M) ?__@*t **?} |L T@) |L _L tL @*tL tii4t U*i@h #itT|i |tctTTLh| uLh i?ULh@}?} i T@?tL? Lu |i Th@|i tiU|Lh t Lu|i? |i4Tihi_ M) @ ui@h |@| TM*U tiU|Lh i@*| tTi?_?} t ?L| € i_ @?_ 4@) Mi ?_ih4?i_ BhLTt LT|?} L| 4@) i**c| t tL4i|4it @h}i_c Ui@ti |L tTTLh| tTi?_?} L? TM*U i@*| tihUit tL }LhLt*) @?_ LU@* i? ULh@}i4i?| |L Th@|i ThLtL? UL*_c? @ UL44L?*) ui@hi_ tUi?@hLcti| ? 4L|L? @ _L?@h_ tTh@* | @? ?Uhi@t?}*) 4TLihti_ TM*U i@*| tiU |Lh tih?} @? ?Uhi@t?}*) TLLh U*i?|i*i }@?t| |t L?i @t |L hiUL}?tic@t TL?|i_ L| M) ,TT*i @?_ +L4@?L EbbSMc|@| LT|?} L| M) tL4i hi_Uit |i ULt| Lu TM*U i@*| ThLtL? uLh |Lti hi4@??} @?_ tTTLh| uhL4 |i4 4@) Mi t|hi?}|i?i_

L*|U@* i^*Mh4 @htit uhL4 ?|ihT*@) Mi|ii? TM*U @?_ Th@|i ULUic | *ii*t Lu TM*U tiU|Lh ^@*|) _h?} ?__@* _iUtL?t |L LT| uLh Th@|i tiU|Lh @*|ih?@|it @?_ Th@|i tiU|Lh ThLtL? _h?} *ii*t Lu TL*|U@* tTTLh| uLh |i ^@*|) Lu TM*U tihUit Ai ?@|hi Lu i^*Mh@ ? t)t|i4t | TM*U @?_ Th@|i ThLtL? @i Mii? ?it|}@|i_ ? @ ?4Mih Lu T@Tiht Etii @h3i* b.c,TT*i @?_ +L4@?L bbS@cbbSMcBLi@ bb.cB*L44 @?_ +@!4@h bbHc@t@4@||@chi4ih @?_ it|i@ bb. 5L4i Lu |iti UL?t_ih U@tit ihi Th@|i ThU@tit tTT*i4i?| TM*U ThLtL? @?_ L|iht U@tit ihi |i) hiT*@Ui | ,TT*i @?_ +L4@?L EbbSM ThL_i @? i @4T*i Lu |i *@||ih U@ti ? U i^*Mh4 U@? ?L*i |i hUih TM*U*) ?thi_ ?__@*t L|?} @}@?t| @ UL@*|L? Lu |i Th@|i*) ?thi_ @?_ |i TLLhih TM*U*) ?thi_ W? U@*Mh@|i_ ?4ihU@* U@*U*@|L?t |i) €?_ TM*U tTi?_?} |L Mi hi*@|i*) ?ti?t|i |L }Lih?4i?| ?Ui?|it uLh Th@|i ?th@?Ui

,4ThU@* i_i?Ui L? |i 4@}?|_i Lu |i ?|ih@U|L?t Mi|ii? |i |L tiU

|Lht t tU@?| |*ih @?_ BhMih EbbS @?_ it*i)cO@** @?_ hit|L? Ebbb *LL! @| |i 4T@U| Lu TM*U tiU|Lh i@*| tihUi ^@*|) L? Th@|i ?th@?Ui _iUtL?tc |i uLh4ih t?} _@|@ uhL4 |i N5 @?_ |i *@||ih uhL4 |i Nk L| €?_ i_i?Ui |@| TLLhih TM*U tiU|Lh ^@*|) 4@) i?ULh@}i }hi@|ih |@!i T Lu Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui AL |@| i |i?|ci_i?Ui i t|t |L ULhhLMLh@|i L?i t_i Lu |i t|Lh) W? |t T@Tih i *LL! @| |i L|ih *?!c?it|}@|?} |i @) ? U tTTLh| uLh TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} t @giU|i_ M) Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui ULih@}i `i _L |t @| |i ?__@* *ii*ct?} @|||_?@* _@|@ uhL4 @ tihit Lu *@h}i tU@*i h|t thi)t

Ai T@Tih t Lh}@?ti_ @t uL**Lt 5iU|L? 2 Thiti?|t @ Mhiu Lihi Lu |i ?t|||L?@* t|hU|hi @?_ 4@? U@h@U|iht|Ut Lu |i N?|i_ k?}_L4 i@*| U@hi tiU|Lh 5iU|L? _itUhMit @? **t|h@|i 4L_i* Lu TM*U @?_ Th@|i tiU|Lh ULUi ? Nk i@*| ?th@?Ui h i4ThU@* @TThL@U @?_ |i _@|@ ti| ti_ |L |it| |i 4L_i* @hi _itUhMi_ ? tiU|L?t e @?_ D 5iU|L? S Thiti?|t Lh hit*|t 5iU|L? . UL?U*_it

2 Ai Nk Oi@*| 5iU|Lh

Ai N?|i_ k?}_L4 i@*| U@hi tiU|Lh t U@h@U|ihti_ M) @ _L4?@?| TM*U tiU|Lh ThL_ihc!?L? @t |i @|L?@* Oi@*| 5ihUi EO5 @*L?}t_i @ t4@** Th@|i tiU|Lh U ThL_it @ *4|i_ h@?}i Lu |hi@|4i?|t

Ai O5cit|@M*ti_ ? beHct €?@?Ui_ uhL4 }i?ih@* |@ @|L? @*|L} |ihi @hi tih U@h}it uLh @ *4|i_ h@?}i Lu tihUit tU @t _i?|@* U@hi @?_ ThitUhT|L?t @?_ uLh ti Lu Th@|i u@U*|it *i ?_ih |hi@|4i?| ? O5 LtT|@*t #h?} |i TihL_ Lu Lh t|_)c|i O5 @t hi}L?@**) Lh}@?ti_ | u?_t @**LU@|i_ Mi|ii? hi}L?t @UULh_?} |L € i_ uLh4*@i U ihi M@ti_ L? t|@?_@h_ti_ 4Lh|@*|) h@|it Ai S +i}L?@* Oi@*| |Lh|it E+Ot uh|ih __i_ |ih u?_t @UhLtt bf *Lih *ii* @|Lh|it L? @ _tUhi|L?@h) M@tt OLtT|@* |hi@|4i?| t ThL_i_ uhii @| |i TL?| Lu ti M| Uih|@? ?L?h}i?| |hi@|4i?|t @hi h@|L?i_ M) @|?} *t|t Lt@?^i|EbH. uL?_ |@| H.I Lu hitTL?_i?|t |L |i h|t 5LU@* |||_it thi) ULti LtT|@* @|?} |4it @t @? @hi@ Lu |i O5 ? ?ii_ Lu 4ThLi4i?| `@|?} *t|t @i UL?|?i_ |L ?Uhi@ti tL |@| @*4Lt| 2I Lu |i Nk TLT*@|L? @t L? tL4i uLh4 Lu @|?} *t| uLh LtT|@* |hi@|4i?| @| |i |4i Lu h|?} E#*?L| @?_ B*itcbbH +i_U?} |i *i?}| Lu @|?} *t|t uLh LtT|@* |hi@|4i?| @t hiUi?|*) Mii? @_LT|i_ @t @ TL*U) ThLh|) M) |i ?UL4?} w@MLh }Lih?4i?| Ew@MLh @h|)cbb.

+L}*) |hii ^@h|iht Lu Th@|i 4i_U@* |hi@|4i?|t ? |i Nk @hi €?@?Ui_ @ Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui @?_ @hL?_ .I Lu |i TLT*@|L? @hi ULihi_ M) Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui ELt@?^i| @?_ L**@h_cbb. at| ?_ih @*u Lu |t t ThL_i_ M) i4T*L)iht @?_ |@ i_ @t @ uh?}i Mi?i€|c*t| TL*Uit ULih?} |Lti @}i_ Lih SD @||h@U|i_ |@ hi*iu Mi|ii? bbf @?_ bb. L*Uit |)TU@**) ULih @ *4|i_ h@?}i Lu ?L?h}i?| |hi@|4i?|t ihi @|?} *t|t uLh O5 |hi@|4i?| @hi *L?}it| U tcLu ULhtic? |ti*u i_i?Ui Lu |i ?|4@|i UL??iU|i_?itt Lu |i |L tiU|Lht 6Lh i @4T*ic? |i 4_ bHftcS.I Lu ?L?@MLh|i |hi@|4i?| @?_ 2HI Lu T hiT*@Ui4i?|t ihi U@hhi_ L| ? |i Th@|i tiU|Lh

4L_i* Lu i@*| ?th@?Ui _iUtL?t

W? |t tiU|L? i L|*?i @ t4T*i 4L_i* Lu Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui _iUtL?tc i |i?_?} |@| ? it*i)cO@** @?_ hit|L? Ebbb |L ?ULhTLh@|i TM*U @t i** @t Th@|i ULUi _iUtL?t Ai _i|@*t Lu |i 4L_i* @hi 4L|@|i_ M) |i ? t|||L?@* ui@|hit Lu |i Nk i@*| tiU|Lh U }i?ih@|it |i _@|@ ti_ ? |i i4ThU@* @TT*U@|L? @?_ |i ?|i?|L? t |L }_i |i tMti^i?| it|4@|L? ThLUi_hi

5TTLti ?__@*t u@Ui |L i@*| ht!t `| ThLM@M*|) w @? ?__@* tgiht **?itt Lu |i €ht| ?L?h}i?| |)Ti uLh U |hi@|4i?| Lu ^@*|) _{^E*i| t}

U@** |t Ri*iU|i th}ih) t @@*@M*i ? |i TM*U E^ '^f _{Lh Th@|i E^'^}

tiU|Lh `| ThLM@M*|) X |i ?__@* tgiht **?itt Lu |i tiUL?_ h}i?| |)Ti uLh U |hi@|4i?| Lu ^@*|)'E*i| t U@** |t Ri4ih}i?U) U@hi t @@*@M*i ? |i TM*U tiU|Lh L?*) W?__@*t _gih ? }hLtt ?UL4it t @?_ ? ThLM@M*|it Lu ** i@*| EwcX

5Ti?_?} L? |i TM*U i@*| t)t|i4 t f @?_ t €?@?Ui_ M) |@ T@)4i?|t

AEtc f U 4@) Mi ?UL4i hi*@|i_ Ai ^@*|) Lu TM*U i@*| U@hi t _i |ih4?i_ M) f |hL} hitLhUi @**LU@|L? h*it ^f _{' ^}f_{Ef @?_ ' ' 'Ef}

h@|i i@*| U@hi Lu ^@*|) ^ _{: ^}f _{t @@*@M*i uLh @ Thi44 U 4@) Mi}

hi*@|i_ |L LMtih@M*i ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut ZEw #tTLt@M*i ?UL4it + @hi |t + _{'t ZEwAEtc f u Th@|i*) ?thi_ @?_ +}f _{'t AEtc f u ?L|}

Bi? ?th@?Ui t|@|tc|*|) _iTi?_t2 _{L? ^@*|) Lu i@U tLh| Lu i@*|}

"_{Iru vlpsolflw| zh ohw t eh d vfdodu exw zh frxog hdvlo| h{whqg wkh uhvxowv wr doorz txdolw| wr}

kdyh pruh wkdq rqh glphqvlrq1

#_{Zh vxssuhvv wkh reylrxv ghshqghqfh dovr rq wkh suredelolwlhv ri loo khdowk +/ , vlqfh wkhvh}

duh qrw fkrlfh yduldeohv1

U@hi @?_ L? _tTLt@M*i ?UL4i @?_ t h||i? TE^c 'c + Ai ?__@* ULLtit Uiih tiU|Lh }it |i }ih i TiU|i_ |*|) tL |@| |*|) tT9_E^f_{c ^}_{c 'c t}

AEtc fc ZEw4@ dTE^_{c 'c +}_{c TE^}f_{c 'c +}f_{o W| t ?@|h@* |L @tt4i ?Lh4@*|)}

Lu i*iU|i U@hi^ }i? |i *ii* Lu i4ih}i?U) U@hi'@?_ ?Lh4@*|) Lu i4ih}i?U) U@hi ' }i? |i *ii* Lu i*iU|i U@hi ^ Aiti @hi i^@*i?|chitTiU|i*)c|L @tt4?} Y

Y+ET*T:f @?_ Y+Y ET2*T:f `i @tt4i @*tL |@| i4ih}i?U) U@hi

't ?L| @ }hLtt UL4T*i4i?| uLh i*iU|i U@hi^? |i ti?ti |@| @ hti ? |i ThUi Lu i*iU|i U@hi L*_ ?L| hi_Ui _i4@?_ uLh 'cU t i^@*i?| |L @tt4?}

Y

Y^ET2*Tf

Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t44@htit |i 4@? ui@|hit Lu Th@|i ULUi ? tU @ 4L_i*e _{Bi? |i ?Lh4@*|) @tt4T|L? @ML| i*iU|i U@hic| t hUih}

?__@*t u@Ui_ | TLLhih ^@*|) Lu TM*U U@hi L @hi 4Lt| *!i*) |L ULLti Th@|i ?th@?Ui wL Thi44t @*tL i?ULh@}i ?th@?Ui _iUtL?t @?_ |t uLh4t T@h| Lu |i t|€U@|L? uLh Lh _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L?t

hLTLt|L?  5TTLti |@| @?)L?i ThU@tit Th@|i ?th@?Ui Ai? |ihi t @ ?^i }hLtt ?UL4i t ' tEwcXc ZEwc f @| U @? ?__@* t ?_gih i?| Mi|ii? UL?t4?} ? |i |L tiU|Lht @?_ |i ?__@* ThU@tit Th@|i ?th@?Ui u @?_ L?*) u t :t t t ?L?_iUhi@t?} ?^f _{@?_ ? ZEw}

hLLu 5TTLti |ihi i t|t @? ?UL4i t tU |@|

TE^f_{c 'ctTE^}_{c 'ct ZEw ' f E}

tL |@| |ihi t @? ?UL4i @| U @? ?__@* t ?_gihi?| Mi|ii? UL?t4?} ? |i |L tiU|Lht #i€?i -E5 @t |i ^@*|) Lu i*iU|i U@hi

U L*_ 4@!i tL4iL?i | _tTLt@M*i ?UL4i 5 @t i** Lg @t |t

$_{D frpprq prgho wr dgrsw zrxog eh dq h{shfwhg xwlolw| prgho1 Vxssrvh wkh khdowk ulvnv duh}

h{foxvlyh/ dqg xwlolwlhv duh x+t> |, li lq qhhg ri hohfwlyh vxujhu|/ X+T> |, li lq qhhg ri hphujhqf| fduh dqg y+|, li zhoo1 H{shfwhg xwlolw| zrxog wkhuhiruh eh

Y +t> T> |, @ x+t> |, . X+T> |, . +4 ,y+|,=

Wkh vwdqgdug dvvxpswlrqv xtt/ x||/ XTT/ X||/ y|| ? 3 dqg xt|/ XT| A 3 zrxog wkhq vxfh

iru wkh lqglfdwhg qrupdolw| dqg frpsohphqwdulw| surshuwlhv1

%_{Wkh uhvxow jhqhudolvhv wkdw lq Ehvoh|/ Kdoo dqg Suhvwrq +4<<<,/ lqyroylqj voljkwo| zhdnhu}

uhvwulfwlrqv rq suhihuhqfhv/ dqg dovr hfkrhv uhvxowv lq/ iru h{dpsoh/ Hssoh dqg Urpdqr +4<<9e/ s1636,1

?__@* i

TE-E5c 'c 5TE^f_{c 'ct 'TE^}_{c 'ct ZEw}

Ai? Y-*Y5 'TE-E5c 'c 5*TE-E5c 'c 5

L UL?t_ih |i igiU| Lu @? ?Uhi@ti ? }hLtt ?UL4i L? |*|it ? |i |L tiU|Lht @| t

TE^fc 'ctTE^c 'ct ZEw

' TE-E tc 'ctTE-E t ZEwc 'ct ZEw

' ] t

t !ZEwdTE-E5c 'c 5Y-E5*Y5nTE-E5c 'c 5o_5

' ] t

t !ZEwdTE-E5c 'c 5

TE-E5c 'c 5

TE-E5c 'c 5 nTE-E5c 'c 5o_5

Ai @tt4T|L? Lu ?Lh4@*|) Lu i*iU|i U@hi Y

Y+ET*T:ft i^@*i?| |L

@tt4?}TT_TnT?i}@|i iih)ihi @?_ |ihiuLhi |i ?|i}h@* 4t|

Mi ?i}@|i At t t ?^i E@tt4?} UL?|?|) Lu T @?_ ?__@*t

ThU@ti Th@|i ?th@?Ui u @?_ L?*) u }hLtt ?UL4i i Uii_t t

Ai u@U| |@|t t ?L?_iUhi@t?} ?^f _{@?_ ?ZEwuL**Lt t|h@}|uLh@h_*)}

uhL4 _gihi?|@|?} E

h@|i **?}?itt |L T@) uLh ?Uhi@tit ? TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} t }i? M)

1E^c 'c + TE^c 'c +EY^*Yf_T nT2E^c 'c +EY'*Yf

E^c 'c + E2

ihi Y^*Yf 'f u |i ?__@* t Th@|i*) ?thi_ @?_ Y^*Yf 'Y^f_{*Yf u}

?L| W? @? LMLt ?L|@|L?c i ti 1 _{@?_ 1}f _{? |i |L UhU4t|@?Uit ti*u}

?|ihit|i_ ?__@* L*_ tTTLh| @ 4@h}?@* tTi?_?} ?Uhi@ti u @?_ L?*) u 1

ihi |L i Uii_ |i 4@h}?@* |@ ULt|YAEtc f*Yf u ULhtic ?__@* tTTLh|

uLhTM*U tTi?_?} 4@) Mi 4L|@|i_ M)_ih UL?t_ih@|L?t |@?Th@|i ?|ihit|

M| ?*itt |iti tLh| Lu tLU@* UL?Uih?t @hi @giU|i_ M) |@!?} L|Th@|i ?th@?Ui

@ UL4T@htL? Lu 1 Mi|ii? |Lti | @?_ |L| Th@|i ?th@?Ui tL*_ t|**

Mi ?uLh4@|i @ML| _gihi?Uit ? @|||_it |L TM*U i@*| tTi?_?}

L44L? ti?ti t}}it|t |@| |iTh@|i*) ?thi_ tL*_ Mi *itt ?|ihit|i_ ?

?Uhi@t?} TM*U tTi?_?} u L?*) MiU@ti |i) _L ?L| Mi?i€| _hiU|*) uhL4 |i

ThLTLh|L? tTi?| L? i*iU|i U@hi N?_ih |i @tt4T|L?t 4@_i @MLi | t @*tL

|hic @*Mi| |@| |t 4@) Mi @ UL?t_ih@|L? Lu tiUL?_@h) 4TLh|@?Ui @?)@)c

|@| **?}?itt |L T@) uLh 4ThLi_ i4ih}i?U) U@hi ** @*tL Mi *Lih

hLTLt|L? 2 5i*u?|ihit|i_ **?}?itt |L T@) uLh TM*U tTi?_?} ?Uhi@tit t *Lih u Th@|i*) ?thi_

hLLu 6hL4 E2

1f_E^f_{c 'c +}f₁_E^_{c 'c +} _' TE^fc 'c +f

TE^fc 'c +f

Y^f

Yf

n

%

T2E^fc 'c +f

TE^fc 'c +f

T2E^c 'c +

TE^c 'c +

&

Y' Yf

Ai €ht| |ih4 t T*@?*) TLt|i @?_ |i TLt||) Lu |i tiUL?_ uL**Lt uhL4

|i @tt4T|L? |@| Y

Y+ET2*T : f @?_ Y^Y ET2*T f }i? |@| +f : +

@?_ ^f _^

#gihi?Uit ? 4Lt| _ithi_ *ii*t Lu tTi?_?} @hi @h_ih |L @?@*)ti u UL?t_

ihi_ @UhLtt h@?}it Lu tTi?_?}U @hi @ttLU@|i_| _gihi?| ULUit LuTh@|i

?th@?Ui t|@|t i f9 _{'@h} 4@}

fT9E^fEfc ^c 'Efc t AEtc fc ZEw W| t

UL44L? ? ?t|@?Uit tU @t |tc ihi Th@|i @*|ih?@|it |L TM*U tihUit

@hi @@*@M*ic uLh Thiuihi?Uit ?L| |L Mi t?}*i Ti@!i_ Etiic uLh ?t|@?Uic 5|}*|3

b.e 6}hi  **t|h@|it |i |)TU@* t|@|L? Ai Uhit *@Mi**i_ T _{@?_}

Tf _{tL |*|) @t @ u?U|L? Lu TM*U tTi?_?} L? i@*| U@hif E?ULhTLh@|?}}

|i UL?ti^i?Uit Lu |i 4T*i_ |@ T@)4i?|t u Th@|i*) ?thi_ @?_ u ?L|

L|i |@| ML| @i Mii? _h@? t?}*i Ti@!i_ @?_ |i 4@h}?@* |*|) Lu TM*U

i@*| tTi?_?} ?i| Lu 4T*i_ |@ T@)4i?|t t }hi@|ih @| @**TL?|t u ?L|Th@|i*)

?thi_ AiTi@! Lu |iT _{Uhi t @*tL U*i@h*) Mi*L|@| Lu |iT}f _{Uhi ?_}

U@|?} |@| |i 4Lt| Thiuihhi_ *ii* Lu tTi?_?} t }ih u ?L|Th@|i*) ?thi_

L?i|i*ittc hiUL}?t?} |@| i|ih Lh ?L| |L MiTh@|i*) ?thi_ t ULti? @U

ULh_?} |L U }it }ih |*|)cT9_E^f_{Efc ^}_{c 'Efc t AEtc fc ZEwU@?}

Mi tii? |L Mi hiThiti?|i_ M) |i TTih i?i*LTi Lu |i |L Uhit @?_ |@| t

U*i@h*) ?L| t?}*i Ti@!i_D

Ai TLttM*) ThLM*i4@|U 4T*U@|L?t Lu ?L?t?}*iTi@!i_?itt uLh TL*|U@*

i^*Mh4 t u@4*@h uhL4 |iTM*U ULUi *|ih@|hi `@| t Lu 4Lhi UL?Uih?

ihi @hi |i 4T*U@|L?t uLh @?tiht |L ^it|L?t L? Thiuihhi_ tTi?_?} *ii*t

W| t ?L| U*i@h ? tU UhU4t|@?Uitc uLh ?t|@?Uic |@| }c 4i_4 @?_ *L

*ii*t Lu tTi?_?} ?ii_ Mi ?@|h@**) Lh_ihi_ ? ?__@*t< Thiuihi?Uit @?_ |t

U@? h@ti ThLM*i4t uLh 4L_i**?} Lu hitTL?tit |L ^it|L?t @t!?} ?__@*t |L

ULLti Mi|ii? |i4 At t i T*Lhi_ uh|ih ? |i _@|@ tiU|L? Mi*L

&_{Ri frxuvh/ wklv lv rqo| d srvvlelolw| dqg lq vrph flufxpvwdqfhv wkhuh zrxog eh vlqjoh shdnhg0}

qhvv exw wkh srvvlelolw| frqvlghuhg khuh lv lq qr zd| rxwodqglvk1

A B

X V V

0 1

6}hiG M*U 5Ti?_?} hiuihi?Uit | @?_|L| h@|i W?th@?Ui

e #@|@

AL |it| |t 4L_i* i4ThU@**)ci _h@L? |LTh4@h) tLhUit Lu _@|@ W?__@*

*ii* _@|@ L? TihtL?@* @?_ LtiL*_ U@h@U|iht|Utc i@*| ?th@?Ui _iUtL?t

@?_ @|||_it |LTM*U i@*| tTi?_?} @hi _h@? uhL4 |ih|t 5LU@* |||_it

E5 5hi) W?uLh4@|L? L? |i4TLh@**) @?_ hi}L?@**) @h)?} ?_U@|Lht Lu |i

^@*|) Lu tihUitThL_i_ M) |i O5 @hi _h@? uhL4 +i}L?@* Ahi?_t

Ai 5 t @? @??@* thi) Lu @ hiThiti?|@|i t@4T*i Lu @hL?_ fff Nk

LtiL*_t U ThL_it _i|@*i_ _@|@ L? @ _i h@?}i Lu tLULiUL?L4U @?_

_i4L}h@TU U@h@U|iht|Ut ?U*_?} ?UL4ic LUUT@|L?c Lt?} |i?hic @}ic

ti @?_ LtiL*_ t3i W? T@h|U*@hc |i bHSc bH.c bHbc bbf @?_ bb ^it

|L??@hit ?U*_i_ 4L_*it L? i@*| W?__@*tihi @t!i_i|ih |i)ihi

ULihi_ M)Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui @?_c u tLci|ih |i 4@Lh|) Lu |i ULt|@t

ULihi_ M) |i4ti*it Lh M) |ih i4T*L)ih ? @ih@}ic @hL?_ DI Lu hitTL?

_i?|t ihi ULihi_ M) Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui _h?} i@U )i@h Lu |i TihL_

| @ *||*i Lih @*u @?} |i 4@Lh|) Lu |i ULt|t 4i| M) |ih i4T*L)ih

#h?} |t TihL_c |i 5 @*tL UL?|@?i_ ^it|L?t hi}@h_?} @|||_it |L

TM*U tTi?_?} L? i@*| AL^it|L?tc ? T@h|U*@hc @hi Lu TL|i?|@* ?|ihit|

uLh Lh ThTLtit ?i Lu |itic ?U*_i_ ? bbf @?_ bb L?*) ELu |i )i@ht

ULti? uLh @?@*)ttc @t!i_ |i uL**L?}G

wt|i_ Mi*L @hi @hLt @hi@t Lu }Lih?4i?| tTi?_?} *i@ti tL i|ih )L L*_ *!i |L tii 4Lhi Lh *itt }Lih?4i?| tTi?_?} ? i@U @hi@ +i4i4Mih |@| u )L t@) 4U 4Lhi<c | 4}| hi^hi @ |@ ?Uhi@ti |L T@) uLh |

At ^it|L? @t @t!i_ uLh i}| @hi@t Lu }Lih?4i?| tTi?_?}c ?U*_?}

i@*|c i_U@|L?c TL*Ui @?_ _iui?Ui 6Lh i@U Lu |iti tTi?_?} ThL}h@44itc

hitTL?_i?|t UL*_ ULLti uhL4 €i LT|L?tG R4U 4Lhic R4Lhic R@ML| |i

t@4ic R*itt Lh R4U *itt tTi?_?} }hi@|ihThLTLh|L? Lu hitTL?_i?|t ULti

}ih tTi?_?} L? i@*| |@? uLh @?) L|ih tTi?_?} ThL}h@44i L4M??}

|i |L )i@htcbILu hitTL?_i?|t ULtiR4U 4LhitTi?_?}cD2I R4Lhi@?_

bI R@ML| |i t@4i | ih) ui?t|@?Uit Lu ?__@*t ULLt?} *Lih *ii*t

Lu TM*U tTi?_?}

Aihi @hic Lu ULhtic @ ?4Mih Lu UL?Uih?t | |iLh_?} Lu |t ^it|L?

6ht|*) |i |@ UL?ti^i?Uit Lu tTi?_?} U@?}it @hi ih) ?U*i@h W?_ii_c ?L

hi_U|L? ? |@ *@M*|it t ii? ?_U@|i_ u tTi?_?} U|t @hi ULti? 6h

|ih4Lhi |i u@U| |@| @ TLttM*|) Lu |@ ?Uhi@tit t ?_U@|i_ L?*) uLh *@h}i

?Uhi@tit 4}| Mi |@!i? |L ?_U@|i |@| @ t4@** ?Uhi@ti UL*_ Mi @Uii_|

L| |@ UL?ti^i?Uit ,i? uLh *@h}i tTi?_?} ?Uhi@titc ihi |i TLttM*|) Lu

|@ ?Uhi@tit t 4i?|L?i_E|L} t|** L?*) @TLttM*|)c ?U_i?Ui t *iu| ?U*i@h

MiU@ti |i |@ ?t|h4i?| t ?tTiU€i_S _{At t Lu UL?Uih? t?Ui |i @TT@hi?|}

|L*ih@?Ui Lu }ih |@ @|L? t|t ?UL4uLh|@M*)| hitTL?tit |L @*|ih?@|i^it

|L?t |? |i 5 U t}}it| |@| @ *@h}i 4@Lh|) Lu hitTL?_i?|t |?!

|@| |ih L? |@ Mh_i? t @*hi@_) R} i?L}

6h|ih4Lhic hitTL?_i?|t< @||i?|L? t ?L| LMLt*) hit|hU|i_ |L 4@h}?@*

U@?}it @?_ ?__@*t @hi ?L| |L*_ |L UL?t_ih L?*) |ih Thiuihi?Uit @tt4?}

|i) UL?|?i ? |i t@4i ?th@?Ui t|@|t At UL*_ MiThLM*i4@|U }i? |i

?@|hi Lu |i |iLhi|U@* hit*|t _ihi_ i@h*ih Ai TLttM*i u@*hi Lu t?}*i

Ti@!i_?itt @t Mii? i T*@?i_ @MLi L?t_ih @}@? 6}hi  @?_ tTTLti

TM*U i Ti?_|hi t @| Ai ?__@* L*_ ULLti |L Mi Th@|i*) ?thi_

ii? |L} t }*LM@* LT|44 L*_ Mi @| ER4U 4Lhi tTi?_?} ihi

TM*U tihUit @hi Lu tUi?|^@*|) |@| iL*_ ?L|ThU@tiTh@|i 4i_U@*

?th@?Ui OLiihc @ 4Li |LUL*_ ?L|T*@tM*) Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t @ 4@h}?@*

U@?}i ? i Ti?_|hi hiuihi?Uit @| |i 4@h}? L*_ Mi uLh R*itt tTi?_?}

ih@** |i hitTL?_i?|<t Thiuihi?Ui Lh_ih?} UL*_ T*@tM*) Mi R4U 4Lhi

uL**Li_ M) R4U *ittc ihi i hi*it L? Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui uLh t

i@*| U@hi ?ii_t @?_ ThiuihtTM*U tTi?_?} @?_ i?Ui |@ @|L? |L Mi @t *L @t

TLttM*ic uL**Li_ M) R*ittc R|i t@4i @?_ R@ *||*i 4Lhi At t T*@?*) ?L|

|i ?@|h@* Lh_ih?} @?_ |i TLttM*|) Lu | @ht?} L*_ Mh?} ?|L ^it|L?c

t@)c |i 4Lt| LMLt Lh_ihi_ *4|i_ _iTi?_i?| @h@M*i 4i|L_t uLh 4L_i**?}

@?tiht |L |i ^it|L?

tiUL?_ ^it|L? L? @|||_it |L TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} @t tiih@* hi@tL?t

uLh hi}@h_?} | @t Thiuih@M*i 6hL4 @ h@?}i Lu tTi?_?} ThL}h@44it ?U*_?}

i_U@|L?c _iui?Ui @?_ |i i?hL?4i?|c hitTL?_i?|t @hi @t!i_G

Oihi @hi tL4i |i4t Lu }Lih?4i?| tTi?_?} `U Lu |i4c u @?)c L*_ Mi )Lh }it| ThLh|) uLh i |h@ tTi?_?}q

eHI Lu hitTL?_i?|t ULti Ri@*| | @ uh|ih 2I ULLt?} i_U@|L? @t

9_{Zh kdyh frooderudwhg zlwk gdwd froohfwruv wr h{soruh wkh frqvhtxhqfhv ri ehlqj pruh vshflf}

derxw wkh qdwxuh ri wkh wd{hv lqyroyhg lq pruh uhfhqw |hduv1 Uhvxowv uhsruwhg lq Kdoo dqg Suhvwrq +4<<;, vxjjhvw uhodwlyho| olwwoh dqg srruo| ghwhuplqhg uhvsrqvlyhqhvv wr wkh lpsolhg wd{ sulfhv1

|ih |LT ThLh|) uLhTM*U i Ti?_|hi Ai i_i?Ui L? @|||_it |L@h_tTM*U

tTi?_?} L? i@*|i LM|@? uhL4 |t^it|L? @TTi@ht 4Lhi t|@M*i uLh @ ?4

Mih Lu hi@tL?t 6Lh L?i |?}c |i^it|L?@t @t!i_ ? @**€i )i@ht h@|ih |@?

L?*) |i €?@* |Lc Lgih?} @ }hi@|ih ?4Mih Lu _@|@TL?|t iU@ti |i @*|ih?@

|i |L @__|L?@* i@*| tTi?_?} t tTi?_?} L? tL4i L|ih TM*U ThL}h@44i

h@|ih |@? @ |@ hi_U|L? |i *@U!Lu tTiU€U|) ? 4T*i_ |@ ?t|h4i?| t @*tL

4U *itt Lhh)?} 6?@**) | t 4U 4Lhi T*@tM*) ?|ihThi|i_ @t @ ^it|L?

@ML| 4@h}?@* U@?}it E@*|L} |i @4L?| Lu |i U@?}i hi4@?t @_4||i_*)

@}i

`i ti ML| ^it|L?t ? Lh i4ThU@* Lh! L|i |@| ii? L? |i 4Lt|

U@h|@M*i ?|ihThi|@|L? Lu |i t|@M*|) Lu |i €ht| ^it|L? |L Lh ThTLtitc

|i it|4@|i_ i^@|L?t tL*_ _gih u?_@4i?|@**) t?Ui |i ?@|hi Lu |i @*

|ih?@|it t _gihi?| ? |i |L U@tit ? |i €ht| U@ti Mi?} @__|L?@* Th@|i

?UL4i uLh |i hitTL?_i?| @?_ ? |i tiUL?_ Mi?} @__|L?@* tTi?_?} L? |i

L|ihti 4Lt| u@Lhi_ |i4 LuTM*U tTi?_?} L?i|i*itt |i _hiU|L? Lu |i

Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui igiU| tL*_ Mi |i t@4i ? |i |L U@titcU t@|

t 4@?*) Lu ?|ihit| ? |i UL?|i | Lu |i Uhhi?| T@Tih

Ai 5 _@|@ @t }LL_ ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} hitTL?_i?|<t }iL}h@TU *L

U@|L? U i ti |L 4ih}i | | +i}L?@* Oi@*| |Lh|) *ii* _@|@ L?

TM*U tiU|Lh i@*| tihUit 5iih@* ?_U@|Lht LuTM*U i@*| tiU|Lh^@*|) @hi

TL|i?|@**) @@*@M*i ?U*_?} *i?}| Lu tLh| @?_ *L?} |ih4 @|?} *t|tc |L|@*

t|@gc i Ti?_|hi L? _@}?Ltt @?_ |hi@|4i?|c tTTLh| tihUit @?_ i@_^@h|iht

,@h*ih Lh! L? |i _i4@?_ uLh i@*| ?th@?Ui Eit*i)c O@** @?_ hit|L? bbb

@t t}}it|i_ ih) t|hL?}*) |@| | t *L?} |ih4 @|?} *t|t |@| 4@||ih 4Lt|

|L ?__@*t @?_ |t t |i L?*) @h@M*i ti_ ? |i i4ThU@* Lh! hiTLh|i_

Mi*L

D ,4ThU@* TT*U@|L?

`|? Lh 4L_i*c ?__@*t u@Ui |L 4@h}?t Lu ULUi 6ht|c |i) 4t| ti*iU|

i|ih Lh ?L| |L UL?t4i i*iU|i U@hi tihUit |hL} |i Th@|i tiU|Lh M)

|@!?} L| @Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?UiTL*U) 5iUL?_c |i) 4t| _iU_i @|||_it

|L@h_t TM*U i Ti?_|hi L? i@*| U@hi

W| t *!i*) |@| |iti _iUtL?t @hiL?|*) _i|ih4?i_ ? |@| UL44L? u@U|Lht

Ui U@??L| LMtihi ?i?Ui ML| _iUtL?t ?iTLttM*|) t |@| ML| _i

UtL?t @hi ?i?Ui_ M) UL?Uih?t Lih i@*| ttitc 4Lt|T@h|U*@h*) MiU@ti Lu

?LMtihi_ @tTiU|t Lu |i hitTL?_i?|t<L? i@*| t|@|t ALti L }i i@*|

ttit @T@h|U*@h ThLh|)c uLh ?t|@?Ui MiU@ti 4Lhi ui@hu* Lu ** i@*|c 4@) Mi

i TiU|i_ ML| |L Mi 4Lhi *!i*) |LThLh|ti ?Uhi@ti_TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} Lih

ML| @*|ih?@|i TM*U tTi?_?} ThL}h@44it @?_ *Lih |@ Mh_i?t @?_ |L Mi

4Lhi *!i*) |L ThU@ti @UUitt |L }ih ^@*|) 4i_U@* |hi@|4i?| uLh |i4ti*it

@ @Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?UiTL*U) tiUL?_TLttM*|) t |@| |ihi 4@) Mi @

t@hi_TL*|U@* UL4TL?i?| |L ML| |i ?th@?Ui _iUtL? @?_ |LTM*U @|||_it

ALti L @hi Lt|*i |L |i t|@|i 4@) Mi ML| 4Lhi ?U*?i_ |L 4ii| |ih L?

4i_U@* ?ii_tTh@|i*) @?_ Mi _t?U*?i_ |L tTTLh| ?Uhi@ti_ i@*| tTi?_?}.

*@tM*i _i?|€U@|L? Lu Lh 4L_i* |ihiuLhi hi^hit @h@M*it U @giU|

|i €ht| t|@}i E?th@?Ui ThU@ti _iUtL? M| ?L| |i tiUL?_ ?i TLttM*|)

t |i *ii* Lu ?th@?Ui Thi44t t?Ui |iti 4@) Mi i TiU|i_ |L ?i?Ui |i

_i4@?_ uLh ?th@?UiTL*Uitc M| }i? |i ?th@?Ui _iUtL?c |L @i ?L uh|ih

4T@U| L? TM*U @|||_itH _{OLiihc i _L ?L| LMtihi Thi44t ? Lh _@|@}

@?_ |ih ti L*_ Mi ThLM*i4@|U @?)@) uc @t UL44L?*) LUUhtc ?__@*

U@h@U|iht|Utc LMtihi_ M) |i ?thih M| ?L| M) tc U @hi hi*@|i_ |L |i

*!i*LL_ Lu hi^h?} 4i_U@* |hi@|4i?| E@?_ |ihiuLhi |iTihUii_ Mi?i€|t Lu

4ThLi_ TM*U tihUit@hi @*tL ti_ |L _i|ih4?i ?th@?Ui Thi44t

W_i@**)c _i?|€U@|L? hi^hit tL4i i L}i?Lt @h@|L? ?Thi44t Mi|ii?

?__@*t 5?Ui }hLTi4T*L)4i?| TL*Uit @**L@_ihti ti*iU|L?ThLM*i4t |L

Mi LihUL4i |i) 4@) @**L Ui@Tih i4T*L)ihThL_i_ ?th@?Ui L|?} |@|

h@|it Lu i4T*L)ih ThL_i_ ?th@?Ui _gih UL?t_ih@M*) Mi|ii? ?_t|hit Etii

A@M*i c i |ihiuLhi ThLTLti |L ti ?_t|h) _44it @t _i?|u)?} ?t|h

4i?|t Ai @*_|) Lu |t @TThL@U _iTi?_t L? |t @h@|L? Mi?} L|ihti

?hi*@|i_ |L i@*| tTi?_?} Thiuihi?Uit `i uii* t@ui ? _tUL?|?} |i tLh| Lu

i?_L}i?i|) |@| L*_ @hti u U@hiih Eh@|ih |@? LM ULUi ihi _hi? M)

|i *!i*LL_ Lu i4T*L)ih ThLtL? Lu i@*| ?th@?Ui OLiihc i @*tL ?ii_

|L |?! U@hiu**) @ML| |i hi@tL?t uLh ?_t|h) _gihi?Uit ? i4T*L)ihThL_i_

?th@?Ui ULih@}i W| L*_ Mi ThLM*i4@|U u |i tLhUi ihi ?_t|h) _gih

i?Uit ? ht!t Lu ** i@*| t?Ui |iti UL*_ @*tL @giU| ?__@* @|||_it |L

:_{Lq wklv fdvh/ hqgrjhqhlw| lvvxhv pd| eh idu ohvv lpsruwdqw zkhq lqglylgxdov duh dvnhg derxw}

wkhlu sulrulwlhv ehwzhhq sxeolf vshqglqj surjudpphv dv rssrvhg wr wkhlu suhihuhqfhv uhjduglqj wkh ryhudoo ohyho ri sxeolf khdowk h{shqglwxuh1

;_{Wkhuh pd| eh d vpdoo lpsdfw wkurxjk wkh hhfw rq glvsrvdeoh lqfrph exw zh wklqn lw}

uhdvrqdeoh wr qhjohfw wklv1 Wkh vwdwhphqw lv wuxh dq|krz li pdgh frqglwlrqdo rq glvsrvdeoh lqfrph1

TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} M| i uii* |@| |t t ?*!i*) |L Mi |i hi@tL? @

Lh i4T*L)4i?|_hi? iTtL_it Lu ** i@*| tU @t ?_t|h@* @UU_i?|t Lh **

i@*| |h}}ihi_ M) i TLthit |L @3@h_Lt UL?_|L?t L*_ Thit4@M*) Mi

ULihi_ M) i4T*L)ih *@M*|) ?th@?Ui h@|ih |@? i4T*L)ihThL_i_ i4T*L)ii

i@*| ?th@?Ui 4Lhi *!i*) i T*@?@|L? *it ? _gihi?Uit ? i4T*L)ih ULt|t Lu

4i_4 |ih4 i4T*L)ii @Mti?Ui |hL} ** i@*|c |iti _gihi?Uit Mi?} _hi?c

uLh i @4T*ic M) *ii*t Lu LMtTiU€U 4@? U@T|@*

`i @_LT| @ ?Lh4@**)_t|hM|i_ *@|i?| @h@M*i tTiU€U@|L? uLh ML|Th@|i

?th@?Ui _iUtL?t @?_ TM*U tTi?_?} @|||_it Ai i4ThU@* 4L_i*t it|

4@|i_ @hi @** ?it|i_ |? |i uL**L?} uLh4

+ 'E+9 :f

+2 '}E+29

+9

 'fqn ED

+9

2 ' Ef2q2n2E+9 :f n Ef2q22n22E+9 f ED2

! -+  2 22 " . , E

! -+ f f f " . ,c ! -+ j2

 4jj2 42jj22

4jj2 j22

42jj22 j222

" .

, ED

Oihi + t ThU@ti Lu Th@|i ?th@?Ui @?_ +2 t i|ih tTTLh| uLh }ih

TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} Lh ULUi Lu i@*| @t |LT ThLh|) uLh i |h@ tTi?_?}c

_iTi?_?} TL? U t Mi?} 4L_i**i_ @| |i |4ib _{W? |i uLh4ih U@ti }E}

t |i 4i@thi4i?| u?U|L? uLh @? Lh_ihi_ ThLM| @?_ ? |i *@||ih }E t |i

4i@thi4i?| u?U|L? uLh @? Lh_?@h)ThLM| t _tUtti_cf _giht uhL4 f2 ?

?U*_?} ?_t|h) _44it i hiTLh| ML| @ `@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu |iti

_44it uhL4 ED2 @?_ @ tULhi |it| uLh |ih i U*tL? uhL4EDf _,t|4@|L?

T*@?*) _i?|€it L?*) |i igiU|t Lu UL@h@|it L? |i ThLM@M*|it U _iTi?_

L?*) TL? h@|Lt Lu ULiUi?|t |L t|@?_@h_ ihhLht q*jc q2*j2 @?_ q22*j22

<_{Wkhuh pljkw eh vrph hflhqf| jdlq lq prghoolqj dqvzhuv wr wkh wzr sxeolf vshqglqj txhv0}

wlrqv mrlqwo|1 Krzhyhu/ jlyhq wkh xqfhuwdlqw| derxw wkh dssursuldwhqhvv ri dw ohdvw rqh txhvwlrq iru wkh sxusrvh uhtxluhg/ zh suhihu wr prgho wkhp vhsdudwho| vr dv wr dyrlg frqwdplqdwlqj hlwkhu vhw ri hvwlpdwhv zlwk wkh frqvhtxhqfhv ri plvvshflfdwlrq uhodwlqj wr wkh rwkhu1

43_{Wklv lv wkh reylrxv dqdorjxh ri wkh frqyhqwlrqdo Vdujdq whvw lq d olqhdu lqvwuxphqwdo yduldeohv}

vshflfdwlrq1 Wkh whvw lv fdofxodwhg dv wkh uhvlgxdo vxp ri vtxduhv iurp uhjuhvvlrq ri d yhfwru ri rqhv rq wkh vfruh frqwulexwlrqv +vhh Jrxulhurx{ dqg Prqiruw 4<<8/ s1<3,1

5?Ui hitTL?_i?|t @hi L?*) iih LMtihi_ ? L?i ?th@?Ui t|@|t ?L ?uLh4@|L?

t iih LMtihi_U 4}| _i?|u) |i *Lih Lg_@}L?@* ULhhi*@|L?t *iu| M*@?!

? ED

L|i |@| |t Rt|U?} ULiUi?|t tTiU€U@|L? @**Lt @** T@h@4i|iht Lu

ED2@?_ED|L @h)| ?th@?Ui t|@|t Ai 4L_i*t @hi @*tL it|4@|i_ ? |i

4Lhi hi@_*) ?|ihThi|@M*i?|ihUiT| tu|uLh4|q2*j @?_ q22*j2 _gih?}

L?*) ? |i UL?t|@?| |ih4t @?_ 4 '42 Ai @UUiT|@M*|) Lu |i hit|hU|L?t @hi

@ttitti_ |L} @ *!i*LL_ h@|L |it|

,t|4@|L? t |hL} 4@ 44 *!i*LL_ 6Lh |i it|4@|it t?}^it|L?t

L? tTi?_?} ThLh|it i @i @** hi*i@?| hitTL?tit uLh @** )i@ht M| uLh |Lti

t?} ^it|L?t L? _ithi_ tTi?_?} *ii*t i @i @?tiht |L |iti T@h|U*@h

^it|L?t L?*) ? |i €?@* |L )i@ht @?_ |i *!i*LL_ UL?|hM|L?t uLh i@h*ih

)i@ht ?ii_ t|@M*i 4L_€U@|L?

S +it*|t

`i hiTLh| it|4@|it ? A@M*it 2 |L D W? @** U@tit i @hi UL4uLh|@M*) @M*i |L @U

UiT| hit|hU|L? |L @? ?|ihUiT| igiU| L?*) L? tTTLh| uLhTM*U tTi?_?} @?_ | t

|ihiuLhi |iti it|4@|it |@| @hi hiTLh|i_ ? |i 4@? |i | W? i@U |@M*i |i€ht|

UL*4? Lu hit*|t }it |i it|4@|it Lu |i Th@|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L?c |i tiU

L?_ |@| Lu |i TM*U tTi?_?} @|||_i i^@|L? @?_ |i |h_c uLh UL4T@htL?c

it|4@|it Lu @ ULhhitTL?_?}ThLM| Lh Lh_ihi_ThLM| tTiU€U@|L? ?U ?th

@?Ui t|@|t @t t4T*) Mii? @tt4i_ i L}i?Lt W? @** U@tit i hiTLh| 4@h}?@*

ThLM@M*|) igiU|t @| 4i@? @*it Lu L|ih i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*it _{** hit*|t ?}

U*_i |4i igiU|t `i }i ML| hit*|tU ?U*_i @?_ i U*_i hi}L?@* i@*|

@|Lh|) E+O igiU|t |iti UL*_ Mi 4TLh|@?| u |i) U@T|hi |i igiU|t Lu

€ i_ _gihi?Uit ? TL*U) @| |t @_4?t|h@|i *ii* @?_ ?_ii_ |i) @hi L?|*)

t}?€U@?| ? ML| A@M*it 2@?_ e

`i €ht| UL44i?| Mhi) L? |i it|4@|i_ Th@|i ?th@?Ui _i4@?_ i^@

|L?t Aiti @hi MhL@_*) UL?tt|i?| @UhLtt tTiU€U@|L?tc @t L?i L*_ LTic @?_

itti?|@**) t4*@h |L |i hit*|t Lu it*i)c O@** @?_ hit|L? Ebbb `i€?_ |@|

?Uhi@tit ? *L?} |ih4@|?} *t|t uLh LtT|@* |hi@|4i?||? |iTM*U tiU|Lh

@hi @ttLU@|i_ | @ }hi@|ih |@!i T LuTh@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui AiThU@ti

44_{Iru vxssruw iru juhdwhu vshqglqj wklv lv uhsruwhg dv wkh hhfw rq wkh suredelolw| ri zdqwlqj}

_pxfk pruh%1 Iru glfkrwrprxv glvfuhwh yduldeohv zh uhsruw wkh hhfw ri d fkdqjh ri vwdwxv dqg iru qxpehuv ri fkloguhq dqg dgxow zh uhsruw wkh hhfw ri dgglqj rqh pruh idplo| phpehu1

Lu ?th@?Ui t @*tL hi*@|i_ |L LtiL*_ ?UL4i2 _{@?_ |i }it| i_U@|L?@*}

^@*€U@|L? i*_ M) |i hitTL?_i?| ,_U@|L?@* i Tihi?Ui UL*_T*@tM*) U@T

|hi @ Tih4@?i?| ?UL4i igiU|c @ _hiU| i_U@|L?@* igiU| Lh Mi @ttLU@|i_ |

@|||_?@* U@?}it hit*|?} uhL4 i Tihi?Ui Lu }ih i_U@|L? Ai hi*@|L?

tT Mi|ii? _i4@?_ uLh Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui @?_ @}i @TTi@ht |L uL**L @

4Ti_ t@TiTi@!?} Mi|ii? |i @}it Luef @?_Df At 4@) Mi i T*@?i_ M)

@ UL4M?@|L? Lu |L igiU|t Ai i*_ih*) |)TU@**) u@Ui @? ?Uhi@ti_ *!i*LL_

Lu hi^h?} 4i_U@* @ttt|@?Uic M| uLh |Lti @}i_ Lih Sfc @ t@hT ?Uhi@ti ?

Thi44t t Lu|i? LMtihi_ `i €?_ |@| |i ?4Mih Lu @_*|t ? |i LtiL*_

hi_Uit |i UL?_|L?@* i TiU|@|L? Lu |i hitTL?_i?| Mi?} ULihi_ M) Th@|i

4i_U@* ?th@?Ui Bi? |@| ?UL4i @t 4i@thi_ @| |i LtiL*_ *ii*c |t

4@) hi@tL?@M*) Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t @? i^@*i?| ?UL4i igiU|

Ai !i) igiU| Lu ?|ihit| uLh |i Uhhi?| T@Tih t |@| Lu ?th@?Ui t|@|t L?

tTTLh| uLh TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} Oihi |i hit*|t @hi hi4@h!@M*) UL?tt|i?|

@UhLtt tTiU€U@|L?t ? i L}i?Lt t|U |L Mi?}Th@|i*) ?thi_ t it|4@|i_

|L hi_Ui |i ThLM@M*|) Lu ThLh|t?} i@*| tTi?_?} @?_ |@| Lu u@Lh?}

4U 4Lhi i@*| tTi?_?} M) tL4iihi Mi|ii? 2f @?_ 2D Tih Ui?| Aiti

igiU|t @hi @*tL t|hL?}*) t|@|t|U@**) t}?€U@?|cT@h|U*@h*) ? |i U@ti LuThLh|

t@|L? ihi igiU|i t@4T*i t3i t *@h}ih 6h|ih4Lhi @**L?} uLh i?_L}i?i|)

Lu |i ?th@?Ui _iUtL? @TTi@ht |L Mi 4TLh|@?| ,t|4@|it Lu4@hi UL?tt|i?|*)

t| Mi*L ff @?_ t|@|t|U@**) t}?€U@?| @?_ |t t hiiU|i_ ? |i u@U| |@|

|i M@h@|iw it|4@|it @hi tMt|@?|@**) 4Lhi ?i}@|i |@?L*_ @i Mii?

uL?_ t?} @? Lh_?@h) ThLM| Lh Lh_ihi_ ThLM| At t UL?tt|i?| | |i

Thiti?Ui Lu ULhhi*@|i_ L4||i_ i|ihL}i?i|) @ttLU@|i_| @ }i?ih@* Thiuihi?Ui

uLh i@*|hi*@|i_ }LL_t @?_ ThLM@M*) UL?Uih??} ?LMtihi_ @tTiU|t Lu i@*|

t|@|t Ai L|ih igiU|U 4}| Mi i TiU|i_ |L Mi UL44L? Mi|ii? |i |L

U@tit t |@| Lu @|?} *t|t M| _t@TTL?|?}*) |t €}hit t}?€U@?|*) ? ?L?i

Lu |i @|||_?@* i^@|L?t

W| t ?|ihit|?} |@| |i igiU|t Lu L|ih @h@M*it @hi ^|i _gihi?| Mi|ii?

|i |L _gihi?| 4i@thit Lu @|||_i @?_ |@| |i) @hi tL ? @)t U @hi

hi@_*) ?|ihThi|@M*i W| @t ?L|i_ @MLi |@| |i ?@|hi Lu |i @*|ih?@|it

45_{Rxu lqfrph yduldeoh qhhgv d olwwoh h{sodqdwlrq1 Lqfrph gdwd lq wkh EVD lv edqghg dqg wkh}

edqgv duh {hg lq qrplqdo whupv dfurvv |hduv1 Wr dyrlg sureohpv ri frpsdudelolw| zh dvvljq hdfk uhvsrqghqw wr wkh phdq srvlwlrq zlwklq wkh lqfrph glvwulexwlrq ri wkrvh krxvhkrogv lq wkh vdph edqg lq wkh vdph |hdu1 Wkh dvvrfldwhg frhflhqwv wkhuhiruh fdswxuh wkh hhfwv ri pryhphqw xs wkh lqfrph glvwulexwlrq1 Wkh wlph gxpplhv zloo slfn xs wkh hhfwv ri lqfrph jurzwk1

_gih u?_@4i?|@**) ? |i |L U@titc Mi?} 4L?i) ? |i TLU!i| ? |i U@ti Lu

|i tTTLh| uLh }ih tTi?_?}^it|L? @?_ tTi?_?} L? |i ?i | 4Lt|Thiuihhi_

ThL}h@44i ? |i U@ti Lu |iThLh|it^it|L? U |i 4Lt|TLT*@h tTi?_?}

|i4 @u|ih i@*| t i_U@|L? W| t |ihiuLhi ?L|@M*i |@| iUL?L4U igiU|t tU @t

i4T*L)4i?| t|@|t @?_ Lt?} |i?hi UL4i |hL} 4Lhi t|hL?}*) ? |i uLh4ih

U@tic ihi@t i_U@|L?@* @?_ _i4L}h@TU igiU|t i4ih}i 4Lhi t|hL?}*) ? |i

*@||ih W?T@h|U*@hc ui4@*i hitTL?_i?|tc |Lti| U*_hi? @?_ |Lti| }LL_

i_U@|L?@* M@U!}hL?_t @hi 4@h!i_*) *itt *!i*) |L ThLh|ti i@*| @t @}@?t|

i_U@|L? @t @ U@?__@|i uLh ?Uhi@ti_ tTi?_?} 4Ti_ hi*@|L?tT |L @}i

Lu hitTL?_i?| t i_i?| ? |i U@ti Lu ML| ^it|L?t

W4TLh|@?|*) uLh |i T*@tM*|) Lu Lh iUL?L4i|hU ThLUi_hitc |i ?_t|h)

_44it ti_ |L ?t|h4i?| ?th@?Ui t|@|t @hi L?|*) t|hL?}*) t}?€U@?| ?

|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L? *i i @hi ?@M*i ? @?) ?t|@?Ui |L hiiU| i U*tL?

uhL4 |i i^@|L?t U@T|h?} @|||_it |L tTi?_?}

. #tUttL?

@?) T@h|t Lu |i TM*U tiU|Lh ULi t| | Th@|iThLtL? Lu t4*@h tihUit

@?_ ? tU UhU4t|@?Uit i 4@) i TiU| |L €?_ ?|ih@U|L? Mi|ii? TM*U @?_

Th@|i ULUit "@*|) LuTM*U*)ThL_i_ tihUit** Mi @ Ui?|h@* ?i?Ui L?

_iUtL?ti|ih |L 4@!i ti LuTh@|i tMt|||it @?_ ti LuTh@|i tMt|||it

** uii_ M@U! ?|L @|||_it |L@h_t |i *ii* Lu TM*U tTi?_?} W? i@h*ih

hiti@hUc i uL?_ i_i?Ui |@|^@*|) Lu i@*| tihUit ThL_i_ M) |i TM*U

tiU|Lh @t @ttLU@|i_| |@!i T LuTh@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui Eit*i)c O@** @?_

hit|L?cbbb W? |tT@Tihi @i tL? i_i?Ui @*tL |@| ?__@* |@!i T

Lu Th@|i 4i_U@* ?th@?Ui ?M|t tTTLh| uLh tTi?_?} L? |i TM*U i@*|

tiU|Lhe _{5U igiU|t @i Mii? tL? |L Mi @TThiU@M*i @?_ @**L@?Ui uLh |i}

L?| _i|ih4?@|L? Lu ?th@?Ui _iUtL?t @?_ @|||_it 4@}?€it |i t3i Lu |i

46_{Qrwh wkdw wkh qrqolqhdulw| lq wkh vshflfdwlrq doorzv xv irupdoo| wr lqfoxgh doo lqgxvwu|}

gxpplhv lq wkh lqvxudqfh htxdwlrq zlwkrxw orvlqj lghqwlfdwlrq1 Wkh ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp duh wkhuhiruh htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri h{foxghg gxpplhv1 Wr wkh h{whqw wkdw wklv lv d frqvhtxhqfh ri ixqfwlrqdo irup dvvxpswlrqv/ lw lv uhdvvxulqj wr qrwh wkdw qrqh ri wkh vfruh whvwv txrwhg zrxog uhmhfw li ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp zhuh uhgxfhg e| rqh1

47_{Zh kdyh douhdg| revhuyhg wkdw djjuhjdwh wdnh0xs udwhv zloo kdyh dq rvhwwlqj uhgxflqj hhfw}

rq wkh frvw ri khdowk surylvlrq iru wkrvh zlwkrxw sulydwh lqvxudqfh1 Lqvridu dv dq| vxfk hhfwv duh suhvhqw wkh| zrxog hqwhu rxu hvwlpdwhv wkurxjk wkh wlph gxpplhv dqg eh lqvhsdudeoh lq rxu gdwd iurp rwkhu djjuhjdwh wlph vhulhv hhfwv1

it|4@|i_ igiU|t ttitt?} |i i |i?| |L U |iti ?|ih@U|L?t UL*_ hi?_ih

|i TM*U tTi?_?} i^*Mh4 ti?t|i |L U@?}it ? ULt|t @?_ L|ih @tTiU|t Lu

|iTL*U) 4@!?} UL?|i | hi^hit Liih @ }hi@|ih ?_iht|@?_?} Lu |i 4@??ih

? U TM*U Thiuihi?Uit |h@?t*@|i |i4ti*it ?|L TL*U) _iUtL?t

A@M*i 

,4T*L)ih ThL_i_ Th@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui M) ?_t|h@* tiU|Lh

hLTLh|L? 5@4T*i

}hU*|hi ffeD D.

,?ih}) @?_`@|ih ffD. 2Se

i|@*t%?ih@*t , |h@U|L? f2S H2

i|@* BLL_t ,?}?iih?} ffHS fbH

|ih @?u@U|h?} ffHH 

L?t|hU|L? ffbf Sf

#t|hM|L? ff.b b2.

Ah@?tTLh| @?_ L44?U@|L? ff.f Sf

6?@?U@* 5ihUit f2b HbH

|ih 5ihUit ffSf 2.f

5LhUiG h|t 5LU@* |||_it 5hi)

A@M*i 2

hLh|) uLh i |h@ TM*U tTi?_?} E+i}L?@* i@*| @|Lh|) igiU|t ?U*_i_

h@|i W?th@?Ui |||_i |L M*U 5Ti?_?}

@h@|i w hLM|

LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i

h@|i ?th@?Ui f2Df e2D. ffD. b2

O5 "@*|)

wL?} |ih4 @|?} *t| f. HDH ff2e f22e ffeS fee

5LULiUL?L4U

OLtiL*_ ?UL4i fSe 2eHf ffb 2Sf. fffH f2

B5, i_U@|L? ffe. DH ff2 DD2 ff2b 2D

wii* i_U@|L? ff. .eSD ffeb 2D. ffS2 ee

#i}hii i_U@|L? ffD2 efe fSS ..D f.. He

5i*u i4T*L)i_ ff2H 2HeH ffD Hf2 fff DD

@?u@U|h?} ff2S H ffe 2.H ffD 

?ih LUUTih ffe Df. ff2b 2SH ff2D 2fH

#i4L}h@TU

}i fbH2 HDH f.2. e2H fD. eb

}i2 _{fHbb .. fHfe eHfe fS.H ef}

6i4@*i fff2 f2. ffeD eDD ffeS eeD

4Mih Lu U*_hi? fff b ffe SDb2 ffe SDS

4Mih Lu @_*|t ff2 SSb fffS fb2S fff ff

4 f2b2 eS

A4i _44it vit

+O _44it vit

5@4T*i t3i fSDb fSDb

w+ |it| uLh ?|ihUiT| igiU| L?*)G 2

'eSHER'fbbH

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 Th@|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L?G

2

f ' SH. ER'ffff

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu+O igiU|t

2

f ' .. ER'ffff

5ULhi |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 TM*U tTi?_?} i^@|L?G

2

f '2fD ER'f2H2

A@M*i

hLh|) uLh i |h@ TM*U tTi?_?} EL hi}L?@* i@*| @|Lh|) igiU|t

h@|i W?th@?Ui |||_i |L M*U 5Ti?_?}

@h@|i w hLM|

LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i

h@|i ?th@?Ui f2b bH2 ffD. b

O5 "@*|)

wL?} |ih4 @|?} *t| fS eSS. ff fD2e ffSD e

5LULiUL?L4U

OLtiL*_ ?UL4i f.S 2DS2D ffb 2DD. ff fe2

B5, i_U@|L? ffeS DDS ff22 S2 ff2b 2b

wii* i_U@|L? ff.f .eDe ffDf e. ffS eef

#i}hii i_U@|L? ffDS e2.f fS .SD2 f.D He

5i*u i4T*L)i_ ff2H 2Hfb ffe .e ff2b Df

@?u@U|h?} ff2H eDb ffe 222 ffe 2H

?ih LUUTih ffef Dfe ff2e 2ff ff2 .e

#i4L}h@TU

}i fbH. HSfb f.. e2Se fDSb eH

}i2 _{fHbH .bf f.b. e.S fS.H e}

6i4@*i fff2 f2.b ffeS ee2 ffe. eDf

4Mih Lu U*_hi? fffe e2 ffD S.ff ffD SS2

4Mih Lu @_*|t ff2e SH2 fffS fHf fff fH

4 f2.D fbH

A4i _44it vit

+O _44it L

5@4T*i t3i fSDb fSDb

w+ |it| uLh ?|ihUiT| igiU| L?*)G 2

H '222 ER'fHD

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 Th@|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L?G

2

f ' .f.HER'ffff

5ULhi |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 TM*U tTi?_?} i^@|L?G

2

f '22bER'f2SS

A@M*i e

5TTLh| uLh }hi@|ih TM*U tTi?_?} E+i}L?@* i@*| @|Lh|) igiU|t ?U*_i_

h@|i W?th@?Ui |||_i |L M*U 5Ti?_?}

@h@|i w hLM|

LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i

h@|i ?th@?Ui f2H 2De ffDf 2f.

O5 "@*|)

wL?} |ih4 @|?} *t| fS H2e fD. fH2f fS f.

5LULiUL?L4U

OLtiL*_ ?UL4i fS2 2e2D fff ffD ffH2 H

B5, i_U@|L? ffe. D ff2. 2f ffe e

wii* i_U@|L? ff. .Df. fffH ff ff2f fHf

#i}hii i_U@|L? ffDS e2DD ffS feDb ff2e fSb

5i*u i4T*L)i_ ff2. 2HfH ffHD 2.H ffH 2S2

@?u@U|h?} ff2H e.D fffS f2b2 fff. f2

?ih LUUTih ffef eb2D ffb. e.S ff2 eDH

#i4L}h@TU

}i fbHb HS2 f.Hb 2.SD fSe2 2

}i2 _{fbfb .2. fbHf Df2 fHDb 2}

6i4@*i fff2 fD ff2 fSS2 ff2 fSH

4Mih Lu U*_hi? fffe D fff ffSf ffff ff

4Mih Lu @_*|t ff2e S.D ffS 2Sf ff2 H.

4 f2HD 2fD.

A4i _44it vit

+O _44it vit

5@4T*i t3i fSDb 2S.f

w+|it| uLh ?|ihUiT| igiU| L?*)G 2

'H. ER'fff

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 Th@|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L?G

2

f ' .f2HER'ffff

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu+O igiU|t

2

f ' .D ER'ffff

5ULhi |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 TM*U tTi?_?} i^@|L?G

2

f '2.D ER'f2H

A@M*i D

5TTLh| uLh }hi@|ih TM*U tTi?_?} EL hi}L?@* i@*| @|Lh|) igiU|t

h@|i W?th@?Ui |||_i |L M*U 5Ti?_?}

@h@|i w hLM|

LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i LiUi?| |@*i

h@|i ?th@?Ui f222 2Sfe ffeb 2fD

O5 "@*|)

wL?} |ih4 @|?} *t| fSD e. ffef fe2f ff.H fH

5LULiUL?L4U

OLtiL*_ ?UL4i f.D 2DeDD fff2 ffS ffHH 2f

B5, i_U@|L? ffeS DDe ff2. . ffD ee

wii* i_U@|L? ff. .D2b fffS f2Df ffb f.D

#i}hii i_U@|L? ffDb ee.H ff fSS ff22 fSe

5i*u i4T*L)i_ ff. 2.D2 ffH. 2HSS ffH 2.f

@?u@U|h?} ff2b Deb fff. f2 fff. fD

?ih LUUTih ffb eHbe ff eSHD ff. eHH

#i4L}h@TU

}i fbb. HeS f.SS 2SH. fSe 22

}i2 _{fb .2SD fbSe eDf fHe fS}

6i4@*i fff2 f.2 ffe f.D ffe f..

4Mih Lu U*_hi? fffD Sf ffff fffS ffff ff

4Mih Lu @_*|t ff2e SHbe ffH ef ff2D 2f.

4 f2b 2

A4i _44it vit

+O _44it L

5@4T*i t3i fSDb 2S.f

w+|it| uLh ?|ihUiT| igiU| L?*)G 2

S' DS2 ER'fbb2

`@*_ |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 Th@|i ?th@?Ui i^@|L?G

2

f ' .2DHER'ffff

5ULhi |it| uLh i U*tL? Lu ?_t|h) igiU|t uhL4 TM*U tTi?_?} i^@|L?G

2

f '2S2 ER'f2eS

+iuihi?Uit

do @h3i*cvc b.c h@|i tULL*t @?_TM*U tULL*t @?_TM*U tULL*€?@?Uic

aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) Hc.eHS

d2o it*i)c A @?_ L@|ic 5 bb M*U ThLtL? Lu Th@|i }LL_t @?_ |i

hi_t|hM|L? Lu ?UL4ic 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii Hc b.bbHe

do it*i)c Ac O@**c a @?_ hit|L?c W bbS@ h@|i i@*| ?th@?Ui @?_ |i

t|@|i Lu |i O5W65 L44i?|@h) L D2W?t|||i uLh 6tU@* 5|_itc wL?

_L?

deo it*i)c Ac O @**c a @?_ hit|L?c W bbb Ai _i4@?_ uLh Th@|i i@*|

?th@?UiG _L@|?} *t|t 4@||ihq aLh?@* Lu M*U,UL?L4Utc uLh|UL4?}

dDo *@U!LhM)c @?_ # #L?@*_tL?c bHHc @t ihtt !?_c ti*uti*iU|L? @?_

iUi?| |h@?tuihtc 4ihU@?,UL?L4U +ii .HcSb.ff

dSo Lt@?^i|c @?_ L**@h_c 5 Ebb. +i@_) uLh |hi@|4i?|G M*U i TiU|@

|L?t @?_ |i u|hi Lu i@*| U@hi 5LU@* @h!i| 6L?_@|L?c wL?_L?

d.o hLL!c wc O @**c a @?_ hit|L?c W bbH `@| _hit tTTLh| uLh TM*U

tTi?_?}q ? 6 A@)*Lh BLLM) Ei_ LUi @?_ M*U L*U)c @U4**@?c

wL?_L?

dHo @t@4@||@c Bc O hi4ih @?_ it|i@ bb. ? |i TL*|U@* tt|@?

@M*|) Lu hi_t|hM|i tLU@* ?th@?Ui t)t|i4tc T@Tih Thiti?|i_ @| W5,

L?uihi?Uic uLh_c #iUi4Mih bb.

dbo |*ihc # @?_ a BhMihc bbSc #Lit TM*U ?th@?Ui UhL_ L| Th@|i

?th@?Uiq "@h|ih*) aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Ut cbef

dfo ,TT*ic# @?_+ +L4@?Lc bbS@c M*U ThLtL? LuTh@|i }LL_tc aLh?@*

Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) fec D.He

do ,TT*ic # @?_ + +L4@?Lc bbSMc ,?_t @}@?t| |i 4__*iG #i|ih4??}

TM*U tihUiThLtL?i? |ihi @hiTh@|i @*|ih?@|itc aLh?@* Lu M*U

,UL?L4Ut S2c 2b.2D

d2o B*L44cB@?_ +@!4@hc bbHcT|?} L| LuTM*U*)ThL_i_ tihUitG

4@Lh|) L|?} hit*|c 5LU@* LUi @?_`i*u@hi Dc H.bb

do BLhihL c @?_ L?uLh| bbD5|@|t|Ut @?_ iUL?L4i|hU 4L_i*tc VL*

2c @4Mh_}i N?iht|) hittc @4Mh_}i

deo BLi@cc bbSc@Lh|) h*i @?_ |iTM*U ThLtL? Lu @ Th@|i }LL_c

M*U LUi bc 222ee

dDo O@**c a@?_ Whit|L? bbHA@ ThUi igiU|t L? @|||_it |L )TL|iU@|i_ |@

?Uhi@titc W65 `Lh!?} @Tih `bH%Sc W?t|||i uLh 6tU@* 5|_itc wL?_L?

dSo w@MLh @h|)c bb. h|@? #itihit i||ihc wL?_L?

d.o 5|}*|3c a ,c b.ec Ai _i4@?_ uLh i_U@|L? ? TM*U @?_Th@|i tULL*

t)t|i4tc aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut c ebHD

H #@|@ TTi?_

i@? #iTi?_i?| @h@M*it

h@|i ?th@?Ui fD

5TTLh| uLh 4Lhi TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} fDH

5TTLh| uLh 4U 4Lhi TM*U i@*| tTi?_?} fHS

Oi@*| |LT ThLh|) uLh i |h@TM*U tTi?_?} fDe

i@? @|i}LhU@* @h@M*it

6i4@*i fDe

B5, i_U@|L?D _f2SD

wii* i_U@|L?S _f2.

#i}hii i_U@|L?. _ffHf

5i*u i4T*L)i_ ff.

@?u@U|h?} f2bD

?ih LUUTih fSbD

i@? 5|@?_@h_ _i@|L? L?|?Lt @h@M*it

wL?} |ih4 @|?} *t| ETihtL?t Tih ff f2b fH

OLtiL*_ ?UL4i EThLTLh|L?H _{fD2f f2HD}

4Mih Lu U*_hi? ETihtL?t f.D fe

4Mih Lu @_*|t ETihtL?t 222 fH2

}i E)i@ht%ff feS2 f.

48_{Uhvsrqghqw*v kljkhvw hgxfdwlrqdo txdolfdwlrq lv JFVH ru htxlydohqw +w|slfdoo| wdnhq dw}

djh 49,

49_{Uhvsrqghqw*v kljkhvw hgxfdwlrqdo txdolfdwlrq lv D Ohyho ru htxlydohqw +w|slfdoo| wdnhq dw}

djh 4;,

4:_{Uhvsrqghqw kdv d ghjuhh ohyho hgxfdwlrqdo txdolfdwlrq}

4;_{Krxvhkrog lqfrph lv phdvxuhg e| wkh phdq srvlwlrq lq wkh lqfrph glvwulexwlrq ri krxvhkrogv}

zlwk wkh vdph edqghg lqfrph lq wkh vdph |hdu +lq wkh zkroh EVD vdpsoh,1