Heterogeneous Consumers, Demand Regimes, Monetary Policy and Equilibrium Determinacy

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Heterogeneous Consumers, Demand

Regimes, Monetary Policy and

Equilibrium Determinacy

Di Bartolomeo, Giovanni and Rossi, Lorenza

Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Milano

5 September 2005

Online at

https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5100/

! " #$ % " $ & " ' ( ) * + " (

" ! ( ( ," " # " - . /* % "

0 " & 0 "

/* "

) ( " 1 2 0 $ " 0 " 0 " "

3+ " 1 +4 0 +45

( " 0 "

" & " ' ( )

* + " " & ( "

# " % ! ( " " &

" "

6

( 0 ' 7 0 8 9 0 7 9 0 : * 0 ' 0 ; 0 ; 0 ; ; 0 8 0 " 0 2 0 ;

0 8 " */+ " ;; 4 9 "

" < ( " & ;/= #8 /' >% " + = #; 9 8 % < ( " / + # 0 *( "% ? & " & ; 9

7 ( " & " ( D

( & ( & " & (

7 0 "

A " & " # , , &%0

A 0 (

( < " &

&

! ( " 0

" ( " ( (

, , & " & ,

9 & " ; < ( # ECE0 EE 0 EE % " "

A / (

" ( # % " (

$ # %0 " F &

$ 0 ( & ,

= " * # 0 %

* " & A " G

& < " $ 0 0 "

" " " " , " 5 ;

0 7 " & # 5%0 H # B% " & # B%B

" " " # " " , , & % ' ( )

( < " ( " F

& " " " " "

* ; < ( # % "

; # 4% " & 5 I

" 0 ( CBI " &

G " & >EI 7"" " " " & 3 # EE %0 * # EE>%0 8 < # EEE%0 * # EEE% " " " & # B%

5

* ; < ( # % " ; # 4% " 9 # >% , , & & F "

B

5

/ 0 7 " & # 5% " " "

" H

# B% A ( & &

" & ( "

0 ( ", < 0 H # B% (

" $ $ & ( "

& # B% ( " & (

, " ,: < F & A " ' ( )

" " ( , &

" H # B% ( & "

" & " "

, , & ( "

& J ( < >! " "

" " & " " "

" " " 0 " " "

" "

* 0 ( " ( , , & "

( ( " " " /

0 $ 0 " "

/ 0

" " < <

( 0 " "

! " & " & 0

H # B%0 "

, , & A 0 & A

"" 0 " /* 0 (

& ( " " "

" ( ' A &

( < " " & ( " " " &

" " * 5

>

B

& " " " " "

* B "

4

! " ' ( ) " " & , "

# H 0 B% / " " " (

" ", " " F & 0 ( " "

! , "

" * ₋λ _{0 "}

( " " λ

" " & " ( " ( 0

" " &

, & " " 0

" , 0 ( & ( "

" " " 1

# % = − −

(

) (

)

# % ω _{= +}υ 0

+$ # % 0 " "

" " + $ 0 ( 0

0 π ζ ₌

(

) (

)

" F 0 ( υ

& D + $ " " "

( " " $ # % & "

4

7 " " " # & " ! " "0 EE G ! " "0 5% " " & " $ " " "

" " " 7 " A 7 7 " A ( , " " & $ 1

' # B% , " " " " " 0 ( , " * " * "

" " " ( 7 & "

>

0 ( & < & ( " " " "

( ω # $ # %% & "

"

" " & " " ( ", <

8 0 & " " " < $ 1C

#5% π =β π₊ + + 0

#B% ω _{= +}

(

)

#>% ₌

(

)

( _{= −} ( A & , 0

( " ( A <0 &

# % " " A , < +$ #B%

F & " " +$ #>% $

" , " " ₌ 0

& (

#4% _{= − −}

₍

) (

)

₍

₎

9 " " #& + ,

& %0 A " 0 " ,

A " (

7 & 0 $ #B% & ,( 1

# %

(

)

+ + +

= − Ω − + Ω∆ 0

( ₍−λζ_{υ λζ)} − +

Ω = 0 ,

E

+$ # % " " " & ' (,)

0 A " (

" " & $ " $

C

" K 0 & " " $ ( " &

E

4

( 7 " 0 $ # % " "

( " 1

7 " " "

* " " & ,

" & # 9 " 0

EEE%

7 " "

" " & $ " , 7

A "

< "

7 #4% " " &

&

(0 ( &

0 0

& " & , < " 9 "

" F " "

" 0 ( (0 &

" " ( " ( ( " # $ #B%%

" " " " " "

& " 0 # $ # %% & " " "

( " " A "

" F / " F 0

1 ( " ( ( "

" " & , " "

" ( 0 " " " 7

" ( (1 ( ( 0

" 0 ( & ( 0

' " " " "," & & (

" F # H 0

BG ; 0 4% 7 " # < % " F & 0 & " 7 " (& < " 0

"

0 " /*, " #

" %

0 ( " " " λ_{0 "}

" 1

#C%

(

)

(

)

(

)

κ κ

λ λ

ζ υ κ θ

∗ +

< = =

+ ₊

0

( ( $ " , "

(

)

(

)

θ η η−

= − ∈ , " < 0 ( η

& " " "

( θ _{" κ0 "}

#λ∗

> % / 0 " " λ∈

[

]

/

θ _{" ( κ0 $ " , " /}

"" 0 θ ._>0 λ

∗ _{( 0}

0 $ " , ( " λ

! ( " / " "

0 ( " &

0 " 0 $ " ,

" 0 " λ

" 0 ( &

0 Ω 0 ,L, " 0 λ_{0 "}

' ( , " 0 λ→ 0 Ω → − 0

0 " " (

/ 0 & ( A "

" " " " " " 1 " & " & "

( " /

C

( " " 7 λ

Ω = +∞ #

$ % λ λ∗

> $ " ,

" #( & ( A "

( " %0

" "

" 0 λ 5

* 0 /* "

" # 7 " & 0 5% 7

& " /* "

!

"

5 ;

&

"

7 " & " & ,

" ; & " " & A 0 (

& 0 & " 0 " " "

& & 0 ( A D

" ( $ " &

A $ & "

& " A ( 1 >

#E% ₌α π ₊α 0

( α " α &

/ " " " $ 1

# % _{> −} −β

5

D 0 θ _"κ λ6_{N 0 #" %}

B

" " " 7 " A 9

>

E

& " " 7 "& <

"

& 0 ( &

" & +

,

(

)

− 7 A

"

₍

₎

+ − > # 0

0 ! " "0 B%

/ $ " , " 0 _Ω 2 0

A 0 ( " Ω = −Ω0 (

$

# % A β β

           − + 

> _ − , − − _

Ω

 

# % β β

           − + 

< _ − , − − _

Ω   ( β − < − Ω

$ # % ( " 8

& " " 0

0 & $ " $ # %0

" " & " # % " 0 & &

& ( & < $ &

( " & < (

&

/ " " 0 "

" " 0 $ " , " 0 (

" " ; " 0 " & "

( 4

% 0 5β

β

+ Ω >

+

" " "

4

&% " 0 β 0 5β

β β

 + + 

Ω ∈  

+ +

  0

" " &

, #( %

"

% 0 ( # β

β

+ Ω <

+ %0

"

" G 0

" " (

" 0 " "

"

( & " &

" , "

$ " , "

, , & $ & "

" " (

" " " # B% (

& ( , , & "

0 JO # O #&%0 #"%% (

" ( 0 & 0

" & # B% 8 # %

" # % " " (

1 " 0

# 0 B% 8 #&% " #"%

" "

# % " # % ( ( " &

( &

D # 4%0 ( $ & "

8 # % " F 1 , , &

0 $ " "

& / ( #&%

$ " & ( A ( , , &

0 < ( C

0 & " $

& 0 & (

" ,: <

7 & ," & " < " $ "0

( "

( ", < 0 0 & < " (

1

# 5% α₅ π

+ =

( α₅ " " & (

& < " & < +$ # %

" " & E "

" # ( ", < %

/ " " 0 " $ 1

# B% ₅∈ , +_

(

)

Ω

 

+$ # % " " " 1 "

" , , 0 " " &

" & < " ! " " # EE %

C

/ ( " 0 & " ( 60 ( "

2 ( 0 ( ( 6

" " " 0 ( ( P 6 "

& < / 0 (

6

(

E

; " 0 $ # % " " , "

#* 0 EEE0 5% " " # " 0 % / & ,& " ( A #! " "0 51 9 4% 2 ( 0 " (

& <F # " α5% " " " F 7

& " ( & " ( <

$ # % " " A

/ $ " , " 0 & $ 1

# >% ₅∈ −_

(

)

Ω

 

; ( & " " & " 8

& < " " , ,

2 ( 0 " " /

0 0 β+

Ω > 0

" " ( < # % A "

0 ₅ (β+) Ω < −

( 7 ,

" < A " G

$ " , " 0 0 " "

, A

" 0 ( (

" A ( & "

& 8 # % ##&%%

( # % , " / " "

0 #( % 8 ( " / $ "

( " & ( ( 1

( #" < % " # % /

" < 0 " " 0 "

" 0 0 "

" , #( % "

"

/ " " 0 0 , "

A " "0 &

8 0 0 " , "

A " " "

" 0 "

5

0 , " A "

" #& 8

%0 " , " A 0 0

" " 0 "

$ " / & < ( 0 , "

A " " ( 0

0 " " 0 " A

,

D ( H # B% / ( 0 &

# B%0 "

" $ " $

2 ( 0 " H # B%0 " <

" 1 " " # 0 /* %

5 ; " &

" " # %,#>% " #E%0 # <

0 ( K %0 ( " " "

" " " " < ( "

" " & ( "

!

#/ % < " B

"

8 # % " #& % " " # <

" <0 %G # %,#& % " # 5%,#&5% "

7 ( B # % " #& %0 " " / "

" " ' ( ) " (

" ( N

8 # B% & " "

$ & J5 / H # B% < $

& ( " F 0

( ( ' 0 A 0

B

0 0 0 ( " /*0 "

" 0 ( & "1

• G

• ( " & ( & " &

B # %,# 5% " #& %,#&5% " & / ( 9 < ( (

( " 7 ( # 5% , <

/ 0

( , , & $ 50 "

" 0 Q C N B / 0 (

( 0 # %0 "

A " " 0

" " "

" , "

7 " < /

0 #& %0 " &

" 0 " A "

" G "

" " " ,

D ( 0 ( #&5% <

" & "

"

# $

" F * + ' ( )

" " " $ # %

" " $ & "

0 ( ( ( ," "

# " /* % "

>

" & 0 "

( /* "

" $ " , " 0 ( " /*

0 "

( 0

" ,

0 "

& " F 0 $ " ,

" 0 "

" " A $ & 0 /*

0 " " " D ( " &

" & " " " &

" " ; " 0 $ " , " 0

" & " (

/ " " " 0

" " (

( & <

" " # % ( 2 ( 0

0 " &

" & # % , 0 ( "

/ & < # % " & (

" A " 0 " $

& < # "

% & 0 0 0 , "

A " " & ,

0 ( ( $ " , " 0

" " & " " ( & < 0 ( <

( " &

A 7 & "" A A

4

" " " " " <

( < ( " "

( " "

""

%

&

" A " & # " % " # , " %0

A ( 1

# % β $# # φ# #

_{

_}

 

 _{+ +} 

 

=

, , ∈ ,

∑

( β∈

(

)

0 ( & #

φ & & ( #₌ 0φ ₌

" ( #₌ 0 φ ₌ ! (

0

( )

& 0 & " 1

# %

# #

# % # # # & & $

' φ '

− −

 − + 

= + _Π − _

 0 ( % (

0 " Π ' (

, " " & 0 " 0 &?

& " 0 ( # " %

"

" " , " F

A & 0 ( & ( , " " 1

# % $ =_β

₍

)

# 5% $ % '

=

# B% " & # B0 >% ( "

" & " & ( &

# B% % '− =κ$#

(

)

_{

_}

∈

+$ # % " # 5% " # ,

+ $ % " , "

#( ( & % +$ # B% G "

& $ # 5% " # B%0 " ,

" A " $ & 0

κ

+

=

"

# >% $ ₌

₍

₎

# 4% =

(

)

$ # B% " # 4%0 ( & ( 1

# % $ %

(

)

κ

= −

, $ # % ( & $ # %0 ₌$

$ & , $ # % " # 5% ( "1

# C% =

(

)

# E%

(

)

+ +

= − − +

# % ₌( ₋

* $ # C% " $ # E% " # % ( &

$ # %

""

%

&

" A ( " " & (

" , , & ! "

" , " "

"

' 0 " H # B%0 " " & , " " " " " "

C

" 0 " " " 0 $ # 5%

" # C%0 ( & ζ $ $−

(

) (

)

= = + + 0 "

A " &

" " 0 ( " "

0 & " " ( ( & " #

" A & $ % 7 0 ( " "

& # " A " & )_∈

_[

_]

" " (

( )

/ " " " & "

/ A 0 " A & 0 0 "

$ <, 1

#& % θ

₍

₎

= −

; 0 "

< 0 "

" " 7 " 0 0

1

#& % *$ % '−

=

$ $ # C% " #& %0 ( & " 1

#& 5% θ κ

(

)

= + 0

( " " "

" & (

θ _{" κ " " " 0 $ " ,}

< & & " θ

E

""

% $ &

" " & , " " #5%,#4%

( "& < #E%0 ( & 1 5

# % π π β      +            +    

Ω + Ω Ω

   

=

   ₋ 

   

* & " " , ( A1

# % *

(

)

(

)

β _{β β}

− _{− −}

− −

 + Ω + Ω − 

Ω + Ω Ω

   

=_{   }=  

− ₋

    _ _

" ( +# %. " !# %. " " 0 ( 1

# 5%

(

)

(

)

 

= + Ω + + Ω 

, A * " " ! " " # 51 7 "

9 B% * " " " "

! " " # 5%0 ( " $ " , " 0 "

$ 1 , + *# %_> 0 <_

₍

₎

, + *# %±! *# %+ <

1

# B% + *# %+! *# %+ =

{

₍

₎

₍

₎

₍

₎

}

 

# >% + *# %−! *# %+ = −Ω

₍

₎

₍

₎

 

$ # B% " # >% ( " " # % " # %0

" # 5%0 & 0 "

" & ( A1

# 4% * β

(

)

(

)

 − Ω − Ω − 

= _{ }

−

 

5

/ + *# % β− 0

= > & $ + *# %±! *# %> −

" + *# %_±! *# %_{< −} + *# %_±! *# %_{< −} "G & 0

# % # %

+ * _±! * _{> −} $ " # >%

" & ( " "

" " " 0 " $ # % " # %0 &

β   β

 

 

 

− +

− > − −

Ω "

β β + Ω >

+ 0 (

"

β β + Ω >

+ " $ 1 %

β −

> − &%

β           + < − −

Ω β − < − Ω β β + Ω <

+ " $ 1 %

β           +

> − −

Ω &%

β −

< − < −β − Ω

" % " % ( " " "

" & "

( " / "" 0

# % β β

          − +

− > − −

Ω Ω 5β β + Ω < +

# C% −β − > − −β Ω β β − Ω > +

" & & " 5β

β

+ Ω <

+ " " & & "

β β − Ω >

+ 0 " & & "

5 0

β β

β β

 + + 

Ω ∈ 

+ +

  " " & ( & "

0 β

β + Ω >

+ " $

β −

> − # %

" 0 β 0 5β

β β

 + + 

Ω ∈ 

+ +

  0 $

β −

> − # % β

 

 

 

 

 

+

< − −

Ω #

0 , # %

$ & " %

5 ( 0 β

β

+ Ω <

+ 0

" $ 1 β

 

 

 

 

 

+

> − −

Ω # 0

$ " & $ & " %

β −

'

7 0 3 " & # 5%0 , , & " ; 8 0

(0 B 1 E ,C5

< 0 " ; ! " " # EE %0 / " ; 8 0

- * . $ / / & 0 B1 4>5,4CB

& 0 D # B%0 / 0 " 7 ; < 8 "

7 "1 + 8 ( <0 $& %

' ' B C

& 0 D # >%0 " 7 ; < 8 0 ; 8 "

#/ "% ) 0 / $ % ' ' E

9 & 0 3 R " ' ; < ( # ECE%0 9 0 / 0 " /

1 * + " 0 & * 0

0 C>, 4

9 & 0 3 R " ' ; < ( # EE %0 8 / 0 9 / 0 " 9 0- & 0 00 / 1 0 00 C1 4>, E

9 & 0 3 R " ' ; < ( # EE %0 9

/ 1 9 , / 0 (0 5>1

5, 4

9 0 3 0 ; + & " 9 + # >%0 ' " "

+ * < ; 8 0 - '

0 51 ,B>

9 " 0 3 H0 " ; # EEE%0 * ; 8 0

- 2 0 5 1 44 ,

+ " * 2 < ? # >%0 ; 8 0 +A "

9 01 / - 0# %

0 3 9 # %0 2 & 9 " / /

; ,8 ; " 0 (0 E 1 54 ,E

0 3 9 " " & # B%0 + + +$ D 0- * 00 > 1 55, >5

H0 3 0 S ,* " 0 3 : T # B%0 , , & 9 "

/ 0 - * $ / / & 0 541

5E, 45

3 0 # EE % ! 9 " 9 " =* + U0 3

- 00 E, 5B

; < (0 ' # %0 * ,* " 8 0

5

; : 7 0 8 0 " 9 # 4%0 " ; 8

/ ' ( ) ; " ( $ " 9 0

& ** '0 1JJ J & KCC CB

8 < 0 3 # EEE%0 2 " 9 8 " &

9 * * A 0 (0 CE1 E>E,E 5

* 0 3 # EE>%0 = 9 " ,9 J8 ,/

2 0 (0 C>1 C4,

* 0 ' * # EEE%0 2 " 9 / A

" 0 (0 CE1 EB ,E>C

* + D # EEE%0 / ; 8 0

-* 00 B51 4 ,4>B

* + D # 5%0 ! ! ( U = 3 "

; 8 0 - 2 0

B 1 B 4,B

0 3 # EE5%0 : 8 8 0 $

0 $ 1 0 ' ' 0 5E1 E>, B

! " "0 ; # 5%04 0 / ' 05 / 0 ! *

' 0 8 = 8 0 8

! " "0 ; # B%0 " D ; 8 0

B & V ; " &

8 : 8

EE

4 + & " "

υ _{> / &}

> "

>

# % #&%

4

# % #&%

# % #& %

# % #& %

# 5% #&5%