1 Check Capital Management Inc. Costa Mesa, CA. (714) 641-3579 (800) 710-5777 $0.00 $1.00 $2.00 $3.00 $4.00
* Expected Results for 2011
Earnings Per Share and Dividends
EPS Dividend/Share
October 2011
Emerson Electric
Price: $47Research Report by
Peter Hughes, Check Capital Management
Emerson Electric (EMR) was founded in 1890 to manufac-ture electric motors. Today the company produces com-plex electrical and electronic products for industrial and commercial markets. EMR has been remarkably consis-tent, raising its dividend for 54 consecutive years and increasing profits in all but three of the last 52 years. THE BUSINESS
Emerson continues to make motors and electrical products. Over time, however, the company has added much breadth and sophistication to its offerings. EMR produces many of the things upon which industries are built—equipment for factories, power plants, data centers and other facilities. Customers depend heavily on Emerson’s products to improve their operations. Most of EMR’s offerings have long life-cycles, so they need not be replaced often. Although complex, Emerson products are rarely subject to the rapid change common in many high-tech industries. Thus, the company is very likely to maintain high marketshare for many years and unlikely to be upended by radical innovations.
Management has focused on investing EMR’s resources in faster-growing businesses while divesting slower-growing, lower-margin businesses. This has taken the company into more-differentiated, less price-competitive technologies. Management has targeted global megatrends, which it believes can enhance growth for many years. Such megatrends include continued re-source scarcity, aging populations and increasing wireless connectivity. Emerson serves markets with annual sales of about $145B, up from $90B in 2000 and indicative of the firm’s product expansion. EMR is broadly diversified across many industries, minimizing its dependence on any one sector of the world economy.
Emerson is also diversified geographically, deriving 60% of its sales outside the U.S. The company ventured into China and India in the early 1980s, far earlier than many peers. EMR now sells in 150 countries and has design centers in Europe, India and China as well as the U.S. China accounts for 13% of sales, and emerging markets as a whole make up 34% of revenues.
2 Check Capital Management Inc. Costa Mesa, CA. (714) 641-3579 (800) 710-5777 Network Power 27% Process Management 28% Climate Technologies 17% Tools & Storage 8% Industrial Automation 20%
Sales by Segment
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% Network Power Process Management Climate Technologies Tools & Storage Industrial AutomationSegment Operating Margin
Diversification and a strong emerging-markets position mitigates Emerson’s country-specific risk and should help the company post higher growth in the future.
The company has five operating segments, each described below. Besides the Tools & Storage unit, all have high marketshares and are often the top players in their respective markets.
Process Management
With over $6B in revenues and over $1B in operating income, this is Emerson’s largest unit. It designs and fabricates systems, compo-nents and services for such industries as energy, chem-icals, beverages and power. This segment’s output helps to maximize the performance of plants and facilities in those industries. Products include measuring instru-ments, meters, software, sensors and valves used in
industrial processes and manufacturing.
Network Power Emerson’s second-largest segment makes efficiency-boosting equipment for
data centers and telecommunications networks. Products include precision cooling systems, electrical-switching devices, power-backup technology and uninterruptible power supplies. Fur-thermore, EMR sometimes provides on-site management of client systems.
Climate Technologies This unit
pro-vides energy efficiency, food safety and comfort to residential and com-mercial customers. Products include compressors, sensors, temperature controls and ventilation systems. Management recently emphasized an example of the Climate Technologies segment: Emerson’s design and
3 Check Capital Management Inc. Costa Mesa, CA. (714) 641-3579 (800) 710-5777 $0 $1 $2 $3 2008 2009 2010 2011 YTD
Deployment of Cash ($ Billions)
Share Repurchases Dividends Capital Expenditures Acquisitions
Industrial Automation Emerson’s third-largest segment furnishes tools that allow factories and
plants to elevate performance. Products include electric motors, industrial equipment and power systems for manufacturers, energy companies and utilities. Applications include vehicle assem-bly lines, petrochemical processing, shopping-mall escalators and supermarket checkout stations.
Tools and Storage Many of this unit’s products are the descendants of Emerson’s original
offer-ings, including fans, appliances, water heaters and various tools. This is now the firm’s smallest segment and the only one with significant sales to retail markets.
MANAGEMENT
Emerson Electric’s experienced management team adheres to a proven, conservative philoso-phy. David Farr joined the firm in 1981, becoming CEO in 2000, and all other senior execu-tives have been with the firm for 20+ years. Although EMR has made many acquisitions under Farr, they have generally been of the small, “bolt-on” variety. Farr has safeguarded Emerson’s success by avoiding the risk of big takeovers. As the adjacent chart reveals, in 2010 the com-pany did make two substantial
acquisitions for $2.8B. However, as further outlined in the Financial Metrics section (page 4), Farr’s tenure featured measured acquisitions and shareholder-oriented capital allocation.
Besides aligning the company with megatrends, management is pursuing growth by continuing its focus on emerging markets. The goal is 45% of total sales arising from these faster-growing economies by 2015. Overall, management expects sales to rise 30%-40% (to $32B-$35B) by 2015, with acquisitions accounting for about one-third of that growth. Long-term goals include 5%-7% sales growth, a 10%-14% free-cashflow margin and a 15%-25% return on capital.
Over the past decade, management has made the firm more efficient. Emerson has improved asset utilization, with “working capital as a percent of sales” and “fixed assets as a percent of sales” both declining substantially since 2000. During the 2008-09 recession, EMR further reduced costs and streamlined operations. While many peers slashed capital expenditures, EMR cut back only modestly. This positions the company well for an improving global economy.
4 Check Capital Management Inc. Costa Mesa, CA. (714) 641-3579 (800) 710-5777 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Financial Metrics
Return on Capital Net Profit Margin
Revenue Net Income EPS Net Margin Debt Cash ROC
$23.5B $2.5B $3.05 10.5% $5.1B $1.6B 16.1%
Key Statistics
(trailing four quarters ending 6/30/2011)
Emerson recently reported strong results: Q2 sales rose 16% to $6.3B, organic “constant curren-cy” growth was 10%, net income grew 17% to $683M and EPS increased 17% to 90¢. In Q3, order trends have slowed with worries about the global economy but remained positive for all units except Climate Technologies. Given the firm’s considerable order backlog, management maintains that revenues should continue to grow for at least the next few quarters.
FINANCIAL METRICS Throughout its history, Emerson has consistently increased its income and built shareholder value. By maintaining a solid balance sheet, the firm is able to endure economic slumps. Its financial metrics are strong, with a net profit margin of 10% and a return-on-capital of 16%. Emersion has $11B of intangi-ble assets on its balance sheet (46% of assets). Amortization of intangibles in 2011 will total about $260M, more than 10% of net income. Thus, the firm’s true economic earnings are sub-stantially higher than reported income.
EMR produces substantial free cashflow and returning it to shareholders is a management priority. Of the $24B in cashflow produced over the past decade, 33% went to dividends, 20% to share buybacks, 25% to net acquisitions and 22% to capital expenditures. Management expects to regularly return 50%-60% of operating cashflow to shareholders, but in the short term more will be allocated to debt reduction and less to share repurchases. Company stock now offers a 3.0% yield. The firm has retired 12% of its outstanding stock since 2000.
VALUATION / CONCLUSION
Emerson has long proven it can steadily increase shareholder value. The firm boasts a high share of several sophisticated markets, an achievement purposefully built over decades. Although its field is somewhat cyclical, EMR is diversified across many countries as well as industries and should be able to produce a high return-on-capital over the course of an entire business cycle. The company’s management—experienced and shareholder-oriented—has a long-term plan to
5 Check Capital Management Inc. Costa Mesa, CA. (714) 641-3579 (800) 710-5777 $0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 Price
15 times Earnings Per Share
10 15 20 25 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 P/E Ratio
keep the firm growing. Given these factors, Emerson will likely perform well in the long run, prospectively rewarding shareholders with a total annual return of over 10%.
Because of Emerson’s global market position and strong financial metrics, the stock historically receives a premium valuation. As the graph (above right) shows, EMR stock has since 1990 frequently traded at more than 20 times earnings. Over the past five years its median P/E has been 18. However, in recent months shares collapsed on fears that the world economy is faltering. While we cannot predict short-term economic trends, Emerson’s stock price appears to undervalue the company’s prospects. Thus, this may be an opportune time to buy one of the world’s premier industrial companies.
[Please see footnotes below]
CCM Research Reports are for informational purposes only and are not an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy. They are not personal recommendations for any particular investor and do not take into account the financial circumstances of any individual investor. Check Capital, or one of its officers, may have a position in the securities discussed and may purchase or sell such securities from time to time. CCM Research Reports are created using third-party data. While Check Capital believes such third-party information is reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy, timeliness or completeness.