Residential stamp duty:Time for a change

Residential stamp duty:Time for a

change

Andrew, Mark and Evans, Alan and Koundouri, Phoebe and

Meen, Geoffrey

April 2003

=]//%( [##P EE

8

_%

₃

_c

_t

_%

_:I

_c

3

_!

_3I

3

_/j

_t

_]Ix

_o

_I

_c

_/

_{% @}

_O(

3

b

\

3

_:

_N%

x

2

_x

_v

₅

#

₄

_r

_x

_#

_d$

_n

₅

#

_z

2

₄₅

?

_c

2

_4$

_n

₅

2

_W

_@

_#

_T

_#

₅

n

_@N4

_r

_@Nx

_^

_n

₅

P

_#

_@

₌₌

_x

_#

_k5

x

_##

₄

_n

₅

q

₄

_^

_c

_#

_x$

_^

_:k5@

₌

₅

7

_#

2

_r

_^

₄

_I

b j_W#5:2_{i5k^#zr5=x@)5$:}2_)[5rN:k5W2_{$5T##45x^$^4I5$W}2_{x[zk5^45x#`#4:5k#</sub>2<sub>x$a55</sub>_<sub>45LuuN2LuuLn5:W#5</sub> k^#zr5d2<sub>$57La,15T^zz^@45`@)[}2_{x#r5d^:W57+Au5)^zz^@45@4zk5=@Nx5k#}2_x$5#2_xz^#xa55

b (_^#zr$5W2_{c#5x^$#454@:5T#`</sub>2<sub>N$#5@=5</sub>2<sub>45^4`x#}2_{$#5^45c@zN)#$5@=5:x}2_4$2_{`:^@4$n5TN:5T#`}2_N$#5@=5:W#5

T@@)5^45W@N$#5[x^`#$a5572<sub>[^r5^4`x#</sub>2_{$#$5^45W@N$#5[x^`#$5</sub>2<sub>4r5:W#5`Nxx#4:5w$z}2_{Tw5$:xN`:Nx#5W}2_$5

rx2<sub>d45[Nx`W</sub>2<sub>$#x$5^4:@5W^IW#x5$:</sub>2<sub>)[5rN:k5T</sub>2<sub>4r$5dW^</sub>`W5^4`x#2_$#$5:W#5:2_i5k^#zra55

b #₄2_zk$^$5@=5[x^`#5wTN4`W^4Iw5$N[[@x:$5:W#5c^#d5:W2_{:5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$:xN`:Nx#5@=5$:}2_)[5rN:k5

r^$:@x:$5:W#5[x^`#5r^$:x^TN:^@45@=5:x2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$a55</sub>O_{Nx:W#x)@x#n5Tk5r^$:@x:^4I5x#z}2_:^c#5[x^`#$n5 :W#5:2<sub>i5z#</sub>2<sub>r$5:@5^4#==^</sub>`^#4`^#$n5$N`W52_$52_c@^r2_{4`#n5^45:W#5@[#x}2_{:^@45@=5W@N$^4I5)}2_xv#:$a55

b ;_^$:x^TN:^@42_{z5[x@Tz#)$5@=5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$:</sub>2<sub>)[5rN:k5$k$:#)5=</sub>2<sub>zz5^45[</sub>2<sub>x:^`Nz}2_{x5@45:W@$#5z^c^4I5}

^45:W#5$@N:W52_{4r5@45=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$5dW@5=}2_{`#5)@x#5`@4$:x}2_^4:$5^452_{``#$$^4I5`x#r^:a}

b j_W^$5x#$#2_{x`W5[N:$5=@xd</sub>2<sub>xr5</sub>2<sub>54N)T#x5@=5</sub>2<sub>z:#x4</sub>2<sub>:^c#$5:@5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)a55}

b O_^x$:zkn52_5Ix2_rN2_:#r5:2_{i5^$5$NII#$:#ra55}x_@c^4I52_d2_{k5=x@)5:W#5`Nxx#4:5w$z</sub>2<sub>Tw5$:xN`:Nx#5:@5@4#5}

^45dW^`W5W^IW#x5:2<sub>i5x</sub>2<sub>:#$5</sub>2<sub>x#5@4zk5^)[@$#r5</sub>2<sub>:5:W#5)</sub>2<sub>xI^45d@Nzr5x#rN`#5^4#==^</sub>`^#4`^#$5$N`W5

2_{$5TN4`W^4Ia55}

b <_{#`@4rzkn5^4r#i</sub>2<sub>:^@45@=5:Wx#$W@zr$5^$5</sub>2<sub>z$@5x#`@))#4r#ra55}j_{W#54^z5:Wx#$W@zr5d}2_$5z2_$:5

N[x2_{:#r5^45N99A5]71unuuu^a55}__{=5:W^$5:Wx#$W@zr5W}2_{r5T##45^4r#i#r5^45z^4#5d^:W5W@N$#5[x^}`#5

Ix@d:W5^:5d@Nzr54@d5T#52_{x@N4r57NAunuuua}

__:I(Ot]bIcO:

#_{z:W@NIW5:W#x#5d#x#54@5`W}2_{4I#$5:@5:W#5x}2_:#$52_{4r5:Wx#$W@zr$5=@x5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5@45x#$^}r#4:^2_z5

:x2_4$2_{`:^@4$5^45:W^$5k#</sub>2<sub>xw$5TNrI#:n5:W#x#5W</sub>2<sub>c#5T##45^)[@x:</sub>2<sub>4:5^4`x#}2_$#$5^45x#`#4:5k#2<sub>x$a55</sub>j2Tz#5N5 $W@d$5W@d5:W^$5W2<sub>$5T##45[</sub>2<sub>x:^`Nz</sub>2_xzk52_{:5:W#5:@[5#4r5@=5:W#5[x^}`#5r^$:x^TN:^@4a55O_{Nx:W#x)@x#n5:W#5:}2_i5

k^#zr5W2_$5x^$#45$W2_x[zka55__{45=^$`</sub>2<sub>z5k#</sub>2<sub>x5LuuN2LuuLn5:W#5k^#zr5d</sub>2<sub>$57La,15T^zz^@45`@)[}2_{x#r5d^:W57+Au5}

)^zz^@45@4zk5=@Nx5k#2_x$5#2_xz^#xa55?_$:^)2_{:#$5$NII#$:5:W}2_{:5:W#5k^#zr5^45LuuL2LuuA5`@Nzr5</sub>2<sub>[[x@</sub>2<sub>`W57F5}

T^zz^@4a

#_{z:W@NIW5:W#5^4`x#</sub>2<sub>$#5^45k^#zr5^$5`z#}2_xzk5c#xk5c2_zN2_Tz#5:@5:W#5?_i`W#lN#x52_:52_5:^)#5dW#45:2_i5

x#c#4N#$5=x@)5@:W#x5$@Nx`#$5W2<sub>c#5T##45T#z@d5#i[#`:</sub>2_{:^@4$n5:W#x#5}2_x#5^)[@x:2_{4:5lN#$:^@4$5}2_T@N:5

EA =]//%( [##P lN#$:^@4$5:2`vz#r5^452<sub>54#d5x#[@x:5Tk5</sub>2<sub>5:#</sub>2<sub>)5=x@)5:W#5</sub>q<sub>4^c#x$^:k5@=5</sub>7<sub>#</sub>2r^4Ia55x<sub>@x#5[x#`^$#zkn5:W#5</sub> x#[@x:52_$v$5dW2_:52_{x#5:W#5^4#==^}`^#4`^#$5^45:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)n5dW2<sub>:5</sub>2<sub>x#5:W#5#==#`:$5@45:W#5#`@4@)k5</sub> 2<sub>4r5dW#:W#x5^:5^$5[@$$^Tz#5:@5r#c^$#5</sub>2<sub>45</sub>2<sub>z:#x</sub>2<sub>:^c#5$k$:#)5:W</sub>2<sub>:5</sub>2<sub>c@^r$5$@)#5@=5:W#5`Nxx#4:5</sub>

[x@Tz#)$m

8_{%p%:]%3@(O/3I}3_/jt]Ix

4_W2_{x:5N5$W@d$5:W#5k^#zr5=x@)5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5@45x#$^}r#4:^2_z5:x2_4$2_{`:^@4$5$^4`#5:W#5)^r5#^IW:^#$a55}j_d@5

[@^4:$52_{x#5`z#</sub>2<sub>x+5=^x$:5:W#5x</sub>2<sub>[^r5^4`x#}2_$#5^45x#`#4:5k#2<sub>x$5</sub>2<sub>4rn5$#`@4rn5:W#5c@z</sub>2_{:^z^:k5@=5:W#5k^#zr5@c#x5}

:W#5W@N$^4I5`k`z#a55O_@x5#i2_{)[z#n5x#c#4N#$5d#x#5)@x#5:W}2_{457N5T^zz^@45^45N9++295}2_:5:W#5[#2_v5@=52₅

W@N$^4I5T@@)n5TN:5=#zz5:@5z#$$5:W2_{457Auu5)^zz^@45}2_{:5:W#5T@::@)5@=5:W#5$NT$#lN#4:5$zN)[5^45}

N99L2ANa557_#c#4N#$5W2_{c#5$NT$#lN#4:zk5x^$#45$W}2_x[zk52_I2_{^45^45x#`#4:5k#</sub>2<sub>x$5:@5x#</sub>2<sub>`W57La,15T^zz^@45^45}

=^42_{4`^</sub>2<sub>z5k#</sub>2<sub>x5LuuN2La55</sub>•2<sub>x^</sub>2<sub>:^@4$5^45:W#5k^#zr5r#[#4r5@45:Wx##5=</sub>2<sub>`:@x$m}

b :W#5z#c#z5@=5[x@[#x:k5:x2_4$2_`:^@4$n

b 5:W#5z#c#z5@=5W@N$#5[x^`#$n5

b :W#5x2_:#$5@=5$:2_)[5rN:ka55

j_{W#5$#`@4r5@=5:W#$#5=</sub>2<sub>`:@x$5^$5lN}2_4:^:2_{:^c#zk5:W#5)@$:5^)[@x:}2_4:a55j_x2_4$2_`:^@4$5W2_c#5T##45

x#z2_:^c#zk5$:2_{Tz#5@c#x5:W#54^4#:^#$5}2_{4r5`W</sub>2<sub>4I#$5^45:W#5x</sub>2<sub>:#$5@=5rN:kn5^zzN$:x</sub>2<sub>:#r5^45</sub>j2<sub>Tz#5Nn5`}2_44@:5

=Nzzk52_{``@N4:5=@x5:W#5x^$#5^45x#c#4N#$a55}

3_\3_(I]o)_c%!t@(O/3I3_/jt]Ix

u Buu

Nnuuu

NnBuu Lnuuu LnBuu Anuuu

N9+B2+1 N9+,2++ N9+929u N99N29L N99A29F N99B291 N99,29+ N9992uu LuuN2uL 7)

<_@Nx`#m5__4z2₄r57_#c#4N#

O_{Nx:W#x)@x#n5:W#5x#I^@4}2_z5r^$[2_{x^:^#$5^45W@N$#5[x^}`#$5^4#c^:2Tzk5)#2_45:W2_{:5)@$:5@=5:W#5x#c#4N#5}

=x@)5$:2_{)[5rN:k5@``Nx$5=x@)5[x@[#x:k5$}2_z#$5^45:W#5<_@N:W5@=5?_4Iz2_4ra55__{45LuuN2LuuLn5}

=]//%( [##P E; :W#5`@N4:xka552<sub>k5`@4:x</sub>2_$:n5z#$$5:W2_45W2_z=5@=5:x2_4$2<sub>`:^@4$5:@@v5[z</sub>2`#5^45:W@$#52_x#2_$a55

k3_V!%]o=_I3_{/jt]Ix (}3_{I%3O:(%3ct%:Ic}3_{! j(Oj%(Ixpo}

4_@))#4`^4I5;2_:# q[5:@5

7Aunuuu

x_@x#5:W2₄₅

7Aunuuun5q_[5

:@571unuuu

x_@x#5:W2₄₅

71unuuun5q_[5

:@57LBunuuu

x_@x#5:W2₄₅

7LBunuuun5q_[5

:@57Buunuuu

x_@x#5:W2₄₅

7Buunuuu

NA5x2x`W5N9+F u N N N N

Lu5;_#`#)T#x5N99N u u u N N

Lu5#_{NIN$:5N99L u N N N N}

N15x2_x`W5N99A u u N N N

+5l_{Nzk5N99, u u N NaB L}

LF5x2_x`W5N99+ u u N L A

N15x2x`W5N999 u u N LaB AaB

L+5x2_x`W5Luuu u u N A F

<@Nx`#m5_4z24r57#c#4N#5

z_@:#$m52_#:d##45Lu:W_{5;#`#)T#x5N99N524r5N9</sub>:W<sub>5#NIN$:5N99Ln5x2:#$5d#x#5u`5N[5:@57LBunuuu524r5N`52T@c#a55h5=x@)5+}:W_5lNzk5 N99,a

3_{(OV!%/3 qcI\I\%b]((%:I 3x3I%/}

j_W#x#52_x#52_{54N)T#x5@=5[@:#4:^}2_{z5[x@Tz#)$5d^:W5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)n54@:}2Tzkm5

b <_:2_)[5rN:k5)2_{k5x#rN`#5:W#5#==^`^#4`k5@=5:W#5#`@4@)ka}

b j_{W#5rN:k5[x@rN`#$5r^$:x^TN:^@4</sub>2<sub>z5^4#lN</sub>2<sub>z^:^#$5T#:d##45z@`}2_:^@4$52_{4r5W@N$#W@zr5:k[#$a}

__{45:#x)$5@=5#==^}`^#4`kn5^45[x^4`^[z#n5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)m55

b 42_N$#$52_{5r^$:@x:^@45@=5x#z}2_{:^c#5W@N$#5[x^}`#$5:Wx@NIW5:W#5wTN4`W^4Iw5@=5W@N$#5[x^`#$52_x@N4r5

:W#5:2_{i5:Wx#$W@zr$555}

b #_{==#`:$5:W#5b@z</sub>2<sub>9^z^9j5@=5[x@[#x:k5:x</sub>2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$5}2_{4r5W@N$#5[x^`#$}

b 72_{^$#$5:W#5W@N$^4I5N$#x5`@$:5@=5`}2_[^:2_z

b __{4=zN#4`#$5W@N$#W@zr5)@T^z^:ka}

1_{]:b\c:NO@j(cb%3}

j_{W#5=^x$:5@=5:W#$#5^$$N#$5^$5r#)@4$:x}2_:#r5^45j2Tz#5Ln5dW^`W5[x#$#4:$54xq_5$Nxc#k5r2_:2_{5@45[x@[#x:k5}

:x2_4$2<sub>`:^@4$n5r^$</sub>2<sub>IIx#I</sub>2<sub>:#r5Tk5[x^</sub>`#5T2_4ra55j_{W#5TN4`W^4I5@=5:x</sub>2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$5}2_{x@N4r5:W#5:Wx#$W@zr$5}

$:2_{4r$5@N:5`z#</sub>2<sub>xzka55</sub>q<sub>@@v^4In5=^x$:n5</sub>2<sub>:5:W#571unuuu5:Wx#$W@zrn5d#5$##5NnL1B5:x</sub>2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$5^45:W#5x}2_4I#5

7B9nuuN]71unuuu5]^45=2_{`:5,uB5:x</sub>2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$5d#x#5#i}2_{`:zk5</sub>2<sub>:571unuuu5</sub>2<sub>4r5NnNNA5T#:d##457B9n9Bu5</sub> 2<sub>4r571unuuu^n5dW#x#</sub>2<sub>$5@4zk5Nu,5:@@v5[z</sub>2<sub>`#5^45:W#54#i:5[x^`#5x}2_4I#a55

E- =]//%( [##P ]FBN52_:5#i2_{`:zk57LBunuuu^5`@)[}2_x#r5d^:W52_{5)#x#5BF5T#:d##457LBunuuN5}2_{4r57LBBnuuua55}O_^42_zzkn52_:5

:W#5N[[#x5:Wx#$W@zrn5NAu5:x2_4$2<sub>`:^@4$5:@@v5[z</sub>2`#5^45:W#57F9unuuN]7Buunuuu5x2_4I#5]+,52_:5#i2_`:zk5

7Buunuuu^5d^:W5@4zk5NB5^45:W#54#i:5[x^`#5`z2_$$a

#_{zz5@=5:W#$#5=^INx#$5$N[[@x:5:W#5c^#d5:W}2_{:5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$:xN`:Nx#5@=5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5r^$:@x:$5:W#5[x^`#5}

r^$:x^TN:^@45@=5:x2_4$2_{`:^@4$a55</sub>O<sub>Nx:W#x)@x#n5Tk5r^$:@x:^4I5x#z</sub>2<sub>:^c#5[x^`#$n5:W#5:}2_i5z#2_r$5:@5

^4#==^`^#4`^#$5^45:W#5@[#x2_{:^@45@=5W@N$^4I5)}2_xv#:$a55

k3_V!%[o:_{c3I(cV]IcO: O@I(}3_:33_{bIcO:3Vxj(cb%V}3_:tpro_p[##_]B[##_[

7 z_N)T#x5@=5:x2_4$2_`:^@4$

BLnuuN]BAnuuu A9,

BAnuuN]BFnuuu A,L

BFnuuN]BBnuuu ,BL

BBnuuN]B1nuuu A,1

B1nuuN]B,nuuu FNB

B,nuuN]B+nuuu BNF

B+nuuN]B9nuuu FNF

B9nuuN]1unuuu NL1B

1unuuN]1Nnuuu Nu,

1NnuuN]1Lnuuu AuF

1LnuuN]1Anuuu A91

1AnuuN]1Fnuuu ABu

1FnuuN]1Bnuuu +F9

1BnuuN]11nuuu AA+

11nuuN]1,nuuu FuL

1,nuuN]1+nuuu B11

1+nuuN]19nuuu A,N

LFunuuN]LFBnuuu Lu1

LFBnuuN]LBunuuu ,u,

LBunuuN]LBBnuuu BF

LBBnuuN]L1unuuu NN,

<_@Nx`#m5<_Nxc#k5@=5x_@x:I2I#5q_#4r#x$n54xq_a

!_O!3_Ic!cIx

<_#`@4rn5$:2_)[5rN:k5)2_k52_{rr5:@5:W#5c@z}2_{:^z^:k5@=5W@N$^4I5)}2_{xv#:$5T@:W5^45:#x)$5@=5:W#54N)T#x5@=5}

:x2_4$2<sub>`:^@4$5</sub>2<sub>4r5W@N$#5[x^</sub>`#$a55_₄₅₌2_{`:n5@Nx5x#$#</sub>2<sub>x`W5=^4r$5:W}2_:52_:5:W#52_IIx#I2_:#n542_:^@42_z5z#c#z5

:W#x#5^$5z^::z#5#c^r#4`#5:W2<sub>:5:W^$5W</sub>2<sub>$5T##45</sub>2<sub>5)</sub>2<sub>t@x5=</sub>2<sub>`:@xa55</sub><_:2_)[5rN:kn5[2_x:^`Nz2_{xzk5^45:^)#$5@=5}

=]//%( [##P E@

#==#`:$5@=5$:2<sub>)[5rN:k5@45:W#5W@N$^4I5N$#x5`@$:5@=5`</sub>2<sub>[^:</sub>2<sub>z5]5:W#5)</sub>2<sub>^45d</sub>2<sub>k5^45dW^</sub>`W5#`@4@)^$:$5 )#2<sub>$Nx#5</sub>2<sub>44N</sub>2<sub>z5@d4#x]@``N[^#x5W@N$^4I5`@$:$a55</sub>j_{W#5N$#x5`@$:5W</sub>2<sub>$5</sub>2<sub>54N)T#x5@=5`@)[@4#4:$a55}j_W#5

)2_^45@4#$52_x#m

• jW#5)@x:I2I#5^4:#x#$:5x2:#5[2^r5Tk5:W#5W@)#]@d4#x5 • jW#5[x^`#5@=5:W#5W@N$#

• jW#5#i:#4:5@=5r#T:5I#2x^4I52$5@[[@$#r5:@5#lN^:k5=^424`#n5^#n5T@xx@d^4I5c#x$N$5:W#5N$#5@=5 W@N$#W@zr$w5@d45=N4r$

• #4k5:2i5x#z^#=52c2^z2Tz#

• ?i[#`:#r5`2[^:2z5I2^4$5@45:W#5W@N$# • q@`2z5:2i#$n5$N`W52$5:W#54@N4`^z5j2i5 • x2^4:#424`#5#i[#4r^:Nx#$5@45:W#5[x@[#x:k55 • <:2)[5rN:k524r5@:W#x5:x24$2`:^@45`@$:$5 • ;#[x#`^2_:^@4

j_{W#x#=@x#n5:W#5:x}2_4$2_{`:^@4$5`@$:$5}2_{$$@`^</sub>2<sub>:#r5d^:W5:W#5[Nx`W}2_{$#5@=5:W#5[x@[#x:k5]@=5dW^`W5$:}2_)[5

rN:k5^$5@4#5`@)[@4#4:^52<sub>rr5:@5:W#5N$#x5`@$:a55</sub>2_{N:5:W#5^)[@x:}2_{4`#5@=5$:</sub>2<sub>)[5rN:kn5^45[x</sub>2<sub>`:^`#n5}

r#[#4r$5@45]2_{^5^:$5$^q#5x#z}2_{:^c#5:@5:W#5@:W#x5`@)[@4#4:$5</sub>2<sub>T@c#n5]T^5:W#5#i:#4:5:@5dW^`W5$:}2_)[5rN:k5

`2<sub>45T#5$[x#</sub>2<sub>r5@c#x5:^)#a55</sub><<sub>@)#5^zzN$:x</sub>2<sub>:^c#5`</sub>2_z`Nz2_:^@4$52_x#5I^c#45^45j2_Tz#5Aa55

k3_V!%Po__!!]3I(3_{Icp%]3%(bO3Ib}3_!b]!3_{IcO:3p V}3_3%tO:[##_]@cN](%3 z_@x:W P_x#2_:#x5q_@4r@4

x_@x:I2_{I#5^4:#x#$:5x}2_{:#5]`^ 1au 1au}

z2:^@42z5<2c^4I$5x2:#5]`^ FaB FaB

X_@N$#5[x^`#$5]7^ ,unBBu N+Nn,Bu

q@245:@5c2zN#5x2:^@5]`^ ,u ,u

72_:#5@=5)@x:I2_I#5:2_{i5x#z^#=5]`^ u u}

q@`2z54@N4`^z5j2i55x2:# Nau uaB

x2_^4:#42₄`#5#i[#4r^:Nx#$5]`^ Nau Nau

;#[x#`^2:^@45x2:#5]`^ Nau Nau

<_:2_)[5rN:k5x2_:#5@452_c#x2_I#5

W@N$#5[x^`#5]`^ Nau Nau

q_$#x5`@$:5@=5`2[^:2z5]2$$N)^4I5

+`5#i[#`:#r5`2<sub>[^:</sub>2<sub>z5I</sub>2<sub>^4^5</sub> Nnu9A Nn9u+ <<sub>@Nx</sub>`#m5__4z2₄r57_#c#4N#n5!;2xn54xqn52_N:W@x$5@d45`2<sub>z</sub>`Nz2_:^@4$5

A# =]//%( [##P 2_b#x2_I#5W@N$#5[x^`#5^45#2`W52_x#2_n5:W#5$:2_)[5rN:k5x2_:#5^$5:W#5$2_)#52_{:5N`a55</sub><<sub>#`@4rn5`</sub>2<sub>z`Nz}2_:^@4$5@=5

:W#5N$#x5`@$:5r#[#4r5`xN`^2<sub>zzk5@45:W#5#i[#`:#r5`</sub>2<sub>[^:</sub>2<sub>z5I</sub>2<sub>^4a55</sub>O<sub>@x5:W#5^zzN$:x</sub>2<sub>:^c#5`</sub>2_{z`Nz</sub>2<sub>:^@4$n5d#5</sub> 2<sub>$$N)#5</sub>2<sub>5c</sub>2<sub>zN#5@=5+`a55}#_:5:W#$#5c2_{zN#$n5:W#5N$#x5`@$:5^45}q_@4r@45^$52_{5)#x#57Nn9u+5[}2₅2_4rn5^45:W#5

z_{@x:Wn57Nnu9Aa55}__:5^$5W2_{xrzk5$Nx[x^$^4In5:W#x#=@x#n5:W}2_{:5@d4#x]@``N[}2_{:^@45^$5[@[Nz}2_xa552_k5`@4:x2_$:n5

$W@Nzr5W@N$#5[x^`#$5T#5#i[#`:#r5:@5=2_zz5^45q_@4r@4n52_{$5$@)#5`@))#4:</sub>2<sub>:@x$5W</sub>2<sub>c#5[x#r^`:#rn5:W#45}

:W#5N$#x5`@$:5x^$#$5rx2<sub>)</sub>2<sub>:^`</sub>2_zzka552_N:5^)[@x:2_4:zkn52_:5:W#52_c#x2_I#5[x^`#n5$:2_{)[5rN:k5^$5$d}2_)[#r5Tk5

:W#5@:W#x5`@)[@4#4:$5@=5:W#5N$#x5`@$:n54@:2Tzk5:W#5`2_[^:2_z5I2_^452_{4r5:W#5^4:#x#$:5x}2_:#a55j_W^$5^$5dWkn5

2_:5:W#52_IIx#I2_:#5z#c#zn5$:2_)[5rN:k52_[[#2_x$5:@5W2<sub>c#5@4zk5z^)^:#r5#==#`:$5@45[x^</sub>`#$52_4r5:x2_4$2_`:^@4$a

X_{O]3c:N/OVc!cIx}

O_^42_zzkn5$:2_)[5rN:k5)2_{k5x#rN`#5:W#5)@T^z^:k5@=5W@N$#W@zr$a55}2_N:52_z)@$:52_{zz5[x#c^@N$5d@xv5@45:W^$5}

$NTt#`:5x#z2<sub>:#$5:@5:W#5</sub>q<<sub>n5dW#x#5:x</sub>2<sub>4$</sub>2<sub>`:^@4$5`@$:$5</sub>2<sub>x#5`@4$^r#x</sub>2_{Tzk5W^IW#x5:W}2_45^45:W#5qn₅2_4r5q<₅

`@4`zN$^@4$5`2<sub>44@:5</sub>2<sub>N:@)</sub>2<sub>:^`</sub>2_zzk5T#52_{[[z^#r5:@5:W#5}qn_a55#_{z:W@NIW5=Nx:W#x5#)[^x^`}2_{z5d@xv5@45:W^$5}

^)[@x:2_{4:5lN#$:^@45^$5)N`W54##</sub>r#rn5:W#x#52<sub>x#5I@@r5x#</sub>2<sub>$@4$5:@5T#z^#c#5:W</sub>2<sub>:5:W#5^)[</sub>2<sub>`:5@=5$:}2_)[5

rN:k5@45)@T^z^:k5^45:W#5qn_{5^$5z^v#zk5:@5T#5z#$$5:W}2_45^45:W#5q<_a55

X_{@d#c#xn5z@@v^4I5}2_:5:W#52_IIx#I2_:#n5:W#542_:^@42_{z5[^`:Nx#5r^$IN^$#$5dW}2_:52_{x#n5^45@Nx5c^#dn5:W#5)@$:5}

^)[@x:2_{4:5[x@Tz#)$5d^:W5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5]5^:$5r^$:x^TN:^@4}2_{z5`@4$#lN#4`#$a55}!_{#54##r5:@5z@@v5}2_:5$[2_:^2_z5

r^==#x#4`#$52_4r5c2_x^2_{:^@4$5T#:d##45W@N$#W@zr5:k[#$a}

:_c3I(cV]IcO:3_!c:%{]3_!cIc%3

!_#5W2_c#52_zx#2_rk5$##45:W2_:n5$[2_:^2_zzkn5$:2_)[5rN:k5=2_zz$5)@$:5W#2_{c^zk5@45:W#5$@N:W5@=5:W#5`@N4:xka55}

j_{W^$5`@4:x</sub>2<sub>$:$5d^:W5</sub>2<sub>4@:W#x5#z#)#4:5@=5:W#5[x@[#x:k5:</sub>2<sub>i5$k$:#)5]5</sub>4<sub>@N4`^z5}j2_i5]5dW^`W5=2_zz$5)@$:5

W#2_{c^zk5@45W@N$#W@zr$5^45:W#5}z_@x:Wa552_{N:5:W#5)@$:5^)[@x:}2_{4:5r^$:x^TN:^@4}2_z5^4#lN2_z^:^#$5@=5$:2_)[5

rN:k5z^#5T#:d##45=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$52_{4r5#i^$:^4I5@d4#x]@``N[^#x$a55}j_W^$52_{x^$#$5T#`</sub>2<sub>N$#n5:k[^`}2_zzkn5

=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$52_{x#5`z@$#x5:@5:W#^x5`x#r^:5z^)^:$5}2_{4rn5:W#x#=@x#n5}2_x#5z#$$52_{Tz#5:@5T@xx@d5:@5`@c#x5}

$:2_)[5rN:k5z^2_T^z^:^#$a

O_{^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$5@45}2_c#x2_I#5^45LuuN5)2r#52<sub>5r#[@$^:5@=5LN`n5dW^</sub>`W5W2_{r5x^$#45`@4$^$:#4:zk5@c#x5}

:W#5W@N$#5[x^`#5T@@)a552_{N:5)@c^4I5#i^$:^4I5@d4#x]@``N[^#x$5[x@c^r#r5}2_5z2_xI#x52_c#x2_{I#5r#[@$^:5@=5}

A1`n5x#=z#`:^4I5:W#5x#]^4c#$:)#4:5@=5#lN^:k5=x@)5:W#5[x#c^@N$5W@)#a55j_W^$5[#x`#4:2_I#5W2_$5

`W2<sub>4I#r5z^::z#5@c#x5:W#5T@@)a55</sub>j<sub>k[^`</sub>2_{zzkn5T@@)^4I5W@N$^4I5)}2_{xv#:$5^)[@$#5$:x@4I#x5`@4$:x}2_^4:$5

@45=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$5:W2_{45#i^$:^4I5TNk#x$a55}<_{^4`#5W@N$#5[x^`#5^4=z}2_:^@45z#2_r$5:@5=^$`2_z5rx2_I52_$5

[x@[#x:^#$5)@c#5^4:@5W^IW#x5:2_i5Tx2_{`v#:$n5=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$5</sub>2<sub>x#5</sub>2<sub>I</sub>2<sub>^45W#</sub>2<sub>c^zk5</sub>2<sub>==#`:#ra55}

j_@5^zzN$:x2_{:#n5`@4$^r#x5</sub>2<sub>5=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x5</sub>2<sub>4r5</sub>2<sub>45#i^$:^4I5TNk#x5d^$W^4I5:@5[Nx`W}2_$#52₄₅2_c#x2_I#5

=]//%( [##P A] x2<sub>:#5@=51`a55</sub>j2Tz#5F5`@)[2_{x#$5:W#5#==#`:$5@=5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5=@x5:W#5:d@n5N4r#x5:W#5}2_$$N)[:^@45:W2_:5:W#5

#i^$:^4I5@d4#x5`2<sub>45</sub>2<sub>rr5:W#5[</sub>2<sub>k)#4:5:@5:W#5)@x:I</sub>2<sub>I#n5dW#x#</sub>2<sub>$5:W#5=^x$:]:^)#5[Nx`W</sub>2<sub>$#x5^$5`x#</sub>r^:5 `@4$:x2_^4#r52_4r5`2_44@:a

k3_{V!% Jo}>_@@%bI3O@3I3_{/jt]IxO:@c(3IbIc/%V]x%(3}3_{:t%vc3Ic:NOq:%(3}

O_^x$:]j_^)#52_Nk#x ?_i^$:^4I5!_d4#x

2_Nx`W2<sub>$#5[x^</sub>`#5]7^5 NBNn9Fu NBNn9Fu

;_{#[@$^:5]`^ LN A1}

x_@x:I2I#5]7^ NLunuAL 9,nLFL

#_44N2_z5^4:#x#$:5[2_{k)#4:5]`^ ,}nLuL Bn+AB

<_:2)[5rN:k5]7^ NnBN9 NnBN9

#44N2z5^4:#x#$:5[2k)#4:n5^=5

$:2_)[5rN:k52rr#r5:@5)@x:I2_I#$ ] Bn9L1 <_@Nx`#m5!;2xn54xqn52<sub>N:W@x$5@d45</sub>`2_z`Nz2_:^@4$

q_4r#x5:W#$#52_r)^::#rzk5#i:x#)#5`^x`N)$:2_{4`#$n5:W#5`@4$:x}2_{^4#r5=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x5d@Nzr5W}2_c#5=2`#5

2_45N[=x@4:5$:2_)[5rN:k5[2_{k)#4:5@=57NnBN9n5TN:5Tk5}2rr^4I5:W#5rN:k5:@5:W#5)@x:I2_{I#n5:W#5#i^$:^4I5}

@d4#x5d@Nzr5x#lN^x#52₄₅2_44N2_{z5^4`x#</sub>2<sub>$#r5^4:#x#$:5`@$:5@=5tN$:579N}L_a55

#_{z:W@NIW5@4zk5^zzN$:x}2_{:^c#n5:W#5`</sub>2<sub>z`Nz}2_{:^@4$5r@5$W@d5:W}2_{:5:W#5TNxr#45^$5z^v#zk5:@5=}2_{zz5)@x#5$:x@4Izk5}

@45=^x$:]:^)#5TNk#x$5]5[#xW2_{[$5:W#5Ix@N[5:W}2_{:5:W#5I@c#x4)#4:5d@Nzr5z^v#5:@5}2_==#`:5z#2_$:5]5N4r#x5

`@4r^:^@4$5dW#x#5`x#r^:5`@4$:x2_^4:$5$:2_{x:5:@5T^:#a55}

"_!I%(:3_{Icp%3 IOI\%b]((%:I 3x3I%/}

j_{W#5#==#`:$5@=5$:</sub>2<sub>)[5rN:k5</sub>2<sub>x#5$N==^`^#4:zk5^)[@x:}2_{4:5:@5`@4$^r#x5[x@[@$</sub>2<sub>z$5=@x5x#=@x)a55</sub>_<sub>45=</sub>2<sub>`:5}

x#z2_{:^c#zk5)@r#$:5c}2_x^2_{:^@4$5@=5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)5Tx^4I5^)[x@c#)#4:$a55</sub>O<sub>^x$:n5d#5`@4$^r#x5}2₅

Ix2_rN2_{:#r5$k$:#)n5dW#x#5rN:k5^$5@4zk5[}2_^r5@45:W#5c2_zN#52_{T@c#5:W#5:Wx#$W@zra55}<_#`@4rn5^45

`@4tN4`:^@45d^:W5:W#5Ix2_rN2_{:#r5$k$:#)n5d#5r^$`N$$5:W#5#==#`:5@=5^4r#i}2_{:^@45@=5:W#5:Wx#$W@zr$a55}

!_4#5@=5:W#52_4@)2_{z^#$5@=5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$k$:#)5^$5:W</sub>2<sub>:5:Wx#$W@zr$5</sub>2<sub>x#54@:5</sub>2<sub>N:@)</sub>2<sub>:^</sub>`2_{zzk5^4r#i#ra55}2_k5 `@4:x2<sub>$:n5^4r#i</sub>2<sub>:^@45^$5:W#5I#4#x</sub>2<sub>zzk5#i[#`:#r54@x)5^45:W#5^4`@)#5:</sub>2<sub>i5</sub>2<sub>4r5^4r^x#`:5:}2_i5$k$:#)a

"_N(3_t]3_I%tI3_v

j2_{Tz#5L5^zzN$:x}2_:#$5:W2_{:5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$z</sub>2<sub>T5$k$:#)5`}2_45z#2_{r5:@5[x^`#5TN4`W^4Ia55}j_{W^$5`@Nzr5T#5}2_c@^r#r5

Tk5:W#5^4:x@rN`:^@45@=52<sub>5Ix</sub>2<sub>rN</sub>2<sub>:#r5:</sub>2<sub>i5]5@4#5^45dW^`W5W^IW#x5:</sub>2_i5x2_{:#$5d#x#5@4zk5^)[@$#r5}2_:5:W#5

)2_xI^4a55__{:5^$5`z#</sub>2<sub>x5:W</sub>2<sub>:5`W}2_4I^4I5=@x)52_5$z2_T5:@52_5Ix2_rN2_{:#r5$k$:#)5d@Nzr5W}2_c#5^)[z^`2_:^@4$5=@x5

T@:W5:2_i5x2_:#$52_{4r5x#c#4N#5I#4#x}2_:#ra55!_{W^z#5:W^$5x#[@x:5r@#$54@:5[x@[@$#5$[#`^=^`5:}2_i5x2_:#$n5^:5

A[ =]//%( [##P

j_{W#5=^x$:5^zzN$:x}2_:^@45@=52_5Ix2_rN2_{:#r5=@x)5@=5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5x#=z#`:$5:W#5`Nxx#4:5=@x)w$5$:xN`:Nx#n5TN:5}

d^:W@N:5:W#5$z2_T$a554_{Nxx#4:zkn5:W#5#i^$:^4I5rN:k5[}2_{^r5@45[x@[#x:^#$5c}2_zN#r52_{:5tN$:5z#$$5:W}2₄₅

7LBunuuu5d@Nzr5T#57LnBuu52_{4r5@45[x@[#x:^#$5dW^`W5)^IW:5T#5$@zr5}2_:5tN$:52_{T@c#57LBunuuu5d@Nzr5}

T#57,nBuua55j_W#52_c#x2_I#5:2_i5[2_k2_{Tz#n5)^r5[@^4:5@=5:W^$5$:#[n5^$57Bnuuua55}!_45:W#5$2_{)#5[x^4`^[z#5:W#5}

)^r5[@^4:5@=5:W#54#i:5$:#[n52_{:57Buunuuun5^$57N,nBuua55}j_{WN$n5T#:d##45[x^`#$5@=57LBunuuu5}2_4r5

7Buunuuun5:W#5:2_i5[2_k2_{Tz#5$W@Nzr5^4`x#</sub>2<sub>$#5Tk57NLnBuun5:W</sub>2<sub>:5^$5</sub>2<sub>:5</sub>2<sub>5)</sub>2<sub>xI^4</sub>2<sub>z5x</sub>2<sub>:#5@=5B`a}

j_{W^$5^$5$W@d45^45}4_W2_x:5Ln5dW#x#52_5Ix2_rN2_:#r5:2_i52_:52₅₎2_xI^42_z5x2_{:#5@=5B`5^$5$W@d45Tk5:W#5r}2_$W#r

z^4#a55j_{W#5$@z^r5z^4#5$W@d$5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$z</sub>2<sub>T5$:xN`:Nx#a55}__{:5`</sub>2<sub>45T#5$##45:W</sub>2<sub>:5:W^$5B`5x}2_:#5d@Nzr5

x#[z2`#5)@$:5@=5:W#5`Nxx#4:5$:xN`:Nx#a55_<sub>:5^$54#c#x:W#z#$$54#`#$$</sub>2_{xk5:@5r#:#x)^4#5:W#5x#$:5@=5:W#5}

$:xN`:Nx#a55#<sub>:5:W#5:@[5#4rn5:W#5`W</sub>2_{xI#5z#c^#r5Tk5:W#5:d@5=@x)$5T#`@)#$5#lN}2_z52_{:57,Bunuuu5$@5:W}2_:5

:W#5Ix2_rN2_:#r5x2_:#52_T@c#n5$2_kn52_{5)^zz^@45[@N4r$5)^IW:5T#5x#rN`#r5:@5F`5:@5x#[z^`}2_{:#5:W#5#i^$:^4I5}

x2_{:#$5@45:W#$#5W^IW#x5c}2_{zN#$5^=5$@5r#$^x#ra55}X_@d#c#xn5d#5W2_c#52_$$N)#r5:W#5x2_{:#5d@Nzr5T#5B`a}

3_\3_{(I [o}=_I3_/jt]Ixok_\%3!3_V 3_:tN(3_t]3_I%t3x3I%/3

<_@Nx`#m5_<sub>4z</sub>2<sub>4</sub>r57<sub>#c#4N#</sub>n52<sub>N:W@x$5@d45</sub>`2_z`Nz2_:^@4$5

#_{:5:W#5T@::@)5#4r5:W#5[@$^:^@45^$5)@x#5r^==^`Nz:a55}j_{W#x#5^$54@5r@NT:5:W}2_{:5:W#5$^)[z#$:5$@zN:^@45}

d@Nzr5T#5:@5`W2<sub>xI#54@5rN:k5@45$</sub>2<sub>z#$5</sub>2<sub>:5[x^`#$5T#z@d57NBunuuun5d^:W5</sub>2_5$^4Iz#5)2_xI^42_z5x2_:#5@=5B`5

@45$2_z#$52_:5[x^`#$52_T@c#5:W2_:5)^4^)N)a55j_{W^$5d@Nzr5x#)@c#5$:}2_{)[5rN:k5=x@)5}2_5c#xk5z2_xI#54N)T#x5

@=5W@N$#5$2_{z#$n5^4r##r5)@x#5:W}2_45W2_{z=n5`@4$^r#x</sub>2<sub>Tzk5x#rN`^4I5:W#54#I}2_{:^c#5#==#`:$5@=5rN:k5@45}

W@N$#W@zr5)@T^z^:ka55X_@d#c#xn52_z:W@NIW5:W#52_{)@N4:$5`@zz#`:#r5}2_x#5$)2_zz5@45#2_{`W5rd#zz^4In5}

T#`2<sub>N$#5:W#54N)T#x5@=5W@N$#$5$@zr5</sub>2<sub>x#5z</sub>2<sub>xI#n5</sub>2<sub>5`@4$^</sub>r#x2Tz#5:2_{i5x#c#4N#5^$5`@zz#`:#r5=x@)5:W#5}

$2_{z#$5@=5:W#$#5z@d#x5c}2_{zN#5[x@[#x:^#$a55}4_{@4$#lN#4:zkn5$N`W5</sub>2<sub>5`W}2_{4I#5d@Nzr54@:5T#5x#c#4N#54#N:x}2_z5

`@)[2_{x#r5d^:W5:W#5LuuN2uL5:}2_i5:2_v#a55X_@d#c#xn52_$52₄₅2_$^r#n5d#5r@5$:x#$$5:W2_{:5N$^4I5:W#5x#c#4N#5}