Navigating the Refractive
Surgery Menu
Bill Tullo, OD, FAAO
Diplomate AAO Cornea, CL & Refractive Surgery Vice-President of Clinical Service
TLC Laser Eye Centers
Disclosures
• TLC Vision – Employee • Alcon – Advisory boardRefractive Surgery
• Corneal – LASIK – Surface Ablation • PRK • LASEK • Epi-LASIK – AK - Femto – ICRS - Intacs • Intraocular – Phakic IOL • Verisys • Visian – CLE – Cataract Surgery • Toric IOL • Multifocal IOL • Accommodative IOL • Femtosecond AssistedPRK vs LASIK
• PRK Advantage – No flap– Less tissue removed
• PRK Disadvantage – Slow visual recovery – Some pain/discomfort
• LASIK Advantage
– Fast visual recovery – Minimal Discomfort
• LASIK Disadvantage
– Flap complications – More tissue removed
Refractive Error
• Myopia • Astigmatism • Hyperopia • PresbyopiaCase # 1
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -3.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
Femtosecond LASIK Flap
iFS
Advantages of Femtosecond Flap
• Independent specificdiameter
• Independent specific thickness
• Better flap centration • Variable hinge size/location • Beveled edge
• Smooth evenly hydrated stromal bed
• Conserve tissue • Planar shape
• Safer
– Less complications – Less loss of BCVA – More gain of BCVA – Biomechanically stronger – Lower risk of keratectasia • Better Efficacy
– Induce less HOA – Smoother beds – Even hydration – Faster visual recovery – Better Low Contrast vision
PRK vs LASIK
• Ocular Health – Dry Eye – EBMD – Corneal Degeneration • FFK (irregular topography) • Terrian’s – Corneal Dystrophy • Meesman’s • Avellino • Fuch’sCase # 2
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -6.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
PRK vs LASIK
• Systemic Disease– Keloids
– Rheumatoid Arthritis
– Crohn’s Disease – IBS – Lupus
– Fibromyalgia
Case # 3
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -9.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
PRK vs LASIK
• Corneal Thickness
– Minimal CCT – Central Corneal Thickness – Minimal RSB - Residual Stromal Bed • Corneal Topography
• Occupation
Case # 4
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -12.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
STAAR Visian®
ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens
)
• FDA approval in December 2005 • Safety • Quality of Vision • Biocompatibility • Versatility • Simplicity • Cosmetic Appearance • Rapid Recovery • Removable
Patient History and Qualifications
• Careful questioning and gauging expectations
• History of contact lens wear
– D/C soft lens for 3 days – D/C rigid lens for 3 weeks
• Opportunity for the patient to ask questions and counseling provided by the
professional/staff
Contraindications
• Patients under age 21 • Progressive refractive error • Cornea/Endothelial pathology • Glaucoma • Narrow AC angle • Cataract or capsular opacification • History of: – Iritis – Synechiae – Pigment dispersion – Pseudoexfoliation • Previous corneal/refractive surgery? • Keratoconus? (Toric ICL)
Exam and Testing
• Manifest and cycloplegic refraction • Unaided and aided visual acuities • Keratometry or corneal topography • Gonioscopy (grade 2 or greater) • Pachymetry-corneal thickness• Pupil size in normal and mesopic conditions (6mm or under mesopic)
Exam and Testing
• Anterior chamber depth• Intraocular pressure (IOP)
• Biomicroscopy-dilated and undilated • Ophthalmoscopy-dilated
• Horizontal white to white-UBM / caliper / Orbscan • Endothelial cell count
Peripheral Iridotomy
• Necessary to avoid pupillary block • Laser vs Surgical
– One or two
• If laser performed one-week prior to surgery
– Post-op Pred-Forte qid
Visian Video
Post-op medications
• Follow normal cataract routine
• First 2 weeks: NSAID, steroid, antibiotic TID
• Next 2 weeks: NSAID and steroid BID
ICL Post-op Care
• IOP is critical • Over-refraction
• A/C exam for inflammation • Evaluate the vault of the ICL
– .5-1x corneal thickness is ideal
• Under .5 observe for anterior capsule haze • Over 1.5 observe for narrowing angle
Vault of the Visian ICL
Unchanged Cornea
Slitlamp Exam ICL
ICL vault
Most common complication is early
pupillary block
Initial IOP check is 2-4 hours after surgery
Pupillary Block - Treatment
• Dilate pupil • Topical Combo – Combigan – CoSopt • Oral med – Diamox • Repeat PI
• Exchange ICL – lower vault
Post-op Day 1, 7 and month 1 &3
• Uncorrected Visual acuity• Dry Refraction (Day 7 & beyond) • Biomicroscopy
• ICL Vault (Vault .5 to 1.5 ct) • PI Patency
• Inflammation
• Tonometry
• Evaluation of crystalline lens • DFE Yearly
Case # 5
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -3.00 -4.00 x 010 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU
• Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
Femto- AK
Incomparable safety
Decisive control of all surgical parameters Fully computerized control
Maximal patient comfort Minimal learning curve
Precision & predictability in the creation of AK resections + 10 Microns
Femtosecond AK and Incisions
Case # 6
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx +3.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
Hyperopia
• Patient Discussion – Dry eyes • Steep keratometry – Regression – EnhancementsCase # 7
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx +6.50 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
Case # 8
• 55 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx +6.50 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 545 OU • Normal Topography OU
Manual Cataract Surgery Today
• Ophthalmic surgeon uses hand-held instruments to create a opening in the lens capsule (capsulorhexis) that is as circular as possible
• The surgeon then breaks up the clouded lens with surgical instruments and ultrasound energy
• An artificial intraocular lens (IOL) is then placed in the eye.
MK-00251 Rev A
Manual Capsulorhexis
Femtosecond Laser Cataract Surgery
• Using femtosecond (FS) laser technology in cataract surgery makescataract removal a more predictable and potentially safer procedure by Creating more perfectly sized/shaped/centered capsulotomy Allowing for easier and more gentle break-up of the clouded lens
(phacoemulsification)
MK-00251 Rev A
Manual vs. Catalys Cataract Surgery –
1 month postop
Manual Surgery Catalys Surgery
MK-00251 Rev A
ENGAGE with Liquid Optics™ Interface
• Gentle dock for patient with minimal intraocular pressure (IOP) rise and minimal hemorrhaging
• No corneal distortion or induced folds
• Clear optical path for precise imaging and laser delivery
Liquid Optics Suction Ring Liquid Optics Docking
Liquid Optics Advantage: Optical and comfort gains Catalys OCT with Liquid
Optics
MK-00185 Rev B MK-00251 Rev A
VISUALIZE and CUSTOMIZE with
Integral Guidance™
• Integrated near-infrared video and 3D spectral domain OCT systems
visualize from anterior cornea through posterior lens
• Sophisticated algorithms customize treatment plan in 3D to anatomy of each patient
Catalys 3D spectral domain OCT
MK-00185 Rev B
Ocular surfaces mapped and treatment customized even when lens
is tilted
More predictable outcomes More predictable and precise cuts
Better outcomes
Catalys Clinical Results:
Capsulotomy Shape
Manual Capsulorhexis
Catalys Capsulotomy
MK-00251 Rev A Images courtesy of OptiMedica Corp.
Catalys Unique Lens Fragmentation
Reduces Phaco Energy and
Manipulations
MK-00185 Rev B
Images courtesy of OptiMedica
MK-00251 Rev A E ff e ct iv e P h a co T im e (s e co n d s)
Standard Cataract Surgery Catalys
Effective Phaco Time (s) Femto (n=57) 0.16 ± 0.21 Standard (n=52) 4.07 ± 3.14 MK-00185 Rev B
Catalys Clinical Results:
Impact on Effective Phaco Time
Data courtesy of Prof. Burkhard Dick, MD, PhD. Ruhr University Eye Hospital. Bochum, Germany, Member of OptiMedica Medical Advisory Board.
96% reduction in effective phaco time compared to standard MK-00251 Rev A 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 70.00 80.00 90.00 100.00 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 IO P R is e ( m m H g ) Suction Vacuum (mmHg) Curved Lens porcine (n=6) Liquid Optics porcine (n=3) Liquid Optics cadaver (n=6)
Interface Configurations: IOP rise
pressure
Liquid Optics has >4x reduction in IOP rise at procedure suction pressure
MK-00185 Rev B Data courtesy of OptiMedica MK-00251 Rev A
Femto-Cataract Video
Patient Experience
• Clinical Workup
– No major changes to standard procedure – Things to note:
• How well patient dilates
• Is patient able to keep still during procedure
• Post-Surgery Follow-up
– Same regimen as existing practices – Things to note:
• Visual recovery may be faster because of reduced ultrasound energy
• Patient may notice slight hemorrhaging on the conjunctiva
Case # 9
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• Dry Rx -5.00 DS OU • BCVA 20/20 OD/OS/OU • Pachymetry 480 OU • Normal Topography OU
• What procedure would you recommend?
Surface Ablation
• PRK – Photorefractive keratotomy • LASEK – Alcohol assisted with epi-flap • Epi-LASIK – mechanical microkeratome • ASA – Advanced Surface Ablation -hybrid
Remove Epithelium
Removal of Epithelium
• Laser – transepithelial • Alcohol – 20% ETOH • Mechanical scrape • Brush – Amoil’s • Epi-keratome – Epi-LASIK
PRK Video
Case # 10
• 25 yo male• Ocular/Systemic health history unremarkable • No medications
• OD -3.00 DS 20/20
• OS -2.00 -2.50 x 160 20/25-• Pachymetry 500 OD 465 OS • Abnormal Topography
Early Keratoconus
Moderate Keratoconus
Severe Keratoconus
Femto-Intacs Goals
• Delay need for corneal transplant • Increase BCVA
• Improve ability to fit/wear CL’s • Increase UCVA
Intacs
CXL – The Use of Corneal
Collagen Cross-linking
Clinical Studies
• 670 Peer-reviewed literature citations • 96% of eyes show topographic stability • Average flattening 1.7D of max-K • Flattening effect reduced max-K > 54D• Formulation Composition • Method of Application
The Key “Ingredients”
• UVA Dose
• Continuous or Pulsed Illumination
• Consumption by Cross-linking Reactions • Supplemental Oxygen Delivery
Dresden Protocol
UVA dosage 3 mW/cm2 for 30 minutes
0.1% riboflavin
Minimal Corneal Thickness
• 400 microns when using 3.0 mW/cm2 • Stromal haze peaks at 1 month post-op anddecreases significantly between 3 and 12 months1
1. Greenstein SA, Fry KL, Bhatt J, Hersh PS Natural history of corneal haze after collagen crosslinking for keratoconus and corneal ectasia: Scheimpflug and biomicroscopic analysis. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2010 Dec;36(12):2105-14
Intacs with Sequential CXL
• Effects of both treatments are synergistic
– Increased K flattening – Increased BCVA – Increased UCVA
• Kamburoglu G, Ertan A: Intacs Implantation with Sequential CXL Treatment in Postoperative LASIK Ectasia. J Refractive Surg. 2008:24:7:S726-S729
• Chan CC, Sharma M, Wachler BS: Effect of inferior-segment Intac with and without C3-R on keratoconus. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2007;33:75-80.
Demarcation Line at 1Month
10 minute soak with VibeX Rapid, 30mW/cm2,7.2J/cm2, Pulsed [2,1]
Credit: Dr. Miguel Rechichi
Transepithelial Cross-Linking with ParaCel
The corneal epithelium is left in place, and topical anaesthetic applied.
ParaCel is applied to completely
cover the cornea, and soaked for 4 minutes. VibeX Xtra is applied and soaked for an additional 6 minutes. Riboflavin is rinsed from the eye.
45mW/cm2 UVA is applied through the intact epithelium using pulsed Illumination
Advantages of Epi-ON CXL
• Faster visual recovery:
– Return to contact lenses in days
• Less pain
• Avoids risk of delays in epithelial healing • Reduced risk of infection
• Reduced development of corneal haze
William Trattler, MD
Keratoconus Treatment
• Early Keratoconus – progressive topography ortomography minimal reduced BCVA
– CXL as soon as Dx confirmed
• Moderate Keratoconus –progressive topography or tomography moderate reduced BCVA
– Consider CXL / Intacs
• Advanced Keratoconus – pachymetry less than 400 microns