• No results found

Monetary Policy Analysis in Models Without Money

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Monetary Policy Analysis in Models Without Money"

Copied!
41
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

#$ ! "%&'( )"*++,,,-!+"".+,%&'( / &010 ..).. 2 - 3!4 05&6% ) WK !" #$%&'()&$* +&,%-&. %&*/&01&-2 $ 0- 1!$ 3!$*$ $#-&-0 & 40- &3& $

(2)

7 7 7. . 3. ) 7 ! " %&'( ) 500& 8 154 604 %( ) 9, ! !. 32"3* : ; 3. , ) 7 !!!. 3 "7 ) 9 . <7 ") 3 .. 7 <7 3.= : ; ) . 3 . .!!. ) .) 3. .." 9 34 - ) > 2 . ! 9 9 ) . .." 9 . 27 .= : ; . " !. -.3 ? 3 7@ 9 3 !. 9 3- . * ) .. 9 - 2 ! ) 9 3 !. 9 . " 7 ) . . ) )2 ,3 . ! 9 = : 2; 7 " 7 . ) 2 ) 7 " "4 -7 .4 ".... ) ) . A) -. 9 <.- 7A) .!!.. 3. - -)2 " :8 . 154 604 %(; $3 ) 9 3. 3 . ! 2. 7 .-!)4 &15&6 3 * B& (&5 5C% 56(' * -01D3,3

(3)

? ) " (" -" ) )!"( )) ) "" """ ! )" ""))" "" @ "" !""" !!"+,< ""< ) " A)" " > !"(" (!)*" ) ""!+, ""@" ) " &" " B))" ) (! "=&)" !"#$%%%

(4)

("""" ")" " "$() ) "&&"!%?") " (! " !( " " )

/))!!"( (""! )"" B""! ""! )&$(9 <)" %C D9 − """9 " ∆"(!" " & ) ""# $9% D)E)$−∆"%EE)$F%E )G3()H3 $1%∆"Dβ∆"Eα$− %E9 3GβG9(αH3 $2%DµE∆"Eµ$∆" −π%Eµ$− %E9 µ(µH3 B$9%"!&<" ? " ) A) "=()<")II $9::J%( $9:::)%(>$9::0(9:::%( ) " ) <(+ "," $1%"

(5)

A" &)"(! """! 9 <( ( $1333%! = 9 ($2%"" $9::2%"(! A"!−∆"! <" $"A%< πK""" )" )! "µ* (& (! !*F)K)("$F %D3$(!) ! 9 %8 " " ($9%F$2% L "( ")( (∆"(?!)")$)% $6% F"D E E Eη( H3( G3 )!)"( )(∆"( ? !)" ) "" $2%" ( (9 ∆"( )

&'&&--.'&-/& & &

' & 0*'$%%% '& &-

(6)

!" $6% (!)!!! (*$9%&$2%("& )@ &") *)< ? ) <""($6%($9%($1%! "(∆"(!$2%) 8 (""@" < (! """ )$"% ) !( $9:::%( "" " )! & "" 1333" ? ")?"(;$1333% () ) )"")"! <( ) ?(!<") " !( $9%&$2%(!& "()7" "$1%? !)A " (!

(7)

&$9%&$2%( ) C =(($9 & %D3"9 ) "$9%!( ) !($−∆"%D−)K)$2%" $0% −)K)DµEµ$∆" &π%EαC 9 !(! C D3( $J% ∆"Dπ−$$)K)%Eµ%$9Kµ% *( )µ*(−)K)( ) )!(!* )@ π)$%εµ ( !π)εKµ (! " @" " (( ) ))7αβ7"" $1%" """)!(( &)$1%) πDβπEα C (! "$!βG9% C H3 (!( "( !")?"" !&)? " ") " ""@

(8)

(!) ! "@"&"( )?$1333%? (!)")! (!""7" "!$1%(!) ) ! ))(" ) !)π−πM C )A

)A ) """)*$9%F$2%!"!* ( !)*$9%$6%() " $2%"))A ! " A" $1%* ) "" ""!))!"=$9%$6%(! ) "1 " ("" " (" (! "" )""(D9 <=

∞ = 9 β$ (ζ%(! "4<& = ")ζ " @) D9(1(N $O% L$7K7%θ−<F!$−9%D EF$9Eπ%E$9E%)F)Eψ$ (%

'- '2$%%%!&'$%%%#$%%%

5+(+ &

8 && &,' + &' 9&

(9)

BL"&!7K7" @ " =""4<& =" < (<"&<"$%')"" !!!!!$−9%@")' ) "'πD$7K7%−9' )))" (" 9K$9E%(( ψ$ (%" (("" " ) " " ")A " LD$(%(! (" **# $5% $(%DL$7K7%−θ (!3GβG9(θH9(!) ψ$ (%H3ψ$ (%≤3 ?"@ !D9(1(N( !λξ)/"$O%$5%# $:% $ (ζ%−λP9Eψ$ (%QD3 $93% −λ!Eξ$(%D3

$99% −λP9Eψ$ (%QEβλ$9Eπ%D3

$91% −λ$9E%EβλD3

$92% λL$9&θ%7θK$7%θEξLθ7θK$7%θD3

*$O%F$92%@ ((()(7(λ(ξ

(10)

*)( $96% D9 $90% DK7 $9J% ;F<DF$9Eπ%E$9E%)−) $9O% πD$7K7%−9 !(;(<<)" ( 7D7LD$(%( !((7(π A"-" +,-< ! )( $95% 9ED$9E%$9Eπ%( ! ( " & (! " " ""! ) $9:% ∆"Dβ∆"Eα$& %( ! $1%B"D7DL! <)&" !)" !" (( D$9(% $9:%*"" ) ("""(" ( )*)-*$96% )"!))

(11)

(" <(! $9%-! - )A)"=*)? !$:%λ)$91%# $13% %Q ( $ R 9 P % S ( $ 9 9 9 9 + D$9E%β      +R $++ (+ + % 9 % S ( $ 9 9 9 9 !(ψ$ (%!")(ψ(*$13%! ( ($" %?!)")!& =""< $19% D)′E E)′E′( !′"ζ&ζ "*( ) " ψ$ (%(&=""< (! "( $11% LD$ KL% E$;KL%;( !$ KL%$;KL% )$19%$11% $12% LDLE)E)E)$F%E( !D;*$9%( ) AA A""ψ$ (% ")( ") (?!(!) ψ$ (% "( )-( - ! "" ? $1333%(?""!&" ψ#

(12)

$16% ψ$ (%D $ K% (H3 (!" $12% ( $10% )$&%≡$ KL%φ$φEσ%$&%( !φD$9E%$ K%(!σ" ) "/!*

$9′%D)E)$&∆"%EE)$F%E)$&%E

!) " " $16% " ) "O(!$99%$91%( !(" $1J% 9Eψ$ (%D$9E% (""<( $1O% &ψ$ (%D !$16% $15% $ K%D

$1:% DP$%K$9E%QE −$9K$9E%%

! ! !" −9K$9E% !" "93 !)

(! ) $1%($2%($1:%($9′%') (∆"((

(13)

(*$1:%P$15%Q(( )/)) −31' "D6(* 33910$(0" "% K910$15%) $6%$910%D33910"D333931 "φ) $23% φD333931$0%$6%$910%D3136$166%D336:5 " )$10%(σD1$ KL%D3O( $29% $ KL%φ$φEσ%D$3O%$336:5%K$136:5%D339O )#βD3::(αD330(θD0( " "µD30(µD39(µD35 < # $2′% D$9−µ%PµE∆"Eµ$∆"−π%EµCQEµE !∆"(AD9$2%(! ! )" D3:0 E(!!(! (" " " " " A$1%!!# $1′% ∆"D30βP∆"E∆"QEαCE B! ∆" ""< "

(14)

(($9′%($1′%($2′%($6%(" ""<$15%)A $10%$9′% ) )∆"-(! < *" ""( "" ! "! )("" )) " ("""""*( 9!"" (∆"( (( ?"! $9′%(! )< ?)"" ) !)"" ) ( $10%! (1! )31( $ % !"" )(" "" ?(* ) ! −39(−31("D:6 ) D3322 D−5(!)1( 9(! $ %! '& :.';<+ &.'=+>:

(15)

8(( " !() <) !?$1333%(! ") =

!

"#

!" ! " A" (" )" ""((A" ! !!=""$ (( ;$9::O% $9::O%%(!( !+ , )@" " (" !)") !")> $9::6%)*)"( !""""() >$9::O%(II$9::J%((;(;$9::O%( $9::O%(;$9:::%($1333%(?(/<( $9:::%($1333%?( & ) ( " " " " )

(16)

(!T( µ(" $2%("" < <" (") $9::O% " < )) $9:::(""J26&0%( ! )*" "))" /) )!! + , )) " !)7-)!$9:6:% !$9:J9%$9:J0%-!))/$9:61%) " 7@ !"))); !$9:J3%( !"! ).$9:J1% ?()( !+" , * )( """ ) ) "" ) -( ) )) " ))( () +,)) )"$% 3& ? @&$%%%$%%% 37 ( =A B%

(17)

) )""!( ) )(=(<" "" & <" !") > $9:O0%<" @<)$9:O:(""2J1&2% " "" )" (! =)7$9:O5% $9:59%(" <" ") " " ) ? )$!"") ))% >&! !" )*) )"))) $ "%)$ % ") ) !<" ?") ( $9:5J% " (" ? "(!( ""!!" " 8!" "=""U <" = '63- 2 &.' -&' --

(18)

+" , .7"") > $9:O0%)?) !) &> $9:O0%""! ! - $9:59(9:5J%>$9:::(1%() ( " > "" ") ) ) > 8$9:O3%(! ! )>@"#" &> !$ (9:5J(" 965%7) > ! !)! ! "!) ?(""! ! " /! ) >!" !" ) ? ) ""$9%&$2%") (! (" = =( """ (""∆"& ) ! " " )! $21% D)$−∆"%EE $22% ∆"Dβ∆"Eα $26% D$9Eµ%∆"EµE #2 ' &( & + '&' &':C(

(19)

B!"")$1%!$2%!()$9% )&" -$9%-!# $20% DρEε Bε!"ρG9 ?*&&)$ V%<" $2J% DφEφ $2O% ∆"DφEφ !Dφρ∆ρDφρ' *( $25% φD9KP9−ρ−)µ−$α)µρ%K$9−βρ%Q $25)% φD)K$9−)µ% $25 % φDαKP$9−βρ%$9−ρ−)µ%−α)µρQ $25% φDα)K$9−)µ% ?φH3(φG3(φH3(φG3-()∆" "" (" & )" V")!& $26% ""(!( & V $2:% DφEφEφ∆" 2+ -&' + ' " 3& B - &' ' ' &'+ &'

(20)

$63% ∆"DφEφEφ∆"( !<)∆" <""D φρEφ$φEφEφ∆"%∆"DφρEφ$φEφEφ∆"% "φ ) <$25%! $69% φD)µφE)µφEφφ $61% φDβφEαφ φ )( ) * $62% φDβφEα)µφK$9F)µ−φ% ?" ")φD3(! "φ D3( ( V)"$62% )* $66% βφ −P9EβEα)µ−)µβQφE$9−)µ%D3( () $60% φD W 1 %Q X ) 9 $ W 6 P ± !*) $66%( "α(β()(µ(µ) V @ - C'! $%%% $=

(21)

""(µD3" " <" ) 9EβEα)µ!)! $66%µG3µHµ.≡P1βE9EβQK$−)α%(!φ $66%!< 93)!µHµ.(!-! )$%)*(!) @"A <" *)( µHµ.(" )<)&" ∆"? ((+",") )) *)") >!(!µ< = ?!!)" (")& V-()))"-" ")"( ! !) )" ( "!) "10? """(?!!*& ("" V " ( <" $% "(?!() )" ! ( C'' 2 &'- &- -&& +

(22)

< "<="< ) ""! ()$""% "<" " ! ")" "<" ( +<" (, ) <" )( A" " $( V∆"Dφρ%$(& V ∆"DφρEφPφEφEφ∆"Q!φ %" -!" -!! ")(?! ( <" * "" " "( (<" ((∆" ( A")"" < ?( !$9:5J%B"A $9:::(1333%"""""* V >" (<"(!)@2 V &)())&&*" ( !µKµ=&

@& '& ' & - '& /&

""--

*-5(,- 2- &

'!3D' & & &&!3D&' 3 :EE0$%%%& E/%

*/ &-&/ -/*

(23)

)K)""& V() )=)$9:5J(""903&2%B"A$9:::("" 65O&03J'1333(93% <" ! V )""=$% * V)&µ ")> !$)%!)<" !" " ) " ("" V )µA)A)!µ. ! " (& V "µ$(A)A)!µ.% ( <"! )D−3O0(βD3::(α D39(ρD35? µ!) $6J% µ. DP1$3::%E9::QK$3O0%$39%DP9::E9::QK3O0D023O µ023O(!))) 023O!)")µ 023O( ) V!) !µ )!(*()023O2(! "" (∆"(! ?

*/ &-&/ /.' & (!& 3E '' '& C'! $%%%

(24)

$(D93%" $(D93%"!µD023µD029 (() ("" V"" !µ60?(! !µD93µD13()! "*) ""∆" =µ 9313 02 )((µ 53133'0 & V "( & 3GµG023O($66% "<$25% !µD029(!))& V$) V %!""J " ! *$9%"" ( "+,!!*(339 $9%"J "!2!( "(& V V!µD 023<( )"J(!µD53? ) µ ""∆" ") ∆")""!"" "(! /!3D' ! -'' + 3 ."+ & ' 9 " -' =BB!&'

(25)

")336339( ∆""") $ !% (""(!& ) V & V$)))% )" ) V ?"(( V"") ( ")µ !))? ("" !!))A )

$

%& '(

(! * " " "((" " )"&&"<" $9:::% (;(;$9:::%"=*(! µH3$21%F$26%("!)"! $" %!< $ %8 " !" " ! ! µHµ()!! $66%" )!µG3) !"" " ! "" !µG3() " " (!( <"!?!(!!) !")"( V"" ()µ G3

(26)

)+ ,!µG3( " !µHµ()< " " ") !µG3?() "!µG3"")( "( " 8 ")) &)$1333% !µG3") &)( *(" ! π(π(π " ))" 9(1(2 &) V ) ) " () µG3" !µG3) "" " ! µD −9!∆"µD3(( ""#D &"&)" (!"=(B!$9::1%"" "( !−9GµG3 )"! ! )<)" $6O% <DE<E<E=( 52 &' &+ µ >% C'! 9' & & µH%

(27)

!=< )! = !"" <" " $65% <DE<E<E3 (! $6:% <DK$9−−% (E"" 93)!( <"" E∞(!E"" 93)<"" −∞ ED9 )!( " ED9" "" (EH9!!() ") " EG9D3(9−H3 $21%&$26%(!µD3(! $03%      α − 9 3 9       ∆"99 D      W 3 X ) 9       ∆ + + 9 9 " E      9 3 3 9       9 9 $09% <D<E= !<DP∆"Q′(=DPQ′( $01% D 9 3 9 −       α −      W 3 X ) 9 D      + α α )X W X ) 9 ! "9−H3"<"$?−%H3? (! < " $?−%

(28)

−α)µ!αH3)G3(*)! µH3!"" V( ! $9:52("9J3%"+)" ) "", " ") ?µ"(µ )<!&)' $1333%( & )αµE$9&β%µH3 ( ( " "?) ? !)"#$% !"&" &'$% " ()* " )'$%)+ ,(( " "<" ()# )" ! '$%" " "() (" -) & )&*)-))" """" !()" (? "( *(<" "" !

(29)

")) ) ( )!" )(()( $1333)% " ( I(."- -) !")" 9:J0&9::5" """ ) (" "-( ! " - ))))

(30)

(4.(+?!T(,7""?? ( 13&19(1333 ( ( >(+? 7 (, .((Y16$)9::O%(J02&J56 (.(I(+/)7 (,>71333& 339$.1333%( / (( (+!&/V !& /(,>7"("1333 (( (+8"=? &/!! ?(,>7"$ ")1333% (/! .(".;(+(,$9:::%( ""1::&29J ( (.;(;(+ 7 #! I7" (,. /2O$4 )9:::%( 9JJ9&9O3O ZZZZZZZZZZ(ZZZZZZZZZZ(ZZZZZZZZZZ(+7 )# (,>7J661(9::O (;>(+ !&*(,. 95$ ")9:5J%(96O&90O (;>( ""B"A(+/4 (,B) (.>(&B(9:::

(31)

ZZZZZZZZZZ(ZZZZZZZZZZ(/<" (7 7(1333( ((+<" ! ?(,7""??( 13&19(1333 (A(+7 # !8 "U,? 1$)9:::%(219&225 ;((+7 #138(, [52$>9::O%(9&11 ;((+ ?U,>7"( 1333 ;(.;(! !( ?(9:J3 B!(7(+? <" (, .7 933$9::1%(OOJ&533 ?(7(+@ (,>7"(" 1333 ?(7(4/<(&(+ "7 (,?<7) J $)9:::%(02O&0OO? # B)7(.(7?(=(I( I! 7)(9::: .(B;(+7 (, !01$.

(32)

9:J1%(210&256 I(>();I(+/?? (, [51$ "9::J%(6O&OJ I((+7 !L8(, [2:$9:::%(1:O&232 I(7(+;= / <" (,. 4 16$ ") 1333%(9630&9612 /(8 (+ @/!# (, (8/( ?(8L( (9:61 / ()(.(+ B"(, 7 48 (; (9:O1 ()(. (+ / */ &/ (,. 65$"9:5:%(22O&2J5 ((+7 /4 !?7 <" (,. 5$)9:59%( 29:&21: ZZZZZZZZZZ(+8&*<" #" 7" (,. $ 9:52%(92:&9J5 ZZZZZZZZZZ(+ ? ?7(7 /4

(33)

4 (,. 9O$. 9:5J%(920&903 ZZZZZZZZZZZ(+ V)<" (,?<7) J$)9:::%(J19&J2: ? #B )7(.(7?(=(I(I! 7)(9::: ZZZZZZZZZZ(+ T/!? (,.((21$)1333%(5JJ&:33 ZZZZZZZZZZ(+7 #"!B (I(."(, [5J$>1333)%(6:&O: ((!(+7 8"7 (,$9:::%(""90&60 ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ(+8"=? &/ " 7 (,.((29$ 9:::)%(1:J&29J =(B(+#7 T?(,! 7 (I(9::: (!(+4 4(,>7"( 1333 8(.B(+87(,.7 O5$.K 9:O3%(530&596

(34)

7( (+" * <" (, 6J$ ")9:O5%(101&151 7(4(+? )7 (, 9O$.9:6:%(9&1O ZZZZZZZZZZ(+ ?/ # ! (, !09$ 9:J9%(:0&99J ZZZZZZZZZZ((?(7 (1B"!(9:J0 )(..( >(+8"=& !7 (, 9::O( ..)(?7(9::O (.( 7(9:O: (.(> (+@@<" (8" ?(8" ""(,.7 52$"9:O0%(169&106 (/8(+? #?" ?(," !69$.9::O%(9999&996J (.(+4 V7 7 (,& 7) 7 2:$4 )9::2%(9:0&196 ZZZZZZZZZZ(7 7(9::: >( (+? 7 # . U,?7 (;!( 7(9::6 ZZZZZZZZZZZ(+7 &/4 >(,

(35)

& 7) 7 62$4 )9::0%(9&6J ZZZZZZZZZZ(+7 /4?(,1?

(36)

!"#" $! %&'( !"#" $! %&'

(37)

!"#" $! %&' !"#" $! )'*

(38)

#" +!$!'& #" +!$!'&

(39)

#" +!$!' #" +!$!'

(40)

! #" +!$!', #" +!$!'

(41)

-. -. & -. , !/0#" +!$!'& -. , -. , -. & & !/0#" +!$!',

References

Related documents

Abstract The development of additive (‘If only I had done … ’) and subtractive (‘If only I had not done … .’) counterfactual reasoning was examined in children with

Once again, come and meet the fans to promote your brand, present your products, know-how, services, and retain a very captive audience.. WeLcOMe TO L’ÉTAPe dU TOUr

If the monetary authority can affect the rates of taxation on capi- tal, liquidity, and deposits through the use of its policy instruments, then any analysis of optimal, steady

As capital markets have become more integrated and exchange controls have been phased out, the amount of deposits held by EU residents denominated in foreign currency, either held

The toolkit and related resources have been developed to help HIE entities and labs lay the foundation for lab results reporting over Direct by starting with a pilot project to work

According to Eq.(2)&amp;(3), we use BFA to modify the framework of network component analysis (NCA) [1] by considering the mixing matrix A as the connectivity matrix between

The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of Breech Version Acumoxa compared to standard care to correct breech presentation, 13 th Annual Symposium on Complementary Health

The aim of this study was to find out the dietary pattern and health awareness of pregnant Saudi women who suffer from gestational diabetes, and to highlight the relationship