Journal ofNeurology,
Neurosurgery,
andPsYchiatrY 1988,51:909-913
Does
a
"moderate" alcohol intake
damage the
brain?
CLIVE HARPER,*t JILLIAN KRIL,* JOHN DALY:
FromtheDepartmentof Pathology,* TheUniversityofSydney, Sydney, NSW,DepartmentofAnatomical Pathology, RoyalPrinceAlfredHospital,t NSW, Departmentof Neuropathology, Royal PerthHospital,4 Perth, WA, Australia
SUMMARY
A
rangeof volumetric and neurochemical
analyseswerecarriedoutonthe brains of 14"moderate" drinkers. These data
were compared with previous studies from controls andalcoholics.
Volumetric
measurementsconsistently
suggest a loss of cerebral tissue although thedifferences
were notstatistically significant. Changes in
the lipid and water content ofthe white matterwerenoted and the significance of
thesechanges in relationtothe pathogenesisof reversiblebrain
shrinkage caused by alcohol abuse is discussed.
There is aconsiderable volume ofclinical,1 2
neuro-radiological,34
neuropsychological'
andneuropath-ological6- dataconcerning thelongtermeffects of
alcohol abuse on the human central nervous system.
A large proportion ofthese data, particularly with
regard to neuropathological changes, deals with
severechronic alcoholism. Theinterpretation of such
data is difficult becauseof thefrequency ofoccurrence
of attendant disorders such as cirrhosis of the liver
and nutritional deficiency disorders (Wernicke's
encephalopathy)inthe moreadvancedcasesof
alco-holism. Ofparticular interesttothe general publicis
the long term effects ofa moderate alcohol intake
whichmany would equate with "social" drinking.
Materials and methods
Casesfor the studies cited in this paperwereselectedfrom thePerthCity Coroner's Department and the Royal Perth and Royal Prince Alfred Hospitals.,The authors classified thecasesaccording tothefollowing criteria:
1 Controls: teetotalorless than 20 grams of ethanol per day.
2 Moderate: 30-80grams perday.
3 Alcoholic: greaterthan 80 grams perday but without additionalmedicalproblems suchascirrhosisorWernicke's encephalopathy(WE).
4 Alcoholic and cirrhosis: as for (3) pluspathologically confirmed alcoholic cirrhosis(without WE).
5 Alcoholic and WE: as for (3) plus pathologically
confirmedWernicke's encephalopathy (without cirrhosis). (Approximately lOgof ethanol is contained in one public
Addressforreprintrequests:Professor CGHarper,Department of Pathology, TheUniversityofSydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Received 17 November 1987 and in revisedform18February1988.
Accepted7March 1988
house serveof alcohol that is, halfapint (284 ml) of beer, 4floz(110ml)wine, Ifloz(28 ml)spirits.10)
Categorisation of individualcases wasbasedon a
com-pilation of clinical and pathological data. These data included clinicalnotesfrom theteaching hospitalsas aresult of previous admissions, detailed questionnaires on the alcohol intakeprovided by the relatives of the subjects and
acomplete necropsy withmicroscopic examination of tissues including the liver and brain. Ourdefinition of the moderate drinking group (20-80g ofalcohol/day) is not meant to
correlatewith oftquoted clinical definitions of moderateor
social drinking. In the most recent literature figures vary from 30to70grams perday." 12 In the recentreporton
"Is therea safe level ofdaily consumption of alcohol formen
and women?" from the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council, the authorsrecommendthat a
safe daily intake is 40 grams for men and 20 grams for women.'3 From a pathological point of view it is an
extremely difficult groupto categoriseonthe basis of the retrospective collectionof data ondrinkinghabits. Thus it
was necessary to utilise a wider range of alcohol intake (30-80g/day) than is generally quoted in clinical papers. Patients withahistoryorpathological evidence ofa
neuro-logicaldisease, other than those associated withalcoholism,
wereexcludedas were anypatients with evidence of head injury. All the cases in these studies were male. Data on
femalecaseshave been collected but there isaninadequate numberofcases for statisticalanalyses. Separation of data
on a sexbasisisimportantasthereis evidence from human studies andanimal models of alcoholtoxicitythat males and females may beaffecteddifferently.214
Theprocedures andtechniquesutilised indeterminingthe
variousparametershave beendescribedin previous papers relatingtochangesinthe alcoholicgroups.91 -20Samples
from thefrontal,parietalandoccipitalwhite matter of the
righthemispherewere used for the various neurochemical assays. Thewater content wasdeterminedby weighingthe tissue before and afterdryingto a constantweight.2' The
dried residuewasaciddigestedand thesodium and potas-sium concentration determinedby flamephotometry.22The 909
910
lipids were extracted into a chloroform/methanol mixture
andaliquots used foreachanalysis.The totallipidwas
deter-minedbydrying23andthephospholipidand cholesterolby
commercial assaypackages.24Thespecificgravitywas mea-suredon akerosene/bromobenzene gradientcolumn.24 The
water soluble protein was determined by the Biuret
method.26 The methods are all standard laboratory pro-ceduresandeach is accurate andreproducible.2-25
The lefthemispherewasfixed and then sectioned at 3 mm
intervals in the coronal plane and morphometrsc
quan-titationof the volumeof the cerebral cortex, white matter anddiencephalicstructures("basal ganglia") performed.An errorof lessthan2% is involved in thedetermination of these
volumes.26Thepericerebralspace(PICS)wasdeterminedby measuring the intracranial cavity volume with a poly-urethanecast.'6Theerrorin thistechnique is less than 2%.16 Although there is a considerable amount of additional information included in the tabular data theprincipal aim of this paper istoaddress the issue of thepathologicalchanges in the brains ofmenregularlydrinkingbetween 30 and 80
gramsof alcohol perday.The controland alcohol dataare
used forcomparison.
Results
Two hundred and forty cases have been studied to
date but it was necessary to exclude many of these
because the clinicalandpathological informationdid
notenableus to be confidentinclassifying thecases
into oneof thefivegroups as outlined inMaterialsand Methods.
Table 1 summarises the numbers of cases, themean Table 1 Meanage,body weight andheight for eachofthe control, moderate and alcoholic groups
Meanage Bodyheight Body weight
(years) (cm) (kg)
n
mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD)
Control 41 53 (20) 172 (6) 70 (13) Moderate 14 53 (16) 173 (11) 73 (17) Alcoholic 28 55 (14) 171 (9) 70 (17) Alcoholic + cirrhosis 14 58 (8) 173 (8) 69 (8) Alcoholic + WE 13 62* (10) 170 (7) 65 (12) *=p<0-05.
Harper, Kril, Dal} Table3 Cerebralgrey matter,whitematterandbasal ganglia volumeas apercentageof the cerebralhemisphere
volume
Cortex Whitematter Basalganglia*
(%) (%) (%)
mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD)
Control 54-6 (2-6) 40-4 (2-8) 5-0 (0-4) Moderate 55-3 (2-9) 396 (2-8) 5 1 (04) Alcoholic 54-7 (2-6) 39-7 (2-4) 5-0 (0-4) Alcoholic + cirrhosis 55-4 (3-8) 38-6 (44) 5 0 (04) Alcoholic +WE 575f (30) 37-2t (2-8) 5 0 (0-7)
*=Basalganglia is thediencephalic structures including; basal ganglia,thalamus, hypothalamus and amygdala.
t=p<0-01.
ageand mean bodyheight and weight in each ofthe
groups. The mean body heightand weight for each group are notstatistically different. Undernutrition is therefore not responsiblefor the changes found. Loss of brain tissue or brain shrinkage is reflected in a variety of measurableparameters. These include fresh brain weight, cerebellar weight, ventricular volume and ameasurement of thedifference betweenthe brain volume and the intracranial volume; this latter volume has beencalled thepericerebral space (PICS) and is themostaccurateindicatorof brainshrinkage orswelling for anindividual case.16 The mean values of each parameter for each of the five groups arelisted intable 2.Although there is no statistical difference betweenthe moderate and control groupsthere is a trend suggesting loss of cerebral hemisphere tissue with a reduced brain weight, increased ventricular volume and increased PICS value. The mean cere-bellarweightwasthe same in control and moderate groups. It was only significantly reduced in the WE group.
Inorder to localisethe tissue loss to specific regions of thebrain, morphometric quantitation ofthe vol-umesof cerebral cortex, white matter and basal
gan-gliawerecarried out.These are shown in table 3. As
might be anticipated there is no significant loss of
tissue fromanyofthe regions in the moderate group
but the trend appears to followthe alcoholic groups
Table 2 Brain andcerebellarweight, ventricularvolume andpericerebral space for each oftheGroups Fresh brainweight(g) Cerebellarweight(g) Ventricularvolume(%) PICS* (%)
mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD)
Control 1438 (102) 186 (15) 1-29 (0-7) 7-3 (39)
Moderate 1415 (129) 187 (20) 1-65 (0-8) 9-8 (44)
Alcoholic 1352$ (144) 177 (13) 2-40$ (1-3) 11-0$ (5-8)
Alcoholic + cirrhosis 1377 (140) 176 (15) 2.96 $ (08) 13-6§ (29)
Alcoholic +WE 1310§ (147) 165T (12) 2-34$ (0-6) 159§ (5-8)
*PICS=Pericerebralspace aspercentageof intracranialspace. t=p<005.
t=p<0-01.
Table4 Meanpercentage water, total lipid, cholesterol andphospholipid content foreachgroup
Watercontent(%) Total lipid (% D W) Cholesterol(umol/gD W) Phospholipid
(,nol/g
DW)mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD)
Control 70 4 (1-4) 18 3 (1-3) 100-8 (11-6) 25-7 (2 8) Moderate 696 (17) 19.2* (14) 1020 (109) 268 (11) Alcoholic 70 6 (14) 18 3 (1 9) 1011 (14.9) 25 1 (2 5) Alcoholic+ cirrhosis 71 4 (1 9) 18 2 (1 1) 94-8 (8-6) 23 7 (2.1) Alcoholic + WE 72-1 (30) 173 (20) 905 (84) 246 (2.1) DW =dry weight. *=p<0-05.
Table5 Specificgravity,electrolyte concentration and water soluble proteincontent ofthewhitematter foreachgroup
Sodium Potassium
Specific gravity (mEqIlOOgdryweight) Protein(mg/g WW)
mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD) mean (SD)
Control 10404 (0-002) 17-6 (2-7) 20-8 (1.5) 22 8 (2 3) Moderate 1-0406 (0-003) 15-7 (2-3) 19.7* (1-5) 22 8 (2 8) Alcoholic 10411 (0002) 17 3 (3-0) 19.7* (1-5) 23 2 (24) Alcoholic +cirrhosis 1.0386* (0002) 18 5 (3-2) 177t (1-7) 198t (24) Alcoholic +WE 1.0384* (0002) 17 7 (0-7) 18.9* (2-7) 22 7 (1.8) WW=wet weight. *=p < 0-05. t=p<0 01. $=p<0-001.
inwhichithasbeenpreviouslyshown that the lossof
tissue islargelyfrom the whitematter.7
Topursuethefindingofareductioninthe volume
ofthewhite matter,blocksweretaken from the fresh
hemisphere for neurochemical evaluation. Water,
lipidandproteincontent, specific gravityand
electro-lyteconcentrationweredetermined ineachcase. The
mean results for each group ofcases are shown in
tables 4 and 5. Changes are relatively small in the
moderategroup but thepoint of interest is thatthe
waterandlipid profilesappear to move in theopposite
direction to those ofthe alcoholic groups(table
6).
Thefigure demonstrates, graphically, thechangesin
water andlipidcontentwithincreasingalcohol intake.
The significance values forthese results arelistedin
table4. Itshouldbenotedthatwehave studied
only
a relatively small number of"moderate" cases and
these
preliminary
results must be followed up by alarger study in order to confirm or refute these findings.
Table6 Patternsof changein the water and lipid content
ofthecerebral whitematter
Water
content Phospholipid Cholesterol
Normalmaturation * * *
Ageing *
Moderate drinkers * *
Alcoholics *
Alcoholtoxicitymodels NA NA *
Walleriandegeneration *
Multiplesclerosis * NA =data notavailable.
73 72 c Go c 71 8 .5 i 70 69 68 21 - 20-C c 8 19-a a. I--a 18 -17 -16
,/0
J0' 0% N1. '0o <209 30-809 >809 +Cir +WE Control Mod Alcoholic*...alcoholicintake
Fig Changesinlipidand water contentofthe white matter with increasingintakeofalcohol.
911 Doesa "ttio(lerate"alt-oholintake
(laniage
the braiii?912
Theelectrolyte concentration (sodium and
potas-sium) of the white matter, the specific gravity and
watersoluble proteincontentwerealsodetermined in
allcases. Themean resultsare shown in table 5. The
potassium value in themoderategroupissignificantly
different from the control group. The reduction in
potassium concentration issimilartothatseeninthe
alcoholic groups. The protein content and specific gravity are unchanged from those of the control group.
Discussion
Brainshrinkage, reduced whitemattervolume, loss of
neurons in the frontal lobes and cerebellar vermis
have been previously documented in the alcoholic groups.7920 Theinterest in this study wasto try to
identify changes in the brains ofagroupofcaseswho
could be defined as moderate or perhaps even
"social" drinkers. A previous CT study of "social" drinkers has shown a high proportion to have significant brain shrinkage.4 The results of these studiescould be saidtobe inconclusive becausemost
of thechanges are not statistically significant.
How-ever,there isaconsistent trend in that all volumes and
weightssuggestalossof cerebral tissue. Moreover in
the context of the brain shrinkage measurements
which are already well documented in alcoholics720
and the fact that there appears to be a pattern of severity of changes within the alcoholicgroups(those withcirrhosisorWE) (seetable 2), it isinterestingto note that the moderate drinkers seem tofit between the controls and the medically uncomplicated alco-holicgroup.Howeverthe neurochemical studies show adifferent trend. Thewater contentrisesand thelipid
contentfalls in the alcoholicgroupswhereasthewater
content appearsto fall and the lipidcontent rises in the moderate group (see figure and table 6). How
couldthis beexplainedonanatomicalorpathological
grounds? Itis obvious that foragiven sample of brain
tissue the lipid and water content should move in
concert. Whitematteriscomposed of approximately 70% water, 20% lipids and 10% protein.27 Asmost
of the lipid and protein is combined to form
mem-branes(myelininparticular), if there isanincrease in
lipidcontentthere will beadecrease inwatercontent
and vice versa. Neurochemical studies of the white
matterfrom demyelinating lesions showanincreasein
watercontentandadecreaseinlipidcontent.28 How-ever, themagnitude of the changes is much greater
than in the moderate drinkers. A similar pattern is
seen in Wallerian degeneration29 although most of these studies have utilised experimental models. During maturation of the brain with active myelination thepatterns are reversed: adecrease in
the water content and an increase in the lipid
con-Harper,
Kril,
Dalb'
tent.27Thelipidandwaterchangesnoted in the
mod-erate and uncomplicated alcoholic groups may, therefore, be an indication of some subtle structural change in the white matter.
Few otherstudies ofthe effects of chronic alcohol abuse on the structurallipids in the human brain have been carried out. Lesch and hiscolleagues30 studied
eight cases with hepatocerebral degeneration; six of
these cases were alcoholics. They showed asignificant loss of phospholipids and cholesterol in the myelin
rich areas of the brain. In relatively acute alcohol toxicity animal models it has been shown that the contentof oneof the membrane lipids, cholesterol, is
increased.3'
Manyclinical'andneuroradiological3 studies have
shown that clinical deficits and brain shrinkage are reversible in a proportion of alcoholics following a prolonged period (months) of abstinence from
alcohol. Theseimprovements are more evident in the younger patients with shorter drinking histories. There is to date, no proven pathological explanation for this reversible brain damage. However, it can be stated categorically that neuronal loss is not revers-ible.Therefore we must look elsewhereforan expla-nation. In viewofourfindings ofchanges in the white matter in the alcoholic groupsandin theknowledge
thatthere is a constant turnover ofmyelin andthat
remyelination can occur to a limited extent in the
CNS, further studies of myelin structure and metabo-lism should becarriedout.There may well prove to be twodifferentpathological changesinthe whitematter as aresult ofalcohol abuse: anirreversiblecomponent due to neuronal death and subsequent Wallerian
degeneration,and a reversiblecomponent which may
relate to subtle structural changes which cannot be
identified by normal subjective histological
exam-ination of human material. The basic cause of the
damagehas also to beelucidatedasthose cases with
the most severe brain shrinkage usually have addi-tional disorders such as WE and/orcirrhosis of the
liver. These may well play an important part in the
degenerative processes although the presence of
abnormalities in the "alcoholic" group who had
neitherWEnorcirrhosis,suggeststhat thealcohol per
seprobably plays a significant role. Animal models of alcohol toxicity and thiamine deficiency in various combinationsmay prove useful inclarifyingsome of theseissues.
Conclusions
Theresults of thevolumetricstudies of themoderate group could be said to be inconclusivebecause most of thechangesare notsignificantly different from con-trols. However, in the context of the brainshrinkage measurementsalready documented in alcoholics and
Does a "moderate" alcohol intakedamage thebrain? the fact that thereappears to be a grading of cerebral shrinkage within the alcoholic group (those with cir-rhosis orWernicke'sencephalopathy), results of mod-erate drinkers seem to fit between the controls and alcoholics. Sincemoderate drinkers are more likely to have reversible changes than severe chronic alco-holics, the differences noted in the water and lipid profiles of the whitematter may be an indication of a subtle structural change which can not be identified by the usual subjective histological examination of human material. Thus there may be two different pathological changes in the white matter as a result of alcohol abuse: anirreversiblecomponent due to neu-ronal death and subsequent Wallerian degeneration and a reversible component as noted above. This research was supported by a grant from the Australian Associated Brewers and the N.H. & M.R.C. (No. 87/0564). The authors thank Ms Joy Gillieswhoprepared this manuscript.
References
I Ron MA.The alcoholic brain: CTscanandpsychologicalfinding Psvchol Med1983;monograph supplNo3:1-33.
2 LishmanWA,JacobsonRR,AckerC. Braindamagein alcohol-ism: current concepts Acia Med Scand 1987;222;suppl 717: 5-17.
3 Carlen PL,WortzmanG, Holgate RC,WilkinsonDA, Rankin
JG.Reversible cerebralatrophyinrecentlyabstinent chronic
alcoholicsmeasuredbycomputed tomographicscans.Science
1978;200:1076-8.
4Cala LA,Jones B, Mastaglia FL,WileyB. Brainatrophyand
intellectual impairmentinheavydrinkers: aclinical, psycho-metric andcomputerisedtomography study. AustNZ JMed 1978;8:147-53.
5 WalshKW.Alcohol related braindamage:Anhypothesis.Aust
Ale/DrugRev1983;2:1-84.
6 Harper CG.Neuropathologyof braindamagecausedbyalcohol. MedJ Aust 1982;2:277-82.
7 Harper CG,KrilJJ, HollowayRL. Brainshrinkageinchronic
alcoholics: apathologicalstudy.BrMedJ1985;290:501-4. 8 Harper C, Kril J. Pathological changes in alcoholic brain
shrinkage.Med J Aust1986;144:3-4.
9 HarperC, KrilJ,DalyJ. Arewedrinkingour neuronesaway?
BrMedJ1987;294:534-6.
10 Paton A, SaundersJB. ABC of alcohol. Br MedJ 1981;283: 1248-50.
11 Lelbach WK.(1974). OrganicPathologyrelatedtovolume and patterns ofalcoholuse.In:GibbinsRJ,etal(eds). Research
913
Advances in Drug and Alcohol Problems. Volume1.New York. JohnWileyand Sons.
12 AustralianBureau of Statistics. Alcohol and Tobacco
Consump-tion Patterns (Catalogue No 4312.0). Canberra. Australian
Bureauof Statistics, 1977.
13 PolsRG,Hawks DV. Is there asafelevel ofdailyconsumptionof alcohol for men and women? National Health & Medical Research Council Report for Health Care Committee, Canberra, 1986.
14 HayDA, Cummins JE.Geneticdependence of alcohol related disease: animal models. Aust NZ J Med1981;11:148-53.
15 HarperCG, Blumbergs PC. Brain weights in alcoholics. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1982;45:838-40.
16 Harper C, Kril J, Raven D, Jones N. Intracranial cavity
volumes-a new method and its potential applications.
Neuro-patholAppINeurobiol1984;10:25-32.
17 Harper CG, Kril JJ, Daly JM. Brain shrinkage in alcoholics is notcausedby achangein hydration: a pathological study.
JNeurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1988;51:124-7.
18 HarperCG,Kril JJ, Daly JM. The specific gravity of the brainsof alcoholic and control patients: a pathological study. Br J Addict1987;82:1349-54.
19 Phillips SC,HarperCG,Kril J. A quantitative histologicalstudy
of the cerebellar vermis in alcoholic patients. Brain1987;110:
301-14.
20 Harper C, Kril J. Brain atrophy in chronic alcoholic patients: a quantitative pathological study. J Neurol Neurosurg
Ps'vhiatrs}
1985;45:211-7.21 YatesAJ, ThelmoW, PappiusHM.Postmortem changesin the
chemistryandhistologyof normal and edematous brains. Am JPathol1975;79:555-64.
22 ShawDM, Frizel D, CampsFE,WhiteS. Brainelectrolytes in depressive and alcoholic suicides. Br J Psychiatris 1969;
115:69-79.
23 FolchJ,Lees M,Stanley GHS.Asimple methodfortheisolation andpurification oftotallipidsfrom animal tissue. J Biol Chem
1957;226:497-509.
24 Marmarou A, Poll W,ShulmanK.Bhabavon H. A simple gravi-metric technique for measurement of cerebral oedema. JNeurosurg 1978;49:530-7.
25 GornallAG,BardawillCJ,David MM. Determinationofserum
proteinsbytheBiuretreaction. J BiolChem1949;177:751.
26 AherneWA,Dunnill MS.(1982)MorphometrY.London.Edward Arnold.
27O'Brien JS, Sampson EL. Lipid composition of the normal human brain: grey matter, white matter andmyelin. JLipid
Res1965;6:537-44.
28 Davison AN,Wajda M. Cerebral lipids in MultipleSclerosis.
JNeurochem1962;9:427-32.
29Cumings JN. (1965) Cerebral lipid biochemistry in the de-myelinations. In: Cumings JN, Kremer MFA. (eds) "Bio-chemical Aspectsof Neurological Disease"Philadelphia,Davis Co. 229-51.
30 Lesch P, Schmidt E, Schmidt FW. Effects of chronic alcohol abuse onthe structurallipidsinthe human brain. Z Klin Chem KlinBiochem 1972;10:410-5.
31 Chin JH,Goldstein DB. Membrane-disordering actionof eth-anol. Variation withmembrane cholesterol content anddepth