10/10/2009
NAVFAC SE
Naval Facilities Engineering Command
Design Build Program
Douglas Dangerfield. PE
Chief Engineer
NAVFAC Southeast
10/10/2009
2
NAVFAC SE
NAVFAC Facilities Engineering
Command (FEC) Structure
Japan/
Far East
Guam
Europe/SWA
Hawaii
Caribbean
NAVFAC MW
NAVFAC Wash
NAVFAC Mid-Lant
NAVFAC FE
10 ECH IV Commands
NAVFAC Marianas
NAVFAC Hawaii
NAVFAC SW
NAVFAC EU & SWA
NAVFAC NW
10/10/2009
3
NAVFAC SE
NAVFAC Southeast AOR
Amarillo Lubbock Abilene El Paso San Antonio Austin Houston Galveston Laredo Harlingen Orange Tyler Wichita Falls Baton Rouge Jackson Montgomery Huntsville Tuscaloosa Rome Columbus Mobile Tallahassee Marietta Tampa St. Petersburg Columbia Greenville Augusta Savannah
West Palm Beach
Ft. Lauderdale Miami
Cape Canaveral Dallas/Ft. Worth
© Isnor’s Functional Maps
IPT South Central
IPT Gulf Coast
IPT South Atlantic
Legend
Austin
Reserve Centers
Ingleside
Ingleside
New Orleans
New Orleans
Key West
Key West
Corpus Christi
Corpus Christi
Kingsville
Kingsville
Andros
Andros
GTMO
GTMO
Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Mayport
Mayport
Blount Island
Blount Island
Jacksonville
Jacksonville
Stennis
Stennis
Kings Bay
Kings Bay
Orlando
Orlando
Pensacola
Pensacola
Milton
Milton
Panama City
Panama City
Keesler
Keesler
Gulfport
Gulfport
Charleston
Charleston
Beaufort
Beaufort
Sumter
Sumter
Atlanta
Atlanta
Meridian
Meridian
Shreveport
Shreveport
Albany
Albany
Fort Worth
Fort Worth
Athens
Athens
Pascagoula
Pascagoula
IPT South Central
IPT South Central
10/10/2009
4
NAVFAC SE
Northwest,
$241,052
MidWest,
$7,957
Washington,
$105,240
FarEast, $0
Hawaii,
$49,207
Marianas,
$947,042
Mid-Atlantic,
$1,143,706
Southwest,
$1,184,332
Southeast,
$202,176
PROGRAMS BY FEC
10/10/2009
5
NAVFAC SE
MILCON
OTHER APPROPIATIONS
MCON/MCNR
PNO APPROP Activity Name UIC INSTALLATION AUTH AMT STRATEGY
105 MCNR NAS CORPUS CHRISTI TX N00216 PARACHUTE & SURVIVAL EQUIPMENT SHOP $2,210,000 Design Build - One Step 196 MCNR HDQTRS 4TH MAW NEW ORLEANS LA M67021 VEHICLE MAINTENANCE FACILITY $4,240,000 Design Build - 8A MACC 006 MCON MCSF BLOUNT ISLAND M67695 PORT OPERATIONS FACILITY $3,760,000 Design Build - MACC 092 MCON NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 MARITIME PRE-POSITIONING FLEET (MPF) SITE $920,000 Design Bid Build - 8A MACC 187 MCON NAVSTA MAYPORT FL N60201 CHANNEL DREDGING $46,303,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 273 MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 T-6B JPATS TRAINING OPS PARALOFT FACILITY $4,120,000 Design Build - MACC 360 MCON MCRD/BEAUFORT PI SC M00263 ELECTRICAL SUBSTATION AND SYSTEM UPGRADE $6,972,000 Design Build - Two Step 437 MCON NAS CORPUS CHRISTI TX N00216 OPERATIONAL FACILITIES FOR T-6, GOLIAD OLF $19,764,000 Design Build - Two Step 441 MCON MCAS BEAUFORT SC M60169 WIDE BODY AIRCRAFT FUEL LANE $1,280,000 Design Bid Build - 8A MACC 630 MCON NAS JACKSONVILLE FL N00207 P-8A (MMA) FACILITIES MODIFICATION $5,917,000 Design Build - MACC 724 MCON NAS PENSACOLA FL N00204 CORRY 'A' SCHOOL BACHELOR ENLISTED QUARTERS $22,950,000 Design Build - Two Step 777 MCON NAVSTA MAYPORT FL N60201 WHARF CHARLIE REPLACEMENT $29,682,000 Design Build - Two Step 782 MCON NAS PENSACOLA FL N00204 SIMULATOR ADDITION FOR UMFO PROGRAM $3,211,000 Design Build - 8A Sole Source 902F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 F-35 HYDRANT REFUELING SYS, PH 1 (EGLIN AFB) $6,208,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 905F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 F-35 JP8 WEST SIDE BULK TANK UPGRADES (EGLIN AFB) $621,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 906F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 POL OPERATIONS FACILITY (EGLIN AFB) $2,056,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 907F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 F-35 JP8 FLIGHTLINE FILLSTANDS (EGLIN AFB) $3,492,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 909F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 F-35 PARALLEL TAXIWAY LADDER (EGLIN AFB) $931,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 918F MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 F-35 A/C PARKING APRON (EGLIN AFB) $11,252,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 925 MCON NAS WHITING FLD MILTON FL N60508 BEQ EOD SCHOOL, PHASE 2 $26,287,000 Design Build
$202,176,000
PNO APPROP Activity Name UIC INSTALLATION AUTH AMT STRATEGY
300V BRAC V NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 CONSOLIDATED BRIG ADDITION $9,790,000 Design Build - Two Step 301V BRAC V NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 SPAWAR DATA CENTER $9,670,000 Design Build - Two Step 521 DLA NAVSTA GUANTANAMO BAY N60514 REPLACE FUEL STORAGE TANK $12,500,000 Design Bid Build 0092 MCA NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 (ARMY)-DEPLOYMENT STAGING AREA PAVING, FENCING AND LIGHTING $4,100,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 1492 MCA NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 (ARMY)-RAILROAD TRACKS $12,000,000 Design Bid Build 1493 MCA NAVAL WEAPONS STATION CHASN N69214 (ARMY)-EXPAND FINGER PIER AND CONSTRUCT RAMPS $5,700,000 Design Bid Build - MACC 2557 MCA TAC SHAW AFB SUMTER SC J28100 HEADQUARTERS BUILDING, THIRD US ARMY-Incr 2 $55,000,000 Design Build - Incr 2 NULL MCAF BARKSDALE AFB LA J67100 Military working Dog Kennel $1,700,000 Design Build - 8A Sole Source 0003 MCAFR AFI KEESLER AFB BILOXI MS J25100 AERIAL PORT FACILITY $9,800,000 Design Bid Build - MACC
120,260,000 $
10/10/2009
6
NAVFAC SE
NAVFAC & Design Build
•
Single Source Accountability - Risk
•
Fast delivery (award to occupancy)
•
Cost - performance driven solutions offer savings;
less cost growth after award
•
Innovation – allow DB to solve the problem;
multiple solutions to choose from; doesn’t restrict
solution to preconceived notion
•
Allows qualifying of contractors
•
Administration – cost less to administer contract
*Why it’s our default acquisition strategy*
(DB=75%;DBB=25%)
10/10/2009
7
NAVFAC SE
Design Build - Concerns
•
Minimize Cost of Proposals
–
Multiple Award Construction Contracts
–
Project Selection
–
Limit Technical Proposal Requirements
•
New Sustainable Design Requirements
–
More technical analysis req
’
d upfront
•
Clients who want to maintain total control
10/10/2009
8
NAVFAC SE
Contractor:
Haskell Construction
•
61,000 SF Administration Bldg
•
Designed to LEED- NC “Certified” Level by Design-Builder
•
Project is currently registered with USGBC to obtain Certification
•
Certification being pursued by NAVFAC “in-house” team
•
Raised Access Flooring; HVAC, Power, Data
•
Grid-distributed power/communications
•
Demountable Office Partitions, flexibility for future renovations
•
Underfloor Air Distribution; maintain good IAQ, highly efficient
ventilation, high level of thermal comfort
•
Water efficient landscaping
•
Day lighting of interior spaces
NAVFAC SE Headquarters, NAS
Jacksonville
10/10/2009
9
NAVFAC SE
P-8 (MMA) Hangar, NAS Jacksonville FL
Contractor: Mortenson Construction / HNTB
•
277,000 SF w/1,126,000 SF of parking apron
•
One of the largest hangars in the Navy
•
Will initially house P-3’s and C-130’s until MMA;s (P-8’s) replace P-3’s
•
Vertical lift fabric doors
10/10/2009
10
NAVFAC SE
BIM Overview
• BIM = Building Information Modeling (3D Modeling)
– Process of generating and managing building data during the life
cycle
– Covers geometry, spatial relationships, geographic information,
quantities and properties of building components
– Facilitates exchange and interoperability of information in digital
format
• NAVFAC BIM Solution for Design and Construction MUST be useable by
Public Works for Operations and Maintenance, and feedback to Asset
Management for full life-cycle functionality.
• Building Information Model (BIM) Roadmap
– Tri-Service CAD/BIM Technology Center assisting development
– Lessons learned from USACE BIM Roadmap experiences
10/10/2009
11
NAVFAC SE
Early Contractor Involvement
CM @ Risk =
Early Contractor Involvement (ECI)
Rule of Thumb: Use ECI when DB and DBB won’t work
Design-Bid-Build:
If you have time to develop
detailed design and you want to get it at the lowest
price, use DBB (actually, the FAR demands it)
Design-Build:
If you know what you want (by at least
the 35% design), you want it fast, and you’re willing
to take what is delivered in the end, use DB
ECI:
If you don’t know what you want and you need it
fast, ECI might be best
10/10/2009
12
NAVFAC SE
Technical Evaluation Factors
•
Corporate Experience and Qualifications
–
Relevant Corporate Experience Narratives (minimum of two; maximum of five)
–
Key Personnel Resumes (Design PM, Mechanical Engineer, Architect, Construction
PM & Construction Superintendent). Design PM & Construction PM must have
Design Build Experience. LEED Accreditation w/Design Build Experience a plus.
•
Past Performance
–
Awards, letters of commendation, or evaluations for the
same
projects submitted
under Corporate Experience.
Must
provide copy of award, letter or evaluation.
•
Safety
–
Safety Awards for past 5 yrs
–
Safety Citations for past 5 yrs w/explanation
–
Experience Modification Rate (EMR) from insurance agent
–
If EMR unavailable, explain why, and submit OSHA DART rate for past 5 yrs
•
Conceptual Drawings
–
Floor Plan, Elevations, Site Plan, Bldg Perspective, Space Tabulation
•
Design Build to Budget
–
If necessary, exercise Feature and/or Square Footage Reductions based on RFP
direction to ensure Proposed Price is within Budget
•
Sustainable Design
–
Scorecard to meet USGBC LEED Silver Requirement
–
EPact 2005 Energy Efficiency Narrative
–
Whole Bldg Energy Simulation per Option 1 of LEED Reference Manual
10/10/2009
13
NAVFAC SE
3
rd
Army Command and Control Facility
Shaw AFB
Contractor: Caddell Construction / LS3P
•
321,230 GSF
•
Two story
•
Planned occupancy: 1477
•
Operation of facility: 24 hours / day – 7 days / week
•
Steel Frame; Precast panel exterior; TPO roof
•
LEED Silver
10/10/2009
14
NAVFAC SE
3
rd
Army Command and Control Facility
Shaw AFB
Contractor:
Caddell Construction / LS3P
•
Essentially square footprint
•
Covered entry portico accents the primary entries
•
Central energy plant and service access at the back portion of the building
•
Interior is organized by a framework of sky lighted atria which provide for
circulation and natural light.
•
The atria are to provide a “front door” to each department
•
There are six passenger elevators plus 1 freight elevator the roof)
10/10/2009
15
NAVFAC SE
3
rd
Army Command and Control Facility
10/10/2009
16
NAVFAC SE
