Not. R. Astron. So c. 000 , 1{7 (2000) Prin ted 30 Jan uary 2002 (MN L A T E Xs t yle le v1.4) Searc h for the Optical/Infrared Coun terpart of the X-ra y Pulsar 1E 1841 045 ? Mereghetti, 1 R.P . Mignani, 2 S. Co vino, 3 S. Chat y , 4 G.L. Israel, 5 ; R. Neuh auser, Plana, 7 L. Stella. 5 ; di Fisic a Cosmic a del C.N.R., Via Bassini 15, I-20133 Milano, Italy; sandr [email protected] Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 2, D-85748 Gar ching b ei Munchen, Germany Astr onomic o d i Mer ate, v. E. Bianchi 46, I-22055 Mer ate (LC), Italy artment of Physics and Astr onomy, The Op en University, Walton Hal l, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, Unite d Kingdom Astr onomic od i R oma, Via F r asc ati 23, I-00040 Montep orzio Catone (R oma), Italy; Extr aterr estrische Physik, D-85740 Gar ching, Germany Astr on omic o Nacional, Ap artado Postal 877,22800 Ensenada, B.C., M exic o d t o ICRA. 2000 . Receiv ed 2000 ; i n original form ABSTRA CT W eh a v e carried out a searc h for the optical and infrared coun terpart of Anomalous X{ra y Pulsar 1E 1841 045 , whic h i s l o cated at the cen ter of the p erno v a remnan t Kes 73. W e presen t the rst deep optical and infrared images the eld of 1E 1841 0 4 5 ,a sw ell as optical sp ectroscop y results that exclude brigh test ob jects in the error circle as p ossible coun terparts. A few of the more red-dened ob jects in this region can b e considered as particularly in teresting candidates, in consideration of the distance and absorption exp ected from the asso ciation with Kes 73. The strong in terstellar absorption in the direction of the source do es not allo to completely exclude the presence of main sequence massiv e companions. Key w ords: Pulsar: individual: 1E 1841 045{ X{ra ys: stars. INTR ODUCTION X-ra y source 1E 1841 045 w as disco v ered with the Ein-Observ atory in 1979 (Kriss et al. 1985) at the cen ter the sup erno v a remnan t Kes 73 (G27.4+0.0), and studied more detail with R OSA T (Helfand et al. 1994). Kes 73 is oung sup erno v a remnan t that sho ws a shell morphology the radio band, without an y evidence for a cen tral syn-nebula originating from a rotation-p o w ered pulsar. most lik ely in terpretation for 1E 1841 045, on the ba-of these earlier observ ations, w as that of an accretion w ered system. Recen t data obtained with ASCA led to the disco v ery a p erio dicit y a t 11.8 s and a p erio d deriv ativ e o f41 0 11 1 (V asish t & Gotthelf 1997). The corresp onding c har-age =P/2 _ P 4,700 yr is consisten t with that of 73, th us strengh tening the asso ciation. The X{ra y s p ec-of 1E 1841 045 is v ery soft (p o w er la w photon index 3.4), and its luminosit y has remained remark ably constan t Based on observ ations collected at the Europ ean Southern Ob-atory , L a Silla, Chile. at a lev el of 31 0 35 erg s 1 (for d=7 kp c) during all the serv ations carried out up to no w (Gotthelf, V asish t & Dotani 1999). On the basis of these observ ational prop erties, 1E 1841 045 can b e included in the class of Anomalous X{ra y Pulsars (AXPs, Mereghetti & Stella 1995). These pulsars, while clearly not p o w ered b y the rotational energy losses, are c haracterized b y soft sp ectra, p erio ds in a nar-ro w range (6 to 12 s), secular spin do wn, absence of massiv companions, no radio emission (see Mereghetti 2000 for review). Three of the six kno wn AXPs are asso ciated to p erno v a remnan ts (SNRs). The AXPs are clearly v ery di eren t from the more com-mon accreting X{ra y pulsars usually found in High Mass X{ra y Binaries, and their nature is still uncertain. Sev eral mo dels (in v olvin g b oth binary systems and isolated ob jects) ha v e b een prop osed, but up to no w the only reasonably w established fact is that AXPs are y et another manifestation of neutron stars. Here w e rep ort a study of the p ossible coun terparts 1E 1841 045 based on deep optical and infrared observ tions of its small error region. 2000 RAS
Date Tel. Instrument Filter Exp. Seeing 24.06.1993 NTT EMMI V 10min 1: 00 2 24.06.1993 NTT EMMI R 10min 1: 00 0 06.08.1997 2.2m EFOSC2 B 10min 1: 00 5 14.09.1999 3.6m EFOSC2 r 15min 1: 00 1 25.07.1999 NTT SOFI J 1min 0: 00 7 25.07.1999 NTT SOFI K s 1min 0: 00 7 12.04.2000 OAN LaRUCA B 15min 1:
00 5 12.04.2000 OAN LaRUCA V 5min 1:
00 5 12.04.2000 OAN LaRUCA R 6min 1:
00 5
Table 1. Summary of the imaging observations of the 1E1841 045 eld.Columnslisttheobservingep o ch,telescop e, imaginginstrument, lter,totalexp osuretimeandaverageseeing conditionsduringeachobservation.
2 OBSERVATIONS
Severalobservationsofthe eld of1E 1841 045 were car-ried out using di erent Europ ean Southern Observatory (ESO)telescop esatLaSillafrom1993to1999.Table1gives a log ofthe observations that are describ ed in moredetail inthefollowing subsections.
2.1 Optical Imaging
ImagesintheV andR lterswereobtained withthe3.5m NTT in June 1993, using the rst generation of the ESO MultiMo deInstrument(EMMI)op eratedinimagingmo de withthered-sensitive CCD.Thedetector,a20482048 Lo-ralCCD,hada eldofview(f.o.v.)of10
0 10 0 withapixel sizeof0: 00 35.
The eld of 1E1841 045 was observedin the Bessel B lter using EFOSC2at theESO/MPG 2.2minAugust 1997. We used the 20482048 Loral chip (ESO CCD No. 40)withapixelscale of0:
00
262p erpixel.
Finally, an image in the Gunn r lter was taken with theEFOSC2instrumentonthe3.6mtelescop einSeptemb er 1999.Weusedthe20482048Loral/Lesser(ESOCCDNo. 40)witha22 rebinningwhichresulted in apixel scale of 0:
00
31p erpixel.
All the data were reduced using standard pro cedures for bias subtraction, at{ eld correction and cosmic rays cleaning. Pro le tting photometry was carried out with the DAOPHOTI I package (Stetson 1987) as implemented inESO{MIDAS98NOVversion.Calibrationwasp erformed by standardstars observed, as faras p ossible, inthe same condition of the scienti c frame. While the relative mag-nitude values from these data are quite accurate (0.01{ 0.02 mag),it wasnot p ossible toderive aprecise absolute calibration sincemost of theobservations werecarried out in non-photometric conditions. Therefore, in order to ob-tain theabsolutecalibration, wereobservedthe eldinthe B,V and R lters under photometric conditions usingthe 1.5mtelescop eoftheObservatorioAstronomicoNacionalat
Figure3.Fluxcalibratedsp ectraforcandidatesA(lowerline) andBtakenatthe1.5mDanishtelescop e.
SanPedroMartir (BajaCalifornia, Mexico)equipp edwith a10241024CCDdetectorwithapixel scaleof0:
00 24p er pixel.Thisallowedtoobtaintheresultssummarizedin Ta-ble2.TheGunn rphotometry wascalibrated by means of standardstarobservedintheRbandandtheaverage rela-tionsb etweenuvgrandUBVRsystems(Kent1985).
2.2 InfraredImaging
Near{infrared observations have b een carried out at the NTTusingSOFI.TheSOFIinstrumentisaninfraredsp ec-trographand imagingcamera withaHgCdTe10241024 arrayandapixelsizeof18.5m.Thecamerawasop erated withaf.o.v.of4:
0 944:
0
94andacorresp onding pixel scale of 0:
00
292. Images have b een taken through the wide-band J ( = 1:247m; = 0:290m) and K
s
( = 2:162m; = 0:275m) lters with exp osure times of 60 s. The typicalseeingfortheseobservationswas0.7
00
.Aftertaking eachimageoftheobject,animageoftheskywasacquired, top ermitthesubtractionoftheblanksky.Theimageswere furthertreatedbyremovalofthedarkcurrent, at eldand bright infraredsky.
2.3 Opticalsp ectroscopy
Sp ectroscopy of the brightest candidate counterparts (ob-jects A and B) was obtained at the 1.5 m ESO Sp ectro-graphictelescop eonJuly1998,usingaB&CSp ectrograph. Theexp osuretime was20min;the slit width was 2
00 .The sp ectra covered the wavelength range 4000{8000
A witha resolutionof10
A(FWHM).Sp ectrawere uxcalibrated undernon-photometric conditions, so thatjusttherelative intensities arereliable.
Figure1.Rbandimageofthe eldof1E1841 045 obtainedwiththeNTT/EMMIin1993.HereandinthefollowingimagesNorth istopandEastleft.Thetwoerrorcircleshaveradiiof3
00 .
3 RESULTS
An R{band image of the eld of 1E 1841 045 is shown in Fig1.Thetwoerror circlesare centeredatthep ositions obtained withtheROSATHRI,R.A.=18
h 41 m 19.2 s Dec. ={04 Æ 56 0 12.5 00
(J2000,Helfandetal.1994)andwiththe Einstein HRI,R.A.=18
h 41 m 19.0 s Dec.= {04 Æ 56 0 08.9 00 (J2000,Krissetal.1985).Bothp ositionswererep ortedwith uncertaintiesof3
00
,butp ossibleerrorsinthesatellites b ore-sight cannot b eexcluded.Forthisreason weconsidered all theobjectswithin10
00
fromthenominalp ositions.Our as-trometry, computed withthe ASTROM software (Wallace 1990)on ashortexp osureEMMIimagebyusingasa refer-ence asetofstars from theDSS2, has anoverallaccuracy of1
00 .
Severalobjects arepresentwithin orclosetotheerror circles. Theirmagnitudesare rep ortedinTable2.Adeep er imageisshowninFig.2.
The sp ectra for the brightest objects, B and A, are showninFig.3.Classi cationwasp erformedbycomparison withthesp ectrallibraryofSilva&Cornell(1992).Basedon this we classify starBas aF6{7I I Iand starA asA5{8V. Bothsp ectra arequite reddened.FromtheEW ofthe NaI lines,wecanestimateaninterstellar absorptionlargerthan A
V
1.5forb othstars(Munari&Zwitter 1997).
Theinfraredimage in theKs band isshownin Fig.4. Tanks to the less severe absorption at long wavelengths, thesedatagivethedeep erviewoftheregion,revealing sev-eralobjectsundetectedinthevisibleband.
4 DISCUSSION
The distance of Kes 73 was determined by means of the 21cmabsorptionmeasurementsbySanb onmatsu&Helfand (1992), who obtained a value of 6{7.5 kp c. These authors also estimated an HI column density to the source of 5 10
21 cm
2
. The equivalent hydrogen column density ob-tainedfromX{raysp ectral tsof1E1841 045 andKes73 isinthe1.5-310
22 cm
2
range(Gotthelf&Vasisht1997). Itisthusclearthatwecanexp ectasigni cantreddeningfor the optical counterpart of 1E 1841 045 . For instance as-sumingN H =210 22 cm 2
andusingtheaveragerelationN H =1.79 10
22 AV cm
2
(Predehl &Schmitt, 1995)weexp ect A
V
11 (notehoweverthatthereisalargescatteraround theab oveaveragerelation).
The two brightest objects we studied (A and B) are normalstarswithoutanydistinctivefeatureintheirsp ectra that might suggest an asso ciation with an X{ray pulsar.
Figure2.DeepRbandimageofthesame eldshowninFig.1.Thecolorscalehasb eenstretchedtoshowb etterthefainteststars.
Theirmagnitudes andcolorsalsoindicatearelativelysmall distanceof3kp c.
The color-magnitude diagram based on the V and R NTTobservationsisshowninFig.5.Thecirclesindicatethe objectswithinorclosetotheerrorregions;theirmagnitudes are given in Table2.None of theseobjects p ossesses esp e-cially unusual colors. The V-R color{magnitude diagram, thatshowsaclearlyde ned sequence,isverysimilartothat of astar cluster,indicatin g that mostof thestars that we observedhavesimilardistanceandreddening.
Thep ossible presenceofastarclusterwouldb e partic-ularlyinteresting;however,amorelikelyexplanationisthat weare lo oking atstarsb elonging tooneofthespiral arms ofourGalaxy.Infact,thelineofsighttowardKes73 inter-ceptsArm3at2.5-3kp c(see,e.g.,Taylor&Cordes1993) andthenisalmosttangentialtoArm2fordistancesb etween 5and8kp c.Forcomparison,thelines corresp onding to a main sequence fordi erent values ofreddening and dis-tanceare alsoplotted in Fig.5.It isclear thatmostofthe p ointsinthediagramcorresp ond tostarsinthespiral arm at 2.5-3 kp c, while only a fewfartherobjects are visible due to the strong reddening in the Galactic plane. There-fore,ifwetrusttheasso ciationb etween1E1841 045 and theSNRatd7kp c,mostoftheobjectsseenintheoptical imagesarelikely foregroundstarsmuchcloserthanKes73. The presence of a large numb er of stars with similar
values of distance and reddening is also evident from the IRcolor-magnitude plotshownin Fig.6.Hereobjects con-sistent witha red giant branch are also visible, as well as many other more distant and/or reddened stars that are notseen in the optical bands. The objects within or close to theerror b oxes of 1E 1841 045 are indicated with di-amonds. Three of them are very reddened (G, 5 and 19), withcolors notcompatible withmainsequence stars.They areprobablyverydistant giant orsup ergiant stars.In par-ticular,whilestarsGand5arequitedistantfromtheerror regionsof1E1841 045,star19shouldb econsidered asa p otentially interestingcandidatecounterpart.
Many accreting pulsars have sup ergiant OB compan-ions.However,theIRmagnitudesofobject19do esnot sup-p ortan early typ estar. OBsup ergiants have typically (J{ K)inthe{0.2to0.1range(Johnson1966,Ruelas-Mayorga 1991)thereforeaveryhighabsorption (A
v >
25-30) is re-quiredbytheobservedvalueof(J{K)=5.240.12,aswellas adistanceplacingitattheedgeoftheGalaxy,wellb eyond Kes73.Thep ossibili ty ofaBesystem seemsalsounlikely: thoughasmallerdistanceisallowed(e.g.10kp cforaB5) stillaverylargeA
V
wouldb erequired,(ofcourse,asmaller AV couldb eassumedinthepresenceofsubstantialIR emis-sionfromcircumstellardust).Amoreplausibleexplanation forstar19isthatofaveryreddened giant atd
>
8kp c. Some mo dels forAXPs involve isolated neutron stars
Figure4.Ks bandimageofthe eldof1E1841 045.
accreting from residual disks (van Paradijs et al. 1995, Ghosh et al. 1997, Chatterjee et al. 1999). Although it is unclear whethersuchdiskscanactually b eformed,(e.g.in the evolution of Thorne{Zytkow objects or as a result of material fallbackafterasup ernovaexplosion), andwhether they can explain all the observed prop erties of the AXP, Perna etal. (2000) made some predictions on the emitted optical andIRsp ectra.Verydi erent opticalandIRcolors canb eobtained bythemo dels presented bytheseauthors, as a function, e.g., of the neutron star age and magnetic eld, inclinati on and mass of the disk, imp ortance of reir-radiation of the pulsar X{ray ux, etc.Thereforeit is not surprising thatthecurrentdatadonotsupp ortnorweaken suchmo dels. Forinstance,thevaluesK17andV28 pre-dictedbyPernaetal.for1E1841 045 assuminganageof 4000yrs,B=810
12
G,adiskmassof0.005 M andan inclinati on of60
Æ
are consistent withseveral oftheobjects visible inourIRdataandb elowthedetectionthreshold in theoptical.
5 CONCLUSIONS
The optical limits on the p ossible counterparts of other AXPs have allowed to rule out the presence of a (non-degenerate) massive companion (see Mereghetti 2000 and references therein). Unfortunately, we cannot do the same yetfor1E 1841 045, based on theobservations presented here.However,anOBsup ergiantcompanionseemsunlikely, asitrequiresvaluesofthedistanceand/orabsorptionmuch inexcessofthoseestimatedfor1E1841 045 tob e
compat-iblewiththeobjectswefound.Massivemainsequencestars cannot b eexcluded. Forinstance aB5starat7 kp cand withAv 8 would have J and K magnitudes fully consis-tentwithe.g.,thoseofstarH.AlthoughtheopticalandIR datacannotexcludethep ossibili tythat1E1841 045 b ea Bebinary,itsX{rayprop ertiesareverydi erentfromthose of such a class of sources, that are characterized by hard X{ray sp ectra,signi cant variabili ty and erraticlong term evolution inthespinp erio d.
None of the objects we studied has p eculiar char-acteristics that might suggest a p ossible connection with 1E1841 045 .However, ifthissource is indeedasso ciated withKes73andthereforesubjecttoasigni cantreddening, wehavediscovered withinits errorregionapromising can-didate (star 19) deserving further sp ectroscopic study. We exp ectthatthe datapresented herewill represent auseful reference to facilitate the identi cation task, oncethe p o-sitional accuracy of1E 1841 045 will b e much improved by observations with the new generation X{ray satellites Chandr a andNew tonXMM.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
S.Ch. acknowledges nancial supp ort from grant F/00-180/A from the Leverhulme Trust. We acknowledge the supp ortsoftwareprovided by theStarlink Projectwhichis fundedby theUKSERC.
Figure5.Opticalcolor-magnitudediagramforthestarsina3 0
3 0
eldaroundthep ositionof1E1841 045.Thecirclesmarkthe starswithinorclosetotheerrorcircles.NotethatthestarsbrighterthanR18arepartlysaturatedandtheirpro le{ ttedmagnitudes aretob econsideredcautiosly.APop.IMSat2.5kp candwithareddeningA
V
2:5givesago o d tofthedata,inagreementwiththe sp ectroscopicestimateforstarA.Thesegmentintheupp errightcornerindicatesthedirectionofreddening(thelengthcorresp ondsto Av =1mag).
Figure6.IRcolormagnitudediagramforthestarsintheregionof1E1841 045.Theexp ectedp ositionsformainsequencestars(full lines)andredgiants(dashedlines)forselectedvaluesofthedistanceandreddeningarealsoindicated.Thediamondsmarkobjectsclose toorwithinthe1E1841 045 errorb oxes.Thesegmentintheupp errightcornesindicatesthee ectofreddeningduetoA
v
star B V R rGunn J K A 17.14 15.95 15.21 16.21 13.53 12.96 B 16.71 15.39 14.56 12.74 12.08 C 18.93 17.55 16.74 17.32 14.78 14.28 D 20.64 17.83 15.92 16.65 11.81 10.33 E 19.49 17.96 16.96 17.66 14.30 12.68 F 20.22 18.55 17.54 18.21 15.17 14.18 G 21.39 19.57 18.49 19.21 15.94 11.76 H 21.66 19.80 18.63 19.40 15.96 14.78 I 21.91 20.16 19.05 19.57 16.48 15.18 L 22.27 20.38 19.35 19.42 15.56 13.39 M 23.51 21.43 19.79 20.34 16.38 15.30 N 22.83 20.86 19.55 20.10 16.58 15.18 O 21.88 20.53 21.07 17.62 16.30 P 22.80 21.41 21.84 19.17 17.08 Q 21.91 20.58 21.18 17.50 14.41 R 22.10 20.75 21.18 17.46 15.54 S 21.96 20.47 20.95 17.84 16.31 T 22.37 23.02 17.16 16.04 U 22.07 22.81 17.34 15.43 V 22.32 22.94 18.05 16.55 Z 22.34 17.16 15.88 1 22.59 23.17 17.91 16.19 2 20.84 21.51 14.72 12.69 3 20.77 21.61 14.73 12.55 4 22.27 23.14 16.93 15.24 5 22.13 20.65 21.20 17.05 12.39 6 16.53 15.06 7 16.94 15.16 8 22.52 23.98 17.28 16.36 9 22.50 23.26 17.00 15.62 10 16.15 13.94 11 14.11 11.94 12 16.96 15.04 13 17.50 15.27 14 16.18 13.73 15 22.41 16.04 13.87 16 23.45 18.09 17.01 17 18.12 16.78 18 23.89 18.07 16.37 19 18.05 12.81 20 17.51 16.33 21 17.05 15.62 22 16.48 14.42 23 18.33 17.08 24 17.73 14.84 25 17.68 15.69 26 17.13 15.44 27 17.38 28 15.59
Table 2. Magnitudes of the stars close to the p osition of 1E1841 045.
REFERENCES
ChatterjeeP.,HernquistL.,&NarayanR.1999,ApJ534,373. GhoshP.,AngeliniL.&WhiteN.E.1997,ApJ478,713. GotthelfE.V.andVasishtG.1997,ApJ486,L133.
GotthelfE.V.,VashistG.andDotaniT.1999,ApJ522,L49. HelfandD.J.,BeckerR.H.,HawkinsG.and WhiteL.R., 1994,
ApJ434,627.
JohnsonH.L.1966,ARA&A4,193. KentS.M.1985,PASP97,165
KrissG.A.BeckerR.H.,HelfandD.J.,CanizaresC.R.1985,ApJ
288,703.
MereghettiS.&StellaL.1995,ApJ,442,L17.
MereghettiS.2000,Pro ceedingsNATOASI"TheNeutronStar -BlackHoleConnection",inpress,astro-ph/9911252 MunariU.&ZwitterT.1997,A&A318,269
PernaR.,HernquistL.&NarayanR.2000,astro-ph/9912297 PredehlP.&ScmittJ.H.M.M.1995,A&A293,889.
Ruelas-MayorgaR.A.1991,RMxAA22,27.
Sanb onmatsuK.YandHelfandD.J.1992,AJ104,2189. SilvaD.R.,CornellM.E.1992,ApJS81,865
StetsonP.B.,1987,PASP99,191
TaylorJ.H.&CordesJ.M.1993,ApJ411,674.
vanParadijsJ.,TaamR. E.& vandenHeuvel,E.P.J.1995, A&A,299,L41.
VasishtG.andGotthelfE.V.1997,ApJ486,L129.
WallaceP.T.,1990,StarlinkUserNote5.11,RutherfordAppleton Lab oratory