...
O~
...
J ...Q.$ . ..
.I ....1.0XS ... .
~>ilc
iTIf1,elHeule): ...•.....L\.~3
..
u ... .
E1I296
'-1\§4\W~lfi1?'i:dr\i1'ndlCase File OfficcrlL'agent chafQ6
:"l:";j(,fsi:r ... '
SCtVlf\.,.JZud.~
... .
w~ ~ ta~St~ G ~
5i
~ ~~ ~~~ W~~~5ij~
---_
...----_.---_
..
~~~~~~g~~t;~~e~~mfSi~~~
Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia
Chambres Extraordinaires au sein des Tribunaux Cambodgiens
~~~~~!¥~~~~~S
Trial ChamberChambre de premiere instance
Kingdom of Cambodia Nation Religion King Royaume du Cambodge
Nation Religion Roi
WRITTEN RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS PUBLIC
Case File N° 002/19.{)9-2007-ECCC/TC
04 May 2015
Substantive Hearing on Evidence 002/02 - Day 277
Prepared by:SE KolvudlY and Robynne CROFT Attendance Record
Before: Judge NIL Nonn (President); Judge Claudia FENZ; Judge YA Sokhan; Judge Jean-Marc LA YERGNE; Judge YOU Ottara
Reserve Judges: Judge Martin KAROPKIN (Reserve); Judge THOU Mony (Reserve) Greffiers: Mrs. SE Kolvuthy; Ms. Robynne CROFT; Mr. EM Hoy
OCP: Mr. SENG Leang; Mr. Dale LYSAK; Mr. Vincent DE WILDE D'ESTMAEL Accused: Mr. NUON Chea (from the holding cell); Mr. KHIEU Samphan
Defence for the Accused Nuon Cheal Mr. Victor KOPPE; Mr. SON Arun; Mr. LlV Sovanna
Defence for the Accused Khieu Samphan: Mr. KONG Sam Onn
Standby Counsel for the Accused Khieu Samphan: Ms. TOUCH Voleak; Mr. Calvin SAUNDERS
Civil Parties: Ms. Marie GUIRAUD; Mr. YEN Pov
Witness: Witness KHOEM Boeun (2-TCW-979) via video-link
Others: Mr. UCH Arun (Court Officer); Ms. SOUR Sotheavy (Associate Court Officer); Mr. NOU Monoroath (Transcriber); Ms. PICH Chariya (Transcriber); Ms. SOK Sopheakmonica (Transcriber); Mr. Sheriffo JAMMEH (Transcriber); Ms. Jodie TRAMPERT; Mr. MAM Ridlea (duty counsel); Mr. HOU Chiseng.
gftlllim13 ~ ftl\l1ri tU1!lmi 31l/) ~t\l1 Ullldm'] "j!tlll)llltirtil!U'l n", ~Ir;;£): «(.j[i[i) -l£Jrn-M.5-(.j",~ ~1ft111: «(.j[i[i) ·l£Jrn·I£J"'.5-(.j~", t1itJllj~l: www.eccc.gov.kh National Road 4 ,Chaom Chau, Dangkao 'Phnom Penh Mail Po Box 71, Phnom Penh Tel:+855(0)23 218914 Fax:023 218941 Web:
www.eccc.gov.kh
IaD_
Case No. 002/25·09·2007·ECCC/TC
E1I296
General court times
Day Start time: 09:04 Finish time: 16: 16 Recess am Start time: 10: 16 Finish time: 10:32 Recess Start time: 11:38 Finish time: 13:32 Recess pm Start time: 14:44 Finish time: 15:03
Total Court Time: 4 hours and 43 minutes
Proceedings
Type of Issue Raised By Start time Finish time Opening of hearing and report Trial Chamber, Greffier 09:04 09:06 on attendance of the Parties
NUON Chea Defence request NUON Chea Defence 09:07 09:09 to follow the proceedings from
the holding cell
KHIEU Samphan Defence KHIEU Samphan Defence 09:09 09:12 request for reasons on why Trial Chamber 09:12 09:14 Witness 2-TCW-979 will be
heard via video-link
Hearing of Witness KHOEM Trial Chamber 09:15 09:21 Boeun (2-TCW-979) via video- Co-Prosecu tors 09:21 15:16
link Civil Party Lead Co- 15: 17 16:08
Lawyer
NUON Chea Defence request Trial Chamber 16:09 16:10 to postpone the 8 May 2015 NUON Chea Defence 16:11 16:14
hearing KHIEU Samphan Defence 16:15 16:15
Co-Prosecutors 16:15 16:16
Summary of Proceedings
Opening of hearing and report on attendance of the Parties
The President opened the proceedings and the Greffier informed the Trial Chamber that all Parties were present, except International Co-Counsel for KHIEU Samphan, Mr. Arthur VERCKEN and Ms. Anta GUISSE, who will be absent during this week's proceedings, with the Accused NUON Chea present in the holding cell.
NUON Chea Defence request to follow the proceedings from the holding cell
The Trial Chamber granted the request of the NUON Chea Defence Team for NUON Chea to waive his right to be present in the courtroom and to follow the proceedings from the holding cell.
~---.~--Case No. 002/25.09·2007·ECCC/TC
E1I296
~---, KHIEU Samphan Defence request for reasons on why Witness 2-TCW-979 will be heard
via video-link
The KHIEU Samphan Defence requested reasons for the hearing of Witness 2-TCW-979 via video-link. The Trial Chamber announced that hearing via video-link was necessary due to the advanced age and health of Witness 2-TCW-979.
Hearing of Witness KHOEM Boeun (2-TCW-979) via video-link
The Trial Chamber, the Co-Prosecutors and the Civil Party Lead Co-Lawyers questioned the Witness KHOEM Boeun (2-TCW-979).
NUON Chea Defence request to postpone the 8 May 2015 hearing
The Trial Chamber sought clarification of the NUON Chea Defence's request to postpone the hearing scheduled for 8 May 2015. The NUON Chea Defence explained that the International Co-Lawyer will be abroad and that the National Co-Lawyer's health situation prevents him from attending. The KHIEU Samphan Defence and Co-Prosecutors
responded to the request. The Trial Chamber announced that it will rule on the matter in due course.
3/6
Written Record of Proceedings - 04 May 2015 / PublicReclassified
D157/31
,00322121; 100833780-100833781
Report on Sao Phan, a new citizen
Case No. 002/25.09·2007·ECCC/TC E1I296
I
.
.
I
,
100833780-100270979100322121 :008337811 , . I 'I
'
I ....•••.•.•.•.•.•••...•..••.•...• ; ... . :00270815-:E3/5860 ,. ..•... __ . __ ._ ... E3/2438 D157.50 '00270854; : '01064165-1 101064197; : '00971272-:00971316 '00270811-1 00270814;I
[00366665-i
00366675 1 ,00591022- : :00591027!
,,00068574-I
i00068575; I ,0076302~ !E3/2281 D108/26.71 '00763034; '00793396-:00793407···· ..
~r--·.. ···
100068576-,
i
100068576;,
I
100742626-iE3/2262 !D108/26.293 :00742628;I
!00760146-Biography of Thach Soeun from Kampuchea Krom
List of number of Cambodian people in Kampuchea Krom made
by Kus sub-district
List of People from T rapaing Thom Cheung commune P 00270847,01064190- 00971307 01064191 P P _ ... _-_ . . . ~- " " - " - " ' - - - ' ' ' ' ' - - ' r ·-"-.... '''-!·''''''·''~i,,--~~I
.
I
List of Kampuchea Krom people in
Popel Commune P
I
I . :00760148 ... " .... ---.~ ... "-~ .. -~- ... j"'"'''''' .... · .... : .... -~ .... -~r-.. ·-··--.. '"'' ...
1 " " " , ... ,,, ... ,,, ... _-,, ..._
.. ,, ,00082724-'E3/2012 00082728; :00276593-:00276597; 00797682-,00797687Educational Office of District 105 Report
Other documents (No Change)
TCNo Title !
I
l j P !00082728 00276597 00797687 , '!
.• " ... ~ ... -'''-.-~." •• --.. " .... --,,!E319.1.21 ; 1 ; :00998722-D118/242 100998767; :01057675-:01057732
160975621-i 10097 5646; ID 118/181 :00982633-: '00982663; 100980616-:00980640 100968170-i 100968196;Written Record of Interview of [REDACTED]
Written record of witness
interview of [REDACTED] 'SC
Case No. 002/25.09·2007-ECCC/TC E1I296 :01057700 101057685 101057691 00998742 i01057698 , 00998730 101057689 ; 00998734 101057695 ; 00998741 i01057697 00998733 ,01057696 00998738 \01057680 00998739 101057681
I
00998729 101057724~iHm.I~:~m~i
·
00998746 :01057720 I 00998736 l01057714-00998758 :01057715 00998754101057698 iN/A 00998757 101057719 00998740 101058712 ; 00998757 101058709 100998750- 101058710-I ; 100998751 '01058711 100998756 i01058718 100998758 01057713 100998753 '01058720 100998764 101058727 00998734101058690-1 0099871901058691 ' 00998756 :01058757 00998739 !0105871~ 100998743- !01058718 100998744 101057700I
101057692-101057693 101057702 1 l 1 I 00975642 100982650 ~009806361 00975643 1009826591009806371I ; Written Record of Interview of
E319.1.33
io118/1671~~~~~~~~~
[REDACTED]SC 00968181 100980288 100982617i
00982607-
I
100982632
I
i;"--""~"'-""",~-""'~C";-~-""~-'"'' '"--'''''-~-'-~'''''';.''''''' .-~ •••••• -~'--•••• -~."" ... '-~~ ••• ~"""'."-'
I E3/2048 ; '00079087- I Report on enemy's actionsfor
IP
00079089 ,00276562- i00611659 1, ... , " , . '
" ;
'Vr
5/6 Written Record of Proceedings - 04 May 2015 / Public
E319.1.32 i00079099; 00276562-100276570; 100611658-100611667
...
r~~~~~~~~~ 18/209 !00983566-,00983590; , '00988934- ' i00988960...
16i029140-Tram Kak District Police
Written Record of Interview of [REDACTED]
Case No. 002/25-09·2007-ECCC/TC E1I296 !00079092- '00276563 !00611662
i
'00079093 i00276565 /00611660! ;00079090 100276563-100276564I
iSC 00980113 100983581 ,00988934 ... ·c ... ·· ... ··· ... ···" E319/13.3.60 0219/19 101029236;i01050334-Written Record of Interview of !SC 101029185- 101050392-
iN/
A[REDACTED] ! 101029187 ;01050395 I
I
'01050461 I .
Oral Orders/Decisions:
• Order auci10rising the Accused NUON Chea to follow the proceedings from the
holding cell and instructing the A V U nit to connect the A V link to the proceedings (09:07).
• Order instructing the security personnel to take the Accused back to the detention
facility and to return them to the courtroom for the hearing on 5 May 2015 (16:16).
Orders for Adjournment of Hearing