RIT Scholar Works
Theses
Thesis/Dissertation Collections
6-5-1992
The Human wrist
James A. Perkins
Follow this and additional works at:
http://scholarworks.rit.edu/theses
This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Thesis/Dissertation Collections at RIT Scholar Works. It has been accepted for inclusion
in Theses by an authorized administrator of RIT Scholar Works. For more information, please contact
Recommended Citation
A Thesis Submitted
to the
Faculty
ofThe College
ofFine
andApplied Arts
in
Candidacy
for
the
Degree
ofMASTER
OF
FINE
ARTS
THE
HUMAN WRIST
By
James A. Perkins
~
/;3 /
(-Z;z
Associate Adviser:
Prof. Glen Hintz
Date:
{p
-1-
92-Associate Adviser:
Prof. David Dickinson
~
Date:
,J
cAA'\JSpecial Assistant to th
Date:
_ _
--"'ftt'---f--'-=---+-~L...=__
Prof. Philip Bornarth
Acting Dean, College of Fine and Applied Arts: Dr. Peter
~iopUIOS
Date:
l'"
l
[5
~
0--,--
__
V
_
I,
James A. Perkins
,
hereby grant permission to the Wallace Memorial
Library of RIT to reproduce my thesis in whole or in part. Any reproduction will not be
used for commercial use or profit.
Date:
J;;~c. ~
INTRODUCTION
1
ANATOMY OF
THE WRIST
4
THE TRIANGULAR FIBROCARTILAGE COMPLEX
7
ILLUSTRATING THE TFCC
12
KINEMATICS
OF THE WRIST
15
WRIST
KINEMATICS:
AN
INTERACTIVE
TUTORIAL FOR THE
MACINTOSH
22
ILLUSTRATIONS
33
BIBLIOGRAPHY
47
We
tend to think ofthe
wrist as a simplejoint
which allowsthe
hand
to move relative to theforearm.
In
fact,
the wristis
one ofthe most complex structures
in
thebody,
madeup
of numerousarticulations
between
theradius,
the eightcarpals,
thefive
metacarpals,
and the contents of the ulnocarpal space.Despite
centuries of
study,
hundreds
ofbooks
andarticles,
and theappearance
in 1975
of ajournal
devoted
exclusively
to research on thehuman hand (Journal
ofHand Surgery),
the wrist remains apoorly
understood structure.Researchers
at theUniversity
ofRochester
School
ofMedicine
and
Dentistry/
Strong
Memorial
Hospital
have
recently
madeimportant
advancesin
ourunderstanding
of two aspects ofthe wrist:the
anatomy
of theTriangular Fibrocartilage Complex
(TFCC)
and themovement of the carpal
bones
during
wrist motion.Dr. Richard
J.
Miller
of theDepartment
ofOrthopedics
andDr. Sarah Totterman
ofthe
Radiology
Department
have
usedhigh
resolutionMagnetic
Resonance
Imaging
(MRI)
tostudy
thedetailed anatomy
of thepoorly-understood
Triangular
Fibrocartilage
Complex,
a mass ofcartilage and
fibrous
connective tissuelying
between
thedistal
ulnaand the proximal carpal row.
They
have
correlated theirMRI
scanswith gross
dissection
andhistological
sections of the same wristspecimens.
In researching
thistopic,
Drs.
Miller
andTotterman
these same
illustrations
have been
"recycled"in
theliterature for
years.
For
thefirst
part ofmy
thesis,
I
chose to create a series ofillustrations
of theTFCC showing both
the normalanatomy
and twoof
its
more common pathologic conditions.Dr. Miller has
alsodeveloped
a new techniquefor
visualizing
the complex movement of the eight carpal
bones
during
wristmotion.
In
thepast,
thishas
proven tobe
adifficult
task sincex-rays provide a poor
image
of thebones,
especially
when the wristis
flexed
or extended.Dissecting
the wrist todemonstrate
the positionof the carpals requires an
arthrotomy
(opening
thejoint
capsule)
which
disrupts
the wristligaments
and alters their range of motion.Instead,
Dr.
Miller
removes the skin andforearm
tendonsfrom
acadaver wrist and
inserts
steel wiresinto
the carpalbones
perpendicular to theflat
surface of thehand.
About
twoinches
ofeach wire
is left protruding from
the wrist.As
thehand is
moved relative to theforearm,
the carpals move and the wires move withthem,
tracking
the rotational and translational movements of eachbone.
While
this techniquehas greatly improved
ourunderstanding
of
both
qualitative and quantitative carpalmotion,
these conceptsare
very
difficult
toconvey
with the written word or even with staticimages.
For
the second part ofmy
thesis,
I
sought todevelop
acomputer
tutorial,
complete with short animatedsequences,
thatcould
be
widely distributed
to aidin
theunderstanding
of carpalmotion.
To
create thistutorial, it
wasfirst necessary
to createanimated sequences.
Both
of these topics are quite complex and represent the"state-of-the-art"
in
ourunderstanding
of the wrist.All
of theillustrations
and the computer tutorial are aimed at thepracticing
orthopedist,
the orthopedicsresident,
and the advanced medicalstudent.
The illustrations
were createdfor
publicationin
a medicaljournal
or textbook and the computer tutorial wasdesigned
tobe
The
wristis
a complex anatomic structure whichincludes
thecarpo-metacarpal
joint
(distally),
the carpals and all of theirarticulations,
the radiocarpaljoint,
and all of the structures within the ulnocarpal space.The
distal
radiusmay be
regarded as part of the wrist sinceinjuries
to thedistal
radius often affect wrist motion.The
radioulnarjoint,
however,
is
not considered part ofthe wrist andis
functionally
part of theforearm
(Taleisnik
1985).
The
carpalbones
themselves are arrangedin
tworows,
oneproximal and one
distal.
The
proximal rowincludes (from
medial tolateral)
thescaphoid,
lunate,
triquetrum,
and pisiform.Proximally,
the scaphoid and
lunate
articulate with thedistal
surface of theradius,
forming
the radiocarpaljoint.
The distal
surface of theradius slopes
volarly
and toward the ulna andis
divided
into
twoconcave
facets,
one medial to receive the scaphoid and onelateral
toreceive the
lunate.
The
triquetrum andlunate have
a proximalarticulation with the structures of the ulnocarpal space
(called
theulnocarpal complex or triangular
fibrocartilage
complex).Under
normal circumstances, these structures separate the triquetrum andlunate from
the ulna.Only
whenpathology has
resultedin
theerosion of the triangular
fibrocartilage
complex can thesebones
make
direct
contact.In
ahealthy
individual,
the ulna makes notrapezium,
trapezoid, capitate,
andhamate.
These bones
articulatewith the proximal row
to
form
the midcarpaljoint.
Distally,
thedistal
rowbones
articulate with the metacarpals toform
the carpometacarpal
joint.
Metacarpal
I
("thumb")
articulates with thetrapezium,
metacarpalII
with thetrapezoid,
metacarpalIII
with thecapitate,
and metacarpalsrv
andV
articulate with thehamate.
Also included in
the wrist are thedozens
ofligaments
whichconnect the carpals to one another and to the metacarpals and
radius.
As
we shallsee,
thereis
not a singleligament
thatdirectly
connects the ulna to the carpals.
Instead,
afew ligaments
arisefrom
the triangular
fibrocartilage
complex whichitself
originates on theradius.
The
muscles which control the movement of the wrist alloriginate
in
theforearm
andinsert
distal
to the carpometacarpaljoint.
There is
not a single muscle origin orinsertion
within thewrist proper.
(The
pisiformis actually
a sesamoidbone
thatforms
within the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon and
may,
therefore, be
considered an exception.)
The ligaments
of the wrist canbe
classifiedinto
twobroad
groups: the extrinsic
ligaments
which connectany
of the carpals toeither the radius or the
metacarpals;
and theintrinsic ligaments
which connect the carpals to one another.
The
extrinsicligaments
arefurther
subdividedinto
a proximalgroup
(connecting
the radius to thecarpals)
and adistal group
(connecting
the carpals to the metacarpals).The
proximal extrinsicgroup
includes:
a singledorsal
radiocarpalligament
connecting
thetriquetrum,
andscaphoid;
agroup
ofligaments connecting
the volarrim of the radius with
the
scaphoid,
capitate,
andlunate
(radioscaphocapitate,
radioscapholunate,
andradiolunate);
the radialcollateral
ligament along
the medial edge of the radiocarpaljoint;
and the ulnocarpal complex or triangular
fibrocartilage
complexwhich will
be
discussed
in
moredetail later.
The intrinsic ligaments
are classifiedaccording
tolength;
short,
intermediate,
orlong.
Each
shortintrinsic ligament
connectsa single pair of adjacent carpals and
has
adorsal,
volar,
andinterosseous
(between
thebones)
component.The
intermediate
intrinsic
ligaments
also connect adjacent carpals(specifically
thelunate-triquetrum,
scaphoid-lunate,
andscaphoid-trapezium)
but
are somewhat
longer.
There
areonly
twolong
intrinsic
ligaments,
one volar which connects the capitate to the
scaphoid,
triquetrumand
(rarely)
thelunate,
and onedorsal
which originates on thetriquetrum and
inserts
on the scaphoid and trapezium(Taleisnik
The
spacebetween
the carpals and thedistal
tip
of the ulnais
filled
with a mass ofligaments
and cartilageknown
as theulnocarpal complex or triangular
fibrocartilage
complex(TFCC).
This
complexis
essentially
aloop
ofligamentous
tissue whichoriginates on the
dorsoulnar
corner of theradius,
passesmedially
around the styloid process of the ulna and then gives rise to two
branches,
the ulnotriquetral and ulnolunateligaments,
which passvolarly
toinsert
on the volar surfaces of the triquetrum andlunate,
respectively.
In
lower
primates,
the ulnar styloidis
long
and articulatesdirectly
with the triquetrum.In
thiscase,
the portion of theTFCC
which wraps around the ulnar styloid
becomes
cartilaginous andforms
ameniscus,
muchlike
the cartilage meniscus within thehuman
knee joint.
In man,
contactbetween
the ulna and triquetrumis lost
and the ulnar styloidhas
recededproximally,
leaving
agap
between
the twobones (Lewis 1967).
Nevertheless,
the portion of theTFCC
that wraps around the ulnar styloidhas
remained thick andcartilaginous and
is
generally
referred to as the meniscushomologue (because
it is evolutionarily
homologous
with the truemeniscus of
lower
primates).The gap
thatis
left
by
thereceding
ulna
is
filled
with a new cartilaginousstructure,
the triangularfibrocartilage
or articulardisc.
Both
the meniscushomologue
andthe
triquetrum, replacing
the ulnotriquetral articulationfound
in
lower
primates.As I
mentionedabove,
all of thefibers
that contribute to thesestructures originate on the
dorsoulnar
corner of the radius.From
there the
fibers
fan
outmedially (toward
theulna)
andvolarly,
covering
the radioulnarjoint
and thedistal
surface of the ulnarhead.
The
articulardisc forms
as athickening
at the center of thisfan,
directly
over the ulnarhead.
Some
ofits
fibers
continuelaterally
toinsert
on the ulna at thejunction
between
the styloidprocess and ulnar
head
proper.The remaining fibers
loop
aroundthe ulnar styloid and turn
back
towards the radius.This
part of thecomplex also thickens to
become
the meniscushomologue.
Some
ofits
fibers
insert
on the ulnar styloid while othersmay
join
thesheath of the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon and extend
distally
asfar
as the
base
of thefifth
metacarpal.The bulk
of thefibers,
however,
give rise to the ulnolunate and the ulnotriquetral
ligaments (Palmer
and
Werner 1981).
The
names of theseligaments
areconfusing
asthey
imply
an origin on thelunate.
In
fact,
they
originate on themeniscus
homologue
whichitself
originates on the radius.These
ligaments
mightbe
moreproperly
called the radioulnolunate andradioulnotriquetral
ligaments
as thefibers
originate on theradius,
form
someinsertions
on theulna,
and then pass to the carpalsin
question.
In
cross section(coronal
orsagittal)
the triangularfibrocartilage
complexis
thinnestin
the middle whereit
overliesthe ulnar
head
and thicker nearits edges,
including
its
origin on theprestyloid recess.
This
spaceis probably
another remnant of thecontinued regression of
the
ulnar styloidaway from
the carpals.It
is
lined
with vascular tissue andmay
assume pathologic significancein
rheumatoid arthritis or otherdiseases
in
which synovitisis
present
(Taleisnik 1985).
The
so-called ulnar collateralligament is
anotherimportant
component of the ulno-carpal complex.
Like
several of the otherstructures
in
thisarea,
its
nameis
misleading; it
is
not a separateligament
at all.Instead,
the ulnar collateralligament
represents athickening
of thedorsal
retinaculum whereit
merges with thesheath of the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon.
Neither
theretinaculum nor the
ECU
tendon attach to the ulnarhead,
but
they
do
receive some
fibers form
theTFCC.
This
thickening
extendsdistally
to
insert
on thetriquetrum,
thehamate,
and thebase
of thefifth
metacarpal
(Taleisnik
1976).
At
this pointit
shouldbe
reiterated that none of the so-calledulnocarpal
ligaments
actually
originate on theulna,
noris
there asingle
ligament
thatdirectly
attaches the ulna to the carpals.The
ulnolunate and the ulnotriquetral
ligaments
actually
attach thedorsoulnar
corner of the radius to the volar carpusby
way
of theulnar
styloid,
and the ulnar collateralligament is
not a separateligament.
This
rather odd arrangementactually
has
animportant
function in stabilizing
the movements of the wrist.The
meniscushomologue,
articulardisc,
and synovium-filled prestyloidrecess,
allulnar portion of the wrist.
In
addition, the
arrangement offibers
acts to stabilize the motion of
the
ulna relative to the radiusduring
pronation and supination.
These fibers
originate on thedorsoulnar
corner of the
radius,
wrap
around the ulnarstyloid,
then turnback
toward the radius to
insert
on the volar surface of the triquetrumand
lunate.
These carpals, in
turn,
are attached to the volar surfaceof the radius.
Thus,
the ulnais
suspendedfrom
the radiusby
acontinuous "sling" of
ligaments.
As
the ulna rotates about the radiusduring
pronation andsupination,
thissling holds
the twobones
in
close
proximity (Palmer
andWerner 1981).
This
system canbe
disrupted
by
damage
toany
of theligaments,
but
the most commonpathology
by
far is
perforation ofthe meniscus
homologue
and/or articulardisc.
One
study
reportedperforation of the articular
disc
in
27.6%
of onehundred
cadaversexamined
(Viegas
andBallantyne
1987)
while another reportfound
perforations
in
more thanhalf
of the specimensdissected (Palmer
1990).
There
is
adramatic increase in
theincidence
ofTFCC
perforation with age
(Mikic
1978)
so these numbersmay
be
exaggerated
by
the advanced age of most cadaver specimens.The
incidence
of perforationsin
the population as a wholeis probably
much
lower.
Nevertheless,
perforation of theTFCC
is
extremely
common and
becomes
both
morelikely
and more pronounced withage.
Perforation of the
TFCC
seems to resultfrom
closeapproximation of the ulna and
lunate,
a problem whichis
particularly
commonin
people withlong
ulnar styloids(Palmer
andrecess, direct
contactbetween
the ulna andlunate,
erosion of theirarticular
cartilages,
andinflammation
of the prestyloid synovialmembrane.
The
abutment andinflammation
cause pain whichmay
ILLUSTRATING
THE
TRIANGULAR
FIBROCARTILAGE
COMPLEX
There
arevery few illustrations
oftheTFCC
and those thatdo
exist are crude and often
confusing (see Taleisnik
1976;
1985).
While
there exist some
decent
photographs of thesestructures,
they
lack
the
clarity
andsimplicity
of a goodillustration.
Therefore,
thefirst
part of
my
thesisinvolved producing
clear,
accurateillustrations
ofthe
TFCC
that were suitablefor
publication.I
chose to create theseillustrations using
ink
since this medium allowsfor
a greatdeal
ofdetail
andholds
up
wellin
reproduction.I
decided
not to use carbondust
(my
secondchoice)
primarily because it is
more expensive andcomplicated to reproduce.
Since many
of the specializedjournals in
the medical
field lack
the most sophisticated reproduction resourcesand often charge the authors
for
the cost ofreproducing
illustrations,
I
felt
it best
to use pen andink.
For references, I
studied theexisting literature
on theTFCC,
consulted with
Drs.
Miller
andTotterman
atStrong
Memorial
Hospital,
and studied theirhigh
resolutionMagnetic
Resonance
Imaging
(MRI)
scans of the wrist.When I
felt
comfortable with theanatomy
of theTFCC region, Dr. Miller
andI
dissected
twofresh
cadaver wrists
from
thehospital's
Institutional
Donor
Program.
Later,
I dissected
two more wrists(the left
and theright)
from
apreserved cadaver specimen
in
theGross
Anatomy
laboratory
at theUniversity
ofRochester College
ofMedicine
andDentistry.
In every
extending
approximately four inches
on either side of thewrist,
cutting
the extensor retinaculum and extensortendons,
andopening
the
dorsal joint
capsule.Once
the
TFCC
wasexposed, I
made severalsketches of the area
from
severaldifferent
views.The
finished
pieces weredrawn using Rotring
rapidographpens on
Bienfang
Satin Design 15 OH
transparent natural vellum.To
scratch outink
lines,
I
used a#10 X-Acto blade.
This
techniqueis
particularly
useful whenbreaking
the outline of an object whichpasses
behind
anotherobject,
creating
more of anillusion
ofoverlapping.
One
set ofline drawings (Fig.
1)
shows the normalanatomy
ofthe
TFCC
and an orientationdrawing
with the wristincision
indicated.
The
wristis
showndissected
open andis
accompaniedby
ablow-up
of theTFCC
area.Figure
2
shows a perforation of theTFCC
which
I
observedin
theleft
wrist of the preserved cadaverin
theGross
Anatomy
Laboratory.
The
ulnarhead
canbe
seen through theperforation.
Interestingly,
this same cadaver showed adifferent
pathologic condition
in
the other wrist.Figure
3
shows an unusualU-shaped
tear of theTFCC,
separating
the articulardisc
from
themeniscus
homologue.
The
articulardisc,
attached to the rest of theTFCC
only
atits dorso-radial corner,
canbe lifted
dorsally
to exposethe ulnar
head below.
Backlit
stats of thefinished drawings
were shotin
theNTID
Printing
Production
Laboratory
and these were then cut out andplaced
into
newlayouts.
These
images
were then copied at75%
ofIn addition,
stats weretaken
at50%
of their original size andI
pasted allofthe
images into
a single8
x 10"layout.
This
was scannedinto
aMacintosh
computerusing
ablack-and-white Apple
Scanner
and
Apple
Scansoftware.
I
thenimported
thisimage into Letraset's
Design
Studiopage
layout
software to createlabels
and animaginary
textbook pagedesign.
I
did
thismerely
to simulate whatthe
illustrations
wouldlook like
in
print.By
checking
the"Don't
Print"button
on the picturedialog
box,
I
was able to print outonly
the text andlabels
and not thescanned
image.
I
then copied the textlayout
onto a piece ofxerographic acetate to create a text
overlay for
thisimaginary
layout.
Figure 4
shows the reducedimages
with the overlaidtext,
allof which was statted again at
75%
tofit
thedimensions
ofthis thesis.KINEMATICS
OF
THE
WRIST
Kinematics is
thestudy
of motion.Taken
as awhole,
thewristis
capable ofjust
six motionsflexion,
extension,
radialdeviation,
ulnar
deviation,
pronation,
and supination.However,
during
thesemovements,
each ofthe eight carpalbones has its
own unique rangeof motion.
To
fully
describe
thekinematics
of thewrist,
it is
necessary
todescribe
the motion of each carpal relative to the radiusand to one another.
The
movement ofone object relative to another such as occursat a
joint
canbe described
by
sixdifferent
parameters or"degrees
of freedom."These
parameters consist of threefor
angular movements(antero-posterior
angularprojection,
lateral
angularprojection,
androtation)
and threefor
translationaldisplacements (antero-posterior
displacement,
lateral
displacement,
and proximo-distaldisplacement
or
distraction-override).
Most
joints
are constrained against certaintypes of motion and therefore can
be described
ashaving
fewer
degrees
offreedom.
The
proximalinterphalangeal
joint
of thefinger,
for
example,
is
constrained to a single type of motionantero-posterior angular
displacement
and thereforehas
a singledegree
offreedom.
The
carpals,
however,
are not constrainedin
such a
way
andhave
a more complex range of motion.Since
thereare eight carpal
bones,
thereis
a total offorty-eight degrees
offreedom (six degrees
perbone
times eightbones)
that mustbe
Fortunately,
there are several anatomicfeatures
of the wristwhich serve to
simplify
the movements of the carpals.First
ofall,
the
intrinsic
interosseous
ligaments
of thedistal
carpal rowbind
these
bones
sotightly
thatthey
function
as asingle,
solid unit.The
distal
rowis
alsotightly
bound
to theindex
andlong
finger
metacarpals such that
these
bones
all movein
unison.These
twometacarpals
along
with thetrapezium,
trapezoid,
capitate,
andhamate form
a"fixed
unit"which can
be
considered as a singlesegment
during
movements of the wrist.The
scaphoid,
lunate,
and triquetrum of the proximal row are alsolinked
by
interosseous
ligaments,
though not astightly
as are thebones
ofthe"fixed
unit".These
bones
tend to movein unison,
but
a small amount of relative motionis
permitted.The fourth bone
of the proximal row the pisiform
is actually
a sesamid within theflexor
carpi ulnaris tendon andis
probably
oflittle
significancein
the
kinematics
of the wrist.From
afunctional
point of view the wrist comprises a soliddistal
element(fixed
unit),
a proximalarticulating
surface(radius)
and a
fairly
rigid segmentintercalated in
between (the
proximalrow).
As
the muscles which control the wristcontract,
they
tend todraw
the metacarpals(and
the carpus as awhole)
toward theforearm,
compressing
the carpalbones
in
between.
The distal
row,
strongly
secured to themetacarpals,
movesin
unison with thecarpus as a whole.
The
proximalrow,
on the otherhand,
is
squeezedbetween
thedistal
row and the articular surface of the radius andmoves
in
response.Since
the articular surface of the radius slopesrotates
into
an extended position.This is precisely
whathappens
during
extension and ulnardeviation.
During
flexion
and radialdeviation, however,
thetendency
of the proximal row to extendis
counteracted
by
otherforces.
As
the carpusis drawn radially
and/orvolarly,
thedistal
rowimpinges
on thedistal
pole of the scaphoidwhich acts
like
alever
arm,
causing
the scaphoid to rotateinto
aflexed
position.Because
ofits strong interosseous
connections withthe rest of the proximal
row,
flexion
ofthe scaphoid causesflexion
ofthe
lunate
and triquetrum aswell,
despite
theirinherent
tendency
toextend.
One
feature
of the wrist whichgreatly
simplifiesits
motionis
the
fact
that all rotational and translational movements are centeredabout a single point within the
head
of the capitate(Youm,
et. al.1978).
The
fixed
unit,
of which the capitateis
apart,
pivots androtates about this point
during
flexion,
extension,
ulnar and radialdeviation.
The
proximal row ,in
turn, is
translatedalong
thecircumference of a circle which
is
centered at this same pointwithin the capitate.
It
shouldbe
noted thatbecause
of thedouble-row
structure ofthe
wrist,
flexion
and extension areactually
compoundmotions,
partoccurring
at the radiocarpaljoint
and part at the midcarpaljoint.
As
was mentioned
previously,
the proximal row slidesvolarly
andextends
during
extension.During
flexion,
the proximal rowflexes
relative to the radius.
These
motions represent the radiocarpalportion of
flexion
and extension.In
addition,
thereis
angulardisplacement
between
the proximal row andfixed
unit(i.e.
at thecenter of rotation
for
both
the
radiocarpal and midcarpalcomponents of
motion;
the proximal row slidesalong
the articularsurface of the radius
following
an arc centeredin
the capitate whilethe rotation of
the
fixed
unit relative to the proximal rowis
alsocentered
in
the capitate(Youm,
et. al.1978).
The
radiocarpal and midcarpal components offlexion
andextension each account
for
abouthalf
ofthe total range of motion ofthe wrist.
However,
a small amount of relative motionis
allowedbetween
thethree
bones
of the proximal rowand,
therefore,
eachmakes a
slightly
different
contribution to the radiocarpalcomponent of motion.
The
movement of the three proximal rowbones is extremely difficult
to observe andit
wasfor
this reason thata special experimental procedure was
developed
to "externalize"their motion without
disrupting
thejoint
capsule.Dr. Richard
Miller
of the
University
ofRochester/Strong
Memorial
Hospital
has
developed
a techniquewhereby
the subtle angular changes of theproximal row
bones
may
be
visualized withoutdisrupting
thestructures of the wrist.
This
methodinvolves
dissecting
away
theskin and subcutaneous
tissue
of afresh
cadaver specimen amputatedat the elbow.
The digits
are removed as are the tendons of thefirst,
third,
fourth,
andfifth
compartments,but
theflexor
and extensortendons
may be left
intact
to act as"motors"
for manipulating
thehand.
Thin
steelKirschner
wires are theninserted
through thedorsal joint
capsuleinto
each of the proximal rowbones
andadditional wires are placed
in
the radius(to
act as a referenceframe)
and
in
the third(long
finger)
metacarpal(to
track the motion of theflexor
or extensor tendons orby
manipulating
the third metacarpal(fixed
unit).The
proximal carpals movepassively in
response toimpingement
by
thefixed
row and this motionis
reflectedin
movements of the
protruding
Kirschner
wires(Miller,
unpublishedmanuscript).
While
this
methodhas
revealedmany
of the subtleties of wristmotion,
one ofits
mostimportant
contributionsis
demonstrating
the relative motion of the proximal carpalsduring
flexion
andextension.
This
methodhas
shownthat,
in
both
ofthesemotions,
thescaphoid always pivots the
most,
the triquetrum somewhatless,
and thelunate
theleast
(Miller,
personal communication).During
flexion,
the scaphoidflexes
more than the otherbones
andduring
extension
it
extends more than the others.Since
the three proximalrow
bones
all move to adifferent degree
relative to theradius,
theextent of radiocarpal rotation
differs for
each.The
proportion oftotal motion that
is
contributedby
the radiocarpaljoint
differs for
each of the proximal row
bones.
For example,
during
flexion
the wrist traverses an angle of90
degrees.
The
scaphoidflexes
approximately 60 degrees
or about two-thirds of thefull
range offlexion,
the other third(30
degrees)
being
accountedfor
by
flexion
at the scapho-capitate
(midcarpal)
joint.
The
lunate,
on the otherhand,
flexes
about40
degrees,
accounting for less
than one-half ofthe total
flexion
of the wrist.The luno-capitate joint flexes
theremaining
50
degrees,
significantly
more thandoes
thescapho-capitate
joint.
The
triquetrumflexes
to an extentintermediate
between
thelunate
andscaphoid,
orabout45 degrees.
The
midcarpalextension of the wrist
traverses
a smaller angle(approximately
70
degrees),
the proportion of movementbetween
the radius and eachof the carpals and
between
each carpal and thefixed
unitis
thesame.
For example,
extension of the scaphoid accountsfor
abouttwo-thirds
of the total range of motion whereas thelunate
accountsfor
less
than one-half or about30
degrees
(Miller,
personalcommunication)
.Now
that wehave
established the general principles of wristmotion,
we can summarize all ofthis information
by
considering
each of the
basic
wrist motions separately.In extension,
the carpusrotates
70 degrees
dorsally
about an axis whichlies
in
the coronalplane and
is
perpendicular to thelong
axis of theforearm.
The
axisof rotation of the carpus
is
a point centeredin
thehead
of thecapitate.
The
fixed
unit pivots about this point while the proximalrow,
pressed against the articular surface of theradius,
slidesvolarly into
an extendedposition,
following
an arc whichis
alsocentered
in
the capitate.The
scaphoid extends about47
degrees,
thetriquetrum extends about
35
degrees,
and thelunate
about30
degrees.
The
fixed
unit extends relative to the proximal rowbones
forming
angles of23
,35,
and40
degrees
with thescaphoid,
triquetrum,
andlunate
respectively.In
flexion,
the carpus rotates about the same axisbut
movesvolarly
through an angle of about90 degrees.
As
the carpusis
drawn
into
thisposition,
it
impinges
on thedistal
pole of thescaphoid,
forcing
the proximal rowinto
flexion.
The
scaphoidflexes
approximately
60
degrees,
the triquetrumflexes 45
degrees,
and the50 degrees
with thescaphoid,
triquetrum,
andlunate,
respectively.Because
of theulnar-facing
slope of the articular surface of theradius, flexion is
always accompaniedby
a significantdegree
ofulnar
deviation.
In
radial and ulnardeviation,
the carpus rotates about an axisthat
lies
in
the sagittalplane,
lies
perpendicular to thelong
axis ofthe
forearm,
and passes through thehead
of the capitate.In
ulnardeviation,
the carpus rotatesmedially
about40
degrees.
The
proximal
row,
pressed against thesloping
surface of theradius,
is
forced
into
extension.As
with other movements of thewrist,
thescaphoid extends the
most,
then thetriquetrum,
and thelunate
extends the
least.
In
radialdeviation,
the carpusis
deflected
laterally,
toward theradius,
by
about10 degrees.
As
in
flexion,
thiscauses the
fixed
unit toimpinge
on thedistal
pole of the scaphoidWRIST
KINEMATICS:
AN
INTERACTIVE
TUTORIAL FOR THE
MACINTOSH
One
of the greatestdifficulties
in
understanding
thekinematics
of the wristis visualizing
the coordinated movement ofall of the carpals
in
severaldifferent
planes.While
a series of staticillustrations may be helpful in achieving
thisgoal,
an animatedsequence
is
much moredramatic
and effective.For
the major part ofmy
thesis ,I
chose to create an animated tutorial program that canbe
viewed on aMacintosh
computer.In
working
with several physicians atlocal
hospitals,
I
have
noticed that the
Macintosh is
the computer ofchoicein
the medicalfield.
However,
most offices are equipped with smallerMacs,
such asthe
Classic, Plus, SE,
orSE30,
which cannot readhigh-density
floppy
disks
and arelimited
to2
megabytes ofRAM
(Random Access
Memory).
Furthermore,
few
of these systemsinclude
any
sophisticated
hardware
(such
as aSyquest
removablehard
drive)
orsoftware.
I
decided
then tokeep
the tutorial as simple as possibleusing
thefollowing
guidelines.1)
the tutorial shouldbe
createdusing
a program thatis
inexpensive,
readily
available,
and requireslittle
memory;
2)
the tutorialitself
should requirelittle memory
andshould
fit
onto one or twolow-density
(800k)
floppy disks;
3)
it
should
be in black-and-white
at a resolution of72
dpi (dots
perinch)
so that
it
displays properly
on thesmall,
built-in
monitors of theUsing
thesecriteria,
I
immediately
ruled out two programwhich are popular choices
for
the
production of computer tutorials:Macromind
Directorand
Aldus
Supercard.
Macromind
Director
is
a
sophisticated,
full-color
animation program thatrequires a
Mac II
system orbetter,
a13 inch
, colormonitor,
and4
megabytes of
RAM.
A
typical tutorial produced with Director canoccupy
several megabytes ofmemory
and requires adata
cartridgeor portable
hard drive just
to transport acopy
of the program.Finally,
Macromind
Directoritself
has
a retail price of about$700
and
is
not"standard
equipment"on most
Macintosh
systems.Another
alternative,
Aldus
Supercard,
has
much moremodest requirements than
Macromind
Director,
but
it is
afull-color program that
simply
reproducedmany
of thefeatures
found
in
other,
less
expensive programs.The
most suitable choicefor my
thesis was
HyperCard,
a programdeveloped
by
Apple
andcurrently
licensed
toClaris.
Apple's latest
version of HyperCard(v.
2.1)
requires
approximately 700
kilobytes
(700k)
ofRAM,
can run onany
Macintosh
computer withoperating
system6.0.3
orhigher,
andis
limited
to72
dpi
black-and-white
images.
Most
importantly,
HyperCard
is distributed
at no additional charge with the purchaseof
every
newMacintosh
computer.It is
standard equipment onvirtually
every Mac currently
in
service.The
tutorial programs producedby
HyperCard are called"stacks."
A
stackis
agroup
of computerized "cards," whichdisplay
onthe screen one at a time.
The
author of the stack caninclude
avariety
of objects on a cardtext,
black-and-white
bitmapped
a short program or "script."
When
the user clicks on abutton
withthe
computer'smouse,
the scriptis
executed.A
scriptmay be
assimple as a command which tells HyperCard to proceed to the next card
in
thestack,
orit may initiate
a more complex set of tasks suchas
animation, making sounds,
oropening
a new stack.An
animatedsequence
is
producedby
creating
a set of cards that are allslightly
different,
and thenwriting
a short script that tells HyperCard toquickly
flip
through these cards.The
usermay simply
click on abutton,
executing
thescript,
and objects on screen will appear tomove as the
image
changesfrom
one card to another.The
first step
in
producing
this tutorial was to create thebasic
card
layout.
I
chose the standard 6x9"format
since thiscompletely
fills
the small screen oflow-end Macs
and showsup
well onlarger
screens as well.
I
find
that white text on ablack background
is
clearer and easier on the eyes than
black-on-white
(especially
on acomputer
screen),
soI
defined
a solidblack background for
all ofthecards.
Next,
I
created thebuttons
that allow the user to navigatethrough the stack of cards.
I
cut and pasted graphic elementsfrom
Claris'
copyright-free HyperCard
clip-art,
defined
each object as abutton,
and wrote a oneline
scriptfor
each.(Note:
a completeprintout of the
Wrist Kinematics
stackis included for
reference atthe end of this
thesis.)
The
broken
arrowbutton
allows the user tostart over
(return
to thefirst
card)
from any
cardin
the stack.The
stack of cards with a question mark allow the user to return to the
table of contents at
any
time,
and thethe
user toflip
forward
orbackward
through thestack,
one card at atime.
The
next,
and perhaps mostimportant,
step in creating
thistutorial
wasproducing
the artwork that appears on the cards.Initially,
I
hoped
to usehalf
tone
illustrations
throughout thestack,
converting
them tobitmapped
images
in
Adobe
Photoshop(v.
1.0.7)
prior toplacing
themin
the stack.First,
I
created threecarbon
dust illustrations
of thebones
of the wrist: a volarview,
adorsal
view,
and a superior viewlooking
down
thelong
axis of theforearm (Figures
5, 6,
and7).
I
scanned theseimages
into
aMacintosh Ilci using
aLaCie Silverscanner
and the Silverscanplug-in software
for Adobe Photoshop.
In
Photoshop,
I
cleanedup
theimages,
increased
theircontrast,
and convertedthem to72
dpi
black-and-white bitmaps.
Unfortunately,
the results were not asgood as
I
had hoped.
Because
of thelow
resolution,
theindividual
bones
of the wrist were nolonger
distinct
and their subtle surfacefeatures
were obscured.Since it is
soimportant
todistinguish
theindividual
carpalbones
in
thistutorial,
I
decided
to useline
rather thanhalftone
illustrations
throughout the stack.However,
the scanned carbondust
images
did
not go to waste.In
Photoshop,
I inverted
theimages
such thatthey
appeared as white onblack
instead
ofblack/gray
on a whitebackground,
andI
saved them ashigh-resolution greyscale
PICT files.
HyperCard
has
abuilt-in
feature
that allows a card to
display
aPICT
file
in
a specially-defined picturelow-resolution,
bitmapped images.
This
requireswriting
a short scriptfor
the card:on openCard
Picture
"dorsal.pictA",
Pict,
rect,
false
show window"dorsal.pictA"
at
272,30
endopenCard
on close
Card
close window "dorsal.pictA"
end closeCard
The Picture
commanddefines
thePICT
file
window,
thefilename
"dorsal.pictA"
is
the nameI
usedfor
thePICT
file showing
thedorsal
view of
the
wristbones,
and the show commanddisplays
the windowat the specified
x,y
coordinates.The
close command closes thewindow when the card
is
closed.Without
thiscommand,
the windowwould remain open throughout the rest of the tutorial.
I
placedPICT
windows on several cards at the
beginning
of the stackbecause
I
felt
they
added somedramatic
emphasis to the otherwisedrab display.
I
considered
using
PICT
windowsfor
all of theillustrations
in
thestack,
but found
this untenablefor
two reasons: thePICT
files
takeup
a great
deal
morememory
thando
thebitmapped images
on the cardsthemselves;
andit
takes timefor
thePICT
file
toload
whenit is
summoned
by
the show window command.On
less
Powerful
Macs,
this can take ten to
twenty
seconds.Obviously
this would not makefor
avery
effective animated sequence.To
create theline
illustrations
which makeup
thebulk
ofthestack,
I
saved abitmapped copy
of each scannedimage
and thenbrought
each oneinto Adobe
Illustrator(V.3.0)
as atemplate.
bone.
I
saved eachline
illustration
(Figures
9,10,
and11)
as anIllustrator
EPS
(Encapsulated
Postscript)
file
with aBlack
andWhite Macintosh Preview
sothat
it
canbe
openedin
Photoshop.
I
also created a
line illustration showing
a para-sagittal section of thewrist
(i.e.,
a"side
view"showing
the radius , proximal carpalrow,
capitate,
andthird
metacarpal) using
a scannedx-ray
as a template(Figure
12).
The
EPS
illustrations
cannotbe
pasteddirectly
into
HyperCard,
soI
first had
to open eachline
drawing
in
Photoshop,
convert
it
to
abitmap,
invert
it
(white-on-black
instead
ofblack-on-white),
and thencopy
and pasteit
into
the appropriate cardin
theHyperCard
stack.
Once
theimage
is
pastedinto
HyperCardand
properly
positioned on the correctcard,
it is
possible to make simplemodifications to
it
using
thedrawing
tools that come withHyperCard.
Most
of the arrows and all of thedot-pattern
fills
in
this stack were created
in
HyperCarditself.
Producing
theillustrations
in
Adobe
Illustratorgreatly
simplified the process of
creating
animated sequences.As
anexample,
I
willdescribe
in
detail
how
I
created one animatedsequence
showing
ulnardeviation
as seenfrom
thedorsal
surface ofthe
hand.
First,
I
opened"dorsal.line,"
the
Adobe
Illustratorline
drawing
of the wristbones in dorsal
view.With
thedirect
selecttool,
I
selected all of the carpal and metacarpalbones but
not the ulna orradius.
I
then chose the rotate tooland,
with the optionkey
depressed,
clicked at a point within thehead
of the capitatecorresponding
the center ofrotation of the carpus.Doing
sodefined
holding
the optionkey
whileclicking
opened the rotate tooldialog
box.
I
specified an angle of10 degrees
and clicked"OK."
This
causedthe
entire carpus(carpals
andmetacarpals)
to rotate10 degrees
clockwise
(toward
the
ulnain
thisview),
centered around a pointwithin the capitate.
I
saved thisimage
under a new name andrepeated the process
three
moretimes,
each timecausing
the carpustorotate an additional
10
degrees
toward
the ulna.In
addition to rotation of thecarpus,
ulnardeviation
involves
extension of the proximal carpal row.
In
thedorsal
view of thewrist,
thedistal
surfaces of the proximal row will turn toward theviewer while the proximal surface will rotate
away from
the viewer.To
simulate thisprocess,
it
wasnecessary
tomodify
the appearanceof the proximal carpal
bones
in
each successiveframe.
To
do this, I
compressed the
bones
to simulateforeshortening
andI
moved thelines representing
surface contours of thebones.
The final
line
illustrations
are shownin
figure 13.
In
theend,
I had five different dorsal
views of thewrist,
onein
the neutral position andfour
with the carpus rotated10,
20, 30,
and
40 degrees
toward the ulna.I
opened each of theseillustrations
in
Photoshop,
converted them tobitmaps,
inverted
them,
and thenpasted them
into five
successive cardsin
theWrist Kinematics
stack.To link
these cardsinto
an animatedsequence, I
created aninvisible
button
that covered the entire wristimage
on thefirst
card of thesequence.
I
opened thebutton
dialog
box
and wrote thefollowing
script
for
thebutton:
on mouse
Up
forward
When
the user clicks anywhere on the wrist(i.e..
on theinvisible
button),
HyperCardexecutes
the
command "forward."This is
not acommand which HyperCard
normally
understands soI
had
todefine
it.
On
the samecard, I
opened the carddialog
box
and clickedon the "script"
button.
In
the scriptdialog
box,
I
entered thefollowing
script:on
forward
repeat
4
go next card
wait
30
end repeat
end
forward
When
theforward
commandis
received,
this script tells HyperCardto close the current
card,
open the next card and wait30
ticks(
1
tick=
1/60
sec;
30
ticks =1/2
second). HyperCard will repeat this
process
four times, stopping
on thefifth
cardin
the sequence.The
wait30
command causes a shortdelay
before
the next cardis
opened,
giving
the user a chance to see the changes that occurwith each
10
degree
increment.
Without
such adelay,
the cardschange so
rapidly
thatit is
hard
tofollow.
Initially,
I
tried to createa
delay
between
frames
by
simply
duplicating
several copies of eachcard and
having
the animation cycle through alarger
number ofcards.
While
this produced thedesired
effect,
theduplicate
cardsoccupied a significant amount of
memory,
especially
sincethere
arefourteen
animated sequencesin
this stack.The
wait30
delay
methodis
much more economicalin
terms ofmemory
allocation.On
thefinal
card of each animatedsequence,
I
offer the userneutral position.
This is done
by
creating
anotherinvisible button
with the
following
button
script:on mouse
Up
backward
end mouse
Up
and the
following
card script:on
backward
repeat
4
go previous card
wait
30
end repeat
end
backward
Upon returning
to
thefirst
cardin
thesequence,
the userhas
theoption to view the animation again or proceed to the next topic
by
clicking
theforward
arrow.Clicking
theforward
arrowdoes
notallow the user to
flip
through theindividual
frames
of the animatedsequence.
Not every
illustration in
this stackis
part of an animation.Of
the seventy-nine
illustrations
in
theWrist Kinematics
stack,
fifty-two are
involved
in fourteen
animated sequences.To distinguish
these
illustrations
from
staticimages,
and toinitiate
theanimation, I
placed a white
box
withblack
lettering
on thefirst
andlast
cards ofeach sequence.
The
remainder of thelettering
in
the stackis
whiteon the
black
background.
To
create this whitelettering,
I
first
typedblack
lettering
on a whitebackground.
Then I
used the marqueeselection tool to
drag
abox
around thelettering
and chose theInvert
command
from
thePaint
menu.I
usedthe New
York Bold
font for
allof the
lettering;
18
point sizefor
majorheadings,
14
pointfor
So
far,
I
have
discussed
the techniquesI
usedfor creating
thecards,
text,
illustrations,
and animationsin
theWrist
Kinematics
stack.
However,
I
have
notdiscussed
the actual sequence of cardsin
the stack,
thetopics
covered,
and the orderin
which the user willmost
likely flip
through the
stack.In
concluding
thissection, I
willbriefly
"walk
through"the
stack,
imitating
the userflipping
through
the stack one card at atime.
Please
refer to the printout ofthe stack at the end ofthis thesis.
The first
cardis essentially
a cover page with aPICT
windowshowing
thedorsal
surface of the wristbones.
Some
of thenavigation
buttons,
including
"startover",
"forward",
and"backward",
areintroduced
on this card.The
second cardis
the tableof contents.
The
user can click onany
of the topicsin
thelist
andHyperCard
will
automatically
turn to that section of the stack.This
card
has
aPICT
windowshowing
a volar view of the wrist and alsointroduces
the "contents"button
which allows the user to return tothe table of contents
from any
cardin
the stack.The
third cardbegins
a section whichbriefly
reviews theosseous
anatomy
of the wrist.It includes
aPICT
window ofthe volarsurface of the
wrist,
as well asline
illustrations
with certainbones
stippled to
identify
the proximal anddistal
rows.The
final
cardin
this section shows the superior view of the wrist
in
both
PICT
andline formats.
The
next sectiondeals
with theterminology
of wristmovements:
flexion,
extension,
radialdeviation,
ulnardeviation,
supination,
and pronation.Three
animatedsequences,
comprising
illustrations
createdin
Adobe
Illustratorfrom
a
pencil-drawing
template.
The
third sectionillustrates
carpal motionduring
wristmovements.
It
starts with adiscussion
of the concept ofdegrees
offreedom
and the potential complexities of carpalkinematics.
Six
cards then
detail
the anatomic constraints which serve tosimplify
our
understanding
of carpalmotion,
including
thelinking
ofbones
into
afixed
unit and proximal row.This
section continuesby
discussing
some of the general principles of wristmotion,
including
the
location
of a rotational center within thecapitate, indicated
onthe
illustrations
by
theintersection
of perpendicular axes.The
rotation of the carpus about this point
is demonstrated
with twoanimated sequences
showing lateral
(ulnar)
deviation
andflexion.
Also
discussed in
this sectionis
theflexion
or extension of theproximal row
during
movements of the wrist.Three
animatedsequences
illustrate
this phenomenon and also showhow
the threeproximal row
bones flex
and extend todifferent degrees.
The Wrist
Kinematics
tutorial concludes with asummary
ofeach of the principle wrist motions and one or two animated
sequences
illustrating
each.To demonstrate flexion
andextension,
the wrist
is
shownin
parasagittal cross-section.To
demonstrate
radial and ulnar
deviation,
the wristis
shownfirst from
the volarsurface and then
from
thedorsal
surface.In
every
case,
the viewermay
choose to reverse the animation or move on to the nexttopic.
The final
cardin
the stackis
a shortlist
of references thatFigure
1.
Cadaver
wrist(left)
dissected
at thelevel
of theradiocarpal
joint
to show theanatomy
of theTriangular
Fibrocartilage Complex (blow-up).
Refer
tofigure
4
for
akey
to theFigure 3.
Right
wrist of the same cadaver asin
figure
2,
showing
an unusual tear of theTFCC.
The
articulardisk has
almostcompletely
Figure 4.
Possible
textbooklayout
ofTFCC illustrations.
Text
andFigure
17
A)
Normal anatomy
ofthe
triangularfibrocartilage
complex.B.
)
Tear
ofthe
TFCC
leaving
aloose
flap
whichhas
calcified.C.
)
Perforation
ofthe
TFCC
exposing
the
ulnar
head
proximally.B
andC
arethe
right andleft
wrists ofthe
same cadaver.Abbreviations: ad,
articulardisc;
mh,
meniscushomologue;
ul,
ulnolunateligament;
uta,
ulnotriquetral
ligament;
ecu,
extensorcarpiulnaristendon;
u,
ulna;
ust, ulnarstyloid; scf,
Figure 5.
Volar
view of thebones
of the wrist.For
akey
to theFigure 7.
Superior
view of the carpalbones
looking
down
thelong
axis of
the
forearm.
The
concave volar surfaceis
the carpal tunnel.V
Figure 8.
Possible
textbooklayout
of wristbone
illustrations.
Text
Volar
Dorsal
Superior
Figure 1.
Volar, dorsal,
and superiorviews of
the
carpalbones.
Abbrevia
tions:
ca, capitate;
h, hamate; hi, lunate;
p,
pisiform;
r, radius;
sc,
scaphoid;
td,
trapezoid;
tm,
trapezium;
ta
tri
quetrum;
u, ulna; ust,
ulnarstyloid; rst,
Figure 9.
Adobe
Illustratorline
illustration
of the volar view ofthe wrist.
To
createthis illustration I
used a scanned version of theFigure 10.
Adobe
Illustratorline
illustration
of thedorsal
viewof the wrist.
I
used thedorsal
view carbondust
(figure
6)
as aFigure
11.
Adobe
Illustratorline
illustration
of the carpalbones in
superior view.The
carbondust
illustration
of the carpalFigure
12.
Adobe
Illustratorline
Figure
13.
Five
line
illustrations,
all createdin
Adobe
Illustrator,
which were used to create an animated sequenceshowing
ulnardeviation,
a.) Dorsal
view of the wristin
the neutral position,b.)
Same
wrist with10
degrees
of ulnardeviation
of the carpus,c.)
20 degrees
of ulnardeviation,
d.)
30
degrees
of ulnarFigures 14
100.
A
complete printout of theWrist
Kinematics
Hyper