7KH )DFWRUV (IIHFW WKH 9HQXH 6HOHFWLRQ DQG
-RLQLQJ WR 3K\VLFDO $FWLYLW\ RI WKH 8VHUV 9LVLW
µg]JUON 3DUN DQG 5HFUHDWLRQ¶ DUHD IRU
3K\VLFDO$FWLYLW\
!"#$!%!&'()#"!*$'!+#
+,+"
$" !"%!(*&'()#"!*$'!+#
+,$"+"
!"$'$!"(#&'(-+"
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
,QWURGXFWLRQ
+# , ( # ## !(( #! 2! #,# #!" # # '' 2 ! # # ! !' qwx/ <" "! , # !,! 2 !,( 20#'#"! (!!## / +#! 2( 2 !' (# # !/ +" # ! # # '#"! (!! 0#! # 2!!! # !!! 2"#!qzx/B(###'####! 0"!2(#'"''!!(##"/%(!'!!2 !"# !#0####>',0!'' , 0# ## ',/ % ! ( # {##7 0 ! #! '(.',#0###,!!(,!'! .!!q;x/
+#6#,(###!(0!F+###!#!( ((##'!#!#(>20(,,#!|#!!!'! 2!!2!!2q8x/+!#A,,!!.'#!0 !###"(#2"2"0!!0( ,!!q8x/
+#! 0"!''###/(#, 0# #! ((! ! # !' 2(" qzx/ +# ! #! !!!("#{!'7'!#2,',,!0! ###(#'!,,'#"!,'!"#,!' !# ,!2,!# '(! qwx/}, '! "(((!!!(###! !'!2"#!'!2!#0#!'!(!" '!/ }!#'#"!!'! !22,!## !#"!'"##",2"',#(#(2 #2! !2!# !! # 2 ! 20 2# '! > !2"!,#(="q:x/
+# !'! '! # ! ( # , ! # ! ! (!!##" !/+#'!' !(!! # , # !! 2 ##" =" ( # ! ( # !! # ' =(! ( !# (( ! # '' ! ! 0 q~x/ !, # ( ! 2" '#"! .!! !'! ! # ' # ! ( # #," " ( # '' # !!! qx/ +# 6 # , # {< ( 6 # &"7 !, w# ' 88/ , # ( 6 #,#''." ''!' '#"! "q8x/'!#, '!.!,# , ( 0!', ### ( .!! !( #/ # ! # !!" ( , # ' ( !' ( ,! ! 2 # {(>,!'7''/%#;z8!# !!#!(!2'' !(# ,!"/%"2!!(# !! !! #! !! # !' !' "0# !! "q;x/
#!|# ( 0/ +# , ( #! ! , # 2" !( "#!,( "' '!"/$# 2((!0qx/
+#(!'!!!'2"# !!((>0 (!" ! (/ +# ''! ( #! '!! ! # # ( 0( ( # ( qx/ % ! ' !#! # # ! 0# # .! 0(''#''0# "# !qx
( # '' (! ( !!, # ##" ( ! # '#"! "/ 0 ''# !!'! #!!((!'! 0# # '! #! ! 2 ' (!" 0# !' q8x/ $ # '!! # 2" ( # '! 0# ! !' 0 ! # , #! !!(2, 0,#2!#(!(# !!!!#!2!!#,##!!##2" q4x/
+#'#"! "!2" '!!,#!2,##"(/ +#! 2" ! 2! ( ! !! !# ! !,#, # ! !"! !! ' , # !'! !! 0,#, !! '#"!'2"/+#'#"! !(="#'0# !"! #'! # !!! !# ! # ! ! !!!"'2!2!"q;x/+#'#"! "#!'! ((!# '2##/+#.!!' !((,!!"2" # 0,# / < # '! ! # ' ( '! '0 ! # ! ! ! # # ( =" (qx/
# '' ( # ! ( '#"! (!! ## (>, !' ! ##" " ! q4x/ 6# " ! ! , ( (, '#"! " #" ! , (( !! ''" #! ( ',! qx/ +#! ',! '#! # ( 2!! # 2(! ( !' '#"! "/+##!','#"! "' ! #,#"(0((0#!!(!#,0,!!!2"# 0,!!2!#!#'#"!!2"q:x/
+#'({# (!7#2!'"2""#! ((!2!!#'!(#(!2"!(!' ! 0# # ! !/ +# # ! (!#, 2" "( !.!!!(!##.'!(#'!!# ( , '! " q~x/ % 2( # ! # " ! 2" ! .! # ( / +#! " " 2 # '#"! ! #,#q;x/
%#!.#,(#!!"!"#' ,(!(,# '#"! ! #0 #'! !! !'#"! " '!/ ! #! !# 0 ! 2! " 2 # ! ! 2 ! ( # !! ( ', !# !/ < , 0" ( 2" (!>,0, ! 2, ( ( 2" ,, !" #," '' " '! ( '#"! " (/ +# !! ! 2 ' ! 2" # ( , !2!#''(2,'#"###!( # ' !!! ( #!/%2 ##!!"0 #!'!/%#! !" ! 0 # .' ! ( # !! ( " '! 2" 2, ', # 0 ! , ( ! ( #0 # '''"!'!("/%!#,###!!#2!#','!! (0'!/
0HWKRG
+# !,!#! "!{5,)-71!2/ }(2,#=!!#!! !5,)-0"0!(20#"#!! "!#0 #" !# 2 !0/ % ! =! # ! !! 0 # =!!/ %!.' # !,! ## =! ! 2 2" !0/
+# 0," ( =!! # (! # # !0 # !!.?48=!!@0##2(48'' #! " "/"88!#!'(# !,/
5HVHDUFK*URXS
+# '' ( # " 2" !" ( # ! ! !#!'!(#!!({5,)-70#4 ,3"/48''0# 3"!(1!2) ! {5, ) -7 #! ! "/ 88 ( ! #!'( "2"2".,#0,"((!/+# ,,(#!88''!204z8/*!!!(#!! #'"!#!"!#,#!# !")!/+# !2088+!#8/888+!#!/
'DWD&ROOHFWLRQ7RROV
+#! "!!#!!## "''!/+#~=!!#(! ', 2 # ,'# (! ( # !! ! # ' / # !',##! "0#4=!!2#!!(!,#' ! # '#"! " # #" , # =! !!, ( z =!!2#(!' #'#"! "/%#!!"0##(! ', #! ,'# =!! # ! ', # ! # +0> )#"! "!!!!$?)$@!!#!!(2,!("' !#'#"! "/+#!+0>)#"! "!!!!$0! 2#!!!q4x/
#!#'#"! "'/+#!#!!,(4!!4'A> "' ?F E F %' F % !7 :F ' 4F C" '|)"@/ +# !2>! ( # (! ' # , # '#"! " !! # (! ' # ( '' # ' !/ +# ! # !!, ( z ! ! ! 4 ' A>"' ?F 2!"&!,F&!,F}",:F,4F2!",@q4x/ 6##'(2,'#!!!!!!!!#+" (!"!><">?<@!!''!0###2 ( 2# 0 ! "! '" 0# (2" } ! ! .0###2(!'2(#''? !@!,# ( ( "!!/ ( # ( " '!! ( # !! )' E' "!!!!#! "2"(2#0!!/ +#E2#'# !!#!!"2"( #!!!!#02##0!!!#(, q4x/
$QDO\VLVRIWKH'DWD
$)$$ w ', !(0 ! ! ! # 2 # ( # '!!/ +# !' !!! #! ?(=" ',@ (#'!!/%'$'!+>+!#=!!( " !,( (( .!! ! ( # , !! ( # !0##"#!#!'!!#)#"! "!/>6"BC ##'!0###!,(((!(# !! ( # ! 0# #" #! #! '! ?) - !@ ! # '#"! "/%!!2(#!!,(((!( #,!!20#!!' #''!(#! " # '#"! "/ >6" BC ! ! ! 0## # ! ,( (( ! ( # !! 20 # !! ' # !''#!!('#"! "/
)LQGLQJV
7DEOH&,'#%(+2()'C!#)-!
C2! 9 +
< ;; :;4
88
8 484
<!!
< w8 44
88
$, 8 ~44
*$!
)"* 8
88
$"* ; :4
,#$# w z4
!" : ~4
)! z :8
888>888 4 ~8
888>4888 ~ 8
4888>8888 w z4
2
$ z :84
88
B! ~ 8
'" 4
$(>'" :: 8
*, ; :4
+# z ;8
!0( 4 w4
- ~ 8
)#! 4
& ; :4
E# 4
-& 4
2 4
A0" 4
,
4>8 48 48
88
>~ ~: 8
w> ~ 8
>z w z4
;>:: 84
:4>48 z :8
4>4~ : 8
4w>~ 4
~>~z 4
~;>w: 8
w4>z8 8
7DEOH+>+!-!!(#$)!(!) #)'C$ ",,#
!! '
)#"! " C$
;; z8w 4~4
>w~ :~; < 8 zwz w;w
!) #)' )#"! "
;; z; ;;
>~8 8; < 8 8z~ 4w
+# ! !,( (( , # , # ! '! ( # ! ! 5, ) - ( '#"! " q>w~ 'D/84x/ +#! ! 2 ! # !! ( '#"! " 7 (( 0#,#,/
7DEOH+>+!-!!(#$)!(#!) )#"! "
C$
<$! !! '
)#"! " C$
< w8 4; 4:
>zz 888 $, 8 ;ww w:
!) # )')#"! "
< w8 w:w 8:
>w 8; $, 8 8z4
E,#!(,#>"'#!!{%!#,((( ,,#,20#!'!('' !5,)-('#"! "7!#!!,(((!!/
}!!#!!!2!!'"!(#,!'!( '' 2 # !! ( '#"! ! #! ! q>~8 'D/84x/+# ' ,!(0?.z;@2#!!( '#"! !#!!#,###!!(!?.8z~@/ +#! (, 2 ' ! # ! '! 2 # !! ( '#"! ! #! ! 7 (( ,, # ,/ }! #! ! # >: "'#!! {%! # !,( (( ! ( # ,!'!(''2#!!('#"! ! #!!7!#!!,(!'"/
+# ! ' (( ! ( # !! # ! '! ( '' !5,)('#"! "/q>zz'/84x/+#! (, 2 ! # !! (( ! ( # !!/ , #! (, # > "'#!! {%! # ,( ((!!,,#!!!'!( !('' ! 5, ) ( '#"! "7 ! ' # !,( !'".!!/
!!/}!#!(,#>4"'#!!{%!#!,((( ! ( # !! ! '! ( !!( ! #! ! 2" '' ! 5, ' ( '#"! "7 ! ' #,(((.!!/
7DEOH-!!(BC(*$!-!!()!+!+ *(
*$!($)!(!) )#"! "C $
*
$! !! ( ' + *
)#"! " C !
)"
$# :~ z
;8 8 >: $"
$# ; ; ~~
,#$# w w:8 4~4
!" : ;: w4~
)!
z 8w4 :4
+ 88 z: ~;
! ' #
'#"! "
)"
$# ~ 8z~
~4 8: >4 $"
$# ; z44 w~:
,#$# w w:4 8
!" : 8z 8w
)!
z zw ::
+ 88 ;; 8z8
+# ! !,( (( ! ( # !! !!'!('' !5,'('#"! "/ q(;8'D/84x/+#!(,2'!# !!(5,' !7((,#!!/
}!#!!#>"'#!!{%!#,(!'" !(#!! !!'!('' !#!!7 !#!!,(((/
+#!!'((,,#!!!'!( #!!('#"! !5,'!( '#"! "/q(~4'D/84x/+#!2!#!'!( #!!('#"! !#!!7((,, #!!/
! 5, ' 7 ! !,( (( 2(/
, # !! ( +" ! # ! ,( (( ( # ! !'!20'" !" q(~z'D/84x/ !,( (( 2 ( 20 " ,# !# ! 0/ q(z'D/84x/+#!'!'"20'"'! , q(z8 'D/84x 2 2 (( ! ( 0# # '" !# ,!2#!'/q(4w'/84x/%2!#!# # ! " ,( (( 20 # ! '! ( '' ( '" !# !",!/
'LVFXVVLRQDQG&RQFOXVLRQ
+#'!22,!#'!!#'#"! "'! # ' , # ( # (! ' # '' ! ! # ( # !! ( '#"! "/ % 0# # 2! !2(#!(,!!'!!2' !!2( (#!!('#"! "0###'(',,!!/ % ! " #! !" # !'(" # (! (( # '' ! ( '#"! " ! ( # 2! ( , , !! !!##"(#!!3"1!2/
%!(##!!(#'#"! !#! !7((0#,#,/%#0!#!!( #'#"! "#!!7#,!(2,(/%! '#!!###! !!'#"! " ! # ! ( 2# 0 / $, >} + <= # !" 2 # !! ( ", !0! !' # #!!2!((2!#,qzx/
% ! 0# #! (,! #! / # !# # # ,>2!((''!#''!((!# '#"! " qwx/ , #! #! #! (( !" !! ( # !" ''/ +#( # 0 !(" '' " # ''((!#'#"! "#!!/+#!!(5, )!(#! !!!0##(#! /?+2>@/##!!#!#(+!0#:~ :4(!## !(# !(,#.! 7 (( ! ( # !! !2>!! q:x/ # # # 2 ! #,# !## # ! (( ! ( # !! ( , '#"! !/ % 0# #! ! # !! ( # '' #! '! ! ((! '' ( '' '#"! " #! !/ % > !! ! # 0 ' # !! ( !, # ,0# # #!0!#" " !' ('#"! " 0 !" ' # # ( ( 2, , " (( # '' # '#"! " ?+2>@/ +# ! ( !,( (( !! '! ( '#"! "/ +#! " 2 ( 2,!#,!(!2!,/6' ## ! #'2#(!(#("/
! 2 # ( !! # =! ##" ,0!!/$"&!$# !<2#(## ''#'#"! !0#0'!0# #2#!q:x/%'0##!''#!#!"(32!#0! # .'/ 3 ' # # !! (( ,,#!!qx/
+# ! ( ' !'" 0# , # , ' ,'!#"!'!2#'#"! ! '!/%#0!#!!!7((2!#, , 2 # #" !!/ } ! ( #! !# # # '' ( # 0 " # '' # ! '2 q~x/ < , # ! ( # # , ! ( ((##'#"! "#", !#" #'#"! "##!qx/
+#!!!2022"#!!##! # (! ' # ( # ( , # '#"! ! # ! "! # ,'# (! 2! # 2! ( ,!!!! 2,/
% ! # ( # !# # # (! # !( ( ! 7 (( ,, # 2! ( , 2 , 2!/ % # 0! 2, ( !, #,# 0 7((#!#'!!#'#"! "/
+#!(((2!#,0##(!' # "/ +# , ! ! # #/ % # (, !,( (( ! ,, # !!/ +# ! , !'" # !( !'!0##!,!/%!!# #(!# #0'",!'!!#!,!!# !#!((!/$##!#!0###!( (#!#"##"7(!/%!!,,!# !! # '",! # !#! # !!! ( (!0##(!/
8 ( # ! 2#! 2 w8 ( # , ( # !" 20/ }! #! (, # #,#>!# , '' 0# '( #'!#"/+## !, ! )! 2 ! #! " / % # # # ,,, ! "'! "((# !/6!###(! (''(#,,'#!!/2# !# ! !,( (( 20 # '" !" '" ##,#!#/},(((.!!20# ! ,(#'" # !"/+#!!2.'2"#! !! # %7 ! # ! !! ( # , # ,'!#2 ' #((!# !/
5HIHUHQFHV
/ $/ +', </ 2" / }" </ ) / ?88~@/ A!+*!%'/(B*?w8@F /
/ 3 $/?88z@/ - < E!! *.' (
/ &"/?88@/$#>}!)#"! "# ,FE% E)#"!" !/?4:@F>/
:/ &!</$# !E+</<2#)/?88@/*A &!! A! + )#"! "F )! ( # A, A}*$"/(*'E"#/44?z@F4~>4~z/
4/ /?8@/ +# ! (( # C $
)#"! "(# !!C!#)-!/
~/ !/?;;4@/0!#'($'F%!%'-)'(
,6/)#6!!F*#E0 !"&'( A!$!/
w/ #!E/}0</E/?88@/!!F
.(,0,/$#!,"/F> /
z/ 2 / ?88@/ # E!! $' ! / */ }!F
*}!
;/ $/?88z@/- !(+/~#*/F
}!/
8/<*/?88:@/!!*.!/>w
/ A/ # / ?;;~@/ A( E! E#,! # E!'
A! !(<6/(&,%!!!~Fz84>zw/ /A!" }</ 6 A/ )!# */ ! E/?88:@/ )#"! "
" ( A(F !!!!, # %( ( " =" %!" C< !/}# </?8@:>/
/<)# / A"! &/ $/ ,#! </ $/ /?88@/ 0 ( A(, % $' )#"! "F # %!# )!' /A!$!/;?@Fz4>88/
:/<,"$/&/?88@/$'!!$)(#
"'! '' < ( , E# $'! +" }! $'!+,/!/1!2"'!)'-, }*)2!#,BF/
4/7E </ A2 A/ )! $/?88~@/ +# ! . ,
, ! ! !,! '#"! " ( # 0# 2/ ) -'/ ( C! %' }!! ,! :w> :wz/
~/52" $/ 2 </?8@/ +# 2!! ( -/ %F < B/ */ %$'!$!/F$')2!#,!/:>w8/
w/5 /?88@/ )#"! !!/ * F B2 )2!#,
&!2/
z/$, / >} -/ + E/ <= $/?88:@/ -!#' }0 ) )#"! 2" $' )' < ! , E' $0!/ ( $'! < )#"! !!/ ::?@F ;:>;;/
;/$'( </ }/ <! */ - *}/ 6 6E/?888@/ )" ) (E"&!!6#,#&A(!"/B0 *,(<:?@F~>/
8/+ & ?884@/ + $/ 8/ }!3/ F + & "33/
/+/-/ +/?88:@/$!$'
+'!/F}3}!/
/+</?;;:@/$,"( !,#A!+/:/*/F
/+!/?884@/A!-<,/4#*/AF -,/
:/+!*/?884@/E!!>E$"(%(() )!
)' -, -F , , ! !"$!/A!$!/w?4@Fz4>:8:/
4/C$///"//E//
?88:@/&()#"! "A ,!/
~/C /?;;@/ &(! ( A! -/ -' (F
!(A!-/?:@F::>:z4/
w//?8@/$,"$'!/F})2!#,!/
z/2*/?88@/)#"!!!/*/F}!/
;/2*/1E/+/</2*/?88~@/$'!(/
1!2F<'E)2!#,!/
8/6 # ,/?88@/6 # -'/
#'F||000/0#/|0#|88||./#