/RVSHFRVRV
0DUFHOD3D]
3UHPLR0XQLFLSDOGH
/LWHUDWXUD
/RVSHFRVRV ,OXVWUDFLRQHV$OHMDQGUD$FRVWD$ 'LUHFFL³QOLWHUDULD6HUJLR7DQKQX]3 (GLFL³Q0DUD3D]$OHJUD0 'LUHFFL³QGHDUWH&DUPHQ*ORULD5REOHV6 'LDJUDPDFL³Q*DEULHOD'HOD)XHQWH* 3URGXFFL³Q$QGUHD&DUUDVFR= 3ULPHUDHGLFL³QGLFLHPEUHGH 7HUFHUDHGLFL³QGLFLHPEUHGH j(GLFLRQHV0DUFHOD3D] j(GLFLRQHV60&KLOH &R\DQFXUDRILFLQD 3URYLGHQFLD6DQWLDJRGH&KLOH ZZZHGLFLRQHVVPFO FKLOH#HGLFLRQHVVPFO $7(1&,1$/&/,(17( 7HO©IRQR 5HJLVWURGHSURSLHGDGLQWHOHFWXDO ,6%13DSHO ,6%1'LJLWDO (GLFL³Q'LJLWDOPDU]R ,PSUHVL³Q6DOHVLDQRV,PSUHVRUHV *HQHUDO*DQD6DQWLDJR ,PSUHVRHQ&KLOH3ULQWHGLQ&KLOH 1RHVW¡SHUPLWLGDODUHSURGXFFL³QWRWDORSDUFLDOGHHVWHOLEURQLVX WUDWDPLHQWRLQIRUP¡WLFRQLVXWUDQVPLVL³QGHQLQJXQDIRUPDRSRU FXDOTXLHUPHGLR\DVHDGLJLWDOHOHFWU³QLFRPHF¡QLFRSRUIRWRFRSLD SRUUHJLVWURXRWURVP©WRGRVVLQHOSHUPLVRSUHYLR\SRUHVFULWRGHORV WLWXODUHVGHOFRS\ULJKW 1&+
,91 \ 3DQFKRFR LEDQ FDPLQR D OD IDUPDFLD +DEDQ LQVWDODGR VX ODERUDWRULR \ FOQLFD \ DO WLHPSR GH HVWUHQDUOD VH GDEDQ FXHQWD GH TXH KDFD IDOWD OR P¡V LPSRUWDQWH HO FORURIRUPR ,EDQ PX\ GHFLGLGRV D FRPSUDUOR WUHQ]DGRV HQ DEXUULGD GLVFXVL³Q
ߚ3DUD TXH WH FRQYHQ]DV GH TXH QR SDVDU¡ QDGD PH FORURIRUPDU¡V D P SULPHUR ߚGHFD 3DQFKRFR ߚ7HFORURIRUPR VL PH GHMDV RSHUDUWH 6L QR QROHYHRHOFKLVWH ߚb%DK4X©JUDFLD1RYDPRVDRSHUDUDWRGR HOPXQGR/HYDPRVDVDFDUODVYHUUXJDVDOD-XDQD \ODYDPRVDFORURIRUPDUSDUDTXHQROHGXHOD(O FORURIRUPR QR HV QDGD (Q (VWDGRV 8QLGRV FORURIRUPDQDWRGRHOPXQGR 3DQFKRFRYHQDOOHJDQGRGHQRUWHDP©ULFD\VH FUHD OD PXHUWH $ FDGD UDWR HVFDQGDOL]DED D VXV SULPRV FKLOHQRV 9LYDQ MXQWRV 7HQD 3DQFKRFR QXHYHD±RVH,Y¡QRFKR\VHGHIHQGDQGHORVFXDWUR KHUPDQRVPHQRUHVGH,Y¡QTXHHVWURSHDEDQVLHPSUH VXVDYHQWXUDV
ߚ(Q&KLOHWDPEL©QFORURIRUPDQ$PLPDP¡ OD KDQ FORURIRUPDGR VHLV YHFHV 3HUR VLHPSUH IXHURQP©GLFRVߨ
ߚ$OO¡ QR OR KDFH FXDOTXLHUD 3RU OR GHP¡V \R WRPR OD UHVSRQVDELOLGDG < SRU ºOWLPR TX© WH LPSRUWDDWLVLOD-XDQDTXLHUHTXHODFORURIRUPH"
ߚb0LUD ߚLQWHUUXPSL³ ,Y¡Q DSXQWDQGR DOJR HQPHGLRGHODFDOOH
(UD XQ SHUUR ORV GRV VH DFHUFDURQ D PLUDUOR (VWDEDPXHUWR\ODDFWLWXGGHVXVSDWDVH[SUHVDEDHO GRORU TXH VX FDUD GH SHUUR QR SRGD H[SUHVDU 3DQFKRFRVHHQFXFOLOO³SDUDWRFDUOR1RHVWDEDIUR \DSHQDVWHQDXQSRFRGHVDQJUHHQHOKRFLFR
ߚ$ORPHMRUHVW¡DWXUGLGRߚGLMR,Y¡QQRPX\ FRQYHQFLGR
ߚb6KRFN (VW¡ VKRTXHDGRߨ ߚ3DQFKRFR OR OHYDQW³ HQ VXV EUD]RV 8Q EDUUHGRU GH OD FDOOH VH DFHUF³DOJUXSR\ORTXHG³PLUDQGRFRQXQDSL]FD GHULVDHQVXVRMRVFDQVDGRV
ߚ(VVX\R"ߚOHSUHJXQW³D3DQFKRFR ߚ1R9LRXVWHGFXDQGRORDWURSHOODURQ"
(OKRPEUHDVLQWL³FRQODFDEH]D
ߚ/HSDV³SRUDWUDYHVDUODFDOOHVLQPLUDU1R OR KDU¡ QXQFD P¡V ߚHO EDUUHGRU VRQUL³ DQWH VX FKLVWH
$SR\DGR HQ HO SDOR GHO HVFRELOO³Q PLUDED D ORVQL±RVHVSHUDQGRTXHFHOHEUDUDQVXVSDODEUDV ߚ+DFHPXFKRUDWR" ߚ5HFLHQFLWR QR P¡V (UD XQ DXWD]R OLQGR \ FROXGRߨ ߚb$OJºQVDOYDMH ߚ/OHY©PRVORDFDVD3RGHPRVKDFHUORYROYHU GHOVKRFNߚGLMR,Y¡Q
ߚ3DUHFH PXHUWRߨ ߚ3DQFKRFR DFDULFLDED DO SHUURWUDWDQGRGHVHQWLUHORSWLPLVPRGHVXSULPR TXHVLHPSUHYHDDOJºQUHPHGLRDORVGHVDVWUHV
$SXUDEDQ HO SDVR GH UHJUHVR ,Y¡Q FRQ OD HVSHUDQ]DGHYROYHUDODYLGDDODQLPDO3DQFKRFR WHPLHQGR TXH GH SURQWR DSDUHFLHUD DOJXLHQ D UHFODPDUOR6HQWDSRUHOSHUURXQYHUGDGHURFDUL±R XQDHQRUPHWHUQXUD\OHKDEDDUUHJODGRODVSDWDVGH PDQHUDTXHSDUHFLHUDGRUPLGRHQVXVEUD]RV
/OHJDURQSRUILQDODFDVD\HQWUDURQFRUULHQGR VLQ KDFHU UXLGR SDUD QR VHU GHVFXELHUWRV SRU ORV FKLFRV3HURHVRHUDLPSRVLEOH-XQWRFRQHQWUDUHQ HO ODERUDWRULR DVRP³ SRU OD YHQWDQD OD FDEH]D GH $QGHFR UXELR \ FKDVF³Q FRQ VXV HQRUPHV RMRV QHJURVVLHPSUHLQWHQVRV
ߚb$ WRPDU W© ߚFKLOO³ FRQ VX YRFHFLWD GHVWHPSODGDߚb+D\JDOOHWDVߚSDV³HOGDWRSHUR VHLQWHUUXPSL³ߚ4X©WLHQHQDK"
ߚb/R TXH D WL QR WH LPSRUWD ߚOD YHQWDQD VH FHUU³ GH JROSH 3HUR HO LQWUXVR IXH WDQ U¡SLGR TXH DOFDQ]³ D SDVDU PHGLR FXHUSR SRU OD SXHUWD MXVWR FXDQGR,Y¡QLEDDSRQHUOHOODYH
ߚb/¡UJDWHߚ\ODSXHUWDVHHQFDUJ³GHTXHOD RUGHQ VH FXPSOLHUD $QGHFR TXHG³ DIXHUD IXULRVR SRU QR WRPDU SDUWH HQ HO ߡPLVWHULRߢ TXH HVWDED VXFHGLHQGR HQ HO FXDUWXFKR GH KHUUDPLHQWDV TXH WHQDHVHOHWUHURGH
/$%25$725,2<&/1,&$ b6HSURKEHHQWUDU
+DEDQ WHQGLGR DO SHUUR VREUH OD PHVD GH RSHUDFLRQHV FXELHUWD SRU XQ VDFR \ PLHQWUDV ,Y¡Q SUHSDUDEDXQDLQ\HFFL³Q3DQFKRFRIURWDEDODSLHUQD GHOSHUURFRQXQDOJRGRQFLWRFRQSDUDILQD
ߚb/LVWR ߚGLMR ,Y¡Q SDVDQGR OD MHULQJD P¡V OOHQD GH DLUH TXH GH RWUD FRVDߚ <R LU© PLHQWUDV WDQWRDEXVFDUXQSRFRGHFDI©
ߚb7RQWR $ ORV SHUURV QR VH OHV GD FDI© 4XL]¡VDJXDUGLHQWHߨ
3DQFKRFRFODY³ODDJXMDFRQWRGDVXHQHUJDHQ OD SLHUQD GHO SHUUR $O FRPSULPLU HO ©PEROR OD
SLHUQDVHHVWLU³
ߚb1R HVW¡ PXHUWR ߚJULW³ WULXQIDQWHߚ b+D HVWLUDGR OD SLHUQD <R WH GHFD TXH HUD XQ VLPSOH
VKRFN7UDHEROVDVFDOLHQWHVߨ
9RO³ HO SUDFWLFDQWH D FXPSOLU ODV ³UGHQHV GHO P©GLFR MHIH \ HQ XQ PRPHQWR HVWDED GH YXHOWD KDFLHQGR IULHJDV PDVDMHV DSOLFDQGR UHVSLUDFL³Q DUWLILFLDO1RIDOW³DOJXLHQTXHHFKDUDJRWDVGHYLQR HQHOKRFLFRGHOSHUUR
(QVXDOERURWR\DQRLPSRUWDEDTXHVHOOHQDUD GH JHQWH HO ODERUDWRULR /RV FKLFRV VH HPSXMDEDQ FRRSHUDQGR FRQ UHPHGLRV WHWHUDV DOJRGRQHV \ GHPDVHV
3RUILQ3DQFKRFRFRQWU¡JLFRGHVDOLHQWRWLU³ OHMRVVXLQVWUXPHQWDOVDOYDGRU
ߚ(VW¡ P¡V PXHUWR TXH HO ߡVROGDGR GHVFRQRFLGRߢ ߚGLMRߚ 5HFLEL³ HO JROSH HQ HO FHUHEURߨ
/RV JUDQGHV RMRV GH ,Y¡Q VH SXVLHURQ EULOODQWHV +DVWD HVH PRPHQWR KDED WHQLGR OD VHJXULGDG GH TXH HO SHUULWR YLYLUD \ DOFDQ]³ D LPDJLQDU HO FDUL±R \ DJUDGHFLPLHQWR GHO DQLPDO UHVXFLWDGR
ߚ(OW©GHEHHVWDUIURߚGLMRODYR]GH-XDQD TXHPLUDEDODPDQLREUDSRUHQFLPDGHVXVFDEH]DV
ߚb4XL©Q TXLHUH W© ߚH[FODP³ 3DQFKRFR GHM¡QGRVH FDHU VREUH HO GLY¡Q GH OD FOQLFD XQ
FDM³Q GH IUXWDߚ b9¡\DQVH WRGRV \ G©MHQQRV SHQVDU
3DUWL³ -XDQD OOHYDQGR GH OD PDQR D ORV GRV FKLFRVSHURDQWHVGHGHVDSDUHFHU\DHVWDEDQHOORV GHYXHOWDFRQWHPSODQGRDOSHUULWR
ߚ/R YDV D HQWHUUDU ,Y¡Q" ߚSUHJXQWDED 0DUFHODXQD±RPHQRUTXH©O
ߚ1R V©ߨ &UHR TXH GHEHUDPRV HPEDOVDPDUOR3DQFKRFR
$O RU HVWR HO P©GLFR IUDFDVDGR VH DQLP³ 6DOW³ GHO GLY¡Q \ FRQ YLROHQFLD HFK³ IXHUD D OD PXOWLWXG
ߚb3RUIDYRUG©MDPHTXHGDUPHDPVRORߚ VXSOLFDEDQXQRDXQRORVH[SXOVDGRV
3HUR 3DQFKRFR HUD LQIOH[LEOH \ RWUD YH] IXQFLRQ³ OD OODYH HQ OD FHUUDGXUD \ ORV J DOHQRV VH MXQWDURQIUHQWHDVXYFWLPD
ߚ7ºVDEHVHPEDOVDPDU"ߚSUHJXQW³,Y¡Q ߚ<R"&ODUR(Q(VWDGRV8QLGRVHPEDOVDPDQ D WRGR HO PXQGRߨ 'HVLQIHFWD HO FXFKLOOR &RQ SDUDILQDFODURb4X©PDOR
,Y¡Q REHGHFL³ \ HO FXFKLOOR TXHG³ QHJUR DO LQVWDQWH
3DQFKRFRPLU³DOSHUUROXHJRDOFXFKLOOR/D LGHD HUD UHOOHQDUOR FRQ DOJR LQFRUUXSWLEOHߨ 3HUR SDUDHVRߨ
(O HPEDOVDPDGRU VH GDED WLHPSR SHQVDQGR FRQFDOPD
ߚ1R OR HPEDOVDPHPRV PHMRUߨ ߚSURSXVR ,Y¡Q
ߚ7UDH HO ERPEQ GH LQVHFWLFLGD ߚRUGHQ³ 3DQFKRFRߚ 6HU¡ XQD RSHUDFL³Q D FXHUSR FHUUDGR ߚH[SOLF³
ߚ<RLU©DEXVFDUORߚGLMRXQDYR]LQHVSHUDGD \ GH HQWUH ODV PDQJXHUDV \ SDODV GH MDUGQ VXUJL³ 3DXODODP¡VSHFRVD
ߚb7ºHVWDEDVDKߚH[FODP³3DQFKRFRߚb/D P¡VFRSXFKHQWDGHOORWHb3HURWHFDOODU¡VSRUTXHVL KDEODV QR WH TXHGDU¡ XQ GLHQWH GH ORV TXH VH WH DVRPDQ
/RVRMRVFDVWD±RVUHVSRQGLHURQDODDPHQD]D\ VXFXHUSHFLWRFKLFRGHVDSDUHFL³FRPRUHO¡PSDJRHQ EXVFDGHOSHGLGR
$SHQDVKDEDSDUWLGRFXDQGRHVWDEDGHYXHOWD HQDUERODQGR HO ERPEQ 3DQFKRFR OR FRJL³ HQ HO SUHFLVR PRPHQWR HQ TXH XQD PXOWLWXG GH SDVRV VH DWURSHOODEDQ&RQWRGRHOFXHUSRFHUU³GHJROSHOD SXHUWD FRQ WDQ PDOD VXHUWH TXH DOJXLHQ TXHG³
FRJLGR\XQDJDUJDQWDODQ]³GHVWHPSODGRVJULWRV ߚb%UXWR ߚ3DXOD FKLFD \ WRGR DEUL³ OD SXHUWD DPHQD]DQWH 3HUR HVR QR FRQPRYL³ D ORV JDOHQRV&XDWURPDQRVODFRJLHURQODSXHUWDYROYL³ DFHUUDUVH\ODGHM³SULVLRQHUDHQHOODERUDWRULR ߚb$SHQDVYXHOYDODPDP¡OHFRQWDU©WRGRߚ DOHJ³URMDGHLQGLJQDFL³Q ߚ1R SXHGHV DFXVDUQRV ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFR VRQULHQGR GHVSUHFLDWLYRߚ 7X PDP¡ HVW¡ D GRVFLHQWRV NLO³PHWURV \ QR YROYHU¡ KDVWD GRV GDV P¡V3DUDHQWRQFHVQLWHGDU¡QJDQDVGHDFXVDUQRV
,Y¡Q \ 3DQFKRFR YROYDQ D LQWHUHVDUVH HQ VX WUDEDMR \ 3DXOD DSURYHFK³ GH VDOLU GDQGR XQ SRUWD]R
ߚb4X© DOLYLR $KRUD D WUDEDMDU /H YDPRV D LQVXIODU DQWLFRUURVLYR 1R SRUTXH VH OH DFDE³ OD YLGDYDDGHMDUGHIXQFLRQDUVXGLVWULEXLGRULQWHULRU
3DQFKRFR HPSH]³ D LQVXIODUOH DO SHUUR HO LQVHFWLFLGD PLHQWUDV H[SOLFDED TXH HVWH VLVWHPD PDQWHQGUD DO SHUUR FDVL FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD YLYR DXQTXH VLQ PRYLPLHQWR < ©FKDOH \ ©FKDOH FRQ HO ERPEQ SRU WRGRV ODGRV PLHQWUDV OHV OORUDEDQ ORV RMRVDORVGRV
3RU ILQ GHFLGLHURQ DEULU OD YHQWDQD SRUTXH WDPSRFRHOORVSRGDQUHVSLUDU
ߚ(VWDPRVWDQHPEDOVDPDGRVFRPRHOSHUURߨ ߚWRVLHURQKDFLDDIXHUD
ߚ<R FUHR TXH FXDOTXLHU PLFURELR VH DUUDQFD GH QRVRWURV \ QR QRV HQIHUPDUHPRV QXQFD P¡V ߚ WRVD,Y¡Q 3DQFKRFR UHYROYD ORV RMRV VLQWL©QGRVH XQ WDQWRUDUR ߚ6DEHV" &UHR TXH HVWR\ XQ SRTXLWR HQYHQHQDGR
ߚ1R WH PXHUDV 3DQFKRFR ߚURJ³ ,Y¡Qߚ 7HQJRXQDLGHD$ORPHMRUVLHVWRPDWDDORVYLYRV TXL]¡ UHVXFLWH D ORV PXHUWRVߨ ߚORV JDOHQRV VH ULHURQ
ߚ0D±DQD OR VDEUHPRV ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ SRUTXH\RQRHQWUDUDKR\DHVHFXDUWXFKRQLSRUXQ PLOO³QGHG³ODUHVߨ
ߚ<'1'(HVW¡HOSHUUR"ߚODYR]GHIODXWD GH $QGU©V VDF³ D ,Y¡Q GH VX VXH±R 7UDV ©O YHQD 3HSH HO PHQRU GH WUHV D±RV WDPEL©Q PHGLR GRUPLGRHQVXSLMDPDGHPDVLDGRFKLFR
$ORUOR,Y¡Q\3DQFKRFRVDOWDURQGHODFDPD 5HFRUGDURQ GH SURQWR OD WUDJHGLD GHO SHUUR 6H FDODURQ OD URSD HQ XQ VHJXQGR \ FRUULHURQ D VX FOQLFD
/DSXHUWD\ODYHQWDQDHVWDEDQDELHUWDVSHURHO SHUULWR HPEDOVDPDGR KDED GHVDSDUHFLGR 1DWXUDOPHQWHVRVSHFKDEDQGH-XDQD
<ODHQIUHQWDURQ6HLVYRFHVLQWHUURJDEDQDXQ WLHPSR SHUR -XDQD HVWDED DUPDGD SDUD GDU OD EDWDOOD \ YRODEDQ SRU HO DLUH ODV SDODEUDV ߡFUXHOGDGߢߡEDUEDULGDGߢߡVLQFRUD]³QFULVWLDQRߢ\ PXFKDV RWUDV ,Y¡Q WUDWDED HQ YDQR GH H[SOLFDU
3DQFKRFR VLHPSUH SU¡FWLFR VROR TXHUD VDEHU TX© KDEDKHFKR-XDQDFRQHOSHUURHPEDOVDPDGR
(UDLQºWLO-XDQDQRFHGDDQWHHOLQWHUURJDWRULR \JXDUGDEDVXVHFUHWRFRPRXQDSLHGUD
ߚ/R KDEU¡ WLUDGR D OD EDVXUD ߚGLMR ,Y¡Q DSHQDGR 3HURHOKDPEUHHVFRVDYLYD\DSHVDUGHWRGR ORVVHLVQL±RVSDUWLHURQDWRPDUGHVD\XQR ߚ4XL©QVHFRPL³PLSDQ"ߚJULW³IXULRVRXQ KDPEULHQWRDOYHUVXSODWRYDFR ߚ)XH$QGHFRߚGLMR3HSHFRQFDUDGHMXH] ߚb1R HV FLHUWR b/R FRPLPRV ORV GRV ߚVH GHIHQGL³HODFXVDGR
ߚ$K SHUR Wº GLMLVWH TXH OR FRPL©UDPRV ߚ DOHJ³HOFKLFR ߚb0HQWLUD'LMLVWHTXH©OORKDEDGHMDGR (VRQRP¡V ߚ3HURWºORDJDUUDVWHߨ ߚ3RUTXHWºWHORLEDVDFRPHU ߚߡ3RUTXHWºWHORLEDVDFRPHUߢߚUHPHG³HO RWUR
ߚb7RQWR FUHGR ߚODV PDQRV GH DPERV VH HPSX±DURQ
,Y¡QLQWHUYLQRDXWRULWDULR
/RV FKLFRV SDWLQDURQ SDUD FXPSOLU OD RUGHQ 9ROYLHURQ WULXQIDQWHV WUD\HQGR FDGD XQR OD PDUUDTXHWD SDUD HO KHUPDQR PD\RU TXH VH KDED HQRMDGR,Y¡QVHHFK³XQDDOEROVLOORPRUGL³ODRWUD \ VLQ GHFLU SDODEUD VH DOHM³ FRQ UXPER GHVFRQRFLGR
< VDOLHURQ D OD FDOOH (Q OD SXHUWD HVWDED HO WDUURGHEDVXUD6LQYDFLODUORYDFLDURQHQHOVXHOR ORKXUJXHWHDURQDQVLRVRV\OXHJRDOFRQYHQFHUVHGH TXHQRHVWDEDORTXHEXVFDEDQHPSH]DURQDYDFLDU HO WDUUR YHFLQR &ODUR D ORV FKLFRV OHV WRFDED YROYHUDOOHQDUORVWDUURV
$V ORJUDURQ HVFDUEDU WRGD OD EDVXUD GH OD FDOOHKDVWDTXHSRUILQVHDEXUULHURQ\GHVSUHFLDURQ XQD FDMD GRQGH ]XPEDEDQ ODV PRVFDV FRPR HQ XQD FROPHQD
ߚb$K QR FDEH ߚGHFUHW³ 3DQFKRFR 3HUR ,Y¡QUHYROYL³HOFRQWHQLGRFRQHOSLH\HQWRQFHVYLR EULOODU DOJR HQWUH ODV F¡VFDUDV \ GHPDVHV ,Y¡Q OR UHFRJL³ $XQTXH OHV SDUHFL³ LQFUHEOH HUD XQD PRQHGDGHRUR<EULOODEDHQWUHVXVPDQRV
$O YHUOD FLQFR SDUHV GH RMRV EULOODURQ WDQWR FRPRHOOD
8QD PRQHGD GH RUR HQFRQWUDGD HQ OD FDOOH HV FDVLLJXDODXQDYDULWDP¡JLFD
ߚ4X© KDUHPRV FRQ HOOD" ߚVH SUHJXQWDURQ PDUDYLOODGRVURMRVGHIHOLFLGDG
< GLVFXWLHURQ VL FRPSUDUDQ XQD PRWR XQ VXSHUPHUFDGR R XQ SHUUR YLYR TXH ELHQ HQVH±DGR OOHJDUDDYDOHUFRPRXQDPLQD
/DLGHDFD\³ELHQ\ORVSUR\HFWRVIXQFLRQDEDQ DPLOSRUKRUD3DUDDOJXQRVHOSHUUR\DYRODEDHQ HO HVSDFLR 3DUD RWURV KDEODED \ KDVWD YHD OD VXHUWH\SDUDORVP¡VFKLFRVMXJDEDIºWERO\KDFD JROHVTXHDWXUGDQDODUTXHUR
/D PRQHGD HVWDED FDOLHQWH HQ HO EROVLOOR GH 3DQFKRFRTXHFDPLQDEDRUJXOORVRVHJXLGRSRUVXV FXDWURSULPRV3HURDQWHVGHOOHJDUDODFDVDYLQRD HQFRQWUDUORV 3DXOD QDGLH VDEH GHVGH G³QGH FRPR XQSHORWD]RDQ³QLPR
ߚb/RHQFRQWU©ߚJULW³VLQDOLHQWR
ߚ4X© HQFRQWUDVWH" ߚORV GHP¡V KDEDQ ROYLGDGRORTXHVDOLHURQDEXVFDU
ߚ(O SREUHFLWR HVWDED WDSDGR FRQ XQDV UDPDV HQHOVLWLRTXHVHYHQGHb/RHQWHUU©
ߚ&DUULOHUDߨ QR WH FUHR FDSD] GH DEULU XQD VHSXOWXUDߚGLMR3DQFKRFR
ߚ&ODUR TXH VHSXOWXUD GH KR\R QR 3HUR VHSXOWXUDGHFHUURV
ߚ$V TXH OR WDSDVWH FRQ EDVXUDߨ < QR HQFRQWUDVWHQDGD"b0LUDORTXHKDOODPRVQRVRWURVߨ HQODEDVXUDߚ\OHHQVH±³ODPRQHGDUHOXFLHQWH
$ 3DXOD OH GLR KLSR GH OD LPSUHVL³Q 1R VH DWUHYL³ D WRFDUOD SHUR VHQWD FRPR XQD HVSLQD SRU
QRSHUWHQHFHUDOJUXSRGHORVGHVFXEULGRUHV
ߚ2\HߚOHGLMRD3HSHHQODRUHMDߚ6LWºPH D\XGDVDHQFRQWUDUDOJRWHSURPHWRTXHVHU¡GHORV GRVWX\R\PR
$ 3HSH OH SDUHFL³ IDQW¡VWLFD OD LGHD /RV PD\RUHVQROHOOHYDEDQHODSXQWH\HVHߡDOJRߢTXH 3DXODRIUHFDHQFRQWUDUWHQDXQVDERUP¡JLFR
&RQ OD YLVWD FODYDGD HQ HO VXHOR VH HQFDPLQDURQORVGRVSRURWURODGR
ߚ/D SXUD WRQWHUD GH RURߨ 3DUD TX© VLUYH" 3DUDWDSDUORVGLHQWHV/D-XDQDVHYDDSRQHUXQR HQWHURGHRURߚGHFD3DXOD
ߚ0HMRU VHUD HQFRQWUDUVH XQ FDUDPHOR ߚ DOHJDED3HSHߚ$OPHQRVVHSXHGHFRPHU (QWRQFHVPLUDURQKDFLDDWU¡V\YLHURQTXHORV RWURVVHKDEDQGHWHQLGRHQODSDQDGHUD$QWHVGH SHQVDUOR\DHVWDEDQHQHOJUXSR3HUR3DQFKRFRQR TXHUDHQWUDUDXQTXHHQWUHWRGRVORDUUDVWUDEDQ ߚb&³PSUDQRVSDQߚJULWDEDQWRGRVDFRUR ߚ(VW¡Q ORFRV" &³PR VH OHV RFXUUH TXH YDPRVDJDVWDUXQDPRQHGDGHRURHQSDQ"
ߚ7HGDUDQYXHOWRߨ
ߚ1HFHVLWDUDPRV XQD PDOHWD SDUD OOHYDU HVH YXHOWRߚ3DQFKRFRVHGHVSUHQGL³GHODFDQWLGDGGH PDQRV \ FRQ JHVWR KHURLFR DSUHW³ ODV QDULFHV SDUD QRROHUHOWHQWDGRUDURPDDSDQIUHVFRTXHVDODSRU
ODSXHUWD
ߚ$ G³QGH YDPRV DKRUD" ߚD 3DXOD VH OH HQUHGDEDQORVSLHVWUDWDQGRGHDODUJDUHOSDVRSDUD VHJXLUDORVPD\RUHV ߚb1DGD GH SUHJXQWDV 2\H ,Y¡Q D G³QGH YDPRV" ߚb$FRPSUDUHOSHUURFODUR ߚ3HURG³QGH" (Q HVH PRPHQWR SDV³ UHPHFL©QGRVH XQD FDUUHWHOLWD FKXHFD WLUDGD SRU XQ YLHMR FDEDOOR FKDVF³Q TXH OHYDQWDED OD FDEH]D D FDGD SDVR /OHYDEDDWU¡VXQOHWUHURTXHGHFDߡ6(%(1'(ߢ
ߚb2\HߚJULWDURQDFRURWRGRVORVTXHVDEDQ OHHUߚ6HYHQGHHVDFDUUHWHODߨb&RPSU©PRVODߚ \VHODQ]DURQDGHWHQHUHODSDFLEOHYHKFXOR
ߚ&X¡QWR YDOH" ߚSUHJXQW³ ,Y¡Q DO YLHMR GXH±R
ߚ'HSHQGH /D FDUUHWHOD VROD YDOH GLH] PHORQHV\HOFDEDOORXQRVYHLQWHߨ ߚ(VH DQLPDO WLHQH FDVL FXDUHQWD D±RV ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRQHJRFLDQGR ߚ$SHQLWDVWUHLQWDߚFRUULJL³HODQFLDQR ߚ/DFDUUHWHODHVW¡DJRQL]DQGRߚDOHJ³,Y¡Q ߚ6LHVWXYLHUDQXHYDYDOGUDFLHQߚHOKRPEUH HVFXSL³\WLU³ODULHQGD$QGU©VVHKDEDDFHUFDGR DODQLPDO\DFDULFLDEDVXWULVWHFDEH]D
ߚ2\H ߚGLVFXWDQ HQ YR] EDMDߚ HVWR VHUD PDFDQXGRSDUDURGDUWLHUUDV3RGUDPRVLUDOVXUVLQ FDQVDUQRV\OOHYDUSDVDMHURVߨ 6DFDURQODEULOODQWHPRQHGD\VHODHQVH±DURQ DOYLHMR ߚ(V GH RUR ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ 9DOH PXFKR P¡V7HQGUDTXHGDUQRVYXHOWR(OKRPEUHFRJL³OD PRQHGD \ OD PRUGL³ /XHJR OD KL]R VDOWDU HQ VX PDQR
ߚb1R YDOH WUHLQWD PHORQHV ߚGLMR FRQ GHVSUHFLRߚ7HQGUDQTXHGDUPHP¡VSODWDHQFLPD ߚ&X¡QWR" ߚ$ORPHQRVGLH]PHORQHV ߚ1R WHQHPRV 3RU TX© QR VH TXHGD FRQ OD FDUUHWHOD\QRVGDHOFDEDOORSRUHOOD" 'LVFXWLHURQXQUDWR\SRUILQHOQHJRFLRTXHG³ KHFKR (O KRPEUH GHVHQJDQFK³ HO FDEDOOR OH VDF³ ORV FRUGHOHV \ VH OOHY³ WLUDQGR HO YLHMR FDUUHW³Q GHVYHQFLMDGR
,Y¡Q \ 3DQFKRFR WUHSDURQ DO FDEDOOR OH SXVLHURQ GRV FLQWXURQHV FRPR ULHQGDV \ DSUHWDURQ FRQIXHU]DVXVWDORQHVSDUDKDFHUORSDUWLU
3HURHODQLPDOQRVHPRYL³
/H J ULWDURQ WLUDURQ GH VXV FULQHV OR SDOPRWHDURQSRUWRGRVODGRVDQLP¡QGRORFRQJULWRV GHLQGLRb,QºWLO(QVD\DURQWLU¡QGRORGHODFRODVLQ
FRQVHJXLU TXH VH GLHUD SRU HQWHQGLGR (O FDEDOOR HVWDEDP¡VILUPHTXHXQ¡UERO
ߚ+D\ TXH DVXVWDUOR ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ /RV DQFLDQRV VRQ SRUILDGRV SHUR PLHGRVRVߨ ߚ\ WLU³ VXFDMDGHI³VIRURVHQFHQGLGDFHUFDGHODVSDWDVGHO DQLPDO 3HUR VROR VDFXGL³ HO SHOOHMR FRPR FRQ XQ HVFDORIUR\QRGLRXQSDVR
$SURYHFKDQGR HO GHVDOLHQWR JHQHUDO $QGU©V PRQW³GHXQEULQFRDSUHW³EUXVFDPHQWHVXVWDORQHV FKLFRV HQ ODV SHOXGDV LMDGDV \ HO FDEDOOR VDOL³ WURWDQGRDQWHODDGPLUDFL³QGHWRGRV/HYDQWDEDOD FDEH]D D FDGD SDVR \ HVWH JHVWR SDUHFD SRQHU HQ PRYLPLHQWRVXVSDWDV/RVQL±RVFRUUDQDVXODGR JULWDQGRVXHQWXVLDVPRFRPRVLIXHUDXQSURGLJLR
$VSDVDURQIUHQWHDVXFDVDWRUFLHURQSRUXQD FDOOH \ SRU RWUD VLQ GHWHQHUVH KDVWD HQWUDU HQ XQ VLWLRFRQXQDFDVLWDGHPDGHUDDOIRQGR
$QGHFRVDOW³DOVXHOR\DFDULFL³DOYLHMREUXWR FRQ HO HQWXVLDVPR GH XQ MLQHWH TXH KD JDQDGR OD FDUUHUD
8QDPXMHUTXHWHQGDXQDVURSDVPLU³DOJUXSR VLQ KDFHU FRPHQWDULRV &XDQGR WHUPLQ³ VX WDUHD VHF³VXVPDQRVHQVXGHODQWDO\SUHJXQW³
ߚ4X©SDV³FRQHOFDUUHW³Q\HOGXH±R"
ߚ/H FRPSUDPRV SXUDPHQWH HO FDEDOOR ߚ H[SOLF³ DOJXLHQߚ SHUR QR KLFLPRV EXHQ QHJRFLR (VPHGLRLGLRWDHOEUXWR
3DQFKRFR PRQW³ RWUD YH] \ QR ORJU³ KDFHUOR WURWDU
ߚ3RU HVR OH GLPRV XQD PRQHGD GH RURߨ 'HVKDJDPRV HO QHJRFLR VH±RUD /H GHMDPRV VX FDEDOOR\QRVGHYXHOYHODPRQHGDߨ ߚ1R KH YLVWR QL YHU© HVD PRQHGD ߚGLMR OD PXMHUOLPSL¡QGRVHODWUDQVSLUDFL³QFRQHOGHODQWDO ߚOVHODKDEU¡JDVWDGR/O©YHQVHDOURVLOORFRPR SXHGDQߨߚ\VHTXHG³PLUDQGRORVHVIXHU]RVGHORV MLQHWHV
ߚb$O PHQRV SRGUD GDUQRV OD UHFHWD SDUD KDFHUORSDUWLU
ߚ1R KD\ UHFHWD (V FXHVWL³Q GH FDSULFKR GHO DQLPDOߚ\VHPHWL³HQVXFDVD
(O URVLOOR VHJXD HQFDSULFKDGR \ ODV FDUDV GH ORV GXH±RV VH DODUJDEDQ \ DODUJDEDQ +DVWD ORV PD\RUHVVHQWDQDOJRGXURHQODJDUJDQWD
8QSHUULWRFXULRVRVHDFHUF³DYHUODPDQLREUD ,QWHUHVDGRODGHDEDODFDEH]D\PRYDVXFROLWD(UD XQD PH]FOD GH TXLOWUR \ XQ SRFR GH FDGD UD]D GH SHUURRDOJºQRWURDQLPDO/HVFD\³VLPS¡WLFRDORV FKLFRVTXHHPSH]DURQDDFDULFLDUORSDUDGLVWUDHUVX SHQD
ߚ3RU TX© QR FDPELDPRV DO URVLOOR SRU HVWH SHUUR" 4XHUDPRV FRPSUDU XQRߨ ߚSURSXVR DOJXLHQ
,Y¡Q\3DQFKRFRHQWUDURQDODFDVDGHODGXH±D D QHJRFLDU HO SHUUR $O SRFR UDWR VDOLHURQ WULXQIDQWHV(OQHJRFLRHVWDEDKHFKR
(O SHUUR QR WHQD FDSULFKRV (UD DOHJUH MXJXHW³QHLQTXLHWR6LJXL³DORVQL±RVVLQSUREOHPDV \ HQWHQGD WRGR OR TXH OH GHFDQ FRPR VL ORV FRQRFLHUDGHWRGDODYLGD$OUHY©VGHOURVLOORFDVL QRSRGDHVWDUVHTXLHWR
/R EDXWL]DURQ 5HVRUWH \ FXDQGR ORV GRV JUDQGHVVDFDEDQODFXHQWDTXHFRQODPRQHGDGHRUR KDEUDQSRGLGRFRPSUDUWDOYH]XQDPRWRORVGHP¡V OHVUHFRUGDEDQ ߚb3HURGHWRGRVPRGRVTXHUDPRVFRPSUDUXQ SHUUR
5(6257( GHYRU³ HQ XQ PLQXWR HO SODW³Q GH FRPLGDTXHOHRIUHFLHURQDOOOHJDUDFDVD8QDYH] OLPSLR HO SODWR ERVWH]³ ODUJDPHQWH HVWLU³ VXV SDWLWDV\DUUROO¡QGRVHDOVROFHUU³ORVRMRV
)XH LQºWLO WUDWDU GH GHVSHUWDUOR $EUD XQ RMR PLUDED D ORV QL±RV \ OR YROYD D FHUUDU (Q ORV GXH±RV GH 5HVRUWH LED FUHFLHQGR XQD HQRUPH GHVLOXVL³Q\KDVWDHOWHPRUGHTXHHOSHUURUHVXOWDUD WDQYLHMRFRPRHOFDEDOOR
ߚb2WUD HQVDUWDGD ߚGHFODU³ 3DQFKRFRߚ (VWH SHUUR QR VLUYH SDUD VDOLU FRQ ©O D FRUUHU HO PXQGR(QGRVFXDGUDVKDTXHGDGROLTXLGDGR
ߚ3RGUDPRVHQWUHQDUORߨߚVXJLUL³,Y¡Q 3HUR3DQFKRFRHVWDEDGHVLOXVLRQDGR\WRGRVX FXHUSRSDUHFDHQGHUURWD7HQDFDUDGHIXQHUDO
KDFHU FLUFR QR ߚSURSXVR 0DUFHOD \ OD LGHD UHVXFLW³KDVWDDOSURSLR3DQFKRFR
ߚ%XHQD LGHD ߚGLMR ,Y¡Qߚ VROR TXH TXL©Q YDDYHQLUDODIXQFL³Q"
ߚ1R QHFHVLWDQ YHQLU b3RGHPRV LU QRVRWURV b+DJDPRVFLUFRDPEXODQWH
&RQHODOERURWR\DSODXVRVDODLGHD5HVRUWH DEUL³XQRMRSHURYROYL³DFHUUDUOR
ߚb<RKDJRORVEROHWRVߚJULWDEDXQR
ߚb<R SLQWR ORV OHWUHURV GH SURSDJDQGD ߚ JULWDEDRWUR
ߚ<RHVFULERHOSURJUDPD
&RUUDQWRGRVHQEXVFDGHPDWHULDO\YROYDQDO LQVWDQWH
ߚ&X¡O HV HO SURJUDPD" ߚSUHJXQW³ HO DQXQFLDGRU FRQ VX SLQFHO HQ HO DLUH FKRUUHDQGR SLQWXUD
ߚ<R SRGUD EDLODU ߚSURSXVR 3DXOD FRQ ORV RMRVEULOODQWHVGHHVSHUDQ]D
ߚ3DQFKRFR SXHGH WRFDU VX WURPSHWD ߚGLMR 0DUFHOD
ߚ3XUDVODWDVߚ3DQFKRFR VHGHVDQLPDED RWUD YH] SHUR UHDFFLRQDEDߚ ORV FLUFRV DPEXODQWHV HQ (VWDGRV 8QLGRV PXHVWUDQ FRVDV UDUDV IHQ³PHQRV QXQFDYLVWRVߨ ߚ(QWRQFHVKDJRPLS³VWHU&LUFR)HQRPHQDO" ߚSUHJXQW³0DUFHOD ߚb*UDQ&LUFR)HQRPHQDOߚFRUULJL³,Y¡Q ߚ(QDQRV \ PRQVWUXRV ߚGLFW³ 3DQFKRFR LQVSLUDGR/XHJRYROYL©QGRVHD$QGU©VTXHHQVX HQWXVLDVPRVHKDEDSDUDGRGHFDEH]DߚWºVHU¡VHO (QDQR 5LJRG³Q HO DWOHWD P¡V FKLFR GHO PXQGR &ODURFRQWUDMHGHHQDQR\WRGRHOWLHPSRSDUDGRGH FDEH]Dߨ
ߚ<RSXHGRVHUODVH±RUDGHOHQDQRߚSURSXVR 3DXODߚ \ EDLOR FRQ ©O GH FDEH]D \ KDJR SUXHEDV P¡JLFDVߨ
ߚ<TX©SXHGRKDFHU\R"ߚSUHJXQWDED3HSH WUDWDQGRGHKDFHUVHRU
ߚ7º YHQGHU¡V FDUDPHORV ߚOH FRQWHVWDURQߚ b<SRUDKRUDWHFDOODV
ߚ< \R" ߚSUHJXQW³ HVWD YH] 0DUFHOD FRQ SHQD
ߚ7ºSXHGHVYHUODVXHUWHGHJLWDQDߚSURSXVR ,Y¡Q3HUR3DQFKRFRLQWHUYLQR
ߚ(VR QR SHJD 0DUFHOD WLHQH TXH VHU RWUR IHQ³PHQR3RUHMHPSORODPXMHUGHGRVFDEH]DVߨ
/D FRPSD±D GH DFWRUHV GHO *UDQ &LUFR )HQRPHQDOORPLU³DWXUGLGD
ߚ&³PR YDPRV D SRQHUOH RWUD FDEH]D" ߚ SUHJXQW³DOJXLHQ
YHVWLGR\DVRPDPRVVXFDEH]DSRUHOFRJRWHb4XHGD IORU
ߚ< ODV SXOJDV" ߚ0DUFHOD VH HPSH]³ D UDVFDUSRUDGHODQWDGR
ߚb6LWHUDVFDVSHUIHFWR/HGDP¡VFDU¡FWHUD WX SHUVRQDMH $KRUD SXUDPHQWH WLHQHV TXH FRQVHJXLUWH XQ YHVWLGR PX\ HOHJDQWH FRQ HVFRWH SDUDTXHTXHSDQODVGRVFDEH]DV
ߚ< Wº TX© YDV D KDFHU" ߚOH SUHJXQWDURQ D 3DQFKRFR
ߚ<RWHQJRTXHDQXQFLDUODIXQFL³QFREUDUODV HQWUDGDV\GLULJLUORWRGRߨ7HSDUHFHSRFR"
ߚ3XHGR FRPHU FDUDPHORV PLHQWUDV ORV YHQGR"ߚSUHJXQWDED3HSH
ߚ/R SULPHUR VHU¡ HO WRTXH GH FRUQHWDߨ ߚ HVFULED,Y¡Q ߚ75203(7$ߚFRUULJL³3DQFKRFR ߚ%XHQRWURPSHWD'HVSX©VGHVILOHGHDFWRUHV \DSDUHFHVWºDQXQFLDQGRߨ ߚߡ$SDUHFHVߢߨ&³PRYDDDSDUHFHUDOJXLHQ VL WRGRV HVW¡Q DK" 1R KD\ WHDWUR HQWLHQGHV" /D FRVDHVHQODFDOOH ߚ%XHQRHQWRQFHVDQRWRD&OHRSDWUDODPXMHU GHGRVFDEH]DV
ߚ$KRUD DQ³WDPH D P ߚOOHJ³ 3DXOD YHVWLGD GHPDPDUUDFKRFRQWRQH¡QGRVH
7RGRVVROWDURQODULVD
ߚb1RV IDOWD XQ SD\DVR ߚ,Y¡Q DEUL³ WUHPHQGRVRMRVߚ8QFLUFRVLQSD\DVRVQRUHVXOWDߨ 3HSHDSURYHFK³SDUDRIUHFHUVXVFKLVWHV\FRQ D\XGDGH$QGHFRHPSH]DURQDHQVD\DUVLQTXHQDGLH ORV WRPDUD HQ FXHQWD 3HUR VHUDQ ORV SD\DVRV D IDOWDGHRWURV
ߚ<\RTX©YR\DKDFHU"ߚGHSURQWR,Y¡QVH GDED FXHQWD GH TXH HVWDED FHVDQWH 3DQFKRFR VH KDEDDGXH±DGRGHWRGDVVXVSRVLELOLGDGHV
ߚ4X© KDU¡ ,Y¡Q" ߚUHSLWL³ OD QXHYD EDLODULQD
ߚ/RVHPSUHVDULRVQRKDFHQQDGDP¡VTXHORV FRQWUDWRVߚH[SOLF³3DQFKRFR
ߚ/RVFRQWUDWRVSXHGHVKDFHUORVWºb<RYR\D VHU PDODEDULVWD ߚ\ DQRW³ VX QºPHUR 0DODEDULVPRVYLNLQJ
8QD YH] UHGDFWDGR HO SURJUDPD YLQR HO GHVEDQGH&DGDXQRSDUWL³HQEXVFDGHVXGLVIUD]
/DSREUH-XDQDQRRDQLVXSURSLDYR]DOWUDWDU GH GHWHQHU HO GHVRUGHQ FRQ TXH ORV VHLV QL±RV EXVFDEDQURSDV\REMHWRV
,Y¡QKDEDHQFRQWUDGRXQDFKDTXHWDGHVXSDGUH FRQ ERWRQHV GRUDGRV TXH OH GDUD FXDOTXLHU DXWRULGDG 8Q FROODU SDVDGR HQWUH ORV ERWRQHV OR FRQVDJUDEDFRPRPDODEDULVWDUHJLR
3DQFKRFR VH FRQYLUWL³ HQ XQD HVSHFLH GH FRVDFR DO SRQHUVH ERWDV EOXVD GH VHGD \ FLQWXU³Q HOHJDQWH
3DXODFRPR0¡JLFD0DULEHOURMDGHFRORUHWH HQMR\DGD KDVWD ORV GLHQWHV HQYXHOWD HQ FRORULGD EXIDQGDHQOXJDUGHYHVWLGRVHFRQWRQHDEDHXI³ULFD EDWLHQGRFDVWD±XHODV
(O (QDQR 5LJRG³Q FRQ FDPLVHWD D UD\DV VH KDED UHOOHQDGR VLPXODQGR PºVFXORV FRQ FDOFHWLQHV FDO]RQFLOORV \ RWURV KDVWD SDUHFHU XQ DWOHWD IHUR] (O SD\DVR YHQGHGRU GH FDOXJDV HUD OD REUD GH DUWH GH 0DUFHOD /R KDED SLQWDGR \ GLVIUD]DGR SDUD TXH QR FXSLHUD OD PHQRU GXGD GHO SHUVRQDMH'HOFXHOOROHFROJDEDXQDFDMDGH]DSDWRV YDFDOLVWDSDUDORVFDUDPHORV
(O YHUGDGHUR SUREOHPD HUD 0DUFHOD 6X WUDMH GH&OHRSDWUDQRHVWDEDPDOSHURVXMHWDUD5HVRUWH GHQWURGH©OFRQVXFDEH]DDVRPDGDMXQWRDODVX\D UHVXOWDED LPSRVLEOH $SHQDV PHWD DO SHUUR SRU HO HOHJDQWH HVFRWH GHO YHVWLGR 5HVRUWH VH UHVEDODED UDVJX±DQGR FRQ VXV SDWDV D OD KHURLFD QL±D (QUHGDGR HQ VX SHOR LEDQ D GDU DO VXHOR ODV GRV FDEH]DV3RUILQ0DUFHODVHFDO³XQDJRUUDGHED±R \DPDUU³DVXFXHOORODVSDWDVGHOSHUULWRSDUDTXH QRVHFD\HUD(OUHVXOWDGRIXHSHRUTXHHOSULPHUR 5HVRUWHTXLVRVROWDUVHGHODIDPRVDDPDUUDWLU³DO VXHORD0DUFHOD\VDOL³DUUDQFDQGRFRQHOGLFKRVR GLVIUD]&XDQGRORJUDURQUHFXSHUDUHOYHVWLGRGHVX
HQUHGR FRQ HO SHUUR HUD VRODPHQWH XQ PRQW³Q GH WUDSRV
ߚ1ROORUHVߚOHGLMR3DQFKRFRD0DUFHODߚ &RQORTXHJDQHPRVOHFRPSUDUHPRVRWURYHVWLGRD WXPDP¡
&OHRSDWUDODPXMHUGHGRVFDEH]DVVHERUUDED GHO SURJUDPD 3HUR HUD QHFHVDULR UHHPSOD]DU HVH LPSRUWDQWHQºPHURSRURWURHQTXHILJXUDUD5HVRUWH 'HVSX©VGHWRGRHUDODDWUDFFL³QSULQFLSDO
'LVFXWLHURQ GH QXHYR $OJXLHQ SURSXVR TXH 0DUFHODFDQWDUDDFRPSD±DGDDOSLDQRSRU3HSHVLQ DFRUGDUVHGHTXHXQSLDQRQRFDPLQD
3RUILQGHFLGLHURQYHVWLUDOSHUURFRQURSDGH PX±HFD\KDFHUOREDLODUPLHQWUDV0DUFHODYHVWDGH GRPDGRUD HQ PDOOD GH JLPQDVLD \ KDFLHQGR VRQDU XQDSHUYHUVDKXDVFD
&RQHVWRTXHG³OLVWRHOSURJUDPD\WDPEL©QHO OHWUHUR DQXQFLDGRU TXH FODYDGR HQ XQ SDOR GH HVFRED\XQSRTXLWRFKRUUHDGRSURFODPDED *5$1&,5&2$0%8/$17( /$0$5$9,//$ +2<(675(1$686)(10(126 (O(QDQR5LJRG³Q OD0¡JLFD0DULEHO
HO7URPSHWLVWD)UDQFL HO*HQLDO5HVRUWH\ VX'RPDGRUD'REULOD HO0DODEDULVWDYLNLQJ 126(9$<$$68&$6$6,19(5126 (OJORULRVRVH[WHWRVDOL³GHVILODQGRWULXQIDQWH HQFDEH]DGR SRU HO WURPSHWLVWD TXH VRSODED D WRGR SXOP³QVHJXLGRPX\GHFHUFDSRUHOOHWUHUR\WUDV©O WRGR HO HOHQFR DUWVWLFR ,EDQ PX\ FRQILDGRV HQ EXVFDGHVXSºEOLFRVLQORJUDULQWHUUXPSLUHOWU¡ILFR \ FRQVLJXLHQGR DSHQDV OD DWHQFL³Q GH DOJºQ FKLFR DEXUULGRWLUDGRSRUODPDQRGHXQDPDP¡
3RUILQORVVLJXLHURQGRVSHUURVXQDFKLFDFRQ VX EROVD GH SDQ \ XQ UHSDUWLGRU GH OHFKH TXH VH GHWXYRMXQWRDHOORVHVSHUDQGRODUHSUHVHQWDFL³Q(O WURPSHWLVWD WDPEL©Q VH GHWXYR FRQVLGHUDQGR TXH KDED EDVWDQWH SºEOLFR SDUD FRPHQ]DU \ OODP³ HQ WRTXHGHGLDQD
5HVRUWH \ ORV RWURV SHUURV URPSLHURQ HQ DODUPDQWHV ODGULGRV OR TXH QR SHUWXUE³ DO WURPSHWLVWDTXHVHODUJ³FRQWRGRVXUHSHUWRULR(O UHVWRGHORVDFWRUHVORURGHDEDHVSHUDQGRVXWXUQR SDUDDFWXDU 8QDYLHMDFRQVXEROVDGHFRPSUDVVHDJUHJ³ DODXGLWRULR (QODYHQWDQDGHODFDVDIDYRUHFLGDVHDVRP³ XQD PXMHU FRQ XQD FULDWXUD HQ VXV EUD]RV \ DO RWUR ODGR GH OD FDOOH VXUJL³ XQ PRQW³Q GH QL±RV FRQ URPDGL]R D FKRUUR 8QD QL±LWD TXH SDVDED HQ ELFLFOHWD VH DJUHJ³ D ORV PLURQHV \ OD IXQFL³Q FRPHQ]³
(ODQXQFLDGRUURMRSRUHOHVIXHU]RFKLOO³ ߚb(VWXSHQGRDFU³EDWDJUDQHQDQRºQLFRHQHO PXQGRHOPRQVWUXR5,*2'1
3HURQXQFDVHVXSRVLIXHODSDODEUDPRQVWUXR TXH RIHQGL³ DO HQDQR R XQ VLPSOH DWDTXH GH YHUJ¼HQ]DSHURQRKXERPDQHUDGHKDFHUORSDUDUVH GH FDEH]D 1L ORV SXQWDSL©V GHO WURPSHWLVWD QL ODV YLROHQWDV ³UGHQHV GHO HPSUHVDULR ORJUDURQ GRPLQDUOR
$QWH HO FRQIOLFWR HO SD\DVR VH RIUHFL³ GH YROXQWDULR \ DXQTXH QXQFD KDED ORJUDGR OD HVSHFLDOLGDGGHVXKHUPDQRDKRUDORFRQVLJXL³SRU XQDYH]6HSDU³HQODFDEH]DDSHQDVXQLQVWDQWH\ OXHJRVHYLQRDOVXHORHQWHUR(OSºEOLFRORDSODXGL³ FRQPXFKDVULVDVSHURHOSD\DVRQRSXGRUHSHWLUVX SUXHEDSRUTXHHVWDEDEDVWDQWHDGRORULGR 3DXODDSURYHFK³SDUDVDOYDUODSDQD ߚ$QºQFLDPHDPWRQWRDQWHVGHTXHVHYD\D ODJHQWH <ODYR]GHOHPSUHVDULRDQXQFLDGRUVHDO]³HQ HODLUHFRQWRQRGHSURIHWD
ߚ$KRUD OD 0¡JLFD 0DULEHO IHQRPHQDO EDLODULQD
<ODSHFRVDVHODUJ³DODSLVWDUHWRUFLHQGRVXV PHQXGRV EUD]RV WDFRQHDQGR ORV HQRUPHV ]DSDWRV TXHDSHQDVSRGDVXMHWDUHQVXVSLHV\VLPXODQGRXQ EDLOH HVSD±RO VLQ PºVLFD $QWH HO SDYRURVR UHVXOWDGR3DQFKRFRDO]³VXWURPSHWD\VRSO³HQHOOD XQDPHORGDXQSRFRGHVDILQDGDTXHIXHDQLPDQGROD FRVD /RV DFWRUHV FRPHQ]DURQ D FRUHDUOD \ HO SºEOLFR\ORVSHUURVVHDJUHJDURQDOFRQMXQWR
(O UHVXOWDGR IXH HVSO©QGLGR +XER DSODXVRV \ HOHOHQFRVHYROYL³GLQ¡PLFR/DUXHGDGHPLURQHV VHKDEDDJUDQGDGRHUDFRPRXQPLOO³QGHRMRVTXH ORV PLUDEDQ \ PXFKDV ERFDV VRQULHQWHV TXH D\XGDEDQDO©[LWR
(OQºPHURGH0DUFHODFRQ5HVRUWHWDOYH]SRU QR KDEHUVH HQVD\DGR SURGXFD WUHPHQGDV FDUFDMDGDV/D0¡JLFD0DULEHOEDLODEDGHQXHYRHO PDODEDULVWD KDFD H[WUD±DV SUXHEDV 3DQFKRFR VRSODED QXHYDV PHORGDV HQ VX WURPSHWD TXH HO SºEOLFRFRUHDED\GHSURQWRHOHQDQRTXHVHWDLP³ DO SULQFLSLR VH GLVSDU³ FDPLQDQGR HQ ODV PDQRV DOUHGHGRU GH ORV DFWRUHV \ HQWRQFHV DJUDQG³ HO FUFXORGHFXULRVRV
(QWUHWDQWRHOSD\DVRDWXUGLGRSRUHO©[LWRVH HVWDED FRPLHQGR VLQ GDUVH FXHQWD ORV SRFRV FDUDPHORVTXHGHEDYHQGHUHQODIXQFL³Q
'HSURQWRXQRGHORVHVSHFWDGRUHVVHIXHVLQ
DYLVR \ GRV P¡V OR VLJXLHURQ ,Y¡Q PX\ DODUPDGR RUGHQ³TXHVHKLFLHUDODFROHFWD (OSD\DVRDODUJ³VXFDMDYDFD\IXHHQWRQFHV FXDQGRHOSºEOLFRGHVDSDUHFL³6RORXQDYLHMDGHM³ FDHUHQODFDMDXQDPRQHGD $TXHOORHUDXQGHVDVWUH/RVDFWRUHVROYLGDEDQ VX©[LWRDQWHODUXLQDHFRQ³PLFDFXDQGRGHSURQWR XQQL±RVXSOHPHQWHUROHVDODUJ³XQELOOHWH/RVRMRV GH ,Y¡Q EULOODURQ GH FRQIXVL³Q \ YHUJ¼HQ]D \ QR VDELHQGR TX© KDFHU FRQVXOW³ D 3DQFKRFR FRQ OD PLUDGD 3HUR 3DQFKRFR VROR FODY³ ORV RMRV HQ HO FLHORߨ 'HVSX©V GH WRGR ORV SHVRV HUDQ SRFRV KDEDQ WUDEDMDGR FRPR YHUGDGHURV DUWLVWDV OD SUXHED HUD TXH WUDQVSLUDEDQ D FKRUUR \ HO PH]TXLQR SºEOLFR VH DSURYHFK³ GH HOORV VLQ SDJDUOHV
,Y¡QVHTXHG³PLUDQGRDOVXSOHPHQWHUR\HVWH DGLYLQDQGR VX SUREOHPD HQ XQ LPSXOVR OH HQWUHJ³ VXV UHYLVWDV \ VH ODUJ³ D FDPLQDU HQ ODV PDQRV \ GDUVHYXHOWDVHQHODLUH
ߚ2\H ߚOH GLMR 3DQFKRFR DGPLUDGRߚ 7H JXVWDUDWUDEDMDUFRQQRVRWURV"
ߚb&ODUR TXH V 3HUR DQWHV WHQJR TXH YHQGHU ODVUHYLVWDVTXHPHTXHGDQߨ
ߚb<RODVSXHGRYHQGHUߚVHRIUHFL³3HSH ߚ$O PHQRV QR WH ODV SXHGHV FRPHU ߚGLMR DOJXLHQ
8QDQFLDQROHFRPSU³ODVUHYLVWDVWRGDV7HQD FDUDGHDFRUGDUVHGHDOJRGHFXDQGRHUDQL±R3HSH VH HFK³ DO EROVLOOR HO GLQHUR VLQ HQWHQGHU SRU TX© WHQDTXHGDUORDOQXHYRDFU³EDWD
ߚ0H JXVWDUD WHQHU XQ GLVIUD] ߚGHFODU³ HO QXHYRDUWLVWD
ߚ9DPRVDEXVFDUXQRDODFDVDߨ
< DO SRFR UDWR VDOL³ GH QXHYR HO FLUFR DPEXODQWHFRQXQDUWLVWDP¡VHO3DQWHUDFRQPHGLR ELNLQL GH OD PDP¡ DXVHQWH < HVWH V TXH HUD DFU³EDWDGHYHUGDGHQFDEH]DEDHOGHVILOHG¡QGRVH YXHOWDVGHFDUQHURVLQVLTXLHUDWRFDUHOVXHOR
(VWD YH] QR HVSHUDURQ D TXH VH MXQWDUDQ ORV HVSHFWDGRUHV IXHURQ GLUHFWR GRQGH VH HQFRQWUDEDQ HOORVRVHDDOSDUDGHURGHPLFURV
/D IXQFL³Q FRPHQ]³ DQWH JUDQ FDQWLGDG GH SºEOLFR OR TXH OH WUDQVPLWD ߡ¡QJHOߢ D FDGD DFWRU +DVWD HO SD\DVR GLVFXUUD EXHQRV FKLVWHV PLHQWUDV LEDSDVDQGRVXFDMD
(UDH[WUD±RHVWDYH]VRQDEDQGHQWURPRQHGDV\ P¡V PRQHGDV /RV DUWLVWDV GHO FLUFR DPEXODQWH WUDQVSLUDEDQ VX ©[LWR FRQ P¡V SUXHEDV EDLOHV \ DFUREDFLDV
3HUR GH UHSHQWH DSDUHFL³ XQ EXV LQPHQVR UHVRSODQGR \ DKRJ³ WRGD PºVLFD &RPR SRU HQFDQWR HO SºEOLFR IRUP³ ILOD \ GHVSUHFLDQGR HO IDQW¡VWLFRHVSHFW¡FXORWUHS³DODSDUDWRTXHVHDOHM³ GHMDQGR VRORV HQ OD YHUHGD DO WURPSHWLVWD GRPDGRUD EDLODULQD PDODEDULVWD HQDQR SD\DVR DFU³EDWD\DXQSHUULWRTXHPRYDODFROD
-8$1$HVSHUDEDHQODSXHUWDGHFDOOHFRQFDUD GH&DSLW¡Q7RUPHQWD
ߚ4X© VH FUHHQ" ߚDOHJDED FRQ HO URVWUR HQFHQGLGRߚ0DQGDUVHDODFDOOHHQHVDVIDFKDV" ߚ\SRUVXERFDVDODQOODPDV ߚb4X©WDQWRHQRMRߚODDSODF³,Y¡Qߚ7RWDO GLVIUD]DUVHQRHVSHFDGR /DPXMHUVHFDOP³XQSRFR ߚ1RYROYHU©DTXHGDUPHFRQXVWHGHVVLVDOH ODVH±RUD ߚ/D VH±RUD VH UH GH HVWDV FRVDV ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ < XVWHG WDPEL©Q VH UHߨ ߚ\ -XDQD VROW³ODFDUFDMDGDPLU¡QGRORV ߚ+D\ JDOOHWDV" ߚSUHJXQW³ 3HSH FRPR VL QDGDSDVDUD
ߚ,PDJQHQVH VL YR\ D GDUOHV JDOOHWDV FRQ HO GHVRUGHQTXHPHKDQKHFKRߨߚHPSH]³-XDQDSHUR ORVFKLFRVGHVFXEULHURQODPLQD
ߚ3XHGR TXHGDUPH D WRPDU W©" ߚHO 3DQWHUD HUDXQFDPSH³QSDUDFRPHUJDOOHWDV
ߚ&ODUR TXH V HUHV GHO FLUFR LJXDO TXH QRVRWURV
ߚb(UHV IORU -XDQD ߚGHFD 0DUFHOD VDERUHDQGRODVJDOOHWDV
/RVQL±RVFRQYHUVDEDQPLHQWUDVWRPDEDQVXW© ߚ'³QGH DSUHQGLVWH D VHU DFU³EDWD" ߚ SUHJXQW³ $QGU©V DO 3DQWHUD ߚ7HQJR XQ WR TXH WUDEDMDHQHOFLUFR
ߚ8Q WR DFU³EDWD GH YHUGDG" ߚSUHJXQWDURQ WRGRV ߚ6 < WHQJR XQ SDGULQR WRQ\ DXQTXH DKRUD MXELO³ ߚ<WºQRSLHQVDVWUDEDMDUHQHOFLUFR" ߚ1R0LSDS¡QRTXLHUH ߚb0HJXVWDUDWHQHUXQWRDFU³EDWDߚVXVSLU³ 3DXOD ߚb<XQDWDGRPDGRUDߚGLMR0DUFHOD ߚ3RGUDVOOHYDUQRVDYHUDWXWR"ߚSUHJXQW³ 3DQFKRFR ߚb&ODUR0D±DQDKD\PDWLQ©ߨ ߚ'³QGHHVHOFLUFR" ߚ(QOD*UDQ$YHQLGDߨ ߚ<SXHGHVOOHYDUQRVDODPDWLQ©" ߚ&ODURVLSDJDQODHQWUDGD
ߚb8I &UHR TXH QR KD\ FDVRߨ $OFDQ]DUD FRQORTXHJDQDPRVKR\"
(OGLQHURVHYDFL³HQODPHVD\HPSH]DURQODV FXHQWDV $SHQDV DOFDQ]DED SDUD WUHV JDOHUDV \ PHGLD ߚ3RGHPRVLUORVPD\RUHV ߚ3RU TX© XVWHGHV V \ QRVRWURV QR" ߚ SURWHVWDURQFXDWURYRFHV ߚ1RDOFDQ]DSDUDWRGRVSRUHVRߨ ߚ(FK©PRVORDODVXHUWHߚGLMR0DUFHOD ߚ-XDQLWDSU©VWDQRVSODWDߨߚLPSORU³3HSH ߚ7HQJR OR MXVWR SDUD HO SDQ GH HVWRV GDVߨ bQRSXHGR
ߚ3HUR WLHQHV KDULQD (QWUH WRGRV WH D\XGDUHPRVDKDFHUSDQ
ߚ$KRUD PH DFXHUGR TXH 3DQFKRFR PH GHEH XQDPRQHGDߚGLMR3HSH
ߚ<R"7HGHERXQDPRQHGD"
ߚ$FX©UGDWHGHHVDPRQHGDTXHPHJDQ©\PH ODSHGLVWHSUHVWDGD
ߚ(VH GD TXH LED PLUDQGR DO VXHOR \ PH OD HQFRQWU©ߨ
ߚ(VD PRQHGD HUD GH OD PDP¡ (VWDED HQ VX FXDUWRߨ ߚb$Kb3HUR\RPHODHQFRQWU© ߚ(UDGHHOODQRWX\D ߚ3HUR3DQFKRFRPHODSLGL³SUHVWDGD ߚ6HODGHERDODWDQRDWL /DVJDOOHWDVVHKDEDQWHUPLQDGR\WDPEL©QHO W© $ &©VDU QR OH LQWHUHVDED VDEHU TXL©Q OH GHED SODWDDTXL©Q\DSURYHFK³SDUDGHVSHGLUVH
ߚ0HHVSHUDQHQPLFDVDߨߚ6SHURYXHOYH PD±DQDߚ$ODVGRVHVWR\DTX
$148('$%$SRUGHODQWHXQEXHQSRFRGHO GD %ULOODED HO VRO HQ ODV YHUHGDV \ OD JHQWH FLUFXODEDFRQEROVDVSDTXHWHVRQL±RV
&DVL VLQ GDUVH FXHQWD VH IXHURQ ORV VHLV SRU HVDV FDOOHV SODQHDQGR OD LGD DO FLUFR SDUD HO GD VLJXLHQWH (VSHUDUDQ D &©VDU HQ OD SXHUWD SDUD HYLWDUSUHJXQWDVGHOD-XDQD\VHLUDQFRQ©O,UDO FLUFRQRHUDPDOR\PHQRVHQHVWHFDVRHQTXHODV HQWUDGDVODVSDJDUDQHOORVFRQVXWUDEDMR
(Q HVD SDUWH GH OD FRQYHUVDFL³Q VH GLHURQ FXHQWDGHXQDODUJDILODGHDXWRP³YLOHVHVWDFLRQDGRV IUHQWH D XQD FDVD TXH WHQD XQ HQRUPH EDQGHUQ EODQFRTXHGHFD5(0$7(
ߚ(QWUDPRV" ߚSURSXVR 3DQFKRFR \ ORV VHLV VH DEULHURQ SDVR HQWUH ODV JHQWHV TXH OOHQDEDQ SDVLOORV\VDORQHV
(UD XQD FDVD HVWUHFKD WDQ OOHQD GH FXULRVRV FRPRHOORVTXHVHKDFDGLIFLOUHVSLUDU6RODPHQWH VHYHDDXQVH±RUWUHSDGRHQXQSXSLWUHPX\DOWR TXHKDEODEDPX\OLJHURPRYLHQGRXQPDUWLOOLWRGH XQ ODGR D RWUR FRPR VL IXHUD XQ S©QGXOR &RQ UDSLGH]LQFUHEOHGHFDQºPHURV\QºPHURV
3RUILQVHTXHG³SHJDGRUHSLWLHQGRXQRVROR\ OXHJRGLRXQPDUWLOOD]RVREUHHOSXSLWUH'LMRDOJR TXHQDGLHHQWHQGL³\VHODQ]³RWUDYH]HQSLFDGD
ߚ(VWD IXHQWH GH FULVWDO YHDPRVߨ 7HQJR GRVFLHQWRV FLHQWR FLQFXHQWD YHLQWHߨ ߚ\ GHVSX©V GH HVH U¡SLGR GHVFHQVR QXP©ULFR HPSH]³ QXHYDPHQWH VX FDUUHUD GH QºPHURV HVWD YH] HQ DVFHQVR
ߚ9HLQWLFLQFR WUHLQWD FLQFXHQWD RFKHQWD FLHQߨ ߚ\ HO PDUWLOOLWR LED GH XQ ODGR D RWURߚ \ FLHQWRYHLQWH\GRVFLHQWRV\GRVFLHQWRV\VHYDHQ GRVFLHQWRVVLQDGLHPHMRUD\VHYD\VHYDߨ
(QHVHPRPHQWR3DXODHPSXM³D$QGHFRSDUD YHU XQ SRFR \ ©O SDUD QR FDHU VH SHVF³ GH XQD VH±RUD TXH VH DQGXYR DVXVWDQGR DQWH HO SHOOL]FR (VWR TXH QR WHQD LPSRUWDQFLD SDUD $QGHFR QL 3DXODUHVXOW³JUDYHSDUDODVH±RUD3RUTXHHOVH±RU GHOPDUWLOORTXHHVWDEDDSXQWRGHGDUVXPDUWLOOD]R YLRHVDHVSHFLHGHVDOXGRGHODFDEH]DTXHKL]ROD VH±RUD\VLQP¡VOHDGMXGLF³ODIXHQWHGHFULVWDO
ߚ6H±RUD" ߚHO FRPSD±HUR GHO VH±RU GHO PDUWLOOROHRIUHFDXQSDSHOLWR ߚ4X©SDVD" ߚ(OUHFLERGHODIXHQWHGHFULVWDO ߚb<RQRKHFRPSUDGRHVDIXHQWHߚODYR]GH ODVH±RUDHUDXQUXJLGRGHOH³Q\VXPLUDGDXQFD±³Q GH PHWUDOOHWD $QWH HVRV RMRV 3DXOD \ $QGHFR HPSUHQGLHURQ VLOHQFLRVD UHWLUDGD \ IXHURQ D FRORFDUVHHQXQULQF³QMXQWRDORVRWURVQL±RV
'HVSX©V GH XQD SHOHD VLQ SX±HWHV OD VH±RUD VDOL³GHODFDVDGHUHPDWHVFRQSRPSD\PDMHVWDG\ HO PDUWLOOLWR YROYL³ D YHUVH HQ HO DLUH 3DXOD \ $QGHFRHPSH]DURQDUHVSLUDUPHMRU
$O SRFR UDWR 3DQFKRFR YLR TXH RIUHFDQ XQ EDU³PHWUR FRQ DJXMDV VXUWLGDV \ RWUDV FRVDV GHVHDEOHV6LQVDEHUF³PRVHOHSDU³HOGHGR
ߚ7HQJRXQDRIHUWDGHWUHLQWDߚFDQW³HOVH±RU GHO PDUWLOOR PLU¡QGROR ILMDPHQWH D ORV RMRVߚ \ VH YD HQ WUHLQWD VL QDGLH PHMRUD < WUHLQWD \ FLQFR \ FXDUHQWDߨߚ\FRQWLQXDEDQVXVRMRVFODYDGRVHQORV GHO SREUH 3DQFKRFR TXH VHQWD PDUHRV 7UDWDED GH FRQYHQFHUVH TXH ELHQ YDOD QR LU DO FLUFR VL FRPSUDEDQHOEDU³PHWUR7RWDOVHUDXQJXVWRP¡V ODUJR \ GXUDGHUR &DVL SRU FRPSODFHU DO VH±RU GHO PDUWLOOR SHVWD±H³ \ HQ HVH PLVPR PRPHQWR HVWH JULW³ FRQ YR] GH WULXQIRߚ b$GMXGLFDGR HO EDU³PHWURHQFLQFXHQWD
8QUHFLRJROSHDOSXSLWUHFHUU³HOQHJRFLRHQ HOSUHFLVRLQVWDQWHHQTXH3DQFKRFRVHGDEDFXHQWD GHTXHDSHQDVWHQDQODPLWDGGHOGLQHUR
/H SDUHFL³ TXH VH DEODQGDED HO VXHOR \ DO
VHQWLU HQ HO EUD]R HO URFH GHO SDSHOLWR TXH OH DODUJDED HO HPSOHDGR LQYLW¡QGROR D SDJDU KDEUD TXHULGRWHQHUXQD±RHQYH]GHQXHYH\OORUDUDWRGR JULWR
6H KL]R D XQ ODGR \ IXH FRUUL©QGRVH VLQ GLVLPXOR KDFLD OD SXHUWD 3RUTXH 3DQFKRFR HVWDED GHFLGLGRDVHUIHOL]HQODYLGD\DQRGHMDUTXHORV SUREOHPDVWXUEDUDQVXSURS³VLWR
ߚ2\H ߚOH GLMR D ,Y¡Qߚ 9DPRV D EXVFDU WX ELFLFOHWD \ OD UHPDWDPRV DO WLUR SDUD SDJDU HO EDU³PHWUR 7RWDO WX ELFLFOHWD HV KDUWR YLHMD \ DGHP¡VSRFRVLUYHSRUTXHQRWHGHMDQLUHQHOODD )DUHOORQHVDVTXHHQEXHQDVFXHQWDVQRVLUYHSDUD QDGD
ߚ3HURODELFLFOHWDHVPDߨߚSURWHVW³
ߚb&ODUR (O EDU³PHWUR WDPEL©Q VHU¡ WX\R \ VLUYH P¡V &RQ ©O VDEU¡V VL YD D OORYHU PD±DQD \ SRGUHPRVKDFHUSDQRUDPDVVHJXURV
'LVFXWLHQGR\GLVFXWLHQGRVDOLHURQGHOUHPDWH IXHURQHQEXVFDGHODELFLFOHWD\YROYLHURQFRQHOOD PX\WULXQIDQWHV
$JXDUGDURQMXQWRDODSXHUWDDTXHHOPDUWLOOHUR DQXQFLDUD FDGD FRVD OD VXELHUD \ EDMDUD KDVWD YHQGHUOD\FXDQGRSRUILQ\DQRTXHGDEDQDGD\HO PDUWLOOHURLEDDEDMDUGHOSHGHVWDOVHDFHUFDURQORV GRV FRQ ,Y¡Q PLHQWUDV ORV FKLFRV VRVWHQDQ HQ OD SXHUWDHOLQGHVHDEOHWURIHR ߚ2LJDVH±RUTXHUDPRVTXHUHPDWDUDQXHVWUD ELFLFOHWDߚOHSLGLHURQ ߚ1RH[LVWHQLQJºQORWHGHELFLFOHWDVDTXߚVH GLVFXOS³HOVH±RU ߚb&ODUR3HURODKHPRVWUDGR\OHSHGLPRVHO IDYRUTXHODUHPDWH(VWHUULEOHPHQWHXUJHQWH ߚ/RVLHQWRSHURHVRQRVHSXHGHKDFHUb9R\D FHUUDU ߚ\ IXHURQ LQºWLOHV ORV UXHJRV \ UD]RQHV SRUTXHHOVH±RUHFK¡QGRORVSDUDDIXHUDQROHVGLR XQDHVSHUDQ]D
(QODFDOOHKDEDEDMDGRHOVRO/DWDUGHHVWDED IUD \ VH LED RVFXUHFLHQGR U¡SLGDPHQWH ,Y¡Q \ 3DQFKRFRVHQWDQTXHODYLGDQRWHQDVHQWLGR/RV FKLFRVORVVHJXDQDUUDVWUDQGRODELFLFOHWDFRPRVL IXHUDXQPXHUWR7RGRVHKDEDYXHOWRFRQWUDHOORV\ OD LGHD GH OD F¡UFHO DVRPDED HQ VX LPDJLQDFL³Q FRPRXQWUXHQRTXHVHYHQDDFHUFDQGR
/RVP¡VGHVHVSHUDGRVGHFLGLHURQVROXFLRQDUHO SUREOHPD
ߚ9ROYHUHPRVPD±DQDDSULPHUDKRUDDKDEODU FRQORVGXH±RVSDUDKDFHUORVHQWHQGHUODVUD]RQHV
3RU ºOWLPR SXHGHQ TXHGDUVH FRQ VX PXJUH GH EDU³PHWUR\DVVHDFDEDHOFXHQWRߨ
8QD YH] DQXQFLDGR HVWR D ORV FKLFRV ORV SHFRVRV YROYLHURQ D UHVSLUDU OLEUHPHQWH \ UHJUHVDURQ GRQGH -XDQD PX\ KDPEULHQWRV \ FRQ JDQDV GH GRUPLUVH OXHJR SDUD GHVSHUWDU DO GD VLJXLHQWH\DUUHJODUHOQHJRFLRGHOEDU³PHWUR
(5$ '20,1*2 \ KDED TXH SRQHUVH URSD OLPSLD6LHVWXYLHUDODPDP¡OHVKDEUDUHYLVDGRODV RUHMDV \ FRUWDGR ODV X±DV 3HUR OD PDP¡ QR KDED YXHOWR\SRGDQDKRUUDUVHHVDVPROHVWLDV 3DUWLHURQ WRGRV D PLVD P¡V R PHQRV LPSHFDEOHV (OGDHVWDEDPX\OLQGR\HOSDQRUDPDGHLUDO FLUFRHQODWDUGHORVKDFDFDPLQDUOLJHUR3DXODVH SLV³XQFRUG³QGHO]DSDWR\VHYLQRDOVXHORFRQWDQ PDOD VXHUWH TXH ERW³ D 3HSH \ VH WL]Q³ OD FDUD 5HFLEL³ UHWRV GH ORV PD\RUHV \ RIHQGLGD GHFLGL³ YROYHUDFDVD3HURVHDUUHSLQWL³/RPDORIXHTXH YROYL³DFDHUVHSRUODPLVPDUD]³Q
ߚb+D\TXHVHUWRQWD
ߚ'HSXURIORMDQRVHDPDUUDHO]DSDWRߨ
OORULTXHDEDODSREUHߚ6LHPSUHPHWRFDQDPORV TXHQRTXLHUHQDGLHORVYLHMRVߨ
ߚ(VTXHDWLQRWHFUHFHQORVSLHV
/RJU³ SRU ILQ DWDU HVH FRUG³Q SDUD VLHPSUH FRQXQSHORW³QGHYXHOWDV\QXGRVGHILQLWLYRV
8Q ERW³Q TXH DSHQDV VRQ³ DO FDHU REOLJ³ D $QGHFRDVXMHWDUVHHOSDQWDO³QGXUDQWHWRGDODPLVD 0HQRV PDO TXH HO FDQWR OHV VDOL³ ELHQ (VH GD WHQDQYR]GHQL±RVFDQWRUHVGHYLHQD
$SHQDV WHUPLQDGD OD PLVD SDUWLHURQ ORV VHLV SHFRVRVFDPLQRDODFDVDGHUHPDWHV
ߚ(V PHMRU TXH HQWUHPRV ORV GRV VRORV ߚ GLMHURQ ,Y¡Q \ 3DQFKRFR D ORV GHP¡V FKLFRV \ JROSHDURQODSXHUWD3HURQRYLQRQDGLH(OWLPEUH HVWDEDPDORDVTXHGHFLGLHURQHQWUDUSRUHOMDUGQ \SUREDUVXHUWHHQHOSDWLRGHVHUYLFLR/DSXHUWDGH OD FRFLQD HVWDED FHUUDGD SHUR KDED XQ SRVWLJR HQWUHDELHUWR 8Q HPSXMRQFLWR HQ OD YHQWDQD VROXFLRQ³HOSUREOHPD
(QWUDURQ SRFR D SRFR PLUDQGR SRU VL KDED DOJXLHQ /XHJR FRQ P¡V VHJXULGDG SUHJXQWDURQ ߡ+D\ DOJXLHQ SRU DK"ߢ SHUR QDGLH FRQWHVW³ < HQWRQFHV FRQYHQFLGRV GH TXH OD FDVD HVWDED VROD HQWUDURQFXDUWRSRUFXDUWRH[DPLQDQGRODFDQWLGDG GHFRVDVHQTXHQRUHSDUDURQHOGDDQWHV ߚ(VWDSLVWRODPHKDEUDFRPSUDGR\RߚGLMR ,Y¡QDFDULFLDQGRXQYLHMRWUDEXFRTXHKDEDHQXQ HVWDQWH ߚ< \R HVWD GDJD ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ &KLWDV TXHKD\FRVDVVDOYDMHVDTXߨ ߚ0¡VYDOHQRKDEHUODVYLVWRߚUL³,Y¡QߚVL QR TXL©Q VDEH FX¡QWR HVWDUDPRV GHELHQGR 0HMRU QRV YDPRV 6L YLHQH DOJXLHQ SXHGH SHQVDU TXH HQWUDPRVDUREDU
ߚ'HMHPRV XQD FDUWD SDUD HO GXH±R GHO EDU³PHWURHQWRQFHV
5HJLVWUDURQ KDVWD HQFRQWUDU SDSHO \ HVFULELHURQ
4XHULGRVH±RU
+HPRV YHQLGR D GHFLUOH TXH HO QHJRFLR GHO EDU³PHWURQRUHVXOW³DQRVHUTXHXVWHGQRVUHFLED OD ELFLFOHWD TXH OH SXHGH VHUYLU P¡V TXH HO EDU³PHWUR9HQGUHPRVFRQHOODPD±DQDOXQHV
/RVDOXGDQVXVVVVV
< ILUPDURQ ORV GRV 3DUWLHURQ VDWLVIHFKRV D UHXQLUVH FRQ ORV RWURV SHUR OOHYDQGR GHQWUR XQD VHQVDFL³QQXHYD\XQUHFXHUGRPX\YLYRGHHVDFDVD VROLWDULD ߚ3RGUDPRVKDFHUDOJRHVWXSHQGRHQHVDFDVD DEDQGRQDGD ߚGLMR ,Y¡Qߚ FRQ WDQWD FRVD HQWUHWHQLGDTXHKD\ߨ ߚ9ROYHUHPRVPD±DQDDYHUTX©SDVD
/RV FKLFRV VH UHXQLHURQ FRQ HOORV HQ OD HVTXLQD +DEDQ HQFRQWUDGR D 5HVRUWH TXH DQGDED SHUGLGRGHVGHODQRFKHDQWHULRU\ORWUDDQDPDUUDGR FRQHOFLQWXU³QGH$QGU©V
ߚ(O SREUHFLWR WLHQH XQ KDPEUH WUHPHQGD ߚ H[SOLFDEDQ
3DUWLHURQ DSXUDGRV SDUD GDUOH GHVD\XQR DO KDPEULHQWR +DEODEDQ WRGRV D XQ WLHPSR SHOHDQGR SRUOOHYDUHQVXVEUD]RVDOSHUUR\GHVSX©VSRUQR OOHYDUOR 3HUR DO WRUFHU OD HVTXLQD VH HQFRQWUDURQ FRQ DOJR LQHVSHUDGR +DED XQD UXHGD GH JHQWH DOUHGHGRUGHXQSDUGHDXWRVFKRFDGRV/RVGXH±RV GLVFXWDQFRPRSHUURVIXULRVRV /RVSHFRVRVIXHURQDEUL©QGRVHSDVRSDUDPLUDU HVHSDUGHDXWRVDUUXJDGRVFRPRWUDSRV/RVGXH±RV VHODGUDEDQ$XQROHWHPEODEDQODVPHMLOODVFRPR MDOHD\HORWURWHQDWRGRHQUHGRQGRRMRVERFD\ QDULFHV0LHQWUDVP¡VURMRVHSRQDXQRP¡VS¡OLGR VHWRUQDEDHORWURKDVWDTXHGHSURQWRHOFRORUDGR VHDEDODQ]³VREUHHOEODQFR\ORPDQG³DOVXHORFRQ XQ IHUR] SX±HWH $OJXLHQ WUDW³ GH VXMHWDUOR \ FD\³ FRQ©O2WURTXLVROHYDQWDUDORVFDGRV\URG³SRU WLHUUD 6LQ VDEHU F³PR $QGU©V VDOL³ GLVSDUDGR \ 3DXOD FRUUL³ D DX[LOLDUOR FRQ WDQ PDOD VXHUWH TXH IDOW³ SRFR SDUD TXH OD UHYHQWDUDQ &XDQGR ,Y¡Q \ 3DQFKRFRTXLVLHURQD\XGDUDORVKHUPDQRVDSDUHFL³ XQ FDUDELQHUR FX\D VROD SUHVHQFLD EDVW³ SDUD OLTXLGDUHOQHJRFLRGHODVFDFKHWDGDV\JDUDEDWRV
8QD VH±RUD VH DFHUF³ D 3DXOD \ EDVW³ TXH DOJXLHQVHLQWHUHVDUDSRUVXHVWDGRSDUDTXHHOODVH OOHQDUD GH FRPSDVL³Q GH V PLVPD \ VH ODUJDUD D OORUDU VLQ FRQVXHOR (O FKLFRFR OORUDED SRU DFRPSD±DUOD\ORVGHP¡VFRQIXQGLGRV\DQRVDEDQ QLF³PRVHOODPDEDQ
$OJXLHQVHDFHUF³DOFDUDELQHUR\GHQXQFL³TXH ߡHVRV QL±RV KDEDQ VLGR DWURSHOODGRVߢ -XQWR FRQ DFHUFDUVH HO FDUDELQHUR D 3DXOD ORV SHFRVRV VH YLHURQ URGHDGRV SRU HO PRQW³Q GH FXULRVRV (Q UHDOLGDG 3DXOD \ $QGU©V HVWDEDQ VXFLRV \ UHYROFDGRV \ FXDOTXLHUD SRGD SHQVDU TXH HUDQ YFWLPDV /RV GXH±RV GH ORV DXWRV KDEDQ GHVDSDUHFLGR
ߚ6X QRPEUH" ߚSUHJXQW³ HO FDUDELQHUR D 3DXOD
ߚ3DXODߚVROOR]³HOODVLQWL©QGRVHJUDYH ߚ(VW¡VKHULGD"7HJROSH³HODXWR" ߚ(ODXWRQRODJHQWHߨ
(O FDUDELQHUR VH GHVLQWHUHV³ GH HOOD \ VH DFHUF³DXQFXULRVR
ߚ(VXVWHGHOGXH±RGHODXWR"
(O KRPEUH GLMR ߡQRߢ FRQ OD FDEH]D \ GHVDSDUHFL³
8QD VH±RUD TXH OLPSLDED OD FDUD WL]QDGD GH 3HSHVHDFHUF³
ߚ(VWRV QL±RV LEDQ HQ HO DXWR ߚDVHJXU³ DO FDUDELQHUR
/RV QL±RV VH PLUDURQ VRUSUHQGLGRV (O FDUDELQHURVHSXVRDDQRWDUHQVXOLEUHWDSHURIXH LQWHUUXPSLGR SRU HO VH±RU GH ODV PHMLOODV GH MDOHD TXHDSDUHFL³GHSURQWR
ߚ(QHODXWRQRKDEDP¡VTXHHOFRQGXFWRUߚ GLMR
ߚb)DOVR (VW¡ WUDWDQGR GH VDOYDU VX UHVSRQVDELOLGDG ߚJULW³ OD VH±RUDߚ +D\ P¡V WHVWLJRVߨߚ\VHYROYL³KDFLDORVFXULRVRV
ߚ6ߚGLMRXQDYLHMLWDߚ\RORYLURGDUSRUHO VXHORVH±RUFDUDELQHURߨ
(O FDUDELQHUR DQRWDED SLGLHQGR QRPEUHV \ GRPLFLOLRV PLHQWUDV OD UXHGD GH PLURQHV LED WRPDQGR SDUWLGR $TXHOOR VH FRQYLUWL³ HQ XQD JXHUULOOD GH SDODEUDV HQ OD TXH ORV KRPEUHV OOHYDEDQODFRQWUDDODVPXMHUHVDVHJXUDQGRTXHORV QL±RVQRLEDQHQQLQJºQDXWR
ߚ3DUD DFODUDU WRGR HVWR VHU¡ PHMRU TXH YHQJDQFRQPLJRDODFRPLVDUDߚGLMRHOFDUDELQHUR DORVSHFRVRV
ߚ1RSRGHPRVߚH[SOLF³,Y¡Qߚ7HQHPRVTXH YROYHU D FDVD DQWHV GH TXH 5HVRUWH VH PXHUD GH KDPEUHߨ ߚ\ SDUWLHURQ FRUULHQGR PLHQWUDV HO FDUDELQHURVHUDVFDEDODFDEH]DWUDWDQGRGHDFODUDU
ORTXHKDEDSDVDGR
38178$/0(17( D ODV GRV GH OD WDUGH DSDUHFL³ &©VDU FRPR KDED SURPHWLGR 9HQD WDQ OLPSLR \ PRMDGR GH SHOR TXH ORV SHFRVRV VH VLQWLHURQREOLJDGRVDODYDUVHODFDUDSDUDVDOLUFRQ ©O
ߚ9DPRV D LU SRU DK ߚOH GLMHURQ D -XDQD \ HOOD TXH WHQD KDUWDV JDQDV GH GRUPLUVH XQD VLHVWHFLWDORVGHM³LUSHURELHQVHUPRQHDGRV ߚ7RGLWRVGHODPDQR\QDGDGHKDFHUOHVHUDV ߚIXHVXGHVSHGLGD <SDUWLHURQ$GHODQWHPDUFKDED&©VDUFRQ,Y¡Q \3DQFKRFR\ORVVHJXDQORVRWURVWRPDGRVGHOD PDQRFRPRRUGHQDUD-XDQD
&©VDU HOLJL³ HO EXV &©VDU SDJ³ ORV EROHWRV \ WDPEL©QIXH&©VDUTXLHQGLRODRUGHQGHEDMDGD
WXYLHURQTXHFDPLQDUEDVWDQWHSDUDOOHJDUDOFLUFR 1R HUD WDQ OLQGR FRPR OR KDEDQ LPDJLQDGR SRUTXH OD FDUSD HVWDED URWD \ VXFLD 8QD UHMD GH SDOLWRV KDFD FDPLQRV KDFLD OD HQWUDGD \ WUHV PºVLFRV YLHMRV VLQ GLVIUD] WRFDEDQ XQ WDPERU FRQ SLWR \ FRUQHWD +DED WDPEL©Q XQ EXTXH PDQLFHUR TXHHFKDEDKXPLWRDWRVWDGR\ORVFKLFRVVXSOLFDEDQ D &©VDU TXH OHV FRPSUDUD XQ FDUWXFKR 3HUR &©VDU QRVHGHM³FRQPRYHU\IXHDODEROHWHUDDSDJDUODV HQWUDGDV
&RPR HUDQ GH JDOHUD WXYLHURQ TXH VXELU HVFDORQHV JUDQGHV \ WHPEOHTXHV TXH VH FROXPSLDEDQ DO SLVDUORV +DED XQ VXDYH RORU D HPSDQDGDV \ XQD HVSHFLH GH IDOWD GH VRQLGR HQ JHQHUDO /D SLVWD GH DVHUUQ OD URGHDEDQ PXUDOOLWDV GH PDGHUD DOJXQDV FDGDV \ DO IRQGR KDED XQD FRUWLQD URMD VREUH OD FXDO VH DFRPRGDURQ ORV PºVLFRV
/RV SHFRVRV RFXSDEDQ WRGR XQ WDEO³Q GH JDOHUDSHURVXVSLHUQDVQRDOFDQ]DEDQHOSLVR\QR SRGDQDILUPDUVH5RPSL³ODEDQGDFRQXQDPDUFKD GHVWHPSODGD DQWH OD FXDO GHVILO³ WRGR HO SHUVRQDO ,EDDGHODQWHXQVH±RUELJRWXGRGHFKDTXHWDURMDFRQ JDORQHVGRUDGRVTXHOOHYDEDXQDODUJDKXDVFD\XQ SLWRTXHUHVRQDEDHQODVWULSDVGHORVHVSHFWDGRUHV /RVHJXDQORVWUDSHFLVWDV\OXHJRORVSD\DVRVFRQ VXV URSDV HQRUPHV FDUDV EODQFDV UD\DGDV \ DOJºQ VRPEUHULWRTXHFDDDOVXHORWRGRHOWLHPSR
/D IXQFL³Q IXH PDJQILFD DXQTXH DO ILQDO VRQDEDQ WDQ IXHUWH ODV KDPEULHQWDV WULSDV TXH QR HVFXFKDEDQODPºVLFD ߚ/O©YDQRVDFRQRFHUDWXWRߚOHH[LJLHURQD &©VDUFRPRFRQVXHOR<&©VDUVHDEUL³SDVRHQWUH ODJHQWHTXHVDODSDUDHQWUDUDODFDUSD\OOHJDUD ORVFDPHULQRV(UDXQDFDVDURGDQWHPX\SLQWDGD\ OOHQDGHFROJDMRVGHURSDV\GHPDVHV
ߚb+ROD WR ߚGLMR &©VDU DFHUF¡QGRVH DO DFU³EDWDTXHDºQOOHYDEDODPDOODFRQFDO]RQFLOORV GHOHQWHMXHODVEULOODQWHV
ߚb+RODߚGLMRHOWRVLQGDUOHQLQJXQDEROD DOVREULQRQLDVXVDFRPSD±DQWHV
&©VDUORVSUHVHQW³GHWRGRVPRGRV
ߚ7R HOORV TXLHUHQ WRPDU FODVHV GH DFUREDFLD
(OWRVHGLRYXHOWDORVPLU³ODUJDPHQWHFRQVX ºQLFR RMR \ IXH KDFL©QGRORV JLUDU XQR SRU XQR FRPRTXLHQHOLJHSROORV
ߚ$V TXH FODVHV GH DFUREDFLDߨ ߚGLMR FRQ FDUUDVSHUDߚ7RGRVHOORV"ߚSUHJXQW³DOVREULQR
ߚ/RVTXHXVWHGTXLHUDߚGLMR,Y¡Q
ߚ3RGUD VHU +DEUD TXH YHU VL WLHQHQ FRQGLFLRQHV&X¡QWDVFODVHVSRUVHPDQD"
ߚ(VRGHSHQGHGHORTXHFXHVWHQODVFODVHVߚ GLMR,Y¡Q
ߚ1RVHSUHRFXSHSRUHVR<RPHDUUHJORFRQ HOSDS¡GHXVWHGHV7LHQHQSDS¡"
ߚ6 FODUR 3HUR ©O QR VDEH GH HVWR ߚGLMR 3DXOD 3DQFKRFR OH GLR XQ SXQWDSL© HQ OD FDQLOOD SDUDTXHVHFDOODUD
ߚb%UXWR &UHHV TXH QR GXHOH" ߚODJULPH³ 3DXOD ߚ$YHUVLWHFDOODVߚVRSO³©OSRUOREDMR ߚ$TX©KRUDFRQYLHQHTXHYD\DDKDEODUFRQ HVHSDS¡"ߚSUHJXQW³HODFU³EDWD ߚ(VHQRWLHQHSDS¡ߚVHHQWURPHWL³3DXODVLQ O¡JULPDVLQGLFDQGRD3DQFKRFR ߚ+DEODU©FRQODPDP¡7LHQHSDWLRODFDVD" &X¡OHVODGLUHFFL³Q"
3DQFKRFR VH DGHODQW³ D GDUOD \ DKRUD IXH ©O TXLHQVHOOHY³ODSDWDGDHQODFDQLOODFRQODVDQGDOLD GH3DXOD
ߚb,GLRWD ߚVH YROYL³ SDUD FRJHUOD GH ODV PHFKDVSHURHOODVHHVFDS³
,Y¡Q FRPSUHQGL³ HO PRWLYR GH OD SDWDGD GH 3DXOD\VHDFHUF³D3DQFKRFR ߚ2\HߚOHGLMRߚDORPHMRUHVPX\FDUR\ QRYDQDTXHUHUSDJDUOH ߚ(VR OR DUUHJOR \R ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFR PX\ VHJXURGHFRQYHQFHUDORVWRVߚ9HQJDPD±DQDHQ ODWDUGH&©VDUVDEHHOFDPLQR
ߚ&RQIRUPH<KDUWRELHQTXHOHVYHQGU¡QODV FODVHVSRUTXHVHYHQPHGLRPHUHQJXHVWRGRVߨ
-XQWRFRQGHVSHGLUVHHPSH]³ODGLVFXVL³Q ߚ<R V© TXH OD PDP¡ OR YD D HQFRQWUDU FDUR 7RGRORHQFXHQWUDFDURߚGLMR0DUFHOD ߚ(VWH JDOOR HV UHEDUDWR 1R KD\ P¡V TXH YHUORߨ\WXPDP¡HVWDU¡IHOL]SRUTXHOHSUHRFXSD TXHXVWHGHVFUH]FDQ\HQJRUGHQߨ ߚ7ºQRWLHQHVSRUTX©PHWHUWHDFRPSOLFDUD PLPDP¡ߚDOHJ³3DXOD3HUR3DQFKRFRODLJQRU³\ HOODVLJXL³SURWHVWDQGR
ߚ$ OR PHMRU DSUHQGHPRV WRGR HQ XQD SXUD FODVHߚGLMR,Y¡QWUHSDQGRDODPLFUR\VLQWL©QGRVH \DP¡VIXHUWH3HURHQHVHPRPHQWRSDUWL³HOEXV\ ORPDQG³YRODQGRDXQULQF³Q
&8$1'2YROYLHURQDFDVD-XDQDDºQGRUPD 0DUFHODSUHSDU³XQDVWRVWDGDVFRQPDQWHTXLOOD DJUHJDGD DO JXVWR GH FDGD XQR QR KL]R IDOWD QDGD P¡V 6H DFDE³ HO KDPEUH HO SDQ \ WDPEL©Q OD PDQWHTXLOOD 3HUR TXHGDED OX] GH PRGR TXH GHFLGLHURQGDUVHXQDYXHOWDSRUODFDVDGHUHPDWHV
$IRUWXQDGDPHQWH HVWDED DELHUWD OD PLVPD YHQWDQD GH PRGR TXH QR KXER SUREOHPDV SDUD HQWUDU 3HUR OD FDVD HVWDED WRWDOPHQWH YDFD /R ºQLFRTXHHQFRQWUDURQIXHXQFKRQJRGHHVFRED\XQ PRQW³Q GH SDSHOHV HQWUH ORV FXDOHV KDED XQDV HWLTXHWDVGHFDUWXOLQDFRQFRUGHO
ߚ6RQPDVߚGHFODU³$QGU©VߚSRUTXH\RODV JDQ©ߚSHURQDGLHOHGLVFXWL³
/DFDVDUHVRQDEDFRQHFR\VXVSDVRV\YRFHV UHSHUFXWDQ'DEDXQDVHQVDFL³QGHVHUGHHOORV
ߚ<TX©KDUHPRVDTX"ߚSUHJXQW³0DUFHOD ߚ(VWD FDVD QR VLUYH SDUD FDVD HPEUXMDGD 7LHQH ODV SXHUWDV EODQFDV \ P¡V SDUHFH FOQLFD 3DQFKRFRODPLUDEDFRQGHVSUHFLR
ߚ<RKDEDSHQVDGRHQKDFHUXQDJXDULGDXQD FXHYDߨ3HURSRGUDPRVKDFHUODFOQLFDVLTXLHUHV ߚGLMR,Y¡Q
1R KDED PDWHULDO SDUD LQVWDODUOD VDOYR DOJXQDV ERWHOODV VXFLDV \ XQD WDEOD GH DPDVDU TXH HQFRQWUDURQHQHOSDWLR
ߚ3DXOD \ 0DUFHOD bD ODYDU ߚRUGHQ³ 3DQFKRFRLQGLFDQGRODVERWHOODV
&RORFDURQ OD WDEOD VREUH HO ODYDSODWRV \ GHFLGLHURQ TXH OD FRFLQD VHUD OD VDOD GH RSHUDFLRQHV +DED JDV HQ OD OODYH GH PRGR TXH SRGUDQ HVWHULOL]DU HO LQVWUXPHQWDO FXDQGR OR FRQVLJXLHUDQ 0DUFHODHQFRQWU³XQFDUW³QHQHOFXDOGLEXM³XQ PDJQILFROHWUHUR
*
5$1&
/1,&$3$5$3(5526<*$726
35(&,26'(2&$6,1 (OOHWUHURIXHFRORFDGRHQODSXHUWD (QWUHWDQWRKDEDRVFXUHFLGR\HQWRGDODFDVD QRHQFRQWUDURQXQDVRODDPSROOHWDSDUDDOXPEUDUVH /DRVFXULGDGHPSH]DEDDLQIXQGLUOHVUHVSHWR\DXQ FXDQGRKDEDQGHFODUDGRTXHHVDFDVDQRVHUYDQL SDUD PLVWHULRV QL HPEUXMRV QLQJXQR VH DWUHYD D VHSDUDUVHGHOJUXSRߚ0HMRUYROYDPRVPD±DQDߚGLMR3DXODߚQR VHSXHGHKDFHUQDGDVLQOX]
(Q UHDOLGDG HPSH]DEDQ D YHU IDQWDVPDV SRU WRGRV ODGRV GH PRGR TXH OD LGHD GH LUVH IXH DFRJLGD<SDUWLHURQFRQYHUVDQGR
ߚ0D±DQD WUDHUHPRV DPSROOHWDV \ ORV LQVWUXPHQWRVGHRSHUDFLRQHV
ߚ<DOJRG³QߚGLMR0DUFHOD
ߚ< GHVLQIHFWDQWH ߚVXJLUL³ HO FKLFRFR PLUDQGRVXVURGLOODVKHULGDV
ߚ(O 5HVRUWH SXHGH VHUYLU SDUD GDUOHV FRQILDQ]DDORVSHUURVHQIHUPRVߚGLMR$QGU©V
ߚ<R DWLHQGR DO SºEOLFR ߚGLMR 3DXODߚ &X¡QWRYDQDSHGLUSRUODVRSHUDFLRQHV"
ߚ'HSHQGHߚGLMHURQORVYHWHULQDULRV
ߚ'HSHQGH GH TX©" ߚSUHJXQW³ OD UHODFLRQDGRUD
ߚ%XHQR GH OD RSHUDFL³Q GHO DQLPDO GHO GXH±Rߨ
RVHDODDUVHQDOHUD
ߚ<RTXLHURD\XGDUDGHIHQGHUDORSHUDGRߚ GHFODU³$QGU©V
ߚ<TX©KDJR\R"ߚSUHJXQW³3HSH
ߚ7º SXHGHV DEULU OD SXHUWD ERWDU ORV DOJRGRQHVVXFLRV\EDUUHUߚGLMRDOJXLHQ
ߚ0H JXVWDUD RWUD FRVD ߚVH GHVDQLP³ HO FKLFRFR
ߚb3RGUDV VHU GDGRU GH VDQJUH ߚVXJLUL³ 3DQFKRFR
ߚb<D ߚHVR OH SDUHFL³ HVWXSHQGRߚ &³PR ORKDJR" ߚ1RWHSUHRFXSHV0D±DQDORVDEU¡Vߨ ߚb/¡VWLPD TXH WHQJDPRV FROHJLR PD±DQD ߚ VXVSLU³,Y¡Q <DVOOHJDURQDODFDVDKDFLHQGRSUR\HFWRV\ VLQVRVSHFKDUODVRUSUHVDTXHOHVHVSHUDED (QODPHVDGHHQWUDGDKDEDXQWHOHJUDPD,Y¡Q ORWRP³\YLRFRQVRUSUHVDTXHHUDSDUD©O ߚb(V SDUD P ߚH[FODP³ HQWXVLDVPDGR \ OR OH\³ HQ YR] DOWDߚ ߡ5HJUHVDUHPRV PD±DQD WDUGH &DUL±RVPDP¡ߢ
ߚb4X© SHQD ߚVXVSLU³ 0DUFHOD \ ORV KHUPDQRVVLQWLHURQXQUHIOHMRGHHVDSHQDTXHGXU³ SRFRSRUTXH3DQFKRFRGLMR
ߚb)HQ³PHQR6LODWDQROOHJDHQODPD±DQD
SRGHPRV WUDEDMDU GHVGH WHPSUDQR HQ OD FOQLFD 6L HOOD OR HVW¡ SDVDQGR ELHQ HVWR\ VHJXUR GH TXH TXHUU¡ TXH QRVRWURV WDPEL©Q OR SDVHPRV ELHQ (V QDWXUDOb1RYDPRVDOFROHJLR /DLGHDFD\³HVWXSHQGDDXQTXH,Y¡Q\0DUFHOD QRHVWDEDQPX\VHJXURV\VRORHOHQWXVLDVPRGHORV RWURVORVFRQYHQFL³ ߚ+DUHPRV KXHOJD GH VXH±R \ QR GHVSHUWDUHPRVKDVWDTXHVHKD\DSDVDGRODKRUDߚ GLMR 3DQFKRFRߚ (Q (VWDGRV 8QLGRV OD KDFHQ VLHPSUH $XQTXH QRV UHPH]FD OD -XDQD QDGLH GHVSLHUWDPD±DQDߨ
&XDQGR YLQR -XDQD DO GD VLJXLHQWH D GHVSHUWDUORVQRKXERFDVRQLVXVVDFXGRQHVQLVXV JULWRVORJUDURQVDFDUGHOVXH±RDORVGRUPLGRV
ߚb'HVSLHUWHQ ߚFKLOODED -XDQD FRQ VX P¡V SRGHURVD YR]ߚ (V KRUD GH LUVH QL VLTXLHUD DOFDQ]DU¡Q D WRPDU GHVD\XQߨ b4X© GLU¡ VX PDP¡ FXDQGRGHVSLHUWH\YHDTXHHVW¡QDWUDVDGRV
ߚ1R GHVSHUWDU¡ SRUTXH QR OOHJ³ DQRFKH ߚ GLMR,Y¡QDEULHQGRXQRMR\FHUU¡QGRORRWUDYH]ߚ b1ROOHJDU¡KDVWDODQRFKH\KR\QRKD\FROHJLR ߚ3RUTX©QRKD\FROHJLR"1DGLHPHGLMRTXH QRKDEDFROHJLR ߚ3HUR QR KD\ (V 6DQ *RORWHR \ KD\ DVXHWR '©MDQRVGRUPLUߨ +DEODQGRVRODVHIXH-XDQDQRPX\FRQYHQFLGD
\ DSHQDV VH SHUGLHURQ VXV SDVRV HQ OD HVFDOD VDOWDURQORVFKLFRVGHODFDPD
ߚb4X©ODWDGRUPLU9DPRVOXHJRDODFOQLFDߨ 6H YLVWLHURQ WRGRV D HVFDSH \ WRPDURQ VX GHVD\XQRVLQUHVXHOOR/XHJRHPSH]³ODUHFROHFFL³Q GH ߡLQVWUXPHQWDOߢ \ RWUDV FRVDV QHFHVDULDV SDUD LQVWDODUODFOQLFD
6H GHVSLGLHURQ FDUL±RVDPHQWH GH -XDQD DVHJXU¡QGROH TXH HVWDUDQ PX\ WUDQTXLORV HQ XQD FDVDYHFLQDSDUDDVGDUOHDHOODWDPEL©QDVXHWRHQ QRPEUH GH 6DQ *RORWHR ,EDQ ELHQ FDUJDGRV SHUR FRQWHQWRV\OOHQRVGHSUR\HFWRV
(O WUDEDMR IXH GLVWULEXLGR \ FDGD XQR FXPSOD FRQ HQWXVLDVPR VX REOLJDFL³Q /D VDOD GH RSHUDFLRQHV TXHG³ HVWXSHQGD FRQ VXV ERWHOODV ODYDGDV \ DOJXQDV DJXDV GLVWLQWDV HQ HOODV DJXD DOLYLRODGD DJXD PHMRUDGD DJXD EXUEXMHQWD DJXD MDERQDGD HWF©WHUD (Q SHUIHFWD KLOHUD GDED XQD VHQVDFL³Q GH FLUXJD FRQ WRGDV ODV KHUUDPLHQWDV RUGHQDGDV VREUH XQ SD±R OLPSLR GH FRFLQD (O DOJRG³QVREUHVDODGHXQIUDVFR\KDEDRWUROOHQR GHWLUDVTXHVHUYLUDQGHYHQGDV
$QGU©V FHGL³ VXV HWLTXHWDV D 3DXOD FRPR FRQWUDVH±D SDUD ORV FOLHQWHV TXH SDJDUDQ SRU DGHODQWDGR
/D VDOD GH HVSHUD WHQD FRPR VRI¡ XQD WDEOD VREUH GRV FDMRQHV XQ IORUHUR \ DOJXQDV UHYLVWDV
YLHMDVVREUHRWURFDM³Q(VWDEDSHUIHFWD ߚ$KRUDHQWUHQ\VDOJDQYDULDVYHFHVߚRUGHQ³ ,Y¡QDORVFKLFRVߚ+D\TXHGHVSHUWDUODFXULRVLGDG GHORVYHFLQRV&RQHO5HVRUWH <HVWDVHGHVSHUW³LQPHGLDWDPHQWH8QDQL±LWD TXHORVPLUDEDGHVGHODFDVDGHOIUHQWHSUHJXQW³ ߚ4X©SDVDDK"
ߚ(V XQD FOQLFD GH DQLPDOHV HQIHUPRV ߚ H[SOLF³$QGU©V ߚ0L JDWR HVW¡ HQIHUPR ߚGLMR OD FKLFD DO PRPHQWR ߚ4X©WLHQH" ߚ$UHVWQߚGLMRODQL±DFRQPRGRLQWHUHVDQWH ߚ3XHGHVWUDHUORVLTXLHUHVߚGLMR3DXOD $ORVSRFRVPLQXWRVOOHJ³ODQL±LWDFRQVXJDWR DUHVWLQLHQWRTXHGDEDO¡VWLPD3DXODODKL]RVHQWDUVH \HVSHUDU\OHGLRVXFRQWUDVH±D
/D GLMR \ HQWU³ GH LQPHGLDWR DO SDEHOO³Q GH RSHUDFLRQHV
3DQFKRFRVHFDODEDORVJXDQWHVGHJRPDH,Y¡Q OH FRORFDED XQ SD±XHOR HQ OD ERFD SDUD HYLWDU FRQWDJLRV
ߚ(OHQIHUPRHVXQJDWRFRQDUHVWQߚH[SOLF³ ߚb&KLWDV (VFRQGH DO 5HVRUWH SRUTXH VH SHJDߨQRGHEHUDPRVUHFLELUHQIHUPRVFRQWDJLRVRV ߚGLMR,Y¡Q
ߚ3HRU HV QR WHQHU HQIHUPRV ߚGHFODU³ 3DQFKRFRߚ+D]ODSDVDU
(OFKLFRFR\$QGU©VVHHQFDUJDURQGHHVFRQGHU D 5HVRUWH HQ XQ FO³VHW \ OD FOLHQWH HQWU³ SRU ILQ D SDEHOO³Q ߚ%XHQDVWDUGHVߚGLMR3DQFKRFRH[DPLQDQGR DOJDWRߚ(VWRHVPX\FRQWDJLRVRb1DGLHWRTXHDO DQLPDOߚRUGHQ³DVXVD\XGDQWHV <OXHJRGHFRORFDUXQGLDULRVREUHODPHVDGH RSHUDFLRQHVSURFHGL³DFRUWDUOHHOSHORDOJDWR\OR XQW³HQWHURFRQGHVLQIHFWDQWH 7RGRV PLUDEDQ PDQWHQL©QGRVH D GLVWDQFLD PLHQWUDV OD GXH±D OORULTXHDED DO YHU HO HVWDGR ODVWLPHURGHVXUHJDO³Q
(OFLUXMDQRDGYLUWL³HOODJULPHRGHODGXH±DGHO JDWR\GHFLGL³DFODUDUODVFRVDV
ߚ2\H ߚOH GLMRߚ FRUWD HO OORULTXHRߨ 7H DGYLHUWR TXH DTX QR VH DFHSWDQ HQIHUPRV FRQWDJ LRVRV DV TXH HVWR\ FXUDQGR D WX J DWR GH OR SXURFULVWLDQRTXHVR\7ºO¡YDWHELHQODVPDQRV\ OO©YDWHOHMRVDWXHQIHUPRߨ
0DUFHODOOHY³DODQL±LWDDODYDUVHHQODOODYH GHO MDUGQ SDUD QR FRQWDPLQDU OD FOQLFD \ HVSHU³ ³UGHQHV
ߚ+D\ TXH TXHPDU WRGR HVWR ߚRUGHQ³ 3DQFKRFRDRWURD\XGDQWHTXHVDOL³FRQHOSDSHOFRQ SHORV D KDFHU XQD IRJDWD HQ HO MDUGQ (O KXPR DSHVWDEDߨ(OJDWRSHODGR\SLQWDGRGHURMRSDUHFD IODFR\VDQJULHQWR\GDEDKRUURUDWRGRV
ߚb&³PRSXGLVWHKDFHUHVRߚUHFODPDEDQORV D\XGDQWHVPLHQWUDVODGXH±DGHOJDWRQLVHDWUHYDD WRFDUOR
ߚ6L WHQHPRV FOQLFD GHEHPRV FXUDU D ORV HQIHUPRV (VH JDWR DUHVWLQLHQWR LED D FRQWDJLDU D WRGRVORVDQLPDOHVVDQRVGH6DQWLDJRߨ
ߚ$KRUD WH OR OOHYDV \ VLJXH ODY¡QGRWH ODV PDQRVWRGRHOGD7DOYH]VHDPHMRUXQW¡UWHODVFRQ GHVLQIHFWDQWHߨ ߚ\ FRQ XQ QXHYR DOJRG³Q HO DV©SWLFR FLUXMDQR GHM³ FRORUHDQGR ORV GHGRV GH OD GXH±DGHOJDWR
$ODVDOLGDGHOHQIHUPR3DXODVHQHJ³DFREUDU ORV KRQRUDULRV PLHQWUDV 3DQFKRFR DOHJDED FRQWUD HOOD
ߚ+HPRV JDVWDGR HO IUDVFR HQWHUR GH GHVLQIHFWDQWH DOJRG³Q \ GHPDVHV b4XHGDV GHVSHGLGDVLQRFXPSOHVWXREOLJDFL³QߚOHGLMR
(QWUHWDQWRHOJDWRVHHVFDS³DWRGRFRUUHU\OD GXH±D VDOL³ GLVSDUDGD WUDV ©O (O HQIHUPR SDUHFD
XQDORPEUL]FRQSDWDV\VHSHUGL³GHYLVWD
$K TXHGDURQ ORV JDOHQRV GLVFXWLHQGR \ OLPSLDQGR3DQFKRFRKL]RKHUYLUORVJXDQWHVTXHVH GHVKLFLHURQGXOFHPHQWHHQWUHODVEXUEXMDVGHDJXD $IRUWXQDGDPHQWHVRQ³HOWLPEUHGHODSXHUWD\ ODGLVFXVL³QWHUPLQ³FRPRSRUHQFDQWR ߚb7RFDQߚ3DXODVDOL³FRUULHQGRߚ'HEHVHU RWURFOLHQWHߨ *UDQGHVHQFDQWR(UDQGRVKRPEUHVTXHWUDDQ XQDVO¡PSDUDV\H[LJDQTXHOHVILUPDUDQHOUHFLER ,Y¡QGHFLGL³GDUOHVHQHOJXVWR\ILUP³FRQPXFKRV JDUDEDWRVHOSDSHO/XHJRORVKRPEUHVVHIXHURQ
ߚ3RGUDPRV FRORFDU ODV O¡PSDUDV ߚGLMR DOJXLHQ \ SDUHFD O³JLFR KDFHUOR ,Y¡Q EDM³ OD SDODQFD GH OD OX] \ SURFHGLHURQ D LQVWDODU XQD GH HOODV HQ HO SDEHOO³Q GH RSHUDFLRQHV 6H YHD IHQ³PHQR\DOXPEUDEDP¡VTXHHOGD
0LHQWUDV FHOHEUDEDQ HVWH DGHODQWR GH OD FOQLFD VRQ³ RWUD YH] HO WLPEUH 5¡SLGDPHQWH ORV HOHFWULFLVWDV VH WUDQVIRUPDURQ HQ P©GLFRV \ FDGD FXDOWRP³VXSXHVWR
3DXOD DEUL³ OD SXHUWD GHFLGLGD D FREUDU SRU DGHODQWDGR OD FRQVXOWD \ PHUHFHU HO SXHVWR TXH VH UHVLVWL³DGHMDU3HURQRHUDXQFOLHQWHQXHYRHUDOD PLVPDQL±LWDHVWDYH]FRQVXVPDQRVYHQGDGDV
ߚ0H DUGDQ WDQWR TXH OD PDP¡ WXYR TXH FXU¡UPHODVߚH[SOLF³
ߚ(VH HV HO DUHVWQ TXH WH FRPLHQ]D ߚOD WUDQTXLOL]³3DQFKRFR
ߚ7DPEL©Q TXHUD GHFLUOHV TXH HO JDWR VH PXUL³ߨ
ߚ6H PXUL³" 1R SXHGH VHUߨ b$QGD D EXVFDUOR
ߚ/DPDP¡ORHFK³DOWDUURGHEDVXUD0XUL³ SRUTXHOD)UHVLDORDJDUU³DSXQWDGHHVFRED]RVߨ
+XER XQ VXVSLUR JHQHUDO GH DOLYLR \ OD QL±LWD SURVLJXL³
ߚ(Q UHDOLGDG HO JDWR QR HUD PR 1L V© GH TXL©QHUDSHURODPDP¡OHKDEDGLFKRDOD)UHVLD TXHORPDWDUDVLYROYDDDSDUHFHU ߚ'HWRGRVPRGRVWºQRVGHEHVXQIUDVFRGH GHVLQIHFWDQWH\XQSDUGHJXDQWHVGHJRPD ߚ6V©TXHORVGHERߚGLMRODFOLHQWH ߚb3¡JDORVHQWRQFHV
ߚ(V TXH VL ORV SDJR QR ORV GHER < TXLHUR GHEHUORVSDUDMXJDUFRQXVWHGHV
ߚb2\H WLHQHV ORV DODPEUHV SHODGRV b/DV GHXGDVKD\TXHSDJDUODVߚDOHJ³,Y¡Q
ߚb&ODUR < \R TXLHUR SDJDU OD PD FRQ WUDEDMR4X©SXHGRKDFHU"
ߚ0DQGDUWH D FDPELDU ߚGLMR 3DQFKRFR HQRMDGRߚb1RWHQHFHVLWDPRV
ߚ3XHGHVWUDHUFOLHQWHVߚGLMR0DUFHODߚ\ߨ
3HURHQWRQFHVVRQ³HOWLPEUH
ߚb/¡UJDWH ߚRUGHQ³ 3DQFKRFR PLHQWUDV 3DXODFRUUDDDEULUODSXHUWD(OWLPEUHVRQDEDFRQ LQVLVWHQFLDDXQFXDQGR3DXODDEUL³ODSXHUWD
ߚ6H SHJ³ HO WLPEUH ߚGLMR $QGU©V 0LHQWUDV FRUUD D GHVSHJDUOR VH HQFRQWU³ FRQ XQ LQPHQVR FDPL³Q\FXDWURKRPEUHVTXHEDMDEDQXQSLDQR
ߚ'³QGH OR FRORFDPRV" ߚSUHJXQWDEDQ PX\ FRORUDGRVPLHQWUDVRWURLQVLVWDHQTXHILUPDUDQXQ UHFLER 6H PLUDURQ WRGRV \ GHVSX©V GH FDPELDU LGHDV ORGHMDURQLQVWDODGRHQXQULQF³Q(OSLDQREDM³DO VXHORHVWUHSLWRVDPHQWH\DKTXHG³VRQDQGRGXUDQWH EDVWDQWHUDWR ,Y¡QILUP³HOUHFLER\ORVKRPEUHVVHIXHURQ ߚ3URE©PRVOR" ߚ3DQFKRFR WUDMR XQ FDM³Q TXHVLUYL³GHVLOOD\FRPHQ]³DLPSURYLVDU,Y¡Q\HO FKLFRFRORDFRPSD±DURQ+DEDWHFODV\QRWDVSDUD ORV WUHV \ VRQDED IHQ³PHQR HQ OD FDVD YDFD /RV HVSHFWDGRUHVDSODXGDQUDELRVDPHQWH
ߚ(V XQD OHVHUD OR GH OD FOQLFD ߚGHFODU³ 3DQFKRFRߚ 0HMRU GDUHPRV XQ FRQFLHUWR HVWD WDUGHߨ
/D LGHD IXH DSUREDGD SHUR FRPR WHQDQ KDPEUH FHUUDURQ ELHQ OD FDVD \ VH IXHURQ D DOPRU]DU
'85$17( HO DOPXHU]R VH SURGXMR XQD GLVFXVL³QHQWUHORVYLUWXRVRVGHOSLDQR\HOUHVWRGH ODIDPLOLD
ߚb8VWHGHV VH FUHHQ HO KR\R GHO TXHTXH ߚ GHFD 3DXODߚ < FRPR YDQ D WRFDU QRVRWURV QRV DEXUULUHPRVFRPROHVRV
ߚ1RVRWURV VRPRV ORV DUWLVWDV HV GHFLU ORV TXHVHVDFULILFDQWUDEDMDQGRPLHQWUDVXVWHGHVR\HQ JUDWLV\FRPSDUWHQORTXHJDQDPRVVLQKDFHUQDGDߨ
ߚb&ODUR 4X© VH FUHHQ" 9DPRV D ODWHDUQRV WRGDODWDUGHߨ
ߚ3RGUDQKDFHUXQFRURߨREDLODUߚSURSXVR 3DQFKRFR
ߚ7º QRV FUHV LGLRWDV ߚ$QGHFR HVWDED LQGLJQDGR\QRTXHUDGHMDUVHSLWDU
PXHUWHߚ\DVVHIXHFDOHQWDQGRHO¡QLPRVHVXEL³ ODPRVWD]D\YLQLHURQORVSX±HWHV
-XDQD ORV HFK³ DIXHUD D SHOHDU 6DF³ LQVRVSHFKDGDVHQHUJDV\VHKL]RREHGHFHU
'H SURQWR 3DXOD GHVFXEUL³ XQDV FDEH]DV DVRPDGDVSRUHQFLPDGHODPXUDOOD\VHDFHUF³
ߚ4X© PLUDQ" ߚSUHJXQW³ FUX]DQGR DWU¡V ODV PDQRV
ߚ/DSHOHDߨߚGLMHURQDXQDYR]ORVLQWUXVRV ߚ3RUTX©SHOHDQ"
ߚ3RU SHOHDU ߚGLMR XQR GH ORV FKLFRVߚ < XVWHGHVSRUTX©PLUDQ"
ߚ3RU PLUDU ߚFRQWHVWDURQ ODV GRV FDEH]DV DO PLVPRWLHPSR
ߚ&³PR VH OODPDQ" ߚSUHJXQW³ HVWD YH] 0DUFHOD ߚ5DP³Q \ /H³Q 6RPRV PHOOL]RV ߚVHJXDQ FRQWHVWDQGRDFRUR ߚ6RQGHORVSHJDGRV"3RUTX©KDEODQDXQ WLHPSR" ߚ(V TXH SHQVDPRV LJXDO 3RU HVR QRV DEXUULPRVߨ ߚ< QR WLHQHQ MXJXHWHV" ߚDOJXLHQ SUHJXQW³ EXUO³Q
ߚ7RGRV ORV MXJXHWHV ߚUHVSRQGLHURQ ORV PHOOL]RV
ߚb&KLWDV ORV IDUVDQWHV $ YHU PXHVWUHQ DOJR ߚGLMR3DQFKRFR
ߚ9HQJDQDYHUORVPHMRUߚGLMRXQRVROR ߚ,UHPRVߚDPHQD]³$QGHFR
< VH ODUJDURQ ORV VHLV D OD FDVD YHFLQD ,EDQ VHJXURV GH QR HQFRQWUDU QDGD LQWHUHVDQWH SHUR IXH JUDQGH VX VRUSUHVD DO YHU TXH HQ HVD FDVD HVWDEDQ WRGRVORVP¡VOLQGRVMXJXHWHVSRVLEOHVGHLPDJLQDU 7UHQHVHO©FWULFRVJRNDUWV ELFLFOHWDVFRQ PRWRUHV EXTXHVVXEPDULQRVWURPSRVGHWRGRWLSRVROGDGRV DYLRQHV WDQTXHV IRUWDOH]DV \ KDVWD XQD QDYH HVSDFLDO 3DUHFD LQFUHEOH TXH ORV PHOOL]RV VH DEXUULHUDQWHQLHQGRWRGRHVRߨ
(Q XQ PRPHQWR FREU³ YLGD HVD FDVD \ ORV MXJXHWHV HPSH]DURQ D IXQFLRQDU HQ PDQRV GH FDGD XQR SRU VHSDUDGR (O UXLGR HUD HVSDQWRVR \ HO HQWXVLDVPRFRQWDJL³DORVDEXUULGRV
=XPEDEDQ ORV DYLRQHV PLHQWUDV FKRFDEDQ WUHQHVRELFLFOHWDV\VHFRPSHWDHQIºWEROHQWHQLV\ KDVWDHQKRPEUHVUDQDGHQWURGHODSLVFLQD1DGLHVH DFRUGDED \D GH OD FDVD YDFD FRQ VX FOQLFD R VX FRQFLHUWRGHSLDQR/DLQWHQVLGDGGHOMXHJRGHFDGD XQRSDUHFDHVWUHPHFHUKDVWDHOMDUGQ
ߚb4XLHUR DJXD ߚGHFODU³ 3HSH GH SURQWR \ HQWRQFHV ORV PHOOL]RV OR OOHYDURQ DO UHSRVWHUR \ OH GLHURQDHOHJLUHQWUHFXDWUREHELGDV