Copyright0 1970 American Society for Microbiology Printed inU.S.A.
Cholesterol
Inhibition of Isopentenyl Pyrophosphate
A3 A2-Isomerase
in
Mycoplasma
laidlawii
PAUL F. SMITH A MARIE R. SMITH
Department ofMicrobiology, SchoolofMedicine, UniversityofSouthDakota,
Vermillion, South Dakota 57069
Received for publication10December 1970
Cholesterol inhibits isopentenyl A',A2-isomerase of Mycoplasma laidlawii in an
apparently competitive fashion. The conversion of mevalonic acid toisopentenyl pyrophosphateis slightlystimulated.Organismsgrownin thepresenceof
mevalonic-2-14C acid contain small amounts ofradio-label in nucleic acid and protein frac-tions. Most of the label is found in the lipids and is reduced dramatically in
or-ganisms grown with cholesterol. No significant accumulation of phosphorylated
intermediatesofpolyterpene biosynthesiswasobserved in cellsorculture superna-tantfluid. All of the radioactivity appearing in the nucleic acid fraction occurs in
theminornucleoside, isopentenyl adenosine, ofthe transfer ribonucleic acid. The necessity for synthesis by the organisms of this minor nucleoside from mevalonic acid mayexplain the site ofenzyme inhibition by cholesterol of polyterpene
bio-synthesis.
Mycoplasma laidlawii differsfromtheso-called parasitic mycoplasmasby its lack of a nutritional requirementfor a planar 3-hydroxysteroland by its capacity to synthesize hydroxylated poly-terpenes (22). The sterol requirement of two
species,
M. arthritidis strain 07 and M. gal-linarium strain J, is considered to be the result ofinsufficiency
for enzymatic synthesis ofpolyterpenes
(11, 12, 24). In the former species all trans3,3'-dihydroxycarotenes
will replace thesterol requirement. It lacks all of the enzymes in the pathway to polyterpenes but apparently canhydroxylate
suchcompounds. M.gallinarium lacks onlythree enzymes inthepathway, i.e., thoseinvolved
in the conversion ofmevalonic acid to A'-isopentenyl pyrophosphate. Growth of this organism withA'-isopentenyl
pyrophosphate substituting for sterol results in the formationofhydrocarbon
and hydroxylated polyterpenes (23). Inhibitors of polyterpene biosynthesis inhibit growth of M.laidlawii
but not of the sterol-requiring species (26).If theinhibitionoccurs at a site in the pathway before condensation of isoprenyl phosphates forms the long-chainpolyterpene,
the organism can overcome this inhibition ifcholesterolissupplied in the growth medium. It is found that cholesterol substitutes for thecarotenoids
in the unsaponifiablelipids
ofthe organism. Cholesterol has been shown to spare the
biosynthesis
of carotenoids in M.laidlawii (19).
These results haveled
to theconclusion that carotenoids and sterols possess analogous functions inmycoplasmas.
This study reports attempts to define the enzymatic site of cholesterol inhibition of the
biosynthesis
ofpolyterpenes
in M. laidlawii.MATERIALS AND METHODS
M. laidlawii strain B was grown in lipid-free mediumaspreviously described (25). Theorganisms
were harvested in the mid-exponential phase of
growth,usually after 16 hr of incubation. Experiments designedtoassessthe fateof mevalonic acid when the organism was grown in the presence of cholesterol
employed culture media of thefollowing composition
per 100 ml: control medium-chloroform:methanol
(2:1, v/v)-extracted tryptose, 2 g; chloroform:
methanol-extractedPPLOserumfraction (Difco),100
mg; potassium oleate, 100 jumoles; mevalonic-2-'4C acid, as the N,N-dibenzylethylenediammonium-bis(3,5-dihydroxy-3-methyl pentoate), 1.0 jAc and
10,moles; and ethanol, 1 ml. Test medium was
identicaltothe control except for addition of2 mg
ofcholesterol in ethanol solution.
Cholesterolwaspurified through dibromide
forma-tion followed byregeneration with zinc powder and
crystallization from absolute ethanol or acetic acid
(6).DL-Mevalonic-1-'4C and -2-'4C acid lactoneswere
obtainedfromNew EnglandNuclearCorp., Boston,
Mass. Afterthe benzenewasevaporated, the residual
lactones were hydrolyzed with potassium hydroxide,
and then thepH level was adjusted to 8.0 by the
addition ofacid (2). DL-Mevalonic acidasthe
N,N-dibenzylethylenediammonium-bis(3,5-dihydroxy-3
-methylpentoate) and
A3-isopentenyl
pyrophosphate27
on March 20, 2021 by guest
http://jb.asm.org/
as thetris(cyclohexylammonium) salt wereobtained
from Mann ResearchLaboratories,Orangeburg, N.Y.
A3-Isopentenyl-1-14C pyrophosphate was synthesized
from mevalonic-2-14C acid with enzymes isolated
from yeast (3) or withpig liver enzymes (2, 18). The
A3-isopentenyl pyrophosphate produced was purified bythedescending paperchromatographic method of
Nandiand Porter(18).
Enzymatic assays used M. laidlawii B sonically
treated in 0.2 M potassiumphosphate buffer (pH 7.5)
for 5 min in a 10-kc Raytheon sonic oscillator. Protein
was determined by the method of Lowry et al. (17).
The conversion of mevalonic acid to A3-isopentenyl
pyrophosphate, which involves the three enzymes,
adenosine triphosphate
(ATP)-mevalonate-5-phos-photransferase (E.C. 2.7.1.36),
ATP-5-phospho-mevalonate phosphotransferase (E.C. 2.7.4.2), and
ATP-5-pyrophosphomevalonate carboxylase (E.C.
4.1.1.33), wasassayed as onecomplete reaction by
trapping the 14CO2 liberated from mevalonic-1-'4C
acid as previously described (11). Isopentenylpyro-phosphate Al,A2-isomerase (E.C. 5.3.3.2) was
assayed by the method ofAgranoffet al. (1).
Cho-lesterol was added to the reactionmixturesinsolutions
of ethanolaftertheaddition ofsonicallytreated cells
but before addition of substrate. This procedure
resulted in micellar stabilization ofthe cholesterol.
Thedistributionof14Cfrom '4C-mevalonicacid in
crude chemical fractions was determined with
organisms grown both in the presence and absence
of cholesterol. Washed cell pellets from 100-ml
cultures wereextracted with 10% trichloroacetic acid
at0 Ctogive low-molecular-weight components and
at 100 Ctogivethe nucleicacid fraction, andfinally
with chloroform-methanol (2: 1, v/v) to give the
crude lipid fraction. The resultant residue contained
crudeprotein. Detection ofpossible accumulation of
precursors of phosphorylated polyterpene
inter-mediates in the cells and culture fluid both of control and cholesterol-grown organisms was accomplished by chromatography through diethylaminoethyl (DEAE) celluloseby usingammonium carbonate of
increasingionic strength (5). Fractions (20ml) were
collected,lyophilized,andassayedforradioactivity.
Isolation of transfer ribonucleic acid (RNA) from
organismsgrown with orwithout cholesterol and in
the presenceofmevalonic-2-'4C acid was performed
bythemethod describedby Zubay (27) through the
isopropyl alcohol precipitation steps. After dialysis
against deionized water, the transfer RNA was
enzymatically hydrolyzed bythe methodof Hall (7).
Afterlyophilization of the reaction supernatant fluid
and solution in water, a samplewas held for
radioi-sotope counting. The remainder was
co-chromato-graphed in two solvent systems (8),
n-butanol-water-ammonia (86:14:5) and isopropanol-concentrated
HCI-water (680:170:144), by the descending method
with authentic isopentenyl adenosine
[N6-(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-adenosine; supplied by Harry B. Wood,
Jr., National Cancer Institute]. After detection of
nucleosidesonthe paper by ultraviolet-lightscanning, allabsorbingareaswerecutoutand counted.
Radioi-sotope countingwasperformed either in a Tracerlab
proportionalcounterorin aPackardliquid
scintilla-tion counter aspreviously described (11).
RESULTS
Enzymatic synthesis of A3-isopentenyl
pyro-phosphate from mevalonic acid actually was
stimulated since the amount of 14CO2 liberated frommevalonic-1-'4Cacidwasmorethandoubled
bythepresenceof cholesterol (Fig. 1). Increased
cholesterol concentration up to a level of 0.05 mg/ml (12.5 mg of protein/ml) resulted in increasing liberation of "CO2. This result was
consistent in repetitive experiments with different lots of M. laidlawii.
The isopentenyl pyrophosphate Al,
A2-iSOm-erase of M. laidlawii shows the opposite effect
in the presence of cholesterol. Increasing con-centrations of cholesterol inhibit the formation of ofA2-isopentenyl pyrophosphate with complete inhibition occurring at a level of 0.03 mg/ml (8.4 mg ofprotein/ml; Fig. 2). When the cho-lesterol concentration was held at 0.015 mg/ml (2.4 mg ofprotein/ml) and the concentration of substrate, A3-isopentenyl pyrophosphate, was
varied, the inhibition by cholesterol was ap-parently competitive. Plotting the reciprocals of
the rates and of substrate concentrations, the
curvesforcontrol and cholesterol-inhibited
reac-tions were linear and intersected at a common point (Fig. 3). Cholesterol reduced the Km from 5.8 X 10-5to 1.5 X 10-4M. These resultsindicate that theinhibition ofpolyterpene biosynthesisby cholesteroloccurs ataspecific enzymatic site,the isopentenyl pyrophosphate A3,A2-isomerase.
A search for thebasisofinhibition atthisstep in the pathway wassoughtsince theexpectation would have beeninhibition ofthe pathwayat the level of mevalonic acid. Organisms were grown inthepresence ofmevalonic-2-'4C acid both with and without cholesterol to determine thefate of mevalonic acid as well asthe possible accumula-tion of A3-isopentenyl pyrophosphate. A small proportion of the total "4C appears in the small molecule fraction and in the crude nucleic acid and protein fractions. The predominant amount is
incorporated
into thelipids
(Table 1). There is little change in the amountincorporated
in all fractions except total lipids inorganisms grown with cholesterol. Mevalonicacid presumably can serve as a precursor for branched-chain aminoacids, explainingits presence inthecrude protein fraction. The labeling ofnucleic acids suggested that mevalonic acid might be a precursor of A2-isopentenyl adenosine in the transfer RNA. Co-chromatography of the enzymatically re-leased nucleosides from transfer RNA from organisms grown in mevalonic-2-14C acid with authentic isopentenyl adenosine resulted in the appearance of all thelabelintransfer RNA with
isopentenyl
adenosine (Table 2). All ofthe14C-J. BACTERIOL.
on March 20, 2021 by guest
http://jb.asm.org/
label in the total nucleicacid wasassociatedwith transfer RNA.
Nosignificantaccumulationofphosphorylated intermediates of the biosynthetic pathway to polyterpenes was found in culture supernatant fluidsororganisms.A traceofacompoundeluting atthe point whereisopentenol phosphateappears was found in the culture supernatant of cho-lesterol-grown organisms.Thismaterial afteracid hydrolysisofthephosphate radical possessedthe characteristics ofa five-carbon alcohol by gas-liquidchromatography.
DISCUSSION
This study revealed three facts. The sparing actionof cholesterolonpolyterpene biosynthesis byM. laidlawii isaresult ofspecificinhibitionof isopentenyl A3,
A2-isomerase.
Theorganism
must alsosynthesize isopentenyl adenosine. Mevalonicacid
probably serves as a precursor for the A2-isopentenyl radical ofisopentenyladenosine.
The nature of cholesterol inhibition of the isomerase apparently is competitive. However, any conclusive statement must await further
10r 0 .1.1 E 0 0. a' 0~ NI.. 5 O 0 0.05 Cholesterol (mg/ml)
FIG. 1. Effect of cholesterol on conversion of
mevalonic acid-1-14C to A3-isopentenyl pyrophosphate.
Reaction mixtureconsistedofadenosine triphosphate,
20umoles; MnCl2, 30,moles; reduced glutathione,
30
;umoles;
potassiumfluoride, 15 jumoles; potassiumphosphate buffer(pH7.5), 500jAmoles;mevalonic-1-1.4C
acid, 10 jAmoles (0.5
lAcAmoles);
ethanol or ethanolsolution of cholesterol, 0.05 ml; andsonically treated
M.laidlawiiprotein,50mg;inatotal volumeof5.0ml.
After3hrof incubationat37 Cintscrew-captubes, the reaction wasstoppedby heatingto 75C. Thereaction
mixture wasacidifiedwith N sulfuric acidand
'4CO2
trappedasbarium carbonatebyaerationwithnitrogen.
Afteradditionofasmallamountofcarrier, the
precipi-tateofbarium carbonatewaswashed, dried,andcounted
inaproportionalcounter. 3r 0 a. 0. 0 0 0 10 20 30 Time (min)
FIG. 2. Effect of cholesterol on isopentenyl A3,A2_
isomerase activity of M. laidlawii B. (i) Control;
(0) cholesterol, 0.015 mg/ml; (-) cholesterol, 0.03
mg/ml, and heat-inactivated control. The reaction
mixture consisted of reduced glutathioiie, 15 i.moles;
MgCI2, 2 ,moles; potassium fluoride, 60 ,moles; A'-isopentenyl-1-14C pyrophosphate, synthesized with
yeast enzymesfrom 20
jumoles
ofmevalonic-2-14C acid(0.5 uc/,umole); Tris-maleate buffer (pH 8.0), 50
,Amoles;sonically treatedM. laidlawii protein, 18.8 mg;
ethanol or ethanol solution of cholesterol, 0.05 ml; in
total volumeof2.2ml. Incubation was at 37 C.Samples
(0.5 ml) were removed at 0, 5, 10, and 30mitt. A
0.5-ml amount of 6% trichloroacetic acid was addedtoeach
sample, thesolution was centrifuged, and the
superna-tant fluid was extracted with 3 ml of
diethzyl
ether.Samples (0.05 and0.10ml) of the aqueous layerwere
countedinaproportionalcounter.
studies with
compounds
ofsimilar structure.The only similar portions of the three molecules in question, cholesterol,A3-isopentenyl
pyrophos-phate,andA2-isopentenyl
pyrophosphate, are the hydrocarbonends. CH2 P-P-O-CH2-CH2-C CH3A3
isopentenyl pyrophosphate CH3/
P-P-O-CH2-CH=C CH3 A2-isopentenyl pyrophosphateon March 20, 2021 by guest
http://jb.asm.org/
Downloaded from
TABLE 1. Distributiont of 'IC in crude chemical
fractions oJ Mycoplasma laidlawii grown with
mevalonic-2-14C acid withand
withoutcholesterol
Fraction ~No Cholesterol Fraction cholesterola growna
Whole cells ... ... 2,794 1, 377
Coldtrichloroacetic acid. 17 23
Hot trichloroaceticacid. 245 235
Chloroform-methanol... 2,046 1,127
Residue ... .... 188 144
-Values express counts
gram (dry weight) of cells.
per minute per
milli-1.5
V/s
FIG. 3. Lineweaver-Burk plots of
isopeniteniyl-A3, A2-isomerase activity in presence anid absenice of cholesterol. The reactioni mixture was the same as
described in thelegendtoFig. 2,except A3-isopentenyl-1-'4Cpyrophosphate wassynthesizedbyusinlgpigliver
enzymesanidits concentrationt variedfrom 0.8to24.0
,umoles and cholesterol concenitration was conistant
at 0.015 mg/ml. Km valuesare expressedasmolarity.
CH3 CH3
I ~~/
R-CH-CH2CH2-CH2-CH CH3 cholesterol
If this apolar end is an attachment site for the
enzyme,competitioncould beexpected.Holloway
and Popjac (13) postulate both lipophilic and
polar binding sites forprenyl pyrophosphates in the A2-isopentenyl and geranyl transferase from
pig liver. Shah, Cleland, and Porter (20) have
shown the existence of an acid-stable,
enzyme-bound component during the isomerization of
isopentenyl pyrophosphate by the pig liver
enzyme.They conclude thata covalentthioether
bond exists between a sulfhydryl group on the
enzyme and the carbonium ion formed by protonation of the methylene carbon atom of isopentenyl pyrophosphate. Our limited data allow for little or no reliable speculation. How-ever, interaction ofenzyme with the apolar end
of thesubstrate doesoccurinthepigliversystem,
suggesting a basis for the apparent competition
by cholesterolwiththe enzymeof M. laidlawii.
TABLE2. Distributioni of 'IC in ntucleosides of
tranisfer RNA from Mycoplasma laidlawii grown with mevalonic-2-'4Cacida
Solvent Ab Solvent Bc RF Counts/min RF counts/min 0. 80d 200 0.83d 194 0.25 0 0.63 0 0.13 0 0.43 0 0.05 0 0.34 0 0 0 0.27 0 0 0
Total transfer RNA hydrolysate amount was
equivalent to that chromatographed, 180 counts/
min.
bni-Butanol-water-ammonium hydroxide. 86:
14:5.
c Isopropanol-concentrated HCl-water, 680:
170:144.
dSpot containing authentic isopentenyl
adeno-sine.
The pig liver enzyme isinhibited by sulfhydryl
inhibitors. No reports exist which demonstrate
specificinhibitionof thisenzyme by intermediates
in the pathway to polyprenols. Polyprenols are
known to inhibit incorporation of acetate into unsaponifiable lipids (14). Siperstein and Guest
(21) suggested that the primary site of feedback control induced byexogenous cholesterolinliver
is the reduction of hydroxymethyl glutaryl coenzymeA(CoA)tomevalonicacid. Cholesterol
alsoinhibitsincorporation of mevalonicacid into squalene in rat liver (16) and Tetrahymena pyriformis (4) but not into ubiquinones. Thus, there areindicationsformultiplesites of feedback inhibitionbycholesterol.
Isopentenyl adenosine has not been identified specificallyasbeing among the minor nucleosides
of mycoplasmas. However, hydrolysates of
transfer RNA from M. laidlawii B and M.
I/v
J. BACTERIOL.
on March 20, 2021 by guest
http://jb.asm.org/
gailisepticum exhibit cytokinin activity (9). Isopentenyl adenosine and its methythio-derivative have cytokinin action (10). From our studies, it would appear that isopentenyl adeno-sine does occur in the transfer RNA of M. laidlawii B. Mevalonic acid
apparently
serves as precursor for the isopentenyl radical of this compound in this organism since 14C in the nucleicacids arising
from mevalonic-2-t4C acid isassociated
solely with theisopentenyl
adeno-sine. Thebiosynthesis
ofisopentenyl
adenosine has been shown to occur in yeast and rat liver by the transfer ofA2-isopentenyl
group from A2-isopentenyl pyrophosphate to an adenosine receptor in suitable transfer RNA(15).
This mechanism requires the isomerization of A3-isopentenyl pyrophosphate to A2-isopentenyl pyrophosphate, the reaction inhibitedby
cho-lesterol inM. laidlawii. Since thebiosynthesis
of isopentenyladenosine
in M. laidlawiiundoubt-edly
occursby
the samepathway,
complete suppression of the isomeraseprobably
does not occur in vivo.High
concentrations(0.1
to 0.2 mg/ml) of cholesterol inhibit growth of myco-plasmas. Otherenzymatic sites in thepathway
to polyterpenesbeyond
the isomerase may also be inhibited;these,.
however, have not beenex-amined.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This investigation was supported by Public Health Service research grant At 04410-08 fromtheNational Institute ofAllergy
andInfectious Diseases.
LITERATURE CITED
1. Agranoff,B.W., H.Eggerer, U.Henning,andF.Lynen. 1960.
Biosynthesisof terpenes. ViI. Isopentenyl pyrophosphate
isomerase. J. Biol. Chem. 235:326-332.
2. Anderson,D.G., and J.W.Porter.1962. Thebiosynthesisof
phytoeneandothercarotenesbyenzymesofisolatedhigher
plantplastids. Arch.Biochem.Biophys.97:509-519. 3. Bloch, K., S.Chaykin,A. H.Phillips,andA.DeWaard. 1959.
Mevalonic acidpyrophosphate andisopentenyl
pyrophos-phate. J.Biol. Chem. 234:2595-2604.
4. Conner,R.L.,J.R.Landrey, C.H.Burns,andF. B.Mallory. 1968. Cholesterol inhibition of pentacyclic triterpenoid biosynthesis in Tetrahymenapyriformis. J.Protozool. 15: 600-605.
5.Dugan,R.E.,E.Rasson, and J.W. Porter.1968.Separation
of water-soluble steroid and carotenoid precursors by
DEAE-cellulosecolumnchromatography. Anal. Biochem. 22:249-259.
6. Fieser,L. F. 1955.Cholesterol, A6-cholesten-3-one, and A4-cholesten-3-one.Org. Syn.35:43-49.
7. Hall, R. H.1964. Isolation of N6 (aminoacyl)adenosinefrom yeast ribonucleic acid.Biochemistry 3:769-773.
8. Hall, R. N. 1965. Ageneral procedurefor the isolation of "minor" nucleosides from ribonucleic acid hydrolysates. Biochemistry 4:661-670.
9. Hayashi, H.,H.Fisher, and D. Soll. 1969. Transfer ribonucleic acid from Mycoplcvma. Biochemistry 8:3680-3686. 10. Hegelson, J. B. 1968. The cytokinins.Science161:974-981. 11. Henrikson, C. V., and P. F. Smith. 1965. Conversion of
mevalonic acid to -y,-y-dimethylallyl pyrophosphate by Mycoplasma. J. Bacteriol. 92:701-706.
12. Henrikson, C. V., and P. F. Smith. 1966. Growth response of Mycoplasma to carotenoid pigments and carotenoid inter-mediates. J. Gen. Microbiol. 45:73-82.
13. Holloway, P. W., and G. Popjak. 1967. The purification of 3, 3-dimethylallyl- and geranyl-transferase and of iso-pentenyl pyrophosphate isomerase from pig liver. Biochem. J. 104:57-70.
14. Isler, O., R. Ruegg, G. Saucy, J.Wursche, K. F. Gey, and A. Pletscher. 1959. Semi-, mono-, sesqui- and triterpenes as cholesterol precursors. Ciba Found. Symp. Biosyn. Terpenes Sterols, 1958, p. 135-146.
15. Kline, L. K., F. Fittler, and R. H. Hall. 1969. N6-(A2-iso-pentenyl)adenosine. Biosynthesis in transfer ribonucleic acidinvitro.Biochemistry 8:4361-4371.
16. Krishnaiah, K. N., V. C. Joshi, and T. Ramasarma. 1967. Effect of dietary cholesterol and ubiquinone on isoprene synthesis in rat liver. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 121:147-153. 17. Lowry, 0. H., N. J. Rosebrough, A. L. Farr, and R. J. Randall. 1951. Protein measurement with the Folin phenol reagent. J.Biol. Chem. 193:265-275.
18. Nandi, D. L., andJ.W. Porter. 1964. The enzymatic synthesis of geranyl geranyl pyrophosphate by enzymes of carrot root andpigliver. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 105:7-19. 19. Rothblat, G. H., and P. F. Smith. 1961. Nonsaponifiable lipids
of representative pleuropneumonialike organisms. J. Bacteriol. 82:479-49 1.
20. Shah, D. H., W. W. Cleland, andJ. W. Porter. 1965. The
partialpurification, properties and mechanism of action of pig liver isopentenyl pyrophosphate isomerase. J. Biol. Chem.240:1946-1956.
21.Siperstein, M. D., and M. J. Guest. 1960. Studies on the site of feedback control of cholesterol biosynthesis. J. Clin. Invest. 319:642-652.
22.Smith, P. F. 1968. Lipids of Mycoplasma. Adv. Lipid Res. 6:69-103.
23. Smith, P. F. 1968. Nature of unsaponifiable lipids of Myco-plasma sp., strain J, grown with isopentenyl pyrophosphate as asubstitute for sterol. J. Bacteriol. 95:1718-1720. 24. Smith, P. F., and C. V. Henrikson. 1965. Comparative
bio-synthesis of mevalonic acid by Mycoplasma. J. Bacteriol. 89:146-153.
25. Smith, P. F., and C. V. Henrikson. 1965. Glucose containing phospholipids in Mycoplasma laidlawii, strain B. J.Lipid
Res.6:106-111.
26. Smith, P. F., and C. V. Henrikson. 1966. Growth inhibition of Mycoplasma byinhibitors of polyterpenebiosynthesis and its reversal by cholesterol. J. Bacteriol. 91:1854-1858. 27. Zubay, G. 1966. Isolation of transfer RNA, p. 455-460. In
G. L. Cantoni and D. R. Davies (ed.), Procedures in nucleic acidresearch.Harper and Row,New York.
VOL.