Public Investment, Taxation and Transfer of Technology

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Public Investment, Taxation and

Transfer of Technology

Kollias, Iraklis and Marjit, Sugata and Michelacakis, Nickolas

April 2017

Online at

https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/78853/

(2)

[1]

!"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)& ' ( *

&

)&

&*

$

% + + # ) * #

+ # ) * + , " #

# , + + +

"

-# . + + "

-# + , "

# + # #

# + + " / # # "

#

. + +

0123 42 3 /556

1

(3)

[2]

.# # ,

+ " $ & %0 )2889* + #

# # # " / 28 9 & :

( ) /(* % ) % * #

# " (0

# + " # # +

# + + , + + +

(0 # # . # #

" # + + # + + +

# # # "

/ # # +

# # # " % # # # #

)2882* )2885* )2885* )288;*

4 " )28 ;*" 4 + . # #

+ )28 1* + , "

# + + # (0 +

# " - , + .

# # +

# "2

- + +

# " + + # # #

2 ₍₀ _& ₊ _# _{" '}

# + + + & #

" ( + + " % # #

(4)

[3]

+ + # " % # #

+ ? ) <;;* ) <=<* + ) <>>* ) <<5*

7 " )28 ;* + "

-# + # " - +

# "

+ " 7 # + +

+ + #

+ " (

# # " #

+ # # + + +

# "

# # + " 2 5 +

" !

- +

+ # # " # " - +

# # " ( ) *

# @ z [0,1]"

#

x

+ z− + z∈[0,1]

2

1

( ) ( ) ( )

2

C z = Wa z x z

,

) *

+

a z x z( ) ( )

,

#

x

z− "

(5)

[4]

z . #

( )

a z =z + " # z

( )

( ) ( )

0

( )

dC z

MC z

Wa z x z

dx z

=

>

(2)

+ MC z( ) z"

( z # #

P

#

2 ( )

1

Maximise ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

2

x z

π

z =Px z − Wa z x z

#

( )

P

x z

Wa z

=

+ x z'( )<0 )5*

# a z'( )>0" A, )5* + #

# " # ,

π

( )z

2

1

( )

2

( )

2

( )

P

z

Px z

P

Wa z

π

=

−

=

)1*

4 #

π

'( )z <0 a z'( )>0" # +

+ #

w W

<

#

τ

# # # "

+ ,

α

( ) : ( ( )z = a z +

τ

) ( )x z

+ + " +

# # " 7 7

(6)

[5]

z # # " B

Z

0 )

* + " );* )=*"

(

)

2 2

0 0

1 1

2 ( ) 2 ( )

P P

Wa Z = w a Z +

τ

);*

0

1

( )

W

w a Z

τ

= + )=*

0

1

( )

W z Z

a Z w

τ

> ⇔ + < " " + 5_"

, # # ) <>>*" - + + +

+ "

" # $ %

# ( )

( )

P x z

Wa z

= +

# " +

# # # # " (

# a z( ) z + # #

, "

G

+ , +

( ) ( )( ( ) )

b z =i G a z +

τ

, (8)

+ i G( ) # i(0)=1" (

lim ( ) 0

G→+∞i G =

ε

> # Glim '( )→+∞i G =0 " " i G( ) +

ε

>

0

" (

3

+ # # # # " "

1 2

( )z a z( )

α

=

τ

+

τ

+

τ

₁ >1,

τ

₂ >0 z>Z₀ # Z₀ + " 4 +

1 1

(7)

[6]

+ # i G( ) + ##

ε

G

i G''( )>0" + # i G( ) # ( 2 +

( )

i G i G( )

C C

8

G

8

G

( ( 2

( # # i G( )

, +

G

=

0

" 4

G

( )

a z +

τ

i G a z( )( ( )+

τ

)" #

G

# # +

# # " , +

(

)

2 1

2 ( ) ( )

Z

P

t dz G

wi G a z +

τ

≥ (9)

, )<* # + # + "

-# " " "

0( 0, 0) t( 0, 0)

(8)

[7]

+ Zt + t

# D " . Zt + ,

( )(1 ) ( )

b Zt t Zt

π

− =

π

+

π

_b( )z # ) * z # +

# . # ( , )t G "

(

)

2 2

1 1

(1 )

2 ( ) ( _t) 2 ( _t)

P P

t

wi G a Z +

τ

− = Wa Z

,

( ) ( )

( ) 1

t

a Z w i G

a Z +

τ

=W −t " ) *

)=* t=0,G=0

0 0

( )

a Z w a Z +

τ

=W

# t

( ) 0

Maximise_t Z −Z_t 1 ( )

t

b Z

t

π

z dz≥G (12)

B , ) *

( ) ( ) :

( )

a z f z

a z

τ

=

+ "

(9)

[8]

2

'( )

'( ) 0

[ ( ) ] a z f z a z

τ

= > +

+ # f z( ) a z'( )>0"

+ ( ) 1

1

i G t <

− Zt <Z0" Zt <Z0

( ) 1

i G < −t" ) 5*

( , )<* +

2

(

)

2

( )

t

P

Q Z

G

wi G

≥

+

( )

1

( )

( ; ) :

Z

Q Z

dz

a z

τ

=

+

) 1*

+ ,

( _t) ( )

tA Z ≥i G G +

2

1

( ) ( ; , , ) : ( ; )

2

P A Z A Z P w Q Z

w

τ

= = ) 9*

0

t

Z <Z + , Z + Zt <Z<Z0"

-( )

A Z A Z( 0)" A, ) 9* +

0 ( ) ( ) i G t G A Z ≥ ) ;*

, #

G

# z>Z0 t"

A, ) ;* + , ) 5* )=* #

0

1

1 : ( )

( ) ( )

G

(10)

[9]

. . #

+ "

G

(0,1)

t∈ ,

0 0

( ) ( ) (1 ( )) ( )

i G G≤tA Z < −i G A Z

, ) 5* + , ) * Zt <Z0"

2 1

2

Zt

( )

P

dz

t

w

a z

+

τ

"

## #

0

( )

i G G t

A Z

= E

G

# + + + "

# + F ) * Zt <Z0 )2*

# 0

2

:

( )

2

t

( )

Z

P

dz

t

H t

w

a z

+

τ

=

"

, ) =* + #

0

1

( )

(11)

[10]

0

( )

G A Z

0

1 / (A Z )

8

G

( 5

+ , ) =*

β

( )G

+ + " ( #

G

β

( )G

) * # + # +

( )G

β

" % # #

β

( )G

β

(0)=0

β

'( )G >0 +

lim '( ) 0

G→+∞

β

G =

1

β

_{''( )}_G

G

9_"

β

_{( )}_G

+ (0, 0) + # @ "

B .#

& ' " B

4

2

'( )

'( ) 0

[ ( )]

i G G

i G

β

= − > and by our assumptions i G'( )<0.

5

2 3

2[ '( )]

( ) ''( )

lim

''( )

lim

0

[ ( )]

G G

i G

i G i G

G

i G

β

→+∞ →+∞

−

=

<

lim '( ) 0

(12)

[11] 2 1 0 ₀

1

( , , ) :

2

( )

P

A P w

dz

w

a z

τ

=

+

G

0

( )G G A

β

<

# , "

& A0 + # # , ) =*

@ + " # #

) =* # # "

& ' "

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

> t Z_t <Z₀ +

"

& # # + # #

β

( )G #

β

( )G +

0

( )

G

A Z G

∧

"

G

# (0, )G

∧

, ) =*

+ t + # ;_{" /} _t

0

t

Z <Z # z , ) *" # # "

+ # # #

β

( )G " & ( 1 ;

"

6

#

G

t

0

( )

( ,1 ( ))

( )

i G G

i G

A Z − + +

(13)

[12] ( )G

β

0

( )

G

A Z

β

( )G ( 0)

G A Z

( )G

β

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

>

( )G

β

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

<

8

G

8

G

( 1 ( 9

( )G

β

0

( )

G

A Z

β

( )G

β

( )G ( ₀)

G

A Z

β

( )G

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

<

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

>

8

G

8

G

(14)

[13] ( )G

β

0

( )

G

A Z

β

( )G

0

1 '(0)

( )

A Z

β

<

8

G

( >

+ +

i

''

<

0

( # #

G

" "

G

, " /

i

''

<

0

'' 0

β

> " (

G

β

( )G + )9*"

'(0)

β

+

0

1

( )

A Z + + "

β

'(0) +

+ # #" + +

0

( )

G

A Z +

( ; >"

G

+

" +

"

# (G G1, 2) # , "

( G∈(G G1, 2) t

0

( )

( ,1 ( ))

( )

i G G

i G

A Z − #

0 t

(15)

[14]

G

t" t

0

( )

( ,1 ( ))

( )

i G G

i G A Z −

, Zt " +

# # , "

' ( 1.> # ( ; > @

E # ) * + ,

) =* " "

β

( )G + ## + #

( 5" B A Z P w( ; , , )

τ

) 1* ) 9* # #

A

Z

P

# #

w

#

τ

+ + " "

2

1

( ; , , ) :

2

Z

( )

P

A Z P w

dz

w

a z

τ

=

+

( "

τ

A Z P w( ; , , )

τ

, ) =*

## @ "

+ +

# . "

w

#

P

" # # # + #

+ + + " ( Z0

#

w

+ + + "

+ +

w

# + + #

A

" 7

w

" " ##

A

"

& ' " " # + # (G G1, 2)

(16)

[15]

&

π

( )z A Z P w( ; , , )

τ

" % ( <

+ 1

( ; , , )

A Z P w

τ

+ # + # "

# # "

( )G

β

8 G1 G2

G

( <

+ " A Z P w( ; , , )

τ

+ # ) =*" % +

( < + " %

t" % ) * Zt

, @ # " G∈(G G1, 2) t + #

" t # # # 5"2

; + # "

# 5"2 # , +

, # +

(17)

[16] ##

" (

G

#

+

0

( ) :

( ) b

i G G t

A Z = " #

0

z>Z t_b

G

0

2

( )

2

tb

( )

Z

b b

Z

P

dz

H t

t

w

a z

τ

=

+

4 + #

G

(G G₁, ₂) #

+ t # G2" +

" # + #

& ' " ) + (G G1, 2)

"

& %

G

t G_b( )"

+ Ztb( )G #

G

" + + #

ε

i G( )

( )

i G " &

ε

i G( ) ≤ −1 t Gb( ) .

G

+ +

# i G( ) # ( )

1 _b( )

i G t G

− .

G

"

+ ) *

G

+ "

( ) 1

i G

ε

> − + #

( ) 1 b( )

i G t G

− " /

( ) 0

'( )

1 0 ( )

( )

i G

i G A Z

i G

ε

+ > > −

(18)

[17]

[

]

0

1

'( ) '( ) ( )

( )

i G i G G i G A Z

> − +

# #

( ) 1 _b( )

i G t G

−

G

" # # "

# # + # # + + +

, " - + #

+ "

, + + + . #

" /## + # #

+ +

# + , # "

+ # #

# , # "

# + # #

+ +" % . +

" (

" 7 4" 0 " G " )28 ;*" (0 7 @ $ @ F

A " *" 518.51<"

2" 7 !" %" ) <> *" . " ) * .

(19)

[18]

5" ( '" ) <=>* " ' + F

# " + ) * . ;"

1" ( '" ) <=>* " # "

,*)2* 2=9.2=<"

9" 4 ! !" '" ) <<9*" 'G0 "

)##" 229.292*" $ & " ;" 4+ 4" " G &" 4" )28 ;*" @

'G0" #+851"

=" " G " ) <<5*" # F %

& . + " ) ) * =9.>>"

>" " G " )2885*" # F .

" )-) * 5. 21"

<" " ) <=<*" % + "

*-)2* 295.2;;"

8" " ) <>>*" % # " ! ,) * ;5.;="

" " G %" )28 9*" A + "

- )5* 1<5.9 "

2" " )28 1*" % "" .*," #

5" %" G A" )288;*" "

./)=* ;<<. =8="

1" " )2882*" F % "

(20)

[19]

9" " G " )A "*" )2885*" ' ( # /

$ $ %"

;" $ & %0 )2889* ( ) * + , # #-.# # #/0 $

# + H D "

=" $ & %0 )28 8*1 ( ' ( & #$

# + H D "

>" ? '" ) <;;*" # "