FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/ :47 PM INDEX NO /2016 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2019

(1)

SUPREME

COURT

OF THE

STATE

OF

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

OF

NEW

YORK

CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY

_CARE, _INC., and Index No. 653849/2016

50

EAST

69™

STREET

_CORPORATION,

Hon. Andrew Borrok Plaintiffs,

Part 53

-against-CSC

ACQUISITION _{I, LLC,}

MIDTOWN

FIFTH

AVENUE

MANAGEMENT,

LLC,

NOTICE

OF

ENTRY

OF

JUDGMENT

GLEN

KLEE

_LAU, _M.D.,

ANDREW

ROSEN, M.D.,

DOUGLAS

CHIN, M.D., and

MARK

REINER, M.D.,

Defendants.

GARFUNKEL

_WILD, _P.C., as escrow agent, Index No. 652927/2016

Plaintiff, Hon. Andrew Borrok

-against-Part 53

CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY

_CARE, INC. and

CSC

ACQUISITION _{I, LLC,}

Defendants.

PLEASE

TAKE

NOTICE

that annexed hereto is a true and correct _copy of the Judgment

entered in office of

New

York _County Clerk _{on July} _30, 2019.

Dated:

New

_York,

New

York

MANATT,

PHELPS

&

PHILLIPS, LLP August _{1, 2019}

s/ Ronald G. Blum By: Ïionald G. Blum

Prana A. Topper Andrew Case 7 Times Square

New

_York,

New

York 10036

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

(2)

To: Brooke K. _Haley, Esq. Jeremy D. Richardson, Esq. Michelman

&

Robinson, LLP 800 Third _Avenue, 24th Flr.

New

_York,

NY

10022

Seth E. Darmstadter, Esq. Michelman

&

_Robinson, LLP 200 S. Wacker Drive, Suite 2500 Chicago, Illinois.

Attorneys for Defendants

205146715.1

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

(3)

F ILED

:

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

CLERK

07/30/2019

01:54

PM

as

car _RECEIVED _NŸSCEF: _07/30/2019

SUPREME

COURT

OF THE

STATE OF

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

OF

NEW

YORK

CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY CARE, INC.and Index No. 653849/2016

50 EAST 69" STREET _CORPORATION,

Hon. Andrew Borrok Plaintiffs,

Part 53

-against-CSC ACQUISITION I, LLC,

MIDTOWN

FIFTH

AVENUE

MANAGEMENT,

LLC,

GLEN

KLEE

LAU, M.D.,

ANDREW

ROSEN, M.D.,

DOUGLAS

CHIN, M.D., and

MARK

REINER, M.D.,

Defendants.

GARFUNKEL

_WILD, _P.C., as escrow agent, Index No. 652927/2016

Plaintiff-Stakeholder, Hon. Andrew Borrok

-against- Part 53

CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY CARE, INC.

and CSC ACQUISITION _{I, LLC,}

Defendants-Claimants.

JUDGMENT

Judgacñt _{as to liability} _having been entered in favor of Center _{for Specialty} Care, Inc. and 50 East 69* Street Corporation and against CSC Acquisition _{I, LLC,} Midtown Fifth Avenue

Managemcñt, LLC, Glen Klee Lau, M.D., Andrew Rosen, M.D., Douglas Chin, M.D., and Mark

Reiner, M.D., on January 16, 2018, as to Causes of Action _{1, 2, 3 and 4 in the Arnended} Complaint in Index No. 653849/2016 (the "Main _Action") (Main _Action, Dkt. 269); and

The Court _having consolidated the Main Action and Index No.652927/2016 (the

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

(4)

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

CEF DOC. NC. 1 0 - --- _RECEIVED _NYSCEF: _07/30/2019

"Iñterpicader _Action") _{on February} 15, 2019 for trial on damages (Main Action, Dkt. 323) (collectively, the "Consolidated Action"); and

. .

. The Court _having tried the Consolidated Action without _{a jury} over the course of three days on June 12*, 13* and 17* of 2019, and having reviewed and heard the trial _tactimony of Lucinda _Hay and of Frank J. Convertini; and having reviewed the exhibits rcccivcd into evidence; and due deliberation having been had thereon and on all prior proceedings in this

matter, and as set forth on the record at trial;

NOW,

upon the Post Trial Decision and Order, dated June 18, 2019 (Main Action, Dkt. 460; Interpleader, Dkt. 43), awarding Plaintiffs Center for Specialty Care, Inc. and 50 East 69* Street Corporation _monetary damages on each of the Asset Fürchase Agiccmcñt (Cause of

Action 1), Lease (Cause of Action _{3), Guaranty} (Cause of Action _{4) and Administrative} Services

Agreernent (Cause of Action 2);

IT IS

HEREBY

ADJUDGED,

1. That Center _{for Specialty} Care, Inc. have judgment against CSC Acquisition, I, LLC, Midtown Fifth Avenue Mauaswuwa, LLC, and Glen Klee Lau, M.D., jointly and

severally, on the First Cause of Action of the Amended Complaint under a certain Asset

Purchase _Agreement, dated as of August _{4, 2015,} in the smount _{of $6,500,000.00,} plus prejudgment interest of 9

%

thercon from November I1, 2015, in the total sum of

2. That 50 East 69* Street Corporation have judgment against

CSC

Acquisition 1,

LLC, Glen Klee Lau, M.D., Andrew _Rosen, _M.D., Douglas Chin, M.D., and Mark Reiner, M.D.,

jointly and severally, on the Third and Fourth Causes of Action of the Amended Complaint

under a certain Lease _Agreement, dated as of October _{1, 2015} and a certain Guaranty, dated as of

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

(5)

F ILED

:

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

CLERK

0 7 /3 0 /2

019 01:5

4 PM| INDEX NO. 652927/2016 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/30/2019

September _{1, 2015,} in the amount of $5,885,119.32;

3. That Center for Specialty Care, Inc. have judgment against Glen Klee Lau, M.D., on the Second Cause of Action of the Amended Complaint under a certain Admi-dstrative

Services Agrccmcñt, dated as of August 4, 2015, in the amount of $613,053.90, plus prejudgment interest of 9

%

thereon from November 1.1, 2015, in the total sum of

IT IS

FURTHER

ADJUDGED,

that Plaintiffs Center for Specialty Care, Inc. and 50 East 69 Street Corporation be awarded costs and disbursemcñts as taxed by the Clerk.

HON.

ANDREW

BORROK

f ofit cross ..

(

6S/

Y7

eef

9/

Gle^

Ayhe..

Ad

\Gt. (30

9e

d

/fvenue

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

(6)

FILED:

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

CLERK

07 /30

/2019

01:54

PMl

INDEX

NO.

652927/2016

NYSCEF

DOC.

NO.

49 RECEIVED

NYSCEF:

07/30/2019

SUPREME

COURT

OF THE

STATE

OF

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

OF

NEW

YORK

CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY

_CARE,

_INC.,

and

50

EAST

69™

STREET

_CORPORATION,

Index

No.

653849/2016

Plaintiffs,

Hon.

Andrew

Borrok

-against-Part 53

CSC

ACQUISITION

_I,

_LLC,

MIDTOWN

FIFTH

AVENUE

_MANAGEMENT,

_LLC,

GLEN

KLEE

_LAU,

M.D.,

ANDREW

ROSEN,

M.D.,

DOUGLAS

CHIN,

M.D.,

and

MARK

REINER,

M.D.,

Defendants.

GARFUNKEL

_WILD,

P.C., as

escrow

agent,

Index

No.

652927/2016

Plaintiff-Stakeholder,

Hon.

Andrew

Borrok

-against-CENTER

FOR

SPECIALTY

_CARE,

INC.

and

CSC

ACQUISITION

I,

LLC,

Defendants-Claimants.

AFFIRMATION

WAIVING

COSTS

AND

DISBURSEMENTS

Ronald

G.

Blum

affirms

under

_penalty

of

perjury:

1. I

am

a

member

of

the

Bar

of the State of

New

York

and

of

_Manatt, Phelps

and

Phillips,

LLP,

attorneys for Center for _Specialty _Care, Inc.

and

50

East

69*

Street Corporation in

this action. This affirmation is based

on

information contained in the files related to this action

and

I submit it in connection with the

proposed

judgment.

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50

RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2019

(7)

FILED

:

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

CLERK

07 /3

0 /2

019 01:54

PM|

INDEX

NO.

652 927/2

016 NYSCEF

DOC.

NO.

49 RECEIVED

NYSCEF:

07/30/2019

2.

Center

for _Specialty _Care, Inc.

and

50

East 69th Street Corporation

_hereby

waive

their rights to recover costs

and

disbursements in this action.

3.

The

street addresses

of

the

judgment

creditors are:

a. Center for _Specialty _Care, Inc.:

10111

Bentcross _Drive,

Potomac,

MD.

b.

50

East 69th Street Corporation:

10111

Bentcross _Drive,

Potomac,

MD.

4.

The

street addresses

of

the

judgment

debtors are:

a.

CSC

Acquisition _I,

LLC:

305

East 47th _Street,

New

York,

NY

10017.

b.

Midtown

Fifth

Avenue

Managément,

LLC:

305

East 47th _Street,

New

_York,

NY

10017.

c.

Glen

Klee

_Lau,

M.D.:

21

Glen

Apline

_Road,

_Piedmont,

CA

94611.

d.

Andrew

_Rosen,

M.D.:

229

East 79th _Street, Unit

_8D-E,

New

_York,

NY

10075.

e.

Douglas

_Chin,

M.D.:

120

Bell

_Avenue,

_Piedmont,

CA

94611.

f.

Mark

_Reiner,

M.D.:

300

Central

Park

_West, Unite _5-E,

New

_York,

NY

10024. Dated:

New

York,

New

York

July 30,

2019

/s/

Ronald

G.

Blum

Ronald

G.

Blum

FILED

JUL

302019

COUNTY

CLERK'S

OFFICE

NEW YORK

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2019 04:47 PM

INDEX NO. 652927/2016

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50

RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2019

(8)

[FILED:

NEW

YORK

COUNTY

CLERK

07/_30/2019

01:54

PM)

INDEX

NO.

652927/2016

NYSCEF

DOC.

NO.

49 RECEIVED

NYSCEF:

07

30/2019

. . .