Take the express to capital.
The shortest distance to capital is straight talk.
In today’s commercial real estate market, we know how to clear the way for an
opportunity. We can deliver flexible financing solutions for virtually any project.
We bring lending power, a solid balance sheet, industry expertise, and an impressively
efficient loan process. If you’re ready to expand, acquire, recapitalize, or pursue
opportunities, give us a call. We’re just the ticket.
Chris Kelly, Managing Director, Commercial Real Estate
212.321.7213, ckelly@capitalsource.com
For more information, visit www.capitalsource.com
Acquisition Financing$24 Million Senior Loan
Single Family For-Rent Portfolio GeorgiaAcquisition Financing
$15 Million Senior Loan
Hospitality – FloridaAcquisition Financing
$28 Million Senior Loan
Mixed Use Office/Telco – Missouri Note Acquisition Financing$15 Million Senior Loan
Condominium – New York Acquisition Financing$35 Million Senior Loan
Industrial – TexasLoans Post 1.2% Quarterly Gain
Returns on commercial mortgages reached 1.15% in the
third quarter, an improvement on the 0.74% return in the
pre-vious three months, according to the Giliberto-Levy
Commer-cial Mortgage Performance Index.
Loan income remained little changed at 1.34%, compared
with 1.32% in the second quarter and identical to the
first-quarter figure. But net returns improved significantly because
loan valuations declined by just 19 bp — compared with a
58-bp slide from April through June.
Spreads, on average, moved up by about 10 bp during the
quarter. Most of that increase was seen on retail and apartment
loans, which accounted for 57% of new lending activity. Office
and industrial spreads, meanwhile, were essentially flat.
Loan losses declined to 120 bp for the period, a modest
improvement over the 130 bp level seen over the trailing 12
months. “We think this trend is likely to continue because
col-lateral values are generally stable to improving, and many
prob-lem loans have now been through restructuring or foreclosure,”
said investment manager
Michael Giliberto,who compiles the
index along with mortgage banker
John Levy.While loan returns often are affected by changes in the
10-year Treasury yield, that wasn’t a factor in the third quarter
since that benchmark yield was nearly the same on Sept. 30, at
1.65%, verses 1.67% on June 30.
Loan originations captured by the index plunged to $4.8
See RETURNS on Page 15
Mortgage-Performance Comparison
Return Return Return 3Q-12 12 mo. Duration(%) (%) (years) Mortgages All commercial 1.15 3.23 3.77 Office mortgages 1.21 4.06 3.73 Multi-family mortgages 1.03 1.81 3.93 Retail mortgages 0.97 3.58 3.97 Industrial mortgages 1.15 2.11 3.41
CMBS Investment-grade 3.91 11.97 3.31
Corporates Barclays Capital Bond Index 3.83 10.76 7.20 Triple-B (duration adjusted) 2.93 9.06 3.77
Treasurys (5-7 year) 1.01 4.47 5.75
Sources: Giliberto-Levy and Barclays
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q Giliberto-Levy Commercial Mortgage Performance Index
Year-over-year percent change
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
N O V E M B E R 2 8th, 2 0 1 2 | N E W Y O R K
2
N D
A N N U A L
Securitization
Finance Summit
KEY TOPICS THAT WILL BE COVERED:
s What is Securitization and why is it frequently misunderstoods4HEDodd Frank-Actand ongoing financial reforms s4HERisk Retention Proposal and QRM
sImproving market transparency for derivatives
s(OW3ECURITIZATIONHASCOMEBACKFROMTHEBRINKOFTHEEconomic Collapse
s#REATIONOFTHEFinancial Stability Oversight Council and its Implications sAsset-Backed Securities and their evolution
s4HEVITALROLEOF3ECURITIZATIONINTHEHousing Sector
s%VALUATINGPERFORMANCEANDGROWTHINTHECMBS sector s#URRENTTRENDSANDRISKINVOLVEDINRMBS investing s)SSUESAFFECTINGABCP
VISIT US TODAY AT
www.iglobalforum.com/securitization2
PE Investing in Real Estate
Opportunities Are on the Horizon
From a Market on the Mend
Chaired by
David Valger, Principal
DVO Real Estate
FULL-DAY CONFERENCE
Wednesday, December 5, 2012 8:00am - 5:00pm
New York City
Contact Mara Kane to confirm your attendance at 212-832-7300, ext 0 or email her at
af@capitalroundtable.com
Special-Servicing Rate Dips Again
The special-servicing rate among securitized commercial
mortgages resumed its gradual decline last month.
The percentage of commercial MBS loans in the hands
of special servicers finished October at 12.66%, down from
12.82% in September, according to
Trepp.The latest tally found
3,711 mortgages in that category, down from 3,828 a month
earlier, and the aggregate balance fell by $1.1 billion to $71.3
billion, the lowest level since the end of 2009.
With some bumps along the way, the dollar value of loans
in special servicing has been trending lower since September
2010, when it hit a peak of $89.9 billion. The percentage rate
has edged down more slowly because the CMBS universe also
has been shrinking.
The only loan of more than $100 million that was added to
Trepp’s index in October was a $144.1 million senior mortgage on
a hotel portfolio. It was originated in late 2006 for
California StateTeachers,
a
Morgan Stanleyfund and
Pyramid Advisorsand was
included in a $1.4 billion transaction (Morgan Stanley Capital I
Inc., 2007-XLF). The note, with an original balance of $152
mil-lion, was part of a $295 million debt package on seven full-service
hotels totaling 2,357 rooms in six states. The loan had a two-year
term and three single-year extension options. It was restructured
in 2009, and last October it was extended for an additional year.
The mortgage was transferred to special servicing days before that
extension ran out last month. At the time, the borrower was
cur-rent on payments and seeking a fifth extension.
November 9, 2012
Commercial Mortgage
15
ALERT
Breakdown of CMBS Servicing
As of Oct. 31
Portion of
Loan Type Share of Share of In Special Special All CMBS Balance Servicing Servicing Loans Collateral ($Mil.) (%) (%) (%) Office $21,989.9 13.08 30.86 29.87 Retail 15,749.6 9.05 22.10 30.93 Multi-family 11,930.8 16.29 16.74 13.01 Hotel 10,927.8 19.13 15.33 10.15 Industrial 4,015.3 15.51 5.63 4.60 Other 6,648.7 10.33 9.33 11.43 TOTAL 71,262.1 12.66 100.00 100.00 0% 3% 6% 9% 12% 15% 18% 12/07 12/08 12/09 12/10 12/11 Source: Trepp
CMBS Loans in Special Servicing
Balance as percentage of all U.S. CMBS loans
Large Loans Recently Transferred to Special Servicing
Current Sent to
Balance Loan Maturity Special
($Mil.) Type Date Date Servicer Status Securitization
HRO hotel portfolio $144.1 Floating 10/5/06 10/9/11 10/4/12 Current MSC 07-XLF
17 Battery Place North, New York (Office) 53.0 Fixed 10/29/04 11/11/09 9/24/12 Current WBCMT 05-C16 Marriott, Overland Park, Kan. 46.8 Fixed 8/7/07 8/15/14 9/27/12 Current JPMCC 07-LDP12 Laurel Springs Apartments portfolio, High Point, N.C. 40.7 Fixed 3/1/07 3/11/17 9/18/12 30-59 days late CSMS 07-C2 New Jersey industrial/office portfolio 39.7 Fixed 1/25/07 2/11/17 9/14/12 Current WBCMT 07-C30 Sandpiper Apartments, Las Vegas 31.9 Fixed 6/30/05 7/11/15 10/1/12 Current LBUBS 05-C5 Equitable Building, St. Louis (Office) 29.1 Fixed 2/15/07 3/1/17 9/14/12 Current MSC 07-IQ14 Carriage Club Apartments, Mooresville, N.C. 25.7 Fixed 3/1/07 3/11/17 9/18/12 Current CSMS 07-C2 200 South Tryon, Charlotte (Office) 20.0 Fixed 4/17/07 5/11/17 9/27/12 30-59 days late WBCMT 07-C31 Beauregard Square, Alexandria, Va. (Mixed-use) 15.0 Fixed 3/13/07 4/5/17 9/7/12 In foreclosure MSC 07-IQ14
Source: Trepp
Returns
... From Page 14billion in the third quarter from nearly $9.9 billion in the
ear-lier period, although some loans that closed late in the
quar-ter may have been omitted.
The proportion of new loans that are interest-only for their
full term swooned to 10% in the third quarter, from 34.5% in
the previous three-month period. And those loans, on average,
had smaller balances than those with full or partial
amortiza-tion — reversing a recent trend.
Other assets bested commercial mortgages in performance
during the period.
Barclaysreported a 3.83% return for its
cor-porate bond index, while investment-grade commercial MBS
posted an impressive 3.91% gain.
The Giliberto-Levy index, produced and distributed by
London-based
IPD,tracks $191.7 billion of fixed-rate
com-mercial mortgages with an average coupon of 5.8% and an
average maturity of 5.6 years.
INITIAL PRICINGS
BB-UBS Trust, 2012-SHOW
Pricing date: Nov. 1
Property types: Retail (100%). Concentrations: Nevada (100%).
Loan contributors: Barclays (50%) and UBS (50%).
Notes: Barclays and UBS securitized an $835 million loan to General Growth Properties on Fashion Show Mall in Las Vegas. Barclays and UBS originated the 12-year, interest-only loan on a 50/50 basis in October. The 4% mortgage is collateralized by 836,000 sf at the 1.9 million-sf property. The collateral was appraised at $1.44 million. General Growth used most of the proceeds to retire $613 million of debt that was securitized via two transactions: Banc of America Commercial Mortgage Inc., 2005-1 and 2005-2. CMA code: 20120151.
Closing date: Nov. 6
Amount: $835 million
Seller/borrower: General Growth Properties Lead managers: Barclays,
UBS
Co-managers: Bank of America, Drexel Hamilton Master servicer: Wells Fargo Special servicer: Wells Fargo
Trustee: U.S. Bank
Certificate administrator: Wells Fargo Offering type: Rule 144A
Amount Rating Rating Rating Subord. Coupon Dollar Yield Maturity Avg. Life Spread
Class ($Mil.) (Moody's) (S&P) (Kroll) (%) (%) Price (%) (Date) (Years) (bp) Note Type
A 539.500 Aaa AAA AAA 35.39 3.430 102.999 3.146 11/5/36 11.98 S+115 Fixed
B 82.600 Aa2 AA AA 25.50 3.882 102.999 3.596 11/5/36 11.98 S+160 Fixed
C 77.800 A2 A A 16.18 4.026 101.580 3.946 11/5/36 11.98 S+195 Fixed
D 42.100 Baa2 A- BBB+ 11.18 4.026 97.418 4.396 11/5/36 11.98 S+240 Fixed
E 93.000 Baa3 BBB- BBB- 0.00 4.026 93.463 4.846 11/5/36 11.98 S+285 Fixed
X-A(IO) 539.500* Aaa AAA AAA 11/5/36 Fixed
X-B(IO) 82.600* Aa2 AA AAA 11/5/36 Fixed
*Notional amount
INITIAL PRICINGS
Loans
... From Page 1about half of the units. The loan is likely to attract interest from
investors interested in taking over the unsold condos.
Offers for both pools are due late next week. Bank of
Scot-land is looking to complete the sales by yearend.
The loans represent nearly all of Bank of Scotland’s
remain-ing U.S. loan book, accordremain-ing to a source familiar with the
mat-ter. The bank has stopped writing mortgages in the U.S.
The pool of performing mortgages has a weighted
aver-age loan-to-value ratio of roughly 65%. The weighted averaver-age
remaining term is 20 months, and the weighted average
cou-pon is about 3.75%. Two-thirds of the underlying properties, by
loan balance, are in or around New York, Washington, Boston,
Los Angeles and Chicago.
The largest loan in the pool is a $68 million participation
interest in a $309 million mortgage on the 1,000-room Hilton
Orlando Bonnet Creek, near Walt Disney World Resort. The
hotel is owned by a partnership between
GEM Realtyof
Chi-cago,
Farallon Capitalof San Francisco and
Blackstoneof New
York.
Other large loans in the pool include:
•
A $59 million participation interest in a $179 million loan
on the W New York-Downtown Hotel & Residences, at
123 Washington Street in Lower Manhattan. The 58-story
property, which encompasses 217 hotel rooms and 223
condominium units, is owned by New York developer
Joseph Moinian.
•
A $40 million participation interest in a $250 million
loan on the 796,000-square-foot office building at 75 State
Street in Boston. The property, which includes 25,000 sf of
retail space and a 235-space garage, is owned by
BrookfieldOffice Properties
of New York.
Bank of Scotland and its parent,
HBOS,were absorbed
by Lloyds in January 2009 as part of a British
government-brokered effort to prevent them from collapsing amid the
global financial crisis. Two months later, Lloyds ceded
par-tial ownership of its operations to the government. Lloyds
has been selling much of its commercial-mortgage portfolio
globally.
November 9, 2012
Commercial Mortgage
17
ALERT
INITIAL PRICINGS
Motel 6 Trust, 2012-MTL6
Pricing date: Nov. 2
Property types: Hotel (100%).
Concentrations: California (35.7%) and Texas (13.5%).
Loan contributors: J.P. Morgan (45%), Deutsche (45%) and Citi (10%).
Notes: J.P. Morgan, Deutsche and Citigroup teamed up to securitize the senior $1.05 billion portion of a $1.37 billion interest-only debt package they originated on Oct. 1 for a Blackstone fund on 517 Motel 6 hotels. Blackstone Real Estate Partners 7 used the loan proceeds to help finance its $1.8 billion buyout of the Motel 6 chain from Paris-based Accor. The fixed-rate senior portion of the debt package has a five-year term and a 5.1% coupon. The $318 million subordinate portion, which was placed with numerous investors, is divided into two pieces: a $118 million floating-rate senior mezzanine tranche with a coupon of Libor plus 760 bp and a three-year term, which can be extended by two years; and a $200 million fixed-rate junior mezzanine tranche with a 10% coupon and a five-year term. Blackstone invested $611.8 million of equity in the buyout, including re-serves and closing costs. CMA code: 20120137.
Closing date: Nov. 13
Amount: $1,050.0 million
Seller/borrower: Blackstone Group Lead managers: J.P. Morgan,
Deutsche Bank
Co-manager: Citigroup
Master servicer: KeyCorp
Special servicer: KeyCorp
Trustee: Wells Fargo
Certificate administrator: Wells Fargo Offering type: Rule 144A
Amount Rating Rating Rating Subord. Coupon Dollar Yield Maturity Avg. Life Spread
Class ($Mil.) (S&P) (Fitch) (MStar) (%) (%) Price (%) (Date) (Years) (bp) Note Type
A-1 105.000 AAA AAA AAA 51.50 1.500 99.750 1.631 10/5/25 1.90 S+125 Fixed
A-2 404.500 AAA AAA AAA 51.50 1.948 100.000 1.952 10/5/25 4.89 S+115 Fixed
B 189.900 AA- AA- AA- 33.40 2.743 100.000 2.752 10/5/25 4.89 S+195 Fixed
C 145.100 A- A- A- 19.60 3.139 100.000 3.152 10/5/25 4.89 S+235 Fixed
D 185.500 BBB- BBB- BBB- 1.90 3.781 100.000 3.802 10/5/25 4.89 S+300 Fixed
E 20.000 BB+ BB+ BBB- 0.00 4.274 100.000 4.302 10/5/25 4.89 S+350 Fixed
XA-1(IO) 405.500* AAA AAA AAA 3.005 6.172 1.893 10/5/25 T+160 Fixed
XA-2(IO) 509.500* AAA AAA AAA 10/5/25 Fixed
XB-1(IO) 540.500* BB+ BB+ AAA 1.692 3.490 3.042 10/5/25 T+275 Fixed
XB-2(IO) 540.500* BB+ BB+ AAA 10/5/25 Fixed
*Notional amount
INITIAL PRICINGS
COMM Mortgage Trust, 2012-CCRE4
Pricing date: Nov. 2
Property types: Retail (40.6%), office (24.5%), mixed-use (14.6%), hotel (12%), industrial (4.7%), self-storage (2.8%), multi-family (0.4%) and other (0.4%). Concentrations: New York (23%) and California (22.7%).
Loan contributors: Deutsche (48.3%), Cantor (38.6%) and KeyBank (13.1%). Largest loans: A $125 million senior portion of a $200 million loan to Eric Hadar and Stanley Cayre on the 355,000-sf Prince Building in Manhattan; a $120 million senior portion of a $210 million loan to Wilmorite on the 1.4 million-sf Eastview Mall and Eastview Commons power center in Victor, N.Y.; a $73 million loan to James Schlesinger of Talisman Cos., Jakob Brodt and Brigita Zaidman on the 376,000-sf Fashion Outlets of Las Vegas retail center in Primm, Nev.; a $60 mil-lion loan to Joseph Paul on the 216,000-sf Synopsys Tech Center in Sunnyvale, Calif.; a $58.8 loan to DivcoWest Properties on Buildings B and D, encompassing 600,000 sf, of the Concord Plaza office complex in Concord, Calif.; a $45.9 million loan to TMI Hospitality on 10 hotels, encompassing 717 rooms, in six states; a $40.1 million loan to Keystone Property on the 248,000-sf Dadeland Office Park in Miami; a $39.9 million senior portion of a $114.7 million loan to Mayflower Realty on the 1 million-sf Emerald Square Mall in North Attleboro, Mass.; a $35 million loan to Mohannad Malas on four stand-alone Lowe’s Home Centers, en-compassing 524,000 sf, in Georgia; and a $33.9 million loan to Gladstone Com-mercial on four office and three industrial properties, encompassing 531,000 sf, in six states.
B-Piece buyer: CBRE Capital.
Notes: Deutsche, Cantor and KeyBank teamed up to securitize commercial mort-gages that they had originated. CMA code: 20120136.
Closing date: Nov. 13
Amount: $1,111.0 million
Seller/borrower:
Deutsche Bank, Cantor Fitzgerald, KeyBank Lead managers: Deutsche Bank,
Cantor Fitzgerald Co-managers:
KeyBank,
CastleOak Securities, RBS
Master servicer: Wells Fargo
Special servicers: Torchlight Loan Services, Midland Loan Services Operating advisor: Park Bridge Lender Services
Trustee: U.S. Bank
Certificate administrator: Wells Fargo Offering type: SEC-registered
Amount Rating Rating Rating Subord. Coupon Dollar Yield Maturity Avg. Life Spread
Class ($Mil.) (Moody's) (S&P) (Fitch) (%) (%) Price (%) (Date) (Years) (bp) Note Type
A-1 59.118 Aaa AAA AAA 30.00 0.704 99.999 0.695 10/15/45 2.69 S+25 Fixed
A-2 148.657 Aaa AAA AAA 30.00 1.801 102.498 1.273 10/15/45 4.99 S+45 Fixed
A-SB 70.571 Aaa AAA AAA 30.00 2.436 102.498 2.069 10/15/45 7.47 S+73 Fixed
A-3 499.354 Aaa AAA AAA 30.00 2.853 102.499 2.568 10/15/45 9.88 S+83 Fixed
A-M 111.100 Aaa AAA AAA 20.00 3.251 102.499 2.964 10/15/45 9.92 S+122 Fixed
B 65.271 Aa3 AA- AA- 14.13 3.703 102.493 3.414 10/15/45 9.92 S+167 Fixed
C 38.885 A3 A- A- 10.63 4.442 102.496 4.151 10/15/45 9.97 S+240 Fixed
D 45.829 Baa3 BBB- BBB- 6.50 4.546 86.050 6.606 10/15/45 10.01 S+485 Fixed
E 19.442 Ba2 BB BB 4.75 4.579 10/15/45 10.01 Fixed
F 18.054 B2 B+ B 3.13 4.579 10/15/45 10.01 Fixed
G 34.719 NR NR NR 0.00 4.579 10/15/45 10.01 Fixed
X-A(IO) 888.800* Aaa AAA AAA 2.028 10/15/45 Fixed
X-B(IO) 222.200* Ba3 NR NR 0.600 10/15/45 Fixed
*Notional amount
C R E F I N A N C E C O U N C I L
January ConferenCe 2013
S o u t h B e a c h , M i a M i , F l o r i d a
January 14-16, 2013
L O E w s M I A M I B E A C h h O t E LRegister Today
www.crefc.org
Join us in Miami this January...
January 2013 Conference Co-Chairs:
Richard Jones, Partner, Dechert LLP
Mark McCool, Executive Vice President, Berkadia Commercial Mortgage LLC
Gregory Michaud, Senior Vice President & Head of Real Estate Finance, ING Investment Management
INITIAL PRICINGS
Freddie Mac Structured Pass-Through Certificates, K-711
FREMF Mortgage Trust, 2012-K711
Pricing date: Nov. 8
Property types: Multi-family (100%).
Concentrations: Florida (21.4%), California (12.5%) and Washington (10.1%). Loan originators: CBRE (31.5%), HSBC (12.7%), Berkadia (12.6%), Walker & Dunlop (9.5%), HFF (6%), Prudential (5%), Wells Fargo (4.5%), NorthMarq Capital (3.6%), PNC (2.5%), Magna Bank (2.4%), Beech Street Capital (2.3%), KeyCorp (2.1%), CWCapital (1.5%), Berkeley Point Capital (1.4%), Jones Lang LaSalle (1.2%), M&T Realty (0.6%) and Oak Grove Commercial Mortgage (0.5%).
Largest loans: A $66.8 million loan on the 558-unit Canyon Creek Apartments in Bothell, Wash.; a $62.6 million loan on the 294-unit Hudson Park North in Yon-kers, N.Y.; a $60.5 million loan on the 576-unit Lincoln Meadows in Schaumburg, Ill.; a $47.2 million loan on the 450-unit Seramonte Apartments in New Haven, Conn.; and a $40.5 million loan on the 448-unit Gardens East Apartments in Palm Beach Gardens, Fla.
B-Piece buyer: RiverBanc.
Notes: Freddie securitized 76 fixed-rate multi-family mortgages originated by 17 of its pre-approved lenders. Freddie guaranteed Classes A-1 and A-2 and floated them via a Freddie shelf. Classes B-D, which are unguaranteed, were placed privately. CMA code: 20120152 and 20120153.
Closing date: Nov. 20
Amount: $1,379.7 million
Seller/borrower: Freddie Mac Lead managers: Wells Fargo,
Morgan Stanley Co-managers: Bank of America, Barclays, Deutsche Bank, Guggenheim Securities Master servicer: Wells Fargo
Special servicer: Wells Fargo
Trustee: U.S. Bank
Certificate administrator: U.S. Bank
Offering type: Fannie/Freddie/Ginnie
Amount Rating Rating Subord. Coupon Dollar Yield Maturity Avg. Life Spread
Class ($Mil.) (Fitch) (Kroll) (%) (%) Price (%) (Date) (Years) (bp) Note Type
A-1 110.000 AAA AAA 16.50 1.321 101.998 0.776 8/25/45 3.88 S+20 Fixed
A-2 1,042.049 AAA AAA 16.50 1.730 101.995 1.395 8/25/45 6.51 S+31 Fixed
B 89.680 A- A- 10.00 8/25/45 6.68 Fixed
C 34.493 BBB BBB+ 7.50 8/25/45 6.75 Fixed
D 103.478 NR NR 0.00 8/25/45 6.76 Fixed
X-1(IO) 1,152.049* AAA AAA 8/25/45 6.26 Fixed
X-2A(IO) 1,152.049* AAA AAA 8/25/45 6.26 Fixed
X-2B(IO) 227.651* NR AAA 8/25/45 6.73 Fixed
X-3(IO) 227.651* NR NR 8/25/45 6.73 Fixed
*Notional amount
November 9, 2012
Commercial Mortgage
21
ALERT
INITIAL PRICINGS
NorthStar Mortgage Trust, 2012-1
Pricing date: Oct. 26 Property types: Retail (33.6%), mixed-use (19.2%), hotel (17%), office (16.6%) and multi-family (13.6%).
Concentrations: California (25.1%), Virginia (20.8%), New Jersey (17.2%), Texas (11.5%) and Colorado (10.1%).
Loan contributors: NorthStar (100%).
Largest loans: A $73 million loan to Coventry Real Estate on the Buena Park Mall and the Buena Park Place power center, encompassing 741,000 sf, in Buena Park, Calif.; a $60.4 million loan to Jack Morris and Joseph Marino on Towne Place at Garden State Park, a 336,000-sf retail and office complex in Cherry Hill, N.J.; a $43.3 million loan to Parmenter Realty Partners on the 486,000-sf SunTrust Center office complex and the adjacent 132,000-sf Mutual Building in Richmond, Va.; a $35.5 million loan to Windsor Capital on the 357,000-sf Citadel Crossing power center in Colorado Springs, Colo.; a $29.8 million loan to LTD Management on four hotels, encompassing 510 rooms, in Virginia; the $20.7 million senior portion of a $33.8 million loan to Gerald Sapp on the 192-room Embassy Suites in Kennesaw, Ga.; and a $20 million loan to Barry Nussbaum on three Houston apartment properties encompassing 1,014 units. Notes: NorthStar Realty Finance securitized 14 floating-rate loans, totaling $351.4 million, that it and an affiliated nontraded REIT, NorthStar Real Estate Income, origi-nated on transitional properties in 2011 and 2012. The transaction is the first with such collateral since the market crash. The loans have a weighted average coupon of Libor plus 534 bp, with individual spreads ranging from 259 bp to 750 bp. The bonds have a weighted average coupon of Libor plus 163 bp. The transaction’s weighted average loan-to-value ratio is 70.7%. NorthStar and its REIT retained Classes E-G and the interest-only strips. NorthStar said it expects to earn a yield of about 20% on the equity it has invested. See article in Oct. 19 issue. CMA code: 20120150.
Closing date: Nov. 20
Amount: $351.414 million
Seller/borrower: NorthStar Realty Finance Lead manager: Citigroup
Co-managers:
UBS, Barclays, Deutsche Bank Master servicer: Wells Fargo Special servicer: NorthStar Trust advisor: Situs Holding
Trustee: U.S. Bank
Certificate administrator: U.S. Bank Offering type: Rule 144A
Amount Rating Rating Subord. Coupon Dollar Maturity Avg. Life Spread
Class ($Mil.) (Moody’s) (S&P) (%) (%) Price (Date) (Years) (bp) Note Type
A 152.864 Aaa AAA 56.50 L+120 99.900 8/25/29 1.97 L+125 Floating
B 30.310 Aa2 AA 47.88 L+164.5 99.750 8/25/29 2.43 L+175 Floating C 24.160 A2 A 41.00 L+214.6 99.750 8/25/29 2.45 L+225 Floating D 20.206 Baa3 BBB- 35.25 L+424.5 99.750 8/25/29 2.51 L+435 Floating E 25.917 Ba2 BB 27.88 8/25/29 2.60 Floating F 12.299 B2 B 24.38 8/25/29 2.60 Floating G 85.658 NR NR 0.00 8/25/29 2.68 Floating
X-WAC(IO) 227.540* Baa3 BBB- 8/25/29 Floating
X-LF(IO) 351.414* NR NR 8/25/29 Floating
*Notional amount
WORLDWIDE CMBS
US CMBS
LOAN SPREADS
ASKING SPREADS OVER TREASURYS
ASKING OFFICE SPREADS
REIT BOND ISSUANCE
UNSECURED NOTES, MTNs, ($Bil.)
MONTHLY ISSUANCE ($Bil.)
SPREADS
Data points for all charts can be found in The Marketplace section of CMAlert.com
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 J F M A M J J A S O N D 2012 2011
MONTHLY ISSUANCE ($Bil.)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N Spread (bp) New Issue
Fixed Rate Avg. Week 52-wk (Conduit) Life 11/7 Earlier Avg. AAA 10.0 5.0 S+53 S+94 S+50 S+95 103 134 AA 10.0 S+194 S+189 265 A 10.0 S+260 S+255 370 BBB 10.0 S+427 S+420 556 Spread (bp) Legacy
Fixed Rate Avg. Week 52-wk (Conduit) Life 11/7 Earlier Avg. AAA 10.0 5.0 S+146 S+93 S+143 S+97 +158 +208 AA 10.0 S+1,638 S+1,630 +1,947 A 10.0 S+2,247 S+2,237 +2,561 BBB 10.0 S+3,914 S+3,895 +4,193 Dollar Price Week 52-wk Markit CMBX 5 11/7 Earlier Avg. AAA 94.6 94.7 92.6 AA 45.5 45.7 45.4 A 26.8 27.1 30.3 BBB 17.7 17.8 18.1
BB 5.0 5.0 5.0
Sources: Trepp, Markit
Month 11/2 Earlier Office 220 225 Retail 207 206 Multi-family 198 208 Industrial 206 217 Source: Trepp 100 150 200 250 300 M J J A S O N 10-year loans with 50-59% LTV
CMBS TOTAL RETURNS
CMBS INDEX
Total Return (%) Avg. Month Year Since As of 11/7 Life to Date to Date 1/1/97
Inv.-grade 3.7 0.0 9.3 191.5 AAA 3.5 0.1 6.5 179.6 AA 4.0 0.1 11.2 79.8 A 3.9 0.0 13.0 63.3 BBB 4.2 0.0 18.4 65.0 Source: Barclays 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 J F M A M J J A S O N D 2012 2011 0 1 2 3 4 S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N
Rating Amount Spread CDS 11/2 Maturity (M/S) ($Mil.) (bp) (bp)
Kimco 10/19 Baa1/BBB+ 300 T+120 108 Simon Property 3/22 A3/A- 600 T+81 79 Equity Residential 12/21 Baa1/BBB+ 1,000 T+105 80 Prologis 3/20 Baa2/BBB- 540 T+163 159 AvalonBay 9/22 Baa1/BBB+ 450 T+113 70 Duke Realty 6/22 Baa2/BBB- 300 T+168 126 Boston Properties 2/23 Baa2/A- 1,000 T+130 87 Health Care Property 8/22 Baa2/BBB 300 T+158 112 Regency Centers 4/21 Baa2/BBB 250 T+147 Liquid REIT Average Baa1/BBB+ 527 T+132 103
Source: Wells Fargo
90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 M J J A S O N
NEW-ISSUE SPREAD OVER SWAPS
CMBS SPREADS
10-Year AAA
WORLDWIDE CMBS ISSUANCE ($Bil.)
2011 2012
01/06/00 J 0.0 0.0 Year-to-date volume ($Bil.)
01/13/00 0.0 0.0 2012 2011 01/20/00 0.0 0.2 US 38.6 28.8 01/27/00 0.0 2.0 Non-US 4.3 3.3 02/03/00 F 0.4 2.0 TOTAL 42.9 32.1 02/10/00 0.4 2.6 02/17/00 5.2 3.2 02/24/00 6.6 3.2 03/02/00 M 6.6 4.3 03/09/00 8.1 5.4 03/16/00 8.5 6.4 03/23/00 8.6 6.8 03/30/00 10.0 7.0 04/06/00 A 10.0 7.6 04/13/00 10.2 7.8 04/20/00 10.3 9.8 04/27/00 10.9 11.1 05/04/00 10.9 12.7 05/11/00 M 10.9 12.8 05/18/00 10.9 15.3 05/25/00 11.1 15.8 06/01/00 14.1 16.0 06/08/00 14.1 17.3 06/15/00 J 16.0 17.3 06/22/00 18.8 19.0 06/29/00 19.5 20.2 07/06/00 19.5 20.2 07/13/00 J 19.5 22.1 07/20/00 20.2 23.6 07/27/00 22.2 24.7 08/03/00 23.7 25.0 08/10/00 A 23.7 26.3 08/17/00 25.6 26.6 08/24/00 25.6 26.6 08/31/00 25.8 27.0 09/07/00 26.0 27.0 09/14/00 S 26.0 30.2 09/21/00 28.5 32.6 09/28/00 30.3 35.1 10/05/00 30.3 37.7 10/12/00 30.9 37.7 10/19/00 O 30.9 39.3 10/26/00 30.9 39.6 11/02/00 31.0 42.6 11/09/00 32.1 42.9 11/16/00 32.3 11/23/00 N 33.4 11/30/00 33.4 12/07/00 33.8 12/14/00 35.9
MARKET MONITOR
Untitled-2 1 11/8/2012 2:33:10 PMTO SUBSCRIBE
YES!Sign me up for a one-year subscription to Commercial Mortgage Alert at a cost of $4,097. I understand I can cancel at any time and receive a full refund for the unused portion of my 46-issue subscription.
DELIVERY (check one): qE-mail. qMail.
PAYMENT (check one): q Check enclosed, payable to Commercial
Mortgage Alert. q Bill me. q American Express. q Mastercard.
q Visa. Account #: Exp. date: Name: Company: Address: City/ST/Zip: Phone: E-mail:
MAIL TO: Commercial Mortgage Alert www.CMAlert.com
5 Marine View Plaza #400 FAX: 201-659-4141 Hoboken NJ 07030-5795 CALL: 201-659-1700
Signature:
COMMERCIAL MORTGAGE ALERT
www.CMAlert.com
Telephone: 201-659-1700 Fax: 201-659-4141 E-mail: info@hspnews.com
Donna Knipp Managing Editor 201-234-3967 dknipp@hspnews.com
Bob Mura Senior Writer 201-234-3978 bmura@hspnews.com
Richard Quinn Senior Writer 201-234-3997 rquinn@hspnews.com
Chad Weihrauch Senior Writer 201-234-3988 chad@hspnews.com
Andrew Albert Publisher 201-234-3960 andy@hspnews.com
Daniel Cowles General Manager 201-234-3963 dcowles@hspnews.com
Thomas J. Ferris Editor 201-234-3972 tferris@hspnews.com
T.J. Foderaro Deputy Editor 201-234-3979 tjfoderaro@hspnews.com
Ben Lebowitz Deputy Editor 201-234-3961 blebowitz@hspnews.com
Dan Murphy Deputy Editor 201-234-3975 dmurphy@hspnews.com
Michelle Lebowitz Operations Director 201-234-3977 mlebowitz@hspnews.com
Evan Grauer Database Director 201-234-3987 egrauer@hspnews.com
Mary E. Romano Advertising Director 201-234-3968 mromano@hspnews.com
Josh Albert Advertising Manager 201-234-3999 josh@hspnews.com
Joy Renee Selnick Layout Editor 201-234-3962 jselnick@hspnews.com
Barbara Eannace Marketing Director 201-234-3981 barbara@hspnews.com
JoAnn Tassie Customer Service 201-659-1700 jtassie@hspnews.com
Commercial Mortgage Alert (ISSN: 1520-3697), Copyright 2012, is published weekly by Harrison Scott Publications Inc., 5 Marine View Plaza, Suite 400, Hoboken, NJ 07030-5795. It is a violation of federal law to photocopy or distribute any part of this publication (either inside or outside your company) without first obtaining permission from Commercial Mort-gage Alert. We routinely monitor forwarding of the publication by employing email-tracking technology such as ReadNotify.com. Subscription rate: $4,097 per year. Information on advertising and group subscriptions is available upon request.
THE GRAPEVINE
... From Page 1
November 9, 2012
Commercial Mortgage
23
ALERT
high-yield mortgage program that,
among other things, invested in
mez-zanine loans and syndicated portions
of debt the insurer originated. MetLife
recently reshuffled some of its real
estate management ranks as it carved
out a third-party asset-management
business. McIntyre previously was head
of syndications for
KeyBankand held
executive positions at
GE Capital Real Estateand
UBS.Managing director
Thomas Deanehas
left
Wells Fargoafter taking a
buy-out package. There’s no word on his
plans. Based in Charlotte, Deane ran
a dispositions unit within the bank’s
special-situations group that handles
foreclosed properties, note sales, joint
ventures, and other transactions
involv-ing commercial real estate assets. The
team also consults on loan workouts
and strategies for resolving troubled
assets. Deane was working for
Wachoviawhen Wells took it over in 2008. He had
joined Wachovia in 2003 and served
as a senior executive in a number of
commercial real estate areas, including
special servicing.
Scott Moore
has joined
CBREas senior
vice president and head of
FHAloan
production for multi-family and
health-care properties. He’s in Columbus, Ohio,
but will relocate to Denver within a
year. Moore previously was a
manag-ing member at Columbus-based
RedMortgage Capital,
where he brokered
FHA loans on healthcare properties. He
also had stints at
Ziegler Financingand
Lancaster Pollard Mortgage.Miles Borden
joined law firm
SeyfarthShaw
late last month as a partner in the
firm’s real estate department. Borden
moved to the firm’s New York office
from his post as a partner at
TroutmanSanders.
At Seyfarth, Borden represents
lenders and borrowers on transactions
that include acquisitions, dispositions,
joint ventures and mortgage financing.
He reports to real estate group chair
Paul Mattingly.
Prime Finance
is looking for an
execu-tive to work on structuring, negotiating
and closing loans. Candidates should
have a legal background, including at
least five years of experience in closing
mortgages on commercial properties.
The recruit would work at the fund
shop’s New York headquarters and
report to principal
Jon Brayshaw.Raj Mehta
joined loan-software firm
CJCTechnologies
of New York last month
as director of client development. He
focuses on expanding the client base
for the firm’s origination and
asset-management software. Clients include
securitization shops, agency lenders,
credit unions and service-providers.
Mehta formerly worked at
J.P. Morganand
Credit Suisse.Situsowns a stake in
CJC, which is based in Franklin, Tenn.
Starwood Property
is looking for an
analyst with 2-3 years of experience to
join its credit and underwriting team in
Los Angeles. Duties include modeling
property and loan cashflows, analyzing
profit and loss statements, reviewing
due-diligence materials, conducting
market research and preparing
presen-tations. Applicants may contact
TessieTalmage thanks our speakers and clients who participated in our 2012 Credit Conference.
Your insights, contributions and ideas made the conference a great success. Thanks
also to our clients and partners for making 2012 one of our most successful years.
Talmage manages $1.7 billion in commercial real estate debt assets across the country
and operates a robust large loan Special Servicing platform. Since 2003, we have made
in excess of $10 billion of investments, acted as the Special Servicer on over $10 billion
of transactions and advised on over $30 billion of loan restructurings and modifications.
Talmage, LLC 430 Park Avenue New York, New York 10022 212.209.1388 talmagellc.com
TALMAGE 2012 CREDIT CONFERENCE AGENDA
The Election & The Economy - Perspectives from Kevin Warsh
Distinguished Visiting Fellow at the Hoover Institution and Lecturer at the Graduate School of Business, Stanford University
The Owner’s Perspective
Jeffrey Kelter - CEO, KTR Capital Partners
David Simon - Chairman & CEO, Simon Property Group
Barry Sternlicht - Chairman & CEO, Starwood Capital Group
Debt Investing and Lending Strategies Post Financial Crisis
Tobin Cobb - Co-CEO, LNR Property
Boyd Fellows - President, Starwood Property Trust
James Flaum - Managing Director, Morgan Stanley
Michael Nash - Senior Managing Director, The Blackstone Group
“Unintended Consequences” - Thoughts on the Economy, Ed Conard
Author of the New York Times best-selling book “Unintended Consequences” and former Bain Capital Partner
The LP Perspective - Opportunities in a New World
Nori Lietz - CEO, Areté Capital
Isabelle Scemama - Head of Commercial Real Estate Finance, AXA Real Estate
David Sherman - President & CIO, Metropolitan Real Estate Equity Management
“The Last Word” - Industry Leaders Share Thoughts on the Market
Michael Ashner - Chairman & CEO, Winthrop Realty Trust
Barry Blattman - 6HQLRU0DQDJLQJ3DUWQHU%URRNÀHOG$VVHW0DQDJHPHQW
Ron Kravit - Senior Managing Director, Cerberus Capital Management