Who we are...
• Child abuse
victim recovers
£5.5m
• Cyclist wins
100% of claim
Personal injury news
Compensation secured for
mesothelioma victim
Michael’s
Story
Mesothelioma
Case
E-coli 0157
Outbreak
The Patels
Compensation secured for
mesothelioma victim
Australian man, Kyle, recovers substantial
compensation after suffering head injuries
Spring 2013
Paul McNeil Partner 020 7861 4019 Peter Williams Partner 020 78614825 Jill Greenfield Partner 020 78614557 Andrew Morgan Partner 020 7861 4036 Caroline Pinfold Partner 020 7861 4022 Richard Earle Senior Associate 020 78614041 Mark Bowman Partner 020 7861 4043 Dushal Mehta Associate 020 7861 4033 Jenny Bradley Solicitor 020 7861 4530FFW provides a
‘first-class’ service to
clients.
The Legal 500 2012“
“
The cases in this newsletter I hope help to demonstrate the very significant level of expertise within our department. Many of our lawyers are recognised as “Leaders” in the field of personal injury law and have recently been added to the newly introduced “Super Lawyers UK” list.Our key focus is our client. If a client instructs a Partner in our department, then it is that Partner that will be progressing their claim for them. It is important that we are able to maintain and establish that very important relationship with the client. We focus hugely on rehabilitation. We put in place the tools to allow the Claimant to recover, so far as possible, a reasonable quality of life. We see this as essential to our role.
Here you will see the kind of work that we have done for and with our clients. These are just a few of the highlights, there are of course many more such cases. Key highlights include: • £5.5 million for a young man
awarded by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme;
• A significant sum (confidential by a Court Order) for our client, Kyle Bullock, who suffered a very severe brain injury when he fell in a pothole;
• £820,000 for an aspiring young Barrister who suffered significant leg injuries in a road traffic accident; and • Campaigning successfully for
the introduction of a brand new compensation scheme to British Victims of Terrorism abroad launched in 2013, which we were instrumental in the campaign for. I do hope you find this interesting. I also hope that you can see that our work is such that we will always work extremely hard for our clients, we are committed to their cases and rehabilitation and we obtain for them extremely good results.
Please take the time to read on and find out what we can achieve for you. If you would like further information, please do contact me or one of our team members.
Alternatively, please visit our website, which has recently been relaunched, at
www.ffw.com/personalinjury.
I hope you enjoy the newsletter. Paul McNeil
Head of Personal Injury & Clinical Negligence Department
Welcome to the 2013 Edition
of our Personal injury news
Contents
9
Cyclist wins 100% of claim after cycling accident2
Welcome11
Compensation secured after catastrophic motorcycle accident4
Australian man, Kyle, recovers substantial compensation14
Useful organisations15
Meet the team13
Campaign to change law on terrorism compensation3
Child victim recovers £5.5m from the CICA12
£400,000 secured for mesothelioma sufferer7
Barrister who suffered brain injury recovers compensation6
Group action for children exposed to E Coli 01575
Seven figure recovery for road traffic accident victimClient sustains multiple injuries due to accident at work
10
8
Mesothelioma claim settled with help from our archives3
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
“
Jill Greenfield and Mark Bowman were instructed by the adoptive mother of a young boy, Chris, who had been injured as a baby.
At just a few weeks old, Chris was subjected to an injury, resulting in him suffering severe brain damage. A claim was made to the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority. Over the initial 18 year period the family were provided with interim payments of just £22,000. In spite of the lack of support, Chris’ adoptive parents, and in particular his mother, selflessly cared for the child including schooling him at home.
The progress that Chris had made under the care of his adoptive mother was even more impressive in view of the contents of an MRI brain scan which revealed that 75% of the right side of the brain had been damaged. It was apparent that the plasticity of the brain for this young boy had allowed him to develop many life skills that confounded the medical experts. However there were clearly very many behavioural problems.
At the time of our instruction in 2010 the family were reliant on DSS benefits. The home environment was unsuitable and the family was struggling significantly to deal with his behaviour.
The injury had occurred before 1992 and so before the CICA had a cap of £500,000. It was clear that the critical issue was to ensure that a proper care and rehabilitation regime was put in place in order to try to deal with some of the outbursts but also in order to let the client’s mother become more independent of her now adult son.
Upon instruction Jill Greenfield and
Mark Bowman were able to:
• Obtain an immediate interim payment of £50,000
• Rent more suitable accommodation for them to live in
• Employ a case manager • Employ carers
• Obtain a full medical evaluation as to his future needs.
Child victim recovers £5.5million from
the CICA
Reports were obtained from a number of experts who all agreed that as a result of the care provided by Chris’ adoptive mother our client had made amazing progress over the previous 20 years. As a result of the severity of the injuries sustained however, there was unlikely to be any further progress, and therefore our client would never be able to live independently. We were able to obtain a further interim payment of £1,000,000. At a CICA hearing in July 2012 we were able to secure an award of over £5.5 million which will ensure that Chris has a suitable care regime for life, that he can live in appropriate accommodation, and that his finances are suitably managed to ensure that he is looked after for life.
Chris was subjected to brain injury at just a few
weeks old.
Field Fisher
Waterhouse not only
helped us to get a
significant payment, but
they also supported us
throughout the process,
and helped us find skilled
brain injury professionals
who have been able to
make a difference to
my son’s life.
Chris’ mum
“
Kyle Bullock was on his way home with friends on 22nd July 2007 when he was coming down Lightfoot Road, Haringey. This road was particularly steep with a 1 in 10 gradient. It was night time and whilst there were street lights it was the Claimant’s case that the road was not terribly well lit. Worse than that however was the presence of large pot holes in the road. It was the Claimant’s case and the evidence of his friends that he had stumbled in one of these potholes whilst coming down the road.
That had caused Kyle to fall very heavily indeed and such was the gradient of the road, he was unable to prevent his fall. He suffered very serious brain damage. Kyle was initially taken to Whittington Hospital and placed in the intensive care unit. He later underwent brain surgery. He spent an extended period in a brain injury rehabilitation unit and required help and support with most aspects of daily living.
Jill Greenfield was instructed. The Defendant, Homes for Haringey Ltd, initially denied responsibility although they accepted that they had not
maintained the road to a proper standard. They denied that the potholes had caused the accident. The road had in fact already been logged in March 2007 as a road that was on the Network Priority List as requiring works. It appeared
that the road may have been left in this condition for some years. Members of the public had also complained about the poor state of the road. Documents indicated that this road was one of the streets in the area that was “subject to high levels of complaints and accident claims.” Eventually the claim in respect of liability settled in 2008 with the Claimant agreeing to accept 72.5% of his full claim value. This agreement was approved by the High Court in London.
There then followed litigation in which the Claim was to be valued. Kyle was at the time working in London for a charity and lived with his partner in a newly purchased flat. He was not however able to return to work and his relationship faltered. He took the decision to return to Australia, where his mother and many of his friends were based to continue with his rehabilitation. Unfortunately Kyle went on to develop epilepsy. He now lives with the consequences of his brain injury on a daily basis and has help and support in Australia.
Following extensive litigation the claim was settled for a substantial sum which was approved before Sir Raymond Jack sitting as a Judge of the High Court on Monday 11th March 2013.
This was a very significant international brain injury case which brought with it very many legal complications. We worked with Australian lawyers and sought specialist advice as to the legal implications of any settlement.
Australian man, Kyle, recovers substantial
compensation against Homes for Haringey Ltd
You helped me
every step of the way
and gained an excellent
result for me. If I look
back and think about
what my life would’ve
been without you
fighting my corner, I
could have been in a
real mess physically,
psychologically and
financially. As they say,
you saved my
bacon!
This was large scale
international litigation;
fortunately we had the
expertise to get it right.
“
“
“
“
“
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
5
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
Caroline Pinfold secures compensation for
Essex mesothelioma victim
This process created a lot of asbestos dust which unfortunately Tom breathed in because he was not provided with a mask. Furthermore his employers did not warn him about the potential risks to his health from the asbestos dust.
In May 2012 Tom developed pain in his chest. A biopsy was performed in July, following which he was diagnosed with mesothelioma. When the diagnosis was confirmed, Tom instructed our asbestos expert Caroline Pinfold to pursue a claim for compensation against the former employers. Caroline was able to obtain an admission of liability and an interim payment of compensation for him in October 2012 within the space of three months. Additional evidence was obtained and following further negotiations the claim was settled in February 2013.
Mr Davy was exposed to asbestos when working in a large scrap metal yard in East London owned by Thos W Ward Ltd. He went straight from school in 1961 and was there until 1965. Tom worked as a lorry driver’s mate and had to load and unload pipes and other scrap metal covered in asbestos lagging.
Our client, Devbai was walking home from shopping when there was an accident on the dual carriageway nearby. As a consequence, a large lorry mounted the pavement and ran her over whereby she sustained very serious head and arm injuries. She required surgery and has since required care and support from family, case managers and carers.
Jill Greenfield was instructed by the family. Initially, there was a denial of liability. However, it soon became apparent that the Defendant driver had been drinking. The Defendant’s legal team at one point did suggest that there ought to be a negotiation in respect of liability.
Given that the Claimant was a pedestrian, we completely refused and sought full compensation. Eventually, the Defence accepted full liability. Very many experts were involved in the valuation of this claim. A care regime was put in place
and Devbai was moved to a more appropriate accommodation. After lengthy negotiations, the claim eventually settled for a seven figure sum. The compensation secured will allow Devbai to receive care and support for the rest of her life.
Devbai Patel - Seven figure recovery for road
traffic accident victim
“
“
Said Mr Davy
Tom had to load and
unload pipes and other
scrap metal covered in
asbestos lagging.
Caroline worked very
hard and was genuinely
concerned for me. From the
very first interview she kept
me in the picture right up
until the case conclusion.
The compensation will
help my wife be financially
sound when I am no longer
around.
Everything went as well as I could have
imagined. I did not have to worry about any
aspects of the claim. Jill looked after all the needs
of my wife from start to finish. She was able to
negotiate a seven figure global settlement, with
the majority of the award being for future care
and support. Jill instructed the best care managers
and physiotherapists and ensured that my wife
will have the best care available to her. I cannot
recommend her services highly enough.
“
“
£820,000 secured for severe leg injury after
road traffic accident
Mark Bowman secured £820,000 for an aspiring Barrister and talented artist, who was the victim of a road traffic accident.
David was walking to his local supermarket in March 2008. He was passing a 10ft concrete wall which adjoined his property, when a lorry exiting the property clipped the wall bringing it down on top of him. David faced a long and arduous struggle with pain management and an intensive physiotherapy regime over the following months. He required the use of an Ilizarov frame for 9 months and moved back in with his parents so they could assist with his care and mobility, as he required round the clock attention. He was also suffering from chronic post-traumatic stress disorder, resulting in nightmares, intrusive thoughts, flashbacks and depression. David commenced his Pupillage with a renowned civil set of barristers in July 2008 despite the Ilizarov frame
still remaining in place. Despite his best efforts, a decision was taken to postpone the second half of his Pupillage until he had made a further recovery. Due to the severity of his injuries he did not return to work until November 2010.
As a result of the accident, David has been left with permanent nerve damage, and a ‘drop foot’. His right leg is shorter than the left meaning that he will require special orthotic footwear for life. He will also require a number of knee replacement operations in the future.
Owing to the severity of the injury, David was in touch with Mark Bowman
to pursue a claim on his behalf. Liability was admitted early on and Mark’s main task was to quantify David’s claim, and in particular the amount of future loss of earnings, as he was not taken on by chambers following his Pupillage. Initial offers from the Defendants of £25,000 and £40,000 were
immediately rejected and sizeable interim payments were obtained to help David fund his ongoing treatment and rehabilitation. Mark successfully negotiated a settlement
of £820,000.
David faced a long and arduous struggle with pain management.
Mark worked very
hard in juggling the various
demands of what became
a very complex, multi-issue
case and was always on top
of the work load and the
timetabling we faced.
“
“
After the case, David had this to say about Mark:
Group action for children exposed to
E-coli 0157 in the largest ever UK outbreak
In 2009, over 90 people contracted E.coli 0157 when visiting Godstone Farm, a petting farm in Surrey, including 76 children under the age of 10. Field Fisher Waterhouse LLP has been acting for more than 30 of the Claimants, some of who have suffered very serious health problems and may require kidney transplants in the future.
The matter came before the High Court in March 2013 to deal with the dispute between Godstone Farm, the Health Protection Agency and Tandridge District Council to decide who was liable. Mr Justice Turner confirmed Godstone Farm were wholly liable for the incident and ruled that no responsibility for the outbreak could be placed on either of the public authorities.
We are pleased that there has been a decision for what has been a trying time for all the families involved. This story was covered heavily by the press and Jill also appeared BBC News and ITV News discussing this matter in detail.
This is an outcome
that I am sure many
families will take comfort
from, they will be relieved
that a resolution has been
found and a conclusion
has been brought to what
has been a long period of
uncertainty.
Partner Jill Greenfield said,
Richard Earle has been acting for over 30 of the Claimants, some of who have suffered very serious health problems.
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
7
Michael Waterworth was a successful Chancery barrister at 10 Old Square. He was seen as a leading light in trust matters and had a highly successful practice. On 30th May 2011 he was at a party for newly appointed silks and went on with colleagues to Daly’s Wine Bar in Fleet Street.
During the course of the evening he went to the bathroom at Daly’s wine bar which was situated down steep stairs. On his return up the stairs he fell. The evidence suggested that he had fallen from the very top of the stairs to the bottom and he suffered an extremely serious brain injury. He required brain surgery and remained in a coma for several weeks.
It was clear upon his emergence from coma that this was a life changing event. His communication difficulties are now poor. He has undergone several surgeries and is undergoing rehabilitation.
Jill Greenfield was instructed by Michael’s wife, Caroline Waterworth (also a barrister) in June 2012 to pursue the Claim. The claim centred on the lack of a sufficient handrail on the particular stairway. This stairway was a “winder” curving to the left; which meant that steps on the left curved around the corner and narrowed as they did. It was Michael’s case that the handrail was insufficient. The hand rail leading up the stairs stopped, there was then a gap and then the hand rail recommenced around the corner. This meant that at the point of the corner itself there was no handrail. We argued that this was in breach of British Standards for winder stairways.
The Claimant denied liability. It should be noted that cases involving stairways are notoriously difficult. The case progressed at a very quick pace and was concluded within 5 months of initial instruction. A compromise settlement for a significant sum was agreed and approved before Mr Justice Ramsay 11th December 2012.
Barrister who suffered brain injury recovers
substantial compensation
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
“
“
Michael’s wife Caroline
says:
Michael and I would
never have imagined that
this could have happened
from something as simple
as climbing a flight of
stairs. We are immensely
grateful for all of the
support and good wishes
we have received during
the last six months and we
are particularly thankful
for the compassionate
and efficient manner
with which Jill Greenfield
brought the matter to
a conclusion. This will
allow us and our family to
adjust to the new set of
circumstances we face.
Peter Williams secures full
compensation with help from our archives
Industrial Disease Specialist Peter Williams acted for Graham Mason who was diagnosed with mesothelioma at Southend Hospital in August 2011. Graham worked as a fitters mate for J.W. Coward & Co of Chelmsford in the 1960s. He worked alongside laggers in schools and hospitals where he was required to mix and strip asbestos from pipes and boiler work with his bare hands in tight confined spaces. His employer provided no protective equipment. In February 2011, Graham began to notice intense chest pains and shortness of breath and was submitted to hospital. He was diagnosed with mesothelioma and was no longer able to undertake basic care activities such as cooking, cleaning and gardening. The company Graham worked for was long dissolved and had no assets. Insurers could not be traced by the Association of British Insurers. Peter Williams was instructed. Field Fisher Waterhouse searched their databases
The company Graham
worked for was long
dissolved and had no
assets.
Peter is
extremely professional
and is obviously very
experienced at his job.
He is very friendly,
compassionate and
a truly nice fellow.
I wish we had met
under different
circumstances. I have
already recommended
his services to
Southend and Guy’s
hospital.
Graham had this to say about Peter:
and was able to find two cases in which we had been able to pursue the company in the 1990s and had recovered compensation. AGF were identified as the responsible insurers for the company in those cases. AGF had no documentary or witness record of insuring the company but we were able to refer them to evidence from a director of the company taken in the 1990s to confirm that they were responsible for the insurance. Despite initially defending the claim AGF finally agreed that they were responsible. Peter Williams successfully negotiated a global mesothelioma settlement of £210,000 in just over 12 months, allowing Graham to obtain the compensation he deserves.
9
Cyclist wins 100% of claim three years
after life changing accident in Marble Arch
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848Cyclist Veronika Pete, a 31 year old marketing professional from central London, was left with life changing injuries after she was run over by a lorry crossing lanes to turn left on the Marble Arch gyratory on 7th December 2010. Jill Greenfield was instructed by Veronika to act for her. Acting on behalf of the defendant, insurance company RSA alleged that Veronika was partially responsible for the accident despite the driver being found guilty of careless driving as well as the vehicle not being fitted with adequate mirrors or safety equipment. Having initially suggested 20% liability to be accepted by Veronika, RSA gave in and acknowledged full liability just weeks before trial.
Veronika was cycling along her regular route to work, travelling around the Marble Arch gyratory and heading towards Oxford Street past the exit to Edgware Road. The driver of the heavy bullion vehicle, Mr John Taylor, stated that he had seen the cyclist but then lost sight of her. He assumed she had turned left, taking the exit to Edgware Road. In fact Veronika was at the front of the bullion vehicle below the cab’s line of sight. The vehicle was not fitted with mirrors designed to increase visibility that are now recommended for all new HGVs. The driver turned left across the lane, dragging Veronika under the lorry’s wheels.
I hope all that
I have been through
will help other victims
in similar situations
stay strong in the face
of legal pressure. But
I hope especially that
the insurance industry
will see this as a wake
up call and realise the
importance of being
fully accountable for
insuring fleets of ill
equipped vehicles.
Commenting on the development, Veronika Pete said:
Graham had this to say about Peter:
She was rushed to St Mary’s Hospital in Paddington where she received emergency life saving treatment. Her leg had to be amputated above the knee and her other leg was severely damaged. This was amongst many other soft tissue and orthopaedic injuries. She was transferred to Charing Cross Hospital where she spent several months undergoing multiple operations and recovering from the impact of the accident. Veronika now uses a wheelchair and is learning to walk using a prosthetic limb. She is receiving intensive rehabilitation and requires help from her partner, James, carers, family and friends. The road to recovery will be long and difficult.
Jill Greenfield has been pursuing Veronika’s claim for personal injury damages against RSA, the insurers of the vehicle.
RSA alleged that Veronika was partially responsible for the accident, claiming initially that she had failed to take proper care for her own safety. A criminal trial was held in the summer of 2012, in which the Defendant driver was found guilty of careless driving, fined £1,300 and given 5 penalty points on his licence. Surprisingly the argument continued with the Defence maintaining that
Veronika should accept to being partially at fault. RSA suggested that she should accept a 20% reduction in her damages claim to reflect this. Following lengthy civil litigation a trial date was set for May 2013. But just weeks before the trial the Defence finally agreed to judgement being entered which means that Veronika will recover her damages on a 100% basis.
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
Our client, Claire contacted Richard Earle, Senior Associate at Field Fisher Waterhouse after she was struck on the head and shoulder by a display sign that had fallen from above as she was walking down her local high street.
As a result of this accident, Claire developed labyrinthine concussion as well as vertigo, tinnitus, depression and distress in crowded or busy environments. Her injuries were severe enough for her to give up her job as a lecturer in London and move to France where she worked as a self employed nutritional expert, with a marked drop in salary.
Immediately after the accident the workman, who dropped or threw the sign intentionally, drove off with his work mate leaving Claire on the pavement badly injured and in a state of shock. With the help of her partner, Claire managed to get to A&E by ambulance.
Richard Earle overcame a number of difficulties with this claim. Initially the defendants alleged that Claire was in some way partly responsible for the
accident. Richard however managed to settle the claim on a global basis, without concessions as to contributory negligence and without prejudice as to liability.
The defendants also alleged that Claire had a pre-existing vulnerability to psychological injury partly due to a previous incident in her life. However Richard was able to rely on the ‘eggshell skull principle’, and secured compensation for the full extent of her injuries without any concession for pre-existing vulnerability.
Three weeks before the trial Richard, with the helpful support of Counsel Dennis Matthews of Crown Office Chambers, successfully managed to negotiate settlement of £100,000+ costs. Claire was very pleased with this settlement as the lump sum would help her towards her loss of earnings that she will experience in the future.
Jennifer Bradley recovers damages for a Claimant
who was dragged into and became trapped in a
compactor machine at work
Jennifer Bradley secured a
settlement for Jack, a factory worker who was seriously injured at the Mineral Refinery where he worked. During one of Jack’s night shift, he was dragged into and became trapped in a compactor machine suffering multiple injuries. This included a dislocated right shoulder, multiple bilateral rib fractures resulting in a left pneumothorax, laceration to the liver; and facial injuries.
Jack was initially treated in intensive care where a chest drain was inserted and a tracheostomy performed. He remained in intensive care for two weeks undergoing multiple operations. Unfortunately the injury has since prevented Jack carrying out heavy lifting and he could not continue his previous job at the refinery.
Our client at the outset instructed previous solicitors but was not happy with the advice being given
and consequently instructed
Jennifer Bradley to continue with his claim. Naturally, there were various arguments over contributory negligence. However, after lengthy investigations and negotiations, Jennifer obtained a considerable offer which Jack was happy to accept.
Richard Earle secures £100,000 for girl
sustaining personal injury
Claire was struck on the
head and shoulder by a
display sign at her local
highstreet.
Jack was dragged and trapped in a compactor machine suffering multiple injuries.
Richard did a
tremendous job working
extremely hard as well
as providing constant
reassurance, regular
updates and positive
advice. This gave me the
confidence to proceed with
the case. I am delighted
with the outcome and the
compensation recovered
which will provide security
for my future as well as
allowing me to get on with
my life.
Claire commented after the case:
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
11
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
Mark Bowman was instructed by Martin following a motorcycle accident. Martin was initially referred to a panel solicitors through his motorcycle insurance policy but came to Field Fisher Waterhouse in March 2012.
On 10 May 2009 Martin was riding his motorcycle along the A41 Bicester Road. He was proceeding a safe distance behind a BMW car. On the other side of the road, a Mercedes car was being driven by the Defendant. The Defendant driver fell asleep behind the wheel of his car and veered across the road, colliding with the BMW motor car that was in front of Martin. As a result of this impact, the BMW was shunted backwards. Martin was unable to avoid this collision and as a result he suffered devastating injuries. Martin was subject to above the knee amputation to his right leg, hypoxic brain injury following respiratory arrest on the side of the road, severe injury to his left knee (which subsequently required a total knee replacement), facial fractures, weakness to the left hand, burning hypersensitivity to the left arm, Peyronie’s disease and urinary complications.
In spite of the circumstances of the collision, the Defendants refused to admit liability. They alleged that Martin was riding too close to the BMW vehicle and that he was not just partially, but totally, to blame
for his injuries. At the time Mark Bowman were instructed Martin had received interim payments totalling £255,000 in the best part of three years. He was living in rented accommodation and was about to be forced to move as his landlord would not extend his tenancy. He did not have sufficient money to purchase suitable accommodation. Notwithstanding the Defendants’ stance, we were able to obtain an interim payment of £540,000 within 3 months of being instructed so that Martin could purchase suitable accommodation in which to live. Following a settlement meeting in January 2013 during which the Defendant legal team finally admitted full liability, Martin was awarded a seven figure sum in compensation, including £50,000 per year for the rest of his life to cover the cost of requiring professional care at home. Martin’s compensation means that he will be able to afford state of the art prostheses in the form of c-legs and water activity limbs. He will have sufficient funds to provide him with the private care regime that he needs and so that his loving wife can return to work.
Seven figure compensation secured after
catastrophic motorcycle accident
We obtained an interim
payment of £540,000
within 3 months of
being instructed.
Mark we really just
want to say how brilliant you
and Field Fisher Waterhouse
were in handling the case for
us. We only moved to you
guys less than a year before
the case settled. I don’t
think the previous solicitors
that our insurers appointed
would have pushed quite as
hard as you did to get us the
settlement you achieved.
They would certainly
not have got the interim
payments that you did, so
we might have been forced
to stay in another rented
property somewhere with
everything else going on
still hanging over our heads.
Thanks to you we were able
to purchase a bungalow
during the case, and it has
made a huge difference to
us. You, and Marise put up
with us so well. You were
very patient with us and
always explained things
well and kept us up to date
with what was going on. We
were never out of the loop.
We would, and have already,
recommend you to friends
and family if they ever need
any legal help.
the meantime he intended to invest heavily in new machinery to improve profitability and to access new markets.
Sadly Mr Searle was diagnosed as suffering from mesothelioma in August 2010; that is when he instructed Andrew Morgan to make a claim. Andrew confirmed that BRB (Residuary) Limited was the successor to Great Western Railways (GWR) and to British Rail (BR) and he made a claim. He obtained an early admission of liability and an interim payment for Mr Searle of £50,000.
Mr Searle’s greatest financial loss was the loss of income from his business in the future, and from the loss of capital from its sale when he intended, eventually, to retire. Andrew Morgan therefore instructed a forensic accountant to prepare a report and obtained statements from a number of Mr Searle’s commercial clients as to the quality of his work and as to their likely need for the services of Cutlass Mechanical Engineering in the future. Mr Searle identified a need for a significant capital investment to purchase a new water jet to help build the business so Andrew applied successfully for a further interim payment of damages of £75,000, making total interim payments of £125,000.
Mr Searle was keen to attend Court in person to give his evidence and the case was listed for trial in London for 16 July 2012. Andrew instructed Matthias
Kelly QC to represent Mr Searle at trial. Just a few days before the trial Andrew was able to negotiate a settlement totaling £400,000 which Mr Searle was happy to accept.
Obtaining the interim payments and then settling the case in July allowed Mr Searle to move his business to more up to date and convenient premises so that he could install the new water jet, the future engine of his business, in August 2012.
Andrew Morgan secures £400,000 for
mesothelioma sufferer
William Searle was born in 1945 and left school in the early 1960s. He was exposed to asbestos whilst working for great Western Railways shortly after. Sadly, in August 2010 he was diagnosed with mesothelioma; 50 years after his exposure. Mr Searle contacted Andrew Morgan, partner and mesothelioma claims expert at Field Fisher Waterhouse, to pursue a claim on his behalf. Andrew was able to secure £400,000 a few days before the case was set for trial.
In his early years Mr Searle had a variety of jobs which involved manual labour including a spell working as an engine cleaner for Great Western Railways (GWR) at their depot in Truro, Cornwall. Laggers employed by GWR would undertake running repairs on the asbestos lagging that insulated the steam engine boilers. Any areas of lagging that had been compromised would be hacked off and replaced by the laggers. This created substantial asbestos debris beneath the engines. It was Mr Searle’s job to clean up the asbestos debris that the laggers generated. He also worked close by the laggers when they were preparing and applying lagging and in this way he was exposed to substantial quantities of asbestos dust.
Redundancies were announced with the introduction of the Beeching cuts and so Mr Searle left GWR and eventually entered into engineering. He started his own business, Cutlass Mechanical Engineering, in 2006. He obtained substantial contracts working on railway and other infrastructure projects in Devon and Cornwall. It was his plan to move into high quality engineering work for specialist markets. He had intended to work full time to age 70 and to derive some income from the business after retirement. In
Mr Searle was
diagnosed with
mesothelioma 50 years
after his exposure.
Field Fisher Waterhouse were excellent to work
with. Andrew handled my mesothelioma claim in an
efficient and professional manner. I really couldn’t have
asked for any more, the service was excellent. I have
already recommended Andrew to others.
13
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
Probono Success – Victims of Terrorism
Scheme introduced November 2012
Since 2005, Jill Greenfield has campaigned with other lawyers including Lord Brennan QC, Gordon Nardell QC and Yasmin Waljee OBE, along side victims of terrorist atrocities, for the introduction of a scheme to provide financial support for British victims of terrorism abroad.
A victim of terrorist atrocity in the UK would receive financial support through the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme. However, a British subject abroad would not. Such incidents include Sharm-el-Sheik, Mumbai and Kusadasi. The campaign involved cross
jurisdictional analysis and contact with
lawyers around the world in order to demonstrate the unfairness of the position for British citizens. The victims themselves were often suffering dreadful injuries including paralysis, head injury and long term psychiatric issues. Working with a Government team headed by Tessa Jowell the group sought to persuade the British Government that the disparity was unwarranted and out to be addressed. A Private Members Bill was raised in the House of Lords by Lord Brennan QC and received cross party support.
Following that campaign, the Labour Government introduced legislation, 6 April 2010, which confirmed the then Government’s commitment to the introductions of such a Scheme. However, there were grave concerns upon the change of Government and the austerity measures taking place that
this proposal would not be followed through. There were many delays and disappointments for the families but the campaign continued.
The Scheme was introduced in
November 2012 following a hard fought 7 year campaign. The scheme works within the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme and gives parity of treatment to victims of Terrorism in the UK and abroad. It is rare that a new financial scheme of this nature is introduced. What is even more remarkable is that this was not a huge public campaign backed by big organisations, it was a relatively modest but targeted campaign that sought proper justice for British Citizens. This campaign will have long term impact for victims with a potential value of many millions
Bill Ross was 33 years of age, when he was struck and knocked down by a motorcar whilst he was on his way to work. Bill was attempting to cross the road at traffic lights as he was walking to the station. The lights were green in his favour but the driver jumped the lights colliding with Bill and knocking him to the ground.
As a result Bill suffered serious injuries including fractures to the orbital sockets of his right eye, right cheek and nose as well as a head injury. He subsequently underwent surgery by way of nose straightening but made a remarkable recovery returning to his job as a head-hunter within three weeks. The injuries led to permanent facial scarring leading to loss of self esteem and depression.
There were difficulties in tracing the driver who had changed his address and similarly, difficulties in locating his insurers who initially denied all
knowledge but subsequently accepted that the driver was validly insured. The driver underwent a safety driver’s course in lieu of prosecution which is akin to a conviction for careless driving but it was anticipated that his insurers might raise issues of contributory negligence.
Our personal injury expert, Richard Earle sought medical reports from a craniofacial/plastic reconstruction surgeon as well as a psychologist. Pending receipt of those reports suggests the drivers insurers made a Part 36 Offer of £25,000 (this can have adverse costs consequences to a client if they fail to “beat the offer” by securing a higher award of damages at
trial) which could have put Bill at risk on costs had there been a finding of contributory negligence.
The medical reports were received and disclosed along with a counter Part 36 Offer (this can similarly have adverse costs consequences to the insurers along with the risk of higher damages/ interest payable) of £42,500 (net of CRU) which was accepted by the insurers and the case settled on that basis together with payment of Bill’s legal costs.
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
Richard Earle obtains compensation for client with
serious injuries following a road traffic accident
Jill Greenfield has been
campaigning for the
introduction of this
scheme since 2005.
The lights were green in his favour but the driver jumped the lights colliding with Bill and knocking him to the ground.
I was grateful for Richard’s
diligence, attention to detail and
strategic acumen with which he
handled all aspects of my case. I
felt I was in safe hands from the
moment I stepped into the office to
the day I received the settlement.
“
With a reputation
for efficiency, the team
put through an impressive
volume of cases, and push
them relentlessly forward.
Chambers UK
Action for kids
www.actionforkids.org
Works with children and young people with physical and learning disabilities
Advisory Centre for Education
www.ace-ed.org.uk
Advice for parents/carers or children in state-funded schools who are experiencing difficulties
Brainwave
www.brainwave.org.uk
Delivers home-based therapies and exercises to support disabled children
Brain Injury Rehabilitation and Development (BIRD)
www.b-i-r-d.org.uk
Brake - the road safety charity
Tel: 01484 559909 Helpline: 0845 603 8570 Email: helpline@brake.org.uk Website: www.brake.org.uk
British Association for Early Childhood Education
www.early-education.org.uk
Support, advice and information for those concerned with the education and care of young children
Centre for Studies on Inclusive Education (CSIE)
www.csie.org.uk
Supports inclusive education as a human right of every child
Child Brain Injury Trust
www.childbraininjurytrust.org.uk
Disability Law Service
www.dls.org.uk
Headway - the brain injury association
www.headway.org.uk
Headway North London
www.headwaynorthlondon.org
National Association for Special Educational Needs (NASEN)
www.nasen.org.uk
Promotes the education, training and advancement of all those with special needs
National Institute of Conductive Education
www.conductive-education.org.uk
Conductive Education to improve the lives of those with neurological disorders
Scope
www.scope.org.uk/education
Scope offers disabled people education and learning opportunities
Silver Lining Charity
www.thesilverlining.org.uk
The Silverlining offers unique hope by helping clients with brain injury rebuild their lives
Special Needs Kids
www.special-needs-kids.co.uk
Special Needs Family Fun
www.family-friendly-fun.com
Support for the family with special needs
Spinal Injuries Association
www.spinal.co.uk
The Spinal Injuries Association is the leading national charity for spinal cord injured people
The March Foundation
www.marchfoundation.co.uk
Supports children with special educational needs to reach their full potential
The United Kingdom of Acquired Brain Injury Forum
www.ukabif.org.uk
Whizz-Kidz
www.whizz-kidz.org.uk
Mobility equipment, opportunities to meet and training for disabled children
Richard Earle
Senior Associate richard.earle@ffw.com 020 7861 4041
Richard specialises in serious injury claims and is a member of Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA) and the Law Society’s Clinical Negligence (and Personal Injury) Panels.
www.ffw.com/personalinjury Freephone 0800 358 3848
15
Caring for our clients Commitment to our cases Cutting edge expertise
Meet the team
Andrew Morgan
Partner
andrew.morgan@ffw.com 020 7861 4036
Andrew has specialised in cases involving industrial diseases, including asbestos diseases, since 1993. He is a past Coordinator of the Occupational Health Group of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) and is an APIL Fellow. He advises the Parliamentary Sub-Committee on Asbestos. Andrew has expertise in accident at work cases and professional negligence claims.
Mark Bowman
Partner
mark.bowman@ffw.com 020 7861 4043
Mark pursues serious injury cases on behalf of victims of accidents and medical negligence. A member of the Law Society Clinical Negligence Panel, Mark is also a senior litigator at the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL). Mark has a particular interest in cases involving cyclists.
Caroline Pinfold Partner
caroline.pinfold@ffw.com 020 7861 4022
Caroline has specialised in asbestos disease claims for over 25 years. She is a Trustee of the East London Mesothelioma Support Group ( ELMS). She is a member of Association of Personal Injury Lawyers and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Medicine. Chambers, a leading legal directory states she is “incredibly hard working, has an eye for detail and fights very hard for her clients”.
Dushal Mehta
Associate dushal.mehta@ffw.com 020 7861 4033
Dushal has specialised in asbestos disease cases, and particularly mesothelioma claims, for a number of years. He joined the firm in 2009 and is a member of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers. He regularly concludes successful claims for clients within a number of months.
Jennifer Bradley
Solicitor
jennifer.bradley@ffw.com 020 7861 4530
Jenny qualified into our personal injury and medical negligence department having trained at the firm. Jenny has a varied caseload and also assists Jill Greenfield with complex and high value cases. Jenny is a keen cyclist both on the road and track and, as such, has a keen interest in cycling claims and campaigning to make London’s roads a safer place.
Paul McNeil
Partner paul.mcneil@ffw.com 020 7861 4019
Paul heads the personal injury and medical negligence department and has specialised in serious injury claims for over 25 years. Paul has acted on behalf of victims involved in the Clapham, South Hall, Ladbroke Grove and Potters Bar rail accidents.
Peter Williams
Partner
peter.williams@ffw.com 020 7861 4825
Peter has specialised in asbestos cases, accident at work and road traffic accident claims for nearly 20 years. He gives annual talks to solicitors on asbestos claims for Central Law Training. He is a member of the Law Society Personal Injury Panel.
Jill Greenfield
Partner
jill.greenfield@ffw.com 020 7861 4557
Jill has 20 years’ experience acting for claimants and is head of our brain injury and spinal injury unit. Jill is recognised by Headway (the brain injury association), SIA (Spinal Injuries Association) and various legal directories as a leading lawyer and specialist in dealing with such claims. Jill heads up the Catastrophic Injury Team within the department and is a member of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL).
www.ffw.com/personalinjury
35 Vine Street, London, EC3N 2PX
Ibex House, The Minories, London, EC3N 1HP
Postal address: PO Box 732, London, EC3N 2AA Email: personalinjury@ffw.com
Freephone 0800 358 3848
Caring f
or our clients
Commitment t
o our cases
Cutting edg
e e
xper
tise