• No results found

Abb REVIEW Iec 61850 72dpi

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Abb REVIEW Iec 61850 72dpi"

Copied!
64
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

IEC

IEC

6185

6185

0:

0:

The

The

new

new

approach

approach

7

7

Pr

Product

oduct

s

s for

for the

the standar

standard

d

16

16

V

V

erification

erification

and

and

validation

validation

23

23

Case

Case stud

stud

ies

ies of I

of I

E

EC

C 6185

6185

0

0

38

38

Special Report

Special Report

IEC 61850

IEC 61850

review

review

A

A

B

B

B

B

The corporate

The corporate

technical journal

technical journal

(2)

2

2 ABB review special reportABB review special report

Communication is more than

Communication is more than

ex-changing data; it means globally

changing data; it means globally

understandable infor

understandable information based mation based onon

syntax and semantic. This is behind

syntax and semantic. This is behind

IEC 61850, the topic of this issue of

IEC 61850, the topic of this issue of

ABB Review 

ABB Review Special ReportSpecial Report..

Electric energy is the backbone of

Electric energy is the backbone of

our global society. Its reliable

our global society. Its reliable

sup-ply from conventional and

ply from conventional and

renew-able sources via complex networks

able sources via complex networks

requires seamless control that is only

requires seamless control that is only

possible with the help of a standard

possible with the help of a standard

provi

providing a ding a highhigh-level -level and compre-and

compre-hensive description of the information

hensive description of the information

exchanged. ABB serves the power

exchanged. ABB serves the power

system with substations as well as

system with substations as well as

utility automation solutions. Learn

utility automation solutions. Learn

more about IEC 61850 and ABB’s

more about IEC 61850 and ABB’s

commitment from the onset both to

commitment from the onset both to

developing the standard and

developing the standard and

imple-menting it in products and system

menting it in products and system

solutions.

(3)

Communication is more than

Communication is more than

ex-changing data; it means globally

changing data; it means globally

understandable infor

understandable information based mation based onon

syntax and semantic. This is behind

syntax and semantic. This is behind

IEC 61850, the topic of this issue of

IEC 61850, the topic of this issue of

ABB Review 

ABB Review Special ReportSpecial Report..

Electric energy is the backbone of

Electric energy is the backbone of

our global society. Its reliable

our global society. Its reliable

sup-ply from conventional and

ply from conventional and

renew-able sources via complex networks

able sources via complex networks

requires seamless control that is only

requires seamless control that is only

possible with the help of a standard

possible with the help of a standard

provi

providing a ding a highhigh-level -level and compre-and

compre-hensive description of the information

hensive description of the information

exchanged. ABB serves the power

exchanged. ABB serves the power

system with substations as well as

system with substations as well as

utility automation solutions. Learn

utility automation solutions. Learn

more about IEC 61850 and ABB’s

more about IEC 61850 and ABB’s

commitment from the onset both to

commitment from the onset both to

developing the standard and

developing the standard and

imple-menting it in products and system

menting it in products and system

solutions.

(4)

Contents

Contents

7 7 13 13 16 16 23 23 29 29 33 33 38 38 42 42 47 47 53 53 57 57 62 62

The concept of IEC 61850

The concept of IEC 61850

A new approach for communication in substation

A new approach for communication in substation

automation and beyond

automation and beyond

Common denominator

Common denominator

Common components have helped ABB adopt the

Common components have helped ABB adopt the

IEC 61850 substation communication standard in

IEC 61850 substation communication standard in

record time

record time

Pushing the limits

Pushing the limits

ABB product development based on the IEC 61850

ABB product development based on the IEC 61850

standard

standard

Verified and validated

Verified and validated

ABB has its own system verification and validation

ABB has its own system verification and validation

center

center

A testing environment

A testing environment

ABB’s comprehensive suite of software testing

ABB’s comprehensive suite of software testing andand

commissioning tools for substation automation systems

commissioning tools for substation automation systems

Next

Next generation substationgeneration substationss

Impact of the process bus

Impact of the process bus

IEC 61850 at work

IEC 61850 at work

Five case studies

Five case studies

When two become one

When two become one

IEC 61850 in combination with ABB’s award-winning

IEC 61850 in combination with ABB’s award-winning

Extended Automation System 800xA is opening doors to

Extended Automation System 800xA is opening doors to

new and

new and cost-cost-effeffective solutionsective solutions

IEC 61850 Edition 2

IEC 61850 Edition 2

From substation automation to power utility automation

From substation automation to power utility automation

Reliable netw

Reliable networkinorkingg

Impact of modern communication technology on system

Impact of modern communication technology on system

reliability

reliability

Seamless redundancy

Seamless redundancy

Bumpless Ethernet redundancy for substations with

Bumpless Ethernet redundancy for substations with

IEC 61850

IEC 61850

IEC 6185

IEC 61850 – a success around the world0 – a success around the world

Substation automation systems pave the way to a

Substation automation systems pave the way to a

smarter grid

smarter grid

The way forward

The way forward

Project

Project

experience

experience

Enabling the

Enabling the

smart grid

smart grid

Smarter

Smarter

substations

substations

I

I

nnovat

nnovat

ion and

ion and

development

development

Background

Background

3 3 Contents Contents

(5)

Claes Rytoft Head of Technology Power Systems division Peter Leupp

Head of Power Systems division Member ABB Group

Executive Committee

control the devices, and how conformity to the standard should be tested.

Following its introduction, the implementation of IEC 61850 has advanced at a remarkable pace. Perhaps never before has an industrial standard been accepted with such speed. Within two years of its release, a majority of the market was demanding IEC 61850 as the preferred communication protocol.

It is increasingly being used for the int egration of electrical equipment into distributed control systems in process industries. The fact that new application areas, such as hydro and wind power are being added is yet another indication of its success.

The bottom line is about how technology can lower cost s, improve reliability and enhance efficiency. IEC 61850 has a proven t rack record of deliverable benefits to both small and large utilities. Communication infrastruc-ture costs money to install, configure and maintain. But the savings that IEC 61850 delivers by way of substation design, installa-tion, commissioning, and operation combined with new capabilities that are not practical or cost effective using legacy approaches, makes it a worthwhile investment.

This special edition ofABB Review looks at

this truly global and unifying standard from different angles and relates many of our experiences based on the vast installed base we have built during the years. We shall also attempt to take a peek into some possible future developments in this area.

We hope you enjoy reading this dedicat ed special issue.

Peter Leupp Claes Rytoft Dear Re ader,

Substations are key components of the pow er grid, facilitating t he efficient transmission and distribution of electricity. They play a vital role in terms of monitoring and c ontrolling pow er flows and provide the interconnection be-tween generating facilities, transmission and distribution networks and end consumers. Substation automation systems make their control and monitoring possible in real time and help maximize availability, efficiency, reliability, safety and data integration. For decades, the power sector was geo-graphically split between two major standards  – IEC (International Electrotechnical

Commis-sion) and ANSI (American National Standards Institute). This often p roved a deterrent to the development of a global technology offering.

IEC 61850 broke this deadlock. Since its publication in 2004, it has been embraced by bot h the IEC and ANSI communities. The new standard was designed to:

− Provide a single protocol for a complete substation

− Implement a common format to describe the substation and facilitate object model-ing of data required in the substation − Define the basic services required to

transfer data using different communication protocols

− Allow for interoperability between products from different vendors

The standardization work commenced in the mid 1990s and continued for almost a

decade, involving more than 60 experts from utility and technology providers across the globe. ABB was very much a part of this process and some of the contributors are represented in this report.

IEC 61850 provides a standardized frame-work for substation integration that specifies the communications requirements, the functional characteristics, the structure of data in devices, the naming conventions for the data, how applications interact and

Editorial

IEC 61850 – A unifying global

communication standard

(6)

5 Editorial

(7)
(8)

7 The concept of IEC 61850

The concept

of IEC 61850

KLAUS-PETER BRAND, WOLFGANG WIMMER –The ability to cope with the natural migration of technology combined with the need for interoper-ability are just some of the reasons the IEC 61850, an international standard that defines communication in and between electrical substation auto-mation systems was developed. Using it’s object-oriented hierarchical data model approach with high-level standardized semantics, IEC 61850 enables the abstract definition of data items and services to not only specify what data or information needs to be exchanged but also the mechanics of how it is to be exchanged using mainstream communication and

networking (mainly Ethernet) technolo-gies. In addition, the cost benefits of implementing IEC 61850 can already be seen in the system design phase and experienced right through to the commissioning and operating phases. All of these factors help to explain the eagerness and speed with which the first edition of the standard has been accepted around the globe.

A new approach for communication in

substation automation and beyond

S

ubstation automation (SA) is commonly used to control, protect and monitor a substa-tion [1]. However, over the

years advances in electronics, informa-tion and communicainforma-tions technology have brought about sweeping changes in the way substat ions are operated. The advent of software-based substation au-tomation systems (hereafter referred to as SA systems) connected b y serial links rather then rigid parallel copper wiring gradually became

the norm rather than the exception. Though successful and widely accept-ed, these systems were based on ei-ther the manufac-turers’ own propri-etary communica-tion solucommunica-tions or the defined use of com-munication

stan-dards from other application domains, such as DNP3 or IEC 60870-5-104. These solutions made interoperability between devices from d ifferent supp liers, and sometimes even between different versions of devices from the same sup-plier, an engineering nightmare which could only be mitigated by expensive protocol conversion or re-engineering.

The connection of the SA system with the switchgear and instrument trans-formers was still left to analog standards such as 1 A and 3 A for current trans-formers, and 110 V and 2 20 V for voltage transformers and contact circuits for switchgear operations.

It took over 20 years before global forc-es, such as international suppliers and transnational utilities raised their voices to request a solution, in the form of a

substation communication standard, to overcome the interoperability prob-lem➔1. While interoperability was a

ma- jor concern, it wasn’t the only one. Only too aware of the dizzying pace at which technologies change, the authors of this new standard, know n as IEC 61850, also set about finding a way to create a “future -proof” standard that would be immune

Using it’s object-oriented

hier-archical data model approach

with high-level standardized

semantics, IEC 61850 enables

the abstract definition of data

items and services.

(9)

various technologies employed in a

various technologies employed in a

typi-cal substation. For example,

cal substation. For example,

fast-chang-ing mainstream communication

ing mainstream communication

technol-ogy will always need to serve the

ogy will always need to serve the

slower-changing requirements of

slower-changing requirements of

protec-tion and substaprotec-tion automaprotec-tion.

tion and substation automation.

To facilitate the use of the standard for

To facilitate the use of the standard for

users, the identification of all transmitted

users, the identification of all transmitted

data should not be based on a limited

data should not be based on a limited

number scheme derived from contact

number scheme derived from contact

terminal rows, but rather on the

terminal rows, but rather on the

object-oriented grouping of data and a naming

oriented grouping of data and a naming

structure that uses standardized

structure that uses standardized

acro-nyms understandable to any substation

nyms understandable to any substation

engineer. In addition, configuration and

engineer. In addition, configuration and

engineering tools should be used to

engineering tools should be used to

cre-ate systems with minimum effort and

ate systems with minimum effort and

with a minimum

with a minimum risk of failure.risk of failure.

The basic approach of IEC 61850

The basic approach of IEC 61850

T

To reach o reach long-tlong-term interoperabilityerm interoperability, ie, , ie, toto

cope with the different time scales of

cope with the different time scales of

function evolution in the domain

function evolution in the domain

substa-tion and with changing communicasubsta-tion

tion and with changing communication

technology, the approach taken in the

technology, the approach taken in the

IEC 61850 standard separates the

IEC 61850 standard separates the

do-main related model for both data and

main related model for both data and

communication services from the

communication services from the

proto-cols, ie, the ISO/OSI seven-layer stack

cols, ie, the ISO/OSI seven-layer stack

used to code and decode information

used to code and decode information

into bit strings for communication over a

into bit strings for communication over a

serial link. This approach not only

serial link. This approach not only

ac-commodates state-of-the-art

commodates state-of-the-art

communi-cation technology, but it also safeguards

cation technology, but it also safeguards

investments in applications and

investments in applications and

engi-neering (based on the object and

neering (based on the object and

com-and devices would need to be stcom-andard-

and devices would need to be standard-

standard-ized, thus blocking any technical

ized, thus blocking any technical

evolu-tion and funcevolu-tional competievolu-tion.

tion and functional competition.

Never-theless it must be possible to exchange

theless it must be possible to exchange

faulty IEDs within the lifetime of the

faulty IEDs within the lifetime of the

SA system. Using IEDs that are

SA system. Using IEDs that are

com-pliant with the same standard in terms

pliant with the same standard in terms

of interoperability will facilitate easy

of interoperability will facilitate easy

exchangeability.

exchangeability. Free architecture Free architecture

For a standard to be termed “global,” it

For a standard to be termed “global,” it

must support the operation philosophy

must support the operation philosophy

of utilities around the world. It has to

of utilities around the world. It has to

support an arbitrary allocation of

support an arbitrary allocation of

func-tions to devices and should therefore be

tions to devices and should therefore be

capable of supporting centralized and

capable of supporting centralized and

decentralized system architectures.

decentralized system architectures. Long-term stability

Long-term stability

Given that the lifetime of a substation

Given that the lifetime of a substation

(primary equipment) is between 40 and

(primary equipment) is between 40 and

60 years, it is anticipated that

60 years, it is anticipated that

compo-nents of the SA system have to be

nents of the SA system have to be

ex-changed, on average, around two to

changed, on average, around two to

three times during this period; some

three times during this period; some

components may need replacements on

components may need replacements on

a more regular basis. Naturally over time

a more regular basis. Naturally over time

the substation will have to cope with the

the substation will have to cope with the

integration of new components from the

integration of new components from the

same or new suppliers, or it may need to

same or new suppliers, or it may need to

be extended. The point is that

be extended. The point is that

irrespec-tive of the changes, interoperability must

tive of the changes, interoperability must

be maintained indefinitely, or to be more

be maintained indefinitely, or to be more

specific, the standard has to be

specific, the standard has to be

future-proof. This requirement not only applies

proof. This requirement not only applies

to substation devices, but also to the

to substation devices, but also to the

Swith Swith yard yard GIS GIS or or AIS AIS Relay Relay room room in GIS in GIS Relay Relay house house in AIS in AIS Operating Operating room room Legacy SA Legacy SA H Haarrddwwiirreed d SSAA IIEEC C 661188550 0 bbaasseed d SSAA LLooccaattiioonn 1

1 Substation automatSubstation automation ion (SA) (SA) architectarchitecture frure from hardwires om hardwires over proprietary protocolsover proprietary protocols to IEC 61850 to IEC 61850 SCADA-distribution, metering SCADA-distribution, metering Copper cables Copper cables Copper cables

Copper cables Copper cablesCopper cables Sensors &Sensors &actuatorsactuators

Bay cubicle Bay cubicle BBaay y ccuubbiiccllee BBaay y ccuubbiiccllee to other bays to other bays to other bays to other bays 1965 1965 1985 1985 2005 2005 YearYear G GIISS GGIISS GISGIS

* The process bus is not a must in IEC 61850 but only an option

* The process bus is not a must in IEC 61850 but only an option

MMI, Control board

MMI, Control board

Copper

Copper

cables

cables

Station bus and

Station bus and

Process bus* Process bus* according to IEC 61850 according to IEC 61850 Proprietary Proprietary Station bus Station bus Serial communication Serial communication (Fiber optics) (Fiber optics) Serial communication Serial communication (Fiber optics) (Fiber optics) Gateway Gateway Gateway Gateway HMI HMI HMI HMI

to any future technological

to any future technological

develop-ments.

ments.

As the IE

As the IEC 61850 C 61850 standard evolved, oth-standard evolved,

oth-er features, such as the definition of two

er features, such as the definition of two

time-critical services – the fast

time-critical services – the fast

transmis-sion of trip-type signals and sampled

sion of trip-type signals and sampled

analog current and

analog current and voltage values – werevoltage values – were

added. These time-critical services

added. These time-critical services

en-able the extension of the serial links to be

able the extension of the serial links to be

used between any intelligent electronic

used between any intelligent electronic

device (IED) and the electronic interfaces

device (IED) and the electronic interfaces

near the switchyard equipment.

near the switchyard equipment. DemaDemand-

nd-ing market requirements, such as the

ing market requirements, such as the

shortening of transfer times down to

shortening of transfer times down to

3

3 ms ms and and time time synchronization in synchronization in thethe

order of 1 µs had also to be considered.

order of 1 µs had also to be considered.

Perhaps the cornerstone of the standard

Perhaps the cornerstone of the standard

is the innovative extensible markup

is the innovative extensible markup

lan-guage or X

guage or XML-bML-based substation coased substation configu-

nfigu-ration description language (SCL). SCL

ration description language (SCL). SCL

formally describes the configuration of

formally describes the configuration of

IEDs in terms of functionality (eg, circuit

IEDs in terms of functionality (eg, circuit

breaker control, measurements and

breaker control, measurements and

sta-tus values) communication addresses

tus values) communication addresses

and services (eg, reporting). It also

and services (eg, reporting). It also

de-scribes the switchyard layout and its

scribes the switchyard layout and its

re-lation to the functions implemented in

lation to the functions implemented in

the

the IEDIEDs.s.

The emergence of a new standard

The emergence of a new standard

When the authors of the IEC 61850

When the authors of the IEC 61850

stan-dard first sat together, they identified a

dard first sat together, they identified a

list of market requirements that would

list of market requirements that would

in-fluence the form the new standard would

fluence the form the new standard would

take. The most important ones were

take. The most important ones were

in-teroperability

teroperability, free architect, free architecture and long-ure and

long-term

term stabilitystability.. Interoperability Interoperability

T

To begin with, o begin with, the standard must bthe standard must be ablee able

to support all functions in its application

to support all functions in its application

domain substat

domain substation. Therion. Therefore, in additionefore, in addition

to protection, automation, control and

to protection, automation, control and

monitoring functions, many service

monitoring functions, many service

func-tions, such as time synchronization, self

tions, such as time synchronization, self

supervision and version handling have

supervision and version handling have

also to be supported. These functions

also to be supported. These functions

are ex

are executed becuted by software implemented iny software implemented in

the IEDs. Interoperability in the SA

the IEDs. Interoperability in the SA

sys-tem means that IEDs from different

tem means that IEDs from different

sup-pliers or different versions from the same

pliers or different versions from the same

supplier must be able to exchange and

supplier must be able to exchange and

use information in real time without any

use information in real time without any

protoc

protocol converters aol converters and without tnd without the nehe needed

for human interpretation.

for human interpretation.

It is important to distinguish

It is important to distinguish

interopera-bility from interchangeainteropera-bility. If IEDs were

bility from interchangeability. If IEDs were

also to be interchangeable, the functions

also to be interchangeable, the functions

Eve

Event nt recordingrecording

Protection

(10)

9 9 The concept of IEC 61850 The concept of IEC 61850

physical device itself are dealt with b

physical device itself are dealt with by any an

LN class named

LN class named LPHD.LPHD.

Only if a LN class for some function is

Only if a LN class for some function is

missing it may be substituted by generic

missing it may be substituted by generic

LN classes that have restricted semantic

LN classes that have restricted semantic

meaning. More demanding, however, is

meaning. More demanding, however, is

the extension of LNs and data according

the extension of LNs and data according

to the strict and restrictive extension

to the strict and restrictive extension

rules of the standard, including name

rules of the standard, including name

spaces as unambiguous references to

spaces as unambiguous references to

semantic meaning. These rules preserve

semantic meaning. These rules preserve

interoperability, even in cases where

interoperability, even in cases where

ex-tensions are required.

tensions are required.

For the functional identification of each

For the functional identification of each

data in the context of the switchyard, a

data in the context of the switchyard, a

hierarchical plant designation system

hierarchical plant designation system

shall be used for the designation of

shall be used for the designation of

sub-station objects and functions preferably

station objects and functions preferably

according to IEC 61346

according to IEC 61346 [6][6]..

The services of the data model

The services of the data model

Interoperabil

Interoperability requires tity requires the standhe standardizaardiza-

-tion of not only the data objects but also

tion of not only the data objects but also

the access t

the access to them. Thereforeo them. Therefore, standard-,

standard-ized abstract services also belong to

ized abstract services also belong to

IEC 61850. The most common ones

IEC 61850. The most common ones

include:

include:

 –

 – ReaRead: reading data such as the valued: reading data such as the value

of an attribute

of an attribute

 –

 – Write: for example writing the value ofWrite: for example writing the value of

a configuration attribute

a configuration attribute

 –

 – Control: controlling switching devicesControl: controlling switching devices

and other controllable objects using

and other controllable objects using

standardized methods such as “select

standardized methods such as “select

before operate” or “direct operate”

before operate” or “direct operate”

 –

 – Reporting: for example, eveReporting: for example, event drivennt driven

reporting after

reporting after value changesvalue changes

 –

 – Logging: the local storage of Logging: the local storage of time-

time-stamped events or other historical data

stamped events or other historical data

 –

 – Get directory: in other words, to readGet directory: in other words, to read

out the data model (important part of

out the data model (important part of

self-description)

self-description)

munication service model). Therefore,

munication service model). Therefore,

the standard is future-proof. The

the standard is future-proof. The

map-ping of the data model to the

ping of the data model to the

communi-cation stack is also standardized in

cation stack is also standardized in

IEC 61850 to ensure interoperable

IEC 61850 to ensure interoperable

com-munication

munication➔➔2.2.

The object-oriented data model

The object-oriented data model

The basic data model structure defined

The basic data model structure defined

in the IEC 61850 standard is application

in the IEC 61850 standard is application

independent. However, depending on

independent. However, depending on

the scope of the standard, the object

the scope of the standard, the object

model classes, as issued in edition 1 of

model classes, as issued in edition 1 of

the standard

the standard➔➔33 [2][2], are related to the, are related to the

domain substation. Object models for

domain substation. Object models for

wind power

wind power [3][3], hydro power, hydro power [4][4] and dis-and

dis-tributed

tributed energy reenergy resourcessources[5][5]were addedwere added

at a later date. All application functions,

at a later date. All application functions,

including the data interfaces to the

including the data interfaces to the

pri-mary equipment, are broken down into

mary equipment, are broken down into

the smallest feasible pieces, which may

the smallest feasible pieces, which may

communicate with each other and, more

communicate with each other and, more

importantly, may be implemented

importantly, may be implemented

sepa-rately in dedicated IEDs. In IEC 61850,

rately in dedicated IEDs. In IEC 61850,

these basic objects are called logical

these basic objects are called logical

nodes (LNs). The class name of the LN

nodes (LNs). The class name of the LN

refers to the function the data objects

refers to the function the data objects

belong to. The data objects contained in

belong to. The data objects contained in

a LN may be mandatory

a LN may be mandatory, opt, optional or con-ional or

con-ditional. The data objects themselves

ditional. The data objects themselves

contain attributes

contain attributes11, which may be seen, which may be seen

as values or detailed properties of the

as values or detailed properties of the

data object

data objects. This hies. This hierarchical data mod-rarchical data

mod-el is illustrated in

el is illustrated in ➔➔4.4.

Since the class names of LNs and

Since the class names of LNs and the fullthe full

names of data objects and attributes are

names of data objects and attributes are

standardized, they formally provide the

standardized, they formally provide the

semantics of

semantics of all exchanged values withinall exchanged values within

the scope of IEC 61850. LNs may be

the scope of IEC 61850. LNs may be

grouped into logical devices (LDs) with

grouped into logical devices (LDs) with

non-st

non-standardized names, and these LDsandardized names, and these LDs

are implemented in servers residing in

are implemented in servers residing in

IEDs. The common properties of the

IEDs. The common properties of the

Communica

Communication networks tion networks and systemsand systems

in substations

in substations

Part

Part 1: 1: IntroductIntroduction ion and and overviewoverview

Part

Part 2: 2: GlossaryGlossary

Part

Part 3: 3: General General requirementsrequirements

Part

Part 4: 4: System System and and project project managementmanagement

Part

Part 5: 5: CommunicatioCommunication n requirements requirements forfor

functions and device models

functions and device models

Part

Part 6: 6: Configuration Configuration descriptdescription ion languagelanguage

for communication in electrical

for communication in electrical

substations related IEDs

substations related IEDs

Part

Part 7-1: 7-1: Principles Principles and modelsand models

Part

Part 7-2: 7-2: Abstract communiAbstract communicationcation

service interface

service interface

Part

Part 7-3: 7-3: Common data Common data classesclasses

Part 7-4:

Part 7-4: CompatibCompatible le logical node (logical node (LN)LN)

classes and data classes

classes and data classes

Part 8-1:

Part 8-1: Mapping to MMS Mapping to MMS and toand to

ISO/IEC 8802-3

ISO/IEC 8802-3

Part 9-1:

Part 9-1: Sampled valueSampled values over s over serialserial

unidirectional multidrop

unidirectional multidrop

point-to-point link

point-to-point link

Part 9-2:

Part 9-2: Sampled valueSampled values over s over ISO ISO 8802-8802-33

Part

Part 10: 10: Conformance Conformance testingtesting

3

3 The parts The parts of the sof the standard IEC 61850tandard IEC 61850 Edition 1

Edition 1 2

2 The splThe split between data model and comit between data model and communicatimunication stackon stack

Data Data model model ISO/OSI ISO/OSI stack stack Domain substation: Domain substation:

What data have to be

What data have to be

communicated? communicated? Communication Communication technology: technology:

How are the data

How are the data

communicated? communicated? Slow Slow changes changes Fast Fast changes changes Definition Definition

Data and services according

Data and services according

to the domain substation

to the domain substation

Mapping

Mapping

Data model to the

Data model to the

communication stack

communication stack

Selection

Selection

ISO/OSI stack from the

ISO/OSI stack from the

mainstream mainstream SPLIT! SPLIT!      C      C    o    o     m     m     m     m     u     u     n     n      i

     i    c    c    a    a

     t

     t

     i

     i    o    o    n    n

Al

Al

l app

l app

li

li

cat

cat

ion

ion

functions, including

functions, including

the data interfaces

the data interfaces

to the primary

to the primary

equipment, are

equipment, are

broken down into

broken down into

the smallest

the smallest

fea-sible pieces, which

sible pieces, which

may communicate

may communicate

with each other

with each other

and be

and be

implement-ed separately in

ed separately in

dedicated IEDs.

dedicated IEDs.

(11)

firmation”), which terminates the control

firmation”), which terminates the control

service.

service.

Performance

Performance requirrequirementsements

The transfer time of messages between

The transfer time of messages between

the sending application (eg, protection

the sending application (eg, protection

function issuing the trip) and the

function issuing the trip) and the

receiv-ing application (breaker function

ing application (breaker function

per-forming the breaker operation) is

forming the breaker operation) is

deter-mined by the requirements of functions

mined by the requirements of functions

that depend on this message transfer.

that depend on this message transfer.

As a protection trip is time critical, with

As a protection trip is time critical, with

a worst

a worst case taking around 2case taking around 20 0 ms, it ms, it isis

allocated to the most demanding

allocated to the most demanding

trans-fer require

fer requirement class, wment class, which means 3 ms.hich means 3 ms.

The transfer of samples using the SV

The transfer of samples using the SV

service is also assigned to this

service is also assigned to this

require-ment class to avoid, for example, delays

ment class to avoid, for example, delays

in fault detection by protection. The

in fault detection by protection. The

re-quirements have to be fulfilled not only

quirements have to be fulfilled not only

by the IEDs but also by the SA system

by the IEDs but also by the SA system

design. The transfer time of a GOOSE

design. The transfer time of a GOOSE

message over a serial link is compared

message over a serial link is compared

in

in ➔➔66 andand ➔➔77 with the response time ofwith the response time of

a hardwired contact circuit.

a hardwired contact circuit.

To properly analyze the sequence of

To properly analyze the sequence of

events in the system and for post-event

events in the system and for post-event

fault analysis, the events need a time

fault analysis, the events need a time

stamp with an accuracy against real time

stamp with an accuracy against real time

of 1

of 1 ms; ms; this incidthis incidentally is bettentally is better thaner than

any contact change. However, time

any contact change. However, time

syn-chronization for current and voltage

chronization for current and voltage

samples, which are needed for

samples, which are needed for

differen-tial or distance protection or global

tial or distance protection or global

pha-sor comparison, requires an accuracy of

sor comparison, requires an accuracy of

the ord

the order of er of 1 1 µs! The 1 ms accuracy µs! The 1 ms accuracy lev-

lev-el is achieved using the simple network

el is achieved using the simple network

time protocol (SNTP) directly over a

time protocol (SNTP) directly over a

se-rial communication link, while one pulse

rial communication link, while one pulse

per second

per second ((pps) over a separate wire orpps) over a separate wire or

fiber achieves the 1 µs

fiber achieves the 1 µs time synchroniza-time

synchroniza-tion. In the future, the IEEE 1588

tion. In the future, the IEEE 1588

stan- –

 – FilFile transfer: for configuration,e transfer: for configuration,

disturbance recording or historical

disturbance recording or historical

data

data

 –

 – GOOSEGOOSE: GOOSE : GOOSE is the acronym fois the acronym forr

generic object oriented system event

generic object oriented system event

and is a service used for the speedy

and is a service used for the speedy

transmission of time critical

transmission of time critical

informa-tion like status changes, blockings,

tion like status changes, blockings,

releases or trips between IEDs

releases or trips between IEDs

 –

 – Sampled value (SVSampled value (SV): the SV ): the SV serviceservice

quickly t

quickly transmits a synchronizedransmits a synchronized

stream of current and voltage

stream of current and voltage

sam-ples for voltages and currents

ples for voltages and currents

The control service implementing the

The control service implementing the

“select before operate with enhanced

“select before operate with enhanced

security” mode is illustrated in

security” mode is illustrated in➔➔55 inin

the context of a switch operation: The

the context of a switch operation: The

SELECT command is issued at the

SELECT command is issued at the

operator’s HMI and communicated to the

operator’s HMI and communicated to the

bay control unit represented by the LN

bay control unit represented by the LN

CSWI. Depending on the system

CSWI. Depending on the system

archi-tecture the SELECT command is

tecture the SELECT command is

con-firmed either by the bay controller or the

firmed either by the bay controller or the

circuit-circuit-breaker IEbreaker IED, which D, which is representedis represented

by the LN XCBR. When the operator

by the LN XCBR. When the operator

re-ceives a positive acknowledgement (ie,

ceives a positive acknowledgement (ie,

“Selected”) from the CSWI, he then

“Selected”) from the CSWI, he then

is-sues an OPERATE command. Once

sues an OPERATE command. Once

per-mission has been granted, an operation

mission has been granted, an operation

request is sent via the bay controller to

request is sent via the bay controller to

the circuit breaker (XCBR). The

the circuit breaker (XCBR). The

execu-tion of the command request is positively

tion of the command request is positively

acknowledged using the message

acknowledged using the message

“Op-erated.” Additional feedback is provided

erated.” Additional feedback is provided

using the reporting service, which is

using the reporting service, which is

initi-ated by the start of the circuit-breaker

ated by the start of the circuit-breaker

contact movement (“Started”) and when

contact movement (“Started”) and when

the end position is reached (“New

the end position is reached (“New

posi-tion”). In cases where a command

tion”). In cases where a command

ser-vice with enhanced security is chosen,

vice with enhanced security is chosen,

the end result is confirmed by the

the end result is confirmed by the

com-mand termination message (“Cmd

mand termination message (“Cmd con-5

5 An An illustration of illustration of the control the control serviceservice

Control circuit Control circuit for for commands commands Indication Indication circuit circuit for breaker for breaker position position H HMMII CCSSWWII Select Select Selected Selected Operate Operate Operated Operated Started Started New position New position Cmd Cmd termination termination XCBR XCBR CircuitCircuit breaker breaker    I    I  n  n    d    d    i

   i  c  c  a  a

   t

   t

   i

   i  o  o  n  n

   C    C  o  o   m   m   m   m   a   a   n   n    d    d   s   s   e   e   q   q   u   u   e   e   n   n   c   c   e   e Enhanced security Enhanced security    S    S  e  e    l    l  e  e  c  c    t    t  e  e    d    d   s   s    t    t  a  a    t    t  e  e 4

4 HierarchHierarchical ical data modeldata model

Implementation Implementation Grouping Grouping Data Data Value Value Properties Properties

Breaker IED (BIED)

Breaker IED (BIED) Names notNames not

standardized standardized Names Names standardized standardized Breaker controller Breaker controller XCBR (circuit breaker) XCBR (circuit breaker) Pos (position) Pos (position)

StVal (status value)

StVal (status value)

Intermediate-state/off/on/bad-state Intermediate-state/off/on/bad-state q (quality) q (quality) good/invalid/reserved/questionable good/invalid/reserved/questionable t (time stamp) t (time stamp) time of change time of change Physical d

Physical device (IED)evice (IED)

defined as Server defined as Server Logical device Logical device (LD)(LD) Logical node (LN) Logical node (LN) Data (Object) Data (Object) Attribute Attribute Attribute Attribute Attribute Attribute

GOOSE is the

GOOSE is the

acronym for generic

acronym for generic

object oriented

object oriented

system event and

system event and

is a service used

is a service used

for the speedy

for the speedy

transmissi

transmissi

on

on

of

of

time critical

time critical

infor-mation like status

mation like status

change

change

s, b

s, b

lock-

lock-ings, releases or

ings, releases or

trips between IEDs.

(12)

11 The concept of IEC 61850

The station bus may be configured in a ring topology with ring redundancy, a redundant star for IEDs with dual port redundancy or any solutions which fulfill

the requested p erformance and reliability requirements. The proc ess bus may also adopt a ring or even a star topology, but at the very least one or more point-to-point connections.

SCL supported engineering

In order to process data received from IEDs, the receiving IED needs to know how this data has been sent; how it has been coded; what it means in the con-text of the switchyard; and the function-ality of the sender. To be able to transfer this information from one tool to another in a standardized way, the XML-based SCL language has been defined.

Edition 2 [8] of the standard scheduled for publication in 2010 will define proto-cols for the connection of IEDs with two ports to two redundant communica-tion systems or the formacommunica-tion of a ring with redundant traffic in both ring direc-tions3.

The station and process buses

The station bus connects the IEDs for protection, control and monitoring (ie, bay units) with station level devices (ie, the station computer with HMI and the gateway to the network communication center (NCC)) using whatever services are required by the applications. The process bus connects the bay units with the switchyard devices, and the munication of status information, com-mands and trips is the same as for the station bus➔9.

However, getting synchronized sam-ples of current and voltage to the rele-vant protection IEDs using the SV ser-vice is quite chal-lenging.

The conversion of

proprietary signals from nonconventional instrument transformers for current and voltage or of t he analog values from con-ventional instrument transformers to IEC 61850 telegrams is done using an IED called a merging unit (MU). An MU merges the 3-phase currents and volt-ages, including the zero-components of one bay high-precision time-synchro-nized by definition. The process bus functionality for the switchgear is pro-vided by the so-called breaker or switch IEDs (BIED, SIED). The free allocation of functions allows the c reation of IEDs with both BIED and SIED, and MU funct ional-ities.

dard [7] will allow high-precision time synchronization also directly over Ether-net.

The communication stack and mapping

IEC 61850 has selected mainstream technology for the communication stack, ie, a stack structure according to the ISO/OSI layers consisting of Ethernet (layers 1 and 2), TCP/IP (layers 3 and 4) and manufacturing messaging specifica-tion, MMS, (layers 5 to 7). The object model and its services are mapped to the MMS application layer (layer 7). Only time-critical services, such as SV and GOOSE are mapped directly to the Ethernet2link layer (layer 2)

➔8.

Ethernet bus architectures and dual port redundancy

IEC 61850 uses Ethernet as the basic communication technology, currently with a speed of 100 MBit/s at the IEDs. Support of message priorities by man-aged switches allows time critical re-quirements, suc h as the 3 ms applica-tion to applicaapplica-tion transfer time, to be met. Tree and ring topologies are possi-ble with switches. However, according to the first edition of the standard, the Ethernet ring topology with automatic reconfiguration in case of link or switch failures is the most common architecture for systems. Tree topologies are not used very often because the switc h represent-ing the root is a potential srepresent-ingle point of failure. It should b e noted t hat in the ring, one switch connection has to be always open – creating in effect a kind of tree topology – to avoid endlessly circulating telegrams. The open switch connection is automatically closed if a failure in any of the ring links or in another switch cre-ates an unwanted second opening (ie, a tree recovery algorithm).

6 Transfer time definition with hardwired contact s

Physical link (wire circuit) Application function 1 Physical device PD1 Transfer time t = ta+ tb+ tc ta tb tc Application function 2 Physical device PD1

7 Transfer time definition with communication stacks

Transfer time t = ta+ tb+ tc

ta tb tc

Physical device PD1 Physical device PD2 Coding in the stack Application function 2 Application function 1 Decoding in the stack

8 Mapping to the stack

Data Model (Data and services)

Ethernet link layer with priority tagging Client-Server

IP TCP MMS

GOOSE Sampled values

Ethernet physical layer with 100 MB/s 7 6 5 4 3 2 1    I    S    O    /    O    S    I    S    t  a   c    k    L  a   y   e   r   s

Time critical services Mapping

Such is the potential of

IEC 61850 that in the future

it is hoped it can be applied

right across the power

(13)

Klaus-Peter Brand Wolfgang Wimmer ABB Substation Automation Baden, Switzerland

[email protected] wolfgang.w [email protected] .com Footnotes

1 The attrib utes carry the data values.

2 Nowadays in communic ation technolog y, most efforts and money are invested in Ethernet technology. In fact Ethernet is now successfully competing with the traditional field busses. 3 Please refer to "Seamless redundancy " on

page 57 of this issue of ABB Review .

References

[1] Brand, K.P., Lohmann, V., Wimmer, W. (2003) Substation Automation Handbook. UAC, ISBN 3-85759-951- 5. (www.uac.ch).

[2] IEC 61850 Ed. 1 (2002-20 05). Communication networks and systems in substations. www.iec.ch. [3] IEC 61400-25-2. Communications for

monitoring and control of wind power p lants –  Part 25-2: Information models for Wind turbines. [4] IEC 61850-7-410. Communication networks

and systems for power utility automation –  Part 7-410: Hydroelectric power plants Communication for monitoring and control. [5] IEC 61850-7-420. Communication networks

and systems for power utility automation –  Part 7-420: Basic communication structure –  Distributed energy resources logical nodes. [6] IEC 81346 . Industrial systems, installations and

equipment and industrial products – Structuring principles and reference designations.

[7] IEEE 1588 – 2008. Standard for a precision clock synchronization protoco l for networked measurement and control systems.

[8] IEC 61850 Ed2 (scheduled for 2010). Communication Networks and Systems for Power Utility Automation. www.iec.ch. [9] Baass, W., Brand, K.P., Gerspach, S., Herzig,

M., Kreuzer, A., Maeda, T. (2008). Exploiting the IEC 61850 potential for new testing and maintenance strategies. Paper presented at the meeting of the International Council on Large Electric Systems (CIGRE), Paris, Paper B5-201.

the system. The principles of engineering with SCL files are shown in ➔10.

As the entire IED data model is visible via the communication system, including possible configuration and setting para-meter values, and all this can be de-scribed in SCL, the SCD file is also a medium usable by other applications in the life-cycle of the system [9], such as the archiving of the system configuration in a standardized form and the transfer of protection parameters to protection system configuration tools. It may be used in simulation and testing tools or to c heck the c onfiguration (version) state of the running system against the intend-ed state. While these applications are outside the scope of IEC 61850 as a communication standard, they are of ad-ditional benefit for the user of the stan-dard.

A future-proof outlook

The long-term value of IEC 61850 for users lies in its object- oriented hierarchi-cal data model approach with its high-level standardized semantics and the use of mainstream communication technolo-gy, which is dominated by Ethernet. However, IEC 61850 is much more than   just a normal communication protocol.

Such is its potential that in the future it is hoped IEC 61850 can be applied right across the power system spectrum. A second edition of the standard is scheduled for publication in 2010. It will contain many additional features, such as the support of dual port redundancy for IEDs.

To allow the exchange of data between tools from different manufacturers, IEC 61850 introduces a basic engineer-ing process: Based on the system speci-fication and the description of the IEDs, the required device types are selected and their formal description, in the form of an ICD file, is loaded into the system

configuration too l. The system configura-tion to ol then defines the meaning of IED functions in the context o f the switchyard by allocating LNs to elements of the switchyard single-line diagram. The data flow between all IEDs is then defined, and all IED names and communication related addresses and parameters are configured. The resulting SCD file is a comprehensive description of the entire system in the context of IEC 61850. This file is then imported into the device tools of the d ifferent IEDs to comp lete their in-dividual configuration in the context of

SIED SIEDSIED SIED

9 Station and process bus examples

HMI Cu wires Switchgear/switchyard SIED SIED BIED BIED MU MU Station level Bay level Process level Station bus Process bus Network level Process interface Station gateway Station computer Protection Control Protection & control Protection Control

10 Example of engineering with SCL

IED Configuration Description ICD IED Configuration

Description ICDIED configurationdescription (ICD) Device

capability

System specification description (SSD)

System configuration description (SCD) Device dataDevice data

Device data Device dataDevice dataDevice data SCD per IED Device in the system

System documentation Reusable for testing,

maintenance and extensions Stand-alone device

configuration

System configuration

System and device configuration and

data flow “system as built” Single-line diagram with

allocated functions represented by logical nodes (LNs)

“system as specified”

Device (IED) Device specific tool    D  e   v    i  c  e   s   e    l  e  c    t    i  o  n System configurator

The station bus

connects the IEDs

for protection,

con-trol and monitoring

with station-level

devices while the

process bus

con-nects the bay units

with the switchyard

devices.

(14)

13 Common denominator

MARTIN OSTERTAG –With the advent of the IEC 61850 standard in 2002, and its growing success in substation automation and later in several other industries, ABB was faced with the challenge of adapting a variety of its prod-ucts to the new technology in a relatively short time. This was successfully accomplished in part due to the develop-ment of common components designed for use in a wide variety of ABB products.

Common components have

helped ABB adopt the

IEC 61850 substation

commu-nication standard in record time

Common

(15)

Already in its fourth ed ition, the guid eline serves as a good introduction to the soon-to-be-available second edition of the IEC 61850 standard and defines the stepwise transition from the first edition to the second.

Based on the principles defined in the application guideline, ABB started to develop reusable

components for a variety of products and tools in its portfolio. Two im-portant compo-nents are the com-munication stack and a set of librar-ies that handles IEC 61850 object models and con-figurations➔2.

Communication stack

The IEC 61850 c ommunication stac k➔3

is effectively a piece of software that im-plements the communicat ion services for IEC 61850-8-1 manufacturing message

A

BB was heavily involved in the process of creating the IEC 61850 standard. As the stan-dardization was in progress, and in order to enable a fast time-to-mar-ket, the standard was already being im-plemented in products in parallel to the standard's finalization between 2002 and 2004. In order to supp ort the standardiza-tion, interoperability tests were arranged for these early implementations. As ABB believed that the standard would be a success, it realized that a wide variety of products would need to support it. The company thus decided to implement re-usable components right from the begin-ning. The results of these activities were reported back to the IEC organization that used them to imp rove the clarity and qual-ity of the standard. In addition, they were presented t o the public at the IEEE PSRC meeting in Sun Valley, USA in 2003➔1

and at the Hannover Fair in April 2004. At that time, ABB outlined a clear step-wise strategy for the introduction of IEC 61850 into its solutions in its very own internal IEC 61850 application guideline. This guideline defines the man-datory subset o f IEC 61850 services that is supported by all ABB devices, it adds additional ABB internal convention, and clarifies and details certain sections where the standard leaves room for in-terpretation.

specification (MMS) and generic object oriented substation event (GOOSE) serv-ers and clients. More import antly, it hides the nitty-gritty details from the more ap-plication oriented research and develop-ment found in ABB’s products, thereby allowing developers to concentrate on providing application value to cust omers. Currently, the c ommunication st ack is

in-tegrated into more than 12 ABB prod-ucts or product families, with a growing number of host platforms set to follow suit as IEC 61850 continues to be ac-cepted by other industries. The benefits of the IEC 61850 stack include

portabili-2 Use of common components in a variety of ABB products

MicroSCADA Pro / SYS 600 C COM600 REB500

IEC 61850 communication

Engineering and testing tools

Relion ® 630 series 650 series IEDs 670 series IEDs

Common IEC 61850 components:

  – communic ation stacks   – t ool libraries

1 Interope rability demonstration between major vendors at the IEEE PSRC meeting in Sun Valley in the United States in 2003

Currently, the IEC 61850

com-munication stack is integrated

into more than 12 ABB

prod-ucts or product families, with

a growing number of host

platforms set to follow suit.

(16)

15 Common denominator

shows several important aspects that need to be observed to successfully capitalize on component develop-ment➔4.

For the upcoming edition 2 of the IEC 61850 substation communication standard, c ommon components will con-tinue to play an important role in sup-porting a market-d riven, phased upgrade and migration strategy for ABB’s product and tool portfolio. Close links to IEC working groups combined with imple-mentation in parallel to standardization will allow ABB to maintain and strength-en its front-row position in IEC 61850 technology.

Martin Ostertag

ABB Substation Automation Products Baden, Switzerland

martin.h.o [email protected] .com

XML-based substation configuration lan-guage (SCL) comes into play. In addition, the communication stack, which is a re-usable component, needs configuration information to enable such communica-tion to take place.

Configuration tools rely on a software component that interprets and generates both SCL and stack configuration files. This component allows the tools to work on an object-oriented data model rather than parsing and interpreting raw files. In addition, it helps to avoid syntax and se-mantic errors and contributes to the high quality of ABB’s products.

Benefits of ABB’s approach

The main benefits of such a component include:

− The ability to carry out maintenance and improvements in one place, allowing all products to benefit − The uniform implementation of functionality, which is crucial for interoperability between devices from ABB and third-parties

− Detailed testing and experience in the field. Because it is integrated into a variety of products, its functionality is tested way beyond what can be achieved for product-specific implementations. Success factors for component reuse ABB’s experience in the development of common components for IEC 61850 ty, and it runs on d ifferent real-time op

er-ating systems as well as under Windows for PC-based products and tools.

File handling and object modeling Each product to be integrated into an IEC 61850-based system needs to have its funct ionality defined in a standardized way that enables it to communicate with, and process information from other prod-ucts in the system. This is where the

3 Use of IEC 61850 stack component

IEC 61850 IED interface (IAL and direct write/read to application)

IEC 61850 SERVER / CLIENT DB    C  o   n    f    i  g  u   r   a    t    i  o  n    h  a   n    d    l  e  r    S    C    L   -  p   a   r   s   e   r Control handler IEC 61850 model H. Report handler GOOSE handler FileXfer handler Setting handler Subst. handler Mod handler Layer 4 Layer 3 Layer 2 Layer 1 SNTP client Third-party MMS protocol SW

IED Application/Data interface

IEC 61850-8-1 MMS/ IEEE802.3 GOOSE S YN 5200 / S YN 5201 / S YN 5202

4 Aspects that need to be observed to capitalize on component development

− Always be a step ahead of the products and tools that will use the components. In other words anticipate upcoming or future IEC 61850 specific communication requirements that component users might not even be aware of at the time they are implemented in the product.

− Fast reaction and premium support during the integration phase of the products research and development. In other words, t he component research and development team must have a very “service provider” oriented mindset in that requests and problems from product research and development teams must be dealt with relatively quickly.

− Version traceability. Keep track of the distributed versions and version dependencies, ie, which version of a product c ontains which version of the component.

− Backward compatibility of the component is very important. If substation primary equipment can have a life expectancy of between 30 and 40 years, it is an absolute certainty that the substation automation system will be extended and upgraded at least once during this time. As a conse-quence, different versions of products and tools need to co- exist in the same system. This puts certain requirements on the definition of the c omponent’s software interfaces and the way functionality is implemented.

− The proper clustering of functionality in a way that keeps the level of detail

component users need to know about IEC 61850 at an appropriate level. This in turn allows the product engineers to focus more on application modeling and concept development.

For the upcoming

edition 2 of the

IEC 61850

com-munication

stan-dard, common

components will

continue to play an

important role in

supporting a

mar-ket-driven, phased

upgrade and

migra-tion strategy for

ABB’s product and

tool portfolio.

(17)

ABB product development based

on the IEC 61850 standard

JANNE STARCK, STEVEN A. KUNSMAN –Since the publication of the first edition in 2004, the IEC 61850 communication standard has practically become the de- facto standard in the context of substation automation. Almost from the moment of its publication, intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) supporting IEC 61850 started to appear on the market. However, for many of these IEDs, it soon became clear that performance and flexibility were sacrificed in the race to get to the market first. ABB took a somewhat different approach. Experts from within the company

participated in the standardization work from day one, and as it was being developed it was decided to upgrade ABB’s Relion ® protection and control product family to support the

IEC 61850 standard. By the time the standard came into existence, ABB had already adopted a philosophy of “native IEC 61850 implementation” in that the standard is imple-mented from the start in new product developments. Today, ABB’s IEC 61850-based protection and control products are recognized as the number one choice for both utility and industrial power systems.

References

Related documents

The 2% enrollment increase projected by Dickinson State University for each of the next two bienniums is based on the following strategies to achieve this increase: increased

The main modules are the object-level domain knowledge model (real world entities and relationships), a strategy level model (for example a model of diagnostic problem

Figure 2 shows the original profile query (at the bottom) which was extended using the transforma- tions from Table 1: Solid lines between query tree and match DAG represent

to help all who participate to fulfill their potential and does not exclude any athlete based on qualifying scores,” but divides the athletes by those scores to ensure fair

The assessment of landholder bores in the QCLNG project area was completed in accordance with the requirements of the Department of Environment and Resource Management (DEHP)

Introduction 4 Opportunities to grow and sustain customer loyalty 5 Opportunity 1: customers are going back to brands 7 Opportunity 2: follow the four tenets of loyalty to build

Depending on the configuration and placement of voltage terminals VA,, contact cavity 115, and pressure reference cavity 120, modular apparatus 100 may accept a different type

For a limited historical period – but one which saw global modern growth at a pace unparalleled in human history—geo-referenced maps allow us to link place names, locations, and time