BIROn - Birkbeck Institutional Research Online
Hubbert, Simon and Morton, Tanya M. (2004) A Duchon framework for the
sphere. Journal of Approximation Theory 129 (1), pp. 28-57. ISSN
0021-9045.
Downloaded from:
Usage Guidelines:
Birkbeck ePrints: an open access repository of the
research output of Birkbeck College
http://eprints.bbk.ac.uk
Hubbert, Simon; Morton, Tanya M. (2004) A
Duchon framework for the sphere. Journal of
Approximation Theory
129
(1): 28-57
This is an author-produced version of a paper published in
Journal of
Approximation Theory
(ISSN 0021-9045). Copyright © 2004 Elsevier Inc.
This version has been peer-reviewed, but does not include the final publisher
proof corrections, published layout, or pagination. The published version is
available to subscribers at
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jat.2004.04.005
All articles available through Birkbeck ePrints are protected by intellectual
property law, including copyright law. Any use made of the contents should
comply with the relevant law.
Citation for this version:
Hubbert, Simon; Morton, Tanya M. (2004) A Duchon framework for the
sphere.
London: Birkbeck ePrints.
Available at:
http://eprints.bbk.ac.uk/archive/00000393
Citation for the publisher’s version:
Hubbert, Simon; Morton, Tanya M. (2004) A Duchon framework for the
sphere.
Journal of Approximation Theory
129
(1): 28-57
http://eprints.bbk.ac.uk
Æ
!"
# $
%
& '
( ¾ )½*
!
"
#
$ %
¾
¾
½
$&&%
#
'
#
$$ %%
$ % (
)
#
+
,
!
-"
$%.
½
$
¼
/
½
% $&*%
! $-&% .$
% " ,
. $%
¾
.
$%
$&0%
#
$
% $
%
-&
(
$&%
( 1 #
$2% " 2 3
4
$2%
¾
.$%
¾
.
¾
½ ¾
$&5%
$ 6 % (
$ 5 % $
$2%
$2%% 7
$2%
$& %/ !
#
$2%- & " 8
$2%.
$2%
$2%
.
$2%8
· ¾
$&9%
$&0%
· ¾
.
$%
$%.
·½ ¾
¾
/
·½ ¾
$&1%
( #
2 . 3
3 2
' '
8
$2%
$3 % $%
.
$2% $&:%
6# 6
2 Æ
¾
¾
!
2.$"% #
-
# $-#
%
$"$&/#%%
)
$% ( " ;
$2% #
$2%
$% ! $
$3 %
$3 % $
$3 %
# '"
" # (
$7 % " "
$&% ;
( " # ;
+ $ &% ;
.%
&
"
$%
&
%%
&
"
; &
8%
$-&% 3 &
" ; < '
8 3
" ; '
%
'
.&
! 8 3
.
$'
% $'
%$%.'
$%$% $*&%
( '
%
! 8 3
%
" =(
$%8 3 3 3
(
$%$"%.
Æ&
$"% "$-&%>
-
$**%
) "#
$% $) -%
$% 8.
$% 8(
$'
%
$3 % .&
$*0%
7
¾
.
(
$'
%
¾
½
½ ¾
$*%
+?.$-&% ?.$-&%
(
% .$?
% %
.$?
%
(
*(
! *
? 3 " + ?
# + . -
+ ?
) = *
? "
@
& . & $
,*% *
&
. & $
,*% *
$*9%
.%
&
4 $&% ;
" #
$ %
$ %8(
$'
%
$3 % .&*
$*6%
7
¾
½
.
(
$'
%
¾
½
½ ¾
$*1%
( " "
4 " ;
$*1% 7 5
" $ %
3
2
.&
$$ %%
% &* $*:%
( #
$$ %% ) "
$$ %%8(
$'
%
$2
% &* 2
.
$*&-%
7
¾
.
(
$'
%
¾
½ ¾
$*&&%
2
.
+ . %
&
"' '
$$ %%
!
$$ %%
.
$'
%
.
$'
%Æ&
$*&*%
!
$'
'
%
'
'
%
&*
+ - $-&% .
$-%
'
&* !
,0
$!&%
, .
$&,0% $ %. $*,0%% '
$ %.
, . $&,0% $ %.
$*,0%%
' $ %.
. $&,0%.
$&,0% $ %.
$*,0%%
&*
' $ %'
$ %
' $ % '
$ %
)
,0 Æ
$ % %
&*
&
$*9%
2
.&
$$ %%.$"
% $*&0%
! 0
! &8 (
,0
2 2
&
8
2
&
$$ %%
&
$$
,0%%
&
$.
$*,0%%$-&% &*
)
4 '
$"
%&
$.
$*,0%%$-&
%$-&% &*
( #
2
.$"
%&
$$ %%$"
/#% $"
/#%$-&% &*
$*&%
< $ % %
$
! *8 +*0
$$ %%
.$'
%Æ&
.$'
%
.- $*&5%
8
% **
,0
$% 2
$*:% $ $"
%>
$%
2
.$"
% $"
/#%$-&% -#
$% 2
$ $'
% Æ &
. -
$$ %%
+ *0 #
AB #
& $ % %
&* $"
%
$*&0% /
/
&* $*&9%
' ( +0
$+0%. +0 .*
$+0% *
! +0 ? 9
+0 .
* *
$+%*
$0% $&/ *
$+%
%
$&/ *
$0%
%
) +0 ? + +0
$ % $*&9% .& (
$*9%
$+0% *
.
$
,*% & $+%& $0% $&/
$
,*% & $+%
%
$&/
$
,*% & $0%
%
# & $% % . $-&% ' '
& $+% . & $0% 7 - & (
& $+%& $0% *
$+0% *
* $
,*% & $+%& $0%
! -$-(,0% -,*--
& $+%& $0% $+0% *
$+0% $
,*% & $+%& $0% 1 $
,*%
#
* .
& $+%& $0% *.
$+0%
+4#7
( 3
" )
7 " 7
7 < '
=
* 1 .*
&$-(Æ %
Æ .
¿¾
1
8.
1/1
&
$0&%
$-
% 2
.
$ 1%
3
4
3
4 1 .1/1 $0*%
2
' +1 $-(Æ %+
$0&% $-
%(2
( *,
+
*
&
&
&
$00%
&
*,$
% (
*
&
&
!08 7
)"2
=
#" "
5 ++ +
= "
"
C!0 ("?
$'% " "
!
" "
"? $
-%) 6 "? "
&
6& $0%
( $+ +
%
$+ +
%.
$+ +
%. 5 6
& &/+
+ $
& 6
&
& 6
&
% $05%
D' 34# $05% $0% $+ +
%
! "
5
#
34#
$+ +
% 5 6
6 $6
/&%&
5 6
& *&
5 *
(
5 *
$+ +
%5
$09%
! +
2
+
=
7!88 "
7!8$"%.+
( " $&%
"?
7!8$?"%.+
( " "?
4$09% $00%+
$ +%.$
+% *
&*
&
(" 1 .*
&
(
*,$
% ($09% $00%
$
% & * $
*
%
&
& *
.*Æ $06%
)
+ +
3
½
$+
%$1/1 %.1
2
.&9
(
$
Æ %$+1/Æ % .&9 $01%
! $+% '
"
"
"
:
"
+
) 7 $06% $
Æ % $ . &9%
= ($01% $+1/Æ %
"
$1/Æ % 9
"
$Æ %
(
9 "
Æ
"
$1 /Æ %
( ' 4 +
9
"
"
1 Æ
/&
4
( " 2
(
2
"
$1% .
" $1%
: $+%.
½
3
$+%: $+%
.
½
3
$+%
: $+% 4:
(
2
4:
" 1
.
)
) - 1
$0&% .
,0
.
,$01% 1 .*
&/1
$-
% 2
#(
0&
$ %
¾
4
¾
½
$0:%
) 0&
' ! 2
&*
2
$ %.&
$$ 1%%
%$-&% $0&-%
) (
$ %
$*&&%
¾
.
(
$'
%
¾
$0&&%
+ 3
3 ! &*
$3 % @ $0&-% + 0&
¾
.
¾
.
$
%$"%
"
.
½
3
$"%$
$"%%
"
4
¾
½
.4
¾
½
$0&*%
< .(
$'
%
# 1 1
,0 + *0 $%
2
$ % (
$'
%
E
$ % $-&%
· ¾
..
(
$'
%
· ¾
$0&0%
$%.
2
82
$ %
$0&%
!' &*
.(
$'
%( $&6%
· ¾
.
$
%
.
$
%
$0&5%
# 2
$ %
$%
$2
$ %%.
$3 %
$ & %
!A 3 2
$ %B
$3 %
$2
$ %%(
$
%.
·½ ¾
½
$ $
%
¾
/
·½ ¾
%
(F
$3 %
$
%
$ $
%F
¾
/ F
·½ ¾
%
$
F%
¾
4
F
¾
½
( $0&*%
F
·½ ¾
4
F
·½ ¾
½
!
*
$
%F
¾
F
·½ ¾
*
$
F%
¾
F
·½ ¾
4 *
F
¾
½
F
·½ ¾
½
( C#E 7
$0&*% G
$
%
4
$
F
¾
½
/ F
·½ ¾
½
%
( "F
$3 %
$
%
4 $
%
$0&9%
#$0&9% $0&5%
· ¾
4
$
%
.4
· ¾
½
('
8
$$ %%
$ %
$
%
.
$$ %%
$*&*% ' $'
%Æ&
$2
%
$3 % &*
"# *
,0 +,
2
$ $'
%Æ&
-
! $-&% # - Æ
( && '
8
$$-&%%
$3 %
$
%$-&/#%
$$-&%%
(" ' $"%
*$;%.;/" - ; 3 $&%
$;%.
$Æ*%
Æ* $;% ; 3 $*%
$
%$"$&/#%%
$$"%% $0%
"#
,0 2
. $"
%
$-&% . +,$% #
$
%$"
$&/#%%$"
/#%$-&%
#
$-&%
$$"
%%
) " '
,0
8
$$ %%
$ % /
$
%
.
$$ %%
+
½
' + 3 +
$$ %% " '
8 $$ %% $ % $ %. $'
%Æ& $&
$ %% 3
$ % $%
@3& 2
( $05% ! & (
% % 2 .$"
%&*
$ %. $' %Æ&
$&
$ %% $5%
8 $$" %%
$3 % $*%
#- 3 &
$' %Æ&
$-&% &* $9%
( & $ % &
$ % $"
%
&* ((&&
$'
%Æ&
$& $ %%.$'
%Æ& $& $ %%.$' %$ % $ %. $'
%$ %.$ % 7
( * $*1%
¾ ½ . # ( # $' # % ¾ ½ . # ( # $' # %( # $ % ¾ ½ )( # $' # %
$3 %'
. $ # $' %Æ&
$& Æ& # % ¾ ½ $5% . $ # $' %Æ&
$& Æ& # % ¾ $9% * $ # $' %Æ&
$& Æ& # % ¾ # . % & & Æ& # 8 & # $% % #
% &
$%
% #
% . 8 &* " ;
( ' ¾ ½ * $ # $' %Æ&
¾ $ $' %Æ&
¾ ½ $6% ($' %Æ&
$$"
%%&*(
( && '
$'
%Æ&
$ % ¾ ½ $ $' %Æ&
¾ (7 ¾ ½ ¾ . $ $1% $05%>
) ' $1%
(
8
$$"%%
$3 %
$$"%%
¾
½
¾
$:%
-
' #
# &
$3 %
4 ' / -
/ $;%
¾
½
$3 % ; 3 $&-%
+ '
$$"%% .&< $:% $&-%
/
¾
½
¾
$&&%
H
¾
- - $&&%
- 4
)
#
'
)
#"
'
$$"
%%
$3 % (
$"
%$-&%
$;%.
$Æ*%
Æ* $;% ; 3
(&& * $&%
$$"
%%
Æ*
$ - H
( -
$$"
%%
¾
.
$ Æ*%
¾
$5&%
$3 %
¾
½
.
$ Æ*%
¾
½
$5*%
+ < . "
%
$"
% )
< $"
%
=8.=$<$"
%%.
&
"; 8"< $50%
"# $ & < . "
%
( =
$"
% * $<% =, $-&%
C #
$$"
%%.
$$"
%%8$"%.- "<
$5%
< $"
% "
= <
$$"
%% '
"
) I
J
$3 %
) "
½
3
1
.J
$3 % $55%
J
J
$3 % "
E "
$ H 1
$55% .
1
$" "
½
%$"
%
½
0J
$"
%1 " "
½
J
)
.
$" "
%$3 %
½
8" "
J
$ 7% ( $" "
½
% 'Æ -
$" Æ% $"
½
Æ% $59%
)
$ $?" "?
½
% $-&%
½ J
$-&% Æ
- $"?
Æ
% $-&% &1
.$"? Æ
% $"?
½ Æ
%
J
$-&%
( ' Æ $"
%
* $-&% J
% $$ 1
Æ
5 < .
"
%
9 1
$"
%
= $50% * =,Æ
1
½
* $<%.* $" %* $" %
%
$
½
%
' , 3 5* * $<% $-&% =, (
"?
$-&% +5
#%
* $" #
%"?
=,Æ
&1
$"?
Æ
%
* $<% +5
( *
$& $ %
$-&% 3
5
$% $-&% "
¾
$%
¾
$$-&%% $
% . - . &1
$
½
%
) '
$'
1
Æ
5 < $"
% 3
= $50%
=,Æ
8
$$"
%%
$3 %
$*%
"
¾
½
¾
$$"
%% $51%
' +
$$"
%% $&5%$5*%$*%
¾
½
.
$ Æ*%
¾
½
! $-&%
¾
½
$ Æ*%
¾
½
, ( && '
"
¾
½
Æ*
¾
$5:%
) 8
$% (=,Æ
+55'
½
* $<% $
½
% $-&%
½
$% ( Æ*
$$-&%% * $<%
( $% $% + 59 (
. '
$%8.- $&5%$56% $5&%
Æ* ¾ ¾ ¾ ( Æ* ¾ ¾ $5&-%
#$5&-% $5:% 7
¾ ½ ¾ ) " .
! " #
(0'
8 $$ %%
$ % ! 7 $6%
¾ ½ $ ¾ ½ $5&&% .$'
%Æ& &* $ $( * $$ %% ! $$"
%% &* Æ
$"
% 56 *
("
' ( K.+
%
8.$K %8.
½
$0+
%. $0
' +
%8+
! $$ %%.
$$ %%8$+ %.- + K $5&0% #
$$ %% ( &* =
.$' %Æ& $$" %% < . &
$+%8+K$ % $" % $5&% $$ %% .$' %Æ&
$$"
%% &*
$$" %%. $$"
%%8$"%.- "<
$5&5%
! &* <
= .
"&
$+% 8+K$ % $5&9% "# $) Æ 5 $$ %% $ $5&9% = Æ
&* $5&6%
56 " &* ¾ ½ $ ¾ . ¾ . $
3 5: '
K <
$"
! $ %
+ K.+
%
$5&*% (K
$ %
.
$0+%8+ K$ %
$5&1%
(
$* K $-(,9%
0
K$ %
$5&:%
' +0 $ % + 0K($5&*%
$0+%)
+
$6% + $ % $0+% 8+K$ %
$5% +, $ %$+ % 0('0
$ %
$+*%
+$! % (0
"
$ +%.$ 0
%/$0
+%.$ 0
%/*
! ' +
K $0
+
% (
7
$ +
%$ 0
%/$0
+
%.$ +%*/$0
+
%
$ 0%/$0+%/.
(+
$ %
$0+
%$0+%/$+0
%/$0
+
%/*/.
4 $0+% 8 + K$ % (
! 8 +
5&-( ' K
<
&*
$ K $-(,9%
0 $ % %
&* =
$5&9%
$ <
.&
$K$ %%
=
&* $5*-%
+2
' + " $"
% 0 . &
$"% $ % , + 5&-
' +K$0+%) *(,0
+*
&
$0%&
$+% .
"&
$+%
! " %
+ K
$-(,9% $5&*% <
,0 >-
.> @ + 5&& > 0 =
&* ! +* ' /
=
/
>
.
/
>
&* $5*&%
( > 0 >
,/
Æ
$5&6%
.'
! 0
/
Æ
"
$5**%
'
$
K
$% $-(,9% $%
,0
$5**% $
,0%
$5%
-
¾
½
¾
$$ %% $5*0%
' (
=
<
$5&6% (
3 5:
!& "
) ,
$ &
3
+ &
! & $%.
+ $
% =
# ,
. $ %
,
¼
½
! $
% (
( 1 >#&&6
$
! $-&%
.$
% .$
% .$ % $5*%
!
) #
% $$
< ."
%
$"
% 3 4
$$"
%%.
$$"
%%8$"%.- "<
$$"
%%
' ) 9 ?$
$$"
%%
$$"
%%
$% $?
$"
%.&.&9 $% ?$
$"
%
#
. .8
(
" =
$$"
%%
(
8
%
$"
%?$
$5*5%
)
(
$$"
%% (
(
8.
(
!
$$"
%%
$$"
%%
( $-&% "
$$"
%%.
$$"
%%
$$"
%%
$&
$-&%
$$"
%%.
$$"
%%8$"%.- "<
( " ( 5&*
)
% $' $-&%
$*%
$$"
%%
$3 % .-&
$%
8
$$"
%%
$3 %
$% $
%
.
$$"
%%
$%
· ¾
½
· ¾
' G$%$% <
$% $ (&&%
$$"
%%
$$"
%%
% $( $-&%
< ."
%
$"
%$-&%
=
=
Æ
$5*6%
Æ
5
"
· ¾
½
· ¾
$$"
%% $5*1%
' ) (5&9
$$"
%%8.
$$"
%%8$"%.- "<
( =,Æ
(56
· ½
·
$$"
-&
"
+
.
$$"%%
.
$3 %-&
.
) "
$) $-&%
K .+
%
$ %
4
$$ %%.
$$ %%8$+%.- + K$ %
$5*:%
@ G 5&6 ( 0
#
7 $6%
· ¾
½
$
· ¾
½
$50-%
.$'
%Æ&
$$"
%% &* $50&%
+ Æ
+5 +
/
$*&9%
.'
0
/
Æ
$50*%
$* $-&%
K
$% $-(,9% $%
,0
5,+ $
,0%
25
-
·
½
·
' ( =
<
$5*6% #
<
&* G5&1 7 $50-%
· ¾
½
$
$
%
· ¾
.$
%
· ¾
.
$
!"#
( " D L
5 ( DH
+#
$
& L G <8 & $ 3 (6 '
) $&:6*%
* L8 4 77 (
( 3< 3 < H $&:61%0*5M00
0 # 4 ( D D8
)
$*--*%
) <+ 4 )8 '
L<' () $&::*%*5M
*96
&&&M&0-5 L + + D8 8 (9 3 6
' & N &#N , 4
$&:6*%
6 D #8 4 ; (
G@ G $&:6&%
1 4 ( 8 * ; (
<H4 $&:61%
#4
D
C
+#)6 *,P
(D D
( D +
D' 4
C G
