-' \ -.-· ·-·.· ·, . . ' .--. ,. .·_S'ERlES--lJl. NUMBER II. ·published Quarter Jj by T11e. Un_ivecst_ty ·._. : •. ;· . · / _,.·-. ·,·_. ' .:, ---~ ...
·
BU.L
- . --- .. - '-.
LETI1\I
' . . . -'·' -·OF _THE ; ' ~~l
'
)j
_
~Pl\I~~r~rEN-T
. <..;..-.·..
' . ' •'-/ - /.~~ntt\{"ed a~ ~eco-~d!CJa~s Matte; in the Post6ttice ~t
Nntr~ Da.rue; ~ry_dia.~~.)uly 171 i90.') ·,
·-l," ., ·, ·, -:·._· -/ · .. .·; -,. . ... ' . i-·< ...
>
[\
·
1- . ! i'> (I .· .. ' ... · ' .. · ,: } : ' ~: ' ·,· ___ ; ·I : .. ·..
.
. ' ) . . .. .. ··-·· • . '' ·---Series III, Number II.
B U L L E T I N
OF T H EUniversity of Notre Dame
NOTRE DAME, INDIANA
M % I %
LAW DEPARTMENT
1 9 0 7 - 1 9 0 8 P U B L IS H E D Q U A R TER LY A T N O T R E D A M E T H E UN IVERSITY PR E SS O c t o b e r , 1907 E n te r e d a t th e P o s to ffic e , N o tr e D am e, I n d ia n a , a s se c o n d c la s s m a t te r , J u ly 17, 1905.R e v .
JO H N C A V A N A U G H , C. S. C.,
P R E S ID E N T OF T H E U N IV E R S IT Y .W IL L IA M H O Y N E S, LL. D.,
D EAN OF DAW FACULTY.T IM O T H Y E . H O W A R D , LL. D.,
PRO FESSO R OF LAW .LU CIU S HUBBARD, LL. D.,
PRO FESSO R OF LAW .A N D R E W A N D ER SO N ,
PRO FESSO R OF L A W . .S H E R M A N S T E E L E ,
L i t t . B .,LL.
B ., IN STR U C TO R I N LAW .ED W A R D H . SCH W A B, LL . M.,
IN STR U C TO R IN L A W . R e v .M A T T H E W SC H U M A C H ER , C.. S. C.,
l e c t u r e r o n e t h i c s a n d n a t u r a l l a w .LAW DEPARTMENT
OF THE
UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME
T he University of N otre Dame has earned a prom
inent place among th e leading educational institutions of
th e country. I t was incorporated sixty-three years ago,
under the laws of Indiana. Its charter empowers it to
teach all preparatory, collegiate and university branches,
and confer th e degrees and honors appropriate to evidence
th eir satisfactory completion.
These degrees represent
as h ig h a standard of educational equipm ent as those of
any other American university.
T h e regular attendance of students num bers between
800 and 900. T h ey are distributed among th e several
halls of th e U niversity, as St. E dw ard's, St. Joseph's,
Carroll, Brownson, Corby, Sorin and the Sem inary. By
th is arrangem ent it has been found practicable to receive
and instruct students of ages varying from early boyhood
to thirty-five or forty years.
T h e attendance is com
posed exclusively of males.
T ho u gh conducted under
Catholic auspices, yet there is no prohibition or restric
tion upon th e m atriculation and attendance of non-
Catholics.
These comprise at times a fifth or more of
th e student body. B ut th e same general rules of disci
pline regarding respectful attention and proper deport
m ent at religious services are applicable alike to all.
THE GROUNDS
im m ediately trib u tary to th e U niversity comprise approxi
m ately 900 acres. T hey adjoin th e corporate lim its of
S outh Bend on th e north, and extend almost to th e
M ichigan boundary. S outh Bend is a well know n and
flourishing city.
Its population is about 50,000. I t is
th e seat of St. Joseph county, 87 miles from Chicago,
and accessible by rail from all p arts of th e U nited States.
T he city of Niles, on th e north, is only 10 miles distant,
and a trolley line from it passes th ro u g h th e U niversity
grounds.
In addition to th e extensive area of land
belonging to th e U niversity in its im m ediate vacinity, it
owns and conducts in th e neighboring tow nship to th e
east a large farm, em bracing in meadow, groves and
cultivated fields, nearly 2,000 acres. F rom it come quite
largely th e m ilk, vegetables and other food supplies
required for th e students, th u s insuring freshness and
wholesomeness in th eir m eat and drink.
T he grounds a t N otre Dame are famous for their
b eauty and attractiveness. T h e lakes, groves and river;
th e meadows and cultivated fields; the orchards and flower-
bedecked parks and gardens, combine to spread out before
th e appreciative vision a prospect singularly picturesque,
beautiful and charm ing.
THE UNIVERSITY BUILDINGS
T h e m ain and ancillary buildings of the U niversity,
including th e various halls, telephone and express offices,
a store and post-office, are about tw enty in num ber.
T h ey are generally of large size, and conform to the
most approved architectural designs and sanitary require
m ents. D ue m easurably to this fact, as m ay be p re
sumed, th e healthfulness of N otre Dame can ju stly be
considered exceptional.
B ut com paratively few of its
inm ates are compelled even in th e m ost try in g seasons to
suspend w ork and have th e ir names entered on th e sick
LAW D E P A R T M E N T
5
premises, and medical services can there be secured,
together w ith the devoted care of experienced and highly
qualified sisters.
T he U niversity is situated about two miles n o rth of
the business center of South Bend, and almost a mile
from its nearest suburb. A trolley line, however, runs
directly from the h eart of the city to N otre Dame. Cars
ru n each way every 15 m inutes. T h u s th e attendance of
town students at the college is greatly facilitated. Y et
it is advisable when practicable for young men to board
lodge and live at th e University.
T hey save tim e
by doing so and escape the distractions incident to
city life. In living at th e college, too, they more readily
conform to
THE RULES OF DISCIPLINE
in force at N otre Dame — rules deemed essential to best
results in educational w ork and th e form ation of sturdy
and m anly character.
These rules contem plate not only
close attention to school duties during the year, b u t also
im m unity from th e distractions and tem ptations, am use
m ents and social claims of city life. T h e regular period
of the school year is too valuable to be lost to any
m arked extent in such trifles.
T h e U niversity has long been noted for thoroughness
in w ork and effectiveness in discipline, as tending to the
utilization of time and the fixing of habits of diligence
and punctuality. A sense of d u ty is involved in the
m aintenance of this reputation. Students are expected
to be regular in attendance at class and diligent and
prom pt in discharging th e duties devolving upon them .
T hey are expected to take a practical view of educational
w ork and to bear in m ind th a t the'few years devoted to
it are to direct and influence all th e subsequent years of
their
lives.-A ll students m atriculated at N otre Dame, no m atter
for w hat course, stan d prim arily on th e same footing.
T h e halls to which they are assigned indicate in a gen
eral w ay th eir respective ages and educational standing,
alth o u g h th e records of entry in th e books of the U ni
versity are th e source of original and controlling evidence
in the m atter. T h e y reside during the academic year in
com fortable quarters w ithin th e precincts of th e U ni
versity; share together food of th e same kind in th e refec
tories; have th e same service at meals and in th e use of
lig h t and heat, as well as in w ashing and mending; some
sleep in dormitories and others in private rooms, accord
ing to th eir standing in scolarship and prelim inary arrange
ments; study in common, each at his own desk, w hether
in th e large study halls or private rooms, and m eet for
class-work in th eir respective recitation rooms, as called
hourly by th e signal bells.
In short, they dwell together,
m eeting for recitation in class, for their meals in the
refectories, and for necessary recreation and healthful
exercise in th e great gym nasium or on th e campus.
B rought th u s daily into close companionship, th ey become
in tim e v irtually th e same as members of one great
fam ily, and a feeling of deep, unselfish and life-abiding
friendship is often awakened among kindred spirits.
E v ery th in g needed can be had at th e University, and
seldom does occasion arise to visit th e neighboring town.
V isits to it are not favored.
T h is is not alone in the
interest of economy and for th e avoidance of habits of
extravagance and improvidence, bu t also to guard against
loss of tim e and possible exposure to tem ptation.
I t is
so u g h t under th e rules of discipline at N otre Dame to
prohibit or avoid things m anifestly tending to underm ine
or m ake against th e grow th of m oral w orth and m anly
character. I t is almost superfluous to state consequently
th a t drunkenness or im m orality is considered ground for
LAW D E P A R T M E N T
7
expulsion and th a t the use of intoxicating liquors is
strictly prohibited.
T he style of living at N otre Dame is simple and
unostentatious. I t is favorable to th e form ation of habits
of th rift and frugality. Distinctions between th e rich
and the poor are discountenanced. No line of dem arca
tion between them is ever know ingly perm itted to be
draw n. T he highest standard of excellence is m easured
by scholarship and honorable deportm ent.
T h o s e
crowned w ith th e brightest laurels of the U niversity are
those who w orthily attain to th a t laudable standard,
w hether they be rich or poor.
T his prelim inary sketch may be deemed pertinent, if
not indespensable, before proceeding to deal specifically
w ith the
LAW DEPARTMENT,
for its students are inm ates of the University, authorized
to attend any of th e collegiate or other classes, subject to
th e rules of discipline prescribed for collegiate students
and entitled to equal righ ts and privileges.
In 1869 the law course was established in a modest
w ay as a separate curriculum during the presidency of
th e late V ery Rev. W illiam Corby, C. S. C.
I t was
reorganized 1884 by the late Rev. Thom as K. W alsh, C.
S. C., who was then president of the University. T h e
present Dean was called from Chicago, w here he was
actively engaged in the practice of law, and placed in
charge of it.
T h e need of m aking another sta rt or
beginning the w ork anew soon became m anifest. A tte n
tion was first given to securing text-books and reports
sufficient to form the nucleus of a law library. In th e
following year began a gradual b u t steady increase in
the num ber of students.
Substantial improvements
th e library, as circumstances seemed to w arrant. N ever
theless, nothing was done in th e way of exploitation, and
for several years th e course was not even advertised, for
it was feared th a t in range of study and equipm ent it
m ight seem presum ptuous to invite comparison w ith th e
older and larger institutions.
I t is well know n th a t
these are advertised m ainly th ro u g h th e expressed good
will and personal recommendations of their students and
graduates, b u t N otre Dame lacked this advantage on
account of th e com parative paucity of such heralds and
representatives. As tim e passed, however, these w ent
fo rth in yearly increasing num ber and proved to be
zealous missionaries in their praise of th e w ork done in
th e law course. T hey found additional assurance of its
thoroughness in th e almost uniform success th a t attended
them in exam inations for admission to the bar in th e
various states in which they resided or to w hich they
w ent for the purpose of establishing new domiciles.
T hey observed w ith even greater confidence in th eir
w ork of preparation th a t graduates of some of th e most
noted law schools failed in th e same exam inations. T hey
were n o t unfrequently complimented by judges and
members of th e exam ining boards upon th e accuracy
and resourcefulness of th eir legal knowlege. T h e p u b
licity of such facts, though slowly spreading, has served
to attra ct here for the study of law a steadily increasing
num ber of industrious and capable young men.
U nder th e influence largely of th e American Bar
Association, the period now commonly prescribed for the
study of law is three years.
T his reform was greatly
needed, and it is gratifying th a t th e response to th e call
for it has been so prom pt and so general. I t means th e
elim ination from th e profession of persons unfitted to
follow or engage in its practice. I t means a higher stand
ard of professional honor and efficiency. N otre Dame
u w D E P A R T M E N T
9
has sought to keep steady pace w ith the progress made
in this direction.
I t aims to do its full share to elevate
to the highest plane practicable the study and practice of
th e law.
Considerations of public good and safety so
demand, and it endeavors not to be second to any other
institution in m eeting th e most exacting test of this salu
tary requirem ent.
T h a t its w ork in this respect has
been followed by fruition is shown not only by th e records
of its students in exam inations, b u t also by the fact th a t
many' of them immediately afterw ard enter successfully
on th e practice of the profession, w ithout previous p ro
bation or experience in the offices of other lawyers.
I t
is also noticeable th a t they adhere to and follow the
practice of the profession in larger proportion th an the
graduates of other institutions.
QUALIFICATIONS FOR ADMISSION
I n some law schools the requirem ents for m atricula
tion are of an order so h igh as to be prohibitory upon th e
g reat mass of young men.
Students are not received as
candidates for diplomas unless previously graduated by
some college of approved standing.
T hey m ust have received degrees evidencing the com
pletion of some of th e collegiate courses.
W ere th is rule
in general effect, all b u t a favored few would be sh u t out
of the legal profession.
T he institutions in w hich it
obtains may judge for themselves as to its operation. I t
m ay be assumed, however, th a t it has proved satisfactory
to them, for otherwise it would probably have been modi
fied or discontinued. In fact, it is hardly open to ques
tion that, generally speaking, a student whose m ind has
been trained and disciplined by years of study in a col
lege is better qualified to undertake th e study of law,
perceive its relations to hum an affairs, fathom its m yste
ries and solve its problems, than one who has not h ad
th a t advantage. A nd yet a fair education and h ard work,
together w ith a b rig h t mind, or natu ral endowments
above th e average, m ay enable the la tte r to do as well in
th e b attle of life as his more favored brother, if not actu
ally to outstrip him . T h e instances th a t m ight be cited
in proof are so num erous as to leave th e question no
longer debatable.
In view of this fact, not to m ention a
sense of d u ty in th e m atter, N otre Dame favors for its
own guidance a rule more liberal th an th a t w hich
excludes all bu t college graduates from th e study of law.
I t is not disposed to shut its doors in th e face of honest
w orth and prom ising manhood, even though th e general
education of th e applicant brings him only to th e th resh
old of th e collegiate courses. T here are m any capable
and even gifted young men whose duties have been so
onerous and means so circumscribed, on account possibly
of absorbing cares and heavy expenses in providing for
parents or brothers and sisters in periods of sickness and
distress, th a t th ey could not devote th e time nor m ake the
outlay requisite for acquiring a collegiate education.
Nevertheless, some of these are well educated along
particular lines. T h ey acquired necessarily a fair educa
tion in th e line of th eir w ork or incidentally to it. T his
is tru e of those w orking in prin tin g offices, commercial
houses, trade establishm ents and offices of insurance,
real estate and law firms, as well as of those who burned
th e m idnight oil in study.
I t seems to be only fair and
in consonance w ith a ju st sense of d uty to allow
credit for learning th u s acquired, and especially so w hen
i t appears to be equal in accuracy and range to th a t *
acquired in th e corresponding branches of an academic
course. Such persons ought to be able to finish in a
com paratively sh o rt tim e at N otre Dame studies of the
p reparatory or high school grade in w hich they may be
deficient. T hey could th en enter upon th e study of law
u w D E P A R T M E N T I I
w ith brigh t prospects, close attention and th e requisite
tim e being given to it.
I t becomes pertinent here to indicate more specifically
th e standard of qualifications for th e m atriculation of
law students at N otre Dame. I t is graduation from any
reputable h ig h school or completion of th e preparatory
course at this place. T his gives collegiate standing to
th e student.
H e is a freshman, so to speak, or entitled
to ra n k as a first year’s student in collegiate w ork. No
persons of lower grade can be received as regular law
students and candidates for degrees.
Students from other law schools are received at any
tim e and allowed due credit for th e w ork previously
done. T hey m ust, however, attend class for at least one
year in order to be entitled to th e privileges and honors
of graduation.
Lawyers who have been engaged in the practice of
th e profession or have only been licensed to practice, as
th e case may be, are adm itted to th e senior class and
entitled to the degrees appropriate to th eir w ork and
standing at graduation in th e following June.
Special students are those who wish to receive instruc
tion in th e science of th e law generally or in some of its
branches w ithout becoming candidates for degrees. No
particular entry requirem ent is prescribed for them , aside
from securing th e consent of the Director of Studies and
being of sufficient age and capacity to understand and
profit by instruction in the law.
T he regular students
who enter the law course as candidates for degrees m ust
be at least 18 years of age, b u t this rule is not necessarily
applicable to those who pursue special studies. As an
education can hardly be called complete w ithout an
elem entary knowledge of th e law, th e num ber of special
students ought steadily to increase. A knowledge of th e
law is the bulw ark of liberty. All th e relations of life
are w ithin th e sphere of its power to destroy, m odify or
protect. I t points out th e safe p a th to follow in all
hum an affairs. I t w arns men of and saves them from
possibly great losses in th e contracts incident to th e ir
business.
I t admonishes them of and guards against
possible heavy damages arising from torts or negli
gence in th e m anagem ent of p rop erty or th e ir personal
conduct tow ard others.
I t accompanies and protects
them in th eir travels on land and sea. N ig h t and day it
is over and around th eir homes and possessions, assuring
them of safety in th eir absolute rig h ts of life, liberty and
property. Mxxreover, no other branch of study compares
w ith it in disciplining th e mind, directing th e currents of
thought, intensifying th e power of analysis and discrim i
nation, and keeping th e judgm ent in all th e affairs of
life w ithin th e boundaries of th e p ractical— or w hat m ay
be called common sense, w hich is th e foundation of th e
law.
THE COURSE OF STUDY
at N otre Dame covers a period of three academic years.
T h e academic year begins for all th e courses early in
September, and closes approxim ately about th e 20th of
lu n e . T here is no break in the regular order of w ork
thro ug h ou t the school year, except du rin g the Christm as
holidays, w hen a vacation of two weeks is allowed, in
order th a t all who wish m ay visit th eir homes.
Students are required to be regular and prom pt in
class attendance. Absence is not excused unless in case
of sickness or th e intervention of im perative and unavoid
able duties. If continued for an unreasonable tim e it
deprives the student of credit in th e year for the tim e
lost and entails forfeiture of th e rig h t to graduation,
unless the lapse be satisfactorily repaired by subsequent
study.
LA W D E P A R T M E N T 13
Lack of reg ularity or remissness in th e discharge of
d u ty is an intolerable evil, disturbing to earnest and
industrious classmates and undoubtedly harm ful to th e
delinquent himself, in th a t it prevents him from form ing
a clear and accurate conception in unbroken continuity
of his prescribed work.
Breaks and intervals in his
knowlege of th e law m ake as evidently against his th o r
oughness and proficiency as broken cogs m ake against
the appearance and efficacy of wheels in m achinery.
Strictness in th e m atter rests not alone upon a conscien
tious sense of duty to th e young men themselves, th eir
parents, the legal profession and th e public, b u t also to
the University, so th a t its reputation of affording excep
tional opportunities and facilities to become thorough,
practical and proficient in th e law m ay not be im paired
or jeoparded.
There are three regular classes in th e law course,
which are distinguished respectively by th eir years of
study, as F irst or Elem entary, Second or Junior and T h ird
or Senior.
For example, after a year’s w ork in th e F irst
Class its members are promoted to the Second; another
year of study in this, and they are advanced to the T hird,
thus becoming Seniors.
In the following June, or at th e
end of the th ird academic year, they are graduated,
receiving the degree of EL. B.
T h is m arks th e tr i
um phant finish of the regular course in law.
Realizing,
however, th a t it is a life study, some of th e more fo rtu
nate of th e young m en may find it practicable to continue
th e w ork for another or fo urth year. In such case they
enter and become members of th e G raduate Class, and
receive a year later the degree of LL. M.
Y oung men find it greatly to th eir advantage, circum
stances perm itting, to study law for th e full four years at
a university, where they are in an atm osphere stim ulating
and favorable to work; where wholesome em ulation
incites them to call into exercise th eir dorm ant energies
and hidden powers; w here they enter into the spirit not
only of th e law, but also of th e different academic courses,
acquiring a helpful knowledge of educational w ork in its
broadest lines.
Moreover, th e day for studying law in '
an office or in private has passed. I t seems now to be
practically out of th e question to acquire a connected or
system atic knowledge of this g reat science in th a t obso-
lescent way.
I t m ust be rem embered th a t in m any
states it is threefold more difficult to pass successfully an
exam ination for admission to th e bar now th an it was
when th e old system prevailed.
Indeed, one ough t to
acquire a m ore general, accurate and system atic knowledge
of th e law in three or four years in a properly equipped
and well conducted law school th an in twice th a t time:
under th e old methods.
Special exercises are announced from tim e to time,
as in th e actual preparation of pleadings, th e exam ina-
tion of abstracts of title, th e w ritin g of deeds and
leases, the m aking of wills and other instrum ents and
th e dispatch of such business as is custom arily transacted
ill a well regulated law office. T h is special w ork requires
from one to two hours a day th ro u g h o u t the year*.
T h e subjects of stu d y are covered by text-books,
ectures and illustrative cases, as well as by theses and
m oot-court work. T hey "are likewise searchingly review
ed in daily quizzes.
T h e regular recitations, four daily
m num ber, cover all branches of th e law, as here indicated:
FIRST YEAR
[B ach su b je c t 5 h o u rs a w eek u n til finished.]
, Persons and Domestic Relations
U W D E P A R T M E N T 1 5
t o one a n o th e r c o n s titu te p rim a rily th e fo u n d a tio n u p o n w hich r e s ts th e w hole s tru c tu re o f th e la w . T he b e tte r w e k n o w th e m th r o u g h s tu d y a n d o b se rv a tio n , th e m o re clearly w e perceive t h e needs in c id en t t o th e ir p ro g re ss a n d d ev elo p m en t a n d th e m o re in te llig e n tly w e prescribe th e la w s re q u isite fo r th e ir p ro te c tio n — fo r th e p ro te c tio n of life, p e rso n a l lib e rty a n d p r iv a te p ro p e rty . T h ey preceded in th e ir o rig in all p o sitiv e la w s a n d even t h e sim p le st fo rm o f g o v e rn m e n t. L a te r th e y estab lish ed so ciety a n d fo rm ed th e s ta te . T h ey en acted la w s a n s w e rin g t o th e req u irem e n ts o f c h a n g in g co n d itio n s in th e line o f th e ir a c tiv ities. T h ey devised m e th o d s o f co -o p eratio n , a n d w ith la p se o f tim e c re a te d artific ial
p erso n s o r c o rp o ra tio n s T he im pulses an d m o tiv es t h a t a c tu a te d
a n d led th e m t o p u rsu e th e course th e y follow ed a re still in u n a b a te d force a n d effect, b ein g essen tial t o p ro g re ss a n d develop m en t. I n v iew o f th ese facts, i t is s o u g h t a t N o tre D am e t o s tu d y th e su b ject o f n a t u r a l p erso n s a s view ed in th e ir d o m estic re la tio n s before o r a t le a s t co n te m p o ra n e o u sly w ith th e ir a c ts. T hese a c ts, w h e th e r in m a k in g a n d p rese rv in g th e la w o r in v io la tio n o f it, com e w ith in th e sphere o f th e s tu d e n ts ’ w o rk a t a s e a rly a d a te as
p ra c tic a b le W hen im p rac tic ab le t o e n te r u p o n th is su b ject a s
a n in itia l o r e a rly s tu d y , a s in th e case o f s tu d e n ts w h o becom e enrolled a fte r i t h a s been fo rm a lly tre a te d , occasio n is fo u n d fro m tim e t o tim e t o re p e a t o r ap p ly its m o s t sa lie n t principles t o k n o w n o r described s ta te s of fact. T h is fully m eets th e req u ire m e n ts u n til th e r e tu r n o f th e tim e fo r its m o re fo rm a l tre a tm e n t.
T ex t-b o o k s: T iffany, D w ig h t, Schouler, Reeves, R odgers.
A d d itio n a l su b jects fo r F i r s t Y ea r stu d e n ts : B ro w n e ’s K e n t’s C o m m en taries, R eed’s Rules of O rder, N a tu r a l L a w a n d L e g a l E th ic s.
L aw of Contracts
T h is is a fu n d a m e n ta l a n d m o s t im p o r ta n t b ra n c h o f th e la w . I t com prises all tra n s a c tio n s in v o lv in g ag reem en t, w h e th e r express o r im plied, in th e com m ercial w o rld o r th e affairs o f d a ily life. In s h o rt, i t is th e b asis o f w ell-nigh all b ran ch es o f th e la w n o t included in th e ra n g e of t o r t s a n d crim es. F o r exam ple, all tr a n s a c tio n s in re a l e s ta te , w h e th e r b y sale, lease o r g ift, are necessarily founded u p o n c o n tra c t. A nd so in resp e ct t o n e g o tia tio n s affecting p e rso n a l p ro p e rty , w h e th e r b y sale o r b ailm e n t, a n d w h e th e r co m p risin g a sh ip a t sea, th e m erchandise on b o a rd , a d ro v e of c a ttle , th e p ro d u c ts o f th e h a r v e s t o r a sp o o l o f th re a d . S o, to o , re g a rd in g bills o f exchange an d p ro m isso ry n o te s, s u r e ty sh ip a n d g u a r a n ty , bo n d s a n d m o rtg a g e s, p rin cip a l a n d a g e n t, p a rtn e rs h ip a n d c o rp o ra tio n s , policies o f in su ran c e an d p o w e rs o f a tto rn e y , a r b itr a t io n a n d a w a rd , th e em p lo y m en t o f skilled w o rk ers a n d co m m o n la b o re rs —indeed, every re la tio n o f life in v o lv in g ag reem en t, a s w here th e m in d s o f p erso n s u n d e r no leg al d isa b ility m eet w ith c o n tra c tu a l p u rp o se u p o n a n y la w fu l su b ject a c tu a lly o r p o te n tia lly in being, a n d o f sufficient m o m e n t n o t t o fall a s a c o n s id e ra tio n b e lo w th e d ig n ity a n d scope o f th e la w . T h is is stu d ie d w ith ex cep tio n al th o ro u g h n e s s a t N o tre D am e. A m o n g its chief su b d iv isio n s a re offer a n d acceptance, ag ree m e n t a n d o b lig a tio n , th e essen tial elem ents o f c o n tra c t, s t a t u t e o f fra u d s,
q u a s i c o n tra c t, illeg a lity a n d public policy, m o ra l o b lig a tio n a n d r e a lity o f co n sen t, m is re p re s e n ta tio n a n d m ista k e , d ep en d en t a n d in d e p en d en t prom ises, im p o ssib ility o f perform ance, conflict o f la w s , c o n s tru c tio n a n d w aiv er, c o n d itio n s a n d w a rra n tie s , a ssig n m e n t a n d discharge.
T e x t-b o o k s: C lark , H a m m o n , L a w s o n , B ishop, B each,
A nson, B enjam in.
Torts or Private Wrongs
A subject o f ex cep tio n al in te re s t a n d re la te d in fu n d a m e n ta l im p o rta n c e t o c o n tra c ts , b u t differing in being o u tsid e th e p ale o f ag ree m e n t a n d w ith in th e scope o f o b lig a tio n a ris in g fro m in ju ry o r d am ag e s cau sed t o o th e rs b y n e g lig e n t o r w ro n g fu l a c ts,
in d e p en d en t o f th e w ill. T he tr e a tm e n t o f th e su b je ct includes
a full o u tlin e o f th e s u b s ta n tiv e a n d adjective la w s g o v e rn in g it, th e line to be d r a w n in d istin g u ish in g t o r t s fro m c o n tra c ts a n d crim es, p erso n s liab le fo r to r ts , negligence a n d nuisance, libel a n d slan d er, w ro n g s afiectin g th e fam ily re la tio n s, w ro n g s affecting p o ssessio n a n d p ro p e rty , rem edies a n d d am ag es. T he la w o f t o r t s differs fro m t h a t o f c o n tra c ts in fixing its o b lig a tio n s in d ep en d en tly o f th e w ill o f th e p a rtie s concerned. In c o n tra c ts m in d m u s t m eet m in d in every e sse n tia l p a r tic u la r to u c h in g tim e, place, subject- m a tte r. c o n s id e ra tio n a n d le g a lity . W hen th e offer in v o lv in g th ese elem ents is u n eq u iv o cally a n d u nqualifiedly accepted th e c o n tr a c t is c re a te d a n d becom es a liv in g force, b in d in g u p o n b o th p a rtie s , a n d no lo n g e r ch an g eab le a t th e w ill o f eith er. T h is o b lig a tio n arises fro m th e c o n tra c t, a n d sh o u ld e ith e r fail t o p erfo rm o r fall s h o r t in p erfo rm an ce i t gives th e o th e r a r ig h t o f a c tio n fo r th e b re a c h o r deficiency. I n t o r t , on th e o th e r h a n d , th e p a rtie s m a y b e e n tire s tra n g e rs t o each o th e r a n d h a v e n o th o u g h t o f e n te rin g in to re la tio n s p ro d u c tiv e o f lia b ility . A p e rso n m a y b y a n eg lig en t a c t in c a u tio u s ly injure a n e n tire s tr a n g e r in th e s tre e t, a s by d riv in g a vehicle a g a in s t him , a n d on so d o in g a n o b lig a tio n a t once arises a n d b in d s him as firm ly a s by c o n tr a c t t o th e in ju red m a n t o m a k e am en d s in d am a g e s fo r th e w ro n g done. A gain, a p e rso n m a y b y a n eg lig en t a n d w ro n g fu l o v ersig h t, a s w here he furnishes t o a c u s to m e r a defective vehicle t h a t b rea k s d o w n a n d causes in ju ry , c re a te a n o b lig a tio n b in d in g u p o n h im t o m a k e am en d s b y th e p a y m e n t o f d am a g e s fo r th e in ju ry th u s
caused. A r a ilr o a d c o m p a n y m a y suffer its tr a c k t o becom e
defective o r i t s em ployes careless in th e p erfo rm an ce o f th e ir d u ties, a n d a t r a i n m a y th u s be derailed o r a collision ta k e place, in ju rin g m a n y p assen g ers. I n such case a like o b lig a tio n w o u ld a t once arise in la w a n d b in d i t t o m ak e p a y m e n t t o th e m fo r th e injuries th u s su sta in e d . Defective m a c h in e ry o r in s tru m e n ta litie s furnished b y a n em p lo y er fo r th e use o f h is w o rk m e n in th e in d u s tria l d o m a in w o u ld ch a rg e h im w ith lia b ility fo r injuries cau sed b y th e ir defectiveness. I n v iew o f such illu s tra tio n s , i t w ill a p p e a r cle a r t h a t , a s a rule, a to r tio u s a c t is in d e p en d en t o f th e w ill, a lth o u g h its com m ission is a tte n d e d w ith a n o b lig a tio n in la w t o m a k e am en d s b y th e p a y m e n t o f d am a g e s fo r th e w ro n g done. M o reo v er, th e p a rtie s t o a c o n tr a c t m u s t be o f le g al age
I/A W D E P A R T M E N T 1 7
b u t as th e w ill is n o t a n elem ent o f t o r t , in fa n ts, in sa n e a n d in to x ic a te d p erso n s m a y becom e g u ilty o f a n d responsible fo r it. I n m a n y cases, indeed, th e w ill m a y be d irectly opposed t o th e com m ission o f th e to r tio u s ac t, b u t w here carelessness o r w a n t of re a so n a b le fo re sig h t nevertheless le ad s t o i t th e o b lig a tio n a t once arises a n d b in d s th e to r tf e a s o r t o m ake g o o d th e cr n se q u e n t loss. I f th e w ill w ere t o e n te r in to o r in sp ire th e w ro n g fu l a c t, i t w o u ld ch an g e its c h a ra c te r u n d e r o rd in a ry circum stances, m a k in g i t a crim e, in s te a d o f a t o r t . I n s h o rt, a d d th e w ill t o th e w ro n g fu l a c t, a n d i t becom es a c rim e ; s e p a r a te i t fro m th e crim e, a n d a
t o r t rem a in s. T h is im p o r ta n t su b je ct is developed in all its
b e a rin g s in th e la w course a t N o tre Dam e.
T e x t-b o o k : H ale, J a g g a r s , Cooley, H illia rd , A ddison, B ishop. Crim inal L a w or Public W rongs
T h is is u su a lly th e firs t la w t h a t m en a re com pelled fo r th e ir co m m o n p ro te c tio n t o fo rm u la te a n d execute in th e o rg a n iz a tio n o f society a n d fo rm a tio n o f th e s ta te . T he d eg e n erate o r vicious elem ent is opposed t o la w a n d p ro n e t o a t t a c k th e p e rso n a n d seize th e p ro p e rty o f h im w h o h a s been in d u s trio u s a n d p ro v id e n t. T h is c o n d itio n precedes all p o sitiv e la w a n d is su b se q u en tly m a n ifest in open o p p o sitio n o r schem es t o ev ad e its enforcem ent. I n th e sy ste m o f s tu d y a t N o tre D am e th e d istin c tio n b etw een th e co m m o n a n d th e s t a t u t o r y la w o f crim e is p o in te d o u t, as i n th e case of m a la in se a n d m a la p ro h ib ita . T he g r o w th of th e crim in al la w fo r th e p ro te c tio n o f th e in d iv id u a l a n d his p ro p e rty a n d th e se c u rity a n d p ro m o tio n o f th e co m m o n w elfare is sh o w n w ith due reference t o ex istin g co n d itio n s a n d tendencies. I n s tr u c tio n o n th is su b ject includes th e elem ents o f crim e, in te n tio n a n d w ill
m aliciously directed, m u rd e r a n d m a n s la u g h te r, a rs o n a n d
b u rg la ry , ro b b e ry a n d larcen y , tr e a s o n a n d offences a g a in s t th e g o v ern m e n t.
T e x t-b o o k s: C lark , B ishop; H e a rd , M a y , W a sh b u rn , W h a rto n , S tephen, C la rk & M a rsh a ll.
Forensic Medicine or Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology
T h is is a v ery in te re s tin g a n d in s tru c tiv e stu d y . I t deals w ith th e p h en o m e n a a n d signs o f d e a th , p o st-m o rte m e x a m in a tir n s, p e rso n a l id e n tity , causes p ro d u c in g v io le n t d e a th , e x a m in a tio n of b lo o d s ta in s , d e a th fro m a s p h y x ia , electricity, h e a t, cold, s t a r v a tio n , etc., feigned diseases, infanticide, idiocy, in s a n ity , d em en tia, m a n ia , p aresis, po iso n s, m in e ra l acids, v eg e tab le a n d a n im a l ir r ita n ts , cerebral n eu ro tic s, m a lp ra c tice a n d m edical su b jects g en erally in th e ir re la tio n t o crime.
T ex t-b o o k s : Reese, D ean, Beck, T a y lo r. Crim inal Procedure
T h is is th e adjective b ra n c h o f th e crim in al la w a n d concerns its e lf w ith th e p en a lties a n d rem edies fo r its b re a c h a n d th e p r o cedure fo r th e ir enforcem ent, a s co n d u c ted in c o u r t a n d c a rrie d in to effect b y th e sheriff. I t deals w ith th e a r r e s t o f accused p erso n s, p re lim in a ry e x a m in a tio n , c o m m itm e n t o r b ail, office of g r a n d ju ry ,
th e in d ic tm e n t a n d p lead in g s, m o tio n s a n d evidence, t r i a l a n d v er d ict, fin al proceedings a n d h a b e a s co rp u s.
T e x t- b o o k s : C lark , B ishop, H e a rd .
Property R eal and Personal
T h is su b je ct of ex c ep tio n al in te re s t is a t th e b a sis o f o u r so c ia fa b ric a n d civ ilizatio n . I t h a s th e s a n c tio n o f e x istin g la w s , a n d u p o n i t re s ts th e s u p e rs tru c tu re o f g o v e rn m e n ts a n d n a tio n s . I n t r e a tin g o f i t th e o rig in o f p ro p e r ty is d w e lt u p o n a n d m a d e clear b y m a n y illu s tra tio n s . P e r s o n a lty is view ed w ith reference t o th e m a t t e r o f ac q u isitio n , r ig h ts o f possession, m o b ility a n d ru les o f tra n s fe r, w hile r e a lty is v iew ed in th e asp ects o f its e s ta te s a n d feu d a l te n u re s, uses a n d tr u s ts , s t a t u t e o f lim ita tio n s , em blem ents, fix tu res, p o w e rs, c o v e n a n ts, easem ents, deeds, m o rtg a g e s , releases, s t a t u t o r y ru les a n d th e r ig h ts respectively o f la n d lo rd a n d te n a n t.
T e x t- b o o k s : H o p k in s, B oone, W a sh b u rn , W illiam s, T iedem an, S chouler, S m ith , D a rlin g to n .
Sales
_ T h is im p o r ta n t su b d iv isio n o f th e la w o f c o n tra c ts is tr e a te d briefly u n d e r t h a t h ead , b u t o n a c c o u n t o f th e en o rm o u s increase of tr a d e a n d com m erce th r o u g h o u t th e w o rld d u rin g th e l a s t c e n tu ry i t h a s o u tg r o w n th e m o d e st c o m p ass o f its fo rm e r p re s e n ta tio n , a n d se v era l te x t-b o o k s a re n o w d ev o ted specially t o it. I n s tu d y in g i t th e elem ents o f c o n tr a c t m u s t be con sid ered p rim a rily , a n d likew ise th e s t a t u t e o f fra u d s. T h e d is tin c tio n b e tw e e n sale a n d b a r t e r o r exchange is explained, likew ise th e need o f accep tan ce as w ell a s delivery in th e tr a n s f e r o f th in g s so ld , th e sa le o f c h a tte ls specific a n d n o t specific, th e n a tu r e o f a n d d is tin c tio n b e tw e e n con d itio n s a n d w a r ra n tie s , s to p p a g e in tr a n s i tu , r ig h ts o f u n p a id sellers a g a in s t g o o d s so ld a n d tra n s fe rre d , efiect o f ille g a lity , p a y m e n t a n d p erfo rm an ce o f c o n tra c t, a n d th e like.
T e x t- b o o k s : T ied em an , B enjam in, T iffany, B urdick.
SECOND YEAR
[ E a c h su b je ct 5 h o u rs a w eek u n til finished.] Corporations—P rivate and Public or M unicipal
T h e line o f d istin c tio n b e tw e en th e se tw o g r e a t classes o f c o r p o r a tio n s is w ell m a rk e d , a n d th e y a re tr e a te d se p a ra te ly . U n d er
th e sy ste m o f s tu d y a t N o tr e D am e, h o w ev er, i t is s o u g h t t o con
c e n tr a te th e a t te n t io n u p o n each b ra n c h o f th e la w u n til i t is n n d h a s ta k e n deep r o o t in th e m ind. I t is co n sid ered m ore fru itfu l o f s a tis f a c to ry a n d a b id in g -results t o p u rsu e th is course t h a n t o fo llo w t h a t o f so m e o th e r in s titu tio n s a n d d eal w ith i t a t w idely s e p a ra te d in te rv a ls, a llo w in g o th e r su b jects t o in terv e n e a n d le a d a t tim es t o confusion a n d lo o se h a b its o f th in k in g . F o r m uch th e sa m e re a s o n i t is s o u g h t here t o a s so c ia te o r b rin g th e m to g e th e r w h en p ra c tic a b le , so t h a t th e ir m u tu a lity o f r e la tio n m a y be m o re re a d ily u n d e rs to o d a n d a clearer k n o w led g e o f th e m acq u ired . H ence, th e se tw o g r e a t classes o f c o rp o ra tio n s a re d e a lt
U W D E P A R T M E N T
19
w ith in consecutive o rd er. As th e y a re d istin g u ish e d a s a rtific ia l p erso n s in la w , i t is deem ed ad v isab le t o d eal w ith th e m e a rly in th e second y e a r, n a t u r a l p erso n s th u s com in g in th e first. T h e su b ject o f p r iv a te c o rp o ra tio n s is m o re extensive t h a n m unicipal, a n d i t is developed a t g r e a te r le n g th . I n brief, th e su b ject of c o rp o ra tio n s includes th e ir n a tu r e a n d c re a tio n , p o w e rs a n d liabilities, a c ts o f p ro m o te rs a n d officers, c h a rte rs a n d m a n a g e m e n t, u l t r a v ires a c ts a n d d isso lu tio n , r ig h ts a n d rem edies of cre d ito rs; also, n a tu r e a n d p o w e rs o f public c o rp o ra tio n s , le g islativ e c o n tro l, m u n icip al securi ties, lia b ility o n c o n tra c ts a n d fo r t o r t s , c ity o rd in an ces a n d police c o u rts.
T h e su b ject o f p r iv a te c o rp o ra tio n s is tr e a te d in all its m u lti tu d in o u s ram ific a tio n s fro m th e in itia l o rg a n iz a tio n t o d isso lu tio n . I t is a lm o s t a s b r o a d a n d needs p ra c tic a lly a s m uch tim e fo r s tu d y a n d re c ita tio n as th e g r e a t b ra n c h of c o n tra c ts o r t o r t s .
M u n ic ip al c o rp o ra tio n s com prise co u n ties, to w n s , cities, o r p u b lic g o v e rm e n ta l agencies. In a b r o a d sense, th e F e d e ra l g o v e rn m en t, n o t less t h a n th e s t a t e o r city, is a c o rp o ra tio n , th e co n s ti tu ti o n b ein g its c h a rte r a n d th e s ta tu te s its b y -law s. B y such c o m p a riso n s i t is s o u g h t t o m ak e su b jects o f s tu d y m u tu a lly aidful.
S tu d y a n d re c ita tio n s in th e se b ran c h e s cover u s u a lly a b o u t tw o m o n th s .
T e x t-b o o k s : M a rsh a ll, C lark , E llio tt, B each, In g erso ll, Tiede- m a n , D illon, Angel, & Ames.
E x t r a re c ita tio n s fo r F i r s t Y e a r s tu d e n ts : B lickenderfer’s
B la c k s to n e ’s C o m m en taries (A bridged).
Partnership
O r th e a s s o c ia tio n o f tw o o r m o re p erso n s fo r c a rry in g on a b usiness a n d d iv id in g th e p ro fits b etw een th e m . I t is a v e ry close a n d co n fid en tial re la tio n , each m em ber becom ing th e a g e n t o f th e o th e r w ith in th e u su a l o r a p p a re n t scope o f th e business. T he s tu d y o f th e su b je ct com prises th e se v eral k in d s o f p a rtn e rs h ip , in clu d in g j o i n t s to c k com panies, artic les o f ag reem en t, essen tia l elem ents o f th e re la tio n , express a n d im plied r ig h ts a n d liab ilities, a c tio n s o r su its b etw een p a rtn e rs , as w ell a s b etw een th e m a n d th ir d p erso n s, lia b ilities a n d g ro u n d s o f d isso lu tio n .
T e x t-b o o k s: B a tes, George, S h u m ak e r, B indley, P a rs o n s , P ollock.
A gency
In th e w id en in g a re a s of com m erce a n d increase o f w e a lth th r o u g h o u t th e w o rld th e la w o f agency h a s g r o w n apace. I n a b r o a d sense th e re la tio n ex ists w h ere one p e rso n a u th o riz e s a n o th e r t o a c t for him o r in his s te a d . I t involves th e g en e ra l principle Qui fa c it p e r aliu m fa c it p e r s e —H e w h o a c ts th r o u g h a n o th e r a c ts himself. I n d ealin g w ith th e su b ject i t is n ecessary t o s tu d y th e m ean s o f c re a tin g th e r e la tio n o f p rin c ip a l a n d a g e n t, d is tin c tio n b etw e en a g e n t a n d s e rv a n t, c re a tio n o f th e agency b y a p p o in tm e n t, ra tific a tio n , esto p p el o r necessity, d e le g a tio n o f a u t h o r it y t o su b a g e n ts, lia b ility o f p rin c ip a l fo r a c ts o f a g e n t, p e rso n a l lia b ility o f a g e n t fo r his a c ts, p o w e rs a n d lia b ilitie s o f p u b lic a g e n ts, m u tu a l
d u tie s a n d lia b ilities o f p rin c ip a l a n d a g e n t t o each o th e r, a n d t e r m in a tio n o f th e re la tio n .
T ex t-b o o k s: T iffany, R e in h ard , M echem , E v a n s, S to ry , W h a rto n .
Bailments and Carriers
T h is is a v e ry p ra c tic a l b ra n c h o f th e la w a n d n ecessarily in c o n s ta n t a p p lic a tio n th r o u g h o u t th e c o u n try . O ur la w o f b a il m e n ts com es fro m t h a t g r e a t w o rld source o f le g a l w isd o m , th e Civil o r R o m a n la w . T h e sev eral k in d s o f b ailm e n ts, ex cluding th e m u tu u m , a re as a c c u ra te ly a n d clearly classified in th e I n s titu te s of J u s tin ia n as in C oggs v. B e rn a rd , 2 E d . R ay m . 909, o r a n y o f th e rece n tly p u b lish ed te x t-b o o k s . Indeed, w e still use th e R o m a n te rm s in d e s ig n a tin g th e m , as d ep o situ m , m a n d a tu m , com m o- d a tu m , p ig n u s a n d lo c a tio . W henever a p e rso n co m m its th e c a re o f o r lo a n s a n a rtic le o f p ro p e r ty t o a n o th e r, o r in tr u s ts its use t o h im fo r hire o r w ith a v ie w t o h a v in g i t c a rrie d t o som e o th e r place, a b a ilm e n t is c rea ted , su ch p erso n becom ing a b a ilo r a n d th e recip ien t a bailee. C a rrie rs com prise all w h o m a k e a business o f c a rry in g g o o d s a n d p assen g e rs fo r hire, w h e th e r th e y be r a ilr o a d o r s te a m b o a t com panies, th e o w n ers of ships o r c ity tru c k s , d ra y m e n o r s ta g e co a ch p ro p rie to rs . T h e y a re liable a s in su rers o f th e g o o d s delivered t o th e m fo r tr a n s p o r ta tio n , a n d th e sa m e is tr u e re g a rd in g th e re sp o n sib ility o f innkeepers fo r th e g o o d s a n d effects o f g u e s ts in tr u s te d t o th e ir c a re a s bailees. A few o f th e chief su b divisions a re delivery a n d acceptance, d is tin c tio n b e tw e e n b a ilm e n t a n d sale, su b jects o f b ailm e n t, lia b ility o f bailee u n d e r special con t r a c t , degree o f ca re n ecessary, d e n ia l o f b a ilo r ’s title esto p p ed , a sale if o w n ersh ip ch an g e t o bailee, w h a t m ay be pledged, in te re s t o f pledgee a ssig n a b le a n d su b je ct t o ju d icial sale, p a y m e n t a n d rede livery, th e h irin g o f services o r c h a tte ls , r ig h ts a n d lia b ilitie s o f w areh o u se m en , f o rw a rd in g m e rc h a n ts, w h arfin g e rs, safe d e p o sit com panies, a g iste rs, fa c to rs, innkeepers a n d ca rrie rs.
T e x t-b o o k s : H ale, H u tc h in so n , E d w a rd s , S to ry , S chouler.
Insurance— Fire, Life, Accident, Marine
_ T he o rig in o f in su ran c e is in v o lv ed in o b sc u rity , a lth o u g h th e
principle as ap p lied t o in d iv id u al o r p r iv a te risk s w a s ev id en tly k n o w n in a n c ie n t tim es. A t a n y r a t e i t existed a s a definite sy s te m a s ap p lied t o sh ip p in g o r m a ritim e risk s d u rin g th e M iddle Ages. E ire a n d life in su ra n c e cam e v e ry slo w ly in to use, a n d n o t e a rlie r t h a n th e l a s t c e n tu ry did i t ta k e definite sh a p e u n d e r s a n c tio n o f th e la w . Since th e n in su ra n c e co m p an ies o f m a n y k in d s h a v e been o rg an ized , a n d a p e rso n m a y n o w in su re a g a in s t lo ss o r in ju ry b y accident, d ish o n e sty o r negligence on th e p a r t o f em ployes o r o th e rs, n o n p a y m e n t o f re n ts o r d eb ts, b a n k r u p tc y o r inso lv en cy o f d e b to rs, failu re o f title in th e p u rc h a se o f la n d o r c h a tte ls , d a m ag e t o o r d e a th o f live sto c k , d e s tru c tio n w r o u g h t b y th e elem ents in e x tr a o r d in a r y s to rm s , etc. I t h a s u s u a lly b een a lu c ra tiv e b u si ness, a n d hence th e s te a d y increase in n u m b e r o f co m p an ies a n d su b jects o f risk . T h e chief su b d iv isio n s fo r s tu d y a re re p re s e n ta tio n s , w a r ra n tie s , co n cealm en t, p rem iu m , f o rm a tio n of c o n tra c t, policies o f v a rio u s k in d s, s u b je c t-m a tte r a n d in su ra b le in te re s t,
LAW D E P A R T M E N T 21
o^S t a n ^ in s u ra n c e , agency, w a iv e r a n d esto p p el, a ssig n m e n t a n d ch an g e o f in te re s t o r title , v a c a n c y a n d re p a irs, n o tice a n d p r o o f o f loss, r ig h t t o re p a ir o r rebuild, m easu re of d am ag es, con
d itio n s affecting m o rtg a g e s a n d s u b ro g a tio n .
T e x t- b o o k s : V ance, M a y , E llio tt, K e rr, Bliss, Joyce, W ood.
Common L aw Pleading and Practice
. T h i s su b je ct calls in to exercise th e s tu d e n t’s p o w e r o f a tte n tio n , a b ility t o co m p are a n d analyze, a ccu racy in th e re la tio n a n d sequence o f th o u g h t, resourcefulness in fin d in g a n d ta k in g th e c o r re c t in itia tiv e in th e th e o ry t o be a d o p te d , a n d skill in th e lo g ical dev elo p m en t a n d e s ta b lish m e n t o f th e th e o ry , p la n a n d fa c ts in th e case. I t is im possible t o find a b e tte r sy ste m o f logic a n d p ra c tic e in close re a so n in g t h a n is afforded b y th e s tu d y o f com m o n la w p lead in g s. M oreover, th ese p le ad in g s as developed th r o u g h sev eral h u n d re d y e a rs o f use a n d p ra c tic e m a y be s a id t o underlie th e code a n d o th e r form s of p lea d in g s m o re recen tly a d o p te d . H ence th e co m m o n la w sy ste m o f p le ad in g a n d p ra c tic e is ta k e n u p p rim a rily a t N o tre Dam e. T he su b d iv isio n s stu d ie d are here in d ic a te d in p a r t : C o u rts a n d ju ris d ic tio n , cap ac itie s a n d d isab ilities of p a rtie s , th reefo ld d iv isio n o f a c tio n s—real, p e rso n a l a n d m ix e d —p e rso n a l a c tio n s ex c o n tra c tu o r on c o n tra c t, a s a ssu m p sit, debt, c o v e n a n t a n d a c c o u n t; p e rso n a l a c tio n s ex delicto o r t o r t , a s case, tre s p a s s , detinue, replevin a n d t r o v e r ; th e su m m o n s o r c a p ia s t o b eg in th e a c tio n , a n d th e n th e d e c la ra tio n , plea, re p lic a tio n , rejoinder, su rre jo in d e r, r e b u tte r a n d s u r r e b u t t e r ; also, th e d em u rrer, p leas in
a b a te m e n t o r in b a r a n d th e sev eral k in d s o f m o tio n s ; likew ise, q u o w a r r a n to , h a b e a s co rp u s, scire facias, g a rn ish m e n t, a t t a c h m e n t a n d ejectm ent in th e real, m ixed a n d s t a t u t o r y a c tio n s a n d fo rm s o f p ro c e d u re ; a r b itr a tio n a n d a w a rd , c e rtio ra ri, p ro h ib itio n a n d m a n d a m u s, t r i a l a n d d evelopm ent o f th e fa c ts under* th e evidence, in s tru c tio n s o f th e c o u r t a n d v e rd ic t of th e ju ry , g ro u n d s o f m o tio n fo r a n ew tr ia l, e n try o f ju d g m e n t o n th e v e rd ic t if m o tio n be re tire d , a n d th e n a p p e a l on claim o f e rro r t o th e c o u r t of rev iew o r suprem e c o u rt.
C h i T - f - b o o k s : S h ip m an , Gould, S tephen, Shinn, H e a rd , P e rry ,
Interpretation and Construction of Laws.
T h is is a useful a n d p ra c tic a l b ra n c h o f th e la w . I t is a lm o s t a s aidful t o th e la w y e r in th e deeper a n d m o re a n a ly tic lines o f his w o rk a s th e la w of evidence is in ju ry tria ls . I t furnishes a key t o th e in te rp r e ta tio n o r c o rre c t u n d e rs ta n d in g o f th e s ta tu te s , gives em phasized significance t o th e w o rd in g o f c o n tra c ts a n d le g a l in stru m e n ts, a n d m akes i t easier t o c o n s tru e th e re p o rte d o p in io n s of th e c o u rts, s e p a ra tin g re a d ily th e d ic ta fro m th e n ecessary su b stan ce . T h e rules o f in te r p r e ta tio n cam e s u b s ta n tia lly fro m th e R o m a n la w . T h ey a n d th e m a x im s w ere tr a n s la te d in to E n g lish a n d em bodied in o u r ju risp ru d en ce. A m o n g the. su b d iv isio n s tr e a te d u n d e r th is h ea d m a y be m e n tio n e d : D efinition a n d o b ject o f in te r p r e ta tio n , in te n t t o be so u g h t, office o f th e ju d ic ia ry , re tro sp ec tiv e o p e ra tio n avoided, m a n d a to r y a n d d ire c to ry p ro v isio n s, p o p u la r
a n d te ch n ic al m ean in g o f w o rd s, ca su s om issus a n d e q u ita b le co n s tru c tio n , s tr ic t a n d lib e ra l c o n s tru c tio n , rejectio n o f su rp lu sa g e , p re s u m p tio n a g a in s t u n c o n s titu tio n a lity , g e n e ra l te rm s fo llo w in g special, express m e n tio n a n d im plied exclusion, red d en d o s in g u la singulis, perm issive, m a n d a to r y a n d d ire c to ry s ta tu te s , a d o p te d a n d re-en acted s ta tu te s , title , p ream b le a n d c o n te x t o f s ta tu te s , t o be c o n s tru e d a s a w hole, a d m issib ility o f ex trin sic aid s, s t a t u t e s in p a r i m a te ria , c o n te m p o ra ry c o n s tru c tio n a n d u sag e, c o n s tru c tio n w ith reference t o th e co m m o n la w , s t a t u t e s re g u la tin g pro ced u re, c o n s tru c tio n o f a m e n d m e n ts a n d d e c la ra to ry a c ts, th e n a tu r e a n d force o f precedents, c o n s tru c tio n o f s t a t u t e s o f o th e r S ta te s , F e d e ra l c o u rts fo llo w in g S ta te la w s a n d decisions in S t a t e m a tte rs , etc.
T e x t-b o o k s : B lack on I n te r p r e ta t io n of L a w s ; B ish o p , L a w son, D w a rris.
T h e State and Federal Courts and their Respective Functions
A s tu d y o f c o u rts , b o th o f la w a n d e q u ity , is aid fu l t o t h e a c q u isitio n o f a p r a c tic a l k n o w le d g e o f th e m o re difficult s u b je c t of p lead in g s. P lac es la w fu lly e s ta b lish e d fo r th e a d m in is tra tio n of ju stic e , th e y a re th e te m p les o f th e la w , a n d th o s e licensed t o serve in th e m s h o u ld do so w ith due reverence a n d a so lem n sense o f
resp o n sib ility . W hile th o r o u g h in s tru c tio n is g iv en in re sp e c t t o
th e c o u rts a n d m e th o d s o f t r i a l in G re a t B r ita in a n d o h th e c o n ti n e n t o f E u ro p e , y e t o u r o w n ju d ic ia l sy ste m , b o th S ta te a n d F e d e ra l, is even m o re specifically described a n d explained, a n d n o d o u b t o r o b sc u rity re g a rd in g i t is p e rm itte d t o lin g e r in th e m in d ' I t is sh o w n h o w th e c o u rts a re divided in to m a n y b ran ch e s, w ith d istin c tiv e n am es, w h e n th e v o lu m e o f le g al b u sin ess is g r e a t a n d so d em an d s, a s in th e la rg e r cities, w hile a single c o u r t u n d e r one n a m e m a y d is p a tc h a s m a n y k in d s o f b u sin ess w h ere th e v o lu m e is sm a lle r a n d th e ju ris d ic tio n a l a r e a less p o p u lo u s. T h e S ta te t r i a l c o u rts a n d th e c o u rts o f rev ie w o r su p rem e c o u rts a n d th e ir fu n c tio n s a re fully described, w h ile th e F e d e ra l S u p rem e C o u r t a n d s u b o r d in a te trib u n a ls , a s c irc u it c o u rts o f a p p e al, c irc u it c o u rts , d is tric t c o u r ts a n d even c o m m issio n ers’ c o u rts , receive becom ing a tte n t io n a n d e x p la n a tio n . T h e p ro ce d u re o n a p p e a l o r w r i t o f e r r o r t o th e S uprem e C o u rt, S t a t e a n d F e d e ra l, is likew ise fully elu cid a ted .
T e x t- b o o k s : H u g h es, D esty, E w b a n k , S hinn, S h ip m an , P le a d in g s F o rm s , B rie f M a k in g .
THIRD YEAR
[ E a c h su b je ct five h o u rs a w eek u n til finished.]
Equity Pleading and Practice.
P le a d in g in c o u rts o f e q u ity o r c h a n ce ry is less te ch n ic al a n d co m p lic a te d t h a n a t co m m o n la w . I t is m a rk e d b y g r e a te r fulness a n d clearness o f s ta te m e n t. We m a y divide e q u ity p le ad in g s in to th e bill, d isclaim er,p lea, a n s w e r a n d re p lic a tio n ; also, th e dem u rrer. T h e bill, a n s w e r a n d re p lic a tio n co m m o n ly s e t f o rth a n d jo in issue o n th e d isp u te d facts, a n d le a d in im p o rta n c e . T h e bills a re c la ssi fied a s o rig in a l a n d n o t o rig in al. A gain, th e y p r a y relief o r do n o t p r a y relief. T h e o rig in a l bills p r a y in g relief a re th o s e claim in g
U W D E P A R T M E N T
23
r ig h ts o f c o m p la in a n t in o p p o sitio n t o d efen d an t, o r th e class o f hills c u s to m a rily in l i t i g a t i o n ; also, bills o f in te rp le a d e r a n d bills
o f c e rtio ra ri. T h e o rig in a l bills n o t p ra y in g relief a re th o s e t o p e r p e tu a te te stim o n y , de bene esse a n d fo r discovery. T h e bills n o t o rg in a l com prise as a c o n tin u a tio n o f th o s e ju s t n am e d th e su p p le m e n ta l bill, th e bill o f re v iv o r a n d th e bill o f re v iv o r a n d su p p le m e n t. T he bills n o t o rig in a l a re re g u la rly in te n d e d fo r p u rp o se s o f cro ss litig a tio n , o r t o c o n tro v e rt, suspend, rev erse o r c a rr y in to ex ecu tio n a decree o f c o u rt. T h ey a re th e cross-bill, th e bill o f review , bill t o im peach a decree fo r fra u d , bill t o su sp en d o r av o id ex e c u tio n of a decree, bill t o c a rry a decree in to execution, bill in n a tu r e o f bill o f review , bill in n a tu r e o f bill o f rev iv o r, b ill in n a tu r e o f su p p le m e n ta l bill, a n d su p p le m en tal bill in n a tu r e o f bill o f review . T he bill is s a id t o c o n ta in nine p a r ts , a lth o u g h seldom h a v in g m o re t h a n five o r six. T h ey a re th e ad d ress, in tro d u c tio n , prem ises o r s ta tin g p a r t, co n fed e ratin g p a r t, c h a rg in g p a r t , a v e r
m e n t o f ju risd ic tio n , in te rro g a tin g p a r t, p ra y e r fo r relief a n d p r a y e r fo r process. I t is sh o w n in th e course o f in s tru c tio n t h a t n o com p la in a n t c a n sue in e q u ity unless th e co m m o n la w fails t o afford
a d e q u a te relief. If he seek d a m a g es he m u s t sue in a com m o n la w c o u rt. N o r h a s e q u ity a n y th in g t o do w ith crim in al m a tte rs . I t h a s no ju r y tria ls . T he chief subjects o f litig a tio n in e q u ity a re co m p rised u n d er th e g en e ra l h ea d s accident, fra u d , m ista k e , specific perform ance, tr u s ts , in ju n ctio n s, th e refo rm in g of in s tru m e n ts a n d in frin g em e n t o f p a te n ts a n d c o p y rig h t.
T e x t-b o o k s : S h ip m an , Shinn, F letch er, B a rb o u r, D aniel.
Special class fo r F i r s t Y ear s tu d e n ts: R o b in so n ’s E lem en ts o f A m erican Ju risp ru d en ce.
Code Pleading
T h is sy ste m is follow ed, w ith s t a t u t o r y m o d ificatio n s, in th ree- fifths o f th e s ta te s . A nd in G re a t B r ita in i t w a s a d o p te d in th e m a in u n d e r th e J u d ic a tu re A cts o f 1 8 7 3 a n d 187 5 . I t h a d its o rig in in N ew Y ork, o u s tin g a n d ta k in g th e place o f e q u ity a n d co m m o n la w plead in g s. T he com m ission t o a c t in th e m a t t e r b e g a n th e w o rk o f co d ificatio n u n d e r th e C o n s titu tio n o f 181 6 . B u t i t req u ired sev eral y e a rs t o com plete th e codes o f civil a n d c rim in a l procedure. I t w a s p ro v id ed t h a t th e re sh o u ld a f te rw a r d be no d istin c tio n b etw een le g al a n d eq u itab le rem edies a n d t h a t th e com m o n la w form s of a c tio n sh o u ld be abolished. T he n ew m e th o d w a s sh a p e d chiefly in acco rd an ce w ith e q u ity procedure, fo r w h ich i t w a s s u b s titu te d . One fo rm o f a c tio n w a s p rescrib ed fo r all classes o f cases, w h e th e r o f a leg al o r e q u itab le n a tu re . T he p le a d in g s w ere g re a tly reduced in n u m b er a n d d esig n a te d th e c o m p la in t o r p e titio n , a n s w e r a n d re p ly ; also, th e d em u rrer. A ru le w a s a d o p te d re q u irin g th e m t o be concise a n d fra m ed in la n g u a g e clear, in tellig ib le a n d easily u n d e rsto o d . T he n ew m e th o d w a s re g a rd e d a s a necessary refo rm in th e in te re s t o f ju stice , a n d w idely a d o p te d , especially in th e n ew s ta te s . Since th e n , h o w ev er, so m a n y s t a t u t o r y rev isio n s h a v e been m ad e, a n d so m a n y ru lin g s of th e c o u rts le a d in g t o divergences h a v e en tered in to it, t h a t i t is n o w h a rd ly less free fro m d o u b t, u n c e rta in ty a n d te ch n ic alities t h a n th e old