eR$8sBR BP Y Zj$}j ]Bjs$Bt ]B^{$tU jB{sj
BAZRtRR stI {BthIt{ $t%sjR
]Y$RB}Y ]BZ- stI ]sY$t *YBt
=t$%R$? N$A I Z-jjR
VARs{U stk BAZR RR$Bt R$8sBR s IhtI Ak 8$t$8$9$t s 8sRZ BP R}sI BP Y R$IZsjR Vt s{{B8}stk$t p1T8sRZ B 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t $R Yt
sR$jk BAs$tI yt Y$R }s} jB{sj BAZRtRR }B}$R BP YR BAZR p1T{B^{$tR s
$t%R$sI y $R sjRB RYBbt YBb {BthIt{ $t%sjR PB Y }B}Zjs$Bt 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t {st A {BtRZ{I $t Y {sR BP 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj$k
k bBIRU yt4Zt{ PZt{$Bt Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t iRR$Bt stsjkR$R p1T
8sRZ iBAZRtRR
e]Vie7 3s{Zj? 7!]! stI ytR$Z I 7s$R$JZ =t$%R$? N$A I Z-jjR ]_Tdd; V% 3* iBBR%j x( Td(x( ZRRjR j$Z8
d ytBIZ{$Bt
qY p1TRs$R${ B RJZsI 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t $R s RstIsI BBj $t s}}j$I
RR$Bt stsjkR$R VjYBZY $ $R tB sjbskR YBZYPZjjk ZRI $ 8s$tR st $tPB8s$% RZ88sk 8sRZ BP Y }I${$% }Bb BP Y Rj{I RR$Bt 8BIj ]sZ$Btsk tBR sABZ p1 {st A PBZtI $t %sjRY wdMxD stI G$jj m 7$t wdMMD G bB, $t s
RstIsI j$ts RR$Bt 8BIj b$Y $t{}U
r7 )L?7d#dLN N NL?7# L7 7) d,N N N , z wddD
bYz$R Y Rs8}j R$9?7 ) w?7d,N N N , ?7D0Y %{B {Bts$t$t Y -}jstsBk %s$sAjR
stI r7 Y R}BtR %s$sAj 7Z}}BR Ys Y BR 7 s $tI}tIt BP Y -}jstsBk
%s$sAjR stI $$I s{{BI$t B s I$R$AZ$Bt Bw?D ) B(w?bD bY $R Y R$IZsj
R{sj }ss8 stI B( %$hR
w3D B( $R $R Rk88${stI Zt$8BIsj sBZtI 9B b$Y R${jk }BR$$% ItR$k
G$Y7w |#N7D )r7?07#|N7|N7Y R$IZsjR PB8 Y NsR 7JZsR wN7D h Y {jsRR${sj p1 {B^{$t $R IhtI sR p1 N7 ) d z 7)d7w |#N7D1 z 7)dwr7rD1, wd1D
b$Y r Y Rs8}j s%s BP Y I}tIt %s$sAj G R Ys Y tZ8sB $t wd1D JZsjR Y %s$st{ BP Y R$IZsjR $t Y PZjj 8BIj bY$j Y ItB8$tsB $R Y %s$st{ BP Y R$IZsjR $t Y IZ{I 8BIjU
r7 )(L7 7) d,N N N , z3 wdnD
ytII Y N7 R$8sB BP ( $t wdnD JZsjR r
7$t{ Y N7 R$8sB $R %k %ZjtsAj $t }Rt{ BP BZj$R $ $R tB RZ}$R$t Ys
p1
N7 $tY$R Y$R }BAj8 qY$R $R $jjZRsI $t 3$Z d bY Y %sjZ BPp1N7 I{sRR
IsR${sjjk bYt Bt R$tj BZj$ }RtI Ak st $t%I $stj $R sIII B Y Rs8}j VjYBZY Y hI N7 j$t $R tB tB8BZRjk sjI Y p1
UC I{sRR PB8 Mn0
B n(0
N ZR IB tBb st -}$8t sjjBb$t ZR B RZIk Y $t4Zt{ BP st BZj$ $t Y
rTI${$Bt w{sjjI s %${sj BZj$D B $t Y ?TI${$Bt w{sjjI s j%s }B$tD Bt p1 N7
V Iss R bsR tsI stI $R 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t {B8}ZI VPbsIR s d
x y -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 -40 -20 0 2 0 4 0 6 0 8 0 R2=0.83 R2=0.30
3$Z dU e&{ BP sII$t Bt R$tj BZj$ $tI${sI Ak n Bt p1 N7
}B$t b$Y {BBI$tsR w(, rD $R sIII bY Y %sjZ BP r stR $t Y $t%sj >x,xH sR $R Rt $t Y Z}} jP }stj BP 3$Z 1 qY jBb jP }stj RYBbR YBb Y$R s&{R Y %sjZ BP p1
N7 V R$8$js -{$R $R IBt PB j%s }B$tR Ak j$t %sk Y %sjZ ? BP st BZj$ }js{I s w?,(D qY %sjZ BP p1
N7 I$I I{sR bYt sII$t YR }B$tR
stI Ak j$t ? B r tI B $tht$k $ b$jj %t tI B 9B 3$Z 1 {Bth8R Ys p1 N7
$R Y$Yjk RtR$Aj B R$tj BZj$R Ns Bt $t Y$R }s} b b$jj JZst$Pk Y $t4Zt{ BP sII$t BAR%s$BtR Ak {B8}Z$t $t4Zt{ PZt{$BtR G b$jj htI Ys Y {st sjRB A st $t{sR $t p1 bYt sII$t BZj$R
yt 7{$Bt 1 b b$jj $tBIZ{ p1T8sRZR bY${Y B sjBt b$Y BAZR RR$Bt hR
yt4Zt{ PZt{$BtR b$jj A {B8}ZI $t 7{$Bt n G b$jj PB{ZR Bt RR$Bt R$8sBR AsRI Bt Y 8$t$8$9s$Bt BP TR$8sBR BP R$IZsj R{sj qY BR TBAZR 8sRZ BP 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt bY${Y 8$t$8$9R Y 8s-$8sj $t4Zt{ Ys st BAR%s$Bt {st Ys% Bt p1 $R BAs$tI 7{$Bt ; -}js$tR YBb {BthIt{ $t%sjR PB Y }B}Zjs$Bt 8Zj$}j
{Bjs$Bt {B^{$t {st A {BtRZ{I $t Y {sR BP 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj$k bY$j 7{$Bt x { Bt{ jZIR
x y -4 -2 0 2 4 -4 -2 0 2 4 x y -4 -2 0 2 4 -4 -2 0 2 4 y R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
Influence of an outlier in y-direction
x R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
Influence of an outlier in x-direction
3$Z 1U e&{ BP sII$t Bt BAR%s$Bt w(, rD B s Iss {jBZI Bt Y %sjZ BP p1 N7 wjP
}stjD stI &{ BP sII$t Bt BAR%s$Bt w?,(D Bt Y %sjZ BP p1
N7 w$Y }stjD qY
YB$9Btsj IsRYI j$t $tI${sR Y %sjZ BP p1
N7 s Y B$$tsj Rs8}j
1 V BAZR 8sRZ BP
p
1G $tBIZ{ Y BAZR p1T8sRZ sR $t VtIRBtT7}{Y wd;D ]BtR$I s RR$Bt
R$8sB IhtI Ak
w|,#|D ) s8$t
w,#D Czwdw, #D, 3 3 3 , zw, #DD w1dD
b$Y 7w, #D ) r7 ?07# stI Cz s R$IZsj R{sj R$8sB %$Pk$t Czwyd, 3 3 3 , yzD ) /y/Czwd, 3 3 3 , zD
PB sjj d, 3 3 3 , zstI y;{p WBb b h Y RR$Bt 8BIj wdnD Ys%$t Btjk st $t{}
8 k$jI$t
|
( ) s8$t
( Czwrd(, 3 3 3 , rz(D3
k {B8}s$t Y R$8sI R$IZsj R{sjR $t Y PZjj 8BIj stI $t Y IZ{I 8BIj wdnD b Iht Ak stsjBk b$Y Y {jsRR${sj PB8Zjs wd1D
p1 C ) d C1 z p dw|,#|D, 3 3 3 , zw|,#|D Q C1 zwrd|(, 3 3 3 , rz|(D 3 w11D n
7$t{ wdnD $R s RZA8BIj BP wddD stI Ak Y Iht$$Bt BP Y RR$Bt R$8sBR w1dD Bt sI$jk RR Ys
(p1 C d3
3B %k R$IZsj R{sj R$8sB C b Ys% stBY RR$Bt R$8sB stI stBY 8sT RZ BP 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt zsjZR BPp1
C {jBR B 9B $tI${s Ys Y -}jstsBk %s$sAjR
s tB -}js$t$t 8Z{Y BP Y I$R}R$Bt BP r bY$j s %sjZ BP p1 {jBR B Bt $tI${sR
Ys Y I$R}R$Bt BP Y R$IZsjR $R sj8BR 9B RB st -{jjt h qY$R $t}s$Bt $R RstIsI AZ Y 8st$t BP XI$R}R$Bt" I}tIR Bt Y Rj{I 8sRZ BP R{sj C
G b$jj PB{ZR Bt Y {jsRR BP TR$8sBR BP R$IZsj R{sj bYCzwd, 3 3 3 , zD $R IhtI
sR Y RBjZ$Bt BP Y PBjjBb$t JZs$Bt $t XU d z z 3 7)d 'wX7D ) K3 qY PZt{$Bt ' $R RZ}}BRI B %$Pk
wiD qY PZt{$Bt' $R Rk88${stI tBt I{sR$t Bt >(, > 3ZY8B'w(D ) ( stI
' $R sj8BR %kbY {Bt$tZBZRjk I$&t$sAj
qY tZ8A K $R s Rj{I {BtRst {YBRt sR oB(>'wDH B tRZ {BtR$Rt R$8s$Bt BP s Y 8BIj
yP b s, 'w`D ) `1 wstI K ) dD Yt C
z $R s RZ8 BP RJZsR stI b Y {jsRR${sj
p1
N7 PB w11D ytRsI BP s RJZsI jBRR PZt{$Bt Bt {BZjI s, 'w`D ) /`/ bY${Y jsIR B
Y 8$t$8$9s$Bt BP Y RZ8 BP sARBjZ %sjZR BP Y R$IZsjR stI k$jIR Y Ud RR$Bt
R$8sB qY sRRB{$sI p1 Nd $R $%t Ak p1 Nd ) d Xz 7)d/r7?07#|Nd|Nd/ z 7)d/r78I$st7r7/ ~1 3
qY sAB% 8sRZ stI s %s$st BP $ Ys% At RZI$I Ak {st m 7$%R wdMD V R8BBY stI ABZtII ' PZt{$Bt $R Y qZ,k $b$Y
'w`D ) 8$t w 1 E, `1 1 `; 11 L `E E; W 3 w1nD
qY RZj$t R$8sB $R Yt st 7TR$8sB wiBZRRZb m OBYs$ dM;D bY${Y b {sjj Y $b$Y 7TR$8sB w 7D qY {BtRst $t w1nD I8$tR Y As,IBbt }B$t BP Y R$8sB bY${Y $R Y 8s-$8sj Ps{$Bt BP {Bts8$ts$Bt Ys st R$8sB {st b$YRstI
k IPsZj Y x(0 As,IBbt %R$Bt $R s,t AZ b b$jj sjRB {BtR$I Y 1x0 As,IBbt $b$Y 7TR$8sB w 71xD
qs,$t s R} PZt{$Bt
'w`D ){w/`/k D,
k$jIR Y wdKD JZst$j BP Y sARBjZ %sjZR BP Y R$IZsjRU
Czwd, 3 3 3 , zD )d//w>wdKDzHD3
qY %sjZ BP K$R I8$tI Ak K)oB(>'wDH ) 1wdB(wDD3 3BK) (3x b 8$t$8$9 Y
8I$st BP Y sARBjZ %sjZR BP Y R$IZsjR stI Y NsR I$st BP 7JZsR wN7D RR$Bt R$8sB BP iBZRRZb wdM;D 3B BY %sjZR BP K b b$jj R}s, sABZ Y NsR +Zst$j BP 7JZsR R$8sB wiBZRRZb m NBk dM } d1;D 3B Y N7 sR sjsIk tB${I Ak VtIRBtT7}{Y wd;D w11D RZjR $t
p1 N7) d X 8I$st7/r7 ?70#|N7|N7/ 7<!iq ~1 ,
bY 7<!iq RstIR PB YsjP BP Y jtY BP Y RYBR $t%sj {B%$t YsjP BP Y r7
BAR%s$BtR
N ZR }s Y -}$8t IR{$AI $t 7{$Bt d PB Y Ud R$8sB Y $b$Y
7TR$8sB stI Y NsR I$st BP 7JZsR 3$Z n RYBbR Y RZjRU YUdR$8sB $R
8Z{Y 8B BAZR Yst N7 stI RZ&R 8B PB8 j%s }B$tR Yst PB8 %${sj BZj$R qY N7 stI $b$Y 7TR$8sB RYBb s %k BAZR AYs%$BU Y $R Btjk s Rj$Y jBRR $t p1
C A{B8$t {BtRst bYt Y BZj$ 8B%R PZY sbsk PB8 Y B$$t qY {Z%
PB N7 $R JZ$ s${bYt Y sIII }B$t $R {jBR B Y hI RR$Bt j$t AZ PB
p1
7 b BAs$t s %k R8BBY {Z% yt Y t- R{$Bt b b$jj tsj$9 stI PB8sj$9
YR htI$tR Ak {B8}Z$t Y sRRB{$sI $t4Zt{ PZt{$BtR
n yt4Zt{ PZt{$BtR
N C A Y R{sj PZt{$Btsj sRRB{$sI b$Y Cz G JZ$ Ys C $R 3$RY {BtR$Rt s
Y B 8BIj I$R$AZ$Bt 8st$t Ys CwBD ) qY R{sj PZt{$Btsj }Rt$t
TR$8sBR BP R{sj $R IhtI sR Y RBjZ$Bt BP
8
'wCwBDDQBwD )K,
y R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
L1: Influence of an outlier in y-direction
x R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
L1: Influence of an outlier in x-direction
y R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
LMS: Influence of an outlier in y-direction
x R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
LMS: Influence of an outlier in x-direction
y R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
BS: Influence of an outlier in y-direction
x R2 -4 -2 0 2 4 0.70 0.80 0.90
BS: Influence of an outlier in x-direction
3$Z nU e&{ BP sII$t Bt BAR%s$Btw(, rDB s Iss {jBZI Bt Y %sjZ BPp1
Nd, p1 7 stI
p1
N7 wjP hZRD stI &{ BP sII$t Bt BAR%s$Bt w?,(D w$Y hZRD sR $t 3$Z 1
qY YB$9Btsj IsRYI j$tR $tI${s Y %sjZ BP p1
Nd, p1 7 stI p1N7 s Y B$$tsj Rs8}j
PB stk Zt$%s$s I$R$AZ$BtB G tI B RK)oB(>'wVDH B BAs$t 3$RY {BtR$Rt{k
s Y B 8BIj I$R$AZ$Bt 3ZY8B b b$jj ItB Cw.D #CwBD PB stk stIB8 %s$sAj . B
yt Y RR$Bt {Bt- b Ys% s RB{YsR${ %s$sAj w , VD {B8$t PB8 s wL dDT I$8tR$Btsj I$R$AZ$Bt I qY RR$Bt PZt{$Btsj {BR}BtI$t B w1dD $R $%t Ak
wywID, KwIDD ) s8$t
,# CwV #
0 D3
qY I$R}R$Bt BP Y R$IZsjR $R 8sRZI Ak Y RR$Bt R{sj PZt{$Btsj
CdwID )CwV KwID0 ywIDD3 qY PZt{$Btsj R$8s$t Y $t{} }ss8 $t wdnD JZsjR y(wID ) s8$t ( CwV (D b$Y sRRB{$sI R{sj C(wID ) CwV y(wIDD3 3$tsjjk b BAs$t sR PZt{$Btsj }Rts$Bt PB Y p1 C Rs$R${ p1 CwID ) d C 1 dwID C1 (wID ) d C1wV KwID0 ywIDD C1wV y(wIDD 3 wndD
yP Y ItB8$tsB $t Y sAB% -}RR$Bt JZsjR 9B Yt Ak {Bt%t$Bt p1
CwID ) d3
qY p1
C 8sRZ YsR s t${ $t%s$st{ }B}k G b$jj b$ p1Cw , VD ) pC1wID
bYt% w , VDI wVjj }BBPR s $t Y V}}tI$-D
_B}BR$$Bt d N \ A s tBtTR$tZjs 8s$- Ks TI$8tR$Btsj %{B stI W) ( stI bB R{sjsR qY p1
CTPZt{$Btsj IhtI $t wndD %$hR
p1
Cw\ LK, V LD )p1Cw , VD3
i{sjj Ys b RZ}}BRI Ys Y BBI Iss s tsI Ak Y 8BIjV )L#0 L
b$Y $tI}tIt BP stI bY Y BR PBjjBbI s I$R$AZ$Bt Bw?D ) B(w?bD
b$Y B( Rs$RPk$t w3D G JZ$ {BtR$Rt{k BP sjj $t%Bj%I RR$Bt PZt{$BtsjR RB Ys ywID ) stI KwID )# k$jI$tCdwID )CwD ) stI
p1 CwID ) d 1 C1 (wVD3
qY sAB% -}RR$Bt k$jIR stBY %sjZ BP p1
CwID PB %k BY R{sj 8sRZ qB 8s,
s {B8}s$RBt Abt s}}Bs{YR AsRI Bt I$&t R{sj 8sRZR sR$ b b$jj sII st -s {BtI$$BtU
w<D qY I$R$AZ$Bt BP Y R}BtR %s$sAj $R s jB{s$BtTR{sj stRPB8s$Bt BP Y BT 8 8BIj I$R$AZ$Bt RB hIwV rD )B(wr VV D3
!P {BZR $P b ZR p1
C sR s IR{$}$% 8sRZ Yt b IB tB tI B Ys% w<D G Btjk
ZR $ B R$8}j$Pk Y YB${sj R$t qY sI%sts $R tBb Ys
p1 CwID ) d 1 1 V U) 1 wn1D
k$jIR s }ss8 $tI}tIt BP C ItBI Ak 1 stI {sjjI Y RJZsI }B}Zjs$Bt
8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t
qY RstIsI -s8}j $R I JZsj B s 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj I$R$AZ$Bt qs,
]w , D V ]w V, V1D stI ]B%w , VD ) V G {st b$ r)L#0?L bY
# ) d
V ) V #0 stI ]w(, 1D3 esRk {sj{ZjZR w{P FBYtRBt m G${Yt
dM } ;1D RYBbR Ys p1 CwID )1 ) V d V 1 V 3 wnnD
WBb b s sIk B {B8}Z Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt BP Y p1
C PZt{$Btsj N w?, rD ; {p{p A st $tI$%$IZsj BAR%s$Bt bY${Y {st A $t}I sR s {Bts8$ts$t }B$t
qY $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt BP Y p1
C PZt{$Btsj s Y 8BIj I$R$AZ$Bt I $R IhtI sR {Bww?, rD, p1
C, ID ) j$8( p 1
CwwdDILw?,rDDp1CwID
bY w?,rD $R s I$R$AZ$Bt bY${Y }ZR sjj $R 8sRR s w?, rD qY $t4Zt{ PZt{ $Bt
8sRZR Y &{ BP s }BRR$Aj BZj$ w?, rD s Y p1
C Rs$R${ y $%R Y s8BZt BP
{Yst $t Y p1
C R$8sB {sZRI Ak st $tht$R$8sj s8BZt BP {Bts8$ts$Bt 3B 8B
Is$jR sABZ $t4Zt{ PZt{$BtR R <s8}j iBt{Y$ iBZRRZb m 7sYj wdMED G hR I$% Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt ZR$t stk R{sj PZt{$BtsjC %$Pk$t s {s$t R8BBYtRR {BtI$$Bt
qYB8 d N Y 8BIj I$R$AZ$Bt I %$Pk w<D qs, w , VD I stI ItB Y B 8 BP Y 8BIj VRRZ8 Ys C YsR Y }B}k Ys wy, KD CwLK0 LyD $R
I$&t$sAj b$Y }s$sj I$%s$%R JZsj B 9B s Y B$$t w(,(D qYt
{Bww?, rD, p1 C, ID ) 1wd1D w {Bwr V V , C, B(D{Bw r#0? , C, B(D W 3 wn;D M
qY $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt BP Y p1
C PZt{$Btsj ZR$t -TR{sj R$8sBR PBjjBbR tBb PB8
qYB8 d Ak {Y{,$t Y {BtI$$Bt Bt C stI Ak ZR$t Y bjjT,tBbt -}RR$Bt BP Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt BP st TR$8sB BP R{sj
_B}BR$$Bt 1 N w , VDI bY Y I$R$AZ$Bt I %$hR w<D qYt
{Bww?, rD, p1 C, ID ) 1wd 1D oB(>'IwDH w 'wr V V D'w r#0? D W 3
y sI$jk PBjjBbR Ys Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt $R ABZtII $P Y'TPZt{$Bt $R ABZtII yt 3$Z ; b }${ZI RB8 $t4Zt{ PZt{$BtR PB s A$%s$s tB8sj I$R$AZ$Bt I b$Y sRRB{$sI RR$Bt }ss8R ) ( stI # ) d G R Ys p1
N7 $R tBtTBAZR R$t{
$ YsR st ZtABZtII $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt wqY$R bsR sjsIk tB${I Ak iB8sts99$ d1D VjBt Y RR$Bt j$t r ) L#? bY Y BBI j%s }B$tR s Y $t4Zt{ BbR Y PsRR B $tht$k 3B Ud b Ys% st ZtABZtII $t4Zt{ PB p1Nd AZ Btjk $t
Y ? I${$Bt ytII $ $R ,tBbt Ys Ud $R BAZR b$Y R}{ B %${sj BZj$R AZ
As,R IBbt $t }Rt{ BP js j%s }B$tR pBBI j%s }B$tR 8sk j Y $t4Zt{ Bt Y p1TRs$R${tI B $tht$k bY$j AsI j%s }B$tR wb$Y YZ ? %sjZR stI Ps
sbsk PB8 Y RR$Bt j$tD {st Ys% st ZtABZtII ts$% $t4Zt{ Bt Y 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t PB Y Ud R$8sB qY $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt PBp1N7 $R ABZtII stI
I$R{ Bt$tZBZR R 3$Z ; Vs$t BBI j%s }B$tR $t{ sR Y %sjZ BP p1
U-C AZ
Btjk B s {s$t -t WB Ys $t s js 9Bt BZj$R Ys% 9B $t4Zt{ %t bYt Yk s AsI j%s }B$tR qY$R $R A{sZR Yk Ys% s R$8$js $t4Zt{ Bt Y R}sI BPr
sR Bt Y R}sI BP Y R$IZsjR sI j%s }B$tR b$Y st BZjk$tr %sjZ s Ys8jRR stI $% s 9B %sjZ PB {Bww?, rD, p1
N7, ID !t Y BY YstI AsI j%s }B$tR b$Y
tBt BZjk$t r%sjZR Ys% s ts$% AZ ABZtII $t4Zt{ 3B Y $b$Y 7TR$8sB b BAs$t st $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt bY${Y jBB,R j$, s R8BBYI %R$Bt BP Y N7 RZj stI YsR Y Rs8 {Yss{$R${R
qY BRRTB RtR$$%$k BP Yp1
CTPZt{$Btsj $R IhtI sR Y 8s-$8sj $t4Zt{ Ys st
BAR%s$Bt {st Ys% ]BtR$I Y PBjjBb$t bB -8 {sRRd bY C$R st TR$8sB
BP R{sj
d qY BAR%s$Bt w?, rD PBjjBbR }P{jk Y RR$Bt j$t r ) ?0#L yP b j ?
dqs, # W) ( BYb$R {B # (
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 X -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 Y -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 IF LS -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 X -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 Y -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 IF L1 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 X -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 Y -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 IF LMS -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 X -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 Y -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 IF BS 3$Z ;U _jBR BP {Bww?, rD, p1
C, ID $t Y {jsRR${sj {sR PB Y Ud R$8sB PB Y N7
stI PB Y $b$Y 7TR$8sB qY I$R$AZ$Bt I $R A$%s$s tB8sj b$Y 1 ) (3x
tI B $tht$k Yt Y $t4Zt{ Bt Y p1 C PZt{$Btsj b$jj A{B8 8s-$8sj L ) RZ} w?,rD{Bww?, rD, p 1 C, ID ) 1wd 1D oB(>'IwDH'w D3
G {Bt{jZI Ys BBI j%s }B$tR Ys% 8s-$8sj stI }BR$$% $t4Zt{ Bt Y 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t
1 qs, r) V stI j ?tI B $tht$k Yt b s{Y ) $tP w?,rD{Bww?, rD, p 1 C, ID ) 1wd 1D oB(>'IwDH'w D3
7B bjj {YBRt AsI j%s }B$tR b$jj I{sR Yp1
C WB Ys tB sjj AsI j%s
}B$tR b$jj I{sR Y %sjZ BP Y 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t sR {st A Rt PB8 3$Z ; G {Bt{jZI Ys Y BRRTB RtR$$%$k BP p1 C $R $%t Ak wp1 C, ID ) 8s-w/L/,//D ) 1wd 1D oB(>'IwDH'w D3 WB Ys wp1
C, ID {B$t{$IR w-{} Ak s {BtRst Ps{BD b$Y Y BRRTB RtR$$%$k
PB Y {jsRR BP TR$8sBR b$Y tsj R{sj sR IhtI $t OBYs$ m s8s wdD qY t- YB8 jjR ZR bY${Y 'TPZt{$Bt k$jIR Y jBbR BRRTB RtR$$%$k G Rsk Ys $ $R BR TiBAZR w{P <s8}j iBt{Y$ iBZRRZb m 7sYj dME } dnnD b$Y$t Y {jsRR BP p1
C 8sRZR AsRI Bt st TR$8sB BP R{sj y $R st $88I$s {BtRJZt{ BP
qYB8 n1 BP OBYs$ stI s8s wdD
qYB8 1 *tB w?D ) WI
(w?DbW(w?D Y R{B PZt{$Bt sRRB{$sI b$Y Y I$R$AZT
$Bt B( Rs$RPk$t wBD 7Z}}BR Ys ?w?Dd YsR s Zt$JZ }BR$$% BB V8Bt sjj 'TPZt{$Bt Rs$RPk$t wiD Y PZt{$Bt
'wrD ) {w/r/k D 8$t$8$9R wp1
C, ID
VR b Ys% Rt $t 7{$Bt 1 Y$R 'TPZt{$Bt $R sRRB{$sI b$Y s NsR +Zst$j BP 7JZsR R$8sB 3B s psZRR$st B I$R$AZ$Bt ) d stI Y B}$8sj JZst$j JZsjR 1 wdDd ) (3EM {BR}BtI$t b$Y s BRRTB RtR$$%$k BP wd1D$1$3 y $R
RB8YBb RZ}$R$t Ys Y N7 $R jRR jB{sjjk BAZR Yst st N+7TR$8sB b$Y JZst$j EM0 wqY$R B}$8sj JZst$j BP EM0 YsR sjRB At BAs$tI Ak OBYs$ m s8s wdD AZ $t s I$&t {Bt-D G b$jj {sjj Y$R 8BR TiBAZR R$8sB Y N+7n1 R$t{ $ YsR s As,IBbt }B$t BP n10 yt Y t- sAj b $% Y %sjZR BP Y BRRTB RtR$$%$k js$% B $R 8$t$8Z8 %sjZ
wp1
C, ID
wd1D$1$ wnxD
PB I$&t R{sj 8sRZR C stI I s 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj I$R$AZ$Bt
qsAj dU ijs$% BRRTB RtR$$%$$R wnxD PB R%sj R$8sBR
N7 Nd N7 7 71x N+7n1 Nq7
js$% BRRTB RtR$$%$k dd1 d1;n dnM d dx;n
G R Ys Y N7 $R {jBR B Y 8$t$8sj %sjZ BP wp1
C, ID qY $b$Y 7TR$8sB
b$Y x(0 As,IBbt }B$t $R t$Y jBR$t 8Z{Y BRRTB RtR$$%$k b Y B}$8sj }B{IZ AZ Y jBRR $t{sR $P Y As,IBbt %sjZ I{sRR B 1x0
; ]BthIt{ $t%sjR PB
1qYst,R B Y }{I$t RZjR b {st {BtRZ{ s {BthIt{ $t%sj PB Y }B}Zjs$Bt }ss8 BP 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt <PB b ZR Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt sR st YZ$R${ BBj B {B8}Z Y sRk8}B${ %s$st{U $P Y PZt{$Btsj p1
C $R XRZ^{$tjk Zjs" Yt $ zDp1 C 1 i Q ]w(, \C~wp1 CDD, bY \C~wp1 CD )oI>{Bww , VD, p1C, ID1H
w<s8}j iBt{Y$ iBZRRZb m 7sYj dME } 11ED G JZ$ $t Y$R 7{$Bt Ys I
$R s 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj I$R$AZ$Bt stI b$jj ItB Y {Z8Zjs$% I$R$AZ$Bt PZt{$Bt BP s Zt$%s$s RstIsI tB8sj
3B Y NsR 7JZsR }B{ IZ qYB8 d $%R \C~wp1
N7D ) ;1wd1D1 PB ( c c d3 7$t{ Y$R sRk8}B${ %s$st{ I}tIR Bt $ $R {ZRB8sk B s}}jk Y 3$RY stRPB8s$Bt k$jI$t
$
zDstYdwp
N7DstYdwDi Q ]w(,dD,
stI sR x0 {BthIt{ $t%sj PB stYdwD
stYdwp
N7D d$3Ez3
yt Y {jsRR${sj {sR %t -s{ ht$TRs8}j I$R$AZ$Btsj RZjR -$R R sjsIk 3$RY wd1MD
3B Y BAZR {sR \C~wp1
CD I}tIR $t s {B8}j${sI bsk Bt VjRB Y b s}}jk
Y 3$RY stRPB8s$Bt YB}$t Ys $ b$jj RsA$j$9 Y %s$st{U
$
zwstYdwp
CDstYdwDDQ ]w(,1wo\>w'IwDDHD1D,
bY \wD ) o>\'w~ LJ0d1D'wJDi1H b$Y J stI ~ bB $tI}tIt RstIsI
tB8sj %s$sAjR yt }s{${ b b$jj ZR sR x0 {BthIt{ $t%sj PB stYdwDU
stYdwp CDd3EP$wpzCD w;dD b$Y PwpCD ) \wpCD p1 Co >'IwDH13 w;1D
qY JZst$k \wpCD stI Yt{ PwpCD {st sR$jk A {B8}ZI ZR$t tZ8${sj $tT
s$Bt yt 3$Z x PwpCD $R }jBI PB s $I BP pC %sjZR stI PB Y N7 Ud 7 stI
N7 AsRI 8YBI y $R {BtRst stI JZsj B d PB N7 3B Ud stI 7 b BAs$t RjBbjk
I{sR$t j$tR RYBb$t Ys b st sj8BR {BtRst %s$st{ PB Y 3$RY stPB8I R$8sBR BP 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt 3B N7 Y 3$RY stPB8s$Bt $R tB RZ{{I$t $t RsA$j$9$t Y sRk8}B${ %s$st{ stI %k js {BthIt{ $t%sjR s BAs$tI PB R8sjj %sjZR BP 3$Z x {jsk RYBbR Y I$&t{R $t ^{$t{k Abt Y I$&t s}}Bs{YRU Y b$IY BP Y {BthIt{ $t%sjR PB Ud s JZ$ {jBR B YBR BP N7 PB
Y 7 R$8sB b sjsIk jBR JZ$ RB8 ^{$t{k bY$j Y $t^{$t{k BP Y N7 }B{IZ $R sj8BR }BY$A$$%1 yt BI B BAs$t R8sjj {BthIt{ $t%sjR bY$j tB
jBR$t BB 8Z{Y BAZRtRR Y 71x {BZjI A ZRI
k h$t {Z%R B Y }B$tR $t 3$Z x sRk B $8}j8t stI -8jk s{{Zs s}}B-$8s$BtR BP PwpCD Ys% At BAs$tI qYk s }BI $t qsAj 1 wsjRB PB 71x
1y $R bjj ,tBbt Ys Y N7 RR$Bt R$8sB YsR s {Bt%t{ s RjBb Ys zdb1 stI {st
YPB A Rs$I B Ys% s 9B ^{$t{k Z Y {BR}BtI$t R$8sB BP 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt b$jj R$jj A sRk8}B${sjjk tB8sj PB k (
Rs W(Rs) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1234 567 LMS BS L1 LS
3$Z xU PwpCD I8$t$t Y b$IY BP Y {BthIt{ $t%sj PB stYdwD sR s
PZt{$Bt BP pC PB Y UC Ud $b$Y C stI U-C AsRI }B{IZR
stI N+7n1D stI }${ZI $t 3$Z x 3$tsjjk b {sjj Ys Y PB8ZjsR PB PwpCD Ys%
At I$%I ZtI Y sRRZ8}$Bt BP 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj$k bY${Y $R s JZ$ R${$% {BtI$$Bt
x ]Bt{jZR$Bt
qY {jsRR${sj {B^{$t BP I8$ts$Bt $R %k RtR$$% B BZj$R yt Y$R }s} b RZI$I Y p1
C Rs$R${sRRB{$sI b$Y BAZR RR$Bt R$8sBR AsRI Bt 8$t$8$9$t
R$8sBR BP R{sj k {B8}Z$t $t4Zt{ PZt{$BtR b Rsb B bY${Y -t BAR%s$BtR qsAj 1U V}}B-$8s$BtR B PwpCD IhtI $t w;1D PB R%sj RR$Bt R$8sBR N7 PwpCD ) d Ud PwpCDd31x(31;pCL (3(Ep1C 7 PwpCDd3M(31EpC(31p1C 71x PwpCDd3dx(3(dpC(3(p1C N7 PwpCDd3Eb$pC N+7n1 PwpCDd31b$pC Nq7 PwpCDn3M13xdpCL (3x(p1C d;
{st $t{sR B I{sR p1
C G sjRB PBZtI Y R$8sB BP RJZsI 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt
Ys%$t Y jBbR BRRTB RtR$$%$k PB Y {jsRR BP TR$8sBR BP R{sj esRk ZjR B {BtRZ{ {BthIt{ $t%sjR sBZtI Yp1
CT{B^{$tR b BAs$tI $t {sR BP 8Zj$%s$s
tB8sj$k
!P {BZR Y s RB8 j$8$s$BtR B BZ RZIk 3B{ZR $t Y }s} bsR Bt RR$Bt R$8sBR AsRI Bt Y 8$t$8$9s$Bt BP TR$8sBR Z qYB8 d {BZjI sjRB A s}T }j${sAj B Y {jsRR BP+TR$8sBR wOBYs$ m s8s dMMD bY${Y s AsRI Bt 8$t$8$9$t s
+TR$8sB BP R{sj qY 8sRZ w11D {st sjRB A {B8}ZI PB YNsR q$88I 7JZsR B Nq7 R$8sB BP iBZRRZb wdM;D 3B Y$R R$8sB b %$hI Ys _B}BR$$Bt 1 s}}j$R Ak }Z$t 'w`D ) 8s-w`1, D PB Y s}}B}$s {BtRst qY js$% BRRTB
RtR$$%$k s psZRR$st I$R$AZ$BtR BP Nq7 JZsjR dx;n bY${Y $R sY js {B8}sI B Y BY R$8sBR b {BtR$II ]BthIt{ $t%sjR {st A {BtRZ{I ZR$t PB8Zjs w;dD b$Y PwpUx CD $%t $t qsAj 1
R$IR Ys Y -$R 8stk RR$Bt R$8sB tB IhtI Ak 8$t$8$9$t s R{sj 8sRZ VR st -s8}j b s, Y --TR$8sB wOBYs$ dMD IhtI sR Y 8$t$8$9
BP z
3
7)d
'wr7#|0?(7D
b$Y |( st $t$sj Y$Y As,IBbt R$8s BP R$IZsj R{sj Vt s{{B8}stk$t p1TRs$R${
$R IhtI sR p1 ) d z 7)d'wr7 |# 0?7| |( D z 7)d'wr7| V|( D 3
stI $8}j8tI $t 7T}jZR 1((( wd } 1MxD qY sAB% Rs$R${$R RZjk s 8sRZ BP -}js$tI %s$s$Bt BP Y R}BtR %s$sAj AZ $ $R tB st R$8sB BP Y 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t yP Y Iss {B8 PB8 s 8Zj$%s$s tB8sj Yt Y$R {B^{$t tIR B
d o >'wDH
o >'wb0d1DH
bY${Y Btjk JZsjR 1 $t {sR BP s JZsIs${ jBRRTPZt{$Bt *}tI$t Z}Bt Y %sjZ BP1
Y 8sk A JZ$ s A$sR wsjRB bYt tB BZj$R s }RtD bYt ZR$t Y$R s}}Bs{Y qY p1
CTRs$R${{BZjI A ZRI B R Y 8BIj wddD ss$tR Y tZjj 8BIj wdnD qY
sRRB{$sI BTR $R $%t Ak
B ) p1CbwzD
wdp1
CDbwdD3
_B}$R stI ht$TRs8}j AYs%$B BP Y sAB% R Rs$R${s RZI$I $t ]BZ- m *YBt w1((dD WB Ys 8stk }B}BRsjR PB BAZR RR $t Y j$ts 8BIj Ys% sjsIk At 8sI $t Y j$sZ w s,sBZ m < d;D AZ Y R$8s$Bt BP Y 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt {B^{$t {$%I 8Z{Y jRR st$Bt
Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt stsjkR$R {BZjI sjRB A Rt sR R}{$sj {sR BP {stBt${sj {Bjs$Bt stsjkR$R bY${Y YsR At BAZR$hI Ak ]BZ- m *YBt w1((dD qY$R s}}Bs{Y {BtR$RR BP R$8s$t BAZRjk Y {B%s$st{ 8s${R s}}s$t $t -}RR$Bt wnnD qYR 8Zj$}j {Bjs$Bt 8sRZR YBb% s tB jBt $t}sAj sR XY }{ts BP R}sI BP r
-}js$tI Ak ?" stI $ $R 8Z{Y jRR tsZsj B ZR Y8 sR st p1T8sRZ $t s RR$Bt
{Bt-V{,tBbjI8t G b$RY B Yst, Y P PB ZRPZj 8s,R stI R}{$sjjk PB RZR$t JZs$Bt wn;D B ZR
E
V}}tI$-_BBP BP _B}BR$$Bt dU k wndD b 8sk b$ p1 Cw\ LK, V LD ) d 8$tK, K#C1w V Lw\0#KD0 K0#KKD 8$tK(C1w V LK(D ) d 8$tK, K#C1wV w \0#KD0 K0#LKK D 8$tK(C1wV K(D ) d 8$t8$t,#C1wV #0 D (C1wV (D bY b R ) wKLK0#KDb # )\0#b ,K stI ( ) wK(Db 3 WB$t Ys Y $R sBtTBTBt js$BtRY$} Abt w, #D stI wK,#KD ht$RYR Y }BBP
_BBP BP qYB8 dU k Iht$$Bt BP Y $t4Zt{ PZt{$Bt stI wndD b Ys% PB stk w?, rD;{p{pU {Bww?, rD, p1 C, ID ) (( w d Cd1wID C1 (wID W /)( ) 1n V w (( C(wID/)( V (( CdwID/)( W , wEdD
R$t{ C(wID )V stI CdwID ) 3WBb b { B8}Z Y I$%s$% s ) ( BP CdwID ) CD4wV KwID0 ywIDD L wd4DwrKwID?ywIDDi
bY 4 $R s tBZjj$ %s$sAj A$t JZsj B d b$Y }BAsA$j$k wdD stI 9B BYb$R
*tB /dwD ) w, ywID, KwIDD stI
/1w, y, KD )CD4wV K0 yD L wd4DwrK0?yDi
PB sjj k(, y;{p, K;{p 7$t{ C
dwID )/1w/dwDD Y {Ys$t ZjR k$jIR ( (CdwID/)( ) ( (/1w, , #D/)(L ( (y/1w(, y, #D/y) ( (ywID/)(L ( (K/1w(, , KD/K)# ( (KwID/)(, wE1D bY b ZRI ywID ) stI KwID )# 7$t{ /1w(, y, #D )CwL wyDD stI /1w(, , KD ) CwL w#KD0 D bY RstIR tBb PB Y B 8 b Ys% Ys Y jsR bB 8R $t
wE1D s JZsj B 9B wYPB b ZR Y {BtI$$Bt Bt CD eJZs$Bt wE1D R$8}j$hR Yt B ( (CdwID/)( ) ( (CwwdDBLr#0?D/)( ) (( CwwdDB(Lwr#0?DbD/)( ) {Bwr#0?, C, B(D wEnD
bY B $R Y B I$R$AZ$Bt stI Ak ZR$t R{sj JZ$%s$st{ BPC
yt s R$8$js bsk b {st RYBb Ys
(
(C(wID/)( )V{Bw
r V
V , C, B(D3 wE;D
ytR$t wEnD stI wE;D $tB wEdD k$jIR
{Bww?, rD, p1 C, ID ) 1 1 1 V w {Bwr V V , C, B(D{Bw r#0? , C, B(D W k wn1D Y RZjR PBjjBbR
_BBP BP _B}BR$$Bt 1U G b$jj RYBb Ys C Rs$RhR Y {BtI$$Bt BP qYB8 d qY RZj PBjjBbR Yt $88I$sjk R$t{ $ $R bjj ,tBbt Ys
{Bw?, C, B(D ) 'w?oDoB(>'w?DH B(>'Iw?D?H
PB TR$8sBR BP R{sj w <ZA dMd }s d(D qs, y ; {p stI K ; {p Yt b
Ys% Ys Xwy, KD )CwLK0 LyD %$hR
8
'wLXwKy, K0?LD yDQBwDQtw?D ) { BtRst, wExD
bY t stI B $R $tI}tIt BP *$&t$s$t ABY R$IR BP wExD b$Y R}{ B K stI %sjZs$t s wy, KD ) w(,(D k$jIR 8 'Iw Dw ? 1 ( (KXwy, KD/K)(DQBwDQtw?D ) (, wEED
R$t{ )Xw(,(D k { BtI$$Bt w3DoB>'IwDH ) ( stI wEED IZ{R B
oB>'IwDH(K( Xwy, KD/K)() (3 wED
k Rk88k oB(>'IwDH k ( RB Ys wED $8}j$R (K(Xwy, KD/K)( ) ( yt s R$8$js bsk $
{st A RYBbt Ys (
(yXwy, KD/y)( ) (
iPt{R
VtIRBtT7}{Y i V wd;D XBIj ]B8}s$RBt stI p1"qY V8${st 7s$R${$st
;M ddnudd
]BZ- ] stI *YBt ] w1((dD XVtsjkR {stBt$JZ AsR? RZ IR R$8sZR BAZRR I js 8s${ I { B%s$st{ " i%Z I 7s$R$JZ V}}j$JZ? B s}}s
]BZ- ] stI *YBt ] XqY 3TR PB Y$Y As,IBbt BAZR RR$Bt" $t }}ss$Bt <s8}j 3 i iBt{ Y$ e iBZRRZb _ F stI 7sYj G V wdMED iBAZR 7s$RT
${RU qY V}}Bs{Y sRI Bt yt4Zt{ 3Zt{$BtR Wb OB,U FBYt G$jk stI 7BtR <ZA _ F wdMdD iBAZR 7s$R${R Wb OB,U FBYt G$jk
FBYtRBt i V stI G${Yt * G wdMDV}}j$I Zj$%s$s 7s$R${sj VtsjkR$R PBZY I$$Bt _t${ <sjj ytts$Btsj eI$$BtR
3$RY iV wd1MD _B{I$tR BP Y iBksj 7B{$k NBtIBt V d1d Ex;TEn
%sjRY q ! wdMxD X]sZ$Btsk tB sABZ p1" qY V8${st 7s$R${$st n 1u
1Mx
s,sBZ stI < wd;D BZtII $t4Zt{ stI Y$Y As,IBbt }B$t R$t }B{IZR $t j$ts 8BIjR" FBZtsj BP Y V8${st 7s$R${sj VRRB{$s$Bt M x;nu x;
{st F G stI 7$%R p N wdMD X]B^{$tR BP I8$ts$Bt PB jsR sARBjZ I%$s$Bt stsjkR$R" 7s$R${R stI _BAsA$j$k NR x ;ux;
iB8sts99$ wd1D Xyt4Zt{ $t {stBt${sj {Bjs$Bt stsjkR$R" _Rk{YB8$,s x 1nu1x
iBZRRZb _ F wdM;D XNsR I$st BP 7JZsR RR$Bt" FBZtsj BP Y V8${st 7s$R${sj VRRB{$s$Bt MduMM(
iBZRRZb _ F stI NBk V wdMD iBAZR iRR$Bt stI !Zj$ *{$Bt Wb OB,U FBYt G$jk
iBZRRZb _ F stI OBYs$ z F wdM;D iBAZR RR$Bt Ak 8stR BP 7TR$8sBR ytU 3st, F <[sIj G s$t i* weIRD iBAZR stI WBtj$ts q$8 7$R VtsjkR$R N{Z WBR $t 7s$R${R 1E Wb OB,U 7}$t zjs
7T_jZR 1((( pZ$I B 7s$R${R zBjZ8 d wdD *ss VtsjkR$R _BIZ{R *$%$R$Bt sYT RBP 7sjj GV
OBYs$ z F wdMD X<$Y As,IBbt }B$t stI Y$Y PP${ $t{ k BAZR R$8sR PB RT R$Bt" qY VttsjR BP 7s$R${Rdx E;1TExE
OBYs$ z F stI s8s i < wdMMD X<$Y As,IBbtT}B$t R$8sR BP RR$Bt Ak 8stR BP Y 8$t$8$9s$Bt BP st ^{$t R{sj" FBZtsj BP Y V8${st 7s$R${sj VRT RB{$s$Bt Mn ;(Eu;dn
OBYs$ z F stI s8s i < wdD X!}$8sj jB{sjjk BAZR -TR$8sR BP RR$Bt" FBZtsj BP 7s$R${sj _jstt$t stI ytPt{ E; 1 n(un1n
G$jj F stI 7$t F * wdMMD XVtBY {sZ$Btsk tB sABZ p1 U $R ZR $t
b$YI jsR RJZsR RR$Bt stsjkR$R" qY V8${st 7s$R${$st ;1 1nEu1nM
