Arde'et: The Magic Book of the Disciples
Author(s): Enno Littmann
Reviewed work(s):
Source: Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 25 (1904), pp. 1-48
Published by:
American Oriental Society
Stable URL:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/592548
.
Accessed: 25/10/2012 13:38
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
.
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
.
American Oriental Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of
the American Oriental Society.
JOURNAL
OF THE
AMERICAN
ORIENTAL
SOCIETY.
Arde'et: Tke lJfagie Book of the Di8ieples.-By
Dr. ENNO LITTMANN, Princeton University, Princeton, N. J.FOLKLORE
and the science of comparative religion have
made much progress within the last quarter of the past century:
the magic superstitions and popular religious beliefs of all
peoples have been studied, and the results of such studies have,
often with marked success, been applied to certain phases of
the history of the great religions of the world. For instance,
the idea of the name of God, as represented in the Old and
New Testaments, has gained an entirely new aspect and has
been discussed in a much more plausible manner than ever
before, since ethnology and folklore have contributed to its
elucidation.' This instance has been chosen here instead of a
great many others, because it touches directly upon the contents
of the Ethiopic book published and translated in the follow-
ing pages.
Abyssinia is a mine of superstitions and magic practices, and
many of them have been written down in the Ethiopic language.
A large part of the Ethiopic literature, therefore, is magic
literature. This, however, has attracted very few scholars, no
doubt partly owing to the crabbedness of the subject, but
partly also to the fact that there have been but few workers in
the field. Except the French translations of several magic
I See Fr. Giesebrecht, Die alttestamentliche
Schdtzung des Gottesna- mens, Konigsberg, 1901 (especially p. 6). Wilhelm Heitmiuller, " Im Namen Jesu." Gittingen, 1903.
2 E. Littmnanm, [1904.
prayers, published by Professor Basset in his Apocryphes tthi- opiens, very little has been done in this line.' But I trust that the time will come when the abundant Ethiopic material will be available for students of folklore and magic.
Among the Ethiopic magic books, the one commonly called Arde'et, i. e. " the Disciples," is held very precious by the Abyssinians, and is of interest to us in more than one respect. It tells how Jesus taught the Disciples his secret names, among them the " great name ;" how the Disciples went about per- forming miracles by the power of Christ's name, and were themselves saved by it from the wrath of the people of Sodom and Gomorrha and from many kings and rulers; and finally, how Jesus showed them hell and paradise. The whole is inter- woven with a number of long prayers which sometimes, as e. g. in chapters IV and VI, are real compendiums of Abyssinian magic.'
Some of the traditions set forth in this book are undoubtedly as early as the first centuries of the Christian era; this is proved by the fact that we find them in gnostic literature. Among these the most striking is the legend of the journey of the Apostles to hell and paradise, led by Christ; the same was known to the gnostics, as we see from C. Schmidt's .Uitersu- ch~ungen uiber die gnostischen Werke.3 Other parallels are the
following: In VIII, 15 Jesus forbids his Disciples to reveal the secrets which they have heard; the same is told in gnostic works.4 In VIII, 16 seq. we read that the secrets revealed here are given to no one else except Mary, John " the Virgin," Abraham, and Moses; this is to be compared with the gnostic tradition that John 7rapfvos was the highest among the Disciples.
Our book, however, speaks of John " the Virgin" as being the Baptist, because the other John was included among the Disciples. Finally we may cite here the " great name " (VIII, 24), which seems to have played an important role in the gnostic
' See also Dr. K. Fries' edition and translation of The Ethiopic Legend of Socinius and Ursula, in Actes du VIIIe Congres International des Orientalistes, and my article The Princeton Ethiopic Magic Scroll, in The Princeton University Bulletin, vol. xv., pp. 31-42.
2 See especially IV, 20 and VI, 11.
3Gnostische Schriften in Koptischer Sprache. Leipzig, 1892 (Texte und
Untersuchungen VIII), p. 464.
Vol. xxv.] 4rcde'et: The lJfagic Book of the Disciples. 3 system.' This tends to show that there are at least certain elements in "Arde'et" that are to be connected with apocry- phal ideas of ancient Christianity. A more detailed discussion of these questions, and particularly a full enquiry into the literary composition and the derivation of Chapters II-VII cannot be given here. I hope that somebody more fit for this work than myself may soon undertake the study. For the present, attention may be called to the following:
It seems to me safe to conclude that the Ethiopic Arde'et, in the form in which we have it now, was composed at some time between the 14th and 17th centuries A. D. The term)ninus ad quewn is given by the fact that manuscripts containing this work belong to the 17th or 18th century;2 the other date is naturally suggested (1) by the Amharic influence which appears through- out the book, showing itself in grammatical constructions, order of words, neglect of the cases, etc.; and (2) by the history of Ethiopic literature; for in the 14th century there was much literary activity in Abyssinia, especially during the reign of Zar'a Ya'qob, and a number of magic books are known to have been translated or composed at that time,3 among others a magic work which seems to be closely related to Arde'et, viz. Asmcta Egz^'entI "The Names of our Lord." Now the ques- tion arises at once whether Arde'et is an original Abyssinian composition, or whether it is a translation like the larger part of Ethiopic literature. The parallels quoted in the foregoing paragraph do not afford conclusive evidence; for the hypotheti-. cal author of Arde'et may have read them elsewhere and adopted them into his own composition. However this may be, we must count with the fact that there is (A) a long and (B) a short recension of Arde'et: the former is represented by the text published here; the latter by Basset's translation, published in his A4pocr-yphes ?th'iopiens.4 The short recension corresponds to ch. II, 17-30 and ch. VIII of the longer one, i. e. it gives only the names of Christ and the vision of hell. Moreover, we
I Ib. p. 197.
2 Conti Rossini, Note per la storia letteraria abissina, p. 51, mentions a manuscript in the British Museum, Or. 65, belonging to the XVI. cen- tury, but in Wright's Catalogue no Or. 65 is to be found.
3 See Conti Rossini, 1. c., ? 18.
4 E. Littmn2tn [1904.
must take into consideration that a number of passages in A describing Abyssinian magic practices can scarcely have been translated, and again that there are other passages which seem to have been badly translated from a foreign language; among others the word Kfrdbos in VIII, 18 may be due to a wrong reading of an Arabic word (Qpnxi@ for U )o and the name Latandwi' may be explained from the Arabic. I conjec- ture, therefore, that the author (or compiler) of Arde'et had certain translations before him-perhaps chiefly chapters
II,
VIII, IX-and that he worked them over and incorporated them into his work, which, after all, may contain very little written by the man himself. Whatever the relation between recensions A and B may be, there is no doubt that, in spite of the somewhat rugged disposition of the matters and the abrupt transitions, the longer recension was compiled with the intention to make the whole a single connected narrative. This is shown by introduction and conclusion; ch. I, 5-7 gives a very brief idea of what is to be found in the ensuing work and refers to several of the events narrated in chs.
II
seq.; and again the verses IX, 8 seq. recapitulate what has been told in the entire book.A few words remain to be said here on what Arde'et contrib- utes toward our knowledge of the so-called "philosophy of names." Although the idea of the power of the "name"1 rulls
like a red thread through the whole book, and thus furnishes new material concerning the results reached by the recitation of names, the list of such names and their translations, given in ch. II, 18 seq., is perhaps even more interesting. For here we learn that, notwithstanding all the humbug and ignorance connected with the " names " and the epiesia graminmata, a great many of them had originally a definite meaning which was in keeping with the derivation of the word. In Awmau'Zl, "forgiver" (II, 20) we easily recognize the Hebrew bKfl2
"God is gracious "; Geyoim " rich " (ibid.) is very probably the Hebrew MY.V; and if LcthCk-, LchCun, Lahd2m is interpreted
' See below, p. 5. 2 Cf.
bNI~M and
bK::M
in Schwab, Vocabulaire de 1'Angaologie,Paris, 1897, p, 130.
Vol. xxv.] 1de'et: The 2lfgig- Boo of <the Disciples. 5 here (II, 29) "god of gods," we see that the original meaning of the Aramaic 'Wllchda or the Arabic 'iljh is still reflected; Meuidter "all-keeper" (II, 24) seems to go back through a Greek MEvaT(T)rqp to a Hebrew-Aramaic KC)i'; JCmya " wise " (II, 20) may be derived from the Hebrew
1,fl2
another form for 11.VV7 1God erects," but its meaning here has been influenced by that of the Ethiopic word K}>nyO,3 which corresponds to theGreek TEXV&TVs. If we consider how often these names must have been copied and recopied, and through how many languages and hands they must have passed, it is only remarkable that there really are some words which are still intelligible. At the same time we see ag-ain that a large number of these " names " originated in Hebrew or Aramaic, and that Jewish demonology and angelology had a very widespread influence among the Christians of many different nations. Other hebrew names represented in our list, which have lost their original meanings, are: Iyhthe (vs. 18), Y-tiu (vs. 26), both as it seems to me, stand- ing for law or Yahweh4; 8Mtrcah (vs. 18, standing for Sfirihel ?), with which we may compare InllD or bKlj or
J)enthUl (vs. 18)6; AhfibyCtr and leniyCWr- (vs. 19) correspond to the hebrew forms I1'1nNX and IyFU'Jl C (vs. 22)=
\NIY; Am.u2 Ct'Jl (vs. 22)
=
9; if 'bl (vs. 23) = '2X'1n ?1oJCIryK~ (v. 23) is probably some derivative of the Aramaic
A-cirit; also the names 'El, 'El&lu, Sh'&tbO<Jt,`2 LT1')-l are recog-
nized to be Hebrew at first appearance. There may be one name in this list which is to be explained from the Arabic, viz:
Lantwan ; "he does not delay" (vs. 22); for this may be
:,s
M.
But
anumber of Greek names also are to be found
among the Abyssinian (3p/hesiat gramml)autct: I believe that most of the names ending ill -as at least have passed through the Greek. Such names in -as occur quite frequently in Ethiopic magic literature; six different names are given, e. g., in Arde'et,
'Cf. 10, ib., p. 186. 2 See Ee , ib., p. 156.
3 This is sometimes used as an attribute of God or Christ; see Dill-
mann, Lex. Aeth., s. v.
4 See Schwab, 1. c., pp. 141, 142, 290. 5
Ib., pp. 195, 196, 230.
6 lb., p. 104.
I This is an Old Testament name; cf. Schwab, 1. c., p. 37.
81b., p. 144. 9Ib., p.212. 10 Ib., p.70.
6 E. Littmcan, [1904. ch. VIII, 24. In this list, again, we meet several Hebrew names, but it would lead me too far here to treat of all these in detail. In conclusion, I wish to refer to the parallel passages given by Basset, in his Apocryp hes Athiolpiens, VIII, pp. 6 and 7, footnotes, and to the very instructive and interesting discus- sion of the "philosophy of names" by Tleitmiiller in his book "1In XAinmen Jesu," Zweiter Teil, -Religionsgeschichtliche Un- tersuchung, especially pp. 156 seq.
The mcnuscript from which the following text is published was acquired in 1900 in Jerusalem, and forms now No. 4 of my small collection of Ethiopic manuscripts. It consists of 81 leaves of heavy parchment, measuring 19 X 13 centimeters. The written space measures 13 X 10 centimeters on an average. This space is divided into two columns with a space of 1 cm. between them, each column containing 19 lines of bold but very regular and well executed writing. The character of the script and the condition of the parchment indicate that the manuscript is scarcely later than the 17th century.
Leaf 1 is blank. Fol. 2 ro-34 vo contain a copy of Arde'et; fol. 35 ro-51 ro the prayer of Mary at BThrt6s; fol. 51 vo-81 ro the prayer of Cyprian.' The manuscript was written for a cer- tain Gabra GIrgis, whose name appeared at the end of a num- ber of inserted invocations, but has been erased almost throughout the book. Such insertions are known to be very common in Ethiopic prayers. They are doubtless in many cases later addi- tions, but sometimes it seems as though they belonged to the originals. All of them, however, are indicated in my transla- tion by smaller type. I thought it worth while to edit this text in Ethiopic, even from a single manuscript; for it is desirable that some, at least, of the Ethiopic magic books should be pub- lished in the originals. On the other hand, I scarcely believe that a comparison of many manuscripts would be of much avail in this case, particularly as my copy is one of the oldest of this book and presents on the whole a reasonably accurate text; I have, therefore, dispensed with an elaborate apparatus criticus. There are, of course, some mistakes which I have attempted to correct from the context. Every case in which my edition dif-
I Both were translated by Professor Basset in his Apocryphes Ethio-
Vol. xxv.] Arcde'et: Rihe Magic Book of the Disciples. 7
fers from the manuscript has been indicated, except the punc- tuation, which I have changed in a few cases in order to make clearer the division of the sentences. WTords which I propose to omit are enclosed in parentheses, whereas brackets indicate additions of my own. I have also deemed it desirable to divide the whole into chapters and verses, a division which is not found in the manuscript. Some later reader, however, has indicated a division according to the days of the week by placing, in a very inelegant hand, the words " for Tuesday, etc." on the top margin of certain pages, but it is not always clear where in the text he intended to make the division. We find H'PA-(: on fol.
6
vo; Ht&lO: on 9 vo; Hdewn4A1I on 16 ro;HWC41
:
on 21 ro; MIRYD x on 28 ro.; HOdkf.': on 33 ro. Besides this there are a number of marginal notes added by later hands.The other manuscripts of Arde'et, extant in European libra- ries, are enumerated in Dr. Conti Rossini's Note per la storia letteraria abissinta, p. 51, s. v. Arde'et. In this paragraph we should read "; 18" instead of "? 16." The manuscripts 573, 574, 578 of the British Museum mentioned here do not contain the work ordinarily called " Arde'et," but hymns addressed to the Apostles; a mistake must be contained in the figure 65 (see above, p. 4, footnote).
2ro. flfldI': ATf: Wc tA9: WDomILA,
+M0fl:
W A,"4h 1
F7z
:
AC ?1
Wr:
xWI HhANN
f7c 0H':
?iqfllnlAfiH5MAi
H
WA 2Ake - PC 'W W4fl:t D.l nHiW' ,b ne* :, 3
3
Xli: . OM, W'59H: Ii(:CT: 7'D4,C: W)j"kt H(PIP: -wIDHII HtM<: 19J41,eft P : Wlth AD5Tha XP1 &&D"t : Ae:. 4
04-T: WHVX91 WAUC91:
Meall7: ahes: hav:;Lg.4,
2 vo. on41: I1LtJ'a: WHieef.: XiY'Th,: ih-f.:: (f+ w7Dsift~: '+gP : W(f Ht:q''7uf1
~th
e:M
v ( 6n 5 H9-te,0 :) roust- - aDffaD': has WfiPO LC
liv: 4jTzq,.:- ensV :h M P : 7A: e."Sl e *:
q9~Zt:
t\A.d 6 XOP&PM6 andWfHhat *
W1711f*
av'MCt* en W01 gI Not in MS.; added according to a MS. of the British Museum (Dill- mann, No. LXXVIII).
8
E.
Littmann, [1904.1,jtx Mit (V: Wff. (iCY: 7WtJ94 havD: 9dm: nflo1,E4av k.il'
ftblfl . wDjCteq: Wf*: Ht741Zh &(l"
:
1aXW- 7ACOV'r
aM7T
Wcfl AtHff t nCl+tl:: MRj: HhIAfi, 83 ro.
Itft*: W)OmfwG -, WI" )feP, Wl W htLIfl::
wJhflgg{]
hfl8,e afi:
w+j>l I fbl)iJwaJi7I"I"
Ifl 9wJ4a'7oO:
gy^e
ha',
.eP"e
A~fll:
wDffncI:
7g., haD,
9 10
3
ro.AOCi ii:
wKarG ffflt,:
hlb(':t WilH
2a,.
Ch(V~ilavo A jfww ha w~wo j. a to'tajj -J 7J.hemJI
n,.: t i g 7
(fllJ
It & n-,igafO .
I0'c 7-: 1
3
S.Cq
fl'2hcIJb:: WA MIhX0
: ll WI ' HfMhhD
W 4(XDjaP,
I&b,
eh: KaraD,
4WYnhaD1.
lnlA4}mcsi
h7 . V7C , @fifit 5. H-Cn,. OrE, Wje6,. hav,~. X-f, ACC0i
t0in1, aJSA
.aD'X:
HilzdM,O7+
Mt,
a1v:
i
IF
5
7Ca~lLil:
toeWin,:
&WRI: 11: IPCHD: HJiliMM 4.: tofl'Y.
(34vo.
'flA0-:tW
k.:AhlkJ,
Alt:l. hiA7,; A74 )1; ILrpT~t. X^n,- havibew., wwonhvbat. Pu~ajj, hap,
t&
'1.:
11 (11
:y$f q :00q I:c,
t
WfA, W. C jOfla7L5%
aD': 11*: 7db:: - AAA10 -: hav:.lvMC
w. n ttC7S
J
3
44o.
. t oeAie
l loAa7o, .
ifJto ?I7T4"T.
5,e wje7k]je
wj
Ah n, sAWP. i'q-thibl, nvfi Hhc9thA ^}l Hw6A, ,
4
ro.
f tx.z Alh&9 *C9;U n -o A&VA-,h>?H
b~t~tt)
Nc"1,
HI(41h.-9 thhhh h b^ 7ttN . il Mt}, : iS ^(},MO - H~ehhhf -. hef - HAr - thav Oftlv -.tn h ,tLA-W- 4n4-, Iah- 5+f. (Vl4-b, Wh3@&fi .
H*--^O ihHf 7.O9a7<b
,
)LthDhD ihe1 - A~TaM4 z,j. Wtp*I, a)4t A(. a xe ,D,(0D>,,q{
tf^:
XP~S&Vz, A
A, Pmd,
C~d,{htLA vt4
vo. Avm4&!al"Z HRM6).. H~t - AYIT
o[]f+>^I
A')
ifsq:.
hay .1s0
Aealff. -x Ah7tHLA
&xt
x
7471Ch
x
'illl
Zf' 10
I Ms. A. 2
Vol.
xxv.]
Arde'et: The Magic -Book of the Disciples.
9
I , (OhYON-C Xh-9 , tot?Y5iffif 474ITCh,9l
74'ZVLZ,
11
C7
wCLfrIP:N
41
VA
WU~lh.*P . WaJAh.Th'vI9 : ?41W Wibdf:I&ai"'Y onI, ANN: VIMI h1J, riM WWUP711, M: WAACRA ,
it;
aTW~idEr:
hI?1tW :-tIiiM
1bWJ WhOa: ,C41e(A13
5 ro. I41~A4't: wW'1qkr: fl'tH ll1 nA is I
12
gbueal) wdATfl' : ihh-el:
MA~
WC11'M: iP*e [f]41hiI
OA5$aIP'
nhWIt7Ci: xx flf J nAA.
n
ATf,
MiAeI W)I .atl
ChAWR-bf.
H*
^
:5A S.. YAOYT,.h^
h<+~
31Lbn4. Alit3
a~i,
&gffih,
n .2
h4v.
U..s*
chf3t,
b,
H
woft(^,
A
wCh~aP':, hapD: W911i'tWP
nit
. Wvdtjr: wW9-"d& 'lOS :16
5 Vo.
3(rV': NUSOMl; WI HrVt'lft,W
It:
7?R
nA ftI)SP
f
wgPas, (1O$W3tIJa' rI>P3,~
WW4,a:~S
WLCA4:X [hClki4nn,":: whn
A8~+gfl,~aP'
a :
t S :hLf
i
:9 C, 7c17
37 (040ftg dhC-;LV IIIt 3;vh- -. X, 'H-
9av
17WOIPlq': Alit +bX?-:
Wf7C?:W;L'P-IA~q
! OI* :.1
h701-bPI M
faP; WIAmi.
'llb,C.
vb~lCP:(ONIMd,
>,e4\t Yit:+
-.* hav irekf , hant--'r.l7C
a ,fl1:tI,
(OMAIN.1tVq
S
hDDR,1 ,1 I)Qt ne, 2Dm. SIam.(Dht.{n"~t~(Dsxv, hOD,
t&+^+ ,e~t.
17CV. wH3T.w AYDT s w18
Am 7i-I A-d-Z t - t1Z
(Dh&P
eaYZndh4<,- %en.ah91*,
19C 4flA i: 'IOti:
Ch:t C; 41Z. x
WaID&,x7"
YLtC:4flZA{:] 4u7'Id
AIi'IAti; 4fZA[{:] i"1YL; Wle:. 4flX;
mfl.4fl::7i3 i. 41
ZAQ
20
6 ro.
OA:-(.A W:
l41'.
hnfaL:%.J
'.41lXS, ilb: 1:
htl!
41
21
C.hi~:
11*&: AtV1
:.
AS7l1.1
;PA.Itl.1IA [.] 11*;
H5t22
41%7;
flA{:]
H;iLA~mnqO:-: 2j 4flZ[:] V-9i.:
jA4:4ti:- n~e13.9-"l23
AsfSLZ,
A{:~g]
?fJ'O, t1: 7, :Y:-
'mn
W1*:
AZAs
n:24
6
ro0::
,
41X .9 h-lqf
h}.
At'
.
41,;jS tii>Hx%Yrf .h
yt
41 [,] 21
L^&
D-, &?& tL YX[]X IP$CPI2
h~&^.tYfl[,] h&$mSO
tA::M:fl Tt'l,"]
Ht1:,
7AS~b D:57 25
WIP:
("1t(?A,'4 .fla{D] t.tq;?i'
;5I4.,
: I41C:. A, :
k:
4L.A]W 282
bX
ewa), '. 41 A"7, CTO:- ROPT.
41A-^. TIPU.-~.- p QXA<.28
t~~~tOW Q@ff 07,4 -. 4Ys 40 4Xt 4Z- Qt 79tb -x h>m527
hi, avhteftj. -fZA[t] ge5 A4Ct A4-C
.
A4C,
[41ZA.] wo28
' MS. a M. 2 Art see. manu. see. manu for 0.
V MS. 21 iAjPL. 5 M S. Ps . 4".
10 F. Littrnann, [1904.
(L.
a 1y ArpGY3
l;
.
41ZA
.
aiX.70
f.
NX'AS.[t.
TI4w:
i.-,
4Y3: 4YI: - 4Y3:.
Tfl,1
A574h 71 Aff7AbT-.4:29
A&~AA . 41ZA[ ] avh.11 avhjj,.. wh^tn nox1, . AqDb.-
H 30
6 vo. )ilthAnJ f. flflV'. ,C: MlO
wfl5me% :. flnPihT Z o3Xt
IJ ix'AIC . dNI4 -. bcW+OJ
wlh
Ripi -. . .. 4h
g HtL avaW<Ir
-.-
AY71M
-.jqavMh
D.
tla" . ib
5
Af. MI5
a9XY0~.e
31
77o
..
2?a
.
MAfi? .7 WhXtYv
fDbtv. s.
f!
t. MC
&J.l h
. wavaj. . wJ141h .
nar,,m\
Z.11,m -. AIW& I
niCh~fl:: Wt~fl:)i~hld )-Ofly. WHIT )i0M1~3
'HIT . >ffit. 24
RU
1t
Z*.Wa) hWal)".
WHIT.
aPP^
()q? 1
32
flre5I4
. e1nVM . . WHIT -. a iZ.l . 'rjl 7DjwMa70. Iiib.- fl: jC. Ita: I*. MOMt le
wDC
17PT.O
flM: ILT
efl: IOR WAA.M
Hil4.
hfa:.
ahP'Dq!Ptbfl:/1
/!!t
A
33
7ro.
}Cgw~
ffiX}7*t,) jXmp~jbat. wfjhXgq -. kt( - ,:)jtWhfli. II0nn
tSA:4GP
tWHIT:A
3
I:
haftfHfl
t.U4f
t0X7A
234
7v
fAto t1u 'HIT tg XPcth ve: t YII'
t: I'70 f\tqvlj qIavktPallt
hame < ,AqGV}f k~t( Hfla"- fq()WAGOR.
- N1 -
K
Af nf.ift -- MHITt 9ac th' (:)A(t*t
iAthqlOit @ Cff 35I&Tt W;L'tL. fqfi"+t }g. @Pt&t.t
747T~ht,l/////l
IztrCIZ
.
w)thi -. X AC.00; MI1t. t& - AW-C. tl, 1e
7Jtit
wI XF IIli-s
WffiffiaS^
t Xavl tnX7tLA4tbG
tAl4h
t * tg H;",:hav
P~qi-
i{I,Xa::
wa i'fafl
.
thaEibauHVIh4nWHIT 11av,. dae:5Lj: ttlY(P. We - mW14 nagf-t1a11
2
MN- x, M-} t MI
t.
41balt Yf-al?it.
WX^h-[t]ZLnSA10',
A7 vo.
WtAta -t 41ball^ODt"
t YfaYTi- lii -- I}al tnA
YD4bl488 @fifiP ffitt et rb4 UP '.t i-
3
AV-: wA,,mO.T,\5pa10, jjtav. fl1i Wf~
It:~
Iz. tvfa'4 fl,:.- \t A4t :- whlfltl -.o X _!A), M' -.H1-t
4
At)"t t3 i\7tLA41C tg W --i ftg Af.I-Cbt
t- htall t'
f
ft11I: t
414
P:: h"Ul t LUJ1L&t:
t V4ICh7
//////// v'CZf:. ? 5) AY1 J t & al Hl * l"
w
a lb A 9 aflh:
1 . A Ce s. 68
ro. tlaitIfFl t :C8+8 .IVam: ?I*'fl : tLa &j).
: tffi.A'MS. arv"" !P'tg 41". 2 Lasftly
prima manu.
Vol. xxv.] Arte'et: The ciagic Book of the Disciples. 11 J,
A-
whOn -. he -1 hav, .pCGj, ., yf~aylt .tHI -%k~
7ea'TPWOWc 'I Jft l. 41 . f& , yh
H~
J!,n'n:
tRAW
7
AM 'Oga4 "AUw
A0g'I-tu'a14
'
wq.t
ZA h
D AitMaO.P
8
Me ;,CbflA nffiet'
A8l'th:
+4Ai,
L*PY,
M4PI'a9:@
ZiD"P >ffian
aH~t: -. Y"-,Z . Atr
s. IN{$
haIDX,
4I0&f(Pw::
mrto
wdMA
1MaI&:
AflAr:
:
G
Ch-Al:
.
A
9
1in't bctl+1l V[]_V Aflll: tHCa:: wha"I.. fHC9',aw 10 8 vo. An('dic A'Alls Wavq9CMflpC hfl
, waAf1jaI, ?A i: 41&.:
WMA,
9RIO: &t
AWICh
4
///j1
///////////
(1EI4 :
'HIT : A
ft1?th, -. keM
X'7H4A XQ'Dff-(
-. hg , 0410 i wD++TA
a9A
who F.O
W dC7Ht, buqYI; WIt, I diO: Wiv-7t: 0411:: XY 11
h41, fl4;L
tfl4;L:aXXPltl h-
N
-SS~
4M
5L,P*,-
XDH
S
flfIX 746h, wt74A. X
IA
:1gt > h . wavflt?7t XP~t- : . MIXtmil .wavOjtp,,s.-.
waXyXpj . t,) )& . waxyDN-C
.~l5.&@XP* . 'A, . yz. . W@i~wuc 'X*. 10CM1. ffi @XP* .
141)i .
2&L.& :zE h^XYfIt.
nnfl4.C
I",: h.W
PtO A:m
.j7"
wkiY"HtM flh.MI: OIC Htib
. WHTRY7D
":xAI'Mut A9
ro.
(ifli
+S
Yl.
wgqn. a} :^?&'I:
S~il*.
ACiS.a?ffh
12
HaT, 19"H -, H~ffith . flat. asWXYD*.t MIX . 5?aYq. H.Chtl)
V. ff}hA-.
nflgsn.-
rSHCALh-.
Htr'YOh-: WHAahYOh- as
Hi(lh, aH7,99-, HC$41: WxHs4, N41 HQa]Db2G, MR.-?
410A: A.
, A. 747Cht
W
////j/////////////////j
hi7ILA
i
mthJi13
fti ""W'SG:
".IA
W74lq'1
wL a..,
Wh
.4rC
wibgl
HA1.
5
5.
yH:C
.
glb
wvhl,:
A.96'i1
flhf
l4i
14
HlifDP '. cWHAIM
7.
a7Htih
W
,: aHtZIC ,l: H
)TWr:.
ha3,s 4:%l), Vo7Ah, aaD7Z&,- OCG, naveK, waveg O :%t, . 1.1 , WaTIOC6- :5at,'- flR.N.4.
OMt.
9-H-i. 474~h.
9 vo.
I/
/ ////////////
W(NW,: 4Raw
t
Mt:
17e:O Xwsn : ACOOW. wflf6Y: W(1:if. l: i1
(HA':) .4lA: -Cfl. : whav..
A141h : W9Th3: W.Y '. MA a&av0 wgfi^PaPs
't
lX7JLXf LM:ba7 MwIfl4i0?
hav:
117 2 Cha't. whao 14CD-(ai4 ft et t'. 2.t&
I MS. thyr corrected from dby. 2 Corrected from
JSieC.
3Corrected from ?iiaVth. 4 MS. aW.Ci.&.12
:E. Littrnann, [1904. tvfta*
a ha]Dlbai.5ns
. hE5
J fbjea *t
WaveX*
.
ffi
uqjlbaP:. audwaD: ifle?awf :a :. :7Z wraf
f I
nV A:th4If~
HOIwW- h0MIC
:
WtY"O'I
WWIY: HEM,:e
fl4e 1?ikibl
-.
3"
hbir . Hthal?Ib
..
a@tY10- . (LY . K-f- . hT0i a@h4. - a
3
1 0 ro- AC66N~av-
-.1
nXIH~tSi.
6-flX[.] I ha?f :i.
Si+.
O'
flhffi,.7-fl . Hi'ka-ft . ea)-Pf , aI'WO@&
-. A,)It -. fl!Phba
AAt:. UAO:
h"'Thhw.
TfP4: M7s4:
haW:.Iha'vlba'w WMb-: aw 4
Uf r. MI(XL 1. H&XSyHaD0a
:. l4lIi
.4-Ch
f. HAiSD9
.Mnn: (nA. 'bn: fl'. WIWI : Maw' ' W TUi.: 1 1Mt . Alff: : 11. HAaV:
'-10411:
We. h
4
flef .law: A
:
Uwa AC.0
:
a
A:
Mo06aI
Al
a
(WI f)il(Wi: wqM-: &XWtmh~v UW)W: &Xg alh:
?
?i7a" AA::D I'Ifl:
Uh. :?jjtj.
fZL5q^7A:
i.2
ailh
[JeA]P,
nn.1VA
9
fl~1?A:
'tfll:S?d''7h
nWsL *5Ist:
.c~0
LW:t
*
flY'7* I
t n~oYX . cD~iT . e~nch . A1 . Ne . t . Al.
cr~r.
a'q'*7fl: jf: asflfi:tbaD.W?ihaH Sl'
ii
vo.a:(ba),iafl.:
. (Y1.. aD:Y(a1t
.
.
1d .
1
a7AJAi . hebav- . hayi7h7an(2
-.
iO.L- .4N+. fpH, I -. NhX
.
Yga7Ttbaoni,, agAfbhp. (1,al. Xa)_vACGRe 6; +. t~sa9. ^{n.3 t^OD1,asnin.41 s. cDIt 11jn. T~adRt
ai,1nnoav. A-fl,. wAl^,, waDlkL. 4141n. -2i AY14b -t whfnes
H~t' . AlYt' -. X71tbhGf&C
.
At~bfi qX .,. Ch-tl . :)Il
-
n:5A
.
av4. vn. tvavz. a)-tit
"n
11tAe
A1thvnf . Sv~h . ngn .HIT -. Anoasth:t [:5AA .] Ohf tg Ys?Y7Tt
9
(3,04, X71LA -c . flHdsa)O
St.
A,:77t. a~avint.t Gh-417
1 fl:5A
M7 . ZiZIaFth: a1D~e:5 a~oD7ZI -. OC -. fly~e7T
H
.
Ct V7A
q~f
av4 -S?. njfl . K-&P4 AbeT IN wf7;04' WavhlIt:
.
0^X
G .
ftifWt
waveDFft , HflPv?( -. WsHflhaYw.C'-.
vnf . 10 Illdh av7ll4qt.. )j7t. tanaif: }lffh: nff(r. avo~fon mhs-f:.. onf-. ysaqt-. O-Ot.- w12t-t-. 4,A.M.nx.*
ibasav
. f
qt.
atvol AN-TiX
g ANft{e},6
4t7]C~h.
l/////|ii///oDC~~~Ah. so. wt7(1Z.
h40i
waslftb.
SPaLhi,, wXeY 12
11vo.
qea. Anf.Xgf n..
AXelt. A1f. Xlt'.
k"Iffsh.. !' Ifn
35*
w C",*
?rCU * Hlfla-)i. assqebo -. :5AII,13
1 MS. gabft" SPO- Sec. man. add. -C (between A. and I).
37 add. sec. man. 4 T sec. man. 5 MS. wai'*4.lf. 6 Sec. man.: MS. originally Ah*.
Vol. xxv.] Arde'et: The ]agic Book' of the Disciples. 13
aV.4
Y
- OCI --d~i.
WMATIaX~cliV'Pl':
V JV tvnl. : hA" -') CW?33Vk }CTit4IG1lt.
- OItffM?ha":a ?iMl
NOI AtT)iP: WATq4.1; Hft:C. ffli'0: vf.: YH4t l.CTOt.:
14
ha'D):l?Bs *h4O avTnfll ueA4. Odt:?$w. 1a:A.
haOi.t
IfL:V
.:
afX5Yht
t. atP&tt. avoRtt. IWO tvar
'.Vi: 11ifl ? 19 12vo
4L(?
.: P
G ot . afCti.
tfl
.11fR".
hav
.
%
a)hD'i'jaw5l~lA:
(I41.fI
a
aHC&He).
4LfD'a HAera1'
fi f: tafla)d
,e: cIP?IJC'.: flhifa'C:
H
a ifD'7. fl1Ni al PH:
4wa'q.
nt a13 ro. Ufall f l n. '.f YAOYht . l cO'ftY . '2tCP . t:. cI .9Rt nflH
16
wtpfr~~
.'7b)q -. R IiPCtf?. a'ah4n M4tl:
Dfla 4V1
a .(jl~Y:
P~fl~: 1CM:
P'.fH: ~ilh: Vh1'~: W'2~:: 0(1: 17 2 C I WlaW- nhihntf M .hfpnrl . awhap
.
keaPs4:+ a)-~fi -. 7n -. :5arLAj, onf . 5ng
R
,~A
.
wtns-.Aqss
nyf,"Ti. Ci-04.18
hlD. C~h-f
Ov~t ,
^fllCh
.
hav.
Oit -. qq, ^ODha
tN-f . :fSA
HY.
g~hq:
WI.T7fl U+Dht
-.
H(bi';:
mf
aal(49
X
h~t.-
kh:
Utf. Y9."?t.
ttt
a2t
+nH&bftfV-l. 5
19
12 vo.
-fef.a)
An
ACH-A
.
ap.-fta vfi.@M4:
lu.-e: ,iCav4.:.
vn.f YA"Tt- CGt04
.
a)R&T: rn
haD: 20AebUavf : Aq-fel7
Mezef
alHlf.
tl()Cb a(Dnf7U: tnOt
ww.
tiheG5.
i Wtlhanc.-D~
. nnhelmhi WtnOMI. I'Pi.7
Ahtal'll aWoV? (?)
M2oeTal.
WYSDeZ: 7e7ial":
nWHITIXA.
g.Zva,,f. :+1P?4
ff-& lIatf[.] ApaD4
.
aw&Jjwahq.OmTr
*f.
A~~^t+. Abf7. -
nn21,
Ds.
Dn
[A\7]}4f
WYD - hf.: onf. q-Ti,.G0,r.
(DA~lthf. n.-HI
1 3 ro.
L
MM.ne.-7nt~h:
vn yg-"Tt: O't:t WR2rt.. 44223
wPfih~-
.
ayih?. 1 a).Ce. anxkilR~.
4,j.A:Xy7,g: \Intq4,Y
.
to-&R.
.
HCMf
-ta~.
Abilk
(h: MAYD: AffI .:.
vilf-
24H~t-.
ff-A Hf(141f ^SiMf: a)(1A{l~f,
9-1tthf: '1n.ODiRCh:
ACI A S a)Il Tt X: 4.e .w^ 114&th Ht: HA :l w .
I MS. 0,41 and Al}. I Corrected from (j. 3 MS. A. 4 The original reading has been made illegible by an indistinct cor- rection.
14 E. Littmann, [1904.
RAg}. --i.
fi7
OZ.* . MAb -.' qat.-
V'317.
t.
(I
Ht-
o4q:
Vifll.Y'"t
CPOt:.
b41.)410A.( aWq'x7A,
-4
25
cm: Ar9n..Ifl: W hf4j m.
a)
7,Pi' wcwtkll -h
26OD :,
Alt,
p-gyu' Rgavi; a@i+tl:,('n
0It:.
7st . A7eC:
13 vo.
Wh"D'IlJ Ai'H'1m7
a~h'~i).h a
iht:
7l:
'I"'lt'7I 4.MwOeh.
fi.:
Ain4I: aWa3JP: a'ke:4:r. hav. gCCIp AMlt: ihe.l @at~fm~.-
MA7Y
.
,,Pih . l&Y huyu.. *ibf. t ni . nftrt
H bf&h
.
hew: .ii:
(0,fh 1i9"'h
H
.
.tlh
.
flh
.f
l('10(
h. *i.
3MO
WIR
ai:
*
: 0R"h.'
:
a
wfl
A
(P.
287C*h: 47ifChl
/
I/I/h:///////7/
77
/7/7
AC&
M'
:5A
27
h: .t1f: lAah.
HtuY.
nHj .'
.
it:
lY.
.At
..
C: (l'h'Y.a)h".eiW'l
ha
. .PAei..
'Ia)h Yv
. 411:
h
/777/t7.
C
7/Ot
.
H7/7/7
cOhaDM.
AHtd0fl: w q:b fRA.o HXcOilfCh nnffi.XP MeO 314 ro. aDnlgWi .ilmt
:
A h
jco.flAt.
klt:iC
.Ahthl' fADl
.qY" .PRa (174 I-h.
Ri/7+7///
.
(.
+11:A'.
n *P 28 Oil".
A4::Cf.
l
ATnff H4I: CD:wWiP MAoI'. fl 38b.
[A]XwifHAjCD~j,
. wji~b -. alkfoD . co-tt. XA; . an
R4T -. 0"T.- Rjet.- AsAt.
affifi@to:,.--~. arbYwi'.
MYn729,
I . OR~t .- Xw~iACet.- sshOTH LAfl)11
.9
Alit
wA+
30
h0YU/
.
ka-L.n-7LA
IH-A
-. ihffav
.14A?
CF1
?Ca4
H Ar.- A,:It -. AXYMOA
*74nCh.
*,//////,I///
WCGA'rc?D4
- ha
*31
WtfLn.t.
.
A+
r.fr+
a~aD'%M'. a)hihln~.
VOvo.
CMra4
+nXAA.
MAYD;-.
mf&,
.
wtwo; ,2A1h.
MOAD
. 1A
At
WHIT
. Al?Yt
.
hUMIA
.
h"U-i A-e'ft
* 1A~nMX
32
71A 111
f
AA --'H T . AllYth: 474IChg W//////,i///,/
A),
33
&?(Whl
H* . HYISD.-a)HRa)-).- H~t .
A1P?.
e:51.alkti-NL
C.
A41A3.
At.h?*
&Az b.
474ICh
.
,///////34
//////X (De*,Ht&00. (-
t?
lM~aH
ACeDi'. ;Lg-'35
n. 1flw. H*.& :5AA . MAb.- Wa)Dqftt.- Cll-el:
a)D
&36
~, >se,4& -, W&Asba., H-4- ih3m -. wehar, 40M, lfsffi g(Dvfi . 74nCh . //ll////l/l/(h"D'
-
7LAHh.
ADf .:5
15 ro
$~.
AA?"th.
I
awflert'-
4,40.ACe~ath
- 44 --n lfsB
,
A7?.41:h.
/////,////9X///
ase
s
AIW
4
.
'
40A
.
Ue437
E~ff)XAGDA~l^:
wtavft , mrbH4Gk.
CXI -
hlhz
at A
aDf
n'f38
Vol. xxv.] Arde'et: The lIiagic Book of the -Disciples. 15
XcoaCgiG.9WP
Waht1Gl~fl: HASV5. R~t: XaW CG9XP aw(lta~1I
A: ,eAhWC.
wel'MA
t-: OIl c-. wfell ?. XAODNA we7CCt :cA: HeA4:
04':
hffi2;
h?"IU.' kielf
X7A1IikaIlti".
nG39
hE W04'fL:. Wt"OPO ?Lt: 't l.
//nC
.///////
/
/7/
I'k' .A f0T: AA0thf W.AOA0 .ODAn. jJ
a;AhC1r
M".OCT
-.
jWR A1. t1T'9 tU' Itht ao XwC. hftpa?M
. (lO4d: W7?ALht:15 vo.
AM4O s 14P,17 AURIN" H-A1. XA : A,19' . fnav -. bnCA+?1 1 40 0.1-10n. wAftalo.
sA~&T. acAejT . 4Ab~j+jj-- aqTr
A.V Abto7j jj a(,;flqjo1P Chjrt. (10. AMl"t.
1 ait ?iOIDTF.
fAX
th71 i541OA
H
f74
. /A////h//./
(Df(W4i
3lAt:l -W whct:n&. iIO1l: fAl: ?ft7 4I 5h: 41
&,& bifb
aAr
.HG
Ya~t(
hOYIP^ 42
MAf AtIvCz: cD0W1' +.- 1A1I: . apgtL,'
A
AW . Afi:ao,
P,:. (she
t~~m
apPat
nih.S
C:
1)71IX: wfqA: 7WLrPAA W11APT A1Ythl w4X 16 ro. U(?tIL -. i0P"IAIe:th
XiYO54":
(741Lhh ,,///C// WIaD43
A'tlP'n Pt ': (WtO: !J'A4
:
cDflhdi .TiC:
(jft V, wxqA'YCvfqgaP!':~
(1910:: Wa~theW:- ?tflghaP-:fl'Lt i'1I:A c01 X'llh I: VAM: 5143 . hfYU - 1Cf.- fl:594t XWLA;
@tdS
'HIT A~ffh t 440
(k:q~ 1Lf?,f'ih0':?A.:
1(h1:J<
ii~lt AV4111(L:A t w71'1'f,' i?At:44
a~nstt,
taHAXD~04
flE. Wt~fofEf &~t.t A(17GhG /////Ar
eajtef
,
@ffi, g@
AGAIT; A[e]q',
I0-., I&
2
C .17Z -. Of-17
.a)7q?&.
117LCOnI.
a,)fA1Ft09i, 4.X&,
t. HMD[Di.~e
WNAt.
nM . nAX7RAQ&C - asA7AA41&bCh0t lA* . Pnf 1 WhA~l .- H~bilf tG
h.Pf
*
WHIT. n- .0 -aDe:5U.- w3
16 vo. UlAM. - XOAl"T I XAn. As7DOF.- nAXWLAQ&C. fl~hf -. Y"W
O.IL1 A4h fls':
-.
:5tMA+. v-rA. XAe.
Zffi.->snO~~~~~~I', .
-4}
.s~ 1-7141 .AMf
A.1av.
ft. K-'#OILPral". -.a^8C $P 7Ah
T Xaf V~arf+ a
(.P>
xAD
n 7 ^tlxl A bclff not~~~~~lf
x.-
WUN,,
Z11rh
tMA
Xn^4sn~
R,:)-.
.Awl' tn*(hWx wXDaDx
'Kebal)4i n-?
Oat)
-.MIAHX~Hf:
x
U&? 5
XvtL
41&C - h~m~bf .- a-XT
SfoxaA~av)
w
-
h?708ODI" -, +A[f xx
W
lIAXIHf.
X st SgV tjoia >Lr104
-. a,).eCC-.
17 ro.
X7tLA41&C x 00?)+X t!!DtjhbavX (Dl.I4tl}^p?tja
6
XW4,offf& A.rb? v y h- . 110M
x
AffyAbat I An&D.fqah.
t
ft: He.(1f-bT?>:. 1SxJX(l~Lt 4 - 40Ah (&+ffi: A 716 E. Littmann,, [1904.
tL~hO,1 hav-.&4I'bO',4-
J;;
tXh 71LA41&C S- N-1,MIYfv
-. MINs*f, Wflnidi 'n WiiiJ", cvrt
@hWo' eT,
w~sT~e':
P
8
M(10 Wi'Oqn)l Wr11'Tha:, havx H;,tZiPr4Ithb0'-: WH 9 it. MIn g. I'PH : IXWRKALM,
t500o,
X.W@j
jibyX WAC9A9'014 !
&lIr
Hfih,
lts"H:
l
tAHHI: aVI?c s: 10
On:,
1,+(a'10: Xw;b} e4tlh: Mtw:i, H'PDfll:'h>,l
nYD,e/
IP0'
- wfti fill: RWM s wfhid-:
WRCAh':HiUelflbq" -
t71M1 d
17 vo.
Xi: MbOl"'c: HChdbaWfO,:1XW0g,
MIH A M2h,:1 he, I?
il 11ontI(I ASASP(g 9': AcI rd: 2k WvSx I AXm, tay7'
1
18 vo.
li
WI:H.'xatI4 $4fl01: x. A.U CV: W1,Jlt1x'W x. 1& 4'PAA tA
X. hext:?ir[n]
Wit:4I7e:
HZeAII2 WiH.eff4OA'0: H?I': 'HI'
'iA~'qO:
In,w1O4ha,
ffi,
:
1i~:
O
20
k
M, bO
"'I,
axC.X
'r " x
A 14
'1
?A
.
Hhi,
~
:> sA
v x
x.p H WIi
h
l
f h l,
WJ?41.9Iiltfl
,Ylxnh tAW'Th4:
fl:5ahiuJ' f:
xh MAP: Mphi
'vhP
( x 7L:A41e:x,Xy"AO:
X, fif:Wi MIO?:
yVDx., 701L.4+, WAtkO4-
A0i tt:1E
;0'rCW-
tqG
At741f~tx 27HA4I
fhG
X. i-jl(s2TP~l
. 11CM1&[0 X. n wAh7t,9 M4Y, fl~l14
IWMY x.hSY Rift, ax. WA&,
Wa:R-O- Hlt fi AiOOf, ^v^^ X7A4 I18 ro. G .
44'& x avIp4IitfFowx, NM(Y-
aftCGx,
7?-rDx.
hYO&
msx WCI
)MLAA&C;G
AP?/1bfx
wtki-&S avq4Iitfx fl:59A.- AY04bf.wftt, x.Cksf9P1, hav x tZJfjbf~t x. vqrlSow- whyf.x H
16
x.
a)-I?
hnt
-X
^f,
Mir ax. nito- ICAA x HJPa:R)Ohb
17
apM1T
. YDlr.
ir.
w~hot,
AtI91114 h&ITX. Ac.00r. h is MltA AQhCO-1x hav ,oS1t, dgz.
e
tILPR-. Vth<fl&bC - AY94bl
I... TDOVAL
X AhaII MT. Htltlt x 9!A. X71H4eCx, AYfD4
18 vo.
bf, Aift x. H,94tabM a9Ae7Ah, xMT1ilfl
ef
.-.
-
Wgffi(bt09
. & 19
OV, fthavi X.
hiGhir.
CT?Zf 7,OYiT X.
a)-+0J34AlA.hg h+^
ow n. P
.lshs nWzft -.*
AAd
31( tHt .1Cx kTWY0 sih4.,2WA~h~r
AltA
h
s tatlh
I~lasXO
lfGAA. h
OD,-
XPA':MShfXH
b
,lfigA57g
aCA
O
22
,P ALY,
-- WN ez nZ: YvIAXw ACehi'
'a)AIR.g&
4nRt, v.n
tl
MT; ftt]6Y.Jx gahfff~p
- Aceir -Ak
-\1O Mrqm
V
wDiLT
23
1 MS. 4. 2ki'7fl' :--ahtW'H repeated in MS. (dittography). 3 MS. At?V>iC. 4 MS. originally "la>.