This webinar will start shortly
T H A N K Y O U F O R J O I N I N G U S
www.xperthr.com
March 16, 2021
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws:
How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Katharine C. Weber
Jackson Lewis P.C. • Cincinnati & Louisville [email protected]
Katharine C. Weber Principal
513.898.0050
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
The 2021 Leave Law Challenge
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Overview of the Law: Alphabet Soup
5
• FFCRA (Voluntary)
• PSL
• FMLA
• ADA
• FRD
• ADEA
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Voluntary FFCRA Through March 31, 2021
6
• FFCRA expired December 31, 2020.
• Employers who were covered by the FFCRA can continue to provide FFCRA through March 31, 2021 and take the tax credit as if the FFCRA had not expired.
• To take the tax credit…
• Employer must have been covered employer under FFCRA
• Employee must have had time still available under FFCRA
• Employer can choose whether to provide, if at all, based on business needs
• Employer must follow all the same rules that applied under FFCRA such as limits on documentation, retaliation etc.
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
American Rescue Plan: Voluntary FFCRA Beginning April 1, 2021
7
• Extends voluntary FFCRA
• Resets the 10 days of EPSL as of April 1, 2021
• Adds new reasons for which EPSL can be taken
• Employee has been exposed to COVID-19 and is seeking or awaiting results of a diagnostic test or medical diagnosis of COVID-19
• Employer has requested a COVID-19 test or diagnosis
• Employee is obtaining the COVID-19 vaccine
• Employee is recovering from any injury, disability, illness, or condition related to the vaccine
• Expands the tax credits by increasing the annual wages an employer may claim the credit for from $10,000 to
$12,000
• Allows EFML to be used for same reasons as EPSL
• Allows certain state and local governments to take the tax credit
• Allows self-employed individuals to take the tax credit
• Adds non-discrimination provision to prevent employers from treating employees differently based on
• Whether they are highly compensated
• Whether they are full-time
• How long they have been employed
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Overview of the Law: State PSL
8
• Many state and local Paid Sick and Safe Leave laws (PSLs) provide time off work to care for a child who is ill or whose school has closed due to public health
emergency.
• Many PSLs provide time off for employee and family members’ illness, which would include time off due to COVID-19.
• Many PSLs provide time off for employee and child preventive care visits. What about time off to obtain a COVID-19 vaccine?
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Many states are considering bills to enact PSL.
• Many states have laws that offer or expand PSLs to cover COVID-19 related absences.
• The state PSLs will likely continue to be passed until Congress passes federal paid family and medical leave.
Overview of the Law: FMLA
9
• Applies to employers with 50+ employees
• Employee must have been employed for 12 months and have worked 1250 hours in last 12 months
• Employee must work at location with 50+
employees in 75-mile radius
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Employee or family member must need time off due to serious health condition
• “Son or daughter”: a biological, adopted, or foster child, a stepchild, a legal ward, or a child of a
person standing in loco parentis who is either under 18 years of age or is 18 or older and
“incapable of self-care because of a mental or physical disability” at the time FML is to
commence
Overview of the Law: FMLA
10
1. Pregnancy and childbirth
2. Conditions requiring inpatient care
3. Conditions that incapacitate you or your
family member (for example, unable to work or attend school) for more than 3
consecutive days and have ongoing medical treatment
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
4. Chronic conditions that cause occasional periods when you or your family member are incapacitated and require treatment by a health care provider at least twice a year
5. Permanent or long-term conditions for which treatment may not be effective, but the person is under continuing supervision of a health care provider
6. Conditions requiring multiple treatments that would likely result in a period of incapacity of more than 3 consecutive calendar days in the absence of the treatment
Overview of the Law: ADA
11
• Americans With Disabilities Act
• Cannot discriminate against employee because of disability
• Cannot discriminate against employee associated with disabled individual
• But no obligation to accommodate medical conditions of family members
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Overview of the Law: FRD
12
Family Responsibilities Discrimination
• EEOC 2007 Enforcement Guidance:
“Although the federal EEO laws do not prohibit discrimination against caregivers per se, there are circumstances in which discrimination against
caregivers might constitute unlawful disparate treatment.”
• Supreme Court in 2003:
“the faultline between work and family [is]
precisely where sex-based overgeneralization has been and remains strongest.”
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Title VII does not prohibit discrimination based solely on parental or other caregiver status, so an employer does not generally violate Title VII’s disparate treatment proscription if, for example, it treats working mothers and working fathers in a similar unfavorable (or favorable) manner as compared to childless workers.
Overview of the Law: FRD
13
Family Responsibilities Discrimination risk:
• Women with caregiving responsibilities may be perceived as more committed to caregiving than to their jobs and therefore less competent.
• Male caregivers may face the mirror image stereotype: that men are poorly suited to caregiving. As a result, men may be denied parental leave or other benefits
routinely afforded their female counterparts.
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
FRD: Risky Business
14
• Asking females, but not males, about their childcare and other caregiving responsibilities;
• Stereotypical or derogatory comments about female caregivers;
• Less favorable treatment soon after learning of caregiving responsibilities;
• Female workers without children or other caregiving responsibilities received more favorable treatment than female caregivers;
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Steering or assigning women with caregiving responsibilities to less prestigious or lower- paid positions;
• Males with caregiving responsibilities received more favorable treatment than females;
• Statistical evidence of disparate treatment against female caregivers;
• Deviating from workplace policy.
Overview of the Law: ADEA
15
Age Discrimination in Employment Act
• Cannot discriminate against employees because of their age (over 40)
Jackson Lewis P.C. Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
The Practical Challenges
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Jackson Lewis P.C. 17
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Do you have to provide more time off once federal, state and local leave entitlements are exhausted?
18
But…
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Jackson Lewis P.C. 19
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to
Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Practical Challenges
20
• Economic issues/ability to pay
• Productivity
• Multiple reasons for leave requests
• Recruitment challenges
• Retention
• Morale
• Female/Family Friendly Reputation
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Creative Solutions
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
22
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
A year ago, most of you were opposed to allowing employees to work from home…
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply 23
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Possible Solutions
24
• Create or expand permanent remote work roles
• Create temporary “transitional” remote work opportunities
• Enhance flexible scheduling
• Expand onsite childcare and tutoring benefits
• Support home childcare and tutoring
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Adjust FSA benefit plans
• Modify FTE status
• Create temporary unpaid leave programs
• Explore temporary or permanent transfers
Addressing Remote Work Challenges
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply 25
and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Addressing Remote Work Challenges
26
• If remote work is going to continue, make sure you have a plan in place that addresses your employee’s unique circumstances and your need to get the job done.
• It may be time for a re-set.
• Set forth the expectations for the job.
• Talk to employees about performance issues that have arisen with any previous flexibility.
• Communicate that while you are willing to work with them during this difficult time, and want them to succeed, ultimately, it will require effort on their part to ensure that the job gets done.
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Final Cheat Sheet
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
Final Cheat Sheet
28
• Check your ABC’s and legal obligations.
• Consider how to make flexibility work for you.
• Don’t be afraid to try something new.
• Keep in mind that while solutions may be unique to each employee’s situation, you need to be consistent in your position that whatever solution is in place, it must satisfy the Company’s needs.
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond
• Avoid assumptions about who in a family acts as the primary caregiver.
• Communicate temporary or trial basis of any solution.
• Set expectations/guidelines for remote work or other solutions.
• Handle each request in a thoughtful, deliberate manner, even if it cannot be granted.
Katharine C. Weber Principal
513.898.0050
Thank you
Untangling the Web of Leave Laws: How to Comply and Succeed During COVID and Beyond