HE
ART
OF
TRANSCRIBING
FOR
THE
ORGAN
A
complete
Text
Book
for the
Organist
in
arranging
Choral
and
Instrumental
Music
By
HERBERT
F.
EIIJNGFORD,
Mus.
BAC.
OXON.
Organistto the Cityof
Liverpool
atSt. George'sHall
PRICE:
Boards,35.00
NetCloth,
6.00 NetNEW
YORK
:THE
H.
W.
GRAY
COMPANY
CONTENTS
PAGE
PREFACE vi
SCHEME OP THE WORK viii
ABBREVIATIONS OP TERMS viii
SECTION
ITRANSCRIBING THE ORCHESTRAL ACCOMPANIMENTS OF
CHORAL WORKS 1
SECTION
IITRANSCRIBING ORCHESTRAL SYMPHONIC WORKS 38
"
SECTION
HITRANSCRIBING WORKS FOR SMALL ORCHESTRA 114
TRANSCRIBING WORKS FOR STRING ORCHESTRA 118
TRANSCRIBING CHAMBER MUSIC 124
TRANSCRIBING PIANOFORTE MUSIC .184
TRANSCRIBING SONGS 148
SUMMARY 154
SECTION
I
Orchestral
Accompaniments
of Choral WorksNo.
1
Mendelssohn,
Elijah("HelpLord")
42
Mendelssohn,
Elijah("Yet
doth
theLord")
6 3Mendelssohn,Elijah
("Yet
doth
theLord")
8 4Mendelssohn,
Elijah("Blessed
are themen")
10 5Mendelssohn,
Elijah("Baal,
we cry tothee")
126
Mendelssohn,
Elijah("Baal!
Hear
andanswer")
14 7Mendelssohn,Elijah("The
fire
descends")
16 8Mendelssohn,Elijah
("Thanks
be toGod")
18 9Mendelssohn,
Elijah("He,watching
overIsrael")
2010
Mendelssohn,Elijah("Then
did
Elijah")
22 11Mendelssohn,Elijah("Then
did
Elijah")
24 12Mendelssohn,Elijah("And
thenshall")
26 ISBrahms,
Requiem
("How lovely
isThy")
28 14Brahms, Song
ofDestiny ("But man")
80 15Brahms, Song
ofDestiny ("Butman")
82 16Brahms, Song
ofDestiny ("But man")
84SECTION
II
Orchestral
Symphonic
Works17
Mozart,
G minorSymphony
"40
18
Mozart,
G minorSymphony
4219
Mozart,
Don Giovanni Overture 4420
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
4621
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
4822
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
5023
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
5024
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
5025
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
'
54
26
Beethoven,
C minorSymphony
5427
Mendelssohn,
MidsummerNight's
Dream 5628
Mendelssohn,
MidsummerNight's
Dream 5629
Mendelssohn,
MidsummerNight's
Dream 5680
Mendelssohn,
MidsummerNight's
Dream 5831
Mendelssohn,
MidsummerNight's
Dream 5832
Mendelssohn,
Midsummer
Night's
Dream 5833
Mendelssohn,
Hebrides
Overture 6234
Mendelssohn,
Hebrides
Overture " 62List
of Excerpts
No. PAGE
36
Schubert,
UnfinishedSymphony
6487
Schubert,
UnfinishedSymphony
61"88
Schumann,
Manfred Overture 6889
Schumann,
Manfred Overture 6840
Weber,
Jubilee Overture 7041
Weber,
Jubilee Overture 7044
Weber,
Der Freischiitz Overture 7448
Weber,
Der Freischutz Overture 7444
Weber,
Euryanthe
Overture 7645
Weber,
Euryanthe
Overture 7646
Wagner,
Tristan and Isolde 8047
Wagner,
TheMastersingers
"83
48
Wagner,
Parsifal 8449
Tschaikowsky,
PatheticSymphony
8650
Tschaikowsky,
PatheticSymphony
8851
Tschaikowsky,
1812 Overture 9052
Brahms,
Tragic
Overture 9253
Brahms,
Tragic
Overture 9454
Brahms,
Tragic
Overture 9655
Grieg,
Pianoforte Concerto 10056
Grieg,
PeerGynt
Suite,No. 1("Anitra'sDance")
10"57
Smetana,
Bartered Bride Overture 10458
Sullivan,
In Memoriam Overture 10659
Sullivan,
In Memoriam Overture " 108SECTION
III
Works for Small and
String Orchestras,
Chamber and PianoforteMusic, Songs
60
Haydn,
La HeineSymphony
11461
Haydn,
La ReineSymphony
11662
Elgar,
Serenade in E minor forStrings
" 11863
Elgar,
Serenade in E minor forStrings
12064
Mozart, String Quintet
in E-flat 12265
Mozart,
ClarinetQuintet
in Amajor
12466
Mozart, String Quartet
in D minor 12667
Schubert, String Quartet
in A minor 12868
Schubert, String Quartet
in A minor 13069
Ellingford,
Nocturne for 'Cello and Piano 13270
Arne-Benedict,
Variations on "Where the bee sucks" 13471
Chopin,
Funeral March 13872
Chopin,
Polonaise inC-sharp
minor 14073
Sullivan,Daydreams
(No. 2)
14274
Sullivan,
Twilight
14475
Rachmaninoff,
Prelude inC-sharp
minor 14676
Rachmaninoff,
Prelude inC-sharp
minor 14677
Ellingford,
Song
"There's a Rosebud" 148 78Ellingford,
Song
"Two Little lives" 150 79Ellingford,
Song
"London Pride"The art of transcribingor arranginga musical
composition
for a combinationof instruments or voices other than that for which it was originally
composed,
has
engaged
the attention of musicians from the 16th century to the presenttime.The earliestform of instrumental music was
probably
an attempt to arrange,as a support for the voices,the actual vocal part itselffor the
stringed
instruments then in use; and it is an historical fact that much of the early music writtenfor the viols isnot
only
similar in structure to, but is an imitation of the choralmusic of the
period.
TRANSCRIPTION, as a distinct art, is only
possible,
so far as instrumentalmusic isconcerned, when the instruments for which the music isto be
arranged,
are mechanicallyand
tonally
sufficient for the purpose. Therefore itis not untilthe time of J. S. Bach
(1685-1750)
that arrangements of any permanent valueare to be found. These,the earliest
transcriptions
of importance, are his organarrangements of Vivaldi's Violin Concertos. Bach also made organ arrangements
of some of his own
original
violin works.With the advent of,and the subsequent improvement in and
development
of,the pianoforte,arrangements became more numerous.
Beethoven, Schubert, Schumann, Mendelssohn and Brahms, each
arranged
some of their own works for an instrument or combination of instruments other
than the
original,
a particularlyfavorite form oftranscriptionbeing
that forpianoforte
(2and 4 hands) from the orchestral score.The pianofortehas been the household instrument for
upwards
of a century,and the publicationof the
pianoforte
arrangements of orchestral,oratorio, and operaticmusic, has been one of the greatest factors indisseminating
the worksof the great masters
throughout
the civilized and musical world.The progress of organ standardization has been much slower than that of the
pianoforte.
Even now there is muchdivergence
in:(1)The number and compass of manuals;
(2)The patternand compass of the pedal-board;
(3)The type of console;
(4)The arrangement of the stops,and
(5)The method of stop-control.
However, the wonderful
improvements
in thetonal-design
and stop-controlof the modern organ, have made transcriptionsfor the organ an artistic
possibility,
which,
early
in the 19th century would have been impossibleof achievement.The names of Nixon, Vincent Novello, Hopkins,
Cooper,
Best,and others,are prominent as forerunners in the art of
transcribing
for theorgan.
W. T. Best, above aH, stands out
pre-eminently
for hisgigantic
series "of"Arrangements
for the organ from the Scores of the Great Masters," this workalone
running
to over 1,000 pages! W. T. Best was the firstorganist
of St.George's
Hall,Liverpool,
and it was a great work toaccomplish
so muchin this particularbranch of musical art,
during
the 40 years he held theLiverpool
appointment.Sir Hubert
Parry,
in the firstvolume of Grove'sDictionary
ofMusic writes :""The objectof arrangement isto make that which was written in one musical
language,intelligible
in another.'*Preface
.
vii
The instruments in common use at the present
day,
may be divided into three great classes,viz.,Wind,String,
and Percussion.Not
only
has each class individual characteristics which are not common to the other classes;but the instruments in each class have characteristicsdiffering
from others in the same class.For instance, the brilliant trillon the
pianoforte
loses its effectentirely
if it be exactlyimitated on the organ; thequick repetition
ofstringed
instruments(violin
family)
becomesclumsy
on thepianoforte,
andincapable
of clearspeech
on the organ;rapid
scalicpassages in Srds and 6ths in the form of successive chords(at
M.M. J = 120, 4 notes to the quarter-note or greaterspeed)
sotelling
and brilliant when divided among the strings,are cumbersome iftrans-ferred to the medium of the piano,andquite
ineffective on the organ; the trem-olo" whether of chords or
single
notes " which isinvariablyaccompanied
withthe use of the
damper-pedal,
on thepiano,
has notonly
anentirely
different effect if it beplayed
on the organ, but it also is far from effective,unless it iscarefully
laid out.It is
hardly
within theprovince
of a book on organtranscription
tocatalogue
a listof the characteristic idioms whichbelong
to the different instruments.Many
of these musical idioms,such as scale passages, are common to themajority
of instruments; but there are some, such as thepizzicato
of thestring
family,
whichbelong exclusively
to one type of instrument.Transcription
is not the imitation orreproduction
ofexactly
similar effects. It is rather a re-writingof theoriginal
form in order that the melodic andrhythmic phrases
andfigures,
the harmonicbackground,
and all theprincipal
features may be distributed as far aspossible,
to suit the altered conditions ofproduction
orpresentation.
That isto say, the music of theoriginal,
should in its transcribed form be re-moulded to suit the tonal and mechanicalpossibilities
of thechanged
medium.The best method for
learning
the art oftranscribing
is the actualexperience
which isgained by comparing
transcribed work with itsoriginal
form, and tojudge
of its effect in actualperformance.
The author
hopes
that this work " the firston"Transcription"
yetpub-
lished
" may be a usefulguide
to organists,the greatmajority
of whom " whethertheir
duty
isto accompany thesimplest
services or the more elaborate forms "have
continually
to"adapt"
the written chants and tunes to the medium of manuals andpedals.
The widestpossibleapplication
of the terms "toadapt"
and "toarrange"
is here assumed.Hymn-tunes
and .chantsareonly played
in thesimple
written form(without
pedals),
as a relief from the endless varietyof arrangements to tfhichthey
can beartistically
subjected.
Though
this is often called"organ accompaniment,"
itpractically
resolves itselfinto the rearrangement in various forms on the organ of the written music.. Beethoven,
in the last 24 measures of the Seventh
Symphony
"Allegretto"
gives
theprincipal
theme of this wonderful movement in a harmonized form, 2 measures at a time. 1st,to flutes and oboe I;2nd to oboe TL and clarinets; 3rd to the bassoons and horns,and then to thestrings,
and repeats the device in the same order,to the end of the 16-measure theme.This,the author considers,is a
perfectexample
fromoriginal
work, of theThe passages selected for
transcription
aregiven:
fa)
In theiroriginal
form \rithcomments on theprominent
features.(b)
In thepianoforte
version,
with remarks on theaccompaniments
asthey
appear in the vocal scores of choral works with orchestra.
(c)
In a transcribed form forthe organ, with notes as to thegeneral
effectthat is aimed at, and
suggestions
forregistering
the passage.The author has drawn
largely
from well-known works for illustrations of transcribed choral and orchestral passages.Choruses from the
oratorios,
cantatas and massesfrequently
form part ofthe
repertoire
of cathedral and churchchoirs;
and the organaccompaniment
ofthese demands careful consideration.
The arrangements can be
effectively
managed
on an instrument with twomanuals and
pedals,
but theregistering
isdesigned
for theordinary
three-manualorgan with
pedals.
Section1 deals with Choral works with orchestral
accompaniments.
Section 2 deals with Orchestralwork alone.
Section3 deals with music for Small and
String
orchestras;
Chambermusic;
Voice and
Piano;
and Pianoforte music.In Sections2 and 3, the
pianoforte
version isgivenmerely
to show a con-densedform of the orchestral score, for the sake of convenience. Some of these
pianoforte
versionsarecomplicated,
such as thoseby Liszt;
while others are in asimplified
form.Abbreviations
of
Terms
used
in this
Book.
In
the Orchestral
and
Choral
Works.
EL Pice. Ob. Cor
Ang.
Fag.
Cl. Cor.Trpt.
Tromb.Ophi.
Timp.
G.C.Cymb.
Tri. Clock, V. V*. Flute. Piccolo. Oboe. CorAnglais.
Bassoon. Clarinet. Horns.Trumpet.
Trombone.Ophideide.
Kettle Drums. Bass Drum.Cymbals.
Triangle.
Bellsor Carillon. Violin 1. Violin2. Va. V'c. C.B. Wood-wind Brass Str.Org.
S. A. T. B. a2. [viiij = Violas. " Violoncello. = Double Bass. =Piccolos,
Flutes,
Oboes,Clarinets,
and Bassoons.=
Trumpets
and Trom-bones.=
Strings.
=Organ.
=Soprano.
= Alto. = Tenor. = Bass. = Bothinstruments
playing
the sameScheme of the Work ix
The key indications given to the various wood-wind, brass and percussion
instruments at the beginning of each full orchestra score, follow the usual custom
of key notation, viz. "in B" implies "in B Flat," "in H" implies "in B," "in Fis"
implies "in F Sharp."
Most of the older orchestral scores and many of the modern ones adhere to
he German form of key-nomenclature: "
B
= BFlat. Fis = F Sharp.
H = B Es = E Flat, etc.
In the
Organ
Transcriptions.
HI, II, and I }
or " = Swell, Great, and Choir Organ.
Sw: Gt: and Ch:
J
Fed.
= Pedal Organ.
HI, II, or I to Ped. = Swell, Great, or Choir Organ coupled to the Pedal Organ.
Man. = Manual or Keyboard.
R. H. or L. H. = Right hand, or Left hand.
" (minus or subtract) = (put a stop "in").
+ (plus or add) = (draw a stop "out") .
8, 4, and 2 = Stops of 8 feet and 4 feet pitch without Gamba or Reed
tone.
HI to Oboe = Swell Organ with 8 feet pitch Diapason and Flute-toned
stops, and the Oboe.
m with Reeds 8 ft. = Swell Organ with Diapason and Flute-toned stops, and
the Reeds, all of 8 feet pitch.
NOTE. For the purposes of illustrating transcribed passages, the author has in mind the average organ of three manuals and pedals " with about thirty or forty sounding stops; couplers, pistons, and com-position
pedals being extra. The Swell organ would contain three or four reeds, the Great, one or two reeds " the Choir, two or three reeds " and the Pedals would perhaps have one or two reeds.
The
Art
of
Transcribing
for
the
Organ
Section I.
Transcribing
for the
Organ
the
Orchestral
Accompaniments
of
Choral Works.
In orderto arrange
successfully
andartistically
an orchestralaccompaniment
for the organ, there are many conditions which
require
carefulconsideration.A chorus may be
fugal,
with all the choralparts
strengthened
by
onesection of the
orchestra,
while another section isemployed
ina freecontrapuntal
accompaniment.
A chorusmay be
harmonic,
fouror fivepart
chordalwriting,
with anentirely
independent
accompaniment
in somepart
of the orchestra.The
accompaniment
itselfmay bemomentarily
ofgreater
importance
thanthe vocal
parts,
withindependent
rhythmic
or melodicfigures
inone or otherof the orchestralgroups.
These are but a few
general
conditionsmet with in choral work withorches-
tral
accompaniment
which will bediscussed,
analyzed,
andexplained
in theexcerpts
given
in this section.But there are other conditions which it
would
be well toenlarge
uponbefore
proceeding
to theexcerpts.
First and foremost is the relativevalue or force of
the
expression
marks inthe differentgroups of the orchestra.
For
instance,
thepianissimo
of thestrings
isa much softereffectthan thatof the
wood-wind;
while the fortissimo of the brass wouldeasily
overweight
the rest of the orchestralforces.
This relative
proportion
in thecarrying
capacity
or volume of sound existsof course in all the
varyingdegrees
ofexpressiveness
from the softestto theloudest,
and must beconstantly
borne in mind whenadapting
an orchestralaccompaniment
on the organ, so that the balance oftone may bepreserved
asfaras
possible.
The
string-group
is the mostimportant
part
ofthe
orchestra,
inasmuchas it forms the foundation of the orchestralforces.
The
bowing
of thestring-work
isnotmerely
a matter for the orchestralstring
player,
but it is of vitalimportance
in theproblem
of organadaptation.
A broken chord passage distributedamongst thestrings
played
with three or morenotes per bow will
give
anundulating
orwaving
effect" but ifplayed
one noteper bow, itwillat once stand out more
prominently
and have a moreindependent
existence than is
possible
with thephrasing
of three or more notes per bow.The
fortissimo
rapid
scales of thestrings
arevigorous,
telling,
and brilliantwhen each note is
played
with a separateJbow
"owing
to thegrip
or bite of thebow for each note.
The same scaleslose much of their force and brilliancewhen
they
are executedwith three or more notes per bow.
The
paramount
importance
of thestring
group in orchestral work is an establishedfact.If the
pianoforte
accompaniments,
asthey
appear in thepublished
vocalscores of the great choral-orchestral
works,
becompared
with the fullscore, itwillbe found that the
string
parts alone,almostinvariably
furnish the materials for theseaccompaniments
This actual
reproduction
of thestring
partsbeing
made to serve the purposeof the
accompaniment
in the vocal scores " apractice
which hasunfortunately
become a tradition" has created many difficultiesfor the
organist
who wishesto
give
a fairrepresentation
of the orchestral work on the organ.Such
pianoforte
accompaniments
are full of falsequantities,
full of mislead-ingstatements.
They
abound in passages which areremarkably clumsy
onthe
pianoforte
andequally
ineffective and oftenimpossible
if transferred to theorgan.
These
pianoforte
partsare false andmisleading
because:1.
They
indude many idioms which arepeculiar
to thestring
family
alone andtotally
unsuited to thepianoforte.
2.
They give
undueprominence
to passages which are subordinate in thescore.
3.
They
often omitimportantrhythmic
and melodicfigures
belonging
to thewood-wind, horns,
or brass"figures,
which assist andhelp
out the vocalleads.
4.
They
exhibitrapid
arpeggio
passages,originally
laidout for the hand of thestring-player,
which do not liecomfortably
under thepianist's
hands.5.
They
often failtogive
any orchestral indications of the instrumentation.This last fault is
fortunately
absent in many of the vocal scores of modernworks.
It will
readily
be seen that these vocal scoreaccompaniments
notonly
embarrass anorganist,
butthey
create unnecessary difficultiesbecause of theChoral Works 3
It would be
very difficult to formulate rules for a subject which has so many
facets, but the subjoined suggestions
or guides may help to elucidate some
problems in transcribing orchestral accompaniments for the
organ.
1. Eliminate the unessential* and lay out the essential to the best advantage
on the organ.
2. Aim at simplicity and avoid complexity.
3. Complex and involved
passages, though they may be technically playable
on the organ, should be altered and rewritten, unless the effectis artistic.
4. Avoid the exact reproduction of any idiom peculiar to one particular
class or group of orchestral instruments, which is not artistic and effective
in the transferred medium.
5. Alter the context or figures of an instrumental part, rather than reproduce
an idiom which does not belong to the organ.
6. Avoid rapid repetitions either of single or double notes. These repeti-tions
may often be technically or mechanically possible at a great speed
on an organ " but they can never sound really well, because at the high
speed one note will run into the other, and this merging of one sound
into the next, results in the effect of one continuous sound, or at best, a
sustained wobble!
7. Try to reproduce the spirit of the score " not the letter.
With these few suggestions, we will proceed to the actual business of tran-scribing.
Each excerpt or quotation will be discussed and analyzed, and each
analysis will lead on to a reasonable presentation of the adaptation.
NOTE. Twelve out of the sixteen excerpts given in Section I,are from Mendelssohn's oratorio Elijah. The Elijah is (after Handel's oratorio The Messiah) the best known oratorio extant, and the Vocal Score with pianoforte accompaniment is probably in ninety per cent, of households throughout the world where the music of the Westerns is enjoyed and encouraged.
The Orchestration of the Elijah is much more modern than that of Handel's Messiah; and for this reason it is more useful and serviceable for the purposes of organ arrangement.
from the first chorus "Help, Lord"
in Mendelssohn's oratorio
Elijah
Andante.iento J:7 Tirap.ELA. PP s. A T. B.
A
f
Will then the
A
Lord be no more God in Zi " on?
'i
NT
r
r
MolSnl Violin II Via. C.B. I I ? I I I i fChoral Works
In
Excerpt
1,
theChorus
sings
quietly
in dosecompact
harmony,
strengthened
by
reiterated
string-chords,
and
a very softdrum-roll.
The
strings
areplaying
one note perbow,
and
except
forthe sixteenth
notesilences,
there isacontinuity
of
sound in thispassageof
repeated
chords. Thereisan appearance of
staccato,
butthe
executionof
thispassage onthe
strings,
produces
no such result.The
softdrum-rollhas the effect
ofasustainedbass-note. The
prominence
of
thisdrum-rollis
greatly
minimized
by
thedose
middleposition
of
the voiceparts,
with the
bassessinging
the
same note atthe
samepitch.
In fact thesound of the vocal bassesmerges into that of
the
drum-roll.No.l
Piano
In
the
pianoforte
score,the
string
parts
alone
aregiven,
thus
producing
thefalse
impression
of
a staccatoaccompaniment.
The
organtranscript
given
below
Nol
Illtoffboe
Pedal
provides
rhythmic
movement andcontinuity
of sound.
The lefthand
takes therhythmic
pulsation
of the
strings,
theright
hand adds
tothe
continuity
(both
on a
swell-organ),
andthe
pedals
take
overthe drum
note.Note that
the latteris
played
an octavelowei^-to add
weight
tothe
ground
tone.If the
processhad been
reversed,
w":"the
right
hand
taking
thesixteenth-notes
and the lefthand the
quarter-
and
eighth-notes"
the
pulsating
effect
wouldfrom the chorus"Yet doth the Lord" inMendelssohn's oratorio
Elijah
Allegro vivace J:"e
Ob.
Cl.inB
dfc
/r
t
pYet doth the Lord
Violin ! Violtn [I Via. V'C. C.B.
r
r
p
"r'Yet doth the Lord see it not;
Excerpt
3
from the latter
part
of the chorus "Yet doth the Lord" in Mendelssohn's oratorioElijah
Grave
J=B8
*Here there is much food for
thought.
The full orchestra is inforce,
andeverything
going
softly,
with anincrease
oftone at the thirdmeasure.But which of the orchestralgroups will
predominate?
Which
quality
orcoloring
willrise,
never mind howslightly,
above
the other?Surely
notthe
strings,
which areplaying
three
notes perbow
and with avery sustained
undulating
effect;
nor thehorns,which,
at the second and thirdmeasures, are overlaid
by
thetrombones;
noryet
the upper wood-wind.As a matter of fact
there
isafine
merging
ofqualities
here.
Thehorns
support
andplay
into theundulating
string
chords
in the firstmeasure and ahalf;
thewood-wind,
horns,strings,
and brasssupporting
the voices for thelastmeasure
and
ahalf,
yet,
the
horns at thebeginning
do filterthrough
thestring-chords,
and
thesonority
of the brassat the second and third measuressuperimposes
a wonderfulweight
and richness which is unmistakable" andwhich is rounded off
by
the rollof the drum.Piano
No.3
The
misleading
and falseimpression
given
in thepianoforte
score isobvious,
when it isseen that
only
thestring
parts
arequoted.
No.3 IIIto Oboe liOftS IIIto 1 n softa into ii IIto Fed Manual Pedal
The
lefthand maintainsthe
undulating
string
chords,
while theright
handsustains the
chords
whichbelong
to the othergroups in theorchestra,
and theExcerpt
4
from the chorusaBlessed are the men"
inMendelssohn'soratorio
Elijah
Allegro
moderateJ=
li Ob. Cor.in G Cor/inC Trpt.inC S. A. T. B. Violin 1 ViolinII Via* V'C. OB. Bless - ed T-men, areJ.
"who are Blessm
edJ
the men men. fear HimBless- - ed .are men
This
lightly
scoredpassage for wood-wind andstrings
requires
a littlecare.The
running
passages for violas and 'cellosare veryimportant
in theaccom-panimental
scheme. Each vocalpart
is reinforced at the unisonpitchby
thestrings
andwood-wind,
the soprano leadbeing
doubled in thehigher
octave as wellby
the flutes. The horns and thestring
bassesplaylongsustaining
notes.Piano
Only
the
string
parts
appear in thepianoforte
score"leaving
the voiceparts
stranded. It willbe noticed in thetranscription
No.4 HI toOboe n ' Manual 18 IIItOII IIItOI Ito Fed Pedal
that we have
compromised
in thedisposition
of thewood-wind;
but the main features of the orchestralaccompaniment
arepresent
in the organ arrange-ment.The sixteenth-note
string
phrases
aregiven
to the left hand on thegreat
organ. Theright
hand takescharge
of the upper wood-wind"but doesnot
attempt
toreproduce
thehigh
entry
of theflutes,
because the firstviolinsand oboes reinforcethesoprano leadatthe unison.
A word as to the continuance of the sixteenth-note
string
passage may behelpful.
If such a passage stillretainsitsprominence
in the orchestralscheme,
and if it lieswell within the
hand,
it would be advisableto continue it in thetranscript.
On the otherhand,
the exactreproduction
of the passage, note for note, shouldnot bepersisted
in,
where it does not lieeasily
under the hand. Such passages should beunhesitatingly
alteredto suitthechanged
conditionsofperformance,
viz.,
to suit thekeyboard,
not thefingerboard.
The outlineof theExcerpt
from the
chorus"Baal,
we cry to thee"inMendelssohn'soratorio
Elijah
Allegro
nontroppo
J=ieoFl.
Ob
CUnB
C.B
8 4 8 * 78
Big
wood-wind and brass sustainedchordsare aprominent
feature of thefirsthalf of thisextract" whilein the lastfour measures, the wood-wind
strengthen
the vocalleadsat the unison. But theeighth-note
passages of thestrings
are veryimportant
indeed,
and areplayed
vigorously
one note per bow.Excerpt
from the chorus "Baal! Hear and answer"
inMendelssohn'soratorio
Elijah
PrestoJc
Fi. Ob. Cor.inA Cor.in D TrptinEHear our cry 0 Baal!
Timp.F*C
Choral Works 15
The shrillcry of the flutes and oboes
here,
is verystriking.
It seems to indicate an excitablephase
in the multitudes'feelings
which thischorus,
"Hearour cry O Baal,"is intended to
depict.
All the vocal leadsare backed upby
thewood-wind,
horns,orbrass;
and the drums thunder out a tremendous roll.The
strings
play
furious passages, one note perbow,
adding greatly
to the effect the composer aims at,viz.,the turmoil anddesperation
of adisappointed
throng.
No. 8
Piano
The criticalremarks
regarding
thepianoforte
score of thepreceding
excerptapply
with almostequal
forceto thepianoforte
score of this. None of the wood-windhorns,
or brass are indicated.In the organ
transcript
most of the
principal
features are indicated or hinted at. Theholding
chords of the wood-wind and horns aregiven
to theright
hand on anample
choir organcoupled
to full swell. The left hand takescharge
of therough string
passagesfrom the chorus "The fire descends from heaven"
in Mendelssohn's oratorio
Elijah
Allegro
con fuocoJ="*
loco FL ClinB Cor. inE! Cor inE Trpt.mE Violin I Vioholl
Choral Works
17Wood-wind
andthe
firstand secondhorns
provide
strong
rhythmic
figures
here.
They
also
give
a bitetothe vocal double
entrieson the lastsixteenth-note of the second beat in
the
second and third measures,supporting
themimmediately
afterby
sustained chords. Thestring
work isfiery,
andbeing
played
one note perbow,
has avigorous
driving
force.
In measure 3 the flutes
play
at thetop
of their compass theintervalof
the
third,
andjump
down an octave on the third beat. This imitative device whichmight
well be called "the motif of descent" and which wasdefinitely
de-visedto
heighten
the dramaticforce
of the words"The
firedescends
fromheaven"
is
repeated
inthe three
following
measures"the oboes
joining
the flutesin thesame device.
It
would
be apity
totry
to imitate thison the organ. If itweredone,
itwould
only
leadto the omission of themoreimportant
rhythmic
andsupporting
upper wood-wind work.
Piano
The
pianoforte
score omits allthe wood- wind and hornwork,
andreproduces
the
string
parts
only.
No. 7
The
abovearrangement
issatisfactory,
inasmuch asthe
principal
features
of
theorchestral
accompaniment
areeffectively
supplied.
The
right
handdisposes
of the wood-wind and horn parts
on anample
choir
organ
coupled
to fullswell,
while the left handadequately
represents
the
Excerpt
from thechorus"Thanks be to God" in
Mendelssohn's
oratorioElijah
Allegro
moderatecon fuocoJ=ia"
Cl.inB
Cor.in
COI.IAB
wa-tersgath-ertheyrush a-loog!
ViolinII
Via.
Vfc
C.B.
Choral Works 19
There are many
points
ofsimilarity
between this and thepreceding
excerpt.The wood-wind and
horns
deal withpronounced
rhythmic
elements,
and thestrings
deliverrushing
sixteenth-notework,
sometimes two notes per bow andsometimes one note
only.
The
pianoforte
score has all the appearance and also the effectof a series ofpianistic
exercisesinarpeggio
and scalepassages, for itgives
asbefore,
merely
thestring
work.No. 8
Piano
845
But what about the other orchestral
groups?
It would have been easy togive
the passage work to onehand,
and somerhythmic
chordal work to the other.Now compare the organ
adaptation.
No. 8 ^
II16,8,and4 with Reed 8
IIItoII
n to Fed.
Pedal
In measure 1,we see the
brightjubilant
chordsgiven
to the manuals andthe
descending
string
phrase
to thepedals.
In measures 2 to
5,
the left hand takes over therunningstring
work,
andthe
right
hand delivers thearresting
andrhythmic
wood-wind chords. Had theeighth-note
rests of the wood-wind been eliminatedhere,
the sustained effectof the horns could have been obtained
by
lengthening
the dottedquarter-note
chords. But the marked
rhythmic
element would have lost much of its effect.The
rhythm
of the hornsmeasures.
Allegro
Excerpt
from the chorus"He,
watching
over Israel"inMendelssohn'soratorio
Elijah
moderate "U12 e FI. Ob, Cl.inA Fag Cor.in D TimpDA He watch-ingo - vei sleeps, He slum -ViolinI ViolinII [80]from the chorus "Then did
Elijah"
in Mendelssohn'soratorioElijah
Moderate maestoso
J=
Fi.
Cl.inB
Cor.inF
Cor in B
Then did E-li - jab the
ViolinI
ViolinIf
Choral Works
The chorus "Then did
Elijah"apparently
presentsa very hard nut to crack! Look at thevigorous
bassoon and bassstring
passages!
Onemight
almost betempted
toindulge
in a kind of violentdribbling
andpassing
of the feetonthe
pedal
board,
a kind of acrobatic feat ofjuggling
eighth-
and sixteenth-notesat a fair
speed
on thepedals.
But wherefore so much wasted
labor,
with at the veryleast,
anequal
lossof effect?
Look at the
powerful
horn chords" the lowest hornproviding
a strongsustained bass. Look at the exultant wood-wind
declamatory
chords"placed
high
up in the compass of the instruments to enforce the sense of the words"Then did
Elijah
break forth like a fire." These are the features we must aim atreproducing
in the organtranscript
" not a slavish adherence to theletter" but a broad reasonable
reproduction
of thespirit
of the work. No.10Piano
The
important
horn and wood-wind chords are omitted in thepianoforte
score. No.10 Manual IIIFull IIFull toReed 9 IIItoII ILto Fed. PedalThe left hand on a
fairly
big
great organ willbring
out the forceful bassstring
passages, and theright
hand willprovide
the chords on the samekeyboard.
The
pedals
take the lowest horn notes whichgive
the foundation tone to theharmony,
and alsopreserve therhythmicfigure.
Or,
theright
hand couldgive
the chords on a full choircoupled
to full swell(an
octavehigher
than indicated in thetranscript)
leaving
the greatorgan for the lefthand.It would be ridiculousto take the
nigged
bassstring
passages on thepedals,
for it would result in
destroying
the proper balance of organ tone.It would be
equally
absurd to tryandreproduce
thesyncopated
work of theupper
strings.
Suchquick
syncopations
arepeculiar
tostring
work " but areuselesson a
keyed
wind-instrument like the organ.In the
transcript,
we must oust thisrhythmic
elementwhich,
in the formgiven
in the excerpt and at thespeed
J
= 76 isdistinctly
an orchestral 'feature.Excerpt
from thelatter
part
of the chorus'Then didElijah"
inMendelssohrfsoratorio
Elijah
Moderato maestoso
J=7*
n. Ob, Cl.inP Fa* Cor.inF Cor In R Trpt.UC Bass Tromb. and Oph. Timp.A.E S. A. T. fi. ViolinI ViolinII Via. V'C. C.B.ycna - not,with fie-~^ry
fie-l.
Laterin the same chorus from which the
previous
excerptistaken,we find quitea differentproblem
to tackle. Here"fiery
chariotsandfiery
horses"areChoral Works
(one
note perbow)
" apartial
imitation of the sound ofrushing
horses" a kind
of musical
"onamatopceia."
All the rest of the orchestral forces deal withprominentfigures
supporting
andamplifying
the vocal elements.NOTE. The bass trombone and ophicleidemaintainingthe forceful foundation work" and the
drums, continuallyrollingon bottom A.
No.ll
Piano
1 *' "
None of the
wood-wind, horn,
or brass groups aregiven
inthepianoforte
score. No. 11Manual
In these
days
ofenormouslylarge
andmarvellously
builtorgans, it would be rash to assert that such and such an effectcannot bereproduced
onamodern instru-ment.But
although
wonderful contrivances arecontinually
being
invented toassist
and,
presumably
to ease, the control of innumerablestop-knobs
orstop-keys,
anorganist
likemost other humanbeings,
has but two hands and two feet!Ifwe look
carefully
at the orchestration ofExcerpt
2,it will be seen thatthere are three definite forms of
accompanying
material.First,
there is thesupportingground
work of drums and low brass. Thesegive
the basis of the harmonic structure. Then there is the wood-wind and horn group, which servesthe double purpose of
filling
up theharmony
andassisting
the choral parts.Lastly,
thestrings
arebusy
with astrongly
definedrhythmicfigure.
A
satisfactory
solution of the firstwill be attainedby taking
the low brassparton the
pedals.
Thisdisposes
of thefeet,
the properplace
for the foundation tone of the harmonic structure.The
filling
in partsassigned
to the wood-wind and horns could be takenby
theright
hand on a small greatorgan(at
firstsmall,
'thenincreasing
inbody)
coupled
to swell. Thus we havesupplied
the necessary support for the voices,and have
disposed
of the feet and theright
hand. We haveonly
one hand leftand that must take over the
string
parts. Here we mustcompromise
and notattempt to
reproduce
thestring
repetitions.
The best way to make an artisticcompromise
of thestring
group isto introduce tremolo chord work. This willproduce
a certain amount of the restlessmovement, which must berepresented
as far aspossible.
a NOTE.
^
The low brasseighth-notephraseisintentionallyaltered in order to clear the air,so to speak.
As it stands in thetranscriptitis clearer and more sharplydefined than it would be if the pedalswere to
adhere to the original.The latteron the pedalswould be inclined to sound thick muddy and raucous.
The alteration isa simpleone, yetthe improvementin the effectamply justifiesthe substitution of the sixth
Excerpt
fromthe finalchorus"Andthen shall your
light"
in Mendelssohn* oratorioElijah
Andante maestoso J-"t
ff I * 8 4 W 5 6
The lastexcerptfrom the
Elijah
serves to illustratetwo veryimportant
points,first,theopeningstring
passage,
played
veryloudly(one
note perbow),and withoutany
wood-wind,
hornor brasswork.
Second,
theappearance in thepianofortescore ofa silent
halfwatwre
in theaccompaniment duringthe [86]Choral Works 27
lasttwo beats of the second and fourth measures. This latter
thoroughly
ex-emplifiesthe utter
falsity
of theaccompaniments
of choral-orchestral works asexhibited in the
pianoforte
scores.There are no silenthalf-measuresin the
accompaniment
here,
for it will be seen in the fullscore, that the whole of the wood-wind, horns,
and brass forms amagnificent
phalanx
of orchestral tone,supporting
the choral forces and at thesame time
enhancing
themeaning
of the words "And then shallyourlight
breakforth as the
light
of themorning
breaketh." No. 12Piano
The
importance
of the firstpoint
lies in the fact thatalthough
it is notgenerally
advisable to substitute fullorgan forbig string
tone, the passagegiven
here isso very strong,the moderatespeed
allowing
each note to beplayed
with a firm bite of the
bow,
that it wouldrequire
anample
great organcoupled
Manual III Full
[I Fullto Reed 8 "
IIIto II IIto Ped.
to a
good
fullswellto endow the passage withsufficiently
vitality
andgrip.
Excerpt
from thechorus "How
lovely
isThy dwellingplace"
in Brahms's
Requiem
Con moto moderate
n. Ob. Cl.inB Fag. Cor.InB S. A. a*
I
f
m
raC.E* " n"* *"EE"
SE
they praise Thy name ev - er - more.
"^"
^
^=^
T. fi.
ViolinI
they praise Thy
theypraiseThv
S
m
^
lame ev - er " more, name ev - er - more, Via, CJ.they praiseThy name ev - er - inore^. they praise
Excerpt
fromthe
Allegro
movement"Bnt
man jnay notlinger'*
iaBrahms's
Song
of
Destiny
Allegro
vb.
CJB.
Choral Works 31
Brahms' Song of Destiny from which this excerpt is taken, is not nearly so
well known as his greater work The Requiem, but it provides some very in-teresting
problems in transcribing for the organ some of its orchestral accom-paniments.
The full score of Excerpt 11 shows that the voices are strengthened at the
unison and octave pitches by all the wood-wind, each pair of wood-wind in-struments
playing in unison, as directed by the orchestral indication a2 " and
not each one playing a separate part.
The strings have vigorous passages to play, one note per bow, and repetitions in sixteenth-notes. The strings here are again absolutely independent " yet
this is the part which is given in the pianoforte score.
No. 14
Piano
In the organ transcript
the string movement is maintained by the left hand on a fairly heavy great
organ. The pedals coupled to the great, with the right hand on an ample choir
organ coupled to a good swell corroborate the voices.
It gives a reasonable representation of what is going on in the orchestra,
Excerpt
fromthe
Allegro
movement "Bnt man may notlinger?'
in
BrahmsfeSong
Of
Destiny
Allegro
" " ^ ' ^ ~ ^ ^ ~ "^*"uMe-bMseg aw, taken offthepassage and puton to the foundationnotes. The
Violin I] VU. vt. CJB. , . . " f
3toa more
complicated
form oforchestration than has yetbeen
given
in thisbook.Excerpt
15 shows a muchChoral Works 33
The
strings
are stillplayingrepetition
sixteenth-notesbrilliantly,
one note perbow, in the form of
wide-range
broken-chord passages.The vocal leads,
excepting
thefirst,
are notsupported,
but the chorus isbacked up
harmonically
by
the whole force of wood- wind,horns,
and brass. Thesyncopated
chords at the end of thephrase
add aprominent
rhythmic
effecthere.No. 15
Piano
The extensive range of the broken chord work in the
strings
issotelling
andbrilliantthat some of itsfeatures should be
brought
out in the organtranscript.
No. 15
Manual
III Full
Let us see how itmay be done.
The
right
hand and lefthand(alternating)
dotted quarter-notechords in the firstand second half of each measure,give
therequisite
harmonicstrength
andbackground
which thewoodrwind, horns,
and brass have in the orchestralscore.The
string
passages are takenby
the lefthand andright
hand(alternately)
inthe firstand second half of each measure, and
playedlegatissimo.
The
playing
of thesestring
passageslegatissimo
so that the chords accumulateand grow, will add breadth and
weight
to the wholegeneral
effect.It should be
played
on a full great organ without reedscoupled
to fullExcerpt
from the
Allegro
movement "But man may notlinger"
inBrahms's
Song
of
Destiny
Allegro
8-Jfal
7WQ:
JT
J
y
Fl Ob ClinB Fag Cor.inC T B. Violin I Violin II Via V'C. C.B.I
p^
and noJL.
no But *i
nanI
nay not lin " ger and no no
-P
Butman may not lin "
ger and no " where, no - where* no
m
Choral Works 35
This lastexcerpt,also from Brahms'
Song ofDestiny,
willbring
to an end thefirstsection of this work on organ
transcription.
The
scoring
islight,
wood-wind and hornsonly being
used in the firstfourmeasures " thefirstviolinand 'cello
being
added for the lastfivemeasures. Eachvocal lead is
helped
outby
one of the wood-wind group.The
pianoforte
score in this case doesgive
a fairrepresentation
of the or-chestral parts" but as no orchestral indications aregiven,
one is left in thedark as to the orchestral color constituents ofthe
phrase.
No,Piano
10
The vocal bass and firstbassoon lead may be taken
by
the lefthand(in
theorgan
transcript),
No.ie
III Soft.S,withGambaioneadded I Soft 8 IIIto I Ito Fed. Manual
^
PedalV-P'ijI
f =3= ui "ii* r 1^1PP
on a softgreat organ, while the
right
handdisposes
of the upper wood-windwork on a choirorgan
coupled
toswell,
both these organshaving
a faircomple-
ment
of soft8 and 4 stopsdrawn.
The second bassoon part can be allocatedto the
pedal*"
for this is the bassof the passage.
Later in the same
phrase,
theright
hand must leave the wood-wind andjoin
the upper vocal
leads,
thequarter-note
movement of flute and firstviolinbeing
The orchestral accompaniment of choral works involves the use of an
ever-varying palette of musical coloring, each color being spread on our musical canvas
in an idiom best suited to the characteristics of each individual instrument or
group of instruments.
The scheme of orchestral accompaniment brings into play four prominent
families or groups of instruments, viz.: string, wood- wind, brass- wind, and per-cussion,
each group providing an inexhaustible supply of musical effects " a
variety of musical effects which no pair of hands and feet could possibly reproduce,
however large and modern the organ might be.
But
organs of a very useful and complete t ype are far more numerous and more
available than that greatest of all musical combinations " the modern full
orchestra with its sixty to eighty performers.
Choral works with orchestral accompaniments are frequently given in
cathedrals, churches and concert-rooms, with the
organ as a substitute for the
orchestra. The organ can never be a reproduction of a complete orchestra, but the
judicious use of a good instrument, with artistically laid out accompaniments,
will make an excellent substitute for it.
An ample technique both on the manuals and pedals is necessary for the
performance of such accompaniments, as well as a true conception of the or-chestral
effects under consideration.
Up to this point we have been dealing with the orchestra as a medium of
accompaniment. The next section will be devoted to the transcription of phrases
from the great orchestral works, where the orchestral forces form one great solo
body.
Additional note to Excerpt IS
The terms "full great organ" and "full swell organ" have a somewhat
vague significance since in some of the largest instruments it would mean twenty or
more stops on each of these manuals " while in small
organs it might mean
only five or six on each. In this latter case, viz.: that of very small instruments,
it would be
necessary to add the pedals to the sixteenth-note phrase in Ex-cerpt
12, because such a small great organ would lack the requisite amount of
body and weight. There are probably no two instruments quite alike in size
and composition of tone, but the author has in mind, for the purpose of illustrat-ing transcribed
passages, the average instrument of three manuals and pedals,
with about thirty or forty sounding stops " couplers, composition pedals
or
The
Transcription,
for
the
Organ,
of
Orchestral
Symphonic
Work.
The
principles
governing
thetranscription
of orchestralsymphonic
workare the same as those which obtain in the
rearrangement
of orchestralaccompaniments.
In the former classof
work,however,
muchgreater
care anddiscrimination
are
needed,
because the orchestral combination isa "solo" one, and not amedium of
accompaniment.
The chief aim should be to endeavour to make that which is
arranged
fortheorgan sound as
though
it had beenoriginally
written for it.It is betterto
simplify
and cut down the orchestralscore than to crowd asmany notes into the three-staveorgan score as the hands and feetcan
actually
grasp. These remarks
apply
moreparticularly
to modern orchestralcomposi-
tion,
in which
large
orchestrasare the rule.With
regard
toearlysymphonic
music,
where arelatively
small orchestrais
employed,
such asMozart, Beethoven,Weber,
and Mendelssohnused,
thereare
greaterdifficulties
tocontend
with.Though
many of thesescores areslender,
the instruments are used ina moreindependent
mannerthan
isthecase with thelarge
modern score. Theharmonic
backing
and
filling-in
material which isgiven
to each groupin.
modern orchestralmusic is
entirely
lacking
in the earlierscores.In the
latter,
the melodicimportance
of the work allocatedto each instru-mentis thrown into
greater
prominence
and reliefthan in the modern scores,because of the absence of the innumerable
doublings
ofso many notes.For thisreason, a
Mozart,
Beethoven,
orWeber
movementis
moredifficult
to arrange
satisfactorily
than
aWagner
movement. WithWagner
orTschaikowsky
there isso much tochoose
from inthe
score, and manyeffective
altenmtivesarepossibleinthetranscript.
WithMozart
orBeethoven
there isverylittlethat
might
beconsideredredundant
from thepoint
of view ofthe
organtranscript.
The
excerpts
given
in thefollowing
pages are all from
works
which arein the author's
repertoire
of the St.George's
Hall,
Liverpool,
Recitals.
They
have
thereforehad thetestofpractical
performance.
Orchestral Works
Many of the examples are capable of being artistically transcribed in several
ways, but the author hopes that the suggestions and adaptations here given,
may stimulate organ recitalists to make a larger and freer use of the splendid
heritage of symphonic works for their recitals.
The more an organist uses his flutes and reeds in an orchestral manner, the
freer and more artistic will his playing become, whether in accompanying or in
solo work. The more an organist studies and strives to play the symphonic
works of Mozart, Beethoven, Weber, Mendelssohn, Schubert, and Schumann,
the clearer and more intelligible will his technique become, whether it be the
Excerpt
from Mozarfs 0 minor