ffi
Suapes
eF
GRAv
f--7Mass
Media
lThe
television
isdetrimental
toour
abitity
tothink
criticalty.
2should
westill
expectobjective
reporting from
today,s mass rnedia?Society
5-34
3Has
globalisation
made theworld
morecivilised?
4clobalisation
has cr€atedtwo worlds,
not onc.Comment.
5somc
high-profile
politicians
havebrought up
claimsthat the
youngadults
in
indllstrialized
or
rapidly industrialized
countries
like
theUnitcd
Statcsand
Singapore are too self-absorbed. Do yott agree?6The
family
has suffered at the expenseofcareer
iD Singapor€an society.Disc6s.
TCri(ically
examine the forcesthreatcning
thefamily
in Singapore.8Critically
examinethe
forcesthreatening the
family
inSingaporc
todav.9Parents
in
Singaporc today hnve generallyabdicated
thcir
responsibilities.
T(, ivhat extent do you agreewith
this statement?lols
ar
agl]ingpopulation
necessarily a badthing?
llls
an ageingpopulation
necessarily a b:rdthing?
12ln
this
modern
era, the agedare
becomingmore
ir.relcvantthan
theyale
useful. Whatarc your
viervs?lS
lhe
greatcst
obstacle to womcn achievingeqtlality
is the wornenthcrnselves. I)o
you agree?
l4our
lives aredetermined by the
places$e :rre
born
into.
How
true
isthis
belicP
IsPublic
figures
haveto
behavewel!
atall times.
Do you agree?l6"Thc road
lesstravellcd." (M.
Scott
Peck) is beingdiffcrent
overratcd?
Valucs
35-43lTHumlln lifc
is precious nndnrtlst
bc preservcdat allcosts.
Discuss.lSAsian
Values: Dothcy
exist?\
38capital
punishment
versusthe
life
sentence. Discuss.3gEx-criminals ought to
be given a secoud chance. Discuss.Sports
82-8940Sport is
taking
fun seriously.
Doyou
agree?4lsport
hasfallen short
ofits
true
ideals. Isthis true of today's
world?
42Isit true that
competitiye
sport
isall
about
fameand
money?43with
technology,sport
is nolonger
the samc. Doyou
agree? Miscellaneous44"H€al
theworld,
makeit
abetter
place."
Can we? 45"Science enslaves, thearfs
liberates."
Discuss.46Any
changein
society beginsin
the
school.Comment.
4THistory
isdominated by wars.
Discuss.48comment
on the st:lteof
tr:rditional
rrts
in
your country.
49GeneticPatcnting
S0Tragedy
and
Our
Response90-104
Quotes
Vocabulary
105-109 110-113
\
The
television
isdetrimental
toour ability
to
think critically.
The srereotypical imase
of
theAmerican
family
isoften
that
of
an obese middle_ aged farher. hiswife
andchitiren
on
thc"",g"
of
b;;;.;;';u"."
,,li"L,*..
,ra';"g
",
].1.^Y:::,q"
white
earine
chips.
rhis
..*u,io.
u,o;;;"";;;;'.;;;;:.,.
nor
enlirety uncommon rn devetoped nar,onsand
rew wonder
"h)
;;
i;i;;"";;;';
orren calted rhe"idior-box".
Of
lare.
it
has [reen accusedof
discouraging""a
"r.*
ir"","g
a
neSari\eeffect on rhe
vieweft'
abiliry
to rhinkcriticaly.i;; #;",iil;,"r""!il,lir"",
n.*".,",,
First
of all. ir
is neccs.an
toclearly
defi
e whet
is
refercd lo
bv
one sability
lo
tlLink
criLica'y.
tr rcfers ro rnear,;liry
of
rhci"di",d";i-;
i;;i';i.Jri
i1,10..,,"..
o, ,,,
issue
and weigh borh
rheir
meriLsand.faltacies
d;"#;;:;firion.
To
thintrcriticatly
is ro rhink independenrtu*a
ai.pu.ionui"ii,;i;;,f";il"*
unafl.ecred by
public
opinion.Lrsrly, ir
is
rheabil;ty
tomake a
rati&i;;:#;;lltson
*hur on","
five
senses have observed, not one based onp*t
"*p"ri"".".
oiffi;"*"
ln
this aspect, the televisionitselfis
to blame to an extent.Most
of
the timc, whatore
sees on any tclevision channcl isthe.A-".i.un
ui.*.
it
illi" i".u"u.."l",ng
,rr" *toUnte.onotnii .uf'er
porrer.
ir
hrr.
nrrmfredtrillrnns
i",o In.Jir',..nn.lorr"',o
p.n1",, ,,.
;,,ji.;;#,J,::,j.;l,l::i
:ig.i.y1l3
.,,"p;"i""
;;;,;:;;";:'",;;,,1.,,,
dround ,,,e:.;;;.;-,;
;,;i
;,"il*"';:,i";l:iH;1
:
::;
iffiI",l:.il.:.,ii
;l:.1#i;:':
advalced satellite technology
in
the
world_A
lot
of
news andeven
entertainmenl we rcceive is notwitholt
an American sltt
"..
is o,rtyu,re'ui.*;;l;:#;:1*
one
wonders how one canthink
criticallv
when Of'ten.the
infomtalion
we reccivc
is
already
in
processedfon]r.
When flmous
:i'::if':f1i:,j:i1fi:::
::":J5;:'"r"
juagn'.,'i
o,'
,,,f
i,,u., iil'o.irr, ,",i";.",
"n,
their idols
say even
if
th.
."l"b.itutl
Atd"nt
fanso[
celebrities hango'
to every wordc.iri";i;;l;;s;b,L,r'i'ii,,"iiii,iil5l'ws
rirrrc
or
nothrrtgrbout
a
Prrticular
issuc.Another
important reasonwhv
rhe telertsion is more prone to such accusation in
comparisoo
ro
orher
rnass nredi:ri< the
,.,.;
;il;
";;;;';#'i',in',
',"."','J,
. *"*,,
il.rlormilin . WlleI
r(rdi
g,u.r..p,,p.r..,u,.
hjlst,,
tr)
^n".s
lr\t
to
tmirAinei
d
s..c thecverr
rcporrc,t
hrpperrinr
ir
'ne
s
rrrirrd
},...
,"1,u
onr1i.
in""oi",*o
.",o,,,"u
nhotoBrilphs
to aj(l the
Fro!c\s.
The radio
only
providcs
sound, so
what
the cventitself
IooL: lrke
r.
upir
ro
intcrtrr,.rirriL,rr
fh"
<lr.rn
_q"i.",r
,o
",,r!ir"'1u"n,.,r,.,,,,,,,*
r(qurre\
rtrnl'18
rlrrlirv
rrnddrttcjenr
peuptc
uil
inrertrcr
,h";;;;;;
."
,i.,,
0",_",,,
opinions-
-Ielc\
tsion, howercr ,
is
mtull
colour
and stercophonic sound and one docs notneedrorhinkJr
:rllwhilc
reccr\ino
rh.
intonrrrun ur".,a.i.,
,rrr"rlr,',i""1.".".,,
I*o.,u,
ol
li\c.cn.es
rle
fttlly
cilterc,l J.ri.rn,l
rhiscrl,ja||r. wlr) it
rs
e.r,)
to
irhsorh 1n;6r_.,,,onil[ri':,:::,:il:l]
rheebir
rytotrrinr,criticairf
Jim;;i;h;.;r;;J;;;i
i"o,r r,utonry
t
I
rl
I
I
I
i
T
I
T
:
f
:
I
I
t
I
!
t
I
.
However'
saying trrar rerevision.is.only
detrimenralto critical
thinking
woutd, alJ:rin beinational.
There are mind-srimulatingp.og.o--".
toi","".
".a'"a"y"a
Uy"li
on
channels
such as Narional
Geographic,'Diicovery
ifr"*"i'ani
ggc
fn.iri.t
Broadcasting
Corporation).
Oftcn, highly
.ont,nu"rriit
,rr"*'_l'ol"o"o
"p
_a
1,:.:!:ll!,"u
c\jltu.,,e,t.
objccriv.ry
,,,,1"i
t.ngrr,,";,;s,,;;._,i.n ll'lno,o
,,,u...
I i
r\s[.s
Jrc dehaled tu tlleevtcllt
rlrar irsfr.r.
and cunsrr(
c\posedJn,l
the publrc canmrke rr.
o$.n
rdtrondtjudBnrenr
Jtrcr lhe
d(tire
,,.,",.
M,:,.;r";:
;ui..,,,.
,,"**
cnJrmets
\ucn
rs
BB(
anLif-lrarrnel \ewsAsr.r gu
r\,gre.rt
lengrh.to irrteivieu
peoplcwho
havc sl.oog views regarcring an issue and they are-caretir
nlot,o
le:we-out any other
perspeclivcs. The
_individual sitting
at
home
ian
thus form
tri"_-o*,,'op,nron
on corrtenrior,\ rssucs Irkc clonrng L,r retrorisDtl
for
exan4rle, t"r.a
on_fri"-o*n
five
senscsJrrrrrnlnKln:
JOrlrl\.norlIib.r.kprolrlld.Lrplrrrrrernr..r puhltcofinion.
Whether the television has a negJti\ c
Effc!t
o[
crillcJl
thrnkingur
not dcpends onwhat
viewcrswant
to
watch..fhc
f:rctihrt
pr,.,gr"nun".
*f,,.1
Jn ',lr?"n.o"u.og"
c.iticat
thinking
tend.to be nrorcpopular
rharr rhosewiL.h.r",
.r,",". ,i", p."pi"
iiuo,,1,
ao no,want
ro
thirk
criticelly_
.I.hcrcforc,
one
has
to
bc
careful
,"ir"n'Ji...-ing
*t,.r
progralnnles to watch as a slaple
dict
and wha( to watchlvhcll
onc wants to relaxThe
,r.e quu aments oJ-the qltestioh
an:
ut
tr.rttroJ,u
h,tn,llcLln,ell
D(.velal)ment pt)ints,,'htdl,. ..tnt,dturt.,t.thr\ r, j,.,thttt,tt,ta,dJ,t.;l
"
"
,'
Ushnish Dc 04s33
Should we
still
expectobjective
reporting from
today's
mass media?The
mass media refersto
institutions
concemedwith
the large-scale pmduction anddiffusion
of
communication. News,which is
the productof
organizational paocessesand human
interaction,
is
shapedby
the
mcthods usedin
the
news-gathering process.News
is
thus
affected
by
the
infbmration
sourcesavailable and the
organizational requirements, resources andpolicies of
pa
icular
institutions.A
pieceof
news is ideallyfree
from
bias,opinio\
personal values, prejudices aod associatedwith
scientihc
datathai
is
generatedunder
experimental conditions.
Unlike
the
past, corporations
andgoverrments
arc lrow
asserting greaterinfluence
on
the
nuss
media today.
Also,
theprofit-motivation
of
mediafirms
aswell
as the professionalismofjoumalists
are growinufactors contributing
to
the distortions
of
newsrcports. Thercfore,
we
should
not still
expect objective repofting in today's mass mediaIn
the
past, media companies weremainly
small scaled andtoo
insignificant
to acquiaeany power
of
illfluencc. The arliclcs that they
published
weie also
mostly balanccd andwell
researched.Today,
ownershipof
the mediais largely
in
the handsof
largemultinatiolal
corporatiolts-Wc
arc facedwith
an incrcasing numberof
multimedia conglomerales such asthe
Ruper(Murdoch's Media Empire
which
havelarge
controlovcr
thevarious tbmrs
of
media.The
proprictoasof
dresc largecolporations often
play therolc
of
gatekecpers. aestrictiltgthc
flow
of
infbmtation in
acountry.
Illey
often
usetheir wide
ciaculationsto
promole
their
pel political
causesor
dcligrate
people
t]rey disagreewith-
These aremaidy
done through thehiring
and firinSof
statT. For examplc, two award-winning FloridaTV
producersworking
for F'ox News have recently bccn fired afterthcy
rehrsedto
broadcastfalsc
reports aboul Monsanto's controversial lleneticallyengineercd
growth
hom)one.Therelbre,
mnnyjoumalists
are'cocrccd' or 'intinidated'
into Dot rEporting things thalatlect
thenolhcr
company and lelalecl intcrcsts. resLrlling in news repofts drat arelargely
onc-sicled andlnisleilding.
Thc prolit
molivation
of
nlediafirms
also ledto
more alisasters beiug broadcast,lhrl
appcal nlorelo
the audicncc. Thus,due
Io
corporate
influe[ces at]ecting
lhe
lrass
iledia,
wc
carno{ expect oiiectivc
reponingfiom
il
today-Cornpared
1rl
in
the
pasl,
media
companics
today
arc
increasingly
irnder government pressure-Vcry otien.
lhe govcrnntent sees the media as aplattbrm
ot
wlich
it
canput
forth its
propagandaalld
changc what the pcoplethink. This is cspccially
sowhen a
ruling pa.ty in
dratcountry
has a large sha.eof
the broaclcast nlcdia timc_In
thc recentfhailand
elections, more television coverage was given (o theprime Ministcr.
Mr_Thaksin
Shinervatre thanto
the opposition
lcaders.This
suggests thatThailand's
massmedia
is not
oeutralin
its broadcasring approach, espccially sinceMr.
Thaksin's fnmily
runs the
kingdon's
largest tclecornmunication corporation.Allhough
the mass media isgiven the
ficcdorn
to repodwhat
i1 wanls and various laws arehid
dob,n to avoid nlediabias
in
many
countries,objeclivc
reportsstill
c
nnot
bc
cxpectedlronr
today's
massnlcdilr due to govemrnent
ill(ervcntiot.
Joulnalists used
to
coocLlr
thal
obicctivily
wts
the
htllnlrrk
of
crediblcjoumirlism- They
largely wroterniclcs
orr rvhichthcy
wcretlloroughly
informed
Today,t
I
I
t
I
t
T
t
t
I
t
I
F
t
t
I
t
I
however, joumalists
lepoft
news based onhow
they see theworld ln
the recent tsunamri,r"il"rrt, i.port"."
tiom
SriLanka
areknown
to ex;ggerate the extentof
damagein their
.*"
"""*.y
to
toy
with
people's
emotionsin
an atGmptto
increasethe
propofiions
of
"ia
,rr"t
rii
po.,i
irr,o
s.i
Lanka
Thc danage
done
to
the
coast
of
other
itft'ectedJoun*i".
*u,
no,."ported. This
skewed pieceoiinformation
may mislead both the locals-J
io..ign"rr.
Sin;e joumalists
report news asthey
seeit'
they would
freque[tly
andu"ini.*io"n"ffy
slant
iheir
"ou"rug".
Oft""'
when
joumalists
try
to
be
objectivc
andU"fm""J, ,ft"y
".a
rp
broadcasting their liberaLslalt'
As
aresult'
we cannot
still
expect non biased reporting in today's massnredia-There l1as been
a
growing
intcrest among readersworldlvide in.objective
news"o-pu."Jio
in
*"
pu.t.
ihis
m"iy <tttueprofit-motivated
media cornpaniesto
broadcast-orJ
otrj".,iu.
n"*i
in orderto
incrcase readelshiP However' the problemof
liberal bias*iff
"f*'"vt
..itt i.
mediacorpotations Unbcknown
to
them'
somcof
their own vie\ts
nl.i
ia.as
*outa
rc
nintecl in theaticles
theywrite,
whether subtly ornot
Hence' westill
can|ot
expect objective reporting in today's massmedia-Morc
ancl more newspapcrsclaim
that they
are indepcndentol
-lhe Sovernmenl"na
ntnerinttu"n.ing
factors
Some of thesc media compuries and
jollrnalisrs
evcn deviseiiJr-"*t t"*tiq*iof
verifying
thc faimessof
the stories theypublish
The Oregonian'"
USfror"a
daily.
for
examples,is
saidlo
enlPloy a system callcd 'prosecutioDediling
ir"-.r;-i.
"a1tii"^,c
a
stoly.
Such news peoplc care aboutftcir
image
and thereforeItrj."titity
l{owevcr,
il
today's globalizc woricl' a
tnediacunpaoy
will
not
he able to..u,'aotuu"-E'ventuxlly'ilrvillhavelohavelinks,cilhe'withothcfmcdiacolnP.lnie\oI
utir", ,yp".
c,f con,panies. Howcver.wllen this
happensalld
the medialomparly
acccpls anykini
of
favor
fiom
any source. its stand onobjectivity
wilL cornc plumnrelingdown-ifr'"."to... it
is
still
not
possiblc
tor
us
lo
expecl objective reporting
in
today's
messmedia.
Mark Twailr
oncc said."[f
you do not rcadftc
newspaPer' you arcuninlormcd:
if
you
do
readthe
ncwspaper,you
are
nrisinfomrecl'"
fhis
is
especially
lruc
{oday'
Llslrguccl
in
the
"bnu"
po.ng."pl,,. To(lx), lhe nasr
rredrrr
lects en,rnclerting
trend
of
r"ii..ri";,v
in
it.
c.,nt.ni.
iherclbre,
pe"plc
necd
to
be cduc'tterl
Icgrrding how
lo
ii"iiirv
trri, various tbrmsof
mediasul'iectivrty
we
rs
re'rdcrs
rlso
ncLd to develop acritical
eye
when
readingttre
nc*'si'rpt'
rnrl
ehsurh
tnlolnrtlLln that l\' truthful
andLrnbiased since morc
opir;onltcd
iclcas are rnjectctlintu
the nrass rnedia rurlay coruparedto
in
the pasl. Thcreforc. !\'e caflnolstill
expectobjcctivc
repotli
g from
thc mass media today.Contcnt of
yttur
esstty is L:lcarlyttnqlc
and x'eLIotganizet!
Atog(ttt etsal'
HongJi
gHar
fl
I
T
Has
globalisation
made theworld
more civilised?
In
our rnodemworld.
theword
in
vogueis
.globalisation,_After
the collapseof
conmunism
and
the
end
of
the
cold war, globafiz;don,
where social, economic
ahdpolitical
barriers
no
longer
exists, emerged.The
workl
is
a
society
insteadof
many smaller sepamte ones,with
human interacdon possible anywhere. Oneof
globalization,s premises is thatit
can eradicate barbarism. violenccalld
wars, repJacing it_with refined a societywith
auniveAal
culture. However, many people,including
myielf,
feel
that fhisdesired effect
ofhaving
a less barbaric society hasnotieen
achievi.
"One
of
the indicationsof
a less barbaricworld
would
be a reductionin
levelsof
violence and wars. Tlreworld
would shrre a commonpolitical ideology in
globalization, wherecountries wouldwork
together to improvc rheu iivcs.This woui-jbe
frade possiblcthrough the
transmissionof
ideasand
ways
of
governance.The
westem
world,
for
example' championed the capitarisl cause and trieclto
influence
the restof
theworld
tofollow suit.
Anterica
was the forerunnerand
its
fbreign policies under
president Bush emphasizeda
hands-on approach, whercthe
Unticd
Siatesof
Arncrica
(U,S) personallyfook
it
upon
itself to
propagare wcstern ideology_They
believed
that the
US
way
of
govenitnce
ought to be adopted by everyone and thaf this way wasglobalization
in termsofpolitical
culture. However, through rhe processof
globalization, t"tre US tract nn quatms:l?ll
r:',"s
jb.*
on
rhc
rcccr.'rin8 narion.They
backed rheTaiibans whcn rhey
werc trghttnB the Sovict invasron in rhe 90s because they fcared communism spreadingfurthel.
But
they bombcd thcmin
the afremurhof
ttre 9/11incidenr They
launciect thc traqWar
to
stem
thc
tide
of
anti
American scnltment.
The
Antericans,
the
chempioris
of
globalization
in
tcmN
of
polirical
ideology,
o[ly
allowed
for
the American way
of
thinking.
other
ideaswoulrl
be quashed andif
e.rtire countrieswere ,,,,in"J
r".uu".
of
globalization through
wars ancl violencr-,ir
was unavordxble.The tjS-lcd
globalization hasonly
shown the inhcaent warring andbrrb.lriL
lurLrrcot
thcArn..i."n,
u"'ur"rutt.
..
The
benefits
()1globalization
in
tenns
of
economiceffects would be that
the divergence_bctween
the rich
and
pooacoult
es would be
reduced..liading
and
rhc exchangeof
technology and ideas would enable less_developed countries io catch upwith
developed ones-Thc
developed countr-icsfelt
that this woulL.l bc an advanced stagein
theprogress towards racial equality since
it
was a caseof
thcrich helping
the poor.It
would
the ulrimare level
of
aftainmentin
tenns
oi
moral
values.Wid
gtiUuliJ^iion
tfllougt
trade,the rich,
advanced countricscould
civilize or
enlighten the'poor,
backwad
onesand
bring
rhem rolhc
same level.I{owever,
rhisonly
workstheoreiicaliy.
Globalisation:tt
,lt"d:
gnly rc\uhcd In lhc ex|loit,rtion
of
cheaplabour
;n
count.i"s'tit"
China
andlnolA.
LaDnurInten\tvc
Lrctoaicl werc situatedilr
third
world
coufltties, whcre
workersuere
trcaredinhuntrncly,
Lvrng rn squalor and bcing paid
extremcly low
wages. f.br rnstance.hum.n
right.
groups crarnrcd thatfor
a
uS$r20 Nikc
shoe riiadein
china,
theworker
reccived less rhan UStlj l_Chikl
labour was also reporledlypracrised
by Nike
shocmanufacturing
ifldLrslricsin
China as
well.
Llencc,
giobalisation fhrougli tradc
has
allowed
multi-lation{l
corpor-ationsto lakc
aclvantageJ
cheaplabout
off.e'rctt Uv rtrira_world
couorr ics. Ycr,whilc
they hide uncler theba[nir of
providingjobs
t., rt,eott,.,*,s"
joblcss
poor and
bringing
them
to
rhe
sanrecivilizcd lcvel
evc"rriually,
rhey
pay
rhev/orkers
peanutsand give
them pathetic
livjog
conditions This is
becauseit
is
notdesirable
for
themto
b;ng
thc Poorto
the samelevel
of
riches since thepoor
would be;;lh"g a
engagein
siuchlabour then. Thus,
glotralisationthrough trade
hasonly
;;;.g-h,
-"";
the-rioney-grubbitg and
hhumane side
of
the
so-calledmore
civilized
nations and matle them appear no less barbaric as a resultIlowever, in
temrsof
global culture' we
havedefinitely
procee'dedin
a positive direction.In
thelarts, aworl6
iulture
has evolved dramatically since the pastfifty
years.Many
nrod".nists have fusedthe
bestqualities
of
the Eastern-and Westem crtlture and formecl a whole new breedof
fusion
ari.
For instance,Bright
sheng, an intemationallyac.tuiorea
Cnin"..
compute.expefl
in
America'
has successfully merged Chinese and.i^.i*f .".i"
togcther.The
successfulfusion
ol O
cnlal
and Westemstvles
would have beel1irnpossiile without globalisation
Furthermore'it
is {ar easier to have access toini".nnLionut
u"t.
becauseof
iire
fact
that they
are awareof
intemationalaudicnces
ln
i.g^p".
"f""",
lhe
numberof
intemational perlonners
is very high'-whar with
theSiniupo*
e*fti.t
e.stivat, Films
Festival and Arts Festival taking placc in thepe'iod
of
n"friuo.y
toltluy. Internatiolal
acts can beflown
in and rve candiverslfi
ourcllture
andt.ing
itio
g."ut". fl.ights. ln
this rcspect. globalisation hdsdefinitely
cxposed stonrore
cultJralchangcs
urd
rnacle us more retined andcivilized-"Gtobalisation"
is a word thats|ells
much (hangc irnd its rcirch is oLrLylimited
toIhe
size
of
our
globe- Despitc
our
ditfercrlces'
be
iI
rn temN
of
phy\i(xl
or
menlal,ilrp".iry,
*.
arc-nonetheleisequally
cauShtup
in
globatisatiolr'-lt
mayofl't
hcnefils'Liti
having avibra t
globalatls;ullurc,
or
ir
may spell tlisastcrlike
cult
ral.rcscnlmcnl',ej".tiun
n-f"
gtot,oiiJentity
to rnaintainindividralily
or the exploilntion
of
cheap lebour'fl"" t*v *.
_-"fi",c
against such changesmay
llso
show
oul
barblrricor
civilizcd
nature. We llave lobleaLthe
egg in oaderlo
nrake xn omelct'bllt
il
is anolher nlater whenit
conres
to
whether
wc
woiLld
bc wilting
to
sacrifice
our
h[manity
for
corplele
glnl\Jtr'irrrnrr irlill
:llca-ofurlr
lrulrrarr'o
ict1Mttin
probltm:
Youtiid
nttttuswer
tl(
Llltcstion"llas
"
htfu
conclusiottGootl
riisr:ussiondt.spit(
lhelttng wirlt:tlness
arul perhapstfu:
stiSht (vot
slightb)
Lackof e\)alua!i.)n. Cool!
c\anPIes
Lirrt
Yi
Niy
has
crdtted
two worlds, not
one.Comment.
I
I
t
I
rl
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
t
I
globalisation was
coiied to rcflect
the creation
of
a world
in
whichare non existent Indeed,
the ideal aim
of
globalisation
is to
unite
thethis
is
made
possible
by
the
mpid
development
in
communication Nevertheless, sociologists and economi.rsaliLe
arcunltzed
wirLr the tr,,ne globa,isationand
feel lhat
jt
ha. fallcn
\hofl
of
its
rrue
ideats.I
here'a'..people
who
feel
dratglobalisation
has separatedthe
world
morethan
it
hasagree
with
this statement to some extent.ir, One
of
the most evident effectsof
globalisationis
the creationof
a
.North_Southle'-
a term coined by economists to describe the huge economic disparity that exisrseen
ich
and poor nations. Globalisation is often see-n as a fagad"mi
rfr",iJ
,ri.rl
apitalise
on
the
poor alrd
m?Lkethemselves
richer.
Most
rich
nations
have)nted
outsourcing
policies thaf
enablethem
to
tap the
."roua"",
of
uuoth"a
for
thei
own development.This
is evidenr evcnin
South_EastAsia
itr"tf
*f,el"
t of_the
oilfields
are ownedby
Westem companies such as ExxonMobil.
Shell
andsh P.troleurn. Former Indone,ian pre\ident
Suklrno
o
\.
dubbcJ
gf"fr"ti",io,,
.rrthe
'new form of
colonialism'.
lndeed,in
the economic sense,*"
;;"
;i;;;';;;
globalisarion has created a huge
disparity
between therich
anil poor
natio.s
insLeaaof
reducing the
rich-poor
gap. Thus,in
a sense, grobalisalion has createcr nor one, but twoPolitically,
lllobalisation
has createda wo.ld
whcrc the
morepowedul
ations have
tltc
most sayin
worlclaffairs. "fhis
rgxin,
ls
eonrralyro thc
ideaihat
elc,balisation\-tould urrrc
llrc
uorld. Ho$
r.
thdr l,trssrbleqlren
rlre rnorrfowerlul n,rrion,',,r,.rt,e,.lr.;
makrrg thc deLrsion?Anlcrirr
rrgucd
lhat therc was ancedio
invade Iraq on thc basisof
SaddamHussein's
weaporsprogranlme. IJowcver, the
Unitc.l N^tio,rlr'1U11
Secu.ity
Council votcd
againstthe invasion
of
Iraq, but
wasp,r*".t...
t,-rfa"u"nt'ilr.
,nuoaiun_After thc
war,
it
soon
becamecvirient
thit
lraq,s
supposedpnr."lr"ion-ui
*""p,rn,
ut
massdestruction
(WMDS) was
a
hoax. The events'that
occurred
in ti,"
traq
Wa,
highlighted a clear
loirr -
rhar theunired
srares runsrh,"
*n,tu
nna ,rntro,tv can srand irrits
way. The situation
hasalso
becnJescribcd
o,
".U.S.
u"r"u.r-ttr.
*olti,.ituution.
Thus,
it
can be seen thatglobalisation
has notyet
fulillcd
irsulr_,
oi"riiin,
ur"
*_fa,
but ha.s crcated a
lrurf
betweennatiors.
Moreov;r,
rr h.r, c,ruscd the lesspn*.i.t,,t
uuriun. to .slrftcr from anirfcdority
complex andcomply
rvrrh thc ,lec,si,rnsol
iti"
,no." p,r*"rtut
natlons._
-"
,t|'r
is
not ro
siry
rhirr
glohtlisarion
is a
complete
tailure
though.
Socially,.9"t1':ll)r,'"1t:i.
tne mirde euhurol tusiun possiblein
many counrrics, whcre the lif.esrylesof
Last
rnd
We\r
.
e buthrhrivrng
regardlcssof
the pafto[
lhc world
thal antndividual
rs
rfl.
t[
l\
commoDro find
n
'L'hin town' in the
Uniled
States ancla
.McDonalds,
in
Sirgapore.
lhe intlux of
forcignersin individual counrrie.
i, o".
* irr.,"""i
ru.,o..'
,rr", makecultural fusion
possibrc. Indeed,culturar fusion
has crealeda
harmoi'riousmrx
ol
cultures and has made peoplc awareof
another pcrson,s cultnre.lftf,ougt
it.
i".u"
.rf
maintain
thcir
roots
even
when
exposedto
tbrciSn
cultures.
In
the
areaof
music, globalisation has enabled musiciansto
take the bestof
bothworlds
and comeup
wiih
;omething
that shows traitsfrom
both worlds. New Age musician,Kitaro'
isf'morrs
for
such com-positions and the Malaysian band'Too
Phat' is renownedfor
making'hipiop'
music usingtraditioral
tuncs. Thus,in
this
area, globalisation hasunited
the bestfrom
both worlds and created a new blend of culhrre that no country can
call
its own'In
conclusion, globalisation may have failedto
unite theworld
economically andpolitically,
butits
successin
fusing culturesis
not to be played down. Thoughit
has notiully
achievert iLs ideal aimof
creating aworld
without
borders'it
ha$ come a long wayfrom the
1940swhen the idea
of
Germanyholdirg
talks
with the
United
States was impossible. Oocof
the barriers that used to restrictunity
language-
has been rernovcdto
an exrent.No
doubt,globalisatioo is
still
not
very
successful-But neve
heless, the future certainly looksbright
as China rises as a supcrpower and balances thepowe'
once hcldby
theU;iGd
States.Hopefully
in the futurc. we can one daylook
fbrward to a realworld
without borders.The grcdt ma
il
is ),aur clear arul ol.leredthillkits
Polentidlly, Lhc grrdtestfaiIing
wouldhc
four
(:ategoricalcl.tssirtcaioll
oftle
effcctsttl
global^ation
eg
p!!j!k!A t
is nottoward one workl,
culturalh,,
it
is--Tan Yee
Kiat
04s:]4
GL@BALrzarr@N,
As
DEFINf DTH IN
G...
YOU
ARE
TALKINGABOUT C€LL
PH(DN€S. Y(DU AREGLoBALTZATIoN
Qu@T E s:IT
HAs sEEN sArD
THAT ARculNG
AcAINsr
GL@BALIzaTl@N's
LIKE ARGUINcACAINST
THE
LA'WS6F
GR,AVITY.-
K@FI ANNANBY
RICH
P€(EPLELIKE
US' !5 A
VERY
NIC€ABOUT
THE
IflT€RNET,
Y(EU ARE
TALKINGTALKING AEOUT C(EITIPUTERS.
TUIS
OOCST'T AFFECT TW@-THIRDSOF THE
PEOPLE (DF THE W(ERLD.-
IlmnY
CARTE RGL@BALIZATIoN
HAs cHAticED
us INTo A
conPANY
THAT
SEARCHES THEWORLD, N(DT JUST
TO
sELL
lDRT@
S{DURC!,BUT
TO
FINO
INTELLECTUAL CAPITAL-
THE 'WORLD.S8€5T
TALENTS AND GREATE5-T IDEAS.some high-profire poriticians
have
brought up
clairns
that
the
Joung adurts
in
industrialized
or
rapidty
industrialized
count.ies
tike
rtr"
Uni;;'i,;il;;
Silgapore
are too self-absorbed- Do you agree?Just two weeks before,
five
hundred youth convened at theNational
Universityof
singapore
in
early Jure
for
the amual
preuniversitf
,;;;;;il;;;,
Durins
the seminar,
Dr.
Vivian
Batakrishnan rlescribed Singaporeanyo"if,
.,::r"ti
".,
frr"g.y
*a
seltrsh".
In
aninformal
poll
conducred-byff,.
S"r.Ar"fi_!,
nnii
"ilil
uarri"tpru.,
*
overwhelming
majorirv
begged rodiffer wirh ,r,. rnrni.*r,
,"r"i,[
nii
iiourr,
,tu,
,t"
people
oI
their generation were becoming rooself
absorbed.So_.
-nigir_p;fff.
p,rtiti.ut
figurcs have brought
up
claims that rhe young
a.tutrsin
rnaustriaiiiea
o.
,upiaty
indusrrialized counrrics
like
rheUnircd
stu""
u"j
sing;po;
;;.;;i;:
r* ,"
*o'-absorbed.
Altfiouglr
thererna)
be some erceprions. inml
opinioni
rhosec,l.t,m"arc
urli.t
toonly
a srnall cxtent.As
educationtoday
takes ona
morc holistic
approach,community work
atul:::l-,^lj,l,,llr"^"reDr
lre
slowty being
inresratediJ," irr.'
"""J'",itrrn.
*un
,rri,
iii!=:Tfli.iLi'f::Tfi'.'.':,'"'a::'"li'":i:::'J";ii'Jlll'"#l$"ily',fi:il:,;
themselvcs
in
chariry
work. be
it
local.
o.
uu"r."ur..i-1".i_*
fii'.*"r"pr",
"ta"y
:j:":l-"::ll:
rrJr
alr
verv
ue
llii"rr.
rc(ci!ed bv theirrtudenr..
in singapore organ,,.. I.lre:c srudenrs.,..,",,.
."i;;;;;i,
in"",,.,'n",,, r.,on.,.
g"
rolreprl
tu huild
proper schools orvisit
rural areas inihailand
ro ronstrucr"anita,.y
toicrslu.
,i.
."iia"nr._ ,trv"y
from
home, thescparticipants
haveno lnalenal
ctrmlon. yet
they
carry out
the
tasks assignedvi
r
nuch
cnjoymenr
and enrhusirsm,t""*i.g
-rrr"i.
"it.,a"
t*iuta
ur"t"
"
positive diftcrence
in
thelives of
rheuldcrprivrlegca
arr"ott-,
"^"r,rii"
r.,
t,act
up
theclaim that youth irt dcveloped counlrics do
r""or*
ir"-."irl.
i" ."rlr"i"r,ri
.,v".0.."*
from
an issueof
us
sEV'ENTEEN
."g;,i;;"1.
l;:;;;;;:il:;..#:1Tir""il;.,_"
highlighted
a groupof
teenagegirls
whu underrook,p".r,.r1r*"J., ,rri
.nrgte hanacdly::::1illi':d..
r'',"',",,e.,s
(onrnrrnirv
invotremcnr
p,"t..,
LJ_,r.""r".i,r,i
*,,,,"ar"ao
sorrlcrllrns
tot
th(
lcsslbrtufi3tc.
Ftorn tlteahovr c\.rmph.s. rr is rhu. er idcnt Ihar
yoLlll
rndevelopcd countdes are
hot
selfish aod:etf
absorbcdbc.;;;;;
;;;;
th" n..,ts
uf
othersbcforc
thek own,
contrary
to uh3t
rhetcmr .,sel[-,rbsorbei..i.Jpii"..
.f.nu.,
,t"
claim
is tnre too
y a snrall exteni.-^,,
^"-1i"t,l:r
ieasonwhy rh(
young adultsin
devcloped coontries are saidro
be nor scrr-aosorDcdlt
hecxuse dLcvale
tblc
totake hardships
in
their stride and adapt tolhcir
situation instcadof
merelywhining
ir
the hopc thal the situarionwill
bet{er itserf,or
that someonewill
coil)e andbetter
thc siruationfor
them.
The
frti",.ir-" .frurl.i".ir,i.
ot
"
::1"j.1,;ii^".,^:l:ll:"'brd
yourh. f, far crytionr
thar in devetopertco"*.t",
i.ouy. r"
,r,"
wdKe
ol
rne terrunst Septentber II
auacks on the USTwin
Towers. the US
ecolomv
wasbrll)
shaten.\4rl)
innu(.crt lrve:
wcr.
l,rst arrd rnarrlsulo
brcr.lwrnrrclr
".,i:;:;'i,;;.
stack.
As
nillions
moumed rhe deathshcro..
rr,"
Us,i*t","
oir""ii,
".,j..'in"
"."",o
:T*U"","0
rrllrecl ro_gcrher. formrng supporr groups lhar helped ride each olhcr over the oeillnul
luvcli
nnes.It
is:uch
'self-absorbed'
for
insteadof
grievirigsilently'
they take hardshipsin
their stride and go a step further to help those in the same boat as they.Closer to home,
just
afew
years ago, the Singapore economy was not doing verywell
and cornpanies carried out rnajor retrenchment exercises'leavilg
many Singaporean parents unemployed. Some, although sti1l employed,took
major
wage cuts such that aitranpe
in
tifesrvie
was warranted. When interviewedor polled by
thelocal
media as tonoru
ih"y *out
i
.op.
with
the reduced incomeflow
in
the household' most parents citedmeasure; such as
."ducing
their
teenagers' pocketmoney
andcutting down
on buyingiu*ury
it
-r,
purchasing
only
what was
absolutely
necessarJ'In
respoDseto
theirp-",it.'
I."ta"rr.lt-"nts or
wage cuts, asmall
numberof
Singaporeanyouth took fo
the;fieets
in
searchof
work
in
an
attempt
to
supplementthe
household's
income
l-ess significantty, however,in
responseto
thepoll
on their parents'.mostofthe
youth polledreieated
ttratthey
would
acceptleductions
andother financial
changes unquestioningly because they understa[d thesituatio[ their
parents arein
Whenfufther
lu"'.tion"a
^i
io
hn*
th"y
would aid the cuffent
economicsituation' most
youth cited sacriftccslike
spending less andgoilg
out and eatingoul
Less often to ease the burden ol1their clders. As such.
ii
can bc seentiom
thc above mentioned that the youth in developed countries are ableto
take hardshipsin
their
stride and adaptto
the situation-
deltnitely
not a mark
of
a
self-absorbed generation. Thus,the
slatemenlthat youth
in
developed countries are too self absorbed is trueonly
to a small extcnt'On the
flipside
however,
there are
instaoceswhen
thc
youth
of
developed countries can besclf
absorbecllt
is lhese limes that catch the ettentionof
inclividualsilr
the govemrnent, who then speak abotlt
il'
tamishing the imageof
the whole gcnelction' Oneiexamplcin
rvhichthis
natureof
being self-absorbed carr surface is whe-n the youngare lacing
sliff
competition-[n this
situation.
it
is
"evcry
manfor himsell''
and manywould gJ
all
out
;i{l
litlle
regard
of
others.just so lhey would
enicrgc
vrcnnious'Althou;h
it
is
convenicntto seJthis
as a characleristicof
the
generation as a whoLe'it
woulcl Le bcfterif
onc examineslhc
situation intowhich
the yoLlng are plxced-ln
today'sfast{aced world,
cspecially
irt
dcvelopcd
countries'thc
young
must keep uPwith
thecompetition should they want
to
keep afloat. Thus,
it
lhen
becomes rccessaryto
bc selfish andself
absorbed.ln
conclusion. the youthill
dcveloPcd coufltrics areself
absorbedto only
a smallcxtenl.
They
have proven
to
be
lble
to
take
hardshipsin
their stride' idapt
to
theirsituation.
and
thcy
clo
put
the
needs
of
the mderprivileged befbrc
the
needs
of
thcmselves.They
do, however bccomesclf
absorbed whcn facedwith
stifTcomlctirlon'
in
which case itiecones
a necessily.Thc
clai
tha{ lhey are toosclf
absorbed probably stems frorn the fact thatit
is easierto
rcmember the bad pointsof
the generation insteadof
the good,but
as has been proven, the characteristics displayedby
the youthof
today","
o
i",
ary
frorn the
"self]absorbcd"
generationpainted
by
many menhers
of
thc gcneration bcforc ours.7)ood essayl
l(ell
baLanced, r:artJu[[y t ttnsidercd wirh ugood
ttst ttf cxutnples NurRaihana
04522The
family
hassuffered
at the expenseofcareer in
Singaporean
society. Discuss.
As
Sirgapore
progresscs.oeopj:
arebecomitg
ntorc
alld nlote
edu.ated.
As
a
;H1'*:\H:::;:t":;":xfi'";:'
rendro
wanrtu rocu'
moreon
rhe,,'i.,.e,s.
rhu'.
dererio,
a,ed
ir
rJ"""
ii'
0",_iur,'i.,fl
"ll".1,
:rff
:;,"oJL#:lll
nlln
Hl;ril:l
ard
te5s rime spenl$irh
lhefa;itv
olhers
mighr""""
.rr.."1,1.,
,. iru.'",i,t.lr.n
in rtr. tust place. Hence,ir
would befair
to say thatf".ify
_f^o"r.i"r.
,i,o.i"nJ
""*,ng
,t.
famity ro be less
ctosel)
knir. as a resutrolenrptra.is
on;;.;;;;;;..'"'
''
,"
"
Traditionally,
men were
the
bjead
winnersof
the family and
women
usually srayedar
homeand
spenrrheir time tooking
,t
"l'
rrr"j'ii;ral"?"lu"olil
n"*.n"a
chores.
Bur xs more
peopic are educated,,n-",;
;";;;
"."',.,,r#:#',tj..
n"r"r,*,
\
here bothlarentri
are notworkins
arAs a
resu
;,;.;;.
;;;.1;_:
;;J
:,
ffi
lJ,xl"iffi
lTii
;:il
ij
Li'l:H:ilT1;:;
responsibilities at
work,
theynow
havr".i.r,,""
"n.,,gr,
;;;;"",*t;;'fi;",T.T"fi
in::"ll].fir-:i::ili;.:1.r,"-i::i
neglcctcd
Filmil)
rellrions
suffer. xitd to worcen the situe{ion,ill
somccases. the
chiklren
pjck
ut) bcd
hrbirs
sucb assnrokrns
In.a
recenr.i
rr'".,ij."r"i,-,i
"
lshown rhatchildlcn whu
atc
djnllcr:I
homc
*]th
rlre
t;rrnill
ucre
Ic.\
jrLcl)
to
rllRjr!,.
1 \rLclracri\'ic\
sucn
n.
rang
fiplt,
i.d
LiruBahu\c
ff,",.,i,-.';;;:'j,;;,,t;;; i;;i
mteraction is higrrry important
in nlainrar.ing
crusebo'ds
"irn
.,,.r.
a*,.'u,"nn".i,
*
.aieir:
couldgrcallv
ti.ducelimrly
t;m, .
,""0
.#'li
:'.ijii;',:;'fi'l
;i,1.',::j::rv'
paretlts ,esoft rohiring
crorncstic hcrpcrs ro.o'sist
of
dual;r;.;'";.;rl;:;:;leDon
rs.cornnlon
in
singapore' as
Inosl fimilies
rl,cir
.trt,tr.ll
"
,i,";"r;;,.'ii";:l'rrrs
ol'Ln
r|'n
pushrh"
r'\pnn',hil'r\
.r
biir*,iI
rp
:rbou
rrrrrrng,n",,',i,,,""i'i".i",.',,1ffi::llli,;;:.:ilir,il',,i."ij'li;,,i,liiilll
j:lg.hl
I:.t
:j,."ii"."
rhu.
prctrnu ,,prrdcsirilbte
r"rt,,..
r"
,,tj,,t,",.
lln,,,
l_,,0.
*o,,,0
De
ucal
r.
Il)cchrl,lrcn
se( therrrrrid.
rrorc
tlr.rn thcrrpJrcl,..
ii,r_.
i, ,rr,,|e,,,.,,rf.,fo,
they mighr bc cioser to thc maids rhan parents. Hence,tbr
thc sakeoiirr"i,:.r,.*,
por"u,,
ffil
,
[iJ;1"1i:lrrrv
nt
rookrns'ti"'
'ur*",'',"''r'".
a,,""]"'iiii,'il.iin",.
o*,,",
,. ,,
tt.1l,
lenpic
in SinpJporc. rlrer.lrrl
tenrilycurrsisr.,,t.fJr.nt,.,l|d,l,rl.lr.o
lrr.
rlr.
rrc
talit)
oI:ocict\
thJt
jr
furnil)
\\uIld
"",
,*.o",1f",.
*,,no,,,
,,,,,0,,.".
Ho$c,c1
x,i.4.,.1,
hcc,me.morqc,Jrrcar-.,"",.""r"*.",,i;:'l;;'",::jl:"..,.,".,_
on thcir
careerstirst
and havcchildren at a
laterage,
or
nor
have.nro_"
,".rii.'
iirlli
placing
so muchelfolt
into
building
up their
uilreers, sonte couplesmighl
nor want
to 'pendo,,.rrirdr...
hur ,nrrcad.p"nj,t,"i,
r,n,a..,n.,i
;";;;.';
;il,,1,lli]:\
r, r
srL,,ryconductc,l rn
Silgaporc
il
lead
uurrrerr\rh!, uent tbf
.f_,,,r,. ,,.."
,1,,^,,.,rjrs:ilyltJr
rr,i,
rr,e)
.rid
,,or
ui,,r
bab,eLro
hro.r.
rr,.,,
.,;;;,,,;;_
i;;
l',l,"lii
lii",.
,,.
",",,,
suffcrs
in
that
couplesare
lesswilling
to slarl
families_Thercforc.
at
the
cxpe[sc
ot
career. fewer
lamilies
are formerlOn the other hand, an emphasis on career does have
its
advantages-With
greater income, thetamily
can lead a comfortablelife. This
woulddefinitely
boostfamily
ties as,fr"
f"-ify
wouli
be
able
to
participate
in
activities
and spendtime with
each other*i
fr"ut ftu"l"g
to
wony abouitaking
on morejobs to
buy thenext
meal
Many
brokenfu-ili"a
."aoliu,
p-enis
resort to deiperate measures' such as cdme, to make ends meet''I'her"fore, a
stable and adequate incomewould
be beneficialto
the
family
With
goodtl-"
-*ug.fn"nt,
family
memberswould
still
be ableto
keep strong bondswith
eachoih.r.
p".."nG
shouldleam how
to
balance bothlamily
andwork
appropriatelyto
keep thefamily
going.Family
ties are extremelyinportant in
keeping afamily
as one' To do so' one hasto.p"nd
ti*"
tog.th"r with
one'sfamily.
However, as pcople,spendmole
time ontheir
."..!.r,
.u"f.tftiify
time is cornpromisld. By
just
Providingfor
thefamily.and
leavingifr"
t".rpontiUifity
oi
t
eping theiamily
goi-ng to orhers woutdonly
worsen the situation-Therefore,to
saythat
thc family
has suffercdat
thc
rxpcnscof
uareelu
sngapolean
society is generally
justified.
DaphneHo
04s26
@RD€R: T(D PUT