• No results found

INTRODUCTION TO CATALYSIS

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "INTRODUCTION TO CATALYSIS"

Copied!
80
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

Université de Rennes 1 – Vietnam National University, Hanoi

CATALYSIS FOR THE SYNTHESIS

OF BIOACTIVE COMPOUNDS

OF BIOACTIVE COMPOUNDS

Prof. Pierre van de Weghe

(2)

Synthesis of Losartan (marketed by Merck & Co), an angiotensin II receptor antagonist drug used to treat high blood pressure (hypertension).

KEY STEP : A PALLADIUM-CATALYZED CROSS-COUPLING REACTION

An example

N OH Cl N N CPh3 N N OH Cl Bu 5 mol% Pd(PPh ) , K CO new aryl-aryl bond catalytic amount !

What is the mechanism of this reaction ?

What is the role of the palladium and the base ?

Br N OH Bu N N N N B(OH)2 N N HN N N losartan + 5 mol% Pd(PPh3)4, K2CO3 THF - H2O then H3O+ aryl-aryl bond

(3)

Pro memoria

A catalyst accelerates the rate of a thermodynamically feasible reaction by opening a lower activation energy pathway. It is added to the reaction mixture in quantities that are much lower than stoichiometric ones and, in principle, it is found unchanged at the end of reaction. Thus it does not appaer in the reaction balance, and is usually written on the reaction arrow in order to emphasis this feature:

A + B [cat] C + D 3 A + B C + D A + B [cat] C + D [cat] [cat]-A A B C + D activation reaction [cat]

1- transition metal complex 2- organic molecule

3- enzyme slow

(4)

The catalyst does not influence the thermodynamics of a reaction. It changes the reaction pathways, i. e. the kinetics; in particular it lowers the energy of transition states.

Comparison of the profiles of the uncatalyzed and catalyzed reaction :

- the energy levels of the starting substrates and reaction products are the same with or without catalyst (∆G° constant), but the activation energy ∆G‡ is much lower when the

reaction is catalyzed (∆G1>>G 2‡).

- a catalyzed reaction can eventually involve one or several reaction intermediates (for instance, one intermediate in the right figure above).

(5)

Three different modes of catalysis

transition metal complexes as catalysts

organic molecules as catalysts or organocatalysis

AcO CO2H NHAc OMe 1 - H2, [cat] 2- deprotection HO NH3 OH CO2 H (S)-DOPA treatment of Parkinson's disease

[cat] = P Rh(MeOH)2 P Ph Ph MeO MeO Mosanto's approach 5

organic molecules as catalysts or organocatalysis

enzymes as catalysts

O Me NH Me O

EtO2C CO2Et

Bn2NH - TFA (cat.)

Lepidopteran sex pheromon

O OEt O reductase in yeast OH OEt O OH OEt O S R

major product minor product

(6)

TRANSITION METAL COMPLEXES

AS CATALYSTS

(7)

Organic versus Organometallic reactivity

(8)

What is a transition metal ?

(9)

Transition metal valence electron count

9

for free (gas phase) transition metals: (n+1)s is below (n)d in energy. Fe 4s 2 3d6 = 3d8 OC Fe CO CO CO CO 3d8

for complexed transition metals: the (n)d levels are below the (n+1)s and thus get filled first.

N

N N

FeΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ Cl Cl

3d6

for oxidized metals, substract the oxidation from the group “8” .

(10)
(11)

The 18-electron rule

Recall : first row of elements have 4 valence orbitals (1 s + 3 p) so they can accomodate up to 8 valence electrons the octet rule.

Transition metals have 9 valence orbitals (1 s + 3 p + 5 d). Upon bonding to a ligand set, there will be a totyal of 9 low lying orbitals (bonding + non-bonding molecular orbitals). Therefore, wa can expect that the low lying molecular orbitals can accommodate up to 18 valence electrons.

the 18-electron rule.

11

Organometallics complexes with 18 electrons are predicted to be a particularly stable because they will have a closed shell of electrons. Complexes with 18 electrons are aften referred to as being coordinatively saturated.

(12)

Electron counting

Two models for counting electrons: the colvalent and ionic models. Both give the same answer, but offer different advantages and disavantages.

Example: CH4

covalent model: since C-H bond are covalent, assume that the electrons are shared equally between carbon and hydrogen. To count the electrons, we dissect the molecule giving each atom 1 electron of the bonding pair.

H C H

H H C

H

H H : 4x1 e = 4C : 4 e

ionic model: alternatively, we can treat the bonds as being ionic. This allow us to assign a formal oxidation state to the carbon atom. This can be useful to determine whether a particular transformation is an oxidation or a reduction. In this model, both electrons are given to the atom with highe electronegativity. For C-H bond, this is the carbon.

H C H H H C H H C : 4 e Total = 8 electrons H C H H H H C H H H H + : 4x0 e = 0 C (-4): 8 e Total = 8 electrons 4

(13)

Covalent model :

NVE= nb metal electrons + nb ligand electrons – complex charge (NVE = Number of Valence Electrons)

•Metal= the number of metal electrons equals it’s row number

examples: Ti = 4e, Fe = 8e, Pd = 10e

• Ligands = in general L donates 2 electrons, X donates 1 electron.

•Formal oxidation state of the metal = nb of ligands X + complex charge

(oxidation states in organometallic complexes are merely formalisms that may bear little resemblance to the actual positive charge on the metal)

13

(oxidation states in organometallic complexes are merely formalisms that may bear little resemblance to the actual positive charge on the metal)

Ionic model :

NVE= nb metal electrons (dn) + nb ligands electrons

• Metal = you must first determine the formal oxidation state of the metal. The number of

electrons is the row number minus the charge on the metal. The formal oxidation state is simply the charge on the complex minus the charges of the ligands.

• Ligands = in general L and X are both 2 electrons donors.

In my opinion the covalent model is easier. All discussions in this class will use the covalent model, so I would encourage you to learn that one. You should also be aware of the ionic method, since you will encounter it from time to time.

(14)

Organometallic ligands :

© R. H. Crabtree, The Organometallic Chemistry of the Transition Metals (fourth edition), John Wiley & Sons, 2005

Most common ligands found in classical transition metal complexes in catalysis :

ligands type L (2 electrons in CM) : PR3, CO, NR3, alkenes, NHC, ROR1

ligands type X (1 electron in CM) : I, Br, Cl, OR, R, Ar, H …

N

C N Ar Ar

(15)

Electron counting and oxidation state:

- procedure for a neutral complex MLlXx NVE = n + 2l + x oxidation state = x

n = nb electrons metal, l = nb of ligands L, x = nb of ligands X

- procedure for complex with charge [MLlXx]q NVE = n + 2l + x – q oxidation state = x + q

n = nb electrons metal, l = nb of ligands L, x = nb of ligands x, q = complex charge

covalent model Rh : d9 = 9 e 3 x PPh3 : 3 x L = 6 e 1 x Cl : 1 x X = 1 e oxidation state : 1 x X = +ΙΙΙΙ ionic model Rh+ : d8 = 8 e 3 x PPh3 : 3 x L = 6 e 1 x Cl- : 2 e total = 16 e, +I Rh PPh3 PPh3 Cl PPh3 Rh PPh3 PPh3 Cl PPh3 Rh PPh3 PPh3 Cl PPh3 (L) (L) (L) (L) (L) (L) (X, 1 e) (X, 2 e) 15

(16)

Electron counting and oxidation state: Fe di(cyclopentadienyl)iron (ferrocene) covalent model Fe : d8 = 8 e 2 x Cp : 2 x (L2X) = 2 x (2 x 2 + 1) = 10 e

oxidation state : 2 ligands X, 0 charge = +ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ionic model Fe2+ : d6 = 6 e 2 x Cp- : 2 x 6 = 12 e total = 18 e, +ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ covalent model Cr : d6 = 6 e ionic model Cr: d6 = 6 e Cr OC OC CO CO CO H Cr : d6 = 6 e 5 x CO : 5 x L = 10 e 1 x H : 5 x X = 1 e oxidation state : 1 x X + 1 x (-1) = 0 Cr: d6 = 6 e 5 x CO : 5 x 2 = 10 e 1 x H- : 2 e total = 18 e, 0 charge : -1 e Pd PPh3 PPh3 Ph3P PPh3 covalent model Pd : d10 = 10 e NVE = 10 + 2 x 4 = 18 e oxidation state : 0 x X = 0000 ionic model Pd: d10 = 10 e NVE = 10 + 2 x 4 = 18 e total = 18 e, 0

(17)

Common geometries for transition metal complexes

Two aspects to define the geometry of the complex : sterics and electronics.

- sterics : to a first approximation, geometries of complexes were determined bu steric factors. The M-L bonds are arranged to have the maximum possible separation around the metal.

- electronics : d electron count combined with the complex electron count must be considered when predicting geometries for complexes with non-bonding d electrons. Often this leads to sterically less favorable geometries for electronic reasons (e.g. CN = 4, d8, 16 e

complexes prefer a square planar geometry). STERICS L 17 L M L (CN = coordination number) CN = 2 linear L M CN = 3 trigonal planar L L CN = 4 L M L LL tetrahedral CN = 5 L M L L L L trigonal bipyramidal CN = 6 M L L L L L L octahedral ELECTRONICS L M L L T-shaped M L L L L square planar L L M L L L square pyramidal

(18)

Main classes of reactions around the transition metal

ligand substitution

oxidative addition & reductrice elimination

MLl [MLl-1] - L MLl-1L1 + L1 A B [M] [M] A B [M] B A

insertion & elimination

NVE (M) < or = 16 e ; o.s. NVE (M) + 2 ; o.s. + 2

[M] A + B [M] A B [M] B A [M] L X C H - L NVE [M] X C H NVE - 2 [M] X C H [M] X C NVE H

(19)

Ligand substitution

Two limiting mechanisms for ligand substitution

- associative mechanism : bond making occurs before bond breaking.

This is the most common mechanism for coordinatively unsaturated metal complexes. The d8 square planar complexes are prototypical examples (Pt(II), Pd(II), Ir(I) and Rh(I)).

Pt L L X L + Y slow Pt L L X L Y Pt Y X L L L Pt L L Y L X fast Pt L L Y L + X 19

-dissociative mechanism : bond breaking occurs before bond making.

This is normally the preferred mechanism for coordinatively 18 e complexes. The rates of ligand substitution for ccordinatively satured complexes are usually significantatly slower than those for coordinatively unsaturated complexes.

L M L L1 L L L - L L M L L1 L L L M L L1 L2 L L + L2 L M L L1 L L L2 M L L1 L L L + L2 + L2 L M L2 L1 L L L

(20)

Oxidative addition – reductive elimination

- oxidative addition : addition of A-B to a metal center resulting in an increase in coordination number by 2, an increase of oxidation state by 2 units, and an increase in the electron count by 2.

- reductive elimination : elimination of two ligands from a metal center to gice a new A-B bond. The metal center is reduced by 2 units and has 2 fewer coordinated ligands. The complex has 2 less electrons (concerted reductive elimination requires cis coordination of the ligands to be eliminated).

m+ A

A

Oxidative addition and reductive elimination are the microscopic reverse of each other. They represent the foward and reverse reaction of an equilibrium. The position of the equilibrium depends on the thermodynamics of the oxidative addition or reductive elimination process. For example many metal complexes will oxidatively add CH3I, but few will reductively eliminate this compound. In contrast, M(H)R usually undergo rapid reductive elimination, but oxidative addition of alkanes is much less common.

LnMm+ + A

B LnM

(m+2)+ B

(21)

Insertion – elimination

Features of this transformation :

- there is no change in the formal oxidation state of the metal unless AB is an alkalydene or an alkylidyne.

- the groups undergoing migratory insertion must be cis to one another. In complexes where the cis coordination sites are blocked by strongly coordinated ligands, insertion or elimination processes are not possible.

- an open coordination site is created during migratory insertion. Therefore, for the reverse reaction (elimination) to occur, an open coordination site must be generated by ligand dissociation.

17

dissociation.

- in the case where C is a chiral center, the reaction usually occurs with retention of configuration.

- cases where C migrates to AB followed by coordination of L in place of C, and where AB migrates to C followed by coordination of L in place of AB are both known.

M A C B M A C B 1,1-insertion elimination M L + L - L A C B M C M A B 1,2-insertion elimination + L - L A B C M A B C L

(22)

Applications : alkenes hydrogenation

The Wilkinson’s catalyst, a Rhodium complex : RhCl(PPh3)3 R + H2 [cat] R H H catalytic cycle Rh Ph3P Ph3P Cl PPh3 = ML3X Rh = d9 NVE (Rh) = 9 + (3 x 2) + 1 = 16 e o.s. = +ΙΙΙΙ = ML3X o.s. = +ΙΙΙΙ = R > R R > R R > R R > R reactivity =

to have a good understanding of the mechanism of the reaction, it is well to determine the NVE and o.s. of the metal at each stage of the catalytic cycle.

(23)

stereoselective synthesis of (+)-biotin : an example of asymmetric hydrogenation. selective hydrogenation. Me Me O O Rh(PPh3)3Cl / H2 Me Me O O

Hydrogenation of olefins (and alkynes) can be carried out in the presence of functional groups such as RCHO, R2CO, OH, CN, NO2, Cl, ROR1, CO

2R, CO2H.

23

stereoselective synthesis of (+)-biotin : an example of asymmetric hydrogenation.

O NH N O O Ph Me O O HO steps H2 / [Rh] O NH N O O Ph Me H H steps S NH HN O H H CO2H (+)-biotin [Rh] = Fe PPh2 t-Bu2 P Me

Rh(COD) COD = cyclooctadiene = ligand L2

(24)

stereoselective synthesis of Naproxen : asymmetric hydrogenation. Naproxen, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug

MeO CO2H Ru-BINAP H2 (100 atm) MeO CO2H Me 97% e.e. (1 mol%) CH2Cl2, 50 °C Ru-BINAP =

(Noyori's catalyst, Nobel Prize 2001) P P Ru O O O O Me Me PhPh Ph Ph

industrial synthesis (Synthex) : non catalyzed synthesis (racemic approach)

(25)

Applications : alkenes reduction – hydride transfer

R + H2 [cat] / base R H H

a Ruthenium complex : RuCl2(PPh3)3

Ru Cl PPh PPh3 Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 Cl PPh3 H H δδδδ− Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 H PPh3 + HCl +B: B:H+ Cl

generation of the Ruthenium active species

25 Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 Cl + B: + H2 H H δδδδ− δδδδ+ Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 Cl PPh3 H H :B δδδδ− δδδδ+ Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 Cl PPh3 H - BH+ -ClRu Ph3P Cl PPh3 H PPh3 Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 H PPh3 Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 H PPh3 R Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 PPh3 R Ru Ph3P Cl PPh3 PPh3 R H H δδδδ− δδδδ+ R R catalytic cycle Ru Cl Ph3P Cl PPh3 = ML3X2 Ru = d8 NVE (Ru) = 8 + (3 x 2) + (2 x 1) = 16 e o.s. = +ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ PPh3

(26)

asymmetric hydrogenation transfer : the Noyori’s ruthenium catalyst. P Ph Ph Ru Cl HN2 Ph O NHMe i-PrOH cat OH NHMe O NHMe F3C fluoxetine (antidepressant agent) cat = = ML4X2 Ru = d8 NVE (Ru) = 8 + (4 x 2)

in classical organic chemistry = Meerwein-Ponndorf-Verley / Oppenauer reaction

P Ph Ph Ru Cl N Ph H2 cat = = ML4X2 + (2 x 1) = 18 e o.s. = +ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ Me Me OH Me Me O + HCl P P Ru H Cl N N H H H H R R1 O O H N Ru H R1 R R R1 OH H H P Cl N H H catalytic cycle

(27)

Applications : hydroboration of olefins

Hydroboration of olefins with catecholborane : the reaction catalyzed by the Wilkinson’s catalyst (Rh(PPh3)3Cl) gives the Markovnikov product.

R + [cat] R H B O B O H O O H2O2 / OH -R H OH R B H O O R OH H + anti-Markovnikov Markovnikov catalytic cycle 27 catalytic cycle classical hydroboration, recall :

hex-1-ene 9-BBN H2O2 / NaOH OH OH 99 1 catalyzed hydroboration : Ph + O B O H RhCl(PPh3)3 H2O2 / NaOH Ph OH application to asymmetric synthesis

(28)

diastereoselective catalyzed hydroboration. OPPh2 1- RhCl(PPh3)3 O BH O 2- H2O2, NaOH 2-Ac2O, base OAc OAc 85% yield syn > 50:1

(29)

Applications : the palladium catalyzed reactions

Generalities

During the last decades, palladium-catalyzed reactions have emerged as versatile tools for the formation of carbon-carbon bonds, hydrogenation and oxidation.

Pd

electronic configuration = 4d8 5s2 or 4d10 5s0 formal oxidation number = 0, +2, (+4)

29 A Pd "Pd" (recycling) + B A fundamental C-Pd activation modification(s) of the Pd complexed organic fragments

C---Pd cleavage

Pd

formal oxidation number = 0, +2, (+4)

(30)

Richard F. Heck Ei-ichi Negishi Akira Suzuki Richard F. Heck Ei-ichi Negishi Akira Suzuki

(31)

The Heck cross-coupling reaction

Br + H R1 Pd(0) cat. base R1 (1968) Nobel Prize 2010

(32)

The Negishi cross-coupling reaction

(1977) X + R1 ZnY Pd(0) cat. base R1

The Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction

(1979) X + R1 B Pd(0) cat. base R1 R R

(33)

Heck reaction

Negishi and Suzuki reactions

(34)

Palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions

The cross-coupling reactions have become powerful synthetic methods because they allow C-C and C-heteroatom bonds to be formed under very mild conditions with high fucntional group tolerance.

(35)

catalyst precursors.

metal sources : Palladium is the most widely used metal for cross-coupling reactions, although there are examples of Nickel,Rhodium and Copper catalyzed cross-coupling reactions.

In general, the palladium is supported by a ligand and the catalyst can be derived from a preformed palladium complex or formed in situ from combination of palladium sources and a ligand. Both Pd(0) and Pd(II) sources can be used although the active species is Pd(0) in all cases.

common sources of palladium Pd/C

Pd(PPh ) = tetrakis(triphenylphosphine) palladium (most common complex)

31

Pd/C

Pd(PPh3)4= tetrakis(triphenylphosphine) palladium (most common complex) Pd2(dba)3or Pd(dba)2 PdCl2(PPh3)2 PdCl2(CH3CN)2 Pd(OAc)2 PdCl2 dba = dibenzylideneacetone O Ph Ph

(36)

ligands.

Palladium alone can catalyze the reactions, but usually only with reactive Ar-I substrates and/or high temperature.

Ligands necessary to - give more active catalyst system, - stabilize the Pd(0) intermediate - solubilize the catalyst

- increase the rate of oxidative addition.

The most ligands use in palladium chemistry = phosphine derivatives. In general arylphosphines remain the most widely used.

P 3 P 3 CH3 Fe PPh2 PPh2 PPh2 PPh2 triphenylphosphine tri-o-tolylphosphine dppf 1,1'-Bis(diphenylphosphino)ferrocene BINAP 2,2'-bis(diphenylphosphino)-1,1'-binaphthyle PMe3 P(t-Bu)3 PR2 R2 = Cy, t-Bu PPh2 Ph2P Ph2P PPh2 1,2-Bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane 1,3-Bis(diphenylphosphino)propane monodentate phosphines

(37)

A new generation of ligands = the N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC)

NHC are stronger electron donors than phosphines and they tend to have stronger M-L bonds, thus they may give more stable catalysts.

N N H3C CH3 CH3 CH3 H3C

..

N N i-Pr i-Pr i-Pr i-Pr

..

N N H3C CH3 CH3 CH3 H3C

..

N N i-Pr i-Pr i-Pr i-Pr

..

33 CH3 IMes IPr CH3 sIMes sIPr

(38)

The Heck reaction (Nobel Prize 2010).

The Heck reaction involves coupling of alkenyl or aryl halides with alkenes in the presence of palladium complex and a base to furnish alkenyl- and aryl-substituted alkenes.

Catalytic cycle

Pd sources : PdCl2, Pd(OAc)2, Pd(PPh3)4. Bases : Et3N, CH3CO2Na, K2CO3, NaHCO3. Solvents : THF, Toluène, DMF, DMA (in general under reflux).

R1-X + R

Pd(0)

base R

1 R R1 = or R2

reactivity order in oxidative addition Ar-I > Ar-OTf > Ar-Br >> Ar-Cl

Base : essential to capture the formation of HX

Pd

Review : Angew.Chem. Int. Ed. 1994, 33, 2379,

(39)

Heck reaction = regioselectivity. Br + Alkene Pd cat. / base Product CO2Me 100% CN 100% 100% 100% Me 80% 20% CO2Me 1% Me 99% 100% OMe MeO 21% Me 79% 7% 93% Me 35

Heck reaction = stereoselectivity.

In general, reactions of terminal olefins give a prepoderance of E product.

OTBS Me I Me + Me OH

cat. Pd(OAc)2, AgOAc

DMF, rt OTBS Me Me Me OH 70% 100% E Chem. Eur. J.2003,9, 1129. R1 R2 Pd Ar X L syn-addition L(X)Pd Ar H R1 R2H H L(X)Pd H R1 ArR 2 ββββ-H-elim (syn) R1 R2 Ar

(40)

Heck reaction = applications. - UV-B sunscreen Br MeO + O O Me Pd/C, Na2CO3 NMP, 180 - 190 °C MeO Me O O Me Me

pilot scale - several tons

- synthesis of Eleptritan or Relprax (Pfizer, for the treatment of migraine headaches)

O

O 1- cat. Pd(OAc) , P(o-Tol) O O

S O O + Br N H

N 1- cat. Pd(OAc)2, P(o-Tol)3 Et3N, CH3CN 2- cat. Pd/C, H2 Me N H N Me S O O

- synthesis of Naproxen (anti-inflammatory) Br MeO < 0.05 mol% PdCl2, L, Et3N 30 bar pentan-3-one H2O, 95 °C MeO MeO Me CO2H 500 tons/year Me

(41)

Heck reaction = β-H-elimination – insertion - migration, case of cyclic ethers. O + I 0.01 mol% Pd(OAc)2 Et3N, 100 °C O Ph + O Ph expected obtained ! Ph Pd L I O +δδδδ -δδδδ syn addition O Ph Pd(I)L2 H H ββββ-H elim only syn O Ph Pd H I L insertion O Ph Pd(I)L2 H Ph Ph Ph L2Pd(I)H Ph 37 ββββ-H elim O Ph H Pd I L insertion O Ph Pd(I)L2 H ββββ-H elim O Ph H Pd L I L2Pd(I)H O Ph

- synthesis of platelet activator factor antagonist OMe OMe I O 2.5 mol% Pd(OAc)2 / PPh3 AcOK, 80 °C OMe MeO O 2.5 mol% Pd(OAc) 2 / PPh3 AgCO3, CH3CN, 80 °C OMe MeO I O H2 / PtO2 OMe MeO O J. Org. Chem.1990,55, 407.

(42)

Heck reaction = β-H-elimination – insertion - migration, case of allylic alcohols. Ar-I + OH Me 2 mol% Pd(OAc)2 PPh3, base OH Me Ar O Me Ar versus

base = AgOAc base = NaOAc

Ar Pd L I HO Me L Pd L I Ar OH Me H Pd L I HO Me Ar L Pd L I Ar OH Me H Pd L I Me OH Ar HO HO Me kinetically favored but reversibly formed

inclusion of Ag+ prevents reversibility

- synthesis of prostaglandin E2 HO HO I C5H11 OTBS 5 mol% Pd(OAc)2 Bu4NCl, DMF, rt (Jeffery's conditions) HO HO H Pd(I)L2 R HO HO R Pd(H)(I)L O HO R - L2Pd(H)(I) O CO H

(43)

The Palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling with organometallic reagent.

The palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling of alkenyl or aryl halides (and triflates) with organometallics proceeds via sequential oxidative addition, transmetallation, (trans-cis -isomerization), and reductive elimination processes.

R X + R1 M [Pd] R R1 + M X

reactivity order in oxidative addition Ar-I > Ar-OTf > Ar-Br >> Ar-Cl

39

General catalytic cycle

(44)

the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction (Nobel Prize 2010).

The Suzuki-Miyaura reaction provides a versatile, general method for stereo- and regiospecific synthesis of conjugated dienes, enynes, aryl substituted alkenes, and biaryl compounds. The wide use of this reaction stems from the tolerance of functional groups, and the ready availability of the starting materials.

Catalytic cycle Pd sources : Pd(PPh

3)4, PdCl2(PPh3)2.

Bases : Na2CO3, EtONa, NaOH, KOH, K3PO4, Et3N. Solvents : THF, toluene (presence of water possible).

X + R1 B Pd(0) cat. base R1 or X + R1 B Pd(0) cat. base R1 R R R R X = I, Br, Cl, OTf L2Pd(0) Ar-X

Solvents : THF, toluene (presence of water possible).

Main sources of organoboron reagents : B HO OH B Ar HO OH B RO RO B Ar RO RO boronic acids boronic esters Ar-X L2Pd Ar X oxidative addition L2Pd Ar transmetallation reductive elimination (II) R1 Ar R1 R1 B R R NaOH R1 B R R OH Na B R R OH + NaX

(45)

- synthesis of Boscalid (polyvalent fongicide, BASF, > 1000 tons/years) NO2 Cl + Cl B(OH)2 Pd(PPh3)4 cat. Bu4NBr, K2CO3 Toluene, H2O NO2 Cl NH Cl O N Cl Boscalid

- preparation of valuable intermediate

(GlaxoSmithKline, 20 L scale) t-Bu

41 N H CO2Et Br + t-Bu B(OH)2 Pd(OAc)2 cat. P(o-Tolyl)3 KHCO3, H2O, i-PrOH N H CO2Et

- kg-scale manufacture of dibenzoxapine (cascade reaction, 2 kg scale)

Br Me O I NO2 (HO)2B Pd(OAc)2 cat. Na2CO3 dioxane, H2O Br O Me NO2 Br O Me NH2.HCl

(46)

- Suzuki coupling of sp nucleophiles (sp – sp bonds) Br 9-BBN Br 9-BBN Pd(0) cat., base OTPS TBSO OMe OMe 9-BBN 9-BBN OTPS TBSO CH(OMe)2 3 S N I OAc PdCl2(dppf) cat

application to the synthesis of epothilone A

PdCl2(dppf) cat CsCO3, AsPh3 H2O, DMF S N OAc CH(OMe)2 OTBS OTPS 71% yield S N O OH O O OH epothilone A

(47)

the Stille cross-coupling reaction.

The Stille reaction involves the palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling of organostannanes with electrophiles such as organic halides, triflates, or acid chlorides. The coupling of the two carbon moieties is stereospecific and regioselective, occurs under mild conditions, and tolerates a variety of functional groups (CHO, CO2R, CN, OH) on either coupling partner. These properties make the Stille reaction frequently the method of choice in syntheses of complex molecules. A problem of the Stille reaction is the toxicity of organotin reagents, especially the lower-molecular weight alkyl derivatives.

R1 X + R2 SnR3

[Pd]

R1 R2 + R3Sn X R1 = acyl, allyl, aryl, vinyl, benzyl

R2 = aryl, vinyl Pd sources : Pd(PPh

3)4, (MeCN)2PdCl2. 43 R = aryl, vinyl L2Pd(0) R1-X L2Pd R1 X oxidative addition L2Pd R1 R2 transmetallation reductive elimination (II) R2 R1 R2 SnR3 X SnR3 Catalytic cycle Pd sources : Pd(PPh3)4, (MeCN)2PdCl2.

improved reactivity with CuI/CsF Solvents : THF, DMF (anhydrous)

Best catalytic system : Pd2(dba)3, AsPh3, LiCl, THF The most widely used groups in transmetalation from tin to carbon are those with proximal π-bonds such as alkenyl-, alkynyl-, and arylstannanes.

reactivity order in transmetallation (R2) :

RC≡C > RCH=CH > Ar > RCH=CHCH2≈ ArCH2>> alkyl

Review : mechanisms of the Stille reaction: Angew.Chem. Int. Ed. 2004,43, 4704.

(48)

- short efficient synthesis of pleraplysillin-1 (isolated from a marine sponge) TfO Pd(PPh ) cat. Bu I + CO2Et Bu3Sn PdCl2(CH3CN)2 cat DMF, rt Bu CO2Et 65% yield I MeO2C + N Bu3Sn PdCl2(PPh3)2 cat THF, 65 °C MeO2C N 95% yield SnBu3 O + TfO Me Me Pd(PPh3)4 cat. LiCl, THF, 70 °C Me Me O 75% yield - enediyne construction system for the dynemicin total synthesis

TeocN O I H OH OH Me I Me3Sn SnMe3 5 mol% Pd(PPh3)4 DMF, 75 °C TeocN O H OH OH Me NH O H CO2H OH Me OH O

(49)

- carbonylative Stille cross-coupling

When the Stille reaction is carried out under a CO atmosphere, the carbonylative coupling proceeds with carbon monoxide insertion; namely, carbonyl insertion into the Pd–C bond of the oxidative addition complex.transmetalation, followed by cis-trans-isomerization and reductive elimination, generates the ketone product. L2Pd(0) R1-X L2Pd R1 X oxidative addition reductive elimination R2 R1 O O

A similar carbonylation could be carried out in the Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction.

LnPd R1 + CO L(n-1)Pd R1 CO LnPd + L O R1 45 L2Pd X L2Pd C X transmetallation (II) CO carbon monoxide insertion O R1 R2 SnR3 X SnR3 L2Pd C R2 O R1 Me OTf SnMe3 Pd(PPh3)4 cat. LiCl / CO (1 atm) THF, 50 °C Me O 78% yield X LnPd X L(n-1)Pd X LnPd - L I + Ph Bu3Sn PdCl2(CH3CN)2 cat CO, THF, 50 °C 65% yield Bu Bu O Ph

(50)

the Sonogashira cross-coupling reaction.

H

R1 +

X Pd(0) cat., CuI cat. base

R1

The Sonogashira reaction has emerged as one of the most general, reliable, and effective methods for the synthesis of substituted alkynes. In addition to Heck and Suzuki-Miyaura coupling reactions, Sonogashira reactions have been realized on an industrial scale as well.

L2Pd(0)

Ar-X

Catalytic cycle

Pd sources : Pd(PPh3)4or (PPh3)2PdCl2.

Solvents : without solvent (the amine was used as reagent

Ar-X L2Pd Ar X L2Pd Ar H R1 CuX Cu R1 Et3N R1 CuX transmetallation (II) R1 Ar oxidative addition reductive elimination Pd sources : Pd(PPh3)4or (PPh3)2PdCl2.

Solvents : without solvent (the amine was used as reagent and as base) or THF or CH2Cl2

CuI / Et3N (or other amines)

(51)

- synthesis of Eniluracil (Glaxo SmithKline ; a chemotoxic agent enhancer used in combination with 5-fluorouracil, one of the most widely used drugs in cancer chemotherapy.

HN N H O O I + H SiMe3 0.5 mol% PdCl2(PPh3)2 0.5 mol% CuI Et3N, AcOEt HN N H O O SiMe3 93% yield NaOH HN N H O O H eniluracil HN N H O O F 5-fluorouracil - synthesis of lipoxin A4. Me Br OTBS + CO2Me OTBS TBSO 47 Me Br 1 mol% Pd(PPh3)4 16 mol% CuI PrNH2, benzene, rt OTBS Me CO2Me OTBS TBSO 96% OH Me CO2H OH HO (5S, 6S, 15S)-lipoxin A4

- cascade reactions in the total synthesis of frondosin B.

OH I OMe + CO2Me Me PdCl2(PPh3)2 cat. CuI cat. Et3N, DMF, rt OH OMe CO2Me Me 50 °C O MeO CO2Me Me O HO Me Me Me frondosin B

(52)

the Negishi cross-coupling reactions (Nobel Prize 2010).

The Negishi palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction of alkenyl, aryl, and alkynyl halides with unsaturated organozinc, organoaluminium, and organozirconium reagents provides a versatile method for preparing stereodefined arylalkenes, arylalkynes, conjugated dienes, and conjugated enynes.

R1 X + R2 M [Pd] cat. R1 R2 + X M M = ZnCl, AlR2, Zr(Cl)Cp2 L2Pd(0) R1-X R1 oxidative addition R2 Catalytic cycle L2Pd R1 X L2Pd R1 R2 transmetallation reductive elimination (II) R2 R1 R2 M X M

(53)

OAc OMe I OHC i-Pr2Zn (0.55 equiv) NMP, rt Li(acac) (0.1 equiv) OAc OMe Zn OHC 2 C6H11 O Cl 2.5 mol% Pd2(dba) 5 mol% P(furyl)3 OAc OMe OHC O 75% yield

- Negishi cross-coupling reaction : applications.

I Br + BrZn SiMe3 2 mol% Pd(PPh3)4 THF, rt SiMe3 Br 81% yield 49 O O Me MeO MeO Cl Me2Al Me Me Me 2 + 2 mol% Pd(PPh3)4 THF, 0 °C O O Me MeO MeO Me Me Me 2 coenzyme Qs Me Ph OMe Me Cp2Zr(H)Cl THF, 50 °C Ph OMe Me Zr(Cl)Cp2 Me H hydrozirconation Cp2Zr(H)Cl = Schwartz reagent Ph OMe Me Me OTBS Me NHBoc OTBS Me NHBoc I Pd(PPh3)4, dry ZnCl2 THF, rt

(54)

Carbon-heteroatom cross-coupling reaction :

the example of the Buchwald-Hartwig coupling reaction (C-N bond formation). X + R1NHR2 R1OH R1SH Y Y = NR1R2, OR1, SR1 X + R1NHR2 NR1R2 [Pd] cat. base base

X

Best catalytic system

Pd2(dba)3 or Pd(OAc)2, Ligand, NaOt-Bu, Toluene rt to 100 °C

Ligand = dppf,

(55)

- process scale synthesis of a pharmaceutical intermediate (Astra Zeneca) N H Ph Me Me Br + N H N Me 0.5 mol% Pd2(dba)3 1.5 mol% BINAP NaOt-Bu, Tol, 100 °C N H Ph Me Me N N Me 95% yield 125 kg scale

- a cholesteryl ester transfer protein inhibitor, the Torcetrapib (Pfizer) (abandoned, excessive mortality during clinical trials)

MeO2C CF3 51 Cl F3C + Me CN H2N 0.5 mol% Pd2(dba)3 1.5 mol% BINAP NaOt-Bu, Tol, 100 °C NH F3C Me CN N H F3C N Me MeO2C CF3 CF3

- double N-arylation : synthesis of Mukonine

MeO2C OMe OTf OTf 2 mol% Pd2(dba)3 10 mol% XantPhos K3PO4, xylene, 100 °C BocNH2 NBoc MeO2C OMe NH MeO2C OMe TFA Mukonine O Me Me PPh2 PPh2 XantPhos

(56)

The Tsuji-Trost reaction : Palladium-catalyzed allylic substitution.

Allylic substrates with good leaving groups are excellent reagents for joining an allyl moiety with a nucleophile. However, these reactions suffer from loss of regioselectivity because of competition between SN2 and SN2’

substitution reactions. Palladium-catalyzed nucleophilic substitution of allylic substrates allows the formation of new carbon-carbon or carbon-hetero bonds with control of both regio and stereochemistry.

R1 OAc + R2 M [Pd] cat. R1 R2 + AcOM L2Pd(0) oxidative R1 OAc R1 Catalytic cycle Pd source : Pd(PPh ) . L2Pd addition L2Pd R2 M AcOM R1 AcO (M = Na, K, Li) R1 R2 R1 R2 Pd source : Pd(PPh3)4. Solvents : THF or DMF.

Other possible leaving groups : OC(O)OR, OP(O)OR2, OPh, Cl, Br.

Nucleophiles : best results with malonate type anions, other soft nucleophiles as anions from nitromethane, enolates, and enamines.

The palladium-mediated allylation proceeds via an initial oxidative addition of an allylic substrate to Pd(0). The resultant π-allylpalladium(II) complex is electrophilic and reacts with carbon nucleophiles generating the Pd(0) complex, which undergoes ligand exchange to release the product and restart the cycle for palladium. With

(57)

- Tsuji-Trost reaction : the stereoselectivity.

Palladium-catalyzed displacement reactions with carbon nucleophiles are not only regioselective but also highly stereoselective. In the first step, displacement of the leaving group by palladium to form the π-allylpalladium complex occurs from the less hindered face with inversion. Subsequent nucleophilic substitution of the intermediate π-allylpalladium complex with soft nucleophiles such as amines, phenols, or malonate-type anions also proceeds with inversion of the stereochemistry. The overall process is a retention of configuration as a result of the double inversion.

CO2Me

OAc

Pd(PPh3)4 cat. CH2(CO2Me)2 / NaH

THF CO2Me PdL Nu CO2Me CH(CO2Me) 53 THF PdL2

The mechanism of double

inversion operates with soft stabilized nucleophiles. In the presence of hard nucleophiles

the reaction occurs with

(58)

- Tsuji-Trost reaction : examples. Me Me Me OAc geranyl acetate Me Me Me neryl acetate OAc + HC CO2Me SO2Ph Na Pd(PPh3)4 cat THF, 65 °C Me Me Me Me Me Me CO2Me SO2Ph SO2Ph CO2Me OAc OAc CO2Me O Me 7 mol% Pd(PPh 3)4 NaH, THF, 65 °C O Me CO2Me 99% yield AcO O CO2R E E E = CO2Me Pd2(dba)3 / PPh3 NaH, THF, 65 °C O CO2R E E H H H only cis

(59)

- π-trimethylene methane cyclization. Me CO2Me + SiMe3 OAc Pd(PPh3)4 / dppe THF Me CO2Me SiMe3 OAc L2Pd(0) SiMe3 PdL2 OAc PdL2 C6H11 O OMe PdL2 H11C6 OMe O C6H11 CO2Me PdL2 55 O O + SiMe3 OAc Ph Pd(PPh3)4 Toluen, reflux O O Ph H H mixture of stereoisomers

(60)

The palladium-catalyzed oxidation reaction of terminal olefins : the Wacker reaction .

R [Pd(II)] cat, CuCl2 cat.

O2 atm, H2O, DMF

Me R

O

The Wacker process consists to oxidize selectively terminal olefins in the presence of palladium +2 as catalyst. The most common palladium source used in this reaction id PdCl2.

R Cu(+2)

Cu(+1) O2 + HCl

PdCl2

Regioselectivity : Markonikov addition usually

Catalytic cycle R PdCl2 H2O O R PdCl2 H H R Pd(H)Cl OH Me O HCl nucleophilic attack ββββ-H elimination oxidation Cu(+2) Pd(0)

Regioselectivity : Markonikov addition usually observed. Anti-hydroxypalladation : R R CH3 R CHO O no formed R Pd Cl Cl H2O O H H anti Pd Cl Cl H2O R OH

(61)

- Wacker reaction: examples.

O

PdCl2 cat, CuCl2 cat O2, DMF / H2O

O O

- The Wacker reaction could oxidize only the terminal olefin regioselective reaction.

H H O

- CuCl/O2 could replace CuCl2 to avoid chlorinated by-products.

57

O

O OTBS

PdCl2 cat, CuCl cat O2, DMF / H2O

O

O OTBS

- Used also in intramolecular process.

OH O Pd(OAc)2 Cu(OAc)2, O2 [Pd(II)] H O [Pd(II)] O O

(62)

Applications : the metathesis of olefins

C H H C R1 C H R4 H C R2 + R3 C H H C R1 C H R4 H C R3 + R2 M=CH2

most common catalysts in metathesis of olefins

PCy3 Ru PCy3 Ph Cl Cl Ru PCy3 Ph Cl Cl N N Mes Mes N Mo Ph i-Pr i-Pr Me Me O O F3C CF3 Me F3C

Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2005

"for the development of the metathesis method in organic synthesis"

PCy3 PCy3 [Ru]-2 [Ru]-1 first generation Grubbs catalyst second generation Grubbs catalyst Me Me CF3 F3C Me [Mo] Schrock catalyst

(63)

( )n ( )n ( )n ( )n [M] RCM - C2H4 ROMP + C2H4 ROM ADMET - C2H4

common metathesis olefins reactions and simplified catalytic cycle.

X M=CH2 X

RCM

M=CH2

X

X

Metathesis = « change places »

59 ( )n ( )n R1 R2 + R1 R2 + C2H4 CM [M] H2C CH2 [M] X [M]

RCM= Ring Closing Metathesis ROM= Ring Opening Metathesis

ROMP = Ring Opening Metathesis Polymerization

ADMET = Acyclic Diene Metathesis Polymerization

CM = Cross Metathesis

All of the above reactions are reversible, so equilibrium mixtures are obtained. To produce high yields of a given product a suitable driving force must be present.

• Cross metathesis: Mixtures of products are produced unless a volatile byproduct (ethylene) is produced that can be removed from the reaction mixture.

• RCM is favored for the production of unstrained rings and is driven both entropically and by the elimination of a volatile alkene.

(64)

- the RCM reaction : examples. C8H17 + C13H27

[Ru]-1 cat

C8H17 C13H27 + H2C CH2 + other products

commercial synthesis of house fly pheromone

N O R N O R ( )n 3 mol% [Ru]-1 ( )n PhH, rt, 1 h n = 0, 78% n = 1, 93% O O OH N S H OH [Ru]-1 O O OH N S H OH desoxyepothilone A 81% yield, E / Z = 9 / 1 PhH, rt, 1 h n = 1, 93%

(65)

Metalloenzymes : examples

Metals play roles in approximately one-third of the known enzymes. Metals may be a co-factor (prosthetic group), and these are known as metalloenzymes. Amino acids in peptide linkage posses groups that can form coordinate-covalent bonds with the metal atom. The free amino and carboxy group bind to the metal affecting the enzymes structure resulting in its active conformation .

Metals main function is to serve in electron transfer. Many enzymes can serve as electrophiles

and some can serve as nucleophilic groups. This versatility explains metals frequent occurrence in enzymes. Some metalloenzymes include hemoglobins, cytochromes, phosphotransferases, alcohol dehydrogenase, arginase, ferredoxin, and cytochrome oxidase.

61

The Methionine Aminopeptidase 2 (MetAP2).

The Methionine aminopeptidase 2 (MetAP2) is a metalloenzyme, a bifunctional protein that plays a critical role in the regulation of post-translational processing and protein synthesis.The MetAP2 catalyzes release of N-terminal amino acids, preferentially methionine, from peptides and arylamides. Methionine aminopeptidases (MetAPs) are the enzymes responsible for the removal of methionine from the amino-terminus of newly synthesized. The removal of methionine is essential for further amino terminal modifications (e.g., acetylation by N-alpha-acetyltransferase and myristoylation of glycine by N-myristoyltransferase, NMT) and for protein stability. H2N H N O Pept O R1 S Me MetAP2 H2N H2N O Pept O R1 S Me OH +

(66)

Active site with an irreversible inhibitor(fumagilline) His 231 Asp 251 Asp 262 Glu 364 Glu 459 His 331 Fumagilline covalent bond O O OCH3 CH3 O H CH3 CH3 O CO2H 3 fumagillin The fumagillin was found to inhibit the

angiogenesis process (construction of new blood vessels). The MetAP2 was identified as biological target of the fumagillin. The formation of a covalent bond between the fumagillin and the MetAP2 was catalyzed by the presence of two cations of Manganese (Mn2+) which act as Lewis

(67)

The Carbonic Anhydrases (CAs).

Carbonic anhydrases (CAs), a group of ubiquitouly expressed metalloenzymes are involved in numerous physiological and pathological processes, including gluconeogenesis, lipogenesis, ureagenesis, tumorigenicity and the growth and virulence of various pathogens. Furthemore, recent studies suggest that CA activation may provide a novel therapy for Alzheimer’s disease.

CAs catalyse the following reaction : CO2 + H2O

HCO3 -+ H+ O C Zn2+ OH -His94 His96 His119 Active site 63 OH Zn2+ His94 His 96 His119 CO2 O Zn2+ His94 His 96 His119 C O O Zn2+ His94 His 96 His119 H O O + H2O - HCO3 OH2 Zn2+ His94 His 96 His119 - BH+ + B

(68)
(69)

Definition : in organocatalysis, a purely organic and metal-free small molecule is used to catalyze a chemical reaction.

This approach has some important advantages :

- small organic molecule catalysts are generally stable and fairly easy to design and synthesize.

- often based on nontoxic compounds, such as sugars, peptides, or even amino acids, and can easily be linked to a solid support, making them useful for industrial applications.

Organocatalysts can be broadly classified as Lewis bases, Lewis acids, Brønsted bases, and Brønsted acids.

Major reaction pathways :

65

Major reaction pathways :

- via covalent activation complexes as enamine and iminium ion

- via noncovalent activation complexes as H-bonding or ion pairing O NH R2 R1 + H+ R1N R2 - H+ R1N R2 O H A

(70)

The most common system : Proline (and derivatives) as catalyst

Why Proline ? N H O O H L-proline Proton delivery Amine function to

active the carbonyl group

Chiral centerasymmetric synthesis Abundant end cheap material

Proline as catalyst for the aldol reaction – proposed mechanism

O + H O R N H CO2H (30 mol%) DMSO OH R O 54 - 97% yield 60 - 96% ee R = aryl or i-Pr

(71)

Proline as catalyst for the aldol reaction – justification of the enantioselectivity

67

(72)

Proline as catalyst for the aldol reaction – comparaison with various organocatalyst O O O pyrrolidine derivatives solvent, rt OH O O

(73)

Proline as catalyst : examples H Me O "2 equiv" 10 mol% L-Proline DMF, 4 °C H O Me Me OH 80% yield 4 : 1 anti : syn 99% ee (anti) H O + H O 10 mol% L-Proline DMF, 40 h, 5 °C then TBSCl, base H O OTBS TBSO OEt BF3.OEt2, CH2Cl2 OH OTBS EtO O 69 Et2O/CH2Cl2 61% (two steps) Me -78 °C, 65% Me O O HO Me 48% HF, H2O, CH3CN 4.5 h, rt, 55% (-) Prelactone B Tetrahedron Lett. 2003, 44, 7607

3 steps, 22% overall yield

O OH + H O + NH2 OMe 35 mol% L-Proline DMSO, rt, 12 h O OH HN OMe 57% yield

(74)

Proline and derivatives as catalysts N H CO2H N H NH Bn Bn Ar OTMS Ar N H CO2H Me N H HN N N N

the MacMillan catalysts

N Bn O Me Me N Bn O Me Me

the MacMillan catalysts

N H Bn Me Me .HCl N H Bn .HCl Me Me O O R1 N N H Bn O Me Me Me .HCl (5 mol%) THF, rt O R1 O 85-99% yield 80-97% ee

(75)

MacMillan as catalysts : examples

(76)

H-bonding catalysis : examples of the chiral phosphoric acid

Ar Ar O O P O OH R1 H N

Boc 2 mol% cat

CH2Cl2, rt, 1 h + Me Me O O R1 NH Boc O Me Me O > 94% yield, > 92% ee N 10 mol% cat Tol, -78 °C, 24 h + NH O OH OEt OTMS H OH R1 H Tol, -78 °C, 24 h R1 OEt > 97% yield, > 88% ee OEt R2 R2

(77)

ENZYMES AS CATALYSTS

(78)

Enzyme-catalyzed chemical transformations are now widely recognized as practical alternatives to traditional organic synthesis, and as convenient solutions to certain intractable synthetic problems.

Typical enzyme-catalyzed transformations

(79)

Enzymes commonly used in organic synthesis

(80)

Examples of applications

- synthesis of a new [beta]-lactam.

H2N O O CO2Me H N O O PhO HN O NH2

- resolution of racemic mixture of alcohols.

R1 R2 OH lipase or esterase + O Me O R1 R2 OH + R1 R2 OAc N O CO2H Penicillin G acylase O N CO2H O N O O Cl CO2H Loracarbef (antibiotic)

- a representative chemgenzymatic preparation of cyclic imine sugars.

Me CHO N3 OH + OPO3 2-O HO 1- aldolase 2- phosphatase Me N3 OH OH OH O OH H2, Pd/C, HCl O OH HCl.H2N OH NaOH N OH OH Me

References

Related documents

As inter-speaker variability among these the two groups was minimal, ranging from 0% to 2% of lack of concord in the 21-40 group and from 41% to 46% in the 71+ generation, we

A key convention in the publication of research is the peer review process, in which the quality and potential contribution of each manuscript is evaluated by one’s peers in

The high level of coastal litter in the study region adds to the findings of the Report on the State of the Mediterranean Marine and Coastal Environment, which

Franklin and Associates Ltd.’s study, Comparative Energy Evaluation of Plastic Products and Their Alternatives for the Building and Construction and Transportation Industries,

However, in participants experiencing less financial strain, those living in neighbourhoods with a greater amount of change in the built environment experi- enced significantly

For the poorest farmers in eastern India, then, the benefits of groundwater irrigation have come through three routes: in large part, through purchased pump irrigation and, in a

Figure 5.6: Harmonic analysis of the solar parallel connection model...59 Figure 5.7: Current harmonics of the solar parallel connection model ...50 Figure 5.8: Current

Paragraph 1904.4(a) of the final rule mandates that each employer who is required by OSHA to keep records must record each fatality, injury or illness that is work-related, is a