Reduced order computational methods for electromagnetic material interrogation using pulsed signals and conductive reflecting interfaces

# 23-"!546 72/*- 98:' /<;=!'>?-/ "!'" .A@

B.C /D46 E2()0 '

F"GHIGKJ1L)MONQP L)MSRT7GUVGKWIXCYOZ[X\

] XCM_^`X\aKbc\d XePfXeL)\hghikj[MlOg-j[XMm^njpoSg ] bcqEYOrO^`Ls^`jpb_M

tbc\n^ni ] L)\`bcZ[jpMKLElm^hLs^nX"uMOj[vcX\hPnjw^yx

dL)Z[Xj[zci|{Ot ]~}ms€__‚„ƒ†…_}c‡_‚

lˆXCMKRg-bc\`\`XCPnYSb_MKRQXMSg-XIL)MKR\nXCYO\`jpMm^ \nXe‰mrOXCPf^`P.^`bKŠ

F"GHIGKJ1L)MKNˆPC{O‹Œjp\`XCg-^nbc\

] XMm^`X\aOb_\d XCPnXCLc\`ghijpMlQgjpXCMm^njpoSg ] bcqEYOrQ^hLs^`jpb_M

J.b„ …_}c‡_‚ tbc\n^ni ] Lc\nb_Zpj[MKLElm^`L)^nX0uMOj[vcXC\`Pnjp^yx

dLcZpXCjpz_i6{Ot ]Ž}_)€c_‚sƒ…m})‡m‚

H>XZ[XYOiOb_MOXc{ KC)ƒ†‚Oe‚„ƒ†‘c_€c…K’ aKL)“{ KC)ƒ†‚Oe‚„ƒhC€_‘c€K’)” q•L)j[Z–{

im^n—KLcMONQPh˜ŒXCb_PCGMSgPnr6GXeRQr

™&š›CœsžOŸ)œ

 ¡X"g-bcMSPfj¢RQX\1^`iOX0j[M_^`X\`\nb_z_L)^nj[bcMk—ˆxq7XeL)MKP1bc£L7YOrKZ[PnXCR¤YOZ¢L)MKLc\ XZ[XCg-^n\`bcq•L)z_MOX-^`j[g¥1L„vcXb)£L7ROjpXCZpXegA^n\`j¢g

PnZ[Lc—¦¥ jp^ni§LPnrOYO\hLcgbcMKRQrSgA^nj[vcX—KLcghNˆj[MOzKG"¨©\nXCvˆjpb_rKP¥.bc\`NrKPnjpMOzL¥ªXeL)N£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM¥ jp^ni¬oKMOjp^nXEXZ[X

ƒ

qEXMm^`P­®a ”ª¯

RQXCq7b_MKPf^n\hLs^nXeR"^`iOXL)—KjpZ[jw^yx"^nb"RQX^nX\`qEjpMKX.q•L)^nX\`j¢L)ZQYKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\`PL)MSR"^`iOXPfZ¢L)—^niKj[ghNˆMOXePnPj[M

^niKXj[MˆvcXC\`PnXYO\`bc—KZpXCq¤G°†Mk^niOj¢P1¥ªb_\nNE¥.XŒ\`XY±bc\n^1bcMk\`XCPnrOZp^`P.rKPnjpMKz7¨©\nb_YSXC\ ²Œ\n^niOb_zcb_MKL)Z±‹Xeg-bcqEY±b_Pnjw^`jpb_M

­®¨1²‹ ¯ ^`bg-\`XCL)^nX•L¤q7b_\nXEX³•gjpXCMm^*PfX^"b)£1—KLcPnj[P£«rKMKgA^`jpb_MKPI^niSL)M¡^niOX&Pf^`LcMKROLc\`R¡a ” —KLcPnj[P£«rKMKgA^`jpb_MKPG

 ¡X*oK\hPf^ŒRQXqEb_MKPy^`\`L)^nX*^niOX7L)—Oj[Zpjp^yxb)£^`iOX\`XCROrKg-XeR—KLcPnj¢P¨.²‹´£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM^nb¤gLcYQ^nrO\`X"^`iOX*XCZpXegA^`\nb ƒ

q•L)z_MOX-^`j[g•—±XiSL„vmj[bc\*jpM§^`iOXgCLcPnX•b)£ ^niKX•£«bc\`¥.Lc\`R¡YO\`bc—KZpXCq¤G ¡X&^`iOXMµLcYOYOZ[x¦^`iOXk¨1²‹¶£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM

^nb^niKXj[MˆvcX\hPnX*PngCLs^n^nX\`j[MOzkYO\`bc—KZpXCq¥ jw^`i¦rOMONˆMObs¥ M¬YKL)\hL)qEX^nX\hPLcMKRPniObs¥,^niSLs^I^niOXE¨.²‹´£«bc\`q*rKZ[L ƒ

^nj[bcM¡YO\`bsvˆj[RQXePŒL¤g-b_MKPnj[RQXC\`Lc—OZ[X*\`XCRQrKg-^nj[bcM¬jpM§g-b_q7YKrQ^`L)^nj[bcMKLcZ>^`jpqEXEbsvcXC\Pf^`LcMKROLc\`Ra ” qEX-^`iObQROPI¥ jw^`i

4 :8 42

‹ŒX-^nXC\nqEj[MKLs^`jpb_Mbc£>q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ“YO\nb_YSXC\f^`jpXeP.—mx•qEXeL)MKP1bc£>L7MObcM ƒ j[MmvsL_Pfj[vcXŒYO\nb_—SXeP1PfrKghiLcP.Z[bs¥~XMKX\`zcx•XZ[XCg-^n\`bcq•L)z ƒ

MOX^nj¢gIYOrOZ¢PfXeP j[PRQXCPnjp\hL)—KZpXIj[ML7—O\`b_L_Rk\hL)MKzcXb)£L)YOYOZ[j¢gLs^`jpb_MKP1j[M¤—Kjpb_Zpb_zcx  LcMKRjpMKROrKPy^`\nx_G©¨3\`Xvˆj[bcrKP.¥.bc\`N&iKL_P

PniObs¥ M¦iObs¥´q7X^`LcZpZ[j[g7b_\bc^niOXC\I\nXKXCg-^nj[vcX7—KLcghNˆj[MOz_Pg-b_rOZ[R¬—±X7XQYOZpb_jw^`XCR¦^nb¤bc—Q^hL)j[M¬j[MQ£«b_\nq•Ls^`jpb_M¬Lc—Sb_rQ^q•L)^nX ƒ

\`j[LcZªYO\`bcY±X\n^nj[XCP7L)MSR zcXCbcqEX-^`\nx C‡GV°†M ^`iKLs^E¥ªb_\nN“{3LoKMOjp^nX¤XZ[XqEXMm^­®a ”ª¯ —KLcPnXCRµvsL)\`j[L)^nj[bcMKLcZ3£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM

¥1LcPEXqEYOZ[bsxcXeRV^`iKLs^&j[MKg-b_\nY±bc\hLs^`XCR5ULsQ¥.XZ[ZP7£«rOZ[ZXC‰mrKL)^nj[bcMKPC{3^`iOXL)Mm^`XMOMKL§PnbcrO\hg-Xg-rK\n\`XMm^C{1L)MSR5gbcMKPf^njp^nr ƒ

^nj[vcX¤Y±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^nj[bcMµq7bQRQXCZ[P­–‹XC—mx_Xb_\|bc\`XMm^ ¯ GYKYOZpj¢gL)^nj[bcM5b)£^`iOXa ” vsL)\`j[L)^nj[bcMKLcZ3£«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMV^`b¡L  ‹

YOrOZ¢PnXCRVj[MOYOrQ^•P`gLs^n^nXC\nj[MOz¦YK\nb_—OZpXCqROXqEbcMKPf^n\hLs^`XCR§^`iOXL)—Oj[Zpjp^yx¡^nb¡gL)YO^nrO\`X•^niKXXCZpXegA^n\`bcq•LczcMOX^nj¢g•—SXCiKL„vˆjpb_\*j[M

^niKXŒ£«b_\n¥1L)\hREYO\`bc—OZ[XqGuPnj[MOz¥ j[MKRQbs¥.XCRkqEj[g\nbs¥1L„vcX YOrKZ[PnXCP.j[M¤L7a ” vsL)\`j¢Ls^nj[bcMSL)ZS£«bc\`q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M6{c^`iOX0L)rQ^`iObc\hPªb)£

C‡ ¥.X\`X•L)—OZ[X7^nbX“XCg-^nj[vcXZ[xrQ^`jpZ[jX7^niOXE^y¥.b¤\nXKXCg-^nXCR¡Pnjpz_MKL)Z¢PE­£«\`bcq^`iOX&L)j[\ƒ RQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[gjpMm^`X\n£®Lcg-XEL)MSR£«\`bcq

^niKX*RQj[XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢g ƒ—KL_ghNmj[MOzEj[M_^`X\n£®LcgX ¯ ^nbkXCPf^nj[qEL)^nX0q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ|RQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[g0YK\nb_YSXC\f^`jpXeP L)MKRq•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ ^niKj[ghNˆMOXePnP j[M^niKX

j[Mmv_X\hPfXYO\`bc—OZ[XqG

lˆb_ZprQ^`jpb_Mkbc£6^niOXj[Mmv_X\hPfXŒYO\`bc—OZ[Xq ^nb7j¢RQXMm^njp£«x•q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZSYO\`bcY±X\n^nj[XCP1gCL)M&—±X^`jpqEX0g-b_MKPnrOqEjpMOzS{ˆiObs¥ªXCvcXC\C{mPfj[MKg-Xjp^

\`XC‰mrOj[\nXeP\nXCYSXeLs^`XCR&gCL)Z[Z[P3^nb"^`iOX£«b_\n¥1L)\hRoKMOjp^nXŒXZ[XqEXMm^.Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M6{_¥ iKb_PnXPfb_ZprO^nj[bcME^nj[qEXz_\nbs¥P3L_P^`iOXŒP`‰mrKL)\`X

b)£“^`iOXMˆrOq*—±X\©b)£ MObQRQXCPCG2°†M&L)MEX“bc\n^3^nb0\`XCROrKg-XgbcqEYOrQ^hLs^`jpb_MKL)ZQ^`jpqEX¥.X iKL„v_X jpqEYOZ[XqEXMm^`XCR•LI\`XCRQrKgXCR7bc\hRQXC\

£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMEb)£“^niKXvsL)\`j[L)^nj[bcMKLcZKL)YOYK\nbmLcghi7b)£6J1L)MONQPC{ "!#$ C‡% G°†M•YOZ¢Lcg-Xb)£±^niOXoKMOjp^nXXCZpXCq7XCMm^ª—KL_Pfj¢P£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKP

bcrK\0v„Lc\nj¢Ls^`jpb_MKL)Z2£«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcM¡rKPnXCPI—KL_Pfj¢PIXZ[XqEXMm^hPIbc—Q^hL)j[MOXCR¬^niK\nb_rOzci§L)YOYKZpj¢gL)^nj[bcM¡b)£©^`iOX•qEX-^`iObQR¬bc£.YK\nb_YSXC\

bc\n^niKbczcb_MKL)Z“RQXeg-bcqEY±b_Pnjw^`jpb_M¡­–¨.²‹ ¯ ^nb&Pf^`LcMKROL)\hR•oSMOjw^`X0XZ[XqEXMm^gbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)Z \`XCPnrOZw^hPG

²ŒrO\7X“bc\n^`P\nXCYSb_\f^`XCR§b_M iOX\`Xk¥.X\`XkqEbc^nj[v„L)^nXeRV—ˆx¬^`iOX¤vcX\`xVPfrSgg-XePnPf£«rOZ.rKPnXkb)£¨1²‹ ƒ —KL_PfXeR§\nXeRQrKg-XeRVbc\hRQXC\

qEX-^`iObQROP3j[M&b)^`iOX\©XZ[XCgA^`\nb_q•L)zcMKX-^nj¢g1j[M_^`X\`\nb_z_L)^nj[bcM7YO\nb_—OZ[Xq•PG2°†M&  { _' ^`iOXŒLcrQ^niKbc\hP3g-b_MKPfj¢RQXC\nXeRXeRORQxEg-rO\`\`XMm^

—KL_PfXeR§q7X^niObQROP£«b_\*j[M_^`X\`\nb_z_L)^nbcM§bc£RQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢g•q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ[P"£«bc\LcMObcq•LcZpj[XCP­(SL„¥PC{ROL)q•L)z_XCPC{X-^`gcG¯ G¬H1iO\`bcrKzci

—±b)^ni,g-b_qEYOrQ^`L)^nj[bcMKLcZLcMKR~XQYSXC\nj[qEXMm^`LcZŒvsL)Z[j¢ROLs^`jpb_M X“bc\n^`PC{^`iOXx~ROXqEbcMKPf^n\hLs^`XCR~^niOX¡XMOb_\nqEb_rKPkY±b)^`XMm^nj¢L)Z

£«bc\•gbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)Z1PnL„vˆj[MOz_PjpMµ^niOj¢PEg-Z¢LcP`P7b)£YO\`bc—KZpXCqEPCG H1iOXePfX¤X“bc\n^`PC{iObs¥.XvcXC\C{XCqEYOZpbsx_XCRVXeRORQx grO\n\`XMm^hP

bc\`j[zcj[MKLs^`jpMOzI£«\`bcqPnq7bˆbc^ni¦­®rOMOjp£«bc\`q ¯ ] Pfj[zcMSL)Z¢PjpMg-bcMSRQrKgA^`jpv_XŒPniOXX^`PCG2H1iKj[PªYSXC\nqEjp^f^`XCR•^`iOX\`XCROrKgA^`jpb_M•b)£ ^niKX

LcP`Pnbˆgj[L)^nXeR0^nj[qEX RQbcq•L)j[MEULsQ¥.XZ[ZP|Xe‰mrKLs^`jpb_M7PnxQPy^`Xq,^nb0LYOiKL_Pfb_\|£«b_\nq´jpMˆvcb_Zpvˆj[MOziSL)\`q7b_MOj¢gªPnxQPy^`Xq•P¥ jw^`iObcrO^

^n\hL)MSPfj[XMm^`PCG) ‰mrOXCPf^nj[bcMbc£2z_\nXeLs^1jpMm^nXC\nXePy^j¢P ¥ iOX^niOXC\1^niOX*\nXeRQrKg-XeRkb_\`ROX\ j¢RQXCL_P1b)£*



{

c'

gL)M¤—±X*PfrSgg-XePnPf£«rOZ[Zpx

XqEYOZ[bsxcXeR7jpMEXZ[XCg-^n\`bcq•L)z_MOX-^`j[g.j[Mm^nX\`\`bcz_L)^nj[bcMYO\nb_—OZ[Xq•P¥ iOXC\nX1^`iOXj[M_^`X\`\n\`bczmLs^`jpMOzIPnjpz_MKL)ZQj¢P3LIqEj[g\nbs¥1L„vcX.YOrOZ¢PnX

L)MSR7^niOX\`XCPnrOZp^nj[MOz"RQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[g j[Mm^nXC\f£®L_g-X \`XKXegA^nj[bcMSP,+„^n\hL)MKPnqEj[P`Pfj[bcMSP>j[Mˆvcb_Zpv_X1^n\hL)MKPnjpXCMm^`P^`iKLs^©qrKPf^©—SXŒLcggrO\hLs^nXCZpx

g-b_qEYOrQ^nXeR$jpM bc\hRQXC\^`bVYSXC\f£«b_\nq ^niOXq•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ j[ROXMm^njpoSgL)^nj[bcM ghiKLc\`L_gA^nXC\njCL)^nj[bcMµROXCPnjp\`XCR G °†M$^niKj[P•YSL)Y±X\•¥.X

YO\`XCPnXMm^1^niOXIoS\`Pf^ Xvˆj[ROXMKgXI^niKL)^ ^niOj¢P ‰mrOXCPf^nj[bcMgLcM—±X"L)MSPf¥.X\`XCRkjpM¤^niKX"Ls³•\nq•L)^nj[vcXcG

¨3\`bcY±X\©bc\n^niOb_zcbcMSL)ZQRQXCgbcqEY±b_Pnjw^`jpb_M6{mLcZ[Pnb0NˆMObs¥ M•LcPYK\nj[MKg-j[YKLcZSg-b_qEYSb_MOXMm^ªLcMKL)Z[xQPfj¢P- }Q' L)MKR•W0Lc\niˆrOMOXCM ƒ 6b/.XvcX

X-QYKLcMKPnjpb_M0 }_} { }c€{“j¢PL•¥.XZ[Z|NˆMObs¥ MqEX^niObQR£«b_\£«XCL)^nrO\`X"Xm^`\`L_gA^`jpb_MjpM¦Pf^`L)^nj¢Py^`j[gCL)Z2L)MKRYKL)^f^`X\`M\nXeg-bcz_MOjp^nj[bcM

oKXCZ[ROP1 C…%G7H1iOX•¨.²‹ qEX-^niKbˆR¬iKL_PLcZ[Pnb¤—SXCXM§L)YOYOZ[j[XCR¬jpM§Lk¥ j¢RQXEvsL)\`jpX^yxb)£ªbc^niOXC\oKXZ¢ROP0PnrKghi¬L_PŒq•L)^nX\`j¢L)Z¢P

YO\`bQg-XCP`PnjpMOz2 e} { }c‘ { }"3 { }) { ‘_‚4{QghiKL)\hLcg-^nXC\njCL)^nj[bcM7b)£ iˆrOq•L)M•£®L_g-XCP5 ‘_‘{ˆLcMKR7^nrK\n—OrKZpXCM_^ g-b_iOX\`XMm^ Kbs¥PŒ­6 3 { 3 {

e‚ { C€ { C { }m { ‘"3"6ƒ PfXCX0L)Z¢Pfb7^niKX"PfrO\`vcXCxQP7 C‘ { })…«¯ G

H1iOX.¨.²‹5q7X^niObQR*Zpj[MOXCLc\nZ[xŒ^n\hL)MKPf£«bc\`q•P|LqrOZp^nj[v„Lc\nj¢Ls^`XªROL)^`LŒPfX^>j[M_^`bŒLcM"bcYQ^`jpq•LcZmPnX-^2b)£KrOMSg-bc\`\`XZ¢Ls^nXeRv„Lc\nj¢L)—KZpXeP

­®¨1²‹ qEbQRQXeP

¯

GH1iKXbc\`j[zcj[MKL)ZSq*rOZp^nj[vsL)\`j[L)^nXROL)^`LgL)M•—±X¥ \njp^f^`XMkL_P3Z[jpMOXeL)\.g-bcq—Oj[MKLs^`jpb_MKP3bc£ ^niOXI¨.²‹ q7bQRQXePG

°†M§q•L)Mˆx¬gCLcPnXCP^niKXk¨.²‹¶qEbQRQXeP0qEbc\`X•X-³&g-j[XMm^nZ[x¬ROXCP`g-\`jp—±XE^niOXkv„Lc\nj¢L)—KjpZ[jw^yx¦b)£.^niOX&b_\nj[zcj[MKLcZ3ROLs^hLL)MKR§PnbcqEX

RQj[qEXMKPnjpb_MKL)Z \`XCROrKgA^`jpb_Mj¢P Y±b_P`Pfj[—OZ[X—ˆx&\`X-^hL)j[MOj[MOzEbcMOZ[x•^niKX0q7bmPy^j[qEYSb_\f^hL)Mm^ qEbˆROXCPCG

d Xeg-XMm^ErKPnXbc£¨.²‹ £«bc\E\`XCRQrSgA^nj[bcM5b)£b_\`ROX\7jpM RQj¢Py^`\nj[—OrQ^`XCR5YKL)\hL)qEX-^`X\7PfxQPf^nXq•P7j[MKg-Z[rKRQXeP•LcPMOb)^`XCRµLc—Sbsv_X

L)YKYOZpj¢gL)^nj[bcMKP0^nbYKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\"XCPf^nj[q•Ls^`jpb_MVbc\"j[MˆvcX\hPnX7YK\nb_—OZpXCq•P8  { _ L_P0¥.XZ[ZªLcP*L)YOYOZ[j¢gLs^`jpb_MKP0^`b—±b)^niVb_YSXCM

b)£2^niKXCPnXIPnxQPy^`Xq•P L)\`XIXCP`PfXCMm^nj¢L)Z[Zpx&bc£>Z[bs¥~oKMKjw^`X"RQjpqEXCMKPfj[bcMLcMKRLcqEXMKLc—OZpX^`b&L)YOYO\`b„Qjpq•L)^nj[bcMk—ˆxkLoKMKjw^`X"PfYKLcM

b)£L)YKYO\nb_YO\`j[L)^nXZ[x•ghiOb_PnXM¤—KL_Pfj¢P1XZ[XqEXMm^hPG

 ¡X&L)YOYOZ[xbcrK\"¨.²‹\`XCRQrKgXCR¦bc\hRQX\IqEbQRQXZ^`bL



‹¶PngCLs^f^`X\`jpMKz¤YK\nb_—OZpXCqjpM§¥ iOj¢ghi§Lk¥ j[MKRQbs¥.XCR¬qEj[g\nbs¥1L„vcX

YOrOZ¢PnXŒj¢P.jpMKgj[ROXMm^.b_MLRQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢gŒPnZ¢L)—&¥ jp^niL*PnrOYO\hLcgbcMKRQrSgA^nj[vcXŒ—KLcghNˆj[MOzKG2 ¡XŒYO\`XCPnXMm^1\nXePfrKZw^hP3£«b_\©^`iOX£«bc\`¥.Lc\`R

YO\`bc—OZ[Xq¶¥ iKj[ghiPfiKbs¥ ^niKL)^.^`iOXI\nXeRQrKgXCRbc\hRQX\.qEbˆROXZ j¢P.gCL)YKLc—OZ[XŒbc£>gLcYQ^nrO\`j[MOz*^`iOXIXZ[XCg-^n\`bcq•L)z_MOX-^`j[g—SXCiKL„vˆjpb_\

rKPnjpMKz¤Pnjpz_MOjpoSgLcM_^`Zpx¤£«XC¥ªXC\ŒqEbQRQXCPŒ^`iKL)M¦^niOX•a ” UVG“ ¡X*^`iOXM§L)YKYOZpx¤^`iOXE\nXeRQrKg-XeRbc\hRQXC\ŒqEbQRQXZ2^`bk^`iOXEjpMˆvcXC\`PnX

YO\`bc—OZ[Xq L)MKR•PniObs¥5^niKL)^©^`iOX\`XCRQrKgXCREb_\`RQXC\qEbˆROXZ±j[P3gCL)YKLc—OZ[Xb)£6LcgCg-rO\hLs^`XZ[x"XCPf^nj[q•Ls^`jpMOz"^niOXYSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP¥ jw^`i

L"Pnjpz_MOjpoSgLcM_^3\`XCROrKgA^`jpb_M•jpM&gbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)ZQ^`jpqEXbsv_X\^`iOXŒPf^`LcMKROL)\hREa ” UVG_ ¬X—±XZ[j[XvcX^niKL)^3^niOj¢Pª¥ªb_\nN*ROXqEbcM ƒ

Pf^n\hLs^nXeP^`iOX7£«XCL_Pfj[—Oj[Zpjp^yxb)£©rQ^`jpZ[jj[MOz¤^niOXE¨.²‹ \`XCRQrKgXCRb_\`ROX\v„Lc\nj¢Ls^`jpb_MKL)Z2qEX-^`iObQR£«bc\IYKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\XePy^`jpq•Ls^`jpb_M

j[M^`\`LcMKPnjpXCM_^ XCZpXegA^n\`bcq•LczcMOX^nj¢gŒPnxQPy^`Xq•P1¥ iOXMgbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)Z“^nj[qEX0j[P LcMjpqEY±bc\n^`L)Mm^g-b_MKPnj[RQXC\`L)^nj[bcM6G

;=! *3 !--7 " ¤ '

›–Ÿcž Sš ] bcMKPnj[ROX\1^niKX*YO\`bc—OZ[Xqb)£jpMm^`X\`\nb_z_Ls^`jpMKzELcMjpMQoSMOjw^`X­®jpM^`iOX¦LcMKRRQj[\`XCgA^`jpb_MKP ¯

PnZ[Lc—µb)£iObcqEb_zcXMKXbcrSP"q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ.—ˆx L¡¥ j[MKRQbs¥.XCRVqEj¢g-\`bs¥.L„v_X&YOrOZ¢PfXV­–a>j[zKG e¯ G5H1iOX¤jpMm^`X\`\nb_z_Ls^`jpMKz¬Pnjpz_MKL)Z.j[P

ghiObmPfXCM^nb—SXEL&Y±bcZ¢L)\`jCXCRYKZ[LcMKL)\ŒXZ[XCgA^`\nb_q•L)zcMKX-^nj¢g0¥1L„vcX"MKbc\`qELcZpZ[xjpMSg-j¢RQXMm^IbcM¦LcMjpMOoKMOjp^nXEPfZ¢L)—bc£©q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ

g-b_Mm^`L)j[MOXeRj[M^`iOX"j[M_^`X\`vsL)Z ! #"$&% ¥ jp^ni£®L_g-XeP YKL)\hL)Z[Z[XZ ^`b•^niOX'¤YOZ¢L)MOX_GH1iOX"XZ[XCg-^n\`j[g0oKXZ¢Rj[PYSb_Z[Lc\njXeR¥ jw^`i

b_P`g-j[Z[Z[L)^nj[bcMKP j[M^`iOX()kYOZ¢L)MKX"bcMOZ[xcGŒH1iOXPnZ[Lc—¥ jpZ[Z2—SX7RQXMObc^nXeR—ˆx*,LcMKR^niKX*\`Xzcj[bcMXm^`X\`jpb_\ ^nbk^niOX7PfZ¢L)——ˆx

*,+cG

z2

z1

z

x

y

Ω

₀

Ω

E(t,z)

H(t,z)

a2jpz_rO\nX  Š©TXbcqEX^n\`x&b)£>^niOX  ‹ PngCLs^n^nX\`j[MOzYK\nb_—OZpXCqG

£«bc\ XOL)qEYOZ[Xc{ })‡«¯

"

"

)"

‡

$+

"

+

+ "

"!#"

­} G„¯

H1iOXŒvcXCg-^nb_\ ƒvsL)Z[rOXCR£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKP LcMKR \`XYK\nXePfXCM_^©^niOXPy^`\nXCMOz)^`iKP©bc£ ^niOXŒXZ[XCg-^n\`j[gŒL)MKR•q•LczcMOX^nj¢g1oKXZ¢ROPC{ˆ\nXePfY±XCg ƒ

^nj[vcXCZpx_{¥ iOj[ZpX# L)MKR$:Lc\nX•^`iOXkXCZpXegA^`\nj¢gkLcMKRVq•L)z_MOX-^`j[g2KrQQXCPC{\nXePfY±XCg-^nj[vcXCZpx_G¦H1iOXgbcMKROrKgA^`jpb_MµL)MKRµPfb_rO\`gX

g-rK\n\`XMm^ROXMKPnjw^`jpXePŒLc\nX\nXCYO\`XCPnXMm^nXeR—ˆx% L)MKR ! {“\nXePfY±XCg-^nj[vcXZ[xcGIH1iOX7XZ[XCg-^n\`j[gL)MKR¦qELczcMOX^nj¢g"Y±bcZ¢L)\`jeL)—Oj[Z[jw^`jpXeP

L)\`X\nXCYO\nXePfXCMm^nXCR&—mx=L)MKR& {Q\nXePfY±XCg-^nj[vcXCZpx_G2H1iOXIXCZpXegA^n\`j¢gŒLcMKR&q•L)z_MOX-^`j[gIPnrKP`g-XYO^nj[—OjpZ[jp^nj[XCP1L)\`XŒ\`XYK\nXePfXCM_^`XCR•—ˆx

+ L)MKR' + {K\nXePfY±XCg-^nj[vcXZ[xkLcMKR&^`iOX"RQXCMKPfjp^yxkbc£|£«\`XX0XCZpXegA^n\`j¢gghiSL)\`zcXj[P1\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^`XCR&—ˆx'SG

H1iOX¤RQbcq•L)j[M * + j[P*^n\`XCL)^nXCRµLcP"XCqEYQ^yxVPfYKL_g-X_G P7PnrKghi6{( ‡ {) ‡ {3L)MKR$ ‡ G°†M$LcROROjw^`jpb_M6{jw^7j[P

LcP`PnrOqEXCR•^`iKLs^LcZpZ“YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\`PªMOXCgXCP`PnLc\nx7£«b_\ª^`iOX0RQX-^`X\`qEjpMKL)^nj[bcMb)£6^`iOXoKXZ¢ROP L)\`XNˆMObs¥ MjpM^niKj[P1\`Xz_jpb_M6G2H1iKX

PnbcrO\hg-Xg-rO\`\nXCMm^* !j[P.zcXCMOX\hLs^`XCR•—ˆx&LcMkj[MQoKMOjp^nX0L)Mm^`XMOMKLL)Z[bcMOz*^niOX LsQj¢P.LcMKR&iKXMKgXŒ¥ j[ZpZ“b_MOZpx•—±XMObcM CX\`bL)^

^niKXCPnX0YSb_jpMm^`P1j[M*,+

’

jp^`P ^nj[q7X

ƒ

vsLc\nxˆj[MOz7gbcqEY±bcMOXCM_^¥ j[Z[Z zcXMKX\hLs^nX^`iOX0jpMm^`X\`\nb_z_Ls^`jpMKz*XZ[XCg-^n\`bcq•L)z_MOX-^`j[gŒ¥1L„vcXCPCG

aOb_\^niOX7YOrO\`YSbmPfXePb)£3^`iOj[PIPf^nrKROxc{6¥.X*¥ j[ZpZq•LcNcXgX\n^`LcjpM¡LcP`PfrOqEYQ^`jpb_MKPL)—±bcrQ^^niOXEq•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ>YK\nb_YSXC\f^`jpXePŒbc£3^niKX

RQb_qELcjpM *{mMKXzcZ[XCg-^nj[MOz*q•LczcMOX^nj¢gX“XCg-^`P.L)MKRLcP`PfrKq7j[MOz0^`iKLs^²ŒiOq P©Z¢L„¥ zcbsv_X\`MKP^niKXŒXCZpXegA^n\`j¢gL)Z±g-b_MKRQrKg-^nj[vmjp^yxcG

H1iˆrKP1¥.X0iKL„vcX

­

¯ ‡

­

¯ +,k­

¯

/. * ­} G}_¯

0 )®žO#21cžQœ&3

54

aOb_\Pfj[qEYOZ[j[gjw^yx_{Q¥ªX^n\`XCL)^1^niOXIj[MKPy^hL)Mm^`LcMOXb_rKP.YSb_Z[Lc\njCL)^nj[bcMk^nbE—SXIYO\`bcY±bc\n^nj[bcMSL)Z±^nb7^niKX

XZ[XCg-^n\`j[goKXZ¢R¤Pfb*^niKL)^687:9 ; +=< •{Q¥ iKX\`X < j[P1L*ROjpXCZpXegA^n\`j¢gŒgbcMKPf^`LcM_^eG2H1iKXŒXCZpXegA^n\`j¢g*KrQkROXMKPnjw^yx•j[M¬­} Ge¯ ^niOXCM

gLcM—±X0¥ \`jw^n^nXML_P

$+

$+ <

$+_­

< ¯

$+=?>@

"

­} G‘m¯

¥ iOXC\nX > 

<)A  j¢P1^niKX0\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXYSXC\nqEXCLc—Oj[Zpjp^yxcG3H1iOXIYKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\@ > j¢P LEPfYSLs^nj¢L)Z[Z[x ƒRQXCYSXCMKRQXMm^YKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\

^niSLs^L)Z[Zpbs¥P©£«bc\1j[MKPf^`L)Mm^hL)MOXCbcrKPªX“XCg-^`P1bcMk^niOX^`iOX0RQj[PnYOZ¢LcgXqEXMm^1jpM * RQrOX^`b*^`iOXIXZ[XCgA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢Rkb_\nj[zcj[MKL)^nj[MOz*j[M

*,+cGH1iOX\`Xq•LcjpMKROX\b)£©^`iOX7qEL_g-\`b_P`g-b_YOj[g"XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢gYSb_Z[Lc\njCLc—OjpZ[jp^yx¤bc£3^niKX7qEXeRQjprKq *,j¢PROXMObc^nXCR¦—ˆx L)MKR¦j[P

\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^nXeRL_P L)M¤jpMm^`Xzc\hL)Z \`XYK\nXePfXCM_^hLs^`jpb_MRQXCYSXCMKRQXMm^rOY±bcMLERQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[gI\`XCPnYSb_MKPnXŒ£«rKMKgA^`jpb_M§­–‹Œda ¯ L)MKR^niKX

YKL_Py^IiOj¢Py^`bc\`xb)£3^`iOXEXZ[XCgA^`\nj¢g*oKXZ¢R5­«£«bc\0L¤RQj[P`g-rSPnPnjpb_Mb)£ª^niOj¢PqEbˆROXZ3L)MSRjp^`PI\`XZ¢Ls^nj[bcMSPfiOj[Y^`b¤bc^niOXC\ŒqEbQRQXCZ[PIj[M

^niKX0Zpjp^nXC\`L)^nrO\`Xc{OPnXX1 C‡

{OYOzSG C‡_¯

•­

"

¯ CB)D

+FE

­

FG "

¯ ­2G "

¯IH G " ­} G3ˆ¯

¥ iOXC\nXIjp^j[PL_PnPnrOqEXCRk^niSLs^J•­

‡

"

¯

‡

G

°†M•YKLc\f^`j[grOZ[Lc\C{c¥ªXghiKbmbmPfX1^`iOX‹ŒX—ˆxcX qEbQRQXCZ C‡

{

„

£«bc\©b_\nj[XMm^hLs^nj[bcMSL)ZQbc\ªRQjpY±bcZ¢L)\©YSb_Z[Lc\njCL)^nj[bcM7jpM *$RQXePng\nj[—SXeR

—ˆx K L

$+_­2M!NFMO ¯

MOP$+Q

"

­} G‚_¯

¥ iOXC\nX ! j¢P1^niKXIPf^`L)^nj¢gI\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXYSXC\nqEXeL)—Oj[Zpjp^yxcGH1iOX"‹ŒX—ˆx_XqEbQRQXCZ6g-bc\`\`XCPnYSb_MKROP©^nb

E

­

¯

SRUT

DWVYX

+ ­W ! Z O ¯Y[

K

j[M´­

}

G

3ˆ¯

H1iOXq•L)z_MOjw^`rKRQXb)£Œ^niOXY±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^`jpb_M \`XYK\nXePfXCM_^hP"^`iOXRQXCzc\`XXkbc£LcZpj[zcMOqEXCM_^•bc£^niKX¤j[MKRQj[vˆj[ROrKL)Z qEbcqEXCM_^hPG ] bcqEYKLc\nj[MOz­ } G ‚_¯ L)MKR¡­ } G ‘m¯ {QbcMKXIoKMKROP.^`iKLs^ ?>Q O jpM*

 jpM* +

" ­} G€m¯

£«bc\1^`iOX"‹ŒX—ˆxcXIY±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^nj[bcMqEbˆROXZG žQœ žOœ®Ÿ_žS ®žOœ3

uPnjpMKz§­} Ge¯ L)MSR¦^`iOX•g-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcM¡b)£ LkYOZ¢L)MKX ƒ YSb_Z[Lc\njXeRj[M_^`X\`\nb_z_L)^nj[MOzkj[MOYOrQ^

Pnjpz_MKL)Z{6bcMKXEgCL)M§L)\`zcrOX­®PnXX& C‡%¯ ^`iKLs^ &­

"

¯ &­

" ¯ L)MKR ­

"

¯ ­

" ¯ £«b_\"PngCL)Z¢L)\hP LcMKRF j[M

*,+cG0ŒPEL\`XCPnrOZw^e{^niKXY±bcZ¢L)\`jeL)—Oj[Zp^yx LcMKRSrQµRQXMSPfjp^yx L)\`XgbcMQoSMOXCR ^nb^`iOX ¬YOZ¢L)MOX§­«¥ jp^ni5MObcM CX\`b

g-b_qEYSb_MOXMm^`PbcMOZ[x¤jpM^`iOX(¡RQjp\`XCg-^nj[bcM

¯

L)MKRgCL)M—±XRQXCMOb)^`XCR—ˆx¤P`gLcZ[Lc\vsL)Z[rOXCPQ¶L)MKR,GlQjpMKgX0^niKX*q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ

* j¢P iOb_qEbczcXCMOXb_rKPªjpM¤^niKX RQj[\`XCgA^`jpb_M6{ˆ^niKXŒoSXZ¢ROPgLcM—±XI\nXCYO\`XCPnXMm^nXeRk—ˆxkP`gLcZ[Lc\ªvsL)Z[rOXeP •{V{ E{OLcMKR' j[M

*~L_P.¥ªXCZpZG3d XCgCL)Z[Zpj[MOz^niKL)^; !LcZ[PnbZ[j[XCP1j[Mk^`iOX RQjp\`XCg-^nj[bcM¥ªXoKMKRk^niSLs^ULsQ¥.XZ[ZP.XC‰mrKL)^nj[bcMKPª^niKXM\nXeRQrKgX^`b

+ + "!

­} Gc¯

J.x•^`LcNˆjpMOz•LcYOYO\`bcYO\`j[L)^nXIRQX\`j[v„L)^nj[vcXeP{Q¥.X0gL)Mg-b_q*—Oj[MOX^niKX0XC‰mrKLs^`jpb_MKP0­} Gc¯ ^nb•zcj[vcX

+ + + + L

F +

L

! " ­} G…m¯

¥ iOXC\nX&­} G‘_¯ ¥1LcP1rKPnXCR¤^`b&XZ[j[q7j[MKL)^nX { C$+m­

­W?> e¯>¯ { RQXCMOb)^`XCPLcM¤j[MKRQj¢gL)^nb_\ £«rOMKg-^nj[bcM£«bc\PfX^

­#(4#[{  j[MµLcMKR ‡ b)^niKX\`¥ j[PnX ¯ { {KLcMKR

L

!

D

G

" 3 42žQ Ÿ 3 4«œ&3>› ML)—KPnbc\`—Oj[MOz•—±bcrOMKRKL)\`xg-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcMj¢PYOZ¢LcgXCRLs^ P ‡ ^`b&YO\`XvcXCMm^ ^niOX\nXKXCg-^nj[bcM

­«—SLcghN&j[Mm^nb7^niOX0\`Xz_jpb_Mbc£>j[Mm^nX\`XCPf^ ¯ bc£>¥1L„vcXeP.Pnb7^niKL)^

#  $ &% (' +

‡ " ­} Gm¯

¥ iOXC\nX

$

%

 [

+ + G2H1iOX©—±bcrKMKROL)\`xIg-bcMSRQjw^`jpb_MKP|L)^6^niKXªPnZ[Lc—

ƒ PnrOYO\hLcgbcMKROrKgA^`jpv_X2—SLcghNˆjpMKz—Sb_rOMKROLc\nxL)\`X ) ‡ {

¥ iOj¢ghi"j¢P>LcrQ^nb_qEL)^nj¢gLcZpZ[xP`Ls^`j[PfoKXeR {sPfj[MKg-X*(*

k{)L)MKRI^`iOX1g-bcMSRQjw^`jpb_MF

)

‡ {„¥ iOj¢ghi"zcj[vcXeP,+&-. &/ +0 ‡ {

Pnb^`iKLs^Q / ; - ‡ bcM^niOX0—±bcrKMKROL)\`xcG3H1iKj[P j¢P Xe‰_rKjpvsL)Z[XMm^1^nb k­

" „¯ ‡ j[MbcrO\PnxQPy^`XqG°†MLcROROjw^`jpb_M6{Q^niKX

PnbcrO\hg-XIg-rO\`\`XMm^ !j¢PPnYSXeg-jpoKXCRL)^

‡ ­®L_P1¥ªX0iKL„v_XŒMKb)^nXeRL)Z[bcMOz^niOXI ƒ LsQj¢P ¯ G

œ 54 1

ž

W332S›

  iOjpZ[XI^niKX"vsL)Z[rOX0b)£ ! Œj[PNmMKbs¥ M6{Q^niKX0v„LcZprKX"b)£ #%Ij[P z_XMOXC\`LcZpZ[x&rOMKNmMKbs¥ M6G© ¡X0rKPnX

L¤YOj[XCg-X ƒ¥ j¢PnX7Z[j[MOXCLc\q•LcYOYOj[MOz^niKL)^0ZpXeL„vcXCPŒ^`iOX•jpMm^`X\`v„LcZ­‡ " ! ¯ j[MmvsLc\nj¢L)Mm^0L)MKR¡q•L)YKP•­! #" #% ¯ ^`b ­! #" e¯ GEH1iKX

X“XCg-^Œbc£2^`iOj¢Pq•L)YKYOjpMKz ‚ { € { e‡ { ‘K' j¢P^nb•^`\`LcMKPy£«b_\nq ^niOXbc\`jpz_jpMSL)Z6rOMKNmMKbs¥ MzcXb_qEX-^n\`x * +54 * ^`b&bcMOX¥ jw^`i

L7NˆMObs¥ Mz_Xb_q7X^n\`x76*6 ‡ " G ,MOXC¥ gbˆbc\hRQjpMSLs^nXvsL)\`j[Lc—OZ[Xj[M86** ‡ "  gL)M¤—±X"RQX-oKMKXCRLcP

6

:9­ ¯ <;

" ‡>= = " ! ­ ! ¯  %

" ! ? @? #%

­} GC‡m¯

H1iOj¢PgLcM¤LcZ[Pnb7—SX0¥ \`jw^n^nXCML_P

9­ ¯

­BA „¯ ­ ! ¯DC

FEHGIJ

­ ¯ " ­} Gc„¯

¥ iOXC\nXKA

T

FE

I T E

LcMKRL9M–­ ¯  ­BA e¯ ­ ¯ GH1iKXghiKLcjpM\`rOZ[X*j¢PrKPnXCR^`bkg-b_MˆvcX\n^ŒPnYKLs^`j[LcZ>RQXC\nj[vsLs^`jpv_XCP1^`b

RQXC\nj[vsLs^nj[vcXeP.jpM¤^nXC\nq•P bc£|^`iOX0MOX¥ vsL)\`j[Lc—OZ[X

6 SG3H1iKLs^ j¢P{ 6 6 N9 ­ ¯ 6

uPnj[MOz H 6 9M®­ ¯ H S{QbcMKX"gL)M¤¥ \`jw^`XŒ^`iOX0j[MOMOX\YO\nbQRQrSgA^`P1bc£>^`iOX0¥.XCL)NE£«b_\nqLcP

" B

I

+

­ ¯ Œ­ ¯H

B

+

6

­

6

¯ Œ­6

6

¯



­A „¯

H

6

­} GC‘m¯

" , B

I

+

­ ¯

­ ¯IH

B

+

­ 

­BA e¯ ¯ 6 1

­

6

¯ 6

­ 6 ¯IH 6

­} G3ˆ¯

S*žQ 4 S›

®žQœ&3 #Sš ]

b_MKPfj¢RQXC\^`iOX•gLcPnX*bc£ªLk‹ŒX—ˆx_XqEXCROjprOq *,¥ jw^`i¬L¤PfrKYO\`L_g-b_MKRQrKg-^nj[vcX

—KL_ghNmj[MOz LcMKRJ

>

­ ¯

O

RQX-oKMKjpMOz ^niOXj[MKPf^`LcM_^hL)MOXCbcrKP&YSb_Z[Lc\njCL)^nj[bcM jpM *G, ¡XoK\hPf^&X-QYO\`XCP`P­ } G…m¯ jpM~LcM

L)Zp^nXC\nMSLs^nX£«b_\nq —ˆx&j[Mm^nXCzc\hLs^nj[MOzEjp^L)z_LcjpMSPy^ Ly^nXePy^£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M {Sbc—Q^hL)j[MOj[MOz

+= " +=+ L "

+ " " + L !)­

" ¯ " " ­ } G e‚_¯

¥ iOXC\nX1^`iOXY±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^nj[bcM Žj[P©b)£“^niKX £«bc\`q­} G3m¯ LcMKR^niOXq•LcYOYOj[MOz0^nb *J6 ‡ "  iKLcP3LcZp\`XCL_RQx"—±XXCMkgLc\n\`jpXeR*b_rQ^CG

°†Mm^nXCzc\hLs^nj[bcM—ˆx&YKL)\n^`P1bc£1­ } G e‚_¯ z_jpv_XCPª^niKX0¥ªXeL)N•£«b_\nq

+ "

+ + L "

+ "

" L &­ "‡m¯ ­‡m¯ + L ! ­

"=¯ "

" ­ } G C€m¯ ¥ iOXC\nXI^`iOX0^nXC\nq L &­ " ‡_¯

­‡_¯ j¢P YKLc\f^bc£^niOX"¥.XCLcN&£«b_\nq\nXePfrOZp^nj[MOz•£«\`bcq ^niOXL)—KPnbc\`—Oj[MOzE—Sb_rOMKROLc\nx¤g-bcMSRQjw^`jpb_M

­} Gm¯ G

aOb_\gbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)Z©YKrO\nY±b_PnXCP*^niKX&^nj[qEXkvsL)\`j¢L)—OZ[X&j¢PP`gLcZpXeR§—mxVL£®L_gA^`bc\*bc£ $  [ + + ­ 6 $ ¯ LcMKR§^niKX

Y±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^nj[bcM, —ˆx¤L•£®LcgA^`bc\bc£  [ $+k­M6 [ $+ ¯ G ¡X*LcP`PfrKq7X"^niKL)^^niOXXZ[XCg-^n\`j[g0Y±X\`qEjw^n^nj[vˆjw^yxL)MKRqELczcMOX^nj¢g

Y±X\`q7XeL)—Oj[Z[jw^yx&bc£>^`iOX0qEXCRQj[rOq * Lc\nXIg-b_MKPy^hL)Mm^CGH1iOX"P`gLcZpXeRkXe‰mrKLs^`jpb_M—±XCgbcqEXCP

6

> "

+ + L " " " L &­ " ‡_¯ ­‡_¯ + L ! ­

" ¯ "

"

­} G„c¯

¥ iOXC\nX 6 ?>c­ ¯  ­ ¯ ­WMO „¯ j[P.^`iOXI\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXXZ[XCgA^`\nj¢gŒYSXC\nqEjp^f^nj[vˆjw^yx¤Pfb^niSLs^@ 6 ?> $+ILcMKRk^niOXIj[q7Y±XCRKL)MKgX b)£ £«\`XXPfYSLcg-Xj[P.RQX-oSMOXCR + + [ $+ ‘m)€ s‘

²ŒiOq•PCG2H1iKXŒj[MOMOXC\©YO\`bQRQrKgA^hP

=

" L)\`X^`iOX¥.Xj[zcim^`XCREj[MOMOX\

YO\`bQRQrKgA^hP1b)£ ­ } G e‘_¯ G 4 –›CŸc

œ&W1_žQœ 3

H1iKXj[Mm^nX\`vsL)Z ‡ "  j¢PrOMOjp£«bc\`q7Z[xRQj[vˆj[RQXeR¦L)^Œ^`iOXY±bcj[Mm^`P 6 ! "

$# {“¥ iOX\`X #  [&%

L)MSR ‡ " = " % G H1iOX¡XZ[XCg-^n\`j[g¬L)MKR~YSb_Z[Lc\njCL)^nj[bcM oKXCZ[ROP LcMKR; Lc\nX¡RQj[P`g-\`X-^`jCXCR ¥ jp^ni % YOj[XCgX ƒ ¥ j[PnX

Z[jpMOXeL)\¤PfYOZ[j[MOX£«rOMSgA^nj[bcMSP

7

­

6

¯ PnrKghi ^`iKLs^

7 ­ 6 ! " ¯ ('=7 " £«bc\ "

‡ " " % G H1iOX¦XePnPnXMm^nj¢L)ZŒ—Sb_rOMKROLc\nx

g-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcM

7

­ e¯ ‡ j¢PPnL)^nj¢PyoKXeR~—ˆx bcqEjp^f^`jpMOz

C~PnYKL)M + " " = " T G3H1iOXoKXZ¢ROPLc\nX^`iOXML)YKYO\nb„Qj[q•Ls^nXeR&—ˆx &­

"$ ¯ S 7­

" ¯

T 7 ' + R 7 ­ ¯ 7

­ ¯ "

•­

" ¯ J 7­

" ¯

T 7 ' + 7 ­ ¯ 7

­ ¯ "

­

}

G

C…m¯

°†Mbc\hRQX\.^`b&L„vcbcj¢RkgbcqEYOrQ^hLs^`jpb_MKL)Z6RQjp³&g-rOZp^nj[XCPC{O¥.XIqELcNcXIbcMKXŒ£«rK\f^`iOX\\`XC‰mrOj[\`XqEXMm^.^niKL)^ ^niOX0q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ —Sb_rOMKR ƒ

L)\`j[XCP1b)£>^niOX"PnZ¢L)— ! "  gbcj[MKg-j¢RQXI¥ jp^nizc\`j[RY±bcj[M_^hPGªH1iOX0zc\`j[RY±bcj[M_^gbcj[MKg-j¢RQj[MOz•¥ jw^`i¤^niOX0q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ —Sb_rOMKROLc\nx

! 1¥ j[ZpZ“—±XROXMObc^nXCR&—mx G2J.x•RQXCPnj[zcM6{m^niKX\`jpz_i_^.XCRQz_Xbc£ ^niOXq•Ls^nXC\nj¢L)ZSiKLcPª—±XXMq•L)YOY±XCR&^nb  {m¥ iOj¢ghi

g-b_\n\`XCPnY±bcMKROPª^`b^`iOX0zc\`j¢RkY±bcj[Mm^ % G

lˆrO—SPy^`jw^`rQ^nj[bcMbc£|^niKX"L)YOYO\`b„Qjpq•L)^nj[bcMKPI­} Ge…_¯ jpMm^`b­} G„c¯ xmj[XZ¢ROP

T 7 ' + R 7 ­ ¯ 6 Y> 7 " T 7 ' + + L R 7 ­ ¯ + 7 " T 7 ' + 7 ­ ¯ 7 " T 7 ' + R 7 ­ ¯ 7 " T 7 ' + L R 7 ­ ¯ 7 ­ ‡_¯ ­ ‡_¯ + L ! ­ " ¯ " "

­} GCm¯

¥ iOj¢ghigL)M¤—±X0¥ \njp^f^`XMLcP

­2 ­WMO( „¯f¯ R ­ + +5 ¯ L R R + ­ } G })‡m¯

£«bc\ R ­2R + " R % " = "YR T ¯ L)MKR ­ + " % " = " T ¯ G3H1iKXŒXCZpXCq7XCMm^`P.£«bc\1^`iOX % % q•Ls^`\nj¢g-XeP1L)\`XŒz_jpv_XM —ˆx 7 " 7 " " N B + 6 7 6 " 

­A „¯

H 6 '" 7 " 7" " SB + 6 7 6 "  ­BA e¯ H 6 " 7 "

7 ­‡m¯

" ­‡m¯ 7 " 7 " " B + ­ 

­BA „¯ ¯ 6

7 6 " H 6 "

­} G}Q„¯

¥ iOj[ZpXI^`iOX %  oKMKjw^`X0XZ[XqEXMm^vcXegA^`bc\ j¢P1zcj[vcXCM—ˆx

7 L ! ­

" ¯ "

7 B

+ L ! 6 7  ­A e¯ H 6

­} G}c}_¯

tbc^nXI^`iKLs^ ^`iOX0jpMm^`Xzc\hL)Z¢P1L)\`XŒj[M¤^nXC\nq•P1b)£2^niKX"PngCL)Z[XCRv„Lc\nj¢L)—KZpXePªbc£1­} GC‡m¯ G

 ¡X¥ j[Z[Z rKPfX^`iOX0‹XC—mx_XŒY±bcZ¢L)\`jCLs^`jpb_MkqEbQRQXZ3­

}

G

‚c¯

^nbEYO\`bsvˆj[RQXŒ^niKXIgbcMKPf^njp^nrO^nj[vcXZ[L„¥~\`XZ¢Ls^`jpMKz*^`iOX0YSb_Z[Lc\njCL)^nj[bcM

´^nb7^niOX0XCZpXegA^`\nj¢gŒoKXZ¢R•G)YOYKZpxˆj[MOzE^niOX"P`L)qEX^nj[qEX"PngCL)Z[jpMKzEL_P1L)—±bsvcX•­;6

[ + " 6 $ ¯ ¥ªXIbc—O^`L)j[M L J

jpM* " ­

} G })‘m¯ ¥ iOXC\nX S ! P O L)MSR  [ $ K GH|bIzcXCMOX\hL)Z[jXª^niOXLc—Sbsv_XªXe‰_rSLs^nj[bcM*^nbI^`iOX XMm^nj[\`X.RQb_q•L)j[M¥.XgLcMqrOZw^`jpYKZpx

^niKX0XC‰mrKLs^`jpb_M—ˆx•^`iOX0j[MKRQj¢gLs^`bc\1£«rOMSgA^nj[bcM ­ ¯ G3H1iOXCM6{KLcYOYOZ[xmj[MOz•L•TIL)Z[X\`NˆjpML)YOYK\nb„Qj[qEL)^nj[bcM6{ˆ¥.XIbc—Q^hL)j[M

L )

H1iOX"gbcq*—KjpMOXeRPnxQPy^`Xq bc£2Xe‰mrKLs^`jpb_MKP1j[P ­ ­WMO( e¯f¯ R ­ + +5 ¯ L R R + L J R ‡

­} G}c‚_¯

lˆrO—SPy^`jw^`rQ^nj[MOz•^`iOX"PfXeg-b_MKR&Xe‰_rSLs^nj[bcML)MSRjp^`PRQX\`jpvsL)^nj[vcXjpMm^nbE^`iOXIoK\hPy^e{QbcMOXoKMSROP ­ ­2?O( e¯n¯ R ­ + +5 ¯ L R ­ % = ¯ R % + L J R ‡

­} G})€m¯

H1iOj¢PgLcM—±X0¥ \`jw^n^nXML_P L*oS\`Pf^ ƒbc\hRQX\1PnxˆPf^nXCq ¥ jp^ni¤^niKX"g-bcqEY±b_Pnjw^`XIv„Lc\nj¢L)—KZpX '´­WR ("

("

L

R ¯ L_P

L '

­} G}_c¯

bc\ L R L R ‡ ‡ ‡ % R L R ‡ ‡ + " ­ } G })…m¯ ¥ iOXC\nX ­WMO( „¯ " % % " % " ­ + + ¯ " ­ } G })m¯ L)MSR j¢P ^`iOX % %

j[RQXCMm^njp^yxkq•Ls^`\njp¥ iOXC\nXI^`iOX"b_MOXCP iSL„vcXI—SXCXM\`XYOZ¢LcgXCR¥ jw^`i XC\nbmP1jpM\`bs¥P



^niO\`bcrKzci

F



G

H1iOXI£«b_\nq bc£|^`iOX"Pfb_rO\hg-X0g-rO\`\`XMm^ j[P ghiObmPfXCMk^`bE—SX

! ­

" ¯ 'Q­ ¯

E ! ­ ¯ + G D ­

¯ 'Q­ ¯ Pfj[M6­

¯ + G D ­

¯ " ­} G‘c‡m¯

¥ iOXC\nX~j¢PLkPnYSXeg-jpoKXCRLcMOzcrKZ[Lc\ £«\nXe‰mrOXMKgxb)£^niKX*j[MOYOrQ^0Pfj[zcMSL)Zª­–L)MKR^niOXEgLc\n\`jpXC\ £«\`XC‰mrOXMSg-x¤b)£^niKX\`XCPnrOZp^nj[MOz

YOZ¢L)MKLc\¥1L„vcX ¯ L)MKR 'Q­ ¯ j[P^niOX7‹j[\`L_g"RQj¢Py^`\nj[—OrQ^`jpb_M¥ jp^nij[MQoKMOjp^nXq•LcP`PLs^ ‡ GH1iOX7Pfj[zcMKLcZ6j¢P^`\nrOMSgLs^`XCRL)^

oKMOjp^nXŒ^nj[qEX gbcj[MKg-j¢RQj[MOz*¥ jp^ni E !„­

¯ ‡ —ˆx7^niOXjpMSRQj[gCLs^`bc\ª£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M

+ G D ­ ¯ ^nb7L„vcbcj¢R•g-b_qEYOZpj¢gL)^nj[bcMKPªL)\`j[Pnj[MOz

£«\`bcq RQj¢P`g-bcMm^`jpMˆrOjp^nj[XCPIj[M¦^`iOX•j[MOYOrQ^*Pnjpz_MKL)ZG ŒP"L\nXePfrOZp^C{

) £«bc\0PnbcqEXEYSbmPfjp^nj[vcXEXCvcXM¬jpMm^`XzcXC\ ) GEH1iKX RQrO\hLs^`jpb_Mbc£|^`iOXIYOrOZ¢PfX0qrKPy^ —±X"PfrO³•gjpXCMm^nZ[xkPfiKbc\n^ª^`bEROj[Pf^nj[MOzcrKj[Pni\nXKXCg-^nj[bcMKPª£«\`bcq¶^`iOX£«\nb_M_^LcMKRk—SLcghN&bc£|^niKX qEXCRQj[rOq{Q^`imrSP \nXe‰mrOjp\`j[MOz*^`iKLs^ $ = } ­#% ¯ G3H1iOX"grO\`\nXCM_^1q•Ls^`\njp&^niKXM—±XCg-b_qEXCP # $ Gm­ ¯ + G D ­ ¯ ‡ T %

­} G‘O„¯

œ&3 œ 54

 ¬XrKPnX0^niOX7Py^hL)MKRKL)\hR ] \hL)MKN ƒtj¢ghiOb_Z[PnbcMPnghiKXqEX0^nb&oKMKRLcML)YOYO\`b„Qjpq•L)^nX"PnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM£«b_\

^niKX"RQj“X\`XMm^`j[LcZ XC‰mrKLs^`jpb_M¤PnxQPy^`Xq­} G}_c¯ Gd XC¥ \njp^nj[MOz­} G}m)¯ LcP

L

N9­

" ¯ ­

¯ T ­

¯ ­} G‘_}_¯

L)MSRghiObˆbmPfj[MOz•LEPy^`XYPfjX"!“{Q¥.X0q•L)N_X^`iOX0jw^`X\hLs^`jpv_XILcYOYO\`b„Qjpq•Ls^`jpb_M

¥ iOXC\nX 9 2­ 9 ¯ 2­ ) ! ¯

{ 9 9$#&% ­



¯

9­

9 " 9

¯

9­

9$# " 9 #

¯ {1LcMKRµ£«bc\E^niKX ] \hL)MKN ƒ tj¢ghiOb_Z[PnbcM P`ghiOXqEX  + }

GH1iOj[P PnxQPy^`Xq gCL)M—±X"Pfb_Zpv_XCRkROjp\`XCg-^nZ[x&£«bc\ 9$#

9$# @ 9

! U9" ­} G‘"3ˆ¯

¥ iOXC\nX ­ !

¯ 9

9$# %

9 " ­} G‘_‚_¯

9$#&% ­  ¯ 9 9 #

{6LcMKR '+P ‡ G ” ‰mrKL)^nj[bcMµ­} G‘_‚c¯ gLcM¦—±X•Pfb_Zpv_XCR—ˆxqEXCLcMKPb)£©—KZpbQghN ƒTILcrKP`Pfj¢L)M

XZ[j[q7j[MKL)^nj[bcM¤^nb•L7—OZ[bˆghNkrOYOY±X\ ƒ^`\nj¢L)MOz_rOZ¢L)\ PfxQPf^nXCq¤{ >u £®Lcg-^nbc\`jCLs^`jpb_M6{QL)MKR¤—KL_ghN ƒPnrO—KPf^njp^nrQ^`jpb_M6G

32›Cœ Ÿcœ 3 1 0 54 › lˆj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M¬rSPfj[MOz^niKX•oKMOjp^nX ƒXCZpXCq7XCMm^*PfxQPf^nXq ­} G}m)¯ L)—±bsvcXEYO\`bsvˆj[RQXePIL

q*rKZw^`jpvsL)\`j¢Ls^nX0ROL)^`LEPnX-^g-b_MKPnj[Pf^nj[MOzEb)£ } vcXegA^nb_\`P = =

­} G‘c€m¯

\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^nj[MOz*^niOX % MKbˆRKL)Z“vsL)Z[rOXCP.b)£8&­

¯ L)MSR •­

¯ L)^

^nj[qEXY±bcj[Mm^`P1RQrO\`j[MOz*^`iOXIPfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M6GH1iOj¢P1bc\`jpz_jpMKLcZ

ROL)^`LEPfX^:j¢P.^n\hL)MSPy£«b_\nqEXCRk^nb•L7MOXC¥ PnX-^bc£>rOMKgbc\`\nXCZ[L)^nXeR&vsL)\`j[Lc—OZ[XCP0­®¨1²‹,qEbˆROXCP ¯ —mx

" % " = " % " ­ } G ‘mc¯

¥ iOXC\nX ^`iOXIg-bcZ[rOqEMKPªb)£6

% " % % " = " % % L)\`X ^`iOXŒXCjpz_XMˆvcXegA^`bc\hPb)£“^niKXŒYO\`bQRQrKg-^ªq•Ls^`\njp­L ¯ % 7 7 % 7 {m\hL)MKNcXCR6{_j[MRQXePngXMKROjpMOzbc\hRQX\e{m¥ jw^`ik\`XCPnYSXegA^©^`b*^`iOXILcP`PfbQg-j¢Ls^`XCREXCjpz_XMˆvsL)Z[rOXŒLcMKRE^niKXŒYO\`j[q7XIPnrOYSXC\`P`g-\`j[YQ^

RQXCMOb)^`XCP0^`iOX&^`\`LcMKPnYSbmPfX•bc£ ^niOXqEL)^n\`jw GH1iOX¤¨.²‹ q7bQRQXeP Lc\nX•b_\f^`iObcz_bcMKLcZ

7 " 7'=7 G " {LcMKR§^niKX ^n\hL)MSPy£«b_\nq•Ls^`jpb_Mkbc£>vsL)\`j[Lc—OZ[XCP1YO\`XCPnX\`vcXeP3^`iOX"ROLs^hL7v„Lc\nj¢L)—KjpZ[jw^yx % ' ­ ¯ % ' ­ ¯ % '

­} G‘c…m¯

” QYKLcMKPnjpb_M"b)£S^niOX1bc\`j[zcj[MKL)ZmROLs^hLjpM^nXC\nq•P2b)£S^niOX1qEb_Pf^Pnj[zcMOjpoSgLcMm^¨1²‹5qEbQRQXeP>qEj[MOj[q7jXeP2^niOX1qEXCLcMP`‰mrKL)\`X X\`\`bc\1b)£L\`XCROrKg-XeR—SLcPnj[P.\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^`L)^nj[bcM C…4 ­ ¯ 7 " ' ­ ¯ 7 ­ ¯ " " ­ } G ‘cm¯

¥ iOXC\nX"! ==}

G&H1iOXEqEb_Pf^*Pfj[zcMKjwoSgCL)Mm^"¨.²‹qEbQRQXCP*L)\`X*^`iOb_PnX&g-b_\n\`XCPnYSb_MKRQj[MOz&^`b^niOX•Z¢L)\`zcXePy^IXj[zcXCMˆv„LcZprKXCPC{ PnjpMKgX*^`iOX7\`L)^nj[bkb)£©LcM¦XCjpz_XMˆvsL)Z[rOX"^`b&^niKXEPnrOqEq•Ls^`jpb_Mb)£©XCjpz_XMˆvsL)Z[rOXCPC{ [$# " ' " { z_jpv_XCP^niOXEY±X\hg-XMm^hL)zcX*b)£ ^niKXŒqEXCLcMP`‰mrKL)\`XXC\n\`bc\ªrOMKLcgCg-b_rOMm^nXCR•£«bc\1—ˆx•XZ[jpqEj[MKLs^`jpMOz^niKXgbc\`\nXePfY±bcMKROjpMOz¨.²‹ qEbˆROX% j[M&^`iOX\nXeRQrKg-XeR

—KL_Pfj¢P©\`XYK\nXePfXCM_^hLs^`jpb_M& e…GH1iOX—±XCPf^.Pf^nbcYKYOjpMKzY±bcj[Mm^ªj[M&^niKXŒXˆYSL)MKPnjpb_M­} G‘__¯ ROXY±XMKROPC{Qj[M&zcXCMOX\hL)Z{_rKYSb_M&^niKX

L)YKYOZpj¢gL)^nj[bcML)MKRvsL)\`jpb_rKP L)Z[zcb_\njp^niKqEP.iKL„v_XŒ—±XXCMYO\nb_YSbmPfXeR }Q, G

0" 4®›eŸ) œW1_žQœ 3 =PfXeg-b_MKRRQj¢Png\nX^njCL)^nj[bcM£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMYO\`bQRQrKgXCP^niOX\nXeRQrKg-XeR—KL_Pfj¢PqEbQRQXCZ–G°†M^`iOj[P

gL_PfX_{Q¥ªXoK\hPf^1rSPfXI^`iOX"¨.²‹,qEbQRQXCP & ^nbEbc—Q^hL)j[M¤^niOX0¨.²‹ XZ[XqEXMm^`P ' ­ ¯ 7 ' ­

¯ 7 7 ­ ¯ " !P  " } " = " }

­} G3_‡m¯

¥ iOXC\nX*^niOX£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKP 7n­

¯

L)\`X"^niKX"oKMOjp^nX7XZ[XqEXCM_^IZ[jpMOXeL)\jpMm^`X\`YSb_Z[L)^nj[bcM£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKPCG0H1iOX*XCZpXegA^`\nj¢g*LcMKRY±bcZ¢L)\

ƒ

qEb_Pf^Pfj[zcMOjpoSgCL)Mm^¨.²‹,qEbQRQXCP

k­

" ¯

­

" ¯

7 ' R 7 ­ ¯ ' 7 ­ ¯ •­

" ¯

­

" ¯

7 ' 7 ­ ¯ ' 7 ­ ¯

­} G3K„¯

¥ iOXC\nX_{Sj[M^niOj¢PgLcPnXc{ ! = % G YOYOZ[j[gCLs^`jpb_Mb)£^niKj[PŒL)YOYO\`b„Qjpq•L)^nj[bcMjpM5­} G„c¯ ­«j[M^`iOj[PgL_PfX0¥.X"rKPnX¨1²‹ ^`XCPf^

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKP

7 ' 7  " } " = " ! ¯ xˆj[XZ¢ROPL•TIL)Z[X\`NˆjpM ƒ¨.²‹,PnxQPy^`Xq

7 ' R 7 ­ ¯ 6 ?>&' 7 " ' 7 ' + L R 7 ­ ¯ + ' 7 " ' 7 ' 7 ­ ¯ ' 7 " ' 7 ' R 7 ­ ¯ ' 7 " ' 7 ' L R 7 ­ ¯ ' 7 ­ ‡m¯ ' ­ ‡m¯ + L ! ­ "= ¯ " ' " ­ } G 3m}_¯

¥ iOj¢ghigL)M¤—±X0¥ \njp^f^`XMLcP

­ ­WMO „¯f¯ R ­ + +5 ¯ L R R + ­ } G 3_‘m¯ £«bc\ R/­WR " R % " = "YR ¯ { ­ " % " = " ¯ {©L)MSR L R, L R " L R % " = " L R ¯

G¬H1iKXkXZ[XqEXCM_^hP"£«b_\"^`iOX ! !

q•Ls^`\nj¢g-XeP L)\`XŒz_jpv_XM¤—mx 7 " ( ' 7 " ' " B + '6 7 6 ' " 

­BA e¯

H 6 " 7 " ' 7 " ' " CB + 6 ' 7 6 ' "  ­BA „¯ H 6 '" 7 " ' 7 ­ ‡_¯ ' " ­ ‡_¯ 7 " ' 7 " ' " B + ­  ­BA „¯2¯ 6 ' 7 6 ' " H 6 "

­} G3 3ˆ¯

¥ iOj[ZpXI^`iOX !  oKMOjp^nX0XCZpXCq7XCMm^vcXCg-^nb_\.j¢P

7 L ! ­ " ¯ " ' 7 B + L

! '6

7



­BA e¯

H 6 " ­ } G 3m‚_¯ L)MSR¤^niOX7jpMm^`Xzc\hL)Z¢PLc\nX0j[M^nXC\nq•PŒb)£^niKXP`gL)Z[XCRvsLc\nj¢L)—OZ[XCPŒRQX-oSMOXCRj[Mµ­ } G C‡_¯ G ] iObˆb_PnjpMKzE^niOXEPfb_rO\hg-X"g-rK\n\`XMm^ŒL_P j[M§­ } G ‘c‡m¯ ¥.XoKMKR 7 $ Gm­ ¯ + G D ­ ¯ ' 7 ­ ‡m¯M ­ } G 3_€m¯ YKYOZpj¢gL)^nj[bcM¤b)£2^niOX"¨1²‹ L)YOYK\nb„Qj[qEL)^nj[bcMKP©^nb7^`iOX"‹XC—ˆxcX0g-b_MKPy^`jw^`rQ^nj[vcXIZ¢L„¥=­ } G ‚c¯ \nXCZ[L)^nj[MOz^niOX0Y±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^`jpb_M' ^nb7^`iOX0XZ[XCg-^n\`j[goKXCZ[R=zcj[vcXeP L ) R

‡ ­} G3ˆc¯

lˆj[MKg-X^`iOX¨.²‹ —KLcPnj[P7£«rKMKgA^`jpb_MKP '

Lc\nXz_Zpb_—KL)ZPnYKLs^`j[LcZpZ[xµRQj¢Pf^n\`jp—OrO^nXCR$£«rKMKgA^`jpb_MKP{.^`iOXq•Ls^n\`jp6

j¢P•MObc^

PnjpMOz_rOZ¢L)\e{m¥ iKj[ghiRQj±XC\`P.£«\`bcq ^niOXIoSMOjw^`X0XZ[XqEXMm^ £«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcM6G

H1iOX"gbcq*—KjpMOXeRPnxQPy^`Xq bc£2Xe‰mrKLs^`jpb_MKP1j[P0­} G3_‘m¯ LcMKR¡­} G3ˆc¯ j[P

­

­WMO „¯f¯

R ­ + +5 ¯ L R R + L R ‡

lˆrO—SPy^`jw^`rQ^nj[MOz•^`iOX"PfXeg-b_MKR&Xe‰_rSLs^nj[bcML)MSRjp^`PRQX\`jpvsL)^nj[vcXjpMm^nbE^`iOXIoK\hPy^e{Q¥ªXIb_—Q^`LcjpM ­

­2MO e¯n¯

R ­ +=+5 ¯ L R ­I % ¯ R % + L R ‡ "

­} G3_m¯

¥ iOXC\nX

j¢P^`iOX!( !´j¢RQXCM_^`jw^yx_GŒH1iOj¢PgCL)M—±X*¥ \`jp^f^nXCM¦LcPŒLEoK\hPy^

ƒ

b_\`ROX\PnxQPy^`Xq ¥ jw^`i^niKX

‘ !=vcXegA^`bc\vsL)\`j¢L)—OZ[X ­WR " " L R ¯ L_P L ' ­ } G ‚)‡m¯ L R L R ‡ ‡ ‡ % R L R ‡ ‡ + " ­ } G ‚Q„¯ ¥ iOXC\nX ­WMO( e¯ " % % = " % " ­ + + ¯ ­ } G ‚c}_¯

H1iOX&PnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM¡^`b^niOX&RQj“X\`XMm^nj¢L)Z3Xe‰mrKLs^`jpb_M¡PnxQPy^`Xq ­} G‚)‡m¯ gCL)M§—±XkL)YOYK\nb„Qj[qEL)^nXeRrKPnjpMKzL ] \hL)MKN ƒtj¢ghiOb_Z[PnbcM

P`ghiOXqEXIjpM¤^`iOX"PnLcqEXq•LcMOMOX\L_P RQXCP`g-\`j[—SXeRLc—Sbsv_XŒ£«b_\1^niOX"a ” U:RQj“X\`XMm^nj¢L)Z Xe‰_rSLs^nj[bcMPnxˆPf^nXCq:­} G}_)¯ G

3 s› #Sš  ¬X¬£«bc\`q*rOZ¢Ls^`X^niKX¦YO\`bc—OZ[Xq RQXePng\nj[—±XCR j[M RQX-^hL)j[ZŒj[M C‡% bc£0^niOX¬jpMm^nXC\n\`bczmLs^`jpb_M$bc£"L

‹ŒX—ˆxcX7RQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢g*qEXeRQjprKq ¥ jw^`i¬LPfrOYK\`L_g-bcMSRQrKgA^`jpv_X*—KL_ghNˆjpMOzk—mxLkYOZ¢L)MOX ƒY±bcZ¢L)\`jCXCR¥ j[MKRQbs¥.XCR¥.L„v_XcG°†M^niKX

j[Mmv_X\hPfXYO\`bc—OZ[Xq¶¥.X0Ls^n^nXqEYQ^1^`bEROX-^nXC\nqEj[MOXIYKL)\hL)qEX^nX\1vsL)Z[rOXeP1b)£|^`iOX0RQj[XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢gq•Ls^nXC\nj¢L)Z±£«\`bcq XQYSXC\nj[qEXMm^`LcZ

qEXCL_PfrO\`XqEXCM_^hP&Ls^ J

‡

b)£I^niKX\nXKXCg-^nXeR XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢g¤oKXCZ[R,G H1iOj¢P&j¢PkL_gg-b_qEYOZpj¢PniOXCR$—ˆx5qEj[MOj[q7jj[MOzV^`iOX

% RQj±XC\nXCMKg-X0—±X-^y¥.XXCMk^`iOX0X-QY±X\`jpqEXCM_^hL)Z6ROL)^`LEL)MSR¤Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M\`XCPnrOZp^`P qEj[M . 3­ ¯ 7 ' + &­ 7 " ‡K’ ¯ 7 + % " ­ } G ‚)‘m¯

¥ iOXC\nX Vj¢P©^`iOXMmrKq*—±X\1b)£>P`L)qEYOZ[XŒRKLs^`LY±bcj[M_^hP 7{QL)^.rOMKjw£«b_\nq^`jpqEXjpMm^nXC\nvsLcZ[P

7 { j[Pª^niKXPnX-^1b)£>L_RQqEj[P`P`L)—OZ[X

YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\`PC{SLcMKR/&­

7" ‡O’

¯ L)\`X0^niOX7XZ[XCg-^nj¢g0oKXCZ[Rv„LcZprKXCPL)\`j[PnjpMKzE£«\nb_q Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKP¥ jp^ni¬YKL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP

GŒH1iKX vcXegA^`bc\

^yxˆYOj[gCL)Z[Zpx&gbcMm^`LcjpMSPªRQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[gL)MSR +„b_\.gbcMKRQrSgA^nj[vˆjw^yx•YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP©ghiKLc\`L_gA^nXC\njj[MOz0^`iOXIqEXCRQj[rOq LcMKR +„b_\

zcXCbcqEX-^`\nj¢gŒYO\nb_YSXC\f^`jpXeP0­®PnXX2 C‡«¯ G

aOb_\ bcrO\ gbcqEYOrQ^hLs^nj[bcMSL)Z“^nXePy^`jpMKz7bc£>^`iOXIqEX-^niKbˆRKPL)MKR¤L)Z[zcb_\njp^niKqEPC{QPfxˆMm^niKX-^nj¢g0ROL)^`L

@7j¢P1YO\nbQRQrSg-XCR—ˆxL_RORQj[MOz

\hL)MKRQb_q MOb_j[PnX^nb7^niOX0\`XCPnrOZp^`P1bc£a

”

UPnjpqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMKP1¥ jp^niL7NˆMObs¥ MPfX^b)£>YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP{M#(4#[{

7 J 7 ­ 

7¯ " ­} G‚%3ˆ¯

¥ iOXC\nXQ 7 Lc\nX1^`iOXŒvsLcZprOXeP©P`L)qEYOZ[XCR7£«\`bcq=^niOXIPnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM•¥ jp^ni&NˆMObs¥ M•YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP{

7 Lc\nXj[MKRQXCYSXCMKRQXCM_^.MObc\`q•L)Z[Zpx

RQj¢Py^`\nj[—OrQ^`XCR \hL)MSRQbcq v„Lc\nj¢L)—KZpXeP•¥ jw^`i~qEXCLcM X\`b L)MSR v„Lc\nj¢L)MSg-XbcMKX e‡G H1iOX¦L)qEYOZ[jp^nrKRQX¬b)£I^niKX¦MOb_j[PnXj[P

YO\`bcY±bc\n^nj[bcMKLcZˆ^nbI^`iOXPnjpz_MKL)ZQZ[Xv_XZ 7 L)MKR^`iOXg-bˆX³•gjpXCMm^

GJªx7ghiObcj¢g-X1bc£

{c¥.XgL)M•gbcMm^n\`bcZQ^`iOX \`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcX MKbcj¢PfX_G

aOb_\X-OLcq7YKZpX_{ C‡ \nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXIMOb_j[PnXIj[PL_ghiOj[XvcXeR¬­®¥ jw^`iYO\`bc—KLc—OjpZ[jp^yx ‡ G_‚"3m‚c¯ —ˆxghiOb_j[gX0b)£

‡‡m‚ Pfj[MKg-X

7 Zpj[XCP

j[M : } +" } + } " }% ­«¥ jp^niYO\`bc—KLc—OjpZ[jp^yx ‡ G_‚"3m‚c¯ G

Uj[MOj[q7jCL)^nj[bcM¡b)£@3­

¯ j[PY±X\n£«bc\`q7XeR¦rSPfj[MOzLJ.\`bsxˆROXM ƒa2ZpX^`ghiOXC\ ƒTbcZ¢Rˆ£®L)\`z ƒlˆiKLcMOMOb­®J1a2T0l ¯ vsL)\`j[Lc—OZpXqEX-^n\`j¢g

L)Z[zcb_\njp^niKq:­>s{“YOzKG 3ˆ})… ‘m}4«¯ GH1iOXzc\hLcRQj[XMm^b)£ 3­

¯ j[Pbc—Q^hL)j[MOXCR£«\`bcq LE£«bc\`¥1L)\hR ƒROj“X\`XMKgX0L)YOYO\`b„ ƒ

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMKPL)\`X•qEbˆROjwoKXeR¡£«bc\7RQbcrO—KZpX

ƒ

YO\`XCgj[Pnj[bcM6G°†M LcRORQjp^nj[bcM|{2gbcMKPf^n\hL)j[Mm^`P"Lc\nX&L_RORQXCR¬^`b\nXKXCg-^"^niKX&YOiˆxQPfj¢gLcZ

Z[jpqEjp^`Ls^`jpb_Mb)£YKL)\hL)qEX^nX\hPC{ #[{±MOb•MOXCz_Ls^`jpv_XIv„LcZprKXCPCGªH1iOX"gbcMˆvcXC\nz_XMKgXŒ\`XC‰mrOj[\nXCqEXMm^ £«bc\-CX\`bcj[MOz7^niOX0z_\`L_RQj[XMm^

j¢P



e‡

T

£«b_\L)Z[Z ^niOX0qEj[MOj[q7jCL)^nj[bcM¤YO\`bc—OZ[Xq•P1\`XY±bc\n^nXCRiOXC\nX_G

H1iOX7vsL)Z[rOXCP &­

7

"

‡K’

¯

L)YOY±XCLc\nj[MOz&j[M5­

}

G

‚)‘_¯

L)\`X*b_—Q^`LcjpMOXeR£«\`bcqPfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMKPŒrKPnjpMOzXjp^niOXC\0a

”

bc\I¨.²‹=—KLcPnj¢P

XZ[XqEXCM_^hPGlˆj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_M§rKPfj[MOz¦a ” —KL_Pfj¢P0v_XCgA^`bc\hPIj[P*Py^`\`Lcjpz_i_^ ƒ£«b_\n¥1L)\hR { —OrO^PfZ[bs¥0{Pfj[MKg-XE^`iOX&—KL_Pfj¢P0v_XCgA^`bc\hP0L)\`X

j[MKRQXY±XMSRQXMm^b)£S^niOX1YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\>vsL)Z[rOXePGUj[MOjpqEjCL)^nj[bcM*bc£ 3­

¯ rKPnj[MOz0Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKP>¥ jw^`iE¨1²‹$—KLcPnj[P2XCZpXCq7XCMm^`P2j[P

£®LcPf^nXC\C{_—OrQ^.q7b_\nXgbcqEYOZ[j[gCLs^`XCR {mPfj[MKg-X1^`iOXŒ¨1²‹ —KL_Pfj¢PXZ[XqEXCM_^hP©Lc\nX z_XMOXC\`L)^nXCR£«\`bcq PfMKLcYKPniOb)^hPbc—Q^hL)j[MOXCR£«\`bcq

a ” PnjpqrOZ¢Ls^nj[bcMSP©¥ jp^nikPnY±XCg-jpoKXeR&YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\©vsL)Z[rOXCPCGaOb_\3^niKXŒqEj[MOjpqEjCL)^nj[bcM&YO\`bc—KZpXCqLg-b_ZpZ[XCg-^nj[bcM&bc£|PfMKLcYKPniOb)^hP

£«\`bcq=Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKP3g-bsv_X\`jpMKzILI\hL)MKzcX1b)£ YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\v„LcZprKXCP­

¯f¯ Lc\nX1rKPnXCR7^`b"zcXCMOX\hLs^`X.^niOX¨1²‹ —KL_Pfj¢PXZ[XqEXCM_^hPG

9

%

­

¯

%

­

% ¯ =

%

­

9 ¯

" ­} G‚c‚_¯

¥ iOXC\nXXCL_ghi PfMKLcYKPniOb)^•\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^ % MKbˆRKL)ZvsL)Z[rOXeP&L)MKRµ^niKX\`XL)\`X

PnMKLcYKPfiKb)^`PEXeLcghi5£«bc\E^`iOXXZ[XCg-^n\`j[gLcMKR

Y±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^nj[bcMoKXZ¢ROPIY±X\"PnjpqrOZ[L)^nj[bcM6G°†M¬z_XMOXC\`LcZ–{“^`iOX•Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM¡\nXePfrOZp^`PIghiKLcMOzcX7zc\hLcROrKL)Z[Zpx¥ jp^ni§ghiKL)MKzcXCPj[M

# ;´8 42 +´?k82 ?

S*žQ 4

Sš

›

 ¡X Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`XCR*^niOX1j[Mm^nX\`\`bcz_L)^nj[bcM0bc£±LRQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢gªPnZ¢L)—7¥ jw^`i7L£«bc\`¥.Lc\`R0£®Lcg-X1Ls^ ! ‡‘_‘

L)MSRLPnrOYO\hLcgbcMKROrKgA^`jpv_X"—KLcghNˆj[MOzkL)^ #% ‡…_ —ˆxL&YOZ¢L)MKX ƒYSb_Z[Lc\njXeR¥ jpMKRObs¥ªXeR¥.L„v_X"rKPnjpMKz&^niKX*^`XCghiOMOj¢‰mrOXCP

bcrO^nZ[jpMOXeR5Lc—Sbsv_XcG H1iOXq•L)YOY±XCR5\nXCzcj[bcM *¶¥1LcPERQj¢Png\nX^njXCR5¥ jp^ni6 % 3ˆ‚)‡ L)MKR e‚c‡ G5H1iKXROjpXCZpXegA^n\`j¢g

YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\ªvsL)Z[rOXeP©¥.X\`X ! ‘m‚ { O ‚ {

K

 e‡ T P{ +,  ‡ C‡ T

%

²ŒiOq T G3H1iOXIPfj[zcMSL)Z±YKL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hP

¥.X\`XghiObmPfXCM&^`b7—±XcŠ

 … C‡ P T { }

\hLcR +)PfXeg){QL)MKR

‘ ‘c‘ C‡ T PCGH1iKXIROj“X\`XMm^nj¢L)Z

PnxˆPf^nXCq ¥1LcP1j[M_^`Xz_\`L)^nXCR¥ jp^niLEPy^`XYPfjXIbc£ H

U‡ e‡ T

MSP.£«bc\L^nbc^`L)Z|b)£

79 C‡ MKPCG

 ¡XXˆY±X\`j[q7XCMm^nXCRµ¥ jw^`i5RQj“X\`XMm^7PnMKL)YSPfiObc^j[Mm^nX\`vsL)Z¢P"£«b_\*^`iOXg-\`XCLs^`jpb_M b)£ ^`iOX¨.²‹q7bQRQXePGV¨1²‹ qEbQRQXCP

g-\`XCL)^nXeRkrKPnj[MOz•LP`L)qEYOZ[XI\`L)^nXc{Qb_\PfMSL)YKPniOb)^1j[M_^`X\`vsL)Z{Qb)£ ‡ G‡_‡_‚ MKP1YO\`bsvˆj[RQXeRkLcMX³•gjpXCMm^\nXCYO\nXePfXCMm^`Ls^`jpb_M&b)£2^niKX

ROL)^`LOGa>j[zcrK\nX

}

PniObs¥P^niOXEY±X\hg-XMm^IvsL)\`j[Lc—OjpZ[jp^yxgL)YO^nrO\`XCR£«b_\^niOX7oKXCZ[R¡ROLs^hL¦­2&­

¯

LcMKR •­

¯f¯

LcPILk£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M

b)£^niOXMˆrOq*—±X\7b)£Œq7bQRQXePELs^7^niOX

‡

G

‡c‡m‚

MKPEP`L)qEYOZ[jpMOz¡j[M_^`X\`vsL)ZGVlQbcqEX\`XYK\nXePfXCM_^hLs^`jpv_X&vsL)Z[rOXCPEL)\`X _

G

‡c_

{

c

G

_€_}

{QLcMKR _

G

c_

£«bc\ ‘_‡

{

‚)‡

{OL)MKR )}

qEbQRQXCPC{O\`XCPnYSXegA^`jpv_XZ[xcG

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

NUMBER OF MODES

PERCENT VARIABILITY REPRESENTED

a2jpz_rO\`X

}

Š©¨XC\`gXMm^ b)£2oKXZ¢RV­W&­

¯

L)MSR •­

¯f¯

vsLc\nj¢L)—Oj[Z[jw^yx\nXCYO\nXePfXCMm^nXCR¤LcPL7£«rOMKgA^`jpb_Mb)£2^niOX*MmrKq*—±X\bc£2qEbQRQXCP

rKPnXCR G3H1iKX"PnLcq7YKZpj[MOzEjpMm^`X\`v„LcZ ¥.L_P

‡

G

‡c‡_‚

MKPC{Ozcj[vˆjpMKz }c‡c‡O

 ¡Xj[ZpZ[rKPf^n\hLs^`X"^niKX*X-³&gCLcg-xbc£^niOXE¨.²‹=\nXeRQrKgXCRb_\`RQXC\\`XYO\`XCPnXMm^hLs^nj[bcM—ˆxPfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[MOz&^`iOX*£«b_\n¥1L)\hRYO\`bc—OZ[Xq

rKPnjpMKz^`iOXIoK\hPy^ c}

¨1²‹,qEbˆROXCP0­«bc£ 3m‡c‡m}

Y±b_P`Pfj[—OZ[XqEbQRQXeP

¯

z_XMOXC\`L)^nXCR&£«\nb_q PnMKL)YKPniObc^`P.^`LcNcXCMLs^ ^`iOX

‡

G

‡c‡m‚

MKP

P`L)qEYOZ[jpMOzE\hLs^`XcG

a2jpz_rO\`XCP ‘sƒ†€

gbcqEYKLc\nXXZ[XCgA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢R¬\nXePfrOZp^`PIb_—Q^`LcjpMKXCRrSPfj[MOza

”

U<­®t 3ˆ‚)‡

L)MKR 8 „‚)‡_¯

L)MKR¡¨.²‹­–d )}_¯

PnjpqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMKPCG2°†Ma2jpz_rO\`X ‘ ^niOXXZ[XCg-^n\`j[goKXZ¢R&j¢P©YKZpbc^f^nXeRkL_PªL"£«rOMKgA^`jpb_Mbc£ ^niOXq•L)YOY±XCRRQj¢Py^hL)MKgX5Ls^ ‡ G MKPCG .^

^niKj[PŒ^nj[qEX*^`iOX7¥ jpMKRObs¥ªXeRYOrOZ¢PfX7iKLcPŒMObc^ŒxcX^Œ\`XCL_ghiOXCR¤^`iOX7ROjpXCZpXegA^n\`j¢g*q•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ–Ga2jpz_rO\nX 3 RQXCYOj¢gA^`PŒ^`iOX*XCZpXegA^n\`j¢g

oKXCZ[R¤Ls^ ‚ G‡ MSP{Q¥ iOXC\nX^`iOX\`XLc\nX—±b)^ni¤\`XKXegA^nj[bcM¤L)MKRk^n\hL)MSPfqEj¢PnPnjpb_M&YOrOZ¢PnXCP1bc\`j[zcj[MKLs^`jpMOz*£«\nb_q^niOXIj[MOjp^nj¢L)Z YOrOZ¢PnX

Ls^* ‡ G°†M—Sbc^nigL_PfXeP.^niOXC\nXIj¢P zcbˆbQRLczc\`XXCq7XCMm^.—±X-^y¥.XXCMk^`iOX"a ” U L)MKR¤¨.²‹ Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKPG

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

−200

−150

−100

−50

0

50

100

150

200

z (mapped)

E

a2jpz_rO\`X ‘ ŠIH1iKX7XCZpXegA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢R¬L)^ ‡ G MSP0LcPIL£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M¬bc£,V­®qELcYOY±XCR ¯ £«b_\I^niOX•a ” U Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM ­®PnbcZ[j[R¬Zpj[MOX ¯

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

−150

−100

−50

0

50

100

150

z (mapped)

E

a2jpz_rO\`X 3 ŠIH1iKX7XCZpXegA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢R¬L)^ ‚ G‡ MSP0LcPIL£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M¬bc£,V­®qELcYOY±XCR ¯ £«b_\I^niOX•a ” U Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM ­®PnbcZ[j[R¬Zpj[MOX ¯

a2jpz_rO\`XCP

‚

L)MSR

€

PniObs¥~^`iOX"XCZpXegA^n\`j¢goSXZ¢RLs^



G

‡

L)MKR e‡

G

‡

MKPCG .^ ^`iOXCPnXI^nj[qEXCPC{ObcMKZpxk^niOXI^`\`LcMKPfqEjp^f^`XCRY±bc\n^nj[bcM

b)£“^`iOXj[MOjp^nj¢L)ZKYKrOZ[PnX\`Xq•L)j[MKPCG2H1iKXRQj¢Png\nXCYKL)MKgjpXeP—±X-^y¥.XXME^`iOXŒa

”

UL)MKR•¨1²‹~Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMKPªL)\`X q7b_\nX XCvˆj[RQXCMm^

RQrOXI^`b&L)Mj[MKg-\`XCL_PfXjpM\`XZ¢Ls^`jpv_XXC\n\`bc\1—±XCgCL)rKPnX0b)£2^niOX0v_X\`xkPnqELcZpZ q•LczcMOjp^nrKROX0b)£2^niOX0XCZpXegA^n\`j¢goKXZ¢R¤bcrQ^hPfj¢RQXI^niKX

RQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[g*qEL)^nXC\nj¢L)ZGH1iKX7J.\`jpZ[Zpb_rOj[MYO\`XCg-rK\`Pnbc\hPL)\`X*XCvˆj[RQXCMm^Œ£«\`bcq ^niKXZ¢L)\`zcX*LcqEYOZpjp^nrSRQXCPb)£^`iOX£«bc\`¥.Lc\`RLcMKR

^n\hL)j[Z[jpMOzIY±XCLcNˆPj[ME—Sbc^ni7oKz_rO\nXePG2H1iOX\`X j¢PPy^`jpZ[ZOX-OgXZ[ZpXCM_^3Lczc\`XXqEXCM_^—±X-^y¥.XXCM*^`iOXa

”

U L)MKRE¨1²‹ Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKPCG

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

−20

−15

−10

−5

0

5

10

15

z (mapped)

E

a2jpz_rO\`X

‚

ŠIH1iKX7XCZpXegA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢R¬L)^



G

‡

MSP0LcPIL£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M¬bc£,V­®qELcYOY±XCR

¯

£«b_\I^niOX•a

”

U Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM ­®PnbcZ[j[R¬Zpj[MOX

¯

L)MSR¨1²‹ Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM§­®ROL_Pfi

ƒ

RQbc^1Z[j[MOX

¯

G3H1iOX"¨.²‹,\`XCRQrSg-XCRbc\hRQXC\.qEbQRQXCZ6rKPnXCR s‡

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

−12

−10

−8

−6

−4

−2

0

2

4

6

8

z (mapped)

E

a2jpz_rO\`X € ŠH1iOXXZ[XCg-^n\`j[gIoSXZ¢R¦Ls^ C‡ G‡ MKPLcPLE£«rOMSgA^nj[bcM¬b)£ ¬­«q•L)YOY±XCR ¯ £«b_\^`iOXa ” U Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_Mµ­®PnbcZ[j¢RZpj[MOX ¯

H1iOX*PnbcZ[rQ^`jpb_M^`jpqEX¥ jw^`i^niOX*¨1²‹ qEbQRQXZ.­

‚

qEj[M

¯

j¢PPnjpz_MOjpoSgLcM_^`ZpxZpXePnP^niKLcM^niOXPfb_ZprQ^`jpb_M¤^nj[q7X\nXe‰mrOjp\`XCR£«b_\

^niKX 3m‚c‡

MKbˆROXka

”

qEbˆROXZŒ­ }_c}

qEj[M

¯

Glˆj[MKgX•^niOXkX-³&g-j[XMKgx¬bc£1^niOX&qEbQRQXeP0j[P*\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXCZpxj[MKRQXCYSXCMKRQXCM_^7b)£1^niKX

MˆrOq*—±X\Ibc£3MObQRQXCPrKPnXCR {“^`iOX^nj[q7X•P`L„vˆjpMOzmPbc£3^niOXE¨.²‹=\`XCRQrKgXCR¦bc\hRQX\Œq7bQRQXCZbsvcX\^niOX•a

”

qEbQRQXCZ2—±XCgbcqEXCP

qEbc\`X0Pfj[zcMOjpoSgCL)Mm^ ¥ iOXM¤qEbc\`XMKbˆROXCPLc\nX\nXe‰mrOjp\`XCR6G

H1iOj¢P.YSb_jpMm^1j[P.j[ZpZ[rKPf^n\hLs^nXeR•j[Ma2jpz_rO\`X  {_¥ iOXC\nXjp^1gCL)Mk—±XIPfXCXM•^`iKLs^1^niKXa ” U:Pfb_ZprO^nj[bcM•^`jpqEXj[P.YO\`bcY±bc\n^nj[bcMKLcZO^`b

^niKXŒMˆrOq—SXC\.bc£|MObQRQXeP.P`‰mrKL)\`XCR6G Z[Pnb*YOZ[b)^n^nXeRLc\nX ^`iOXIXC‰mrOj[vsL)Z[XMm^.¨1²‹ PnbcZ[rQ^`jpb_M•^nj[qEXCPC{Q¥ iOj[ghi¤L)\`XŒgCL)Z¢g-rOZ¢Ls^`XCR

j[M&^niKXŒP`L)qEXq•L)MKMOX\1LcPªL)—±bsvcXcGH1iKL)^ªj¢P{m£«bc\.XCL_ghi %ƒ MObQRQXCR&a ” U Pfj[q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM¦­«^niOXYKL)\hL)qEX^nX\ªvsL)Z[rOXCPªL)\`X^niKX

P`L)qEX7L_PIL)—±bsvcXc{“XQgXYQ^

79 ‚ ‡ MSP ¯ ^niKXE¨1²‹ q7X^niObQR¬j[P0LcYOYOZ[jpXeR^`bPnMKLcYKPfiKb)^`PLs^ ‡ G‡_‡_‚ MKPIj[Mm^nXC\nvsL)Z¢PCG

H1iOX*Pnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_Mk^`jpqEX"rKPnj[MOz•^niKX"¨.²‹,£«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcM¥ jp^ni q7bQRQXeP"­®ghiKb_PnXM¤^nb&gCL)YQ^`rO\nX"L)^Z[XCLcPf^ c G_c b)£

^niKX*vsL)\`j[Lc—Oj[Zpjp^yx ¯ j[P^niOX"Xe‰mrOjpvsLcZpXCM_^¨.²‹´PnbcZ[rQ^`jpb_M^nj[q7X_Ga2jpz_rO\nX  PfiObs¥P ^niKL)^^niOXXC‰mrOj[vsL)Z[XMm^Œ¨.²‹=Pfb_ZprO^nj[bcM

^nj[qEXCPLc\nX\`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcXCZpxkjpMKROXY±XMKRQXCMm^b)£2^niOX0MˆrOq—SXC\ b)£a ” U MKbˆROXCPCG

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

x 10

5

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

N

2

SOLUTION TIME (MIN)

FEM

EQUIVALENT POD

a2jpz_rO\`X  Š>H1iOXªPnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM"^nj[q7X1LcP2L £«rKMKgA^`jpb_M*b)£K^niOXªMmrKq*—±X\b)£OMObQRQXeP>P`‰mrKL)\`XCR0£«bc\>^niOX.a ” U ­®b ¯ ¥ jp^ni

7:9 ‚ G‡

MKPCG Z¢Pfb*PniObs¥ M&Lc\nX ^`iOXXe‰mrOjpvsLcZpXCM_^.¨.²‹ PnbcZ[rQ^`jpb_ME^nj[q7XePŒ­« ¯ {ˆ¥ iOX\`X ^`iOXMˆrOq—SXC\©b)£6qEbQRQXeP©gLcYQ^nrK\nXeP©Ls^ªZpXeLcPf^

3 s› Sš ž  ¬X*^nrO\`M^`bkg-b_q7YKrQ^`L)^nj[bcMKLcZ6oKMKROjpMOzmP£«b_\ŒLkbcMOX"YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\*­2?!

¯

YO\`bc—OZ[Xq

b)£^`iOX*j[Mm^nXC\n\`bczmLs^nj[bcM¤b)£©LkRQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢g*PnZ[Lc—¥ jw^`i¬L&PnrOYO\hLcgbcMKROrKgA^`jpv_X0—KLcghNˆj[MOz&—ˆx¤LkYOZ¢L)MOX

ƒ

Y±bcZ¢L)\`jCXCR¤¥ j[MKRQbs¥.XCR

¥1L„vcXcG|°†M"^niKX.j[MˆvcXC\`PnX3YO\`bc—OZ[Xq ¥.XªL)^f^`XqEYQ^^nbIRQX-^`X\`qEjpMOXª^niKXªYKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\>vsLcZprOXePª­2M!

¯

bc£O^niKX.RQj[XZ[XCg-^n\`j[gªq•Ls^`X\`j[LcZ

£«\`bcq¶qEXCL_PfrO\`XqEXCM_^hP.b)£|^`iOXIXZ[XCg-^n\`j[goKXZ¢R¤Ls^

‡

GH1iOX0RQjpXCZpXegA^`\nj¢gIPfZ¢L)—¤RQjpqEXCMKPfj[bcMSP.LcMKRYKL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hPªLc\nXŒ^niKX

P`L)qEX0LcP L)—±bsvcXj[M^`iOXI£«bc\`¥1L)\hR&YO\`bc—OZ[Xq{QXQgXYQ^ £«b_\

%

e‚c‡

{

‚)‡

{QLcMKR

%

 p_

e‡

T

G

°†M¬^niOj¢PIX-OL)qEYOZ[Xc{|¥ªXEj[Mmv_XCPf^nj[z_L)^nX"^`iOX•j[Mmv_X\hPfXYO\`bc—OZ[Xq£«b_\^niOX•PnjpMOz_ZpXErOMKNmMKbs¥ M¦YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\ M!"jpM¬^niOXE\hL)MOz_X

‘O ? M!? ‘c GH1iO\`XX7a ” PnjpqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMKP7­WM! ‘K " ‘c‘ ".L)MKR ‘__¯ XeLcghi¥ jp^ni

‚c‡O PnMKL)YSPfiObc^`PŒb)£^`iOX % 

MObQROLcZ3vsL)Z[rOXCP£«b_\I^niOX•XCZpXegA^nj¢g•L)MSR¬Y±bcZ¢L)\`jCLs^`jpb_MoKXCZ[RKP"L)\`XErKPfXeR¬^nbbc—O^`L)j[M¬^niOX&¨1²‹¶—KLcPnj¢PIXZ[XqEXMm^`P£«b_\0^niKX

qEjpMKjpqEjCLs^`jpb_MYO\nb_—OZ[Xq

T

&

T

%

­2?! ‘O„¯

T

%

­WM! ‘_‚_¯

T

%

­WM! ‘__¯

­‘ G‚)€m¯

H1iOX0XCZpXeg-\`j[gŒoKXCZ[R¤j¢P qEXCLcPnrO\`XCR¤Ls^ ‡ G‡O MKP1j[Mm^nXC\nvsL)Z¢P.£«\`bcq ‡@=

= ‚ MKPCG©a2jpz_rO\`X … PniObs¥P.^niKX0bc—KPnX\`vcXeR&vsL)Z[rOXCP

b)£2^niKX0XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢gŒoKXZ¢RLs^

‡

L_P L£«rOMKgA^`jpb_Mb)£>^nj[q7X_G

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

−200

−150

−100

−50

0

50

100

150

200

TIME (ns)

ELECTRIC FIELD AT Z=0

a2jpz_rO\`X … ŠH1iKXb_—KPfXC\nv_XCRXCZpXegA^n\`j¢g0oKXCZ[R¬Ls^5 ‡ L_PŒL&£«rOMKgA^`jpb_M¦bc£3^nj[qEXcG0UXCL_PfrK\nXCq7XCMm^`PL)\`X"q•LcRQX7Ls^ ‡ G‡O MKP

H1iOX¤L)—Oj[Zpjp^yx§b)£ ^`iOX¨1²‹ £«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcM§^`b¦\`XCg-bsv_X\I^`iOXk^`\nrKXkvsL)Z[rOXCP*jpMµ^niOXjpMˆv_X\hPfX&YK\nb_—OZpXCq:j¢PjpMˆvcXePy^`jpzmLs^`XCR

LcPEL¬£«rOMKg-^nj[bcM$b)£Œ^niOXMˆrOq—SXC\7bc£ŒqEbQRQXCPErSPfXeRŽ­–a>j[zKG _¯

G$H1iKX£«b_ZpZ[bs¥ j[MOz¡gbcMKROjw^`jpb_MKPE¥ªXC\nX¤rKPnXCRµ^nb¡bc—Q^hL)j[M

^niKXCPnX\`XCPnrOZp^`PCŠ ‡

MObcj¢PnXc{NM!s­^`\nrKX

¯

‘_‘

{ M!s­«j[MOjp^nj¢L)Z

¯

‘ˆ

{3L)MSR*3­

¯

q7j[MOj[qEjCXCR5¥ jw^`iµ\`XCPnYSXegA^*^`b¬b_—KPnX\`v„L)^nj[bcM

qEXCL_PfrO\`XqEXCM_^hP0£«\`bcq^nj[qEXCP

‡

?

?

‘‚

MKPG PX-QY±XCgA^`XCR {^`iOX¤\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX•X\`\`bc\"z_XMOXC\`LcZpZ[x¡ROXCg-\`XCL_PfXeP"LcP*^niKX

MˆrOq*—±X\.b)£ qEbQRQXCPªj[MKg-\`XCL_PfXePG²PngjpZ[Z[L)^nj[bcMKP©q•L„x—±XŒRQrKX^nb*^niOXŒjpM KrOXMSg-Xbc£ ^niOXLcROROjw^`jpb_M&b)£6YKLc\f^`j[grOZ¢L)\3qEbQRQXCP

¥ jp^ni¦\`XCPnY±XCgA^Œ^nbk^niOX*^n\`rOX*YKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\vsL)Z[rOX_G5Pa2jpzSG  jpMSRQj[gCLs^`XCPC{K^`iOX\`XZ¢Ls^`jpv_X"X\`\`bc\RQXeg-\`XCL_PfXePPfZ[bs¥ Z[x¤L)£^nX\

L)YKYO\nb„Qj[q•Ls^nXCZpx ‚c‡ qEbQRQXePG

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

−1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

NUMBER OF MODES

PERCENT RELATIVE ERROR

Data

Cubic smoothing spline

a2jpz_rO\`X



Š•H1iOXYSXC\`gXMm^*\`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcXk\nXeg-bsvcXC\nXeR¦YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\"XC\n\`bc\k­ C‡_‡

+?!e­«^n\`rOX ¯0ƒ

M!„­«\`XCgbsvcXC\nXeR ¯f¯

+ M!­«^n\`rOX

¯

+

¯

LcPL

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcM$b)£^`iOX¤MmrKq*—±X\Eb)£qEbQRQXeP¤­–g-j[\`gZpXeP

¯

G H1iOXg-rO\`vcX¤RQ\`L„¥ M ^niO\`bcrOz_iV^niKX¤ROL)^`L¬j[PEL¬g-rO—Oj¢gPfqEbˆb)^`iOj[MOz

 ¡X7MKX-ˆ^j[MˆvcXePy^`jpzmLs^nXeR^niKXELc—Oj[Zpjp^yxb)£3^`iOX•¨.²‹=£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM^`b¤\`XCgbsvcXC\QM!0¥ jp^ni§LkMOb_j[PnxPnjpz_MKL)ZL)MKR¬L&oKˆXeR

MˆrOq*—±X\ bc£|qEbQRQXCP0­ €c‡_¯

Ga>j[zcrK\nX C‡

zcj[vcXeP.LcMkXQLcqEYOZpXIbc£|^niKXb_—KPnX\`vcXCR&XZ[XCgA^`\nj¢goKXZ¢Rk¥ jp^niKbcrQ^MOb_j[PnXIL)MKR¥ jw^`i

‚

MObcj¢PfX0L_RORQXCR6G°†M^`iOj¢PgL_PfXM! ‘c‘

G

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

160

170

180

190

Observations

E

Example of observed and noisy signal at 5% error

Noisy

True

a2jpz_rO\`X e‡ Š),Y±bc\n^nj[bcMb)£>^niOX*bc—KPnX\`vcXeR&XZ[XCg-^n\`j[goSXZ¢R¤L)^- ‡ ¥ jp^ni ‚ MObcj¢PfX•­–Pfb_Zpj¢R¤Zpj[MOX ¯ LcMKR¤¥ jw^`iObcrO^LcRORQXeR

H1iOX7LcggrO\hLcg-x¤b)£^`iOX¨1²‹ £«b_\nqrOZ¢Ls^nj[bcMj[M^`iOX7Lc—Sbsv_X0jpMˆv_X\hPfX"YK\nb_—OZpXCq ¥ jw^`ibcMOXrOMONˆMObs¥ MYSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\*­2?!

¯

j¢Pg-b_q7YSL)\`XCRk^nbE^niKX*a

”

U:£«bc\`q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MjpMa2jpzSG _

{Q¥ iOXC\nXI^`iOX"\`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcXIXC\n\`bc\1j¢P YOZ[b)^f^`XCRL_PL7£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMb)£^niKX

Y±X\hg-XMm^0MOb_j[PnXj[M¬^niOX&Pnjpz_MKL)ZGaKbc\I—KL_Pfj¢Pb)£.gbcqEYKLc\nj¢Pfb_M6{“^niKXEP`L)qEXEPfXCXCR$­

ƒhe}c‘"3m‚c€_¯

£«bc\^niOXE\hL)MKRObcqMˆrOq*—±X\

zcXCMOX\hLs^`bc\j¢PrKPnXCR£«b_\LcZpZgL_PfXeP¥ jp^ni¬MObcM

ƒ

XC\nbkMObcj¢PfX_GŒ°†M¦zcXMKX\hL)Z6^`iOX7\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX"XC\n\`bc\ŒjpMKg\nXeLcPnXCPZpj[MOXCLc\nZ[x¥ jw^`i

\`XCPnYSXegA^.^nb^niOXYSXC\`gXMm^1MObcj¢PfXŒ£«bc\.—±b)^ni^niKX¨1²‹ LcMKRka

”

U£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMKPCG

”

Og-XYO^.Ls^.^niKX7CX\`b*Y±X\hg-XCM_^1MOb_j[PnX

Z[XvcXCZ–{ª^niKX¨.²‹ qEX-^`iObQR5j¢P•PnZpj[zcim^nZ[xµqEb_\nXLcgCg-rO\hLs^`X^`iKL)M5^niKXa ” UD£«bc\`q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKPG  ¡XLs^n^n\`jp—OrO^nX¤^niOj¢PE^`b

PnX\`XMKRQj[YOjp^yx&\hLs^niKX\1^niSL)ML)Mˆx&\`Xq•L)\`NsL)—OZ[XŒqEX^niObQRQb_Zpb_zcj¢gL)Z“YO\`j[MKg-j[YOZ[XcG

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

ε

_s

(true) = 39

ε

_s

(true) = 33

% NOISE

% RELATIVE ERROR

POD

FEM

a2jpz_rO\`X _ ŠH1iOX7Y±X\hg-XMm^I\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX\nXeg-bsvcXC\nXeRYKL)\hL)qEX^nX\X\`\`bc\­ C‡_‡ +?!e­«^n\`rOX ¯ƒ ?!„­®\nXeg-bsv_X\`XCR ¯n¯+ M!C­^`\nrOX ¯ +¯ LcPL

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMbc£>^`iOX"Y±X\hg-XMm^MOb_j[PnXI£«bc\^niOX*¨1²‹ ­«bS{ €c‡ qEbQRQXeP ¯ LcMKRa ” U ­ ¯ £«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMKPCG3°†M—±b)^nigCLcPnX"ROLs^hL

Y±bcj[M_^hPL)\`XIg-bcMKMOXCg-^nXCR¤—ˆxkPf^n\hL)j[zcim^1Zpj[MOXCPCG

,YOZ[b)^ b)£2^niKX0\`L)^nj[bbc£a ” UPnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM^nj[qEXCP1^`bE¨1²‹ Pfb_ZprO^nj[bcM^nj[q7XeP j[ZpZ[rKPf^n\hLs^nXeP.^niOXI^`jpqEX"P`L„vˆjpMOzmP©b ±XC\nXeRk—ˆx

^niKXŒ¨.²‹ŽqEX-^`iObQR G P.a>j[zKG „}

jpMSRQj[gCLs^`XCPC{c^`iOX¨1²‹~qEX-^`iObQR•j¢P©qEb_Pf^ªX³&g-j[XMm^.L)^©^niKX ‡

MOb_j[PnXZ[Xv_XZK¥ iKX\`Xjp^

j¢PMOj[MOX1^nj[qEXCP£®L_Py^`X\^niSL)M7^niOXa

”

U £«b_\nqrOZ¢Ls^nj[bcM|G P^niOX MOb_j[PnX1ZpXCvcXCZQjpMKg\nXeLcPnXCP2^`iOX¨.²‹ X³•gjpXCMKg-x7RQXCg\nXeLcPnXCPC{

Xv_XMm^nrSL)Z[Zpx"\`XCL_ghiOj[MOz0L

‚

G

3cƒ

£«b_Z[R*^nj[qEXP`L„vmj[MOz0Ls^^`iOX e‚

MOb_j[PnX1ZpXCvcXCZ–GH1iOX¨.²‹ ^nj[q7XeP3L)\`X1MOb)^.ghiKL)MOz_jpMKzŒqrKghi

LcP.^`iOX0MOb_j[PnXIZpXCvcXZ6ghiSL)MOz_XCPC{m—KrQ^ ^niOX"a

”

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

% NOISE

T

FEM

/ T

POD

ε

_s

(true) = 33

ε

s

(true) = 39

a2jpz_rO\`X e} Š&H1iOXk\hLs^`jpb¬b)£PnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM ^nj[q7XeP­®H +)H ¯ LcPL£«rOMSgA^nj[bcM$b)£ ^`iOX¤YSXC\`gXMm^MOb_j[PnXcG§H1iOXROLs^hL

Y±bcj[M_^hPL)\`XIg-bcMKMOXCg-^nXCR¤—ˆxkPf^n\hL)j[zcim^1Zpj[MOXCPCG

3 s› ( Kš ž °†M"^niOj¢P2X-OL)qEYOZ[Xc{„¥.X©j[Mmv_XCPf^nj[z_L)^nX^niKXªj[MˆvcX\hPnX3YO\`bc—OZ[Xq ¥ jw^`i

K

L_P ^`iOX.Pnj[MOzcZ[X

rOMONˆMObs¥ MYKL)\hL)qEX^nX\eGH1iOXŒYK\nb_—OZpXCq¶g-bcMSRQjw^`jpb_MKP1L)\`X^`iOXP`L)qEXILcPªjpM^niKXŒYO\`Xvˆj[bcrKPªX-OLcq7YKZpX_{mXOg-XYO^ª^`iKLs^ MObs¥

¥.XXqEYOZ[bsxoOQXCR ! ‘m‚

L)MSR

K

j¢P©vsL)\`j[XCR GH1iO\`XXŒa

”

Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKP­

K



e‡

T

%

"



e‡

T L)MKR



C‡

T

+

¯

XCL_ghi¥ jw^`i

‚)‡O

PnMKLcYKPfiKb)^`Pb)£^niKX

%



MObQROLcZ>vsL)Z[rOXeP £«bc\^niOX*XZ[XCgA^`j[gL)MKRY±bcZ¢L)\`jCLs^`jpb_M¤oKXZ¢ROPL)\`X0rKPfXeR

^nbEb_—Q^`LcjpM¤^niKX"¨.²‹,—KL_Pfj¢P1XZ[XqEXMm^hP.£«bc\1^niKX0q7j[MOj[qEjeLs^nj[bcMYO\`bc—KZpXCq

T

T

%

­

K

 C‡ T

%

¯ T

%

­

K

 C‡ T ¯ T

%

­

K

 e‡ T

+

¯

­‘ G‚_c¯

H1iOXkLc—Oj[Zpjp^yx¬bc£ ^niOX¨.²‹¶£«b_\nqrOZ¢Ls^nj[bcM§^`b\`XCg-bsv_X\I^`iOX&^`\nrOXkv„LcZprKXCP"j[M§^niKXkj[Mmv_X\hPfX•YK\nb_—OZpXCq:j¢P"YKZpbc^f^nXeR LcP*L

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcM¬b)£^niKXMˆrOq—SXC\Œbc£3q7bQRQXePrSPfXeRj[M¦a2jpzSG e‘ GŒH1iKX*£«b_ZpZ[bs¥ jpMKzkg-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcMKPŒ¥ªXC\nX*rKPfXeRj[M^niKXCPnX\`XCPnrOZp^`PCŠ

‡ MObcj¢PnXc{

K

­«^n\`rOX ¯ ‚ C‡ T $

{

K

­®jpMKjw^`j[LcZ¯ ‘ ‚ C‡ T {2LcMKR ­

¯ qEjpMOj[qEjCXCR§¥ jp^ni§\`XCPnYSXegA^0^nbb_—KPnX\`v„L)^nj[bcM

qEXCL_PfrO\`XqEXCM_^hP7£«\nb_q ^`jpqEXCP ‡ ?

? ‘‚ MSPG H1iKX\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcXX\`\`bc\EzcXCMOX\hL)Z[Zpx ROXCg-\`XCL_PfXeP•LcPE^`iOXMˆrOq*—±X\kb)£

qEbQRQXCPj[MKg-\`XCL_PfXePG ŒPIjpM¦^niOXEYO\`Xvˆj[bcrKPX-OLcq7YKZpX_{ b_P`g-j[ZpZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKPq•L„x—±X7ROrOX7^nb^niOXEj[M KrOXCMKg-XEb)£©^niOX•LcRKRQjw^`jpb_M

b)£YKLc\f^`j[grOZ¢L)\qEbQRQXCPŒ¥ jp^ni\`XCPnYSXegA^^`b&^niKX0^n\`rOX*YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\vsL)Z[rOX_GH1iOX"\`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcX0XC\n\`bc\ROXCg-\`XCL_PfXePPnZpbs¥ Z[xL)£^nX\

L)YKYO\nb„Qj[q•Ls^nXCZpx 3m‡

qEbQRQXeP{O¥ iKX\`Xjp^j¢PL)Z[\nXeLcRQx•rKMKRQX\



10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

55

60

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

NUMBER OF MODES

PERCENT RELATIVE ERROR

Data

Cubic smoothing spline

a2jpz_rO\`X e‘ ŠH1iOXYSXC\`gXMm^•\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX¤\nXeg-bsv_X\`XCR§YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\7XC\n\`bc\­e‡c‡ +

K

­«^n\`rOX ¯*ƒ

K

­«\`XCg-bsv_X\`XCR ¯n¯+

K

­^n\`rOX ¯ +¯ L_PEL

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcM$b)£^`iOX¤MmrKq*—±X\Eb)£qEbQRQXeP¤­–g-j[\`gZpXeP ¯ G H1iOXg-rO\`vcX¤RQ\`L„¥ M ^niO\`bcrOz_iV^niKX¤ROL)^`L¬j[PEL¬g-rO—Oj¢gPfqEbˆb)^`iOj[MOz

PnYOZpj[MOX&­ .j[MULs^`Z[Lc— ¯ ¥ jw^`iPfqEbˆb)^`iOjpMKz7YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\1XC‰mrKLcZ“^nb ‡ G

H1iOXILcgCg-rO\hLcgxbc£6^niOXI¨.²‹ £«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM&¥ jp^ni

K

rOMONˆMObs¥ Mkj[P1g-b_qEYKL)\`XCR7^`b*^`iOXa

”

U£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcM&j[Ma2j[zKG 3

{

¥ iOXC\nX©^niOX.\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX3XC\n\`bc\>j[P2YOZ[b)^n^nXeR*LcP2L £«rKMKgA^`jpb_M*b)£Q^`iOX.YSXC\`gXMm^2MKbcj¢PfXªjpM*^niOX1Pfj[zcMSL)ZG|aOb_\>—KL_Pfj¢P>b)£SgbcqEYKL)\`j¢Pfb_M6{

^niKX*PnLcqEX"PfXCXCR§­ƒhe}c‘"3m‚c€_¯ £«bc\ ^`iOX"\hL)MKRObcq MˆrOq—SXC\zcXCMOX\hLs^`bc\1j¢PrKPnXCR£«bc\ŒL)Z[Z>gL_PfXeP1¥ jw^`iMObcM ƒCX\`b7MKbcj¢PfX_G P

X-QY±XCg-^nXCR6{3^niKX¤\`XZ¢Ls^`jpv_XkXC\n\`bc\7jpMSg-\`XCLcPnXCP¥ jp^ni$\nXePfY±XCg-^^`b¦^`iOXYSXC\`gXMm^7MKbcj¢PfX£«bc\E—±b)^ni5^niKX¨1²‹ L)MKR5a ” U

£«bc\`q*rKZ[L)^nj[bcMKPCG2H1iKXa ” UqEX-^`iObQR•j¢P3qEbc\`XLcgCg-rO\hLs^`X1^niKLcM•^niKXŒ¨.²‹ŽLs^©Z[bs¥ MObcj¢PnXZpXCvcXCZ[PCG2Fbs¥ªXCvcXC\C{mL)—±bsvcX1^niKX

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

% NOISE

% RELATIVE ERROR

POD

FEM

a2jpz_rO\`X  3 ŠH1iOXYSXC\`gXMm^•\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX¤\nXeg-bsv_X\`XCR§YKLc\`Lcq7X^nXC\7XC\n\`bc\­e‡c‡ +

K

­«^n\`rOX ¯*ƒ

K

­«\`XCg-bsv_X\`XCR ¯n¯+

K

­^n\`rOX ¯ +¯ L_PEL

£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMbc£>^`iOX"Y±X\hg-XMm^MOb_j[PnXI£«bc\^niOX*¨1²‹ ­«bS{ €c‡ qEbQRQXeP ¯ LcMKRa ” U ­ ¯ £«b_\nqrOZ[L)^nj[bcMKPCG3°†M—±b)^nigCLcPnX"ROLs^hL

Y±bcj[M_^hPL)\`XIg-bcMKMOXCg-^nXCR¤—ˆxkPf^n\hL)j[zcim^1Zpj[MOXCPCG

,YOZ[b)^ b)£2^niKX0\`L)^nj[bbc£a

”

UPnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM^nj[qEXCP1^`bE¨1²‹ Pfb_ZprO^nj[bcM^nj[q7XeP j[ZpZ[rKPf^n\hLs^nXeP.^niOXI^`jpqEX"P`L„vˆjpMOzmP©b ±XC\nXeRk—ˆx

^niKX¨1²‹ŽqEX^niObQR G)ŒP.a2j[zKG e‚ j[MKRQj¢gLs^`XCPC{m^niOXI¨.²‹ qEX-^`iObQRkj¢P 3 G‚ ^nb … ^nj[q7XeP.q7b_\nXŒX-³&g-j[XMm^.^niKLcMk^`iOXIa ” U

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

7

7.5

8

8.5

9

% NOISE

T

FEM

/ T

POD

a2jpz_rO\`X e‚ Š&H1iOXk\hLs^`jpb¬b)£PnbcZ[rQ^nj[bcM ^nj[q7XeP­®H +)H ¯ LcPL£«rOMSgA^nj[bcM$b)£ ^`iOX¤YSXC\`gXMm^MOb_j[PnXcG§H1iOXROLs^hL

Y±bcj[M_^hPL)\`XIg-bcMKMOXCg-^nXCR¤—ˆxkPf^n\hL)j[zcim^1Zpj[MOXCPCG

3 s› Kš ž °†ME^niOj¢P©XOL)qEYOZ[X—Sbc^ni&YSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\hPNM!1L)MKR

K

Lc\nXPnj[q*rOZp^`LcMOXb_rKPfZ[xPnbcrKzcim^

j[ML^y¥ªbŒYKL)\hL)qEX-^`X\2jpMˆv_X\hPfXªYO\nb_—OZ[XqG ” QgXYQ^2£«bc\ M!3LcMKR

K

{cPnj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_Mg-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcMKP>¥.X\`X3^niKX1P`L)qEX.LcP2jpMjpM^niKX

bcMKXYSL)\hL)qEX-^`X\1jpMˆv_X\hPfXYO\`bc—OZ[Xq•P L)—±bsvcX_G2H1iKX0XZ[XCg-\`j¢goKXCZ[R¤j¢P qEXCL_PfrO\`XCRLs^

‡

G

‡O

MKP j[Mm^nXC\nvsL)Z¢P.£«\`bcq ‡>=

= ‚

MKPCG.tjpMKX*a

”

Pfj[q*rOZ¢Ls^`jpb_MKP"­–g-bcq—Oj[MKLs^`jpb_MKP b)£ ! ‘O

"

‘c‘

"

‘_

L)MSR

K



e‡

T

%

"



C‡

T "



C‡

T

+

¯

XeLcghi

¥ jp^ni

‚c‡O

PnMKL)YSPfiObc^`P bc£^niOX

%

3_

MKbˆRKL)Z6vsL)Z[rOXeP £«bc\^niOXXZ[XCgA^`j[g*L)MKRY±bcZ¢L)\`jeLs^`jpb_MkoKXCZ[RKPL)\`X0rKPnXCR¤^`b

bc—O^`L)j[M^niOX"¨1²‹,—KLcPnj[P1XCZpXCqEXMm^`P1£«b_\1^niOX0qEj[MOj[q7jCL)^nj[bcMYO\`bc—OZ[XqG

a2jpz_rO\`XCP e€ LcMKR „ PnrOqEq•L)\`jCX>^`iOX^y¥.b YKL)\hL)qEX^nX\“j[MˆvcX\hPnX2\`XCPnrOZp^`P rKMKRQX\6^niOX£«b_ZpZ[bs¥ j[MOzg-b_MKRQjp^nj[bcMKP M!s­«^n\`rOX ¯ ‘c‘ {

M!„­«j[MOjp^nj¢L)Z¯ ‘m {

K

­^`\nrOX ¯ ‚ C‡ T $

{

K

­«j[MOjp^nj¢L)Z¯ ‘‚ C‡ T $

{cLcMKR 3­

¯ qEj[MOjpqEjXeR*¥ jp^ni\nXePfY±XCg-^>^`bb_—KPnX\`v„L)^nj[bcM

qEXCL_PfrO\`XqEXCM_^hPª£«\nb_q ^nj[qEXCP ‡ ?

? ‘ ‚ MKPG

a2jpz_rO\`X e€ YOZpbc^`P1^`iOX0\`XZ¢Ls^nj[vcXIXC\n\`bc\.£«bc\^niOX0\`XCgbsvcX\`XCR ?!ŒvsL)Z[rOXeP LcPL£«rOMKg-^nj[bcMbc£|^niKX"MObcj¢PnXZ[Xv_XZ©­‡sƒy})‡ ¯ £«b_\

^niKXk¨.²‹L)MKRVa ” U qEX^niObQROPCGaO\`bcqa>j[zKG e€ jw^EgL)MV—±XkPnXXCM§^niKL)^"^niOX¤a ” U \`XCPnrOZw^hP"L)\`X•zcXCMOX\hL)Z[Z[x¦qEbc\`X

LcgCg-rO\hLs^`X•^niSL)MV^`iOX¨1²‹ \`XCPnrOZp^`PC{2—KrQ^^`iKLs^^niOX\nXCZ[L)^nj[vcX&XC\n\`bc\"£«bc\*—±b)^`iµj¢P*rKMKRQX\ ‡ G} G¦H1iKXk\`XZ¢Ls^nj[bcMSPfiOj[Y

—±X-^y¥.XXME^`iOX\`XZ¢Ls^`jpv_X.XC\n\`bc\3LcMKR7^niKXMObcj¢PnX ZpXCvcXZSL)YOY±XCLc\`P^`b"—±XMObcMKZpj[MOXCLc\C{crOMOZ[jpN_X ^niOXbcMOX YKLc\`LcqEX-^nXC\3\`XCg-bsv_X\`x