Construction Criteria Weights
Metro Electric
Benchmark
FIXED WEIGHTING FOR SUB-CRITERIA MAXIMUM POINTS 79.79 65.75 1 2 100% 60.00 51.12 60.00
11.1 Proposed construction contract price (base price plus alternates). Contract price shall include both base price and total alternate price. Final weighting distribution between base Price and total of alternates will be a calculated percentage
98,591.00
$ $ 84,000.00
100% 6.66 5.34 2.42
11.2 MISD Administrative staff will contact three Owners, identified in Criteria Item No. 11.4-11.6 the list of school district projects completed within the past five (5) years of similar scope and size.
20% 1.33 0 0
11.3 List all claims, judgments, arbitration proceedings or suits pending or
outstanding against your company or its officers. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.00
11.4 List current or past MISD projects completed within the past five (5) years of
similar scope and size. 20% 1.33 1.33 0.70
11.5 List current or past K-12 projects completed within the past five (5) years of
similar scope and size. 30% 2.00 2.00 0.75
11.6 List current or past Non K-12 projects completed within the past five (5)
years of similar scope and size. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.30
11.7 Provide three (3) letters of reference from major suppliers and/or contractors which specifically address the bidder’s history of paying sub-contractors and material providers on time.
10% 0.67 0.67 0.67
CSP No. 2012-126 - James Bonham Elementary School Electrical Services Evaluation
CRITERIA/RATIONALE
Texas Government Code (a)(1) The price.
Construction Criteria Weights
200% 13.32 5.99 0.00
11.8 The bidder’s history of on-time project completion. Based on references
contacted by MISD Administrative staff as stated in section 11.2. 40% 2.66 0.00 0.00 11.9 The bidder’s history of repeat business with owner(s). Based on references
contacted by MISD Administrative staff as stated in section 11.2. 40% 2.66 2.66 0.00 11.10Provide evidence of sufficient resources necessary to manage, staff and
successfully perform the Work. 20% 1.33 0.00 0.00
11.11List of individuals and provide detailed resumes of the positions for Project Manager, Assistant Project Manager, Project Superintendent, Assistant Project Superintendent and MEP Quality Control Specialist who will be assigned for the entire duration of the Project. Resumes should address the following points for each of the positions mentioned above.
• Amount of time assigned to project; • Years of experience;
• Relevant K-12 experience; • Certifications
100% 6.66 3.33 0.00
0% 0.00 0.00 0.00
11.12 Not applicable to School Districts. 0.00 0.00
100% 6.66 6.67 0.00
11.13Provide Workers Compensation Experience Modification Rate (EMR) for the
last three years, as obtained from your insurance agent. 35% 2.33 2.33 0.00
11.14Provide OSHA No. 200 Log information for the past three (3) years regarding following points:
• Number of injuries and illnesses • Number of lost time accidents • Number of recordable cases • Number of fatalities
• Number of employee direct hire fixed hours worked (round to 1,000's)
30% 2.00 2.00 0.00
11.15Provide your company’s safety program manual. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.00 11.16Provide your company’s safety orientation program for new employees. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.00 11.17State the fequency safety inspections are conducted for projects. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.0 11.18Provide your company’s drug/alcohol prevention policy. 5% 0.33 0.33 0.00 Texas Government Code (a)(3) The quality of the offeror’s goods or services.
Texas Government Code (a)(5) The offeror’s safety record.
Construction Criteria Weights
100% 6.67 6.67 3.33
11.19 Submit Bond on MISD mandated form. 5% 0.33 0.33 0.00
11.20Provide your company’s single limit coverage. 15% 1.00 1.00 1.00 11.21Provide your company’s aggregate/total available limit of coverage. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.67 11.22List your surety company and address following points. (Maximum Points
0.66)
• Years your company has had a business relationship with surety; • AM Best Rating;
State if surety company is registered in the State of Texas
10% 0.66 0.66 0.66
11.23List projects your company has in progress. For each project listed address the following points.
• Name of project;
• Owner's contact person and phone number;
• Architect, Architect's contact person and phone number; • Contract amount;
• Percent complete;
• Scheduled completion date;
• List total worth of work in progress and under contract.
10% 0.67 0.67 0.00
11.24The offeror must submit a current financial statement of the financial
condition sworn to before a Notary Public. • Preferably audited;
• Your organization's latest balance and income statement showing current assets, net fixed assets,
other assets, current liabilities and other liabilities;
• Indicate name and address of firm preparing financial statement, and date thereof; • If the financial statement is not for the identical organization submitting offer, explain the relationship and financial responsibility of the organization whose financial statement is provided (parent, subsidiary, etc.)
40% 2.67 2.67 1.00
11.25 List your company’s Dunn & Bradstreet risk rating. 10% 0.67 0.67 0.00
100% 6.67 4.00 0.00
11.26Provide a project schedule/timeline. Include project specific parameters or
limitations (e.g. evening, summer, holiday work). 60% 4.00 4.00 0.00
11.27Provide cost saving ideas and associated cost. 40% 2.68 0.00 0.00 Texas Government Code (a)(7) Any other relevant factor specifically listed in the
request for bids or proposals.
Texas Government Code (a)(6) Whether the offeror’s financial capability is appropriate to the size and scope of the project
Responded
Recommendation
No Bid
Address
Late Bid
Competitive Sealed Proposal No. 2012-126 - James Bonham Elementary School Electrical Services
Vendor List
Date Sent
Vendor
222 East Van Buren #503
Harlingen, TX 78550-
2/12/2013
Alpha Building Corporation
Owner:
10808 Hillpoint
San Antonio, TX 78217
2/12/2013
Baish Electric Company, Ltd.
Owner:
2014 West Avenue
San Antonio, TX 78201
2/12/2013
Bexar Electric Company Ltd
Owner:
PO Box 8237
San Antonio, TX 78208
2/12/2013
Big State Electric Company
Owner:
4/11/2013
2nd Highest Ranked
PO Box 720083
McAllen, TX
78504-BM Benchmark Construction LLC
Owner: George Boghs & David Karam
11111 Lota Street
San Antonio, TX 78217
2/12/2013
Brandt Engineering Company
Owner:
5309 Bandera Road, Suite B
San Antonio, TX 78238
2/12/2013
Capital Electric, Inc.
Owner:
1149 South Commerce Street
Harlingen, TX 78550
2/12/2013
Consolidated Electrical Dist
Owner: Corporation
1430 N. Flores
San Antonio, TX 78212
2/12/2013
Corbo Electric Company, Inc.
Owner:
PO Box 1680
Pharr, TX 78577
2/12/2013
D & F Industries Inc
Owner:
16294 IH 35 North
Selma, TX 78154
2/12/2013
Dausin Electric Company
Owner:
533 County Road 130
Edna, TX 77957-
2/12/2013
Dayton E. Itz dba Itz Services
Owner:
PO Box 3464
Victoria, TX 77903
2/12/2013
Easley Roofing & Sheet Metal Inc
Owner:
Responded
Recommendation
No Bid
Address
Late Bid
Competitive Sealed Proposal No. 2012-126 - James Bonham Elementary School Electrical Services
Vendor List
Date Sent
Vendor
PO Box 98
Floresville, TX 78114
2/12/2013
F & W Electrical Contractors Inc
Owner:
4705 Towerwood Drive
Brownsville, TX 78521
2/12/2013
Global Electric
Owner:
16875 Diana Lane
Houston, TX 77058-
2/12/2013
Jamail & Smith Construction
Owner:
2306 Port Lavaca Drive
Victoria, TX 77901-
2/12/2013
Juan R Lozano Sr dba Rain Seal Master Roofing
& Sheet Metal Inc
Owner: Juan R. Lozano Sr.
504 East Street Elmo
Austin, TX 78745-
2/12/2013
KBS Electrical Distribuitors Inc
Owner:
PO Box 460747
San Antonio, TX 78246-0747
2/12/2013
Klecka Electric Company, Inc.
Owner:
4801 Auburn Avenue Unit 5
McAllen, TX 78504
2/12/2013
Komplex Electric
Owner:
PO Box 1265
Bellville, TX 77418
2/12/2013
Liteco Electric Inc
Owner:
3093 Wiestruck Road / PO Box
1265
Bellville, TX 77418
2/12/2013
Liteco Electric, Inc.
Owner:
6044 Dona Beatriz
El Paso, TX 79932
2/12/2013
McGraw Hill Construction Dodge
Owner:
4/11/2013
Highest Ranked
1901 Industrial Drive
McAllen, TX 78504-4015
2/12/2013
Metro Electric Incorporated
Owner: Jack L. Gerdes
PO Box 700490
San Antonio, TX 78270-0490
2/12/2013
Nathan Alterman Electric Company Ltd
Owner:
Responded
Recommendation
No Bid
Address
Late Bid
Competitive Sealed Proposal No. 2012-126 - James Bonham Elementary School Electrical Services
Vendor List
Date Sent
Vendor
PO Box 271482
Corpus Christi, TX 78427
2/12/2013
Port Enterprises LTD
Owner:
PO Box 241075
San Antonio, TX 78224-1075
2/12/2013
Quinney Electric, Inc.
Owner:
6918 West Expressway 83
Harlingen, TX 78552
2/12/2013
RGV Associated General Contractors
Owner:
PO Box 2347
Harlingen, TX 78551
2/12/2013
Sechrist Hall Company
Owner: Corporation
9435 East Loop 1604 N.
Converse, TX 78109
2/12/2013
Southwest Electrical Contracting Svcs., Ltd.
Owner:
88 Pine Street
Manchester, NH 03103-
2/12/2013
Structures Unlimited Inc
Owner:
12700 O'Connor Road
San Antonio, TX 78233
2/12/2013
TD Industries
Owner:
8901 North 23rd
McAllen, TX 78501
2/12/2013
Topcon Inc
Owner:
616 South Getty
Uvalde, TX 78801
2/12/2013
Trevino Electric Service Inc
Owner:
2277 Old Route 66
Atlanta, IL 61723
2/12/2013
Universal Sports Lighting
Owner:
1697 Hwy. 83 S.
Carrizo Springs, TX 78834
2/12/2013
Urban Electrical Services, Inc.
Owner:
PO Box 2225
McAllen, TX 78502
2/12/2013
Victor T Rios dba Lumatec Lighting Service
Owner:
4047 Naco Perrin Suite 100
San Antonio, TX 78217
2/12/2013
Virtual Builders Exchange
Owner:
Responded
Recommendation
No Bid
Address
Late Bid
Competitive Sealed Proposal No. 2012-126 - James Bonham Elementary School Electrical Services
Vendor List
Date Sent
Vendor
16902 El Camino Real 4C
Houston, TX 77058-
2/12/2013
Weatherproofing Technologies Inc
Owner:
16902 El Camino Real 4C
Houston, TX 77058-
2/12/2013
Weatherproofing Technologies Inc
Owner:
4533 Baldwin Boulevard
Corpus Christi, TX 78408
2/12/2013
Wesco Distribution Inc
Owner:
604 Palmview Drive
Palmview, TX 78574-
2/12/2013
Zitro Electric Company
Owner:
