Comparison CCTV and IP Cameras

(1)

A

S

K

C

o

m

u

n

i

c

a

t

i

o

n

s

Muh

Muhammammad Yousad Yousafaf IqbIqbalal Cell 0092-321-4444405 Cell 0092-321-4444405

(2)

•• ASK CommunicationsASK Communications is a true solution provider company. Weis a true solution provider company. We

believe that solution for your business is critical to growth, expansion believe that solution for your business is critical to growth, expansion and ultimate success.

and ultimate success.

•• We haWe have cve certertified pified profrofessessionalionals on ss on staff ttaff to aso assissist yot you in thu in the plae planningnning and implementing

and implementing of any of any solution for solution for your business your business or organization.or organization. Our professionals have the training and experience necessary to Our professionals have the training and experience necessary to make the right recommendations for your specific needs.

(3)

Introduction

•• IN

INT

TRO

ROD

DUC

UCT

TIO

ION

N TO

TO IP

IP V

VID

IDEO

EO

•• A

AN

NA

AL

LO

OG V

G VS

S. I

. IP V

P VIID

DE

EO

O

•• D

DV

VR

R V

VS

S. . N

NV

VR

R S

SO

OL

LU

UT

TIIO

ON

N

•• NV

NVR

R RE

RECO

COR

RDI

DIN

NG

G S

SOF

OFTW

TWA

AR

RE

E

•• IP

IP VI

VIDE

DEO

O NE

NETW

TWOR

ORK

K CO

COMP

MPON

ONEN

ENTS

TS

•• An

Anal

alog

ogue

ue CC

CCTV

TV V

Vs.

s. CC

CCTV

TV/I

/IP

P

(4)

•• Co

Conv

nver

erge

genc

nce o

e of I

f IT a

T and

nd Ph

Phys

ysic

ical

al Se

Secu

curi

rity

ty

•• Ma

Many

ny co

corp

rpor

orat

atio

ions

ns us

use I

e IT a

T and

nd Se

Secu

curi

rity

ty fo

for

r

Surveillance, Security and Loss

Surveillance, Security and Loss Prevention

Prevention

•• IT

IT ma

mana

nage

ges d

s dat

ata w

a whi

hile

le Se

Secur

curit

ity u

y use

ses d

s dat

ata

a

•• Sc

Scal

alab

abililit

ity a

y and

nd re

remo

mote

te ac

acce

cess

ss

•• Cab

Cablin

ling in

g infra

frastr

struct

ucture

ure all

allows

ows for e

for ease

ase of i

of inst

nstall

allati

ation

on

•• R

Rem

emo

ote

te ac

acc

ces

ess v

s via

ia in

inte

terrne

nett

•• Op

Open

en IT

IT st

stan

anda

dard

rds a

s allllow

ows f

s for

or fu

futu

ture

re pa

path

th

•• R

Re

ed

du

un

nd

da

an

nc

cy

y

•• A

Abi

billit

ity t

y to r

o re

eco

cord

rd of

off s

f sit

ite

e

•• Lo

Lowe

wer

r co

cost

st o

of

f o

own

wner

ersh

shiip

p

Security surveillance

(5)

5 5

Internet Internet

Surveillance Management Software

D

Diiggiittaal l CCaammeerraass AnAnaalloog g CCaammeerraass

Local Console Local Console Remote Monitor

(6)

Analog

••

D

DV

VR

R n

ne

ee

ed

de

ed

d iin e

n ea

ac

ch

h

location

••

Ca

Cam

mer

eras

as lo

loc

cke

ked t

d to s

o spe

peci

cifi

fic

c

DVR

••

M

Mo

orre e

e ex

xp

pe

en

ns

siiv

ve c

e ca

ab

blliin

ng

g

•• EExxppeennssiivve le laabboor r •• CCaabbllees s rruun n bbaacck k ttoo

DVR DVR

••

N

No

on s

n stta

an

nd

da

arrd p

d prro

otto

oc

co

olls

s

••

Ca

Cam

mer

eras

as li

lim

mit

ited

ed to

to ca

capt

ptu

ure

re

card

Analog vs. IP Video

IP Video

••

C

Ce

en

nttrra

al

l rre

ec

co

orrd

diin

ng

g

••

F

Flle

ex

xiib

blle m

e ma

ap

pp

piin

ng

g

••

C

Ch

he

ea

ap

pe

er

r c

ca

ab

blliin

ng

g

•• LLeesss s eexxppeennssiivve e llaabboor r •• UUsse e eexxiissttiinngg

infrastructure infrastructure

•• CCoonnnneecctteed d tto o nneeaarreesstt switch

switch

••

S

Stta

an

nd

da

arrd p

d prro

otto

oc

co

olls

s

••

C

Ca

am

me

erra

as l

s liim

miitte

ed o

d on

nly

ly b

by

y

processing power

(7)

Analog

Analog vs. IP Video

IP Video

•• LLooccaal l DDVVR R NNeeeeddeedd •• CCoossttlly y ccaabblliinngg

•• CaCamemeraras lis limimiteted td to Do DVR VR cacapapaccitityy

•• RRememotote Se Stotorragage pe posossisiblblee •• RRememotote e ususerers s popossssibiblele •• LLoow w ccoosst t ccaabblliinngg

•• ViVirtrtuaually lly ununlimlimitited ed nunumbmber er of of cacamemerarass

Ethernet Switch Ethernet Switch

(8)

A little More to Know

(9)

•• C

Ca

ap

pttu

urre

ed

d

•• Usi

Using

ng a C

a CCD

CD (Ch

(Charg

arge C

e Coupl

oupled

ed Dev

Device

ice) o

) on t

n the

he cam

camera

era

•• D

Diig

giittiiz

ze

ed

d

•• Co

Comp

mpre

ress

ssio

ion m

n met

etho

hods -

ds - MJ

MJPE

PEG,

G, MP

MPEG

EG, M

, MPE

PEG4

G4,,

etc..

•• S

Se

en

nt a

t ac

crro

oss

ss IIP N

P Ne

ettw

wo

orrks

ks

•• Loc

Local

al Are

Area N

a Netw

etwork

orks (

s (LAN

LANs),

s), Met

Metro

ro Are

Area N

a Netw

etwork

orks

s

(MANs) or the Internet

A little More to Know

V

Viiddeeo o DDeeccooddeerr VViiddeeo o PPrroocceessssoor r EthernetEthernet Transceiver

(10)

Analog

A little More to Know

A/D Converter A/D Converter Signal Processor Signal Processor D/A Converter D/A Converter LAN Port LAN Port Analog Video Out

Analog Video Out

IP Camera

A/D Converter A/D Converter Signal Processor Signal Processor Video Video Compression Compression

Gain, BLC, AWB, etc.. Gain, BLC, AWB, etc..

(11)

Analog

•• MMaax x LLeennggtth h ~ ~ 1100000 0 fftt.. •• RRGG--559 9 –– llaabboor r iinntteennssiivvee,,

costly costly

A little More to Know

Cat 5 Ethernet Cable Cat 5 Ethernet Cable

Wireless Bridge Wireless Bridge

W W i i r r e e d d

Analog

•• RRF (F (RRaaddiio Fo Frreeqquueennccyy)) •• MMiiccrroowwaavvee

•• PPrroopprriieettaarryy

•• CCoossttlly y SSoolluuttiioonnss

W W i i r r e e l l e e s s s s

IP Video

•• PPhyhysisiccal al mmax ax lelengngtth ~ h ~ 32328 f8 ftt.. •• VVirirttuaualllly ny no mo max ax lelengngtth dh duue te too

network switch locations network switch locations •• CCaatt55e e ssttaannddaarrd d –– lloow w ccoosstt

IP Video

•• 880022..1111aa, , bb, , g g –– LLoow w ccoosstt,, open standard

open standard

•• WWiiMMaaxx oor r PPrroopprriieettaarry y –– Longer distances

(12)

•• U

Un

niic

ca

as

stt

•• S

Str

tre

eam

am v

vid

ide

eo

o to

to 1

1 c

cli

lie

ent

nt

•• Cl

Clie

ient

nt is

is a P

a PC,

C, NV

NVR t

R that

hat vi

view

ews I

s IP v

P vid

ideo

eo

•• M

Mu

ullttiic

ca

as

stt

•• St

Stre

ream

am vi

vide

deo t

o to m

o mul

ulti

tipl

ple c

e clilient

ents a

s at o

t onc

nce

e

•• C

Can

an be

be p

pas

assw

swor

ord p

d pro

rote

tec

cte

ted

d

A little More to Know

(13)

•• A

An

na

allo

og

g C

Ca

am

me

erra

a

•• N

NT

TS

SC

C s

stta

an

nd

da

arrd

d

•• B

BN

NC

C c

co

on

nn

ne

ec

cttiio

on

n

•• R

RG

G--5

59 9 ffo

or

r v

viid

de

eo

o

•• R

RS

S--4

48

85 5 c

co

on

nttrro

oll

•• 1

12 2V

VD

DC

C o

or

r 2

24 4V

VA

AC

C

A little More to Know

24VAC or 12VDC 24VAC or 12VDC RS-485 RS-485 Analog Video Analog Video

Power over Ethernet Power over Ethernet

24VAC or 12VDC 24VAC or 12VDC Wireless Wireless Access Point Access Point

•• IIP

P C

Ca

am

me

erra

a

•• M

MJ

JP

PE

EG

G o

or

r M

MP

PE

EG

G

standard

•• RJ

RJ-4

-45 c

5 con

onn

nec

ecti

tio

on f

n for

or vi

vide

deo

o

and control

•• C

Ca

att5

5 o

or

r W

Wiirre

elle

es

ss

s

•• P

Po

oE

E –

– 1

1 c

ca

ab

blle

e ffo

or

r

everything

(14)

•• A

An

na

allo

og V

g Viid

de

eo R

o Re

ec

co

orrd

de

er

r

•• C

Ca

ap

pttu

urre

e C

Ca

arrd

d

•• In

Inte

teg

gra

rate

ted m

d mul

ulti

tip

ple

lex

xin

ing

g

•• L

Lo

oc

ca

al

l rre

ec

co

orrd

diin

ng

g

DVR vs. NVR

•• N

Net

etw

wor

ork

k V

Viide

deo

o R

Rec

ecor

ord

der

er

•• Pr

Proc

oces

esso

sor

r is

is ca

capt

ptur

ure

e de

devi

vice

ce

•• N

Ne

ettw

wo

orrk

k s

sw

wiittc

ch

h

•• R

Re

emo

mote

te re

reco

cord

rdiing

ng po

poss

ssib

iblle

e

Analog DVR Analog DVR

Network switch Network switch

Network Video Recorder Network Video Recorder Analog signal

Analog signal

Cabling must be home run to DVR Cabling must be home run to DVR

Signal is digitized Signal is digitized and compressed and compressed at DVR at DVR Digital signal Digital signal compressed at compressed at camera camera

Cabling need not be home Cabling need not be home

run to DVR run to DVR

(15)

•• N

NV

VR

R U

Un

niitt

•• NNVVR R HHaarrddwwaarree

•• IInnssttaalllleed Nd NVVR sR sooffttwwaarree

•• Pre-Pre-coconfnfigigurured ed hahardrdwaware re anandd physical size physical size

NVR Recording Software

•• N

NV

VR

R S

So

offttw

wa

arre

e

•• NNVVR R SSooffttwwaarree

•• IInnssttaalllleed d oon n a a 33rdrd _{party server}_{party server}

•• CCuussttoommiizzaabblle he haarrddwwaarree •• PPhhyyssiiccaal l ssiizze e ooppttiioonnss

•• HaHardrdwwarare me musust mt meeeet st sofoftwtwararee requirements and compatibility requirements and compatibility

(16)

Video Components

Analog

Matrix

DVR

Spot Monitor

Camera streams Camera streams analog video analog video Matrix routes Matrix routes video video DVR manages / DVR manages / stores video stores video User views video User views video

Ethernet Switch Ethernet Switch

Server

Storage Array

Camera streams Camera streams digital video digital video Switch routes Switch routes video video Server manages Server manages video video Storage archives Storage archives video video

IP Video

Remote Remote Workstation Workstation

(17)

CCTV/IP Advantages over Traditional Systems

•• ImImprprovoved ed sysyststem em scscalalababililitityy

•• AddAdding ing camcameras eras is is simsimilailar to r to addadding ing anothanother er compcomputeuter tr to yo your our netwnetwork ork –– nono additional TMC equipment

additional TMC equipment

•• ViVideo sdeo swiwitctchinhing is hg is hanandled adled at the pt the pacackeket levt level by tel by the nehe netwtworork –k – no mno mororee matrix switch expansion modules

matrix switch expansion modules

•• NeNetwtworork cok convenvergrgencence -e - CCCCTV caTV can intn integregratate wite with othh other Eter Etherhernenet/It/IPP

field network devices (i.e. traffic controllers) over the same backbone – field network devices (i.e. traffic controllers) over the same backbone – no additional communications infrastructure required

no additional communications infrastructure required

•• ReReliliabiabilitlity –y – IP neIP netwtwororks sks supupporport altt alterernatnate roue routinting and reg and redudundanndantt network links

(18)

CCTV/IP Advantages over Traditional Systems

•• OOpepen sn statandndarards ds susupppporortt

•• EncEncodinoding/Dg/Decodiecoding ng forformats mats are are stastandardndardizeized d –– opeopen n soursource ce sofsoftwatwarere decoders exist, hardware decoder interoperability improving

decoders exist, hardware decoder interoperability improving •• EtEthehernrnetet/I/IP neP netwtworork trk trananspsporortt

•• CComompapatitiblble e wiwith th NTNTCICIPP

•• SofSoftwatware bre based ased concontrotrol ell eliminaiminates tes dedicdedicateated and and prod propriprietaretaryy •• hahardrdwaware –re – swswitcitch mh matatririx, mx, mulultiptiplelexerxers, s, sesequequencncersers

(19)

CC

TV

oI

P

Su

mm

ar

y

•• CCTV security industry is migrating to IPCCTV security industry is migrating to IP

•• Traditional analog systems may be more cost effective for Traditional analog systems may be more cost effective for •• ssmmaalllleer der deplplooyymmeennttss

•• CCTVoICCTVoIPP may bmay be more cose more cost effect effective fortive for::

•• Systems with large number of field camerasSystems with large number of field cameras

•• SysteSystems with existinms with existing Ethernet/IP infrasg Ethernet/IP infrastructure –tructure – leveraleverage existingge existing •• hhaarrddwwaarree

(20)

Additional feathers of IP cameras

•• MMoottiioon dn deetteectctiioonn •• FFiirre e AAllaarrmmss

•• HHeeaat t MMaappss

•• POPOE (E (PoPowewer or ovever Er Eththerernenet)t)

•• InIntetelllligigenence ace at tt the Che Camamerera La Levevelel

–

– AlAlararm m MaMananagegemementnt –

– ImImagage Ee Enhnhanancecemementnt –

– NuNumbmber Pler Platate Idee Identntifificicatatioionn –

– PTPTZ tZ thrhrouough gh NeNetwtwororkk –

– II//O O ccoonnttrroollss

•• BidBidirirecectitiononal al AuAudidio o susurvrveilleillanancece •• SuSupeperrioior r ImImagage e QQuaualilityty

(21)

Additional feathers of IP cameras

•• DDigigitital al PaPann/T/Tililt/t/ZZoooomm

•• HHigighlhly ry releliaiablble -e - nno mo movovining pg parartsts •• CaCaptpturure eve evererytythihingng, al, all thl the tie timeme •• MuMultltipiple le sisimumultltananeoeous us cocontntroroll

Network Transport Network Transport •• EEtthheerrnneet t oor r WWii--FFii??

•• AvAvaiailalabibilility ty of of coconnnnecectition on poportrtss •• BBanandwdwididtth uh usasage ge on on LLANAN

(22)

Higher resolution improves

coverage

(23)

For More Information Contact Us

Muh

Muhammammad Youad Yousafsaf IqbaIqball ASK Communication ASK Communication

Opp. Sungam Cinema GT Road Gujranwala, Pakistan Opp. Sungam Cinema GT Road Gujranwala, Pakistan Tel: 0092-55-8035200,1 Tel: 0092-55-8035200,1 Fax 0092-55-3255530 Fax 0092-55-3255530 Cell: 0092-321-4444405 Cell: 0092-321-4444405 E-mail

E-mail info@askcom.pkinfo@askcom.pk

Web